RecordWell Data

2024

City of Norfolk · Norfolk City County · Budget documents

Open the original document More from City of Norfolk

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

BUDGET FI SCAL YEAR 2024 CITY OF NORFOLK ADOPTED OPERATING ORDINANCE #49220, CIP #49222 This page intentionally left blank 3 June 14, 2023 Honorable Mayor and City Council, I respectfully present to you the Adopted Fiscal Year (FY) 2024 Financial Plan for the City of Norfolk, which is comprised of the General Fund, Enterprise Funds, Special Revenue Funds, Internal Service Funds, Capital Improvement Plan (CIP), the Annual Plan for the Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Block Grants, and the Annual Grants Plan. Discussions with City Council during our Budget Work Sessions and input from residents shared during the Budget and Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) public hearing and the tax assessment hearings resulted in amendments to the Proposed FY 2024 Operating and Capital Budgets. Amendments to the Proposed FY 2024 Budget were adopted at the June 13, 2023 City Council meeting. The table below illustrates the final Adopted FY 2024 Financial Plan: Adopted FY 2024 Financial Plan Fund Adopted Budget General Fund $1,079,245,028 Enterprise Funds $189,980,838 Special Revenue Funds $52,016,213 Internal Service Funds $118,615,533 Total Operating Funds $1,439,857,612 Capital Improvement Plan $395,613,169 Total Operating and Capital Funds $1,835,470,781 Annual Plan for HUD Block Grants $7,054,048 Annual Grants Plan $86,498,241 Total Financial Plan $1,929,023,070 The Adopted FY 2024 Budget emphasizes providing the right services at the right scale based on data, and resident and City Council input. Resident survey data regarding resident priorities and satisfaction with city services as well as feedback from public hearings guided the strategic funding decisions for the FY 2024 budget. This budget funds the right services for today while charting a sound and sustainable plan for the future. Budget Highlights  No tax rate increases  Suspension of the Motor Vehicle License Fee for calendar year 2023  Pay raise for Team Norfolk o 5% general wage increase for all general, constitutional, and nonsworn employees 4 o A step increase plus a 2.5% increase (minimum of a 5% increase) for sworn Public Safety  $8.5M and 39 FTE in enhancements to address resident priorities  $4.5M and 26.8 FTE in enhancements to improve organizational effectiveness  $10.5M increase in local contribution to Norfolk Public Schools  $9.4M to purchase 120 vehicles /pieces of equipment  $4.2M to improve hardware and software systems  $56.6M in matching funds for the Downtown Floodwall Project  $65.5M for a new Norfolk Fitness and Wellness Center  $39.2M more than planned for maintenance of city infrastructure  $13.6M increase in Debt Service due to a growing Capital Improvement Plan (CIP)  Fee changes for a number of the city’s special revenue and enterprise funds: o A $1.50 increase to the Solid Waste Residential fee o A 4% increase to the Storm Water fee o An increase to various Cemetery fees  Automatic fee increases for Water, and Wastewater/Sewer This memo details City Council’s budget amendments to the proposed budget. Operating Budget Amendments/Adjustments: The following amendments to the Proposed FY 2024 Operating Budget reflect City Council directives and technical adjustments after proposal: Enhancements to Outside Agencies Increase Support for Outside Agencies: $454,897 This action provides additional funding for the outside agencies listed in the table below: Outside Agencies Amendments FY 2024 Proposed FY 2024 Reconciliation Increase Downtown Norfolk Council $108,000 $258,000 $150,000 Chrysler Museum of Art $2,627,397 $2,753,955 $126,558 Virginia Arts Festival $931,252 $967,505 $36,253 Virginia Opera $306,002 $317,178 $11,176 Virginia Stage Company $284,246 $294,335 $10,089 Virginia Symphony $294,902 $305,523 $10,621 Norfolk Sister City Association $58,500 $65,500 $7,000 Norfolk Commission on the Arts and Humanities $220,524 $300,000 $79,476 Hampton Roads Planning District Commission $264,410 $288,134 $23,724 Total $5,095,233 $5,550,130 $454,897 Relocation Assistance for the Hurrah Players: $100,000 Provide one-time assistance for the Hurrah Players to relocate their offices and performance studio. 5 Enhancements to Improve Organizational Effectiveness Provide Funds to Enhance Right of Way Inspections: $101,228 Provide funds for a Construction Inspector II position to assist with inspection of outdoor dining in the public right of way as well as construction projects including the installation of broadband and inspections of code violations. This action will support the cost of the Construction Inspector II position as well as provide one-time funds for a work truck and equipment. Provide Funds for City Assessor Salaries: $136,000 This action will align salary funding with current staffing levels and support the cost of merit raises previously provided. Provide Funds for the City Auditor’s Office Salaries: $104,810 This action will align salary funding with current staffing levels. Provide Funds for City Clerk: $81,062 Provide funds to support three enhancements for the City Clerk’s office: additional funds for community engagement through enhanced outreach, aligning salaries for the Chief Deputy City Clerk and Deputy City Clerk/Secretary positions, and converting the temporary Municipal Intern III position to a Deputy City Clerk/Secretary position. These actions will enhance the City Clerk’s capacity and support City Council outreach and engagement with residents. Provide Funds for the General Registrar for Enhanced Election Support: $31,061 Expanded early and absentee voting has resulted in the need for additional staff support for the General Registrar, particularly in years with multiple elections. This action provides funds for a Deputy Elections Administrator to assist with managing early voting at office and satellite locations. The FY 2024 funding will support six months of the FTE’s salary, as the General Registrar will not be filling the position until January 2024. Provide Funds to Enhance Citywide Title VI Compliance: $66,102 Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act prohibits discrimination based on race, color, national origin, or disability status in any program or activity that receives federal funds or other federal financial assistance. As a recipient of federal funds, the city is legally required to address Title VI compliance. This action will provide funds for a dedicated Management Analyst II position to manage and enhance citywide Title VI compliance. Provide One-Time Funds for a Traffic Operations Vehicle: $85,000 This action will support the cost of a truck that will be used to transport materials necessary for multimodal maintenance, such as items used to repair bike lanes, install bike racks, and improve signage and roadway markings. 6 Provide Funds to Enhance Veterinary Services at the Norfolk Animal Care Center: $500,000 This action will support four additional positions including a licensed Veterinarian, two Veterinary Technicians, and a Veterinary Assistant. Funding is also provided for one-time and ongoing operational costs for veterinary services provided to animals housed at the Norfolk Animal Care Center Shelter. This will replace a contract arrangement that had been in place with a more permanent solution. Provide Funds for a Citywide Trail Assessment and Master Plan: $150,000 Provide one-time funds to develop the city's "Trail Assessment and Recreational Trail Connectivity Plan" which will be used as a framework to help the Department of Parks and Recreation decide how to best construct and connect blueways and trail networks throughout the city. Enhancements to Improve Public Safety Provide Funds for Fire-Rescue Emergency Medical Services Operations Staff: $259,082 Provide funds for three dedicated Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Transport Supervisors (one per shift) to oversee operations, as well as a new response vehicle. These staff will perform quality assurance, patient care review, EMS training, liaise with long term care facilities, and ensure adherence to Virginia Department of Health Emergency Service Regulations. Provide Additional Funding for the Real Time Crime Center: $532,202 Provide one-time funds to support technology and contractual requirements for the Real Time Crime Center (RTCC). These funds will support connectivity for real-time video cameras, a video wall, and other features that are integral to the role the RTCC will play in enhancing public safety. Provide Funds for Community Violence Intervention Training: $350,000 The city has been partnering with the Newark Community Street Team (NCST) to utilize the organization's evidence-based, trauma informed approach to violence reduction. This action will provide funds to support additional community group violence intervention training led by the NCST. Provide Funds for the Nighttime Basketball Program: $250,000 This program, for residents aged 18 and up, has an emphasis on positive activities while providing additional assistance such as employment opportunities, professional development, G.E.D. enrollment, healthcare services, and more. This action will provide funds to support security, referees, uniforms, and additional programming outside of basketball to include dance and G.E.D. classes. Provide Funds for Enhanced Street Outreach Efforts: $108,000 The street outreach team provides those experiencing homelessness with transportation to shelters, referral to benefits, services, and long-term planning to end their homelessness. These funds will support enhanced homeless street outreach by adding an additional permanent full-time Case Manager III position as well as support a temporary full-time Case Manager III position that will proactively connect with and offer services to individuals experiencing homelessness in Norfolk. One-time funds for a vehicle are also included. 7 Miscellaneous Enhancements Provide Funds for a One-Time Retiree Supplement: $1,500,000 The budget funds additional financial support for retirees, particularly due to recent inflationary impacts. At Council’s direction, this will provide $1,500,000 for a one-time $660 supplement for retirees with 20 years of creditable service who have been receiving a retirement benefit starting on and prior to June 30, 2022. All 2,275 retirees (as of 6/30/2022) will receive this supplement. Reconciliation Items Impacting Revenue Revenue Impact of Suspension of Motor Vehicle License Fee: ($1,400,000) On March 22, 2022, Council voted to temporarily exempt every owner of a motor vehicle, motorcycle or motorbike from the city’s motor vehicle license fee that would otherwise have been assessed for calendar year 2022, from January 1, 2022, to December 31, 2022. City Council has again directed to suspend this fee for calendar year 2023. The overall revenue impact of this action is a $1,400,000 decrease. This revenue decrease will also impact the Norfolk Public Schools (NPS) funding formula. The impact to NPS is detailed below. Revenue Impact of Removing Proposed Increases to Parking Fees: ($3,263,751) The FY 2024 Proposed Budget included increases to various parking fees. This action will remove those proposed increases and the associated revenue. To balance the parking enterprise fund, the department’s expenditure appropriation for debt service will be reduced by $3,236,751 to account for the revenue impact of removing the proposed fee increases. Parking will be able to meet their debt service obligations for FY 2024; however, adjustments will be necessary for FY 2025 anticipated debt obligations. Parking’s Re-Lamping Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) project will be reduced in FY 2024 by $1.55 million to lessen the future impact on debt service. Increase to Projected FY23 Projected Surplus: $1,827,030 Increase to projected FY23 end of year surplus resulting from better than forecasted growth in non-real estate tax revenue. Assessment Increase in 4th Quarter New Construction Revenue: *$1,387,000 Real Estate tax revenue from new construction is assessed in quarterly supplements. The 4th quarter assessments related to new construction was stronger than originally estimated in the Proposed Budget due to strong economic activity. *$993,069 of the $1,387,000 is the city’s share of the additional revenue, while $393,931 will go toward the city’s local contribution to Norfolk Public Schools. Reconciliation Items Impacting Expenditures Expenditure Impact of Removing Proposed Increases to Parking Fees: ($3,263,751) The FY 2024 Proposed Budget included increases to various parking fees. This action will remove those proposed increases and the associated revenue. To balance the parking enterprise fund, the department’s expenditure appropriation for debt service will be reduced by $3,236,751 to account for the revenue impact of removing the proposed fee increases. Parking will be able to meet their debt 8 service obligations for FY 2024; however, adjustments will be necessary for FY 2025 anticipated debt obligations. Parking’s Re-Lamping Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) project will be reduced in FY 2024 by $1.55 million to lessen the future impact on debt service. Reduce Non-Mandated Reserves: ($2,200,000) This action reduces the Virginia Retirement System (VRS) reserve by $1,000,000, reduces the Flexible Spending Account (FSA) reserve by $1,000,000, and eliminates the $200,000 Energy Reserve. Net Impact of Adjustments on Local Contribution to Norfolk Public Schools: ($19,769) The city’s revenue sharing formula with NPS will be reduced by $413,700 due to the motor vehicle license fee suspension. However, the additional funding due to fourth quarter construction has increased school funding by $393,931. The net impact of these two revenue adjustments is a reduction of $19,769 in the local contribution to NPS. Eliminate Long-Term Vacancies: ($775,645) Recognize savings from the elimination of long-term vacancies. The tables below detail:  A summary of the cost of amendments and adjustments to the operating budget  The sources of funds that will be used to fund the operating budget amendments and adjustments Uses of Operating Budget Amendments/Adjustments Amount Increase Support for Outside Agencies $454,897 Provide funds for Relocation Assistance for the Hurrah Players $100,000 Provide Funds to Enhance Right of Way Inspections $101,228 Provide funds for City Assessor Salaries $136,000 Provide Funds to Right-Size City Auditor Salary Funds $104,810 Provide Funds for City Clerk $81,062 Provide Funds for the General Registrar for Election Support $31,061 Provide Funds to Enhance Citywide Title VI Compliance $66,102 Provide One-Time Funds for a Traffic Operations Vehicle $85,000 Provide Funds to Enhance Veterinary Services at NACC $500,000 Provide Funds for a Citywide Trail Assessment and Master Plan $150,000 Provide Funds for Fire-Rescue EMS Operations Staff $259,082 Provide Additional Funding for the Real Time Crime Center $532,202 Provide Funds for Community Violence Intervention Training $350,000 Provide Funds for the Nighttime Basketball Program (Nighthawks) $250,000 Provide Funds for Enhanced Street Outreach Efforts $108,000 Provide Funds for a One-Time Retiree Supplement $1,500,000 Total Impact from Reconciliation $4,809,444 9 Sources of Operating Budget Amendments/Adjustments Expenditures Revenues Total Impact from Reconciliation $4,809,444 Expenditure Impacts: Reduce VRS Reserve ($1,000,000) Reduce FSA Benefit Reserve ($1,000,000) Eliminate Energy Reserve ($200,000) Savings from Eliminating Long-Term Vacancies ($775,645) NPS Reduction from Motor Vehicle License Suspension ($413,700) Remove Parking Expenditures ($3,263,751) NPS Expenditure Share from 4th Quarter New Construction Revenue $393,931 Revenue Impacts: Recognize 4th Quarter Assessment for New Construction Revenue* $993,069 Increase FY 2023 Projected Surplus $1,827,030 Revenue Reduction for Vehicle Licensing ($1,400,000) Remove Parking Rate Fee Increases ($3,263,751) NPS Revenue Share from 4th Quarter New Construction Revenue $393,931 Change to Proposed Operating Budget ($1,449,721) ($1,449,721) FY 2024 Proposed Operating Budget $1,441,307,333 Changes Via Reconciliation ($1,449,721) Final Proposed Operating Budget $1,439,857,612 With the adjustments above, the FY 2024 Operating Budget is balanced and results in a net decrease to the total budget of $1.45 million. This decrease is predominately due to the elimination of the proposed parking rate adjustments. Through strategic decisions and valuable input from both City Council and residents, these amendments to the Operating Budget continue the theme of providing the right services at the right scale and expanding or right-sizing services where appropriate. Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) Amendments The FY 2024 – FY 2028 CIP is being reduced by $13,090,378 over the five-year plan. FY 2024 has been reduced by $18,970,378 from $414,583,547 in the proposed budget to $395,613,169. The adjustments to projects and sources of funding are: Provide Funds for the Virginia Arts Festival Capital Campaign: $1,000,000 As a part of the city’s partnership with the Virginia Arts Festival, the FY 2024 capital budget is amended to include $1,000,000 in support of their capital campaign. Provide Funds for Norfolk Botanical Garden’s Capital Campaign: $2,500,000 Provide funds to support Norfolk Botanical Garden’s “The Garden of Tomorrow” capital campaign. The project will improve the entrance to the garden, construct a conservatory, and create a water education and rowing center. Funding for this project will be provided in FY 2024 and FY 2025. 10 Provide funding for Fred Huette Center Maintenance: $500,000 Funding will update major systems including heating and air conditioning of the facility. Provide Funding for Maintenance of Banks Community Center in Berkley: $500,000 The building has sustained damage from water leaks and intrusion. Currently, the building is undergoing an evaluation and cost analysis for necessary repairs. Provide Funds for Dredging of the Lafayette River: $2,510,000 Various sections of the river will be dredged during the same fiscal year to reduce mobilization costs. Increase Funds for Invest in Housing Rehabilitation (Renovate Norfolk) Program: $200,000 The Renovate Norfolk program provides Community Development Block Grants (CDBG) to low-to- moderate income homeowners who need repairs made to their homes related to health and safety concerns. This funding will provide a match to the CDBG funds to allow funding to homes requiring more health and safety repairs than allowed by the programs current cap of $25,000. Increase Funds to Improve and Maintain the Virginia Zoo: $550,000 Some improvements include updates to barriers and upgrades to exhibits. Increase Funds to Address Norfolk Public Schools Major Maintenance: $11,000,000 To correct an error, an $11,000,000 increase in funding to support major maintenance and repair of school facilities is recommended for the FY 2024 CIP. This action will increase school funding to help preserve the life of buildings, perform major preventative maintenance, and undertake significant repairs. This increase is funded by school reversion funds. Also, use of debt in the CIP will increase to support city projects which were incorrectly funded using school reversion funds. Increase Funds to Improve Granby Street Corridor: $2,000,000 This project will construct pedestrian and vehicular safety improvements along the Granby Street corridor. The project will be done to support the federally funded Granby Bike Lanes project. Increase Funds to Renovate Chrysler Hall: $1,000,000 Provide funds to complete the design work for the renovation of Chrysler Hall. Decrease Funds to Support Parking Garage Re-Lamping Program: ($1,549,178) Decrease funds provided to replace lighting at Town Point Garage and Main Street Garage with high efficiency LED lighting. The funding for this project is being reduced due to the removal of the proposed parking fee increase. Decrease Funds to Restore Riverside Memorial Park Shoreline: ($800,000) The cost to the city for the project in FY 2024 is being reduced as the city has received grant funds that are being recognized in FY 2023. Restoration work will include various living shoreline techniques that will both restore and stabilize the area. 11 Decrease Funds for Tanners’ Creek – NW Branch Neighborhood Dredging: ($750,000) This project is being consolidated into the Dredging of the Lafayette River project. Provide funds to perform maintenance dredging of the northwest branch of Tanners Creek. Navigational channels must be re-dredged every 10 to 15 years to prevent shoaling from natural processes and storms. Decrease Funds to Improve Citywide Dredging and Waterways: ($660,000) These funds included maintenance and replacement of navigational markers and underwater inspections of city infrastructure. Decrease Funds to Construct a Downtown Flood Wall: ($36,371,200) The Downtown Flood Wall Project provides the required 35% match funds to support Phase I of the city’s Coastal Storm Risk Management Project that was developed in partnership with the United States Army Corps of Engineers. Phase I includes improvements to the Downtown Flood Wall, pumps, and levees that will protect the city's commercial core. This amendment decreases the FY 2024 budgeted amount for the local match by $36.4 million, from $93.0 million to $56.6 million. The entire match amount of $93.0 million is no longer necessary in FY 2024 due to updates to the anticipated costs and timeline. The $36.4 million reduction to the local match in FY 2024 will be allocated to the latter years of this project, beyond the five-year FY 2024 – FY 2028 CIP. Move Funds for Perform Pretty Lake Main Channel Maintenance Dredging: ($1,100,000) Shift funds provided to perform maintenance dredging of the main channels in Pretty Lake from FY 2024 to FY 2027. The navigational channels in Pretty Lake consist of ancillary channels in the lake branches which access the various residential areas and are connected by main channels. Move Funds for Improve Richmond Crescent and Surrey Crescent Shoreline to FY 2024-2025 from FY 2026: $500,000 Move timeline up for funds to replace failing bulkheads at Richmond Crescent and Surrey Crescent with living and rock shorelines to protect the roadways from rising tides and mitigate frequent nuisance flooding in the area. The project will also include expanding the existing living shoreline between Myrtle Park and Larchmont Library. $500,000 is provided in FY 2024 and $5,000,000 is planned in FY 2025. The tables below detail the sources of funds used to fund the CIP amendments and adjustments outlined above: Sources of CIP Amendments/Adjustments FY 2024 – FY 2028 FY 2022 Surplus/Fund Balance $5,950,000 Increase State Contribution for Flood Wall $28,800 Reduce Restore Riverside Memorial Park Shoreline due to grant funds ($800,000) Decrease Parking revenue transferred to CIP ($1,549,178) Debt ($16,720,000) Total ($13,090,378) 12 Uses of CIP Amendment Funds FY 2024 – FY 2028 Create new project Provide Funds for Virginia Arts Festival Capital Campaign $1,000,000 Create new project Provide funding for Norfolk Botanical Garden's Capital Campaign $5,000,000 Create new project Provide funding for Fred Huette Center Maintenance $500,000 Create new project Provide Funding for Maintenance of Banks Community Center in Berkley $500,000 Create new CIP project Provide Funds for Dredging of Lafayette River $3,810,000 Increase Invest in Housing Rehabilitation $1,000,000 Increase Improve and Maintain the Zoo $2,550,000 Increase Address School Major Maintenance $11,000,000 Increase Improve Granby Street Corridor $2,000,000 Increase Renovate Chrysler Hall $1,000,000 Decrease Support Parking Garage Re-Lamping Program ($1,549,178) Decrease Restore Riverside Memorial Park Shoreline ($800,000) Decrease Tanners' Creek - NW Branch Neighborhood Maintenance Dredging ($750,000) Decrease Improve Citywide Dredging and Waterways ($1,980,000) Decrease Construct a Downtown Flood Wall ($36,371,200) Move timeline up for Perform Pretty Lake Main Channel Maintenance Dredging $0 Move timeline up for Improve Richmond Crescent and Surrey Crescent Shoreline $0 Total ($13,090,378) 13 Next Steps As we move forward, the administration will continue to partner with stakeholders to deliver high quality, efficient, and effective programs to our residents. On behalf of the dedicated members of Team Norfolk, I thank City Council for their forward thinking and valuable input on the usage of the city’s funds and taxpayer dollars. I look forward to implementing the many initiatives supported by the Adopted FY 2024 Budget. Sincerely, Dr. Larry H. Filer II City Manager FY 2024 - FY 2028 CIP Amendments/Adjustments Project Title FY 2024 Adopted FY 2025 FY 2026 FY 2027 FY 2028 Total Construct a Downtown Flood Wall $56,628,800 $93,000,000 $93,000,000 $93,000,000 $93,000,000 $428,628,800 Address School Major Maintenance $25,891,347 $9,000,000 $3,000,000 $3,000,000 $3,000,000 $43,891,347 *Provide Funds for Dredging of Lafayette River $2,510,000 $1,300,000 $0 $0 $0 $3,810,000 Provide funding for Norfolk Botanical Garden's Capital Campaign $2,500,000 $2,500,000 $0 $0 $0 $5,000,000 Improve Granby Street Corridor $2,000,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $2,000,000 Restore Riverside Memorial Park Shoreline $2,000,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $2,000,000 Provide funds for Virginia Arts Festival Capital Campaign $1,000,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,000,000 Renovate Chrysler Hall $1,000,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $1,000,000 Improve and Maintain the Zoo $550,000 $500,000 $500,000 $500,000 $500,000 $2,550,000 Provide Funding for Fred Huette Center Maintenance $500,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $500,000 Provide Funding for Maintenance of Banks Community Center in Berkley $500,000 $0 $0 $0 $0 $500,000 Improve Richmond Crescent and Surrey Crescent Shoreline $500,000 $5,000,000 $0 $0 $0 $5,500,000 Invest in Housing Rehabilitation $200,000 $200,000 $200,000 $200,000 $200,000 $1,000,000 Improve Citywide Dredging and Waterways $0 $0 $0 $660,000 $660,000 $1,320,000 Perform Pretty Lake Main Channel Maintenance Dredging $0 $0 $0 $1,100,000 $0 $1,100,000 Support Parking Garage Re-Lamping Program $2,000,822 $0 $0 $0 $0 $2,000,822 Total $97,780,969 $111,500,000 $96,700,000 $98,460,000 $97,360,000 $501,800,969 *Funding for Tanner's Creek Dredging has been consolidated into the Dredging of Lafayette River project <----------------------------Planned---------------------------> This page intentionally left blank 