RecordWell Data

July 20, 2026 ARB Agenda and Packet

City of Norfolk · Norfolk City County · meeting of Jul 20, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Norfolk

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Next two ARB meetings: August 10, 2026 & August 24, 2026 City Hall Building, City Council Chamber 11th floor / 810 Union St, Norfolk, Virginia 23510 Ph. (757) 664-4752 / Fax (757) 441-1569 Architectural Review Board Meeting Agenda Monday, July 20, 2026, 4:00 PM Norfolk City Hall, 810 Union Street, 11th Floor I. Call to Order II. Roll Call III. Approval of Meeting Minutes: a. July 6, 2026 IV. Consent Agenda V. Continued Applications a. COA/DR #26-00399 – 421 E City Hall Avenue & 480 E Plume Street – MacArthur Memorial – Modifications to approved COA #25-93 Archive Addition. VI. Certificate of Appropriateness a. COA #26-00408 – 736 W Princess Anne Road – Window replacement. VII. Application(s) Determination of Architectural Appropriateness VIII. Recommendation(s) to City Planning Commission IX. Discussion X. Public Comments XI. Staff Updates XII. New Business a. Mt. Pleasant Church Cemetery Presentation – Annika Sabol XIII. Old Business XIV. Adjourn 1 of 4 DRAFT Architectural Review Board Meeting Motions Monday, July 6, 2026, 4:00 PM Norfolk City Hall, 810 Union Street, 11th Floor I. Call to Order Ms. Barrientos called the meeting to order at 4:00 pm. II. Roll Call: Airiel Barrientos, Chair Katie Nguyen, Vice Chair (Absent) Robert Wojtowicz (Absent) Greta Gustavson Taylor Gould Rebecca Rand Greg Rutledge (Absent) Larry Pendleton, CPC Appointment Karen Reynes City Staff Present: Elizabeth Nowak Faith Hamman Rob Brennan Susan Pollock III. Approval of Meeting Motions: June 22, 2026 Vote: Motion by Ms. Gustavson to approve the minutes with revisions; second by Mr. Gould. The motion passed by a vote of 4 in favor to 0 against, with Ms. Rand and Ms. Reynes abstaining as they were not present on June 22, 2026. IV. Consent Agenda The five items on the Consent Agenda—COA #26-00401 – 613 Westover Avenue – Installation of new paver driveway; COA #26-00411 – 539 Warren Crescent – Installation of new fence; COA #26-00406 – 2500 Church Street – Installation of painted-on signage; COA #26-00412 – 218 W 25th Street - Installation of painted-on signage; and DR #26- 00410 – 526 Frederick Street – Fire Station No. 8 – Construction of addition for a fitness room—were approved with no discussion. Vote: Motion by Mr. Gould to approve the consent agenda items as submitted; second by Ms. Gustavson. The motion passed with a vote of 6 in favor and 0 against. V. Continued Applications There were no continued applications. VI. Certificates of Appropriateness There were no Certificates of Appropriateness. Agenda 2 of 4 VII. Determinations of Architectural Appropriateness a. DAA #26-00413 – 1211-1213 W Ocean View Avenue – Deviation from Coastal Character District Pattern Book to renovate existing buildings. Speakers: Keith Kulow (Applicant) Staff introduced the item, noting that the scope of the project was primarily limited to interior renovations and minor exterior improvements, and explained that as this is an existing development that does not conform to the Coastal Character District Pattern Book, a determination of appropriateness from the board was required. Mr. Kulow provided an overview of the scope of the renovation and added that they will also be screening the dumpster. Ms. Reynes asked what the materials would be for the dumpster enclosure. Mr. Kulow said they hoped to be able to use a stockade-style fence. Ms. Nowak clarified that, per the Zoning Ordinance and the pattern book, the enclosure would need to be masonry. Ms. Rand asked whether it would be possible to increase and improve the public/shared space outside the buildings by converting parts of the parking lot. Mr. Kulow said that the existing parking lot does not have any space that could be converted without affecting parking availability. He also described the various proposed exterior improvements, including enhanced landscaping, and the history of the new name for the apartment complex. Mr. Gould asked whether there is sufficient parking with the addition of the two new units. Ms. Nowak said that there is. Mr. Gould asked what the width of the turf strip in the right-of-way at the edge of the parking lot is. Ms. Nowak and Mr. Kulow said it was very narrow, between two and three feet. Mr. Gould said trees would be ideal, but the area was probably too narrow to support them. He asked if the applicant planned to mill the parking lot, which could create additional space for plantings. Ms. Rand agreed, saying that her concern had been about buffering the parking area and ensuring there were available amenities in the shared common spaces. Mr. Kulow said that the parking lot is in generally good shape and that while they may restripe, they will only mill if they have to. Mr. Kulow asked if there was a preferred