RecordWell Data

Police Civilian Oversight Board — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Police Civilian Oversight Board · meeting of Sep 10, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Regular Meeting Agenda Police Civilian Oversight Board September 10, 2026 CitySpace 100 5th St NE Charlottesville, VA 22902 Police Civilian Oversight Board Dr. Jeffrey Fracher, Chair Dr. Kyle Dobson, Vice Chair George Dillard Jr., LE Rep Andrew Frye, At Large Albe LaFave, At Large Caron LeNoir-Kelly, Community Nathalie Reaves, Community Ruairi Vaughan, At Large 6:30 PM Regular Session I. Call to Order | Roll Call II. Agenda | Minutes Approval III. Announcements IV. First Public Comment Period V. Welcoming Joshua Barr, Chief Prosperity Officer VI. Community Connections VII. Grounding Review of CPD General Orders in the Data VIII. Developing an Audit Framework IX. Work Plan Project Status Updates X. Second Public Comment Period XI. Adjournment Notice: For members of the public participating virtually, if you experience technical difficulties, you may call (434) 970-3115, and a staff person will assist you. Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call the ADA Coordinator at (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide a 48-hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made. Approval of agenda: September 10, 2026• Approval of minutes: August 13, 2026• Sunday, November 8 from 1:00 to 7:00 PM — Board Retreat (location TBD)• Update on digital access to CPD Internal Affairs case files• Candidate interviews for Operations and Engagement Specialist position• Update on proposed ordinance revisions• Report on surveys collected to date• Board community engagement goal and call to action• Report on CPD Internal Affairs cases and 4th Amendment analysis• Board priority check on General Orders most relevant for review• Auditing framework, data sources, and opportunities• -- 1 of 2 -- PCOB Meeting Public Participation Rules Please adhere to respectful conduct, treat other attendees with courtesy, listen actively, avoid interruptions, and refrain from personal attacks or inflammatory language. For the public comment periods, for which there will be two opportunities, please wait for the designated time on the agenda to provide your comments. There is a three-minute time limit for individual comments, but all public participants are welcome to speak during both opportunities. When you speak, we request that you clearly state your name, your organization affiliation, if any, and whether you're a resident of Charlottesville, Albemarle County, or another jurisdiction. During public comment, the Board will not enter into dialogue. The Board will listen carefully to all comments. If there are specific questions, please submit them in writing to the PCOB Office staff after the meeting. Questions or additional comments can be sent to: pcob@charlottesville.gov Using the “Email PCOB” form on the right side of our website homepage: https://www.charlottesville.gov/1440/Police-Civilian-Oversight-Board Acronyms & Abbreviations ADA- Americans with Disabilities Act CCS - Charlottesville City Schools CPD- Charlottesville Police Department FY - Fiscal Year LE - Law Enforcement MOU- Memorandum of Understanding PCOB- Police Civilian Oversight Board SOP - Standard Operating Procedure(s) SRO- School Resource Officer -- 2 of 2 -- CHARLOTTESVILLE POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD SEPTEMBER 2026 Community Survey Results A tabulation of every survey response received to date on trust in, experience with, and alignment to the Charlottesville Police Department, shown next to the counts published in August 20 +6 community members surveyed to date, six of them since the August report 11 of 20 open-ended experience responses coded as positive 64/100 average of the 0–100 trust ratings given; the August report showed 69 across 14 responses Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey responses July 7 to September 1, 2026. COMMUNITY SURVEY · TRUST Trust in CPD, cumulative and since August 0 = No trust 25 50 75 100 = Full trust Each dot is one respondent (n = 20). 