15 March 28, 2023 Honorable Mayor and City Council, I respectfully submit to you the Proposed Fiscal Year (FY) 2024 Financial Plan for the City of Norfolk, which is comprised of the General Fund, enterprise funds, special revenue funds, internal service funds, the Capital Improvement Plan (CIP), the Annual Plan for Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Block Grant programs, and the Annual Grants Plan. A summary of the Proposed Financial Plan is shown in the table below: Proposed FY 2024 Financial Plan Fund Proposed Budget General Fund $1,077,430,998 Enterprise Funds $193,244,589 Special Revenue Funds $52,016,213 Internal Service Funds $118,615,533 Total Operating Funds $1,441,307,333 Capital Improvement Plan $414,583,547 Total Operating and Capital Funds $1,855,890,880 Annual Plan for HUD Block Grants $7,054,048 Annual Grants Plan $86,498,241 Total Financial Plan $1,949,443,169 As we solidify our emergence from the pandemic, we continue to focus on strategically funding the right services for today and developing a sound and sustainable plan for the future. Data-informed decision making and resource allocation were the guiding principles for the development of the FY 2024 budget. In the fall of 2022, the City of Norfolk undertook a resident survey in partnership with ETC Institute. The survey data regarding resident priorities and satisfaction with city services guided the strategic funding decisions for the FY 2024 budget. The resident survey represents a random and statistically valid sample of residents from across the city. ETC Institute monitored responses and followed up to ensure all wards of the city were equally represented. Residents not selected in the random sample also had the opportunity to provide feedback. Going forward, a resident survey will be conducted every two years so that we can continue to ensure that our services are responsive to residents' needs and priorities. The main resident priorities that emerged from the survey were:  Direct Services to Residents  Neighborhood Quality 16  Infrastructure Maintenance and Sustainability  Public Safety  Public Schools Based on City Council and resident feedback, in addition to new initiatives included in this budget, we will build on and enhance programs that are already in place to address these resident priorities and strategically add or expand services in areas where we are not meeting resident demand. The FY 2024 budget also includes funding to support the city’s organizational effectiveness ensuring we remain operationally sound and responsive to resident needs. This budget right-sizes our programs and services and places the emphasis on quality over quantity. By focusing on expanding the right services for today, based on resident feedback, we can ensure higher quality service delivery. Economic Outlook We continue our recovery from the pandemic with strong revenue growth. The FY 2023 revenues driven by consumption-based and real estate taxes are outperforming the budget. Personal property taxes are also anticipated to be slightly above budget due to car values not declining as quickly as anticipated. While car values remain high, personal property tax amounts paid by Norfolk residents remain lower than in neighboring cities. We are also projecting continued real estate assessment growth of 6.8% – a slower rate than in FY 2023. There is healthy revenue growth for consumption-based taxes (i.e., hotel, sales, and admissions) with a projected revenue growth of 8.9%. The Federal Reserve’s increasing interest rates are positively impacting the city’s interest earnings; however, they are simultaneously driving significantly higher debt service. The higher cost of borrowing to finance Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) projects and fewer refunding opportunities for existing debt has a significant cost impact to the city’s operating budget. The city’s strong revenue growth is juxtaposed with economic challenges due to inflation, a tight labor market, and high interest rates on municipal bonds. High inflation continues to impact city operations, just as it impacts resident purchasing power, resulting in nearly $5 million in higher costs to maintain our current service level. The January 2023 unemployment rate of 3.4% was the lowest since May 1969. The combination of historically low unemployment, a labor force participation rate that is below the pre- 17 pandemic level, and increasing compensation costs has resulted in a challenging hiring environment where we continue to see higher than normal vacancy rates paired with higher personnel costs. Budget Overview The Proposed FY 2024 General Fund Budget is over $1 billion – 6.9% more than last year. The total operating budget is $1.4 billion – 5.9% more than last year. The total spending plan is more than $1.9 billion and includes $414.5 million in Capital Improvement Plan funds, $7 million in HUD entitlement grants, and $86.4 million in anticipated grant funding. The budget includes:  No tax rate increases  Pay raise for Team Norfolk o 5% general wage increase for all general, constitutional, and nonsworn employees o A step increase plus a 2.5% increase (minimum of a 5% increase) for sworn Public Safety  $6.4M and 34 FTE to address resident priorities  $3.5M and 20 FTE to improve organizational effectiveness  $10.5M increase in local contribution to Norfolk Public Schools  $9.4M to purchase 120 vehicles /pieces of equipment  $4.2M to improve hardware and software systems  $93M in matching funds for the Downtown Floodwall Project  $65.5M for a new Norfolk Fitness and Wellness Center  $12M for improving the Half Moone Cruise Terminal  $53.5M more than planned for maintenance of city infrastructure  $13.6M increase in Debt Service due to a growing Capital Improvement Plan (CIP)  Proposed fee changes for a number of the city’s special revenue and enterprise funds: o A $1.50 increase in the Solid Waste Residential fee o A 4% increase to the Storm Water fee o An increase to various Parking fees o An increase to various Cemeteries fee  Automatic fee increases for Water, and Wastewater/Sewer The budget relies on $13.2 million of State and Local Fiscal Recovery funds (SLFRF) and anticipated surplus to balance. As discussed with City Council during last year’s budget development, we are beginning the three-year drawdown of the Continuity of Services Set Aside from the American Rescue Plan Act (ARPA) funds. Use of this set aside allows us to enhance city services in response to the resident survey and provide a much-needed raise to employees all while avoiding having to raise taxes. The city expects to return close to structural balance by FY 2027. Organizational Effectiveness - Investing in Team Norfolk Last fiscal year, we invested heavily in Team Norfolk in order to strengthen our ability to recruit and retain the employees that provide core government services. We provided employees with a 5% general wage increase, increased the minimum wage to $18 an hour for permanent employees and $15 an hour for temporary employees, ensured that City of Norfolk employees saw no increase in healthcare 18 premiums, and provided paid family leave and a dependent care benefit, among other employee- focused initiatives. Competition for employees remains fierce, and we continue to see higher vacancy rates than pre- pandemic. However, our investments in our staff have not been without impact – we have retained 94% of the 651 employees that were impacted by the minimum wage increase in last year’s budget. For FY 2024, I am again proposing a 5% general wage increase for all general, constitutional, and nonsworn employees as well as a step increase plus a 2.5% increase (for a minimum of a 5% increase) for sworn employees on Pay Plan 5 effective July 2023. Employees will again see no increases in healthcare premiums in FY 2024 and will also see improved coverage of health care benefits such as hearing aids, no or minimal cost diabetic supplies, and more. With the strategic investments in our compensation and benefits offerings in last year’s budget paired with these investments in FY 2024, we hope to be able to continue to attract and retain talented employees that provide quality services to our residents. Additionally, the city is taking further steps to address recruitment and retainment for certain hard to fill or hard to retain positions, including for 911 Dispatch. The Telecommunicator series will be moved to the Pay Plan 5 which will significantly increase their starting pay so that our salaries are competitive with other cities in the region. Telecommunicator salaries will now be on a step system that will provide a more predictable pay progression and career ladder. This change will facilitate the recruitment and retention of these invaluable employees. Last year, we began a pilot program for Police physical and mental wellness services which has proven to be effective and well-received by Police personnel. In FY 2024, this contract will be expanded to include Fire Rescue and 911/Emergency Preparedness and Response. This wellness program is tailored to meet the needs of and support public safety and 911 personnel through targeted therapy, training, and biofeedback data. Organizational Effectiveness – Operational Investments While this budget’s primary focus is addressing resident priorities as identified in the resident survey, we must also assess our internal operations and processes. Information Technology (IT) infrastructure, Fleet vehicles and equipment, funding to train staff and develop work plans, and sufficient staffing to keep the gears of government turning efficiently are cornerstones of an effective organization. This budget makes meaningful investments in these areas. In FY 2019, City Council implemented a real estate tax increase – a portion of which went to address growing backlogs in our IT infrastructure and Fleet vehicles and equipment. This investment has continued in every budget since, and this year is no different. This budget allocates $9.4 million for Fleet investments including 120 vehicles/pieces of equipment (26 Police vehicles and 4 Fire-Rescue vehicles) and $4.2 million for software and technology investments, all of which will be funded with cash. The proposed budget also includes enhancements to both cyber and physical security with the addition of a Chief Information Security position and IT security software to address growing cybersecurity threats and minimize our vulnerabilities. As of March, IT has stopped nearly 8.3 million malicious emails in FY 2023, with a weekly average of 219,000. The budget also adds six Physical Security Specialists to provide enhanced security in city facilities and parking garages. The survey indicated that residents receive a significant amount of their information directly from city employees; with this budget we will establish an Internal Communications program with four FTE within 19 the department of Communications & Marketing. This will enhance communication across the organization and ensure city staff are adequately equipped to communicate effectively and consistently both internally and with residents. Additionally, approximately $60,000 is provided for staff development and training. Overall, the FY 2024 proposed budget adds a total of 20 FTE across various programs to improve organizational efficiency and enhance resident services. Addressing Resident Priorities Direct Services to Residents The city continues to meet and exceed demand for core resident services including waste management services such as trash/garbage collection services, yard waste/leaf/brush pick-up services, and curbside recycling services. In order to maintain this high level of service, I propose increasing the solid waste residential fee for residents by $1.50 dollars from $27.01 a month to $28.51 a month. This fee increase will ensure that the waste management fund is sustainable and that residents continue to receive excellent waste management services despite increased operating costs due to inflation and cost increases from the regional waste facility. Other high satisfaction services within Direct Services to Residents include libraries and the physical condition of outdoor parks, trails, and outdoor facilities. This year’s proposed budget includes additional temporary part-time staffing support for both Norfolk Public Libraries and the Slover which will ensure that libraries are fully open and available to residents at least 40 hours a week. Funds are also included to enhance landscaping to ensure residents can continue to enjoy the city’s parks and trails. While we continue to maintain and build on these areas of higher satisfaction, we recognize that we have more to do to meet residents’ expectations for recreation facilities and programming. The budget includes funds to enhance recreation programming by adding three recreation specialists and three part-time recreation activity instructors. The positions will instruct outdoor environmental and nature programming at recreation facilities and parks throughout the city. Additionally, funds are included to support four new unarmed Park Ranger positions to reduce the burden on Police for minor incidents in parks. Funds to compensate Sheriff Deputies to provide event security at youth sports leagues, athletic programs and other special recreation events for youth and adults are also included. 20 In FY 2023, the city conducted an assessment of all city tennis courts. Tennis courts will be repaired and renovated in phases based on the final report and its recommendations. In FY 2024, the courts at Booker T. Washington and Lake Taylor High School will be improved. Funding for these improvements is included in the CIP. The FY 2024 proposed CIP also provides $65.5 million to fully fund the construction of the new Norfolk Fitness and Wellness Center (NFWC) and library. The FY 2022 budget included four million dollars to design a combination recreation center and library facility on the site of the current NFWC. Additionally, funding is included in the CIP for the acquisition and renovation of the Rosna Theatre which will serve as the future home of Norfolk’s boxing program. In order to ensure we are offering the best possible service to our most vulnerable residents, $1.4 million is included in the proposed budget to support continued improvements to the Human Services building. Funds will address safety and security improvements, additional restrooms, security fencing, access controls and cameras, signage, and furnishings. The renovation is designed to provide a safe and secure environment and is designed around trauma-informed principles. These improvements will create a positive environment that supports customer and employee safety. The FY 2024 CIP also provides funds for a commercial kitchen for the city’s homeless shelter, The Center. The 100-bed shelter was purchased and began operating in FY 2022 and continues to support and provide services to homeless individuals as they work toward transitioning to permanent housing. Since opening, 484 people have been served of which 56 of have moved on to either temporary (28 people) or permanent housing (28 people). The proposed budget also includes increases to various Cemeteries fees. These fees were last adjusted in FY 2019. These increases ensure the city is equipped to continue to offer excellent service during times of increasing operational costs and allow for better future planning for the care of the cemeteries. Even with the increase, Norfolk’s Cemeteries fees will remain substantially lower than private cemeteries, and we will continue to offer the most affordable options to our residents. A table of all proposed Cemeteries fee increases can be found in the Proposed Fee Changes section. Neighborhood Quality While residents were generally satisfied with the overall quality and condition of housing in their neighborhood and the overall appearance of their neighborhood, residents were less satisfied with the level of trash and debris on private property and the overall enforcement of codes and ordinances. The FY 2024 proposed budget takes several steps to address these concerns. Funding is included to enhance nuisance abatement and promote a safe, clean, and friendly environment for all residents and 21 visitors. Nuisance abatement involves the cleanup of illegal dumping, construction debris in the public right-of-way, timbers, overgrown vegetation, and other nuisances deemed a risk to public health and safety. The additional funding will allow for more timely abatement responses to improve the health, safety, and aesthetics of an area. This funding will supplement the 12 positions added in FY 2022 within the department of Parks and Recreation to improve overall litter control. The proposed budget also fully funds the code enforcement expansion for private property maintenance. This expansion effort will add 12 FTEs responsible for enforcing city ordinances and the Virginia Maintenance Code (VMC). In addition to core services such as nuisance abatement, vacant building registration, and annual inspections of elevators and escalators, expanded services include but are not limited to hotel/motel inspections, Residential Rental Program (RRP), issuing Waste Management citations with civil fines, and increased enforcement along commercial corridors. This brings the total Code Enforcement FTE count to 40 positions who will support increased engagement, education, and enforcement to improve the appearance of the city and its neighborhoods. Funds for one-time abatement assistance for eligible property owners with extenuating circumstances and a plan to enhance education of property maintenance responsibilities for property owners are also funded as a part of the expansion. Additionally, code enforcement operating hours will be increased from 5pm to 7pm during weekdays, and Saturday hours will be added to assist with enforcement efforts. To accommodate the additional staff and hours, funding for a satellite location is also included. The proposed budget also enhances Conditional Use Permit (CUP) application processing, particularly for restaurants that serve alcohol, by funding an additional City Planner I position who will be responsible for processing applications related to CUPs to ensure compliance with the Zoning Ordinance. A Residential Plan Coordinator FTE is also added to enhance processing for residential permits. Last year’s budget funded the Business Compliance Unit (BCU) which has now fully staffed its nine FTEs to ensure consistent enforcement of codes related to compliance with conditional use permit requirements with a primary focus on after-hours activities occurring at nightclubs, other late-night entertainment, and short-term rental activities. Residents had lower satisfaction levels regarding the availability and affordability of housing options. To address this, the city is working with a consultant to prepare a comprehensive housing study and recommendations for a set of affordable housing policies. The FY 2024 budget will fund one new Senior Design and Rehabilitation Specialist to enforce the requirements associated with the anticipated Resident Satisfaction with Affordability of Housing Options 22 inclusionary zoning policy. Other initiatives to address affordable housing include expanding the city’s fair housing education and enforcement activities, with the addition of a new Fair Housing Compliance Specialist, and a grant-funded partnership with Housing Opportunities Made Equal of VA to complete fair housing testing and education in Norfolk. These efforts will strengthen the local, state, and federal fair housing protections for all protected classes. Other efforts include the transformative redevelopment of the St. Paul's area, now known as Kindred, continuation of the Renovate Norfolk and Strengthening Neighborhoods’ owner-occupied rehabilitation and down-payment assistance programs, the city-owned vacant property online auction, and the Department of Neighborhood Services’ Rent Ready Norfolk education program and Norfolk Eviction Prevention Center. As of March 2021, $1.9 million has been allocated and 469 households have been assisted through the Eviction Prevention Center. Infrastructure Maintenance and Sustainability Continued investment in maintaining and improving our infrastructure is essential to ensure the long- term safety and sustainability of our city. The highest resident satisfaction areas for Infrastructure Maintenance and Sustainability include water and sewer services, the quality of the city’s drinking water, and the condition of street signs and traffic signals. The proposed Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) makes significant investments in maintaining and enhancing the city’s water and sewer infrastructure including upgrades to water treatment plants, replacement of water transmission distribution, and improvements to the wastewater collection system and wastewater infrastructure in both the Larchmont and Kindred areas. The water and wastewater infrastructure improvements in the Kindred area will provide the infrastructure required to transform the area into a multi-use, mixed-income development to deconcentrate poverty and enact place-based initiatives. Lower resident satisfaction areas identified in the survey include bicycle infrastructure, the maintenance of major city streets, neighborhood streets and sidewalks, traffic flow, the adequacy of street lighting, and flooding. 23 The proposed FY 2024 CIP includes $16.6 million for improvements to street infrastructure citywide and a downtown traffic study. I also propose funding to support a Transportation Program Manager that will oversee field investigations generated by staff and citizen requests, traffic data collection, guardrail maintenance, streetlights, and the parking permit program. Funds are also proposed for multimodal maintenance as well as two Traffic Maintenance Technician positions who will assist with maintaining infrastructure related to e-scooters, e-bikes, bicycles, and pedestrian ways across the city. Repairs will be made to improve pavement markings, signage, and lane delineators. The city is also continuing its partnership with Dominion Energy to replace all streetlights with LEDs for better illumination of streets, parks, and parking lots – $5 million was appropriated for this effort in FY 2023. Residents recognized that we have more work to do in the areas of storm water management and flood control. Our resilience as a coastal city must be a priority now and in the years to come. The FY 2024 proposed budget makes substantial investments in addressing storm water and flood control concerns. The proposed CIP includes funding to support Phase 1 of the Coastal Storm Risk Management project which includes a large-scale extension of the Downtown Norfolk floodwall and the design and construction of storm surge barriers, levees, and pump stations. Norfolk will need to provide an annual $93 million match over the next ten years to this $2.6 billion project. This is the largest direct investment made by any Council to ensure the ongoing safety and prosperity of our residents and businesses. The project will be completed in five phases over the next decade and ensure Norfolk is a resilient and sustainable coastal city. Five FTE are included in this budget to manage the project. While the $93 million each year is the required non-federal match, our ability to pay this match will be substantially tied to the state being an equal partner in the project. The city will offset the bonding requirements through in-kind matches of land and infrastructure. 24 In addition, the proposed budget and CIP will address “behind the wall” flooding by reallocating the dedicated Citywide Flooding Reserve from the Storm Water monthly fee to the Blue/Green Way and allocates $5 million in FY 2024 for neighborhood storm water drainage projects in eight neighborhoods including:  Sylvan and Walnut Hill Street  East Ocean View  Overbrook/Coleman Place  Glenwood Park  Glenrock  Chesapeake Boulevard  Bruce’s Park  Lowery Road Overall, $40 million is programmed in the CIP from FY 2024 through FY 2028 to address neighborhood flooding. The Blue/Green Way in Kindred will redevelop approximately 26 acres of public housing and other properties into an aesthetic open space designed to treat and store storm water runoff during storm events. This transformation will create a water eco-center comprised of parks and green spaces. The budget also includes funds to enhance street sweeping to improve storm water infrastructure in order to further mitigate flooding and funding for the Hague Bulkhead repairs, critical maintenance to the Riverside Memorial Park shoreline, and repairs at the Pagoda Basin Waterfront. The proposed CIP begins an investment in citywide dredging efforts. Funding for dredging Tanner’s Creek is included in FY 2024; additional waterways will be dredged in FY 2024 and going forward based on a citywide dredging plan. Other CIP Investments The proposed CIP also funds the maintenance of city facilities, road and bridge infrastructure as well as the design of a new Norfolk Animal Care Center (NACC) facility that will also include space for Police Animal Protection. Funds for improvements to the Half Moone Cruise Terminal are also included as Carnival Cruise line has announced that they will be offering year-round cruises departing from Norfolk beginning in FY 2025. The Half Moone Cruise Terminal will be renovated to support the increased number of cruise ships that will be docking in Norfolk. The FY 2024 proposed budget also includes various increases to parking fees. These increases will make the Parking Fund sustainable and support various improvements including enhanced cameras and servers for safety and security in city parking facilities, a license plate reader, and the ongoing cost of the new Parking Access Revenue Control System (PARCs). There have been a few minor rate increases to short- term hourly and event rates and citation fees in the last 22 years; however, long-term monthly rates, both business and residential, have not increased in 25 years (since 1998). With the implementation of so many improvements to the customer experience, it is the right time to adjust these fees for the continued sustainability of the fund. A table of all proposed Parking fee increases can be found in the Proposed Fee Changes section. 