RecordWell Data

October 5, 2026 ARB Agenda and Packet

City of Norfolk · Norfolk City County · meeting of Oct 5, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Norfolk

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Next two ARB meetings: October 19, 2026 & November 9, 2026 City Hall Building, City Council Chamber 11th floor / 810 Union St, Norfolk, Virginia 23510 Ph. (757) 664-4752 / Fax (757) 441-1569 Architectural Review Board Meeting Agenda Monday, October 5, 2026, 4:00PM Norfolk City Hall, 810 Union Street, 11th Floor I. Call to Order II. Roll Call III. Approval of Meeting Minutes: a. September 21, 2026 IV. Consent Agenda A. Design Review a. DR #26-00426 – 1136 Vista Street/Barraud Park – Design review of replacement baseball dugouts at Barraud Park. V. Continued Applications VI. Certificate of Appropriateness A. Downtown a. COA #26-00428 – 127 Bank Street – Replace 6 windows and install railing. VII. Application(s) Determination of Architectural Appropriateness a. COA #26-00425 – 1700 Kingston – Design review to deviate from certain single- family dwelling form standards in the Coastal Character District. VIII. Recommendation(s) to City Planning Commission IX. Discussion X. Public Comments XI. Staff Updates XII. New Business XIII. Old Business XIV. Adjourn 1 of 3 DRAFT Architectural Review Board Meeting Motions Monday, September 21, 2026, 4:00 PM Norfolk City Hall, 810 Union Street, 11th Floor I. Call to Order Ms. Barrientos called the meeting to order at 4:00 pm. II. Roll Call: Airiel Barrientos, Chair Taylor Gould, Vice Chair Robert Wojtowicz Greta Gustavson Rebecca Rand Greg Rutledge (absent) Larry Pendleton, CPC Appointment Karen Reynes City Staff Present: Elizabeth Nowak Faith Hamman Susan Pollock III. Approval of Meeting Motions: March 9, 2026 Vote: Motion by Ms. Gustavson to approve the minutes with one correction; second by Dr. Wojowicz. The motion passed by a vote of 7 in favor to 0 against. IV. Consent Agenda The single item on the Consent Agenda—COA #26-00423 – 722 Redgate Avenue – installation of new awning—was approved with no discussion. Vote: Motion by Ms. Reynes to approve the consent agenda item as submitted; second by Mr. Gould. The motion passed with a vote of 7 in favor and 0 against. V. Continued Applications There were no continued applications. VI. Certificates of Appropriateness There were no additional Certificate of Appropriateness applications. VII. Determinations of Architectural Appropriateness There were no Determinations of Architectural Appropriateness. VIII. Recommendations to City Planning Commission There were no recommendations to City Planning Commission Agenda 2 of 3 IX. Discussion a. 427 W 35th Street – New construction related to a Development Certificate Speaker: Ronald Possanza (Applicant) Staff introduced the item, explaining that the property is located within the 35th Street Pedestrian Commercial Overlay, which requires a Development Certificate for all new principal structures. Staff also noted that the existing building and its addition are a non- contributing resource to the Park Place Historic District and currently have no concerns regarding the demolition of those buildings to accommodate the new development. The applicant, Mr. Possanza, presented the proposed four-story mixed used development to the board. He requested feedback on building height, parking layout, fenestration, balcony arrangements, and material/color selections, including storefront and signage concepts. The applicant also described the landscaping compliance, rooftop open space, and rooftop parapet design. The board shared the following feedback:  Windows placement, especially on the second and third levels, lacks consistent alignment. The board also raised concerns about window sizes, operability, and scale for bedrooms and asks for clarification on types such as casement or double hung, recommending further study of typology and proportion.  The board raised concerns about inaccuracies in the renderings, including incorrect scaling and contextual elements, such as the palm trees depicted in rear elevation.  Review building code requirements for egress, specifically regarding dead-end corridor length and the separation of exit stairs for a 145-foot, sprinklered building.  Provide a full landscape plan for the rooftop in the next submission.  Prepare street-view renderings from 34th Street, looking back over the houses, to illustrate the visual impact of the proposal.  