12 ratings are 70 or above; 4 are 10 or below. SINCE THE AUGUST REPORT TOTAL RESPONSES 20▲ +6 was 14 in August AVERAGE TRUST 64▼ −5 was 69 of 100 MEDIAN TRUST 75▼ −7 was 82 of 100 RATED TRUST 70+ 60%▼ −11 pts 12 of 20; was 10 of 14 POSITIVE EXPERIENCE 55%▼ −9 pts 11 of 20; was 9 of 14 ALIGNMENT WITH POLICE 4.6▼ −0.2 of 7; was 4.7 Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to September 2026 (n = 20) 02 / 7 MEAN 64 COMMUNITY SURVEY · VALUES ALIGNMENT Each respondent rated how well their values align with the community and with the police Two questions, each on a 1 to 7 scale. Comparing one respondent’s two answers gives the difference below. One square = one respondent (19 answered both). 2 of 19 Rated the police closer to their own values by 1 point 10 of 19 Rated the community and the police the same no difference 7 of 19 Rated the community closer to their own values by 1, 2, or 4 points HOW FAR APART THE TWO RATINGS WERE No difference same rating for both 1 point apart 2 toward police, 1 toward community 2 points apart all toward community 4 points apart all toward community n = 19; one of the 20 respondents did not answer the community question. No respondent was 3 points apart. AVERAGE DIFFERENCE BY RESPONSE PERIOD July (n = 13) 0.85 → Aug to Sep (n = 6) 1.00 Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to September 2026 03 / 7 COMMUNITY SURVEY · EXPERIENCE Experience with CPD: themes named in open-ended responses THEMES IN RESPONSES CODED POSITIVE Visible patrols: bike patrols, Downtown Mall presence, neighborhood rounds Quick, respectful responses: help after a theft, respectful conduct even during a citation, a professional response to a home- safety call Protection of gathering places: congregation security, school communities Gratitude for the job itself: two respondents thanked officers for serving in difficult and dangerous work THEMES IN RESPONSES CODED CRITICAL Little foot presence in residential neighborhoods; slow response to non- emergency calls Perceived inaction downtown: open drug activity and encampments described as tolerated Perceived hesitancy: a view that officers avoid enforcement for fear of complaints Bias in an investigation: one respondent felt her Black partner was treated as the aggressor while reporting a crime, in front of her son Police in schools: opposition to school resource officers, and a call for non-police intervention programs instead “Overall very positive. They have had quick response times and have been very respectful and responsive.” Community respondent, July “I have found police I interact with to be professional and courteous thus far. I thank them for willingness to serve in what can be a difficult, dangerous job.” Community respondent, August “Not present on foot in neighborhoods. Slow to respond when non-emergency calls made.” Community respondent, July “It made him question whether he could trust the people who are supposed to protect and help us.” Community respondent, August Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to September 2026 (n = 20) 04 / 7 COMMUNITY SURVEY · PLACES & OPEN COMMENTS Locations named and closing comments Downtown / Downtown Mall 9 Residential neighborhoods* 7 Other sites† 5 *Prospect Ave & Westhaven, 14th St, Fifeville / 10th & Page / Rose Hill, Riverview, Locust Ave, Old Fifth Circle, Fry’s Springs †UVA Health, Hydraulic Rd, city schools, Free Bridge area. Some responses named multiple places; one gave no location. Shaded areas approximate the streets and neighborhoods respondents named (not exact addresses); area size reflects how many respondents named that area. Data: OpenStreetMap contributors. Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to September 2026 (n = 20) 05 / 7 COMMUNITY SURVEY · WHO RESPONDED Age, race, gender, and income of respondents AGE (N = 16) 65+ 7 · 44% 45-54 2 35-44 5 · 31% 25-34 1 18-24 1 Under 18 0 Four respondents left the age question blank, three of them in the responses added since August. RACE (N = 16) White, non-Hispanic 12 · 75% Black/African-American 3 · 19% Multiple/Other 1 · 6% Hispanic/Latino 0 Asian/Asian Indian/Pacific Islander 0 Indigenous/American Indian 0 GENDER (N = 17) Man 10 · 59% Woman 7 · 41% Non-binary 0 Other 0 INCOME (N = 3) Three answers to the optional income question, all from responses added since August: under $15,000; $75,000 to $99,999; $100,000 to $150,000. Not charted. Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to September 2026 06 / 7 TREND TRACKING · TRUST Trust ratings, July vs. August/September JULY 7 TO JULY 29 14 RESPONSES mean 69 · median 82 · SD 32 AUGUST 11 TO SEPTEMBER 1 6 RESPONSES mean 52 · median 51 · SD 42 0 = No trust 25 50 75 100 = Full trust TRUST 70+ 71% → 33% 10 of 14, then 2 of 6 TRUST 10 OR UNDER 14% → 33% 2 of 14, then 2 of 6 SPREAD (SD) 32 → 42 cumulative 35 RESPONSE PACE 14 → 6 per collection period Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Trend tracking · responses grouped by submission date 07 / 7 MEAN 69 MEAN 52 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE · POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD Survey Action Plan Name THE BOARD'S GOAL, AS A WHOLE 120 responses this month ÷ 4 weeks → 30 responses per week ÷ 8 members → 4 per member, per week 1MY GOAL I will personally help bring in completed surveys by 2WHAT I NEED FROM STAFF Paper surveys Flyers or palm cards with QR code Translated copies Talking points I can read from A staff member or fellow board member with me Other: 3WHAT MIGHT GET IN THE WAY 4COMMUNITY CONNECTORS TO REACH OUT TO COMMUNITY CONNECTOR WHO I'LL ASK I'LL MAKE A CONNECTION AND KEEP JAMES INFORMED 10th and Page Neighborhood Association Amalgamated Transit Union (City transit workers) Big Brothers Big Sisters of the Central Blue Ridge Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (BRACH) Blue Ridge Commons Boys & Girls Clubs of Central Virginia Burnett Commons HOA Center for Non-Profit Excellence COMMUNITY CONNECTOR WHO I'LL ASK I'LL MAKE A CONNECTION AND KEEP JAMES INFORMED Charlottesville Pride Community Network City of Promise Commonwealth Justice Coalition Downtown Business Association of Charlottesville Fry's Spring Neighborhood Association Greenbrier Neighborhood Association Greenleaf Neighborhood Association IMPACT (Interfaith Movement Promoting Action by Congregations Together) International Rescue Committee - Charlottesville Islamic Society of Central Virginia Jefferson Area Board for Aging (JABA) Jefferson Park Avenue Neighborhood Association Jefferson School African American Heritage Center Kellytown Neighborhood Association Kiwanis Club of Charlottesville Love INC of Charlottesville/Albemarle Meadowbrook Hills Neighborhood Association NAMI Blue Ridge Charlottesville Network2Work On Our Own of Charlottesville One Stop Shop Cville PACEM PFLAG Greater Charlottesville PHAR - Public Housing Association of Residents COMMUNITY CONNECTOR WHO I'LL ASK I'LL MAKE A CONNECTION AND KEEP JAMES INFORMED Piedmont Housing Alliance Planned Parenthood - Charlottesville Health Center ReadyKids Rose Hill Neighborhood Association Rotary Club of Charlottesville Salvation Army Center of Hope Starr Hill Neighborhood Association The People's Coalition Thomas Jefferson Adult Career Education (TJACE) Thomas Jefferson Area Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) United Way of Greater Charlottesville University Neighborhood Association Venable Neighborhood Association Virginia Organizing (Charlottesville Chapter) Westhaven Tenants Association White Feather Willoughby Property Owners' Association Women's Initiative Woodhaven Neighborhood Association Woolen Mills Neighborhood Association INTERNAL AFFAIRS CASE DATA REVIEW Internal AffairsCase Data 2022 – 2026 2026 is a partial year — cases received January through June. 157 cases opened 262 allegations within complaints 136 / 21 complaints / service inquiries CASELOAD BY YEAR N = 262 ALLEGATIONS Allegation volume by year, internal and external Internal External Service inquiries 51 14 37 8 inquiries 2022 46 18 28 6 inquiries 2023 75 36 39 4 inquiries 2024 65 24 41 0 inquiries 2025 25 10 15 3 inquiries 2026 PARTIAL YEAR JAN–JUN MOST FREQUENT ALLEGATIONS TOP 12 OF 70 CATEGORIES Allegation counts, 2022–2026 Unsatisfactory Performance 43 Courtesy 29 Unbecoming Conduct 18 Truthfulness 16 Conformance to Law 12 Mobile Audio/Video Recording 11 Constitutional Procedures 11 Bias-Based Policing 10 Respect 9 Statements and Appearances 7 Harassment 7 Excessive Force 7 ALLEGATIONS BY DISPOSITION TOP 10 ALLEGATION CATEGORIES How each allegation was resolved Sustained Unfounded Exonerated Open / other Unsatisfactory Performance 23 12 4 4 4353% sustained Courtesy 14 11 3 2948% sustained Unbecoming Conduct 11 6 1861% sustained Truthfulness 5 8 2 1631% sustained Conformance to Law 7 3 1258% sustained Mobile Audio/Video Recording 9 2 1182% sustained Constitutional Procedures 2 5 3 1118% sustained Bias-Based Policing 10 100% sustained Respect 4 5 944% sustained Statements and Appearances 2 2 2 729% sustained INTERNAL VS. EXTERNAL COMPLAINT ALLEGATIONS BY ORIGIN Complaint origin and outcome Sustained Unfounded Exonerated Open / other Internal 102 allegations 63%of resolved allegations sustained Unsatisfactory Performance 12 Truthfulness 10 Conformance to Law 9 Courtesy 8 Unbecoming Conduct 8 External 160 allegations 40%of resolved allegations sustained Unsatisfactory Performance 31 Courtesy 21 Unbecoming Conduct 10 Bias-Based Policing 10 Mobile Audio/Video Recording 10 SUSTAINED RATE BY YEAR SHARE OF RESOLVED ALLEGATIONS Sustained findings, 2022–2026 Internal External 100% 75% 50% 25% 0% 38% 78% 69% 70% 29% 50% 37% 54% 21% 38% 2022 2023 2024 2025 2026 PARTIAL YEAR FOURTH AMENDMENT REVIEW DETENTION DATA Encounters Leadingto Detentions 2021 – 2025 2026 data was not available at the time this was prepared. 