plant or one that would do particularly well in the right-of-way area. Ms. Barrientos and Mr. Gould recommended using a coastal grass, 3 of 4 such as those listed in the Coastal Resilience Overlay list, in that area to help soften the parking lot. Vote: Motion by Mr. Gould to approve the application as discussed and with the recommended conditions in the staff report; second by Ms. Rand. The motion passed with a vote of 6 in favor and 0 against. VIII. Recommendations to City Planning Commission a. DR #26-00409 – 715 Orapax Street – After-the-fact material change to previously approved encroachment. Speakers: Sam Woomer (Applicant) Staff introduced the item. In 2023, a concrete structure with powder-coated aluminum railings was approved as part of design review. The applicant changed the materials and design when he constructed the structure in 2026. Staff shared concerns with the longevity of the structure as built, noting issues with the material used and construction, but also said that the overall style was not incompatible with the immediate area and so recommended approval with conditions. Mr. Woomer spoke briefly about the project. He said that he had changed the material to save money, but that the encroachment is within the same footprint as had been approved. He added that they did not have much material leftover after construction, which is why they kept the warped boards. Mr. Pendleton asked about a timeline to address the repairs recommended by Staff. He asked Mr. Woomer if he had received any quotes. Mr. Woomer said that he planned to do the work himself. There was general discussion among the board members about a reasonable timeline for completing the work. Concern was raised about the high temperatures and wanting to ensure that work could be completed safely. 60 to 90 days were suggested. Ms. Gustavson said that she preferred the original design and felt that it was more compatible with the building. Ms. Rand asked whether what was constructed had the same dimensions as what had been reviewed and approved. Mr. Woomer said that they were and that it had been approved by the building inspector and that the building received a certificate of occupancy. 4 of 4 Mr. Gould asked for clarification on the type of material that was used. Mr. Woomer said that it was pressure treated lumber. Mr. Gould asked if the wood still needed to cure before it could be properly sealed. Mr. Woomer said that the wood has cured enough that it could be stained. Mr. Pendleton returned to the question of timeline for completion. He noted that the City Planning Commission is likely to ask about forward progress on the project as it is already constructed. After additional discussion, there was consensus that 90 days would be sufficient; Mr. Woomer added that the actual work would only take him a day or two to complete and that he intends to be finished by Labor Day. Vote: Motion by Mr. Pendleton to recommend approval of the application with the six recommended conditions in the staff report and an additional condition that the work be completed within 90 days; second by Ms. Reynes. The motion passed with a vote of 6 in favor and 0 against. IX. Discussion There was no general discussion. X. Public Comments There were no public comments. XI. New Business There was no new business. XII. Old Business There was no old business. XIII. Adjournment: 5:15 pm 1 of 18 Date: July 20, 2026 To: Norfolk Architectural Review Board City of Norfolk Virginia From: Elizabeth Nowak, Historic Preservation Officer - Historic Preservation Subject: #26-00399 COA to amend previously approved plans for additions to the Archive Building at the MacArthur Memorial Ward/Superward: 2 (Doyle)/6 (McGee) Recommendation: Approval with Conditions Location of 421 E City Hall Avenue and 480 E Plume Street Approved: Elizabeth Nowak Historic Preservation Officer #26-00399 Certificate of Appropriateness Report and Design Review Report with Development Certificate I. Property Address: MacArthur Memorial Plaza – 421 E City Hall Ave and 480 E Plume St II. Applicant Information Applicant: Adam Schultz Property Owner: Mac Arthur Memorial Foundation III. District Information Relevant Documents: NFK2050 (2025), Historic District Design Guidelines (2012), Downtown Norfolk Pattern Book (2009) Civic League: Downtown Norfolk Civic League, Downtown Norfolk Council Date of Structure: 1964 Historic District: Downtown Historic District Contributing/Noncontributing: Noncontributing Zoning: Downtown – Business Center (D-BC)/Downtown Historic Overlay/Coastal Resilience Overlay Agenda 2 of 18 IV. Project Description Application Background On December 15, 2025, the Architectural Review Board approved a Certificate of Appropriateness and recommended approval for a Development Certificate for an approximately 10,000-square-foot addition for the Jean MacArthur Research and Education Center. This expansion is part of a comprehensive campus