Meet with the civic league to receive feedback with a note to address rear balconies and potential overlooking concerns. X. Public Comments There were no public comments. XI. Staff Updates Staff provided several updates on ongoing survey and National Register projects. The Titustown Preliminary Information Form was recommended eligible at the State Review 3 of 3 Board’s September 18, 2026, meeting. Staff and the consultant will attend the October civic league meeting to share project updates. The draft Lindenwood National Register Nomination is currently being revised, and Staff will attend their October civic league meeting as well. Staff also reported on the progress of the 2026 Cost Share project, a joint effort with Virginia Beach to survey mid-century suburban developments. Draft survey materials have been received and a draft report is pending. A 2027 Cost Share award was granted by DHR to continue the survey of mid-century suburban developments. Staff reminded the board that CLG training information is due by September 30, 2026. Staff also reminded the board that a CLG Training will be hosted at Slover Library on November 13, 2026, and attendance at the workshop will count towards next year’s CLG requirement. XII. New Business There was no new business. XIII. Old Business There was no old business. XIV. Adjournment: 5:05 pm 1 of 11 Date: October 5, 2026 To: Norfolk Architectural Review Board City of Norfolk Virginia From: Faith Hamman, City Planner II - Historic Preservation Subject: #26-00426 DR to build two new baseball dugouts Ward/Superward: 3 (Johnson)/7 (Clanton) Recommendation: Approval Location of 1136 Vista Street. Approved: Elizabeth Nowak Historic Preservation Officer #26-00426 Design Review Report Without Development Certificate I. Property Address: 1136 Vista Street II. Applicant Information Applicant: Stephen Zurek Property Owner: City of Norfolk III. District Information Relevant Documents: Parks and Recreation Master Plan Assessment (2022); NFK2050 (2025) Civic League: Lindenwood, Cottage Heights, Barraud Park Date of Structure: N/A Historic District: N/A Contributing/Noncontributing: N/A Zoning: OSP (Open Space & Preservation); Coastal Resilience Overlay Agenda 2 of 11 IV. Project Description In December 2024, the Architectural Review Board reviewed a design review application for renovations and new construction at Barraud Park. A proposal for two new baseball dugouts has since been added to the scope of park renovations. The two existing dugouts, along with the fencing and benches, will be demolished. The new dugouts will have steel black column framing with a shed roof clad in blue metal roofing. These materials will match the material palate of the new park shelters. The proposed dugouts will be approximately the same size as the existing ones, measuring 30 feet in length and 11 feet in width. New chain link fencing will be installed around the dugouts, and new benches will also be installed. V. Relevant Plans, Pattern Books, and Design Guidelines Parks and Recreation Master Plan Assessment (2022)  4.1.2 Summary of Findings o Barraud Park was among six identified park sites that scored “Very Poor” on a conditions assessment that evaluated 122 sites around the City. o Issues for Barraud Park were identified as having inadequate access and poor parking, hard courts, and sidewalks.  Appendix D: Complete Survey Results o 74% of respondents prioritized “[improving] existing neighborhood and community parks.” (Barraud Park is a community park.) NFK2050 Celebrating Our Community Pillar – Goal 4 10. Support the implementation of the Parks and Recreation Master Plan as it related to facility needs and improvements. g. Make necessary repairs and improvements to community parks, prioritizing those with the highest percentage of issues as depicted in the Parks and Recreation Master Plan. VI. Public Outreach The applicant attended the Lindwood/Cottage Heights Civic League Meeting on Tuesday, June 9, 2026. VII. Evaluation and Recommendation In Staff’s opinion the proposed dugouts at Barraud Park are consistent with the recommendations in NFK2050 as well as the recommendations in the Parks and Recreation Master Plan Assessment. 3 of 11 The design of the new dugouts incorporates the same materials used in the new park shelters and is consistent with the other existing parking buildings and helps create a cohesive appearance throughout the park. The new dugouts will match the size of the existing structures. Staff recommends approval for the project as submitted. VIII. Site Photographs Location of 1136 Vista Street. Pictometry, 2026. 