57 months of analyst reports 385 contacts recorded in 2025 79% recorded as male 4 incidents classified unconstitutional ACTIVITY AND DETENTIONS 57 MONTHS WITH BOTH MEASURES Department activity did not track detention counts 0 25 50 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 Department incidents Detention incidents Mar 2021 — 49 detentions, mid-range activity OCTOBER 2025 5,053 department incidents 25 detentions — a typical month DEMOGRAPHIC HIGHLIGHT 2025 · 385 CONTACTS Black males are the largest recorded group Black / male 47% White / male 26% Black / female 11% White / female 9% All other recorded codes 6% ABOUT 4 IN 5 79% recorded as male 306 of 385 contacts A similar pattern each year: 76– 80% recorded as male. DEMOGRAPHIC HIGHLIGHT SHARE CLASSIFIED AS ARRESTS Arrest share by group Black contacts White contacts 2021 2022 2023 2024 2025 2025 SNAPSHOT 53% vs 44% Black: 118 of 224 White: 60 of 136 A difference to explore, not an explanation of why. 100% 50% 0% 50%51% 44% 56% 52%47% 46%49% 53%44% DEMOGRAPHIC HIGHLIGHT 2021–2025 AVAILABLE REPORTS Four reported incidents, seven individual contacts JANUARY 2021 1 incident 1 individual 1 Black / male AUGUST 2022 1 incident 1 individual 1 White / male APRIL 2023 1 incident 1 individual 1 White / male APRIL 2024 1 incident 4 individuals 2 White / female 2 White / male CPD General Order Excerpts Based on your perspective and experience, select each topic's priority for the Board's Monitor, Audit, Review model of oversight. Choose one level per topic: 1 = Low, 2 = Mid, 3 = High. Levels may repeat. TOP FIVE SUSTAINED ALLEGATION TYPES PRIORITY Unsatisfactory Performance G.O. 320, §320.7.17(A) 1Low 2Mid 3High Department members shall maintain sufficient competency to properly perform their duties and assume the responsibilities of their positions. Members shall perform their duties in a manner that will maintain the highest standards of efficiency in carrying out the functions and objectives of the Department. NOTES Courtesy G.O. 320, §320.7.36(A) 1Low 2Mid 3High Department members shall be tactful in the performance of their duties, shall control their tempers, and exercise the utmost patience and discretion, and shall not engage in argumentative discussions even in the face of extreme provocation. In the performance of their duties, members shall not use coarse, violent, profane, or insolent language or gestures, and shall not express any prejudice concerning race, religion, politics, national origin, lifestyle, gender, or any personal characteristics. NOTES Unbecoming Conduct G.O. 320, §320.7.5(A) 1Low 2Mid 3High Members shall conduct themselves at all times, both on and off duty, in such a manner as to reflect favorably on the Department. Conduct unbecoming shall include that which brings the Department into disrepute or reflects discredit upon the employee as a member of the Department, or that which impairs the operation or efficiency of the Department or member. NOTES Mobile Audio/Video Recording G.O. 424, §424.4(C)–(D), (I) 1Low 2Mid 3High Officers shall activate the “record” function of the BWC when engaged in law enforcement activity. Officers may also activate BWC recording when they are in circumstances that cause them to reasonably fear for their own safety, or the safety of any other person(s). Activation shall occur at the commencement of law enforcement activity, or as soon thereafter as is practical and safe under the circumstances. An officer is not required to activate the BWC if activation would jeopardize the safety of themself or any other person(s). […] If an officer fails to activate the BWC, fails to record the entire law enforcement activity, or interrupts/mutes a recording, the officer shall document that within written reports (e.g., incident, arrest, and related reports) with an explanation. NOTES Conformance to LawG.O. 320, §320.7.6(A) 1Low 2Mid 3High Members shall obey all federal, state laws