RecordWell Data

Planning Commission Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Planning Commission · meeting of May 12, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Planning Commission Meeting Agenda May 12, 2026 610 East Main Street City Council Chambers Charlottesville, Virginia 22902 Carl Schwarz, Chair Danny Yoder, Vice Chair Ross Harness Hosea Mitchell Betsy Roettger Lyle Solla-Yates Josh Carp Michael Joy I. Commission Pre-Meeting (Agenda discussion(s)) Beginning: 5:00 p.m. Location: (Council Chambers, 605 E. Main Street, Charlottesville, VA 22902) II. Commission Regular Meeting Beginning: 5:30 p.m. Location: (Council Chambers, 605 E. Main Street, Charlottesville, VA 22902 and Electronic/Virtual) 1. Commissioner's Reports 2. University of Virginia Report 3. Chair's Report 4. Department of NDS Report 5. Matters to be Presented by the Public not on the Formal Agenda 6. Consent Agenda III. Planning Commission Public Hearing Items Beginning: 6:00 p.m. 1. Zoning Map Amendment and Zoning Text Amendment - 801 West Street [PL-26- 0042 and PL-26-0043] IV. Commission's Action Items Beginning: following any public hearings 1. Critical Slope Special Exception - 2010 Meadowbrook Road [PL-26-0037] 2. Critical Slope Special Exception - Botanical Gardens of the Piedmont [PL-26- 0044] V. Presentations Beginning: following any action items 1. Environmental Regulations and Policy Update 2. Downtown Mall Action Plan Implementation VI. Future Meeting Schedule/Adjournment Tuesday, May 26 - 5:00 PM - Work Session Tuesday, June 9 - 5:30 PM - Regular Meeting Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call the ADA Coordinator at (434) 970-3185 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide a 48 hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made. Planning Commission pre-meeting and regular meetings are held in person and by Zoom webinar. The webinar is broadcast on Comcast Channel 10 and on all the City's streaming platforms including: Facebook, Twitter, and www.charlottesville.gov/streaming. Public hearings and other matters from the public will be heard via the Zoom webinar which requires advanced registration here: www.charlottesville.gov/zoom . You may also participate via telephone and a number is provided with the Zoom registration or by contacting staff at 434-970-3182 to ask for the dial in Page 1 of 82 number for each meeting. Written comments may be submitted via email to planningcommission@charlottesville.gov. Page 2 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – Planning Commission Review – May 12, 2026 (4/27) 1 PLANNING COMMISSION PUBLIC HEARING APPLICATION FOR A ZONING MAP AMENDMENT (ZMA) AND ZONING TEXT AMENDMENT (ZTA) APPLICATION NUMBERS: PL-26-0042 and PL-26-0043 DATE OF MEETING: May 12, 2026 DEPARTMENT OF NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT SERVICES STAFF REPORT Author of Staff Report: Kate Richardson Date of Staff Report: April 27, 2026 Origin of Request: Richard Hunt, Property Owner Applicable City Code Provisions: Section 34-5.2.5.B (Zoning Amendment) and Section 34-2.9.3 (IPP designation) Planner: Carrie Rainey Application Information Property Street Address: 801 West Street (“Subject Property”) Tax Map & Parcel/Tax Status: 310042000 Total Square Footage/ Acreage Site: Approx. 0.3 acres (13,068 sq. ft.) Comprehensive Plan (General Land Use Plan): General Residential (Sensitive Community Areas) Current Zoning Classification: RN-A Current Overlay District: None Background A Zoning Map Amendment (“ZMA”) Application and a Zoning Text Amendment (“ZTA”) Application, both pursuant to Charlottesville City Code Section 34-5.2.5, have been submitted for property located at 801 West Street, Charlottesville, Virginia, TMP # 310042000 (“Subject Property”). Consistent with the provisions of Section 34-2.9.3., the Subject Property owner requested the City initiate the ZTA and ZMA process to designate the Subject Property (an existing house at 801 West Street) as an Individually Protected Property (“IPP”). The proposed IPP designation will overlay an approximately 0.3-acre parcel, located at the NW corner of West Street and 8th Street, NW, within the 10 th and Page Neighborhood. On December 9, 2025, the Planning Commission approved by motion to initiate the necessary review to amend Section 34-2.9.3.B. to designate this parcel an IPP, and, per Section 34-5.2.5, amend the City Zoning Map to identify this parcel as having an IPP overlay. Designation of an IPP follows the process for an amendment to the City's zoning ordinance and zoning map, including a public hearing and notification. Page 3 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – Planning Commission Review – May 12, 2026 (4/27) 2 Per Section 34-5.2.5.B.1.a., a ZTA may be initiated by the City Council or Planning Commission. The City’s designated IPPs are specifically identified and listed in Section 34-2.9.3.B, therefore requiring the ZTA be completed in tandem with the ZMA. Proposed revision to Section 34-2.9.3.B. - Established Individually Protected Properties: Following is a list of landmarks, buildings and structures outside the City’s ADC Districts, which are deemed by City Council to be of special historic, cultural, or architectural value. Street Number Street Name Tax Map Number Parcel Number […] 801 West Street Tax Map 31 Parcel Number 42 The Board of Architectural Review (BAR) approved a motion recommending the ZTA and ZMA to City Council on January 21, 2026 (link to BAR motion and case archive). Subsequently, the required Community Meeting was held on March 11, 2026, at the Subject Property. On the Subject Property, the proposed contributing structure is a two-story, framed dwelling, clad in stucco. The dwelling is characterized by a hipped roof with pedimented gables, a wood-railed widow's walk in the center, with an attached single-story, rear addition. The addition features a gabled roof and side porch with shed roof. In 1905, James Patterson, a white carpenter, constructed the dwelling for his family. The Patterson family sold the property in 1944 during WWII to James Fleming, a fireman with the railroad, and his wife Maude Fleming, a prominent local teacher at the Jefferson school for forty years. The property remains in the family to this day. (The NE corner of the 10th & Page Neighborhood was initially segregated. Between 1930 and 1950, it transitioned to predominantly Black residents, including the Flemings.) Mr. Hunt (owner of the Subject Property) is the Great-Great-Great Great Grandson of Henry Martin (1826-1915), the bell ringer at UVA from c.1868 until 1909. Vicinity Map Page 4 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – Planning Commission Review – May 12, 2026 (4/27) 3 Context Map Standard of Review When initiated, per Section 34-5.2.5.D, the Planning Commission reviews and studies the proposed amendments to determine: 1. Whether the proposed amendment conforms to the general guidelines and policies contained in the Comprehensive Plan; 2. Whether the proposed amendment will further the purposes of this Chapter and public necessity, convenience, general welfare, and good zoning practice require such amendment; 3. Whether there is a need and justification for the change; 4. When pertaining to a change in the zoning district classification of property, the effect of the proposed change, if any, on the property itself, on surrounding property, and on public services and facilities. In addition, the Planning Commission must consider the appropriateness of the property for inclusion within the proposed zoning district, relating to the purposes set forth at the beginning of the proposed district classification; and 5. Such other considerations as permitted by law. Request Based on the criteria found in Section 34-2.9.3.C.2. (analysis below), staff asks the Planning Commission to recommend that City Council amend Section 34-2.9.3.B by adding this parcel to the list of IPPs and to amend the Zoning Map to designate this parcel as an IPP, with the two-story framed dwelling being listed as a contributing structure within the GIS feature class. Discussion Page 5 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – Planning Commission Review – May 12, 2026 (4/27) 4 In June 2020, on behalf of the City, the 106 Group completed a Reconnaissance Architectural History Survey of 438 properties within the 10th & Page Neighborhood. As a result, the Virginia Department of Historic Resources State Review Board recommended the approximately 50-acre Tenth and Page Historic District be eligible for listing on the Virginia Landmarks Register (VLR) and the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP). Within that review, the Subject Property was assessed as retaining excellent integrity of both location and setting. In the areas of design, materials, and workmanship the house was assessed as retaining good integrity and therefore recommended as potentially individually eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) under criterion A as one of the oldest extent houses within the (also eligible) 10 th & Page Neighborhood (See Attachment 1). Link to the 2020 survey: Survey of 10th and Page Neighborhood 2020 In 1991, the first IPPs were established by Council applying an ordinance intended to preserve, protect, and enhance certain buildings, structures, and landmarks, together with their landscapes and settings, which are of special historic, cultural, or architectural significance, and which are located outside the City’s ADC Districts. Charlottesville currently has eight ADC Districts, three Historic Conservation Districts, and 76 IPPs. Similar to the ADC district designation, the IPP designation is an overlay, and as such the underlying zoning remains the same. It is only through this local [City] designation that a historic property comes under the purview of the Board of Architectural Review (BAR) and, with that, is regulated by the City Code relative to demolitions, alterations, and new construction. The BAR cannot deny or prohibit a zoned use. Also, BAR actions are appealable to City Council and then to the courts. That is, the BAR cannot, by its actions alone, prevent a demolition or prevent a new structure or alteration to an existing structure. Note: An IPP is a local designation, therefore evaluation of a proposed IPP should consider its importance to this city and this community. While it is helpful to refer to the NRHP criteria, neither eligibility nor listing should be considered requirements for local recognition. In fact, the relevant City Code section states that IPP designation is not determined by NRHP listing, but a way to encourage nomination of historic properties to the National Register of Historic Places and the Virginia Landmarks Register (See Attachment 2). Standard of Review – IPP Designation [Section 34-2.9.3.C] C. Amendments to Individually Protected Property List 1. City Council may, by ordinance, from time to time, designate individual buildings, structures or landmarks as Individually Protected Properties; or remove individual buildings, structure or landmarks from the City’s list of Individually Protected Properties. Any such action will be undertaken following the rules and procedures applicable to the adoption of amendments to the City’s Development Code and official zoning map. 2. Prior to the adoption of any such ordinance, the City Council will consider the recommendations of the Planning Commission and the Board of Architectural Review (BAR) as Page 6 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – Planning Commission Review – May 12, 2026 (4/27) 5 to the proposed addition, removal or designation. The Planning Commission and BAR will address the following criteria in making their recommendations: a. The historic, architectural or cultural significance, if any, of a building, structure or site and whether it has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places or the Virginia Landmarks Register, or are eligible to be listed on such registers; Staff comment: Per the Department of Historic Resources’ Virginia Cultural Resources Information System (VCRIS) entry [Attachment 1], the Subject Property is recommended potentially individually eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A as one of the oldest extant houses in the neighborhood. b. The association of the building, structure or site with an historic person or event or with a renowned architect or master craftsman; Staff comment: The Subject Property does not meet this standard. However, James Patterson was a well-known local builder and carpenter. c. The overall aesthetic quality of the building, structure or site and whether it is or would be an integral part of an existing ADC district; Staff comment: Per the VCRIS entry [Attachment 1], the