4 of 11 Site photo of Barraud Park. Site photo of Barraud Park. 5 of 11 Site photo of new picnic shelters. 6 of 11 IX. Concept Site Plan Site plan. 7 of 11 X. Elevations Demolition plan. 8 of 11 New Reflected Ceiling Plan, New Roof Plan, and New Work Floor Plan. 9 of 11 West and East Demolition Plans. 10 of 11 Elevations of new dugouts. 11 of 11 XI. Renderings Rendering of new dugout. Rendering of new dugout. 1 of 18 Date: October 5, 2026 To: Norfolk Architectural Review Board City of Norfolk Virginia From: Faith Hamman, City Planner II - Historic Preservation Subject: #26-00428 COA to replace 6 windows and install railing Ward/Superward: 2 (Doyle)/6 (McGee) Recommendation: Approval Location of 127 Bank Street. Approved: Elizabeth Nowak Historic Preservation Officer #26-00428 Certificate of Appropriateness Report I. Property Address: 127 Bank Street II. Applicant Information Applicant: Sussex Development Corporation Property Owner: Das Autohaus of Virginia Beach, LLC III. District Information Historic District: Downtown Historic Overlay District Contributing/Noncontributing: Contributing Period of Significance: Late 19th century and early 20th century Date of Structure: 1912-1913 (NR) / 1913 (AIR) Architectural Style: Classical Revival (NR) Builders: Hines and Wieland (Virginian-Pilot and the Norfolk Landmark, 1912) Agenda 2 of 18 IV. Project Description The applicant proposes replacing six windows and installing a new railing on the lower roof section. Exterior modifications were originally approved under a Certificate of Appropriateness in January 2023; however, the previous general contractor did not complete all of the work. Some of the work approved under the 2023 COA has been completed, including a new ADA ramp with screening, a new door, and a new awning. That COA has since expired, and a new one is required for the remaining work. The six first floor openings are currently sealed with plexiglass and are covered with iron security bars. The security bars will be retained, painted with a black rust-inhibiting coating, and replaced where necessary. The applicant proposes aluminum-clad, double-hung, one- over-one pocket insert windows from Marvin as the replacement windows. On the south elevation, the lower roof area has been converted to a usable space. A door providing access to this area was installed and approved by the previous COA. The applicant proposes installing a new aluminum cable safety railing with a square top rail along the parapet. The railing will span approximately 23 feet, stand 3 feet and 6 inches in height, and be anchored into the parapet wall. Additional items within the scope of work qualify as in-kind replacement or repair and are exempt from review. These include the roof replacement, replacement of terracotta parapet caps in-kind, and repair or replacement in-kind of wood windows and steel windows on the side elevations. V. Relevant Guidelines and Plans 4.1.1 Entrances – Porches, Balconies, Decks Recommended 5. Adapt historic and existing handrails, porch rails, and balcony rails to meet building code and accessibility or safety requirements with methods that retain a semblance of the historic design (e.g., booster rails). a. If new rails must be installed to meet building code or other requirements, use rails that are simple and compatible with the style and material of the primary structure, such as simple black metal pipe railings. 7. Install new handrails, porch rails, and balcony rails with methods that minimize damage to historic materials and can be easily reversed. 4.1.3 Windows – General Recommended 1. Preserve and retain historic windows and their surrounding elements, such as muntins, mullions, shutters, lintels, and sills.   3 of 18 2. Prioritize repair over replacement, and whenever possible repair window materials by removing damaged areas and patching them with materials that closely match in texture, color, composition and strength.   3. Replace windows only when they are demonstrably beyond repair.   4. Replace missing windows or windows that are demonstrated to be beyond repair that match the historic or original window in: a. Design, b. Size, c. Depth of reveal, d. Muntin and mullion configuration, e. Color of glass and glazing, f. Profile, and g. Material.   