and regulations. They will also obey all laws and ordinances of the City of Charlottesville and any other jurisdiction in which they are present, whether on-duty or off-duty. NOTES POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA Source: CPD General Orders (provided compilation). Selected excerpts; consult full policies for context. PCOB Priority Worksheet FIVE ADDITIONAL HIGH-FREQUENCY ALLEGATION TYPES PRIORITY Bias-Based Policing G.O. 401, §401.4; §401.5.1 1Low 2Mid 3High Bias-based policing is strictly prohibited. However, nothing in this policy is intended to prohibit an officer from considering protected characteristics in combination with credible, timely and distinct information connecting a person or people of a specific characteristic to a specific unlawful incident, or to specific unlawful incidents, specific criminal patterns, or specific schemes. […] Officers contacting a person shall be prepared to articulate the reason for the contact, independent of the protected characteristics of the individual. NOTES Truthfulness G.O. 320, §320.7.45(A) 1Low 2Mid 3High Department members are to speak the truth at all times and under all circumstances. In cases where it is not allowed by law or by Department regulations to divulge facts and/or opinions within their knowledge, they will not speak on the subject. The only exception to this rule is during undercover investigations or toward lawful objectives during an investigation. NOTES Constitutional Procedures G.O. 348, §348.2 1Low 2Mid 3High It is the policy of the Charlottesville Police Department to respect the rights of citizens of the United States of America as well as visitors and citizens of other countries. As such, all members shall observe and comply with every person’s clearly established rights under the United States and Virginia constitutions and shall follow professional policing standards as promulgated within this policy. NOTES Respect G.O. 320, §320.7.47(A) 1Low 2Mid 3High Department members shall treat superiors, subordinates, and associates with respect. They shall be courteous and civil at all times in their relationships with one another. When on duty and in the presence of the public, officers shall be referred to by rank. Supervisors are forbidden to injure or discredit those under their authority by tyrannical or capricious conduct or by abusive language. Members shall work in harmony with each other and will not engage in disputes or altercations. NOTES Excessive Force G.O. 300, §300.4.1(A)–(B) 1Low 2Mid 3High Officers shall use only that amount of force that reasonably appears necessary given the facts and circumstances perceived by the officer at the time of the event to accomplish a legitimate law enforcement objective/purpose. The reasonableness of force will be judged from the perspective of a reasonable officer on the scene at the time of the incident. Any evaluation of reasonableness must allow for the fact that officers are often forced to make split-second decisions about the amount of force that reasonably appears necessary in a particular situation, with limited information and in circumstances that are tense, uncertain, and rapidly evolving. NOTES POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA Source: CPD General Orders (provided compilation). Selected excerpts; consult full policies for context. PCOB Priority Worksheet ADDITIONAL OVERSIGHT FOCUS — INVESTIGATIVE DETENTIONS Additional provisions relevant to the Board's Monitor, Audit, Review model of oversight. Assign a priority level as above and use the notes area to record observations and questions. Temporary Detention (Terry Stop) G.O. 348, §348.8.1(A)–(D) 1Low 2Mid 3High Police officers are allowed to stop a person and detain them briefly for questioning upon a reasonable articulable suspicion that they may be involved in criminal activity. To lawfully stop an individual, an officer must be able to articulate reasonable suspicion that the person stopped has committed, is committing or is about to commit a crime. Reasonable suspicion exists when an officer can articulate facts sufficient to cause a reasonably prudent person to suspect that criminal activity is, has or is about to occur. The scope of activities permitted during an investigatory stop is determined by the circumstances that initially justified the stop. NOTES Encounters Leading to Detention — Reporting & Review G.O. 348, §348.8.17(B)–(F) 1Low 2Mid 3High Whenever a person is stopped based on