RecordWell Data

20200519 May 19, 2020 BZA Minutes

Spotsylvania County · Spotsylvania County · meeting of May 19, 2020 · Minutes

Open the original document More from Spotsylvania County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING IN THE MATTER OF: Spotsylvania Board of Zoning Appeals A 19-0003 Michael O'Bier, Zach Stevens, Sean Fogarty and David Hammond A 20-0001 Michael O'Bier, Brenda O'Bier, Zach Stevens, Sean Fogarty, David Hammond, Joanne Booth, Ernest Booth and Robert Leith ____________________________________________________________ May 19, 2020 ____________________________________________________________ Cherryl Maddox Reporting 540-372-6874 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 2 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING COUNTY OF SPOTSYLVANIA BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS PUBLIC HEARING Case Number: A19-0003, Michael O'Bier, Zach Stevens, Sean Fogarty and David Hammond A20-0001, Michael O'Bier, Brenda O'Bier, Zach Stevens, Sean Fogarty, David Hammond, Joanne Booth, Ernest Booth and Robert Leith A meeting of the Spotsylvania County Board of Zoning Appeals was held at the Richard E. Holbert Building, Board of Supervisors Meeting Room, 9104 Courthouse Road, Spotsylvania, Virginia, on Tuesday, May 19, 2020, at 7:30 p.m., before Cherryl J. Maddox, Registered Professional Reporter and Notary Public in and for the Commonwealth of Virginia. CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING 540-372-6874 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 3 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MEMBERS PRESENT: Mr. Peter R. Kolakowski, Chairman, Lee Hill District Mr. George M. Allen, Vice-Chairman, Berkeley District Mr. Ronnie W. Hilldrup, Secretary, Salem District Mr. Mark Stepongzi, Chancellor District Mr. Larry Bramlette, Courtland District Ms. Lynn Smith, Battlefield District Ms. Nancy Biscoe, Livingston District STAFF PRESENT: Ms. Kimberly Pomatto, Zoning Administrator 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 4 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING P-R-O-C-E-E-D-I-N-G-S MR. KOLAKOWSKI: I would like to call toorder the May 19 meeting of the Spotsylvania CountyBoard of Zoning Appeals. Welcome to everybody herethis evening.I believe this is the first time that the BZA isbeing televised, so, we hope, we welcome the televisionaudience, the cable audience.My name is Peter Kolakowski, I'm Chairman of theBoard, representing Lee Hill District. And on my left,which would be your right, is Ms. Lynn Smith,Battlefield District. Mr. Larry Bramlette, from,representing Courtland District. Mr. George Allen,representing Berkley District. Mr. Ronnie Hilldrup,immediately to my right, your left, Salem District.Ms. Nancy Biscoe, Livingston District. And last andcertainly not least, Mr. Mark Stepongzi, representingChancellor District.So, with that, I would like to go to ourannouncements. I want to talk first about our meetingtonight. As you notice, we are wearing masks, and thosethat wish to speak may either remove the mask or be sure 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 5 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING to speak clearly and loudly. And just want to remindthe Board members that if you wish to speak, please putyour microphones on and, of course, take them off whenyou are done. We would like to make sure that the courtreporter and the Board hears everybody's comments.Cleaning supplies are available at the podium.Please feel free to wipe down the area, as you wish.And I thank everybody for practicing social distancing.Before we talk about the procedures for our publichearings tonight, we do have our third item on theagenda, which is an approval of our BZA transcripts fromtwo previous meetings. You received in your packet oneof the two. The first one from case V19-0002. Youreceived those last month, and we delayed it becauseMr. Hilldrup was not present at the last meeting, but hewas at that meeting that had that hearing. And we didhave one correction to those minutes, and that was that,at that time, we had Livingston District's position wasvacant. It had yet to be filled. And then also, weneeded to change the Zoning Administrator's title fromActing to the Full Zoning Administrator. So we havethose changes to those minutes.The minutes that you have, and the transcript that 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 6 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING you had provided to you, again, we need to, on page two,drop the term Acting for the Zoning Administrator, andthen also on page three forward, I would like to have myname spelled correctly in the minutes. It has itcorrectly on page two and being present, but the nameforward is missing a K in the minutes.Are there any other changes to the transcripts?MR. BRAMLETTE: Mr. Chairman, I have oneother change.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay, Mr. Bramlette.MR. BRAMLETTE: On page 99, line five, thewords, "There is no second," needs to be putbetween my name, semicolon, and the word and. Andit would make more sense. There is no second and,Mr. Chairman, by the rules of the Board.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay.MR. BRAMLETTE: I have no other comment.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Any other corrections to ourtranscripts? NO RESPONSE FROM THE BOARDMR. KOLAKOWSKI: Entertain a motion for bothsets of minutes be approved.MR. BRAMLETTE: Mr. Chairman, I motion that 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 7 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING we accept the minutes as changed for thatparticular transcript and meetings.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Second?MR. HILLDRUP: Second.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Hilldrup seconded. Anyother discussion?NO RESPONSE FROM THE BOARD MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Hearing none, all those infavor, say aye.ALL ANSWER IN THE AFFIRMATIVE MR. KOLAKOWSKI: I see none opposed. Thankyou.As you know, we are here tonight for two publichearings. I would like to take a few moments here todescribe our process, which is somewhat our normalprocess for public hearings, but because we have askedfor comments in writing, those need to be accounted foralso so.So, please, members of the Board, when we presentto you what I see as our proceedings tonight, make surethat we are on board and then we will proceed. We willconduct two separate public hearings. We will do themsequentially. We will conduct the first public hearing 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 8 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING for case A19-0003. We will ask the Zoning Administratorto provide the information for the case, and make thenecessary comments from her. And then we will ask theappellant to present their comments, and then we willask SPower to present their comments. The County'sAttorney's Office will then have an opportunity topresent their information. And then we will open thehearing for verbal public comment. And we will ask forthose that are for, to speak first, and those that areagainst, to speak second. And then we will ask for thewritten comments to be read into the record by thestaff. And it is my understanding, we have a number ofthose that will probably cover both cases, and so wewill hear those.We will close the first public hearing for thecase and then we will follow our process to accept amotion and the written materials that we have previouslyreceived, as well as we received today. And then wewill consider any kind of motion for any kind of action.And then, of course, proceed from there.We will follow the same process for the secondpublic hearing after we conclude the actions, as well asthe public hearing in the first case. I would ask in 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 9 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING the second presentation that we limit duplication ofcomments that were made from the first public hearingand just provide information or highlight the additionalinformation that is necessary for consideration.I would like to remind those people that speakthat please present your name, give your address, givethe case number, and speak clearly for the courtreporter's minutes. The people that are providing thecomments to the case, you know, we like to keep those towithin ten minutes. We kind of give and take because wewant to have the information, and we ask all the otherpeople to speak at least, hold their comments to threeminutes, and try to avoid repetitive comments. Also,please be reminded that the BZA members may askquestions of any of the speakers.With that, does anybody have, on the Board, haveany questions or comments about the process for tonight? NO RESPONSE FROM THE BOARD MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay, thank you for yourparticipation. So, we will open the public hearingfor case A19-0003, and Ms. Pomatto would you pleasepresent the case to us.MS. POMATTO: Thank you, Mr. Chairman, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 10 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Members of the Board.Tonight our first case is Appeal Case NumberA19-0003. The appellants are Michael O'Bier, ZachStevens, Sean Fogarty and David Hammond, all representedby Clark Leming. The property owner is H.A. Highlander,LLC, which is a company of SPower.The first case is an appeal to the ZoningAdministrator's determination related to the enforcementof the conditions governing Special Use PermitSUP18-0001, for the SPower solar energy facility. Theappeal specifically questions whether violations existwithin the 100-foot setback and buffer by allowing theplacement of storm water control basins and roads withinthe buffer and setback, as identified on the approvedPhase 1 site plan for the projects.A separate appeal, case A20-0001, is also on youragenda tonight, which challenges the ZoningAdministrator's determination letter, dated February 7,2020, related to the enforcement of the 100-foot setbackand buffer.To begin, I will provide a brief background of theproject. The SPower solar energy facility includes6,350 acres with three separate project areas, Sites A, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 11 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING B, and C. The Board of Supervisors approved the threeSUP's in April of 2019, for each project area, and eachwere approved with conditions, which for the most part,are identical for each project area.The approved Phase 1 site plan, which is subjectof the appeal before you tonight, includes 1,960 acres,including the projects entrance on Orange Plank Road,solar rays, required landscaping and supporting entrancestructure, including access roads and storm waterfacilities.During the special use permit process, thestandards related to setbacks, buffers and landscaping,changed a number of times and there were severaldifferent issues that these setbacks and buffers wereintended to address.Early concerns raised by the public had to do withthe heat island effect, which is essentially an increasein the ambient temperature due to development andchanges of land use. Other drivers for setbacks andbuffers revolved around the visual impact and the noisefrom the construction. The heat island effect was discussed throughoutthe process, but ultimately the county's consultants 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 12 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING agreed with SPower's experts that there was no heatisland effect, but perhaps the short lived temperatureincrease of one to two degrees coming from the facility.So, the discussions changed again regarding the setbacksand buffers and what was needed. And then the issue wasfinally laid to rest when the experts agreed and thecounty experts agreed, that solar facilities withrevegetation under the panels have no heat increases.SPower site is designed to be revegetated underthe panels and therefore the heat impacts became anonissue. All that was left at that point was how toaddress the visual impacts and noise.Initially, what was identified was a 50-footsetback and buffer around the entire perimeter of theproject. And this is what you see on the approved GDPis the 50-foot setback and buffer. However as the SUPprocess neared completion, rather than revising the GDP,the project was approved with conditions specifyingseveral different types of setbacks for a number ofdifferent items, including solar panels, girders,cemeteries, mulch piles, timber waste burning. Theoriginal 50-foot setback and buffer identified on theGDP was replaced by these conditions. And by the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 13 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING adoption of a separate plan referenced in the conditionas Exhibit H, Buffer Area Plan. In order to determinewhat setbacks and buffers are required, the conditionsand the Exhibit H Buffer Area Plan must be reviewedtogether.So, now that you have heard the background of howwe got here and the changes that occurred and theunderstanding that one must rely on both the conditionlanguage and the Exhibit H Buffer Area Plan together, inorder to accurately enforce the setback and bufferrequirements, it's probably not hard to understand whythere may be some confusion.I want to take this opportunity to clarify earlycommunications between myself and the SPower projectteam, which the appellants have highlighted in theirapplication. Early in the site plan review process, Istated that the storm water facilities would not bepermitted within the 100-foot buffer. These commentswere questioned by SPower, which led me to complete amore thorough analysis. After a comprehensive review ofthe conditions and Exhibit H, and the specificexceptions and allowances that are included in theconditions, I found that the Phase 1 site plan was in 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 14 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING compliance. And I will provide a more detailedexplanation of how I got to that point shortly.The role of the Zoning Administrator is tointerpret and administer and enforce the zoningordinance. If the language is unclear or conflicts,it's the Zoning Administrator's responsibility tointerpret the language. Any person aggrieved by theZoning Administrator's decision may appeal that decisionto the Board of Zoning Appeals. It is not the ZoningAdministrator's role to determine if the appellant hasstanding. That's the responsibility of the BZA.In the packets of materials provided to you by theappellants' counsel, as well as the county, you willfind references to the Friends of the Rappahannock case,which established a person aggrieved must meet a twopart test.First, they must be in close proximity to thechallenged element, and the second test is they mustdemonstrate a harm, which is greater than that of thegeneral public.For this appeal case, only two of the fourappellants are adjacent to the project, Mr. O'Bier andMr. Stevens. The issue that has been challenged is 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 15 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING whether the visual screening requirements have been met.However, the specific harm has not been identified forany of the appellants in either of the cases you willhear tonight.Here is a proximity map which outlines the Phase 1site plan area only. This is the Phase 1 site plan thatis subject to the appeal. And we have identified theproperties of the appellants and you can see those areidentified with the four blue dots.At this point, I will take you through both theconditions and the Exhibit H Buffer Area Plan. As Ihave said, you can't have one without the other in orderto determine the appropriate setbacks, the buffers, andwhat may or may not be located within each.This is the Exhibit H Buffer Area Plan. This planestablished five distinct setbacks and I will zoom intothe legend so that you can see for yourself. As you cansee here, each setback identifies what type of screeningor what type of buffer will be provided.First, there is a 100-foot minimum setback withproposed berms with plantings, and this plan sheetprovides a detail of that berm and planting. Second,there is a 100-foot minimum setback with proposed 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 16 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING revegetation with planting. Again, a detail is providedon this plan sleet. 100-foot minimum setback withpreserved vegetation. A 100-foot minimum setbackallowing vegetation to grow back naturally. And then a425-foot solar equipment setback from existing houses.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Ms. Pomatto, it is numbertwo of your handout that you provided to us?MS. POMATTO: Yes, sir.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay. Just want to makesure I am with the program.MS. POMATTO: Okay.So, here you can see how these setbacks played outon this plan. The red was where the berm with plantingswas required. The green was to allow for clearing, butto allow the area to grow back naturally. The purple,you can see, follows along with wetland and RPA areas.The yellow was to allow for clearing, but also had aplanting requirement, as well.Exhibit H, like I said, provided a berm detail.Now, this detail is not to scale, but you can see theimage of the person standing on the ground right at theproperty line. You see the tree planting, you see theberm. From this detail, it is clear that the view for 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 17 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING that person is looking into the side of an 8-foot berm.Here I have zoomed into Exhibit H, so you can seethe red line, which calls for the 8-foot planting, the8-foot berm with planting. This is the buffer that isrequired between the project and the two appellants, Mr.O'Bier and Mr. Stevens' properties. They are locatedright here in this corner.The appellants argue that this plan does not showthe access roads or storm water facilities. And itdoesn't. But the simple response to that is the purposeof this Exhibit H, was not to identify theinfrastructure. The purpose was to establish setbacksand buffers, which is exactly what it does.So, now we will move on to the conditions, and wewill start with condition E-8. No tree shall be removedfrom any 100-foot setback area or 100-foot preservebuffer, as shown on Exhibit H, except for the removal ofnonnative species, which is anything not included in thenative species list in the County's Design StandardsManual; hand clearing for safety or the removal of deador dying trees; or any clearing necessary foringress/egress or infrastructure connectivity. Thiscondition establishes a clear distinction between the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 18 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING 100-foot setback area, and the 100-foot preservedbuffer. However, the allowances for clearing apply toboth. Clearing is allowed to remove nonnative species,dead or dying trees, or any clearing necessary foringress/egress or infrastructure connectivity.The appellants challenge the language here, thatingress/egress means only one point of access and not anaccess road. They also challenge that infrastructureconnectivity does not include roads or storm watermanagement facilities. My response to that is to pointright back to the Spotsylvania County Code, whichconsistently identifies access roads and storm watermanagement as required infrastructure for alldevelopment. This condition was crafted tointentionally allow for exceptions to accommodate thoserequired infrastructure.Condition E-6 is as follows: The setbackrequirements do not apply to fencing, berms,landscaping, plantings, access roads, bridges, oraboveground utility poles. Condition E-6 clearly allowsfor access roads within the setback, which goes hand inhand with the language we just reviewed in conditionE-8, which allows for the clearing to occur. Berms are 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 19 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING also exempt from the setback requirements. In order toconstruct a storm water basin, a berm is a necessarycomponent.Another important takeaway here is that while thiscondition specifically calls out fencing, berms,landscaping, planting, access roads, bridges andaboveground utility poles within the 100-foot setback,they are not individually listed under condition E-8,related to the allowed clearing, except under the terminfrastructure connectivity.Infrastructure connectivity is an all-inclusiveterm for those improvements and facilities needed tosupport the developed site. It simply would not makesense for the conditions to exempt these improvementsand in some cases require the installation of theseimprovements for a berm, for example. Within thesetback but not allow for the necessary clearing tooccur to accommodate them.Condition E-9 is as follows: The sharedboundaries between the property and abutting parcels,and between the property and any VDOT right-of-way shallbe screened with berms and plantings, preservedvegetation, revegetated areas with planting and 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 20 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING vegetated areas left to regrow as applicable, accordingto Exhibit H. This is the language that goes hand inhand with Exhibit H, to establish what screening or whatbuffer alternatives are required within each setbackshown on Exhibit H.And then finally, we come to condition E-16. If,in the sole discretion of the Director of Planning,supplemental plantings are needed to effectuate theintent of these conditions to provide adequatescreening, the operator shall engage a landscapearchitect, licensed and certified in accordance withVirginia Code Title 54.1, to design such supplementalplannings consistent with the requirements herein. This language serves as a safeguard, sinceconditions E-6 and E-8 allowed for specific clearing,and the placement of improvements within the setback.And given the conditional nature of Exhibit H, thiscondition insures that if some how, some way, there wasa gap in the screening, then additional plantings willbe required.Each of the identified setbacks and requiredscreening and buffers are in compliance with Exhibit Hon the Phase 1 site plan. In the areas identified as a 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 21 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING 100-foot minimum setback with proposed berm andplantings, an 8-foot berm with plantings is provided.In the areas for a minimum setback of 100 feet, withpreserved vegetation, the area is preserved beyond thepermitted clearing that is allowed by the conditions inE-8. In the areas identified for 100-foot minimumsetback allowing vegetation to grow back naturally, anative species mix will be planted and allowed to grownaturally beyond the permitted clearing that's allowedby the conditions.The same standard applies to berms and the limitedportions of storm water basins, which are located withinthe 100-foot setback. The basins will be planted with anative species seed mix and allowed to grow naturally inaccordance with Exhibit H.Now, the Board has received a significant amountof information. You have the appellant's application and materials and supplemental materials that weresubmitted yesterday. You also have responses fromSPower and the Board of Supervisors in opposition to theappeal before you. And on top of that, you have twoseparate appeal cases that are essentially arguing thesame issue, were the setback and buffers violated by 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 22 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING allowing access roads and storm water basins to beplaced within? The appellants' response filed yesterday, were forboth of the cases together, so at this point, I want toaddress each of the challenges that have been submittedfor both cases now.The appellants have specifically challenged thelocation of the access road at the project's entranceand that is not permitted in the 100-foot setback andbuffer. As presented, conditions E-6 and E-8specifically allow for access roads, ingress/egress andinfrastructure connectivity. But beyond that, thelocation of the road was consistently shown in thislocation from the beginning.These are two snapshots from sheets within theapproved GDP. Here is the first where you show theentrance coming in from Orange Plank Road, and it hitsthe project here. This dashed line is what was at thattime the 50-foot buffer. But here is the road. Theroad was always running parallel along the property linebefore it turned into the site. Here is another sheetfrom the GDP, showing the entrance the same way. Cominginto the site and hugging along the property line before 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 23 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING it turns in.I believe that the approval of the Special UsePermit with this GDP, the Board of Supervisors hasalready answered the question about whether or not theaccess road can be located here. Of course, theconditions only reinforce that.While none of the appellants have identified theirspecific harm related to the visual impact, the O'Biers,the Booths and Mr. Stevens' property are adjacent to theSPower Phase 1 project site. I expect the appellants'counsel to argue that they have been impacted or havereceived a greater harm than that of the general publicbecause they are adjacent to the project. However, theSpecial Use Permit conditions and Exhibit H Buffer AreaPlan, required an 8-foot berm with plantings to beinstalled along their shared property line.This is the detail that we just saw from theapproved SUP demonstrating the visual impact for theO'Bier's, for the Booth's and Mr. Stevens' vantagepoint, which is looking at plantings and at the side ofan 8-foot berm.Here is the view standing at the property linefrom Mr. O'Bier's property. Regardless of whether the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 24 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING roads or storm water basins are located inside oroutside of that 100-foot setback, the visual impact forMr. O'Bier is the same. Here is a view fromMr. Stevens' property. Looking down, to the left isMr. Stevens' property, to the right is SPower site.That red line is highlighting the property line, and youcan even see the stakes here where the future plantingswill be installed. Again, regardless of whether theaccess roads are within or outside of the 100-footsetback, Mr. Stevens' visual impact is the same, andmatches that of the Exhibit H.This was a picture provided by the appellantstaken from the Booth's front yard. Again, regardless ofwhether the access road or storm water basins are in orout of the 100-foot setback and buffer, their visualimpact remains the same.In their application materials, the appellantschallenged that embankments built to create sedimentbasins, storm water conveyance channels, and other stormwater BMP's should be considered part of the structure,and therefore excluded from the 100-foot vegetativebuffer, unless they are constructed to have trees andshrubs grown on them, which will become part of the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 25 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING vegetative buffer. So, in this statement, theappellants affirm the Zoning Administrator's decision,by acknowledging that if an embankment, a berm, servesas the side wall of a basin and meets the vegetativebuffer requirements, then it is allowed within the100-foot setback.Per the Special Use Permit, the requiredvegetative buffer between the SPower project site andthe O'Bier's, the Booth's, and Mr. Stevens' property, isan 8-foot berm with plantings. The storm water basinidentified as SBA-8, on the Phase 1 site plan, is thebasin which lies closest to the O'Bier's and Booth's andMr. Stevens' properties. The design for this basin didnot require an 8-foot berm. However, the height of theberm was increased to 8 feet to meet the special usepermit requirement for visual screening. Landscapingwill be installed between the berm and the propertyline, as required.Here is the project engineer's exhibit of the overdesign of the embankment berm. This illustrates how thevisual screening requirement is met by increasing theheight of the berm beyond that which was required forthe embankment. So, the hatched area shows what was 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 26 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING required for the embankment of the basin. The grayshaded area is what was provided above and beyond inorder to meet that vegetative buffer requirement fromExhibit H.On the same issue related to the basin embankmentsand landscaping, the appellants challenge whether thereis sufficient room to install the required landscaping.This is Page 2 of Exhibit A provided by the appellants.Here they identified the berm and the storm waterbasin, and note that no woody vegetation is allowedwithin 25 feet of the toe of the permanent storm waterembankment. Now, this 25-foot offset is a DEQrequirement. The intent, of course, is to insure thatthe root systems from trees or other plantings do notimpact the integrity of the embankment. This concernwas raised not long after the Phase 1 site plan wasapproved, and it was confirmed that there were areaswhere the plantings, which are required by Exhibit H,would need to be moved 25 feet from the berm. A siteplan amendment was submitted, it's been reviewed by theCounty, to correct this issue. And the trees and shrubsthat are required to be 25 foot from the embankment,have been shifted and now meet this requirement. And 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 27 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING not only does it meet DEQ's requirement, but itcontinues to meet the requirements of the Special UsePermit. If the Board wishes to see the amended siteplan, that can be provided.Continuing on the same point. If you refer toExhibit C, Page 2 of the appellants' materials, you willsee they are noting the 25 foot DEQ requirement in theirillustration. And again, the SPower does not havesufficient room on their property to install therequired landscaping and meet DEQ's 25-foot setback.This depiction that shows the landscaping crossing overthe property lines, in these locations, is simplyincorrect. There has been an ongoing property linedispute with the O'Biers and SPower for a long time.Under normal circumstances, property line disputes are acivil issue and the County does not get involved.However, given the nature of this project, and thechallenges that have been made to the landscaping, theCounty did commission an independent survey to mark theproperty lines. The survey was based on the subdivisionplats that were recorded. The results of the surveyconfirmed the property lines marketed by SPower, werecorrect and further confirmed that there is sufficient 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 28 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING room to accommodate the required landscaping per theSUP, and meet the DEQ requirements.This is Page 3 of Exhibit A provided by theappellants, where they show the basins relocated 125feet from the property line. This image appears toreflect how they would like the design to be, but myrole is to enforce the conditions as they are written,and the conditions are clear on that point. The basinsare permitted within the 100-foot setback and buffer.The embankment to the basin was over designed to meetthe 8-foot berm requirement of the SUP. The requiredlandscaping will be installed, and the landscaping willmeet DEQ requirements.This is a picture from the appellants' Exhibit C,Page 10, where they call out the outflow pipes withinthe 100-foot setback and buffer. I call this pictureout because on their own application materials, for thefirst case, A19-0003, on Paragraph 6, they acknowledgethemselves that outflow must traverse the buffer, andthere is the expert provided for you here.This exhibit is from Exhibit C, Page 8, and theargument here is that there is not sufficient room toplant the required landscaping and meet the DEQ 25 foot 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 29 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING setback requirement. Again, this is just not correct.The 25 foot offset is measured from the dam embankment.The full length of the berm does not serve as the damembankment, which is what you see in this image. Thisis just a berm, therefore there is no reason why thelandscaping cannot be installed at the toe of the bermas shown on the site plan.The amended site plan, which reflects the DEQrequirements, again like I mentioned, has been reviewedby County staff. It's also been reviewed by theCounty's third party engineers, SBI's, and all thisconfirmed compliance on this issue with respect to theSUP and DEQ requirements.This image is from Exhibit C, Page 9, which arguesthe same point regarding the landscaping, but also notesthat the fencing on top of the berm is permanent andwill have barbed wire on top of the fence. Again, thisis not correct. This fencing was installed with afabric liner as a temporary screening measure, and wasactually requested by one of the appellants, Mr. O'Bier.Once construction is complete, and the site isstabilized, the fencing will be removed. The facilitywill have security fencing, but this security fencing 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 30 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING surrounds the solar panel raised interior to the siteand in no instances does the security fencing sit on topof a berm.Obviously, the two cases overlap in many ways,however the basis for this appeal, Case A19-0003, was tochallenge the approved site plan. I understand SPoweris challenging whether the site plan is appealable, andon that topic I am not taking a position. But if theBZA finds that the appeal is not appealable, then youwill simply dismiss the appeal. But if you find that itis, then here are your considerations.Has the appellant provided sufficient evidence tosupport their aggrieved status, and is there sufficientevidence to overturn the Zoning Administrator's decisionthat the Phase 1 site plan was approved in compliancewith the approved conditions of the Special Use Permit?That concludes my presentation, I'm happy toanswer any questions.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Questions by the Board.MR. BRAMLETTE: Mr. Chairman.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Bramlette.MR. BRAMLETTE: Yes, Ms. Administrator, youshowed one site with the orange storm water basin 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 31 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING at 125 feet, yeah, that the appellant wanted.Where is the location then of the extra?MS. POMATTO: The berm and portions of thestorm water basin are located within the 100-footsetback, and buffer. And the landscaping and thevisual berms that are required are also locatedwithin that 100-foot setback and buffer.MR. BRAMLETTE: So both of these are movedbasically further toward the property line.MS. POMATTO: This is, was included in theappellant's materials where they are demonstratingwhere they think the basin should be and they don'tbelieve the storm water basins are permitted to bewithin the 100-foot setback and buffer. And theyhave added 25 feet to accommodate the DEQrequirements.MR. BRAMLETTE: All right. Thank you verymuch.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Any other questions from theboard for Ms. Pomatto? NO RESPONSE FROM THE PANELMR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay, seeing none. Mr. Leming, you are speaking on behalf of the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 32 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING appellants.MR. LEMING: Yes, sir.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: You may have the floor.MR. LEMING: Thank you. And I don't knowwhether Ms. Pomatto ran this by you, but with thepermission of the Board, we would like to come tothe table. There is a lot of paper here and wewill have somebody operating our screen, so I'mgoing to be telling him what we need to look at.So, is that all right with you?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: As long as you speak intothe microphone so we can hear you. MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. I'm going to sit downand try to look over the monitor so I can see theleft wing, right wing, whichever position you are.And Mr. Posante, you come right here, please. AndDave, you are going to be there, right. You haveone exhibit that is posted here, which may helpwith some references.Thank you, Mr. Chairman, and members of the BZA.We appreciate you hearing us under these unusualcircumstances. If you had given me two more days, Iwould have come with a haircut, because that's when my 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 33 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING barber opens.You are going to, there is --MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Could you please state yourname, address. MR. LEMING: Yes, sir, I'm Clark Leming, andthe address is 233 Garrisonville Road, in Stafford,Virginia. And I am here on behalf of theapplicants. In this case, the O'Biers, theStevens, Mr. Fogarty, and Mr. Hammond.Do you need me to repeat anything?