property retains excellent integrity of both location and setting. In the areas of design, materials, and workmanship the house retains good integrity. Additionally, the site as a whole retains excellent integrity of feeling and association. d. The age and condition of a building or structure; Staff comment: The structure’s date of construction is 1905 and is currently in good condition both internally and externally. e. Whether a building or structure is of old or distinctive design, texture and material; Staff comment: The structure is now 130 years old and retains both interior and exterior design elements that are representative of the late 19th-c. and early 20th-c. vernacular style and of the period in which it was fashioned [See photographs within Attachment 1]. Its overall integrity is mildly compromised by late 20th-c. replacement windows and stucco cladding. f. The degree to which the distinguishing character, qualities or materials of a building, structure or site have been retained; Staff comment: As noted within standard c above, the Subject Property retains its historic setting and association within the 10th and Page neighborhood. The presence of a widow’s walk is a unique element of its construction. The notable changes to the Page 7 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – Planning Commission Review – May 12, 2026 (4/27) 6 structure and site in the last 100 years include: loss of the original one-story garage or outbuilding prior to 1963, the addition of exterior stucco, and replacement windows. g. Whether a building or structure, or any of its features, represents an infrequent or the first or last remaining example of a particular detail or type of architecture in the City; Staff comment: Staff does not believe this structure represents an infrequent design within the City as a whole. It is recommended however, that additional research be conducted to determine the sequence of development of 10th and Page in the early 1900’s. The property’s retention of historic setting, feeling and association do recommend consideration under this standard. h. Whether a building or structure is part of a geographically definable area within which there exists a significant concentration or continuity of buildings or structures that are linked by past events or, aesthetically, by plan or physical development, or within which there exist a number of buildings or structures separated geographically but linked by association or history. Staff comment: Per the VCRIS entry, the 10 th and Page Historic District is eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A in the areas of Ethnic Heritage, Community Planning and Development and Social History, and under Criterion C in the area of Architecture. This property would be a primary contributing resource of such a nominated district. It is the owner’s wish to designate the Subject Property as an Individually Protected Property in order to maintain this continuity. Staff Responses to Standards of Review – ZMA/ZTA (Section 34-5.2.5.D) 1. Whether the proposed amendment conforms to the general guidelines and policies contained in the Comprehensive Plan; Staff response: The proposed ZMA and ZTA to designate the Subject Property as an Individually Protected Property (IPP) conforms to the general guidelines and policies contained in the City of Charlottesville's Comprehensive Plan. The Comprehensive Plan expressly recognizes historic preservation as a core community value and identifies the protection of historic resources as essential to sustaining Charlottesville's character, identity, and sense of place. The 10th and Page neighborhood is one of Charlottesville's historically significant African American communities, and the Subject Property represents a tangible, physical connection to that heritage. The Comprehensive Plan supports the identification, designation, and protection of properties that contribute to the city's architectural, cultural, and social history. Designating the Subject Property as an IPP directly advances land use policies that encourage the preservation of historic structures, reinforce neighborhood character, and promote stewardship of irreplaceable community assets. The designation is also consistent with Comprehensive Plan goals related to equitable recognition of historically underrepresented communities, as the 10th and Page neighborhood reflects a distinct chapter of Charlottesville's African American history that warrants acknowledgment and protection through the city's regulatory framework. Page 8 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – Planning Commission Review – May 12, 2026 (4/27) 7 Therefore, staff finds the amendment conform to the general guidelines and polies contained in the Comprehensive Plan. 2. Whether the proposed amendment will further the purposes of this Chapter and public necessity, convenience, general welfare, and good zoning practice require such amendment; Staff response: Chapter 34 establishes a framework for land use regulation that, among other objectives, protects and enhances the character of Charlottesville's neighborhoods and preserves resources of historic, architectural, and cultural significance. The IPP designation mechanism under Chapter 34 exists precisely to achieve these goals on a property-specific basis, providing targeted protection for structures whose loss would constitute an irreversible harm to the community's heritage. Designating the Subject Property as an IPP serves the public necessity by ensuring that a historically significant structure is not inadvertently altered or demolished without appropriate review. It serves public convenience by creating a clear, transparent regulatory status for the property that informs owners, neighbors, and prospective buyers of the property's significance. It advances the general welfare by preserving a physical artifact of the 10th and Page neighborhood's history for the benefit of current and future residents. And it reflects good zoning practice by using the city's established IPP process — a purpose-built tool — in precisely the manner prescribed by the Code. Therefore, staff finds the amendment will further the purposes of this Chapter and public necessity, convenience, general welfare, and good zoning practice. 3. Whether there is a need and justification for the change; Staff response: Historic and Architectural Significance: The Subject Property is a historic home situated within the 10th and Page neighborhood, a community with deep roots in Charlottesville's African American history. The structure embodies the architectural character and community identity of one of the city's most historically meaningful residential neighborhoods. Without formal designation, the property lacks the regulatory protection necessary to ensure that its historic fabric is considered before any future alterations, demolition, or redevelopment are permitted to proceed. Irreversibility of Loss: Historic structures, once demolished or significantly altered, cannot be restored. The IPP designation provides the minimum necessary regulatory safeguard — a requirement for review — to ensure that decisions affecting the Subject Property are made with full awareness of its historic significance. The risk of inaction, in the form of potential loss of this resource, far outweighs any burden imposed by designation. Community and Neighborhood Context: The 10th and Page neighborhood has been identified as a priority area for recognition of Charlottesville's African American heritage. Designating 801 West Street as an IPP is consistent with the city's broader efforts to document, recognize, and protect the physical legacy of this community, and responds to community interest in preserving neighborhood character and historic resources. Page 9 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – Planning Commission Review – May 12, 2026 (4/27) 8 Therefore, staff finds there is need for the amendment, and the change justified. 4. When pertaining to a change in the zoning district classification of property, the effect of the proposed change, if any, on the property itself, on surrounding property, and on public services and facilities. In addition, the Planning Commission must consider the appropriateness of the property for inclusion within the proposed zoning district, relating to the purposes set forth at the beginning of the proposed district classification; Staff response: Effect on the Property Itself: The IPP designation does not change the underlying zoning district classification of the Subject Property, nor does it alter the property's permitted uses. It imposes a layer of review — specifically, Certificate of Appropriateness review by the Board of Architectural Review (BAR) — prior to the approval of certain alterations or demolition. This review process is well-established, predictable, and designed to be navigated collaboratively between property owners and the city. The designation affirms the property's significance and may, over time, enhance its cultural and market value by recognizing its historic character. Effect on Surrounding Properties: The designation of the Subject Property as an IPP will have no adverse effect on surrounding properties. It does not alter setbacks, density, permitted uses, or any other development standard applicable to neighboring parcels. The designation may have a positive stabilizing effect on the surrounding neighborhood by signaling the city's commitment to preserving the character of the 10th and Page neighborhood and discouraging incompatible redevelopment of a key historic resource. Effect on Public Services and Facilities: The proposed designation has no impact on public services or infrastructure. It does not increase density, generate additional traffic, or place any new demands on utilities, schools, or emergency services. The BAR review process that accompanies IPP designation is administered within existing city staff and commission capacity. Appropriateness for the IPP Classification: The IPP classification under Chapter 34 is designed for properties of individual historic, architectural, or cultural significance that warrant protection on their own merits, independent of any historic district designation. The Subject Property meets this standard. It is a historic home in a historically significant neighborhood, and its individual designation reflects the property's standalone importance to Charlottesville's heritage. The purposes set forth for the IPP classification — protecting significant historic resources and ensuring informed review of proposed changes — are directly and fully served by this designation. Therefore, staff finds the impact does not affect the underlying zoning district classification, does not adversely affect the surrounding properties, has no impact on public services or infrastructure, and is appropriate for the Subject Property. 5. Such other considerations as permitted by law. Staff response: Equity and Inclusive Preservation: Charlottesville has acknowledged, through various planning and policy processes, the importance of equitably recognizing the historic contributions of African American residents and communities whose heritage has historically been underrepresented in formal preservation programs. The designation of the Subject Property advances this equity goal Page 10 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – Planning Commission Review – May 12, 2026 (4/27) 9 by extending the protections of the IPP framework to a property associated with the 10th and Page neighborhood's African American history. This is consistent with the Commission's broader responsibilities to promote the general welfare of all Charlottesville residents. Owner and Community Support: To the extent that property owner concurrence and community support have been expressed, such support further affirms the appropriateness of the designation and reduces any concern regarding the regulatory burden the designation may impose. Public Comments Received Staff received no public comments regarding the ZMA and ZTA requests at the publishing of this report. Staff Recommendation Staff asks the Planning Commission to recommend that City Council adopt both rezoning applications: PL-26-0042 (ZMA) and PL-26-0043 (ZTA). Appropriate Motions - ZMA 1. Having reviewed the criteria for designation of Individually Protected Properties per Section 34-2.9.3., I move the Planning Commission recommend that City Council approve the Zoning Map Amendment to designate the Subject Property (801 West Street; Parcel 31-42) an Individually Protected Property. 2. Having reviewed the criteria for designation of Individually Protected Properties per Section 34-2.9.3., I move the Planning Commission recommend that City Council deny the Zoning Map Amendment to designate the Subject Property (801 West Street; Parcel 31-42) an Individually Protected Property. 