reasonable articulable suspicion or probable cause and property is not seized, the reasonable suspicion or probable cause must be fully articulated in a Temporary Detention Report. Whenever property is seized or the person is arrested as a result of a detention, an Incident (IBR) report and a Temporary Detention report must be completed. The narrative must articulate the officer's reasonable suspicion leading to the stop/frisk/search and the events surrounding the incident. The reviewing Supervisor and Shift Commander shall ensure that the facts and circumstances provided by the officer meet the requisite legal standard prior to approving the report. The Department's 4th Amendment Analyst will review all temporary detention reports and related incident reports, as well as all related BWC footage and evidence to ensure the officer and Department are adhering to the requisite legal standards. NOTES POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA Source: CPD General Orders (provided compilation). Selected excerpts; consult full policies for context. PCOB Priority Worksheet G.O. 1034 — SWORN PROMOTIONS §1034.5 ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS Listed from highest to lowest are those requirements that a candidate must meet to be eligible for promotion to a specific rank. In addition to the rank-specific requirements, a candidate must meet all the requirements of the lower rank and currently be holding that rank as well as those specified for the rank to which promotion is sought. a. Assistant Chief of Police / Major 1. Education — High school diploma or GED equivalency and 60 credit hours from an accredited college or university required; bachelor's degree preferred. 2. Experience — Has held a senior management position (Captain) within the Charlottesville Police Department, or a like size law enforcement agency or larger, for a period of one year or more. 3. Training — Holds an active Virginia Law Enforcement Officer certification thru the Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) or is eligible to obtain certification within six months of appointment. Successful completion of a Tier I law enforcement command college, or equivalent as approved by the Chief of Police. b. Captain 1. Education — High school diploma or GED equivalency and 60 credit hours from an accredited college or university required; bachelor's degree preferred. 2. Experience — Has held a supervisory position (Lieutenant) within the Charlottesville Police Department, for a period of two years or more. 3. Training — Holds an active Virginia Law Enforcement Officer certification thru the Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS). Successful completion of either a Tier I or Tier 2 law enforcement command college, or equivalent as approved by the Chief of Police. c. Lieutenant 1. Education — High school diploma or GED equivalency and 30 credit hours from an accredited college or university required; bachelor's degree preferred. 2. Experience — Has held a first line supervisory position (Sergeant) within the Charlottesville Police Department, for a period of one year or more. 3. Training — Holds an active Virginia Law Enforcement Officer certification thru the Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS). Successful completion of an advanced law enforcement supervisor's course is preferred. d. Sergeant 1. Experience — Has five years of continuous law enforcement experience as a sworn police officer within the Commonwealth of Virginia. 2. Training — Holds an active Virginia Law Enforcement Officer certification thru the Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS). Successful completion of a first line supervisor's course is preferred. [VLEPSC — PER.07.01(e)]   [CALEA — 34.1.3, 34.1.5(c)] PROPOSED CHANGE TO G.O. 1034 — BOARD FEEDBACK PROPOSED — NOT CURRENT POLICY Lieutenant — 30 credit hours or completion of FBI-LEEDA Trilogy or equivalent. Captain — 60 credit hours or a combination of 30 credit hours and 3 years of service at the rank of Lieutenant or completion of FBI-LEEDA Trilogy or equivalent. Timing — FBI-LEEDA or equivalent may be completed within the first calendar year after placement on the eligibility list. All other eligibility requirements would remain the same. The proposal is intended to open the process to additional candidates and increase competition within the promotional process. BOARD COMMENTS / NOTES / RECOMMENDATIONS POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA Source: CPD General Orders (provided compilation). Selected excerpts; consult full policies for context. PCOB Priority Worksheet DRAFTINTERNAL WORKING DOCUMENT Framework for Forms AN-1 – AN-5 Audit Framework Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board The concept the rest of the audit documents are built on. It began as handwritten notes. The forms that followed, covering nomination, scope, methodology, scorecard, report, and record, are this framework worked out in detail. Read this first; each form says which stage it belongs to. 1. Why do it Cities and organizations need a third-party assessment of their work. Three reasons carry most of the weight. Every audit states which one it is chiefly for. That choice is recorded on the refined scope and shapes what the deliverable has to show. DISCOVERY Surfaces uncut gems, the solutions staff have already invented, and the triggers behind poor-quality service. REFINEMENT Takes those discoveries and sharpens the tactics and strategies behind them, so the organization actually functions better. TRANSPARENCY Gives the public a clear view of the quality of service the organization delivers. AUDIT FRAMEWORK — WORKING DRAFT NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 2. How it runs Seven stages, in order. Each one has a document that carries it, and each one ends in something the next stage is held to. 01A nomination arrives. AN-1 Anyone may ask the Board to look into something, in their own words, on a standard form. The nominator names a concern, not yet a scope and not yet a method. “I don’t know” is a real answer to every field. 02The Office refines it into a scope; the Board votes. AN-2 Clarifying questions to the nominator, a feasibility check against what still exists, and an anchor: the Director compiles the policies, procedures, and practices plausibly in play, and the Board selects which the audit attaches to. The refined scope names the policies, the timeframe, the location, the material, and what is out of scope. It proceeds on a majority vote; a declined nomination receives a written reason. 03The method is developed before any material is pulled. AN-2B Design, sample, codebook, and analysis plan, written and pre-registered in advance. Changes are logged. 04Material is sampled and coded, and the work is recorded as it happens. AN-5 Whichever the accepted scope draws on: body-worn camera footage, ridealongs, reports, interviews, surveys, administrative data. Coders assess a subsample; where they disagree, the code gets rewritten rather than the difference split. No answer is left blank — cannot determine is an answer, and a drawn case whose material is missing is counted as missing rather than quietly replaced. Every draw, sheet, and tabulation is filed as it is produced. AUDIT FRAMEWORK — WORKING DRAFT NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 05The result is analyzed, judged, and turned into recommendations. AN-4 Three things kept apart: what the material shows is counting, and belongs to the Office; what it means is the Board’s judgment; what should change is a vote. Recommendations are issued regardless of the score. 06A scorecard communicates it to the public. AN-3 The assessment in a form people can read: an overall score, every component scored on the same scale, and a page per component saying what was looked at, what was found, and what is being asked for. Published with the report on adoption. 07The Department responds. AN-4 → AN-5 The Department sees what the material shows and the Board’s reading of it before the vote, and its response is printed with them; a second written response, on what it will act on, is due after adoption. AUDIT FRAMEWORK — WORKING DRAFT NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 3. What the audit looks at Three layers. The original notes brace all three together with one instruction: these should all be aligned. Policy WHAT IS WRITTEN DOWN Review of the policies themselves Comparison against outside standards Procedure WHAT PEOPLE ARE TRAINED AND TOLD TO DO Alignment to practice Alignment to policy Review of training materials Observation of training as it is delivered Practice WHAT ACTUALLY HAPPENS BWC review sample · live stream · full day Ridealongs sample · full or part shift Report writing sample Interviews officers + CMs Surveys officers + CMs Administrative data census where it exists HOW A LAYER BECOMES A NUMBER Each thing examined is a component, scored on the same 0–100 scale: the share of applicable cases that met the requirement, with partial credit counted as half. The bands below are fixed across audits so two scorecards can be read against each other. The overall audit score is the Board’s judgment, not an average. The components carry the detail, and every one of them is published with its margin. 