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes.MR. LEMING: I'm Clark Leming, I'm here onbehalf of the applicants in A19-0003. My addressis 233 Garrisonville Road, Suite 203, in Stafford,Virginia.Now, I think that gets us back to square one. Idon't, I heard something about the time limits earlier.I have been listening to the Zoning Administrator nowfor at least 35 minutes. There is a lot of materialhere.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: We are being flexible.MR. LEMING: Thank you. And what youindicated about the not repeating ourselves in the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 34 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING second hearing, I think is very appropriate.Now, so there will be a good bit of redundancysubstantively between these two appeals. I would liketo point out, though, that there is going to be a goodbit of redundancy between what you heard from Ms.Pomatto, your Zoning Administrator, and what you aregoing to hear from SPower and what you are going to hearfrom the County Attorney. The themes are essentiallythe same with a few variations that we will touch on.So, it's us against three others here.Now, first, what I want to do is address standing.And I want to, I want to start with a State CodeProvision, so that you understand why this appeal of theunderlying zoning determinations of the site plan, wasmade by the applicants here. This was not one that wehad filed for them.Under Virginia law, Virginia Code Section15.2-2311, what it says, and these are the appeals andyou are probably familiar with this, but what it says isthat an appeal may be taken by any person aggrieved byessentially anybody, from any order, requirement,decision or determination. Any.Now, there have been efforts by the localities to 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 35 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING narrow down what's a determination and what's not adetermination. Some require applications now. OnSpotsylvania's e-mails you get an e-mail from Ms.Pomatto, she says at the bottom of it, "This is not adetermination." Well, this is state law, and it saysany determination.So, when we have a site plan, we have any numberof underlying determinations that have to be made inorder for the site plan to be considered and acted upon,and one of those determinations concerns exactly howthese conditions were going to be interpreted. So, thatis the basis for the appeal. It is not an appeal of thesite plan approval, it is an appeal of the underlyingdeterminations.Now, to lend validity to this, SPower, in theirbrief, actually tells you that these decisions were madeway back, way back when, and that, you know, we are toolate with the appeal because they relied on this for 60days, and of course they dispute the validity of theappeal and the standing in the first place. But that'sexactly what the point of the appeal was, because theremay well, and has now been the allegation that if wewaited for the zoning determination, which is your case, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 36 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING too, that it would be too late, because under 2311,Subsection C, if you have a determination, and itremains in place and is unchallenged and the beneficiaryof that determination relies on it in good faith for aperiod of more than 60 days, it can't be changed. So,that's the reason for the appeal of the underlyingdeterminations of the site plan approval, which occurredway back on November the 22nd.Now, chronology here is important. That appealwas filed within the 30 days, which is subject, is whatthe statute requires; but within three days, thedetermination letter, the request for the determinationwas filed. So everybody knew what was being challengedhere. Now, it took the Zoning Administrator two and ahalf months to render that determination, so that waspast the 60 days. So, that's why you have the firstappeal. The determination had been filed but nobodyknew when that determination would be made, and indeed,it was beyond the 60 days.Now, let's talk about the merits of the appeal.And what I'm going to do is to address the standingissue first, and I apologize for the lateness, but, youknow, the issue of standing was not brought to our 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 37 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING attention until the staff report and then the memorandumfrom the County Attorney, then SPower's memorandum. I'mnot aware of any case that you have heard, and correctme if I'm wrong, where this BZA has addressed the issueof standing. I know of one case in Stafford where ithas come up. But it is true that the statute does sayan aggrieved party. So what is an aggrieved party?Well, our position is that, even more so with thesecond appeal, but even with this one, that the countyhas conceded standing. And what they have done withregard to this appeal, is to accept the appeal,determine that it's complete, process the appeal, andeverything else, before there is a word issued aboutstanding. I guess you could say, well, they should knowthat they have demonstrated standing. Well, it hasn'tbeen done here before.Now, I think the reason for that is that in mostcases, it is patently obvious. For instance the casefrom a couple months ago. Dixie Joe's. I think it wasvery obvious why there was standing there. There was anotice of violation to them. They certainly hadstanding to challenge the notice of violation, whichthey did. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 38 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Now, I submit to you that it is just as clear inthis case. And without even getting into VirginiaSupreme Court case law, the county confers standing uponthe applicant here, through its zoning ordinance. Andthere are several sections that are applicable here.Section 23.4.5.6-C. Now, this is what covers specialuse permits and the conditions that go with them. Andit specifically says, "The Board of Supervisors mayattach such conditions to the approval of a special usepermit as it deems necessary to prevent or minimizeadverse impacts on other property in the neighborhood.Such conditions may include but are not limited to theprovision of screening or buffering between the proposeduses and uses on adjoining properties."So, the two adjoining property owners here, O'Bierand Stevens, are adjoining. But this is even broaderthan that. It says, "The proposed uses and uses onadjoining properties." Fawn Lake is a residential usewhere many people live. That is the use, that is theadjoining use to this. So, it's very broad. But thereis no question that Mr. O'Bier and Mr. Stevens areadjacent owners here, immediately next-door, and theyare the beneficiaries of these conditions that your 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 39 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING ordinance requires that the Board consider to protecttheir interest.Now, we go on. Under the special regulations forsolar energy, which is in that same ordinance section,it specifically, and this is the Board added as a resultof this, the consideration of these applications."Solar energy facilities shall be screened as determinedby the Board of Supervisors in order to minimizevisibility and esthetic impacts to neighboring uses androadways."Now, the conditions, some of, two that Ms. Pomattohas been discussing, Conditions E-8 and E-9, are, theyimplement these particular provisions. So, theseneighbors are the beneficiaries of these sections of thezoning ordinance. So, of course, they have standing todetermine whether or not, not whether the conditions areadequate, they are not contesting how the conditionswere written. They are contesting the interpretation ofthe conditions. And the same interpretation that wefind in Ms. Pomatto's later determination letter, isunderlying the site plan approval. She had to come tothe same conclusion, or somebody did, within Zoning, theZoning Department, the Planning Department, to approve 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 40 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING the site plan.Now, so, I don't think, I think that's as far asyou need to go with the analysis, because you have gotan ordinance that gives these people standing in and ofitself.Now, to challenge the interpretation. Everybodyis challenging the condition itself, we are challengingthe interpretation of it and specifically thepermitting, permitting the roads to be, the BMP's, theother storm water devices within the 100-foot buffer.Now, but let's look at Friends of The Rappahannockfor a moment. Friends of The Rappahannock is a 2013Supreme Court case, came out of Caroline County. Andthe adjacent property owner was among the plaintiffsthat filed suit. And I believe that counsel in thatcase representing her assumed that just because she wasnext door, you know, that was sufficient. Well, theCircuit Court, later the Supreme Court, said not sofast. We have got two prongs here that we have got todeal with to get by this. And this was, this was thechallenge of a legislative decision of the issuance of aspecial exception, which is the same thing asSpotsylvania's special use permits. So we are not even 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 41 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING talking about the BZA realm here at all, we are talkingabout a challenge to a legislative decision.Now, the Supreme Court agrees that there are twoprongs. And the first prong really is just that you beadjacent. And clearly this plaintiff was adjacent inthe Friends of The Rappahannock, but where they failedis the second prong. And that is the articulation, andthe Supreme Court adopts this for zoning cases for thefirst time, the articulation of a particularized harmdifferent from that suffered from the public generally.And there was no allegation of that. Now, the plaintiffhad leave to amend in that case, and regrettably didn'ttake that leave, and went to the Supreme Court. And theSupreme Court said it is not there, we agree with theCircuit Court. There needs to be something saying well,what is the harm here?Now, Ms. Pomatto spent a good bit of time talkingabout there just being one thing at issue here, thevisuals. The ordinance says, mentions that, but alsothe esthetics. And one of the major issues that wasbrought out in the county's own study, which was, thisis the study by Dewberry, which is Exhibit D to theletter that we had sent to you. And without getting 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 42 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING into that, the study brings up, as I think Ms. Pomattoconceded, this issue, this heat island effect and howmuch the ambient temperature would rise on theproperties next door to a facility like this. This isthousands of acres of solar panels.Now, Ms. Pomatto suggests that, well, all that gotresolved and everybody agreed. Well, I can tell youthat the applicants here did not agree. And moreover,what I have is an e-mail here, and this comes fromcounsel for SPower, and it comes at the same time thatthe public hearings occurred, and that the buffer waschanged. Ms. Pomatto eluded to that, too. The bufferat the end of the process, and after the publichearings, the vegetative buffer went from 50 to100 feet. And the setback from the nearest houses wentup to 425 feet. That was all negotiated after thepublic hearings.But here is what's said, and this is sent to thesupervisors, "As you were aware, SPower submitted arevised setback exhibit that requires SPower to setbacksolar panels no less than 350 feet from any residentialhome versus the boundary line." Now, it got up to 425."And to further provide a minimum 100-foot vegetation 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 43 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING buffer from all adjoining property lines for purposes ofscreening the view from all property lines." And itgoes on to say, "Our heat island and property valueexperts believe a 100-foot buffer is more than adequate.We submitted the attached heat analysis Monday to staffunder the current planning commission and staffconditions, the requirement --" Then it gets back intothe setback from the houses.So, the heat island is still an issue, even as ofthat late date, March of 2019, just prior to theapproval of the Special Use Permits. So, we absolutelyare concerned about that. And to the extent that thevegetative buffer is what has been determined essentialfor mitigating that effect, to the extent that thatlegislative buffer is compromised, it doesn't serve thesame purpose. You don't serve the same purpose with aroad or with a storm water facility. You know, thatdoesn't do the same thing that the vegetation does.So, and so the basis for standing is that there isa particularized harm here resulting owing to thisinterpretation. It is not just what they are lookingat. And those are lovely pictures, and we sent thosewith our material, so I hope you had a chance to look at 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 44 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING it. You are looking at, I don't see any vegetation, butit's wintertime. There is a few tall trees. But youare looking basically at the base of a berm with novegetation with what's supposed to be a temporary fenceat the top of the thing. And the contention is thatbecause you are looking straight into this berm, whichis really all that you see right now, no vegetation tospeak of, that it's okay to do something else within the100 feet just on the other side of the berm. Well, ifthe berm were moved back 50 feet and you had thatvegetation in front, you know, that would be a much moresatisfactory result, and we don't contest that you canput a berm within the buffer.I will tell you that I live next-door, I havelived next-door for 35 years to Vulcan Materials. Ilive next-door to a big rock quarry and a pit that goesdown hundreds and hundreds of feet. It works great.And they are a good client of mine, too, but when I looktoward the Vulcan rock quarry, I see 300 feet ofvegetation and a hundred foot berm. I have no idea thatthey are there, because they have buffered theindustrial use with the residential use so effectively.This site is even bigger, much bigger than Vulcan's rock 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 45 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING quarry. Vulcan's rock quarry is just a couple hundredacres. We are talking here about almost 2000 acres ofsolar panels.Now, so, we think that we have, there issufficient harm and that we have alleged it, and thatthe storm water ponds, the BMP's in the roads simplydon't accomplish the purpose of the 100-foot vegetativebuffer.Now, that's all I'm going to say about standing,but in summary, we, the ordinance confirms standing onus, because these applicants are the beneficiaries ofthose conditions, and the interpretation of thoseconditions. They are fine with the conditions as theywere written. The problem is with their interpretationby the Zoning Administrator.Now, moving on to the substantive aspects of thiscase. The important starting point is that, in theplanning world, there is a great difference betweensetbacks and buffers. They are entirely differentthings used for different purposes throughout thehistory of planning.Now, the conceptual difference, setbacks, turningattention to the Spotsylvania ordinance, the Zoning 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 46 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Ordinance. Setbacks are used throughout your zoningordinance to establish the distance between structuresand property lines and natural features, like aroundLake Anna. So, you have setbacks. You can only get soclose with a structure or with some kind of facility tothose lines. That's a setback. It's simply a distanceback. You can only be so close to a road.Well here, there is a setback. You can only be100 feet from the buffer. Doesn't have anything to dowith 100 feet from the property line, doesn't haveanything to do with the vegetative buffer. It's asetback. And the best illustration is the 425 footsetback that is now in the conditions, and we will turnto that in a moment. That 425 foot setback is from thehouse to the solar panels. And that contains within it,the 100-foot buffer. But there is a big, broad setback.Any other setback within that 425 feet is superfluous.Why would you even talk about another setback withinthat one? There is a buffer within that one.Now, buffers, however, are covered in a wholedifferent section of your ordinance, your ZoningOrdinance, Section 23-5.51, landscaping and screening.It covers screens and buffers, and there is a design 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 47 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING standards manual that handles things like thetransitional screens and buffers between different uses,which is what we are talking about here. A screenbetween these uses and the effectiveness of that screen.Now, the SUP portion of the ordinance, and this isSection 23-4.56(c) 2 and 4. And that specificallyindicates, talks about two different things that can bepart of the SUP's. And they are in this case.The first is the conditions may includerequirements for side yard, front yard, real bridge andsetbacks, and we have examples of those. We have in theconditions, setbacks from roads, setbacks from thehouses, any number of different kinds of setbacks. Butyour ordinance goes on to say, this is the portion ofthe ordinance that authorizes the Special Use Permit.It says, "Conditions may provide for screening orbuffering between the proposed uses and the uses onadjacent properties," which is what we are talking abouthere. So setbacks and buffers. They are apples andoranges. They are not the same thing at all.Now, the issue that has occurred here -- oh, andlet me point out also that in the site plan submission,the county actually required that two different plans be 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 48 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING submitted, one for setbacks and one for the buffers.And can we bring those, can we bring those up just toshow? That is E-14, or L-14 and L-15. And I make thispoint just to show that all along through the processhere, and through your underlying ordinance, buffers andsetbacks are treated completely differently.Now, the first one is the, is the setback. Isthat the buffers? Okay, so the first one you arelooking at here is the buffer area. And this shows, andthere is a legend that goes with it. Unfortunately,this one is not in color. But this shows all of thebuffered areas that are going to be implemented bySPower.Okay, now if you turn over to setbacks. If youlook closely at them, these are some of the picturesthat Kimberly was showing you earlier. Here is thelegend, and it shows that the hatched area, thecrisscrossed area, is the 100 foot minimum buffer withpreserved vegetation. And then another symbol for theminimum buffer allowing vegetation to grow back innaturally. And the 100 foot minimum buffer withproposed berm with plantings. Now, this correspondswith Exhibit H that Ms. Pomatto has talked to you about. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 49 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Now, let's go to the site plan display. Or thesetback. Yeah, the setback. Now, the setback, and Iwish you could see them side-by-side, because you willnote that they are fundamentally different. So, this iswhat shows all of the setbacks on the property. And canwe look at that legend?Now, in this legend, you will notice that there isnot a single reference to a buffer. These are alldifferent kinds of setbacks on the property, okay. So,everybody knew. Now, in addition to that, can we pullup L-5 and attachment four. I'm sorry, it's not L-5.L-6, the attachment e-mail.Okay, now what we have here -- now, the point ofdivergence, obviously, throughout all of this is theinterpretation that's being given to these conditions.Now, pertaining to that -- all right, now what I want totalk about is the, are the conditions themselves,because that is where the confusion comes in.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Leming. MR. LEMING: Yes, sir.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: What you are posting up onhere, was this in the materials that you havealready provided to us? 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 50 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. Well, not on thatscreen, but what I am going to -- okay, and let mejust touch on this before we get into a discussionof the conditions.We have a couple of e-mails, and I don't thinkthere is any secret about these, but this shows thestruggle that occurred with regard to the interpretationof all of this earlier on in the process.Now, I'm looking first at an e-mail from Ms.Pomatto dated June 14, 2019. And this is to theengineers and others associated with SPower. And in thesecond paragraph there, what it says is, "Based oncondition E-8," which we are going to talk about in amoment, and this is exactly the e-mail. This has beenprovided to you as part of our submission. "Based oncondition E-8 and Exhibit H Buffer Area, these buffers,berms, revegetated and preserved, may not include thestorm water basins. Even on the GDP, which onlyreflected 50-foot buffers, the potential basins areoutside of the buffer. It appears to be clear that thebasins were never intended to be allowed within thesebuffers." Now, that was what the Zoning Administratorarticulated back in June of 2019. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 51 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING And there is another e-mail that is dated a littlebit later, that shows the same thing, that says the samething. It says, you know, she's reconsidered it, butshe's, she says specifically, and this is an e-maildated June 27, 2019, and it is to the same group. Andshe says, "While I was willing to listen to yourposition, my decision that the 100 foot buffers mustremain intact and shall not include the basins isunchanged." So, that's where we are now.Now, some time between June, site plan wassubmitted right after the applications were approved, ifnot before, somewhere between June of 2019, and Novemberof 2019, when the site plan was approved, she changedher mind. Now, we don't know why, there doesn't appearto be any record. We have done a Freedom of Informationrequest and we don't know what caused that. It'sexplained in one of the county's, in the county's briefthat it's just, well, a gradual issue of growth andunderstanding on her part, a process that she is goingthrough. Well, I think her first reaction was exactlycorrect.Now, what I would like to do is to take a momentand look at the conditions. And there has been great 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 52 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING discussion about this, but I think that there is adecidedly different -- if you want to, if you can pullup the page that has E-2, 3, 4, 5, so forth and 9.Okay.Now, Ms. Pomatto, when she did her presentation onthe conditions, she pretty much went backwards withthem, and started down with 8 and 9 and worked back upto some earlier conditions. I don't think that's thecorrect way to interpret these conditions. I give thedrafter of these conditions -- and let me tell you thatthis is an impressive set of conditions. In all of myexperience, I don't think I have ever seen such acomplete set of conditions. They cover many, manyissues, and I know the staff worked tirelessly on them.But let's give them some credit for using language theyunderstood, and a sequence or an order that theyunderstood and put some meaning into.Now, I want to start with number four, becausenumber four is the first one. This is E-4, the firstone that deals with setbacks. "No structure,improvement, equipment, including but not limited to,"and so forth, "Shall be located within the ordered 25feet of the center point of any lot that is the subject 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 53 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING of a residential site plan application, or part of anapproved residential site plan."Now then if you go down to the last sentence, itsays, "This setback shall not apply under any boundariesshared between a property and another property owned bythe operator." So, the same property owner. SPowerversus SPower, in other words.So, what we have here is what's clearlycharacterized as a setback. Now, this came along withthe change in April of 2019, the last change, expansionof the setback, and expansion of the buffer area.Now, we go to number five. "The minimum setbackof any structure, improvement, or equipment, includingbut not limited to," and then it gives some examples.But the point here is that we are talking again, and weare talking about roads here, from VDOT, VDOTright-of-way shall be 100 feet. So, again we aretalking about a setback from a road here, anothersetback. Okay. Nobody is talking about buffers and youknow, buffers, the buffer provisions here are mandatory.The setback provisions, whatever you might do or mightnot do, are permissive.Now, going down to number six, which Ms. Pomatto 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 54 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING covered. This is the next in the sequence. We arestill dealing with setbacks here. The setbackrequirements do not apply, and then it gives a litany ofthings. It lists them all out. Fencing, berms,landscaping, plantings, access roads, bridges andaboveground utilities poles. Okay, fine. The setbacksdon't apply. You can have those things within thesetbacks, those things, okay.And then there is also one about fencing, which Idon't think is particularly relevant here. But then weget into what I will call the mystery condition. Theone that so much of this turns on, because it says,first of all, states categorically, "No trees shall beremoved from any 100-foot setback area or 100-footpreserved buffer, as shown on Exhibit H." No trees, notrees shall be removed, period, okay, from either ofthem. Now why they are both in the same condition, issomething of a mystery. There is, if you look at, ifyou look at Exhibit H, you will see that there is someoverlap. There is some areas where, yeah, there is a100-foot setback in place, and there is a 100-footbuffer in place. There are also areas where that's notthe case. And if you, can you pull up Exhibit H, which 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 55 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING is, L-6 Attachment 1.Now, there are exceptions to this. If you look atthe very last line, we will read past the dying treeline, but it does say, "Or any clearing necessary foringress/egress, or infrastructure connectivity." Now,what do we do with that?Now, Ms. Pomatto says, oh, well this means thesame thing. The ingress/egress, now that means the samething as access road. No, it doesn't. Ingress/egressis defined by Black's Law Dictionary, means the abilityto get into a property and then get out of a property.Okay, it's getting in and getting out. Okay. It's not,that's not the same thing as an access road. So, let'sgive staff credit for knowing what they were talkingabout. These were reviewed by your County Attorney. Ifthey thought they, the clarification was needed, I guessthey would have said, well what do you mean here?Ingress and egress seem to be perfectly relevant. No,we don't have any problem with an ingress/egressentrance road coming in. Contrary to what has beensuggested here. But on the original, on the GDP, and wewill look at that in a moment, too, it shows the road,the access, the ingress/egress road coming straight into 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 56 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING the property. What we object to is the left turn thatthis ingress/egress road makes and then runs 1500 feetwithin the vegetated buffer before it gets out. Wedon't have any problem with, we understand that thereare certain things that need to cross the buffer, andthat gets to the second point, which is infrastructureconnectivity. You can't separate, it's one phrase here,infrastructure connectivity.Now incredibly in the staff report, what you haveis a definition of infrastructure. We all know whatinfrastructure is. We don't agree with the definitionof infrastructure, but this is infrastructureconnectivity.Now, an ingress/egress road certainly is that.What are other examples of that? A power line. Youhave got to get power into the site. They are makingpower, they have got to get power out of the site.That's the connectivity that were talking about. Water,county water, those things have got to come across thebuffer. But most significantly, the drafters of theseconditions did not use the same words that are includedup in number six. They used different words.Now, the elementary rule of statutory 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 57 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING interpretation is that you have got to give meaning toall of the language used. You can't assume anything.And this is where I think the Zoning Administrator mostoversteps her bounds, because she conflates the wholething. Well, we can do any of these things, and sincethis says we can do ingress and egress orinfrastructure, we can do anything. We can do stormwater ponds, we can do BMP's, we can do other roads,internal roads, and put those within the buffer area,too. No, that's not what the condition says and that'snot what is permitted. And remember the opening phrasehere, no tree shall be removed, except, from either one,either the setback or the buffer, except for those twothings.Now, we come down to Condition 9, which is theimportant one from the standpoint of the buffer, becauseit says, categorically, the shared boundaries between,and we know it's a 100-foot buffer now because that's in8. We know it's a 100-foot buffer and it was changedfrom 50 to 100 feet as a last minute compromise to helpget the applications through. Now being watered down.But it says, "The shared boundaries between the propertyand abutting parcels and between the property and any 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 58 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING VDOT right-of-way, shall be screened with berms," and weare fine with berms if they do the job, with planting,berms with plantings. Do you know how long it takesplantings to come in on a berm to provide anyeffectiveness whatsoever? Which is another good reason,if you have got a 100-foot buffer, for goodness sakes,put the berm back on the buffer so you still have somescreening while something grows on the buffer.Otherwise, you are looking at 8 feet of dirt, you know,as opposed to what was intended here, which is avegetated buffer. And then it lists preservedvegetation, revegetated areas with plantings andvegetated areas left to regrow as applicable, accordingto Exhibit H.Now, you may remember, and can we pull up thelegend to Exhibit H. You may remember Ms. Pomattopulled up this legend to H, which showed what all ofthese different colors were. There is the legend rightthere. Well, you know what, this condition, thesewords, these terms here, correspond with that legend oncondition H.Now, while we are on condition H, you will noticethat it says for each of those colors, it does say, it 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 59 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING talks about the 100 foot minimum setback. Now, why wasthat word used there? I have no idea. I assume thatthat was scribner's error, that there was something theengineer put there. But it does say the 100 footsetback. But then this whole thing is called the bufferarea plan. That's what the document is. And if youlook just below that on the notes, it says that thebuffer locations are approximate and based on theinitial panel proximity to the roadways and adjacentproperties.So, then it talks about buffers and it talks aboutusing buffers again at the bottom of the page. So,there is not much question what this is about, and butthis is, this is the exhibit that is referenced here.And Ms. Pomatto talked about this, this is the area, andthis is the area of significance for the first appeal,because these are where O'Bier and Stevens reside,adjacent to this area shown in red here.Now, the red says that that's 100 foot minimumsetback with proposed berm with plantings. Now, youhave seen the pictures of that. Now, when you arelooking at those pictures, I think what you have got toask yourself is, does that comply with the clear intent 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 60 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING of Condition 9 here, the screening requirement and thevegetation requirement. And moreover does it evencomply with number eight, where it talks about no treesbeing removed. How many trees were removed, number one,for the berm, which is permitted; but number two, howmany additional trees were removed for the road or forthe BMP that is just on the other side of the berm. Theberm could be where the road is, the berm could be wherethe BMP is, not the foot, but get the whole BMP out ofthe 100 foot buffer. There is simply no authority forthat here.Now, a couple other conditions I think that arenoteworthy here. Number 10, and this helps to actuallyexplain some things. The plantings required in ExhibitH shall comply with the GDP's landscape plan. But thenit goes on to say except to the extent that the GDP'slandscape plan is contrary to the conditions therein.And when we are talking about the landscape plan, it hasthis clause that is determined solely by the county.The conditions herein shall supercede and control. Theconditions shall supercede and control over the GDP, andby extension, this Exhibit H, as well.Now, there is another provision within the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 61 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING conditions right at the front that says categoricallythat, "To the extent that any conditions are contrary tothe GDP, the conditions herein shall supercede the GDPand control."So, you heard a lot of discussion about balancingand reading one with the other, what controls here isthe language. The illustrations are nice, but whatcontrols is the language that is used here. And in thesequence that I have described, going from setbacksthrough the vegetation portion of the conditions here,you know, I would submit to you that there is noauthority under these conditions, which are thegoverning conditions, that permits roads, other thaningress and egress, to come through the buffer. Andthose come in at a straight angle. They get you in,they get you out, they don't run along with the buffer,in the buffer. There is no authority in here for a BMP,for a sediment pump or any kind of storm water facility.Why? Because you have to take out the vegetation to dothose things, and the vegetation provisions here ismandatory. Anything you can do within a setback ispermissive and you can do it in a setback, but not asetback that is where a vegetated, 100 foot vegetated 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 62 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING buffer is super imposed, and the buffer controls. Andthe language, I think, supports that interpretation.Now, there was also some discussion aboutCondition 16. Now, I don't think this has anything todo with what we are talking about tonight. You know,this just says if the Planning Director determines thatsome plantings are ineffective or something else isneeded to effect the purpose of the ordinance, then thezone, the Planning Director can hire this landscapearchitect to go out and have a look at it, but we arenot talking about gee, what do we do now that we havecompromised the buffer by putting things in them thatcan't go there? That's not what Condition 16 is about.So, Mr. Chairman, and members of the BZA, thankyou very much for your patience. And I, we have covereda lot of ground here. I do, there are a few defensesthat are raised in the, both the county and the SPowermemos that I do want to touch on. First --MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Please give us yourhighlights. MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. Did that come fromyou, Mr. Chairman?