plan for the MacArthur Memorial. A second expansion of the Jean MacArthur Research and Education Center was planned for a later phase. As the MacArthur Memorial Foundation has proceeded with design and project planning for the approved project, it has become apparent that including the second addition with this first phase will be more efficient. This current application was initially presented to the Architectural Review Board on June 22, 2026. The board voted to continue the application and requested material samples and additional information about the proposed EIFS that would be used on the 1964 building and its second-story addition. Note: This application was received prior to June 1, 2026 and is therefore reviewed under the 2012 Norfolk Historic District Design Guidelines. Application Summary The applicant is requesting to amend previously approved plans for additions to the Jean MacArthur Research and Education Center. The planned two-story addition fronting E Plume Street and associated site improvements are very similar to what was previously exhibited. The additional work proposed includes adding a second story to the existing single-story archive building. The overall purpose of the project—to create additional archival storage, processing, and research spaces, as well as expanding educational programming spaces and offices—remains unchanged. The second-story addition to the 1964 archive building will primarily be dedicated to the archival needs of the facility. The proposed renovation of the 1964 archive building, which underwent an extensive update in the 1990s that included changes to the exterior (existing today), will include the construction of a second story and redesign of the exterior walls. Existing fenestration on the east and west elevations will remain, however, no windows will be included on the north elevation or the upper story of the east elevation. The minimal use of windows is due to the requirements of the archival space to minimize lighting to protect archival materials. The west elevation, which faces the interior of the campus courtyard, will have two aluminum- framing systems for two banks of windows near the new center of the building. All three remaining exterior walls of the 1964 building are now proposed to be finished with an exterior-insulated stucco system from Rockwool. The system uses a traditional 3-coat stucco application overtop a steel frame, gypsum sheathing, water/air barrier, mineral wool insulation, and lath. The intention is to carry over the joint lines that are proposed on the E 3 of 18 Plume Street addition to create a sense of cohesion, but stucco will require additional control joints than the precast concrete. The primary entrance to the building will be reoriented from the west elevation to the two- story addition on E Plume Street. A small loading area will be constructed at the corner of E City Hall Avenue and Court Street that will include a concrete ramp and stairs with black metal railings that will lead to a man door access and an overhead coil door for receiving. While most of the design for the new two-story addition facing E Plume Street is unchanged, the connection between the addition and the existing building has been revised. The previous design included a slight hyphen between the two masses to better resolve where the existing cornice of the one-story building died into the new building. The hyphen has been omitted with this amendment as the exterior facades of the one-story building are being redesigned. The two masses will have the same wall plane as a single exterior wall, reading as one building. No changes are proposed to the landscape design that was previously approved. Additional Material Information Since the last ARB meeting, the applicant has identified a product that will provide the uninterrupted insulation barrier they require that will also have a traditional stucco finish: 4 of 18 Watertable Details The proposed stucco wall system will be applied overtop the existing CMU wall of the 1964 building, including the existing precast sill as the stone wool insulation is thick enough for the assembly to bypass it. The stucco will terminate above grade. The sliver of exposed CMU block will be parge coated. V. Relevant Guidelines and Plans Historic District Design Guidelines (2012) 1.2 Additions 1. Locate an addition to a building on a secondary elevation, preferably at the rear. 2. Limit the size and footprint of the addition so as not to overwhelm the primary building or the site. 3. Keep the height of the addition at or below that of the primary building. Additional stories should not be added in residential districts or to properties and must be carefully considered and highly distinguishable in non-residential applications. 4. Design additions to be compatible with the main building, without duplicating it exactly. Similar siding materials and detailing, complementary rooflines, and fenestration patterns can produce a compatible appearance. 