RecordWell Data

Wetlands Board Meeting Packet (PDF)

City of Suffolk · Suffolk City County · meeting of Oct 15, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Suffolk

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD AGENDA FOR OCTOBER 15, 2026 PREPARED BY THE CITY OF SUFFOLK PLANNING DIVISION CASSIDY MCKELVIE, SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD SECRETARY A MEETING WILL BE HELD AT 6:00 P.M. IN THE SUFFOLK CITY COUNCIL CHAMBERS OF THE CITY HALL BUILDING IF YOU CANNOT ATTEND OR NEED SPECIAL ACCOMMODATIONS AT THE MEETING, PLEASE CALL OR EMAIL THE CITY OF SUFFOLK PLANNING DIVISION AT 757-514-4060 OR PLANNINGEMAIL@SUFFOLKVA.US PRIOR TO 12:00 NOON ON WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 14, 2026 GEOFFREY HINSHELWOOD CHAIRMAN AGENDA SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD October 15, 2026 6:00 P.M. I. Call to Order II. Roll Call III. Approval of Minutes from the February 19, 2026 meeting. IV. Approval of Minutes from the September 17, 2026 work session meeting. V. Public Hearing A. SWB2026-00017 submitted by Benjamin Johnson, applicant and property owner, for a permit to construct a living shoreline at 1504 White Dogwood Trail along Chuckatuck Creek; further identified as Tax Map 5*1. VI. Restoration Hearings - None VII. Permit Extensions - None VIII. Old Business - None IX. New Business - None X. Compliance and Inspections – None XI. Adjournment 1 MINUTES SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD July 16, 2026 6:00 P.M. The meeting of the Suffolk Wetlands Board was held on Thursday, July 16, 2026, at 6:00 p.m., in the City Council Chambers of the City Hall Building, 442 West Washington Street, Suffolk, Virginia. MEMBERS: Geoffrey Hinshelwood, Chairman Sidney Hazelwood Kathy Doerner Bryan Cattenhead Ellis Dallas STAFF: Cassidy McKelvie, Wetlands Board Secretary Margaret Pittenger, Assistant Director of Planning Jennifer Wilmoth, Assistant City Attorney Kirsten Travis, Virginia Marine Resources Commission ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by Chairman Hinshelwood. The roll was then called by Mrs. McKelvie, who informed Chai rman Hinshelwood that a quorum was present. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES: The minutes of the previous meeting were approved as presented by a voice vote of 5 to 0. Minutes Suffolk Wetlands Board July 16, 2026 2 PUBLIC HEARING: VMRC2023-0895, submitted by David Spencer, applicant and property owner, for a permit to modify and extend an existing riprap revetment located at 6954 Respass Beach Road along the James River, further identified as Tax Map 7A(1)*3. Ms. McKelvie gave a presentation and overview of the project. Staff recommended approval of VMRC2023-0895 with the prop osed conditions outlined in the staff report. The public hearing was opened, and David Kledzik with Marine Engineering spoke in favor of the application. Ms. McKelvie informed the Board that preferred method of mitigation for impacted vegetated tidal wetlands, as of July 2025, is to purchase credits from a tidal wetlands mitigation bank, instead of replacement onsite as proposed with this application. Kirsten Travis with the Virginia Mari ne Resources Commission provided further clarification of the July 2025 regulations change for tidal wetlands mitigation. Beth Cross with the Nansemond River Preserv ation Alliance spoke in favor of the application. The floor was opened for those who were in opposition of the application, and there was no opposition. Minutes Suffolk Wetlands Board July 16, 2026 3 The public hearing was closed. Following discussion by the board, Board Member Hazelwood made a motion to approve VMRC2023-0895 with the proposed conditions. The motion was seconded by Board Member Dallas and was approved by a voice vote of 5 to 0. NEW BUSINESS: Ms. McKelvie presented a proposal to change the permit number identification system for Wetlands Board applications a nd permits. Applications are currently tracked under the VMRC permit number. The proposed change would identify and track permit numbers under a SWB number , representing the Suffolk Wetlands Board. There was no opposition to the proposed change. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD DATE: JULY, 2026 , MT: Hazelwood 2 ND: Dallas TO: Approve with Conditions BOARD MEMBERS ATTENDANCE VMRC23-0895 VOTE: 5 - 0 PRESENT ABSENT YES NO Chairman Geoffrey Hinshelwood X X Vice-Chairman Darius Davenport X Sidney Hazelwood X X Bryan Cattenhead X X Richard Vroman X Kathy Doerner X X Kittrell Eberwine X Ellis Dallas - Alternate X X Kaitlyn Price - Alternate X 1 MINUTES SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD WORK SESSION September 17, 2026 6:00 P.M. The meeting of the Suffolk Wetlands Board was held on Thursday, September 17, 2026, at 6:00 p.m., in the City Council Conference Room of the City Hall Build ing, 442 West Washington Street, Suffolk, Virginia. MEMBERS: Geoffrey Hinshelwood, Chairman Darius Davenport, Vice-Chairman Sidney Hazelwood Kittrell Eberwine Richard Vroman Kathy Doerner Bryan Cattenhead Ellis Dallas STAFF: Cassidy McKelvie, Wetlands Board Secretary Margaret Pittenger, Assistant Director of Planning Stephanie Pough, Assistant City Attorney ROLL CALL: The meeting was called to order by Chairman Hinshelwood. Th e roll was then called by Ms. McKelvie, who informed Chairman Hinshelwood that a quorum was present. OPENING REMARKS Chairman Hinshelwood provided a summary of the Virginia Marine Resources Commission (VMRC) meeting from August 25, 2026. The VMRC remanded the permit application #23-0895 back to the Suffolk