3. Move to defer this action item. Appropriate Motions - ZTA 1. Having reviewed the criteria for designation of Individually Protected Properties per Section 34-2.9.3., I move the Planning Commission recommend that City Council approve the Zoning Text Amendment to designate the Subject Property (801 West Street; Parcel 31- 42) an Individually Protected Property. 2. Having reviewed the criteria for designation of Individually Protected Properties per Section 34-2.9.3., I move the Planning Commission recommend that City Council deny the Zoning Text Amendment to designate the Subject Property (801 West Street; Parcel 31-42) an Individually Protected Property. 3. Move to defer this action item. Attachments 1. VCRIS and Historical Survey 2. NRHP Status of City IPPs & Vicinity Map 3. BAR Case Archive, January 2026 Page 11 of 82 Virginia Department of Historic Resources DHR ID: 104-5936 Architectural Survey Form Other DHR ID: No Data Property Information Property Names Name Explanation Name Function/Location House, 801 West Street Property Addresses Current - 801 West Street County/Independent City(s): Charlottesville (Ind. City) Incorporated Town(s): No Data Zip Code(s): 22903 Magisterial District(s): No Data Tax Parcel(s): No Data USGS Quad(s): CHARLOTTESVILLE EAST Property Evaluation Status Additional Property Information Architecture Setting: Urban Acreage: No Data Site Description: January 2020: This two-story house is located on the north side of West Street on the west corner of 8th Street NW and West Street. The walkway to the house is lined with box hedges, and there are large, mature trees around the house and along the rear of the property. This property consists of a house. Surveyor Assessment: January 2020: According to City of Charlottesville Property Records, this house was constructed in 1905 (City of Charlottesville GIS Viewer 2020). It first appears on the 1913 Sanborn Map with the same footprint it maintains through the Sanborn Maps to 1950 and into today (Sanborn Map Company 1913; Sanborn Map Company 1950; Google.com 2020). On the 1913 Sanborn Map, this house has a single-stall garage to the south east of the property (Sanborn Map Company 1913). This becomes a double-stall garage in the 1920 Sanborn Map and is maintained in the 1929 and 1950 Sanborn Maps (Sanborn Map Company 1920; Sanborn Map Company 1929; Sanborn Map Company 1950). This garage was demolished before 1963 (NETR 1963). Due to the multiple entranceways, this single- family house may now be a multi-family dwelling. This property retains excellent integrity of location and setting. This property retains good integrity of design, materials, and workmanship, mildly compromised by replacement windows. This property retains excellent integrity of feeling and association. Overall, this property retains good integrity. This property is recommended potentially individually eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A as one of the oldest extant houses in the neighborhood. Further research should be conducted to determine if this is one of the first properties to be built in the neighborhood. Additionally, it is located in the potential 10th & Page Historic District, which is recommended as potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP. Further study is recommended to determine if the 10th & Page Historic District is eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A in the areas of Ethnic Heritage, Community Planning and Development, and Social History, and under Criterion C in the area of Architecture. This property includes one contributing primary resource. Surveyor Recommendation: Recommended Potentially Eligible Ownership Ownership Category Ownership Entity Private No Data Primary Resource Information Resource Category: Domestic Resource Type: Single Dwelling NR Resource Type: Building Date of Construction: 1905 Date Source: Local Records Historic Time Period: Reconstruction and Growth (1866 - 1916) Historic Context(s): Domestic Other ID Number: No Data May 22, 2020 Page: 1 of 3 Attachment 1 Page 12 of 82 Virginia Department of Historic Resources DHR ID: 104-5936 Architectural Survey Form Other DHR ID: No Data Architectural Style: Vernacular Form: No Data Number of Stories: 2.0 Condition: Good Threats to Resource: None Known Architectural Description: January 2020: This two-story house is clad in stucco and has a hipped roof with pedimented gables covered in asphalt shingles with a wood- railed widow's walk in the center of the crossing. The front (southwest) facing facade features a one-story, full-width porch with a hipped roof supported by wood columns. The main entrance for this house is on the east end of the southwest facade. There is an interior concrete chimney near the center of the roof on the northwest roof slope at the ridgeline. There is a one-story, full-width, front-gable wing on the rear (northeast) elevation of the house. It has an open porch on the southeast elevation with turned wood columns and railings. This porch provides access to two entrances. Visible fenestration includes two-over-two, double-hung, wood windows, most with fixed wood shutters; and a single-leaf wood door with a transom and a metal and glass storm door. Exterior Components Component Component Type Material Material Treatment Chimneys Interior Central Concrete Uncoursed Foundation Solid/Continuous Unknown Stuccoed/Parged Structural System and Wood Frame Unknown Stuccoed Exterior Treatment Windows Double-hung Wood No Data Porch 1-Story Full-Width Wood Doric Roof Hipped w/Lower Cross Gables Asphalt No Data Secondary Resource Information Historic District Information Historic District Name: No Data Local Historic District Name: No Data Historic District Significance: No Data CRM Events Event Type: Survey:Phase I/Reconnaissance Project Review File Number: No Data Investigator: Erin Que Organization/Company: The 106 Group Ltd. Photographic Media: Digital Survey Date: 2/5/2020 Dhr Library Report Number: No Data Project Staff/Notes: Erin Que, Principal Investigator and Sr. Architectural Historian Holly Good, Architectural Historian Saleh Miller, Sr. Architectural Historian Project Bibliographic Information: City of Charlottesville GIS Viewer 2020 Property Record. Electronic document, http://gisweb.charlottesville.org/GisViewer/, accessed January 27, 2020. Hill Directory Co. 1931, 1940, 1950, 1959 Hill’s Charlottesville City Directory. Hill Directory Co., Inc., Publishers, Richmond, Virginia. National Environmental Title Research, LLC [NETR] 1963-2016 Historical Aerial Photograph, Charlottesville Independent City, Virginia. Electronic document, http://historicaerials.com/, accessed March 19, 2020. May 21, 2020 Page: 2 of 3 Page 13 of 82 Virginia Department of Historic Resources DHR ID: 104-5936 Architectural Survey Form Other DHR ID: No Data Neighborhood Development Services 2012-2016 The 10th and Page Historic Survey. On file at the City of Charlottesville Neighborhood Development Services, Charlottesville, Virginia. Sanborn Map Company 1907, 1913, 1920, 1929, 1950 Fire Insurance Map of Charlottesville, Virginia. Sanborn Map Company, New York, New York. United States Geological Survey [USGS] 1994-2019 Historical Aerial Photograph, Charlottesville Independent City, Virginia. Electronic document, accessed on Google Earth, February 20, 2020. Bibliographic Information Bibliography: No Data Property Notes: No Data May 21, 2020 Page: 3 of 3 Page 14 of 82 Page 15 of 82 - 801 West Street: (DHR #104-5936) Architectural Survey Form - Photographs February 2020 Front and side (west ) elevations - from West Street Front and side (east) elevations from West Street Page 16 of 82 - 801 West Street: (DHR #104-5936) Architectural Survey Form - Photographs February 2020 Front elevation - from West Street Rear and side (east) elevations from 8th Street, NW Page 17 of 82 Attachment 2 Status of the City’s 76 Individually Protected Properties (IPPs) • 48 are not listed on the NRHP • 28 are individually listed on the NRHP • 19 are contributing resources to a NRHP historic district (most, if not all, were IPPs before being included in a district) Vicinity Map indicating proximity of existing IPPs to 801 West Street Page 18 of 82 Archive City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Regular Meeting January 21, 2026 Re commendation to City Council – IPP Designation Application for ZMA/ZTA [PL-26-0042 & PL-26-0043] 801 Wes t Street; TMP 310042000 Owner: Richard H. Hunt, Jr. Applicant: City of Charlottesville, Neighborhood Development Services Project: Zoning amendment to designate property an IPP Reporting Staff: Kate Richardson Appl ication components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to the report pages): • Motion of Approval - Recommendation to City Council • BAR Staff Report • DHR-VCRIS Historical Survey • Subject Property Photographic Documentation • Owner correspondence requesting designation Attachment 3 Page 19 of 82 City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Motion of Approval January 21, 2025 Recommendation to City Council – IPP Designation 801 West Street; TMP 310042000 Owner: Richard H. Hunt, Jr. Applicant: City of Charlottesville, NDS Project: Zoning map and text amendment to designate property an IPP Mr. Hunt, The fol lowing motion was approved for the above referenced case by the City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review on January 21, 2026. The following action was taken: Mr. Sch warz moved to approve the recommendation to City Council as follows: Having reviewed the criteria for designation of Individually Protected Properties per City Code Section 34-2.9.3., I move the BAR recommend that City Council approve the request to designate 801 West Street (Parcel 31-42) as an Individually Protected Property. The motion was seconded by Ms. Lewis and passed 7-0. For specifics of the discussion, see the Board of Architectural Review’s YouTube channel for a recording of the January 21st meeting: https://youtu.be/aRWaqfJjdUk?list=PLSKqYabjF44UhoEZrMWdDF9znV1CnlNUV Sincerely, Kate Page 20 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – BAR review Jan 21, 2026 (1/13) 1 City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Staff Report January 21, 2025 Recommendation to City Council – IPP Designation 801 West Street; TMP 310042000 Owner/ Applicant: Richard H. Hunt, Jr. Project: Zoning map and text amendment to designate property an IPP Background Year Built: 1905 Style: Vernacular Constructed in 1905, the now stucco-clad house consists of two-stories, a hipped roof with pedimented gables, and a central widow’s walk defined by wooden rails. The primary southwest façade features a full-width, one-story porch supported by wooden columns. A northeast wing extends to the rear of the property, complete with open porch, turned columns and railings. The side porch on the East elevation as recently been enclosed (see photographic documentation). In 1905, James Patterson, a white carpenter, constructed the dwelling for his family. The Patterson family sold the property in 1944 during WWII to James Fleming, a fireman with the railroad, and his wife Maude Fleming, a prominent local teacher at the Jefferson school for forty years. The property remains in the family to this day. (The NE corner of the 10th & Page Neighborhood was initially segregated. Between 1930 and 1950, it transitioned to predominantly Black residents, including the Flemings.) Mr. Hunt (owner of the Subject Property) is the Great-Great-Great Great Grandson of Henry Martin (1826-1915), the bell ringer at UVA from c.1868 until 1909. Prior BAR Reviews This property is not locally designated, therefore there are no prior applications to the BAR. Request The BAR is asked to make a recommendation to City Council on the owner’s request to designate as an Individually Protected Property (IPP) an approximately 0.3-acre parcel located at the NW corner of West Street and 8th Street, NW, within the 10th & Page Neighborhood. On December 9, 2025, in response to a request from the property owner, the Planning Commission voted to initiate the necessary review to amend City Code Chapter 34, Section 2.9.3.B. to designate this parcel an IPP, and, per City Code Chapter 34, Section 5.2.5, amend the City Zoning Map to Page 21 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – BAR review Jan 21, 2026 (1/13) 2 identify this parcel as having an IPP overlay. Designation of an IPP follows the process for an amendment to the City's zoning ordinance and zoning map, including a public hearing and notification. Per City Code Chapter 34, Section 5.2.5.B.1.a., a Zoning Text Amendment (ZTA) may be initiated by the