5. A hyphen, or connector, which links distinct building elements, may be used to visually distinguish the addition from the original structure. It is acceptable to inset walls of additions away from building corners a minimum of one foot to help minimize visibility and differentiate walls of the original and new sections. 5 of 18 6. A greater flexibility of design should be considered in non-residential districts and non-residential areas of other districts, because function and usage of buildings will likely be more varied, presenting a wider variety for both modern and traditional styles. 8. Design additions so that, as much as possible, they may be removed without causing damage or significant alteration to the original historic building. 9. Use of materials found in the historic district, such as wood, brick, stone, precast, terra cotta and metal is recommended. 11. Vinyl and aluminum siding and trim products and synthetic stucco products, such as Exterior Insulation and Finish Systems (EIFS), are not appropriate materials. 13. Various window materials may be used for additions, and should match those found on the building. … Metal, storefront-style windows may be used for commercial applications. 15. During construction of an addition, protect significant site features and minimize ground disturbance from heavy construction equipment. Downtown Norfolk Pattern Book (2009) Section D Façade Types: Façade Type A: Low-Rise  2 to 4 stories in height  Articulate in a way that is harmonious with the scale of the area  All facades should be articulated to have a one-story base and a top Step 4: Windows and Entrances: Mixed Use  Windows should have vertical proportions with a ratio of up to 60% solid to void in linear measurement. A wide variety of window types including clusters of up to 6 vertical windows are permitted.  Roof forms should be varied and may be either pitched roof or parapets. Section E Architectural Styles: Downtown Modern  Masonry wall systems  Glass curtain walls  Materials: o Cladding: brick, stone, cast stone, precast concrete, glass fiber-reinforced concrete, metal or composite panel systems, or aluminum and glass curtain wall o Roofing: flat roofing systems, standing seam roofing on penthouse elements, stone or cast stone or precast parapets o Window walls: aluminum framing system with clear glazing, spandrel glass, metal panels o Windows; aluminum window systems, coated steel window systems, clear glazing, spandrel glass, metal panels 6 of 18 o Canopies: metal, glass, or canvas awnings VI. Public Outreach The applicant contacted the Downtown Norfolk Council and the Downtown Norfolk Civic League in 2024 when the first iteration of the project was proposed. VII. Evaluation and Recommendation In Staff’s opinion, this project generally meets the Historic District Design Guidelines (2012) and is consistent with recommendations for downtown found in Downtown Norfolk 2030 and NFK2050. Staff recommended approval of the previously exhibited plans for the two-story addition to the one-story 1964 archival building in 2025 and recommended approval with conditions in the June 22, 2026 staff report. The plans for the E Plume Street Addition are nominally similar; the proposed revision to how that addition will join the existing building are, in Staff’s opinion, logical and compatible. The existing one-story building is not located within the Downtown Norfolk National Register Historic District and has undergone extensive alterations since it was first constructed. It is Staff’s opinion that joining the addition to the building in a way that will create the appearance of a singular building is in-keeping with the overall forms and designs of the MacArthur Memorial campus, will reflect the uses of each portion of the building, and will have no adverse effect on a historic structure. The proposed redesign of the existing one-story building is extensive; however, it is Staff’s opinion that the proposed new design of the exterior walls is consistent with other infill on the campus. Removing the heavy cornice and pilasters, while changing the character of the building, will bring the building into conformity with other more recent infill on the site and will better harmonize the existing building with the new addition on E Plume Street. Given the programmatic needs for limiting as much ambient light as possible, Staff believes that the limited fenestration is acceptable. Existing windows on Court Street will remain, as will a bank of windows on the west elevation on the upper and lower story. The applicant has indicated they are interested in a recommendation from Staff to incorporate story panels on the north elevation as are found elsewhere on the campus. This, in Staff’s opinion, will make this blind elevation more inviting at the pedestrian level. The material palette for the new two-story addition on E