RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Work Session — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Planning Commission · meeting of Sep 22, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Planning Commission Meeting Agenda September 22, 2026 100 5th Street Northeast City Space Conference Room Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 Carl Schwarz, Chair Danny Yoder, Vice Chair Ross Harness Hosea Mitchell Betsy Roettger Lyle Solla-Yates Josh Carp Michael Joy I. Commission Work Session Beginning: 5:00 p.m. Location: (Cityspace, 100 5th Street NE, Charlottesville, VA 22902) 1. Comprehensive Plan Five Year Review II. Future Meeting Schedule/Adjournment Tuesday October 13 - 5:30 PM - Regular Meeting Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call the ADA Coordinator at (434) 970-3185 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide a 48 hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made. Planning Commission pre-meeting and regular meetings are held in person and by Zoom webinar. The webinar is broadcast on Comcast Channel 10 and on all the City's streaming platforms including: Facebook, Twitter, and www.charlottesville.gov/streaming. Public hearings and other matters from the public will be heard via the Zoom webinar which requires advanced registration here: www.charlottesville.gov/zoom . You may also participate via telephone and a number is provided with the Zoom registration or by contacting staff at 434-970-3182 to ask for the dial in number for each meeting. Written comments may be submitted via email to planningcommission@charlottesville.gov. Page 1 of 39 City of Charlottesville Neighborhood Development Services Department PLANNING COMMISSION WORK SESSION Subject: Comprehensive Plan 5-Year Review Draft Scope Staff Contacts: Tori Kanellopoulos, NDS Long-Range Principal Planner Date: September 22, 2026 Background In November 2021, City Council formally adopted the City’s Comprehensive Plan (“Comp Plan”). Since then, there have been several amendments thereto, including adopting the Climate Action Plan and the Parks & Recreation Master Plan. Per Virginia State Code §15.2-2230, each locality must review its Comprehensive Plan at least every five years to determine whether it is advisable to amend the Comp Plan. While there have been several amendments to the City’s Comp Plan to date, it is best practice to complete a review of the Comp Plan every five years and determine if additional changes are needed. The purpose of this work session is to share an overview of the draft scope of work for the City’s Comp Plan 5-year review process and ask for the Planning Commission’s feedback to inform the final scope. Staff Analysis The attached presentation provides an overview of the general expectations for the content of Virginia localities’ Comp Plans and their reviews, the City’s draft process and approach for reviewing the City’s Comp Plan, initial existing conditions data, and project objectives. The Comp Plan review is an opportunity to evaluate and respond to challenges, opportunities, and emerging issues that have been identified since the City adopted the updated Comp Plan in 2021. Page 2 of 39 The Comp Plan review will be informed by feedback and expertise from City staff, community members, the Planning Commission, and City Council, along with qualitative and quantitative data, State Code requirements, and best practices. This will include: • Updating existing conditions data and trends • Incorporating any new State Code requirements • Alignment with City plans that have been completed since November 2021 and coordinating with in-progress plans that are moving in parallel • Evaluating strategies and priorities and where changes are needed • Opportunities for community input and information-sharing throughout the process The existing conditions data that is provided in the attached presentation is a summary of initial findings on regional trends, development patterns, and affordable housing. As staff continues to scope the Comp Plan, staff will continue to collect and analyze data to inform the Comp Plan review. The community, Planning Commission, and Council will be informed throughout the project, and will be engaged at key points to ask for input and feedback. Staff will provide regular project status updates and share upcoming opportunities for engagement, including through a future Connect Charlottesville page. Staff will hold work sessions with the Planning Commission and will share the Commission’s recommendations and feedback with Council at corresponding work sessions. This work session is an early step in the process to ask for Planning Commission feedback on the draft scope. Staff will hold a work session with Council later this fall to ask the same questions and will share a summary of the Commission’s feedback from today’s work session. Staff would anticipate the 5-year review process to formally kick off in