RecordWell Data

City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · City Council · meeting of Sep 21, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

City Council Meeting Agenda September 21, 2026 City Hall Council Chamber 605 E. Main St. Charlottesville, VA 22902 Juandiego R. Wade, Mayor Natalie Oschrin, Vice Mayor Jen Fleisher Michael K. Payne J. Lloyd Snook, III Kyna Thomas, Clerk 4:00 PM Opening Session I. Call to Order/Roll Call II. Agenda Approval III. Reports 1. Presentation: Parks & Recreation Master Plan Updates 2. Report: Historic Resources Committee Annual Report 5:30 PM Closed Meeting (if called) 6:30 PM Business Session IV. Moment of Silence V. Announcements VI. Recognitions/Proclamations • Proclamation: Week Without Driving: October 1-8 VII. Community Matters Public comment for up to 16 speakers (limit 3 minutes per speaker). Preregistration available for first 8 spaces at https://www.charlottesville.gov/692/Request-to-Speak; speakers announced by Noon on meeting day (9:00 a.m. sign-up deadline). Additional public comment at end of meeting. Comments on Public Hearing items are heard during the public hearing only. VIII. Consent Agenda* The consent agenda consists of routine, non-controversial items whereby all items are passed with a single motion and vote. Individuals speaking during Community Matters may address items on the Consent Agenda. 3. Resolution: Resolution to Appropriate $450,707 in Dockless Mobility Revenue for Bicycle Programming (2nd reading) 4. Resolution: FY 2027 Budget Amendments and Appropriation of $300,252 of Additional General Fund Revenue (2nd reading) 5. Resolution: Resolution to Appropriate Virginia Juvenile Community Crime Control Act Grant (VJCCCA) $452,704 (2nd reading) 6. Resolution: Resolution for the Draft Program Year 2025-26 (“PY25”) Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (“CAPER”) (2nd reading) 7. Ordinance: Ordinance amending City Code Chapter 2, Article XVI. - Police Civilian Oversight Board (2nd reading) 8. Resolution: Resolution to Authorize a Special Exception Permit for Roof-Mounted Equipment (323 2nd Street SE) Page 1 of 240 9. Resolution: Resolution to Appropriate $200,000 in TAP Grant Funding from the Virginia Department Transportation (VDOT) Funding for the Meadowcreek Trail Project (1 of 2 readings) 10. Resolution: Resolution to appropriate funds from the Virginia Department of Housing and Community Development - Virginia Homeless Solutions Program - $441,796 (1 of 2 readings) 11. Resolution: Resolution to appropriate State Historic Resources Grant Funds to Jefferson School African American Heritage Center - $500,000 (1 of 2 readings) 12. Resolution: Resolution to appropriate funds from the Charlottesville/Albemarle Adult Drug Treatment Court Grant Award - $227,892 (1 of 2 readings) IX. City Manager Report • Report: City Manager Report a. Report: Participatory Budgeting Pilot Update X. Action Items 13. Public Hearing/Res.: Public Hearing and Resolution for the Draft Program Year 2025-26 (“PY25”) Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (“CAPER”) (2nd reading) 14. Public Hearing/Res.: Public Hearing for a Proposed CDBG-Funded Activity, the 2026 BEACON Kitchen Accessibility Enhancements Project, a Substantial Amendment to the Program Year 2026-27 Annual Action Plan, in the Amount of $55,000 (2nd reading) 15. Public Hearing/Res.: Public Hearing for a Proposed CDBG-Funded Activity, the 2026 IX Arts Foundation Accessibility Enhancements Planning Grant, a Substantial Amendment to the Program Year 2026-27 Annual Action Plan in the Approximate Amount of $25,000.00 (2nd reading) 16. Resolution: Resolution to Appropriate Revenue from Participation in Energy Load Reduction Program in the Amount of $12,375.53 (1 of 2 readings) 17. Resolution: Resolution to Temporarily Reallocate $1,000,000 from the Kindlewood Phase 3 Project to Piedmont Housing Alliance (PHA) for a Loan Payment for Carlton Mobile Home Park Loan XI. General Business XII. Community Matters (2) XIII. Adjournment Page 2 of 240 MEETING GUIDELINES • This is an in-person meeting with an option for the public to participate electronically by registering in advance for the Zoom webinar at www.charlottesville.gov/zoom. The meeting may also be viewed on the City's streaming platforms and local government Channel 10. Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide 48 hours’ notice so that proper arrangements may be made. • The presiding officer shall ensure that individuals address their comments to City Council at appropriate times, in accordance with the meeting agenda and Council’s Rules of Procedure. • No person who is not a member of the city council shall orally address it until leave to do so has been granted by the city council or until invited to do so by the mayor. (City Code sec.2-71) • Remarks and actions that disrupt the progress of the Council meeting, and remarks from persons other than councilors, the City Manager, the City Attorney, or a presenter for an Agenda Item are not permitted. • The presiding officer shall call an individual to order, including a councilor, when that individual goes afoul of these rules. The following are examples of remarks and behavior that are not permitted: i. Interrupting a speaker who is addressing Council at the speaker's microphone, or interrupting a speaker who has otherwise been invited to address Council during Community Matters or a Public Hearing ii. Interrupting a councilor who is speaking iii. Shouting, and talking (either individually or in concert with others) in a manner that prevents a speaker or a Councilor from being heard or that otherwise hinders the progress of the meeting iv. Blocking paths for emergency exit from the meeting room; engaging in any conduct that prevents a member of the audience from seeing or hearing councilors during a meeting; standing on chairs or tables within the Council meeting room v. Threats or incitement of violence toward councilors, City staff or members of the public vi. Engaging in conduct that is a criminal offense under the City Code or the Virginia Code vii. Campaigning for elected office viii. Promotion of private business ventures ix. Using profanity or vulgarity x. Personal attacks against Councilors, City staff or members of the public xi. Behavior which tends to intimidate others • During a City Council meeting the presiding officer shall have control of the Council Chambers and the connecting halls and corridors within City Hall, and any other venue where a Council meeting is being held. In case of any conduct described above, the presiding officer may take measures deemed appropriate, including but not limited to suspending the meeting until order is restored, ordering areas to be cleared by the Sergeant at Arms, or requiring any individual to exit the meeting room and adjacent premises (connecting halls and corridors.) Page 3 of 240 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Parks & Recreation Master Plan Updates Staff Contact(s): Riaan Anthony, Director of Parks & Recreation, Katie Lockhart, Deputy Director of Parks Presenter: Riaan Anthony, Director of Parks & Recreation Date of Proposed Action: September 21, 2026 Issue Parks & Recreation Master Plan updates and look ahead. Background / Rule Analysis Financial Impact N/A; staff report to Council. Financial impact will include any funds appropriated for Master Plan project work. Recommendation Receive as information. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) N/A; staff report to Council Attachments 1. Parks & Recreation Master Plan Updates Page 4 of 240 C VA CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION Parks & Recreation Master Plan Updates September 21, 2026 A 10-year framework for equitable, resilient and joyful public spaces. Page 5 of 240 MASTER PLAN UPDATE Meeting Agenda 01 Welcome and Background 02 Mission, vision, and values 03 10 –Year CIP 04 Expanded Service Projects 05 Visionary Projects 06 Non-Resident Fees CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION • SEPTEMBER 15, 2026 Page 6 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Executive Summary A concise view of the adopted plan, investment horizon and decisions ahead. $78.2M 10-year capital program 3 project tiers 10 YEARS adopted April 7, 2025 SCOPE Strategic framework • Financial plan • Major projects • Fee policy Plan lens Equity Resiliency Sustainability Community engagement PARKS & RECREATION MASTER PLAN • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 Page 7 of 240 MASTER PLAN UPDATE Mission, Vision, and Values MISSION To serve and enhance our community through inclusive spaces, recreational experiences, and exceptional public service. VISION Creating a happy, healthy community for all. VALUES Professionalism Accountability Respect Knowledge Service CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION • SEPTEMBER 15, 2026 Page 8 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Executive Summary A concise view of the adopted plan, investment horizon and decisions ahead. $78.2M 10-year capital program 3 project tiers 10 YEARS adopted April 7, 2025 SCOPE Strategic framework • Financial plan • Major projects • Fee policy Plan lens Equity Resiliency Sustainability Community engagement PARKS & RECREATION MASTER PLAN • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 Page 9 of 240 05 / COST ESTIMATING $78.18M across three ambition tiers 21% SUSTAINABLE Maintain core assets and service 22% EXPANDED SERVICE Increase reach and quality 57% VISIONARY Transformative long-range concepts Page 10 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Capital Improvement by Project Type 52% Existing developed parks, facilities & trails 32% New shared use paths PARKS & RECREATION MASTER PLAN • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 Page 11 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • 10-Year Capital Improvement Plan FY27–FY31 | First five years FY27 $1,091,250 FY28 $4,128,250 FY29 $3,734,467 FY30 $2,070,934 FY31 $1,215,717 HIGHLIGHTED PROJECTS PARKS & RECREATION MASTER PLAN • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 Page 12 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • 10-Year Capital Improvement Plan FY27–FY31 | First five years FY28 $4,128,250 FY29 $3,734,467 FY30 $2,070,934 FY31 $1,215,717 PARKS & RECREATION MASTER PLAN • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 Page 13 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • FY27 Low-Cost / High-Impact Early investments that improve comfort, identity and everyday use. 01 Washington Park Restroom Schematic design finalized; completion Spring 2026. 02 Signage Plan Three monument sign designs with Burruss Signs. 03 Site Furnishings Benches, picnic tables, grills, trash and dog- waste stations. PARKS & RECREATION MASTER PLAN • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 Page 14 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • FY27 Fifeville Park plan — $150K FY28 Forest Hills Park plan — $700K FY29 Summit Elementary — $250K FY30 Riverview Park — $250K FY31 McIntire Park plan — $175K Playground Highlights FY27–FY33 investment sequence PARKS & RECREATION MASTER PLAN • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 Page 15 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Connect the missing links $4.54M Meadow Creek Valley Trail • FY27 YMCA Link / 250 Bypass — $376K FY27 Pollocks Branch Bridge — $440K FY27 West McIntire Trail — $500K FY28 Holmes to Park Street — $500K FY31 For planning purposes only; not official or legal information. TRAILS + SHARED USE PATHS Page 16 of 240 TRAILS + SHARED USE PATHS Connect the missing links $4.54M Meadow Creek Valley Trail • FY27 YMCA Link / 250 Bypass — $376K FY27 Pollocks Branch Bridge — $440K FY27 West McIntire Trail — $500K FY28 Holmes to Park Street — $500K FY31 For planning purposes only; not official or legal information. CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Page 17 of 240 10 / EXPANDED SERVICE Market Street Park: Swords Into Plowshares FRUIT & SEEDS A baobab art tree anchors an amphitheater, flexible plaza and event lawn—supported by benches, picnic tables, preserved mature trees and renewed planting. A distributed approach could extend elements to Washington, Belmont, Forest Hills or Tonsler parks. CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Page 18 of 240 EXPANDED SERVICE Market Street Park: fruit, seeds and civic life BOABAB TREE . CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Page 19 of 240 EXPANDED SERVICE fruit, seeds and civic life FRUIT & SEEDS . CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Page 20 of 240 1CONCEPTUAL TRANSFORMATION Swords into plowshares BELMONT PARK Baobab Art Seed • a place for reflection and community healing FOREST HILLS PARK A richer park experience through art, shade and gathering CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Page 21 of 240 VISIONARY PROJECT • FEASIBILITY STUDY Adaptive Recreation Center Not a committed construction project. A study of joyful, barrier-free recreation: splash pad, sensory and hide-and-seek play, adaptive swings, balance challenge, adult mobility area, treehouse, ground-level merry-go-round, ziplines and freestyle track / play tower. Accessibility is the design brief—not an add-on. PARKS & RECREATION MASTER PLAN • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Page 22 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE • PARKS & RECREATION • Resident vs. Non-Resident Fee Parity A consistent policy for equity, clarity and predictability RESIDENT BASE RATE NON-RESIDENT +30% STANDARDIZE Staff found gaps in shelters, facility rentals, adult leagues and some admissions. Most programs already use separate rates. The Advisory Board supported advancing this community-input item. PARKS & RECREATION MASTER PLAN • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 Page 23 of 240 CITY COUNCIL WORK SESSION • SEPTEMBER 21, 2026 QUESTIONS THANK YOU Charlottesville Parks & Recreation • charlottesville.gov/parksandrec Page 24 of 240 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Historic Resources Committee Annual Report Staff Contact(s): Jeffrey Werner, Historic Preservation and Design Planner Presenter: Julie Basic Date of Proposed Action: September 21, 2026 Issue Annual report by the Historic Resources Committee on their work over the past year. Background / Rule Presentation will be provided by Julie Basic, current chair of the Historic Resources Committee (HRC). Ms Basic will be presenting the HRC's work from the past year as well as the current work program. Analysis N/A Financial Impact N/A Recommendation N/A Recommended Motion (if Applicable) Attachments None Page 25 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE WEEK WITHOUT DRIVING OCTOBER 1–8, 2026 WHEREAS transportation is essential to full participation in community life, connecting people to workplaces, schools, health care, businesses, family, friends, and the many opportunities that make a community vibrant and connected; and WHEREAS approximately one-third of people in the United States are nondrivers, including older adults, people with disabilities, and individuals who cannot afford the increasing costs of vehicle ownership, fuel, insurance, and maintenance, yet many communities continue to be designed around the assumption that everyone drives; and WHEREAS Week Without Driving invites residents to experience their community from the perspective of a nondriver by choosing, whenever possible, to walk, bike, scoot, ride public transportation, or ask for a ride for a single trip, a day, or the entire week; and WHEREAS the Charlottesville region offers a diverse range of transportation options, including public bus service through Charlottesville Area Transit (CAT), the Afton Express, Jaunt Connect, and the Virginia Breeze intercity bus routes; on-demand rideshare services such as MicroCAT; alternative commuting programs including Wahoo Commute and RideShare’s carpool matching, vanpool coordination, and emergency ride home services; transportation information and referral assistance through the Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission’s Partnership for Accessible Transportation Help (PATH), with a focus on older adults and people with disabilities; and active transportation options including walking, biking, eBiking, and scooters, supported by local bike rentals, lending libraries, and community bike resources; and WHEREAS, launched in 2021 by author and disability advocate Anna Zivarts, Week Without Driving has grown into an international effort, with more than 800 community organizations, public officials, and transit agencies across all fifty states, Canada, and Australia participating in activities that promote awareness, accessibility, and understanding of transportation challenges; and WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville recognizes that learning from the experiences of nondrivers can build empathy, illuminate transportation gaps, and inspire continued investment in a more accessible, equitable, and connected community where everyone has the opportunity to move, participate, and thrive; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT PROCLAIMED that the Charlottesville City Council hereby recognizes October 1–8, 2026, as “Week Without Driving” in the City of Charlottesville and encourages community members to participate by choosing an alternative to driving when possible, supporting transportation options that strengthen accessibility, independence, and connection throughout our community, while also helping to achieve the city’s climate goals. Signed and dated the 21st day of September 2026. ___________________________ Juandiego Wade, Mayor ___________________________ Kyna Thomas, Clerk Page 26 of 240 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Resolution to Appropriate $450,707 in Dockless Mobility Revenue for Bicycle Programming (2nd reading) Staff Contact(s): Ben Chambers, Transportation Planning Manager, Thomas Robert Safranek Presenter: Ben Chambers, Transportation Planning Manager, Thomas Robert Safranek Date of Proposed Action: September 21, 2026 Issue Revenues from the Dockless Mobility Permit Program have been held aside for use for bicycle infrastructure and programming. However, these funds were never appropriated to a specific account. Revenues collected to-date from the Dockless Mobility Permit Program total $410,707. Spending on bicycle infrastructure and programming has previously been funded in the Capital Improvement Plan through the Bicycle Infrastructure account. This account receives bonded revenues, which should be spent on infrastructure and assets only. To provide funding for bicycle programs, like Bike Month programming and promotion, updates to BikeCville.com, helmet giveaways for CCS students, and supporting a regional bike and pedestrian counter system, staff is recommending the creation of a new account, Bicycle Programming. Revenues from the Dockless Mobility Permit Program would be assigned to this account going forward. From the $410,706.80 in existing revenues, a portion ($184,909) would be assigned to the Bicycle Infrastructure account to cover expenses incurred since the beginning of the Dockless Mobility Permit Program, in 2019. The remaining revenues ($225,798) would be assigned to the new Bicycle Programming account. Background / Rule Since 2019, the Dockless Mobility Permit Program has created $410,707. Prior to 2023, the City’s permit regulations required additional per-vehicle fees and higher per-ride fees, earning an average of $58,000 per year. With changes to the permit regulations adopted in 2023, revenues have lowered to $41,327 in 2024 and $42,128 in 2025. Assuming consistent demand and continued service from the current provider, Veo, staff would anticipate the City would continue to see revenues from this program consistent with more recent years. Staff estimates $40,000 will be collected for FY 2027. While the Dockless Mobility Permit pilot did identify the revenues from the program as being dedicated to bicycle infrastructure and programming, these revenues were never specifically appropriated to any budget for bicycle infrastructure. The Dockless Mobility Permit Revenues were also not appropriated to the general fund. Bicycle infrastructure and programs have, since the initial hiring of a bicycle and pedestrian coordinator in 2012, been funded using the Bicycle Infrastructure CIP account. However, the revenues from this account are bonded, which means they should be used for infrastructure and assets, and not programming needs. Analysis Rather than review all past purchase orders to determine which past expenses should be funded with bonded revenues and which should be funded with the Dockless Mobility Permit Program revenues, staff summarized all expenses for the Bicycle Infrastructure account and recommends that the full amount of these expenses ($184,909) be appropriated from the Dockless Mobility Permit Program revenues to the balance of the Bicycle Infrastructure CIP account. These expenses include $59,909 in purchases through the account, as well as re-appropriations of $75,000 in 2025 and $50,000 in 2026 of Page 27 of 240 funds to the E-bike Voucher Program account. Future uses of this account would be restricted to bicycle infrastructure, including implementation of protected bicycle facilities, long-term and short-term bicycle parking, and expansion of the city’s school bike fleet. The remaining $225,798 would be appropriated into the new Bicycle Programming CIP account. These funds would be used for programming associated with events like Bike Month and e-bike demonstrations, community resources like helmet giveaways for City students and updates to BikeCville.com, and supporting the development of a regional bicycle and pedestrian counter system. Revenues from the Dockless Mobility Permit Program would continue to support this new account and no additional funding requests would be anticipated outside that revenue source. Financial Impact This action seeks to appropriate $450,707 in dockless mobility permit revenue collected in prior years and $40,000 anticipated to be collected in FY 2027. $265,798 will be appropriated to a new Bicycle Programming account and $184,909 will be appropriated to Bicycle Infrastructure account. The funds will used to support bicycle programming and ensure that the City is following best practices in the use of bonded revenues. No impacts to the City’s general fund or capital budget revenues are anticipated from this action. Recommendation Staff recommends the creation of the Bicycle Programming CIP account, the appropriation of existing Dockless Mobility Permit Program revenues to the Bicycle Infrastructure account and this new Bicycle Programming account, and the continued future appropriation of Dockless Mobility Permit Program revenues to the new Bicycle Programming account. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) Attachments 1. Resolution to Appropriate $450,707 in Dockless Mobility Revenue Page 28 of 240 RESOLUTION #R-__-___ Resolution to Appropriate $450,707 in Dockless Mobility Revenue for Bicycle Programming WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville created a Dockless Mobility Permit Program in 2019 and has collected $410,706.80 in revenue since inception; and WHEREAS, these revenues have not previously been appropriated although the original pilot permit program identified these revenues as being dedicated to bicycle infrastructure and programming; NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville that $410,707 in previously collected revenue will be appropriated from the fund balance of the Capital Projects fund and $40,000 in revenue anticipated to be collected during FY 2027 is hereby appropriated in the following manner: Revenue: $40,000 Fund: 426 WBS Element: P-01141 G/L Account: 422150 Expenditure: $265,798 Fund: 426 Funded Program: P-01141 G/L Account: 599999 $184,909 Fund: 426 Funded Program: CP-083 G/L Account: 599999 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville that all future revenues generated by this program shall be appropriated to the Bicycle Programming account unless further action is taken by City Council. Date Adopted: Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 29 of 240 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: FY 2027 Budget Amendments and Appropriation of $300,252 of Additional General Fund Revenue (2nd reading) Staff Contact(s): Krisy Hammill, Director of Budget Presenter: Krisy Hammill, Director of Budget Date of Proposed Action: September 21, 2026 Issue Since the adoption of the FY 2027 budget, the City has received $300,252 in unanticipated revenue that needs to be appropriated, and funds previously appropriated for the City's Grand Illumination celebration need to be moved from the City's Communication and Public Engagement department to Parks and Recreation. Background / Rule Ordinance #0-26-44 sets the City of Charlottesville's budget and spending plan for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2027. The ordinance outlines both revenue and expenses to promote transparency and accountability. If the City receives any extra revenue during the year that was not part of the original ordinance, Council approval is required before it can be spent. Similarly, any changes to departmental budget totals must be appropriated by Council. Analysis Appropriation of Additional Revenue As part of the FY 2026 closeout, Jaunt has remitted $225,252 to the City as its share of excess funds. Furthermore, City Council recently adopted resolution #R-26-116, approving an agreement for legal services between the City of Charlottesville and the Charlottesville-Albemarle Airport Authority, which includes a $75,000 fee for those services. These two items together contribute $300,252 in revenue that was not reflected in the annual budget ordinance. Staff recommends these funds be appropriated to the Citywide Reserve account within the General Fund, making these resources available to the City Manager for addressing unforeseen needs during the fiscal year. Budget Amendments The FY 2027 Communications and Public Engagement budget included an appropriation of $25,000 for expenses associated with the Grand Illumination event, which is hosted annually by the City. Management responsibility for this event has since transitioned to Parks and Recreation, and staff is requesting that the corresponding budget allocation be transferred to reflect this change. Financial Impact We aim to keep $500,000 in the Citywide Reserve account. The FY 2027 proposed budget included $417,771 for replenishment, but after Council changes, the reserve was reduced to $187,032, with no carryover expected from FY 2026. Adding these funds will bring the unallocated reserve balance to $487,284. Moving the $25,000 Grand Illumination budget between departments has no financial impact. Recommendation Staff recommends approval of the resolution. Page 30 of 240 Recommended Motion (if Applicable) Attachments 1. Resolution to Allocate $300,252 to the Citywide Reserve Page 31 of 240 RESOLUTION #R-__-___ FY 2027 Budget Amendments and Appropriation of $300,252 of Additional General Fund Revenue WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville, VA will receive a total of $300,252 from Jaunt ($225,252) and the Charlottesville-Albemarle Airport Authority ($75,000) that was not previously appropriated as part of the FY 2027 budget; and WHEREAS, the FY 2027 adopted budget included $25,000 for the Grand Illumination event which was appropriated to the Communications and Public Engagement department that will now be reallocated to the Parks and Recreation budget; NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia that funds in the amount of $300,252 be appropriated to the Citywide Reserve account and $25,000 be re-allocated as follows: Revenue: $ 225,252 Fund: 105 WBS: 9723001000 G/L Account: 451050 $ 75,000 Fund: 105 WBS: 1701001000 G/L Account: 434820 Expense: $ 300,252 Fund: 105 WBS: 1631001000 G/L Account: 599999 Budget Reallocation From: $25,000 Fund: 105 WBS: 1601003000 G/L Account: 599999 Budget Reallocation To: $25,000 Fund: 105 WBS: 3681004000 G/L Account: 599999 Date Adopted: Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 32 of 240 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Resolution to Appropriate Virginia Juvenile Community Crime Control Act Grant (VJCCCA) $452,704 (2nd reading) Staff Contact(s): Misty Graves, Director of Human Services, Reginald Allen, Human Services Planner Presenter: Date of Proposed Action: September 21, 2026 Issue Resolution to appropriate funds Background / Rule In July 2010, the City of Charlottesville became the fiscal agent for the Virginia Juvenile Community Crime Control Act (V.J.C.C.C.A.) funds for both Charlottesville and Albemarle County. This funding stream was established by the 1995 Virginia General Assembly to create balanced, community-based systems of sanctions, programs and services for juvenile offenders. These funds are used to support the Community Attention programs. In Fiscal Year 2027, $292,058 in V.J.C.C.C.A.funds will be received from the Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice, with a required local maintenance of effort of $52,231 from Albemarle County and $108,415 from the City for a total of $452,704. The grant period is from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027 Analysis The VJCCCA grant funds the delinquency prevention and youth development services provided by The Department of Human Services for Charlottesville/Albemarle youth involved in the juvenile justice system. These services include the following programs: the Teens GIVE service learning program that provides community service opportunities during both the school year and the summer; the Community Support Services, which provides pro-social skills training like anger management, individual and group support services and services for youth on electronic monitoring; the Community Attention Youth Internship Program (C.A.Y.I.P.) which provides paid internship opportunities; the Check and Connect Program provides evidence-based, school engagement programs. Financial Impact The VJCCCA grant aligns with the City of Charlottesville's goal of improving community health and safety outcomes by connecting residents with effective resources. Community Attention’s VJCCCA- funded programs provide community-based services that prevent delinquency and promote the healthy development of youth. Expected outcomes include decreased delinquent behavior during and after program participation. Recommendation Staff recommends approval and recommendations of funds. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) Staff recommends a motion to adopt the resolutions as written. Attachments Page 33 of 240 1. RES_Appropriate $452,704 VJCCCA funds Page 34 of 240 #R-__-___ RESOLUTION TO APPROPRIATE $452,704 IN GRANT FUNDING FROM THE VIRGINIA DEPARTMENT OF JUVENILE JUSTICE AND LOCAL FUNDS PURSUANT TO THE VIRGINIA JUVENILE COMMUNITY CRIME CONTROL ACT WHEREAS, the City of Charlottesville has been awarded $292,058 from the Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice for uses consistent with the VJCCCA; and WHEREAS, this grant requires local maintenance of effort funds in the amount of $52,231 from Albemarle County and $108,415 from the City; and WHEREAS, the grant award covers the period from July 1, 2026, through June 30, 2027. NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville that the sum of $452,704 is hereby appropriated in the following manner: Revenue - $452,704 $292,058 Fund: 220 Cost Center: 3523001000 G/L Account: 430080 $52,231 Fund: 220 Cost Center: 3523001000 G/L Account: 432030 $108,415 Fund: 220 Cost Center: 3523001000 G/L Account: 498010 Expenditures - $452,704 $103,704 Fund: 220 Cost Center: 3523001000 G/L Account: 519999 $343,000 Fund: 220 Cost Center: 3523001000 G/L Account: 599991 BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that this appropriation is subject to the receipt of $292,058 from the Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice and $52,231 from Albemarle County. All funds hereby appropriated shall be accounted for and expended in accordance with requirements of the VJCCCA grant program. Date Adopted: Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 35 of 240 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Resolution for the Draft Program Year 2025-26 (“PY25”) Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (“CAPER”) (2nd reading) Staff Contact(s): Anthony Warn, Grants Analyst, Taylor Harvey-Ryan, Grants Program Manager Presenter: Anthony Warn, Grants Analyst Date of Proposed Action: September 21, 2026 Issue The City of Charlottesville (“City”) is an active ‘participating jurisdiction’ (“PJ”) in the Community Development Block Grant (“CDBG”) program administered by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development ("HUD"). The City is also a contributing member of the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium (“TJHC”) in partnership with the counties of Albemarle, Fluvanna, Greene, Louisa and Nelson, and through the Consortium shares in the benefits of participation in HUD’s HOME Investments Partnership Program (“HOME”) program. Background / Rule HUD guidance requires PJs to review and report on an annual basis progress made in the preceding program year in carrying out their strategic and annual action plans. This Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (“CAPER”) is a required element for continued participation in HUD-funded programs like CDBG & HOME. Each year, city staff and staff from the Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission (“TJPDC”) collaborate to prepare the CAPER. Analysis During Program Year 2025-26 (“PY25”), the City awarded CDBG funds to eight (8) Charlottesville- based nonprofits in support of: two (2) economic development activities; one (1) accessibility-focused public facilities & infrastructure activity; one (1) affordable housing activity, and; three (3) public services activities. Similarly, through its participation in the HOME Consortium, the City awarded HOME funds to one (1) local nonprofit in support of income-eligible city residents and continues to work with another on refining their proposal for an affordable home rehabilitation activity. Due to the nature of the applications received for HOME funding, a small pool of HOME funds remains available to support suitable eligible activities. The draft PY25 CAPER will be available online for a 15-day public comment period at https://tjpdc.org/our-work/thomas-jefferson-regional-home-consortium/ from September 1 through September 16, 2026, or by contacting Laurie Jean Talun, LJTalun@tjpdc.org (434-422-4080), and/or Anthony Warn, warna@charlottesville.gov (434-906-2582). Financial Impact Approval of the CAPER does not involve the appropriation of funds from the city’s General Fund. As such, no adverse impacts to the City’s budget are anticipated. Rather, approval of the CAPER is an important step in ensuring the City’s continued ability to participate in the CDBG and HOME programs and, by extension, the ability of our Consortium partners to participate in the HOME program as well. Recommendation Page 36 of 240 Based on the demonstrated benefits to the Charlottesville community and to the communities served by the HOME Consortium, staff recommends that Council approve the PY25 CAPER as presented before Council. Staff further recommends that Council establish its priorities to guide the work of the CDBG/HOME Taskforce in preparing funding recommendations for Program Year 2027-28 CDBG and HOME activities. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) I move that Council approve the RESOLUTION now before us to approve the Program Year 2025-26 Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (“CAPER”). and I move that Council approve the RESOLUTION now before us to establish certain priorities to guide the work of the CDBG/HOME Taskforce in preparing funding recommendations for Program Year 2027-28 CDBG and HOME activities. Attachments 1. PY25 CAPER Resolution to Approve 2. PY25 CAPER Charlottesville-TJPDC Draft 3. CDBG & HOME Proposed Council Priorities 2027-28 Page 37 of 240 RESOLUTION R#-__-___ Resolution to Approve the Program Year 2025-26 (“PY25”) Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (“CAPER”) for the Community Development Block Grants and HOME Investment Partnerships Programs WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville (“City”) is an active ‘participating jurisdiction’ (“PJ”) in the Community Development Block Grant (“CDBG”) program administered by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development ("HUD"); and WHEREAS the City is a contributing member of the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium (“TJHC”) in partnership with the counties of Albemarle, Fluvanna, Greene, Louisa and Nelson, and through the Consortium shares in the benefits of participation in HUD’s HOME Investment Partnerships Program (“HOME”); and WHEREAS City Council approved a 5-Year Consolidated Plan covering program years 2023- 2027 at a public hearing held on May 1, 2023 (#R-23-065) and the associated 1-Year Annual Action Plan (“AAP”) for PY25 at a public hearing on May 5, 2025 (#R-25-038); and WHEREAS HUD requires all localities receiving HUD funds to report on their annual accomplishments for the prior program year through the CAPER; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the City Council of Charlottesville, Virginia, hereby approves the city’s PY25 CAPER report, as presented here before us. Date Adopted: Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 38 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 1 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Page 39 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 2 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-05 - Goals and Outcomes Progress the jurisdiction has made in carrying out its strategic plan and its action plan. 91.520(a) This could be an overview that includes major initiatives and highlights that were proposed and executed throughout the program year. The HOME program's goals are to assist first-time homebuyers, preserve existing housing stock by rehabilitating owner-occupied homes, and develop new housing units for home ownership or rental. HOME Consortium activities are carried out through nonprofit housing foundations in the region: the Albemarle Home Improvement Program (AHIP), the Fluvanna/Louisa Housing Foundation (F/LHF), the Nelson County Community Development Foundation (NCCDF), and Skyline CAP (serving Greene County). HOME funds are often combined with other funding, extending the reach and effectiveness of the program. The current Consolidated Plan, which is a five-year plan that consolidates CDBG and HOME Consortium activities, began in 2023. The following charts show progress made based on the initial goals set at that time. The HOME Consortium has completed a large number of homeowner rehabilitations, and is in the process of purchasing and developing several rental units. Due to the cost of construction labor and materials, the total amount of funding is being used strategically to have the greatest impact possible, within a challenging housing and construction economy. Comparison of the proposed versus actual outcomes for each outcome measure submitted with the consolidated plan and explain, if applicable, why progress was not made toward meeting goals and objectives. 91.520(g) Categories, priority levels, funding sources and amounts, outcomes/objectives, goal outcome indicators, units of measure, targets, actual outcomes/outputs, and percentage completed for each of the grantee’s program year goals. Page 40 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 3 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Goal Category Source / Amount Indicator Unit of Measure Expected – Strategic Plan Actual – Strategic Plan Percent Complete Expected – Program Year Actual – Program Year Percent Complete Energy efficiency and environmental stewardship Affordable Housing Non-Housing Community Development Public Facility or Infrastructure Activities other than Low/Moderate Income Housing Benefit Persons Assisted 500 6 1.20% Enhance and improve access to transportation Non-Housing Community Development Public Facility or Infrastructure Activities other than Low/Moderate Income Housing Benefit Persons Assisted 500 65 13.00% Ensure housing access for low income residents Affordable Housing Direct Financial Assistance to Homebuyers Households Assisted 22 0 0.00% 2 0 0.00% Ensure housing access for low income residents Affordable Housing Tenant-based rental assistance / Rapid Rehousing Households Assisted 24 13 54.17% 6 0 0.00% Expand the affordable housing stock Affordable Housing Rental units constructed Household Housing Unit 37 1 2.70% 10 0 0.00% Page 41 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 4 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Expand the affordable housing stock Affordable Housing Homeowner Housing Added Household Housing Unit 10 6 60.00% 2 1 50.00% Expand the affordable housing stock Affordable Housing Homeowner Housing Rehabilitated Household Housing Unit 0 19 0 19 Foster small and local business development Non-Housing Community Development Businesses assisted Businesses Assisted 40 117 292.50% Increase access to jobs that pay a living wage Non-Housing Community Development Jobs created/retained Jobs 50 65 130.00% Preserve existing supply of affordable housing Affordable Housing Rental units rehabilitated Household Housing Unit 1 1 100.00% 0 1 Preserve existing supply of affordable housing Affordable Housing Homeowner Housing Rehabilitated Household Housing Unit 116 41 35.34% 24 16 66.67% Strengthen living environment & expand opps Non- Homeless Special Needs Non-Housing Community Development CDBG: $ Public Facility or Infrastructure Activities other than Low/Moderate Income Housing Benefit Persons Assisted 0 0 1 153 15,300.00% Page 42 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 5 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Strengthen living environment & expand opps Non- Homeless Special Needs Non-Housing Community Development CDBG: $ Tenant-based rental assistance / Rapid Rehousing Households Assisted 0 0 4 0 0.00% Strengthen living environment & expand opps Non- Homeless Special Needs Non-Housing Community Development CDBG: $ Jobs created/retained Jobs 0 0 13 0 0.00% Strengthen living environment & expand opps Non- Homeless Special Needs Non-Housing Community Development CDBG: $ Businesses assisted Businesses Assisted 0 0 8 7 87.50% Strengthen living environment & expand opps Non- Homeless Special Needs Non-Housing Community Development CDBG: $ Housing for Homeless added Household Housing Unit 0 0 10 0 0.00% Strengthen living environment & expand opps Non- Homeless Special Needs Non-Housing Community Development CDBG: $ Other Other 0 0 Page 43 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 6 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Support homeless and transition to independence Affordable Housing Homeless Homelessness Prevention Persons Assisted 6 258 4,300.00% Support investments that aid fair housing choice Non- Homeless Special Needs Non-Housing Community Development Public service activities for Low/Moderate Income Housing Benefit Households Assisted 5 0 0.00% Support the expansion of mental health services Non- Homeless Special Needs Public service activities other than Low/Moderate Income Housing Benefit Persons Assisted 50 0 0.00% Support the provision of supportive housing Affordable Housing Non- Homeless Special Needs Other Other 1 0 0.00% Table 1 - Accomplishments – Program Year & Strategic Plan to Date Page 44 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 7 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Assess how the jurisdiction’s use of funds, particularly CDBG, addresses the priorities and specific objectives identified in the plan, giving special attention to the highest priority activities identified. As in previous years, Charlottesville continues to carefully direct investments of its limited CDBG and HOME funds to address pressing needs within our community. For example, investments of our limited CDBG funds were successful in leveraging more than $300,000 in non-federal funds, an amount equal to more than 64.53% of our total PY25 CDBG allocation. The lack of affordable housing options, both homeownership and rental, continues to be a significant challenge for our region, as it is in most metropolitan areas across the country. Specifically, the presence of substandard housing continues to be a pressing need within our community, which we have attempted to address through, among other efforts: support for the work of the Albemarle Housing Improvement Partnership (AHIP) to provide emergency and critical rehabs for income-eligible homeowners; support for energy-efficiency upgrades for income-eligible homeowners through the Local Energy Alliance Program (LEAP) to prepare their homes for free solar panels from Dominion Energy. In addition, we have continued to try to enlist new partners in this work and are very excited to announce that we been able to award both CDBG and HOME homeowner rehabilitation funds to a new partner, the Building Goodness Foundation (“BGF”) for the 2026-27 program year. Page 45 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 8 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-10 - Racial and Ethnic composition of families assisted Describe the families assisted (including the racial and ethnic status of families assisted). 91.520(a) CDBG HOME White 106 13 Black or African American 161 19 Asian 3 0 American Indian or American Native 2 0 Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander 1 0 Total 273 32 Hispanic 60 0 Not Hispanic 213 32 Table 2 – Table of assistance to racial and ethnic populations by source of funds Narrative With HOME funds, the HOME Consortium served a large number of individuals and households; over half of the beneficiaries identify as Black or African American. According to Census data, approximately 11% of the population of the Charlottesville Metropolitan Statistical Area is at or below the federal poverty level. Of these, approximately: 7.5% identify as White/Not Hispanic; 26.4% identify as Black/African American; 26.7 identify as Asian; 17.5% identify as Latino/Hispanic; with the rest identifying as Other/Multiracial. In the TJPDC, non-white/other race households have low-incomes at a 22% higher rate than white households. About one third (37%) of households led by someone who identifies as white have incomes equal to or less than 80% area median income. In contrast, over half (59%) of households led by someone who identifies themselves as included in another racial group have incomes equal to or less than 80% AMI. Page 46 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 9 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-15 - Resources and Investments 91.520(a) Identify the resources made available Source of Funds Source Resources Made Available Amount Expended During Program Year CDBG public - federal 445,452 171,317 HOME public - federal 4,316,160 1,359,140 Table 3 - Resources Made Available Identify the geographic distribution and location of investments Target Area Planned Percentage of Allocation Actual Percentage of Allocation Narrative Description 10th and Page Albemarle County 14 14 City of Charlottesville 14 14 Fifeville Fluvanna County 14 14 Greene County 30 30 Greene County was the CHDO recipient this year Louisa County 14 14 Nelson County 14 14 Ridge Table 4 – Identify the geographic distribution and location of investments Page 47 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 10 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Leveraging Explain how federal funds leveraged additional resources (private, state and local funds), including a description of how matching requirements were satisfied, as well as how any publicly owned land or property located within the jurisdiction that were used to address the needs identified in the plan. The city also continues to work closely with its partners to utilize sources of non-federal funds that can be leveraged to support its HUD-funded activities. For example, the city awarded $50,000 in CDBG funding to support long hoped for accessibility enhancements at the site of one of Charlottesville’s oldest youth-serving nonprofits, funds which the subrecipient used to help secure private philanthropic donations well in excess of the funds awarded, resulting a greater than 1:1 leveraged match ratio. Similarly, CDBG-funded activities in PY25 leveraged more than $580,000 in non-federal funds (or $1.25 leveraged for each $1 of CDBG funds utilized). Fiscal Year Summary – HOME Match 1. Excess match from prior Federal fiscal year 10,094,576 2. Match contributed during current Federal fiscal year 684,003 3. Total match available for current Federal fiscal year (Line 1 plus Line 2) 10,778,578 4. Match liability for current Federal fiscal year 339,785 5. Excess match carried over to next Federal fiscal year (Line 3 minus Line 4) 10,438,793 Table 5 – Fiscal Year Summary - HOME Match Report Page 48 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 11 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Match Contribution for the Federal Fiscal Year Project No. or Other ID Date of Contribution Cash (non-Federal sources) Foregone Taxes, Fees, Charges Appraised Land/Real Property Required Infrastructure Site Preparation, Construction Materials, Donated labor Bond Financing Total Match AHIP Repair 05/04/2026 166,800 0 0 0 0 0 166,800 Habitat Core 2026 05/04/2026 286,027 0 0 0 0 0 286,027 PHA 1025 Park 05/04/2026 231,176 0 0 0 0 0 231,176 Table 6 – Match Contribution for the Federal Fiscal Year HOME MBE/WBE report Program Income – Enter the program amounts for the reporting period Balance on hand at begin-ning of reporting period $ Amount received during reporting period $ Total amount expended during reporting period $ Amount expended for TBRA $ Balance on hand at end of reporting period $ 113,119 39,948 20,249 0 212,510 Table 7 – Program Income Page 49 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 12 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Minority Business Enterprises and Women Business Enterprises – Indicate the number and dollar value of contracts for HOME projects completed during the reporting period Total Minority Business Enterprises White Non- Hispanic Alaskan Native or American Indian Asian or Pacific Islander Black Non- Hispanic Hispanic Contracts Dollar Amount 214,282 0 0 39,475 8,600 166,207 Number 19 0 0 2 1 16 Sub-Contracts Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 Dollar Amount 0 0 0 0 0 0 Total Women Business Enterprises Male Contracts Dollar Amount 217,380 20,000 197,380 Number 20 1 19 Sub-Contracts Number 0 0 0 Dollar Amount 0 0 0 Table 8 - Minority Business and Women Business Enterprises Minority Owners of Rental Property – Indicate the number of HOME assisted rental property owners and the total amount of HOME funds in these rental properties assisted Total Minority Property Owners White Non- Hispanic Alaskan Native or American Indian Asian or Pacific Islander Black Non- Hispanic Hispanic Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 Dollar Amount 0 0 0 0 0 0 Table 9 – Minority Owners of Rental Property Page 50 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 13 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) Relocation and Real Property Acquisition – Indicate the number of persons displaced, the cost of relocation payments, the number of parcels acquired, and the cost of acquisition Parcels Acquired 0 0 Businesses Displaced 0 0 Nonprofit Organizations Displaced 0 0 Households Temporarily Relocated, not Displaced 0 0 Households Displaced Total Minority Property Enterprises White Non- Hispanic Alaskan Native or American Indian Asian or Pacific Islander Black Non- Hispanic Hispanic Number 0 0 0 0 0 0 Cost 0 0 0 0 0 0 Table 10 – Relocation and Real Property Acquisition Page 51 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 14 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-20 - Affordable Housing 91.520(b) Evaluation of the jurisdiction's progress in providing affordable housing, including the number and types of families served, the number of extremely low-income, low-income, moderate-income, and middle-income persons served. One-Year Goal Actual Number of Homeless households to be provided affordable housing units 0 0 Number of Non-Homeless households to be provided affordable housing units 43 20 Number of Special-Needs households to be provided affordable housing units 0 0 Total 43 20 Table 11 – Number of Households One-Year Goal Actual Number of households supported through Rental Assistance 6 0 Number of households supported through The Production of New Units 11 1 Number of households supported through Rehab of Existing Units 24 19 Number of households supported through Acquisition of Existing Units 2 0 Total 43 20 Table 12 – Number of Households Supported Discuss the difference between goals and outcomes and problems encountered in meeting these goals. During this program year, the HOME Consortium continued the development of rental units, which will be completed in the coming program year. During the program year, 16 low-income households received rehabilitation of their homes, and one household purchased a unit. Due to the current cost of construction and other aspects of producing homes, this is a reasonable number of completed activities, based on the total amount of funding available. Page 52 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 15 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) To complete the CDBG efforts in the Consolidated Plan, through its close partnership with TJPDC, the City continues to seek out additional opportunities to blend funding from multiple sources to deliver benefits to our community. Discuss how these outcomes will impact future annual action plans. We anticipate a higher rate of completed rental units in the coming year, as the result of advancements made this year in the production of the planned rental units. Include the number of extremely low-income, low-income, and moderate-income persons served by each activity where information on income by family size is required to determine the eligibility of the activity. Number of Households Served CDBG Actual HOME Actual Extremely Low-income 0 6 Low-income 3 8 Moderate-income 0 3 Total 3 17 Table 13 – Number of Households Served Narrative Information HOME funding is intended to assist households at various low levels of income. By assisting primarily low income and extremely low income households, funding in our region met needs for crucial home repairs, and produced one additional unit available at an affordable rent. The challenges we have experienced related to affordable housing have informed our work in many years, notably by leading us to a renewed effort to try to help subrecipients connect to additional funding sources that can extend their impact. For example, the city is working to support subrecipients in their applications to related city programs, like the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (CAHF) or funding opportunities available throughout city departments, like Economic Development of Human Services. Page 53 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 16 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-25 - Homeless and Other Special Needs 91.220(d, e); 91.320(d, e); 91.520(c) Evaluate the jurisdiction’s progress in meeting its specific objectives for reducing and ending homelessness through: Reaching out to homeless persons (especially unsheltered persons) and assessing their individual needs The Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (BRACH) Continuum of Care maintains a coordinated system of care so that homelessness in our region is rare, brief, and nonrecurring when possible. BRACH connects individuals and families experiencing homelessness to permanent housing without preconditions and barriers to entry, such as sobriety, treatment, or service participation requirements. A Community Case Review convenes 2 times a month to provide a problem-solving body to area providers working with individuals and families experiencing homelessness. The Community Case Review consists of a convener appointed by BRACH and staffed by representatives from anchor agencies, including PACEM, The Haven, Region Ten, On Our Own, and area Departments of Social Services. Each meeting, the Community Case Review works through the community's By-Name List of everyone known to be experiencing homelessness in the area and documents action steps aimed at quickly resolving homelessness for each person reviewed. There is now additionally a Community Case Review for chronic cases, and a separate Community Case Review for veteran cases for veterans of the military. Particularly complex cases are referred to the Community Case Review for solution-focused discussion designed to resolve homelessness quickly and effectively. A coordinated assessment process is used to determine eligibility for available services, collect required data, and develop case plans for individuals and families experiencing homelessness. Coordinated assessment is available every day at The Haven. Households can call the Haven’s Homeless Information Line (HIL) to schedule a homeless intake appointment. BRACH homelessness service providers collect required data elements and enter data into HMIS on a weekly basis to ensure close to real-time community level data and on-time reporting to local, state and federal stakeholders. BRACH is pairing HOME-ARP funding with capacity building funding from the City, to hire a staff member who will continue to enhance outreach beyond the urban center of the region, and also partner with SupportWorks Housing at Vista 29, to help prepare beneficiaries to live in permanent supportive housing. BRACH, Region Ten PATH Program, and On Our Own provide street outreach to individuals and families experiencing homelessness, with a focus on those who do not have shelter, to provide them with information and access to services. Region Ten conducts in-reach with Western State Hospital to assist Page 54 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 17 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) with transitions and community reintegration – clients can come to Region Ten for support. Region Ten PATH program conducts in-reach at The Haven, Mohr Center and SupportWorks Housing to engage guests in mental health treatment and care. SupportWorks Housing provides supportive housing in the region, addressing the long-term needs of chronically homeless households and individuals. The Vista 29 project, which used HOME-ARP funds, among many other sources, has transformed a hotel into Permanent Supportive Housing, and construction is near completion. Addressing the emergency shelter and transitional housing needs of homeless persons Community leaders are working together to provide a year-round, overnight shelter, in partnership with multiple nonprofits and the City of Charlottesville. The City of Charlottesville continued to seek out novel ways to use HUD funding to support programs serving the area’s unhoused population, such as through continued support for the Coordination of Community Service Providers work being done by a Charlottesville-based nonprofit, The Haven at First & Market. The City of Charlottesville purchased for $6.2MM an approximately 27,000 square foot building on 3.8 acres of land, commonly referred to as 2000 Holiday Drive, on which to develop a year-round, low- barrier overnight shelter and source of wraparound services for persons experiencing homelessness. The city also helped coordinate over the past year the work of a team of nonprofit community organizations dedicated to supporting the unhoused, including BRACH, The Haven, and PACEM, and Central Arizona Shelter Services (CASS), an experienced shelter management provider, to develop a coordinated plan to transform the property into a usable site. The City also worked closely during the program year with state legislators to secure a special appropriation of $7MM from the Virginia General Assembly in FY27[AW3.1] to support the expansion of services for the unhoused, including $3MM to the Salvation Army to help them expand the capacity of their high-barrier shelter and additional funds to support the rehabilitation of the 2000 Holiday Drive facility and to move work forward on preparing to provide services at the location. The City of Charlottesville purchased a building and land to develop a year-round, low-barrier overnight shelter for people experiencing homelessness. The past year has involved a great deal of stakeholder effort to develop plans to develop the property into a usable site. Key leaders involved include City of Charlottesville staff, BRACH, The Haven, and PACEM. The City was awarded state level funding to rehabilitate the building and move forward with preparing to provide services on location. PACEM provides a seasonal, low-barrier emergency shelter to individuals from late October to mid-April using host church sites for shelter and meals. PACEM provides coordinated assessment services to those individuals and families that seek shelter but have not completed a coordinated assessment through Coordinate Entry. ACPS McKinney-Vento Connection (formerly Families in Crisis) provides emergency hotel/motel Page 55 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 18 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) vouchers to families experiencing homelessness and complete a coordinated assessment packet, and assists McKinney-Vento Coordinators in the region with addressing the needs of families identified by schools as at risk of homelessness. Salvation Army provides high-barrier emergency shelter services year-round for individuals and families experiencing homelessness that can maintain sobriety and are looking for work or are working. Salvation Army is currently developing additional beds. The City has coordinated with Salvation Army staff to expand capacity, including coordination with the Virginia legislature to secure $3 million, paired with $3 million invested from the City’s budget. The Shelter for Help in Emergency (SHE) provides emergency shelter services year-round for women and children fleeing domestic violence, referred by other emergency shelters and emergency room staff. Monticello Area Community Action Agency (MACAA) Hope House provides transitional housing and supportive services with a preference for households with children where one adult is working. Helping low-income individuals and families avoid becoming homeless, especially extremely low-income individuals and families and those who are: likely to become homeless after being discharged from publicly funded institutions and systems of care (such as health care facilities, mental health facilities, foster care and other youth facilities, and corrections programs and institutions); and, receiving assistance from public or private agencies that address housing, health, social services, employment, education, or youth needs Existing rental assistance resources include Pathways through the United Way, the Network2Work Emergency Fund, The Haven, PHA eviction reduction programs, HOPWA through the Blue Ridge Health Department, the Charlottesville Supplemental Rental Assistance Program (CSRAP) through the City of Charlottesville and CRHA, the Albemarle County Emergency Relief Program (ACERP) through Albemarle County, and Housing Choice Vouchers in various counties. The Haven served 152 individuals representing 94 households during this period, using the Laura DeLapp fund. Prevention staff at The Haven, PACEM, and McKinney Vento services in schools, coordinate activities in communication with area emergency assistance providers including Alliance for Interfaith Ministries (AIM), Pathways Fund, Love, Inc., departments of social services, and area churches whenever possible. Monthly case management is provided to develop and implement a housing stability plan. Helping homeless persons (especially chronically homeless individuals and families, families with children, veterans and their families, and unaccompanied youth) make the transition to permanent housing and independent living, including shortening the period of time that individuals and families experience homelessness, facilitating access for homeless individuals and families to affordable housing units, and preventing individuals and families who were recently homeless from becoming homeless again Page 56 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 19 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) The Haven provides housing navigation services through the Rapid Rehousing program to assist individuals and families experiencing homelessness to identify available low-income housing resources and negotiate leases. Rapid Rehousing Case Managers serve as a housing navigator to develop relationships with area landlords and provides education on available rental subsidy programs to housing organizations. The Haven provides rapid re-housing services to quickly connect individuals and families experiencing literal homelessness to permanent housing. Rental arrearages and utility bills may be paid if they represent an actual barrier to permanent housing. Rental subsidies may be provided to ensure housing stability. Ongoing eligibility is determined every 90 days. Monthly case management is provided to develop and implement a housing stability plan. Region Ten operates a HUD-funded permanent supportive housing program for about 33 chronically homeless individuals. Community Case Review prioritizes the most vulnerable individuals with the longest histories of homelessness for this program when there are openings. SupportWorks Housing's The Crossings provides 30 units of permanent supportive housing for chronically homeless individuals in partnership with the Albemarle County Department of Housing and the Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority (CRHA). The Continuum of Care now includes 153 Permanent Supportive Housing beds, including 25 units that service Veterans, and 38 that are run by Region Ten and funded through HUD. Page 57 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 20 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-30 - Public Housing 91.220(h); 91.320(j) Actions taken to address the needs of public housing The Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority (CRHA) prioritizes individuals with greatest need in our community, 40% of new admissions to public housing each year are considered “extremely low-income families.” The PHA has three self-sufficiency programs (ROSS, FSS, and Jobs Plus) that provide opportunities for residents to gain economic independence and encourage healthy living. The CRHA is also in the process of redeveloping two sites (South First Street, Phase II and Sixth Street, Phase I). The PHA anticipates developing 40-65 affordable new units with a mix of 1-5 bedroom units. Actions taken to encourage public housing residents to become more involved in management and participate in homeownership The CRHA continues to involve residents in long-term planning, self-determined programs, and site modernization via Resident Planners and the Public Housing Association of Residents (PHAR). The PHA has a housing counselor on staff that has been working with FSS participants on opportunities for homeownership. The CRHA has received down-payment assistance funds that will help these individuals in their homebuying process. Actions taken to provide assistance to troubled PHAs CRHA is the only PHA in the region and is not troubled. Page 58 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 21 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-35 - Other Actions 91.220(j)-(k); 91.320(i)-(j) Actions taken to remove or ameliorate the negative effects of public policies that serve as barriers to affordable housing such as land use controls, tax policies affecting land, zoning ordinances, building codes, fees and charges, growth limitations, and policies affecting the return on residential investment. 91.220 (j); 91.320 (i) During the 2025-26 program year, the City of Charlottesville and its partners continued their shared work of addressing forthrightly and proactively our shared history and the resulting barriers to affordable housing through, in part, its commitment to preserve and expand affordable housing opportunities for our neighbors who need them most. For example, City Council continues its commitment of no less than $10MM per year to support a wide range of affordable housing activities, from the construction of new units, the preservation and rehabilitation of existing units (including Kindlewood, CRHA, LEAP, and Building Goodness units), to supporting a range of eviction prevention and downpayment assistance/counseling services. The city also continues to support the growth of a community land trust that can work in conjunction with our nonprofit partners as well as a targeted tax abatement strategy to further support the development of affordable housing opportunities. Actions taken to address obstacles to meeting underserved needs. 91.220(k); 91.320(j) One of the biggest steps taken by the city in recent years to remove obstacles to the development of affordable housing is the development of a new, more inclusive zoning code. While great challenges in this work remain, the new zoning code, with its removal of requirements for single-family residences in all neighborhoods and features that allow developers the ability to develop additional units in certain circumstances if they also deliver a certain number of affordable units (or pay a fee in lieu), offers great promise in addressing the areas housing shortage. Additionally, the city and TJPDC continue to coordinate closely to design and implement HUD-funded programs that address the needs of the largest number of underserved individuals possible, including activities that have the potential of leveraging non-federal funds. Actions taken to reduce lead-based paint hazards. 91.220(k); 91.320(j) The city continues to work with its partners, including AHIP, LEAP, the Piedmont Housing Alliance, Habitat for Humanity, and the Building Goodness Foundation (“BGF”), to identify and remove lead- based paint hazards wherever they may be encountered. The HOME Consortium completes reduction of lead-based paint hazards through partnerships with AHIP in Albemarle County, NCCDF in Nelson County, and Fluvanna-Louisa Housing Foundation. Actions taken to reduce the number of poverty-level families. 91.220(k); 91.320(j) Charlottesville continues to provide significant financial resources to help reduce the number of poverty-level families in the City, including by providing CDBG funds to support of financial literacy Page 59 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 22 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) programs provided by one of the region’s most active affordable housing developers and adult/workforce literacy tutoring for adults experiencing literacy issues. Similarly, the city continues its commitment to assist families at risk of eviction or other adverse actions through a commitment of local funds in excess of $130,000 to the Charlottesville Supplemental Rental Assistance Program (“CSRAP”) in FY26 and additional commitments of grant funds through other programs (e.g., CDBG, HOME, VCF, etc.). Fluvanna-Louisa Housing Foundation, Nelson County Community Development Foundation, and Skyline Community Action Partnership, along with AHIP, provide extensive services related to housing for low- income households. As a result of their services, families facing poverty experience greater housing safety and stability. Actions taken to develop institutional structure. 91.220(k); 91.320(j) The City and TJPDC continue to emphasize the development and refinement of tightly integrated systems to support our shared strategic goals. Charlottesville, TJPDC and the members of the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium (TJHC) work closely together to promote regional cooperation and the creative use of funds to maximize the impact of our many programs. The city also continues to offer unused city office space to area nonprofits, such as the Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (BRACH), at below-market rates as a way of supporting their work. This helps integrate these entities into the other work the city is doing while at the same time allowing them to develop a great portion of their scarce resources on their core missions. Actions taken to enhance coordination between public and private housing and social service agencies. 