Wetlands Board for recons ideration with updated drawings and an updated VIMS report. Chairman Hinshelwood further advised the board to attend any trainings relevant to Minutes Suffolk Wetlands Board September 17, 2026 2 tidal wetlands and to stay current on state regulation changes. APPROVAL OF THE MINUTES: The board was advised by Ms. Pough to defer the vote on the minutes of the July 16, 2026 meeting until the next meeting of the board, which is tentatively scheduled for October 15, 2026. OPENING REMARKS: Chairman Hinshelwood provided a summary of the Virginia Marine Resources Commission (VMRC) meeting from August 25, 2026. The VMRC remanded the permit application #23-0895 back to the Suffolk Wetlands Board for recons ideration with updated drawings and an updated VIMS report. Chairman Hinshelwood further advised the board to attend any trainings relevant to tidal wetlands and to stay current on state regulation changes. WORK SESSION: Meeting Procedures - Ms. McKelvie provided an overview of meeting procedures, including the opening and closing of public hearings, the appropriate time for comments and questions from the Board, and the types of motions th at can be made for a decision on a public hear ing item. Ms. McKelvie also explained the importance of speaking into the microphone during public meetings. Ms. Pough explained the difference between deferring and tabling a vote. Chairman Hinshelwood asked whether there is a specific timeframe in which the board must decide on a public hearing item. Ms. Pough stated that she would investigate and an update will be provided to the board. Draft Bylaws Amendment - Ms. McKelvie provided an overview of the proposed changes to the Bylaws, generally consisting of the addition of a mission, date ch anges to the procedure for the Minutes Suffolk Wetlands Board September 17, 2026 3 election of officers, a date cha nge for when notification should be provided to the board when a regular meeting is canceled, and wording and restructuring changes for clarity. Ms. Pough suggested adding “busine ss/working” days to the proced ures outlined in Article III, Section 1 for the rescheduling of regular meetings that fall on a holiday. Chairman Hinshelwood requested that the election of officers be held in June instead of July. Draft Suffolk Wetlands Board Application – Ms. McKelvie provided an overview of the new proposed application for the Suffolk Wetlands Board for consistency with other applications with the City of Suffolk Planning Division. Chai rman Hinshelwood, Vice-Chairman Davenport, and Board Member Hazelwood expressed concern rega rding the removal of the requirements for Chesapeake Bay Preservation Area (CBPA) compliance. Ms. Pittenger stated that Staff would discuss with the legal team regarding the appropriate order of operations for consideration of projects when there are impacts to the jurisdictional areas of both the Wetlands Board and the Resource Protection Area buffer. Chairman Hinshelwood requested additional information regard ing the requirements of the resiliency assessment. Board Member Vroman requested that the schedule requirements be more detailed. Regulatory Updates – HB521 and HB237 – Ms. McKelvie provided an overview of House Bill 521 about impacts to nonvegetated wetlands and the “no net loss” policy and House Bill 237 about marsh migration. Board Members and Staff discussed what potential impact these bills may have on Wetlands Board regulations in the future. Virginia Marine Resources Commission – Tidal Wetlands Guidance – Ms. Mckelvie provided Minutes Suffolk Wetlands Board September 17, 2026 4 a brief overview of the Tidal Wetlands Guidan ce, focusing on the preference toward living shoreline designs and the order of preference for mitigation measures to tidal wetland impacts. The guidelines indicate that tidal wetland impacts should first be avoi ded, then minimized and mitigated when avoidance is not feasible. Comp ensatory mitigation should be considered first with the purchase of credits fro m a mitigation bank, then from an in-lieu-of fee program, then onsite and/or in-kind replacement, then off-site and/or out-of-kind replacement. CLOSING REMARKS Chairman Hinshelwood provided a brief overview to the Board of a violation of the Wetlands Act that was reported and investigated in the Winter of 2025. The Chairman then requested guidance on what measures the Wetlands Board should take when handling violations. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned. CITY OF SUFFOLK 442 W. WASHINGTON STREET, P.O. BOX 1858, SUFFOLK, VIRGINIA 23439-1858 PHONE: (757) 514-4060 FAX: (757) 514-4099 October 15, 2026 Suffolk Wetlands Board City of Suffolk, Virginia Dear Board Members: Attached for your consideration is information pertaining to a Wetlands Board permit, SWB2026- 00017, submitted by Benjamin Johnson, applicant and property owner, for a permit to construct a living shoreline at 1504 White Dogwood Trail along Chuckatuck Creek; further identified as Tax Map 5*1. Information and maps pertaining to this request are attached for your consideration. Please contact me if you have any questions in advance of the October 15, 2026 meeting. Respectfully submitted, Cassidy McKelvie Cassidy McKelvie Wetlands Board Secretary Attachments DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT Division of Planning October 15, 2026 1 STAFF REPORT DESCRIPTION PROPOSED PROJECT: The applicant is requesting a Wetlands Board permit, SWB2026- 00017, to construct a living shoreline spanning 520 linear feet between mean low water (MLW) and mean high water (MHW). The