Plume Street is unchanged from the previous submittals and Staff still finds them to be compatible with the overall campus, the Downtown Historic District, and the design guidelines. Staff’s previous concerns about the proposed materials for the renovation and expansion of the 1964 building have been addressed: the current proposed wall system will have a traditional stucco finish, which is consistent with recommended materials in the Historic District Design Guidelines and will be compatible with the campus and district. Staff recommends approval of the application with the following conditions: 7 of 18 1. Revised elevations shall be submitted to ARB Staff reflecting the revised material palette and proposed control joints before the COA is issued. 2. The renovation of the existing 1964 portion of the building, to include the new second story, shall use the exhibited Rockwool exterior-insulated stucco system and shall be finished with a color and finish that is compatible with the precast concrete on the E Plume Street addition. 3. Story panels or similar narrative graphics shall be included on the north elevation of the archive building (fronting E City Hall Avenue) as exhibited in the attached drawings. 8 of 18 VIII. Site Photographs Location of 421 E City Hall Avenue and 480 E Plume Street, Pictometry, 2026. Site photo of existing archive building, 12/09/2025. 9 of 18 Site photo of existing archive building and the portico that will be enclosed, 12/09/2025. Site photo of rear of existing archive building where the new addition will be located, 12/09/2025. 10 of 18 Site photo of the memorial campus and the location of the new addition, 12/09/2025. Site photo of the southwest corner of the memorial campus where the new addition will be located; the MacArthur Memorial is in the background, 12/09/2025. 11 of 18 IX. Concept Site Plan 12 of 18 13 of 18 X. Concept Landscaping Plan 14 of 18 XI. 6/22/2026 Exhibited Elevations 15 of 18 XII. Floorplans 16 of 18 XIII. Renderings 17 of 18 XIV. Material Information 18 of 18 XV. Previously Approved Elevations 1 of 14 Date: July 6, 2026 To: Norfolk Architectural Review Board City of Norfolk Virginia From: Annika Sabol, Executive Intern; Faith Hamman, City Planner II - Historic Preservation Subject: #26-00408 COA to replace 14 windows. Ward/Superward: 2 (Doyle)/6 (McGee) Recommendation: Approval with Conditions Location of 736 W Princess Anne Road. Approved: Elizabeth Nowak Historic Preservation Officer #26-00406 Certificate of Appropriateness Report I. Property Address: 736 W Princess Anne Road, Unit #2 II. Applicant Information Applicant: Kyle Butters Property Owner: Karen Twiddy III. District Information Historic District: Ghent Historic District Contributing/Noncontributing: Contributing Period of Significance: 1897-1929 Date of Structure: 1920 (NR) Architectural Style: Colonial Revival Architect: N/A Agenda 2 of 14 IV. Project Description The applicant is proposing the replacement of 10 existing wood windows with new aluminum-clad wood windows in Unit 2, which is located on the eastern first floor of the condominium building. Although replacement of a total 14 windows is planned, not all are visible from the public right-of-way. The applicant proposes installing six-over-one aluminum-clad windows from the Pella Lifestyle line, which would match the existing window configuration. The proposed replacement windows will be simulated-divided lights (SDLs) with the muntin profile of ⁷⁄₈ inch, with the existing windows appearing to be ⁵⁄₈ of an inch. They will be a pocket installation with minimal changes to the overall glass area. No spacer bar is proposed. The applicant states that the existing windows show a significant amount of rot from water intrusion and are beyond repair. They also noted that minor repair attempts made in the past. Note: At least two other units in the condominium have replacement windows. One fourth- floor unit received a COA in 2010 to install JELD-WEN replacement windows due to damage and rot of the original windows. On the west elevation, the first-floor unit has replacement windows with SDLs. Staff was unable to locate any previous approvals for the replacement of the windows on the first-floor unit. The applicant noted that there several other units within the building that have aluminum-clad replacement windows. The 1997 photograph from the survey of North Ghent shows all the units with six-over-one wood windows. This application was received prior to June 1, 2026, and is therefore reviewed under the 2012 Norfolk Historic District Design Guidelines. V. Relevant Guidelines and Plans City of Norfolk Historic District Design Guidelines (2012) 2.1 Substitute Materials 1. Unavailability of historic materials. 2. Unavailability of skilled craftsmen. 3. Replacement of poor-quality original materials. 4. Code-requirement changes. Life safety, accessibility and code issues must be considered as applicable, and the Virginia Rehabilitation Code should be consulted when applying these criteria to historic buildings. 