91.220(k); 91.320(j) The Regional Housing Partnership meets quarterly, and engages over 22 organizations who represent public, private, citizen, and for-profit sectors of those working to provide affordable housing in the TJPDC region. The city and TJPDC work closely together to support social service and housing agencies that are involved in serving special needs populations, including the Jefferson Area Board for Aging (JABA), the Arc of the Piedmont for people with developmental disabilities, Region Ten Community Services Board for people with mental illness and substance abuse and the Independence Resource Center. The Jefferson Area Board for Aging (JABA) assists elderly persons with long-term health care needs and serves the TJPD region. JABA partners with senior housing providers in Charlottesville (Timberlake Place, Woods Edge, and Park View Apartments) and in Nelson County (Ryan School Apartments). Regular JABA health screenings and services are provided by JABA nurses at Park View at South Pantops, Ryan School Apartments and Woods Edge Apartments. The City continues its work to implement and refine its new inclusive Zoning Ordinance and on an update to it citywide Comprehensive Plan Update, coordinating with partners from the Charlottesville Page 60 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 23 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) City School Board, Albemarle County, the University of Virginia, a range of nonprofit organizations, Neighborhood Leaders Group, the Charlottesville Redevelopment and Housing Authority (“CRHA”), the Blue Ridge Area Homelessness Consortium (“BRACH”), among many others.. The Region Ten Community Services Board provides comprehensive diagnosis, treatment and training for persons with Serious Mental Illness and chemical dependence for persons within the Planning District. Region Ten administers Continuum of Care (CoC) Permanent Supportive Housing projects, using a scattered site model. Region Ten also serves people with housing in apartments or Single Room Occupancy (SRO) units with funding through the Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (DBHDS). Region Ten administers about 220 Housing Choice Vouchers. Region Ten provides case management services. For people with disabilities, housing foundations in the Counties and projects funded through the Charlottesville Affordable Housing Fund (CAHF) in the City include necessary accessibility features as part of the scope of work for rehabilitation and emergency repair projects. Identify actions taken to overcome the effects of any impediments identified in the jurisdictions analysis of impediments to fair housing choice. 91.520(a) One of the greatest insights from the regional Community Needs Assessment conducted during the development of the current FY 2022-2027 Consolidated Plan is the several lack of affordable rental units, both in the city and across the larger metropolitan area served by the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium members. This condition is greatly exacerbated by the significant rise of home prices during the course of the COVID pandemic that has driven the median purchase price within the city up on average 3.5% year-over-year, up from approximately $360,000 in June of 2020 to a little over $456,000 in June of 2023 according to Redfin calculations of home sales data from MLS and/or public records. Based on these insights, the city has reemphasized its efforts to preserve and expand the current stock of affordable rental units. For example, the city is in the final stages of approval for funding agreements that will direct our portion of the recent HOME-ARP award to supporting critical rehabilitations necessary to preserve and maintain 7 or more residential rental units as affordable to households at or below 60% of the local Area Median Income (AMI). Land use and zoning policies have historically been discriminatory in Charlottesville, a practice that has severely limited residential development and the overall supply of housing, especially for residents at the lower end of the income spectrum. These policies are further compounded by community resistance to change the land use policies that reinforce and prioritize preserving existing single-family neighborhoods over the development of new affordable housing that would provide and expand housing options in the community. As mentioned above, the city continues working to implement and refine its new Zoning Ordinance that will emphasize new inclusionary policies and other provisions designed to eliminate long-standing barriers to affordable housing. Page 61 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 24 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) TJPDC has developed the PATH, which connects riders with accessible rides throughout the region, allowing access to transportation particularly for those who are most greatly disadvantaged. This allows those who live in more challenging locations for transportation, due to housing costs, to be more connected to the places they need to be. Page 62 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 25 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-40 - Monitoring 91.220 and 91.230 Describe the standards and procedures used to monitor activities carried out in furtherance of the plan and used to ensure long-term compliance with requirements of the programs involved, including minority business outreach and the comprehensive planning requirements The HOME Consortium maintains annual monitoring plans. This year included desk reports from rental providers, as well as a site visit to Habitat for Humanity of Greater Charlottesville (Habitat), to review their files, procedures, and the housing units they have developed for low-income homebuyers. Habitat was found to have excellent files and records, and have completed countless impactful projects in their region. TJPDC carries out HOME desk reviews throughout the year, with oversight from the Finance Director and Executive Director. On-site visits are not required for subrecipients with no staffing changes, with no significant change in the type of projects carried out, and who have no outstanding findings from previous monitoring visits or financial audits. No sub-recipient will go more than three years without an on-site monitoring visit. Citizen Participation Plan 91.105(d); 91.115(d) Describe the efforts to provide citizens with reasonable notice and an opportunity to comment on performance reports. (Will be completed after public comment is complete.) Page 63 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 26 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-45 - CDBG 91.520(c) Specify the nature of, and reasons for, any changes in the jurisdiction’s program objectives and indications of how the jurisdiction would change its programs as a result of its experiences. The City of Charlottesville continues its commitment to internalizing the growing understanding of the depth and breadth of needs within our community referenced in previous CAPER reports, including the broader regional nature of many of the challenges were face and the consequent importance of fostering strong regional partnerships through, for example, the Thomas Jefferson Planning District Commission, the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium (“TJHC”), regional economic partnerships, among many others. The high cost of housing and, consequently, the limited affordable options for many people who work in the city but who cannot afford to own or rent here, continues to be a significant challenge for our community, as it does for so many communities across the country. We are also increasingly seeking out opportunities to strengthen our local childcare/early learning ecosystem. The city and its many housing-focused partners continue seeking to enhance our understanding of community needs and, more importantly, the steps needed to address them in a productive manner that brings results for those in our community who need them the most. One significant outgrowth of this developing awareness can be seen in City Council’s commitment to commit at least $10 million per year to support affordable housing initiatives, a commitment that is being delivered upon but which would be challenging even for city’s much larger than Charlottesville. (As noted elsewhere in this CAPER, the City of Charlottesville continued in its annual commitment of more than $10MM to support a variety of affordable housing initiatives in 2025.) Similarly, the city continues to work to refine its new inclusive zoning code that removes single-family zoning requirements from all residential neighborhoods and that increases the by-right development options available to homeowners seeking to expand residential density and affordable housing options. The 2025-26 program year planning process reinforces our understanding of how the level of need within our community exceeds the limited funds available. Consequently, continued emphasis will be placed on seeking out opportunities to develop activities that can further leverage the city’s investment of scarce CDBG funds. Does this Jurisdiction have any open Brownfields Economic Development Initiative (BEDI) grants? No Page 64 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 27 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) CR-50 - HOME 24 CFR 91.520(d) Include the results of on-site inspections of affordable rental housing assisted under the program to determine compliance with housing codes and other applicable regulations Please list those projects that should have been inspected on-site this program year based upon the schedule in 24 CFR §92.504(d). Indicate which of these were inspected and a summary of issues that were detected during the inspection. For those that were not inspected, please indicate the reason and how you will remedy the situation. HOME-assisted rental units are owned and managed by sub-recipients of the Charlottesville HOME Consortium. Sub-recipients share a role in the implementation of the HOME program, including inspection of rental units. For units with tenants using Housing Choice Vouchers, which constitute the majority of rental units, Charlottesville HOME Consortium Sub-recipients have reciprocal agreements to perform inspections on units owned and managed by another subrecipient. For HOME-assisted units with no rental assistance, the sub-recipient performs inspections at least annually to identify any maintenance issues, and to replace smoke detectors and filters. Inspections may be done more frequently, if there is a concern about the tenant. Some subrecipients, such as AHIP, have inspectors on staff. Others hire inspectors to identify the outcomes of contractors’ work. All rental units are inspected annually. TJPDC conducts site visits, including visits to affordable housing units, with subrecipients. This year, TJPDC visited properties developed by Habitat for Humanity of Greater Charlottesville, Nelson County Community Foundation, and Fluvanna-Louisa Housing Foundation. The sites were maintained in good condition. No issues were detected. Provide an assessment of the jurisdiction's affirmative marketing actions for HOME units. 24 CFR 91.520(e) and 24 CFR 92.351(a) All HOME projects are carried out by HOME Consortium subrecipients. These organizations have developed extensive networks with agencies and organizations in their localities to create a steady stream of referrals for HOME programs. Public outreach is carried out through a variety of means. The HOME Consortium maintains its Affirmative Marketing Policy, which applies to all projects that involve 5 or more units. Refer to IDIS reports to describe the amount and use of program income for projects, including the number of projects and owner and tenant characteristics Program Income information is collected quarterly from subrecipients. Not all subrecipients collect Program Income, because some primarily provide grants or conduct home repairs. Only the City of Charlottesville transfers PI back to TJPDC for use with their specific subrecipients. The HOME Consortium permits county-based non-profits to utilize Program Income for purposes of advancing Page 65 of 240 DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT DRAFT FOR PUBLIC COMMENT CAPER 28 OMB Control No: 2506-0117 (exp. 09/30/2021) affordable housing, and reports all receipts and expenditures to HUD through IDIS. Describe other actions taken to foster and maintain affordable housing. 24 CFR 91.220(k) (STATES ONLY: Including the coordination of LIHTC with the development of affordable housing). 24 CFR 91.320(j) Subrecipient organizations maintain continual contact with their local community members, assessing the needs for affordable housing units, homeowner rehabilitation for low-income households, and other needs. The Program Manager at TJPDC attends regular meetings, listening to the needs and opportunities expressed by service providers, community members, locality staff, and leaders in housing and homelessness efforts. TJPDC participates in the USDA Housing Preservation Grant, allowing subrecipients to increase their rates of rehabilitating low-income housing. TJPDC also has distributed funding from the Virginia Department of Environmental Quality to improve homeowner septic systems. The City of Charlottesville provides extensive funding to affordable housing efforts, as evidenced in section 15 of this report, regarding Match funds. Through the RHP, TJPDC hosts summits every two years to increase the connection between private, public, and for-profit organizations that are focused on housing needs. Page 66 of 240 RESOLUTION R#-__-___ Resolution to Establish Council Priorities for the Program Year 2027-28 Community Development Block Grant & HOME Investment Partnerships Programs WHEREAS the City of Charlottesville (“City”) is an active ‘participating jurisdiction’ (“PJ”) in the Community Development Block Grant (“CDBG”) program administered by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development ("HUD"); and WHEREAS the City is a contributing member of the Thomas Jefferson HOME Consortium (“TJHC”) in partnership with the counties of Albemarle, Fluvanna, Greene, Louisa and Nelson, and through the Consortium shares in the benefits of participation in HUD’s HOME program; and WHEREAS in accordance with the city’s Citizen Participation Plan (“CPP”), the volunteer members of the CDBG/HOME Taskforce will be called on to review requests for funding for potential CDBG- and/or HOME-funded activities and to make subsequent funding recommendations to Council for Program Year 2027-28; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the City Council of Charlottesville, Virginia, that the Program Year 2027-28 CDBG & HOME programs shall prioritize to the degree possible: • A continued emphasis on expanding access to affordable housing opportunities, including but not limited to low-income housing redevelopment, downpayment assistance, homeowner rehabilitations and/or energy-efficiency upgrades for income- eligible homeowners • Workforce development, including but not limited to efforts to bolster Section 3 training opportunities and/or other economic development activities • Microenterprise assistance, including through financial literacy, business education, mentoring, networking, and microloan supports • Access to quality and affordable childcare • Improvements to public infrastructure designed to eliminate or reduce barriers to access to public amenities for mobility-impaired residents • Any other guidelines or directions Council may wish to give in determining how CDBG and HOME funds should be spent For Program Year 2027-28, the CDBG Admin & Planning budget shall be set at 20% of the City’s CDBG Allocation from HUD. Date Adopted: Certified: _________________________ Clerk of Council Page 67 of 240 Policy Briefing Summary City Council Regarding: Ordinance amending City Code Chapter 2, Article XVI. - Police Civilian Oversight Board (2nd reading) Staff Contact(s): James Walker, PCOB Executive Director Presenter: James Walker, PCOB Executive Director Date of Proposed Action: September 21, 2026 Issue The proposed revisions to City Code Chapter 2, Article XVI transition the Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board ("PCOB") from a model focused on independent investigations to a "Monitor, Audit, and Review" model that strengthens oversight by aligning the Board's authority with what it can legally and operationally deliver. Council received a high-level overview of the proposed direction and a matrix of proposed changes at the joint work session held May 18, 2026. Legal review by the City Attorney's Office and by the Board's independent counsel has since been completed. Presented for Council's consideration is the complete revision: a clean copy of the proposed ordinance, a redline against the last Council-approved version, and the matrix of revisions presented on May 18, 2026. The revisions resulting from legal review are documented in the presentation accompanying this item. Staff requests that Council consider the proposed revisions for adoption following two readings. Background / Rule The PCOB was established pursuant to Virginia Code § 9.1-601 and is governed by Chapter 2, Article XVI of the City Code. The Article was last substantively amended in 2021; the most recent Council- approved revision took effect in November 2025 and serves as the baseline for the redline presented with this item. As currently written, the ordinance authorizes the Board to receive and investigate complaints, investigate incidents, hold hearings, recommend discipline in individual cases, and compel testimony through subpoena. Since the Office of Police Civilian Oversight ("the Office") became formalized, implementation has revealed structural tensions between several of these authorities and the legal framework governing police administrative investigations, including the Law-Enforcement Officers Procedural Guarantee Act (Virginia Code § 9.1-500 et seq.), the protections established in Garrity v. New Jersey, 385 U.S. 493 (1967), the Charlottesville Police Department ("CPD") Collective Bargaining Agreement, and the Chief of Police's exclusive disciplinary authority. These tensions have limited the Board's practical capacity to fulfill its existing primary oversight expectation of conducting independent investigations. The revision now before Council is the product of work undertaken by the Board and the Office beginning in late 2025: • November 2025: Last Council-approved revision to Chapter 2, Article XVI takes effect. • Late 2025 – April 2026: The Board and Office review implementation barriers and draft the proposed transition to a Monitor, Audit, and Review model. • May 18, 2026: Joint work session with City Council; Council receives the overview presentation and the matrix of proposed changes. • May – August 2026: Section-by-section legal review conducted by the City Attorney's Office and by the Board's independent counsel. • September 8, 2026: Complete ordinance text, redline, and the May 18 revision matrix presented to Council for first reading; the legal review revisions are documented in the presentation. Page 68 of 240 Analysis The proposed ordinance revision restates the Board's purpose as supporting community well-being and safety by advancing the quality of policing in the City of Charlottesville through civilian-led transparency and accountability under a "Monitor, Audit, and Review" model of oversight. This transition preserves every function the Board currently performs effectively while removing authorities that cannot be implemented within existing legal and operational constraints. Rather than narrowing oversight, the revision solidifies it by expanding underdeveloped authorities into fully articulated functions with clear procedures and public reporting obligations. Three directional shifts frame the proposed revisions. 1. From independent investigation to monitored investigation with substantive review: The revised ordinance replaces the Board's independent investigation authority with a receive-and-refer process under which CPD conducts the administrative investigation with concurrent monitoring by the Office. The Board retains and strengthens its authority to review completed investigations for accuracy, completeness, and impartiality, and to issue findings that may include non-concurrence, identification of investigative deficiencies, or recommendations for systemic change. The Director's monitoring authority is newly codified in detail, including observation of internal affairs interviews, review of investigative plans and evidence, and post- interview feedback. 2. From hearings on individual complaints to hearings on policy, practice, and systemic concerns: The revised ordinance refocuses Board hearings on examining department policies, practices, procedures, audit findings, and patterns of concern, rather than adjudicating individual complaints. This aligns hearing practice with the Board's capacity as a volunteer body and produces systemic accountability outputs that apply across the department. 3. From case-specific disciplinary recommendations to disciplinary policy review: The Board's authority to recommend discipline in individual cases is replaced with authority to render opinions on the appropriateness of discipline imposed by the Chief of Police and to recommend changes to the department's disciplinary matrix. This reorientation addresses practical barriers, including compressed disciplinary timelines, the exclusion of Board recommendations from grievance proceedings under Sec. 29.8(G) of the CPD Collective Bargaining Agreement, and confidentiality constraints on individual personnel matters. The revision allows the Board to produce recommendations with broader and more durable impact. Legal review, May – August 2026 Following the May 18 work session, the full revision underwent legal review by the City Attorney's Office and by the independent counsel retained by the Board earlier in 2026. Both reviews responded to a single section-by-section set of questions extending through the entire ordinance revision, and each returned clear recommendations with stated reasoning. Where the two reviews diverged, the position of the City Attorney's Office took precedence; the independent counsel's recommendation was taken into consideration to shape the final language. The Board voted at its May 2026 meeting to adopt these revisions, and any modifications required by the legal review. The vast majority of revisions made as a result of legal review were for clarification, specificity, and alignment with state code, the City Code, and the CPD Collective Bargaining Agreement. These revisions did not substantively change or alter any of the proposed powers, duties, or activities of the Board and Office as presented in the matrix of changes at the May 18, 2026 work session. The revisions were limited enough in number and scope to be presented in full; they are logged section by section in the presentation accompanying this item, and appear in the redline. Financial Impact The proposed ordinance revisions carry no financial impact. No new appropriation is required, and the revisions are implementable within the existing budget of the Office of Police Civilian Oversight. Recommendation Page 69 of 240 Staff recommends that Council receive the presentation, consider the proposed revisions to Chapter 2, Article XVI on first reading, and adopt the revised Article following the second reading. The Director is available to respond to Council's questions at tonight's meeting and in the period between readings. Recommended Motion (if Applicable) Attachments 1. 9-8-26 Presentation to Council - PCOB Proposed Ordinance Revisions 2. 9-8-26 Preamble - PCOB Proposed Ordinance Revisions 3. 9-8-26 Clean Version - PCOB Proposed Ordinance Revisions 4. 9-8-26 Redline Version - PCOB Proposed Ordinance Revisions 5. 5-18-26 Changelog Prior to Legal Review - PCOB Proposed Ordinance Revisions Page 70 of 240 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE CITY COUNCIL Police Civilian Oversight Board Proposed revisions to Chapter 2, Article XVI of theCity Code FIRST READING September 8, 2026 PRESENTED BY James Walker, Director Page 71 of 240 ACTION ITEM Tonight's Request Council is asked to consider the proposed revisions toChapter 2, Article XVI, Police Civilian Oversight Board foradoption following two readings. 2 Page 72 of 240 THE PACKAGE Materials Before Council 01 Clean copy of the proposed ordinance The full text as proposed for adoption 02 Redline version Every change since the November 2025 Council-approved revision 03 Matrix of revisions The section-by-section change log presented May 18, 2026 3 Page 73 of 240 LATE 2025 – SEPTEMBER 2026 Revision Timeline November 2025 Last Council-approvedrevision to Chapter 2, Article XVI takes effect;the baseline for tonight's redline. Late 2025 – April 2026 Office and Board reviewimplementation barriers and draft the Monitor,Audit, and Review revision. May 18, 2026 Joint work session:Council receives the overview presentationand the matrix of proposed changes. May – August 2026 Dual legal review by theCity Attorney's Office and the Board'sindependent counsel. September 8, 2026 Complete ordinancetext, redline, and the May 18 revision matrixpresented for first reading. The legal review findings areincluded in this presentation. 4 Page 74 of 240 THE PROPOSED FRAMEWORK The Monitor, Audit, and Review Model Monitor Real-time observation of internal affairs investigations, interviews, briefings, training, data systems, and budget; codified in detail rather than left to practice. Audit A formal process with published audit plans, department cooperation standards, structured findings, and public audit reports. Review Substantive review of completed investigations for accuracy, completeness, and impartiality, with findings that include non- concurrence. The Board's purpose statement is restated around these functions: advancing thequality of policing through civilian-led transparency and accountability. 5 Page 75 of 240 WHAT CHANGES IN PRACTICE Three Directional Shifts CURRENT ORDINANCE PROPOSED REVISION Independent investigation by the Board and Office Receive and refer, with concurrent monitoring andsubstantive review of the completed investigation Hearings that adjudicate individual complaints Hearings on policy, practice, audit findings, andpatterns of concern Disciplinary recommendations in individual cases Opinions on discipline imposed andrecommendations to the disciplinary matrix 6 Page 76 of 240 SINCE MAY 18 · MAY – AUGUST 2026 Legal Review: Scope and Method City Attorney's Office Review of the full revision for legal sufficiency, consistency with state code, and the City's position as employer. Board's Independent Counsel Retained earlier in 2026; review of the same revision from the perspective of the Board's oversight authority. METHOD Both reviews responded to a single section-by-section set of questions extendingthrough the full ordinance revision, and each returned clear recommendations withstated reasoning. 7 Page 77 of 240 SINCE MAY 18 Legal Review: Reconciling the Two Reviews 01 Both reviews answered the same questions, section by section, across the whole revision. 02 Where the reviews aligned, the recommendation was adopted into the text. 03 Where they diverged, the City Attorney's Office position took precedence, andindependent counsel's reasoning was used to shape the final language. 8 Page 78 of 240 SINCE MAY 18 Legal Review: Nature of the Changes The oversight model presented onMay 18 is unchanged. Whatthe Board can reach wasexpanded, and how it must actwas tightened. Expanded Reach Jurisdictional exclusions cut from seven to three; the misconduct standard broadened. Legal Soundness Subpoena, conflict-of-interest, and training provisions rewritten tooperate correctly under state law. Alignment Language conformed to the Code of Virginia, the City Code, and the Collective Bargaining Agreement. 9 Page 79 of 240 SINCE MAY 18 What Changed Substantively SEC. 2-459(C) Jurisdictional Exclusions Seven exclusions reduced to three. Theone-year lookback, the civil-proceeding bar, the complainant opt-out, and thepolicy-violation test are gone. SEC. 2-451 Misconduct Standard The nine-item list becomes onestandard: significant violations of city policy, general orders, and SOPs.Protected classes tracked to the Virginia Human Rights Act. SEC. 2-458 Records Access FOIA exemptions the department mayinvoke against the Board cut from thirteen to seven; unilateral withholdingnow runs through the city manager. SEC. 2-453(E) Records Management New: all Board and office records arepublic records under the Virginia Public Records Act, retained on Library ofVirginia schedules. SEC. 2-455(D) Term Limit Eight consecutive years, stated explicitly.Unexpired terms do not count; prior service is credited; no entitlement toreappointment. SEC. 2-456(C) Meeting Trigger Quorum stays at four, but three or moremembers discussing Board business now constitutes a meeting requiring notice. 10 Page 80 of 240 POST-REVIEW LOG · 1 OF 2 Changes by Section: 2-451 – 2-455 SEC. 2-451 Definitions Single misconduct standard replaces the nine-item list;protected classes expanded to immigration and military status and to perceived characteristics. Immediate family member defined by Code of Virginia § 2.2- 4368. SEC. 2-453 Office Established New records management subsection: Virginia Public RecordsAct coverage, Library of Virginia retention, Chief remains custodian of department originals. SEC. 2-454 Powers and Duties Purpose statement expanded with community-voice and dignity language. Reviewable incidents narrowed to the three statutorycategories. SEC. 2-455 Membership, Appointment, Terms Eight-year term limit stated; terms restaggered. Conflict-of-interest self-deeming replaced with general compliance as applicable. 11 Page 81 of 240 POST-REVIEW LOG · 2 OF 2 Changes by Section: 2-456 – 2-469 SEC. 2-456 Meetings Quorum for voting clarified as distinct from the three-member threshold thattriggers a public meeting. SEC. 2-458 Records Access Exemption list narrowed; the department’s unilateral withholdingclause replaced by the city manager’s dispute process. SEC. 2-459 Jurisdiction Exclusions reduced from seven to three; the one-year lookback and its good-cause process removed. SEC. 2-460 Subpoenas Rewritten so the provision governs theBoard’s request to the court rather than directing the court. SEC. 2-462 Department Monitoring Director’s activity access made expresslynon-exhaustive; interview feedback limited to process observations. SEC. 2-464 · 2-466 · 2-469 Review, Reports, Training Deference broadened to operational andtactical decisions; hearings framed within the monitoring structure; trainingconsolidated to six months and every two years. IN SUMMARY Twelve sections were touched after legal review. The full text of each change appearsin the redline. 12 Page 82 of 240 REQUEST Adoption Staff recommends that Council consider the proposedrevisions to Chapter 2, Article XVI for adoption followingtwo readings. The Police Civilian Oversight Board voted to adopt these revisions, and anymodifications required by the legal review, at its May meeting. 13 Page 83 of 240 Discussion The Director is available to answer any Council questions. 14 Page 84 of 240 ORDINANCE #O-26-____ AN ORDINANCE TO AMEND AND REENACT CHAPTER 2, ARTICLE XVI OF THE CODE OF THE CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE TO TRANSITION THE POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD AND THE OFFICE OF POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT TO A MONITOR, AUDIT, AND REVIEW MODEL OF OVERSIGHT AND TO MAKE OTHER CHANGES FOR CLARIFICATION AND CONSISTENCY WHEREAS, Chapter 2, Article XVI of the Charlottesville City Code, adopted pursuant to Code of Virginia § 9.1- 601, establishes the Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board and the Office of Police Civilian Oversight, and was last amended and reenacted in its entirety by Ordinance No. O-25-142, adopted November 17, 2025; and WHEREAS, Chapter 2, Article XVI as presently written authorizes the Board to investigate complaints and incidents, to hold hearings on individual complaints, to recommend discipline in individual cases, and to compel statements from Department employees by subpoena, and implementation has revealed conflicts between these authorities and the law governing administrative investigations of law enforcement officers, including the Law -Enforcement Officers Procedural Guarantee Act (Code of Virginia §§ 9.1- 500 et seq.), Garrity v. New Jersey, 385 U.S. 493 (1967), the Charlottesville Police Department collective bargaining agreement, and the exclusive disciplinary authority of the Chief of Police; and WHEREAS, certain amendments to Chapter 2, Article XVI are necessary to align the Board’s authority with the oversight it can lawfully and effectively perform, to fully articulate oversight functions the Article leaves undeveloped, to consolidate into the City Code the standard operating procedure and memorandum of understanding governing access to Department information, to align the Article with federal and state law, and to make minor changes for clarification and consistency; and WHEREAS, these amendments replace independent investigation by the Board with referral of complaints to the Department, monitored by the Office and subject to substantive Board review; refocus hearings on policy, practice, and systemic concerns rather than individual complaints; replace case -specific disciplinary recommendations with review of the disciplinary matrix and its application; add provisions governing intake, monitoring, audits, reviews, and public reporting; expand the Board’s access to Department records and activities; narrow the exclusions from the Board’s jurisdiction; and revise Board membership, terms, and training; and WHEREAS, the amendments were presented to the City Council at a joint work session held May 18, 2026, and reviewed between May and August 2026 by the City Attorney’s Office and by independent counsel retained by the Board; and WHEREAS, in a public meeting and by recorded vote on May 14, 2026, the Police Civilian Oversight Board recommended adoption of these amendments and of any modifications resulting from the legal review then pending; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT ORDAINED by the Council of the City of Charlottesville, Virginia that Chapter 2, Article XVI of the Code of the City of Charlottesville is hereby amended and reenacted in its entirety as follows: Page 85 of 240 - CODE Chapter 2 - ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE XVI. POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD ARTICLE XVI. POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD1 Sec. 2-450. Title. This article shall be known as the Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board Ordinance. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-451. Definitions. (a) Authorized purpose. Those powers and duties delineated in Sec. 2-454. The term lawful purpose used in Sec. 2- 454(b)(8) specifically refers to Code of Virginia § 9.1-601. (b) Closure letter. For purposes of this article, a "closure letter" shall mean the written notification issued by the department at the conclusion of an internal affairs investigation that communicates the findings and determinations of the investigation to the complainant and, when applicable, to the director. (c) Complainant. For purposes of this article, a "complainant" shall mean any civilian who submits a complaint to the office or the department. A complainant need not be the individual directly affected by the alleged conduct. (d) Complaint. For purposes of this article, a "complaint" shall mean an allegation submitted by any civilian to the office or the department that a law enforcement officer or civilian employee of the department has engaged in misconduct. A complaint may be submitted in any form, either orally or in writing. (e) Hearing. For purposes of this article, a "hearing" shall be any public session conducted by the board to review the facts, issues, and implications of a department policy, practice, procedure, pattern, trend, audit report, systemic concern, or other matter within the board's authority. Hearings may also examine patterns in the findings, determinations, and disciplinary actions resulting from administrative investigations conducted by the department. (f) Immediate family member. For purposes of this article, "immediate family member" shall have the same meaning as that provided by Code of Virginia § 2.2-4368. (g) In writing. For purposes of this article, electronic mail (e-mail) shall constitute communication in writing. (h) Personal information. For purposes of this article, "personal information" shall have the same meaning as that provided by Code of Virginia § 2.2-3801. (i) Records. For purposes of this article, "records" shall be construed to broadly include writings, files, photographs, audio and visual recordings, and any other data, information, and evidence within the possession of the department requested by the director for an authorized purpose of the board, subjec t to limitations in this article. (j) References. For purposes of this article, the following references shall be used: (1) The board. The established and authorized Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board shall be referred to as "the board." (2) The chief. The City of Charlottesville Chief of Police shall be referred to as " the chief." (3) The commander. The Charlottesville Police Department's Commander of Internal Affairs shall be referred to as "the commander." (4) The department. The Charlottesville Police Department shall be referred to as "the department." 