proposed shoreline will consist of five (5) 100-foot sills of Oyster CatcherTM tables and pillows with five-foot gaps between each sill to allow for water flow and wildlife movement. The proposed project will be constructed over 4,680 square feet of nonvegetated tidal wetlands. This project does not qualify under a general permit due to the approximate two (2) miles of fetch at the project site. APPLICANT: Submitted by Benjamin Johnson, applicant and property owner. LOCATION: The subject property is located at 1504 White Dogwood Trail along Chuckatuck Creek. ASSOCIATED STATE AND FEDERAL PERMITS: NAO-2026-01131 and VMRC2026- 1192 PERMIT HISTORY: None. VIMS REPORT: No report was received for this project from the Virginia Institute of Marine Science at the time of this Staff Report. PUBLIC NOTICE: This request has been duly advertised in accordance with the public notice requirements set forth in Sectio n 28.2-1302 of the Code of Virgin ia, as amended, and with the applicable provisions of the Unified Development Ordinance. A copy of staff’s report shall be provided to the applicant. STAFF ANALYSIS ISSUE The applicant is requesting a permit from the Suffolk Wetlands Board to construct a living shoreline spanning 520 linear feet between mean low water (MLW) and mean high water (MHW) to prevent future erosion of the shoreline and pr ovide habitat for native wildlife. The proposed living shoreline will comprise of five (5) 100-foot long sills created with Oyster CatcherTM tables and pillows, five-foot gaps with baffles in betwee n each sill to allow for water flow and wildlife movement, and 2,000 plantings of Spartina alterniflora . The specifications for the Oyster CatcherTM tables and pillows are included in Exhibit E. The proposed project will be constructed over 4,680 square feet of nonvegetated tidal wetlands. Each sill will contain five (5) interlocked rows of Oyster Catcher TM tables, starting at MLW. The landward-most row of Oyster CatcherTM tables will be collocated with an Oyster CatcherTM pillow. Three (3) plantable pillows collocated with two (2) Oyster Catcher TM tables will be placed landward of the gap between each sill as a baffle. All plantable pillows and the nonvegetated tidal wetlands landward of the sills are proposed to be planted with Spartina alterniflora. October 15, 2026 2 The approximate width of each sill is nine (9) fe et. The approximate width of each baffle is two (2) feet. All structures are proposed to be placed between three (3) and te n (10) feet seaward of existing marsh so that there are no impacts to existing vegetated tidal wetlands. No fill is proposed with this project. All work is proposed to be completed by hand. Project mate rials will be stored upland in the existing parking lot of Johnson & Sons Seafood. Construction access will be taken from the existing boat ramp at Johnson & Sons Seafood. No impacts to the Resource Protection Area (RPA) buffer are proposed with this project. The applicant indicated that they will engage contractors to complete the work once all necessary permits have been acquired, which is anticipa ted to be completed by early spring 2027. The installation of the oyster catcher materials and plantings are expected to be completed within two (2) weeks once permits are acquired and contractors have been engaged. This project does not qualify under a general permit due to the approximate two (2) miles of fetch at the project site. The appl icant has provided examples of other living shoreline projects completed using Oyster Catcher TM materials. The provided examples are for sites that experience a similar volume of fetch and were constructed similarly to the proposed project. These example projects are included in Exhibit F. CONSIDERATIONS AND CONCLUSIONS 1. Living Shoreline projects are the preferred solution for shoreline erosion issues but can be sensitive to large fetch volumes . The use of Oyster Catcher TM tables and pillows will provide structural integrity to the project that will protect the shoreline from further erosion by abating wave energy. The proposed planting of the nonvegetated areas of the shoreline will further help stabilize the intertidal zone at the project site. Additionally, the proposed baffle between each sill will abate wave energy while still allowing exchange of water, sediment, and wildlife between Chuckatuck Creek and the marsh. The staggered design of this request may promote sediment accretion that would counteract the erosion that has already occurred at the project site. 2. This project does not require authorizat ion from the Virginia Marine Resources Commission (VMRC) as all proposed work is located landward of MLW. Permitting and approvals from other agencies, including, but not limited to, the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality and the Army Corps of Engineers, may be required prior to any land disturbing activities. Ob taining all required permits a nd approvals is proposed as a condition of approval for the permit. 