_03132024-1106
City of Newport News · Newport News City County · meeting of Mar 13, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Newport News
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
MINUTES
HILTON VILLAGE ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW BOARD
W E D NE S DAY, March 13 , 2 02 4
Main Street Library
6 :3 0 P.M.
PRESENT: William C. Black; Theresa Cansler; Matt Perez ; Anne Peterson; Da na
Robbins; John Scruggs
Derek Lapiska (visitor)
ABSENT:
STAFF: Saul Gleiser D. , Staff
Nyoka Hall, Zoning Administrator
The meeting was held at the Main Street Station meeting room .
(A) Election and installation of Chair and Vice-Chair
Mr. Gleiser called for the election of Chair for the Board accepting
nominations from the floor. Ms. Cansler nominated Mr. Scruggs, the
nomination was seconded by Ms. Peterson. Mr. Scruggs accepted the
nomination and was elected by acclamation.
Mr. Scruggs called the meeting to order and requested nominations for
the position of Vice-Chair Ms. Cansler nominated Mr. Black ; after
accepting the nomination, he was elected by acclamation.
(B) Minutes November 8, 2023 Meeting
The minutes were approved unanimously (Ms. Robbins abstained as
she was not a Board Member when the meeting took place.)
(C) Preliminary Design Reviews :
There were no requests for reviews.
(D) Guidelines
Mr . Gleiser explained that although the Board has been wanting to
undertake a review of the existing guidelines this had not been
possible b ecause of the many board vacancies. He said he was happy to
report that once Mr. Lapiska is sworn in , there will be no openings on
the Board for the first time in 5 years.
He asked the Board for suggestions as how they would want to
2
undertake the review of the guidelines .
He reported that the City Attorney ’s office had reminded him that
Board members should not discuss issues concerning the Board
outside of the meetings. That includes group emails.
He requested a ll comments on the guidelines be forwarded to him
only , to avoid legal issues .
Mr. Gleiser said that one important item that was missing from the
guidelines was a clear understanding of were the authority to review
undertakings stop s. He said that it is common practice around the
nation for Architectural Review Boards to review all exterior changes
to a property within a historic district only when visible from a public-
right-of-way.
Discussion ensued regarding the authority to review exterior changes
not visible from the public-right-of-way.
Ms. Hall explained that limiting the review to those changes visible
from the public-right-of-way is consistent with the capabilities for the
City to enforce the mandate, as anything that is not visible would
require officials to trespass into private property, which is not legal.
Mr. Gleiser requested any revisions to the guidelines include the
incorporation of language reflecting the l imitations of review
authority.
Mr. Black reminded the Board of the need for the guidelines to be
broad enough to allow for the use of new appropriate materials or
techniques.
Ms. Peterson brought to the Boards attention the issue of new
synthetic materials, specifically for roofs. She had with her samples of
different synthetic slates and was curious as to why these products
would not be approved when replacement of a slate roof was
necessary. There was discussions as to the monotone an even texture
quality of some of the products as well as the concern that they were
not durable products.
Mr. Gleiser pointed out that the National Park Services does reviews of
most new products that claim to be good replacements for historic
materials. He added that the NPS has many helpful resources including
the Preservation Briefs publications in which the NPS discusses
different topics and makes recommendations.
3
For roof, replacements there are at least 2 briefs. He said that they do
not recommend the use of synthetic slate because of the same reasons
cited by the Board.
It was decided that staff would schedule meetings over the next 3 or 4
sessions to review and propose changes or clarifications to the
guidelines for formal action at the Board's annual meeting.
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 7 :47
P.M.
Source: City of Newport News website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.