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 63 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. LEMING: Okay. The highlights.First, the issues that were time barred here, thatwe should have appealed it back when the SUP wasadopted. As I indicated, we are not appealing theconditions, we are appealing the interpretation of theconditions. Okay. Okay.Now, and then there is also the issue that weshould be, we can only appeal certain particularconditions, or elements here. There is no merit tothat, because the determination that's made, and I thinkwe can understand the determination made for purposes ofeffecting the site plan with the determination letterthat comes out later. This is very broad. It appliesacross the board. There are no limitations here, andunder this interpretation, any tree can be taken out forany of the purposes at any time, for any of the purposesthat the Zoning Administrator now says are compatiblewith the 100-foot vegetated buffer, okay.Now, the county says that, or I'm sorry, let meturn to SPower, the standing argument. The, SPowercites a case called Shilling, and Shilling stands forthe proposition that in the context of a subdivisionplanned review, not what this is. This is a site 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 64 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING review. Subdivision plan review arrises from Article 6under Virginia Code, of Planning and Zoning. Site planscome out of Article 7 and are in your Zoning Ordinance.So, we are talking about a subdivision case here, first.And you know, what it says is that in that context, anadjacent property owner can't contest a subdivision planapproval. Well, that's not what we are dealing withhere. It's not a subdivision, number one. Number two,we are talking about a site plan. Number two, we arenot disputing the approval. As we started off talking alittle while ago, the appeal is to the underlyingdetermination, which we have to appeal for the nextreason that SPower throws into the mix here. They aresaying that we cannot, that the appeal, they are talkingabout the ability to appeal and to hear, I think, eitherof these cases. But what they are saying is thatbecause these determinations were made back inconnection with the site plan, and they have movedahead, and have started construction, that they reliedin good faith on whatever determinations were made inthe context of the site plan and, you know, that's theend of it. It can't be changed, it can't be modified,which is the province of Virginia Code Section 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 65 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING 15.2-2311-C, which is one that we talked about a couplemonths ago in the Dixie Joe's. But that's notapplicable at all in this particular situation, becausethere is no good faith reliance.There was an appeal filed within 30 days of thesite plan approval, and there was a request for adetermination within just a couple of days.Now, this gets back to where I started, which isthat's why we appealed the determinations underlined inthe site plan approval, because this was the exactargument that we were anticipating, and thus the needfor the appeal.But for purposes of who can appeal, the case thatis cited here has nothing to do with the circumstancesthat are before you now. It is not a subdivision planapproval at all. Whole different animal.Now, and the final word, the presumption that theZoning Administrator is correct. That has been the,that has been what the law has been, case law has beenin Virginia for ages, but in each of the cases that dealwith that, we have a 2015, 14 amendment to theordinance, where, or 2015, where that's actuallycodified, but it's in all the case law before that. But 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 66 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING in cases where the Zoning Administrator has misappliedthe ordinance, your prerogative and, in fact, your duty,is to reverse and overturn the determination made by theZoning Administrator.Now, the statute goes on to say that, here is howwe do it, The Zoning Administrator presents her case, wepresent our case. If we, with the preponderance of theevidence, which is the normal civil standard,evidentiary standard, preponderance of the evidence, anycivil case, except maybe fraud, when that, if we dothat, that's the end of it. Then we have overcome thepresumption of correctness, such that it is nowstatutorily codified.All right, thank you very much and thank you foryour patience. I realize this is not your ordinary casethat you have to contend with here.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: We are all earning our paytonight.MR. LEMING: Yes, but thank you all very muchfor your patience.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you, Mr. Leming.MR. LEMING: And I promise the second case Iwill not repeat the arguments. Yes, if you have 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 67 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING any questions, yes.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes. MR. LEMING: Sorry, you are muffled with themasks.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Board members, questions?Mr. Stepongzi?MR. STEPONGZI: The question I have, theapplicants, other than they see the berm, there areno trees, how are they negatively impacted, and notpast the berm but to their property line to theberm, how are they negatively impacted?MR. LEMING: Well, the visual is certainlyone thing, and that's the one that Ms. Pomattocovered in some length and said, well, this is whatthey are going to see one way or another. Well,and you have to use your own judgment as to whatthey are actually seeing there as opposed to what'srequired under the conditions. But beyond that,the statute, your statute is pretty broad. Itdoesn't just talk about visual screening, butbasically the entire ambiance of the setting thatis created there. Very broad under your ordinance.But, beyond that, and we talked about this for a 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 68 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING moment, we have this issue of the heat island, and theconcession by SPower's attorney, they have gottentogether, what did they do? They widened the buffer.They went from 50 feet to 100. And that was forscreening, but also to address this issue of the heatisland. We also have noise attenuation and granted theberm, I think, is effective for noise attenuation, to anextent. But the combination of effective vegetation andthe berm is what is most effective, and I can attest tothat myself because of where I live and what I'm lookingat. So it's visual, it's the continued heat islandconcern that was addressed by the 100 foot buffer.So, what I don't think is possible here is to say,okay, we are going to address these, and remember, thesethings came in after the public hearing. So here we aregoing to address the concerns that were expressed by thepublic at the public hearing, we are going to widen thevegetative buffer to 100 feet. Oh, but then we aregoing to take a substantial portion of that back becausewe are going to use that 100 feet for these otherthings. And of course, Ms. Pomatto originally said, no,no, you can't do that. So, the harm, visual, estheticsis the word that your ordinance uses. And certainly 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 69 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING from the neighbors' standpoint, the esthetics of lookingat a dirt berm are significantly diminished contrastedwith looking at a vegetated berm or the 100 foot buffer,50 feet of vegetation, and then the berm, which would bemost effective.But it really turns on, and I think there isstanding, I think they are also harmed by theinterpretation of the condition, which diminishes thevery thing that the buffer area was set up for, and theeffectiveness of that.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Hilldrup.MR. HILLDRUP: I just had a question.MR. LEMING: Yes, sir.MR. HILLDRUP: I wanted to talk to the ZoningAdministrator about what percentage of this projectis actually completed. You are showing things thatit's dirt and things like that. But at the end,before anything is finally approved and permitsissued, all of this stuff has to be put in place.So, right now you are in the early stages of thisthing and you are not going to get a tree, a grassto grow overnight with the impact of weather andstuff that you have got. So, the people who are 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 70 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING aggrieved about this, they have to be, wait thetime to see what's actually going to be done at theend.MR. LEMING: Well, I can tell you that if Iwere faced with that kind of decision, I don'tthink the burden should fall on the residents towait for that, because there were alternative ways,the same goals could have been accomplished, andthat would have been to retain the vegetation, notcut out everything to put the berm so close, butsimply move the berm back so that you would have,at least in the short term, more than what you haveright now, which is a pile of dirt. So, I don'tthink the burden should, does or should fall on theadjacent property owner to wait that time beforethings get finished. How long have you lived inyour house? How long will these people live intheir house, you know? I mean, what they hadbefore any of this started, was a vegetatedneighbor, you know. That's all that they saw.Now, the SPower has an absolute right to developtheir property, but they negotiated for 100 footvegetated buffer, and that's what the neighbors think 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 71 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING they should be held to. That's all.Now, we attached photographs with our submission,and I think Ms. Pomatto looked at some of them, so Idon't want to go through any other photographs.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: We have a complete set thatyou provided to us. MR. LEMING: Yes, sir, okay. All right, well, I hope that answers yourquestion, Mr. Hilldrup.MR. HILLDRUP: Well, it does to a certainextent. I mean, you still have to be a littlepatient on things being done. But I understandwhat you are saying about being, seeing a berm andstuff, but you even plant grass, it takes sixmonths to grow. A tree would take a couple ofyears to get up, whatever type of species you putthere. But, you know, same thing as you are sayingthose people moved in there, when they moved there,how long did it take to get the grass to grow? Welook out the window and see a bare yard.MR. LEMING: Yes, things take a -- of course,grass grows in one season. But I think the realquestion, Mr. Hilldrup, is simply, you know, why is 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 72 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING the burden on them to be patient and wait for aperiod of years before the berm can be effective?So, that's, you know, that, I think, is thequestion. I don't think the expectation shouldfall on them, oh, just wait it out, it will bebetter in a decade or so.MR. HILLDRUP: Thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Ms. Pomatto, did you want tocomment?MS. POMATTO: What I would say to that,Mr. Chairman, is that, one, this project area was afull culture operation. It was completelytimbered, for one. And in the pictures that wehave looked at, no, there is not any vegetationthere. This is an active construction site. Whatyou see right now are temporary stabilizationmethods. That berm will be vegetated with grass.Those trees that are required by Exhibit H have notbeen planted yet. In one of the pictures that Ishowed you, the stakes are there marking where theywill plant those, and those will be installedbefore the Zoning Office will sign off on the finalinspection. So, they are not there yet. This is 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 73 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING an active construction project.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Ms. Biscoe.MS. BISCOE: Yes, going back to your island,your heat island.MR. LEMING: Yes, ma'am.MS. BISCOE: What percentage of the perimeteris affected by this situation that you are bringingup?MR. LEMING: Have you looked at the Dewberryreport? I think we were talking about distances of300 or 350 feet onto the adjacent properties.MS. BISCOE: And that's just in one section,correct? What's the perimeter of this, the entireperimeter of this project, not just Site A, but allof them?MR. LEMING: Well, for purposes of thisappeal, what we are looking at is that one area.MS. BISCOE: Okay.MR. LEMING: And the heat that would comefrom the panels adjacent to those. I think therewould be, of course I think some of it would dependon prevailing winds, but what was clear, I think,from the studies that were done, is that that heat 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 74 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING island effect could be tempered with the vegetativebuffer. MS. BISCOE: I just wondered how much, whatpercentage it would be affected?MR. LEMING: I believe that the studyindicates that you get back to ambient temperaturewithin a, you know, within a fairly short distancewith the vegetation. And of course, yeah, and thatis we are talking about the entire perimeter,although for the first appeal, it's just that onecorner.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Other questions? NO RESPONSE FROM THE BOARDMR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Leaning, before I letyou go, I just got kind of two questions.You talk about Number 8, and you kept referring tono trees. There is kind of a couple other sentences inthere of that section that says removal of nonnativetrees, as well as construction that is necessary foringress and egress, especially for infrastructure. Youhave no quarrel with that, do you?MR. LEMING: Well, Condition 8 says what itsays, and specifically, you know, the last clause 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 75 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING here, and we are talking about hand, let's see,the, we are talking about getting rid of certaintrees the county doesn't want that are not speciesthat are desirable to have in, that's covered inthe Design Standards Manual. And then the handclearing for safety or removal of dead or dyingtrees, because you don't want the tree to fall.And then we get to the clause that I think is ofmost interest to you, "Or any clearing necessaryfor ingress/egress or infrastructure connectivity." No, I mean, it says what it says. Now, we spentsome time talking about what these things mean.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Understand. I just want,because you kept emphasizing the first part of thatparagraph, and I just want to make sure. MR. LEMING: The language here, as I say, weare not contesting the condition itself, it's theinterpretation. It is the equation here ofingress/egress and infrastructure connectivity withthe things listed above at Number 6, having to dowith each other. And, you know, our position,quite simply is that the drafters of this usedifferent words for a reason, because they are not 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 76 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING the same thing. So, ingress/egress, in and out, noquestion. And infrastructure connectivity. Notjust bare infrastructure. That's what the staffreport gives you that definition of infrastructure.We don't contest that. Infrastructure isinfrastructure. But connectivity, what do you haveto get into the site, what do you have to get outof the site. Not within the site. You have got toget water, public water, I think is going to thissite. You have got to get electrical power in, andyou have to have a road into the site, you know.Not parallel, not through the buffer, but crossingthe buffer, certainly. So, we don't have any quarrel at all with theconcept of this infrastructure connectivity, becausethat's straight into the site and getting what'snecessary to the site to serve the site. Now, thatdoesn't cover things like storm water ponds or BMP's.Those can be placed in many different places. Why theychose to use the buffer area for them, is something of amystery. Or other roads that don't get you into thesite. They get you from one place within the site toanother location within the site. That's not what -- 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 77 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. KOLAKOWSKI: And I guess that's my secondquestion is that you said it several times, is thatit is an interpretation, and your desire is aremedy that, your interpretation is the one thatshould be implemented.MR. LEMING: Not my interpretation, theinitial interpretation of the Zoning Administrator.She is the first one that said, no BMP's, that'snot something you can do within the 100 footbuffer. Now, I think what she says back in June isequally applicable here.Now, interestingly enough, at that period of time,there were inquiries made by SPower about asking eventhen for a zoning determination. It didn't happen. Iguess something got worked out, but her initialinterpretation was the correct one, I think. So, it'snot my interpretation, although I think that, you know,a plain reading of the conditions. The ZoningAdministrator is not entitled to render a determinationthat changes the meaning of the conditions. And thebest example of that, I think, is the equation ofingress/egress and infrastructure connectivity with theitems listed at Number 6 above. They are different 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 78 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING lists. They are not the same thing. So, that, thereshe took license.Now, the overall misinterpretation is the equationof this 100 foot setback and the 100 foot buffer, thoseare different things. And we went through all of thesupport for that. The ordinance provisions, the specialprovisions, everything within the county's ordinance andplanning backdrop treats setbacks and buffers ascompletely separate.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Any other questions,comments, for Mr. Leming?MR. BRAMLETTE: Just clarification now.MR. LEMING: Yes, sir.MR. BRAMLETTE: Are buffers allowed inside --I mean, are berms allowed inside the buffer area?MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. It says right therein the conditions, that a berm may be includedwithin the buffer. Now, if you use the back of theberm, though, as a stop for the BMP, or for a stormwater facility of some kind, and that intrudes intothe buffer, then you have got to move the bermbecause you can't have that storm water facilitywithin the berm. That's not one of the things that 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 79 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING are permitted here. That has nothing to do withthe two things that are permitted, which areingress/egress and infrastructure connectivity.MR. BRAMLETTE: But you don't have to movethe berm, you just have to move the storm water.MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. Now, the county makesthe case, they say, well, why can't, it'seffective, it is cost effective to use the back ofthe berm, you know, for this edge of the stormwater facility. Well, I don't dispute that, butfine, move the berm back. But you are correct,Mr. Bramlette, that if the, if the berm is there byitself, that's fine, we don't. And I don't seeanything in the buffer that, you know, really, inthe conditions that really controls where, withinthat 100 foot buffer the berm can go. I think thekey, though, is maintaining the most effectivebuffer here, and, you know, putting the berm rightnext to the houses, or so close, that there is noroom for any vegetation except for the grass on theberm is not the most effective way to do that.I will tell you, in Stafford County, my neighbor,Vulcan Material, is next to another subdivision. They, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 80 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING years after they had a long vegetated buffer there, noberm, they said, well, this lets us put a berm there andwe have got extra dirt so we will put a berm, and theymoved it right next to the houses and the neighborscomplained. And you know what, they moved the bufferback, because they had to wipe out all the vegetation. Now, there are different rules, different rulesgoverning that situation. And this one, differentconditions, but the question as to what is effective andwhat's an effective buffer, I think, is controllinghere. I think the mandate under Condition 9 here is toprovide the most effective buffer possible to effect thecauses and the reason for the buffer. I hope thatanswers your question.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you, Mr. Bramlette.Okay, shall we move on to --MR. LEMING: Yes, sir, again, thank you all.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Sure.SPower, is it Mr. Wisegarver.MS. WISEGARVER: Jamie Wisegarver, yes,Chairman.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Just a reminder, please,name, address and case number. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 81 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MS. WISEGARVER: Yes, sir. I'm going to takeoff my mask so you all can hear me better and I canbreath a little better. Mr. Chairman and Board Members, my name is JamieWisegarver, with the law firm of Hirschler Fleischer.That is located in Richmond, Virginia, at 2100 East CaryStreet, and I am here on behalf of SPower.Ms. Pomatto has done an excellent job ofexplaining her reasoning behind her approval of the siteplan and her determination. I would like to add a fewpoints that have been eluded to by both Ms. Pomatto andby Mr. Leming in a few different areas.You know, question number one that we have toanswer here is do the appellants even have the abilityto make this appeal? And because the answer to thatquestion is no, really, this hearing could end there.Like I said, this has been eluded to already by both Ms.Pomatto and Mr. Leming, but SPower has made a standingargument sort of separate and apart from The Friends ofThe Rappahannock discussion that you have already hearda little bit about, and it is set forth in our brief,but I would like to clarify it a little bit here thisevening. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 82 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING The Virginia General Assembly has crafted a veryspecific set of rules that apply to site plans. Thosestatutes appear at Virginia Code Sections 15.2-2258, to2261. They govern how site plans are submitted, theygovern how site plans are approved and how they areappealed. By statute, only the applicant of a site planhas the ability to appeal the disapproval of a site planto the Circuit Court. So, just breaking that down,again, if a site plan is disapproved, the applicant thatsubmitted the plan has the ability to appeal it to theCircuit Court. That statute is pretty darn clear, butif there was any doubt as to how it is to beinterpreted, the Virginia Supreme Court has alreadyclarified that for us.Mr. Leming mentioned the case, it's Shillingversus Yumenus. Mr. Leming took issue of the fact thatthe Shilling case involved a subdivision plat. That'strue, but what Mr. Leming failed to mention is that allof those same Code Sections that I just cited to youall, they apply not only to subdivision plats but alsoto site plans. The Code, Virginia Code 15.2-2246 statesthat site plans are subject to the same provisions ofthe Code dealing with subdivision plats. And it uses 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 83 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING some lovely, legal Latin here, mutatis mutandis, whichbasically means you can substitute in site plan forsubdivision plat. So, not only has the General Assemblycrafter had a very specific set of statutes that governsite plan appeals, but the Virginia Supreme Court hasaffirmed that when it comes to appealing a site plan,the only person that can do it is the applicant, notdisgruntled neighbors.The scenario that Shilling was attempting toaddress and the Virginia Supreme Court was explaining inthat case, is sort of a warning against exactly what hashappened here, which is that you have got a third partychallenge to a site plan long after it has been approvedand the applicant has relied on that approval. Under15.2-2311(c), because SPower has a vested right in thesite plan approval, it cannot now be changed, modifiedor reversed.I note that the circumstance that Mr. Lemingpresents here that if these neighbors are allowed toappeal this site plan, presents a scenario that cannotpossibly be what the General Assembly envisioned. Andthat scenario is one in which the site plan is approvedand down the road neighbors are permitted to appeal that 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 84 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING approval to the BZA. But by statute, the site planapplicant must appeal a disapproval to the CircuitCourt. That can't possibly be the case, it doesn't makeany sense. And in fact, that isn't the case, becausethe statute states very clearly who can appeal, how, andwhere, and that's not the circumstance that we havehere. So, I would submit that the analysis can prettymuch stop there. These neighbors do not have theability to appeal because they are not the applicant.If you, even if you go on to address sort of themore substantive arguments, which I would like to turnto now, there is no justification for overturning thesite plan appeal in any way. Both of these appeals, notonly the one we are discussing now, but the appeal ofthe zoning determination, are based upon the appellants'contention that there is this 100 foot buffer that issomehow separate and apart from the 100 foot setbackalong the perimeter of the project. And that that's howit failed to comply with that, with the buffer area planbecause it located BMP's and roads inside this buffer.The appellants argue that SPower has violated ConditionE-8, because it cleared trees to install BMP's androads. This simply is not true. SPower has not cleared 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 85 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING any trees within the 100 foot setback, and Ms. Pomatto,when she stood up just recently to answer a question,explained that the previous owner cleared some trees forlogging purposes. And Mr. Leming submitted just yesterday, a fewpictures of the project site. I have got a few othershere that I would like to make a part of the record.I'm attempting to observe this social distancingrequirement, so I don't necessarily want to pass themout here, but hopefully you all can take a look at them,you know.These are pictures that were taken before SPowercame on the scene, and you can see the clearcutting thatwas on the property. So SPower hasn't removed thosetrees, it was the prior owner that did that for logging.And I don't know how you all want to handle these, but Iwill just set them on the podium, if I may.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: If you would please givethem to Ms. Pomatto, and then, I think, unless theBoard has an objection, I don't think there is aproblem handing the file around.MS. WISEGARVER: Thank you. There areduplicates in there. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 86 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. KOLAKOWSKI: We will accept those.MS. WISEGARVER: Thank you, Mr. Chairman.It is also worth noting with respect to thephotographs that Mr. Leming produced yesterday thatagain, to Mr. Hilldrup, to your point exactly, all ofthose photos have been taken during construction. Thetrees haven't been planted yet, the grass hasn't hadtime to grow. So, it's a little bit, it's a littleunfair to look at those pictures and think that this isthe end all, be all of what the project site is going tolook like, because it certainly isn't. Mr. Hilldrup,you picked up on that point precisely. So, in short,there can't possibly be a violation of Condition E-8because SPower hadn't cleared any trees.The appellants focus a lot of their attention intheir brief on Condition E-9. And again, argue that theBMP's and the roads within the setback violate thebuffer area plan in Condition E-9, which references thebuffer area plan.The buffer area plan is not the final layout ofeach and every project feature. It was never intendedto be. The buffer area plan is a conceptual design. Itshows the approximate location of the various screening 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 87 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING methods. It states on the plan itself, and again we aretalking about Exhibit H, the buffer area plan, states onthe document that the buffer area locations areapproximate and will be adjusted.So, the purpose of this buffer area plan, thisExhibit H, is to depict the setback distance from theadjacent parcels, the visual screening within thosesetbacks, the perennial streams and rivers, and the areaof preserved vegetation that has to be maintained alongthose streams and rivers. It's not meant to depictevery single element of the project as it was going tobe on the day that the construction is complete, becauseif that was the case, then why in the world would youhave pages and pages of conditions. As Ms. Pomattosaid, it's important to read the two things together,the conditions and the Exhibit H buffer area plan.There would be no need for those conditions if you couldsimply say, refer to Exhibit H, the buffer area plan foreverything you need to know about the locks of everyelement of the project, and that's not what we have.The BMP's are precisely the screening that isrequired by Condition E-9 and the buffer area plan.It's berms with plantings that will be permitted to 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 88 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING regrow naturally to provide visual screening and soundbuffering. The BMP's will blend in with and become partof the natural landscape, and that is exactly what iscontemplated.We have been talking a lot about BMP's, these bestmanagement practices. I thought it might be helpful togive a little bit more detail as to what those actuallyare. With respect to the SPower site, it's literallyjust grading to improve drainage. So you have a basinthat's already located at a natural low spot, and thenyou have got a berm. And it's designed to hold backwater and release it very slowly during the storm, andthe berms divert the water into the basin. In about aweek, the basin will dry out completely. So, it is notas if it remains like a standing pond. It will be a drybasin, assuming that the rain stops.So, I notice that Mr. Leming conceded towards theend of his presentation that berms could be located inwhat he calls the buffer, but his issue seems to be withthe basin. It takes both of those things to create aBMP, because the berm diverts the water into the basin.So, it's not as if you can move the berm but not thebasin. Those two go hand-in-hand to achieve the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 89 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING functionality of the BMP.Ms. Pomatto mentioned this condition already,E-16, but I just like to touch on it briefly. If at theend of the day, there is some issue with the screening,the solution here is not to invalidate the site planapproval. The solution is to rely on that ConditionE-16, which gives the Director of Planning thediscretion to require some supplemental planning. Thiscondition should basically render moot any concern aboutinadequate screening at the project site. Because inother words, everybody was anticipating that, you know,to the extent there were concerns about screening, thereneeds to be a condition to address it, so they includedCondition E-16. At this time, it's impossible to judgethe adequacy of that screening because the plant, thetrees haven't grown and the grass hasn't grown, so it'sjust, it's too early to tell what it will look like.And to the extent more screening is needed, theconditions provide the ability to add that.With respect to the Friends of The Rappahannockcase and the aggrieved party standard, Ms. Pomatto did agreat job of explaining this, but I just like to touchon it briefly. Two of the appellants in this particular 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 90 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING appeal don't live anywhere close to the project site.One of them is over a mile away, and the other one isclose to a mile away. You can see those distances inthe attachments submitted to my letter as Exhibits B andC. I'm speaking of Mr. Fogarty and Mr. Hammond. Thoseneighbors, not only are they not adjacent to the projectsite, but they certainly can't show that they havesuffered a particularized harm. There is literally alake separating those neighbors from the project site.The other neighbors that own parcels that areadjacent to the project site, there has been a good bitof discussion on this, but again no matter what basin orstorm water facility gets installed, the view from thebackyards of those folks, is going to remain the sameand it is going to be that eight foot berm withplantings, which is exactly what the conditions inExhibit H require.Mr. Leming has mentioned these concerns about heatisland. Those concerns have been completely debunked bythe experts involved, and so I just don't think thatthey are, I think that's a red herring for purposes ofwhat we are talking about here today.That's all I have for you all, unless you have 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 91 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING questions for me, and I am happy to address those.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you, Ms. Wisegarver.Mr. Bramlette?MR. BRAMLETTE: Yes, ma'am. I have aquestion concerning the berm.Generally, about the perimeter of your property,the berm has no impact as far as where it sits insidethe buffer zone, because no one is going to see itanyhow. You have three houses, though, where the bermdoes have an impact as to where it sits, and only one ofthose berms, SBA 14, that hides that particular stormwater facility. And the question I have is around thosethree properties, why wasn't the berm put outside of thesetback so that it would be at the further extent awayfrom those three houses?MS. WISEGARVER: The berm was placed exactlyas it is required to be placed on Exhibit H, thebuffer area plan. That's the berm, when we haveseen the blown up of the small person with the treeand the berm depicted, that's the berm we aretalking about, is that berm in the corner of thoseproperties.MR. BRAMLETTE: Yes, ma'am. The question is, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 92 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING it's not the fact that that's where it's shown inH. The question is why couldn't it have been movedfurther away from the property, property line atthose particular locations? We are only talkingabout three places. One of them, you know, isclose to being there anyhow, and I don't understandwhy the topography or the engineering requiredwould have that berm inside the buffer zone.MS. WISEGARVER: Well, SPower is permitted tohave berms inside the setback, which is exactlywhat that is.MR. BRAMLETTE: Yes, I am saying I agree withthat totally. It doesn't mean that because you areallowed to have it, you are required to have it.My question is, why did you design it such at thosethree houses, that the berm could not have beenoutside or adjacent to the setback line or the bermline, thereby giving the 100 feet, nullifying anyneed for us to be here tonight?MS. WISEGARVER: Mr. Bramlette, I apologize,I am no engineer, but I have to assume that SPowerrelied on the fact that the berm was explicitlycontemplated in the Exhibit H, and the conditions 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 93 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING expressly allow for a berm to be inside that 100foot setback. So, sure, I mean, knowing what weknow now, maybe things would have been donedifferently, but in the time of construction and inthe time these plans were being developed, all youcan do is rely upon the approvals and theconditions that you have in place. You know,hindsight is 20/20, but at the time, SPowerconstructed a berm exactly as it's depicted onExhibit H, and within the provisions of the SUVconditions.MR. BRAMLETTE: Okay. Thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Other questions?MR. STEPONGZI: Just a point ofclarification. I love it when law is quoted, but Ijust, the question with Shilling, it says a lawsuitto challenge an approved subdivision plat, and asite plan applicant with the ability to appeal adisproval of a site plan is to the Circuit Courtare the only ones that can do so. You keep talkingabout that, our Zoning Administrator made adetermination on a site plan that, I think isgenerally recognized. And we are being asked to 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 94 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING render a decision on an interpretation of that siteplan. So, my question is, is does Shilling reachinto an interpretation of a site planimplementation, or is it just strictly people wereaggrieved about the total site plan?MS. WISEGARVER: I think that the appellants'use of, their phraseology in terms of styling thisas an appeal of an inherent zoning determination,is quite frankly a way to get around the operationof the statute, which is, what this boils down tois the appeal of a site plan approval, not someinherent interpretation. They don't like the factthat the site plan was approved, and now they wantto appeal it, but they can't. And so they aretrying to read in some determination that'sinherent in it to give them some ability to appeal.MR. STEPONGZI: Okay.MS. WISEGARVER: When none exists.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you.MS. WISEGARVER: Thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Is it Ms. Cook that is goingto speak for the county.MS. COOKE: Yes, sir. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 95 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Good evening, ladies and gentlemen of the BZA, myname is, and Chairman Kolakowski, my name is SusanCooke. I'm the Deputy County Attorney. I'm here withrespect to matters A19-0003, which is before you now,and so I won't do the other case number yet. As theDeputy County Attorney, my address is 9105 CourthouseRoad. And I am here tonight because the Board ofSupervisors has authorized me to represent it in frontof you.There are a lot of issues being tossed aroundtonight. First, I would like to address what is not atissue tonight, because that kind of sometimes is theelephant in the room. This is not a vote on thecontinued existence of SPower project, obviously, and Iknow that there has been, I was around through thiswhole process, I know there was a lot of opposition toit. That's not at issue before the BZA tonight.Further, excuse me, we don't get to rewrite theconditions that were adopted by the Board as I think theapplicants would like to do. The conditions are whatthe conditions are. And we are going to get into alittle bit of that discussion of interpretation, butthat's not something that the BZA can do, is rewrite the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 96 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING conditions adopted by the Board.And second, please remember that in everythingbefore you tonight, you do need to give, legally you arerequired to give the Zoning Administrator thepresumption of correctness. That's a legal presumptionthat has to be overcome by a preponderance of theevidence in the other direction. And the applicantshave to carry the burden on every issue. And that meansthat to the extent that you have any doubt, you have tobelieve the Zoning Administrator. If you say I reallydon't know what to say, that means the ZoningAdministrator wins, okay.It also bears keeping in mind here that SPower ishere, SPower is the entity that asked for the SpecialUse Permit. It applied for the Special Use Permit. Iam here representing the Board, and the Board approvedthe Special Use Permit. And Ms. Pomatto is here as theZoning Administrator who administers the Special UsePermit. And we all agree, and there are some neighborswho disagree with the way this whole process is going,but we need to keep that in context and not, theneighbors are in no doubt good people, but they don'thave a veto power and they don't have some plenary 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 97 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING review over the site plan process.So, the Board has three fundamental issues withthese appeals, and they are dispositive issues, whichmeans that whatever you think of the issues I don'taddress, the issues I do address, resolve the issues,the matters before the BZA entirely.Let me see, SPower has also raised the issue ofthe site plan appeal ability. The Board just isn'taddressing that issue. We are just staying out of thatfight. It doesn't mean it doesn't exist before you, weare just not having a say in it.If you find that the site plan isn't appealable,then everything that I'm saying right now will be moot,it won't mean much, but I'm still going to go ahead andsay it because you haven't taken that vote yet.The three issues that the Board has with, are thelack of standing, which is a very fundamental issue withthe Board, that there are three challenges that arelabeled as interpretations but they are actuallychallenges to the grant of the Special Use Permit, and Iam going to be able to demonstrate that to you. And assuch, they had to be appealed within 30 days of whenthat was granted. It hasn't been appealed, you can't 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 98 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING say well, I'm not really appealing the Special UsePermit and only the interpretation of the Special UsePermit, and get outside of that time limitation. So,that's the second thing. And the third thing is that the Board, the Boardsays -- excuse me, bifocals aren't always the best. Theapproved site plan complies with the SUP conditions andthat's important to the Board for, that is important forme to represent the Board's position. Okay. On the lack of standing, Mr. Leming has made a lotof arguments about standing that are demonstrably wrong,and what I mean to say is they are demonstrably wrong.I'm not trying to be demeaning. What I mean is youdon't have to take my word for it. I'm going to be ableto show you extrinsic things that you can see that youwill understand that it's not what he said or what Isaid, it's that they are demonstrably wrong. And I amgoing to walk you through the law so that you canunderstand that it doesn't depend on what Mr. Leming orI say, what the Virginia Code says and what the VirginiaSupreme Court says.Standing is an important issue because it relatesdirectly to the BZA exercise of authority. The BZA, as 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 99 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING you may know, is a creature of statute. And what thatmeans is you are created by statute. As such, it isalso limited by statute. You may know that, you mayhave heard the phrase that Virginia is a Dillon Rulestate. What that means is that our Board of Supervisorsis limited in authority to what the General Assembly hasgranted it. And they can't rise any higher than that.So, what the General Assembly has given to the Board ofSupervisors, the Board of Supervisors can then act on.If the General Assembly hadn't given it to the Board ofSupervisors, the Board of Supervisors can't create thatauthority. They can't decide, you know, they can'tdecide. If they do something that would contravene thatauthority or contradict it or exceed it, then it is whatwe call ultra virus and the decision would be void.So, the Board of Supervisors couldn't say to theBZA, you know, we think that you should hear tax appealcase. We think that's a good idea. We are going towrite our ordinance. Now you get to decide tax appealcases. It exceeds your statutory authority, so theyjust couldn't do it. Or animal control cases, oranything like that. So, if the BZA, pardon me, if theBoard of Supervisors wanted to say, we want our BZA to 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 100 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING be able to hear an appeal from any person in the county,any resident in the county should be able to look into aland use decision, see whether it's right or not, andbring it to the BZA. The Board doesn't have theauthority to do that, because the authority that theBoard can give to the BZA is limited in the statute thatauthorizes the BZA.Now, this concept is critically important becauseMr. Leming raises four procedural and two substantivearguments that all say the Board conferred standing. Hesaid it several times. He says regardless of what theVirginia statutes say, regardless of what the SupremeCourt says, we don't have to look at that because theBoard gave standing. The Board gave standing when itacquiesced, it conceded standing when it didn't have, itaccepted the application, it accepted our fees, itallowed this process to go forward. The Board conferredstanding. Those are the process arguments.I might have missed one here. But it doesn'tmatter, because the Board cannot create a process. Itcouldn't say I'm going to create a form and on thatform, it is going to say, the BZA can hear tax appeals.We check that box for tax appeals, and now the Board can 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 101 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING hear tax appeals. It wouldn't convey that authority.So, by the same token, whether or not standing is on aform is meaningless. Whether or not, you know, becausethe Board can't convey that authority.The substantive arguments that Mr. Leming says,well, the county Code Section 23-4.5.6, there the Boardconferred standing on my clients because it says thatthe Board can attach conditions to the approval of anSUP, and those provisions can include screening orbuffering requirements for proposed uses and uses toscreen between proposed uses and uses on adjoiningproperties.First of all, as I have just explained, I hope youunderstand that even if the Board did try to, in itsordinance, confer standing on residents, it wouldn't beaffective, it would be ultravirus, and I will get to whyin a minute. But second of all, the code sections thatMr. Leming cites don't pretend to give standing. Thecode section that he cited first is entitled Review andDecision by the Board of Supervisors, and it says thatthe Board may attach such conditions to the approval asdeemed necessary to have proposed use meet the standardsset forth in the section below and blah, blah, blah, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 102 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING regarding screening. And so, it's a huge step to gofrom the Board can decide on screening, to say that theBoard can let somebody else decide whether they have metthat standard. It does not confer standard. It doesnot confer standing, excuse me.In the same way, when Mr. Leaning cites the countysolar energy ordinance, the SCF, Mr. Leming, it says,"SCF shall be screened as determined by the Board ofSupervisors, in order to minimize visibility andesthetic impacts to neighboring uses and roadways." Mr.Leming says this gives my client standing because theyare neighbor uses, they are not roadways. ForMr. Leming's argument to be correct, however, this wouldhave to be, have to say, shall be screened as determinedby the Board of Supervisors, and as enforced asdetermined by the owners of the neighboring uses. Itdoesn't say that. It can't say that as a matter of law.The Board of Supervisors cannot confer standing outsideof what the Virginia statute, the Virginia statutes haveconferred as interpreted by the Virginia Supreme Court.So, there is another important point here, whatMr. Leming also notes, because also when he is implicitywhen he is raising these arguments, they just raised 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 103 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING standing, we filed this appeal, they accepted theappeal, they accepted our money. Virginia law does notgive Ms. Pomatto, as the Zoning Administrator, anyauthority to either turn down an appeal or to turn downa determination to say, you don't have standing. It'ssimply not there. I am a resident of Stafford County, Icould request a determination. I don't have anystanding. I might not be able to appeal it. I canrequest it and I can pay for it. Ms. Pomatto can't sayno to me. And she also can't say no, I'm going toadjudicate your standing and not let you appealsomething that you want to appeal. I don't think siteplans can be appealed, I'm not going to let you appealit. She doesn't have an adjudicatory role. Because ofthat, she gets to say no. She can make herdetermination, and has to make determinations, that'sset out, but she cannot adjudicate. So, the first place in Virginia statutes wherestanding becomes an issue is before the BZA. It's anissue beyond the BZA. Standing can be raised in theCircuit Court, and then it can also be raised in theSupreme Court, and we have many cases where it is. Andin fact, in Friends of The Rappahannock, it worked 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 104 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING exactly that way, at least from the Circuit Court to theSupreme Court.So, sometimes statutes are efficient with words.15.2-2311(c), (a) and (c), says that the BZA can hearappeals from aggrieved persons. What you might notrealize is that's a limitation. It's not saying, oh,good, you get to hear appeals. It says, no, it has tobe an aggrieved person. And what happens next is thatyou say, okay, well, what's an aggrieved person? Well,there is a whole lot of case law telling us what anaggrieved person is. So, let me tell you first off, I said that I wasgoing to show you demonstrably that Mr. Leming'sarguments are wrong. Mr. Leming didn't cite anything tosay why the code, he just said, look there is this code,but he didn't tell you how the Board of Supervisorswould have the authority to confer standing in theircode, and I tell you explicitly, they don't.So, we have 15.2-2311(a) and (c), differentstatutes that define your authority to hear appeals froman aggrieved person. And then we have the case law.But before we get to the case law, let me say somethingelse. Mr., because these are verifiable legal 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 105 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING arguments, what I didn't understand at that time, youknow, Mr. Leming, they don't always hit the gut of whatwe feel. Mr. Leming said these are the exact peoplethat these statutes are designed to protect. If youlook at this, surely they can appeal, they are the exactpeople that these are written for. And I would like toconsider an analogy. If you are in the neighborhood,let's say you have a lot of small children who play inyour neighborhood and you have small roads, maybe it'san older neighborhood and they don't have quite thesetbacks, you might want to petition the Board to say wethink we should have a 15 mile an hour speed limit inour neighborhood, and the Board could look at that andgo through a process, and it might say, yeah, you areright, you get to lower your speed limit. We can dotraffic monitoring measures, and you can lower yourspeed limit to 15 miles per hour. That decision wouldbe made expressly to benefit those neighbors, but thatdoesn't give them authority to go out and write ticketsfor people who go over 15 miles an hour. They can'tenforce it even though it's created for their benefit.So, just because the neighbors are the recipientsof, you know, the screening requirements, they are the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 106 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING people who are going to be most affected, that doesn'tgive them standing. That does not confer standing.Instead, standing is, standing requires a two-part test.Now, Mr. Leming asked you to believe that the case citedby the county, Friends of The Rappahannock versusCaroline County, applies to standing in some cases, butnot in all cases. He says that it implies, well, it's alegislative determination of the Board of Supervisorsthat's going to appeal the Circuit Court, then Friendsof The Rappahannock defines what an aggrieved person is.But if it's an appeal to the BZA of the ZoningAdministrator's determination, or of a site plan, thenFriends doesn't say what an aggrieved person is. Again,that's demonstrably wrong if you read Friends of TheRappahannock.In Friends of The Rappahannock, one of the pointsof the argument, one of the argument's points brought bythe plaintiff, the Friends of The Rappahannock, who weretrying to say they had standing was that the courtapplied the wrong standard. They thought we had, and Iam going to get it wrong. There were two standards.One of them was you had judicable interest after adeclaratory judgment, and the other standing is do we 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 107 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING have an aggrieved person. And they said we applied thewrong one of those. The Supreme Court said they are thesame thing. They are the same thing. An aggrievedperson is the same thing as having a judicable interest.And in doing so, the Supreme Court cited a case calledVirginia Beach Beautification, which is cited, it's inSPower's materials. I'm not citing that for the firsttime tonight. Where in Virginia Beach Beautification,that was the appeal from the BZA of a variance request.And the standard was, was the appellant an aggrievedperson? And the court said, no. Aggrieved person meansaggrieved person if it's, it's also the standard in atax appeal case, and it has the same standard and wecite the same cases. An aggrieved person is anaggrieved person, is an aggrieved person. There is nodifferent aggrieved person for a different kind of landuse case. That's simply not, that's simply not true.And in fact Friends says in it, in writing the opinion,the court says, "The particular statutory requirement,however, for standing in the context of a challenge to aland use decision by a Board of Zoning Appeals is thatthe party be aggrieved." And then the court goes on andcites the statute for an appeal from the BZA to the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 108 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Circuit Court for that to be aggrieved. It's the samestandard to the BZA.And then it goes on and says, "Additionally, wehave stated," well, I'm sorry, I skipped. It says,"Although the text of Code 15.2-2314 refers only to theBoard of Zoning Appeals, we have previously applied thesame standard to actions originating from land usedecisions made by local governing bodies. Additionally,we have stated that it would be inconsistent tointerpret the statutory section governing appeals fromBoard of Supervisors differently from statutory sectiongoverning appeals from Board of Zoning Appeals." Itwould be inconsistent. That's your analytical frameworkto apply. That you can have comfort in knowing that,no, aggrieved means aggrieved, aggrieved person is thesame standard here because it would be inconsistent foran aggrieved person to mean something different goingfrom the Zoning Administrator to the BZA, than it wouldmean from the BZA to the Circuit Court, to the CircuitCourt to the Supreme Court. The standard doesn'tchange. It's the same parties, it's the same facts. Anaggrieved person is an aggrieved person. I'm sorry tobelabor this, but these, I had to correct these 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 109 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING statements of law.So, Mr. Leming doesn't give you any case tosupport his theory that aggrieved person means somethingdifferent in one case than another. He simply says, oh,this was one type of case and we are something differenthere. So I left, you know, if you have any questions,Friends of the Rappahannock is in the materials that theBoard provided a week ago, and you can tell that I'm notmaking it up.Okay, Mr. Leming also says that the county codeuses the words abutting, adjacent, neighboring, andadjoining synonymously. And so he then says it doesn'tmatter what word we use, when we are talking aboutstanding. Well, maybe the county code does, maybe itdoesn't, I don't want to get into that today, but Idon't have to because it's irrelevant, because as wehave already seen, the county code doesn't effectstanding. But those words in the law of standing make ahuge difference, and you can't just, you can't just putin neighboring for abutting. They are not the samething.So, who exactly is an aggrieved person as definedin the law? Most importantly, it isn't someone who 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 110 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING lives here, it isn't even enough to live near the SPowerproject site. To be aggrieved by law, each person mustshow that he or she owns or occupies property in closeproximity to the land use decision. That's the caselaw. That's the word. And that they have suffered aparticularized harm or burden.But if we go to, and each person, each applicantmust meet both tests. It's not enough to say, well, oneof them does, so everybody gets to appeal. The BZA ischarged with dismissing from an appeal anyone whodoesn't meet both of those tests.So, the first test of owning or occupying realproperty in close proximity to the property, I have, wehave an easel and we have some exhibits here. Theexhibits are also in your materials. Is it easier tolook at your materials, or would you like me to use theeasel? I don't care. I want to do what's easier foryou.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: If it's the same materials,because we do have them. Did you want to make surethat you reference them and tell us, because Ithink you labeled them. Did you label them?MS. COOKE: We did. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 111 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. KOLAKOWSKI: As exhibits?MS. COOKE: We did. And the first one Iwould direct your attention to in the county's, theBoard's materials, I have to not say county, Ibelieve is exhibit, I believe is exhibit --MR. KOLAKOWSKI: If it's the match, just tellus which one.MS. COOKE: It's the match. I'm sorry, Ihave got everybody's materials here and findingmine for a minute is a little -- oh, there we go.First one is Exhibit Three, and it's a two page,you should have it, I hope, as an 11 by 16, or bigger,so that you can actually read the elements on it. Now,if you look at the first page, we are here talking aboutA19-0003, that is the site plan appeal. What isdepicted in the outlined area here is the area of thesite plan. That's what's at issue, not the wholeproject. And you can see, from the legend here, whereMr. Fogarty lives up in the top right-hand corner at thenumber one, where Mr. Hammond lives, just a bit belowhim at number two, and then in the far left, bottom,left corner, at number six, well, Mr. Leith, I'm sorry,he isn't, this is A19-0003, so we won't get to Mr. Leith 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 112 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING yet. What this also depicts, however, is where each ofthe challenged elements are on the site plan. Now, alot of this is focused, for instance, Mr. Leming hastalked considerably about the roads, but you can seehere that his clients aren't near any of the challengedroads. There is one that's slightly to the left ofthem, and I am going to get to that one in a minute, butall of the other roads, they aren't in close proximityto it.The first test of standing requires that theapplicant be in close proximity to the subject of theland use decision, such that the person would have adirect, immediate, pecuniary and substantial, I believe,we quoted the language, but point is you have got to beright there. The second requirement is that you have tobe able to articulate a particularized harm that'sdifferent from the general public.So if you are, you know, if you are looking againat this exhibit and you see three, four and five whereMr. O'Bier and Mr. Stevens and Mr. Booth, Mr. O'Bier andMr. Stevens are the subject of this appeal, when you seewhere they live, how are they going to articulate anyparticularized harm from these elements that are miles 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 113 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING away from them with lots of intervening things. Theyhaven't even tried in this whole, lengthy presentation,they didn't try to articulate any particularized harm toanything other than the things that are right in frontof them. They did talk about the roads, but they didn'tsay how the roads harmed them. And since the roadsaren't there where their properties are, the roadscouldn't have harmed them. So, that map is important toshow what we mean, really I think that the applicantshave conceded that Mr. Fogarty and Mr. Hammond are notin close proximity and do not have standing. But ifthere is any question, I think the map shows they can'teven meet the first test. And they haven't tried tomeet the second test.It's important, however, to note that Mr. O'Bierand Mr. Stevens don't really appear to be contesting anyother element because they haven't made any effort toshow how any other element harms them. It's not enoughfor them to say, look, these hurt me and there areothers like this that may hurt other people, but I amstanding in the shoes of those other people. That's notstanding. You are not allowed to do that under Virginialaw in this context. The applicant, each person can 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 114 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING only challenge what they are in close proximity to andwhat they have articulated a particularized harm for.So, Mr. Leming says there is no support for myargument that the appeal should be limited just to thechallenged elements, but it's just those tests. Thesupport is the close proximity and the requirement forparticularized harm. He hasn't explained how this couldmeet either of those to any of the other elementsbecause they can't.Okay, so to sum up, before we move on, it is thelaw and it is the Board's position that Mr. Fogarty andMr. Hammond don't meet step one of the standing test,and should be dismissed from the appeal outright. ThatMr. O'Bier and Mr. Stevens meet step one with respect tothe challenged elements, meaning they are in closeproximity to the ones that they are adjacent to,actually they are abutting, and only have the potentialto meet step two with respect to those elements thatthey border. And I am going to go on from there.So, with that, we return to whether they meet testtwo for SBA 8, SBA 16 and SBA 14. If you look at theexhibit we were just looking at, that's what those arelabeled that are right there near them. The first issue 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 115 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING that we have to address is this argument raised for thefirst time yesterday that there is a heat island effect.And I have to explain to you why that is not somethingthis Board has, the BZA has authority to consider, andthe why is this. Yesterday, for the first time, theapplicants claimed that without what they think is anappropriate 100-foot buffer, that they will suffer fromheat island effect and that that confers standingbecause that is some particularized harm. That's howthey are using the heat island effect. And theapplicants provided a document that was provided, datedNovember, 2018, to support their claim that the heatisland effect is real and should support their claim forstanding.They cherry picked one document from a wealth ofdocuments that was before the Board when it consideredthis issue. Now, this issue was brought up over andover and over again at different, before even the actualSpecial Use Permit was heard at citizen comment time,the idea of heat element was brought up over and overagain. In fact, the Board heard from differing experts,experts on different sides of the equation. And theBoard, and it went back and forth. So, that means it 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 116 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING was something that was before the Board for the Board'sconsideration. This is important because that means,because that changes the legal status of the question.Ms. Pomatto gave you an exhibit that was datedMarch 27, 2019, months after the one that the applicantspicked, and shortly before the SUP was granted. Andthat one, I need to find it, excuse me for just aminute. I think it's right here. That one sets thematter to rest. It states in it, at the bottom, thereis a, it's entitled Project Setback, there is anunderlined temperature increase and bullet points. Thelast bullet point before visual impact says, "Thisadditional data suggests that no vegetative shieldingfor heat effects would be necessary at all, let alone350 feet." And you are welcome to read through this,but what the controlling element was, the tests and someof their experts where they noticed a heat islandeffect, they weren't here in Virginia, they were inother areas where they didn't have vegetation growingunder the solar panels. That's all in here, I'm notmaking it up, and you are welcome to read this. Whenyou consider that this plant will have, the SPower isallowing grass and native, it's not all grass, but it's 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 117 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING green stuff glowing under the beds to keep the solarpanels, that negates any heat island effect that couldoccur, and there is not even a temporary temperatureincrease. This is important because the Board adoptedthis, and you don't have to take my word for that. I'mgoing to demonstrate to you how they did it.If you go back to condition E-16, which has beendebated a little bit over now, that's the one that sayswhen all this is said and done, the Director of Planningcan decide whether there has been enough screening, andin fact, what it says is that the Director of Planning,in her sole discretion, can require SPower to hire alandscape architect to design and put in place whateverplantings are needed, and I quote here, "To effectuatethe intent of these conditions to provide adequatescreening." Now, if the Board had thought there was potential,any potential for a temporary temperature increase thatwould have required more screening, the Board could haverequired, could have authorized the Director of Planningto measure the temperature and to also address anypotential temperature increase. The Board did not dothat. The Board rejected those arguments and only 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 118 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING authorized the Director of Planning to adjust plantingsfor screening. The BZA, therefore, cannot go back andrevisit that decision. The BZA doesn't have authority,you might have if they appealed it within 30 days, butthey didn't. That was in the grant of the Special UsePermit. So the BZA does not, not for any fault of yourown, but because of the way the law works, doesn't haveauthority to go back and decide was the Board right tonot include that in the condition? It just doesn'tmatter, the time has gone. So, the heat island effect,last minute effort to try to say, hey, we have somestanding because we are showing that we were affecteddifferently. They weren't, you can't consider it as amatter of law. It would be reversible error to considerheat island effect.In the same vein, the applicants can't challengethe location of the berm in the 100-foot setback. Now,that is Exhibit H, which I call the buffer plan, becauseI think we have it as Exhibit Three, and I didn't likeExhibit H to be Exhibit Three, or Exhibit Three to beExhibit H. The applicants had attached this exhibit totheir initial application, but you couldn't read it.I'm not faulting them, it was an eight and a half by 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 119 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING eleven. That's what happens when you -- and it's notExhibit Three, my apologies, it's Exhibit, I'm going toguess Nine. Yes. Exhibit Nine.Now, Mr. Leming would have you believe that thelegend on this Exhibit Nine, which is Exhibit H, thebuffer plan, was a scribner's error. He said that acouple times, this is just an error. There is nosupport for that, and we don't get to just say that.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Ms. Cooke, just to make surethat the Board knows what Exhibit H is, it's behindExhibit Nine, it's this one, it's this one here.MS. COOKE: Yes. Thank you, Mr. Chairman, itis this one, and as I say, there is a big one. Itmight be actually easier for you to see the one infront of you than the big one, which is why I amdoing it this way.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Actually, we received ittwice. Once from Ms. Pomatto's presentation, aswell as yours.MS. COOKE: Well, thank you. So, we boththought this was an important exhibit. Theinteresting thing about this, it is labeled bufferplan. We do have to, it's interesting when you are 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 120 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING involved in statutory construction, which isbasically what this is, you are construing theordinance because the Special Use Permit is anordinance. We don't get to make up words, we don'tget to disregard words to the extent that we can,and we have to construe all the words together.So, this is actually very specific. It says thatthe red area depicted in red here, is 100 foot minimumsetback with proposed berm with plantings, see detail.And there is the detail on the page. The Board acceptedthis, the 100 foot minimum setback with berm in that redarea. The applicants can't contest the berm. It's notsubject to challenge because the Board accepted it ayear ago April.The yellow is the 100 minimum, the yellow area isthe 100 foot minimum setback with proposed vegetationwith plantings. The purple is a 100 foot minimumsetback with preserved vegetation. And the green is the100 foot minimum setback allowing vegetation to grownaturally.Mr. Leming went on to quite some length about howthe owner shouldn't have the burden of having the bermnot vegetated. The areas with preserved vegetation are 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 121 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING purple. Their area is red, and it is not supposed tohave preserved vegetation, because it couldn't havepreserved vegetation because they had to build a bermand you can't build a berm and preserve the vegetation,it's just not possible. So, while I can certainlysympathize with the fact that it takes a while to growback, it's not a valid argument. Now, the only thing that you can point to on this,that you can use the legend, if you took a ten year oldthat's learning how to read a map and you say, point tothe buffer. Ten year old is going to say, I don't know,because there isn't anything on here that's labeledbuffer, but there is buffer mentioned on here veryspecifically in the notes. Buffer locations shown areapproximate and are based on initial panel proximity toroadways and adjacent properties. Buffers will beadjusted based on final site plan and approved specialuse conditions, but shall provide no less screening thandepicted herein. So, the buffers are approximate, and,and they will be adjusted. The setbacks aren'tapproximate, and won't be adjusted. And the 100 footarea from the property that I call the border area,because it gets a little bit away and gives us the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 122 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING ability to reference something without falling into anyof the words. The 100 foot border area around theproperty is all depicted as setback. What is depictedas buffer, what is adjustable and which is going tovary, are the plantings. In fact, it says bufferplanting list, and it has trees. Here, you know, thedetail that Ms. Pomatto put up here in the upperright-hand corner with the little diagram of the man andthe tree and the berm and the panel, that is entitledberm detail, and if you can read above the line, it saysberm and buffer. The berm is the berm and the buffer isthe tree. So, the buffer detail is not something youcan point to in here. That's important for anotherreason, and I don't mean to jump around too much, but ifI just read, it's going to be completely boring. But asMs. Pomatto and Ms. Wisegarver have said, there has beenmuch discussion of condition E-8 and they talk aboutremoval of trees. No trees were removed to constructthe berm and therefore E-8 cannot have been violated.The trees were all removed and, in fact, the Board sawmany pictures of the removal of the trees long beforethe SUP hearing ever came up, and that's in the recordbecause it was brought to their attention, by the former 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 123 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING owners who were engaged in sylviculture. You can'tviolate a condition if you haven't removed a tree, sothat condition would have applied to areas where thetrees hadn't been removed before the SUP was granted.That doesn't happen to be any of the areas theapplicants have challenged, and so it's irrelevant tothe discussion before the BZA today.The applicants, I have been talking about how theapplicants couldn't challenge the berm in the 100 footsetback because it is depicted on the approved ExhibitH, which is part of the SUP, and that's true. But theapplicants actually, they don't want to contest theberm, they don't want to say the berm can't be decided afacility or of a storm water retention pond. They saythat because that's what they don't want. But there isnothing in the SUP that says that can't happen. Theycan't point to anything that says that can't happen.Again, they say, oh, yes we can, because we can point tocondition E-8, where it says no trees can be removed,but no trees were removed. It wasn't violated, there isnothing that says that it can't be there. And again, itwas setback area and setback has condition E-6, whichallows a whole host of things. So that argument really 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 124 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING just doesn't make sense. But I bring those things upbecause they actually also relate to standing, becauseMr. O'Bier and Mr. Stevens haven't articulated anyparticularized harm. They have, that they canchallenge, maybe they could have said we don't like theberm, we don't think the berm should be there, we aregoing to appeal the SUP, but it was granted with theberm there and it's where it's supposed to be on themap, on Exhibit H, so they no longer have the right tochallenge that. They say, well, we don't like thedegree of plantings, we don't want to look at the dirthill, but it couldn't have been preserved buffer, itwasn't supposed to be a preserved buffer. You have gotto wait and you have got to let the Director of Planningdo her thing. Now, you don't get to challenge. Theydon't get to be a roving board of inquiry for thesethings.Now, we have gone over some of these things. I'mgoing to look at my notes a little bit because I don'twant to get too repetitive. I do think it's importantthat the border area is not coextensive with oraccurately referred to as buffer. The buffer plan wewere looking at a minute ago, Exhibit H, I think has 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 125 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING been made pretty clear. They say, well, it doesn'tdepict any roads. It wasn't intended to depict anyroads. The only roads in there were the ones thatpredated the SUP, not the ones that they were going tocreate, but those that were already in the area. Itdoesn't have anything other than the buffer stuff.But there is one important thing with roads,again, I'm going to play guess the exhibit number. Iknow where it is here, maybe that's the better way to doit. The Board, there has been much -- oh, wait aminute, maybe I found it. Exhibit Number Seven, it isgoing to be easier, I think, if you look in your book.Mr. Leming again, made quite a big deal about how hesays, you can only have ingress/egress. The road can'tgo down the buffer area. We actually know that's nottrue. Again, you don't have to take my word for it.The Board approved the Special Use Permit with sheet,it's Exhibit Seven in my materials, and it's labeledsheet EX-2-2. And if you look up in the top, there isan arrow up at the top that says entrance one, and Iwill tell you, maybe I can, maybe it's easier if I pointup here. It says entrance one. It shows you, there is 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 126 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING a dashed line that shows where the, this is back whenthere was going to be a 50 foot setback, it's not the100 foot setback. So, it shows, the dashed line, if youlook at the key, shows the 50 foot setback. The redline shows the property line. And here at thebeginning, going in, it shows --MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Ms. Cooke, let's make surewe got all the Board members --MS. COOKE: Thank you, Mr. Chairman, Iapologize. Is it okay?