6. Substitute materials like aluminum clad wood, wood composite, fiberglass, metal, or other material determined to be appropriate per the Guidelines for Substitute Materials when: b. They match the existing dimensions or historic dimensions; c. They match the historic window style and configuration; d. They closely match or closely approximate existing or historic muntin profiles Not Recommended 7. Wholesale window replacement, especially replacement of historic windows with new windows made of substitute materials.   10. Vinyl replacement windows for any window except a vinyl window that was original to a building’s construction.   VI. Public Outreach The applicant contacted the Downtown Norfolk Council and Downtown Norfolk Civic League on September 23, 2026. The Downtown Norfolk Council indicated that a Vibrant Spaces Grant had been awarded to the property owner for the renovation and are comparing the information in the new application with the details they have on file. The proposed work does not undermine the conditions of the grant. VII. Evaluation and Recommendation In Staff’s opinion, this proposal is generally consistent with the Norfolk Historic District Design Guidelines and recommends approval as submitted. The guidelines recommend preserving and retaining original windows and their surrounding elements and replacing missing windows to match the historic or original appearance. The existing first floor openings are currently infilled with plexiglass installed by a previous contractor and do not meet the guidelines. The aluminum-clad windows proposed by the applicant are consistent with the guidelines and are a more appropriate replacement than 4 of 18 the existing. Metal security bars currently cover the openings, and though it’s unclear if they are original, they appear in early photographs of the buildings. These will be retained and repaired or replaced in-kind as needed. The proposed railing to be installed at the parapet is a simple metal cable railing. The guidelines recommend that new railing be simple in design and will read as a modern addition to the building. It will be anchored into the parapet wall, and this modification can be reversed and repaired in the future if necessary. Staff recommends approval as submitted. 5 of 18 VIII. Site Photographs Location of 127 Bank Street. Pictometry, 2026. Site photo of 127 Bank Street. Taken by Staff, 9/17/2026. 6 of 18 Site photo of 127 Bank Street. Taken by Staff, 9/17/2026. Site photo of 127 Bank Street. Taken by Staff, 9/17/2026. 7 of 18 Site photo of 127 Bank Street. Taken by Staff, 9/17/2026. Site photo of 127 Bank Street. Taken by Staff, 9/17/2026. 8 of 18 IX. Historical Photographs 127 Bank Street, undated though likely c. 1910s. 127 Bank Street, undated though likely 1920s-1930s 9 of 18 X. Site Survey Site Survey. 10 of 18 Demolition Plans for Level 1, Level 2, Attic, and High Roof. 11 of 18 XI. Elevations Demolition Plans for East Elevation, North Elevation, and South Elevation. 12 of 18 Demolition Plans for Easement and Low Roof. 13 of 18 South and East Elevations details. 14 of 18 South Elevation and Ramp Plan. 15 of 18 Attachement details for railing. 16 of 18 XII. Material Information Proposed window replacement – Marvin aluminum-clad window. 17 of 18 Proposed window replacement – Marvin aluminum-clad window. 18 of 18 Proposed window replacement – Marvin aluminum-clad window. 1 of 18 Date: September 8, 2026 To: Norfolk Architectural Review Board City of Norfolk Virginia From: Elizabeth Nowak, Historic Preservation Officer - Historic Preservation Subject: #26-00425 DAA to deviate from certain single-family dwelling form standards Ward/Superward: 5 (Smigiel)/6 (McGee) Recommendation: Approval with Conditions Location of 1700 Kingston Avenue Approved: Elizabeth Nowak Historic Preservation Officer #26-00425 Determination of Architectural Appropriateness Report I. Property Address: 1700 Kingston Avenue II. Applicant Information Applicant: Charlene Wimbish Property Owner: ABC Supportive LLC III. District Information Relevant Documents: NFK2050 (2025), Coastal Character District Pattern Book (2017) Civic League: Willoughby Civic League Date of Structure: 1965/1966 (AIR/Property Record Card) Historic District: n/a Zoning: Residential Coastal (R-C), APZ-2, 65-70 DNL Agenda 2 of 18 IV. Project Description The applicant is proposing to convert an existing 1965 two-story, multi-unit building to a single-family dwelling with an accessory dwelling unit. To maximize reuse of the existing structure, the applicant is requesting a Determination of Architectural Appropriateness, per Section 5.9.2(B)(3)(a), to deviate from the following form standards included in Table 5.9.3 Single-Family Detached Dwellings Form Standards:  If located on an improved street, the primary entrance shall face the street.  