3. The proposed project will be constructed over 4,680 square feet of nonvegetated tidal wetlands. All structures are proposed to be placed between 3 and 10 feet seaward of existing marsh so that there are no impacts to existing vegetated tidal wetlands. No fill is proposed with this project. Since the proposed Living Shoreline project will promote sediment accretion, includes plantings of Spartina alterniflora, and there are no proposed imp acts to tidal vegetation, this project does not require compensatory mitigation. October 15, 2026 3 4. The construction laydown yard and access path to the project site will be taken from the adjoining Johnson & Sons Seaf ood parking lot and boat ramp. These areas consist of existing impervious areas. As such, no land disturbance or vegetation removal is proposed within the Resource Protection Area buffer. Therefore, no further approvals are required under the Chesapeake Bay Preservation Act. 5. Pursuant to Section 34-325 of the Suffolk Code of Ordinances, the Board shall prevent the despoliation and destruction of wetlands while accommodating necessary economic development in a manner consistent with wetlands preservation. Section 34-327 of the Suffolk Code of Ordinances states that a Wetlands Permit may be issued by the Board only if the applicant demonstrates that: a) The anticipated public and private benefi t of the proposed activity exceeds its anticipated public and private detriment. The public and private benefit of the proposed project is anticipated to be greater than the detriment. The proposed project will protect the existing shoreline, which would have a net benefit by reducing the effect of erosion while also promoting the exchange of water, sediment, and wildlife. b) The proposed development conforms with the standards prescribed in Code of Virginia, § 28.2-1308 and guidelines promulgated pursuant to Code of Virginia, § 28.2-1301. i. Wetlands of primary ecological significance shall not be altered so that the ecological systems in the wetlands are unreasonably disturbed. The proposed project includes plantings of Spartina alterniflora that will be protected by the proposed sills. Five-foot gaps are proposed between each sill to allow for the continued ecological exchange between Chuckatuck Creek and tidal wetlands. Therefore, no wetlands, nor their ecological systems, of primary ecological significance are expected to be unreasonably disturbed. ii. Development in Tidewater Virginia, to the maximum extent practical, shall be concentrated in wetlands of lesser ecological significance, in vegetated wetlands which have been irreversibly disturbed before July 1, 1972, in nonvegetated wetlands which have been irreversibly disturbed prior to January 1, 1983, and in areas of Tidewater Virginia outside of wetlands. The shoreline at the project site has experienced shoreline and marsh loss from years of unabated wave energy. This project proposes to reduce marsh loss and would provide a net benefit to the intertidal zone at the project site. c) The proposed activity does not violate the purposes and intent of Chapter 13 Title 28.2 of the Code of Virginia, (§ 28.2-1300 et seq.) and of Article VIII of the Suffolk Code of Ordinances. October 15, 2026 4 The intent of these regulations and th e purpose of the Board is to allow for necessary economic development in a manner consistent with wetlands preservation. The construction of th e proposed living shor eline project is considered to support wetland preservation while also deterring further erosion at the project site. RECOMMENDATION It is staff’s opinion that the pr oposed permit for the construction of a living shoreline meets the requirements established by Section 34-327 of the Su ffolk Code of Ordinances. Therefore, staff recommends approval of permit application SWB2026-00017 with the following conditions: 1. The Wetlands Permit for this project shall expire on October 15, 2027, after which time this permit shall be void. Permit coverage may be extended by the Board, at its discretion, provided that a written request describing the reasons for the extension and the requested new expiration date is submitted to the Suffolk Planning Division no later than August 15, 2027. 2. The permittee shall notify the Board no later than 48 hours prior to the commencement of any work under this permit. 3. The permittee shall comply with all applicab le laws, ordinances, rules, and regulations affecting the conduct of the project. The gr anting of this permit shall not relieve the permittee of the responsibility of obtaining any and all other permits or authority required for the project, including but not limited to approvals from the Department of Environmental Quality, the Virginia Marine Resources Commission, the Army Corps of Engineers, and the City of Suffolk. 4. All phases of the project shall conform in all particulars to the permittee’s application for Wetlands Permit. The duly authorized agents of the Board shall have the right to enter upon the premises at any reasonable time for the purposes of inspecting the work being done pursuant to this permit. 5. The permittee shall, to the greatest extent practical, minimize the adverse effects of the project upon adjacent properties, wetlands, and the natural resources of the Commonwealth. 6. The permittee shall notify the Board no later than one week following the completion of all work under this permit. 7. This permit shall not be transferred without the prior written approval of the Board. 