25 Public Safety We are currently meeting and exceeding resident demand for Fire and Emergency Medical Services (EMS), 9-1-1 dispatch, and emergency management; however, the feedback we received from the resident survey confirms that we need to further adapt and innovate our approach to policing. The visibility of police and residents’ ability to engage with police in crime prevention activities were lower resident satisfaction areas. Last year’s budget took several steps to address the high public safety vacancy rates. We implemented a public safety redesign which made changes to the Pay Plan 5 to provide career progression opportunities and salary adjustments to make us competitive with our regional peers for sworn Police, Fire-Rescue and Sheriff personnel. Given the current hiring environment, we know that we will not be able to fill all of our sworn Police vacancies in the next fiscal year. This is not an issue unique to Norfolk; Police departments around the nation are struggling to fill vacancies that have steadily increased since the pandemic. To meet demand for public safety, we must reimagine what policing looks like and make conscious efforts to police smarter and align these efforts with 21st Century policing. We will not be able to fill our sworn vacancies in FY 2024. This budget provides funding for 652 sworn officer positions. I am recommending that we strategically redirect payroll savings in FY 2024 to three areas: 1. Continue the enhanced public safety salaries implemented in FY 2023 2. Invest in our Real Time Crime Center (RTCC) 3. Invest in a new Public Safety Aide classification The proposed budget will result in 5% raises for sworn staff, continuation of longevity bonuses of $12,000 for those who commit to remaining with us for five years. In addition, 167 police officers and 190 other sworn positions will receive a pay increase of 7.5% as they reach key career progression steps on Pay Plan 5, an additional 2.5% over the general wage increase of 5% for the sworn workforce. I am proposing that City Council redirect funds from unfilled positions toward these actions to improve retention of our current officers while ensuring the action is budget neutral. I am also proposing a significant investment in the Real Time Crime Center. The RTCC will serve as a central intelligence hub for public safety by providing 24/7 citywide real-time surveillance, emergency management, and crime analysis. RTCCs leverage multiple camera and data feeds to present a picture of what is taking place in real time; they also provide a centralized place to unite technology with intelligence and analysis by providing law enforcement the ability to respond quickly to developing situations. RTCCs efficiently enable even a single analyst or law enforcement officer to monitor several areas at once. This facility and its advanced technology will help provide critical intelligence to officers on the street and ensure effective crime prevention and emergency response. Finally, I am proposing that we create a new sworn classification, Public Safety Aide, a community-focused position that will enhance Police recruitment by offering employment to candidates as young as 18 years old and preparing them to enter the Police Academy. This will provide a path for recruitment and career progression for those interested in a public safety career and enhance services while preparing the next generation of officers. In addition to these investments, the FY 2024 proposed budget includes funds for training, enhanced fitness and wellness programs for public safety personnel, additional investment in the K-9 program to replace dogs as they age out of service, replacement body armor for Police and Sheriff, two FTEs and $2 26 million in additional funding for the jail medical contract, and a digital x-ray system for the bomb squad. We will also leverage grant funding to purchase and outfit a new bomb truck and a new fire truck. Funds are provided to establish a contract with a consultant that will help develop and implement an ongoing grassroots-level street safety program. Additional funding and an FTE within the City Manager’s Office are also included; the position will coordinate Equity in Policing efforts, the new anti-violence street safety program, and staffing a citizen review panel. A position within the department of Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) is also included to focus on public safety equity and inclusion efforts. Additionally, we will purchase a new automated fingerprint identification system and a cloud-based interview recording system for investigative and administrative purposes. The replacement of 911 Center computers, technology improvements for the Sheriff’s Office and jail, and mobile routers for Fire apparatus to enhance communication with local hospitals are also proposed. I also propose funding in FY 2024 to conduct a public safety facility needs study to understand what would be required to modernize public safety facilities throughout the city. The study will inform a Fire-Rescue Modernization Plan to renovate existing and construct new fire stations in future fiscal years as well as a new Public Safety Emergency Operations Center. These significant investments will ensure that Norfolk is equipped with the necessary tools to address public safety in an evolving and challenging environment. The Police budget will see an overall increase of $2.7 million in funding in FY 2024. This realignment will ensure that these funds are actively being used to improve public safety in Norfolk instead of being set aside for vacancies we know we cannot fill in this current hiring environment. These funds will support the ongoing cost of the Pay Plan 5 Redesign implemented last year and new initiatives such as public safety employee fitness and wellness, salary adjustments, additional code enforcement, and staffing the new Real Time Crime Center (RTCC). 27 Norfolk Public Schools Operating Budget The information below is based on the Superintendent’s proposed budget as the budget was not adopted by March 15, 2023. We will bring forward any necessary revisions with the adopted budget. Through the continued use of the funding formula, the local contribution to NPS is projected to increase by more than $10.5 million. This increase, along with $11 million in increased funding from the state and other sources, results in a 5.7% operating budget increase for NPS in FY 2024. The increase in local support has helped NPS invest in substantial pay increases for teachers, administrators, and support staff and raise teacher starting pay by 7%. The NPS Budget includes:  7% increase in the starting pay for teachers from $49,500 to $53,000  6.9% average salary increase for teachers  6.9% average salary increase for classified employees  5.1% average salary increase for administrators NPS Capital Improvement Plan Proposed FY 2024 – FY 2028 capital funding for NPS includes $32.8 million for school maintenance and $5 million for school buses. Additionally, funds are included for the construction of Norview Elementary School and Maury High School. Last year’s CIP included funds to renovate Booker T. Washington. The planned funding for Norview and Maury has been delayed by one fiscal year pending decisions from the School Board on whether they intend to consolidate and close certain schools due to declining enrollment in order to meet student needs more effectively and efficiently. We acknowledge the difficulty associated with redistricting students and will work with school administration to ensure that our investments in school modernization, when implemented, align with the long-term needs of students and staff. Debt Service Debt service payments increased by $12.2 million from FY 2022 to FY 2023. Debt service payments are expected to further increase in FY 2024 by $13.6 million from $87.6 million in FY 2023 to $101.3 million in FY 2024. 28 The city manages its long-term financing needs through periodic issuance of General Obligation bonds and last sold these bonds in August 2021. After years of reduced capital projects, the CIP has begun to grow. The FY 2022 and FY 2023 CIPs authorized more capital projects than in recent years. Large projects such as the Downtown Floodwall and school modernization are financed with General Obligation bonds and are further driving increased debt service. As a city we remain fiscally strong, but the recent rapid increase in debt service is not to be trivialized. The pending costs of the flood protection system combined with an aging city infrastructure will require significant investment over the next decade. Investments, with a focus on revenue enhancing investments, will need to be made during the decade to keep our debt service costs manageable. Conclusion The city’s proposed FY 2024 budget emphasizes providing the right services at the right scale. By focusing on strategic resource allocation based on data and resident feedback, we are expanding or right-sizing services where appropriate. We will continue to solicit and implement feedback from residents and measure our performance as we strive for the provision of quality service delivery across all programs and services. A special thanks to my Senior Executive Team of Deputy City Managers and Department Heads who played an important role in building this budget. I would also like to thank the Department of Budget and Strategic Planning for their work throughout the last year. I look forward to discussing this budget with you over the next six weeks. Sincerely, Dr. Larry H. Filer II City Manager Budget Overview Acknowledgments Distinguished Budget Presentation Award City of Norfolk Government Norfolk City Council and City Manager City of Norfolk Ward Map City Council’s Vision for Norfolk City of Norfolk Organizational Chart Reader's Guide to the Budget Financial Policies Fund Structure Basis of Budgeting and Accounting Budget Process Budget Calendar Financial Plan General Fund Budget Overview Estimated General Fund Revenues by Source Estimated Revenues by Source (All Funds) Estimated Expenditures by Use (All Funds) Estimated Expenditures by Fund Type Estimated General Fund Expenditures by Area Major Revenue Sources Appropriations Selected Tax Rates and Fees General Fund Balance Reserves Estimated General Fund - Fund Balance Summary of Changes in Fund Balance Summary of Changes in Net Assets Transfers From/To Full Time Equivalent (FTE) Staffing Summary City Indebtedness Yearly Maturity of Long-Term Debt General Fund Revenues General Fund Revenue Summary Adopted Fee Changes Adopted Fee Changes General Fund Expenditures General Fund Expenditure Summary Strategic Goals and Objectives Strategic Goals and Objectives Annual Grants Plan Annual Grants Plan 33 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 44 50 53 54 56 57 58 59 61 63 65 67 69 81 84 86 87 88 90 92 93 95 99 101 103 111 113 115 117 119 121 135 137 Table of Contents 29 Program Budget Pages Program Budget Pages Legislative City Auditor City Clerk City Council City Real Estate Assessor Executive Budget and Strategic Planning City Manager Communications & Marketing Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Housing and Community Development Resilience Department of Law City Attorney Constitutional Officers City Treasurer Clerk of the Circuit Court Commissioner of the Revenue Commonwealth's Attorney Sheriff and Jail Judicial Circuit Court Judges General District Court Juvenile and Domestic Relations Court Magistrate Norfolk Juvenile Court Service Unit Elections Elections General Management Finance General Services Human Resources Information Technology Community Development City Planning Economic Development Neighborhood Services Parks, Recreation and Culture Cultural Facilities, Arts and Entertainment Libraries Nauticus Parks and Recreation 151 153 165 167 170 173 174 177 179 189 198 208 216 227 235 237 239 241 244 246 248 251 257 259 262 264 266 268 271 273 277 279 298 323 337 353 355 375 393 407 409 420 437 449 30 Table of Contents Slover Library Zoological Park Public Health and Assistance Human Services Norfolk Community Services Board Public Health Public Safety Fire-Rescue Police Public Works Public Works Transportation Transportation Central and Outside Agency Appropriations Central Appropriations Outside Agencies Debt Service Debt Service Public School Education Public School Education Special Revenue Funds Special Revenue Fund Summary Cemeteries Emergency Preparedness and Response Golf Operations Public Amenities Tax Increment Financing Towing and Recovery Operations Waste Management Enterprise Funds Enterprise Fund Summary Parking Facilities Fund Storm Water Management Utilities - Wastewater Fund Utilities - Water Fund Internal Service Funds Internal Service Fund Summary Fleet Management Norfolk Healthcare Consortium Capital Improvement Plan Capital Improvement Plan Unfunded Capital Requests Unfunded Capital Requests Annual Plan 467 481 493 495 514 542 551 553 572 607 609 623 625 647 649 655 665 667 669 671 691 693 695 704 715 717 720 722 731 745 747 749 761 779 784 805 807 809 821 827 829 1011 1013 1021 Table of Contents 31 Annual Plan Norfolk Statistical Information Norfolk Statistical Information Glossary Glossary Ordinances 1023 1029 1031 1043 1045 1057 32 Table of Contents Budget Overview This page intentionally left blank Acknowledgments 35 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The preparation of the city’s annual resource allocation plan requires a tremendous amount of hard work and dedication on the part of many people. Developing expenditures and revenues information requires varying sources of data and multiple perspectives. The FY 2024 Budget was developed with the assistance of many who deserve acknowledgment and appreciation: • Residents of the city and civic league members, particularly those who attended community outreach meetings • Members of the city’s Employee Relations Committee • Executive budget team • Department and office directors • Members of the business community • Council Appointees • Constitutional Officers Special recognition and gratitude to the Department of Budget and Strategic Planning staff who worked to prepare this year’s budget. Director, Department of Budget and Strategic Planning Catheryn Whitesell Department of Budget and Strategic Planning Staff Anne Agorsor, Jason Beasley, Alan Boring, Moira Facer, Patricia Harrison, Matthew Konopka, Amanda Kostusiak, Carl Larsen, Dyteya Lewis, Stephen Lucas, Pamela Marino, Betty Meyer, Izek Montebon, Miguel Ortiz, Cecelia Rieb, Caylin Sawyer, Natasha Singh-Miller, Crystal Skinner, Jay Spare, Anne Marie Strano, Adam Tabakin, Genevieve Thomas, Andréa Vargas, and Timothy Werner . City Manager, Larry H. Filer, Ph.D. 36 Distinguished Budget Presentation Award DISTINGUISHED BUDGET PRESENTATION AWARD The Government Finance Officers Association of the United States and Canada (GFOA) presented an award of Distinguished Presentation to the City of Norfolk, Virginia for its annual budget for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2022. The review process by GFOA has not commenced for the annual budget for the fiscal year beginning July 1, 2023. This prestigious award is presented to governmental entities that prepare budget documents which exhibit the highest qualities in meeting or exceeding both the guidelines established by the National Advisory Council on State and Local Budgeting and GFOA’s standards of best practices. Documents submitted for the Budget Awards Program are reviewed by selected members of the GFOA professional staff and by outside reviewers with experience in public- sector budgeting. The award is valid for a period of one year. The FY 2024 budget continues to conform to program requirements and will be submitted to GFOA for award eligibility. City of Norfolk Government 37 CITY OF NORFOLK GOVERNMENT Norfolk City Council is the legislative body of the city government. It is authorized to exercise all the powers conferred upon the city by the Commonwealth of Virginia in the state constitution, state laws, and the Charter of the City of Norfolk. City Council is composed of eight members. Seven members are elected through a ward system, and the Mayor is elected at large by the residents of Norfolk. These members elect a vice president (Vice Mayor) of the Council. For further information on the duties, powers, and meetings of the Council, call the Office of the City Clerk, 757-664- 4253. The City Council meets the first, second, and fourth Tuesday of each month in Norfolk City Hall. There are two formal meetings held at 6:00 p.m. in the Council Chambers on the second and fourth Tuesday. Work sessions are held prior to the formal meetings and on the first Tuesday of each month. Starting times of the work sessions are determined by the agenda. The City of Norfolk operates under a Council-Manager form of government whereby the Council appoints a chief executive, the City Manager, Larry “Chip” Filer, PhD. The Council also appoints a City Attorney, Bernard A. Pishko; City Auditor, Tammie Dantzler; City Clerk, Richard A. Bull; and City Real Estate Assessor, W.A. (Pete) Rodda. 38 Norfolk City Council and City Manager NORFOLK CITY COUNCIL AND CITY MANAGER City Manager Larry “Chip” Filer, Ph.D. Mayor Kenneth Cooper Alexander, Ph.D. Vice Mayor Martin A. Thomas Jr. Ward 1 Council Member Courtney R. Doyle Ward 2 Council Member Mamie B. Johnson Ward 3 Council Member John E. “JP” Paige Ward 4 Council Member Thomas R. Smigiel Jr. Ward 5 Council Member Andria P . McClellan Superward 6 Council Member Danica J. Royster Superward 7 is .et •. I I LEGEND • Supenvards FC Wards I Cr} ) '03% t, • • •b I • • •••• - •,,z • • # crgiFf e. Cpl icity Ti Mee Ai.11; Los 4\'‘ • I 7, r- • sl -`, •• • rk City of Norfolk Ward Map 39 CITY OF NORFOLK WARD MAP 40 City Council’s Vision for Norfolk CITY COUNCIL’S VISION FOR NORFOLK Vision Statement • Norfolk is a national leader in the quality of life offered to all its citizens. • This is achieved through effective partnerships between city government and its constituents. • As a result, Norfolk is a physically attractive, socially supportive, and financially sound city. • Here, the sense of community is strong. • Neighborhoods are designed so that people of all ages can know their neighbors and travel the streets and sidewalks safely. • The sense of community exists citywide. • Norfolk is known nationally as a strategically located place where there are abundant and fulfilling employment, recreational, and educational opportunities. Residents of Norfolk City Council ( Constitutional Officers and other Local Officials • City Treasurer • Clerk of the Circuit Court • Commissioner of the Revenue • Corn monwea th is Attorney • Courts • Magistrate • Norfolk Juvenile Court Services Unit • Registrar • Sheriff Council Appointees • City Attorney • City Auditor • City Clerk • City Real Estate Assessor • Budget and Strategic Planning • City Planning • Communications& Marketing • Cultural Facilities, Arts and Entertainment • Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion • Economic Development • Emergency Preparedness and Response • Finance • Fire-Rescue City Manager City Departments Appointed Boards • General Services • Housing and Community Development • Human Resources • Human Services • Information Technology • Libraries • Nauticus • Neighborhood Services • Norfolk Community Services Board • Architectural Review • Civic Fac ilit ies Comm ission • Civil Service Commission • Economic Development Authority • Norfolk Employee's Retirement System • Norfolk Airport Authority • Norfolk City Planning Commission • Norfolk Community Services Board • Norfolk Redevelopment and Housing Authority • Public Arts Commission • Public Library Board of Trustees • Wetlands Board • Resilience • Parks and Recreation • Police • Public Health • Public Works • Slaver Lbrary • Transportation • Utilities • Zoological Park 'Appointed by State Board of Elections City of Norfolk Organizational Chart 41 CITY OF NORFOLK ORGANIZATIONAL CHART 42 Reader's Guide to the Budget READER'S GUIDE TO THE BUDGET PURPOSE The budget is an instrument that sets policy and summarizes public service programs provided by the city government and how the programs are funded. It is the annual plan for coordinating revenues and expenditures. The budget presented covers the period of July 1, 2023 to June 30, 2024 . The Adopted Budget document may include technical changes made after the City Manager’s presentation of the proposed budget to City Council. BUDGET OVERVIEW This section provides information on budget and financial policies, fund structure, basis of budget and accounting, budget process, budget calendar, and the city’s organizational chart. The section also includes revenue and expenditure summaries, discussion of major revenue sources, indebtedness, and personnel staffing. Historical revenue and expenditure amounts for FY 2022 provided in the summaries do not include designations and financial adjustments posted after June 30, 2022. FY 2024 adopted amounts may include technical changes made after the City Manager’s presentation of the proposed budget to the City Council. GENERAL FUND REVENUE AND EXPENDITURE The General Fund is used to account for primary government services. A summary of historical and estimated revenue from each source is provided for the General Fund. For each department within the General Fund, a summary of historical and approved expenditures is provided. Historical revenue and expenditure amounts for FY 2022 do not include designations and financial adjustments posted after June 30, 2022. FY 2024 adopted amounts may include technical changes made after the City Manager’s presentation of the proposed budget to the City Council. ANNUAL GRANTS PLAN This section provides an overview of the grants that the city anticipates to receive annually from federal, state, and other agencies that are dedicated for specific purposes. This information provides readers a more complete picture of the city’s resources available to provide programs and services for residents. DEPARTMENT PROGRAM BUDGETS This section provides detailed budget information by program for every department within the General Fund. This includes a brief description of proposed FY 2024 budget actions, their impact on the budget and full time equivalent (FTE) personnel. Performance measures for each program are included in program budget pages to measure outcome and impact of the program. Program enhancements that were requested by the department but not funded in the FY 2024 budget are also provided in this section. Historical revenue and expenditure amounts for FY 2021 and FY 2022 provided in the department summaries do not include designations and financial adjustments posted after June 30 of each fiscal year . FY 2024 adopted amounts may include technical changes made after the City Manager’s presentation of the proposed budget to the City Council. Reader's Guide to the Budget 43 PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATION This section provides information on the proposed appropriation for Norfolk Public Schools. SPECIAL REVENUE, ENTERPRISE, AND INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS These sections provide detailed budget information by program for the city’s Special Revenue, Enterprise, and Internal Service Funds. A brief description of proposed FY 2024 budget actions, their impact on the budget and full time equivalent (FTE) personnel are provided in this section. Performance measures for each program are included in program budget pages to measure outcome and impact of the program. Program enhancements that were requested by the department but not funded in the FY 2024 budget are also provided in this section. Historical revenues and expenditures for FY 2021 and FY 2022 provided in the department summaries do not include designations and financial adjustments posted after June 30 of each fiscal year . FY 2024 adopted amounts may include technical changes made after the City Manager’s presentation of the proposed budget to the City Council. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN The city’s debt service as a percentage of the General Fund budget must not exceed eleven percent (11%). Net debt, as a percentage of property, must not exceed four percent (4%). Due to these affordability measures, the city cannot afford to fund all requested General Capital projects. The Unfunded CIP Request Report shows projects that were requested by departments, but not included in the five-year Capital Improvement Plan. ANNUAL PLAN - U.S. DEPARTMENT OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVELOPMENT (HUD) ENTITLEMENT GRANT PROGRAM This section contains the Annual Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG), HOME Investment Partnerships Program, and Emergency Solutions Grant Program. The Annual Plan identifies the annual funding of the city’s priority community development projects and activities as outlined in the five-year Consolidated Plan. NORFOLK STATISTICAL INFORMATION This section provides statistical and general information about the city such as an overview of the organization, services, and selected functions. ORDINANCES, GLOSSARY, AND INDEX The ordinances adopted by the City Council establish the operating, capital improvement plan, annual grants, and the Annual Plan budget. The glossary provides definitions of budget-related terminology. The index contains an alphabetical reference of information contained in the document. 