City Council or Planning Commission. (ZTA is necessary because the City’s designated IPPs are specifically identified and listed in City Code Chapter 34, Section 2.9.3.B.) Per City Code Chapter 34, Section 5.2.5.B.1.b., a Zoning Map Amendment (ZMA) may be initiated by the City Council, the Planning Commission, or the owner of a property. Property information and attachments: • VCRIS and Historical Survey • Interior and exterior photographs • Written request to staff asking to begin the designation process Proposed revision to Chapter 34, Section 2.9.3.B. - Established Individually Protected Properties: Following is a list of landmarks, buildings and structures outside the City’s ADC Districts, which are deemed by City Council to be of special historic, cultural, or architectural value. Street Number Street Name Tax Map Number Parcel Number […] 801 West Street Tax Map 31 Parcel Number 42 Discussion Based on the criteria found in Section 2.9.3.C.2. (analysis below), staff asks the BAR to recommend that City Council amend Chapter 34, Section 2.9.3.B by adding this parcel to the list of IPPs and to amend the Zoning Map to designate this parcel as an IPP, with the two-story framed dwelling being listed as a contributing structure within the GIS feature class. In June 2020, on behalf of the City, the 106 Group completed a Reconnaissance Architectural History Survey of 438 properties within the 10th & Page Neighborhood. As a result, the Virginia Department of Historic Resources State Review Board recommended the approximately 50-acre Tenth and Page Historic District be eligible for listing on the Virginia Landmarks Register (VLR) and the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP). Within that review, the property at 801 West Street was assessed as retaining excellent integrity of both location and setting. In the areas of design, materials, and workmanship the house was assessed as retaining good integrity and therefore recommended as potentially individually eligible for listing in the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP) under criterion A as one of the oldest extent houses within the (also eligible) 10 th & Page Neighborhood. [See property survey Attachment 1.] Link to the 2020 survey: Survey of 10th and Page Neighborhood 2020 In 1991, the first IPPs were established by Council applying an ordinance intended to preserve, protect, and enhance certain buildings, structures, and landmarks, together with their landscapes and settings, which are of special historic, cultural, or architectural significance, and which are Page 22 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – BAR review Jan 21, 2026 (1/13) 3 located outside the City’s ADC Districts. Charlottesville currently has eight ADC Districts, three Historic Conservation Districts, and 76 IPPs. Similar to the ADC district designation, the IPP designation is an overlay, as such the underlying zoning remains the same. It is only through this local [City] designation that a historic property comes under the purview of the Board of Architectural Review (BAR) and, with that, is regulated by the City Code relative to demolitions, alterations, and new construction. The BAR cannot deny or prohibit a zoned use. Also, BAR actions are appealable to City Council and then to the courts. That is, the BAR cannot, by its actions alone, prevent a demolition or prevent a new structure or alteration to an existing structure. Note: An IPP is a local designation, therefore evaluation of a proposed IPP should consider its importance to this city and this community. While it is helpful to refer to the NRHP criteria, neither eligibility nor listing should be considered requirements for local recognition. In fact, the relevant City Code section states that IPP designation is not determined by NRHP listing, but a way to encourage nomination of historic properties to the National Register of Historic Places and the Virginia Landmarks Register. Additionally, of the City’s 76 IPPs: • 48 are not listed on the NRHP • 28 are individually listed on the NRHP • 19 are contributing resources to a NRHP historic district (most, if not all, were IPPs before being included in a district) Page 23 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – BAR review Jan 21, 2026 (1/13) 4 Suggested Motions Recommend approval: Having reviewed the criteria for designation of Individually Protected Properties per City Code Chapter 34, Section 2.9.3., I move the BAR recommend that City Council approve the request to designate 801 West Street (Parcel 31-42) an Individually Protected Property. Or Recommend denial: Having reviewed the criteria for designation of Individually Protected Properties per City Code Chapter 34, Section 2.9.3., I move that for the following reasons the BAR recommend that City Council deny the petitions to designate 801 West Street (Parcel 31-42) an Individually Protected Property: … Standard of Review – IPP Designation [Ch. 34, Div. 2.9.3.C] C. Amendments to Individually Protected Property List 1. City Council may, by ordinance, from time to time, designate individual buildings, structures or landmarks as Individually Protected Properties; or remove individual buildings, structure or landmarks from the City’s list of Individually Protected Properties. Any such action will be undertaken following the rules and procedures applicable to the adoption of amendments to the City’s Development Code and official zoning map. 2. Prior to the adoption of any such ordinance, the City Council will consider the recommendations of the Planning Commission and the Board of Architectural Review (BAR) as to the proposed addition, removal or designation. The Planning Commission and BAR will address the following criteria in making their recommendations: a. The historic, architectural or cultural significance, if any, of a building, structure or site and whether it has been listed on the National Register of Historic Places or the Virginia Landmarks Register, or are eligible to be listed on such registers; Staff comment: Per the VCRIS entry [Attachment 1], this property is recommended potentially individually eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A as one of the oldest extant houses in the neighborhood. b. The association of the building, structure or site with an historic person or event or with a renowned architect or master craftsman; Staff comment: The property does not meet this standard. However, James Patterson was a well-known local builder and carpenter. c. The overall aesthetic quality of the building, structure or site and whether it is or would be an integral part of an existing ADC district; Staff comment: Per the VCRIS entry [Attachment 1], the property retains excellent integrity of both location and setting. In the areas of design, materials, and Page 24 of 82 801 West Street – IPP – BAR review Jan 21, 2026 (1/13) 5 workmanship the house retains good integrity. Additionally, the site as a whole retains excellent integrity of feeling and association. d. The age and condition of a building or structure; Staff comment: The structure’s date of construction is 1905 and is currently in good condition both internally and externally. e. Whether a building or structure is of old or distinctive design, texture and material; Staff comment: The structure is now 130 years old and retains both interior and exterior design elements that are representative of the late 19th-c. and early 20th-c. vernacular style and of the period in which it was fashioned [See photographs within Attachment 1]. Its overall integrity is mildly compromised by late 20th-c. replacement windows and stucco cladding. f. The degree to which the distinguishing character, qualities or materials of a building, structure or site have been retained; Staff comment: As noted within standard c above, 801 West Street retains its historic setting and association within the 10th and Page neighborhood. The presence of a window’s walk is a unique element of its construction. The notable changes to the structure and site in the last 100 years include: loss of the original one-story garage or outbuilding prior to 1963, the addition of exterior stucco, and replacement windows. g. Whether a building or structure, or any of its features, represents an infrequent or the first or last remaining example of a particular detail or type of architecture in the City; Staff comment: Staff does not believe this structure represents an infrequent design within the City as a whole. It is recommended however, that additional research be conducted to determine the sequence of development of 10th and Page in the early 1900’s. The property’s retention of historic setting, feeling and association do recommend consideration under this standard. h. Whether a building or structure is part of a geographically definable area within which there exists a significant concentration or continuity of buildings or structures that are linked by past events or, aesthetically, by plan or physical development, or within which there exist a number of buildings or structures separated geographically but linked by association or history. Staff comment: Per the VCRIS entry, the 10 th and Page Historic District is eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A in the areas of Ethnic Heritage, Community Planning and Development and Social History, and under Criterion C in the area of Architecture. This property would be a primary contributing resource of such a nominated district. It is the owner’s wish to designate 801 West Street as an Individually Protected Property in order to maintain this continuity. Page 25 of 82 Virginia Department of Historic Resources DHR ID: 104-5936 Architectural Survey Form Other DHR ID: No Data Property Information Property Names Name Explanation Name Function/Location House, 801 West Street Property Addresses Current - 801 West Street County/Independent City(s): Charlottesville (Ind. City) Incorporated Town(s): No Data Zip Code(s): 22903 Magisterial District(s): No Data Tax Parcel(s): No Data USGS Quad(s): CHARLOTTESVILLE EAST Property Evaluation Status Additional Property Information Architecture Setting: Urban Acreage: No Data Site Description: January 2020: This two-story house is located on the north side of West Street on the west corner of 8th Street NW and West Street. The walkway to the house is lined with box hedges, and there are large, mature trees around the house and along the rear of the property. This property consists of a house. Surveyor Assessment: January 2020: According to City of Charlottesville Property Records, this house was constructed in 1905 (City of Charlottesville GIS Viewer 2020). It first appears on the 1913 Sanborn Map with the same footprint it maintains through the Sanborn Maps to 1950 and into today (Sanborn Map Company 1913; Sanborn Map Company 1950; Google.com 2020). On the 1913 Sanborn Map, this house has a single-stall garage to the south east of the property (Sanborn Map Company 1913). This becomes a double-stall garage in the 1920 Sanborn Map and is maintained in the 1929 and 1950 Sanborn Maps (Sanborn Map Company 1920; Sanborn Map Company 1929; Sanborn Map Company 1950). This garage was demolished before 1963 (NETR 1963). Due to the multiple entranceways, this single- family house may now be a multi-family dwelling. This property retains excellent integrity of location and setting. This property retains good integrity of design, materials, and workmanship, mildly compromised by replacement windows. This property retains excellent integrity of feeling and association. Overall, this property retains good integrity. This property is recommended potentially individually eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A as one of the oldest extant houses in the neighborhood. Further research should be conducted to determine if this is one of the first properties to be built in the neighborhood. Additionally, it is located in the potential 10th & Page Historic District, which is recommended as potentially eligible for listing in the NRHP. Further study is recommended to determine if the 10th & Page Historic District is eligible for listing in the NRHP under Criterion A in the areas of Ethnic Heritage, Community Planning and Development, and Social History, and under Criterion C in the area of Architecture. This property includes one contributing primary resource. Surveyor Recommendation: Recommended Potentially Eligible Ownership Ownership Category Ownership Entity Private No Data Primary Resource Information Resource Category: Domestic Resource Type: Single Dwelling NR Resource Type: Building Date of Construction: 1905 Date Source: Local Records Historic Time Period: Reconstruction and Growth (1866 - 1916) Historic Context(s): Domestic Other ID Number: No Data