8. This permit may be revoked at any time by th e Board upon the failure of the permittee to comply with any of the terms and conditions hereof. Attachments  General Location Map  Zoning / Land Use Map  Proposed Permit October 15, 2026 5  Exhibit A – Wetlands Board Application Checklist JPA Application  Exhibit B – JPA Application  Exhibit C – Site Plan  Exhibit D – Site Photos  Exhibit E – Oyster CatcherTM Specification Sheets  Exhibit F – SANDBAR Oyster CatcherTM Project Examples Associated State and Federal Permits (included for tracking ONLY): NAO-2026-01131 VMRC2026-1192 CITY OF SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD Wetlands Permit SWB2026-00017 Granted October 15, 2026 Expires October 15, 2027 Pursuant to Chapter 13 of Title 28.2 of the Code of Virginia (1950, as amended) and the City of Suffolk Wetlands Ordinance, the City of Suffolk Wetlands Board, hereinafter referred to as the Board, hereby grants unto Benjamin Johnson, applicant and property owner herein after referred to as the permittee, pe rmission to undertake the following described project. Location: 1504 White Dogwood Trail along Chuckatuck Creek; further identified as Tax Map 5*1. Description of Project: Construction of a living shoreline. Conditions: 1. The Wetlands Permit for this project shall expire on October 15, 2027, after which time this permit shall be void. Permit coverage may be extended by the Board, at its discretion, provided that a written request describing the reasons for the extension and the requested new expiration date is submitted to the Suffolk Planning Division no later than August 15, 2027. 2. The permittee shall notify the Board no later than 48 hours prior to the commencement of any work under this permit. 3. The permittee shall comply with all ap plicable laws, ordinances, rules, and regulations affecting the conduc t of the project. The gran ting of this permit shall not relieve the permittee of the responsibility of obtaining any and all other permits or authority required for the project, including but not limited to approvals from the Department of Environmental Quality, the Virginia Marine Resources Commission, the Army Corps of Engineers, and the City of Suffolk. Associated State and Federal Permits (included for tracking ONLY): NAO-2026-01131 VMRC2026-1192 4. All phases of the project sh all conform in all particulars to the permittee’s application for Wetlands Permit. The duly authorized agents of the Board shall have the right to enter upon the premises at any reasonable time for the purposes of inspecting the work being done pursuant to this permit. 5. The permittee shall, to the greatest extent practical, minimize the adverse effects of the project upon adjacent properties, wetla nds, and the natural resources of the Commonwealth. 6. The permittee shall notify the Board no later than one week following the completion of all work under this permit. 7. This permit shall not be transferred without the prior written approval of the Board. 8. This permit may be revoked at any time by the Board upon the failure of the permittee to comply with any of the terms and conditions hereof. IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the City of Suffolk Wetlands Board has caused these presents to be executed on its behalf by CITY OF SUFFOLK WETLANDS BOARD By:__________________________________ (Chairman or designee) m US Army Corps of Engineers ® Norfolk District • ~!lW VIRO MENTAL QUALITY Regulatory Agency Contact Information Virginia Marine Resources Commission (VMRC) Habitat Management Division 380 Fenwick Road, Building 96 Fort Monroe, VA 23651 Phone: (757) 247-2200, Fax: (757) 247-8062 Website: http://www.mrc.virginia.gov/hmac/hmoverview.shtm United States Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) Norfolk District 803 Front Street, ATTN: CENAO-WR-R Norfolk, Virginia 23510-1011 Phone: (757) 201-7652, Fax: (757) 201-7678 Website: http://www.nao.usace.army.mil/Missions/Regulatory.aspx Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) Virginia Water Protection Permit Program Post Office Box 1105 Richmond, Virginia 23218 Phone: (804) 698-4000 Website: http://www.deq.virginia.gov/ LOCAL WETLANDS BOARD (LWB) CONTACT INFORMATION: Links to LWB information on the Web can be found at http://ccrm.vims.edu/permits_web/guidance/local_wetlands_boards.html In addition, the phone numbers listed below can be used to contact the LWB. Please be advised that these phone numbers are subject to change at any time. Accomack County (757) 787-5721, Cape Charles (757) 331-3259, Charles City County (804) 829- 9296, Chesapeake (757) 382 -6248, Colonial Heights (804) 520- 9275, Essex County (804) 443- 4951, Fairfax County (703) 324- 1364, Fredericksburg (540) 372 -1179, Gloucester County (804) 693-2744, Hampton (757) 727- 6140, Hopewell (804) 541- 2267, Isle of Wight County (757) 365- 6211, James City County (757) 253-6673, King and Queen County (804) 769-4978, King George County (540) 775-7111, King William County (804) 769-4927, Lancaster County (804) 462-5220, Mathews County (804) 725- 5025, Middlesex County (804) 758- 0500, New Kent County (804) 966-9690, Newport News (757) 247 -8437, Norfolk (757) 664 -4368, Northampton County (757) 678-0442, Northumberland County (804) 580-8910, Poquoson (757) 868-3040, Portsmouth (757) 393-8836, Prince William County (703) 792- 6984, Richmond County (804) 333- 3415, Stafford County (540) 658- 8668, Suffolk (757) 923- 3650, Virginia Beach (757) 427- 8246, Westmoreland County (804) 493-0120, West Point (804) 843-3330, Williamsburg (757) 220-6130, York County (757) 890-3538 Application Revised: August 2023 1 Part 1 - General Information (continued) 1. A pplicant’s legal name* and complete mailing address: Contact Information: Home (____)_____________ Work (____)_____________ Fax (____)_____________ Cell (____)_____________ e-mail __________________ State Corporation Commission Name and ID Number (if applicable) _____________ 2. Property owner(s) legal name* and complete address, if different from applicant: Contact Information: Home (____)_____________ Work (____)_____________ Fax (____)_____________ Cell (____)_____________ e-mail __________________ State Corporation Commission Name and ID Number (if applicable) _____________ 