A front porch shall be installed with the dimensions established.  A front porch shall be installed in the location established. The existing building is a two-story, brick, stripped Mid-Century modern building. It is oriented perpendicularly to Kingston Avenue so that its primary elevation fronts on the alley on the west side of the property. This orientation is typical for many two- and three-story multi-family buildings from this period in the Willoughby, Bayside, and Ocean View communities. This orientation pattern is most likely due to development fitting traditionally narrow and deep lots found throughout plats in this part area of Norfolk. The building’s exterior is entirely clad with brick, which has been painted. There is no ornamentation to the building, save the railings and metal pole columns on the porches on the primary (west) elevation and the projecting flat roof that covers the porches. This building type is found throughout Willoughby and Ocean View. Most alterations to the 1965 building that are needed to convert it to a single-family dwelling are primarily interior changes. In addition to painting the building white with black trim, the following exterior alterations are proposed:  Conversion of the doors on the primary (west) elevation as follows: o The doorways of the former upper right corner unit and the former corner units on the first story will be partially infilled with brick and will be converted to windows with sill heights matching the existing window openings. o The two sets of doors in the center of the west elevation will be converted to two sets of double doors.  Alteration of exterior stairs: o An existing stair on the south elevation to the front porch will be removed. o A new set of masonry steps will be installed centrally on the first floor porch to access the new front double leaf entrance.  Railings: o The existing second-story railing will be replaced, matching a new railing that will be installed on the first story porch. The new railings will be black metal with simple vertical balusters.  Kingston Avenue (south) elevation: 3 of 18 o Two windows will be added to the second story, one in each bedroom on that side of the building. o Sconce lighting will be added on the first story to provide exterior lighting and relief to the wall.  Site: o Yaupon Holly or a similar small tree is proposed at the northwest, southwest, and southeast corners of the building and on either side of the new entry stairs on the west elevation. o The existing parking area will be reconfigured. The driveway from Kingston Avenue will be narrowed to 19.1 feet in width (providing only two standard parking spaces). The remainder of the pavement on Kingston Avenue will be removed, along with a strip parallel to the alley and pavement at the rear of the building, and replaced with turf. o Two Common Hackberry or similar large trees are proposed in the front yard and one in the rear yard. o A fence is proposed along the eastern property line to separate the parking area and front yard from the adjoining multi-family property. V. Relevant Plans, Pattern Books, and Design Guidelines NFK2050: Celebrating Our Community (2025)  Goal 2: Support Complete and Healthy Neighborhoods NFK2050: Growing Equitably (2025)  Goal 1: Support a Housing Market that Meets the Needs of All Residents  Goal 2: Increase Housing Production and Adapt Housing Options for a Changing Population o 2.2: Explore options for gentle density where appropriate via accessory dwelling units and Missing Middle Housing Coastal Character District Pattern Book (2017)  Community Character (p. 6) o A casual atmosphere with indoor spaces opening easily to the outdoors o Porches and galleries to provide shelter from rain and sun while outdoors o Indigenous plant materials different from those in urbanized areas  Architectural Character (p. 7) o Diversity and individuality of architecture: not a development o Simple, well-proportioned architectural forms o Large vertical windows to let in light o Porches in a wide variety of forms o Soft colors o Consistent image for all building types established by porches and detailing 4 of 18  A Coastal Architectural Assembly Kit (p. 13) Coastal buildings have human scale, relate to each other and share similar elements: o The basic massing is articulated both vertically and horizontally o The façade is an orderly composition o Windows and doors reinforce the composition o Porches