44 Financial Policies FINANCIAL POLICIES OPERATING BUDGET The operating budget for the city is developed pursuant to Section 67 of the Charter of the City of Norfolk, Virginia. In accordance with the City Charter, the City Manager submits to the City Council, no less than 60 days before the end of the fiscal year, a proposed operating budget for the ensuing fiscal year . The operating budget includes expenditure amounts based on detailed estimates furnished by departments and other divisions of the city government. The budget is presented in a manner that identifies appropriations, taxes, and estimated revenues with comparative statements. The budget is prepared by fund and department. Following the formal presentation of the proposed budget by the City Manager, a public hearing is conducted to provide an opportunity for the public to make comments on the proposed operating budget and any proposed tax and fee adjustments such as, proposed changes to the real estate tax rate. The public hearing for the operating budget is held at least seven days prior to City Council’s approval of the budget. City Council is required to approve a final operating budget no later than 30 days before the end of the current fiscal year . The formal approval of the budget is executed by the adoption of the ordinance delineating appropriations by fund. Additional budget controls are exercised administratively on an appropriation unit basis over combinations of object categories (account groups: personnel services, materials, supplies and repairs, contractual services, equipment, public assistance, department specific appropriation, and debt service), as well as on a line item basis over individual objects (budget accounts). Departments may transfer funds within a departmental budget with approval from the City Manager or the Department of Budget and Strategic Planning. The City Manager or designee is authorized to transfer from any department, fund, or activity which has an excess of funds appropriated for its use to any department, activity, or fund all or any part of such excess. Basic policies and guidelines for the development of the city’s annual budget are provided below. The administration is committed to high standards of financial management and currently maintains and follows financial practices and guidelines. On February 26, 2019, City Council passed a resolution to update the city’s policies on reserves, debt affordability, and surplus funds utilization, and adopt new financial policies on pension funding and enterprise fund financial management. On May 11, 2021. City Council passed a resolution updating the Pension Funding Policy to allow for the positive impacts garnered from the sale of debt to refinance a portion of the city’s pension liability. The update also provides a framework of when the city’s existing reserves will be utilized. The city’s Reserve Policy documents the city’s approach to establishing and maintaining strong reserves across the spectrum of city operations. The policy is designed to: • Identify city operations and functions for which reserves should be established and maintained, considering risks to the operation from unexpected events and the availability of other resources to address such events, and the volatility of expenditures and revenues of the operation; • Establish target reserve levels and provide a timeframe for meeting reserve targets, using a phased approach where necessary so that reserve goals are balanced appropriately with current budget availability; and • Establish criteria for the use of reserves and the process to replenish reserves. Financial policies demonstrate commitment to consistent financial practices, operational efficiencies, and best practices; preserve fiscal integrity; and improve fiscal stability to promote long-term fiscal sustainability. Sound financial management practices contribute to maintaining high city credit ratings and lower borrowing costs for capital projects. Financial Policies 45 RESERVE FUNDS PENSION FUNDING Description Policy General Fund Unassigned Reserve Maintained for the purpose of sustaining General Fund operations in the case of public emergency such as a natural disaster or other unforeseen catastrophic event, and will not be accessed to meet operating shortfalls or to fund new programs or personnel. At least ten percent (10%) of General Fund expenditures plus General Fund transfers out. City Council must approve all planned uses. Risk Management Reserve Provide funding sources for certain claims made against the City. Maximum funding of eight million dollars ($8,000,000) and no less than five million dollars ($5,000,000). City Council must approve all withdrawals. Economic Downturn Reserve Serves as a countercyclical reserve or "bridge funding" . The Council may use this to transition expenditure growth to match slower revenue growth during an economic recession, or to mitigate the impact of a severe, but temporary revenue loss, or to fund one-time economic stimulus to speed the city's recovery from an economic downturn. Fund at no less than two and one-half percent (2.5%) of the three (3) year average of real estate tax revenues, not-to-exceed five million dollars ($5,000,000). City Council must approve all withdrawals. Inclusive Development Opportunity Fund The Fund can be used to advance inclusive economic development and reduce inequities by improving the health, stability and economic security of residents and neighborhoods; fostering business and job growth; increasing household wealth; and supporting people, places, and actions that promote inclusive economic growth throughout the city’s diverse communities. Supports inclusive economic growth, with a targeted threshold of two million dollars ($2,000,000). City Council must approve all withdrawals. Reserve Replenishment In the event a reserve, is used to provide for temporary funding needs, the city shall restore the reserve to the minimum level within five (5) fiscal years following the fiscal year in which the event occurred and shall include a projected timeline for full reimbursement in the authorizing ordinance. Description Policy Pension Funding Policy The year following the issuance of pension obligation bonds, the contribution will be the current year’s actuarially defined contribution plus debt service on the bonds. Each subsequent year, the city’s total pension contribution will be the greater of the prior year’s contribution or the current year’s actuarially defined contribution. The contribution may be adjusted if one of the following conditions is met: 1). NERS’ funded ratio reaches 100%, 2). the year over year increase in the city’s total pension contribution exceeds six percent (6%) or 3). if the total pension contribution rises above eighty million dollars ($80,000,000). The city will strive to fund the actuarially defined contribution plus debt service on the pension obligation bonds in any year. The city’s enterprise funds will pay their respective portion, from dedicated fees and revenues, of pension costs including debt. 46 Financial Policies DEBT AFFORDABILITY MEASURES USE OF SURPLUS PARKING FUND Description Policy Net Debt as a Percent of the Total Assessed Value of Taxable Property Keep General Fund net debt below three and one-half percent (3.5%) with a not-to-exceed of four percent (4.0%) of the total assessed value of taxable property. For purposes of this ratio, the city will exclude debt issued to fund pension costs, as that debt is replacing an existing liability rather than funding a new capital project. Debt Service as Percent of General Fund Budget Keep General Fund debt service below ten percent (10%) with a not-to- exceed of eleven percent (11%) of General Fund budget. For purposes of this ratio, the city will exclude the debt service on debt issued to fund pension costs, as that debt is replacing an existing liability rather than funding a new capital project. Ten-year (10) General Obligation Payout Ratio Strive to repay the principal amount of the long-term general obligation bonds by at least fifty-five percent (55%) or greater within ten (10) years. Overlapping Debt – e.g. Special service district financing or tax increment financing that would be subject to annual appropriation The total amount of overlapping debt not to exceed one-half percent (0.5%) of total assessed value of taxable property. Variable Rate Debt Limit the city’s outstanding debt with variable interest rate to no more than twenty percent (20%) by fund. Description Policy Surplus Policy Use of Surplus 1 If reserves are not at their required minimum. Entire prior fiscal year-end surplus will fund reserves until the minimum requirement of each reserve has been met. Funding of reserves will be in the following priority. 1. General Fund Unassigned Reserve 2. Risk Management Reserve 3. Economic Downturn Reserve 4. Inclusive Development Opportunity Reserve 2 If reserves have met the required minimum, but not the maximum. Fifty percent (50%) of prior fiscal year-end surplus will fund reserves and fifty percent (50%) will cash fund (pay-go) the Capital Improvement Plan. 3 If reserves are fully funded at the maximum requirement. Entire prior fiscal year-end surplus will cash fund (pay-go) the Capital Improvement Plan or one-time technology and equipment purchases. Description Policy Debt Service Coverage Maintain debt service at a minimum of 1.1 times. Unrestricted Cash Maintain a minimum of 240 days of operating and maintenance expense. Financial Policies 47 Parking Fund (continued) WATER UTILITY FUND WASTEWATER UTILITY FUND Description Policy Repair & Replacement Reserve Intended to be used for emergency or unforeseen capital needs. Maintain a repair and replacement reserve of one million dollars ($1,000,000) within five (5) years. City Council must approve all withdrawals. Ten-Year Financial Plan Develop a ten-year financial plan annually that integrates revenue and expense projections and project cashflow forecasts relative to the financial policies. Description Policy Debt Service Coverage Maintain debt service at a minimum of 1.5 times gross of ROI and PILOT. Unrestricted Cash Maintain a minimum of 240 days of operating and maintenance expense. Repair & Replacement Reserve Intended to be used for emergency or unforeseen capital needs. Maintain a repair and replacement reserve of two million dollars ($2,000,000) within five (5) years. City Council must approve all withdrawals, and the intended use must comply with all legal and Master Indenture of Trust requirements. Return on Investment (“ROI”) The General Fund ROI transfer from the Water Utility Fund shall not exceed $8.5 million in a given year. Additional transfers may only be considered in the event the Water Utility Fund receives one-time, significant revenues and provided that the additional transfer would not cause the Fund to fail to adhere to any other financial policies. Payment in Lieu of Taxes (“PILOT”) The PILOT paid by the Water Utility Fund to the General Fund to be based on the taxable assessed value of real property using the applicable tax rate. Ten-Year Financial Plan Develop a ten-year financial plan annually that integrates revenue and expense projections and project cashflow forecasts relative to the financial policies. Description Policy Debt Service Coverage Maintain revenue bond debt service at 1.15 times and 1.1 times combined coverage (General Obligation and Revenue) minimum gross of ROI and PILOT. Unrestricted Cash Maintain a minimum of 180 days of operating and maintenance expense. Repair & Replacement Reserve Intended to be used for emergency or unforeseen capital needs. Maintain a repair and replacement reserve of one million dollars ($1,000,000) within five (5) years. City Council must approve all withdrawals. Return on Investment (“ROI”) The General Fund ROI Transfer from the Wastewater Utility Fund shall not exceed $1.5 million in a given year. Additional transfers may only be considered in the event the Wastewater Utility Fund receives one-time, significant revenues and provided that the additional transfer would not cause the Fund to fail to adhere to any other financial policies. 48 Financial Policies Wastewater Utility Fund (continued) STORM WATER UTILITY FUND CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN The city uses several guiding principles and best practices to manage the Capital Improvement Plan (CIP). The principles (see Guiding Principles under CIP section) governing the CIP are closely linked with the debt affordability measures in the financial policies described in the previous section. Using the principles as a foundation, the CIP is developed to promote capital infrastructure to support the city policies by establishing a five-year capital implementation plan. In formulating this long-range plan, input is solicited from various parties such as city departments, City Council, residents, and businesses. The CIP includes projects that meet the following city policy areas (see CIP section for definitions): • Education • Economic Development • Environmental Sustainability • Cultural Facilities • General and Other • Neighborhood Development • Public Buildings • Parks and Recreation Facilities • Transportation To be included in the CIP , the project must cost $75,000 or more and should enhance, increase the value of, or extend the life of the asset by more than the life of the debt instrument used to finance the improvement or grant program. Various sources of funding are used to fund the CIP . These sources include General Fund supported debt and Description Policy Payment in Lieu of Taxes (“PILOT”) The PILOT paid by the Wastewater Utility Fund to the General Fund to be based on the taxable assessed value of real property using the applicable tax rate. Ten-Year Financial Plan Develop a ten-year financial plan annually which integrates revenue and expense projections and project cashflow forecasts relative to the financial policies. Description Policy Debt Service Coverage Maintain revenue bond debt service coverage minimum at 1.15 times coverage and 1.1 times combined coverage (General Obligation and Revenue). Unrestricted Cash Maintain a minimum of 180 days of operating and maintenance expense. Repair & Replacement Reserve Intended to be used for emergency or unforeseen capital needs. Maintain a repair and replacement reserve of one million dollars ($1,000,000) within five (5) years. City Council must approve all withdrawals. Ten-Year Financial Plan Develop a ten-year financial plan annually that integrates revenue and expense projections and project cashflow forecasts relative to the financial policies. Financial Policies 49 nongeneral fund supported debt, such as revenue bonds or cash contributions from various resources. For general capital improvements, the city strives to achieve an annual pay-as-you-go cash contribution. MULTI-YEAR PLANNING The city’s multi-year planning process includes preparing a long-term base budget forecast annually. The long-term forecast of base revenues and expenditures enables the city to plan for the upcoming fiscal year’s budget and to identify financial challenges projected over the next five years. The long-term forecast is also utilized for monitoring the city’s debt affordability measures. In addition, the annual budget development process incorporates a two-year lens, whereby each recommended budget action is analyzed to determine its impact not just in the upcoming fiscal year but also in the following year. In the summer of each fiscal year, the Department of Budget and Strategic Planning (Budget Office) initiates the process of compiling information for the long-term forecast from city departments, regional and city partner agencies, state and federal agencies, and state and regional economists. In FY 2019, the Budget Office integrated the long-term forecast submission process in the performance budgeting (“budget”) system. As a result of the budget system enhancement, items in the forecast were seamlessly incorporated in the department’s base budget for the upcoming fiscal year . The actions in the Adopted FY 2023 Budget that impact the following fiscal year’s base budget are incorporated in the start point of the following year’s long-term forecasting process. Also, the long-term base revenue forecast is updated to reflect actions in the adopted budget. During the fall, the Budget Office refined the long-term forecast compiled during the summer. Although the long-term forecast was not presented at the fall financial update, the internal long-term forecast highlighted the projected fiscal impact from the Norfolk casino delay in coming online, compensation and benefit cost increases, debt service payment increases, other inflationary and contractual increases, and the potential use of one-time funds to bridge the budget deficit. The long-term base budget forecast annually incorporates adjustments to base revenues and expenditures due to: state, federal, and local mandates; debt payments; compensation and benefit cost increases; and other inflationary or contractual cost increases needed to maintain existing levels of service; the estimated impact of the Norfolk Public Schools (NPS) revenue sharing formula; obligations related to regional partnerships; the opening of new city facilities; economic development projects coming to fruition; national, state, and regional economic forecasts; state budget actions enacted by the General Assembly; state budget forecasts; annualization of prior year prorated costs; and removal of one-time budgetary items. However, the base revenue and expenditure forecast does not include: new fees; fee or tax rate changes; the cost of budget enhancements such as, new programs or initiatives, and program or service expansion; or policy changes under consideration and requiring City Council or administrative action. The preliminary long-term forecast provided the start point of the development of the budget for the upcoming fiscal year (FY 2024) as well as the base budget outlook for the following year (FY 2025). 50 Fund Structure FUND STRUCTURE The city uses fund accounting to ensure and demonstrate compliance with finance-related legal and regulatory requirements. A fund is a grouping of related accounts used to maintain control over resources that have been segregated for specific activities or objectives. The city’s funds can be divided into four categories: governmental funds, proprietary funds, component unit funds, and fiduciary funds. GOVERNMENTAL FUNDS Governmental funds consist of the General Fund, Special Revenue Funds, Capital Projects Fund, Debt Service Funds, and Permanent Fund. Most governmental functions of the city are financed through these funds. Governmental funds are supported by taxes and intergovernmental revenues. The modified accrual basis of accounting is used for the budgets of all governmental funds. General Fund The general operating fund of the city accounts for all financial transactions of the general government, except those required to be accounted for in another fund. The General Fund accounts for the city’s normal recurring activities such as police, fire-rescue, public education (K-12), and public works. These activities are supported by revenue from: general property and other local taxes; permits, fees and licenses; fines and forfeitures; use of money and property; charges for services; recovered costs; and aid from the Commonwealth and Federal Government. Special Revenue Funds The Special Revenue Funds account for the proceeds of specific revenue resources restricted or committed to expenditure for specific purposes (other than expendable trusts or major capital projects) and require separate accounting because of legal or regulatory provisions or administrative action. Capital Projects Fund The Capital Projects Fund accounts for the acquisition, construction, or renovation of major capital facilities of the city and Norfolk Public Schools. PROPRIETARY FUNDS Proprietary funds consist of Enterprise Funds and Internal Service Funds. Enterprise Funds account for operations similar to those found in the private sector and include Water Utility, Wastewater Utility, Storm Water Management, and Parking Facilities. Internal Service Funds account for the financing of goods and services provided by one department to other departments in the city on a cost reimbursement basis and include Healthcare and Fleet Management. The Proprietary Funds measurement focus is based upon determination of net income, financial position, and changes in financial position. Enterprise Funds Water Utility Fund This fund accounts for the operations of the city-owned water system. The cost of providing services is financed or recovered through user charges to customers, which include Norfolk residents, commercial customers, the U.S. Navy, and other regional localities and authorities. Wastewater Utility Fund This fund accounts for the operation of the city-owned wastewater (sewer) system. The cost of providing services is financed or recovered through user charges to Norfolk residential and commercial customers. Fund Structure 51 Storm Water Management Fund This fund accounts for the operation of the environmental storm water management system, including maintenance of storm water drainage facilities. The cost of providing services is financed or recovered through user charges to Norfolk residents and commercial and industrial customers. Parking Facilities Fund This fund accounts for the operation of city-owned parking facilities (garages, lots, and on-street meters). The cost of providing services is financed or recovered through user charges for long-term and short-term customer use and fines for parking violations. Internal Service Funds Healthcare Fund This fund accounts for the financing of medical coverage provided to employees of the Norfolk Healthcare Consortium through a city-administered health insurance plan. The Consortium includes the City of Norfolk, Norfolk Public Schools, and the Norfolk Redevelopment and Housing Authority. Employees and the Consortium share the costs of the health insurance premium, medical claims, administrative costs, wellness program costs, fees related to the Affordable Care Act, and benefit consultant expenses are paid by the Healthcare Fund. Fleet Management Fund This fund accounts for the maintenance, repair, and service for the city fleet of vehicles, heavy equipment, and miscellaneous machinery on a cost reimbursement basis. COMPONENT UNIT FUNDS Education The city’s total budget includes the funds of the Norfolk Public Schools. The primary sources of revenue are the city’s local contribution, basic school aid and sales tax revenues from the state, and educational program grants, Major expenditures are for instructional salaries and schools’ facility operating costs. School Operating Fund The School Operating Fund is the General Fund of the School Board. It accounts for all financial resources except those required to be accounted for in another fund, such as School Nutrition Services. School Grants This fund accounts for revenues and expenditures for federal, state, and other grants for educational programs. School Nutrition Services This fund supports the school breakfast and lunch program. School Nutrition Services is a self-funded non-reverting operation supported through cafeteria sales and federal and state reimbursements. FIDUCIARY FUNDS AND ENDOWED CARE FUND Fiduciary Funds are used to account for resources held for the benefit of parties outside the city and include the city’s Pension Trust Fund, Pension Funding Trust Fund, Commonwealth of Virginia custodial fund, and other custodial funds. Custodial funds are used to account for assets held by the city for individuals, private organizations, other governmental units, and/or other funds. The Endowed Care Fund is used to report resources that are restricted by the City Code to be used for perpetual and endowed care at certain city-owned cemeteries. Fiduciary Funds and the Endowed Care Fund are not included in the city’s budget, since its resources are not available to support the city’s own programs. These funds financial statements are presented separately within the city’s Annual Comprehensive Financial Report. 52 Fund Structure FUND STRUCTURE Governmental Funds General Fund Budget and Strategic Planning Central Appropriations Circuit Court Judges City Attorney City Auditor City Clerk City Council City Manager City Planning City Real Estate Assessor City Treasurer Clerk of the Circuit Court Commissioner of the Revenue Commonwealth’s Attorney Communications & Marketing Cultural Facilities, Arts and Entertainment Debt Service Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion Economic Development Elections Finance Fire-Rescue General District Court General Services Housing and Community Development Human Resources Human Services Information Technology Juvenile and Domestic Relations Court Libraries Magistrate Nauticus Neighborhood Services Norfolk Community Services Board Norfolk Juvenile Court Service Unit Norfolk Public Schools Outside Agencies Parks and Recreation Police Public Health Public Works Resilience Sheriff and Jail Slover Library Transportation Zoological Park Special Revenue Funds Cemeteries1 Golf Operations3 Emergency Preparedness and Response Tax Increment Financing Public Amenities Towing and Recovery Operations4 Capital Projects Fund Waste Management4 Proprietary Funds Internal Service Funds Fleet Management3 Norfolk Healthcare Consortium Enterprise Funds Parking Facilities3 Utilities - Water Utilities - Wastewater Appropriated Funds Storm Water Management4 Grants Special Revenue Community Development2 1Receives management oversight from the Department of Parks and Recreation 2Receives management oversight from the Department of Housing and Community Development 3Receives management oversight from the Department of General Services 4Receives management oversight from the Department of Public Works Basis of Budgeting and Accounting 53 BASIS OF BUDGETING AND ACCOUNTING BASIS OF BUDGETING The budgets of governmental fund types (General Fund, Special Revenue, and Capital Projects Funds) of the city are generally prepared on the modified accrual basis of accounting. The accrual basis of accounting is generally used to budget for the Enterprise Funds and Internal Service Funds except for depreciation, debt principal payments, capital outlay, and contractual commitments (see Basis of Accounting below). For the modified accrual basis, expenditures are recorded as expenditures when the related fund liability is incurred (other than interest on general long-term liabilities). For budgetary purposes, purchase orders issued and other contractual commitments are considered expenditures when executed. Revenues are recorded when they are measurable and available. The accrual basis recognizes expenses when the liability is incurred regardless of the related cash flows. Revenues, however, are recognized when earned. The accrual methodology is based upon known present and future expenses and revenues and not upon cash spent or received. The level of control at which expenditures may not exceed the budget is at the department level for the General Fund and fund level for all other funds. The City Manager or designee is authorized to transfer from any department, fund, or activity with excess funds appropriated to any department, fund, or activity all or any part of such excess appropriation. Unencumbered appropriations lapse at the end of the fiscal year, except appropriations that are designated or are for the Grants (Special Revenue) and Capital Improvement Programs, which are carried forward until the designation, grant, or project is completed or terminated. BASIS OF ACCOUNTING The Annual Comprehensive Financial Report (ACFR) presents the status of the city’s finances in accordance with Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP). In most cases this conforms to how the city prepares its budget. Exceptions are as follows: • Compensated absences are recorded as earned by employees (GAAP basis), as opposed to being expended when paid (Budget basis); • Principal payments on long-term debt within the Proprietary Funds reduce the amount of debt remaining on a GAAP basis as opposed to being expended on a Budget basis; • Capital Outlay within the Proprietary Funds is recorded as assets on a GAAP basis and expended on a Budget basis; • Depreciation expenses are recorded on a GAAP basis only; and • Recording unfulfilled purchase orders and contractual obligations as expenditures in the year executed. In addition to the fund financial statements, government-wide financial statements are prepared on the accrual basis of accounting. In government-wide financial statements, certain funds are grouped together for reporting purposes. 