3. Authorized agent name * and complete mailing Contact Information: address (if applicable): Home (____)_____________ Work (____)_____________ Fax (____)_____________ Cell (____)_____________ e-mail __________________ State Corporation Commission Name and ID Number (if applicable) _____________ * I f multiple applicants, property owners, and/or agents, each must be listed and each must sign the applica nt s ignature page. 4. P rovide a detailed description of the project in the space below, including the type of project, its dimensions, materials, and method of construction. Be sure to include how the construction site will be accessed and whether tree clearing and/or grading will be required, including the total acreage. If the project requires pilings, please be sure to include the total number, type (e.g. wood, steel, etc), diameter, and method of installation (e.g. hammer, vibratory, jetted, etc). If additional space is needed, provide a separate sheet of paper with the project description. Application Revised: August 2023 6 Part 1 - General Information (continued) 5. Have you obtained a contractor for the project? ___ Yes* ___ No. *If your answer is “Yes” complete the remainder of this question and submit the Applicant’s and Contractor’s Acknowledgment Form (enclosed) Contractor’s name* and complete mailing address: Contact Information: Home (____)_____________ Work (____)_____________ Fax (____)_____________ Cell (____)_____________ email __________________ State Corporation Commission Name and ID Number (if applicable) _____________________ * If multiple contractors, each must be listed and each must sign the applicant signature page. 6. List the name, address and telephone number of the newspaper having general circulation in the area of the project. Failure to complete this question may delay local and State processing. Name and complete mailing address: Telephone number (____) __________________ 7. Give the following project location information: Street Address (911 address if available)_________________________________________ Lot/Block/Parcel#___________________________________________________________ Subdivision________________________________________________________________ City / County___________________________________ ZIP Code_____________________ Latitude and Longitude at Center Point of Project Site (Decimal Degrees): ________________________ / -________________________ (Example: 36.41600/-76.30733) If the project is located in a rural area, please provide driving directions giving distances from the best and nearest visible landmarks or major intersections. Note: if the project is in an undeveloped subdivision or property, clearly stake and identify property lines and location of the proposed project. A supplemental map showing how the property is to be subdivided should also be provided. 8. What are the primary and secondary purposes of and the need for the project? For example, the primary purpose may be “to protect property from erosion due to boat wakes” and the secondary purpose may be “to provide safer access to a pier.” Application Revised: August 2023 7 Part 1 - General Information (continued) 9. Proposed use (check one): ___ Single user (private, non-commercial, residential) ___ Multi-user (community, commercial, industrial, government) 10. Describe alternatives considered and the measures that will be taken to avoid and minimize impacts, to the maximum extent practicable, to wetlands, surface waters, submerged lands, and buffer areas associated with any disturbance (clearing, grading, excavating) during and after project construction. Please be advised that unavoidable losses of tidal wetlands and/or aquatic resources may require compensatory mitigation. 11. Is this application being submitted for after-the-fact authorization for work which has already begun or been completed? ___Yes ___No. If yes, be sure to clearly depict the portions of the project which are already complete in the project drawings. 12. Approximate cost of the entire project (materials, labor, etc.): $___________________________ Approximate cost of that portion of the project that is channelward of mean low water: $____________ 13. Completion date of the proposed work:________________________________-_____________ 14. Adjacent Property Owner Information: List the name and complete mailing address, including zip code, of each adjacent property owner to the project. (NOTE: If you own the adjacent lot, provide the requested information for the first adjacent parcel beyond your property line.) Failure to provide this information may result in a delay in the processing of your application by VMRC. Application Revised: August 2023 8 Part 3 – Appendices (continued) Appendix B: Projects for Shoreline Stabilization in tidal wetlands, tidal waters and dunes/beaches including riprap revetments and associated backfill, marsh toe stabilization, bulkheads and associated backfill, breakwaters, beach nourishment, groins, jetties, and living shoreline projects. Answer all questions that apply. Please provide any reports provided from the Shoreline Erosion Advisory Service or VIMS. NOTE: It is the policy of the Commonwealth that living shorelines are the preferred alternative for stabilizing tidal shorelines (Va. Code § 28.2-104.1). Information on non-structural, vegetative alternatives (i.e., Living Shoreline) for shoreline stabilization is available at http://ccrm.vims.edu/coastal_zone/living_shorelines/index.html. 1. Describe each revetment, bulkhead, marsh toe, breakwater, groin, jetty, other structure, or living shoreline project separately in the space below. Include the overall length in linear feet, the amount of impacts in acres, and volume of associated backfill below mean high water and/or ordinary high water in cubic yards, as applicable: 2. What is the maximum encroachment channelward of mean high water?