May 22, 2020 Page: 1 of 3 Page 26 of 82 Virginia Department of Historic Resources DHR ID: 104-5936 Architectural Survey Form Other DHR ID: No Data Architectural Style: Vernacular Form: No Data Number of Stories: 2.0 Condition: Good Threats to Resource: None Known Architectural Description: January 2020: This two-story house is clad in stucco and has a hipped roof with pedimented gables covered in asphalt shingles with a wood- railed widow's walk in the center of the crossing. The front (southwest) facing facade features a one-story, full-width porch with a hipped roof supported by wood columns. The main entrance for this house is on the east end of the southwest facade. There is an interior concrete chimney near the center of the roof on the northwest roof slope at the ridgeline. There is a one-story, full-width, front-gable wing on the rear (northeast) elevation of the house. It has an open porch on the southeast elevation with turned wood columns and railings. This porch provides access to two entrances. Visible fenestration includes two-over-two, double-hung, wood windows, most with fixed wood shutters; and a single-leaf wood door with a transom and a metal and glass storm door. Exterior Components Component Component Type Material Material Treatment Chimneys Interior Central Concrete Uncoursed Foundation Solid/Continuous Unknown Stuccoed/Parged Structural System and Wood Frame Unknown Stuccoed Exterior Treatment Windows Double-hung Wood No Data Porch 1-Story Full-Width Wood Doric Roof Hipped w/Lower Cross Gables Asphalt No Data Secondary Resource Information Historic District Information Historic District Name: No Data Local Historic District Name: No Data Historic District Significance: No Data CRM Events Event Type: Survey:Phase I/Reconnaissance Project Review File Number: No Data Investigator: Erin Que Organization/Company: The 106 Group Ltd. Photographic Media: Digital Survey Date: 2/5/2020 Dhr Library Report Number: No Data Project Staff/Notes: Erin Que, Principal Investigator and Sr. Architectural Historian Holly Good, Architectural Historian Saleh Miller, Sr. Architectural Historian Project Bibliographic Information: City of Charlottesville GIS Viewer 2020 Property Record. Electronic document, http://gisweb.charlottesville.org/GisViewer/, accessed January 27, 2020. Hill Directory Co. 1931, 1940, 1950, 1959 Hill’s Charlottesville City Directory. Hill Directory Co., Inc., Publishers, Richmond, Virginia. National Environmental Title Research, LLC [NETR] 1963-2016 Historical Aerial Photograph, Charlottesville Independent City, Virginia. Electronic document, http://historicaerials.com/, accessed March 19, 2020. May 21, 2020 Page: 2 of 3 Page 27 of 82 Virginia Department of Historic Resources DHR ID: 104-5936 Architectural Survey Form Other DHR ID: No Data Neighborhood Development Services 2012-2016 The 10th and Page Historic Survey. On file at the City of Charlottesville Neighborhood Development Services, Charlottesville, Virginia. Sanborn Map Company 1907, 1913, 1920, 1929, 1950 Fire Insurance Map of Charlottesville, Virginia. Sanborn Map Company, New York, New York. United States Geological Survey [USGS] 1994-2019 Historical Aerial Photograph, Charlottesville Independent City, Virginia. Electronic document, accessed on Google Earth, February 20, 2020. Bibliographic Information Bibliography: No Data Property Notes: No Data May 21, 2020 Page: 3 of 3 Page 28 of 82 Page 29 of 82 - 801 West Street: (DHR #104-5936) Architectural Survey Form - Photographs February 2020 Front and side (west ) elevations - from West Street Front and side (east) elevations from West Street Page 30 of 82 - 801 West Street: (DHR #104-5936) Architectural Survey Form - Photographs February 2020 Front elevation - from West Street Rear and side (east) elevations from 8th Street, NW Page 31 of 82 BAR—Supplemental Documentation Alterations to East elevation, enclosed side porch. Page 32 of 82 801 West Street, East Elevation. Current enclosed side porch. Photograph date: January 2026. Courtesy C. Schwarz, BAR. Page 33 of 82 801 West Street, rear yard and site conditions. Photograph date: January 2026. Courtesy C. Schwarz, BAR. Page 34 of 82 801 West Street, rear yard and site conditions. Photograph date: January 2026. Courtesy C. Schwarz, BAR. Page 35 of 82 801 West Street, East Elevation. Original side porch. Photograph date: July 2019. Image retrieved from Google Earth. Page 36 of 82 801 West Street, East Elevation. Original side porch. Photograph date: July 2019. Image retrieved from Google Earth. Page 37 of 82 801 West Street, East Elevation. Side porch detail. Photograph date: June 2018. Image retrieved from Google Earth. Page 38 of 82 801 West Street, East Elevation. Side porch detail. Photograph dates: August 2008 (top); August 2012 (bottom). Images retrieved from Google Earth. Page 39 of 82 Interior details—801 West Street Page 40 of 82 Interior details—801 West Street Page 41 of 82 1 Werner, Jeffrey B From: Richard Hunt Sent: Friday, July 25, 2025 9:33 AM To: Werner, Jeffrey B Subject: Historic Designation - 801 West Street Attachments: BAR Offical Request 7-26-25.pdf Follow Up Flag: Follow up Flag Status: Flagged W ARNING: This email has originated from outside of the organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. To hel p o ec y p ivac M c o s ft O fice p even e au o ma ic downl ad this pic u f om the Inte net Mr. Werner - Please accept this email, with official letter attached, as my request for consideration of 801 West Street as an Individually Protected Property. Many thanks in advance, Richard Hunt ============== Kellie Brown, Director Charlottesville Planning Commission Neighborhood Development Services City of Charlottesville 605 East Main Street Charlottesville, VA 22902 Dear Ms. Brown – I am writing to request that, on my behalf, you initiate the necessary Zoning Text and Map Amendments for City Council to consider designation of 801 West Street (TMP 31-42) as an Individually Protected Property under City Code Chapter 34, Section 2.9.3. The City’s 2020 historical survey of the 10th and Page Neighborhood recommended the approximately 50-acre neighborhood be eligible for listing as a historic district on the National Register of Historic Places (NRHP), with 801 West Street identified as one of the 353 resources contributing to the district’s significance. Additionally, the survey identified the house as “one of the oldest extant houses in the neighborhood” and recommended it as potentially eligible for individual listing on the NRHP. (The house was constructed in 1905, likely by James T. Patterson, a local carpenter. Patterson and his family owned and occupied the home until the early 1940s.) Page 42 of 82 2 I realize that if the property is designated by Council, exterior alterations and new construction will require review and approval by the City’s Board of Architectural Review. This had been my grandmother’s home, and my family and I feel strongly about ma intaining the house and keeping its original features. As a Charlottesville native, I have great pride in the city, and I also have strong interest in keeping the 10th and Page neighborhood vital and welcoming for the community. Additionally, I plan to contact the Virginia Department of Historic Resources to seek NRHP designation for the house. Thank you for your consideration. Please let me know if any additional information is needed. Respectfully, Richard Hunt Page 43 of 82 Page 1 of 5 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE DEPARTMENT OF NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT SERVICES STAFF REPORT PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING APPLICATION FOR A CRITICAL SLOPE SPECIAL EXCEPTION APPLICATION NUMBER: PL-26-0037 DATE OF MEETING: May 12, 2026 Project Planner: Dannan O’Connell, AICP Date of Staff Report: April 17, 2026 Applicant: Scott Williams, Crescent Development Homes Current Property Owner: Ryan Farr and Lindsay Meck Application Information Property Street Address: 2010 Meadowbrook Road Tax Map & Parcel/Tax Status: 400006100 (real estate taxes paid current – Sec. 34-12) Total Project Area (Limits of Disturbance): 3,715 sq. ft. Total Area of Critical Slopes on Parcels: 11,098 sq. ft. | 34% Area of Proposed Critical Slope Disturbance: 1,155 sq. ft. | 3.5% of total site area | 10.4% of total critical slopes area on parcel Comprehensive Plan (General Land Use Plan): General Residential Current Zoning Classification: R-A Overlay District: None Applicant’s Request (Summary) Scott Williams (applicant), representing Ryan Farr and Lindsay Meck (property owners), wishes to improve the above-referenced property with a residential addition, terrace, paved path and retaining wall. The proposed improvements will impact critical slopes on-site as defined by Section 34-4.10.1.B.1. Per Section 34-4.10.1.D a request for a critical slope special exception must be heard by the Planning Commission before these improvements can be permitted. Improvements specific to areas where critical slopes would be impacted should the waiver be approved are shown on a Concept Plan (Attachment B) and include a retaining wall, residential addition, and associated land disturbance/grading. Critical slope areas are shown by the applicant in the Critical Slope Encroachment Exhibit (Attachment D). Page 44 of 82 PL-26-0037 2010 Meadowbrook Road Critical Slope Page 2 of 5 Existing critical slope areas located on this Property total approximately 11,100 square feet or 34 percent of the site. The applicable definition of “critical slope” is as follows: 1. A grade of 25% or greater; 2. A portion of the slope has a horizontal run of greater than 20 feet; 3. An area of 6,000 square feet or greater; and 4. A portion of the slope is within 200 feet of any waterway protected by the Standard and Design Manual or Chapter 10 of the Charlottesville Code of Ordinances, or shown on the map entitled “Properties Impacted by Critical Slopes”, maintained by the Neighborhood Development Services. (Sec. 34- 4.10.1.B.2) Based on the information presented within the application materials, Staff verifies that the area for which this waiver is sought meets all of the above-referenced components of the definition of “critical slope”. Vicinity Map Page 45 of 82 PL-26-0037 2010 Meadowbrook Road Critical Slope Page 3 of 5 Critical Slopes per the Zoning Ordinance Standard of Review Per Sec. 34-5.2.16, The Planning Commission will review the application and report its findings and recommendations to the City Council. City Council may then grant a Critical Slopes Special Exception when it finds that: a. Due to unusual size, topography, shape, location, or other unusual physical conditions, or existing development of a property, the requirements of 4.10.1. Critical Slopes would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the use, reuse or redevelopment of such property or would result in significant degradation of the site or adjacent properties; or b. The public benefit of the proposed encroachment outweighs the public benefit of protecting the area of slope proposed to be impacted. City Council will review an application for a Critical Slopes Special Exception according to the following criteria: a. Whether the amount of impact has been limited to the greatest extent possible; b. Whether sufficient mitigation has been proposed to limit the impact of the proposed encroachment; Page 46 of 82 PL-26-0037 2010 Meadowbrook Road Critical Slope Page 4 of 5 c. Whether steps have been taken to limit or prevent impacts to portions of the sloped area with environmental or scenic value or vulnerability to disturbance; and d. Whether the proposed project is consistent with the zoning district and Comprehensive Plan. Project Review and Analysis A concept plan of the proposed retaining wall and addition has been provided by the applicant (Attachment B), along with a survey of the existing property (Attachment A). Staff Analysis 34-5.2.16.D.1, Criteria A: Planning Department: The subject property is designated General Residential by the Comprehensive Plan’s Future Land Use Map. No additional dwelling units are proposed for the subject property. The existing use and proposed improvements are consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Staff finds that due to the topography of the area, zoning restrictions on maximum building width, and the presence of a sanitary sewer easement within the front yard (noted by the applicant in Attachment C), the requirements of Sec. 34-4.10.1 would unreasonably restrict the use of the subject property. The critical slope area to be disturbed is minimal and limited to the area to the rear of the existing residential structure. Utilities Department: City Utilities has no comment specific to this Special Exception. Staff Analysis 34-5.2.16.D.1, Criteria B: As the area in question is privately held, and no additional dwellings or public improvements are proposed, staff finds that Criteria B is not applicable to this request. Staff Recommendation Staff recommends the Planning Commission consider the following when making a recommendation to City Council: Purpose and Intent of the Critical Slope Provisions The purpose and intent of the critical slope provisions in Section 34-4.10.1 are to protect and maintain the environmental quality in the City by limiting development and disturbance of steeply sloped areas near waterways, adjacent properties, and environmentally sensitive areas and to protect those steeply sloped areas and waterways from the negative impacts of erosion and stormwater as well as preserve their ecological value. Page 47 of 82 PL-26-0037 2010 Meadowbrook Road Critical Slope Page 5 of 5 Recommended Conditions Staff has no recommendations for conditions related to this project and recommends approval of this Special Exception. Suggested Motions 1. “I move to recommend approval of the critical slope special exception for Tax Map and Parcel 400006100 as requested, with no reservations or conditions, based on a finding that [reference at least one]: • Due to unusual size, topography, shape, location, or other unusual physical conditions, or existing development of a property, the requirements of Section 34- 4.10.1 would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the use, reuse or redevelopment of such property or would result in significant degradation of the site or adjacent properties.” • The public benefit of the proposed encroachment outweighs the public benefit of protecting the area of slope proposed to be impacted.” 