early 2027. Staff Recommendation Staff is asking for the Planning Commission’s feedback on key questions to determine the Comp Plan 5-year review scope, which are on presentation slides 35 and 36. Attachments A. Presentation for September 22, 2026 Page 3 of 39 Comprehensive Plan 5-Year Review Planning Commission Work Session September 22, 2026 Page 4 of 39 Agenda • Review of the Cville Plans Together process • Comprehensive Plans: purpose, how implemented, topics included • 5-year review of Comp Plans for Virginia localities • Draft process and approach for how the City will review the 2021 Comprehensive Plan • Initial existing conditions data • Project objectives for the 5-year review • Planning Commission input: key questions to determine the project scope Page 5 of 39 Cville Plans Together • Affordable Housing Plan • Comprehensive Plan • Development Code Page 6 of 39 Cville Plans Together Process (March 2021) (Nov 2021) (In effect as of Feb 2024) Was a community process for updating the future vision for the city, with a focus on equity and affordability.    Page 7 of 39 Cville Plans Together Process: Affordable Housing Plan Vision: The City of Charlottesville will achieve a local housing market that is healthy,high quality, affordable, and above all, equitable. Guiding Principles: • Racial Equity • Regional Collaboration • Comprehensive Approach Major Initiatives: • Dedicate $10M annually to affordable housing • Build inclusive governance at all levels • Adopt progressive and inclusionary zoning reforms Recommendations related to: • Funding, Governance, Land Use, Tenants' Rights, and Subsidy Page 8 of 39 Cville Plans Together Process: Comprehensive Plan Five Guiding Principles These are community-input-driven priorities that apply to the entire Plan. Equity & Opportunity Community Culture & Unity Local & Regional Collaboration Environmental Stewardship & Sustainability Connections & Access Page 9 of 39 Comprehensive Plan Priority Areas Six Priority Areas For Implementation • Support the development of more housing throughout the city, with a focus on creation of more housing that is affordable to more people, especially those with the greatest need. • Make sure all people have access to shelter, food, job opportunities, and other resources they need to thrive and succeed. • Work to both mitigate and prepare for theimpacts of climate change. • Make it safer, easier, and more desirable towalk, ride a bicycle, utilize public transportation, or use other non-single-occupancy vehicle transportation options. • Keep Charlottesville green, make it greener, and protect the natural environment and the many benefits it provides. • Continue to evolve and improvecommunication and collaboration. Page 10 of 39 Comprehensive Plan Future Land Use Objectives • Build upon land use recommendations from other plans. • Ensure citywide, equitable opportunities for additional housing. • Increase opportunities for development near community hubs and amenities, to maximize access. • Explore the potential of vacant or underutilized properties. • Establish correlations between the City’s land uses, UVA, and the County’s Urban Ring. • Increase access to transit, as well as walking and biking infrastructure. • Protect, preserve, and enhance natural and cultural resources. • Ensure long term economic sustainability of the City by planning for a wide range of commercial land use types. Page 11 of 39 Cville Plans Together Process: Development Code • Informed by guidance and recommendations in the Comprehensive Plan • Changes from the previous ordinance (2003) include: • Allowing more 'missing middle' and multifamily housing by-right • No minimum parking requirements • Updated affordable housing requirements that apply to projects with 10 or more units • More focused on form and urban design Page 12 of 39 Draft Approach and Scope for the Comprehensive Plan 5- Year Review Page 13 of 39 What is a Comprehensive Plan? • Establishes a 20-year vision with recommendations to guide growth, development, and public infrastructure, amenities, and services. • Comp Plans have recommendations for how and where localities should grow, supporting local economic development, protecting and restoring natural and historic resources, and guiding decisions on providing public infrastructure (such as schools, roads, sidewalks, parks, and utilities). • Recommendations in the Comprehensive Plan are used to guide: • Initiating and evaluating plans, policies, and programs • Developing the capital improvement program (CIP) • Evaluating and developing local ordinance changes (e.g. zoning, water protection) • Review of certain applications Page 14 of 39 What topic areas does a Comprehensive Plan provide guidance for? Comp Plan recommendations support the City's Vision Statement: To be a place where everyone thrives, by guiding how and where the city should accommodate projected population and employment growth and the delivery of the