54 Budget Process BUDGET PROCESS FORMULATION OF THE CITY MANAGER’S BUDGET The City Charter requires the City Manager to prepare and submit to the City Council an annual budget. The annual budget process commences at the beginning of the fiscal year . The budget calendar establishes the timeline for the process, dates for submission of department requests, budget work sessions, and public hearings leading to final adoption of the budget. Department requests are based on budget instructions. Each request must relate to the organization’s program objectives and the priorities of the city. The requests are received and compiled by the budget staff. Due to revenue constraints, departments are generally encouraged to develop proposals to realign or reduce expenditures rather than seek additional funding. An operating budget is adopted each fiscal year for the General Fund, Enterprise Funds (Water Utility, Wastewater Utility, Storm Water Management, and Parking Facilities), Special Revenue Funds (Cemeteries, Emergency Preparedness and Response, Golf Operations, Public Amenities, Tax Increment Financing, Towing and Recovery Operations, and Waste Management), and Internal Service Funds (Fleet Management and Healthcare). Budgets are also individually adopted within the Special Revenue (Grants) Fund. Ordinances are generally adopted when a grant to the city has been awarded. Recurring grants identified in the Annual Grants Plan section are appropriated as part of the operating budget ordinance. All funds are under formal budget control, the most significant of which is the General Fund. No less than 60 days before the end of the current fiscal year, the City Manager submits to the City Council a proposed operating budget for the next fiscal year . The operating budget includes recommended expenditures and the means to finance them. The adopted budget may include technical changes made after the City Manager’s presentation of the proposed budget to City Council. CITY COUNCIL’S AUTHORIZATION AND APPROPRIATION After general distribution of the proposed budget, public hearings are conducted to obtain comments and recommendations from the public. No less than 30 days before the end of the fiscal year, the City Council shall pass an annual appropriation ordinance which shall be based on the budget document submitted by the City Manager and subsequent changes made by the City Council. The annual operating budget ordinance appropriates funding for use by departments for salaries, benefits and positions, and nonpersonnel as set forth in the detailed budget document. Amounts appropriated to each department are intended to be expended for the purposes designated by object group categories including: personnel services; materials, supplies and repairs; contractual services; equipment; public assistance; department specific appropriation; and debt service. CITY MANAGER’S AUTHORIZATION In accordance with the City Charter, at least 60 days before the end of each fiscal year, the City Manager shall prepare and submit to the City Council an annual budget for the ensuing fiscal year . The budget shall be balanced at all times. The total amount of appropriations shall not exceed the estimated revenues of the city. Budget Process 55 In a given year, the City Manager or designee is authorized to transfer from any department, fund, or activity with excess funds appropriated to any department, fund, or activity as necessary. BUDGET IMPLEMENTATION Once the budget is adopted, it is effective on July 1 and becomes the legal basis for the programs and services of each department of the city during the fiscal year . No department or other agency of the city government may spend in excess of adopted and appropriated amounts, unless authorized by budget transfer as approved by the City Manager or designee. Financial and programmatic monitoring of departmental activities to ensure conformity with the budget takes place throughout the year . The budget can be found in the libraries and on the city website. The City Manager is responsible for maintaining a balanced budget at all times. In the event a gap is identified between revenues and expenditures, the City Manager will take actions necessary to rebalance the budget. Budget amendments may be made by the City Council to meet the changing needs of the city. The means by which the City Council may amend the budget include, but are not limited to, appropriation of additional funds and decreasing the amount of appropriated funds. CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN, ANNUAL GRANTS PLAN, AND ANNUAL PLAN City Council also adopts a Capital Improvement Plan, Annual Grants Plan, and the Annual Plan budget. These budgets are submitted by the City Manager with the operating budget, and public hearings are held and the budgets are legislatively enacted through adoption of ordinances. Appropriations for project funds and grant funds do not lapse at year end, but continue until the purpose of the appropriation has been fulfilled or terminated. Amendments to these budgets may be affected by City Council actions. The level of budget control is on a project basis with additional administrative controls being exercised. BUDGET PRINCIPLES AND POLICIES These include the following: • Provisions to strive for a structurally balanced budget whereby ongoing expenditures are supported by ongoing revenues; • Preparation of a mid-year budget update, reporting projected revenues and expenditures for the entire fiscal year and receipt of unanticipated revenues and other major changes to the adopted budget; • Preparation of a five to ten-year forecast, which serves as the basis for the City Manager’s annual recommended budget; and • Requirement that the City Manager prepare a Five-Year Capital Improvement Plan that incorporates operating costs and is stated in “year of expenditure dollars.” 56 Budget Calendar BUDGET CALENDAR Date Responsible Party Description Legal Requirement August - September 2022 City Departments Long-term Forecast Operating Budget Requests N/A October 2022 - December 2022 City Departments Departments Submit Operating and Capital Improvement Budget Requests Department Program Budget Development with Budget Staff N/A January 2023 - March 2023 Budget and Strategic Planning Management Leadership Team City Departments Department Meetings with Management Leadership Team on Operating and Capital Budget Requests N/A February 14, 2023 Budget and Strategic Planning City Manager’s Mid-Year Budget Review and Financial Update N/A March 22, 2023 Norfolk Public Schools School Board approves FY 2024 Educational Plan and Budget Code of Virginia 15.2-2503 March 28, 2023 Budget and Strategic Planning Public Hearing Notice of the HUD Grant (CDBG, ESG, and HOME) Budget U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) March 28, 2023 City Manager City Manager Presentation of Proposed Budget to City Council City of Norfolk Charter Sec. 67 April 8, 2023 City Clerk Public Hearing Notice of the Real Estate Tax Increase due to increased reassessment Code of Virginia 58.1-3321 April 10, 2023 City Clerk Public Hearing Notice of the Operating and Capital Improvement Plan Budgets Code of Virginia 15.2-2506, 58.1-3007 April 11, 2023 City Council City Council Budget Worksession N/A April 19, 2023 City Council Public Hearing on the Operating, Capital Improvement Plan, and HUD Grant (CDBG, ESG and HOME) Budgets Code of Virginia 15.2-2506, 58.1-3007 April 25, 2023 City Council City Council Budget Worksession N/A May 7, 2023 City Clerk Second Public Hearing Notice of the Real Estate Tax Increase due to increased reassessment Code of Virginia 58.1-3321 May 9, 2023 City Council City Council Budget Worksession - Reconciliation N/A May 9, 2023 City Council Public Hearing on the Real Estate Tax Increase due to increased reassessment Code of Virginia 58.1-3321 May 23, 2023 City Council City Council Budget Worksession - Reconciliation N/A June 6, 2023 City Clerk Second Public Hearing on the Real Estate Tax Increase due to increased reassessment Code of Virginia 58.1-3321 June 13, 2023 City Council City Council Budget Adoption City of Norfolk Charter Sec. 68 Code of Virginia 15.2-2503 Financial Plan 57 FINANCIAL PLAN The city’s financial plan consists of the General Fund and other operating funds, Capital Improvement Plan, Annual Grants Plan, and Annual Plan for U.S. Housing and Urban Development (HUD) block grants. The following table compares the Adopted FY 2024 Financial Plan to the Adopted FY 2023 Financial Plan. The tables and charts in the pages that follow show revenues and expenditures for the General Fund and operating funds combined (“All Funds”). FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted FY 2023 vs. FY 2024 $ Change % Change General Fund 1,008,355,624 1,079,245,028 70,889,404 7.0% Special Revenue Funds 50,928,594 52,016,213 1,087,619 2.1% Enterprise Funds 184,755,843 189,980,838 5,224,995 2.8% Internal Service Funds 117,374,103 118,615,533 1,241,430 1.1% Total Operating Funds 1,361,414,164 1,439,857,612 78,443,448 5.8% Capital Improvement Plan 299,822,385 395,613,169 95,790,784 31.9% Total Operating and Capital 1,661,236,549 1,835,470,781 174,234,232 10.5% Annual Plan for HUD Block Grants 6,431,703 7,054,048 622,345 9.7% Annual Grants Plan 50,326,212 86,498,241 36,172,029 71.9% Total Financial Plan 1,717,994,464 1,929,023,070 211,028,606 12.3% Note: Percentages may not total to 100 due to rounding. Adopted FY 2024 Financial Plan General Fund 55.9% Special Revenue Funds 2.7% Enterprise Funds 9.8% Internal Service Funds 6.1% Capital Improvement Plan 20.5% Annual Grants Plan 4.5% Annual Plan for HUD Block Grants 0.4% 58 General Fund Budget Overview GENERAL FUND BUDGET OVERVIEW Note: Percentages may not total to 100 due to rounding. *Does not incl ude in-kind support. Adopted FY 2024 General Fund Revenues $1,079,245,028 Adopted FY 2024 General Fund Expenditures $1,079,245,028 Funding for Norfolk comes from a variety of sources as shown at right. “Other City Funds” include local taxes, fees, charges, fines, rent and interest. “Consumer Taxes” include sales, hotel, meals, admissions and cigarette taxes. In the FY 2024 budget, “Other Departments and Services” include public works, transit, libraries, Slover library, recreation, cultural facilities, zoo, Nauticus, planning, neighborhood development, economic development, finance, human resources, information technology, general services, legislative, executive, law, judicial, constitutional officers, outside agencies, and central appropriations. Real Estate Taxes $319,465,700 29.6% Other Property Taxes $64,903,500 6.0% Consumer Taxes $107,184,000 9.9% Other City Funds $194,682,830 18.0% Other State Funds $95,507,862 8.8% State and Federal Funds for Health and Human Services $52,401,390 4.9% State and Federal Funds for Norfolk Public Schools $245,099,746 22.7% Other Departments and Services 340,547,839 31.6% Public Safety $142,236,866 13.2% Debt Payments $101,365,244 9.4% Health and Human Services $90,519,907 8.4% Norfolk Public Schools* $404,575,172 37.5% Estimated General Fund Revenues by Source 59 ESTIMATED GENERAL FUND REVENUES BY SOURCE The following table compares the Adopted FY 2024 General Fund Operating Budget to the Adopted FY 2023 General Fund Operating Budget and the FY 2022 Actual amount. Funding sources are shown by category to provide an overview of the principal sources of revenue for the general operating fund of the city. These revenue sources support general government operations. The tables and charts in the pages that follow show revenues and expenditures for all funds. Note: FY 2022 amounts may not sum to total due to rounding. Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted FY 2023 vs. FY 2024 $ Change % Change General Property Taxes 345,879,422 355,118,800 384,369,200 29,250,400 8.2% Other Local Taxes 173,337,193 171,966,025 181,084,500 9,118,475 5.3% Permits and Fees 3,883,494 3,965,900 4,068,000 102,100 2.6% Fines and Forfeitures 1,353,222 1,340,000 1,505,000 165,000 12.3% Use of Money and Property 7,995,023 9,013,620 13,603,434 4,589,814 50.9% Charges for Services 23,580,895 25,491,731 26,172,740 681,009 2.7% Miscellaneous Revenue 10,889,955 9,227,966 8,669,610 -558,356 -6.1% Recovered Costs 11,179,703 12,058,130 10,997,183 -1,060,947 -8.8% Non-Categorical Aid - State 39,719,848 38,682,200 39,362,165 679,965 1.8% Shared Expenses - State 22,779,442 23,544,200 25,119,100 1,574,900 6.7% Categorical Aid - State 282,023,720 306,286,328 319,960,477 13,674,149 4.5% Federal Aid 9,763,200 8,420,256 8,615,256 195,000 2.3% Other Sources and Transfers In 44,885,400 43,240,468 55,718,363 12,477,895 28.9% General Fund Total 977,270,518 1,008,355,624 1,079,245,028 70,889,404 7.0% 60 Estimated General Fund Revenues by Source /g38/g122/g3/g1006/g1004/g1006/g1008/g3/g39/g286/g374/g286/g396/g258/g367/g3/g38/g437/g374/g282/g3/g90/g286/g448/g286/g374/g437/g286/g400/g3/g271/g455/g3/g94/g381/g437/g396/g272/g286 /g69/g381/g410/g286/g855/g3/g87/g286/g396/g272/g286/g374/g410/g258/g336/g286/g400/g3/g373/g258/g455/g3/g374/g381/g410/g3/g410/g381/g410/g258/g367/g3/g410/g381/g3/g1005/g1004/g1004/g3/g282/g437/g286/g3/g410/g381/g3/g396/g381/g437/g374/g282/g349/g374/g336/g856 /g4/g282/g381/g393/g410/g286/g282 /g39/g286/g374/g286/g396/g258/g367/g3/g87/g396/g381/g393/g286/g396/g410/g455/g3 /g100/g258/g454/g286/g400 /g1007/g1009/g856/g1010/g1081 /g75/g410/g346/g286/g396/g3/g62/g381/g272/g258/g367/g3 /g100/g258/g454/g286/g400 /g1005/g1010/g856/g1012/g1081 /g87/g286/g396/g373/g349/g410/g400/g3/g258/g374/g282/g3/g38/g286/g286/g400/g3/g258/g374/g282/g3 /g38/g349/g374/g286/g400/g3/g258/g374/g282/g3/g38/g381/g396/g296/g286/g349/g410/g437/g396/g286/g400 /g1004/g856/g1009/g1081 /g104/g400/g286/g3/g381/g296/g3/g68/g381/g374/g286/g455/g3 /g258/g374/g282/g3/g87/g396/g381/g393/g286/g396/g410/g455 /g1005/g856/g1007/g1081 /g18/g346/g258/g396/g336/g286/g400/g3/g296/g381/g396/g3 /g94/g286/g396/g448/g349/g272/g286/g400 /g1006/g856/g1008/g1081 /g68/g349/g400/g272/g286/g367/g367/g258/g374/g286/g381/g437/g400/g3 /g90/g286/g448/g286/g374/g437/g286 /g1004/g856/g1012/g1081 /g90/g286/g272/g381/g448/g286/g396/g286/g282/g3/g18/g381/g400/g410/g400 /g1005/g856/g1004/g1081 /g94/g410/g258/g410/g286/g3/g69/g381/g374/g882/g18/g258/g410/g286/g336/g381/g396/g349/g272/g258/g367/g3 /g4/g349/g282 /g1007/g856/g1010/g1081 /g94/g410/g258/g410/g286/g3/g94/g346/g258/g396/g286/g282/g3 /g28/g454/g393/g286/g374/g400/g286/g400 /g1006/g856/g1007/g1081 /g94/g410/g258/g410/g286/g3/g18/g258/g410/g286/g336/g381/g396/g349/g272/g258/g367/g3 /g4/g349/g282 /g1006/g1013/g856/g1010/g1081 /g38/g286/g282/g286/g396/g258/g367/g3/g4/g349/g282 /g1004/g856/g1012/g1081 /g75/g410/g346/g286/g396/g3/g94/g381/g437/g396/g272/g286/g400/g3 /g258/g374/g282/g3/g100/g396/g258/g374/g400/g296/g286/g396/g400/g3/g47/g374 /g1009/g856/g1006/g1081 Estimated Revenues by Source (All Funds) 61 ESTIMATED REVENUES BY SOURCE (ALL FUNDS) The following table compares the Adopted FY 2024 Operating Budget to the Adopted FY 2023 Operating Budget and the FY 2022 Actual amount. Funding sources by category are shown to provide an overview of the sources of revenue for the general and nongeneral operating funds of the city. Revenues are reflected in those categories where they are originally raised. Note: FY 2022 amounts may not sum to total due to rounding. Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted FY 2023 vs. FY 2024 $ Change % Change General Property Taxes 352,647,822 362,319,500 392,905,200 30,585,700 8.4% Other Local Taxes 185,001,440 183,035,801 193,171,096 10,135,295 5.5% Permits and Fees 4,514,498 4,829,469 4,936,100 106,631 2.2% Fines and Forfeitures 3,324,085 4,009,028 3,616,000 -393,028 -9.8% Use of Money and Property 8,079,555 10,291,475 14,671,289 4,379,814 42.6% Charges for Services 316,787,232 340,867,459 355,071,262 14,203,803 4.2% Miscellaneous Revenue 11,615,878 10,021,378 9,587,955 -433,423 -4.3% Recovered Costs 14,918,281 15,045,189 13,984,242 -1,060,947 -7.1% Non-Categorical Aid - State 39,719,848 38,682,200 39,362,165 679,965 1.8% Shared Expenses - State 22,779,442 23,544,200 25,119,100 1,574,900 6.7% Categorical Aid - State 282,091,591 306,422,328 320,096,477 13,674,149 4.5% Federal Aid 12,044,562 8,533,873 8,728,873 195,000 2.3% Other Sources and Transfers In 47,210,313 53,812,264 58,607,853 4,795,589 8.9% Total All Funds 1,300,734,548 1,361,414,164 1,439,857,612 78,443,448 5.8% 62 Estimated Revenues by Source (All Funds) FY 2024 Revenues by Source (All Funds) Note: Percentages may not total to 100 due to rounding. Adopted General Property Taxes 27.3% Other Local Taxes 13.4% Permits and Fees and Fines and Forfeitures 0.6%Use of Money and Property 1.0% Charges for Services 24.7% Miscellaneous Revenue 0.7% Recovered Costs 1.0% State Non-Categorical Aid 2.7% State Shared Expenses 1.7% State Categorical Aid 22.2% Federal Aid 0.6% Other Sources and Transfers In 4.1% Estimated Expenditures by Use (All Funds) 63 ESTIMATED EXPENDITURES BY USE (ALL FUNDS) The following table compares the Adopted FY 2024 Operating Budget to the Adopted FY 2023 Operating Budget and the FY 2022 Actual amount. Funding uses by category are shown to provide an overview of the principal uses of expenditures for the general and nongeneral operating funds of the city. Expenditures are reflected in those categories where they are originally spent. Note: FY 2022 amounts may not sum to total due to rounding. Uses FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted FY 2023 Adopted % Change Personnel Services 295,199,093 392,312,688 426,149,609 33,836,921 8.6% Materials, Supplies and Repairs 62,155,397 68,186,480 78,555,664 10,369,184 15.2% Contractual Services 147,008,290 200,860,116 207,197,960 6,337,844 3.2% Equipment 9,134,061 14,300,879 15,429,750 1,128,871 7.9% Department Specific Appropriation 82,462,952 120,844,305 121,691,730 847,425 0.7% Public School Education 343,066,532 385,180,630 404,575,172 19,394,542 5.0% Debt Service/Transfers to CIP 136,524,545 164,289,513 170,700,519 6,411,006 3.9% Public Assistance 12,947,717 15,439,553 15,557,208 117,655 0.8% Norfolk Redevelopment & Housing Authority 53,475 0 0 0 0.0% Total All Funds 1,088,552,062 1,361,414,164 1,439,857,612 78,443,448 5.8% 64 Estimated Expenditures by Use (All Funds) Note: Percentages may not total to 100 due to rounding. *Does not include "in-kind" support. See Public School Education section. Adopted FY 2024 Expenditures by Use (All Funds) Personnel Services 29.6% Materials, Supplies and Repairs 5.5% Contractual Services 14.4% Equipment 1.1% Department Specific Appropriation 8.5% Public School Education* 28.1% Debt Service/Transfers to CIP 11.9% Public Assistance 1.1% Estimated Expenditures by Fund Type 65 ESTIMATED EXPENDITURES BY FUND TYPE The following table compares expenditures by fund type in the Adopted FY 2024 Operating Budget to the Adopted FY 2023 Operating Budget and the FY 2022 Actual amount. Note: FY 2022 amounts may not sum to total due to rounding. Fund Type FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted FY 2023 vs. FY 2024 $ Change % Change General Fund 833,542,646 1,008,355,624 1,079,245,028 70,889,404 7.0% Special Revenue Funds 45,705,405 50,928,594 52,016,213 1,087,619 2.1% Enterprise Funds 136,393,942 184,755,843 189,980,838 5,224,995 2.8% Internal Service Funds 72,910,069 117,374,103 118,615,533 1,241,430 1.1% Total All Funds 1,088,552,062 1,361,414,164 1,439,857,612 78,443,448 5.8% 66 Estimated Expenditures by Fund Type Note: Percentages may not total to 100 due to rounding. Adopted FY 2024 Expenditures by Fund Type (All Funds) General Fund 75.0% Special Revenue Funds 3.6% Enterprise Funds 13.2% Internal Service Funds 8.2% Estimated General Fund Expenditures by Area 67 ESTIMATED GENERAL FUND EXPENDITURES BY AREA The following table compares the Adopted FY 2024 General Fund Operating Budget to the Adopted FY 2023 General Fund Operating Budget and the FY 2022 Actual amount by area. Major areas of service are shown to provide a broad overview of the expenditures for the general operating fund of the city. 1The FY 2022 amount reflects the transitioning of eligible expenses to the Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds (SLFRF) grant. Note: FY 2022 amounts may not sum to total due to rounding. Service Area FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted FY 2023 vs. FY 2024 $ Change % Change Legislative 5,242,990 5,765,596 6,378,474 612,878 10.6% Executive 11,139,642 14,642,550 19,321,880 4,679,330 32.0% Department of Law 5,062,426 5,509,385 5,963,932 454,547 8.3% Constitutional Officers 51,124,525 58,356,436 62,793,765 4,437,329 7.6% Judicial 1,309,000 1,446,826 1,522,739 75,913 5.2% Elections 1,108,609 1,031,721 1,179,525 147,804 14.3% General Management 53,446,819 60,235,927 65,839,103 5,603,176 9.3% Community Development 12,534,650 14,570,246 16,727,751 2,157,505 14.8% Parks, Recreation and Culture 38,252,745 45,806,308 52,598,666 6,792,358 14.8% Public Health and Assistance 72,871,669 84,576,523 90,519,907 5,943,384 7.0% Public Safety1 66,602,943 133,452,386 142,236,866 8,784,480 6.6% Public Works 16,978,181 22,366,099 22,188,536 -177,563 -0.8% Transportation 11,338,517 11,564,407 12,119,902 555,495 4.8% Central and Outside Agency Appropriations 67,758,000 76,153,863 73,913,566 -2,240,297 -2.9% Debt Service 75,705,398 87,696,721 101,365,244 13,668,523 15.6% Public School Education 343,066,532 385,180,630 404,575,172 19,394,542 5.0% General Fund Total 833,542,646 1,008,355,624 1,079,245,028 70,889,404 7.0% 68 Estimated General Fund Expenditures by Area /g38/g122/g3/g1006/g1004/g1006/g1008/g3/g39/g286/g374/g286/g396/g258/g367/g3/g38/g437/g374/g282/g3/g28/g454/g393/g286/g374/g282/g349/g410/g437/g396/g286/g400/g3/g271/g455/g3/g4/g396/g286/g258 /g69/g381/g410/g286/g855/g3/g87/g286/g396/g272/g286/g374/g410/g258/g336/g286/g400/g3/g373/g258/g455/g3/g374/g381/g410/g3/g410/g381/g410/g258/g367/g3/g410/g381/g3/g1005/g1004/g1004/g3/g282/g437/g286/g3/g410/g381/g3/g396/g381/g437/g374/g282/g349/g374/g336/g856 /g910/g24/g381/g286/g400/g3/g374/g381/g410/g3/g349/g374/g272/g367/g437/g282/g286/g3/g919/g349/g374/g882/g364/g349/g374/g282/g919/g3/g400/g437/g393/g393/g381/g396/g410/g856/g3/g3/g94/g286/g286/g3/g87/g437/g271/g367/g349/g272/g3/g94/g272/g346/g381/g381/g367/g3/g28/g282/g437/g272/g258/g410/g349/g381/g374/g3/g400/g286/g272/g410/g349/g381/g374/g856 /g4/g282/g381/g393/g410/g286/g282 /g393/g455 /g62/g286/g336/g349/g400/g367/g258/g410/g349/g448/g286 /g1004/g856/g1010/g1081 /g28/g454/g286/g272/g437/g410/g349/g448/g286 /g1005/g856/g1012/g1081 /g62/g258/g449 /g1004/g856/g1010/g1081 /g18/g381/g374/g400/g410/g349/g410/g437/g410/g349/g381/g374/g258/g367/g3 /g75/g296/g296/g349/g272/g286/g396/g400 /g1009/g856/g1012/g1081 /g58/g437/g282/g349/g272/g349/g258/g367 /g1004/g856/g1005/g1081/g28/g367/g286/g272/g410/g349/g381/g374/g400 /g1004/g856/g1005/g1081 /g39/g286/g374/g286/g396/g258/g367/g3 /g68/g258/g374/g258/g336/g286/g373/g286/g374/g410 /g1010/g856/g1005/g1081 /g18/g381/g373/g373/g437/g374/g349/g410/g455/g3 /g24/g286/g448/g286/g367/g381/g393/g373/g286/g374/g410 /g1005/g856/g1009/g1081 /g87/g258/g396/g364/g400/g853/g3 /g90/g286/g272/g396/g286/g258/g410/g349/g381/g374/g3 /g258/g374/g282/g3/g18/g437/g367/g410/g437/g396/g286 /g1008/g856/g1013/g1081 /g18/g286/g374/g410/g396/g258/g367/g3/g258/g374/g282/g3/g75/g437/g410/g400/g349/g282/g286/g3 /g4/g336/g286/g374/g272/g455/g3/g4/g393/g393/g396/g381/g393/g396/g349/g258/g410/g349/g381/g374/g400 /g1010/g856/g1012/g1081 /g87/g437/g271/g367/g349/g272/g3/g44/g286/g258/g367/g410/g346/g3/g258/g374/g282/g3 /g4/g400/g400/g349/g400/g410/g258/g374/g272/g286 /g1012/g856/g1008/g1081 /g87/g437/g271/g367/g349/g272/g3 /g94/g258/g296/g286/g410/g455 /g1005/g1007/g856/g1006/g1081 /g87/g437/g271/g367/g349/g272/g3/g116/g381/g396/g364/g400 /g1006/g856/g1005/g1081 /g100/g396/g258/g374/g400/g349/g410 /g1005/g856/g1005/g1081 /g24/g286/g271/g410/g3 /g94/g286/g396/g448/g349/g272/g286 /g1013/g856/g1008/g1081 /g87/g437/g271/g367/g349/g272/g3/g94/g272/g346/g381/g381/g367/g3 /g28/g282/g437/g272/g258/g410/g349/g381/g374/g910 /g1007/g1011/g856/g1009/g1081 Major Revenue Sources 69 MAJOR REVENUE SOURCES Evaluating the city’s current and long-term financial health requires a review of the economy and major revenue sources. Overall, the city’s revenues are anticipated to continue to recover in FY 2023 from the impact of the COVID- 19 pandemic. General Fund revenues are projected to increase by 7.0 percent while revenues citywide (all funds) are projected to increase 5.8 percent. Real estate assessments, which drives real estate taxes, the largest locally generated General Fund revenue source are projected to grow by approximately 7.29 percent in FY 2024, the second highest increase since FY 2008, after increasing 10.2 percent in FY 2023. ECONOMIC OVERVIEW The economy’s growth decelerated in 2022. Real gross domestic product (GDP) which is the broadest measure of economic activity, declined in the first half of the year, then bounced back in the latter half to end the year with an annual growth of 2.1 percent (second estimate). In comparison, real GDP increased by 5.9 percent in 2021. Consumer spending on services, business inventory, business investment in equipment and intellectual property products (such as, software and research and development), and state and local government spending contributed positively to the economy’s growth in 2022, but their growth was below their 2021 growth. Offsetting the growth were consumer spending on goods, business investment in structures, and residential investment given the rise interest rates. Net exports and federal spending also contributed negatively to the growth. The consensus view is for the economy’s growth to slow further in 2023 with the possibility of a recession occurring during the year, although the timing of the recession is not clear . In addition, the consensus view of the recent crisis in the banking sector which surfaced with the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank in March is that it could further increase the possibility of a recession this year . National employment continued to grow in 2022 and has exceeded the pre-pandemic peak in February 2020. The Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) reported the average annual nonfarm employment grew by 4.3 percent in 2022, after increasing 2.9 percent in 2021. The economy added an average of 399,000 jobs per month, with all the major sectors gaining jobs. Job growth continued in the first two months of 2023, having added an average of 408,000 jobs per month (preliminary). With the job growth, the unemployment rate continued to fall in 2022. The annual unemployment rate fell from 5.3 percent in 2021 to 3.6 