2.4 Windows and Doors 1. Preserve and retain historic windows and doors, including surrounding elements such as transoms and sidelights, shutters, and decorative lintels or sills. 4. Repair original materials whenever possible by removing damaged areas and patching them with a material similar in texture, color, composition and strength. 3 of 14 5. If a window is damaged beyond repair or is missing, documentation of its condition must be provided. Wholesale replacement of windows is not appropriate. If a window or windows must be replaced, it should be replaced with one matching the original in design, material, size, depth of reveal, muntin configuration and profile, detail, and color of glass and glazing. It should be a true divided-light window. Insulated glass may be considered when it meets the above criteria. 6. Vinyl replacement windows are not appropriate. VI. Evaluation and Recommendation In Staff’s opinion, this request meets the general intent of the City of Norfolk Historic District Design Guidelines (2012) and recommends approval with conditions. The guidelines recommend the repair and retention of historic windows; replacement may be appropriate when repair is not feasible. When replacement is necessary, the windows should closely match the original in design, materials, muntin configuration, and detailing. The applicant reports that the existing windows have extensive rot due to water intrusion and are beyond repair. Most of the proposed replacement windows are located on the east elevation, which faces an adjacent building and receives limited sunlight. The applicant also states that minor repairs have been made to some of the windows. The proposed aluminum-clad wood windows are consistent with the guidelines, and the slight dimensional variations between the existing and proposed window components will be minimally noticeable. The condominium building also has several previously replaced windows in other units. One fourth-floor unit received a COA in 2010 to install JELD-WEN replacement windows due to damage and rot of the original windows. On the west elevation, the first-floor unit has replacement windows with SDLs, it is unclear when those were installed. The remainder of the windows appear to be original. Given the condition of the existing windows, repair attempts, and the number of replacement windows already present in the building, Staff believes that the proposed aluminum-clad windows are an appropriate replacement material and a high-quality alternative. A clad window will also provide better long-term performance on the eastern elevation with the reported issues of water intrusion. As submitted, the windows do not include an interior spacer bar; however, Staff recommends incorporating a spacer bar to better replicate the depth and appearance of true-divided lights. The addition of a spacer bar creates shadow and depth to give the appearance of true-divided-lights. The SDL profiles will be slightly larger than the existing muntins. Staff recommends approval with the following conditions: 1. The replacement aluminum-clad, wood simulated-divided-lite windows shall have a spacer bar. 4 of 14 VII. Site Photographs Location of 736 W Princess Anne Road. Pictometry, 2026. Site photo of 736 W Princess Anne Road. Taken by Staff, 5/21/2026. 5 of 14 1997 photograph of 736 W Princess Anne Road, North Ghent National Register Nomination. Site photo of 736 W Princess Anne Road. Taken by Staff, 5/21/2026. 6 of 14 Site photo of 736 W Princess Anne Road. Taken by Staff, 5/21/2026. Site photo of 736 W Princess Anne Road. Taken by Staff, 5/21/2026. 7 of 14 Site photo of 736 W Princess Anne Road. Taken by Staff, 5/21/2026. Site photo of window on east elevation. Submitted by the applicant. 8 of 14 Site photo of window proposed for replacement. Submitted by the applicant. Site photo of window proposed for replacement. Submitted by the applicant. 9 of 14 Site photo of window proposed for replacement. Submitted by the applicant. Site photo of window proposed for replacement. Submitted by the applicant. 10 of 14 Site photo of window on rear elevation. Submitted by applicant. Site photo of window on the rear elevation with muntin width approximately ⁵⁄₈ of an inch Submitted by the applicant. 11 of 14 VIII. Site Photographs of Units with Existing Replacement Windows Site photo of 736 W Princess Anne Road: western first-floor unit with replacement windows. Taken by Staff, 6/24/2026. Site photo of 736 W Princess Anne Road – fourth-floor unit with replacement windows. Taken by Staff, 6/24/2026. 12 of 14 IX. Material Information Order Sheets for proposed replacement windows. 13 of 14 Order Sheets for proposed replacement windows. 14 of 14 Order Sheets for proposed replacement windows.

Source: City of Norfolk website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.