RecordWell Data

_04062026-1293

City of Norfolk · Norfolk City County · meeting of Apr 6, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Norfolk

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

DRAFT Architectural Review Board Meeting Motions Monday, March 23, 2026, 4:00 PM Norfolk City Hall, 810 Union Street, 11th Floor I. Call to Order Ms. Barrientos called the meeting to order at 4:00 pm. II. Roll Call: Airiel Barrientos, Chair Katie Nguyen, Vice Chair Robert Wojtowicz Greta Gustavson Taylor Gould Rebecca Rand (Absent) Greg Rutledge Larry Pendleton, CPC Appointment (Absent) Karen Reynes City Staff Present: Elizabeth Nowak Faith Hamman Susan Pollock Brian Ballard Francesca Genovese III. Approval of Meeting Motions: March 9, 2026 Vote: Motion by Ms. Gustavson to approve; second by Dr. Wojowicz. The motion passed by a vote of 5 in favor to 0 against, with Mr. Gould abstaining as he was not present on March 9, 2026. Ms. Nguyen joined the meeting shortly after the minutes were adopted. IV. Consent Agenda Mr. Rutledge requested that the application for 234-242 W 24th Street be removed from the consent agenda. The remaining three items on the Consent Agenda—COA #26-00371 – 241 Granby Street – Installation of new signage; COA #26-00373 – 525 Westover Avenue – Window replacement on rear sleeping porch; and DR #26-00374 – 419 W 21st Street – Installation of new signage related to an encroachment—were approved with no discussion. Vote: Motion by Mr. Rutledge to remove COA #26-00375 – 234-242 W 24th Street from the consent agenda and to approve the remaining consent agenda items as submitted; second by Mr. Gould. The motion passed with a vote of 7 in favor and 0 against. V. Continued Applications a. COA #26-00375 – 234-242 W 24th Street – Adapt an industrial building for residential use. Prior to the item being heard, Ms. Barrientos stated that as she had worked on a landscape plan for this property, she would be abstaining from the item. Staff introduced the application, noting that when the applicant had originally come to request to rezone these properties into the Norfolk & Western Railroad district, no Certificate of Appropriateness was issued; however, the plans provided by the applicant are the same as they were when they applied for local designation. The applicant indicated that they were available for any questions. Mr. Rutledge indicated that he did not recall that the properties had been rezoned into the local district. He asked for clarification that the majority of the proposed alterations would be to the non-historic building; Ms. Nowak indicated that was correct. Mr. Rutledge also asked for clarification about the changes to openings on the historic building. Vote: Motion by Mr. Rutledge to approve the application as presented; second by Ms. Reynes. The motion was passed by a vote of 6 in favor to 0 against with Ms. Barrientos abstaining. Prior to hearing the next item, Ms. Barrientos acknowledged the likelihood of lengthy discussion for the application for 485 Saint Pauls Boulevard—The Norfolk Academy Building and asked the board whether they would be amenable to hearing the final items in the following order: VI a, VII a, and VI b. Vote: Mr. Rutledge made a motion to amend the agenda to hear the applications in the following order: VI a, VII a, and VI b; second by Ms. Nguyen. The motion passed unanimously. VI. Certificates of Appropriateness a. COA #26-00370 – Stockley Gardens Park – Park renovations. Speakers: Stephen Zurek (Representative) Staff introduced the application, summarizing the type and scope of renovations and highlighting some of the historic design features of the park that will be preserved. Mr. Zurek added a brief history of the project, which began planning stages 10 years ago. He said that the project will begin later this year after the Stockley Art Show. There were three public speakers who shared comments on the project. The first, Mark Bind, expressed support for most of the scope of the renovations but said that the cobblestones that will remain are a tripping hazard and requested that no benches be put back in the park as he feels that they are attracting people with unwanted and unsafe behaviors. Jeff Theuer spoke in favor of the application and of returning benches to the park. He said that when the benches were first removed years ago, Stockley Gardens became the only park in the city without benches. He said that he uses the benches that are currently in the park and has seen many of his other neighbors enjoying them. He added that a FOIA request from the Police Department did not yield police reports that support the kind of activity that was described by the other speaker and that there have been no issues since the benches were recently reinstalled. Lastly, Denise Brown said that she likes the benches. She said that the ones with dividers are uncomfortable and cannot be lain on, but they are comfortable to sit on and take a rest. She noted that increased brightness of lighting would aid with sense of safety in the park and recommended that rather than removing the benches. She added that she likes the look of the cobblestones and would like to see them retained, but said that the mortar between the stones has been worn away. Ms. Gustavson asked for clarification about whether or not the benches to be installed would have a divider. Mr. Zurek noted that the benches do have dividers but that the stock image included in the material palette was shown without it as the company offers the divider as an extra feature. Ms. Reynes asked for clarification about the fencing. She said that she had heard that a full fence had previously been installed to allow certain types of events and whether its removal would affect the kinds of events that could be held. Mr. Zurek said that he didn’t believe there would be any recreational constraints with the fence removal. He added that retaining the fence along the south edge was for pedestrian safety. Mr. Gould asked about edging for the stone dust path. Mr. Zurek said it would be a metal edge and that all improvements would be up to the line of the right-of-way. Mr. Gould asked whether this project is a first phase and that there will be later work. Mr. Zurek said that the current budget projections did not support additional work at this time; this is considered Mr. Gould asked about the lighting in the park. Mr. Zurek said that there are pedestrian acorn/globe streetlamps along the central path. He added that they are Dominion’s lights and that Dominion is responsible for keeping them on. Mr. Bind said that many are out but that he has contacted Virginia Power. Mr. Gould asked when the park closes at night. Mr. Zurek said that it closes at dusk. Dr. Wojtowicz noted that the park also acts as a median and should be lit. Vote: Motion by Dr. Wojtowicz to approve the application as presented; second by Mr. Gould. The motion passed with a vote of 7 in favor