infrastructure, amenities, and services to provide current and future community members with a high quality of life. State Code provides a framework of requirements to include in Comprehensive Plans, and localities can then choose how to meet those requirements and how to organize their plan. Topics typically include: Page 15 of 39 How often are Comprehensive Plans reviewed or updated? • Virginia State Code requires localities to review their Comprehensive Plans every 5 years and leaves it up to each locality to determine what level of changes (if any) are needed to their Plans. • For example, some localities may only update one chapter or review their Plan and decide no changes are needed, while others may rewrite the whole Plan. Localities also need to review Virginia State Code to determine if there are any new State Code provisions that are applicable to incorporate into their Comp Plan review. • This review is an important opportunity to evaluate changing conditions, emerging issues, updated priorities, any revised population and employment projections, and progress on current Plan implementation. Page 16 of 39 What is the City's process for reviewing the Comp Plan? The process is still being scoped, and an initial outline is provided below. There will be opportunities for community participation throughout the process, along with work sessions and finally public hearings with the Planning Commission and City Council. Page 17 of 39 How is the City approaching this Comp Plan review? The Comp Plan review is an opportunity to evaluate and respond to challenges, opportunities, and emerging issues that have been identified since the 2021 Comp Plan and subsequent Development Code. • Recent (past 6-12 months) community feedback shows support for previously identified values and goals, such as housing affordability and multimodal transportation, but differing opinions on the best ways to achieve those outcomes. • Larger projects close to "core neighborhoods" have drawn concerns especially regarding the potential for displacement and neighborhood change. • There is limited information to date on Development Code implementation, as the Code has only been in effect since February 2024 and development applications have had limited time to fully move through the process. • There is continued community interest in topics that relate to and support land use and housing, including transportation, protecting the natural environment and historic resources, and parks/recreation. Page 18 of 39 How is the City approaching this Comp Plan review? The Comp Plan review is an opportunity to coordinate with the range of parallel City projects that are either completed or in progress, which cover many of the 2021 Plan chapters. Page 19 of 39 How is the City approaching this Comp Plan review? Updated data and existing conditions analysis is needed to inform this project and respond to challenges, opportunities, and emerging issues. An overview of the in-progress initial existing conditions analysis is provided below and additional data for other topics will be gathered and analyzed throughout the project. • Where have development and redevelopment been occurring? • Types of development being built (including types of housing units) and distribution across the city • How many affordable housing units have been built, and where? • Including comparison of on-site vs paying in-lieu fees • Where are development and redevelopment likely to occur moving forward? • Buildout analysis • Noting constraining factors, including financial feasibility and property owner decisions on whether or not to develop • What are the changing demographics of our community? • Who is at most risk of displacement (e.g. cost-burdened households) Page 20 of 39 Initial Data: Existing Conditions Analysis Page 21 of 39 Regional Considerations The following data and key takeaways were provided by Hamilton Lombard (Demographer): • For housing costs: Charlottesville metropolitan statistical area (MSA) has become one of the most expensive metro areas in the Eastern U.S. • Growth in upper-income households in Charlottesville MSA has increased at a faster pace than in the U.S. overall. • Few U.S. metro areas rely more on the Education and Health employment sectors than Charlottesville. From the 2026 'State of the Community' Presentation: Median home value by MSA, American Community Survey (ACS) 2023 (1-year estimates); Charlottesville area highlighted with navy blue circle Page 22 of 39 Regional Considerations The following data and key takeaways were provided by Hamilton Lombard (Demographer): • An increasing share of the Charlottesville region's workers live outside of Albemarle County and the City of Charlottesville. Of the 352 U.S. urban areas with 100,000+ population, only the Boulder MSA has a higher % of daytime population change, which is from in-commuters; Charlottesville MSA is second highest. • The availability of relatively higher income jobs within the Charlottesville area (e.g. healthcare, finance, biotech) along with the relatively lower cost of housing in surrounding localities and regions, is one of the reasons for this trend. This is occurring along with workers who are unable to afford the cost of housing in the Charlottesville area and therefore live further away. 2010 2023 Change in median household income From the 2026 'State of the Community' Presentation:American Community Survey (ACS) 2010 and 2023 (1-year estimates) Page 23 of 39 Where have development and redevelopment been occurring? • Total completed residential units 2021-2025: approx. 