1Ord. No. O-25-142, adopted Nov. 17, 2025, amended Art. XVI in its entirety to read as herein set out. Former Art. XVI, §§ 2- 450—2-468, pertained to similar subject matter, and derived from Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, adopted Dec. 20, 2021; Ord. No. O-22-164, §§ 1, 2, adopted Dec. 19, 2022; and Ord. No. O-24-155, adopted Nov. 18, 2024. Page 86 of 240 (5) The director. The appointed Director of the Office of Police Civilian Oversight under the division of the City Manager's Office shall be referred to as "the director." (6) The office. The established and authorized Office of Police Civilian Oversight shall be referred to as " the office" for purposes of this article. (k) Securely retained. A physical or electronic storage format, location, or device to which access is restricted by physical or logical access controls and limited to the director and to staff of the office authorized by the director. Department records in the custody of the office shall not be accessed by any other person except in the presence of the director or authorized staff. Such records shall be maintained in accordance with the Virginia Public Records Act, Code of Virginia § 42.1-76 et seq., the records retention and disposition schedules issued by the Library of Virginia, and other applicable standards under state and federal law. (l) Serious abuse of authority or misconduct. For purposes of this article, "serious abuse of authority or misconduct" shall be defined as significant violations of city policies or procedures, including the department 's general orders and any associated standard operating procedures. This includes, but is not limited to, harassment or discrimination against, or verbal or other conduct that maligns or shows hostility toward, an individual or group because of that individual 's or group's actual or perceived: race; color; religion; national origin or ethnicity; immigration status; sex; sexual orientation; gender identity or expression; marital status; familial status; age; disability; or military or veteran status; or any other characteristic protected under the Virginia Human Rights Act (Code of Virginia § 2.2- 3900 et seq.). (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-452. Police civilian oversight board established. Pursuant to Code of Virginia § 9.1-601, there is hereby established a Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board, with powers granted as provided in this article. The board is a body established and appointed by the city council of Charlottesville pursuant to Code of Virginia § 9.1-601(B) to perform functions authorized by the city council in accordance with Code of Virginia § 9.1-601(C). It shall not be able to bring suit or to be sued in its own name, except to the extent needed to request and defend subpoenas as authorized in this article. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-453. Office of police civilian oversight established. (a) Office established. There is hereby established an Office of Police Civilian Oversight, which is a division o f the City Manager's Office, and shall have the powers granted as provided in this article to facilitate and support the authorized purpose of the board. The office shall have the authority to carry out its duties and responsibilities under this article with respect to all law enforcement activities and all sworn and civilian personnel operating under the authority of the department. (b) Director. There shall be a full-time director of the office. The director shall be responsible for and report to the board on the day-to-day operational activities of the board and the office. The director shall report to the city manager, and the city manager shall delegate to the director the authority to employ such additional staff as funded by the city council for the board to effectively fulfill its obligations under this article, and any such additional staff shall report t o the director. (1) Appointment. The city manager shall appoint a director with the approval of a majority vote of the city council. (2) Interview process. As a part of the appointment process, the city manager shall convene an interview panel that includes two (2) members of the board. If those two (2) members recommend a candidate for appointment as director, the city manager shall provide a written justification to the board if a different candidate is appointed. (c) Duties of the city manager. The city manager shall have the following duties: (1) Operating procedures. The city council authorizes the city manager to establish operating procedures for the performance of duties by the board and the office. Those procedures may be amended from time to time by the city council or by the city manager. The city council or the city manager, as applicable, shall consult with the board and the director before establishing or amending any such procedures. Page 87 of 240 (2) Supervision. The city manager or a designee shall supervise the work of the director. The city manager 's annual evaluation of the director's performance shall consider a written performance review submitted by the board to the city manager. The board may request that the city manager meet with the board 's chair to discuss the director's performance. (3) Vacancy. If there is a vacancy in the position of director, the city manager may designate some other city employee who is not an employee of the department to act as director until a new director is appointed. (d) Duties of the director. The director shall have the following duties: (1) Duties. The director shall support the board in the implementation and exercise of its oversight functions and undertake or ensure the performance of specific tasks assigned by majority vote of the board, pursuant to the powers and duties of the board authorized in this article. The director shall be responsible for management of all administrative and fiscal needs of the board and the office as authorized by the city manager. (2) Director's authority to conduct audits. The director may conduct retrospective examinations and audits as provided in Sec. 2-463 of this article, including patterns in internal affairs investigations, arrests and detentions, department expenditures, and other public-police interactions pursuant to the authorized purpose of the board. The board may request the director to conduct additional audits by majority vote. The director shall provide a summary report of any audit conducted to the board and the city manager upon completion. (3) Director's authority to engage in oversight activities on behalf of the board. The director may engage in additional oversight activities as provided in Sec. 2-462 which support and inform the functions of the board, consistent with the authorized purpose of the board. This may include, but is not limited to, review of department data systems, attendance at department meetings, review of department policies, practices, and procedures, participation in interviews of candidates for employment with the department, participation in use of force and similar conduct review panels, and other activities which are reasonably related to the board 's authorized purpose. The board may request the director to conduct additional oversight activities by majority vote. The director shall report all activities to the board and the city manager in accordance with the limitations in this article. (e) Records management. All records created or received by the board, the director, or the office in the transaction of public business are public records within the meaning of the Virginia Public Records Act, Code of Virginia § 42.1 -76 et seq., without regard to whether such records are exempt from disclosure under the Virginia Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA"). The director shall ensure that such records are retained, maintained, and disposed of in accordance with that Act and the records retention and disposition schedules and electronic records guidelines issued by the Library of Virginia, in coordination with the city's designated records officer under Code of Virginia § 42.1-85. Nothing in this subsection shall alter the chief's status as custodian of original department records. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-454. Powers and duties of the police civilian oversight board. (a) Purpose. The purpose of the board is to support community well-being and safety through civilian-led oversight that brings transparency and accountability to policing in the City of Charlottesville. The board provides the community with a direct voice in public safety and promotes policing that is lawful, fair, and respectful of the rights and dignity of all people. The board fulfills this purpose by monitoring, auditing, and reviewing department conduct, policies, practices, and procedures, and by issuing public reports wi th recommendations for corrective action and the adoption of best practices in policing. (b) Powers and duties. The board shall have the following powers and duties: (1) To receive complaints from civilians regarding the conduct of law enforcement officers and civilian employees of the department, and to refer such complaints, at the request of the complainant, to the department for investigation with monitoring by the office on behalf of the board; (2) To review and issue findings on department incidents, including the use of force by a law enforcement officer, death or serious injury to any individual held in custody, and serious abuse of authority or misconduct as defined in this article; Page 88 of 240 (3) To review policies, practices, and procedures of the department and to make recommendations regarding changes to such policies, practices, and procedures; (4) To review investigations conducted internally by the department and to issue findings regarding the accuracy, completeness, and impartiality of the investigations and the sufficiency of any discipline resulting from such investigations; (5) To review reports of the annual expenditures of the department, and to make recommendations to the city council concerning future appropriations; (6) To make public reports on the activities of the board, including reviews, hearings, findings, determinations, recommendations, and oversight activities; (7) To hold hearings and if, after making a good faith effort to obtain the voluntary attendance of witnesses , with the exception of employees of the department, and the production of books, papers, and other records or evidence necessary to perform its duties, the board is unable to obtain such attendance or production, to apply to the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville for a subpoena compelling the attendance of such witness or the production of such books, papers, and other records or evidence; and (8) To undertake other duties, as reasonably necessary, for the board to effectuate its lawful purpose as provided in this article, including the delegation of administrative support functions, department monitoring, auditing, and other routine oversight activities to the office established in this article. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-455. Board membership, appointment, and terms. (a) Objectivity. In making appointments under this section, the city council shall seek members who are fair and objective, and who will be perceived as fair and objective, in the conduct of their duties . (b) Appointment process. The city council shall appoint the members of the board. City council shall announce a public application process with applications available online and by hardcopy for individuals interested in serving on the board. The application window shall remain open for a minimum of thirty (30) calendar days from the date of public announcement. City council shall seek to appoint members with a demonstrated commitment to community service who have training and experience, including lived experience, with topics relevant to the business of the board, including law, police practices, human resources practices and pro cedures, trauma-informed mental health issues, or the sociology of historically overpoliced communities. (c) Board composition. The board shall reflect the demographic diversity of the City of Charlottesville. The board shall be composed of seven (7) voting members and one (1) non-voting member. The members shall be removable by the city council for cause, including conduct specified in the board's code of ethics set forth in the board's operating procedures, violating the duty of confidentiality, failing to participate in required training, or other good cause. (1) The seven (7) voting members of the board shall be residents of the City of Charlottesville or Albemarle County. Priority shall be given to city residents. Residents of Albemarle County appointed to membership on the board shall be employed in the City of Charlottesville or shall have significant and demonstrable ties to the city. If, after the defined public application process, the city council determines that there are insufficient eligible applicants who are residents of the City of Charlottesville or Albemarle County to fill a vacancy on the board, the city council may appoint a resident of the Commonwealth of Virginia who is employed in the City of Charlottesville or who has significant and demonstrable ties to the city. (2) The non-voting member of the board shall be an individual with policing expertise or experience. The non- voting member may be a retired law enforcement officer who prior to retirement was employed in a locality similar to the City of Charlottesville. (3) No board member shall be a current candidate for public office, a former member of the department, an immediate family member of a current department employee, or a current employee of a law enforcement agency, the fire department, the emergency communications center, or the sheriff's office. If the city council Page 89 of 240 considers appointing a board member who is employed by the City of Charlottesville, the city council shall seek to avoid potential conflicts of interests. (d) Terms. Each board member shall be appointed for a term of two (2) years. Except as otherwise provided in this section, appointments and terms shall be subject to the provisions of chapter 2, article I, § 2 -8 of the city code. No person shall serve more than eight (8) consecutive years on the board, and no person shall be appointed or reappointed to a term that, if served to completion, would exceed that limit. Service in the unexpired portion of a term shall not be counted toward this limit. Service in a term under this article as it existed before the effective date of this amendment shall be credited as the number of years in that term. Members serving on the board as of the effective date of this amendment shall continue to serve the remainder of their current term. The composition requirements, term length, and term limit established by this section shall apply to all appointments and reappointments made on or after the effective date of this amendment. Nothing in this section shall entitle any person to reappointment. (e) Conflicts of interests. A board member shall not participate in any matter before the board under circumstances in which the objectivity of the board member could reasonably be questioned, including, without limitation, the consideration of a complaint of someone who is an immediate family member. All board members shall comply with the requirements of the Virginia State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act, as applicable . (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-456. Meetings. (a) Number of meetings. The board shall hold public meetings at least once per calendar quarter. Additional meetings may be called by the chair or any two (2) board members. (b) FOIA. The board shall comply with all applicable requirements of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA") pertaining to disclosure of public records and the conduct of its meetings. (c) Quorum. A quorum of the board for the transaction of business and the taking of any vote shall be four (4) members. However, for purposes of Virginia FOIA, a meeting of the board occurs whenever as many as three (3) members are gathered to discuss or transact the business of the board, and any such gathering shall be noticed and conducted in accordance with that Act. (d) Minutes. The board shall keep minutes of its meetings, which shall include: (1) The date, time, and location of the meeting; (2) The members present and absent; (3) A summary of the discussion on matters proposed, deliberated, or decided; and (4) A record of any votes taken. (e) Rules and procedures. Meetings of the board shall be conducted in accordance with Robert 's Rules of Order or such other procedures as the board may adopt. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-457. Board legal counsel. The director may retain independent legal counsel to advise and represent the board in connection with its oversight powers and duties, and in any other matters involving the interests of the board. Such independent legal counsel shall be chosen from a list of attorneys recommended by the city attorney. The director is authorized to execute a contract in the name of the board for legal services if the contract has first been approved by the board and endorsed by the city' s finance director to verify that funding is available and has been appropriated to support performance of the payment obligations of the board under such contract. The board's legal counsel shall be paid only from funds that have been appropriated to the board's budget by city council. The board and the director are encouraged to consult the office of the city attorney for legal advice, except in matters involving potential conflicts of interests between the board and the department. Page 90 of 240 (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-458. Information access and limitations. (a) Access to department information. Subject to certain narrow limitations described in this article and through administration by the director, the board is authorized to receive, and shall be provided full access to, all department reports, files, and records determined by the board or the director to be necessary to carry out its authorized purpose. All records, documents, and materials in the possession of or provided to the board or the director shall be subject to the protection of confidential and personal information as defined in this article and the board's operating procedures. (b) Records to be routinely provided. The department shall provide the following records to the director within five (5) calendar days of the receipt or creation of the record by the department: (1) Initial complainant contact letter; (2) Complaint closure letter; (3) Monthly report by the department's Fourth Amendment auditor; and (4) Monthly report by the Office of Internal Affairs. (c) Requests for department records. The department shall provide all records specifically identified by the director, as well as those related to the subject matter and reasonably necessary to permit the board to review the identified subject matter. The director shall notify the chief or a designee in writing when the following occurs, as applicable, which shall constitute a request for records for purposes of this article: (1) The review of an internal affairs investigation has been scheduled. The director shall provide sufficient information to allow the department to identify the investigation and any related complaints or disciplinary records. (2) The review of a specific department policy, practice, or procedure. The director shall provide sufficient information to allow the department to identify records in its possession relevant to the review. (3) An audit has been initiated by the director or requested by the board. The director shall provide the chief or a designee with a copy of the audit plan, which shall indicate the general nature of the contemplated audit such that the department may identify records relevant to the audit. (d) Delivery of records. Upon the provision of such written requests for records, the department shall provide the director with the requested records within five (5) calendar days of the director 's request or, if applicable, within five (5) calendar days of the city manager's written ruling regarding a dispute about access to records. In either case, the director and the chief or a designee may agree to a different timeline for the delivery of the requested records. In the absence of a director or appointed designee, written requests shall be issued by the chair of the board with a majority vote of its members. The chief or a designee shall appoint an employee of the department to administer records access to the board until such time as a new director or designee is appointed to such role by the city manager. (e) Format of department records. The board shall be provided department records, administered by the director, in the following formats: (1) Body-worn and dashboard camera video. The director shall be provided with independent access privileges to any relevant department systems to view all footage from cameras worn or operated by the department if relevant to the subject of an authorized purpose of the board. The director shall not share the access credentials with any other person, and the director shall not allow any person to view such video footage, other than a member of the board who has signed a confidentiality agreement, which the director shall certify , and in which case the board member may review the video footage only in the presence of the director. (2) Originals or exact copies. The director shall be provided with the original version of the requested department records or, if feasible, may be provided copies of such records, at the department 's discretion. If copies of the original records are provided to the director, they shall be exact duplicates of the original versions other than minor formatting or cosmetic differences that do not impact the content of the records. Page 91 of 240 (3) Secure retention, return, or destruction. The original records and any copies thereof provided by the department to the director shall be returned to the chief or a designee as the custodian of the original records within five (5) calendar days of completion of the board review or audit, except that upon agreement in writing by the chief or a designee, copies of department video footage and records provided to the director may be securely retained for up to one (1) year or destroyed. A review or audit shall be deemed complete upon occurrence of the following, as applicable: (i) Public release of the final findings, determinations, and recommendations of a review; (ii) Presentation by the director of a final audit report to the board; or (iii) In a case in which (i) or (ii) above does not apply, at such other time as the director notifies the chief or a designee in writing that the authorized purpose for which the records were requested is complete. (f) Department information to which the board shall not have access. The director and the board shall not have access to: (1) Records that may reveal the identity or personal information of a confidential informant; (2) Investigative files related to an active civil or criminal investigation by the Commonwealth's Attorney, the Virginia Attorney General, the Virginia State Police, or the United States Department of Justice; (3) Files related to an active Equal Employment Opportunity Commission claim, Human Rights Commission investigation, or civil claim involving a department employee; (4) Files containing information exempt from mandatory public disclosure or prohibited from public disclosure pursuant to Code of Virginia §§ 2.2-3706(B)(2), (3), (5), (8), (11); 2.2-3706(C); and 2.2- 3706.1(E); and (5) Any information that the department is not legally authorized to share. (g) Disputes over access. If the director and the board seek access to information the disclosure of which the department believes is outside the scope of, or expressly prohibited by the authority granted in this article, and the director and chief cannot resolve this dispute after mutual discussion and consultation, then the city manager shall resolve the dispute consistent with the purposes and provisions of this article. The city manager may conduct an informal hearing at which both the director and chief may be heard, and the city manager shall issue a written ruling within three (3) business days thereafter. If the board believes that the city manager is unreasonably withholding such information, the board may consider whether to seek a subpoena requiring the production of such information as provided in Sec. 2-460 of this article. (h) Confidentiality. Each member of the board and the director shall maintain the confidentiality of all personal information and confidential or privileged information, including, but not limited to: (1) Materials from police internal investigative files; (2) Disciplinary actions, memos, and reports; (3) Statements of any police officer or civilian employee who was required by the department to give a statement; (4) Criminal investigative files; and (5) Any other information that the chief or city attorney's office has deemed confidential. This requirement to maintain confidentiality continues indefinitely or until the information no longer meets the definition of confidential or privileged as defined in this article. (i) Protocols to prevent improper dissemination. The director and the board shall adhere to the following protocols to prevent improper dissemination of confidential records, including records containing personal or privileged information not subject to public release: (1) The director and board shall not use or disseminate non-public personal information regarding any person, for any purpose or in any manner, other than as authorized by applicable state and federal law, local ordinances, and the authority to release public records defined in this article. Page 92 of 240 (2) The director and board shall take all appropriate measures to maintain the security and confidentiality of all non - public personal information contained within department records to which access has been provided. (3) Within any written reports to be presented at a public meeting of the board or released to the public, and during any public comments about matters currently or likely in the future to be the subject of a review or audit by the board or director, the board and director may disclose the following personal information about any person, except as otherwise prohibited by state or federal law: (i) Personal information previously publicly disclosed (by a party or pa rties other than the board or director); and (ii) Non-public personal information regarding a department officer or employee with the prior written consent of the officer or employee. (4) In all other cases, written reports to be presented at a public meeting of the board or released to the public, and public comments about matters currently or likely in the future to be the subject of a review or audit by the board or director, shall refer only to anonymized information regarding any specific department officer or employee, and information that would not permit the particular officer or employee to be personally identified. (j) Records to remain department records. The chief, as the custodian of original department records, shall be responsible for decisions as to whether copies of such records (or information contained in such records) may be publicly disclosed, subject to the direction and control of the city manager. In the event of a request pursuant to Virginia FOIA for records in the possession of the board or director, the director, as applicable, shall consult with the city attorney' s office and claim all relevant exemptions allowed by FOIA to withhold the records or portions thereof from public disclosure, except in cases where public disclosure is authorized in writing by either the chief or the city manager and is otherwise lawful. Nothing in this paragraph shall preclude the city manager from establishing guidelines in the operating procedures regarding public disclosure of certain types of information contained within department records. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-459. Exclusions, limitations, and suspension. (a) Compliance. Any oversight activities shall comply with all federal, state, and local laws, as well as with requirements for the conduct of the board's powers and duties described in this article and in accordance with the board's operating procedures. (b) Compelled statements. The board may not compel a statement from any department employee. (c) Exclusions. The board shall not consider complaints, incidents, claims, or issues involving the following: (1) Matters that are the subject of a pending criminal proceeding in any trial court, or any pending City of Charlottesville grievance proceeding; (2) An allegation of misconduct only by employees of law enforcement agencies other than the department. Such complainants shall be referred to the appropriate law enforcement agency; and (3) Any other claim outside the scope of the board's authority expressly set forth in this article. (d) Suspension of oversight activity. If a complaint asserts criminal conduct by an employee of the department, or if at any point in the performance of oversight powers and duties, the board or director become aware that an employee may have committed a criminal offense, the board and the director shall suspend all oversight activity and notify the chief and Commonwealth's Attorney of the alleged conduct. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-460. Subpoenas. (a) Application for subpoenas. If the board determines that there are records, including witnesses, not within the control of the department that the board is unable to obtain voluntarily, the board by two -thirds (⅔) vote may authorize the Page 93 of 240 director, on behalf of the board, to apply to the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville for a subpoena compelling the production of such records, or the attendance of such witnesses to a public hearing held in accordance with Sec. 2-466(f) of this article. (b) Requests for access. If the director is denied access to material records within the control of the department that the director deems necessary to perform their duties and the duties of the board, the director may request the city manager to require the department to produce the requested records. No request shall include witnesses who are employees, sworn or civilian, of the department, and the board's authorized subpoena power shall not be used to compel attendance of or statements from department employees. The city manager or a designee shall not unreasonably deny such a request, but may place conditions on the production of the requested records as necessary to preserve confidentiality for the reasons set forth in this article. The city manager or a designee shall issue a decision on the director's request within five (5) business days of the date of that request. (c) Scope of subpoenas. If the city manager or a designee denies the director's request made pursuant to subsection (b) above, the board by two-thirds (⅔) vote may authorize the director, on behalf of the board, to apply to the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville for a subpoena compelling the production of such records . The board shall give the city manager and the department reasonable notice of its intent to subpoena such records and shall give the city attorney a copy of the request for subpoena. The board shall not unreasonably withhold its agreement to limitations on the scope of the subpoena requested by the city manager that may be necessary to protect confidential information. The parties may request that any hearing to be held in the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville on the request for a subpoena be conducted in a closed courtroom, to the extent permitted by state law. The board may request that all or any portion of the court file relating to any such application be placed under seal to the extent permitted by state law. (d) Retention of subpoena records. If a subpoena is granted which compels the production of records, the board shall provide the department with copies of any such records. (e) Conduct of compelled attendance by witnesses. If a subpoena is granted which compels the attendance of a witness or witnesses at a public hearing of the board, such attendance shall comply with the board' s operating procedures, including a hearing manual adopted thereunder, and the following provisions: (1) In any application for a witness subpoena under this section, the board shall request that the subpoena include a statement that any testimony provided shall be made under oath and that the witness is entitled to representation by an attorney. The board shall, in any event, provide such notice in writing to any witness subpoenaed under this section. (2) Any witness failing to comply with a subpoena issued under this section may be subject to a charge of contempt by the issuing court as provided by law. Any witness so subpoenaed may petition the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville to quash the subpoena. (3) In the case of refusal or neglect to comply with a subpoena, the board may petition for its enforcement in the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-461. Intake and referrals. All submissions of complaints, review requests, inquiries, recommendations, comments, and compliments shall be received and documented by the office in accordance with the procedures established in the board's operating procedures. The office shall provide a response to all submissions indicating receipt and advising on any next steps. The following actions shall be taken: (1) For all complaints related to the alleged misconduct of a department employee, the office shall establish communication with the complainant and collect all relevant information regarding the complaint and ascertain whether the complainant desires to have the department conduct an official investigation with monitoring by the director. If the complainant does not request a department investigation, the complaint shall be documented by the office and the information contained therein shall be available to the director for purposes Page 94 of 240 of monitoring, auditing, and other oversight activities authorized under this article. Additionally, the director shall: (i) Provide updates to the complainant, upon request, regarding whether an administrative investigation has commenced, is pending, or has concluded. Such updates shall not disclose any substantive information about the investigation, including its evidence, witnesses, findings, or d eterminations, and shall remain subject to the limitations in this article; and (ii) Verify the complainant has received a closure letter from the commander at the conclusion of any investigation. (2) For all review requests of an internal affairs investigation previously concluded by the department, the office shall obtain a copy of the case closure letter and collect all relevant information regarding the original complaint, investigation, and reason for the review request. (3) For all complaints received which allege misconduct by a city employee outside the department or an employee of another law enforcement jurisdiction, the director shall provide the complainant with contact information for the agency, office, or entity who may best assist the complainant. (4) For all inquiries, recommendations, and comments related to the conduct, policies, practices, or procedures of the department, the office shall provide as much information as is readily known or obtain such information to provide in response. (5) For all compliments or commendations, the office shall collect all relevant information and provide this information to the board. (6) For any complaint, review request, inquiry, recommendation, comment, or compliment which is outside the scope of the board's authorized power and duties, the office shall provide the contact information for the agency, office, or entity who may best assist the individual. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-462. Conduct of department monitoring. (a) Referral of complaints. If a complainant asks that their complaint be investigated by the department, the complaint shall be investigated by the department with monitoring by the director. (b) Monitoring of investigations and incidents. The director may actively monitor investigations of complaints and incidents of alleged employee misconduct by the department and shall have access to records and witnesses to the same extent as the department, subject to the limitations or requirements set out in this article. Such monitoring may include: (1) Reviewing the investigative plan of the department; (2) Reviewing any records within the department's digital evidence management system; (3) Reviewing any pertinent law enforcement records within the department's records management system; (4) Observing any real-time interviews of witnesses by the department; (5) Reviewing any recorded interviews; and (6) Reviewing facts gained from investigation. For active criminal investigations, the director shall be limited in participation to the same extent the department is limited in its participation in such investigations. The director may monitor the department 's administrative investigation of alleged employee misconduct after the close of the active criminal investigation in the same manner as all other investigations of employee conduct handled by the department as described in this ar ticle. When monitoring department investigations, during the pendency of the investigations the director shall not disclose information about the investigation to any person other than as authorized in writing by the chief or the city manager. Page 95 of 240 (c) Observation of internal affairs interviews. The director shall be authorized to observe real-time interviews conducted by the department as part of an administrative investigation in accordance with the board' s operating procedures and the following provisions: (1) The commander shall notify the director, in writing, of all external complaints filed against or about d epartment personnel immediately after receiving each such complaint, or by the next business day. (2) The commander shall notify the director, in writing, of the date, time, and location of all scheduled interviews associated with the complaint. Unless exigent circumstances exist, the d irector shall be provided at least twenty- four (24) hours of advance notice of the interview. If, due to exigent circumstances, the d irector is provided with less than twenty-four (24) hours of advance notice, the commander shall include a description of such circumstances. (3) If the director chooses to observe an interview, the director shall notify the commander in writing as soon as practically possible before the interview. (4) The director shall be permitted to monitor the interview from a separate room, if possible, or from within the same room where the interview occurs. The director shall be able to clearly see and hear the interview as it occurs. The director shall not interfere with or interrupt the department's interview process. (5) The director shall, at the conclusion of any observed interview, be afforded the ability to provide verbal feedback to the commander, and the assigned investigator if not the commander, regarding the impartiality and sufficiency of the interview conducted. Any feedback provided by the director shall be shared with the board if the investigation is reviewed by the board after the conclusion of the investigation. Nothing in this subsection shall require the Office of Internal Affairs to implement feedback provided by the director during the investigation. Any such feedback is limited to process-related observations and is not evidence or a recommendation on the merits of the complaint. (d) General oversight of department operations. In addition to the monitoring of investigations and incidents, the director may engage in ongoing monitoring and oversight activities to support and inform the functions of the board consistent with this article. The board may request the director to conduct additional monitoring or oversight activities by majority vote. The director shall report all activities conducted under this section to the board and the city manager in accordance with the information access and limitations established in Sec. 2- 458 of this article. (1) Director access. The director may participate in or observe department activities, including but not limited to the following: (i) Department staff meetings, command staff meetings, briefings, and roll calls; (ii) Use of force review panels and similar internal conduct review processes; (iii) Interviews of candidates for sworn and civilian employment with the department; (iv) Department training sessions, including in-service and specialized training; (v) Review of department data systems, reports, and performance metrics; (vi) Review of current or proposed department policies, practices, procedures, and directives; and (vii) Other activities reasonably necessary for the board to effectuate its authorized purpose under this article. The enumeration in this subsection is illustrative and not exhaustive, and shall not be construed to limit the director's access to other department activities. Access to activities under this subsection shall be limited only as provided in subsection (d)(3) or Sec. 2-458 of this article. (2) Notice. The department shall provide the director with reasonable advance notice of the activities listed in subsection (d)(1)(i) through (vii), including the date, time, and location, sufficient to allow the director the opportunity to attend. The chief or a designee and the director may establish a standing schedule or notification protocol to satisfy this requirement. (3) Limitations on participation. The director's participation under this section shall be in an observational and advisory capacity and shall not include authority to direct, countermand, or delay department operations or personnel decisions. The department may temporarily limit the director 's access to a specific activity if the chief Page 96 of 240 or a designee determines in writing that the director's presence would compromise an active criminal investigation, officer safety during a tactical operation, or a legally protected proceeding. Any such limitation shall be narrowly tailored and shall expire when the stated justification no longer applies. (4) Disputes. If the director is denied access to any activity under this section and the director and the chief are unable to resolve the matter through mutual consultation, the dispute shall be resolved in accordance with the procedures established in Sec. 2-458(g) of this article. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-463. Conduct of department audits. (a) Purpose and scope. The director may conduct retrospective audits of department patterns, practices, procedures , data, and outcomes to provide relevant information to the board to effectuate its authorized purpose and to identify systemic changes that may improve police services to the community. Audit topics may include, but are not limited to, patterns in internal affairs investigations, use of force incidents, arrests and detentions, searches and seizures, department expenditures, implementation of policies and training directives, deployment of systems and technologies, and other public-police interactions. Audits shall not be used to adjudicate individual complaints or to make findings of misconduct against individual employees, but the director may re fer information discovered during an audit to the department or the city manager if it suggests conduct warranting separate review. Audits shall be conducted in accordance with the board's operating procedures, which shall include an audit manual adopted thereunder. (b) Initiation. An audit may be initiated by the director or by majority vote of the board. If initiated by board vote, the request shall identify the general subject matter and purpose. The director shall commence the audit within ten (10) business days or provide the board a written explanation if the audit is not feasible within the limitations of available resources, in which case the board and director shall confer to resolve scheduling or scope. (c) Audit plan. Prior to any collection of data or requests for department records for the purpose of an audit, the director shall prepare a written audit plan and provide a copy to the chief or a designee and to the board. The plan shall include: (1) The subject matter, scope, and time period to be examined; (2) The categories of records, data, or other information anticipated to be necessary; (3) The anticipated methodology for analysis; and (4) An estimated timeline for completion. (d) Department cooperation. Upon receipt of the audit plan, the department shall provide records and data in accordance with this article within five (5) calendar days, designate a liaison to coordinate with the director for the duration of the audit, and make a good faith effort to respond to reasonable requests for additional records or clarification. (e) Audit report. Upon completion, the director shall prepare a written report and provide it to the board, the chief, and the city manager. The board shall review the report and may adopt, modify, or supplement the director 's recommendations before issuing findings and recommendations pursuant to this article. The report shall include: (1) A description of the scope, methodology, and time period examined; (2) A summary of findings, including identified patterns, trends, or areas of concern; (3) Recommendations, if any, for changes to department policies, practices, procedures, training, or resource allocation; and (4) Any relevant response or information provided by the department during the audit. Page 97 of 240 (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-464. Conduct of board reviews. (a) Purpose. The board may conduct reviews of information provided by the department, the director, and other sources to fulfill its oversight functions authorized under this article. The board 's reviews are intended to provide a civilian-led perspective on department conduct and operations, grounded in objective evidence, and to serve as the basis for the findings, determinations, and recommendations issued pursuant to Sec. 2 -466 of this article. (b) Matters subject to review. The board may conduct reviews of any of the following: (1) Internal affairs investigations, including the department's case file, investigative methodology, and resulting findings and disciplinary determinations; (2) Department incidents, including use of force incidents, deaths or serious injuries of persons in custody, and other incidents identified in Sec. 2-454(b)(2) of this article; (3) Audit reports prepared by the director pursuant to Sec. 2-463 of this article; (4) Department policies, practices, procedures, and directives, whether existing or proposed; (5) Department data, performance metrics, trends, and patterns identified through monitoring activities conducted pursuant to Sec. 2-462 of this article; or (6) Any other matter within the scope of the board's authorized purpose regarding the conduct or operations of the department and department employees. (c) Information provided to the board. The director shall prepare and present to the board materials necessary to conduct a review, which may include written summaries, relevant records provided by the department subject to the limitations of Sec. 2-458 and Sec. 2-459, data analyses, research, and any other information obtained through the oversight activities authorized under this article. The director shall present information in a manner that protects personal information and maintains the confidentiality requirements established in Sec. 2- 458 of this article. (d) Evaluation and deliberation. In evaluating matters under review, the board shall consider the totality of information available and shall base its findings, determinations, and recommendations on objective evidence. The board may consider any of the following in its deliberations: (1) Records, data, and reports provided by the department through the director; (2) The director's analysis, observations, and recommendations, including information obtained through monitoring and audit activities; (3) Applicable department policies, general orders, training standards, and the disciplinary matrix; (4) Applicable federal, state, and local law, including constitutional standards governing law enforcement conduct; (5) Published research, professional standards, and best practices in law enforcement, including guidance from professional organizations such as the National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement; (6) Testimony or written statements from subject matter experts, community members, or other persons with relevant knowledge, received during a public meeting or hearing conducted pursuant to this article; (7) Comparative practices of other law enforcement agencies; and (8) Any other information the board determines to be relevant and reliable. Page 98 of 240 (e) Standard of review. The board shall evaluate the matters before it based on the reasonableness of the department 's actions, decisions, and policies in light of the totality of the circumstances and the information available. The board 's role is to provide an informed civilian assessment, not to substitute its judgment for the operational or tactical decisions of sworn personnel. Where the board disagrees with the department 's findings, determinations, or actions, the board shall articulate specific reasoning supported by the evidence and information considered. (f) Department participation. The board may request that the chief or a designee appear before the board during a review to present information, provide context, or respond to questions regarding the matter under review. Any such participation by department personnel shall be voluntary and shall not constitute a compelled statement for purposes of this article or applicable law. The board may also request written responses from the department on specific questions arising during the course of a review. (g) Public participation. The board may receive public comment relevant to a matter under review during any public meeting in accordance with the board's operating procedures. The board may establish reasonable time limits and guidelines for public comment. Public comment received by the board may be considered as part of the board' s deliberations but shall not be the sole basis for any finding, determination, or recommendation. (h) Procedures. Reviews shall be conducted in accordance with the board's operating procedures, including a review manual adopted thereunder, which shall address scheduling and notice of reviews, the format for presentation of information to the board, procedures for deliberation and voting, and the documentation of the board' s reasoning in support of its findings, determinations, and recommendations. All findings, determinations, recommendations, and any resulting resolutions of the board shall only be made by a majority vote of the board with an established quorum. Any portion of a review involving discussion or consideration of criminal investigative files, audit findings, or deliberations regarding police operations related to a specific complaint before the board, where the complaint involves an offense enumerated in Code of Virginia § 2.2-3711(A)(56), shall be conducted in closed session as authorized by that subdivision. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-465. Annual review of police budget and expenditures. During the city manager's preparation of a proposed city budget, the budget office shall provide the director with annual expenditure estimates and future year projections for the department, itemized to the same level of detail as provided to the city manager. The estimates shall be presented to the board by the director. The board may review the estimates and may make budgetary recommendations to the city manager and to the city council during the annual budget process. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-466. Findings, determinations, recommendations, and public reporting. (a) Board outcomes. Upon the completion of a review, audit, or other oversight activity authorized under this article, the board may, by majority vote, issue findings, determinations, recommendations, resolutions, or public reports. Any such outcome shall be issued within thirty (30) calendar days of the board's vote. All outcomes shall be released publicly in accordance with subsection (i) and shall conform to the board's operating procedures. (b) Outcomes related to review of internal affairs investigations. Upon review of an internal affairs investigation conducted by the department, the board shall issue one of the following findings: (1) The board concurs with the findings and determinations provided in the internal affairs case closure letter; Page 99 of 240 (2) The board does not concur with some or all of the findings and determinations provided in the internal affairs case closure letter and shall provide specific reasoning as to why the findings and determinations are not supported by the information reasonably available to the department; or (3) The board finds that the investigation is incomplete or otherwise unsatisfactory and shall provide a detailed written explanation of the basis for such finding. In review of any investigation in which the board issues a finding under subsection (b)(2) or (b)(3), the board may include determinations regarding systemic, policy, or procedural issues with the investigation and may make recommendations to the chief and to the city manager regarding further review, corrective action, or changes to investigative practices. Any resulting determinations or recommendations related to broader policies, practices, or procedures of the department, beyond the scope of the investigative process, shall be made in accordance with Sec. 2-466(d) and (e). (c) Outcomes related to department incidents. Upon review of an incident involving the department or actions of department employees, the board shall issue one of the following findings: (1) The incident does not merit a formal investigation; (2) The incident merits a formal investigation conducted by the department's Office of Internal Affairs with monitoring by the director, and the board shall provide specific reasoning for this finding; or (3) The board does not have enough relevant details about the incident to make a finding and may request additional information from the department or third parties before pursuing another review of the incident. The board, upon receiving such additional information, may determine no further review is necessary. In review of any incident in which the board issues a finding under subsection ( c)(2), the board may include determinations regarding systemic, policy, or procedural issues with the incident and may make recommendations to the chief and to the city manager regarding further review, corrective action, or changes to investigative practices related to incidents. Any resulting determinations or recommendations related to broader policies, practices, or procedures of the department, beyond the scope of the incident review, shall be made in accordance with Sec. 2- 466(d) and (e). (d) Outcomes related to disciplinary policy and application. Upon making a finding as the result of a review of an internal affairs investigation or incident, the board may issue determinations and recommendations regarding the department's disciplinary policy and its application, in a manner that protects personal information regarding identifiable employees against public disclosure and in accordance with the information access and limitations established in Sec. 2-458 and Sec. 2-459 of this article. Such recommendations may include: (1) Proposed amendments to the department's disciplinary matrix or any related policies, practices, or procedures that had a direct impact on the disciplinary outcome under review; or (2) A recommendation to the chief regarding the consistent application of disciplinary sanctions as established in department policy. (e) Outcomes related to audits, policies, practices, and procedures. Upon board review of a completed audit conducted by the director, or a board review of department policies, practices, or procedures, the board may issue determinations , recommendations, or resolutions addressing identified patterns, trends, deficiencies, or opportunities for improvement. Determinations and recommendations may address changes to department policies, practices, procedures, training, resource allocation, equipment, or implementation of systems and technologies. (f) Hearings. The board may hold public hearings to examine matters within the scope of its authorized purpose in greater depth than is afforded during regular public meetings. A hearing serves as a culminating oversight activity, drawing on the reviews, audits, and monitoring conducted under this article to develop the public record supporting Page 100 of 240 the findings, determinations, recommendations, and resolutions the board may issue under this section. Hearings shall be subject to the following provisions: (1) Purpose and scope. A hearing may be convened by majority vote of the board to examine a specific policy, practice, procedure, pattern, trend, audit report, systemic concern, or other matter within the board's authority. A hearing shall not be convened for the purpose of adjudicating an individual complaint or incident of alleged misconduct, or for the purpose of making findings of misconduct against an identified department employee. (2) Participation. The board may invite or receive participation from any of the following: (i) Department representatives, including the chief or a designee, on a voluntary basis; (ii) Members of the public with relevant knowledge or experience; (iii) Subject matter experts, researchers, or professionals with expertise relevant to the hearing topic; (iv) Representatives of community organizations, advocacy groups, or other public agencies; and (v) Media representatives, for purposes of public transparency. (3) Evidence and testimony. The board may receive and consider documentary evidence, data, research, written statements, and oral testimony relevant to the hearing topic. The board may exercise its subpoena authority as provided in Sec. 2-460 of this article to compel the production of records or evidence from the department, and to compel the attendance of witnesses or the production of records or evidence from third parties. The board shall not exercise its subpoena authority to compel the attendance of or any statement by a n employee of the department but may request voluntary participation by the department in the proceedings. (4) Procedures. Hearings shall be conducted in accordance with the board's operating procedures, including a hearing manual adopted thereunder, which shall address notice to the public, scheduling, order of proceedings, time allotments for participants, and the format for receiving evidence and testimony. All hearings shall comply with Virginia FOIA and limitations established in Sec. 2-458 and Sec. 2-459 of this article. (5) Hearing outcomes. At the conclusion of a hearing, the board may issue determinations, recommendations, or resolutions in accordance with subsection (i). The director shall prepare a written summary of the hearing, including testimony received and evidence considered, which shall be included in or appended to the board' s published findings. (g) Department response. Within thirty (30) calendar days of receiving the board's findings, determinations, or recommendations issued under this section, the chief shall provide a written response to the board, the city manager, and the city council, as applicable, indicating acceptance, partial acceptance, or declination of such board outcomes with supporting rationale specific to address the board's stated reasoning and evidence for issuing each finding, determination, or recommendation. The chief's response shall be made available for public inspection. (h) Follow-up. The director may conduct follow-up monitoring at reasonable intervals to assess the department's implementation of accepted recommendations by the board. The results of any follow-up monitoring shall be reported to the board and included in the office's annual report. (i) Public reporting. All findings, determinations, recommendations, and resolutions issued by the board under this section shall be provided to the chief and the city manager, and shall be made available for public inspection, subject to applicable confidentiality protections and limitations of this article . When the director and chair of the board determine that an outcome has substantial relevance to matters of public policy, resource allocation, or systemic concern, such outcome shall also be provided to the city council. The director shall maintain a public record of all board outcomes issued under this section, including the department 's written responses, and shall make such records accessible on the board's website. Page 101 of 240 (j) Annual report. Each calendar year, the director shall provide the board, the city manager, and city council with an annual report of activities conducted during the preceding calendar year. The report shall be published and made available for public inspection on or about June 1 of each year for the preceding year and shall include: (1) Committees appointed and their actions; (2) An overview of complaints and review requests received, including the number of complaints monitored, the number and content of audits conducted, the number of reviews conducted and any resulting outcomes, and the number of complaints deferred due to pending proceedings; (3) Proposed amendments to department policies, practices, or procedures, and whether the department implemented them; (4) The attendance by members of the board at public community listening sessions, community events, or other events which relate to the work of the board, including a summary of board actions or any public input and recommendations received; (5) Other recommendations of the board regarding policing within the city; (6) Training received by members of the board; (7) Engagement in department collaboration in fulfillment of the board's oversight mandate; and (8) Any other information necessary to provide an overview of board and office activities. The board and the director may publish additional reports as deemed appropriate to provide transparency into oversight activities of the board and the office, including monthly and quarterly reports. (k) Legislative recommendations. The board may make recommendations to the city council of any proposed changes in state law, for the council's consideration to include in its annual legislative program to present to the General Assembly. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-467. Alternative resolution. (a) Informal resolution. Upon receiving a complaint or review request, the office may, before referring a complaint to the department or initiating a formal board review, offer the complainant information or referral to appropriate resources, including department programs, other city services, or community resources that may address the complainant's concerns. Any informal resolution shall be documented by the director and reported to the board. Nothing in this section shall prevent or discourage a complainant from filing or pursuing a formal complaint or review at any time, and the office shall inform the complainant of that right when offering informal resolution options. (b) Mediation and alternative dispute resolution. If the department maintains a mediation or alternative dispute resolution program, the office may inform the complainant of the availability of such program as an option. Participation in any such program shall be voluntary for all parties. A complainant 's decision not to participate in mediation or alternative dispute resolution shall not affect the complainant 's right to pursue remedies under other sections of this article, including a formal complaint or review request. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-468. Community engagement. The board and the director shall engage in regular community outreach and collaboration to seek the assistance and input of community members and to provide education, awareness, and guidance on policing matters. The board may host public community listening and discussion sessions regarding policing matters of pressing public concern, such as questions about transparency, availability, legitimacy, mutual respect and trust, and community safety and order. The board and the Page 102 of 240 director may also host or participate in public police-community relations meetings focused on topics such as the impacts of local policing on historically disadvantaged communities that currently experience or traditionally have experienced disparate policing. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-469. Board member training. Each board member shall receive training, provided or facilitated by the director, within six (6) months of the member's appointment and every two (2) years thereafter. The training shall be consistent with the board' s purpose, this article, and the board's operating procedures, and shall include, at a minimum: (1) NACOLE training. At least four (4) hours of training using content from the National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement, or a comparable professional organization. (2) City and department training. At least two (2) hours of training or information: (i) Describing the legal and ethical obligations of members of a public board, including the need to comply with Virginia FOIA and other statutes and ordinances governing their service; (ii) Explaining department policies, practices, and procedures; (iii) Describing the substance of police department personnel record-keeping; (iv) Describing such other city policies, procedures, and systems relevant to the duties of the board; and (v) Explaining the board's operating procedures and code of ethics. (3) Additional training. As needed, the board may request additional relevant training by subject matter experts on subjects that may include mental health, trauma-informed policing, civil rights and constitutional law, race and racism, community outreach, mediation, investigation, and policing practices. The board may also request opportunities for ride-along experiences with the department and participation in the Community Police Academy. The director shall facilitate or provide this training as is feasible with available funding and other relevant considerations. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-470. Commendations for exceptional community service. (a) Purpose. The board recognizes that effective oversight includes acknowledging excellence in policing. Commendations issued under this section are intended to highlight conduct by department employees that exemplifies the principles of equitable, constitutional, and community-oriented policing. (b) Bases for commendation. The board may consider commendations for department employees based on any of the following: (1) Conduct reflecting exceptional de-escalation, crisis intervention, or resolution of volatile situations in a manner that preserved the safety and dignity of all persons involved; (2) Demonstrated commitment to community engagement, problem-solving, or relationship-building that has measurably strengthened trust between the department and the communities it serves; (3) Actions taken to identify, report, or correct deficiencies in department policies, practices, or conduct that contributed to improved accountability or public safety outcomes; (4) Performance during a critical incident, including life-saving actions, that demonstrated professionalism and adherence to department policy and training; or (5) Other conduct that the board determines to be exemplary of the principles stated in subsection (a). (c) Sources of information. The board may identify commendation-worthy conduct through any of the following: Page 103 of 240 (1) Written nominations from members of the public, provided that such nominations describe the specific conduct or incident forming the basis for the commendation; (2) Information obtained by the director or the board in the course of performing oversight, audit, or review functions authorized under this article; or (3) Data, reports, or records made available to the board in the ordinary course of the board 's work. (d) Review and issuance. Before issuing a commendation, the board shall verify, to a reasonable extent using information available to the board, that the conduct forming the basis for the commendation is supported by more than a single unsubstantiated assertion. The board may consult with the chief regarding the conduct of individual employees under consideration for recognition in accordance with this section. The board may issue public citations or other forms of recognition, by majority vote, to department employees whose conduct meets the criteria in subsection (b). The board shall notify the chief and the city manager of any commendation prior to its public issuance. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Secs. 2-471–2-479. Reserved. Page 104 of 240 - CODE Chapter 2 - ADMINISTRATION ARTICLE XVI. POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD ARTICLE XVI. POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD1 Sec. 2-450. Title. This article shall be known as the Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board Ordinance. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-451. Definitions. (a) Authorized purpose. Those powers and duties delineated in Sec. 2-454. The term lawful purpose used in Sec. 2- 454(b)(8) specifically refers to Code of Virginia § 9.1-601. (b) Closure letter. For purposes of this article, a "closure letter" shall mean the written notification issued by the department at the conclusion of an internal affairs investigation that communicates the findings and determinations of the investigation to the complainant and, when applicable, to the director. (c) Complainant. For purposes of this article, a "complainant" shall mean any civilian who submits a complaint to the office or the department. A complainant need not be the individual directly affected by the alleged conduct. (d) Complaint. For purposes of this article, a "complaint" shall mean an allegation submitted by any civilian to the office or the department that a law enforcement officer or civilian employee of the department has engaged in misconduct. A complaint may be submitted in any form, either orally or in writing. (e) Hearing. For purposes of this article, a "hearing" shall be any public session conducted by the board to review the facts, issues, and implications of a department policy, practice, procedure, pattern, trend, audit report, systemic concern, or other matter within the board's authority. Hearings may also examine patterns in the findings, determinations, and disciplinary actions resulting from administrative investigations conducted by the department. (f) Immediate family member. For purposes of this article, "immediate family member" shall have the same meaning as that provided by Code of Virginia § 2.2-4368. (g) In writing. For purposes of this article, electronic mail (e-mail) shall constitute communication in writing. (h) Personal information. For purposes of this article, "personal information" shall have the same meaning as that provided by Code of Virginia § 2.2-3801. (i) Records. For purposes of this article, "records" shall be construed to broadly include writings, files, photographs, audio and visual recordings, and any other data, information, and evidence within the possession of the department requested by the director for an authorized purpose of the board, subject to limitations in this article . (j) References. For purposes of this article, the following references shall be used: (1) The board. The established and authorized Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board shall be referred to as "the board." (2) The chief. The City of Charlottesville Chief of Police shall be referred to as " the chief." (3) The commander. The Charlottesville Police Department's Commander of Internal Affairs shall be referred to as "the commander." (4) The department. The Charlottesville Police Department shall be referred to as "the department." 