and 0 against. VII. Determinations of Architectural Appropriateness a. DAA #26-00372 – 2860 Chesapeake Boulevard – Construct a single-family house with deviations from form standards. Speakers: Wayne Russell (Applicant); Rich Hodge (Builder) Staff presented the item, citing the form standards from the Zoning Ordinance from which the applicant is requesting to deviate. The proposed house would have a porch only 5 feet wide and the porch would not extend 50% beyond the front façade. Staff described an eclectic mix of architecture and building styles in the area of the project site. The applicant and builder said that they were available for questions. Ms. Gustavson said that she was distracted by the blank area on the first floor and the second floor. She said that the knows that it is in a bathroom. Dr. Wojtowicz said that the two blank areas appeared to cancel each other out for him. Mr. Rutledge agreed. Mr. Rutledge, Mr. Gould, and Dr. Wojtowicz briefly discussed whether it would be feasible to bring the front porch forward slightly and bring the roof line across to meet the edge of the garage. In discussing the possibility, they realized that the difference in the plane is approximately two feet so the additional porch area would not be usable space. Ms. Gustavson asked whether anyone had concerns about the width of the porch and whether it would be usable. Mr. Hodge confirmed that the porch would be 5 feet deep and that it is a space in which people can stand or sit in a chair. He added that the window shown in the stairwell can also be a fanlight window, but that the organization of the bathroom makes it extremely difficult to add a window in that area on the front elevation. He also said that when he has constructed this house in the past, he has included a taller planting to mitigate the blank area in the center bay of the first floor. Mr. Gould asked whether approval of this application would allow this build anywhere in the city. Ms. Nowak clarified that the type of deviation that is being requested would need to be requested in any instance and that the board would review any application against its own context. Mr. Gould said he commended the use of a side-loading garage. Vote: Motion by Dr. Wojtowicz to approve with the condition in the staff report; second by Ms. Nguyen. The motion passed with a vote of 7 in favor with 0 against. VI. Certificates of Appropriateness b. COA #26-00360 – 485 Saint Pauls Boulevard & 307 E Charlotte Street – Norfolk Academy – rehabilitate the Norfolk Academy Building, construct an addition, and make related site improvements. Speakers: Burrell Saunders (Representative); Robert Cross (Applicant, VAF); Nicole Warmsley (Representative) Staff introduced the item, summarizing the revisions made to the design since the application had been presented for discussion in February. Mr. Cross with Virginia Arts Festival briefly introduced the different teams from Commonwealth Preservation Group and Saunders & Carouse and indicated all were available for questions. Ms. Reynes asked why no downspouts or gutters were being added to the historic building given the stated water issues. Mr. Saunders explained that there is existing internal drainage system that is still working, though they have not been able to verify all the details of the system. He noted that removal of the wall will Mr. Gould said he agreed with Staff about differentiating the ground plane. He asked for clarification whether that would come back to the board or not; Ms. Nowak said that a condition could be crafted to require it come back to the board otherwise it would be reviewed by Staff. He suggested concrete and brick banding to read differently and articulate the space differently. Dr. Wojtowicz asked whether there is a connection of the ground level of the historic building to the Annex. Mr. Saunders said you enter at a half level and you can descend to a lower level or ascend to upper levels. Dr. Wojtowicz asked whether the basements are connected; Mr. Saunders said that they are but that while the ceiling heights align, the new basement will have to be dug deeper and a ramp will bring the two floors back together. Dr. Wojtowicz said that he did not mind the offset doors given the axiality and offset of the building. Ms. Nguyen said that the off-centeredness of the doors bothers her some, but that they are not street facing and there is an internal reason for their location. Mr. Rutledge said he agreed with Staff and wondered why the doors could not be symmetrical, but also agreed that it is not highly visible even though it is the entrance to the building. Mr. Rutledge asked to review the east elevation. He said that there is so much texture on the temple building that gives it a nice scale; he said that he would like to see some of that brought over to the Annex to make it more complementary. He suggested recessing the windows to give a deeper relief to the fenestration and to make the corner pilasters pop more. He said the design is very flat. He added that there are replicative details that could make the design more complementary. He suggested a plinth for the pilasters or to make the projecting elements of the corners stronger. Mr. Rutledge noted that increasing the weight of the corners on the side elevations (east/west) would set the stage for the turn on the south elevation and would unite all the visible elevations to have the same three bay vocabulary. Mr. Saunders noted that they were given direction to keep the addition very contemporary. Mr. Rutledge said he appreciated that. Ms. Warmsley asked for clarifications for the conditions, asking whether there was a preference of color. Mr. Gould said that his suggestion for inclusion of concrete would introduce contrast. Ms. Warmsley asked whether the south doors are being requested to be moved. Ms. Barrientos said that the doors were fine in their current configuration. Vote: Motion by Mr. Rutledge to approve the application with the first condition in the staff report and the condition that the size of the corner pilasters on the east and west elevations shall be increased in width to span from the corner to the outside edge of the nearest window bay; second by Ms. Nguyen. The motion passed with a vote of 7 in favor with 0 against. VIII. Recommendations to City Planning Commission There were no recommendations to City Planning Commission IX. Discussion There was no general discussion. X. Public Comments There were no public comments. XI. New Business Ms. Barrientos informed the board that a new board member had been appointed by City Council to fill Ms. Li’s recently vacated seat. She noted that Ms. Rebecca Rand would be joining the board following conclusion of her maternity leave. XII. Old Business Staff noted that the guidelines are nearing a final stage of completion. XIII. Adjournment: 5:15 pm

Source: City of Norfolk website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.