744 units • Staff were able to estimate the total number of units completed in the past 5 years and anticipate having 10+ years of completed units in future iterations of this data analysis Completed units by type of unit 2021-2025 Single-family detached (red) 108 Single-family attached (blue) 47 Two family dwelling (purple) 17 Additional dwelling unit (orange) 14 Multifamily (apartment, condo, multistory unit) (green) 558 Manufactured housing unit 0 Approximate distribution of completed units by type 2021- 2025, using Cityworks permit data Page 24 of 39 2023 Development Code: Projects Approved, In Progress, or Under Review 2023 Development Code Completed permits (built) Permits in progress / under construction Permits under review 47 47 27 • Development Dashboard (left) shows projects that are approved, under review, and under construction. This snapshot only shows projects that are moving forward under the 2023 Development Code, as of August 2026 • Since the Dashboard is pulling from permit data, there are several non-residential projects included on the map as they have associated permits/plans (e.g. building modifications, bus stops, hotels) Access the dashboard here: https://www.charlottesville.gov/1902/Development-Map Page 25 of 39 2023 Development Code: Completed Projects Map and Pie Chart: Completed residential permits by unit type that were approved under the 2023 Development Code Page 26 of 39 Affordable Housing Units Estimates • Total Affordable Units Completed 2009-2026: 561 • 85% of completed affordable units built in three neighborhoods: Belmont-Carlton, Ridge Street, & North Downtown • 83% of affordable units in pipeline in three neighborhoods: North Downtown, 10th & Page, & Ridge Street Affordable Units by Neighborhood 2009-2026 Belmont-Carlton 212 Ridge Street 160 North Downtown 106 Starr Hill 62 10th & Page 15 Fry's Spring 4 Woolen Mills 2 Total 561 Affordable Units Under Construction, Approved, and Under Review by Neighborhood North Downtown 288 10th & Page 264 Ridge Street 157 Fifeville 71 Locust Grove 53 The Meadows 19 Total 852 Page 27 of 39 Affordable Housing In Lieu Fees • Total Affordable Housing In Lieu Fees (for completed projects) 2009-2026: $2,702,304 • In Lieu Fees for projects Under Construction: $11,103,080 • In Lieu Fees for projects Under Review: $8,160,685 Page 28 of 39 Measuring Neighborhood and Demographic Change • There are multiple ways to estimate which areas may be at a greater risk of future displacement and to measure where neighborhood change has been occurring. Examples of data that can be used include: • Cost-burdened households (spending more than 30% of income on housing costs) • Demographics (e.g. age, race/ethnicity) • Median household income • Poverty rate and ALICE (Asset Limited, Income Constrained, Employed) • Lack of health insurance • Health indicators and outcomes • Educational attainment • Limited English Proficiency Page 29 of 39 Measuring Neighborhood and Demographic Change • The 2021 Comp Plan uses the designation of 'Sensitive Communities' to identify areas estimated to be at a greater risk of displacement • Comp Plan used the following criteria to identify which Census Block Groups were designated: • Areas that are General Residential on the Future Land Use Map, and • Have a relatively high proportion of households with income less than $30,000/year (which was about 30% Area Median Family Income or 50% Area Median Household Income) and Black residents, Hispanic residents, and other residents who do not identify as White and Non- Hispanic (ACS 2018 5-year estimates) • Comp Plan recommends revisiting the methodology for identifying communities at risk of displacement with each 5-year Plan review • This information can be used to help inform Comp Plan recommendations and priorities • The next two slides include updated income distribution and housing cost-burdened data for Charlottesville. Additional data sources to measure change and displacement risks will be identified during the Comp Plan review process Page 30 of 39 Charlottesville: Change in Income Distribution • Consistent with Hamilton Lombard's regional findings, the income distribution is shifting towards higher incomes • This data does include University of Virginia students that live in Charlottesville. American Community Survey (ACS) 5-year Census