percent in 2022, which was the lowest annual rate since 1969. During the first two months of 2023, the seasonally adjusted unemployment rate fell to 3.4 percent in January, the lowest since May 1969, but rose back to 3.6 percent in February. Despite the number of jobs being above the pre-pandemic level, the labor force participation rate which had fallen during the pandemic, remains below the pre-pandemic participation rate. (4%) (2%) 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023*` Source: Bureau of Economic Analysis. Shaded areas denote recession. *Survey of Professional Forecasters median forecast Slower Economic Growth Projected (Real GDP annual percent change) 58% 60% 62% 64% 66% 68% 110 120 130 140 150 160 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 Nonfarm Employment (thousands) Labor Force Participation Rate (percent) Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics. Shaded areas denotes recession. U.S. Employment Above Pre-Pandemic Labor Force Participation Below Pre-Pandemic 70 Major Revenue Sources Along with the tight labor market, compensation rose in 2022. The Bureau of Labor Statistics employment cost index, which measures the quarterly change in the cost of employee compensation (salary and benefits), free from the influence of employment shifts among occupations and industries, rose 5.1 percent for private sector workers year- over-year for the fourth quarter of 2022 compared to the 4.4 percent and 2.6 percent increase in the fourth quarter of 2021 and 2020, respectively. Similarly, the employment cost index for state and local government workers rose 4.8 percent year-over-year for the fourth quarter of 2022 compared to the 2.6 percent and 2.3 percent increase in the fourth quarter of 2021 and 2020, respectively. The prices of goods and services continued to rise in 2022 from 2021 brought on by the supply chain issues and war in Ukraine. Both the Consumer Price Index (CPI) and Personal Consumption Expenditures (PCE) price index for all-items and excluding food and energy prices, continued to rise in 2022. Although the increase in both the CPI and PCE has been declining, both inflation indices remain elevated. As a result, the Federal Reserve raised the target level for the federal funds rate seven times in 2022 from 0.0- 0.25% to 4.25-4.50% in 2022. The increase continues in 2023 as the Federal Reserve raised the target level to 4.50-4.75% in February and 4.75-5.00% in March. The Federal Reserve is anticipated to continue to raise rates during 2023 to continue to bring down inflation. Although the consensus is for a recession in the national economy to occur during 2023, the economic outlook for the region from the economists at Old Dominion University presented in January, is positive. Hampton Roads is likely to grow faster than the nation and may outperform the nation. Growth in jobs, taxable sales, hotel revenues, and port activity in Hampton Roads is expected to continue in 2023. More importantly, the outlook anticipates that defense spending will continue to boost the Hampton Roads economy in 2023. Likewise, the economic outlook from the Hampton Roads Planning District Commission (HRPDC) also presented in January, is positive as well. The HRPDC outlook is also anticipating the region’s growth to exceed that of the nation, and the growth in jobs and taxable sales to continue in 2023. GENERAL FUND REVENUE OVERVIEW The city generates revenue through taxes, user charges, and intergovernmental transfers from the state and federal government. Over half of the city’s General Fund revenues are generated locally from various taxes and fees including real estate, personal property, retail sales, permits, fines, and user charges. These sources fund municipal services such as police, fire-rescue, parks and recreation, libraries, street maintenance, public education (K-12), public health, and human services. Similar to other Virginia localities, Norfolk is highly dependent on real estate taxes to fund the city’s general operations including police, fire-rescue, and public schools 0% 1% 2% 3% 4% 5% 6% 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 Private Industry Compensation State and Local Government Compensation Employment Cost Index (year-over-year percent change) Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and Bureau of Economic Analysis. Shaded areas denote recession. (4%) (2%) 0% 2% 4% 6% 8% 10% 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 PCE (2012=100) CPI (1982-84=100) Consumer Price Index and Personal Consumption Expenditure Price Index for All Items (year-over-year percent change) Source: Bureau of Labor Statistics and Bureau of Economic Analysis. Shaded areas denote recession. $0 $75,000 $150,000 $225,000 $300,000 $375,000 0 1,000 2,000 3,000 4,000 5,000 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 Calendar Year Norfolk Home Sales and Average Sales Price Home Sales Average Sales Price Source: Real Estate Information Network Major Revenue Sources 71 (K-12). Real estate taxes are the city’s largest source of locally generated revenue. For FY 2024, the Office of the Real Estate Assessor is estimating that the land book value of taxable real estate assessments on July 1, 2023 will increase by approximately 7.29 percent from the July 1, 2022 land book value. This would mark the eleventh consecutive year of growth. Although the 7.29 percent increase is lower than the previous year’s growth of 10.2 percent, it will be the second highest increase since FY 2008. The increase is largely from residential assessments which reflects the continued strength in the local housing market. Although home sales declined, the sales price of homes sold continued to rise. Home sales declined in calendar year 2022 compared to calendar year 2021. The number of existing and new homes sold in Norfolk decreased by approximately 15 percent, after increasing by approximately 19 percent in 2021. However, the average sales price of existing and new homes sold combined continued to increase in 2022, rising by approximately 6 percent after increasing by approximately 13 percent in 2021. On the other hand, general commercial assessments is anticipated to decline largely due to the decline in MacArthur Mall’s value. New housing units permitted continued to increase. In FY 2022, the number of housing units permitted rose again, increasing to 1,702 in FY 2022 from 1,194 in FY 2021. In contrast, the number of nonresidential (or “commercial”) building permits was flat from FY 2022, while their value decreased in FY 2022 from FY 2021. The new residential and commercial building activity and improvements to existing structures permitted throughout the city should support future growth in real estate assessments. It is important to note that the city of Norfolk is predominantly built out, and the building activity occurring currently is mainly redevelopment, infill development, and vertical expansion. The Commonwealth of Virginia provides approximately 35.6 percent of General Fund revenues in the FY 2024 General Fund budget. Revenue from the Commonwealth consists of funding that are mostly for dedicated purposes such as K-12 education, social services, transportation, and shared expenses of constitutional officers. House Bill (HB) 599 funds for law enforcement, the city’s share of the Commonwealth’s personal property tax (“car tax”) relief funds, and the tax on rental of cars also comprise revenue from the Commonwealth. In total, it is the largest revenue source category in the General Fund. As a result of the Great Recession, the Commonwealth saw a significant decline in revenues and in turn, reduced direct aid to education, HB 599 funds for police, Constitutional Officers salaries and benefits funding, jail per diem, and funds for street maintenance. The Commonwealth also imposed a “flexible cut” to state aid to localities and permanently eliminated the local share of ABC profits and wine tax. Not all revenues from the Commonwealth have returned to the pre-recession peak such as, HB 599 funds, and jail per diem funding, even though the Commonwealth’s General Fund revenues have been above its last pre-recession peak since FY 2012. The Proposed FY 2023 Budget for revenues from the Commonwealth are based upon the funding approved by the 2022 Special Session I and the 2023 Session of the General Assembly as of February 25, 2023. The remaining revenue comes from the federal government, recovered costs, interfund transfers, and carryforward of prior year funds. Revenue from the federal government are mostly dedicated to Norfolk Public Schools and the Norfolk Community Services Board. Interfund transfers include a return on investment from Utilities (water and wastewater) operations. It also includes funding from the Public Amenities Fund to support the Norfolk Consortium (see Outside Agencies) and excess revenues from the Tax Increment Financing Fund. Carryforward funds are generated through a combination of projected current year savings, realized savings from prior years, and account closeouts. Carryforward funds may also include the re-appropriation of prior year(s) unspent designated funds. For FY 2024, the budget includes the carryforward of budget savings from the transition of eligible expenses in FY 2022 to the Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds (SLFRF) grant for the continuity of services. 0 100 200 300 400 500 600 0 300 600 900 1,200 1,500 1,800 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Fiscal Year Norfolk Residential Building Permits and Housing Units Permitted Permits Housing Units Housing Units Source: Dept. of Planning and FY 2022 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report Permits 72 Major Revenue Sources Preliminary General Fund revenue projections, based on historical data and current economic data, were initially compiled over the summer. Estimates were updated in the fall with submission of estimates from city departments and offices and information from the Governor’s amendments to the 2022-2024 biennial budget. Projections were updated through February to incorporate the current information available from the city, Commonwealth, and Norfolk Public Schools. Initial revenue estimates were based on the analysis of the collection history and patterns, underlying drivers that impact a revenue source, information from departments that collect revenue, overall economic environment, and developments projected for the city in the coming year. The revenue amounts shown in the discussion that follows include the FY 2023 budget and FY 2024 budget. The Adopted FY 2024 General Fund budget is approximately $1.1 billion, which is 7.0 percent (70.9 million) above the Adopted FY 2023 Budget. REVENUE MONITORING Collection of the city’s revenue sources are monitored throughout the year. Financial reports are monitored monthly and quarterly to determine the accuracy of budget projections. This allows for appropriate administrative action if actual results differ substantially from projections. A detailed analysis is completed to project future revenue collections taking into account revenue drivers, information from departments that administer revenues, seasonal fluctuations, and economic conditions. Strong collection rates for locally generated taxes and fees reflect Norfolk residents’ commitment and fulfillment of responsibility to the city. General Fund Revenue Summary Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted FY 2023 vs. FY 2024 FY 2024 % of Total$ Change % Change General Property Taxes 345,879,422 355,118,800 384,369,200 29,250,400 8.2% 35.6% Other Local Taxes 173,337,193 171,966,025 181,084,500 9,118,475 5.3% 16.8% Permits and Fees 3,883,494 3,965,900 4,068,000 102,100 2.6% 0.4% Fines and Forfeitures 1,353,222 1,340,000 1,505,000 165,000 12.3% 0.1% Use of Money and Property 7,995,023 9,013,620 13,603,434 4,589,814 50.9% 1.3% Charges for Services 23,580,895 25,491,731 26,172,740 681,009 2.7% 2.4% Miscellaneous Revenue 10,889,955 9,227,966 8,669,610 -558,356 -6.1% 0.8% Recovered Costs 11,179,703 12,058,130 10,997,183 -1,060,947 -8.8% 1.0% Non-Categorical Aid - State 39,719,848 38,682,200 39,362,165 679,965 1.8% 3.6% Shared Expenses - State 22,779,442 23,544,200 25,119,100 1,574,900 6.7% 2.3% Categorical Aid - State 282,023,720 306,286,328 319,960,477 13,674,149 4.5% 29.6% Federal Aid 9,763,200 8,420,256 8,615,256 195,000 2.3% 0.8% Other Sources and Transfers In 44,885,400 43,240,468 55,718,363 12,477,895 28.9% 5.2% General Fund Total 977,270,518 1,008,355,624 1,079,245,028 70,889,404 7.0% 100.0% Note: FY 2022 Actual amounts may not sum to total due to rounding. Percentages may not total to 100 due to rounding. Major Revenue Sources 73 GENERAL PROPERTY TAXES General property taxes are levied on the assessed value of real estate and personal property including motor vehicles and machinery and tools. These taxes make up approximately 35.6 percent or $384 million of the city’s FY 2024 General Fund revenues. Real estate tax revenue is the largest component of general property taxes, comprising approximately $319 million or 29.6 percent of FY 2024 General Fund revenues. It includes current and delinquent real estate taxes as well as, the tax on public service corporations and the additional $0.16 per $100 of assessed value levied on real estate located within the Downtown Improvement District (DID). The estimate for current real estate taxes reflects the real estate tax rate of $1.25 per $100 of assessed value and setting aside a sum sufficient amount estimated at approximately $5.5 million for real estate tax relief to qualifying senior and disabled homeowners and to state mandated disabled veterans and surviving spouses of the armed forces killed in action. This year’s Operating Budget includes funding to increase the exemption level for senior and disabled homeowners from $203,386 to $267,609 and to allow for automatic adjustments to the average city home value going forward. The current real estate tax revenue estimate also reflects the Office of the Real Estate Assessor’s estimate of the overall taxable assessments in the land book on July 1, 2023. The most recent update from the Office of the Real Estate Assessor indicated that overall taxable assessments on July 1, 2023 are projected to be approximately 7.29 percent above the land book value on July 1, 2022. This would be the eleventh consecutive year of growth and the second highest growth since FY 2008. In comparison, over the past ten years, taxable real estate assessments have increased at an average annual rate of 3.3 percent. The projected increase in FY 2024 continues to be largely from residential assessments due to the robust housing market. On the other hand, general commercial assessments are anticipated to decline by 0.47 percent largely due to the decline in MacArthur Mall value. It is also important to note that due to the significant property owned by federal, state, and local governments, and religious and secular organizations in Norfolk, approximately 35 percent of the city’s real estate assessed value is tax exempt. This would be equivalent to a potential $298 $306 $321 $346 $355 $384 $0 $125 $250 $375 $500 FY 2019 Actual FY 2020 Actual FY 2021 Actual FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Budget FY 2024 Budget Millions General Property Taxes $203,386 $267,609 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 2024* Fiscal Year Home Value Eligible for Tax Relief in the Senior/Disabled Tax Relief Program *FY 2024 is Adopted -8% 0% 8% 16% 24% 32% 1990 1992 1994 1996 1998 2000 2002 2004 2006 2008 2010 2012 2014 2016 2018 2020 2022 2024 Percent Change Fiscal Year Taxable Real Estate Assessments Projected to Increase in FY 2024 (year-over-year percent change in the July 1 land book) FY 2024 estimated growth: +7.29% Source: Real Estate Assessor's Office. *FY 2024 is estimated. 74 Major Revenue Sources revenue loss of approximately $166 million based on the FY 2023 assessed value and the current real estate tax rate of $1.25 per $100 of assessed value. The second largest component of general property taxes is the personal property tax, which is levied on tangible personal property, that includes motor vehicles, boats, aircraft, business furnishings, and office equipment. Household goods and personal effects are exempt from taxation. Personal property taxes in total include current and delinquent collections, refunds, and taxes from public service corporations. In FY 2024, these comprise approximately 5.4 percent or $58 million of General Fund revenues. Personal property taxes are estimated to be approximately 7.6 percent above the FY 2023 budget . The increase reflects the value of motor vehicles not declining as quickly as anticipated in FY 2023 from FY 2022. As a result, revenues are anticipated to be above budget in FY 2023. The FY 2024 budget assumes no change in the general tax rate on personal property at $4.33 per $100 of assessed value. The estimate is also based on the state car tax relief at 55 percent (55%) rate for FY 2024 (tax bills due June 5, 2024). The 55 percent relief rate is anticipated to fully exhaust relief funds provided to the city by the Commonwealth under the Personal Property Tax Relief Act. This means that qualifying vehicles with an assessed value of more than $1,000 will receive a 55 percent (55%) tax relief rate on the vehicle’s first $20,000 of assessed value. Qualifying vehicles with an assessed value of $1,000 or less will receive 100 percent (100%) tax relief rate. Prior to FY 2006, qualifying vehicles with an assessed value of more than $1,000 were reimbursed for 70 percent of the total property tax eligible for relief. State legislation passed in 2004 capped car tax relief funds statewide at $950 million beginning in FY 2006. Consequently, each locality in the state now receives a fixed share of the $950 million of statewide personal property tax relief funds per state code. Each locality’s share was determined based on the proportional share of actual personal property tax relief payments received in tax year 2005, as certified by the Virginia Auditor of Public Accounts, of which, Norfolk’s share is $16,871,056. The machinery and tools tax is the third largest component of general property taxes. In FY 2024, the tax makes up approximately 0.6 percent or $6.5 million of General Fund revenues. The tax is levied on machinery and tools used in manufacturing, mining, radio and television broadcasting, cable television, dry cleaning or laundry businesses at a rate of $4.25 per $100 of assessed value. That tax rate is eight cents below the tax rate on general personal property of $4.33 per $100 of assessed value. Machinery and tools tax revenue is expected to remain stable in FY 2024. It is important to note that there have been several attempts by state legislators to curtail or eliminate localities’ taxing authority over this source. $6.2 $6.7 $5.8 $6.5 $6.2 $6.5 $0.0 $1.5 $3.0 $4.5 $6.0 $7.5 $9.0 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Budget 2024 Budget Millions Fiscal Year Machinery and Tools Tax Major Revenue Sources 75 OTHER LOCAL TAXES Other local taxes are comprised of consumer and business- based taxes, including taxes on utilities (water, gas, electricity, and communications), sales, hotel, restaurant/meals, admissions, and cigarettes, as well as franchise, business license, and recordation taxes. Historically, the revenue category are sensitive to changes in economic conditions and was impacted by the economic effects of COVID-19. It declined in FY 2020 but rose back to the pre-pandemic level in FY 2022 with the growth in sales tax and recovery of food and beverage and hotel taxes. Other local taxes are projected to comprise approximately 16.8 percent or $181 million of General Fund revenues in FY 2024 and are 5.3 percent above the FY 2023 budget. Other local taxes include consumption- based taxes, which have now recovered and have risen back to pre-pandemic levels. Citywide (all funds), other local taxes make up approximately 13.4 percent or $193.2 million of the operating budget in FY 2024 and are approximately 5.5 percent above the FY 2023 budget. The citywide amount includes the Public Amenities Fund portion of the hotel and food and beverage taxes and Emergency Preparedness and Response portion of the telecommunications sales and use tax. Also, the adopted budget reflects the ordinance adopted by the City Council on April 25, 2023 to continue the temporary exemption of certain motor vehicles from the city’s motor vehicle license fee that would otherwise have been assessed from calendar year 2022 through calendar year 2023. The sales and use tax makes up approximately 4.1 percent or $44.8 million of the city’s General Fund revenue in FY 2024 which is approximately 3.9 percent above the FY 2023 budget. Unlike the other consumption-based taxes, sales and use tax did not decline during the pandemic, and continues to grow. The sales and use tax is levied on selling, distribution, leasing, or renting of tangible personal property, use or consumption of tangible personal property, as well as taxable services in Virginia. Revenue from this source has historically been sensitive to the state of the economy, household income, and underlying price level changes. Changes in the local retail activity (such as new businesses, expansions, closures, and job changes) and in the local economy impact the projection of this revenue source. Also, much of the growth in FY 2020 and FY 2021 was largely due to Wayfair-related legislation. Since July 1, 2019, sales tax requirements have been in place for remote sellers and marketplace facilitators that have an economic nexus in Virginia. Under the law enacted during the 2019 session of the General Assembly, a remote seller or marketplace facilitator who meet the economic nexus standards of selling or facilitating the sale of more than $100,000 in annual gross retail sales or 200 or more transactions to Virginia customers began collecting sales tax on July 1, 2019. Prior to the law, mainly businesses with a physical presence in Virginia were required to collect the state’s sales and use tax. Adjustments made by the Virginia Department of Taxation for overpayments and underpayments of the tax by businesses also affect sales and use tax collections. Taxes are collected on prepared food and beverages. The tax rate is 6.5 percent of the value of the meal. One percentage point is allocated to the Public Amenities Fund, and 5.5 percentage points is allocated to the General Fund. The revenue generated by 1.0 percentage point of the tax rate for the Public Amenities Fund is estimated to be approximately $7.1 million in FY 2024, and the revenue generated from the 5.5 percentage points of the tax rate allocated to the General Fund is estimated to be approximately $39.3 million or 3.6 percent of General Fund revenues in FY 2024. The FY 2024 estimate is approximately 14.4 percent above the FY 2023 budget, which reflects the continued recovery from the $166.5 $161.7 $165.0 $173.3 $172.0 $181.1 $50 $100 $150 $200 $250 FY 2019 Actual FY 2020 Actual FY 2021 Actual FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Budget FY 2024 Budget Millions Other Local Taxes (General Fund amount only*) *Excludes Public Amenities Fund and Emergency Preparedness and Response $33.1 $29.9 $30.7 $36.9 $34.3 $39.3 $0 $12 $24 $36 $48 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Budget 2024 Budget Millions Fiscal Year Food and Beverage Tax Revenue (excludes Public Amenities Fund allocation) 76 Major Revenue Sources pandemic and has risen above its pre-pandemic level. The recovery has been faster than anticipated. As a result, FY 2023 revenues are outpacing the budget. Hotel taxes are levied on occupied hotel rooms at the rate of 8.0 percent of the room charge. Similar to the food and beverage tax, 1.0 percentage point is allocated to the Public Amenities Fund and 7.0 percentage points is allocated to the General Fund. The 8.0 percent tax rate does not include the 1.0 percent tax imposed by the General Assembly for the regional transportation district. The revenue generated by the 1.0 percentage point of the tax for the Public Amenities Fund is estimated to be approximately $1.4 million in FY 2024, and the revenue generated from the 7.0 percentage points allocated to the General Fund is estimated to be approximately $9.6 million or 0.9 percent of General Fund revenues in FY 2024. The FY 2024 estimate is 9.2 percent above the FY 2023 budget, which reflects the continued recovery from the pandemic and has risen above its pre-pandemic level. The hotel tax estimate does not include the $3.00 surcharge per room night (“bed tax”), estimated to generate approximately $3.4 million in FY 2024. The bed tax was enacted on April 1, 2006 at the rate of $1.00 per room night with support from the Norfolk Hotel-Motel Association and the revenue designated for Norfolk Convention and Visitor’s Bureau (Visit Norfolk) for visitor promotion and advertising for conventions and tourism. In FY 2012, the bed tax was raised to $2.00 per room night with the additional $1.00 revenue designated for the Norfolk Consortium (see Outside Agencies section). In FY 2019, the bed tax was raised to $3.00 per room night (current rate) to offset budget reductions to Outside Agencies (see Outside Agencies section). Business license taxes are collected from entities that engage in a business, trade, profession, or occupation in the city. It is generally imposed as a percentage of gross receipts generated during the previous calendar year. It is also applied to individuals that maintain a place of business, either permanent or temporary, or conduct a business- related activity. Business license tax rates vary depending on business classification and gross receipts generated. Norfolk’s rates are at the state maximum allowed for the main business classifications. Revenue collections in recent years have been reduced by refunds of overpayments. In FY 2022, the city recorded over $5 million in business license tax refund liability. Business license taxes makes up approximately 3.0 percent or $32.1 million of General Fund revenues in FY 2024. Consumer utility taxes on water, gas, electricity, and the communications sales and use tax combined, make up approximately 3.0 percent or $32.3 million of the city’s General Fund revenue in FY 2024. The consumer utility tax is levied on the purchase of utility service including water, gas, and electricity. Monthly receipts are monitored and used as a basis for estimating the revenue yield, taking seasonal variations into consideration. The consumer utility tax on telephones, cell phones, and cable TV was abolished and replaced by a statewide uniform communications sales and use tax on January 1, 2007. The Emergency 911 (E-911) tax on telephones was also replaced by a statewide