1Ord. No. O-25-142, adopted Nov. 17, 2025, amended Art. XVI in its entirety to read as herein set out. Former Art. XVI, §§ 2- 450—2-468, pertained to similar subject matter, and derived from Ord. No. O-21-183, §§ 1, 2, adopted Dec. 20, 2021; Ord. No. O-22-164, §§ 1, 2, adopted Dec. 19, 2022; and Ord. No. O-24-155, adopted Nov. 18, 2024. Page 105 of 240 (5) The director. The appointed Director of the Office of Police Civilian Oversight under the division of the City Manager's Office shall be referred to as "the director." (6) The office. The established and authorized Office of Police Civilian Oversight shall be referred to as " the office" for purposes of this article. (k) Securely retained. A physical or electronic storage format, location, or device to which access is restricted by physical or logical access controls and limited to the director and to staff of the office authorized by the director . Department records in the custody of the office shall not be accessed by any other person except in the presence of the director or authorized staff. Such records shall be maintained in accordance with the Virginia Public Records Act, Code of Virginia § 42.1-76 et seq., the records retention and disposition schedules issued by the Library of Virginia, and other applicable standards under state and federal law. (l) Serious abuse of authority or misconduct. For purposes of this article, "serious abuse of authority or misconduct" shall be defined as significant violations of city policies or procedures, including the department 's general orders and any associated standard operating procedures. This includes, but is not limited to, harassment or discrimination against, or verbal or other conduct that maligns or shows hostility toward, an individual or group because of that individual 's or group's actual or perceived: race; color; religion; national origin or ethnicity; immigration status; sex; sexual orientation; gender identity or expression; marital status; familial status; age; disability; or military or veteran status; or any other characteristic protected under the Virginia Human Rights Act (Code of Virginia § 2.2-3900 et seq.). (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-4512. Police civilian oversight board established. Pursuant to Code of Virginia § 9.1-601, there is hereby established a Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board, which shall be referred to as "the board," with powers granted as provided within this article. The board is a body established and appointed by the city council of Charlottesville pursuant to Code of Virginia § 9.1-601(B) to perform functions authorized by the city council in accordance with Code of Virginia § 9.1-601(C). It shall not be able to bring suit or to be sued in its own name, except to the extent needed to request and defend subpoenas as authorized byin this article. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-4523. Office of police civilian oversight established. (a) Office established. There is hereby established an oOffice of pPolice cCivilian oOversight, which shall be referred to as "the office," which is a division of the cCity mManager's oOffice, and shall have the powers granted as provided within this article to facilitate and support the authorized functionspurpose of the board. The office shall have the authority to carry out its duties and responsibilities under this article with respect to all law enforcement activities and all sworn and civilian personnel operating under the authority of the Charlottesville Police Department, which shall be referred to as "the department." (b) Director. There shall be a full-time director of the office. The director willshall be responsible for and report to the board on the day-to-day operational activities of the board and the office. The director shall report to the city manager, and the city manager shall delegate to the director the authority to employ such additional sta ff as funded by the city council for the board to effectively fulfill its obligations under this article, and any such additional staff sh all report to the director. (1) Appointment. The city manager shall appoint a director with the approval of a majority vote of the city council. (2) Interview process. As a part of the director appointment process, the city manager shall convene an interview panel that includes two (2) members of the board. If those two (2) members recommend a candidate for appointment as director, the city manager shall provide a written justification to the board if a different candidate is appointed. (c) Duties of the city manager. The city manager shall have the following duties: (1) Operating procedures. The city council authorizes the city manager to establish operating procedures for the Page 106 of 240 performance of duties by the board and the office, in consultation with the board and the director . Those procedures may be amended from time to time by the city council or by the city manager , in consultation with the board and the director. The city council or the city manager, as applicable, shall consult with the board and the director before establishing or amending any such procedures. (2) Supervision. The city manager or a designee shall supervise the work of the director. The city manager 's annual evaluation of the director's performance shall consider a written performance review submitted by the board to the city manager. The board may request that the city manager meet with the board 's chair to discuss the director's performance. (3) Vacancy. If there is a vacancy in the position of director, the city manager may designate some other city employee who is not an employee of the department to act as director until a new director is hired appointed. (d) Duties of the director. The director shall have the following duties: (1) Duties. The director shall support the board in the implementation and exercise of its oversight functions and undertake or ensure the performance of specific tasks assigned by majority vote of the board, pursuant to the powers and duties of the board authorized in this article. The director shall be responsible for management of all administrative and fiscal needs of the board and the office as authorized by the city manager. (2) Director's authority to conduct audits. The director may conduct retrospective examinations and audits ofas provided in Sec. 2-463 of this article, including patterns in internal affairs investigations, arrests and detentions, department expenditures, and other public-police interactions pursuant to the powers and duties of the board authorized in this articlepurpose of the board. The board may request the director to conduct additional audits by majority vote. The director willshall provide a summary report of any audit conducted to the board and the city manager upon completion. (3) Director's authority to engage in oversight activities on behalf of the board. The director may engage in additional oversight activities as provided in Sec. 2-462 which support and inform the functions of the board, consistent with the powers and duties of the board authorized in this articlepurpose of the board. This may include, but is not limited to, review of department data systems, attendance at department meetings, review of department policies, practices, and procedures, participation in interviews of candidates for employment with the department, participation in use of force and similar conduct review panels, and other activities which are reasonably necessary for the board to effectuaterelated to the board's its lawfulauthorized purpose. The board may request the director to conduct additional oversight activities by majority vote. The director shall report all activities to the board and the city manager in accordance with the limitations outlined in section 2-454 of this article. (e) Records management. All records created or received by the board, the director, or the office in the transaction of public business are public records within the meaning of the Virginia Public Records Act, Code of Virginia § 42.1 -76 et seq., without regard to whether such records are exempt from disclosure under the Virginia Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA"). The director shall ensure that such records are retained, maintained, and disposed of in accordance with that Act and the records retention and disposition schedules and electronic records guidelines issued by the Library of Virginia, in coordination with the city's designated records officer under Code of Virginia § 42.1-85. Nothing in this subsection shall alter the chief's status as custodian of original department records. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-4534. Powers and duties of the police civilian oversight board. (a) Purpose. The purpose of the board is to establish and maintain trust between and among the department, the city council, the city manager, and the public.support community well-being and safety through civilian-led oversight that brings transparency and accountability to policing in the City of Charlottesville. The board provides the community with a direct voice in public safety and promotes policing that is lawful, fair, and respectful of the rights and dignity of all people. The board fulfills this purpose by monitoring, auditing, and reviewing department conduct, policies, practices, and procedures, and by issuing public reports wi th recommendations for corrective action and the adoption of best practices in policing. Page 107 of 240 (b) Powers and duties. The board shall have the following powers and duties: (1) To receive, investigate, and issue findings on complaints from civilians regarding the conduct of law enforcement officers and civilian employees of the department, and to refer such complaints, at the request of the complainant, to the department for investigation with monitoring by the office on behalf of the board; (2) To investigatereview and issue findings on department incidents, including the use of force by a law enforcement officer, death or serious injury to any individual held in custody, and serious abuse of authority or misconduct as defined in this sectionarticle, allegedly discriminatory stops, and other incidents regarding the conduct of law enforcement officers and civilian employees of the department ; (3) At the conclusion of any investigation conducted pursuant to paragraphs (1) and (2), above, if the board has found that an employee has committed misconduct, to recommend disciplinary action to the chief of police; (43) To investigatereview policies, practices, and procedures of the department and to make recommendations regarding changes to such policies, practices, and procedures; (54) To review investigations conducted internally by the department and to issue findings regarding the accuracy, completeness, and impartiality of the investigations and the sufficiency of any discipline resulting from such investigations; (65) To requestreview reports of the annual expenditures of the department, and to make recommendations to the city council concerning future appropriations; (76) To make public reports on the activities of the board, including investigationsreviews, hearings, findings, recommendationsdeterminations, determinationsrecommendations, and oversight activities; (87) To hold hearings and, if, after making a good faith effort to obtain the voluntary attendance of witnesses , with the exception of employees of the department, and the production of books, papers, and other records or evidence necessary to perform its duties, the board is unable to obtain such attendance or production, to apply to the Circuit Court forof the City of Charlottesville for a subpoena compelling the attendance of such witness or the production of such books, papers, and other records or evidence; and (98) To undertake other duties, as reasonably necessary, for the board to effectuate its lawful purpose as provided for in this article, to effectively oversee the department,including the delegation of administrative support functions, department monitoring, auditing, and other routine oversight activities to the office established in this article. (c) Definition of "serious abuse of authority or misconduct." "Serious abuse of authority or misconduct" shall include the following: (1) Verbal or other conduct regarding an individual or group that maligns or shows hostility for the individual or group because of race, color, religion, gender, national origin, age, disability, sexual orientation, or gender identity and expression; (2) Harassment or discrimination based on race, color, sexual orientation, gender, religion, national origin, marital status, age, familial status, immigration status or disability; (3) Acting in a rude, careless, angry, retaliatory or threatening manner; (4) Reckless endangerment of a citizen, detainee, or person in custody; (5) Violation of laws or ordinances; (6) Criminal or other misconduct occurring on or off the job which is related to job performance or is of such a nature that to continue the employee in the assigned position or in any city employment capacity would constitute negligence in regard to the city's duties to the public or to other city employees; (7) In any matter within the jurisdiction of any officer, department or agency of the city: a. The knowing falsification, concealment or cover-up of a material fact; and/or Page 108 of 240 b. The knowing making of any false, fictitious or fraudulent statement or representation, and/or the making or using of any writing or document knowing the same to contain a false, fictitious or fraudulent statement or entry; (8) Sexual activity, including consensual sexual activity, on the job; and (9) Other serious violations of Charlottesville or department policies or procedures, including the department code of conduct. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-455. Board membership, appointment, and terms. (a) Objectivity. It is of fundamental importance that members of the board be fair and objective in the conduct of their duties, and that they be perceived as fair and objective in the conduct of their duties In making appointments under this section, the city council shall seek members who are fair and objective, and who will be perceived as fair and objective, in the conduct of their duties . (b) Appointment process. The city council shall appoint the members of the board. The cCity council shall announce a public application process with applications available online and by hardcopy in English and Spanish for individuals interested in serving on the board. The application window shall remain open for a minimum of thirty (30) calendar days from the date of public announcement. The cCity council willshall seek to appoint fair-minded and objective members with a demonstrated commitment to community service who have training and experience, including lived experience, with topics relevant to the business of the board, including law, police practices, human resources practices and procedures, trauma-informed mental health issues, andor the sociology of historically overpoliced communities. (c) B oard composition. The board shall reflect the demographic diversity of the City of Charlottesville. The board shall be composed of seven (7) voting members and one (1) non-voting member appointed by the city council. The members shall be removable by the city council for cause as, including conduct specified in the board's code of ethics set forth in the board's operating procedures, violating the duty of confidentiality, failing to participate in required training, or other good cause. (1) Council shall appoint at least three (3) members who are residents of public housing or who come from historically disadvantaged communities that have traditionally experienced disparate policing. (1) The seven (7) voting members of the board shall be residents of the City of Charlottesville or Albemarle County. Priority shall be given to city residents. Residents of Albemarle County appointed to membership on the board shall be employed in the City of Charlottesville or shall have significant and demonstrable ties to the city. If, after the defined public application process, the city council determines t hat there are insufficient eligible applicants who are residents of the City of Charlottesville or Albemarle County to fill a vacancy on the board, the city council may appoint a resident of the Commonwealth of Virginia who is employed in the City of Charl ottesville or who has significant and demonstrable ties to the city. (2) Council may appoint one (1) member who represents an organization that seeks racial or social justice on behalf of historically disadvantaged communities. (32) The non-voting member of the board shall be an individual with policing expertise or experience. The non- voting member may be a retired law enforcement officer who prior to his or her retirement was employed in a locality similar to the City of Charlottesville. (4) T he seven (7) voting members of the board shall be residents of, or shall be employed in, the City of Charlottesville or Albemarle County, with priority given to city residents and those with significant and demonstrable ties to the city. (53) No board member shall be a current candidate for public office, a former member of the department, an immediate family member of a current department employee, or a current employee of a law enforcement agency, the fire department, the emergency communications center, or the sheriff' s office. If the city council Page 109 of 240 considers appointing a board member who is employed by the City of Charlottesville, the city council willshall seek to avoid potential conflicts of interests. (d) Terms. Each board member shall be appointed for a term of three (3) years. Appointments and terms shall be subject to the provisions of chapter 2, article I, section 2-8 of the City Code.Each board member shall be appointed for a term of two (2) years. Except as otherwise provided in this section, appointments and terms shall be subject to the provisions of chapter 2, article I, § 2-8 of the city code. No person shall serve more than eight (8) consecutive years on the board, and no person shall be appointed or reappointed to a term that, if served to completion, would exceed that limit. Service in the unexpired portion of a term shall not be counted toward this limit. Service in a term under this article as it existed before the effective date of this amendment shall be credited as the number of years in that term. Members serving on the board as of the effective date of this amendment shall continue to serve the remainder of their current term. The composition requirements, term length, and term limit established by this section shall apply to all appointments and reappointments made on or after the effective date of this amendment. Nothing in this section shall entitle any person to reappointment. (e) Conflicts of interests. NoA board member mayshall not participate in any matter before the board under circumstances in which the objectivity of the board member could reasonably be questioned, including, without limitation, the consideration of a complaint of someone who is an immediate family member. For purposes of the Virginia State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act, the board shall be deemed a " governmental agency" and each board member shall be an "officer," as those terms are defined in Code of Virginia, § 2.2-3101. All board members shall comply with the requirements of the Virginia State and Local Government Conflict of Interests Act, as applicable. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-456. Meetings. (a) Number of meetings. The board shall hold public meetings at least once per calendar quarter. Additional meetings may be called by the chair or any two (2) board members. (b) FOIA. The board shall comply with all applicable requirements of the Virginia Freedom of Information Act ("FOIA") pertaining to disclosure of public records and the conduct of its meetings , including the requirement that all meetings shall be open to the public except under circumstances when the topic is authorized by FOIA to be discussed in a closed meeting. (c) Quorum. A quorum of the board shall be four (4) members.A quorum of the b oard for the transaction of business and the taking of any vote shall be four (4) members. However, for purposes of Virginia FOIA, a meeting of the board occurs whenever as many as three (3) members are gathered to discuss or transact the business of the b oard, and any such gathering shall be noticed and conducted in accordance with that Act. (d) Minutes. The board shall keep minutes of its meetings, which shall include: (1) The date, time, and location of the meeting; (2) The members present and absent; (3) A summary of the discussion on matters proposed, deliberated, or decided; and (4) A record of any votes taken. (e) Rules and procedures. Meetings of the board shall be conducted in accordance with Robert 's Rules of Order or such other procedures as the board may adopt. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-457. Board legal counsel. The director may retain independent legal counsel to advise and represent the board in all cases, hearings, controversies, orconnection with its oversight powers and duties, and in any other matters involving the interests of the board. Such independent legal counsel shall be chosen from a list of attorneys recommended by the city attorney. The Page 110 of 240 director is authorized to execute a contract in the name of the board for legal services if the contract has first been approved by the board and endorsed by the city's finance director to verify that funding is available and has been appropriated to support performance of the payment obligations of the board under such contract. The board' s legal counsel shall be paid only from funds that have been appropriated to the board' s budget by city council. The board and the director are encouraged to consult the office of the city attorney for legal advice , except in cases, hearings, investigations, controversies that are before the board, or in any other matter in which the board' s and the department's interests may conflictmatters involving potential conflicts of interests between the board and the department. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-4548. Information access and limitations. (a) Access to department information. The board, administeredSubject to certain narrow limitations described in this article and through administration by the director, the board is authorized to receive, and shall be provided full access to, all department reports, files, and records determined by the board or the director to be necessary to carry out its authorized powers and responsibilitiespurpose. All records, documents, and materials in the possession of or provided to the board or the director shall be subject to board procedures adopted for the protection of confidential and personal information as defined in such proceduresthis article and the board' s operating procedures. The city manager, in consultation with the chief of police and the board, shall establish a standard operating procedure setting forth how this access shall be given by the department to the board, how personal information shall be managed and protected by the board in accordance with the requirements of the Code of Virginia, § 2.2-3800 et seq., and under what circumstances or conditions it may be made available to the parties . (b) Records to be routinely provided. The department shall provide the following records to the director within five (5) calendar days of the receipt or creation of the record by the department: (1) Initial complainant contact letter; (2) Complaint closure letter; (3) Monthly report by the department's Fourth Amendment auditor; and (4) Monthly report by the Office of Internal Affairs. (c) Requests for department records. The department shall provide all records specifically identified by the director, as well as those related to the subject matter and reasonably necessary to permit the board to review the identified subject matter. The director shall notify the chief or a designee in writing when the following occurs, as applicable, which shall constitute a request for records for purposes of this article: (1) The review of an internal affairs investigation has been scheduled. The director shall provide sufficient information to allow the department to identify the investigation and any related complaints or disciplinary records. (2) The review of a specific department policy, practice, or procedure. The director shall provide sufficient information to allow the department to identify records in its possession relevant to the review. (3) An audit has been initiated by the director or requested by the board. The director shall provide the chief or a designee with a copy of the audit plan, which shall indicate the general nature of the contemplated audit such that the department may identify records relevant to the audit. (d) Delivery of records. Upon the provision of such written requests for records, the department shall provide the director with the requested records within five (5) calendar days of the director 's request or, if applicable, within five (5) calendar days of the city manager's written ruling regarding a dispute about access to records. In either case, the director and the chief or a designee may agree to a different timeline for the delivery of the requested records. In the absence of a director or appointed designee, written requests shall be issued by the chair of the board with a majority vote of its members. The chief or a designee shall appoint an employee of the department to administer records access to the board until such time as a new director or designee is appointed to such role by the city manager. (e) Format of department records. The board shall be provided department records, administered by the director, in the following formats: Page 111 of 240 (1) Body-worn and dashboard camera video. The director shall be provided with independent access privileges to any relevant department systems to view all footage from cameras worn or operated by the department if relevant to the subject of an authorized purpose of the board. The director shall not share the access credentials with any other person, and the director shall not allow any person to view such video footage, other than a member of the board who has signed a confidentiality agreement, which the director shall certify , and in which case the board member may review the video footage only in the presence of the director. (2) Originals or exact copies. The director shall be provided with the original version of the requested department records or, if feasible, may be provided copies of such records, at the department 's discretion. If copies of the original records are provided to the director, they shall be exact duplicates of the original versions other than minor formatting or cosmetic differences that do not impact the content of the records. (3) Secure retention, return, or destruction. The original records and any copies thereof provided by the department to the director shall be returned to the chief or a designee as the custodian of the original records within five (5) calendar days of completion of the board review or audit, except that upon agreement in writing by the chief or a designee, copies of department video footage and records provided to the director may be securely retained for up to one (1) year or destroyed. A review or audit shall be deemed complete upon occurrence of the following, as applicable: (i) Public release of the final findings, determinations, and recommendations of a review; (ii) Presentation by the director of a final audit report to the board; or (iii) In a case in which (i) or (ii) above does not apply, at such other time as the director notifies the chief or a designee in writing that the authorized purpose for which the records were requested is complete. (bf) Department information to which the board mayshall not have access. The director and the board shall not have access to: (1) J uvenile records; (21) Records that may reveal the identity or personal information, as defined in the Code of Virginia, § 2.2- 3801, of a confidential informant; (32) Investigative files forrelated to an active civil or criminal investigation by the cCommonwealth's aAttorney, the Virginia Attorney General, the Virginia State Police, or the United States Department of Justice; (43) Files related to an active EEOCEqual Employment Opportunity Commission claim, hHuman rRights cCommission investigation, or civil claim involving a department employee; (54) Files containing information exempt from mandatory public disclosure or prohibited from public disclosure pursuant to the Code of Virginia, §§ 2.2-3706(B)(2), (3), (4), (5), (6), (7), (8), (10), (11); 2.2- 3706(C); 2.2-3706.1(C)(1) through (C)(6); 2.2-3706.1(D); and 2.2-3706.1(E); orand (65) Any information that the police department is not legally authorized to share. (cg) Disputes over access. If the director and the board seek access to information the disclosure of which the department believes would compromise ongoing investigations, disclosure may be withheld until such time as the need for maintaining confidentiality is no longer present, or until the city manager has determined that the matter will not be compromised by the release of the information. If the board believes that the city manager is unreasonably withholding such information, the board may consider whether to seek a subpoena requiring the production of such information pursuant to section 2-459is outside the scope of, or expressly prohibited by the authority granted in this article, and the director and chief cannot resolve this dispute after mutual discussion and consultation, then the city manager shall resolve the dispute consistent with the purposes and provisions of this article. The city manager may conduct an informal hearing at which both the director and chief may be heard, and the city manager shall issue a written ruling within three (3) business days thereafter. If the board believes that the city manager is unreasonably withholding such information, the board may consider whether to seek a subpoena requiring the production of such information as provided in Sec. 2-460 of this article. Page 112 of 240 (dh) Confidentiality. Each member of the board and the director shall maintain the confidentiality of all personal information and confidential or privileged information, including, but not limited to: (1) Materials from police internal investigative files; (2) Disciplinary actions, memos, and reports; (3) Statements of any police officer or civilian employee who was required by the department to give a statement; (4) Criminal investigative files; orand (5) Any other information that the chief or city attorney's office has deemed confidential. This requirement to maintain confidentiality continues indefinitely or until the information no longer meets the definition of confidential or privileged as defined in relevant board proceduresthis article. (i) Protocols to prevent improper dissemination. The director and the board shall adhere to the following protocols to prevent improper dissemination of confidential records, including records containing personal or privileged information not subject to public release: (1) The director and board shall not use or disseminate non-public personal information regarding any person, for any purpose or in any manner, other than as authorized by applicable state and federal law, local ordinances, and the authority to release public records defined in this article. (2) The director and board shall take all appropriate measures to maintain the security and confidentiality of all non - public personal information contained within department records to which access has been provided. (3) Within any written reports to be presented at a public meeting of the board or released to the public, and during any public comments about matters currently or likely in the future to be the subject of a review or audit by the board or director, the board and director may disclose the following personal information about any person, except as otherwise prohibited by state or federal law: (i) P ersonal information previously publicly disclosed (by a party or pa rties other than the board or director); and (ii) N on-public personal information regarding a department officer or employee with the prior written consent of the officer or employee. (4) In all other cases, written reports to be presented at a public meeting of the board or released to the public, and public comments about matters currently or likely in the future to be the subject of a review or audit by the board or director, shall refer only to anonymized information regarding any specific department officer or employee, and information that would not permit the particular officer or employee to be personally identified. (ej) Records to remain department records. The chief of police, as the custodian of the original department records, shall be responsible for decisions as to whether copies of such records (or information contained in such records) may be publicly disclosed, subject to the direction and control of the city manager. In the event of a request pursuant to Virginia FOIA for records in the possession of the board or director, the director, as applicable, shall consult with the city attorney's office and claim all relevant exemptions allowed by FOIA to withhold the records or portions thereof from public disclosure, except in cases where public disclosure is authorized in writing by either the chief or the city manager and is otherwise lawful. Nothing in this paragraph shall preclude the city manager from including with the standard operating procedure guidelines forestablishing guidelines in the operating procedures regarding public disclosure of certain types of information contained within department records. In the standard operating procedure, the city manager shall issue guidelines for what information may be included in board or office reports or otherwise publicly disclosed. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-4589. Investigation eExclusions, limitations, and suspension. (a) Compliance. Any investigationoversight activities shall comply with all federal, state, and local laws, as well as with requirements for the initiation and conduct of investigationsthe board's powers and duties described in the Page 113 of 240 procedures promulgated by the city council as authorized in this article this article and in accordance with the board's operating procedures. (b) Compelled statements. The board may not compel a statement from any department employee, other than by means of its subpoena powers. (c) Exclusions. The board shall not consider complaints, incidents, claims, or issues involving the following: (1) Any incident that occurred more than one (1) year before the filing of the complaint, or one (1) year before the board received notice of the incident, except as otherwise authorized by subsection (d) of this section; (2) Except as otherwise authorized by subsection (d) of this section, a matter that was the subject of an investigation where more than seventy-five (75) days has elapsed since the department sent notice to the complainant informing the complainant that the department's internal affairs investigation is complete (unless the board determines that there is good cause to extend the filing deadline); (31) Matters that are the subject of a pending criminal proceeding in any trial court, a pending or anticipated civil proceeding in any trial court (as evidenced by a notice of claim or a filed complaint), or any pending City of Charlottesville grievance proceeding; (4) A ny financial management related issue; (5) Any complaint, incident, claim or issue where the complainant requests that the board not have access to their files; (6) Any complaint, incident, claim or issue that has previously been the subject of an investigation by the board, unless substantial new information has come to the attention of the board; (72) An allegation of misconduct only by employees of law enforcement agencies other than the department. Such complainants shouldshall be referred to the appropriate law enforcement agency; and (8) An allegation of conduct that does not violate the Charlottesville Police Policies and Guidelines, Disciplinary Orders, or Code of Conduct;. This does not preclude violations of other rules, standards, ethics and specific action or inaction that is detrimental to efficient department service; and (93) Any other claim outside the scope of the board's authority expressly set forth within this article. (d) Exceptions to time limits. With the concurrence of the city manager, the board may review investigations and incidents beyond the time limits specified in subsections (c)(1) and (c)(2) if: (1) The board determines that there is good cause for doing so; or (2) As part of an audit taking place under subsectionSec. 