_______feet. Channelward of mean low water?_______feet. Channelward of the back edge of the dune or beach?_____feet. 3. Please calculate the square footage of encroachment over: • Vegetated wetlands __________square feet • Non-vegetated wetlands __________square feet • Subaqueous bottom __________square feet • Dune and/or beach __________square feet 4. For bulkheads, is any part of the project maintenance or replacement of a previously authorized, currently serviceable, existing structure? ____ Yes____ No. If yes, will the construction of the new bulkhead be no further than two (2) feet channelward of the existing bulkhead? _____Yes ____No. If no, please provide an explanation for the purpose and need for the additional encroachment. Application Revised: August 2023 17 Aerial Image Depicting Proposed Living Shoreline at Johnson and Sons Seafood, 1504 White Dogwood Trail, Suffolk VA A A1 C C1 B B1 Note: A-A1 , B-B1 , C-C1 cross sections detailed in Drawings 5,6,7 of 8 Materials Staging Area Upland Parking Lot Access Utilizing Existing Landing as Foot Access Only, No Heavy Machinery JOHNSON AND SONS SILL PROPOSAL PREPARED FOR THE JAMES RIVER ASSOCIATION LIVING SHORELINE PROJECT VIEW OVER AERIAL DRAWING 1 of 8 9/14/2026 0 10 25 50 SCALE BAR 1” = 50’ 100’ Resource Protection Area NFloodEbbChuckatuck Creek Proposed Sill: 520 LF in sill length (including four (4) five-foot gaps) • Construct a single row of Oyster Catcher Sedimentation Pillows, laid parallel with shoreline, waterward of the extent of wetlands • 4 full rows of Oyster Catcher Tables, plus one 1/2 row of Tables on waterward edge to increase roughness and wave attenuation • Per 100’ Section of Sill, 209 Tables and 25 Pillows. Full project length- 1045 Tables and 125 Pillows • Every 100’, proposed gap baffle (5’) with three (3) plant-able pillows and two (2) Table Pins ( shown on Drawing 3 of 4) EDGE OF MARSH TO UPLANDS JOHNSON AND SONS SILL PROPOSAL PREPARED FOR THE JAMES RIVER ASSOCIATION TOP VIEW–STRUCTURAL DETAIL, 100 LF TYP Section 1:10 Scale DRAWING 3 of 9 9/14/2026 100’ Section of Sill (TYP) Scale 1” = 10 LF (1:10) N MHW 2.6 Ebb Flood MLW 0.0 AREA TO BE PLANTED Chuckatuck Creek EXTENT OF WETLANDS 3.9’ GAP DETAIL- Five-foot gaps, with baffle section, per every 100 Linear Feet of Sill • Gap (5LF Wide) with offset baffle section (5’) with three (3) plant-able pillows (Total 12 LF) and two (2) Tables to serve as Pins (24” base width) TO UPLANDS 100’ Section of Sill (TYP) 100’ Section of Sill (TYP) 5’ Fish Gap JOHNSON AND SONS SILL PROPOSAL PREPARED FOR THE JAMES RIVER ASSOCIATION TOP VIEW–Detail, Gap Baffle TYP Section 1:10 Scale DRAWING 4 of 9 9/14/2026 NChuckatuck Creek Ebb Flood EDGE OF MARSH MHW 2.6’ MLW 0.0’ 3 Plantable Pillows and Two Tables, Every Gap (Offset Baffle) AREA TO BE PLANTED EXTENT OF WETLANDS 3.9’ Scale 1” = 10 LF (1:10) To CHUCKATUCK CREEKTo UPLANDS Marsh floor/mud bottom 22” Max above substrate 12” Pillow JOHNSON AND SONS MARSH SILL PROPOSAL PREPARED FOR THE JAMES RIVER ASSOCIATION CROSS-SECTION VIEW, TYPICAL SILL SECTION, A to A1 DRAWING 5 of 9 9/14/2026 NOT TO SCALE Approx 9 LF Base Width Cross Section Depicting TYP Sill Section One Row of Pillows and 4 ½ Rows of Tables MHW 2.6 MLW 0.0 EXTENT OF WETLANDS 3.9’ 3’ waterward of Edge of Marsh A A1 To CHUCKATUCK CREEKTo UPLANDS Marsh floor/mud bottom 22” Max above substrate 12” Pillow JOHNSON AND SONS MARSH SILL PROPOSAL PREPARED FOR THE JAMES RIVER ASSOCIATION CROSS-SECTION VIEW, TYPICAL SILL SECTION, B to B1 DRAWING 6 of 9 9/14/2026 NOT TO SCALE Approx 9 LF Base Width Cross Section Depicting TYP Sill Section One Row of Pillows and 4 ½ Rows of Tables MHW 2.6 MLW 0.0 EXTENT OF WETLANDS 3.9’ 10’ waterward of Edge of Marsh B B1 TO MLW 0.0To UPLANDS 22” Max above substrate JOHNSON AND SONS MARSH SILL PROPOSAL PREPARED FOR THE JAMES RIVER ASSOCIATION CROSS-SECTION VIEW, TYPICAL SILL SECTION, C to C1 DRAWING 7 of 9 9/14/2026 NOT TO SCALE Cross Section Depicting Gap Baffle Section “Plant-able Pillow” Standard Table TYP Sill Section For reference Marsh floor/mud bottom MHW 2.6 Approx 2.0 LF Base Width EXTENT OF WETLANDS 3.9’ C C1 JOHNSON AND SONS MARSH SILL PROPOSAL PREPARED FOR THE JAMES RIVER ASSOCIATION SUPPLEMENTAL DRAWING SHOWING ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY OWNERS DRAWING 8 of 9 9/14/2026 PROJECT LOCATION 1504 White Dogwood Trail PCWB LLC ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY 1500 White Dogwood Trail John and Angela Frye ADJACENT RIPARIAN PROPERTY 120 Woodfern Lane James and Maureen Brownfiel NEbb Flood JOHNSON AND SONS MARSH SILL PROPOSAL PREPARED FOR THE JAMES RIVER ASSOCIATION SUPPLEMENTAL DRAWING FEMA FLOOD ZONES 9/14/2026PROJECT LOCATION 1504 White Dogwood Trail PCWB LLC NEbbFlood Chuckatuck Creek SUPPLEMENTAL DOCUMENT- ASSESSMENT OF SURGE,SLR, RESILIENCE "Include an assessment of the impacts of storm surge, sea-level rise, climate change, and coastal resilience on the subject property as it relates to the proposed shoreline stabilization methods using NOAA SLOSH and/or AdaptVA” Based on the Seawell's point tide gauge, this area has experienced 0.61ft of sea level rise since 2000 and is anticipated to have around an additional 1 foot of sea level rise by 2050. The intermediate high climate projection shows the water is predicted to be 1.67 feet higher in 