2. “I move to recommend denial of the critical slope special exception for Tax Map and Parcel 400006100.” Attachments A. Property Survey and Existing Conditions B. Landscape Concept and Grading Plan C. Constraints Exhibit D. Critical Slope Encroachment Area E. Project Narrative and Description Page 48 of 82 Page 49 of 82 FREEZERREF HB HB 16'-114" 6'-934" N 04816 110105 112 FFE 101.30 MECK FARR RESIDENCEJUNE 18, 2025Landscape Concept and Grading PlanWJLA PROPOSED CONTOUR, TYPEXISTING CONTOUR, TYP EX. PARKINGAREA REPLACEEX. STEPPING STONE PATHRENOVATEEXISTING PAVEDTERRACE4' TO 6 RETAININGWALL EDGE OF CRITICAL SLOPEEDGE OF DISTURBANCENOTE: PLANT DISTURBED SLOPE WITHNATIVE TREES, SHRUBS ANDGROUNDCOVERS INCLUDING: FERN,VIRGINIA SWEETSPIRE, ANDDOGWOOD 105101.00 101.00PROPERTY LINE Page 50 of 82 Mar 11 2026formwork 619A East High St Charlottesville, VA 22902 434 296 2223 Meck Farr Residence Exhibit C – Constraints on Use of Property N ft 0510 20 Exsiting sanitary sewer Utility easement Proposed C.I.P. retaining walls Increasing width of building exceeds district's maximum building width Parcel ID: 400006100 90'-4" Width of street-facing building facade Note: T opographic and physical survey date prepared by Robert Coleman Jr, December 6, 2024. Sewer location based on Robert Coleman Jr survey prepared Feb 25 2026. Critical Slopes Areas below existing structure not shown, see Diagram "B" Approximation of critical slope area Existing 1- Story Dwelling 2010 Meadowbrook Rd Proposed 1-story addition Page 51 of 82 Mar 11 2026formwork 619A East High St Charlottesville, VA 22902 434 296 2223 Meck Farr Residence Exhibit D – Critial Slope Encroachment Area N ft 0510 20 Region "A" 1-foot contour, typ. Region "B" Region "C"Note: Existing topography indicated this sheet; see Exhibit B for proposed final grading Region "A" Area of Proposed Disturbance Legend Region "B" Aggregate Critical Slope Area Approx. 11,098 sf Region "C" Area of Proposed Encroachment 1,155 square feet Line segment 4 feet in length; relative to 1-foot contours, indicates slope less than 25% Parcel ID: 400006100 .74 acres Boundary Line Note: Survey data based on topographic and physical survey prepared by Robert Coleman Jr, December 6, 2024. Meadowbrook Rd Existing 1- Story Dwelling 2010 Meadowbrook Rd Page 52 of 82 Mar 11 2026 Meck Farr Residence Web Form Responses Submitted in support of application for a Critical Slopes Special Exception for proposed construction at 2010 Meadowbrook Rd (Parcel ID: 400006100) 1/3 Project Narrative & Description of Proposed Development The Owners propose an addition of 580 gross square feet to an existing single-story wood-frame single- family residence. The new work would be added toward the rear of the parcel, disturbing, in places, existing grades in excess of 25%. Cast-in-place concrete retaining walls are proposed to manage grades in the area of the proposed disturbance, allowing access around the rear of the house and to prevent storm run-off from draining directly toward house. Further documentation of proposed conditions is provided via grading plan prepared by Mary Wolf, Landscape Architect (March 9, 2026 - attached as Exhibit B to this application). Existing Conditions See Sheet 2–"Existing Conditions", this application T otal Site Area . 74 acres 32,642 square feet Percentage of Area that is made up of Critical Slopes 34% Percentage of Critical Slope Area that will be disturbed 10.4% Any SUP or other Waivers being requested: Current use of the property Single-family detached dwelling Page 53 of 82 Mar 11 2026 Meck Farr Residence Existing Conditions Submitted in support of application for a Critical Slopes Special Exception for proposed construction at 2010 Meadowbrook Rd (Parcel ID: 400006100) 2/3 rear facade of existing structure rear facade of existing structure Existing Conditions The existing structure is set on a generally sloped site. The grades to the rear of the existing structure are quite steep (up to 1:1), which appear to have resulted from cutting into the slope to create the building pad and access around the rear of the house. The slopes are primarily planted with ferns and English ivy. See photography this sheet documenting terrain at the rear of the parcel. LOOKING WEST LOOKING WEST Further documentation of existing conditions is provided via topographic survey prepared by Robert Coleman, Jr. on December 6, 2024 (attached as Exhibit A to this application). LOOKING EAST LOOKING EAST Page 54 of 82 Mar 11 2026 Meck Farr Residence Satisfaction of Special Exception Review Criteria Submitted in support of application for a Critical Slopes Special Exception for proposed construction at 2010 Meadowbrook Rd (Parcel ID: 400006100) 3/3 Development Code Section 5.2.16.D – Criteria for Review and Design (Critical Slopes Special Exception) 5.2.16.D.1.a – Due to unusual size, topography, shape, location, or other unusual physical conditions, or existing development of a property, do the requirements of 4.10.1. Critical Slopes effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the use…of such property…? The Owners' use of the subject property is unreasonably restricted owing to constraints elsewhere on the property (see attached Exhibit C. Expansion of the existing structure, which would be uncontroversial on many other parcels, is constrained by: a) A sanitary sewer easement in close proximity to the north face of the building; b) Current Zoning Code’s maximum width constraints (Sec. 2.2.2.B.2.c, plus exception Sec. 2.10.1.E); c) Critical Slope Areas: the site is generally sloped. The building pad appears to have been created by increasing the slope immediately to the above and below the area graded for construction, such that the great majority of the "shoulder" slopes exceed 25%. Note that the net slope from the rear of the parcel to the street boundary, parallel to the slope, is roughly 18%. 5.2.16.D.2.a – Has the amount of impact been limited to the greatest extent possible? The Owners propose a modest addition of 580 gross square feet to an existing home of 2,115 gsf. The addition would contain a kitchen and an office, functions which would not be feasible in a smaller footprint. (See attached Exhibit D). 5.2.16.D.2.b – Has sufficient mitigation been proposed to limit the impact of the proposed encroachment? The Owners propose to construct cast-in-place concrete retaining walls to leave finished grade in unbuilt areas close to existing grade. 5.2.16.D.2.c – Have steps been taken to limit or prevent impacts to portions of the sloped area with environmental or scenic value or vulnerability to disturbance? See response to item above. 5.2.16.D.2.d – Is the proposed project consistent with the zoning district and Comprehensive Plan? The proposed project is consistent with the zoning district. Many comparable properties in the same district could accommodate a similarly scaled and configured addition without requiring special exemptions. The Comprehensive Plan's Future Land Use Map designates the subject parcel as "General Residential". Page 55 of 82 Page 1 of 5 CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE DEPARTMENT OF NEIGHBORHOOD DEVELOPMENT SERVICES STAFF REPORT PLANNING COMMISSION REGULAR MEETING APPLICATION FOR A CRITICAL SLOPE SPECIAL EXCEPTION APPLICATION NUMBER: PL-26-0044 DATE OF MEETING: May 12, 2026 Project Planner: Dannan O’Connell, AICP Date of Staff Report: April 20, 2026 Applicant: John Wilson, Timmons Group Current Property Owner: City of Charlottesville Application Information Property Street Address: 950 Melbourne Road, 0 Melbourne Road, 345 US 250 Bypass Tax Map & Parcel/Tax Status: 460002000, 460001200, 450001000 Total Project Area (Limits of Disturbance): 406,400 sq. ft. Total Area of Critical Slopes on Parcels: 887,829 sq. ft. | 13.1% Area of Proposed Critical Slope Disturbance: 14,645 sq. ft. | 3.56% of total site area | 1.65% of total critical slopes area on parcel Comprehensive Plan (General Land Use Plan): Open Spaces and Parks Current Zoning Classification: CV Overlay District: None Applicant’s Request (Summary) John Wilson (applicant), representing the Botanical Gardens of the Piedmont (developer), wishes to improve the above-referenced City properties with a public botanical garden complex. The proposed improvements will impact critical slopes on-site as defined by Section 34-4.10.1.B.1. Per Section 34-4.10.1.D a request for a critical slope special exception must be heard by the Planning Commission before these improvements can be permitted. Improvements specific to areas where critical slopes would be impacted should the waiver be approved are shown on a Critical Slope Exhibit (Attachment B) and include pedestrian pathways, a pedestrian footbridge, and associated land disturbance/grading for pathways and utilities. Critical slope areas are shown by the applicant in the Critical Slope Exhibit. Page 56 of 82 PL-26-0044 Botanical Garden of the Piedmont Critical Slope Page 2 of 5 Existing critical slope areas on these properties total approximately 887,829 square feet or 13 percent of the site. The applicable definition of “critical slope” is as follows: 1. A grade of 25% or greater; 2. A portion of the slope has a horizontal run of greater than 20 feet; 3. An area of 6,000 square feet or greater; and 4. A portion of the slope is within 200 feet of any waterway protected by the Standard and Design Manual or Chapter 10 of the Charlottesville Code of Ordinances, or shown on the map entitled “Properties Impacted by Critical Slopes”, maintained by the Neighborhood Development Services. (Sec. 34- 4.10.1.B.2) Based on the information presented within the application materials, Staff verifies that the area for which this waiver is sought meets all of the above-referenced components of the definition of “critical slope”. Vicinity Map Page 57 of 82 PL-26-0044 Botanical Garden of the Piedmont Critical Slope Page 3 of 5 Critical Slopes per the Zoning Ordinance Standard of Review Per Sec. 34-5.2.16, The Planning Commission will review the application and report its findings and recommendations to the City Council. City Council may then grant a Critical Slopes Special Exception when it finds that: a. Due to unusual size, topography, shape, location, or other unusual physical conditions, or existing development of a property, the requirements of 4.10.1. Critical Slopes would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the use, reuse or redevelopment of such property or would result in significant degradation of the site or adjacent properties; or b. The public benefit of the proposed encroachment outweighs the public benefit of protecting the area of slope proposed to be impacted. City Council will review an application for a Critical Slopes Special Exception according to the following criteria: a. Whether the amount of impact has been limited to the greatest extent possible; b. Whether sufficient mitigation has been proposed to limit the impact of the proposed encroachment; Page 58 of 82 PL-26-0044 Botanical Garden of the Piedmont Critical Slope Page 4 of 5 