uniform $0.75 tax per phone at the same time. The E-911 tax is distributed to the city together with the communications sales and use tax in one lump sum. Consequently, a portion of the city’s communications sales and use tax is allocated to directly support emergency communications (E-911) in the Emergency Preparedness and Response Special Revenue Fund (approximately $3.6 million). The FY 2024 estimate is 0.6 percent below the FY 2023 budget, largely due to the communications sales and use tax. The General Fund portion of the communications sales and use tax is estimated to be approximately $11.1 million in FY 2024 which is approximately 3.9 percent below the FY 2023 budget. Since the inception of the tax, revenue has fluctuated due to adjustments for overpayments and underpayments of the tax by telecommunications service providers. Revenue has also been on a downward trend due to changes in technology and lower utilization of communications services subject to the tax such as, landline telephones. State legislation to modernize local taxation authority to reflect technological changes in communication services were proposed during the 2018 General Assembly Session but were not enacted. $7.6 $6.5 $6.7 $9.8 $8.8 $9.6 $0.0 $3.5 $7.0 $10.5 $14.0 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Budget 2024 Budget Millions Fiscal Year Hotel Tax* (excludes Public Amenities Fund allocation) *Excludes $3.00 surcharge per room per night ("bed tax") Major Revenue Sources 77 PERMITS AND FEES Permits are issued to regulate new construction and ensure public safety. Revenues from this source are comprised of fees for permits, licenses, and other privileges subject to city regulation. The revenues partially cover the expense of providing regulatory services such as, zoning inspections, building code inspections, plan review, right-of-way permitting, and fire inspections in the city. Revenue from this source has generally fluctuated based upon the level of building construction activity in the city and large commercial projects. Permits and regulatory fees are projected to be approximately 0.4 percent or $4.1 million of General Fund revenues in FY 2024 and is approximately 2.6 percent above the FY 2023 budget. FINES AND FORFEITURES Fines and forfeitures in the General Fund largely consist of revenues received from the courts as fines and forfeitures for violations of city ordinances. In FY 2023, fines and forfeitures provide approximately 0.1 percent or $1.5 million of General Fund revenues. The FY 2024 budget is approximately 12 percent or $119,000 above the FY 2023 budget. Citywide, fines and forfeitures total approximately $4.2 million of revenues from all operating funds in FY 2024. The majority of the revenues from this source citywide are generated from fines for parking citations which support the operations of the Parking Facilities Fund (nongeneral fund). USE OF MONEY AND PROPERTY Revenue from use of money and property is comprised primarily of interest earned on cash balances, rent from short-term and long-term property leases, income from cultural facilities venues, and prudent management of city assets. In FY 2024, revenue from this source makes up approximately 1.3 percent or $13.6 million of General Fund revenues. The FY 2024 budget is approximately 50 percent or $4.6 million above the FY 2023 budget. The growth largely reflects the positive impact of rising interest rates on the city’s interest from investments. CHARGES FOR SERVICES Charges for services include fees charged for various programs and services such as, recreation centers, Virginia Zoo, courts (judiciary), paramedical rescue, Norfolk Public School activities, Norfolk Community Services Board (NCSB), cruise ship terminal, and Nauticus. Charges for services make up approximately 2.4 percent or $26.2 million of FY 2024 General Fund revenues. The FY 2024 budget is 2.7 percent above the FY 2023 budget which reflects increased utilization of city facilities such as, the cruise ship terminal, Nauticus, and recreation centers anticipated in FY 2023. Charges for services continues to recover and has risen above its pre- pandemic level. Citywide, most of the revenue from this source are charges for services by nongeneral funds. Charges for services citywide make up approximately $354 million of operating budget, over ten times the amount in the General Fund alone. Nongeneral fund charges are mostly from user fees for utilities (water and wastewater services), parking facilities, storm water management, and refuse disposal. The rates for these user fees are set to ensure operations are fully supported by the fees collected. $24.3 $20.4 $19.6 $23.6 $25.5 $26.2 $0 $7 $14 $21 $28 $35 FY 2019 Actual FY 2020 Actual FY 2021 Actual FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Budget FY 2024 Budget Millions Charges for Services 78 Major Revenue Sources This year’s proposed Operating Budget includes an increase in Cemeteries, Storm Water, Parking, and Waste Management fees in addition to the automatic fee increases in Water, Wastewater, and Storm Water. See Selected Tax Rates and Fees and Proposed Fee Changes section for changes in the rates for nongeneral fund charges for services in FY 2024. MISCELLANEOUS REVENUE Miscellaneous revenue consists of revenues not classified in other categories and includes revenue from payments in lieu of taxes (PILOT), fee for services provided to the U.S. Navy’s housing public-private venture, administrative fees, and proceeds from the sale of city-owned land. In FY 2024, the city is estimating to receive approximately $8.7 million, which represents 0.8 percent of FY 2024 General Fund revenues. The FY 2024 budget includes estimated proceeds from the auction of city-owned vacant property that began in Spring 2022. RECOVERED COSTS Recovered costs consist of revenue from nongeneral funds, partner agencies, and the public for certain expenses, such as indirect costs, employee compensation, debt service, and communications and information technology services. Recovered costs make up approximately 1.0 percent or $11.1 million of FY 2024 General Fund revenues. The FY 2024 budget is approximately 8.4 percent ($1.0 million) below the FY 2023 budget. The decrease in the FY 2024 budget from FY 2023 is largely due to the distribution and allocation of indirect costs to nongeneral fund departments. REVENUE FROM THE COMMONWEALTH Revenue from the Commonwealth totals approximately $384 million or 35.6 percent of FY 2024 General Fund revenues and is 4.3 percent above the FY 2023 budget. Revenue from the Commonwealth is divided into three categories which are discussed below: Non-categorical aid ($39.4 million), Shared expenses ($25.1 million), and Categorical aid ($320.0 million). Estimates are based upon the funding approved by the 2022 Special Session I and the 2023 Session of the General Assembly as of February 25, 2023. If the state amends the budget at a later date, the city may amend its budget to reflect additional revenue resulting from state amendments. NON-CATEGORICAL AID - VIRGINIA Non-categorical aid consists of revenue from the Commonwealth without restriction as to use. Non-categorical aid is estimated to be 3.6 percent or $39.4 million of General Fund revenues and is approximately 1.8 percent above the FY 2023 budget. The increase is largely from the estimate for state aid for HB 599 funds for law enforcement based upon the funding approved by the 2022 Special Session I and the 2023 Session of the General Assembly as of February 25, 2023. The increase was partly offset by the delay in the opening of a temporary gambling facility affiliated with the casino project. The temporary gambling facility had been anticipated to open in the beginning of the 2023 calendar year . Major Revenue Sources 79 SHARED EXPENSES Shared expenses consist of recovered costs from the Commonwealth for a portion of the state-supported salaries and benefits, and qualifying nonpersonnel expenses of constitutional offices and other offices serving the Norfolk community, including the Norfolk Electoral Board, Sheriff, City Treasurer, Commissioner of the Revenue, Clerk of the Circuit Court, and Commonwealth’s Attorney. Shared expenses make up approximately 2.3 percent or $25.1 million of FY 2024 General Fund revenues. The FY 2024 amount is approximately 2.4 percent above the FY 2023 budget. The increase largely reflects the five percent state salary increase of state-supported constitutional officers and staff, along with the registrar and electoral board members based upon the funding approved by the 2022 Special Session I and the 2023 Session of the General Assembly as of February 25, 2023. The General Assembly passed a “lite” version of the state budget which only included a 5 percent increase for constitutional employees. If the state amends this budget to include a higher increase for Sheriff Deputies as has been discussed, we will work with the Sheriff to adjust their pay increase appropriately and reflect the increased revenue from the state. STATE CATEGORICAL AID Categorical aid from the Commonwealth consists mainly of revenues earmarked for core services including, K-12 education, social services administration and public assistance grants, Norfolk Community Services Board (NCSB), libraries, Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) funding for street maintenance and localities that host port- owned facilities, and local adult correctional facility. State categorical aid makes up approximately 29.7 percent or $320.0 million of General Fund revenues in FY 2024 which is approximately 4.5 percent above the FY 2023 budget. The increase is largely for Norfolk Public Schools ($12.0 million), street maintenance and human services. Of the $320.0 million of state categorical aid estimated to be received in FY 2024, most of the revenue is earmarked for Norfolk Public Schools, approximately $239.6 million of the $320.0 million. Categorical aid for Norfolk Public Schools includes the state sales and use tax and state school funds. State sales and use tax for schools is the revenue from the city’s proportionate share of the state sales and use tax designated for public education. Since July 1, 2012, the city’s share of the state sales and use tax is based on the population estimate provided by the Weldon Cooper Center for Public Service at the University of Virginia. In addition, in FY 2014, state sales and use tax dedicated to public education increased to 1⅜ cent as part of the statewide transportation bill. Prior to FY 2014, 1¼ cent of the state sales and use tax was dedicated to public education, which reflected the change in FY 2005 when half of the one-half cent sales and use tax increase adopted by the General Assembly was earmarked for local school divisions and real estate tax relief. Half of that quarter percent is distributed in the manner discussed above. The other half of the quarter percent goes to support the Standards of Quality (SOQ), which is included in state school funds. State school funds support school operational costs. The rate of reimbursements is based on the SOQ formula with reimbursement rates varying by program and area of emphasis. Changes in enrollment figures affect this revenue source. Localities are required to $22.0 $22.9 $22.0 $22.8 $23.3 $25.1 $0 $7 $14 $21 $28 $35 FY 2019 Actual FY 2020 Actual FY 2021 Actual FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Budget FY 2024 Budget Millions Shared Expenses - State Aid $194.1 $199.1 $201.2 $210.8 $228.5 $239.6 $0 $75 $150 $225 $300 FY 2019 Actual FY 2020 Actual FY 2021 Actual FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Budget FY 2024 Budget Millions State Aid for Norfolk Public Schools 80 Major Revenue Sources match the state contribution based on a composite index. Norfolk continues to provide more than its required share of local effort. Categorical aid also includes the state reimbursement for the cost of operating the Department of Human Services and Norfolk Community Services Board, estimated to be approximately $39.9 million and $9.5 million, respectively. State aid is tied to operating costs that include the cost of personnel, fringe benefits, nonpersonal services, and rent for buildings and parking. The reimbursement rate of the overall costs varies by program. The jail per diem estimate is approximately $1.6 million in FY 2024 with no changes anticipated in the jail per diem rates based on the estimate provided by the Virginia Compensation Board. Since the 2016-2018 biennium, the amount appropriated by the Commonwealth has been based on the expected cost of jail per diems. In prior years, the General Assembly did not appropriate the full estimated statewide cost for jail per diems and the funding shortfall was addressed in the mid-biennium or caboose budget. However, if the appropriation falls short due to statewide inmate population being higher than anticipated, the Compensation Board will prorate the amounts distributed to local jails. The last time jail per diem rates were changed was during the 2010 session of the General Assembly. Since March 1, 2010, per diem payments for local responsible inmates in local or regional jails was reduced to $4.00 per day from $8.00 per day, while the per diem payments for state inmates housed in local jails was changed to $12.00 per day from $8.00 or $14.00 per day (reflecting the $6.00 bonus payment for certain state inmates). Payment for jail contract beds fell to $8.00 per day from $14.00 per day. These changes in the per diem rates resulted in approximately a $2.0 million decline in jail per diem funding to the city. Effective July 1, 2022, the per diem payment for state inmates housed in local jails was changed to $15.00 per day from $12.00 per day. Categorical aid also includes funds received from the Virginia Department of Transportation (VDOT) for street construction and maintenance and support for localities that host Virginia Port Authority owned real estate, estimated in total to be approximately $28.7 million in FY 2023. The funds for street construction and maintenance are received from VDOT to maintain the city’s principal and minor arterials, collector roads, and local streets based on moving lane miles. The revenue allocated to the city is based on a statewide maintenance index of the unit costs used on roads and bridges. Changes in the index are used to calculate and implement annual per-land-mile rates. The rates fluctuate on index changes and number of miles assessed. These funds offset qualifying operating costs recorded in the city’s budget. FEDERAL AID Aid from the federal government primarily includes funds for Norfolk Public Schools and Norfolk Community Services Board. Federal aid totals approximately $8.6 million or 0.8 percent of General Fund revenues in FY 2024 and is 2.3 percent ($195,000) above the FY 2023 budget. OTHER SOURCES AND TRANSFERS IN Revenue from other sources and transfers in consist of intra-governmental transfers and carry forward funds. It totals approximately $55.7 million or 5.2 percent of General Fund revenues in FY 2024, which is an increase of approximately $12.5 million from the FY 2023 budget. In FY 2024, other sources and transfers in includes transfers in of $20.5 million from nongeneral funds such as: Utilities ($10 million); Tax Increment Financing Fund ($7.0 million) which consists of the annual transfer of excess revenue; and Public Amenities Fund ($3.5 million) to support the Norfolk Consortium. See Outside Agencies section of the budget document for details on the Norfolk Consortium. The remaining amount of approximately $35.2 million consists of: carryforward of prior year budget savings from transitioning eligible expenses to the Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds (SLFRF) grant ($13.3 million); carryforward of prior year savings by the Norfolk Community Services Board ($2.0 million); carryforward of the Department of Public Health’s FY 2022 year-end settlement ($471,000); and carryforward of prior year savings and anticipated current year savings ($19.4 million). Appropriations 81 APPROPRIATIONS Department FY 2024 Adopted GENERAL FUND LEGISLATIVE City Auditor 1,214,892 City Clerk 1,932,740 City Council 395,607 City Real Estate Assessor 2,835,235 Total Legislative 6,378,474 EXECUTIVE Budget and Strategic Planning 3,562,058 City Manager 4,293,548 Communications & Marketing 2,572,850 Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion 1,393,649 Housing and Community Development 6,341,473 Resilience 1,158,302 Total Executive 19,321,880 DEPARTMENT OF LAW 5,963,932 CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS City Treasurer 3,098,885 Clerk of the Circuit Court 3,470,939 Commissioner of the Revenue 3,483,443 Commonwealth's Attorney 7,085,084 Sheriff and Jail 45,655,414 Total Constitutional Officers 62,793,765 JUDICIAL Circuit Court Judges 958,303 General District Court 260,761 Juvenile and Domestic Relations Court 81,833 Magistrate 12,248 Norfolk Juvenile Court Service Unit 209,594 Total Judicial 1,522,739 ELECTIONS 1,179,525 GENERAL MANAGEMENT Finance 8,283,788 82 Appropriations General Services 31,269,174 Human Resources 5,043,080 Information Technology 21,243,061 Total General Management 65,839,103 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT City Planning 6,416,205 Economic Development 3,375,939 Neighborhood Development 6,935,607 Total Community Development 16,727,751 PARKS, RECREATION AND CULTURE Cultural Facilities, Arts and Entertainment 6,865,561 Libraries 10,981,220 Nauticus 4,776,144 Parks and Recreation 21,962,524 Slover Library 2,971,111 Virginia Zoological Park 5,042,106 Total Parks, Recreation and Culture 52,598,666 PUBLIC HEALTH AND ASSISTANCE Human Services 55,770,320 Norfolk Community Services Board 31,348,922 Public Health 3,400,665 Total Public Health and Assistance 90,519,907 PUBLIC SAFETY Fire-Rescue 58,844,372 Police 83,392,494 Total Public Safety 142,236,866 PUBLIC WORKS 22,188,536 TRANSPORTATION 12,119,902 CENTRAL AND OUTSIDE AGENCY APPROPRIATIONS Central Appropriations 23,132,668 Outside Agencies 50,780,898 Total Central and Outside Agency Appropriations 73,913,566 DEBT SERVICE 101,365,244 PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATION (Norfolk Public Schools) 404,575,172 Total General Fund 1,079,245,028 Department FY 2024 Adopted Appropriations 83 SPECIAL REVENUE FUNDS Cemeteries 2,220,050 Emergency Preparedness And Response 7,023,383 Golf Operations 15,000 Public Amenities 8,651,000 Tax Increment Financing 8,536,000 Towing and Recovery Operations 1,813,787 Waste Management 23,756,993 Total Special Revenue Funds 52,016,213 ENTERPRISE FUNDS Parking Facilities 21,318,487 Storm Water Management 23,721,854 Utilities - Wastewater 37,444,240 Utilities - Water 107,496,257 Total Enterprise Funds 189,980,838 INTERNAL SERVICE FUNDS Fleet Management 12,914,995 Healthcare 105,700,538 Total Internal Service Funds 118,615,533 TOTAL CITY OPERATIONS 1,439,857,612 CAPITAL IMPROVEMENT PLAN 395,613,169 ANNUAL GRANTS PLAN1 86,498,241 ANNUAL PLAN 7,054,048 TOTAL APPROPRIATIONS 1,929,023,070 1The amount reflects the “up to” amount appropriated by the operating budget ordinance. The actual grant award will vary annually. Note: Numbers may not add to total/subtotal due to rounding. Department FY 2024 Adopted 84 Selected Tax Rates and Fees SELECTED TAX RATES AND FEES Description FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted PROPERTY TAXES Real Estate (General Tax) $1.25/$100 Assessed Value $1.25/$100 Assessed Value Real Estate (Downtown Improvement District) $1.41/$100 Assessed Value $1.41/$100 Assessed Value Personal Property Airplane $2.40/$100 Assessed Value $2.40/$100 Assessed Value Motor Vehicle $4.33/$100 Assessed Value $4.33/$100 Assessed Value Recreational Vehicle $1.50/$100 Assessed Value $1.50/$100 Assessed Value Business Furniture, Fixtures, and Equipment $4.33/$100 Assessed Value $4.33/$100 Assessed Value Watercraft - Business $1.50/$100 Assessed Value $1.50/$100 Assessed Value Watercraft - Recreational $0.000001/$100 Assessed Value $0.000001/$100 Assessed Value Machinery & Tools $4.25/$100 Assessed Value $4.25/$100 Assessed Value OTHER LOCAL TAXES Amusement and Admissions 10% 10% Cigarette 95 cents/pack of 20 cigarettes (47.5 mils/cigarette) 95 cents/pack of 20 cigarettes (47.5 mils/cigarette) Emergency 911 (Landline) Replaced by the statewide E-911 tax rate of $0.75/line/month Replaced by the statewide E-911 tax rate of $0.75/line/month Hotel/Motel Lodging 8% 8% Bed Tax $3.00 per room night $3.00 per room night Food and Beverage 6.5% 6.5% Recreational Boat License: Boats under 16 feet in length $15.00 $15.00 Boats 16 feet and over in length $40.00 $40.00 Motor Vehicle License: Small Trailers (<2,000 pounds) $11.50 $11.50 Motorcycles $20.00 $20.00 Cars and Small Trucks $31.00 $31.00 Mid-Size Trucks/Vans (>4,000 pounds) $36.00 $36.00 Large Vehicles (over 19,000 pounds) $1.60-$1.80/1,000 pounds of gross weight (additional $5 flat fee) $1.60-$1.80/1,000 pounds of gross weight (additional $5 flat fee) Selected Tax Rates and Fees 85 REFUSE DISPOSAL Residential Single or Multiple Units (four units or less) $27.01/unit/month $28.51/unit/month Multiple Units (five units or more) $45.94/container/month $47.44/container/month Commercial Business 1 times per week $61.18/unit/month $61.18/unit/month Business 5 times per week $151.64/unit/month $151.64/unit/month Combined Commercial and Residential $88.19/unit/month $88.19/unit/month WATER AND WASTEWATER UTILITY FEES Water $5.87/100 cubic feet $6.08/100 cubic feet Wastewater $5.03/100 cubic feet $5.23/100 cubic feet STORM WATER FEES (rate calculated based on a 30-day month) Residential $13.05/month $13.57/month Commercial $13.05/month per 2,000 sq. ft. $13.57/month per 2,000 sq. ft. UTILITY TAXES Commercial Gas Rate/month: $3.225 + $0.167821/CCF 0-70 CCF + $0.161552/CCF 71-430 CCF + $0.15363/CCF on balance (maximum of $500/month) Rate/month: $3.225 + $0.167821/CCF 0-70 CCF + $0.161552/CCF 71-430 CCF + $0.15363/CCF on balance (maximum of $500/month) Electricity (Manufacturing) Rate/month: $1.38 + $0.004965/kWh 0-3,625,100 kWhs + $0.004014/kWh on balance (maximum of $53,000/month) Rate/month: $1.38 + $0.004965/kWh 0-3,625,100 kWhs + $0.004014/kWh on balance (maximum of $53,000/month) Electricity (Non-Manufacturing) Rate/month: $2.87 + $0.017933/kWh 0-537 kWh + $0.006330/kWh on balance Rate/month: $2.87 + $0.017933/kWh 0-537 kWh + $0.006330/kWh on balance Telephone (Cellular, Landline) Replaced by the State Communications Sales & Use Tax 5% of sales price of services Replaced by the State Communications Sales & Use Tax 5% of sales price of services Water 25% on first $75, plus 15% of bill in excess of $75 25% on first $75, plus 15% of bill in excess of $75 Residential Cable and Satellite Service Telephone (Cellular, Landline) Replaced by the State Communications Sales & Use Tax Replaced by the State Communications Sales & Use Tax Electricity $1.75 + $0.016891/kWh monthly (capped at $3.75/month) $1.75 + $0.016891/kWh monthly (capped at $3.75/month) Gas $1.50/month $1.50/month Water (5/8" Meter) 25% on first $22.50/month 25% on first $22.50/month Description FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted 86 General Fund Balance Reserves GENERAL FUND BALANCE RESERVES The establishment and maintenance of general operating reserves is considered one of the most effective management practices a local government can employ. The purpose of a reserve is to act as the city’s “savings” account to meet emergency, unanticipated needs without jeopardizing the ongoing provision of city services. Reserves help to cushion against cash flow challenges such as providing an interim source of funding for emergency costs from a significantly large unexpected expenses such as a hurricane. The appropriate size of reserves depends on variability of revenues and expenditures and an organization’s cash flow needs. The City Council adopted a resolution on May 16, 2000 to create reserve funds. On July 23, 2013, City Council adopted a resolution that updated the policies on reserve funds establishing reserve target levels, formalized the city’s long- standing self-imposed debt affordability measures, and established financial policies for the Parking Facilities Fund. City Council’s resolution passed on February 26, 2019, updated the city’s policies on reserves, debt affordability, and surplus funds utilization, and adopted new financial policies on pension funding and enterprise fund financial management. On May 11, 2021, City Council passed a resolution updating the Pension Funding Policy to allow for the positive impacts garnered from the sale of debt to refinance a portion of the city’s pension liability. The update also provides a framework of when the city’s existing reserves will be utilized. The city’s Reserve Policy documents the city’s approach to establishing and maintaining strong reserves across the spectrum of city operations. The city’s financial policies demonstrate its commitment to consistent financial practices, operational efficiencies and best practices. Sound financial management practices contribute to maintaining high city credit ratings and lower borrowing costs for capital projects, preserve fiscal integrity, and promote long-term fiscal sustainability. The Financial Policies section provides more detail on the policies. 1The amounts are in accordance with the most recent financial policies adopted by City Council. The FY 2022 General Fund unassigned reserve policy minimum is equal to ten percent (10%) of General Fund expenditures, plus General Fund transfers out as of June 30, 2022. The FY 2022 Estimate and FY 2023 Projection are equal to the FY 2020 policy minimum and assumes no change from the FY 2020 General Fund Unassigned Reserve amount. 