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes, please.MS. COOKE: Okay. So, up here near wherethat double arrow is where it says entrance one, ifyou go down entrance one, you can see that the roadruns here for some length, between the dashed lineand the red line before it turns in. And you mightthink, well, that's not all that long, but if youlook at the graph scale up here and you measure it,which I have done, it's actually about 500 feet.Now, that's important because it also tells you thewidth of all these roads, and the roads are 20 feetwide, 19 feet wide. The widest is 24 feet. So,24-foot road running 500 feet in the 50-foot buffer 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 127 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING area, is not ingress/egress by Mr. Lemming'sdefinition, it's running in the buffer area. Butthe Board approved the Special Use Permit withthis, with the road running in the buffer area, andwhat that means is, you can't come back andchallenge that now. You had to challenge it as anappeal to the grant to the SUP.These are GDP's, they don't lay out everything.Things change between GDP and site plan, we know that,but we know that the Board allowed the road in thebuffer area for more than ingress/egress because it ison the exhibit that was part of the SUP when theyadopted it. It doesn't, you can't do an end run aroundit just by calling it interpretation. It just doesn'tfly.Okay, they also don't have standing to challengethe roads because they aren't near any roads, but theyalso don't have the legal, they are out of time. Theyare time barred, they had to do that within 30 days or60 days, whatever it was. Okay.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Are you summarizing?MS. COOKE: I am, thank you, I'm trying to. Irealize that we have been here a long time. A few 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 128 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING more points.They point to E-9, Condition E-9 really only saysExhibit H says what it says it says. And if you look atit and you compare it to Exhibit H, you will see itdoesn't add anything to Exhibit H, it doesn't modifyanything from Exhibit H.I took a lot of notes. I just want to make surethat I hit. I believe I have hit all the issues that Iintended to, and I can probably stand up here foranother hour. You don't want me to and I don't want to.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Well, thank you. How aboutquestions from the Board?Mr. Allen.MR. ALLEN: I don't know if you can answerthis question or not, but maybe Ms. Pomatto can orMr. Leming, if you followed this in your research,the site was previously sylviculture site, is thatcorrect?MS. COOKE: Yes. That came out in all of thediscussions beforehand.MR. ALLEN: Were those roads existing when itwas a sylviculture site?MS. COOKE: There were some roads and 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 129 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING actually Exhibit H, Ms. Pomatto may very well wantto add to my answer, but Exhibit H does show someroads that were existing. I do believe SPower iscreating some new roads, as well. Should I stoptalking?MR. ALLEN: Dominion Power had access tothose roads in there as did Rappahannock Electric,is that correct?MS. POMATTO: Right. And there were, becausethe property was timbered by the previous owner,there were logging roads throughout the site, aswell. And there was a logging road that followedthe same entrance from Orange Plank Road andfollowed the property line, but it was actuallyeven closer to the property line than the accessroad that SPower has installed.MR. ALLEN: And so it was a sylviculturesite, do you know if there was land applicationsuntil biosolids? MS. POMATTO: I don't know that information.MR. ALLEN: Mr. Leming?MR. LEMING: That's correct, to myunderstanding, is the property was used for 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 130 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING sylviculture.MR. ALLEN: Was the placement of the waterrunoff basins threatened by how the topography runsand those basins would be in a specific place? MR. LEMING: That's a question much betteraddressed to, I think, the engineers for SPower.We don't know why the storm water basins ended upwhere they ended up. We just know where they endedup. So we don't know whether there was atopography issue or not, or whether it was, as wewould suspect, the intent is to clear as much landfor the solar panels, and you know, move as muchdirt as necessary, put as much infrastructureoutside of that area so you have maximum land forthat. So, I'm not sure that the originaltopography would effect that decision. It seems tome that from a development standpoint, and this isjust my, this is my educated guess, that what wehave is a parcel of land and you want to put solarpanels on it. You want that land as flat as it canpossibly be to accommodate as many solar panels asis possible, so I think there would be asubstantial amount of grading that would be done, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 131 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING regardless of what topography was already there. MR. ALLEN: Okay, I think that's a partialanswer to my question. What I'm getting at, and Iwill get right to it --MR. LEMING: Yes, sir.MR. ALLEN: Is that the drainage situation ofthat land, since it was land applied withbiosolids, where those things, where those basinswere at and where those berms were placed wouldprevent any of the runoff from the biosolids to getinto Fawn Lake, would that be correct?MR. LEMING: I don't know the answer to thatquestion.MS. COOKE: I don't know the answer either.MR. LEMING: There is no drainage coming intoFawn Lake. No existing drainage that we are awareof coming into Fawn Lake from the original parcel.MR. ALLEN: Okay, thank you very much.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Other questions? Mr. Stepongzi?MR. STEPONGZI: No, nothing.MS. BISCOE: No.MR. BRAMLETTE: Yes, sorry. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 132 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. KOLAKOWSKI: No, that's sorry, Mr.Bramlette, go ahead.MR. BRAMLETTE: You have covered a great dealof territory. Can you, in about three very shortpoints, tell me exactly what you want us to takeaway from your discussion?MS. COOKE: Yes, absolutely. And that Ishould have gotten to. It is the Board's positionthat the applicants lack standing to challengeanything because of all the reasons I have gonethrough. We know Mr. Fogarty and Mr. Hammond haveno standing because they are no where near. Weknow that Mr. O'Bier and Mr. Stevens, theirproperty are near, but they have the berm that wassupposed to be there. They can't rechallenge now.It's alleged there is a heat island effect, thatcan't be challenged now. They have alleged thatE-8 is violated because the trees were removed, butthe trees were removed before the SUP was granted.So, nothing that was challenged, that they aretrying to challenge that was a particularized harm,that wasn't part of the original SUP, and that canbe brought in by a challenge. So, we say that 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 133 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING there is no standing.Aside from that, even if there were standing,which I strongly believe there isn't, but even if therewere, then basically what the applicants have given usis what they think the condition should say, and whatthey would like to see, but they don't get to rewritethe conditions. The conditions are what they are, thebuffer plan says what it says, the setback is thesetback. Nothing has been violated. The Board is ofthe opinion that the site plan complies with what theyadopted as the Special Use Permit, and so they want youto deny the appeal, and that's what we are requesting.I'm sorry, that wasn't just three words.MR. BRAMLETTE: Well, I didn't say you had todo it in words, I said a short number of points. Igot it. Thank you.MS. COOKE: Thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: It is kind of a followup. Iwanted to ask about the standing. I guess it'syour position to say that they have no standing,period, even though there are three adjacentproperty owners, two specifically in A19-003 andthree in 20-0001. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 134 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MS. COOKE: Yes, it is. Close proximity isthe first step, but then there is another step, andthey don't meet that. They didn't make any attemptbefore yesterday to even --MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Understand that. But thebottom line is, is that the Board can consider theadjacent property owners' appeal.MS. COOKE: No, the BZA can only consider theappeal if they meet both tests. They can't say,well you are close, you are in close proximity sowe can say you have standing. Friends of TheRappahannock is very clear, articulates veryclearly that for anyone, for the BZA -- what itcomes down to is this, the BZA's jurisdiction, youcan't invoke the jurisdiction of the BZA unless youmeet these tests. If you entertain an appeal bysomebody, you say, well you are close by, so Ithink we should be able to hear that, then you haveacted outside of your jurisdiction and yourdecision is void. And I did cite to you in ourmaterials the case that says that. The BZA actedoutside, this person has no standing and the BZAacts on it, then the BZA decision was void, and it 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 135 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING is not enough to be in close proximity. You haveto have the particularized harm, as well.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Well, I guess my question toyou would be whether or not we decide on thestanding, or if we say that the three adjacentproperty, or the adjacent property owners havestanding, but they do not pass the second test,isn't that a valid decision of the BZA?MS. COOKE: That's a very interesting point.What that would mean is that the applicants couldappeal to the Circuit Court the denial of theirapplication, and the Board could appeal the findingof standing. You are right in that the Board, ifthe applicants didn't appeal, the Board wouldn'tbother because there would be nothing to appealbecause it would be, to the extent that it waserror, it would be what we would call harmlesserror, and I don't say that to be --MR. KOLAKOWSKI: No, I understand.MS. COOKE: But yeah, it's interestingbecause when, because it seems to not make adifference. It's like well, we end up in the sameplace, but if you read the cases and you get to the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 136 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING places where these get appealed, every littledecision does count. So, that's why we raise theissue to say that Mr. Hammond and Mr. Fogartyshould be dismissed regardless, even if you don'tbelieve anything else I say, they should bedismissed from the case. They clearly don't havestanding. They haven't even made an argument thatthey have standing, and it matters. Every one ofthe decisions matters.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Well, on the flip side, saythe Board just dismisses these appeals because itsays no standing, they could still appeal to theCircuit Court, correct?MS. COOKE: They could appeal to the CircuitCourt. The issues framed for the Circuit Courtwould be different.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Right, understand that.Just a point of information for the record, youquoted or provided or referenced some documentsthat you had on the heat island, and I don't thinkwe have those. Could you provide those toMs. Pomatto so we can put them in the record.MS. COOKE: Yes, I apologize. I thought that 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 137 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Ms. Pomatto had given them to you earlier. Maybewe miscommunicated about that.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Well, we got a door stopfrom your office and, at least, I didn't see it inthere. I just want to make sure it's part of therecord.MS. POMATTO: It wasn't in there.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: We just want to make sure weget all the documents in the record.Any other questions? NO RESPONSE FROM THE BOARDMR. KOLAKOWSKI: All right, let's get on withthe second part of this public hearing. Thank you,Ms. Cooke.MS. COOKE: Yes, sir, thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: For verbal public comments,those of you who have been patient enough to staywith us on this, all those that wish to speak forthe appeal, please come forward.Again, I ask you to state your name, address andspecific case number, which is A19-0003. Anybody wishto speak for the appellants?MR. HAMMOND: I have a question, I'm an 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 138 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING appellant, do I get three minutes to speak?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes, please.MR. HAMMOND: I have got a question for your,am I allowed three minutes as an appellant?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes, please give us yourname, address and the case --MR. HAMMOND: I want to show a video, if I'mallowed to speak.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: How long is your video?MR. HAMMOND: A minute and a half.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay. Well, again, I amasking you to --MR. HAMMOND: My name is David Hammond, 11416Seymore Lane, Spotsylvania. Livingston District.MS. COOKE: Mr. Chairman, Mr. Hammond is oneof the applicants who is represented by counsel.He's already had his time before the BZA.MR. LEMING: I didn't know we were permittedto make objections just extraneously like that. Icould be up a few times if that is the procedure.MS. COOKE: I am merely informing, I believe.MR. LEMING: You are making an objection andyou don't have the floor. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 139 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Let me ask this, let me askthe Board, do we want to see a minute and a halfvideo, give Mr. Hammond the opportunity to say whathe wishes to say?MR. BRAMLETTE: Mr. Chairman, if we allowboth sides individually, after the lawyers, tostand up, if they wish to, and speak, we havelimited it to three minutes because of the lengthof this, I would say --MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Have at it.MR. BRAMLETTE: One side wants to speak.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes. So, let's proceedbecause we have already spent a minute and a halfon this.MR. HAMMOND: If we could have the floorcomputer. There we go. So, this is a drone videotaken one week ago, Tuesday, up above ChancellorMeadow Lane, and I thought you should get a goodpicture of what we are looking at here because, youknow, we are talking about very close proximity.Go ahead and start this, Sean.You can see the basins lined up along ChancellorMeadow Lane. Over to the very right is the entrance 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 140 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING road. The bump out there is around the cemetery, is a100 foot setback, so you can get a feeling for how far100 foot is, and how close these basins are. And theberms that they talk about, if you could stop rightthere for a second, Sean.Mr. Booth's house is just to the left there, Seanhas got the curser on it, and you can see how big, theseare embankments, they are not berms. They are part ofthe basin structure, and how far they push these closeto the property line. It's appalling. They should beset way back. Continue on, I don't want to take moretime than I promised.So, this is the basin opposite Mr. Booth's house.We are coming up to the huge basin adjacent toMr. O'Bier's house. And again, you can see how close itis. This is 15 feet off the property line. And theycan't put vegetation against an embankment for asediment basin. So, there is no buffer here. There isa -- keep going, Sean, because I don't want to spendmore time.There is a pile of dirt here that's theembankment, and basically no vegetation, or a single rowof trees, and that's not 100 feet of vegetative buffer. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 141 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING We are going to turn the corner here, and you cansee the huge embankment, basin there, and half of thebasin is inside the 100 foot buffer. And this isturning, that is Zach Stevens' house right there, andthere is a 425 foot setback. There is nothing going --stop right there for a second. There is nothing goingfor 425 feet, and they push this right up against Zach'sback yard.So, that's the video. I thought, you know,picture is worth a thousand words. It would be good foryou to see what this actually looks like.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you, Mr. Hammond.MR. HAMILTON: Thank you for your time.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you.Anybody else wish to speak for?MR. O'BIER: My name is Michael O'Bier. Ilive at 11201 Chancellor Meadows Lane. Basinnumber eight is in my back yard. This is what myback yard looks like now. This is what I took outfrom last week. This is coming down out of basinnumber eight, which is only 75-foot from myproperty line, and it's all mud. This was taken200-foot inside my property. And this is what I'm 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 142 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING getting from SPower's project. So, I have nostanding, I have no impact on me. This right hereproves the impact that I'm getting. This is mudand leaves off of what's coming out of basin numbereight across my property. It's undermining all myoak trees. I have already lost four of them. I dohave impact. I'm emotional, you know, I have beenworking my whole life for this place, and for thesepeople to say I have no impact, they do what theywant to with it. Hey, this is proof that thisthing needs to be moved out and needs to gosomewhere else. The riprap is not doing its job,the silk fence is not doing its job. The erosioncontrol is not doing its job. When it comes out200-foot on my property like this, this kind ofmud, is something wrong. It needs to be addressed,it needs to be looked at, it needs to bere-engineered. Thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you, Mr. O'Bier.Anybody else wish to speak for?MR. HAMILTON: He's got some pictures toshow.MR. FOGARTY: Sean Fogarty, Livingston 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 143 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING District. I live in Fawn Lake, 11609 Fawn LakeParkway. Speaking about A19-001 or 0003, I guessit is. Just real quickly, I have a few pictures toshow you. The comment was made about trees andalso the -- So this is the entrance road coming from OrangePlank Road, looking south, towards, into the site. Thiswas taken in August of last year by a drone, and you cansee on the right-hand side they are starting to buildtheir entrance road that he's got the curser on. Thereare some trees, not a lot of trees, but there are someshrubs and trees in there that are adjacent to thatprivate property on the right, the triangle of trees.You can go to the next one. This is the site planthat depicts what you just saw. This is with north tothe top, so it's kind of reversed. That prior propertyis to the left, that's owned by Mr. Seaton, who hasowned that property for a hundred years in his family. So, they put the road inside the buffer adjacent to hisproperty.Go to the next one, Dave. All they had to do wassimply move, come to the ingress that I have heard a lotof comment about ingress/egress. Clearly this is an 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 144 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING ingress/egress. You should have come in for 100 feet,200 feet, move it on over, get it outside of the 100feet so that this property owner over here is notaffected and has a buffer. You can't plant trees. Theywill never be allowed to grow where there is a road.Next slide. That's just a depiction of where the100 foot buffer is, that red line. The road just simplyhas to be moved over to the left. They will lose a fewpanels. No big deal to this 6,300-acre project. Andthis gentleman on the right, who owns that property,would have an adequate buffer.And the last slide. Yeah, flip to the next one.So this is, this is a drone video from last week lookingfrom a different direction over towards that property.Now you look at the access road. They have actuallydoubled the width of it. It is 85 feet wide now. Theyhave built another road, increased the limit ofdisturbance over there to 15 feet. Seaton has 15 feetthat's not taken up by road. The rest, 85 feet, is awide road that they use for staging, parking, and themain access road. That's an area on the GDP and on thesite plan that's designated to grow the vegetation issupposed to grow back naturally. No vegetation is ever 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 145 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING going to grow back there. This guy is going to belooking at a road forever for this whole project. Idon't know how they can justify saying that that is nota violation of the buffer. That was it. Thank you,sir.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you, sir.Anyone else wish to speak for the appellants? NO RESPONSE FROM THE PUBLICMR. KOLAKOWSKI: Seeing none there, thosethat wish to rise to speak against.MR. HILLDRUP: Ron Flemming.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Is Mr. Flemming, I amassuming it is Mr. Flemming.Have you got another?MR. HILLDRUP: This is the only one.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Ma'am, do you wish to rise?MS. PARRIS: I have the written ones to read.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Let's make sure we get theverbal. Any verbal comments?MS. ENGLE: I would like to say something.I'm Elizabeth Engle and I work for SPower. Youknow, I do think it's really important tounderstand that the basins are constructed and 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 146 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING designed from a civil engineer aspect. They drainand treat the water before it leaves the site. So,it's just, it's something that I think is missingform this a little bit, is the connection tooutside drainage areas. It's not like we just putbasins wherever we want. They actually have to goand be designed. So, that's all I have to say.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay. Could you give usyour address, please.MS. ENGLE: Yes, I'm at 844 Chelmford Road,Chesterfield, Virginia 23235.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you.MS. ENGLE: Thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay. Last call for anyverbal comments anybody wishes to make? NO RESPONSE FROM THE PUBLICMR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay, seeing none, we didhave a number of written comments, and it's goingto be a tag team, I guess, reading these. Do youhave them by for and against?MS. PARRIS: Yes.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Any of them specifically forthis one case, or they cover both cases? 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 147 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MS. PARRIS: They cover both cases.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay. So, we need to keepit in mind that this is for both cases. And wewill enter them into the record, as such.Whoever wants to start first. Do you want to doit first?MS. PARRIS: So, these are in support of theappellants.The first one is Deborah Banks, no address wasprovided. I would like to voice my opinion againstSPower, whereas this project has been approved and intheir claims of being committed to residents' wellbeing.I believe they need to immediately correct theviolations they have committed. They need to realizethat they are building next to a neighborhood and thatmeans taking extra care to live up to their agreements,creating buffers and working expeditiously to helpcorrect damaging and distressing circumstances theycreate to their neighbors. If this means taking extratime and money, then so be it. It is better to get itright the first time for those in the adjacentneighborhoods that must live with its effects for alifetime. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 148 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MS. CURTIS: This is from Claudette Taylor,11500 Henegan Place, Spotsylvania 22551, LivingstonDistrict.I am strongly in favor of the CCSC appeals. It isquite obvious that SPower does not plan on keeping therequired 100 foot buffer that was required. What elsedo they plan to do, not taking into consideration whatis required? We as a community have expressed ourconcerns about the buffer of 100 feet from day one.Please listen to us.MS. PARRIS: Richard Janelle, resident ofLivingston District. In March of 2019, our elected Spotsylvania CountyBoard of Supervisors approved by formal vote a SpecialUse Permit for the solar project. The SUP included acondition requiring a 100-foot wide vegetated buffer bemaintained around the entire perimeter of the solarsite. The purpose of this condition was to insure avisual and noise buffer between the solar infrastructureand nearby residences and properties. Some time lateran unelected county official apparently granted a waiverto the SUP condition allowing the solar developer tobuild erosion control infrastructure, retention ponds 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 149 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING base and swales, and roads within the 100-foot vegetatedbuffer. In some locations, erosion controlinfrastructure was constructed within the 50-foot limitof development stints from the adjoining property line.Clearly, retention basins and roads are not vegetativein nature. They are, in fact, a required part of thesolar site infrastructure. Constructing erosion controlinfrastructure and roads within the 100-foot vegetationbuffer is not consistent with the spirit and intent ofthe SUP condition approved by formal vote of our electedsupervisors. An additional waiver was apparentlygranted allowing the basins to be built to temporarystandards. The size of temporary basins need only besix feet wide at the top, which is insufficient bycounty standards for planting landscaping, trees andshrubs. This restriction limits plant and landscapedtrees and shrubs a minimum of 25 feet from the toe ofthe basin wall. In some locations, the basins have beenbuilt within 25 feet of the property line, which makesplant and landscaping trees and shrubs impossible evenin locations where sufficient space exists. The growthof landscaping trees and shrubs will likely be stuntedbecause the sun will be blocked in, blocked on one side 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 150 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING by the basin wall and on the other side by dense standsof tall trees growing on adjacent properties. Consequently, there will be no vegetative buffer inthese areas as required by the SUP. The two waiversthat were granted by the county staff had the effect ofdeleting the 100 foot vegetation buffer requirement fromthe SUP without due process. These changes should havebeen subject to public comment and voted on by the Boardof Supervisors. Since the waivers were illegallygranted, the Board of Zoning Appeals should strike themdown and require the solar developer to comply with theSUP buffer and setback requirements as requested inZoning Appeals A19-0003 and A20-0001.MS. CURTIS: Kathleen Hayden, 11414 SeymourLane, Spotsylvania Courthouse, Virginia 22551.Hello, and thank you for the opportunity to sharemy concerns about the zoning violations at theSPower sites. The buffers and setbacks areabsolutely essential to protect the values of theadjourning properties. At numerous Board ofSupervisors' meetings prior to the approval of theSPower project, the importance of setbacks andbuffers to protect property values were presented 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 151 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING by multiple real estate professionals. I am aresident and realtor in the community that borderthe sites. In my experience, the marketability ofthe parcels bordering the site has been reduced bythe projects. Adequate buffering and setbacks arethe only measure of protection promised by thecounty. These are currently not being enforced,and that puts landowners at risk of property valueloss. It also further stigmatizes all otheradjoining properties because market value isinfluenced by the perception of the quality of theproperty. If the public perceives that theseminimal requirements are not being enforced, theywill assume that the enforcement is at risk alongthe many miles of border. You must enforce theseprotections in order to protect the property rightsof all the adjoining landowners. I urge you toplease vote in favor of the CCSC appeals beingconsidered tonight. Thank you.MS. PARRIS: David Hoffmeister, 11006 LakeHaven Way, Spotsylvania resident. My home is verynear to the perimeter of the SPower power plant andit will be visible to my family for many years to 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 152 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING come. The Spotsylvania County Planning Commission,County Board of Supervisors, SPower, and thecitizens spent many hours for over a yeardeveloping and agreeing to a Special Use Permitthat's supposed to protect the citizens ofSpotsylvania County and the environment. It isincumbent upon the county to verify and enforce theSPower and all parties obey the county lawsincluding any and all SUP requirements. SPower isopenly and purposefully not adhering to the SUP tolower their costs resulting in harm to some peopleof this county, as well as the environment. Aminimum 100-foot vegetation buffer is usuallyunderstandable. It is primarily included in theSUP to protect the people. This is not a debateover the merits and value of solar power, it isabout respecting the people, landowners andproperty of this county. SPower is essentiallyrenting land in Spotsylvania as a large powerfulcompany with high priced lawyers and politicalcontacts that is wielding its influence to makechanges that harm some people who have no abilityor resources to compete with their influence. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 153 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING SPower may use their promise of nonlegally bindingmonetary donations to the county to influence theBoard of Supervisors to allow changes to the SUP.This would be unethical behavior, at best, andshould not be allowed. Any SUP changes that effectthe people of this county should be required to gothrough the same planning process as the originalSUP. Otherwise that planning process was a sham.I want to be a reasonable neighbor and work withSPower for the common good, but their current lackof adherence to the SUP leaves me disgusted. TheBZA and the Board of Supervisors have theresponsibility to represent the people of thiscounty, especially those most affected by thisenormous power plant. That means you must simplyrequire and enforce SPower to adhere to theoriginal requirements of the SUP that they agreedto meet, including the 100-foot vegetation bufferand other stipulations. Thanks for your time inlistening to my comments.MS. CURTIS: Dan and Lori Schmidt, no addressprovided. Thank you for the opportunity to addressthe identified violations concerning SPower's 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 154 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING construction of its solar farm in SpotsylvaniaCounty. Since the beginning of the construction,SPower has flagrantly and with impunity ignored theapproved construction site rules and requirements.There are numerous examples of violations thatinclude roads, storm water control measures,valuable basins that control water flow anddistribution. Additionally, dangerous overheadpower lines are placed inappropriately inside therequired 100-foot vegetative buffer, violating thespecial use requirements. The entire 100 footbuffer that included right sized and essentialtrees and shrubbery to abate noise and line ofsight and heat, have been totally ignored. Thestorm water operation and structures should beconstructed at least 100 foot away from theproperty line to insure non-interference with the100 foot buffer.As you are aware, the Board of Supervisorsincreased the buffer to 100 feet at their April 9, 2019,meeting. This change was instrumental in keeping anappropriate buffer between homes and properties. Thisrequirement has not been enforced and in most cases 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 155 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING never been discussed with SPower for compliance. TheZoning Administrator has woefully neglected her job andrequired duties. Her responsibility should be toenforce the rules and requirements the Board ofSupervisors has approved. The administrator works forthe citizens of Spotsylvania County and for the CountyAdministrator. Why is she not being held accountable,especially now, so far into the construction phase ofthe project? Someone should examine and supervise herwork or lack thereof and find out why SPower is notbeing held accountable.It's unfortunate this project was approved and Iam sure we, most citizens, will regret this constructionand existence for decades to come. However, can ourelected and appointed officials ensure they obey therules that we have set forth for SPower to abide by.This is our county not theirs. Their clear and in yourface violations must stop and be corrected immediately.We implore you to do what is right and hold SPoweraccountable and make sure they follow the rules thathave been set forth.MS. PARRIS: Irving M. Chewning, Sr. He isco-owner of two properties, 13537 Post Oak Road and 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 156 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING 13520 Post Oak Road.I am sending this comment on be behalf of myselfand the property co-owners cc'd on this e-mail. Theyare listed as Catherine A. Bird and Irving M. Chewing,Jr.Our property has considerable water frontage incommon with the land that is subject to the zoningappeal discussion, and any precedents it will set forother unaddressed parcels. We consider any failure tohonor the original specified requirements of the100-foot setback border to be indefensible.Specifically roads and storm water basins should not beallowed within the setback borders. Thank you for theopportunity to comment.MS. CURTIS: Kim Koch. No address provided.I am against this solar plant. It is destroyingour county. What a big mess it is creating. Shameon you. MS. PARRIS: Mike Mikalosco, 11400 BluffsRidge, in the Livingston Voting District.I am writing in support of BZA appeal A19-0003filed on December 22, 2019. The appeal cites numerousviolations of a Special Use Permit issued to SPower for 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 157 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING phase one of the construction of the 165 megawatt solarutility approved by the Spotsylvania Board ofSupervisors as SUP 18-0001. The appeal describes theviolation of the 100 foot vegetative buffer that wasincluded in the SUP. Both SPower and the county havecome to an agreement on many conditions required for theapproval of the SUP, including the condition for a full100-foot vegetative buffer around the entire perimeterof the project.If SPower can ignore the requirements written inthe SUP without penalty, then they can continue carteblanch to violate these and other requirements knowingthat the county will not enforce them. Failure toenforce the SUP requirements will only set a precedentfor the remainder of SPower's construction of the solarutility under SUP 18-0001, 000202, and 0003, but willalso set a precedent for any future projects by SPoweror any other organization requesting approval from thecounty.SPower itself has pointed to the extensiveprovisions, conditions and regulations put into the SUPas indicative of their and the county's concern for theproper implementation of the solar utility project. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 158 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Please hold SPower to its own imposed standards byrequiring them under penalty to follow all theprovisions stated in the SUP 18-0001.MS. CURTIS: Katherine Phillipp, 10504Chatham Ridge Way, Spotsylvania 22551.I'm writing to urge you vote in favor of theconcerned citizens of Spotsylvania appeal. I want youto strictly enforce the buffer and setback requirementspassed by the county regarding the construction of theSPower solar facility.I drove down Chancellor Meadows Lane and wasappalled at the muddy runoff and lack of trees and lackof space to even plant vegetation in the mud. Iattended some of the hearings last year and I distinctlyremember the Board of Supervisors increase the buffer to100 feet at the April meeting. SPower is clearly inviolation of this requirement. There should be a full100 feet of trees and shrubs around the entire perimeterof the project. It's obvious that the construction isway too close to the property line. I feel so bad forthe citizens who live on Chancellor Meadows Lane. Please enforce the SUP requirement and vote infavor of the BZA appeal A19-0003 and also appeal 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 159 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING 20-0001. Thank you for considering my request.MS. PARRIS: Deborah McCarthy, 11400 MeadePointe. I'm writing in support of the zoningappeal brought forward by concerned citizens whichseeks to hold SPower accountable to the SUPstandards set up for 100-foot buffers. There arecurrently roads, storm water control structures,such as basins and relocated overhead power linesthat are placed inside the required 100-footbuffer, which is in direct violation of the SUPrequirements set forth by Spotsylvania County. Thecitizens of this county should have the full100-foot buffer full of trees and shrubs and itmust be provided around the entire perimeter of theproject. Storm water facility should be placed atleast 100 feet away from the property lines so theydo not interfere with the 100-foot buffer. The100-foot buffer full of trees and shrubs allows forvisual screening, noise and heat abatement. Theseare major issues, particularly because there arefamilies and property owners that are located nextto this monstrosity.Currently there are areas with only a single row 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 160 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING of trees or none at all. Not following the SUP is justirresponsible, greedy, spiteful and disrespectful ofSpotsylvania citizens who pay the taxes in this county.The use of bullying tactics, intimidation, tormenting,brow beating, and in some cases forcing citizens to payfor engineers to assess their boundaries that SPower hasdecided to encroach upon.Please stand up for the people of this county. Ifyou are willing to allow this outrageous overreach by acompany coming to do business here, then you have noground to stand on with any other project coming to thecounty. I ask you to stand up and hold SPoweraccountable with all SUP conditions and force them toretro-correct and move all construction they haveestablished in defiance of requirements. The entireproject is far too big for the area it is in. WhileSPower was able to get this monstrosity to move forward,they are running roughshod over anyone in their path. Iask you to hold them accountable.Protect this county from any predator who seeks todeny the conditions set forth by decisions made by thecounty.MS. CURTIS: Susan Noon, no address provided. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 161 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING This e-mail is in reference to appeals made to theBZA by concerned citizens of Spotsylvania onDecember 22, 2019, and February 7, 2020.My continuing concern as a resident of Livingstonarea of Spotsylvania is that blatant violation by SPowerto the agreement they made with the Spotsylvania board.Buffer zones, vegetation, just to name two of theviolations of the special use requirements. Why is thecounty approving site plans with numerous violations?Why is the financial gain, what is the financial gain toSpotsylvania County or the Board or persons to continueto look the other way? As you are well aware, an overwhelming majority ofresidents of Spotsylvania County were not in favor of asolar facility of this size in a residential setting.So far, our Board of Directors is not concerned withSPower following the guidelines they agreed to and theBoard is not concerned with the opinion of the residentsof Spotsylvania County.Still hopeful you will hold SPower to theiroriginal agreement.MS. CURTIS: Ron Morris, no address provided.I am in support of the CCSC BZA appeals and should 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 162 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING be upheld with your decision. Any work that is out ofcompliance with changes to the original approved SUP forthis massive solar plant should be corrected immediatelywith a stop work order written to SPower until everyitem in the CCSC appeals are corrected.Appeals are A19-0003, and A20-0001. Please voteto affirm the CCSC appeals as written and presented. Dothis on behalf of all Spotsylvania citizens.MS. PARRIS: Edward and Dorothy Migliore.11605 Pine Hollow Lane.Reference: BZA appeals A19-0003 and A20-0001.Why are we at this stage of the SPower project?After vigorous debate on both sides and an argument bySPower and the county on the management of this project,it now appears that SPower does not wish to abide by theagreement.After reviewing the issues, we strongly recommendthat the BZA to vote in favor of the CCSC appeals andrequire the county to strictly enforce the buffer andsetback requirements agreed to.MS. CURTIS: Ernest and Joanne Booth, 11223Chancellor Meadows Lane. For 28 years, we have resided at this address. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 163 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING The location of the iron pipe property markers on thefour corners of this property is recorded in Deed Book374 page 13, dated August 21, 1975. Our house plat andthe deed recorded in Book 1036 page 47, SpotsylvaniaCounty Circuit Court Clerk's Office, on May 13, 1992,verifies these same coordinates. On these, the westernedge of all the properties on Chancellor Meadows Lane isa straight line at north 19 degrees, 12 minutes, 25seconds west.Since this project began, we note three differentsets of coordinates for our western property line andSPower's site plans, several surveys have been done, andup until last month, all have matched our recorded line.We note the wooden LOD markers, 16 feet 5 inches fromour southwest corner, less than the required 25 feet.The berm at the end is approximately 75 feet from thatLOD marker. There is insufficient space to plant thevegetation listed in the SUP without compromising theintegrity of the berm beside the sediment basin behindit.Additionally the space, when full, does not filterthe sediment nor does it then allow good out flowwithout pumping, so cloudy, muddy affluent often crosses 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 164 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING through our property to reach the Norton prong, a feedercreek eventually leading to the Chesapeake Bay. On May 5 to 6, just two weeks before this meeting,a new independent survey implies our property line issuddenly incorrect, in effect seizing 3,000 square feetof our land to avoid correcting SUP violations. TheSpotsylvania County Board of Supervisors has issuedopposition to these appeals, claiming we have nostanding even though we can see this from our frontdoor. And SPower has sent mail to non impactedresidents asking them to call us liars, trying to stalltheir project. And he has here that he has submitted photos forverification of the concerns. And we ask the BZA to vote in favor of theseappeals and require Spotsylvania County to strictlyenforce the buffer and setback requirement of the SUP.MS. PARRIS: That's all I had on the opposed.MS. CURTIS: That was it for those in favorof the appellant.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay. And so you have -- MS. PARRIS: Those in favor.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: -- against. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 165 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MS. CURTIS: Yes.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay. Read away.MS. PARRIS: Chad Sanders. No addressprovided.I would like to voice my support for this projectwhich the BZA is reviewing next week. SPower has beenin compliance with all of the conditions from the SUPapproved last year, and they are in the progress ofbringing an amazing facility to our community. It'salso pretty clear to me we have a great company in ourcommunity with what they donated locally duringCovid-19.Opponents of this project continue to put theirown interests ahead of what is best for our community.This is the same tactic of delaying progress as lastyear. I'm urging the BZA to deny the opponent's appeal.MS. CURTIS: Matthew Ray, 8105 Linden OaksCourt, Fredericksburg, Virginia 22407.I work on the Spotsylvania Solar Energy Centerconstruction site. I am grateful to have a job at thistime because I know of multiple friends across thecountry that are currently unemployed due to theCovid-19 pandemic and this job allows me to provide for 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 166 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING myself and pay my bills. Without this job I would be ina very difficult spot financially.Both SPower and Mortensen are providing a greatplace to work by providing hand sanitizer and handwashing stations, as well as encouraging us to followCDC recommendations both on and off the job site. Inaddition, we are provided a safe place to work wherepeople do work in the safest way possible and areencouraged to point out safety problems and improvementsthat can make a task less dangerous or less straining. This project also does community involvement withhelping from local Food Banks to volunteering time atlocal schools. In my experience of traveling forconstruction, large scale projects like the SpotsylvaniaSolar Project helped the local economy by bringing morepeople to the area for both construction work, as wellas to run the facility once built. This increases homesales and rentals in the area. Projects like this onealso greatly help small business such as grocery stores,restaurants, car dealers, mechanics, gas stations andmany more. Overall, I am very happy to have my job here atthe Spotsylvania Solar Energy Center. This job helps me 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 167 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING to support myself while also helping the local economyfor the duration of construction, as well as intocompletion.Lastly, the way in which SPower and Mortensen arerunning the job, shows that they care about how theproject is run. The people working on the project andthe community as a whole.MS. PARRIS: Peggy Brewer, 12812 Orange PlankRoad, Locust Grove 22508.In late March, Bridgett Ennis visited at our hometo introduce herself and asked if we had any questionsor concerns regarding the project and to let us know wewould be seeing an increase in truck traffic. We aredirectly impacted and our concerns have mostly beenregarding the traffic on Orange Plank Road and moreimportantly our driveway is hidden from vehicle traffictraveling east on Orange Plank Road. Due to a few largetrees on the edge of our property, we are havingdifficulty being able to see when it was safe for us toexit our driveway, as well as those traveling east tosee us, and then adding the increased traffic of thetrucks exiting the project, we became pretty anxious.Bridgett was responsive to those concerns, and reached 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 168 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING out to the project manager and they agreed they couldassist us by removing those trees. Their concern andcompassion for our situation and more importantly, thequick response, was greatly appreciated. I am pleasedto say the trees are gone, we feel much safer and ourinteraction with SPower has been extremely positive.MS. CURTIS: Robert H. Ryan, Port Royal,Virginia. I work for Mortensen on the Spotsylvania Solarsite. My home is in Port Royal, Caroline County. I'man engineer by education and career. I joined Mortensenalmost two years ago when they built a site in Montross,Virginia. I have worked as an engineer my entirecareer, many for a Fortune 500. I was so impressed withthe safety culture of this company and their sincerepositive relationship with employees and community, thatI joined the company permanently. In my 30 year career,it's the best company I have worked for being local. Iknow many working at this site and it is truly ablessing for them and their families.MS. PARRIS: Mary E. Hartigan, 11602Sarrington Court, Fredericksburg 22407.I would like to voice my support for SPower in 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 169 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING this latest attempt by their opponents to disruptSpotsylvania County's progress into a future of fossilfree power generation. The SPower facility is both astep toward a cleaner environment and a leading edge toeconomic growth in our county.MS. CURTIS: Nancy Costello. No addressprovided.We support. MS. PARRIS: Gloria Danielson Hinkle, 10717Gordon Road, Spotsylvania 22553. To the Membersof Planning Commission. I grew up on the corner ofHood Drive where the Royal Farms now sits. I haveseen many changes in Spotsylvania County and I havenot always agreed with decisions made by thecounty, but I believe this project will be an assetto the community, and the inconveniences theneighbors are experiencing during its constructionwill be resolved just as it was when the interstatewas built in my neighborhood all those years ago.MS. CURTIS: Ellen and Ray Wiseman. This is in reference -- no address provided. This is in reference to the appeal to the solardecision. As long time residents and voters in 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 170 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Spotsylvania County, we have had our share of neighborsinterfering with what we would like to do with our land.We bought the land, tended it, paid taxes on it foryears, and yet we were not allowed to sell the land toan assisted living facility. Eventually this doeshappen, but only after a change in county supervisorsand some neighbors.We did not benefit nor profit from the currentfacility. Our belief is that a person should be able todo as he wishes with his land if it does not interferewith the use of another person's land. People whosemain objection is just not in my back yard, areextremely selfish. We think the solar project should goahead as planned. Thank you for your consideration.MS. PARRIS: Jim Engle, 567 Iron Point Lane,Cobbs Creek, Virginia 23035.I am a technical consultant for a local utilitycompany, who is very impressed with SpotsylvaniaCounty's commitment to the future growth and health ofour country. The SPower project is a valuable investment inenergy independence with the additional benefit ofreducing their future carbon footprint. The economic 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 171 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING return to your county and your citizens will be realizedfar into the future. I live in Matthews County, wherewe have been hoping to benefit from such a rewardingopportunity. I understand this project is massive. Some ofyour citizens have their concerns and these matters mustbe discussed and addressed.You are fortunate that a company as professionalas SPower is leading this venture, and I am certain allappeals can be resolved. You and your county should be proud to be such animportant player in our state's energy policy of being100 percent renewable energy by 2050.MS. CURTIS: Ben Bailey, 700 Meadow LaneNorth, Minneapolis, Minnesota 55422. We really appreciate the opportunity to build thisamazing project in your county. My family has beenwelcomed into our neighborhood and we have been able toget involved with the Mustang Mentor Program at RobertE. Lee Elementary, where my two girls attend school,participate in the STEM Programs at local high schoolsand be involved with cleanup projects around historicsites along the Rappahannock River. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 172 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Mortensen and SPower is a strong proponents ofcommunity engagement and we do our best to cast apositive vibe on everything we do. This project isproviding hundreds of local jobs where team members arelearning how to perform challenging tasks safelytechnical skills, leadership skills, and a sense ofaccomplishment that will benefit them and the communityfar beyond the completion of this project.I'm grateful for the opportunity to help Virginiaprogress towards its goal of 100 percent electricity forrenewable energy sources by 2050, and that SpotsylvaniaCounty is willing to be part of the decarbonizationmovement to help provide a cleaner future for those whocome after us.MS. PARRIS: Laura McLeod, 813 HanoverStreet, Fredericksburg 22401.Every large building project usually runs into anfew code violations along the way that have to becorrected as the project progresses. That's why youhave code inspections. You correct the problem and moveforward with the project. The same goes for this solarproject in Spotsylvania County. Keep it rolling to setthe future in motion for clean energy. Thank you for 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 173 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING your time.MS. CURTIS: Isabel Rodriquez, 6901 AspenLane, Spotsylvania, Virginia 22551.I live in Spotsylvania and I am in support ofsolar because I believe this is the only way to achievesustainable energy production. This project willbenefit our community, not only by supplying cleanenergy to our schools, homes and hospitals, it will alsoprovide jobs for more people within our community.Doing so would be a great step in leading this state byexample to achieve Virgina's clean economy act.MS. PARRIS: Randall Shrader, 6311 WendoverCourt, Fredericksburg, Virginia 22407.I work on the Spotsylvania Solar Energyconstruction site, and I am grateful to have a job atthis time. As a local Veterans Community Leader, I seethis project as a boost not only for the local economy,but as an opportunity for many veterans and other peoplewho are in need of a good job. This project is aperfect example of two large companies not only justbuilding a site, but two companies who are concerned fortheir neighbors and local area as a whole.Both SPower and Mortensen are developing this site 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 174 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING in a safe and responsible manner, even more so at thistime. As you are aware, swift action has been taken tomitigate traffic, truck traffic on local records. Wework hard at ensuring our traffic adheres to the SUP.SPower environmental and compliance teams are veryactive to insure we are good stewards of the land andareas around us.Think about the 500 or so people who are workingat this site. Yes, many came from across the country,as this is their profession. They are hard working,honest Americans who want to do a good job, and they aredoing great. Better yet the couple hundred local peoplehired from all walks of life are working hard to seethat Spotsylvania is successful as an example to showthe power industry that we have the wherewith all tolead the east coast into the future of power,environmental stewardship and community support. Lastly as a state leader of a VeteranOrganization, I would like to thank Spotsylvania,Mortensen, and SPower of taking on this great task inour community, support our veterans, charities andproviding meaningful job opportunities to many in thistime of economic difficulty. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 175 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Do the right thing, keep the solar energyconstruction site open without delay.MS. CURTIS: Jim McCloud, 8205 Gold MineCourt, Courtland District 22407.I want to say that I fully support the SPowerproject. Three weeks ago I toured the project site andI was most impressed with the operation. The stormwater run off measures taken were some of the mostimpressive that I have ever seen. In the early 1970's,I worked as an assistant geologist with PiedmontMinerals on an erosion control project on land next toContrary Creek in Louisa. I also helped mitigate andtreat mine water discharge from the copper mine, so I'mfamiliar with storm water abatement and management.In my personal opinion, from direct fieldobservations, the SPower facility is being constructedwith measures that meet or exceed federal, state andlocal standards. The general contractor building theproject, Mortensen, has built many similar solarprojects, therefore they know how to build a solarfacility correctly from preparing the land withspecialized equipment, constructing roads with properdrainage, placing metal piping, constructing solar panel 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 176 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING racking and by completing a fully working solar section.The operation has many different kinds ofemployees that interface well to create the picture of awell oiled machine. Spotsylvania County is fortunate tohave an ongoing, large project like this to supplementour tax income during a time of diminished funds becauseof Covid-19 problems. The county is even more fortunateto have a quality run operation by Mortensen and SPowerwho are living up to the compliance of SUP and the 180additional conditions.MS. PARRIS: Martin Horechny, 4113 CrossgateDrive, Lee's Hill, South, Fredericksburg 22408.I would like you to know that I am in favor of thesolar power facility being constructed in the county.Solar power appears to be safe and clean. It is a quietneighbor once construction is complete. It will bringrevenue into the county and will provide full timeemployment, while enhancing the county's reputation forenvironmental protection and power generation.MS. CURTIS: John McQuade, no addressprovided. I'm a drone pilot for the Spotsylvania SolarEnergy Center, helping to evaluate land, make sure 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 177 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING things are being installed as designed, and surveyingthe project. It's really cool to be in something that Ihave always been interested in. I have gained a ton ofexperience and learned a lot about flying drones on thisproject. The opportunity to expand my skills as a dronepilot while also receiving other on the job training,will be beneficial for job opportunities down the road.Growing up in Orange, next-door to theSpotsylvania Solar project, I love that I am helpingbuild the future of energy production right here in thisregion. I hope you all allow the project to continue.MS. PARRIS: Jane E. Todd, 152 RingneckTrail, Mooresville, North Carolina 28117.I have frequently traveled in other countries andwas always impressed by the large number of solar andwind sites. Tour guides would give us the percentage ofenergy provided to the areas by such sites. I alwayswondered why I had not seen such sites in the UnitedStates. My wish has come true with this SpotsylvaniaSolar Energy Center. I am proud to say that my niece,Liz Engle, is part of the team responsible for thedevelopment and maintenance with a safe site with theenvironment as their primary concern. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 178 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Although my primary home is located inMooresville, North Carolina, my husband and I own landin Grayson County, Virginia. I was born in Virginia, soI am pleased that the State of Virginia is leading theway with alternative methods of energy production.MS. CURTIS: Patricia Busk Zinelle.I worry about climate change, so I am enthusiasticabout Spotsylvania having SPower setting up its solarenergy site in our county. I think it would supportgood jobs that would produce revenue for our county.Hopefully it would also encourage other businesses inour county to use solar, to use solar, as well.MS. PARRIS: Savannah Brown, Edinburgh Drive,Spotsylvania 22553.My family and I live in Spotsylvania, and I am insupport of SPower and this project because I believethis is the only way to reach our sustainable energygoals as a nation. This project provides a boost to ourlocal economy while supplying clean energy to ourschools, homes and hospitals, which is critical whenfacing uncertain times such as now.MS. CURTIS: Bridgett Ennis, 1306 ConfederateDrive, Locust Drove, Virginia 22508. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 179 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING I hope this finds you well. As you are aware, Iwork as the Community Liaison for the Spotsylvania SolarEnergy Center. I moved here to Locust Grove fromMassachusetts to set down roots solely because of it. Ihave always worked with the public, but working on thisproject teaches me something new and useful every dayabout renewables and educating others about the manybenefits of this growing industry.I was able to meet with members of theSpotsylvania School Board, who shared my growingenthusiasm for renewable energy, and we discussed atlength all the career pathways we would be able toexpose students to by introducing them to this projectright in their own county. This is just a small exampleof why I'm proud to do this work in this community andwhy I am proud of SPower. Having us as a communitymember means we will be here for decades not only tooperate, but to be involved.SPower holds education about renewables in highregard and we hope to share this passion and knowledgewith others. Additionally, SPower cares deeply aboutthe needs of the communities that they become part of,and will always pitch in to a just or necessary cause. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 180 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING For example, SPower arose to the occasion to lend aideduring the recent Covid-19 pandemic. We are a sponsorfor FR K-9, First Responders K-9, a nonprofitorganization whose volunteers train and deliver servicedogs for injured fire, police and emergency personnel.We have donated $200,000 to Mary Washington Healthcare,$50,000 through the community foundation of theRappahannock River Region to benefit regionalnonprofits, and we just made donations to SpotsylvaniaFire and Rescue Foundation and The Friends of TheSpotsylvania Sheriff's Office Community Policing. Thiswas all in addition to sponsorships and donationsalready made to Spotsylvania County Law Enforcement,Fire Departments, schools, Little League and more. Allof this in just a few years. Imagine the impact SPowercan have in the community after decades of involvement.Caring about the community as a whole is only partof it. In my job, I speak with individuals one on one,and hear their complaints, concerns and questions. Atno time have any of these concerns been met by SPower,nor any workers on the project, with indifference.Whatever is within our means and power to accomplish forthe comfort of our neighbors, is always considered and 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 181 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING discussed at length. In my experience, I'm alwayssupported when trying to find ways to help neighboringresidents through this transitional period duringconstruction. I watch this company follow through ontheir promises to the very best of their ability, timeand time again. This is a company that just trulycares. We care about clean energy and saving our planetfor future generations and working diligently, safelyand responsibly. We care about educating youth aboutrenewable energy and all the career paths this boomingindustry has to offer. We care about the businesses,residents and organizations in our communities.I encourage you to continue to allow us to buildour project here. The growing relationship betweenSpotsylvania County and SPower has the potential to dogreat things for this area. I personally am excited tonot only be a part of it, but also benefit from it as aneighbor to your community. Thank you for your time.MS. PARRIS: George Graves, address 1525Heatherstone Drive, Fredericksburg 22407.Courtland District.It is obvious that certain residents of Fawn Lakeare sore losers. Even after approval from the county, a 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 182 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING few of them are trying to harass the developer even tothe point of hiring a law firm to argue their pointsbefore the BZA. Reminds me of the tree sitters andothers who are determined to stimy the construction ofthe much needed natural gas lines in Western Virginiaand West Virginia by using illegal and political systemto stop a much needed infrastructure project, causingmultiple job losses and increase cost to citizens. Veryself-centered. After rest regarding the information reported onthe county website regarding the issue, those appealingthe Zoning Administrator's ruling seemed to be graspingat straws. Their current complaint focuses on bufferrequirements. Not sure what their next complaint willbe. As I understand it, some of those appealing thedetermination do not live near the project, but Ibelieve they have recruited some of the adjoiningproperty owners to act as surrogates to carry on theirattempt to stop or cripple the project. It is obviousto me that the county has the power to require thedeveloper to meet the spirit of the SUP regardingbuffering and that the developer is eager to work withthe county to satisfy those requirements. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 183 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING I urge the members of the BZA to fully support thedetermination of the Zoning Administrator and if theydisagree with that determination, I urge them toencourage the county and the developer to modify theconstruction to meet the spirit of the SUP. It is quiteobvious that the developer is eager to be a goodneighbor as evidenced by their active support of variousprograms located in the county. Of course, in anyproject, there are those activists who try to stopdevelopment in the county and this seems to be theirlatest attempt. Thank you.MS. CURTIS: Art Shiago Realty, 401 ChathamSquare Office Park, Fredericksburg, Virginia 22405.As a resident of Spotsylvania, I have read thetalking points of SPower, and I agree and support thesolar farm in Spotsylvania.MS. PARRIS: David Meadows, 12410 Five AcrePlace, Locust Grove 22508.My name is David Meadows, and my family and I ownclose to one-half mile of land that adjoins SPower'scurrent construction area, and I would like to say thatthey have been good neighbors since they purchased theland. I support solar power as a positive renewal 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 184 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING source that helps eliminate pollutants in the air andwater while subsequently reducing global warming. I amno fan of the concept of not in my back yard (NIMBY).My family and I believe that it is our Christianobligation to try and do what is best for our county,state, nation and our world with the blessings that Godhas bestowed on us. This project fills the bill.We purchased the land that we sold to SPower inmid 1960, and have used it for recreation, farming,weekend family gatherings, church, youth retreats, andthe pleasure of being alone in nature with the creator.God has been good to us and we have been blessed, but asin Lamentations, there is time for everything and itbecame the time to let 400 acres of our property go fora bigger cause. Clean energy.We owned the land that borders Mr. O'Bier'sproperty on two sides, long before Chancellor Meadows,where Mr. O'Bier lives, existed. As a familypartnership, we had a study of our timberland done andwe were shown that our timber needed to be cut, so wecarefully selected a timber company to harvest our land,making sure they would use best management practices.Mr. O'Bier sued my brothers and me over the timbering we 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 185 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING had done using BMP. This is the first and only timethat I have be sued in my 75 years of living.Mr. O'Bier lost the suit. If you were to go to the westof Mr. O'Bier's property and look back at it, you wouldthink he was the one that needed to put up visualbarriers because of the junk trucks, ATV's, pipes, junktractor and other miscellaneous eyesores on hisproperty.SPower, on the other hand, has been responsive onthree occasions when we had reasonable concerns. On oneoccasion, they had spent a great deal of time, effortand money to construct and plant a water retentionsystem only to have two and a half inches of rain beforethe grass could get established. With no prompting fromus they returned and once again spent days repairing thedamage from the heavy rain. On a second occasion, theymet with us and discussed what kind of landscaping wewould like in the area where we can easily see thepanels. The landscaping is not in yet, but if thecounty approves the plans we are asking for, they willinstall it this September. We are requesting fallbecause the mortality rate of the plants will be lowerthen if planted now. On the third occasion, we were 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 186 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING concerned that several cars were being parked in adirect view line from our home. We were informed thatthey needed the space for vehicles during constructionbut they would look for workable solution. Only twodays later, they installed a fence that hide the vehicleparking.I could go on, but you get the picture. SPower isa good neighbor who is trying to do the right thing butis getting undue pressure from NIMBY people. Please let SPower continue with the important workthey are doing to make our county, state, nation andworld a better place. Thank you.MS. CURTIS: Tiffany Tripaza, no addressprovided.I am writing as I am appalled to hear that thearguments against the SPower projects are still wastingyour time. I hope that when you consider the complaintsagainst them, you can realize that this company has comein and quickly followed through with promises to localnonprofits with their donations, and I have never onceexperienced any issues with the construction site ortraffic while driving to either Miller Farm or to pickup my CSA, Walmart or Food Lion at Locust Grove to pick 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 187 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING up my online order.Further in the BOS meetings that I attended I tooknotes of the people complaining about the reuse of thisformer timber harvesting property and could notunderstand why anyone would complain about solar panelsover ravaged land. After looking into those filingcomplaints, I quickly saw the light. For example,Mr. Sean Fogarty, Fawn Lake resident, according to hisprofile works as a recruiting consultant at Excenture, acompany known for the lobbying for oil companies. Andhere there is a website inserted.Further, Greg Mueller, another complainer, isbehind the CRC. And again, there is another websitereferenced. Which has questionable ties to Fox News,which is likely why this misleading news was publishedby them. And again, there is another link to a Fox Newsarticle that appears to have the title, Massive EastCoast Solar Project Generates Fury From Neighbors InVirginia.I am sure you are all tuned into this, however asa property owner in Spotsylvania County, whose taxesjust went up significantly on our property, the worstthing that I could see happening in our county is 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 188 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING driving away business, especially business that is goodfor the environment. Thank you for your consideration.MS. PARRIS: Jason field, no addressprovided.I'm writing to voice my support for SPower in theSpotsylvania Solar Energy Center. Support for solarenergy and the Solar Energy Center is in Spotsylvania'sbest interest as it provides jobs, income for thecounty, increases our energy independence as well asreduces our overall environmental impact.I strongly encourage you to support SpotsylvaniaCounty and SPower. Thank you.MS. CURTIS: Matthew J. Gise, no addressprovided.On behalf of First Responder K-9, FR K-9, ourBoard, community service, and numerous volunteers, Ihumbly write to inform you all of our new foundpartnership with SPower, and share with you the value Ibelieve they bring to both FR K-9, our mission, andthose we serve. FR K-9 represents a vision to give backto those that make everyday, unsung sacrifices for theircommunities. Our objective of placing highly skilledservice dogs with retired police, fire, EMS officials 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 189 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING that have incurred life altering events would go undonewithout those within our communities who understand theimportance of what we do, and the incrediblesignificance of those we support.At present, FR K-9 has 18 dogs all in variousphases of training. Some of which are actively employedwith Police Departments right here in the State ofVirginia, where they are assigned to clinician and peersupport personnel, and utilize them as a preemptive toolto deescalate situations, reduce anxiety and stressassociated with the intensity of being a firstresponder, as well as in some cases, leverage duringvictim interviews to assist interrogative personnel.The victims of violence and sexual crimes, alike, forpurposes of minimizing the trauma specific to theexperience they may have suffered.SPower has become an integral partner of FR K-9,with their recent sponsorship of FR K-9 Brooks, a yellowLabrador Retriever named in the memorial of Chief Brooksof Spotsylvania County Fire Department. Chief Brooks'career and life exemplified commitments and sacrificeand it is those qualities that will be brought to bearin support of a first responder in the future that will 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 190 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING need the care, love and nurturing spirit of thewonderful dog currently in training that will eventuallybe placed with an every day hero who needs him. FR K-9cannot do what we do for those we do it for withoutcommitment, trust and partnership of our community basedorganizations, and businesses that have elected tosupport the financial needs associated with raising,training, placing and maintaining these amazing animals.On average the cost associated with the care of aservice dog in training is approximately $25,000 to$30,000. Barring additional costs associated withveterinary expenditures that are often unknown and justas often exponential. SPower's generosity and passionfor our mission will most certainly go on to enhance thelife of someone in our community that will desperatelyneed it.As a former resident of Spotsylvania County, a taxpayer in the State of Virginia, and the president andCEO of FR K-9, I wish to openly recognize SPower as avalued member of our organization, and one that Ibelieve will bring great value to the county andresidents, as well. Should you wish to discuss thispartnership further, or have questions with respect to 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 191 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING FR K-9's role in supporting our first responders, pleasedon't hesitate to contact me directly.MS. PARRIS: Alan Meadows, 12400 Five AcrePlace, Locust Grove 22508. My name is Alan Meadows. My family soldapproximately 400 acres to SPower that is now part ofthe solar project in western Spotsylvania County. I wasand still am completely in support of this project. Ourcountry has been seeking ways to provide clean,renewable, sustainable energy for decades. In myopinion, there is no better and longer lasting sourcethan our sun. This program represents the future of ourworld.I have already seen the positive economic effectthe project has had. There have been many jobs createdand more to come in regards to maintenance and upkeep ofthe facility. SPower and Mortensen have been diligentin addressing the issues that have arisen and have seenthat all items of concern have been resolved. We havenot had one single negative interaction with them andexpect the same moving forward. The interactions speakto the character instilled in the workers by thecompanies and give me faith that the right thing will 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 192 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING always be done.I would ask a double edged question to those whooppose the project. Is your opposition truly for thegreater good, or do you have selfish reasons to oppose?Every time SPower addresses and resolves concerns from acommunity, someone from the NIMBY community digs aroundfor anything else they can find to try to slow or stopprogress of the project. The whole idea of NIMBY isselfish. If not here, then where? It's my opinion thatthese folks are simply unwilling to embrace change.SPower has gone above and beyond what has beenasked of them, both in the planning phase and executionphase. They have met or exceeded local, state andfederal guidelines in terms of protecting theenvironment. They have worked with both supporters andopposition of the project to ensure satisfaction. Whatgood will it be if the project is completely halted? Will the neighbors in opposition be willing to do theirshare to fix issues that arise if SPower isn't around tobe held accountable? My guess is no. And by the way,things have been dragging along, they will always try tohold SPower accountable whether they are here or not.Thank you for taking the time to read my letter. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 193 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING I sincerely hope that SPower is here for a long, longtime.And I have some voice mails.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay.MS. PARRIS: Ms. Hardigan called to expressher support for the plan as they had previouslybeen approved. She thought this matter had beensettled and the dispute was over.Mary Pope lives in Partlow, Virginia 22434. Shewas talking to someone on the phone and understands thatthe solar energy passed but now someone is opposing itor the county is opposing it. Whatever is going on, thesolar power needs to be left alone. Solar energy is thefuture of the world. She thinks the county will get agood deal, too, as she understands the county can buysome of the energy back at a reasonable rate. Sherecommends to leave the solar energy be, as it is thefuture and we do not want to live in the past. Thankyou.Rosselle Reif, no address provided. She received a call, a card in the mail regardingsolar power. She is very much in support of the countyhaving a solar power facility. She understands there 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 194 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING are other people that are concerned about the countyhaving a solar power facility, but feels she would havemore concerns if another housing project had beenapproved on the property where the solar power facilitywill be. She is very positive that the county's solarpower project, and is very sorry that there is so muchopposition to it. She is hoping for a positive outcomefor the dilemma.Texis Van Davender, 206 Pender Street,Fredericksburg 22408. She is a retired teacher and resides inSpotsylvania County. She would like to educate everyonethat solar power is the way to go. She put her voicebehind the support of solar power. She is sorry thatpeople are spreading rumors about solar power and againis completely in support of solar power. James Morris, no address provided.He received a post card and wants to say he is insupport of solar power and the jobs that it will create.Stan Kloda, no address provided.Please be informed that my wife and I support theSPower solar project. It was approved by the Board ofSupervisors after an extensive review, including 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 195 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Virginia Tech, and other experts. So now the oppositionis launching another campaign to disparage a very goodproject. I just noticed that the appellants includeO'Bier, a plumber who worked on my house and left manyleaks. There is also another guy named Hammond, whoportrays himself as the best chemical engineer in thecountry. I and he worked for the same company, ExonResearch and Energy Company. Believe me, he isexaggerating his competence, which excludes solar powerplants, period.The best example is my neighbor who objected tothe SPower project because it would eliminate land fordeer. This is the same person that petitioned FLCS/NTSdevelopers to sponsor a deer kill in Fawn Lake so thather shrubs would not be harmed. The SPower project makes sense on many accounts.It was already approved by the Board of Supervisors.Thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: All right. Thank you verymuch for reading that.That concludes our public hearing. I would askthe Board, in a motion, to put into the record thematerials that were provided today, as well as the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 196 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING materials that we previously were provided. MR. STEPONGZI: Mr. Chairman, I so move thatwe make the motion to add the materials into therecord.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Stepongzi andMr. Hilldrup second. Any discussion? NO DISCUSSION FROM THE BOARDMR. KOLAKOWSKI: Any discussion? All thosein favor say aye. ALL ANSWER IN THE AFFIRMATIVEMR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay. What's the pleasureof the Board?MR. STEPONGZI: Mr. Chairman, hearing all thearguments this evening, I believe the mostcompelling argument right now is the question onstanding for the applicants, in that if they don'thave, if it's decided they do not have standing,then we lack the jurisdiction to entertain theirappeal. And I believe right now we need to makethat decision before we go forward to work on theappeal, hear the appeal.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay. What I'm hearing isthat we should decide on the standing question 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 197 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING that's before us. Anybody want to opine on it orwant to hear my opinion?MR. STEPONGZI: Well, Mr. Chairman, let me goahead and make a motion, then we can go discuss it.And my motion is that all the applicants havefailed to show standing by not demonstrating thatthey fully meet the aggrieved person's requirementand thus the BZA lacks the jurisdiction toentertain their appeal.MR. HILLDRUP: That's your motion, sir?MR. STEPONGZI: That is my motion.MR. HILLDRUP: I second.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: There is a motion andseconded, appropriately seconded. Discussion?MR. ALLEN: I would like to add that by therule, such a hardship is shared generally by otherproperties in the same zoning district or thevicinity, and such a variance is contrary to theintended spirit and purpose of the ordinance.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Other discussion?MR. STEPONGZI: Mr. Chair, the reason why Imade the motion tonight is when listening to thecounty attorney make her arguments and talk about 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 198 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING standing this evening. I felt they were verycompelling that the issue of aggrieved persons wason point tonight, and that the issues that therewere no, there was really no argument made as towhat their grievances were, how they wereaggrieved. Yes, they didn't like the berm. Theberm had some esthetic values, it was too close,they wanted it moved back, but as was made by theZoning Administrator, the berm, whether where it'splaced now or moved back, it's going to be thesame.MR. HILLDRUP: It's been seconded. Are wegoing to vote on it?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Well, I would like to make acomment. It's in discussion. Did you want to saysomething?MR. HILLDRUP: No.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Any other discussion? NO RESPONSE FROM THE BOARDMR. KOLAKOWSKI: I would like to make acomment and really state, and I think we arepunting the decision if we don't provide forstanding of the adjacent property owners. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 199 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Notwithstanding what the county attorney has saidin response to my question, in my mind, I feel itis up to whether a Circuit Court or the VirginiaSupreme Court to decide the standing, but I thinkit's important that adjacent property owners, theyhave a right to petition their government and theZoning Administrator and it has been dulyadvertised, that we have spent a good amount oftime talking about their appeal of what the ZoningAdministrator has opined. I feel like the ZoningAdministrator has been correct in it, and I thinkwe should stand up and vote on the merits of thecase. And I think it's important that the citizensthat have brought their appeal, be appropriatelyheard and not use this as an excuse to answer thequestions.The bottom line is, is that any party can appealour decision afterwards. But I think we should do theright thing. Let the citizens be heard and then vote itup or down. And you know, that's my opinion.MR. HILLDRUP: Are you talking about thisfirst case?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: This first case. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 200 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. HILLDRUP: First case.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes, because we have anothercase.MR. HILLDRUP: I know, but it's the same.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Right. Yeah, the subsequentcase has many, many things and hopefully we will gothrough that.MR. HILLDRUP: So, did you want a motion forthis case?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes.MR. HILLDRUP: Well, I make a motion we deny--MS. BISCOE: There is a motion on the floor.MR. HILLDRUP: Oh, about what you talkedabout?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: You. You seconded themotion. You can withdraw the second. The motionwould then fail due to a lack of second, or we cando a substitute motion.MR. HILLDRUP: It's up to you to make themotion.MR. STEPONGZI: I feel the motion needs tostand. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 201 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. HILLDRUP: Okay.MR. STEPONGZI: That because by law, wecannot, the applicants need to have standing beforethey come before us, and that is something that hasbeen brought up. We need to address. I understandyour need, your concern that you want to go andhear the appeal, you want to make a decision on it.A decision will be made. It will be probably atthe Circuit Court level, and that's probably whereit needs to be made, because if we start opening upand looking at everything, we are not prepared, asa Board, to start looking at, well, what about thisengineering aspect, that engineering aspect. Therehas been a lot of stuff discussed, and we don'tneed to rehash out the SUP. We really don't.That's not our job.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Well, I would say to you, weare not, in my mind, we are not rehashing the SUP,we are making a determination of whether the ZoningAdministrator's decision, with the standing of thepeople that are making the appeal, is it correct orincorrect, or needs to be modified.MR. BRAMLETTE: Mr. Chairman. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 202 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes, sir.MR. BRAMLETTE: It seems to me that there isno doubt in this two step process, that thelandowners right next to this property are, infact, qualified to put in this appeal.The second step is the part that concerns theBoard. And in that respect, I will say that I feel thatthey have suffered some harm by the placement of theberm, not the fact that the berms are not allowed insidethe buffer, but by the placement of the berm being wellinside the buffer, it places them a visual aspect thatthey have to put up with. So, I'm agreeing with you inthat, I think they need both of the steps. They areadjacent, obviously; and two, that they are harmed insome specific matter.MR. STEPONGZI: Mr. Chairman, Mr. Bramlette,how are they harmed? Define it, please.MR. BRAMLETTE: Well, they put the berm thatclose to my property, it would upset me a littlebit, versus being at the 100 feet away from me.Now, 100 feet is from me to that first windowcomplex there, maybe a little bit more, whereassome of these are less than 20 feet. So, you know, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 203 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING that's like not too much from behind me and thewall here. So, it's the aspect of someone has puta wall right up next to me, is a problem.MR. STEPONGZI: I understood it's close.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Stepongzi, before wedebate the merits of the case, I think we have anappropriate motion on the floor, whether we feelthat there is, your motion is that there is nostanding by any of the applicants or theappellants.MR. STEPONGZI: All four, that's all four forthe aggrieved persons. That's step number two.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay, it's been moved andduly seconded that for case A19-003, that the fourappellants do not have standing and therefore thecase should be dismissed. Does everybodyunderstand that is what the motion is?Okay, are you all ready to vote? Any additionalconversation? NO RESPONSE FROM THE BOARDMR. KOLAKOWSKI: Okay, all those in favor ofthe motion say aye. RESPONSE FROM THE BOARD 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 204 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. KOLAKOWSKI: All those opposed, nay. RESPONSE FROM THE BOARDMR. KOLAKOWSKI: I think we need a role callvote. I guess I call the role, right.MR. STEPONGZI: Show of hands.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: All those in favor say aye.There are four.All those opposed? Three. The motion passes fourto three. So the first case is dismissed.All right, with that, we go on to our second casethat we have tonight. MR. STEPONGZI: Mr. Chairman, could we takeabout a five minute recess, five to ten minutes.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Five minutes.MR. STEPONGZI: Five minutes?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes. Five minute recess. SHORT RECESS TAKEN MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Our second public hearing.Do you want to call that to order. And it isA20-0001. We will follow the same process that wedid for the first hearing. Hopefully, we will be a 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 205 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING little bit briefer. We are covering a lot of thesame ground, so I would ask, one, the presenters tojust provide us any information that differentiatesit from the first case, as well as any othercomments that they have that are for this case.With that we will start with Ms. Pomatto.MS. POMATTO: Thank you, Mr. Chairman.The case A20-0001, the difference with this case,as there are additional appellants. The appellants areMichael O'Bier, Brenda O'Bier, Zach Stevens, SeanFogarty, David Hammond, Joanne Booth, Ernest Booth andRobert Leith. All but Sean Fogarty and David Hammondare adjacent to the project area. Mr. Leith is adjacentto the overall project area that was enabled by theSpecial Use Permits. He is not adjacent to the phaseone project area that we just considered.So, in the essence of time, I'm going to adopt thepresentation that I gave previously for this case. Idon't have any other additional points to make or toaddress. The only thing I did want to clarify one moretime is just to answer Mr. Bramlette's question aboutthe berm, and the location of the berm.The Exhibit H required that a berm be placed 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 206 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING within that 100-foot setback. So, by enforcing that,SPower did not have a choice to put it outside of the100 foot setback, and there were no other requirementsin the conditions about where, within that 100 feet,that the berm had to be located.And the only other item I would point out on theberm is the vegetation. That is going to be avegetative berm. There will be landscaping at the toeof that berm or in the instances where it is adjacent tothe embankment of the berm, that landscaping will bepulled out 25 feet. But you are going to have a row ofevergreen plantings. You are going to have it filled inwith evergreen shrubbery. The entire berm will bestabilized with a native seed mix so this will grow andbecome part of that vegetative area altogether. For thatmatter, the basin will, as well.That basin, in the pictures that you see, is in atemporary condition. It is meant to hold that waterthat is running off from the site. It's muddy waterbecause you have a di-muted site. So, you have muddywater going into the basin, and as it discharges, it'smuddy. When this site is stabilized, that pond will beconverted to its permanent condition. It will be 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 207 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING stabilized with vegetation, so even the pond itself isgoing to be completely vegetated. That will operate asa dry basin, meaning it's not meant to hold water forextended periods of time.The entire SPower site will be vegetated evenunderneath the panels. So, when you have that raincoming down, hitting the vegetation on the site, that'sclean water going into that basin, being held for verytemporary period of time, and that clean water is beingdischarged at the same rate that it was dischargedbefore SPower ever got onto the site.So, that was the only points that I wanted toclarify that had been questioned. I am happy to answerany questions, but that's the extent of my presentation.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you. Members of theBoard, questions?Mr. Allen.MR. ALLEN: Ms. Pomatto, to the best of yourknowledge, have any NOV's been issued as a resultof on site inspections or monitoring by thePlanning and Zoning Officials? If yes, have theybeen corrected?MS. POMATTO: Yes, sir. During the course of 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 208 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING construction, this project was approved with, Iwant to say 169 conditions to be enforced. Andsome related to construction traffic, some relatedto disturbed acreage. They covered a wide numberof items. The Zoning Office has issued a total of15 notices of violation since they beganconstruction, all today have been resolved.MR. ALLEN: Thank you very much.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Bramlette.MR. BRAMLETTE: Just a followup. The bermbasically now is defined and set by the Board?MS. POMATTO: Yes, sir, that's correct.MR. BRAMLETTE: And so that's out of ourquestion altogether, but what isn't is where theroads and the storm water collection is behindthose berms.MS. POMATTO: Well, I would argue that theroads were decided as well, based on what wasapproved on the GDP. The basins, as I stated in myposition earlier, the basins are infrastructure fora development. Mr. Leming makes the point thatinfrastructure connectivity only means certainthings. Well, you can't pick and choose. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 209 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Infrastructure is infrastructure. A storm waterbasin is collecting runoff from a site and it isdischarging into a drainage way, into a channel.That is infrastructure connectivity.So, my position, based on how the conditions readand what was allowed within the setbacks, again gettingback to Exhibit H, looking at Exhibit H should, no wheredoes it say buffers. It says setbacks. This is thesetback and this is what can be in the setback. Andthen you have condition E-6 that specifically says whatcan be in the setbacks. It says access roads. It saysa number of other things. But the berm itself wasrequired by the SUP, and SPower, I don't have theauthority to say it can, you know, it can be relocatedelsewhere.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Any other questions?Well, thank you, Ms. Pomatto. And Mr. Leming.MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. With your permission,I'm going to come to the table again.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: You are welcome.MR. LEMING: Thank you.Okay, Mr. Chairman, members of the BZA, I'm Clark 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 210 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Leming, and I am here on behalf of the applicants.And let me start by saying that I don't want anymember of the BZA to assume that the standing issues inthe two appeals are identical. They are not. And themain reason that they are not, number one, we haveadditional applicants in different areas, but we alsoare dealing with a determination now.The entire issue was cast, and incidentally, thisdetermination was filed, the request for thedetermination was filed with the county just three daysafter the site plan was approved. So, there was nosecret that the applicants were seeking thedetermination from the Zoning Administrator; and if youhave read the request for the determination, it setsforth their position. So, everyone was in, that is thecounty, SPower, everybody was on notice as to what wasbeing sought here. Now why it took two and a halfmonths to get the determination, I don't think Ms.Pomatto has responded to that. But that's what it took.But everyone understood that's where this was headed, Ithink, from the git go.Now the reason that the standing issue isdifferent in the second appeal, is because of the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 211 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING breadth of the determination, and what Ms. Pomatto saysin her first paragraph, "My response applies to each ofthe three permits," recall there are three specialpermits at issue here, "Regarding those conditions, asapplicable to your request." So, this particulardetermination is going to govern the course of what canbe done with the berms forever more here. And based onwhat's happened, it gives nearly carte blanch to thedeveloper to continue what is going on now, and that isthe construction of BMP's, storm water ponds, roads,within the 100 foot vegetated buffer.So, now specifically, and I want to go back to myoriginal comments because I think that this is stillcontrolling, and I said this last time, and maybe someof you understood or agreed with this argument.Obviously a majority did not. But the whole standingissue, remember we are talking about a statute here thatsimply says who was aggrieved. An aggrieved person mayfile an appeal. So, what does aggrieved mean, and wheredo we look for an understanding of that. The courtshelp, but none of the decisions, none of the discussionthat has occurred before you this evening has to dodirectly with what that means at this level. It is all 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 212 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING at the next level. Now does it mean the same thing?Here is why I do think that all of these adjacentproperty owners, and let's dispense with Mr. Fogarty andwith Mr. Hammond for just a movement. We have fouradjacent property owners here, and we have an ordinancethat establishes, and I shared that with you before, wehave an ordinance that establishes the whole point ofconditions. This is not like a rezoning where there areproffers made, these are conditions that are there forthe express purpose of protecting the persons in theabutting and adjoining properties, period.So, now, there was a comment made that, oh, well,the ordinance doesn't, in and of itself, conferstanding. Well, of course not. We are trying tounderstand what aggrieved means. And what you havereceived, particularly from the Board of Supervisors, isan exceptionally narrow dissertation about what thatmust mean. It is simply not that narrow, and there isnothing in the case law that would suggest that that isthe case.So, we have ordinances that set up the adjacentproperty owners as the beneficiaries of the conditions.Now, it remains my position that that establishes that 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 213 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING if the conditions are alleged not to be interpretedcorrectly, that they have standing to allege that,because they are the ones that are intended to be thebeneficiaries. So, I think frankly that it's thatsimple, particularly at this level.Now, when we get into the, when we get into thecase law, you heard about two cases tonight. You haveheard about Friends of The Rappahannock, which dealtwith a Zoning decision, a discretionary decision. Mostimportantly, the Friends of The Rappahannock seats upthis two prong test, but there is no application of thesecond prong of the test, the particularized harm prongof the test. And the reason for that is because therewas no allegation of particularized harm. The appealwent up from the plaintiff, and the plaintiff'sattorney, alleging that it was enough just to be anadjacent property owner. And the Supreme Court said,no, you have got to, there is more to it, there is aprong two. Well, the complaint that had been filed withthe Circuit Court were silent on that. There was noallegation. There was an opportunity the court providedto amend the complaint, and that was rejected and theywent straight up on the appeal just the adjacent 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 214 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING property owner, period. So, we do not have guidance onparticularized harm. And I would have said that if Ihad rebuttal for the first appeal, but you all arecreating new law here. There is nothing that coversthis, notwithstanding anything.The county attorney particularly wants very muchfor you to extend and she wants you to push and pull andbring that Friends of The Rappahannock over to you andtell you what particularized harm is. Well, there is nostandard for that and not one created by Friends of TheRappahannock.Now there was also this cross reference to thisold Virginia Beautification case. VirginiaBeautification case is so simple. VirginiaBeautification tried to appeal this variance, but theydidn't own any property at all. They weren't adjacentproperty owners, they weren't any kind of propertyowners. So, that's why that case didn't go anywhere andthe Supreme Court, you know, agrees that the VirginiaBeautification does not have standing. Not much toargue about there. But that's not where we are. We aredealing with adjacent property owners here.Now, there is some, and this is different because 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 215 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING we have a very, very broad determination here from theZoning Administrator. Now, you conceivably could arguewith regard to the first appeal, well, we are talkingabout two adjacent property owners, and it's just thislittle section, but what we have now is a determinationthat extends this for the life of the project and everysingle buffer that is going to be developed to protectthe adjacent property owners.Now, specifically, we do have some moreinformation here, and this was provided to you from ourletter that you received today, the standing letter.First, we have a letter, this is L-2, and let's, can wetry to bring up one of the photos here. And this is theBooth property now. You heard a letter from Ms. Booth.She is not, she is not here tonight to speak, but thisis, yeah, this is the one. I want you to, this is whatthey are looking at. This is what the Booths arelooking at right now, okay. Now, all this wetness, you know, you remember where the buffer is at the berm andhow close that is to the property line here. So youhave got all of this coming from this BMP that'sestablished on the other side of the berm at the toe ofthe berm. And all of that is coming over here. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 216 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Now, the point here, maybe there is a way tocorrect it, I don't know, but it's a mess. Now, itwouldn't have happened if you didn't have a BMP in the100 foot buffer area as Ms. Pomatto originally decidedwas the correct interpretation of these proffers, or theconditions.Now, in addition let's see, let's go to L-4.Mr. O'Bier was, and you had this before you, and shameon me for not pointing it out, but this is what, notonly Mr. O'Bier, but what Mr. Stevens sees now when theylook out from their properties toward the berm. I don'tthink there is too much question that it is simply amess. So, that's what they are looking, that's howsuccessful, and our position, quite simply, is that thereason for this is because of the location of theseBMP's and the locks they have chosen to put the berm in.Now, there was some discussion about this earlier.What's driving the choice for the location of the berm?Is it, oh, well, we can put it anywhere? Maybe. Butwhat appears to be driving the location of the bermchoice is what they want to do with the BMP on the otherside of the berm. So, that's improper and that'scompletely inconsistent with Condition 9. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 217 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING There was also some discussion about the clearingthat already occurred and it not being possible forthere to be a violation of Condition 8. And there maybe, technically, an argument there. But the reason,there was what, next to Mr. O'Bier's property andMr. Stevens', there was a 60 year old stand of trees.It was removed just prior to SPower's purchasing theproperty, and it was removed, according to Mr. O'Bier,because it was contractually required to be removed bySPower. That was a condition of the purchase, that theproperty be clear cut like this. So, they didn't haveto deal with it.Now, technically, did SPower cut down any trees?Probably not. Their predecessor, the Meadows did. Theyare the ones that engaged in it, but they did it at thebehest of SPower. So, a little bit misleading to saythat SPower had nothing to do with that.So, now, so with regard to standing. What we do,what we have, and what we have is the same issues aslast time, and I think it's a little clearer from thesephotographs about the visibility. Let me see the reportfrom Mr. Nicely, the Dewberry report.Yeah, this is the, and this was included with our 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 218 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING letter also, it's L-5. I'm not sure it's necessary tolook at this. I can read the portion. Now, yes, thisdid come in in November 26, 2018, but this was the groupthat was retained by the county to look at the issue ofthe heat created by the solar farm.And I direct your attention and these are numberedas part of something else, so there is a page 61 at thevery bottom, and it says that Dewberry offers thefollowing recommendations based on the independentresearch in SPower's executive summary. Now, there area couple of bullets there. The second one is what'simportant here. "The vegetative buffers and berms mustbe installed with shade trees, as well as shrubs tocreate a dense screen and maximize absorption of anyradiative heat." So, that was the recommendation of thecounty's own contractor and expert retained to look atthat issue.Now, I read to you in the last hearing an e-mailfrom counsel for SPower to the supervisors in March of2019, explaining why they were offering the additionalbuffer, and specifically referenced, even at that latepoint in time, this is how things got resolved, butspecifically referenced at that point in time is the 100 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 219 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING foot, a new, going from 50 to 100 foot minimumvegetation from all adjoining property lines forpurposes of screening the view and the heat island.They get into the heat island again. And property valueexperts, which is another issue here, and something thathas been alleged in the comments that you heard lasttime, is what is going to happen. You had an opinionfrom a real estate broker read to you. As I understand,those letters are supposed to cover both of thesehearings. So, you had a broker tell you that there isno question that the co-location of these homes next toSPower are going, the value of their property is goingto be negatively impacted, particularly because of whatis not being done with the buffers here, and what's notplanned to be done.Put aside for a moment the status of growth ofthings on the berm. We know now we are not going tohave shade trees, we know we are not going to haveextensive vegetation, because of what's already been putinto place. And that was addressed at the very end. Sothis allegation that, oh, this was all wrapped up andeverybody was fine with it, is simply not the case ifthe counsel, if counsel for SPower was still addressing 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 220 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING it just prior to the vote on the SUP. So, it's a viableissue, and to the extent that the buffer does not complywith what I think are the clear requirements of theconditions, to the extent, we don't get that 100 footvegetative buffer, the protection that was envisioned byit is diminished.All right. Now, so for purposes of standing, Imean, you have some pretty clear graphics here. Youhave an allegation that property values are going to bediminished. So, there certainly is a visual andesthetic component to this. And, and we still have theheat island affect, and not that it hasn't beenaddressed, but it was addressed through the concept ofthe 100 foot vegetative buffer with shade trees. Thatwas the whole point.Now, all of the applicants that are before youthis evening, are either looking at something, such asthe pictures that we covered, or have that pond, thatBMP located very close to their property lines. So, forpurposes of standing, and given the breadth of theopinion or the determination that has been provided toyou by the Zoning Administrator that we are viewingtonight, given the breadth of that determination, then I 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 221 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING don't think there is any question at all with regard tothis appeal that these individuals, for what it's worth,have met both prongs of the Friends of The Rappahannocktest. They have articulated, particularized harm.Now I will tell you this also, there was theattorney the county suggested that Ms. Pomatto didn'thave any ability to raise the standing issue at herlevel, but you know what, there is a big differencebetween saying, okay, here's an issue that's going tohave to be addressed at the BZA, and saying nothingabout it until other parties chime in the last week orless than a week before the hearing, and say, oh, thereis a standing issue here. Okay. The point is simply,we addressed it, I think, but the point is simply itcould be much better and more effectively addressed ifit's something that, unlike any other appeal that I'maware of that's ever come before this Board, if it'ssomething that's going to be expected, yeah, I think theapplicants are entitled to notice that you need toaddress that. Okay. Whether the Zoning Administratordoes anything with it or not is another matter, butcertainly you would expect that that would be somethingyou would be notified that needs to be addressed. And 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 222 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING in some cases it's much more significant than others, asit's turned out to be in this case.Now, with regard to the substance again, andthankfully, you will be pleased to know that there ishere a fair amount of duplication, and I will not goback through everything that we talked about the firsttime. Now, we still have an important conceptualdifference between setbacks and buffers. Buffers, thebuffer requirement is the buffer requirement. AndCondition 9 is pretty clear about what is required.Now, it's true there are some areas where berms can beput in. There is, however, as I said the last time, tothe extent that the berm is placed in an area thatbetween the buffer and the BMP behind it, completelydeteriorates any effective vegetation, that's notconsistent with Condition 9. That interpretation simplycannot hold, I think, for interpretation nine.Now, I won't say anything else about Condition 8,except that the clearcutting that occurred would nothave occurred without SPower coming into the picturehere and buying the property. So, they got somebodyelse to do that work for them. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 223 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Now, the buffers and setbacks, as we talked aboutbefore, they come from completely different sections ofyour Zoning Ordinance. And the condition in theordinance covering SUP's, very clearly distinguishes theability to develop, the Board to develop and impose acondition for setbacks versus one for buffers.Now, in the determination letter, there are twothings that are pretty clearly decided. The first isthat there is a distinction between setbacks andbuffers. Ms. Pomatto starts off by saying that. Ittalks about Condition 8, where the distinction isactually built in. There are two different things. Andthe fact that you satisfy one does not mean that yousatisfy the other.Now, the other thing, that there is no contestabout is that these things are actually in the, thesethings are in the buffer area. The BMP's, the roads,and the storm water devices.Now, I want to turn for a moment. There has beensome discussion about the road and particularly the onethat runs right along the buffer. Can we, let's see canwe pull up the GDP, and Dave, what I want is thatsection of the GDP that shows the road coming on to the 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 224 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING property. Do we know what page that is? It's L-12.So, it is X2-2. Well let me represent to you, and we will get tothis in a moment, this is sheet 2-2 of the GDP. Therehas been some suggestion, that, well, there was alwaysgoing to be a road running through the buffer. Well,this shows the entrance and it shows a, here is, I thinkthis is it, isn't it? Yes, the entrance way. If youlook at the, about the middle of the page at the topthere, it says entrance. Now, that shows, if we canzero in on that, that shows, see that blue line? Just aline coming right straight into the property. You know,there is no turn. That's the entrance road. That's theone that now turns and runs along the length of thebuffer. Yes, short distance, but it comes right, itcomes almost immediately into the property here, andthere is a very short distance where it runs paralleland should be on the inside of the buffer, not in thebuffer area itself. But it does run a very shortdistance and come straight into the property. Andthere, I think you can see how it's structured there.And so this was not something that was originallyplanned and shown, it's something that had always been 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 225 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING there. You know, that developed with the site plan, andof course, that's what, in the first appeal and in thisone, we are challenging, is the road that runs parallelwith the buffer.Now let's show this one picture. This is L-21.What I'm going to show you is a photograph that showswhere the road has been set up here. Here is thephotograph. Now, the buffer runs just to, if you arelooking, just to the left of the road there. That redline, is that the buffer line there, the red line?Yeah, so the road is actually just to the right of thisred line, and that's totally within the buffer. So, youknow, that's so much for that buffer.Now, I will point out that Fawn Lake is right atthe top there. This whole road, these houses that yousee right at the top, they are the ones, they arelooking in at the beginning of this. But this road runsthe entire -- this is Chancellor Meadow, for purposes oforientation there. You know, I think the correctreading of the conditions would require that this roadrun just inside the 100 foot buffer, otherwise, you aredefeating the purpose of the buffer. Run a road throughyour buffer, put a BMP in the buffer, a storm water 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 226 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING pond, you know, move your berms up so you can cram asmuch as you possibly can on the back side of the berms.And there is a big difference between the back side of avegetative berm and one that has to be strong enough tosupport a detention or BMP facility. Those aredifferent structures. So, that's what, that's what youare seeing there. And again we raised this the firsttime. Why is this being done? Is there not sufficientroom in 2000 acres to bring the BMP's out of the bufferarea? Of course there is. But you lose panels.Now, here is an illustration that shows how theroad passes through for ingress and egress. And this isingress and egress.Now, with regard to the conditions, again, becausethat's where we are, and I won't repeat this, but pleaserecall that under these, I won't repeat this in detail,please recall that under these conditions, you have apreamble of conditions dealing with setbacks leading upto the conditions that are of greatest significancehere. You have four, five and six, all dealing withsetbacks, a different animal than the buffers.Now, and there has been discussion one way oranother, there was a suggestion that the language used 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 227 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING at Exhibit H had the same standing as these conditionsdo. But if you read the conditions on their face,particularly Condition Number 10, I think it's very,it's at least implicit that wherever you have aconflict, and if that terminology was in error where itsays, use of the setback language on Exhibit H, then theconditions are what control, not the exhibits to theconditions incorporated or not. And that was certainlytrue with the GDP. And there is an ironclad statementthat simply says GDP shows one thing and the conditionssay something else. The conditions control.So, the conditions that control here now, andrecall that the violations, the alleged violations arefor both 8 and 9, and I get this business about no treesbeing technically removed by SPower from the 100 footbuffer, but they were removed very shortly before SPowercame onto the scene. But Condition 9 still stands onits own, because it makes very clear that the sharedboundaries between the property and abutting parcels,and we have got four abutting parcels now in-between theproperties of any VDOT right-of-way, shall be screenedwith berms and plantings, preserved vegetation,revegetated areas with plantings and vegetated areas 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 228 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING left to grow as applicable. There is nothing in hereabout BMP facility, nothing. There is nothing in hereabout storm water facilities. There is nothing in hereabout roads being within the buffer area at Condition 9.Now, these do correspond with the legend that welooked at at Exhibit H. So, each of these things thatis listed here is one of those things. They all have todo with plantings. Berms? Yes, you can do them. I dothink there is a, but it's very reasonable to say theberm should be placed in the position within the 100foot buffer that is most advantageous to those having tolook at it. And to the extent that the berm placementis dependent on wanting to put a BMP in, that can'thold. That is, it's completely inconsistent, I think,with Condition 9, and should not be permitted.Now, the arguments that SPower has made about, oh,well, we started construction, it's too late now, youknow, nothing can be done, you know, we relied on thisdetermination. Well, SPower knew very shortly, if notthree days after the site plan had been approved, thatthis determination request had been made, that there wassomebody, a group that was seeking an answer to whatthey saw was violations represented on the site plan. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 229 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Okay. So, I don't think that they can meet the standardof 2311(c), which says good faith reliance. Whatappears to happen is they moved forward as quickly asthey could, either without regard to the fact that therewas this question pending about the way they had setthis up, or perhaps to get to the point where you canclaim the protection of 2311. So, that I don't thinkbears any weight. And that was one thing that wasrelevant between the two appeals and why the firstappeal was made, because the argument was anticipated.Now, let's talk for just a moment about theconnectivity issue. Let's look at L-25. You know, thisis, this explanation from the Zoning Administrator isstill perplexing to me, no, baffling, because what,first of all, what she is doing is still completelydisregarding the fact that at Condition 8, there aredifferent things. You can remove the trees more than upabove and now she is extrapolating and saying, well,because of Condition 8, even though we are not talkingabout removing trees anymore, I get to do all of thesethings that are listed up at number six, that I can doin the setback. You know, so, it's an either or. Thesethings have to be reconciled. You cannot read one 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 230 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING condition and exclude the other altogether by readingthat in. The purpose and the effectiveness of thebuffer is decimated. So, that is one respect when,where I think that, you know, she is simply dead wrongin her interpretation of the conditions. I think theconditions speak for themselves. Different language,and a lot of discussion about the language that is used.Well, the best illustration is that, is the comparisonof the language between that last clause and Condition8, and the litany of things up in Condition 6.Different language, different meaning. And you have togive full effect to the whole thing and reconcile thesethings.Now, the exhibit that I have up here, this has todo with the connectivity issue, and Ms. Pomatto, in herpresentation here before this application, says that,well, infrastructure is infrastructure, and that's whatthe staff report says. Now there was some effort totalk more about connectivity this time because it wasobviously missing from the staff report. What we havedone here is to show illustrations of what we see isconnectivity. The water line coming in. These are ournotes, the entrances coming in, the electrical 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 231 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING connections coming in. These are things that eitherneed to come from the inside in or get from the insideout. And yes, those things, that's in infrastructureconnectivity. So, that is something that is permitted,at least under Condition 8. Now, you still have togive, I think, full force, as much as full force aspossible to Condition 9, which requires the buffer.Now, there was a suggestion that somehow thesystem of BMP's was infrastructure connectivity. Well,you have seen the pictures of the one property there,where, you know, what you are getting in the way ofconnectivity is drainage onto the neighbor's propertyfrom the BMP. So, that's not, that's not connectivity.Now, there may be internal connectivity between theBMP's on the site, but storm water provisions inVirginia are very clear. You have got to contain yourwater within your site.Now, the placement of the BMP's is, I wouldventure to say from an engineering standpoint, fairlydiscretionary. There may need to be some relationshipinternally and connectivity internally, but has nothingto do with the buffer, has nothing to do with thevegetative buffer. And those can be cited any number of 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 232 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING locations within this 2,000 site, rather than within the100 foot vegetative buffer there for the express purposeof protecting the neighbors.Now, let me see if there is anything else. I amalmost done, Mr. Chairman, here.Now, just reiterate that the whole idea that weare appealing something that should have been appealed30 days after the SUP's were adopted is simplynonsensical here, and even more so in this case becausewe have a zoning determination that was requested. Weare appealing the zoning determination. So, there isno, I don't think there can be any suggestion thatsomehow what we are doing now should have been done 30days after the SUP. And what we are challenging is notthe SUP. I'm not sitting here quibbling with thelanguage of the conditions. We are quibbling about theZoning Administrator's interpretation of the conditions.And I think at this point you all, every one of you canunderstand that, you know, there is some inconsistencybetween some of these. So, what is the interpretationthat gives meaning to all parts of these conditions, youknow, without leaving Condition 9 out in the coldbecause the Zoning Administrator has a preference for 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 233 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING Condition 6, and says that somebody, the PlanningDirector can come in and rescue it if there is a problemunder Condition 16. Condition 9 stands on its own andspeaks for itself, and is simply not being enforced.And is being ignored largely.Now, I believe that those are the, yeah, there wassome more discussion about a presumption that the ZoningAdministrator is correct. The statute says that, butthe statute goes right on to say, you know, ZoningAdministrator puts on their case, the applicant puts ontheir case, and if the BZA finds, with a preponderanceof the evidence, which is, you know, just a little more,then the decision, the determination should beoverturned. All right.Thank you all very much. I know it is very lateand I hope I get some credit for being somewhat morebrief.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Leming, we have got somequestions.MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Stepongzi.MR. STEPONGZI: Yes. You had presented acounty engineer's report. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 234 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. LEMING: Yes, sir.MR. STEPONGZI: When you were talking aboutthe heat -- MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. MR. STEPONGZI: -- island effect. Could youdisplay that report again, if you could. MR. LEMING: Sure. This was a, it's attachedto our letter that you would have received today.I think it's Exhibit 5.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Is that November 26.MR. LEMING: To that letter, that's correct,uh-huh. Now, this is, Dewberry is an engineeringfirm that was retained by the county specificallyto look at the issue of this heat island effect.And they provided an extensive report to thecounty. And what I was reading to you from, it's aseven or eight page document, which was attached tomy letter. And again, this is another problemwith, you know, trying to address something likethis at the last minute, and that could have beenavoided. But this is about an eight page letter.And I was reading to you from the recommendationsection of that. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 235 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. STEPONGZI: Right.MR. LEMING: At the very end of it.MR. STEPONGZI: Wasn't, we heard in the priorhearing that they were going to be puttingvegetation underneath the solar panels, the panelsthemselves, that was going to take care of the heateffect island. And wasn't that the decision thatthe engineer made to reduce it? Now, that, Ibelieve, was made in 2019, that supercedes this. MR. LEMING: That was what SPower's engineersproposed. And you are correct, it may have someeffect. But just prior to the final vote, theattorney for SPower is still talking about the heatisland affects, still raising issue, and using thenew 100 foot buffer as a means to prevent that, toameliorate and mitigate that. Let me be sure thisgets in the record, because I don't think this, butthis is, this is L-23.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: What are you talking about,Mr. Leming?MR. LEMING: Now, the reason that I sharethis with you is simply because that it indicatespretty clearly that the issue of the heat island 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 236 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING was still alive, notwithstanding what SPower'sengineers may have discussed or thought would be agood idea as far as grass was concerned. And veryclearly -- if we could just submit this so you havea record of this. There are several copies here.But the heat island effect appears to still havebeen at issue at the very end, notwithstanding what theSPower engineers had come up with. Moreover, that,whatever was proposed there was not consistent with whatDewberry came up with, which was large shade trees intheir recommendation. So, to suggest that there wassome kind of consensus that came together at the end, Ithink is incorrect.Now, yes, they want you to believe that that wasthe case now, but the e-mail I think belies that, andalso stands for the proposition that the 100 foot, the50 foot buffer was expanded to 100 feet, at least inpart, to address the issue of the heat island. So, Ithink that's pretty clearcut. Now, were there anyother?MR. STEPONGZI: Yes. I have got one otherquestion.MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 237 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. STEPONGZI: You talked quite extensivelyabout the SPower entrance road. MR. LEMING: Yes, sir.MR. STEPONGZI: How far away is that from thefour properties?MR. LEMING: Can we go back to that onepicture, I think is helpful.MR. STEPONGZI: Yes, that is fine. That'sthe one I'm looking at. I was looking at.MR. LEMING: Now, can you show your curserwhere the lake is.MR. HAMMOND: This is the Chancellor Meadow,so it is right across. And this road heads rightto Mr. O'Bier's house. MR. STEPONGZI: But the question you had onthe road was that it should be more to the right ofthe red, excuse me, it should be where the red lineis. And the question I have, if the applicantswere to have standing with this, wouldn't they needto be adjacent to it, that this would not evenfigure into the, into their complaint?MR. LEMING: Well, I guess it's a question ofwhat kind of distance are you talking about there, 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 238 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING and what is it that you want to be looking atacross from their homes that are right there at thetop of the screen. I don't disagree that theproperty that's immediately adjacent to that, thatthey are the ones that would be protected by that,but the benefit to these other owners over here issimply that you do have a full buffer on that sideof the property, the visual looking across thatvast expanse. And then you will notice at the top,that red line actually continues a little bitstraight, the road curves and looks like it goes onfor about 100 feet to where it would directly turnby, I gather, Mr. O'Bier's property.MR. STEPONGZI: The property owners to theright of the road with the entrance road, are noton the application, correct?MR. LEMING: That's correct.MR. STEPONGZI: Thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Mr. Bramlette. MR. BRAMLETTE: Reference Condition 8 and 9.MR. LEMING: Yes, sir.MR. BRAMLETTE: Would you agree that both ofthose are dependent upon Exhibit H? They both 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 239 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING back, for instance, 9, you were reading 9, but youstopped before you got to, as applicable accordingto Exhibit H. MR. LEMING: Yes.MR. BRAMLETTE: And then on 8, it says asshown on Exhibit H. So, Exhibit H controlled bothof these, do you agree?MR. LEMING: Yes, sir. I think that it does.And to bolster that, I think at condition 9, whatis spelled out there at the last part of thatcondition, corresponds with the legend on ExhibitH. It actually runs through everything, except, iteven includes the berms. Screens with berms withplantings, berms with plantings, preservedvegetation and revegetated areas with planting andvegetated areas left to regrow. Those are the fourspecific categories shown on Exhibit H.MR. BRAMLETTE: Unfortunately, there is notimeline as to when. MR. LEMING: No, you are correct. As to whenthose things have to be in place.MR. BRAMLETTE: Correct. MR. LEMING: I can't disagree with that. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 240 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. BRAMLETTE: Okay.MR. LEMING: Although, Mr. Bramlette, I wouldsay that, you know, the further the timeline goesout there, you know, the less effective the buffercan possibly be.MR. BRAMLETTE: I would agree, but you know--MR. LEMING: But it's not spelled out.MR. BRAMLETTE: Right.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: No further questions.Thank you, Mr. Leming.MR. LEMING: Yes, sir, and thank you all foryour indulgence here.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: We are burning the midnightoil.Ms. Wisegarver.MR. LEMING: Thank you all very much.MS. WISEGARVER: May I proceed, Mr. Chairman?MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Yes. MS. WISEGARVER: Jamie Wisegarver withHerschler in Richmond, Virginia, on behalf ofSPower. This is appeal number A20-0001.Board members, you should reach the exact same 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 241 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING result in this appeal that you reached in the firstappeal. There is, there is no reason for additionalanalysis, no reason to rehash what we have already goneover.I would like to adopt my previous arguments that Imade in the earlier appeal.I wrote down that Mr. Leming led off his mostrecent presentation by stating that the standing issueis not the same in the second appeal because this is adetermination as opposed to the earlier appeal of thesite plan. That is in direct contradiction to theletter that he submitted yesterday addressing standing.I'm looking at page three of that letter, sort of in themiddle under paragraph two where he states that theapplicants Stevens, Booth, O'Bier and Leith, all clearlysatisfy the Friends of The Rappahannock test as detailedbelow. It's the Friends of The Rappahannock test thatwe are talking about once again. So, it's the sameanalysis here, and for the same reasons, the appellantsdon't have standing in this case.For purposes of preserving the record, I wouldalso argue that the zoning determination request andsubsequent appeal is really nothing more than an attempt 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 242 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING to circumvent the operation of the statute that Idiscussed in my first presentation, which is the statutethat demands that only the applicants that file a siteplan can appeal a disapproval of that site plan to theCircuit Court. Again, refiling the same appeal as arequest for a zoning determination, doesn't change whatit really is, which is an improper appeal of a siteplan.We have talked a little bit about the standard ofreview today, but since we are now on the second appealthat involves the appeal of the Zoning Administrator'sdetermination, I think it's appropriate to emphasizethat this Board must presume that Ms. Pomatto'sdetermination is correct. And I know Mr. Leming wantsto undermine that presumption, but it's an importantpoint to make. The BZA can only reverse thatdetermination if it's contrary to the plain meaning ofthe zoning ordinance, which it is not. You must deferto her interpretation, which in this case is incrediblysound.There has been some discussion or some suggestionthat the tree cutting that occurred, that was undertakenby the previous owner of the property, was somehow at 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 243 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING the instruction of SPower. That's simply not true.There is no support for that in the record. In fact,quite the opposite. The Meadows family had a contractfor that land to be timbered long before they began anynegotiations with SPower.Even if these appellants did have the ability toappeal, which they do not, the site plan complies withthe SUP conditions. Ms. Pomatto's zoning determinationletter was sound. This appeal should be dismissed, oralternatively, Ms. Pomatto's zoning determination shouldbe affirmed.Unless you have questions, that's all I have foryou.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Questions?Thank you, Ms. Wisegarver.MS. WISEGARVER: Thank you very much.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Ms. Cooke.MS. COOKE: Good morning. My name is SusanCooke, and I'm Deputy County Attorney and this is,well technically, this is Case A20-0001, and asDeputy County Attorney my address is, what is myaddress, 9105 Courthouse Road, Spotsylvania. I'mgetting the numbers mixed up. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 244 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING I will not belabor the point, but I do have a fewissues that I have to address. Actually, I'm going to,first of all I adopt all the arguments I made in theearlier hearing, because they apply, as well, and thememos that I understand have been adopted into therecord, I believe. So, we can take care of repeatingeverything.I also want to echo what Ms. Wisegarver said aboutthe tree removal. Mr. Leming speculates that the treeremoval somehow, without any evidence, that it was doneat the behest of SPower when actually one of the lettersread into the record was from Mr. Meadows, who said thatwe hired a sylviculture expert. I was actuallylistening. We hired a sylviculture expert to tell uswhen to cut the trees, and that was the person that saidwhen to cut the trees, and his property bordersMr. O'Bier's on two sides and that's why the trees werecut. So, actually Mr. Leming isn't just speculating, heis dead wrong. So, you can't, you can't read intoanything for the fact that the trees were gone, exceptthe condition that Condition E-8 doesn't apply. Now,Condition E-8 is one of the interesting things, and Mr.Leming did stop reading at an opportune moment. He 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 245 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING suggests that the Zoning Administrator, and he uses aword, I wrote it down, but he was very disparaging whenhe says that, well, just because no trees are cut down,that doesn't mean you get what's in, you get to have allthe things that are in 6. Condition 8 only applies towhen trees can be removed. It says you can only removetrees for these reasons. It doesn't say, you can't doanything in the preserved buffer except foringress/egress and infrastructure connectivity. It justsays you can't remove trees in the preserved buffer foringress/egress or infrastructure connectivity. So, ifyou haven't removed the trees because someone elseremoved them before you got there, Condition E-8 isinexplicable, it's just gone. So, she was not wrong.Mr. Leming also says, oh, the fact that the road,and they showed the exhibit up there and they said,look, the road just goes in there a little bit, and sothat's ingress/egress. The exhibit where I showed theroad and then they showed the road, I measured that roadand I pointed out to you the key. And I would like youto measure it. It's 500 feet. And I adopt thatargument again. 500 feet is not just ingress/egress.They said earlier in their argument that ingress/egress 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 246 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING was just crossing the road at right angles and notrunning along the road. Well, this was a 50 footbuffer, not 100 foot buffer that was inside of 400 feet.I would also mention, and this is the interestingthing about standing, because Mr. Fogarty got up at thecomments and he put that up there and he talked aboutthe other property owner who is not a part of thisappeal, and how bad that road was for him. And thenthey pointed out where Chancellor Meadows Road is. Now,that's where three of the four applicants live. AndMr. Fogarty, who lives in Fawn Lake, way off the map,you couldn't even see it and point the curser there, wasactually suggesting to you that SPower moved the roadcloser to the three other appellants. I don't know ifyou noticed that. He said you have to remove the roadthat way. Well, that's farther away from someone whoisn't an appellant and closer to the three propertieswho are appellants. So, it just illustrates whystanding is important. You have to actually have aninterest because if you actually live right there andyou have that interest, you don't make that mistake.So, yes, and Mr. Leming also, he wants to say,look, and then he misspoke, Mr. Bramlette, when you 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 247 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING asked your question, he said Exhibit H is subservient tothe conditions. And he reads Condition E-10, and heallied certain facts. E-10 says, "Plantings required inExhibit H shall comply with the GDP's landscape plan."Except that to accept the GDP's landscape plan iscontrary to the conditions herein and determine -- theconditions herein shall supercede or control. Itdoesn't say the conditions supercede Exhibit H, it saysthe landscape plan. So his argument that earlier,before Mr. Bramlette's question that Exhibit H issuperceded and none of this applies, is just, it's justwrong. E-10 doesn't override.The standing arguments are the same. I'm notgoing to take the time. Storm water facilities areactually infrastructure that must be connected. Mr.Leming testified to you about several things he has noreport for. He says, by the way, you have to, drainageis infrastructure connectivity. You have to contain thewater on your site, that's law. No actually, that's notright. When you have natural drainage that goes fromyour site to another site, you absolutely, that'sVirginia law in drainage. It can continue to go to thatsite. What you can't do is increase it to the point 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 248 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING where it damages another site. It's not an issue here,but he is telling you the wrong law.He says, I dare to say the placement of BMP's isdiscretionary. Is he no expert on BMP's? He'stestifying to you. There is no evidence before you thatthe placement of BMP's is discretionary. He says toour, I just want to make this point, because I don'twant it to get lost. The point with the heat island, itisn't that, that they haven't reached consensus. Noparty had to reach consensus. The Board adopted theSUP. That's an ordinance. It doesn't matter what wenton beforehand. When that was adopted, that becomes law.And my point in pointing out to you Condition E-18 wasthey implicitly, but necessarily, rejected the heatisland effect when they allowed the Director of Planningto go back and increase screening, but not check forheat island effect. It doesn't matter what consensus,it doesn't matter who sent what letters. It's allbefore the Board. You can tell, you don't have to takemy word for it, you can see that the Board rejected it,and because of that you can't fuss with that now. Itwas decided in April of 2019, and the time to appeal itis longing. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 249 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING And I know everybody else's patience is long gone,and so I really don't want to belabor the point. It isexactly the same standing issue. Mr. Leith, I will doone more thing, if you look at your Exhibit Three to myfiling, it will show you that Mr. Leith's property, heis the only one added now, Mr. Booth is in-betweenMr. Stevens and Mr. O'Bier and Mr. Leith, he can't seeanything. The property, they are not building anythingnear him. They are saying, well maybe they might buildsomething some day, that's what we call speculative andyou don't get to have standing based on something thatis speculative. Friends of The Rappahannock says that,not exactly those words, but you can find it there, soyou don't have to take my word for that.I'm happy to answer your questions.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Thank you Ms. Cooke. Questions? Mr. Stepongzi?MR. STEPONGZI: Yes, the question is for anappeal that standing must still be shown, correct?MS. COOKE: Absolutely.MR. STEPONGZI: Okay, thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Other questions? NO RESPONSE FROM THE BOARD 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 250 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING MR. KOLAKOWSKI: Ms. Cooke, thank you.MS. COOKE: Thank you.MR. KOLAKOWSKI: All right, now we are at thestage of the verbal public comments. All those infavor of the appellants' position that wish tospeak, please step forward. Please again identify yourself, your address andthe case number please.MR. O'BIER: My name is Michael O'Bier, Ilive at 11201 Chancellor Meadows Lane. This is for18.0-0001.I'm sitting here listening to this all this stufftonight, and some of the things are right. Some of themare wrong. The attorney for the Spotsylvania County wastalking about the runoff, you know, in the basins. Whatthe Supreme Court of Virginia states if you do notcapture rain water and disburse it on someone else'sproperty, unless it's a natural water course, whichthere is not behind my property. They forced it down onme prior to them, you know, doing the timber cut off.They cut all the ditches in off of the logging roadsstraight in toward my house, which made the water comethere. Then all of a sudden, they say it's a natural 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 91011121314151617181920212223 251 CHERRYL MADDOX REPORTING water course. The Federal Government says it's not.They came out there and looked at it. It's not a watercourse. They don't understand why Spotsylvania Countyerosion put it there, they don't know why the engineersput it there, but it is not a water course. All right.Then she talked about the heat island effect.Well, she did her research a little bit better, but theproceedings from the court from the supervisors, theyknow

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: Spotsylvania County website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.