0–49 Substantial gaps 50–69 Inconsistent 70–84 Adequate 85–100 Strong alignment AUDIT FRAMEWORK — WORKING DRAFT NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 4. The document set Six documents across the seven stages. Five of them carry a stage each; the record (AN-5) is kept alongside all of them, from the first material request to adoption. Each is written by someone specific, decides something specific, and has a default release. Nothing in the set is optional; an audit missing one of them is an audit with a gap. FORMDOCUMENT WRITTEN BY WHAT IT SETTLES RELEASE AN-1Nomination Anyone What someone wants looked into, in plain language. Public form AN-2Scope refinement & refined scope Office; Board votes What is examined, against what anchor, over what window, and what the audit will not answer. Internal until the vote AN- 2b Methodology plan Office; Board reviewer signs How it is examined: design, sample, codebook, and the analysis, all fixed before the material is seen. Published with the report AN-3Scorecard Office, from the record The finding at a glance: overall score, every component, one page each. Public AN-4Analysis & recommendations Office (Part 1); Board (Parts 2–3) What the material shows, what the Board makes of it, and what it officially asks be changed. Public on adoption AN-5Audit record Office, throughout The evidence behind every number, in twelve lettered sections, closed on adoption. By section Release here is the default. The Board’s decision on the refined scope, covering what is public and when, overrides it for a given audit. AUDIT FRAMEWORK — WORKING DRAFT NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 5. Rules the whole process rests on Eight commitments. Where a form seems fussy, one of these is the reason. PLAN BEFORE MATERIAL The method is written and frozen before the first case is pulled, so it cannot be shaped by what is found. COUNTING, JUDGING, ASKING Kept in separate parts, by separate authors. Fact does not borrow the authority of opinion, and opinion does not disguise itself as fact. EVERYTHING TRACES BACK Any number in the report can be followed through the record to the cases it came from and the rule that coded them. That is what answers a challenge. NO INDIVIDUAL IS NAMED An audit examines a system. Conduct concerns leave as a count and go to the complaint process; good practice is credited to a unit or shift. A MISSING RULE IS A FINDING If nothing can be named to anchor the concern, the audit reports the gap rather than declining the nomination. SAY UP FRONT WHAT IS PUBLIC Release is decided with the scope, before results exist, so nothing is withheld on the strength of how it turned out. SAY WHAT IT CANNOT SAY Each design’s limits are named in the plan, not discovered in the argument afterward: correlation is not cause, one window is not a trend, a sample is not the whole. Anything noticed that the plan did not commit to is reported as exploratory and carries no score. SOMETHING COMES OUT EITHER WAY A clean audit still produces recommendations. Discovery is a result, not a consolation prize. AUDIT FRAMEWORK — WORKING DRAFT NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION 6. Who does what Four parties: the Office does the work, the Board decides, the Department answers, and the person who raised it hears back. Nominator Says what concerns them and answers clarifying questions. Does not choose the material, the method, or the scope, and is told the outcome whether the audit runs or not. Director & Office Refines the nomination, compiles the candidate anchors, writes the methodology plan, draws and codes the sample, keeps the record, and writes what the material shows. Board Votes on the scope, judges the results, sets the overall score, drafts the report, and decides what is released. Department Supplies the frame and the material under an access agreement, responds in writing to the adopted report, and considers carrying out what is recommended or responds to what was not accepted with reasoning. AUDIT FRAMEWORK — WORKING DRAFT NOT FOR DISTRIBUTION

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.