c. Whether steps have been taken to limit or prevent impacts to portions of the sloped area with environmental or scenic value or vulnerability to disturbance; and d. Whether the proposed project is consistent with the zoning district and Comprehensive Plan. Project Review and Analysis A concept plan of the proposed botanical garden complex and proposed critical slope impacts has been provided by the applicant (Attachment B), along with a narrative statement describing the proposed impacts and mitigation measures (Attachment A). Staff Analysis 34-5.2.16.D.1, Criteria A: Planning Department: The subject property is designated Open Spaces and Parks by the Comprehensive Plan’s Future Land Use Map. No additional dwelling units are proposed for the subject property. The existing use and proposed improvements are consistent with the Comprehensive Plan. Staff finds that due to the topography of the area, the requirements of Sec. 34-4.10.1 would unreasonably restrict the use of the subject property. The critical slope area to be disturbed is minimal and limited to areas necessary to provide ADA-compliant path connections to McIntire Park and utility and stormwater upgrades necessary for the Botanical Gardens complex. Staff Analysis 34-5.2.16.D.1, Criteria B: The subject property is located within McIntire Park and is currently undeveloped. The proposed development would establish a botanical garden as a public amenity, connected to existing trails within McIntire Park and existing pedestrian and bike infrastructure along Melbourne Road. Staff finds that the public benefit of the botanical gardens outweighs the public benefit of keeping the existing critical slopes undisturbed. Staff Recommendation Staff recommends the Planning Commission consider the following when making a recommendation to City Council: Purpose and Intent of the Critical Slope Provisions The purpose and intent of the critical slope provisions in Section 34-4.10.1 are to protect and maintain the environmental quality in the City by limiting development and disturbance of steeply sloped areas near waterways, adjacent properties, and environmentally sensitive areas and to protect those steeply sloped areas and waterways from the negative impacts of erosion and stormwater as well as preserve their ecological value. Page 59 of 82 PL-26-0044 Botanical Garden of the Piedmont Critical Slope Page 5 of 5 Recommended Conditions Staff has no recommendations for conditions related to this project and recommends approval of this Special Exception. Suggested Motions 1. “I move to recommend approval of the critical slope special exception for Tax Map and Parcel 460002000, 460001200, and 450001000 as requested, with no reservations or conditions, based on a finding that [reference at least one]: • Due to unusual size, topography, shape, location, or other unusual physical conditions, or existing development of a property, the requirements of Section 34- 4.10.1 would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the use, reuse or redevelopment of such property or would result in significant degradation of the site or adjacent properties.” • The public benefit of the proposed encroachment outweighs the public benefit of protecting the area of slope proposed to be impacted.” 2. “I move to recommend denial of the critical slope special exception for Tax Map and Parcel 460002000, 460001200, and 450001000.” Attachments A. Critical Slope Special Exception Narrative B. Critical Slope Exhibit Page 60 of 82 City of Charlottesville CRITICAL SLOPES WAIVER REQUEST SUPPLEMENT Please review city zoning ordinance section 34-1120(b) “Critical Slopes” and submit a completed Waiver Application Form, Critical Slopes Waiver Request Supplement and a Critical Slope Exhibit*. Applicant: Property Owner: Project Description: What are you proposing to do on this site? Existing Conditions: Total Site Area: Zoning (if applying for rezoning-please note existing and intended change): Percentage of Area that is made up of critical slopes - meets criteria set forth in Sec. 34-1120(b)(2) Definition of critical slope: greater than or equal to 25% slopes and a) a portion of the slope has a horizontal run of greater than twenty (20) feet and its area is six thousand (6,000) square feet or greater; and b) a portion of the slope is within two hundred (200) feet of any waterway: Total Critical Slope Area: Critical Slope Area Disturbed: ___ acres of the total critical slope area identified above will be disturbed, or ___ % of the total critical slope area. Proposed critical slope area to be disturbed is ___ % of the site area. *Critical Slope Exhibit: Survey indicating location and area of critical slopes and what portions of critical slopes are proposed to be disturbed. Survey should be prepared, sealed, signed and dated by a professional engineer or land surveyor licensed to practice within the Commonwealth of Virginia. Page 61 of 82 This application should be used to explain how the proposed project meets some or all of the requirements as described in Section 34-1120(6) “Modification or waiver.” The applicant is expected to address finding #1 and/or finding #2 and justify the finding by utilizing the “critical slope provisions” as a guide. Completing this application will help staff make their recommendation to the Planning Commission and City Council. City Council may grant a modification or waiver, upon making one or more of the following findings: Finding #1: The public benefits of allowing disturbance of critical slope outweigh the public benefits of the undisturbed slope( public benefits include, but are not limited to, stormwater and erosion control that maintains the stability of the property and/or the quality of adjacent or environmentally sensitive areas; groundwater recharge; reduced stormwater velocity; minimization of impervious surfaces; and stabilization of otherwise unstable slopes) ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Finding #2. Due to unusual size, topography, shape, location, or other unusual physical conditions, or existing development of a property, one (1) or more of these critical slopes provisions would effectively prohibit or unreasonably restrict the use, reuse or redevelopment of such property or would result in significant degradation of the site or adjacent properties. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Please address how Finding #1 and/or Finding #2 will be met utilizing the “critical slope provisions” noted below. 1. Erosion affecting the structural integrity of those features. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Page 62 of 82 ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ 2. Stormwater and erosion-related impacts on adjacent properties. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ 3. Stormwater and erosion-related impacts to environmentally sensitive areas such as streams and wetlands. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ 4. Increased stormwater velocity due to loss of vegetation. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ 5. Decreased groundwater recharge due to changes in site hydrology. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ 6. Loss of natural or topographic features that contribute substantially to the natural beauty and visual quality of the community such as loss of tree canopy, forested areas and wildlife habitat. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Please list all attachments that should be viewed as support to the above explanations. ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ ________________________________________________________________________ Page 63 of 82 □ □ □ /2 /3 /4 /5 /6 /4 □ /6 /7 /8 /9 □ /10 /11 /4 □ /12 /13 /3 /3 /13 /14 /7 /9 /8 □ /6 /10 /5 /10 /4 /15 /4 /9 /10 /16 □ □ □ □ □ /17 □ /18 /4 /19 /10 /7 /12 /20 □ /10 /11 /5 /10 /21 □ /10 /13 □ /10 /11 /4 □ /22 /4 /6 /10 □ /13 /12 □ /15 /20 □ /23 /9 /13 /14 /3 /4 /24 /8 /4 /21 □ /10 /11 /4 □ /7 /9/12 /13 /19 /15 /5 /10 /7 /13 /9 □ /17 □ /11 /5 /25 /4 □ /26 /19 /13 /25 /7 /24 /4 /24 □ /5 /22 /13 /25 /4 □ /7 /6 □ /22 /5 /6 /4 /24 □ /13 /9 □ /6 /13 /27 /9 /24 □ /4 /9 /8 /7 /9 /4 /4 /19 /7 /9 /8 □ /5 /9 /24 □ /6 /27 /19 /25 /4 /20 /7 /9 /8 □ /24 /5 /10 /5 □ /5 /9 /24 □ /10/11 /5 /10 □ /10 /11 /7 /6 □ /6 /7 /10 /4 □ /11 /5 /6 □ /22 /4 /4 /9 □ /18 /5 /19 /4 /12 /27 /3 /3 /20 □ /7 /9 /6 /26 /4 /18 /10 /4 /24 □ /5 /9 /24 □ /19 /4 /25 /7 /4 /14 /4 /24 □ /12 /13 /19 □ /10 /11 /4 □ /26 /27 /19 /26 /13 /6 /4 /6 □ /13 /12 □ /18 /13 /15 /26 /3 /4 /10 /7/9 /8 □ /10 /11 /7 /6 □ /5 /26 /26 /3 /7 /18 /5 /10 /7 /13 /9 □ /5 /18 /18 /27 /19 /5 /10 /4 /3 /20 /16 □ □ /17 □ /18 /4 /19 /10 /7 /12 /20 □ /10 /11 /5 /10 □ /5 /6 □ /10 /11 /4 □ /26 /19 /13 /26 /4 /19 /10 /20 □ /13 /14 /9 /4 /19 /28 /5 /26 /26 /3 /7 /18 /5 /9 /10 □ /17 □ /11 /5 /25 /4□ /9 /13 /10 □ /8 /7 /25 /4 /9 □ /12 /5 /3 /6 /4 □ /7 /9 /12 /13 /19 /15 /5 /10 /7 /13 /9 □ /10 /11 /5 /10 □ /15 /5 /20 □ /5 /12 /12 /4 /18 /10 □ /10 /11 /4 □ /24 /4 /18 /7 /6 /7 /13 /9 /6 □ /15 /5 /24 /4 □ /19 /4 /8 /5 /19 /24 /7 /9 /8 □ /10 /11 /7 /6 □ /24 /4 /25 /4 /3 /13/26 /15 /4 /9 /10 /16 □ □ /2 /19 /13 /26 /4 /19 /10 /20 □ /29 /14 /9 /4 /19 □ □ □ /30 /26 /26 /3 /7 /18 /5 /9 /10 □ □ □ /2 /3 /4 /5 /6 /4 □ /24 /13 □ /9 /13 /10 □ /14 /19 /7 /10 /4 □ /22 /4 /3 /13 /14 □ /10 /11 /7 /6 □ /3 /7 /9 /4 /16 □ □ /31 /13 /19 □ /13 /12 /12 /7 /18 /4 □ /27 /6/4 □ /13 /9 /3 /20 /16 □ /2 /3 /5 /9 /9 /4 /19 /32 /6 □ /33 /13 /15 /15 /4 /9 /10 /6 /28 /34 /4 /18 /13 /15 /15 /4 /9 /24 /5 /10 /7 /13 /9 /6 /35 □ /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36/36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36/36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36/36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36/36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 □ □ □ /37 /9 /8 /7 /9 /4 /4 /19 /32 /6 □ /33 /13 /15 /15 /4 /9 /10 /6 /28 /34 /4 /18 /13 /15 /15 /4 /9 /24 /5 /10 /7 /13 /9 /6 /35 □ □ /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36/36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36/36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36/36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36/36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 /36 □ □ □ Page 64 of 82 TM 46-1201BERGLAND, FRANKLYN &SUSAN MCCULLEY113 MELBOURNE PARK CIR EDB 2013 PG 2286 TM 61-193ACITY OFCHARLOTTESVILLE950 MELBOURNE RDDB 526 PG 238 TM 61-193CITY OFCHARLOTTESVILLE955 MELBOURNE RDDB 739 PG 735TM 61-192SBA GC TOWERSLLC901 MELBOURNE RDDB 4473 PG 710 TM 61-193CITY OFCHARLOTTESVILLE955 MELBOURNE RDDB 739 PG 735 TM 46-3CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE0 MELBOURNE RD TM 46-2CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE950 MELBOURNE RD TM 45-1CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE345 250 BYPASS N35°15'10"E 1730.63' S22°56'51"E 1067.50'C1 S55°08'11"W 138.52' C2 S22°27'57"E 338.38'S15°09'50"E 48.97'S1°54'08"W 181.72'S56°29'22"E 123.95'S33°27'22"E 33.00'S20°18'22"E 151.79'S36°01'22"E 72.91' N35°15'10"E 1730.63' S22°56'51"E 1067.50' JOHN W. WARNER PARKWAY RAILROAD PROPERTY(NS WASHINGTON DISTRICT)TM 45-1CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE345 250 BYPASS G G G G G G G GG G G G G OHPOHPOHPOHP OHPOHPOHPOHP OHP OHPOHP SANSANSANSANSANSANSANSAN OHPOHPOHPOHPOHP OHP OHP OHP OHP UGP OHPOHPOHPOHPOHP OHP OHP OHP OHP OHPOHPOHP SAN SAN SAN SAN OHPOHPOHPOHPOHPOHP OHP OHP OHP WWWWWWWWWWWW GG 5084385.50TSP G G G G G G G G G G G GGGGGGGGGGG G S S FIELD SURVEY LIMITS 04-05-2024 FIELD SURVEY LIMITS 04-05-2024 FIELD SURVEY LIMITS 04-05-2024 FIELD SURVEY LIMITS 04-05-2024 XXXXXXX XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX X X XX X XXXXXXXXXXXX XXXXXXX XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXXX X X X XXXXXXXXXXXXXOHP OHPOHPOHPW18" (GIS) GGGGGGGG SAN BIRD HOUSEBIRD HOUSE(2) WWWWWWW8" (GIS) MELBOURNE PK CIR JOHN W. WARNER PARKWAYVARIABLE WIDTH ROWSTATE ROUTE #631 SAN SANOHPOHP MELBOURNE ROAD2" GALVANIZED(GIS) (ABANDONED) UGP T E UGP E OHPOHP OHP E 2" MUNICIPEX (GIS)TO BE ABANDONED2" (GIS) 360360360360360360360360360360360360360360 365365 365365365365365365365365365 365365365365365365365365365365 370370 370370370370370370370370370370 370370370 370370 375 375375 375375375375375375375375375 375375375375375 380 380380 380380380380380380380380380 380 380380 385385 385 385385385385385385385385385 385 390390390390 390390390390390390 390 395395395 395395395395395395395 395 400400 400400400400400400 400405405 405405 405410410 410415415415 420425430 360360365365 365365365365 370370 370370 370370370370 375375375375 375375 375375 375375 380380380380 380380 380380 380 380380380 380 380 380380 385385385385 385385 385 385 385 385385 385385 385 385 385 390390390390 390390 390 390 390 390390 390390 390 390 390 395395395395 395395 395 395 395 395395 395395 395395 395 400400400400400 