2050 than the water levels in 2000. The site is also in a FEMA designated flood zone, Zone VE. Under storm surge for hurricanes categories 1-3, the shoreline is expected to be inundated. For any hurricane with a category 4 strength or higher would, the storm surge would inundate the land and property above the shoreline. While an oyster reef, such as the one that will be created by the Oyster Catcher structures, will reduce these impacts by slowing down waves, it is not anticipated to reduce sea level rise or prohibit storm surge, but the oyster reef can lessen the impacts by slowing the water velocity and wave impacts. The benefit of creating a robust oyster reef is that the oysters reef will grow and adapt overtime and can continue to protect the shoreline from wave and storm surge impacts into the future. Oyster Catcher™ Tables Reef building tables for oyster habitat creation and living shorelines Oyster Catcher™ substrate is a composite of two materials: jute cloth hardened with cements. Our ability to shape the cloth after soaking in a cement slurry allows production of a wide variety of Oyster Catcher™ shapes. Design and Composition Dimensions Our Tables are approximately 2ft L, W, and H. Average Table weight is 25-30 lbs. They offer exceptional reef design versatility and can be interlocked for increased stability even in high energy environments and during storm events. Structural Features The initial open space of Table reef frameworks rapidly infills as oysters grow on and among tables. The surfaces of Oyster Catcher™ elements are deeply textured making them highly attractive to oyster larvae and protective for young oysters. The rough surface of Table legs acts to lock Tables in place once the legs are partially sunk into bottom sediments. Pricing The Table price is $130plus shipping and handling and applicable taxes. (Prices for 2026) Oyster Catcher™ Pillows Sediment accumulation pillows for oyster habitat creation and living shorelines Oyster Catcher™ substrate is a composite of two materials: jute cloth hardened with cements. Our ability to shape the cloth after soaking in a cement slurry allows production of a wide variety of Oyster Catcher™ shapes. Design and Composition Dimensions Our Pillows are approximately 4ft wide and 1 foot tall and wide. Average pillow weight is 30-35 lbs. They offer exceptional structure, sediment accumulation and stability even in high energy environments and during storm events. Structural Features Pillows are deeply textured making them highly attractive and protective to oyster larvae and young oysters. Pillows are paired with Oyster Catcher™ Tables to produce a living shoreline that will protect shorelines from damaging wave energy and trap sediment behind the sill. Pricing The Pillow price is $150 plus shipping and handling and applicable taxes (prices for 2026) SANDBAR Oyster Catcher Marsh Sill/Living Shorelines A few examples of past projects involving larger fetch areas August 2026 Example #1 NC Aquarium at Pine Knoll Shores Installed early 2025 Over 2 miles in fetch NC Aquarium Pine Knoll Shores Example #1 Continued Image early 2025, depicting install NC Aquarium Pine Knoll Shores Example #1 Continued Picture- December 2025, 8-9 months months after install sediment captured (no fill was placed) August 2026 NC Aquarium Pine Knoll Shores August 2026 sediment capture/retention NC Aquarium Pine Knoll Shores Example #1 Continued Image August 2026, about 16 months after install NC Aquarium Pine Knoll Shores Example #1 Continued Picture- Sediment capture and increasing vegetation August 2026 NC Aquarium Pine Knoll Shores- Example 1 continued Example #2 SANDBAR Oyster Lease Newport River Installed 2019-2020 Example #2 continued SANDBAR Oyster Lease Newport River Site began as a unvegetated subtidal sandbar Example #2 continued SANDBAR Oyster Lease Newport River Site began as a unvegetated subtidal sandbar Example #2 continued SANDBAR Oyster Lease Newport River Site began as a unvegetated subtidal sandbar Example #3 Homeowner Project Newport, NC Installed 2023 Example #3 continued Homeowner Project Newport, NC Installed 2023, Photo 2026 Example #3 continued Homeowner Project Newport, NC Installed 2023, Photo 2026 Example #3 continued Homeowner Project Newport, NC Installed 2023, Photo 2026 Example #4 Wachapreague, VA Installed 2023 1.5 mi fetch PHOTO October 2025 August 2026 Example #4 Wachapreague, VA Installed 2023 Example #4 Wachapreague, VA Installed 2023, Photo 2026 Example #4 Wachapreague, VA Installed 2023, Photo 2026 Example #5 Homeowner Project Salvo NC (OBX) Pillow-based sill (No oyster catcher tables on this project) Installed 2026 Example #5 Homeowner Project Salvo NC (OBX) View of fetch from shore, 2026 Example #5 Homeowner Project Salvo NC (OBX) Installation of Pillow-based sill at low tide Example #5 Homeowner Project Salvo NC (OBX) Installation of Pillow-based sill at low tide Example #5 Homeowner Project Salvo NC (OBX) One month after installation Pillow-based sill disappears under high tide Example #5 Homeowner Project Salvo NC (OBX) One month after installation Pillow-based sill disappears under high tide Example #5 Homeowner Project Salvo NC (OBX) One month post installation Sill disappears under high tide Example #6 Homeowner Project Morehead City NC Installed 2023 Example #6 Homeowner Project Morehead City NC Installed 2023 Example #6 Homeowner Project Morehead City NC Installed 2023, Photo 2026 Example #6 Homeowner Project Morehead City NC Installed 2023, Photo 2026

Source: City of Suffolk website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.