2-45263(d). (ed) Suspension of investigationsoversight activity. If a complaint asserts criminal conduct by an employee of the department, or if at any point in an investigation of a complaint or incident the performance of oversight powers and duties, the board or director becomes aware that an employee may have committed a criminal offense, the board shall:and the director shall suspend all oversight activity and notify the chief and Commonwealth' s Attorney of the alleged conduct. (1) Suspend the investigation and notify the chief of police and commonwealth' s attorney of the alleged conduct, ensuring that no statements obtained from the police department employee(s) whose actions are the subject of the matter are shared with criminal investigators or any prosecuting authority except in accordance with applicable law; and (2) Evaluate, in consultation with board legal counsel, the city attorney, and the commonwealth' s attorney, whether competing public interests and civil rights involved permit the resumption of continued, parallel investigation by the board. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-45960. Subpoenas. Page 114 of 240 (a) Application for subpoenas. If the board determines that there is evidenceare records, (including witnesses), not within the control of the department that the board is unable to obtain voluntarily, the board by two -thirds (⅔) vote may authorize the director, on behalf of the board, to apply to the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville Circuit Court for a subpoena compelling the production of such records, or the attendance of such witnesses to a public hearing held in accordance with Sec. 2-466(f) of this article or the production of such books, papers, and other evidence. (b) Requests for access. If the director is denied access to material witnesses, records, books, papers, and other evidence within the control of the department that the director deems necessary to perform their duties and the duties of the board, the director may request the city manager to require the department to produce the requested witnesses and documentsrecords. No request shall include witnesses who are employees, sworn or civilian, of the department, and the board's authorized subpoena power shall not be used to compel attendance of or statements from department employees. The city manager, or theira designee, shall not unreasonably deny such a request, but may place conditions on the production of the requested witnesses and documentsrecords as necessary to preserve confidentiality for the reasons set forth in this article. The city manager, or theira designee, shall issue a decision on the director's request within five (5) business days fromof the date of that request. (c) Scope of subpoenas. If the city manager, or theira designee, denies the director's request made pursuant to subparagraphsection (b) above, the board by two-thirds (⅔) vote may authorize the director, on behalf of the board, to apply to the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville Circuit Court for a subpoena compelling the attendance of such witnesses or the production of such books, papers, and other evidencerecords. The board shall give the city manager and the department reasonable notice of its intent to subpoena such witness or records and shall give the city attorney a copy of the request for subpoena. The board shall not unreasonably withhold its agreement to limitations on the scope of the subpoena requested by the city manager that may be necessary to protect confidential information. The parties may request that any hearing to be held in the cC ircuit cCourt of the City of Charlottesville on the request for a subpoena be conducted in a closed courtroom, to the extent permitted by state law. Upon request, the court file for any such subpoena request shall be kept under seal to the extent permitted by state law. The board may request that all or any portion of the court file relating to any such application be placed under seal to the extent permitted by state law. (d) Retention of subpoena records. If a subpoena is granted which compels the production of records, the board shall digitally record any interviews or depositions conducted pursuant to the subpoena and shall make copies of any documents obtained by subpoena. The board shall provide the department with copies of any such interview/deposition recordings and documents. The board shall delegate its authority to subpoena and question witnesses to the director, who shall conduct any interviews, depositions, or questioning of witnesses in a non- public forum that adequately protects the privacy of the individual being subpoenaed, the confidentiality or sensitivity of information shared or sought, and the integrity of any pending or concurrent investigation records. (e) Conduct of compelled attendance by witnesses. If a subpoena is granted which compels the attendance of a witness or witnesses at a public hearing of the board, such attendance shall comply with the board' s operating procedures, including a hearing manual adopted thereunder, and the following provisions: (1) In any application for a witness subpoena under this section, the board shall request that the subpoena include a statement that any testimony provided shall be made under oath and that the witness is entitled to representation by an attorney. The board shall, in any event, provide such notice in writing to any witness subpoenaed under this section. (2) Any witness failing to comply with a subpoena issued under this section may be subject to a charge of contempt by the issuing court as provided by law. Any witness so subpoenaed may petition the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville to quash the subpoena. (3) In the case of refusal or neglect to comply with a subpoena, the board may petition for its enforcement in the Circuit Court of the City of Charlottesville. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Page 115 of 240 Sec. 2-461. Intake and referrals. All submissions of complaints, review requests, inquiries, recommendations, comments, and compliments shall be received and documented by the office in accordance with the procedures established in the board's operating procedures. The office shall provide a response to all submissions indicating receipt and advising on any next steps. The following actions shall be taken: (1) For all complaints related to the alleged misconduct of a department employee, the office shall establish communication with the complainant and collect all relevant information regarding the complaint and ascertain whether the complainant desires to have the department conduct an official investigation with monitoring by the director. If the complainant does not request a department investigation, the complaint shall be documented by the office and the information contained therein shall be available to the director for purposes of monitoring, auditing, and other oversight activities authorized under this article. Additionally, the director shall: (i) Provide updates to the complainant, upon request, regarding whether an administrative investigation has commenced, is pending, or has concluded. Such updates shall not disclose any substantive information about the investigation, including its evidence, witnesses, findings, or d eterminations, and shall remain subject to the limitations in this article; and (ii) Verify the complainant has received a closure letter from the commander at the conclusion of any investigation. (2) For all review requests of an internal affairs investigation previously concluded by the department, the office shall obtain a copy of the case closure letter and collect all relevant information regarding the original complaint, investigation, and reason for the review request. (3) For all complaints received which allege misconduct by a city employee outside the department or an employee of another law enforcement jurisdiction, the director shall provide the complainant with contact information for the agency, office, or entity who may best assist the complainant. (4) For all inquiries, recommendations, and comments related to the conduct, policies, practices, or procedures of the department, the office shall provide as much information as is readily known or obtain such information to provide in response. (5) For all compliments or commendations, the office shall collect all relevant information and provide this information to the board. (6) For any complaint, review request, inquiry, recommendation, comment, or compliment which is outside the scope of the board's authorized power and duties, the office shall provide the contact information for the agency, office, or entity who may best assist the individual. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-4602. Conduct of investigationsdepartment monitoring. (a) Conduct of complaint investigationsReferral of complaints. If thea complainant asks that their complaint be investigated by the department, the complaint willshall be investigated by the department with monitoring by the director. When the department's investigation is concluded, the department will provide the complainant with a closure letter of its findings and the resolution of the complaint and will provide the board a summary of the department's resolution of the complaint. (b) Monitoring of investigations. The director may actively monitor investigations of complaints of employee misconduct conducted by the department and shall have access to records and witnesses to the same extent as the department, subject to the limitations or requirements set out in this article. Such monitoring may include reviewing the investigative plan of the department, reviewing any records within the department 's digital evidence management system, reviewing any pertinent law enforcement records within the department 's records management system, observing any real-time interviews of witnesses with the department, reviewing any recorded interviews which the director chooses not to attend in real time, providing feedback during the interview to be relayed to department s taff Page 116 of 240 conducting the interview, providing feedback to department staff in determining next steps in the investigative process, and reviewing facts gained from investigation. For active criminal investigations, the director shall be limited in their participation to the same extent the department is limited in its participation in such investigations. The director may monitor the department's administrative investigation of employee misconduct after the close of the active criminal investigation in the same manner as all other investigations of employee conduct handled by the department as described in this section. When monitoring department investigations, during the pendency of the investigations the director shall not disclose information about the investigation to the board, any board member, or any person other than as authorized in writing by the chief of police or the city manager. (c) Investigative reports. If the complainant asks that the complaint be investigated only by the board, the director shall initiate an investigation on behalf of the board. The director will provide the chief of police with enough identifying information to allow the department to give the director access to information, records and witnesses as may be relevant to the complaint. When the investigation is concluded, the director will provide the board, the complainant and the department with an investigative report that includes a summary of the circumstances of the incident(s) of alleged misconduct, the evidence related to whether there was any misconduct, and any suggested findings related to each allegation. (d) Conduct of incident investigations. If the board is investigating an incident, the board may request information from the department, may seek subpoenas as authorized above, and may conduct an investigation of the incident. When the investigation is concluded, the director will provide the board, the department, and (if a complaint has been filed) the complainant, with an investigative report that includes, at a minimum, a summary of the circumstances of the incident, the evidence related to whether the incident involved any police or employee misconduct, and any suggested findings related to the incident. The director may make recommendations as to whether an allegation, if substantiated, could constitute serious abuse of authority or misconduct as defined in subsection 2 -453(c). The investigative report shall also be provided to any employees identified within the investigative report as having committed employee misconduct. (e) Duration of investigations. Investigations of complaints and incidents will be completed, and any investigative report will be submitted, within seventy-five (75) days from the date the complaint is received, or the board received notice of the incident. The board may extend the seventy-five-day period upon request of the police chief or the director to protect an ongoing investigation or prosecution, or for other good cause, with notice to the complainant and the city manager. (b) Monitoring of investigations and incidents. The director may actively monitor investigations of complaints and incidents of alleged employee misconduct by the department and shall have access to records and witnesses to the same extent as the department, subject to the limitations or requirements set out in this article. Such monitoring may include: (1) R eviewing the investigative plan of the department; (2) R eviewing any records within the department's digital evidence management system; (3) R eviewing any pertinent law enforcement records within the department's records management system; (4) O bserving any real-time interviews of witnesses by the department; (5) R eviewing any recorded interviews; and (6) R eviewing facts gained from investigation. For active criminal investigations, the director shall be limited in participation to the same extent the department is limited in its participation in such investigations. The director may monitor the department 's administrative investigation of alleged employee misconduct after the close of the active criminal investigation in the same manner as all other investigations of employee conduct handled by the department as described in this ar ticle. When monitoring department investigations, during the pendency of the investigations the director shall not disclose information about the investigation to any person other than as authorized in writing by the chief or the city manager. (c) Observation of internal affairs interviews. The director shall be authorized to observe real-time interviews conducted by the department as part of an administrative investigation in accordance with the board' s operating procedures and the following provisions: Page 117 of 240 (1) The commander shall notify the director, in writing, of all external complaints filed against or about d epartment personnel immediately after receiving each such complaint, or by the next business day. (2) The commander shall notify the director, in writing, of the date, time, and location of all scheduled interviews associated with the complaint. Unless exigent circumstances exist, the d irector shall be provided at least twenty- four (24) hours of advance notice of the interview. If, due to exigent circumstances, the d irector is provided with less than twenty-four (24) hours of advance notice, the commander shall include a description of such circumstances. (3) If the director chooses to observe an interview, the director shall notify the commander in writing as soon as practically possible before the interview. (4) The director shall be permitted to monitor the interview from a separate room, if possible, or from within the same room where the interview occurs. The director shall be able to clearly see and hear the interview as it occurs. The director shall not interfere with or interrupt the department's interview process. (5) The director shall, at the conclusion of any observed interview, be afforded the ability to provide verbal feedback to the commander, and the assigned investigator if not the commander, regarding the impartiality and sufficiency of the interview conducted. Any feedback provided by the director shall be shared with the board if the investigation is reviewed by the board after the conclusion of the investigation. Nothing in this subsection shall require the Office of Internal Affairs to implement feedback provided by the director during the investigation. Any such feedback is limited to process-related observations and is not evidence or a recommendation on the merits of the complaint. (d) General oversight of department operations. In addition to the monitoring of investigations and incidents, the director may engage in ongoing monitoring and oversight activities to support and inform the functions of the board consistent with this article. The board may request the director to conduct additional monitoring or oversight activities by majority vote. The director shall report all activities conducted under this section to the board and the city manager in accordance with the information access and limitations established in Sec. 2- 458 of this article. (1) Director access. The director may participate in or observe department activities, including but not limited to the following: (i) Department staff meetings, command staff meetings, briefings, and roll calls; (ii) Use of force review panels and similar internal conduct review processes; (iii) Interviews of candidates for sworn and civilian employment with the department; (iv) Department training sessions, including in-service and specialized training; (v) Review of department data systems, reports, and performance metrics; (vi) Review of current or proposed department policies, practices, procedures, and directives; and (vii) Other activities reasonably necessary for the board to effectuate its authorized purpose under this article. The enumeration in this subsection is illustrative and not exhaustive, and shall not be construed to limit the director's access to other department activities. Access to activities under this subsection shall be limited only as provided in subsection (d)(3) or Sec. 2-458 of this article. (2) Notice. The department shall provide the director with reasonable advance notice of the activities listed in subsection (d)(1)(i) through (vii), including the date, time, and location, sufficient to allow the director the opportunity to attend. The chief or a designee and the director may establish a standing schedule or notification protocol to satisfy this requirement. (3) Limitations on participation. The director's participation under this section shall be in an observational and advisory capacity and shall not include authority to direct, countermand, or delay department operations or personnel decisions. The department may temporarily limit the director 's access to a specific activity if the chief or a designee determines in writing that the director's presence would compromise an active criminal investigation, officer safety during a tactical operation, or a legally protected proceeding. Any such limitation shall be narrowly tailored and shall expire when the stated justification no longer applies. Page 118 of 240 (4) Disputes. If the director is denied access to any activity under this section and the director and the chief are unable to resolve the matter through mutual consultation, the dispute shall be resolved in accordance with the procedures established in Sec. 2-458(g) of this article. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-463. Conduct of department audits. (a) Purpose and scope. The director may conduct retrospective audits of department patterns, practices, procedures , data, and outcomes to provide relevant information to the board to effectuate its authorized purpose and to identify systemic changes that may improve police services to the community. Audit topics may include, but are not limited to, patterns in internal affairs investigations, use of force incidents, arrests and detentions, searches and seizures, department expenditures, implementation of policies and training directives, deployment of systems and technologies, and other public-police interactions. Audits shall not be used to adjudicate individual complaints or to make findings of misconduct against individual employees, but the director may refer infor mation discovered during an audit to the department or the city manager if it suggests conduct warranting separate review. Audits shall be conducted in accordance with the board's operating procedures, which shall include an audit manual adopted thereunder. (b) Initiation. An audit may be initiated by the director or by majority vote of the board. If initiated by board vote, the request shall identify the general subject matter and purpose. The director shall commence the audit within ten (10) business days or provide the board a written explanation if the audit is not feasible within the limitations of available resources, in which case the board and director shall confer to resolve scheduling or scope. (c) Audit plan. Prior to any collection of data or requests for department records for the purpose of an audit, the director shall prepare a written audit plan and provide a copy to the chief or a designee and to the board. The plan shall include: (1) The subject matter, scope, and time period to be examined; (2) The categories of records, data, or other information anticipated to be necessary; (3) The anticipated methodology for analysis; and (4) An estimated timeline for completion. (d) Department cooperation. Upon receipt of the audit plan, the department shall provide records and data in accordance with this article within five (5) calendar days, designate a liaison to coordinate with the director for the duration of the audit, and make a good faith effort to respond to reasonable requests for additional records or clarification. (e) Audit report. Upon completion, the director shall prepare a written report and provide it to the board, the chief, and the city manager. The board shall review the report and may adopt, modify, or supplement the director 's recommendations before issuing findings and recommendations pursuant to this article. The report shall include: (1) A description of the scope, methodology, and time period examined; (2) A summary of findings, including identified patterns, trends, or areas of concern; (3) Recommendations, if any, for changes to department policies, practices, procedures, training, or resource allocation; and (4) Any relevant response or information provided by the department during the audit. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Page 119 of 240 Sec. 2-464. Conduct of board reviews. (a) Purpose. The board may conduct reviews of information provided by the department, the director, and other sources to fulfill its oversight functions authorized under this article. The board 's reviews are intended to provide a civilian-led perspective on department conduct and operations, grounded in objective evidence, and to serve as the basis for the findings, determinations, and recommendations issued pursuant to Sec. 2 -466 of this article. (b) Matters subject to review. The board may conduct reviews of any of the following: (1) Internal affairs investigations, including the department's case file, investigative methodology, and resulting findings and disciplinary determinations; (2) Department incidents, including use of force incidents, deaths or serious injuries of persons in custody, and other incidents identified in Sec. 2-454(b)(2) of this article; (3) Audit reports prepared by the director pursuant to Sec. 2-463 of this article; (4) Department policies, practices, procedures, and directives, whether existing or proposed; (5) Department data, performance metrics, trends, and patterns identified through monitoring activities conducted pursuant to Sec. 2-462 of this article; or (6) Any other matter within the scope of the board's authorized purpose regarding the conduct or operations of the department and department employees. (c) Information provided to the board. The director shall prepare and present to the board materials necessary to conduct a review, which may include written summaries, relevant records provided by the department subject to the limitations of Sec. 2-458 and Sec. 2-459, data analyses, research, and any other information obtained through the oversight activities authorized under this article. The director shall present information in a manner that protects personal information and maintains the confidentiality requirements established in Sec. 2- 458 of this article. (d) Evaluation and deliberation. In evaluating matters under review, the board shall consider the totality of information available and shall base its findings, determinations, and recommendations on objective evidence. The board may consider any of the following in its deliberations: (1) Records, data, and reports provided by the department through the director; (2) The director's analysis, observations, and recommendations, including information obtained through monitoring and audit activities; (3) Applicable department policies, general orders, training standards, and the disciplinary matrix; (4) Applicable federal, state, and local law, including constitutional standards governing law enforcement conduct; (5) Published research, professional standards, and best practices in law enforcement, including guidance from professional organizations such as the National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement; (6) Testimony or written statements from subject matter experts, community members, or other persons with relevant knowledge, received during a public meeting or hearing conducted pursuant to this article; (7) Comparative practices of other law enforcement agencies; and (8) Any other information the board determines to be relevant and reliable. (e) Standard of review. The board shall evaluate the matters before it based on the reasonableness of the department 's actions, decisions, and policies in light of the totality of the circumstances and the information available. The board 's role is to provide an informed civilian assessment, not to substitute its judgment for the operational or tactical Page 120 of 240 decisions of sworn personnel. Where the board disagrees with the department 's findings, determinations, or actions, the board shall articulate specific reasoning supported by the evidence and information considered. (f) Department participation. The board may request that the chief or a designee appear before the board during a review to present information, provide context, or respond to questions regarding the matter under review. Any such participation by department personnel shall be voluntary and shall not constitute a compelled statement for purposes of this article or applicable law. The board may also request written responses from the department on specific questions arising during the course of a review. (g) Public participation. The board may receive public comment relevant to a matter under review during any public meeting in accordance with the board's operating procedures. The board may establish reasonable time limits and guidelines for public comment. Public comment received by the board may be considered as part of the board' s deliberations but shall not be the sole basis for any finding, determination, or recommendation. (h) Procedures. Reviews shall be conducted in accordance with the board's operating procedures, including a review manual adopted thereunder, which shall address scheduling and notice of reviews, the format for presentation of information to the board, procedures for deliberation and voting, and the documentation of the board' s reasoning in support of its findings, determinations, and recommendations. All findings, determinations, recommendations, and any resulting resolutions of the board shall only be made by a majority vote of the board with an established quorum. Any portion of a review involving discussion or consideration of criminal investigative files, audit findings, or deliberations regarding police operations related to a specific complaint before the board, where the complaint involves an offense enumerated in Code of Virginia § 2.2-3711(A)(56), shall be conducted in closed session as authorized by that subdivision. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-461. Matters on which the board may conduct hearings. (a) Hearings. Hearings of the board shall be conducted in accordance with board operating procedures. (1) At the conclusion of an investigation of an incident or a complaint the board may conduct a review hearing whose scope and procedures are described in the board's operating procedures. Review hearings shall be defined as any hearing conducted by the board to review the facts, issues and findings of a closure letter of the department related to an internal affairs investigation, or of an investigative report of the director related to a complaint or incident investigation. (2) The board may conclude that no hearing, or a hearing only on a limited issue, is necessary to support the board' s decision related to a particular complaint or incident. If so, the board may issue a report without a hearing. (b) Hearing findings. Within thirty (30) days of a review hearing of an internal affairs investigation, the board shall report their findings publicly and to the city manager, the police chief, and the complainant with respect to each allegation or issue under review as follows: (1) That the board finds that the investigation of the complaint was satisfactory, and the board concurs with the findings of the investigation; (2) That the board finds that the investigation of the complaint was satisfactory, but the board does not concur with the findings of the investigation, in which case the board may make recommendations to the city manager concerning disposition of the review request; or (3) That the board finds that the investigation is incomplete or otherwise unsatisfactory and provides a detailed written explanation of the basis for such finding. (c) Independent investigation findings. If the board makes a finding under subsection (b)(3) above, the board may conduct an independent investigation of the matter that is the subject of the complaint. The board shall report Page 121 of 240 publicly and to the city manager, the chief of police and the complainant that the board has made one (1) of the following findings: (1) That the board now finds that, despite the defects in the original internal affairs investigation, the board' s own investigation has produced no material evidence to dispute the original findings of the internal affairs department; (2) The board's independent investigation has produced substantive new information that causes them to disagree with the findings of the internal affairs investigation. In this case, the board shall make recommendations to the city manager concerning disposition of the complaint; or (3) That despite the board's best efforts, the evidence is insufficient to allow the board to determine whether the findings of the internal affairs investigative report are correct. (d) Allegation findings. Within thirty (30) days of a review hearing of a complaint or incident investigation, the board shall report their findings publicly and to the city manager, the police chief, and the complainant with respect to each allegation or issue under review as follows: (1) That the board finds that the department employee committed misconduct; (2) That the board finds that no department employee committed misconduct; or (3) That despite the board's best efforts, the evidence is insufficient to allow the board to determine whether any department employee committed misconduct. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-25) Sec. 2-464. Board review of law enforcement policies, practices and procedures. The board may review and make recommendations regarding policies, practices, and procedures of the department, including written policies, procedures and standing orders. The board shall present in writing its findings and recommendations with supporting rationale to the city manager and chief of police. If the department declines to implement any changes recommended by the board, the chief of police shall explain in writing, which shall be made available for public inspection, why the department declines t o implement the board's recommendation, unless the board instead withdraws the recommendation based on the rationale provided. The board' s withdrawal of any such recommendation shall be made available for public inspection. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-25) Sec. 2-465. Request aAnnual reportsreview of police budget and expenditures. During the city manager's preparation of a proposed city budget, the budget office shall provide the director with annual expenditure estimates and future year projections for the department, itemized to the same level of detail as provided to the city manager. The estimates shall be presented to the board by the director. The board may review the estimates and may make budgetary recommendations to the city manager orand to the city council during the annual budget process. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-466. Findings, determinations, recommendations, and public reporting. (a) Board outcomes. Upon the completion of a review, audit, or other oversight activity authorized under this article, the board may, by majority vote, issue findings, determinations, recommendations, resolutions, or public reports. Any such outcome shall be issued within thirty (30) calendar days of the board' s vote. All outcomes shall be released publicly in accordance with subsection (i) and shall conform to the board's operating procedures. Page 122 of 240 (b) Outcomes related to review of internal affairs investigations. Upon review of an internal affairs investigation conducted by the department, the board shall issue one of the following findings: (1) The board concurs with the findings and determinations provided in the internal affairs case closure letter; (2) The board does not concur with some or all of the findings and determinations provided in the internal affairs case closure letter and shall provide specific reasoning as to why the findings and determinations are not supported by the information reasonably available to the department; or (3) The board finds that the investigation is incomplete or otherwise unsatisfactory and shall provide a detailed written explanation of the basis for such finding. In review of any investigation in which the board issues a finding under subsection (b)(2) or (b)(3), the board may include determinations regarding systemic, policy, or procedural issues with the investigation and may make recommendations to the chief and to the city manager regarding further review, corrective action, or changes to investigative practices. Any resulting determinations or recommendations related to broader policies, practices, or procedures of the department, beyond the scope of the investigative process, shall be made in accordance with Sec. 2-466(d) and (e). (c) Outcomes related to department incidents. Upon review of an incident involving the department or actions of department employees, the board shall issue one of the following findings: (1) The incident does not merit a formal investigation; (2) The incident merits a formal investigation conducted by the department's Office of Internal Affairs with monitoring by the director, and the board shall provide specific reasoning for this finding; or (3) The board does not have enough relevant details about the incident to make a finding and may request additional information from the department or third parties before pursuing another review of the incident. The board, upon receiving such additional information, may determine no further review is necessary. In review of any incident in which the board issues a finding under subsection ( c)(2), the board may include determinations regarding systemic, policy, or procedural issues with the incident and may make recommendations to the chief and to the city manager regarding further review, corrective action, or changes to investigative practices related to incidents. Any resulting determinations or recommendations related to broader policies, practices, or procedures of the department, beyond the scope of the incident review, shall be made in accordance with Sec. 2- 466(d) and (e). (d) Outcomes related to disciplinary policy and application. Upon making a finding as the result of a review of an internal affairs investigation or incident, the board may issue determinations and recommendations regarding the department's disciplinary policy and its application, in a manner that protects personal information regarding identifiable employees against public disclosure and in accordance with the information access and limitations established in Sec. 2-458 and Sec. 2-459 of this article. Such recommendations may include: (1) Proposed amendments to the department's disciplinary matrix or any related policies, practices, or procedures that had a direct impact on the disciplinary outcome under review; or (2) A recommendation to the chief regarding the consistent application of disciplinary sanctions as established in department policy. (e) Outcomes related to audits, policies, practices, and procedures. Upon board review of a completed audit conducted by the director, or a board review of department policies, practices, or procedures, the board may issue determinations , recommendations, or resolutions addressing identified patterns, trends, deficiencies, or opportunities for Page 123 of 240 improvement. Determinations and recommendations may address changes to department policies, practices, procedures, training, resource allocation, equipment, or implementation of systems and technologies. (f) Hearings. The board may hold public hearings to examine matters within the scope of its authorized purpose in greater depth than is afforded during regular public meetings. A hearing serves as a culminating oversight activity, drawing on the reviews, audits, and monitoring conducted under this article to develop the public record supporting the findings, determinations, recommendations, and resolutions the board may issue und er this section. Hearings shall be subject to the following provisions: (1) Purpose and scope. A hearing may be convened by majority vote of the board to examine a specific policy, practice, procedure, pattern, trend, audit report, systemic concern, or other matter within the board's authority. A hearing shall not be convened for the purpose of adjudicating an individual complaint or incident of alleged misconduct, or for the purpose of making findings of misconduct against an identified department employee. (2) Participation. The board may invite or receive participation from any of the following: (i) Department representatives, including the chief or a designee, on a voluntary basis; (ii) Members of the public with relevant knowledge or experience; (iii) Subject matter experts, researchers, or professionals with expertise relevant to the hearing topic; (iv) Representatives of community organizations, advocacy groups, or other public agencies; and (v) Media representatives, for purposes of public transparency. (3) Evidence and testimony. The board may receive and consider documentary evidence, data, research, written statements, and oral testimony relevant to the hearing topic. The board may exercise its subpoena authority as provided in Sec. 2-460 of this article to compel the production of records or evidence from the department, and to compel the attendance of witnesses or the production of records or evidence from third parties. The board shall not exercise its subpoena authority to compel the attendance of or any statement by a n employee of the department but may request voluntary participation by the department in the proceedings. (4) Procedures. Hearings shall be conducted in accordance with the board's operating procedures, including a hearing manual adopted thereunder, which shall address notice to the public, scheduling, order of proceedings, time allotments for participants, and the format for receiving evidence and testimony. All hearings shall comply with Virginia FOIA and limitations established in Sec. 2-458 and Sec. 2-459 of this article. (5) Hearing outcomes. At the conclusion of a hearing, the board may issue determinations, recommendations, or resolutions in accordance with subsection (i). The director shall prepare a written summary of the hearing, including testimony received and evidence considered, which shall be included in or appended to the board' s published findings. (g) Department response. Within thirty (30) calendar days of receiving the board's findings, determinations, or recommendations issued under this section, the chief shall provide a written response to the board, the city manager, and the city council, as applicable, indicating acceptance, partial acceptance, or declination of such board outcomes with supporting rationale specific to address the board's stated reasoning and evidence for issuing each finding, determination, or recommendation. The chief's response shall be made available for public inspection. (h) Follow-up. The director may conduct follow-up monitoring at reasonable intervals to assess the department's implementation of accepted recommendations by the board. The results of any follow-up monitoring shall be reported to the board and included in the office's annual report. (i) Public reporting. All findings, determinations, recommendations, and resolutions issued by the board under this section shall be provided to the chief and the city manager, and shall be made available for public inspection, subject Page 124 of 240 to applicable confidentiality protections and limitations of this article. When the director and chair of the board determine that an outcome has substantial relevance to matters of public policy, resource allocation, or systemic concern, such outcome shall also be provided to the city council. The director shall maintain a public record of all board outcomes issued under this section, including the department 's written responses, and shall make such records accessible on the board's website. (j) Annual report. Each calendar year, the director shall provide the board, the city manager, and city council with an annual report of activities conducted during the preceding calendar year. The report shall be published and made available for public inspection on or about June 1 of each year for the preceding year and shall include: (1) Committees appointed and their actions; (2) An overview of complaints and review requests received, including the number of complaints monitored, the number and content of audits conducted, the number of reviews conducted and any resulting outcomes, and the number of complaints deferred due to pending proceedings; (3) Proposed amendments to department policies, practices, or procedures, and whether the department implemented them; (4) The attendance by members of the board at public community listening sessions, community events, or other events which relate to the work of the board, including a summary of board actions or any public input and recommendations received; (5) Other recommendations of the board regarding policing within the city; (6) Training received by members of the board; (7) Engagement in department collaboration in fulfillment of the board's oversight mandate; and (8) Any other information necessary to provide an overview of board and office activities. The board and the director may publish additional reports as deemed appropriate to provide transparency into oversight activities of the board and the office, including monthly and quarterly reports. (k) Legislative recommendations. The board may make recommendations to the city council of any proposed changes in state law, for the council's consideration to include in its annual legislative program to present to the General Assembly. (Ord. No. O-26-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-4627. Alternative resolution. (a) Mediation. The board may propose procedures for the use of mediation or other alternative dispute resolution techniques to resolve complaints against employees of the department. Such procedures shall not affect the ability of complainants to pursue remedies under other sections of this article. (b) Informal resolution. At any time after receiving a complaint and before issuance of the written findings required at the conclusion of a hearing, the board and any party may propose an informal resolution within the scope of the express authority granted to the board within this article, which informal resolution may be adopted if all parties and the board agree to such a resolution. At any time, the parties may agree to refer the matter to mediation or other alternative dispute resolution methods, without prejudice to the right to have a hearing on the review request. (a) Informal resolution. Upon receiving a complaint or review request, the office may, before referring a complaint to the department or initiating a formal board review, offer the complainant information or referral to appropriate resources, including department programs, other city services, or community resources that may address the complainant's concerns. Any informal resolution shall be documented by the director and reported to the board. Page 125 of 240 Nothing in this section shall prevent or discourage a complainant from filing or pursuing a formal complaint or review at any time, and the office shall inform the complainant of that right when offering informal resolution options. (b) Mediation and alternative dispute resolution. If the department maintains a mediation or alternative dispute resolution program, the office may inform the complainant of the availability of such program as an option. Participation in any such program shall be voluntary for all parties. A complainant 's decision not to participate in mediation or alternative dispute resolution shall not affect the complainant 's right to pursue remedies under other sections of this article, including a formal complaint or review request. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-463. Disciplinary recommendations. The board shall be authorized to make disciplinary recommendations regarding department employees in a manner that protects personnel information regarding identifiable employees against public disclosure, in accordance with the operating procedures established pursuant to subsection 2 -452(c) and the standard operating procedures established pursuant to subsection 2-454(a). Subject to the foregoing provisions, the following process may be used, as appropriate: (a) Board recommendations for discipline. Upon making a finding that a department employee has engaged in a serious breach of departmental and professional standards, the board shall meet to discuss appropriate recommendations for disciplinary action. Prior to commencement of any such disciplinar y deliberations, the subject employee shall be given notice of the proceedings and of the range of disciplinary actions under consideration for recommendation, and the employee shall be offered an opportunity to be heard. If permitted by FOIA, some or all of the disciplinary hearing may be held in closed session. No department employee, and no other city employee, shall be compelled to provide statements to the board during its deliberations. Disciplinary action to be considered for recommendation by the board shall only include those specified within any applicable disciplinary matrix utilized by the department. After considering these sources of information, the board may make a disciplinary recommendation to the department. (b) Decline of discipline recommendations. If the board makes a disciplinary recommendation to the department, and the department declines to implement the board's disciplinary recommendations, the chief of police shall, within thirty (30) days of the board's recommendation, provide a written explanation of the reason for declining to implement the board's recommendation. This explanation shall be made available to the board, the city council, the city manager, and the public. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-25) Sec. 2-4668. Community engagement, legislative recommendations, and reporting. (a) Community engagement.The board and the director shall engage in regular community outreach and collaboration to seek the assistance and input of community members and to provide education, awareness, and guidance on policing matters. The board may host public community listening and discussion sessions regarding policing matters of pressing public concern, such as questions about transparency, availability, legitimacy, mutual respect and trust, and community safety and order. The board and the director may also host or participate in public police -community relations meetings focused on topics such as the impacts of local policing on historically disadvantaged communities that currently experience or traditionally have experienced disparate policing. (b) L egislative recommendations. The board may make recommendations to city council of any proposed changes in state law, for the council's consideration to include in its annual legislative program to present to the General Assembly. These recommendations shall be presented to the city attorney's office by August 15 of each year. (c) Reporting. Each calendar year, the director shall provide the board and city council with an annual report of activities conducted during the preceding calendar year. The report shall detail activities of the board and the office in the prior calendar year, with sections related to the appointment of committees and their actions; the establishment of any community advisory panels; an overview of complaints received during the calendar year including the number of complaints, the complaints' findings, and the number of complaints deferred due to pending proceedings; the number and outcome of any independent investigations; an overview of proposed policy recommendations and amendments to department policies and whether the recommendations and amendments were implemented by the department; Page 126 of 240 the number, type, and attendance at community listening sessions; a summary of public input and recommendations of the public during those sessions; recommendations of the board about policing within the city; and any other information necessary to provide an overview of board and office activities. The director may provide the board, city council, and the city manager additional reports as deemed appropriate by the director to provide transparency into oversight activities of the board and the office. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-46769. Board member training. Each board member shall receive training, provided or facilitated by the director, within six (6) months of the member's appointment and every two (2) years thereafter. The training shall be consistent with the board' s purpose, this article, and the board's operating procedures, and shall include, at a minimum: (a1) NACOLE training. At least once every two (2) years, and within six (6) months of any new board appointments, the director shall facilitate or provide board members with at least four (4) hours of training, presented using training content from the National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement, or a comparable professional organizationThe training shall be consistent with the board's mission, this article, and the board's operating procedures. (b2) City and CPDdepartment training. At least once every two (2) years, and within six (6) months of any new board appointments, the city, the director, and the chief of police or their respective designees, shall facilitate or provide board members with at least two (2) hours of training or information: (1i) Describing the legal and ethical obligations of members of a public board, including the need to comply with Virginia FOIA and other statutes and ordinances governing their service; (2ii) Explaining police department procedures, policies, practices, and regulationsprocedures; (3iii) Describing the substance of police department personnel record-keeping; (4iv) Describing such other city policies, procedures, and systems relevant to the duties of the board; and (5v) Explaining the board's operating procedures and code of ethics. (c3) Additional training. As needed, the board may request additional relevant training by subject matter experts on subjects that may include mental health, trauma-informed policing, civil rights and constitutional law, race and racism, community outreach, mediation, investigation, and policing practices. The board may also request opportunities for ride-along experiences with the department and participation in the Community Police Academy. The director shall facilitate or provide this training as is feasible with available funding and other relevant considerations. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Sec. 2-46870. Commendations for exceptional community service. (a) Soliciting public comment. The board may solicit comments from the public concerning incidents of exceptional performance by employees of the department. (b) Exemplary employees. The board may consult with the chief of police regarding individual employees who have made outstanding contributions exemplary of equitable, just, and professional policing. (c) Recognition of outstanding contributions. The board may issue public citations recognizing individuals deemed to have made such contributions. (a) Purpose. The board recognizes that effective oversight includes acknowledging excellence in policing. Commendations issued under this section are intended to highlight conduct by department employees that exemplifies the principles of equitable, constitutional, and community-oriented policing. (b) Bases for commendation. The board may consider commendations for department employees based on any of the following: Page 127 of 240 (1) Conduct reflecting exceptional de-escalation, crisis intervention, or resolution of volatile situations in a manner that preserved the safety and dignity of all persons involved; (2) Demonstrated commitment to community engagement, problem-solving, or relationship-building that has measurably strengthened trust between the department and the communities it serves; (3) Actions taken to identify, report, or correct deficiencies in department policies, practices, or conduct that contributed to improved accountability or public safety outcomes; (4) Performance during a critical incident, including life-saving actions, that demonstrated professionalism and adherence to department policy and training; or (5) Other conduct that the board determines to be exemplary of the principles stated in subsection (a). (c) Sources of information. The board may identify commendation-worthy conduct through any of the following: (1) Written nominations from members of the public, provided that such nominations describe the specific conduct or incident forming the basis for the commendation; (2) Information obtained by the director or the board in the course of performing oversight, audit, or review functions authorized under this article; or (3) Data, reports, or records made available to the board in the ordinary course of the board 's work. (d) Review and issuance. Before issuing a commendation, the board shall verify, to a reasonable extent using information available to the board, that the conduct forming the basis for the commendation is supported by more than a single unsubstantiated assertion. The board may consult with the chief regarding the conduct of individual employees under consideration for recognition in accordance with this section. The board may issue public citations or other forms of recognition, by majority vote, to department employees whose conduct meets the criteria in subsection (b). The board shall notify the chief and the city manager of any commendation prior to its public issuance. (Ord. No. O-25-142, 11-17-2526-XXX, 09-21-26) Secs. 2-46971–2-479. Reserved. Page 128 of 240 PCOB Ordinance Revision Comparison Table Updated May 1, 2026 Includes Appendices A–C with Detailed Reasoning on Core Model Revisions Green rows = New sections or subsections | Pink rows = Struck or relocated sections | Blue rows = High impact sections Original Section New Section New Title Summary of Change Reasoning 450 450 Title No change. N/A (New Section) 451 Definitions Add and consolidate defined terms: (a) authorized purpose, (b) closure letter, (c) complainant, (d) complaint, (e) hearing, (f) in writing, (g) personal information, (h) records, (i) references, (j) securely retained, and (k) serious abuse of authority or misconduct (relocated from former 453(c)). Added for organization, clarity, and to consolidate definitions throughout the ordinance into a single location. Some definitions brought over from consolidation of the SOP and MOU. Definitions (b), (c), (d), and (j) are new to the ordinance. 451 452 Police civilian oversight board established Section renumbered. Stike 'the board' and 'within’ → 'in'. Strike and replace 'by' → 'in'. Reference to ‘the board’ moved to Sec. 2-451. Revision made for internal consistency. 452 453 Office of police civilian oversight established Section renumbered. No other change. N/A 452(a) 453(a) Office established Strike 'the office' and 'the department’. Capitalize “City Manager’s Office’. Strike and replace 'functions' → 'purpose’. Strike 'within' → 'in'. Reference to ‘the office’ and ‘the department’ moved to Sec 2-451. Revision made for internal consistency. 452(b) 453(b) Director Strike and replace 'will' → 'shall’. Revision made for internal consistency. 452(b)(1) 453(b)(1) Director — Appointment No change. N/A 452(b)(2) 453(b)(2) Director — Interview process Strike ‘director’. Revision made to improve grammar. Struck language implied by subsection (b) title. 452(c) 453(c) Duties of the city manager No change. N/A 452(c)(1) 453(c)(1) Duties of the city manager — Operating procedures Stike and replace consultation clause to separate into its own sentence and expand application to both establishment and amendment of procedures, and to apply to both city council and city manager actions. Revision made to improve clarity and grammar. Ensures the consultation obligation clearly applies to all scenarios. 452(c)(2-3) 453(c)(2-3) Duties of the city manager — Supervision; Vacancy No change. N/A 452(d) 453(d) Duties of the director No change. N/A Page 129 of 240 Original Section New Section New Title Summary of Change Reasoning 452(d)(1) 453(d)(1) Duties of the director — Duties No change. N/A 452(d)(2) 453(d)(2) Duties of the director — Director's authority to conduct audits Add cross-reference 'as provided in Sec. 2-463 of this article, including'. Strike and replace 'powers and duties of the board … in this' → '… purpose of the board' and 'will' → 'shall'. Added cross-reference ties audit authority to new dedicated audit section. Revision made for internal consistency. 452(d)(3) 453(d)(3) Duties of the director — Director's authority to engage in oversight activities on behalf of the board Add cross-reference 'as provided in Sec. 2-462'. Strike and replace 'powers and duties of the board … in this article' → '... purpose of the board’ and 'lawful' → 'authorized'. Strike 'outlined … § 2-454 of’. Added cross-reference ties oversight authority to new dedicated monitoring section. Revision made for internal consistency. Removal of specific section reference replaced with general article reference. 453 454 Powers and duties of the police civilian oversight board Section renumbered. No other change. N/A 453(a) 454(a) Purpose Rewrite. Broad trust-based purpose replaced with community focused mission language: transparency, accountability, monitoring, audit, review, with issuance of public reports on recommendations and best practices. Rewrite based on significant Board member discussion. The existing purpose statement is general, not focused on mission objectives for the Board, and emphasized an ideal outcome rather than actionable implementation of oversight. Moves community focus to the top. 453(b) 454(b) Powers and duties No change. N/A 453(b)(1) 454(b)(1) Powers and duties (receive complaints) Strike ', investigate and issue findings on'. Add refer-and- monitor model language. [See Appendix A for more detailed reasoning] Revision made to remove independent investigation model language and add monitoring model component. Independent investigations are not feasible for a range of reasons, including: (1) no ability to compel officer testimony; (2) resource and staffing constraints; (3) procedures of investigations defined in VA Code, CPD General Orders, and the CPD Collective Bargaining Agreement; (4) lack of a relevant binding outcome making an independent investigation ineffective as an oversight tool. 453(b)(2) 454(b)(2) Powers and duties (review and issue findings on incidents) Strike and replace 'investigate' → 'review' and ‘section’ → ‘article’. Add 'department'. Revision made to remove independent investigation model language and add review model component. 453(b)(3) — (Struck) Powers and duties (recommend disciplinary action) Strike entirely. Replace with new Sec. 2-466(d) outcome-based disciplinary application assessment and policy recommendations. [See Appendix B for more detailed reasoning] Strike made to remove specific disciplinary recommendations regarding the misconduct of a Department employee, which is not viable for reasons detailed in struck section 2-463 below. Page 130 of 240 Original Section New Section New Title Summary of Change Reasoning 453(b)(4) 454(b)(3) Powers and duties (review policies, practices, procedures) Subsection renumbered. Strike and replace 'investigate' → 'review’. Add ‘,’. Revision made to align language to review model component. Added ‘,’ for internal consistency of grammar. 453(b)(5) 454(b)(4) Powers and duties (review department investigations) Subsection renumbered. No change. N/A 453(b)(6) 454(b)(5) Powers and duties (review annual expenditure reports) Strike and replace 'request' → 'review’. Revision made to align language to review model component. 453(b)(7) 454(b)(6) Powers and duties (make public reports) Strike and replace 'investigations' → 'reviews’. Revision made to align language to review model component. 453(b)(8) 454(b)(7) Powers and duties (hold hearings and subpoena authority) Add 'with the exception of employees of the department' re: compelled attendance. Add ‘records or' in two instances. [See Appendix C for more detailed reasoning] Addition made to align language to review model component and clarify subpoenas. Using the subpoena power to compel testimony or statements from department employees is not viable for two reasons: (1) inherent conflict between the Board's ability to compel Department employees and the Board's ability to adhere to and provide protections guaranteed to law enforcement personnel under CPD General Orders, the CPD Collective Bargaining Agreement, and VA Code; (2) under a review model, this function would be generally irrelevant as disciplinary action would have already been taken, if any. 453(b)(9) 454(b)(8) Powers and duties (undertake other duties) Strike ‘for’. Add clause authorizing delegation of admin support, monitoring, auditing to the office. Revision made to clarify the role of the Office and Director to act on the Board’s behalf to conduct monitoring, auditing, and other oversight functions authorized by the Board's powers and duties. Specifies the Office's authority as a support and advise function for the Board. 453(c) — (Relocated) Definition of serious abuse of authority or misconduct Strike entirely. Relocate to new Sec. 2-451(k). Strike and relocate made to consolidate internal definitions. 455 455 Board membership, appointment, and terms Add ‘,’. Addition made for internal consistency of grammar. 455(a) 455(a) Objectivity Rewrite. Reframed as appointment directive to council. Rewrite made to convert non-operative statement of importance into an operative appointment standard, tying objectivity directly to the council's selection duty under this Page 131 of 240 Original Section New Section New Title Summary of Change Reasoning section. Also aligns to internal consistency of grammar. 455(b) 455(b) Appointment process Add ‘city’ and ‘the city’. Add 30-day minimum application window. Strike and revise 'will' → 'shall' and ‘and’ → ‘or’. Strike 'fair-minded and objective'. Additions and revision made for internal consistency. Added the thirty-day application window as a response to prior inconsistencies. In summer 2025, an application window for PCOB appointments, from the time of public notice to the time of application closure, was less than two weeks. Strike made to fair and objective language as redundant to (a). The 'and' to 'or' revision is intended to clarify an applicant does not need all listed experience. 455(c) 455(c) Board composition Strike ‘as’. Add language of conduct and board’s operating procedures. Strike made for internal consistency of grammar. Addition made to clarify where the code of ethics resides and shifts removal-for- cause framing from exhaustive ('as specified in') to illustrative ('including conduct specified in'), consistent with the existing catch-all 'other good cause' provision. 455(c)(1) — (Struck) Board composition (public housing or disadvantaged community seats) Strike entirely. Strike made for legal concern of limiting criteria. 455(c)(2) — (Struck) Board composition (racial or social justice seat) Strike entirely. Strike made for legal concern of limiting criteria. 455(c)(3) 455(c)(2) Board composition (non- voting member with policing expertise) Subsection renumbered. Moved from (3) to (2). No change. N/A 455(c)(4) 455(c)(1) Board composition (residency or employment requirement) Subsection renumbered. Moved to (1). Rewrite: City or Albemarle County resident priority; Albemarle must be employed in or tied to city. Priority first given to city residents. Add exception for VA residents if insufficient eligible applicants after public application process. Rewrite based on significant Board member discussion. Rewrite made to clarify priority of member appointment. Resolves a concern about priority level but ultimately does not change the impact on eligibility. 455(c)(5) 455(c)(3) Board composition (disqualifying affiliations) Moved from (5) to (3). Minor edits: 'council' changed to 'the city council' (2 instances); 'will' changed to 'shall.' Grammatical and terminology consistency. 455(d) 455(d) Terms Revised. 3-year terms → 2-year terms. Transition clause for current members. Prospective application of composition requirements, term length, and term limit. Term lengths have often been cited by Board members as too long. Decreases length and increases number of terms possible (4). Does not affect current member term. 455(e) 455(e) Conflicts of interest No change. N/A 456 456 Meetings No change to entire section. N/A Page 132 of 240 Original Section New Section New Title Summary of Change Reasoning 457 457 Board legal counsel Strike and replace investigation-oriented language ('cases, hearings, controversies') with framing that describes the board's oversight powers and duties. Also simplifies the conflict-of-interest exception. Revision made to reframe counsel's role around the board's oversight powers and duties, retaining a catchall for other matters involving the board's interests. The closing exception is clarified. 454 458 Information access and limitations Section renumbered. No other change. N/A 454(a) 458(a) Access to department information Rewrite. Strike SOP mandate and replace with SOP language in ordinance throughout section (see below). Add 'subject to narrow limitations' framing; 'authorized powers and responsibilities' → 'authorized purpose.' Clarify confidentiality provisions found in 'this article' and 'operating procedures.' Rewrite and revision made to remove language related to the establishment of a Standard Operating Procedure (SOP) governing access to Department information as the language of the SOP has been consolidated into the ordinance itself. Additional revisions made for internal consistency. (New) 458(b) Records to be routinely provided Add from SOP. Department must provide four record types to Director within 5 days: contact letter, closure letter, 4th Amendment Auditor report, monthly IA report. Additions made to consolidate existing SOP with the Department into ordinance. Defines how information access is provided, allowing for the agreement to become solidified into city code, rather than an extension of it. Creates a more robust framework to support the monitor, audit, review model of oversight beyond the current Chief of Police and Department culture, which provides broad access as a current practice. (New) 458(c) Requests for department records Add from SOP and new language to support monitor, audit, review model. Formal written notification process for IA reviews, policy reviews, and audits. (New) 458(d) Delivery of records Add from SOP. Include 5-day delivery; alternative timelines by agreement; vacancy provisions; dept. liaison. (New) 458(e) Format of department records Add from SOP and new language to support monitor, audit, review model. BWC and dashcam access rules; originals or exact copies; secure retention, return, destruction. 454(b) 458(f) Dept. info. to which the board may not have access Subsection renumbered. Strike (b)(1) juvenile records. Revise capitalization in (f)(2) to ‘Commonwealth’s Attorney’. Strike in (f)(4): '(1) through (C)(6)'. Strike in (f)(5) ‘police”. Strike to (f)(1) made to align with HB1476 signed by the Governor on April 13, 2026 which now allows oversight boards like the PCOB to obtain access to juvenile records as needed for its authorized purpose. Strike in (f)(4) to align with current VA Code. Revise and strike in (f)(2) and (f)(5) for internal consistency and grammar. 454(c) 458(g) Disputes over access Subsection renumbered. Strike ‘pursuant to section 2-459’. Add director-chief consultation, city manager informal hearing, 3-day written ruling. Addition provides process clarity from the SOP to situations in which there is a dispute over access to Department information. 454(d) 458(h) Confidentiality Subsection renumbered. Adds 'personal information' to scope. Subpoints unchanged. Closing paragraph strike and revise 'relevant board procedures' → 'this article.' Add and revision made to clarity FOIA limitation and for internal consistency. Page 133 of 240 Original Section New Section New Title Summary of Change Reasoning (New) 458(i) Protocols to prevent improper dissemination Add from SOP. Four-part: unauthorized use prohibition; security measures; limited exceptions (prior disclosure, employee consent); anonymization. Additions made to consolidate existing SOP with the Department into ordinance. 454(e) 458(j) Records to remain department records Subsection renumbered. Strike ‘of police’; ‘the’ → ‘department’; ‘standard’. Add from SOP the FOIA response provision requiring exemption claims. Revision made for internal consistency. Additions made to consolidate existing SOP with the Department into ordinance. 458 459 Exclusions, limitations, and suspension Section renumbered. Strike ‘Investigation e’. Revision made to align to monitor, audit, review model of oversight. 458(a) 459(a) Compliance Strike and revise of investigation language and replace with general oversight language. Strike and revise article and operating procedures reference. Revision made to align to monitor, audit, review model of oversight and for internal consistency. 458(b) 459(b) Compelled statements Strike ', other than by means of its subpoena powers'. [See Appendix C for more detailed reasoning] Strike made to remove the subpoena power specifically for compelling officer testimony, which was an existing contradiction in the hearings section. Officer testimony cannot be compelled for many of the same reasons independent investigations are not feasible. Primarily, however, ne

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.