data for 2015-2019 and 2020-2024. Incomes are not adjusted for inflation. Page 31 of 39 Charlottesville: Housing Costs • Using 2024 5-Year American Community Survey data, approximately 40% of all Charlottesville households are considered cost-burdened (paying more than 30% of household income toward housing costs), including: • 21.3% of homeowner households and • 55.5% of renter households Page 32 of 39 Example: Charlotte NC Comprehensive Plan • The City is reviewing Comp Plans from a variety of localities to inform best practices, including Charlotte, NC • As part of their Comprehensive Plan update, the City of Charlotte developed an Equitable Growth Framework with a variety of mapping and data analysis tools, including a 'populations vulnerable to displacement overlay' • Charlotte used this data analysis to identify areas where residents and businesses may not have access to daily needs, choices for housing, a diversity of employment, or safe and healthy environments 1. Informed the development of Goals and supporting Policies, Projects and Programs in the Comprehensive Plan 2. Identified priorities for Community Planning Areas for subsequent mapping and planning efforts within sub-geographies throughout the community 3. Assessing and tracking progress towards becoming a more equitable, fair and just city over the next 20 years Page 33 of 39 Example: Charlotte NC Comprehensive Plan • Populations vulnerable to displacement overlay map shown to the right. The analysis identifies residents that have characteristics that tend to make them more vulnerable to potential displacement. This map was one in a series of Charlotte's Equitable Growth Framework. • Four measures have been documented as major contributors to vulnerability to displacement and are used to identify the areas with the most vulnerable populations across Charlotte: • Poverty Rate; • Educational Attainment; • Race; and • Age Page 34 of 39 Determining the Scope for the Comp Plan 5-Year Review Page 35 of 39 Comprehensive Plan 5-Year Review: Objectives The City's approach to this Comp Plan review informed the project objectives, which are outlined on this and the following slide: • Review and potentially update the City's Comprehensive Plan to meet the State Code requirement for the 5-year review • Update existing conditions and trends data, including updated population and employment projections • Incorporate any new (since Nov 2021) State Code requirements for Comp Plans that apply to the City • Align any Comp Plan updates with City plans that have been completed since Nov 2021 (e.g. Climate Action Plan, Parks and Rec Master Plan) Page 36 of 39 Comprehensive Plan 5-Year Review: Objectives • Evaluate current Plan strategies and priorities and where changes are needed • This would include any potential major policy or other substantive Plan changes • The community will be informed throughout the Comp Plan review process and will be asked to provide feedback at key points; this is an area where community feedback will be especially important • Establish a process for regular tracking and reporting on Plan metrics and implementation progress, in coordination with the City's Strategy Office • Establish a framework and approach for Small Area Planning • Coordinate across related projects that will be moving in parallel (e.g. Mobility Plan) Page 37 of 39 Questions for Determining the Comp Plan Review Scope • Does the 2021 Comp Plan land use vision still align with today's community priorities and meet current community needs? If changes are needed, what outcomes are desired and what should they address? • Would you anticipate the need to significantly change the Comp Plan and/or Development Code approaches? Page 38 of 39 Questions for Determining the Comp Plan Review Scope • What are the main challenges, opportunities, and emerging issues that should be addressed with the Comp Plan review? Staff would recommend building on the initial list as outlined in this presentation and summarized below: • Address continued concern about displacement and neighborhood change, especially in/around 'core neighborhoods'. • Increase multimodal transportation options to support new development and redevelopment (noting that the Comp Plan review will be coordinated with the Mobility Plan). • Address barriers to housing development (esp. missing middle housing) while protecting the natural environment, ensuring the city has high quality public infrastructure and buildings, and supporting walkability and quality of place. • Align Comp Plan with new (since 2021) plans, streamlining and updating Comp Plan strategies where possible. • Revisit limited and smaller-scale commercial uses in residential districts. • Provide opportunities for community members to learn and understand how the City makes decisions and what tools are available, building on the Community Engagement chapter. Page 39 of 39

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.