400 400 400 400 400400 400400 400 405405 405 405405405405405 405 405 405405 405405 410 410410410410 410 410 410410 410410 410410 410 415415 415 415415 415415 415 415 415415415415 415415 415415 415415415415 420420 420420420420 420420420420 G G G G 2" MUNICIPEX (GIS)TO BE ABANDONED WWWW D D 380 380385 385 390 395 395385 385380380 375375 370 375 395 400 405 400 400 370 370370 375 375 375 375 370 380 380 380 380380 385 385 385 390 390 385385 385385 390 390 390 395400 390 385 385 380380 385 400 395 375 375 373367 380 370371 365 370 3:13:13:1392393 390 390 395 395 400400391 391392 392393 393394 394 396 396 397 397 398 398399399401402403404 395400392393394396397398399390395387388389391392393394396 400 398399 401402 395394396397 405404406407390395400391392393394396397398399401402403 395392393394396 W W W WW W WW WW W WW W WWWWWW SAN W G TERRACE SHED EP DOORSELEV @ 379.96' DOORSELEV @ 379.96' DOORELEV @ +379.96' DOORELEV @ +384.98'DOORELEV @ +384.98' LEGENDLIMITS OF DISTURBANCEEXISTING CRITICAL SLOPESPROPOSED CRITICAL SLOPESDISTURBANCE (±0.48 ACRES) CRITICAL SLOPESEXHIBITEX-1 C 2024, TIMMONS GROUPsheet number sheet title issue dateproject phaseproject addressclientproject name revisions BOTANICAL GARDEN OF THE PIEDMONT950 MELBOURNE RD, CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA 22901 project teamproject managerprincipal in chargeCRAIG KOTARSKIJOHN WILSONBROCK WAREKIM ROESER BOTANICAL GARDENOF THE PIEDMONT MARCH 6, 2026100% CONSTRUCTIONDOCUMENTS - PHASE 0 CIVIL ENGINEER, GEOTECH, & ENVIRONMENTALTimmons Group608 Preston Ave, Suite 200, Charlottesville, VA 22903T (434) 295 5624 LANDSCAPE ARCHITECT OF RECORDWaterstreet Studio802 East Jefferson Street, Suite 3, Charlottesville, VA 22902T (434) 295 8177 IRRIGATION DESIGNERAqueous1 Dundee Park Drive, Suite 10, Andover, MA 01810T (978) 470 1695SOILS DESIGNERTellus Consulting564 Rainbow Acres Lane, Radiant, VA 22732T (434) 981 2885WATER FEATURE CONSULTANTSCMS Collaborative404 Little River Way, Sacramento, CA 95831T (831) 425 3743MEP ENGINEERInversity Consulting Engineers250 Wylderose Commons, Suite 102, Midlothian, VA 23113T (804) 977 0403STRUCTURAL ENGINEERDunbar1025 Boulders Parkway, Suite 310, Richmond, VA 23225T (804) 323 0656LIGHTING DESIGNERLAM PARTNERS3307 M Street NW, Suite 301, Washington, DC 20007T (703) 829 0548 consultantsENVIRONMENTAL GRAPHICSDesign by Hyphen240 North Madison Street, Staunton, VA 24401T (540) 830 8006 SCALE 1"=50'100'50'0 NAD 83 Page 65 of 82 Environmental Regulations and Policy Review Project Update May 12, 2026 Page 66 of 82 Agenda • Review project objectives and potential outcomes • Update on project progress • Highlighting overlap with/implementation of the City's Climate Program • Next steps Page 67 of 82 Project Objectives • Objectives • Balance community and Comprehensive Plan priorities of housing/by-right density with protecting the natural and built environments • Increase community resilience, including to increased flooding and extreme heat risks • Ensure alignment between regulations across topics (e.g., stormwater managementand flood management) • Use an equitable framework for prioritization and implementation • Potential project outcomes • City Code updates, including the Development Code • Updated policies for the 5-year Comprehensive Plan review • Updates to City programs and policies • Coordination on related projects and plans Page 68 of 82 Summary of Potential Project Outcomes Topic Potential Outcomes Stormwater Management • Updates to stormwater management regulations that improve the feasibility of infill development while also increasing the use of onsite measures for water quality (e.g. rain barrels, green roofs) • Data to support future infrastructure needs and a long-range Stormwater Capital Improvement Plan Flood Management • Coordination on Community Flood Preparedness Fund grant for a more robust flood management program • Updated regulations and standards for development in the floodplain • Participation in the Community Rating System Tree Canopy and Preservation • Updated landscaping requirements such as tree canopy, street trees, and tree preservation bonus • Updated guidance for tree planting and health • Recommendations to increase tree canopy (including street trees) in coordination with the Urban Forest Management Plan Stream Buffers • Updates to the Water Protection Ordinance requirements • Additional or revised incentives and voluntary measures to protect existing trees and vegetation along waterways and to plant additional trees and vegetation Critical Slopes • Updated review criteria for critical slopes special exceptions • More clear guidance in the Comprehensive Plan, which could inform updates to critical slopes regulations Energy Efficiency • High Performance Building Standards / update to the 2008 Green Building Policy • High Performance Buildings best practices and potential regulations/incentives for private sector • Community Electric vehicle (EV) charging plan • Public right of way policy for EV charging Page 69 of 82 Project Roadmap As staff identifies standalone projects by topic, staff anticipates transitioning the Environmental Review into these individual projects, with continued collaboration across project teams. Page 70 of 82 City Project Partners Departments collaborating on this project include: • Neighborhood Development Services • Office of Sustainability • Public Works / Engineering • Utilities • Parks & Recreation • Additional departments involved at key points Eco Fair Spring Festival Photo Credit: Botanical Garden of the Piedmont Page 71 of 82 Charlottesville’s Community Climate Action Plan Adopted in 2023 as an amendment to the City’s Comprehensive Plan, the Climate Action Plan is a strategic roadmap for helping guide action towards our emissions reduction targets. Emissions Reduction Goals 2030: 45% Reduction 2050: Carbon Neutrality Strategies Enduring Designed to get us to 2030 goal and position us to meet 2050 goal Key Actions Dynamic Designed to be completed, crossed off, with new actions being added over time Guiding Principles: effectiveness, affordability, equity, and inclusivity Key Actions support the strategies, which are grouped by sector: • Community Emissions • Buildings & Energy • Transportation • Waste • Nature-based Solutions • Funding & Financing • Municipal Emissions • Buildings & Energy • Streetlights & Traffic Signals • Transportation & Mobile Assets Page 72 of 82 Implementing the Climate Action Plan • Each Fiscal Year, the Climate Program develops a cross- departmental workplan to support implementation of the Climate Action Plan. • The workplan is organized by outcome area: • Resilience Building • Municipal Energy Efficiency & Use Reduction • Community Energy Efficiency & Use Reduction • Municipal Transportation Electrification • Community Transportation Electrification • Community Transportation Improvement • Nature Based Solutions • Community Waste Reduction • Other Programmatic Activities • Workplan activities can include program delivery, projects, or policy improvements 2011 2023 2030 2050 0 100,000 200,000 300,000 400,000 500,000 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050 Emissions (MT CO2e) Charlottesville Community-wide GHG Emissions (Total by Year) Page 73 of 82 Reducing Emissions AND Adapting to Impacts Climate Action Plan Adaptation & Resilience Plan Page 74 of 82 Resilient Together: Developing a Climate Adaptation & Resilience Plan Resilient together is a joint planning and community engagement process through which the City, UVA, and Albemarle County have worked in parallel to develop Climate Adaptation and Resilience Plans for each entity. The City’s Plan is currently in the first round of internal review. 18 Strategy Areas: • Biodiversity • Buildings • Communications & Information • Community Training & Partnerships • Emergency Alerts • Emergency Response Capacity • Electric Energy Infrastructure • Food System • Hazard Monitoring • Resilience Hubs • Small Business Resilience • State Support for Local Resilience • Stream Corridors & Floodplains • Transportation • Urban Heat Islands • Urban Stormwater • Water Supply & Conservation • Wildfire Preparedness Page 75 of 82 Resilient Together: Example of Project Overlap Urban Stormwater section of Resilient Together: Urban stormwater management facilities and infrastructure that can withstand projections for severe precipitation and population growth, prioritizing nature-based solutions Action: • Through the Environmental Review Project, update relevant sections of code to facilitate the implementation of best practices for green stormwater infrastructure. In particular, develop standards and policy for on-site and site- adjacent green stormwater infrastructure to help address the tension between stormwater regulations and desire for increased density on small parcels. Credit: Virginia Department of Wildlife Resources Page 76 of 82 Project Progress Request for Proposals (RFP) for Stormwater Management regulations project Lead departments: Public Works and Neighborhood Development Services • Stormwater management regulations update RFP: anticipated early May release with mid-June closing • Review committee will review RFP's and select a consultant this summer; project will kick off late summer/early fall • Project purpose: increasing the feasibility of smaller infill developments (land disturbance under 10,000 sq ft), balancing Comp Plan goals of density/housing choice with a protected and restored natural environment • Project scope includes: • Develop updates to the City's stormwater management requirements • Develop associated technical reports and toolkits • Significant community engagement and information-sharing Rainwater harvesting Credit: VA Soil and Water Conservation Districts Page 77 of 82 Project Progress Urban Forest Management Plan Lead departments: Parks & Rec and Office of Sustainability • Community engagement in progress • Launched Connect Charlottesville UFMP page • Tabling at EcoFair 4/18 and Rivanna RiverFest 5/09 • Survey and activity open through 5/24 • After this round of engagement, the team will review community input and develop the draft UFMP, which will be shared for additional community feedback prior to finalizing the plan • Tree Commission and Parks & Rec shared the 2025 State of the Forest Report at 4/20 Council meeting • Supports UFMP and Environmental Review Project • NDS and Parks collaborating on improving tree preservation review and enforcement Page 78 of 82 Project Progress Community Flood Preparedness Fund (CFPF) Grant Project Lead department: Office of Sustainability • Staff completed the scope of work for the CFPF grant project to build a more robust and future-forward Flood Management Program, and the procurement process has started Water Protection Ordinance (WPO) Stream Buffers and Critical Slopes Lead department(s): Needs to be determined • Reviewed previous critical slopes special exception requests • Evaluating potential impact of changing regulations for WPO buffers and critical slopes • Will compare results from the buildout analysis once that data is available, in part to inform potential prioritization of areas and/or features to protect • Potential for consultant support once determine remaining funds after selecting stormwater RFP consultant Page 79 of 82 Project Progress High Performance Buildings Lead department: Office of Sustainability • Council approved High Performance Buildings resolution on 4/06 • Updated High Performance Building Standards for City buildings • Resources in progress to encourage best practices in the private sector • Potential for additional incentives for private sector; further study is needed Electric Vehicle (EV) Charging Lead department: Office of Sustainability • Community EV Charging Study completed • Next steps being determined; recommendations include a residential curbside charging ordinance and options for City fleet vehicle charging Page 80 of 82 Next Steps Short-term next steps: • Review RFPs and select consultant for the stormwater management regulations project • Select consultant for CFPF grant project: Flood Management Program updates • Continued UFMP engagement • High Performance Buildings best practices for the private sector Additional next steps: • Identify project leads and funding resources to scope the remaining topic areas • Focused on WPO buffers/critical slopes, may also include energy efficiency • Transition the Environmental Review Project into multiple standalone projects by topic with continued coordination across teams • Likely to include individual Connect project pages (see UFMP as example) QR Code for Urban Forest Management Plan Connect Page: Survey Open through May 24 Page 81 of 82 Thank You! Page 82 of 82

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.