create scale and detail for the composition VI. Evaluation and Recommendation In Staff’s opinion, the proposed alterations are generally compatible with the character of the existing building and trends for this building type as found on this block of Kingston Avenue and the greater bayside area. As such, Staff recommends approval of the request as the design meets the general intent of the Coastal Character District Pattern Book and other recommendations in NFK2050. The subject building was designed and constructed in the 1960s, long before design or form standards were adopted for this part of Norfolk. As previously stated, it is a building form that is found throughout the bayside area and is arguably a character-defining element of the overall mix of architectural styles and forms here. Current form standards in the Zoning Ordinance require that elevations fronting streets contain the primary entrance to a building, as well as a porch that is at least 48 square feet that projects beyond the front façade. As constructed, the building at 1700 Kingston Avenue has a two-story porch that runs the full width of the building (approximately 80.5 feet) that is approximately 6.5 feet deep, measurements which far surpass the dimensional requirements in the Zoning Ordinance and provide ample opportunity for outdoor living and interaction between the building and the street as porches recommended in the Coastal Character District Pattern Book are intended to facilitate. Staff also notes that there are several multi-family buildings immediately adjacent to this parcel that are also sited perpendicularly to Kingston Avenue that do not have porches oriented towards the street. This is an established pattern on this block, which transitions to single-family residences on the opposite side of the alley next to 1700 Kingston Avenue. The applicant is also proposing to add fenestration to the Kingston Avenue-facing elevation and elements that will articulate the façade, including landscaping. Architectural relief and transparency are among the primary reasons for the form standards’ requirements for porches and entrances. The goal is to encourage social interaction between the pedestrian realm and the building and to minimize and mitigate blank walls. The applicant’s solution will soften the building and add transparency to the south elevation, all while, in Staff’s opinion, respecting the original design of the building and block. The proposed windows, however, could be more proportionate to the building if they were slightly larger and more rectangular, as suggested in the AI-assisted rendering submitted by the applicant. The proposed site changes will result in overall reduction of impervious surfaces on this lot and will help better define the residential edges of the parcel next to the alley and Kingston 5 of 18 Avenue. While parking in the front yard is discouraged in the pattern book, parking between the building and street is commonly found at single-family homes on this block and large parking lots are associated with the multi-family buildings. The proposed condition is consistent with the character of the area, even as it reduces areas to be used for parking. The proposed plantings are consistent with recommendations for salt tolerant species and meet the canopy requirements in the Zoning Ordinance. Staff believes, however, that as the steps on the south elevation will be removed and only lights added to the first story, more robust foundation plantings are needed on the south elevation to help soften and screen the building. Such treatment will help the property read more as a single-family building. Staff recommends approval of the application with the following conditions: 1. An enhanced foundation planting plan shall be developed, installed, and maintained at the base of the south elevation (Kingston Avenue elevation). 2. The new windows on the south elevation shall be larger and more rectangular. 6 of 18 VII. Site Photographs Location of 1700 Kingston Avenue, Pictometry, 2026. Site photo of 1700 Kingston Ave, 8/20/2026. 7 of 18 Site photo of 1700 Kingston Ave, 8/20/2026. Site photo of 1700 Kingston Ave, 8/20/2026. 8 of 18 Site photo of 1700 Kingston Ave, 8/20/2026. Site photo of 1700 Kingston Ave, 8/20/2026. 9 of 18 Site photo of 1700 Kingston Ave, 8/20/2026. 10 of 18 VIII. Concept Site Plan 11 of 18 IX. Elevations 12 of 18 13 of 18 14 of 18 15 of 18 16 of 18 17 of 18 18 of 18

Source: City of Norfolk website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.