2The amounts above exclude reserves for encumbrances and other legally restricted reserves and designations for specific appropriations. General Fund Balance Reserves Reserve FY 2022 Estimate FY 2022 Minimum FY 2022 Maximum FY 2023 Projection General Fund Unassigned Reserve1 $66,085,337 $62,298,236 N/A $66,085,337 Risk Management Reserve $8,000,000 $5,000,000 $8,000,000 $8,000,000 Economic Downturn Reserve $5,000,000 $5,000,000 $5,000,000 $5,000,000 Inclusive Development Opportunity Fund $2,000,000 $2,000,000 $2,000,000 $2,000,000 General Fund Balance Reserves at June 302 $81,085,337 $81,085,337 Estimated General Fund - Fund Balance 87 ESTIMATED GENERAL FUND - FUND BALANCE Beginning General Fund - Fund Balance, July 1, 2022* $329,784,361 Add Revenues** Revenues (excluding transfers) $965,115,156 Return from water and wastewater utility funds 10,000,000 Return from tax increment financing fund 5,700,700 Return from Norfolk Public Schools (reversion funds) 2,556,191 Public amenities fund support for Norfolk Consortium 3,500,000 Total Fund Balance and Revenues $1,316,656,408 Less: Anticipated Expenditures** Norfolk Public Schools operating budget $385,180,630 Public safety 133,452,386 Public health and assistance 84,576,523 Other city departments $241,295,501 Central appropriations and outside agencies 76,153,863 Debt service 87,696,721 *Amount reported in the FY 2022 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report **Based on FY 2023 Adopted Budget 88 Summary of Changes in Fund Balance SUMMARY OF CHANGES IN FUND BALANCE General Fund FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted Operating Revenues General property taxes 345,879,422 355,118,800 384,369,200 Other local taxes 173,337,193 171,966,025 181,084,500 Permits and fees 3,883,494 3,965,900 4,068,000 Fines and forfeitures 1,353,222 1,340,000 1,505,000 Charges for services 23,580,895 25,491,731 26,172,740 Miscellaneous 10,889,955 9,227,966 8,669,610 Recovered costs 11,179,703 12,058,130 10,997,183 Commonwealth 344,523,010 368,512,728 384,441,742 Federal 9,763,200 8,420,256 8,615,256 Total Operating Revenues 924,390,094 956,101,536 1,009,923,231 Operating Expenses Personnel services 254,231,004 333,017,455 360,628,052 Contractual services 50,097,896 59,692,587 67,015,429 Materials, supplies and repairs 36,584,919 42,667,443 47,871,070 Department specific appropriation 405,876,096 460,111,179 475,790,032 Public assistance 13,450,940 15,439,553 15,557,208 Total Operating Expenses 760,240,855 910,928,217 966,861,791 Operating Income (Loss) 164,149,239 45,173,319 43,061,440 Non-Operating Revenues (Expenses) Use of money and property 7,995,023 9,013,620 13,603,434 Capital outlay (9,632,571) (6,972,755) (7,452,064) Debt service (75,964,232) (88,268,047) (101,897,354) Acctg. for Encumbrances for Budget not GAAP (3,077,946) 0 0 Total Non-Operating Revenue/Expense (80,679,726) (86,227,182) (95,745,984) Income (Loss) Before Operating Transfers 83,469,513 (41,053,863) (52,684,544) Operating transfers in 18,768,400 21,756,891 20,536,000 Operating transfers out (3,448,425) (2,186,605) (3,033,819) Total Operating Transfers 15,319,975 19,570,286 17,502,181 Net Change in Fund Balance 98,789,488 (21,483,577) (35,182,363) Beginning Fund Balance at July 1 230,994,873 329,784,361 308,300,784 Ending Fund Balance at June 30 329,784,361 308,300,784 273,118,421 Note: FY 2022 amounts are based on figures in the city’s Annual Comprehensive Financial Report. The net change in fund balance in FY 2023 and FY 2024 includes FY 2022 budget savings from the use of Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds (SLFRF) to offset FY 2022 qualifying expenses, FY 2021 budget savings from the use of CARES Act Coronavirus Relief Funds (CRF), and other prior year budget savings. Summary of Changes in Fund Balance 89 Special Revenue Funds FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted Operating Revenues General property taxes 6,768,400 7,200,700 8,536,000 Other local taxes 11,664,247 11,069,776 12,086,596 Fines and forfeitures 0 11,000 11,000 Charges for services 24,045,417 23,975,192 25,301,345 Miscellaneous 43,539 561,775 637,445 Recovered costs 0 1,919,594 1,919,594 Commonwealth 1,618,384 136,000 136,000 Federal 3,215 113,617 113,617 Total Operating Revenues 44,143,202 44,987,654 48,741,597 Operating Expenses Personnel services 12,378,880 14,678,212 16,106,387 Contractual services 10,240,846 13,193,813 12,940,901 Materials, supplies and repairs 2,559,951 2,605,862 2,712,641 Department specific appropriation 955,103 937,157 1,066,481 Total Operating Expenses 26,134,780 31,415,044 32,826,410 Operating Income (Loss) 18,008,422 13,572,610 15,915,187 Non-Operating Revenues (Expenses) Use of money and property 54,870 925,335 925,335 Capital outlay (3,308,752) (3,564,798) (2,077,818) Debt service (6,548,728) (6,748,052) (6,575,985) Total Non-Operating Revenue/Expense (9,802,610) (9,387,515) (7,728,468) Income (Loss) Before Operating Transfers 8,205,812 4,185,095 8,186,719 Operating transfers in 674,294 1,499,321 2,190,929 Operating transfers out (10,268,400) (9,200,700) (10,536,000) Total Operating Transfers (9,594,106) (7,701,379) (8,345,071) Net Change in Fund Balance (1,388,294) (3,516,284) (158,352) Beginning Fund Balance at July 1 12,756,923 11,368,629 7,852,345 Ending Fund Balance at June 30 11,368,629 7,852,345 7,693,993 Note: FY 2022 amounts are based on figures in the city’s Annual Comprehensive Financial Report. For FY 2023, the majority of the net change in fund balance reflects the change in fund balance of the Public Amenities Fund and Waste Management Fund. See Public Amenities Fund and Waste Management Fund sections for details. 90 Summary of Changes in Net Assets SUMMARY OF CHANGES IN NET ASSETS Enterprise Funds FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted Operating Revenues Permits and fees 0 863,569 868,100 Fines and forfeitures 0 2,658,028 2,100,000 Charges for services 178,665,490 174,684,561 185,581,818 Miscellaneous 2,002,176 231,637 280,900 Recovered costs 0 1,003,600 1,003,600 Total Operating Revenues 180,667,666 179,441,395 189,834,418 Operating Expenses Personnel services 18,409,026 39,851,746 43,926,874 Contractual services/Materials, supplies and repairs 42,099,516 39,444,042 43,375,279 Depreciation 30,309,075 0 0 Department specific appropriation 0 24,276,578 26,683,460 Total Operating Expenses 90,817,617 103,572,366 113,985,613 Operating Income (Loss) 89,850,049 75,869,029 75,848,805 Non-Operating Revenues (Expenses) Use of money and property (1,118,924) 349,020 139,020 Capital outlay 0 (2,619,613) (4,738,706) Intergovernmental revenue 2,730,661 0 0 Miscellaneous revenue (expense) (28,597) 0 0 Interest and Fiscal Charges (16,818,403) 0 0 Gain/(Loss)-Sale of fixed assets & investments 8,101,316 7,400 7,400 Debt service 0 (66,032,166) (58,491,319) Total Non-Operating Revenue/Expense (7,133,947) (68,295,359) (63,083,605) Income (Loss) Before Operating Transfers 82,716,102 7,573,670 12,765,200 Capital Contribution 0 0 0 Operating transfers in 0 0 0 Operating transfers out (10,500,000) (12,531,698) (12,765,200) Total Operating Transfers/Capital Contribution (10,500,000) (12,531,698) (12,765,200) Net Income (Loss) 72,216,102 (4,958,028) 0 Beginning Net Assets at July 1 597,099,229 669,315,331 664,357,303 Ending net assets at June 30 669,315,331 664,357,303 664,357,303 Note: FY 2022 amounts are based on figures in the city’s Annual Comprehensive Financial Report. The FY 2023 net income change is due to the Parking Facilities Fund. See Parking Facilities Fund section for details. Summary of Changes in Net Assets 91 Internal Service Funds FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted Operating Revenues Charges for services 101,063,749 116,715,975 118,015,359 Miscellaneous 138,445 0 0 Recovered costs 0 63,865 63,865 Total Operating Revenues 101,202,194 116,779,840 118,079,224 Operating Expenses Personnel services 2,089,398 4,765,275 5,488,296 Cost of Goods Sold 4,933,939 0 0 Contractual services 74,634,572 108,337,713 108,055,717 Materials, supplies and repairs/Other 4,838,673 4,210,059 4,884,512 Depreciation 383,794 0 0 Total Operating Expenses 86,880,376 117,313,047 118,428,525 Operating Income (Loss) 14,321,818 (533,207) (349,301) Non-Operating Revenues (Expenses) Use of money and property 0 3,500 3,500 Capital outlay 0 (38,790) (59,237) Miscellaneous revenue (expense) 0 0 0 Gain/(Loss)-Sale of fixed assets & investments 0 3,000 3,000 Debt Service 0 (22,266) (127,771) Total Non-Operating Revenue/Expense 0 (54,556) (180,508) Income (Loss) Before Operating Transfers 14,321,818 (587,763) (529,809) Capital Contribution 30,932 0 0 Operating transfers in 0 0 0 Operating transfers out 0 0 0 Total Operating Transfers 30,932 0 0 Net Income (Loss) 14,352,750 (587,763) (529,809) Beginning Net Assets at July 1 516,964 14,869,714 14,281,951 Ending net assets at June 30 14,869,714 14,281,951 13,752,142 Note: FY 2022 amounts are based on figures in the city’s Annual Comprehensive Financial Report. The budgeted FY 2023 and FY 2024 net income change is due to the Fleet Management Fund. See Fleet Management Fund section for details. Ending net assets at June 30 will vary based on actual revenues and expenditures. 92 Transfers From/To TRANSFERS FROM/TO The tables below present certain fund to fund transfers which include: General Fund support of capital projects and special revenue funds; transfers from enterprise activities and special revenue funds to the General Fund; and cash contribution from General Fund and nongeneral funds for capital projects. 1Actual amount transferred from the General Fund may vary based upon the actual grant award. See Annual Grants Plan for details. 2See Adopted CIP Ordinance for details. Transfer from General Fund to FY 2024 Capital Improvement Plan 842,890 Cemetery Fund 329,252 Emergency Preparedness and Response Fund 1,861,677 Grants Fund (estimated)1 5,340,632 Total Transfers from General Fund 8,374,451 Transfer to General Fund from Public Amenities Fund 3,500,000 Tax Increment Financing Fund 7,036,000 Wastewater Utility Fund 1,500,000 Water Utility Fund 8,500,000 Total Transfers to General Fund 20,536,000 Capital Improvement Plan Cash Sources General Fund2 62,142,890 Community Development Block Grant 1,500,000 Norfolk Public Schools2 16,891,347 State Match2 24,628,800 Storm Water Management Fund 1,315,200 Wastewater Utility Fund 20,880,000 Water Utility Fund 34,700,000 Total Capital Improvement Plan Cash Sources 162,058,237 Full Time Equivalent (FTE) Staffing Summary 93 FULL TIME EQUIVALENT (FTE) STAFFING SUMMARY FY 2022 Adopted FTE FY 2023 Adopted FTE FY 2024 Adopted FTE Change FY 2023 to FY 2024 General Fund Budget and Strategic Planning 19.0 22.0 29.0 7.0 Circuit Court Judges 5.0 5.0 5.0 0.0 City Attorney 34.0 37.0 37.0 0.0 City Auditor 9.0 9.0 9.0 0.0 City Clerk 13.0 13.0 13.8 0.0 City Council 8.0 8.0 8.0 0.0 City Manager 16.0 18.0 18.0 0.0 City Planning 63.0 71.0 73.0 2.0 City Real Estate Assessor 25.0 25.0 25.0 0.0 City Treasurer 31.0 32.0 32.0 0.0 Clerk of Circuit Court 46.0 46.0 44.0 (2.0) Commissioner of the Revenue 37.0 37.0 37.0 0.0 Commonwealth’s Attorney 64.0 64.0 64.0 0.0 Communications 16.0 14.0 18.0 4.0 Cultural Facilities, Arts & Entertainment 41.0 46.0 47.0 1.0 Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion 0.0 8.0 11.0 3.0 Economic Development 16.0 22.0 22.0 0.0 Elections 6.0 6.0 7.0 1.0 Finance Department 55.0 65.0 68.0 3.0 Fire-Rescue 514.0 523.0 526.0 3.0 General Services and Administration 128.4 127.4 138.4 11.0 Housing and Community Development 19.0 28.0 30.0 2.0 Human Resources 31.0 33.0 35.0 2.0 Human Services 490.5 486.5 483.5 (3.0) Information Technology 84.0 85.0 86.0 1.0 Libraries 95.0 100.0 114.5 14.5 Nauticus 27.0 27.0 29.0 2.0 Neighborhood Services 52.0 56.0 69.0 13.0 Norfolk Community Services Board 272.8 310.5 311.5 1.0 Parks and Recreation 180.0 202.0 215.0 13.0 Police 859.0 830.0 750.0 (80.0) Public Health 7.0 7.0 7.0 0.0 Public Works 141.0 138.0 140.0 2.0 94 Full Time Equivalent (FTE) Staffing Summary Note: Totals may not add up due to rounding. Only permanent positions are reflected in the Budget Document. Resilience 6.0 7.0 11.0 4.0 Sheriff and Jail 440.0 436.0 438.0 2.0 Slover Library 30.0 30.0 35.0 5.0 St. Paul’s Area Transformation 7.0 0.0 0.0 0.0 Transit 62.0 57.0 60.0 3.0 Zoological Park 48.0 51.0 51.0 0.0 Total General Fund 3,997.7 4,082.4 4,097.7 15.3 Special Revenue Funds Cemeteries 26.0 29.0 29.0 0.0 Emergency Preparedness and Response 76.5 82.0 82.0 0.0 Towing and Recovery Operations 8.0 8.0 8.0 0.0 Waste Management 106.0 106.0 106.0 0.0 Total Special Revenue Funds 216.5 225.0 225.0 0.0 Enterprise Funds Parking Facilities 67.2 66.4 85.4 19.0 Storm Water Management 111.0 112.0 113.0 1.0 Wastewater Utility 103.0 102.0 101.0 (1.0) Water Utility 289.0 289.0 291.0 2.0 Total Enterprise Funds 570.2 569.4 590.4 21.0 Internal Service Funds Fleet 52.0 52.0 52.0 0.0 Healthcare 8.0 13.0 14.0 1.0 Total Internal Service Funds 60.0 65.0 66.0 1.0 Total All Funds 4,844.4 4,941.8 4,979.1 37.3 FY 2022 Adopted FTE FY 2023 Adopted FTE FY 2024 Adopted FTE Change FY 2023 to FY 2024 City Indebtedness 95 CITY INDEBTEDNESS The Virginia Constitution authorizes cities and counties in Virginia to issue general obligation bonds secured by a pledge of its full faith and credit. For the payment of such bonds, the governing body of the city is required to levy an ad valorem tax on all property subject to local taxation to ensure debt service payment. The issuance of general obli- gation bonds is subject to a limit of 10 percent of the assessed value of taxable real property in the city. The Public Finance Act of Virginia authorizes a city in Virginia to issue limited liability revenue bonds provided that the rates, rents, fees, or other charges are sufficient to pay the cost of operation and administration and the principal and interest on the bonds when due. In determining general obligation statutory debt limitations, certain classes of indebtedness may be excluded, including revenue anticipation notes maturing in one year or less, general obligation bonds payable from a specified revenue producing undertaking, so long as the undertaking is self-supporting, capital leases, and revenue bonds. The city's Wastewater and Storm Water enterprise operations finance capital needs through a combination of self-supporting, general obligation and revenue bonds and the water enterprise utilizes only revenue bonds for its financing needs. The city's Parking, Nauticus, Towing and Recovery and Waste Manage- ment operations finance capital needs with self-supporting general obligation bonds. The following table shows the estimated General Obligation Legal Debt Margin for the current fiscal year as of June 30, 2023, and for the past four fiscal years. (1)The figure includes the assessed valuation of the following properties: public service corporations (as assessed by the State Corporation Commission and the Virginia Department of Taxation); and residential, commercial, apartments and vacant land (as assessed by the City Assessor). (2)Taxable Real Property Assessed Value is estimated as of March 31, 2023. (3)Projected Debt Applicable to Debt Limit excludes $362,613,171 of General Obligation Bonds authorized by ordinance for Cap- ital Improvement Projects, but not yet issued. (4)Includes $50,375,000 that has been economically defeased, but must be included as part of the city’s debt subject to the debt limit. (5)Existing Debt as June 30, 2023. Exclusive of any future amount borrowed on the Line of Credit and future bond issuance. As of Taxable Real Property Assessed Value (1) Debt Limit: 10% of Assessed Value Debt Applicable to Debt Limit(3)(4)(5) Amount of Debt as % of Debt Limit Legal Margin for Additional Debt June 30, 2023 (2) 25,250,814,276 2,525,081,428 1,204,396,707 47.71% 1,320,684,721 June 30, 2022 23,076,117,734 2,307,611,773 1,253,606,783 54.32% 1,054,004,991 June 30, 2021 22,154,797,959 2,215,479,796 1,267,408,068 57.21% 948,071,728 June 30, 2020 21,134,551,094 2,113,455,109 1,099,194,913 52.01% 1,014,260,196 June 30, 2019 20,344,603,804 2,034,460,380 988,038,371 48.57% 1,046,422,009 96 City Indebtedness OVERLAPPING DEBT The City of Norfolk is autonomous and independent of any county or other political subdivision and is not subject to taxation by any county or school district, nor is it liable for any county or school division indebtedness. Currently, there is no overlapping debt. STATEMENT OF NO PAST DEFAULT The city has never defaulted on the payment of either principal or interest on its general obligation debt. OUTSTANDING DEBT Debt service for General Capital Improvements is funded from the General Fund. The debt of the enterprise and other fee-supported operations are paid from the respective revenues. The estimated total outstanding bonded indebtedness, including revenue bonds, at the end of FY 2023 is estimated to be $1,320,684,707 (exclusive of the bonds economic defeased, the amount borrowed on the Line of Credit and any future bond issuance). GENERAL CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS–AFFORDABILITY MEASURES City Council’s has adopted policies on debt affordability measures. The city’s financial policies demonstrate its com- mitment to sound financial practices and recognize that they contribute to maintaining the city’s high credit ratings and lower borrowing costs for capital projects, preserve fiscal integrity, and promote long-term fiscal sustainability. The Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) for General Capital Improvements (bonds not supported by self-supporting user fees) is now guided by five measures of affordability. These measures, or internal debt limits, are as follows: • Debt Service as a percent of the General Fund budget (remain below 10 percent, with a not to exceed of 11 per - cent of the General Fund budget) • Net Debt as a percent of taxable property (remain below 3.5 percent, with a not to exceed of 4 percent of the total assessed value of taxable property) • Ten-year General Obligation Payout Ratio (retirement of the principal amount of the long-term general obliga - tion bonds by at least 55 percent or greater within 10 years) • Overlapping Debt Limit (overlapping debt not to exceed 0.5 percent of total assessed value of taxable property) • Variable Rate Debt Limits (the city’s outstanding debt with variable interest rate will not exceed 20 percent by fund) The FY 2024 Capital Improvement Plan is currently within the five measures of affordability listed above, and the city plans to continue to remain below a debt to taxable property ratio of 3.5 percent or less and a debt service to budget expenditures ratio of 10 percent or less. However, the new policy levels provide the city flexibility to consider projects of significance and importance in moving the city forward in addressing our resiliency challenges of coastal flooding, neighborhoods resiliency, and economic vibrancy. City Indebtedness 97 ENTERPRISE OPERATIONS DEBT Norfolk's Water, Wastewater, and Storm Water Revenue Bond programs are governed by bond indentures of trust and financing agreements, which specify debt coverage requirements for their respective operations. Each of the revenue bond programs are backed by the revenues of their respective system. The city has covenanted that it will establish, fix, charge and collect rates, fees, and other charges so that in each Fiscal Year Net Revenues are not less than the debt service coverage requirement. All revenue bond programs, historically and estimated for FY 2024 meet debt coverage requirements. As previously noted, outstanding Wastewater and Storm Water bonds are a combination of general obligations of the city and revenue bonds, and Water bonds are solely revenue bonds. The city’s Parking operations finance capital needs with self-supporting general obligation bonds. As a matter of practice, the city pays such general obligation bonds from its respective enterprise activities. If money in the respective funds is not sufficient to pay debt service on the general obligations, the city is obligated to pay such debt service from the General Fund or other available revenues. BOND RATINGS Bond or credit ratings are an independent opinion of the general creditworthiness of an issuer, such as the city, based on relevant risk factors. Long-term general obligation ratings are based on an issuer's ability and willingness to repay fully the principal and interest of its debt obligations, on a timely basis. Municipal credit ratings are primarily based on four main factors: the issuer's financial position, the issuer's current and future debt burden, financial man- agement and the economy. Often an investor places significant emphasis on a bond's credit rating to help evaluate a price or willingness to hold the investment. Each of the three major credit rating agencies in the U.S.: Moody's Investors Service ("Moody's”), S&P Global Ratings ("S&P") and Fitch Ratings ("Fitch") applies its own methodology in measuring creditworthiness and uses a specific rating scale to communicate its ratings opinions. Typically, ratings are expressed as letter grades that range, from 'AAA' to 'D' to communicate the agency's opinion of relative level of credit risk. Credits are further distinguished with “notches” within each rating category. Credit ratings for the city’s General Obligation and Water Revenue Bond programs are as follows: Norfolk's ratings on its General Obligations Bonds are considered very strong and continue to assist the city in achiev- ing least cost of funds to finance key capital projects throughout the city. In general, AA category rating signifies very high-quality bonds with some elements of long-term risks and AAA signifies the highest-quality bonds. The city’s Wastewater and Storm Water Revenue Bonds do not maintain an underlying, or stand-alone unenhanced, credit rating. Bonding Program Moody’s S&P Fitch General Obligation Aa2 AAA AA+ Water Revenue Aa2 AA+ AA+ 98 City Indebtedness Computation of Legal Debt Margin (1) Includes all non-general fund supported General Obligation debt such as Wastewater, Parking, Storm Water, Nauticus, Towing and Recovery Operations and Waste Management. (2) The Legal Debt Margin computation does not include any Revenue Bond debt issued by the city, because such debt is not sub- ject to the Commonwealth’s Constitutional Debt Limit. (3) Excludes $362,613,171 of General Obligation Bonds authorized by ordinance for Capital Improvement Projects, but not yet issued. Includes $50,375,000 that has been economically defeased, but must be included as part of the City’s debt subject to the debt limit. (4) Existing Debt Service as of June 30, 2023. Exclusive of any future amount borrowed on the Line of Credit and any future bond issuance. June 30, 2022 (Estimated) Total Assessed Value of Taxed Real Property as of March 31, 2021 $25,250,814,276 Debt Limit: 10 percent of Total Assessed Value 2,525,081,428 Amount of Debt Applicable to Debt Limit:(1)(2)(3)(4) Gross Debt 869,066,707 Economic Defeasance 50,375,000 Series 2021 (Pension Obligation Bonds) 204,955,000 Line of Credit 80,000,000 Legal Debt Margin $1,320,684,721 Amount of Debt as a percent of Debt Limit 47.70% Yearly Maturity of Long-Term Debt 99 YEARLY MATURITY OF LONG-TERM DEBT *Fiscal Year amounts may not add to total due to rounding. Fiscal Year General Obligation(1)(2) General Obligation Equipment(1) Water Revenue(1) Principal Interest Total Principal Interest Total Principal Interest Total 2024 76,002,969 32,027,593 108,030,563 585,000 148,275 733,275 19,195,000 10,934,013 30,129,013 2025 77,878,264 29,577,577 107,455,841 460,000 120,750 580,750 17,880,000 10,014,638 27,894,638 2026 77,703,559 27,317,993 105,021,552 355,000 100,375 455,375 18,965,000 9,101,013 28,066,013 2027 78,518,855 25,138,767 103,657,622 355,000 82,625 437,625 11,915,000 8,325,813 20,240,813 2028 78,924,151 22,814,102 101,738,254 190,000 69,000 259,000 12,600,000 7,706,363 20,306,363 2029 72,693,982 20,424,404 93,118,386 1,285,000 32,125 1,317,125 13,400,000 7,049,388 20,449,388 2030 70,290,290 18,230,279 88,520,569 - - - 8,675,000 6,490,125 15,165,125 2031 66,025,290 16,219,034 82,244,324 - - - 7,605,000 6,075,063 13,680,063 2032 66,170,290 13,838,835 80,009,125 - - - 7,840,000 5,680,400 13,520,400 2033 59,720,290 12,038,979 71,759,268 - - - 8,080,000 5,273,606 13,353,606 2034 41,800,290 10,009,548 51,809,837 - - - 8,515,000 4,849,413 13,364,413 2035 41,320,290 8,811,960 50,132,250 - - - 9,000,000 4,401,656 13,401,656 2036 48,940,290 7,500,421 56,440,771 - - - 7,315,000 3,983,288 11,298,288 2037 49,672,899 6,155,480 55,828,380 - - - 6,300,000 3,633,575 9,933,575 2038 46,745,000 4,521,383 51,266,383 - - - 6,655,000 3,301,581 9,956,581 2039 38,140,000 3,298,387 41,438,387 - - - 7,035,000 2,950,713 9,985,713 2040 14,515,000 2,545,400 17,060,400 - - - 5,150,000 2,639,794 7,789,794 2041 14,615,000 2,014,442 16,629,442 - - - 5,415,000 2,371,856 7,786,856 2042 5,670,000 1,520,325 7,190,325 - - - 8,480,000 2,016,988 10,496,988 2043 7,025,000 1,323,706 8,348,706 - - - 8,920,000 1,570,613 10,490,613 2044 7,215,000 1,103,108 8,318,108 - - - 10,050,000 1,079,869 11,129,869 2045 7,410,000 877,020 8,287,020 - - - 10,590,000 541,981 11,131,981 2046 7,600,000 643,921 8,243,921 - - - 1,685,000 223,875 1,908,875 2047 7,935,000 395,553 8,330,553 - - - 1,770,000 137,500 1,907,500 2048 5,400,000 178,431 5,578,431 - - - 1,865,000 46,625 1,911,625 2049 2,860,000 45,560 2,905,560 - - - - - - Total 1,070,791,707 268,572,210 1,339,363,917 3,230,000 553,150 3,783,150 224,900,000 110,399,744 335,299,744 100 Yearly Maturity of Long-Term Debt YEARLY MATURITY OF LONG-TERM DEBT (CONTINUED) *Fiscal Year amounts may not add to total due to rounding. (1) Existing Debt Service as of June 30, 2023. Exclusive of bonds economic defeased, the amount borrowed on the Line of Credit, and any future bond issuance. (2) General Obligation bonds have been used to finance Wastewater, Parking, Storm Water, Nauticus, and Towing and Recovery, and Waste Management projects. The bonded debt associated with those projects is self-supported by the respective funds. The Debt Service portion of the General Fund budget finances only General Capital projects, and equipment, but not its self- supporting funds. Fiscal Year Wastewater Revenue(1) Storm Water Revenue(1) Totals(1) Principal Interest Total Principal Interest Total Principal Interest Total 2024 8,327,090 59,840 8,386,930 34,578 676 35,254 104,144,637 43,170,397 147,315,034 2025 8,254,955 55,504 8,310,459 34,664 590 35,254 104,507,883 39,769,058 144,276,941 2026 8,454,222 86,592 8,540,814 34,751 503 35,254 105,512,532 36,606,475 142,119,008 2027 7,752,445 70,946 7,823,391 34,838 416 35,254 98,576,137 33,618,567 132,194,704 2028 7,070,271 62,286 7,132,557 34,925 329 35,254 98,819,347 30,652,080 129,471,427 2029 6,361,301 58,756 6,420,057 35,012 241 35,254 93,775,295 27,564,914 121,340,209 2030 5,939,849 55,208 5,995,057 35,100 154 35,254 84,940,238 24,775,766 109,716,004 2031 5,518,415 51,643 5,570,057 35,188 66 35,254 79,183,892 22,345,805 101,529,697 2032 5,146,998 48,059 5,195,057 - - - 79,157,288 19,567,294 98,724,582 2033 4,650,600 44,458 4,695,057 - - - 72,450,889 17,357,043 89,807,932 2034 4,421,719 40,838 4,462,557 - - - 54,737,009 14,899,798 69,636,807 2035 3,902,873 37,200 3,940,074 - - - 54,223,163 13,250,817 67,473,980 2036 3,366,546 33,545 3,400,090 - - - 59,621,835 11,517,253 71,139,088 2037 2,787,323 29,870 2,817,193 - - - 58,760,222 9,818,926 68,579,148 2038 2,386,960 26,178 2,413,138 - - - 55,786,960 7,849,142 63,636,102 2039 2,177,716 22,467 2,200,182 - - - 47,352,716 6,271,566 53,624,282 2040 2,069,401 18,737 2,088,138 - - - 21,734,401 5,203,931 26,938,332 2041 1,897,808 14,989 1,912,797 - - - 21,927,808 4,401,288 26,329,096 2042 1,476,235 11,222 1,487,457 - - - 15,626,235 3,548,535 19,174,770 2043 760,021 7,436 767,457 - - - 16,705,021 2,901,754 19,606,775 2044 763,826 3,631 767,457 - - - 18,028,826 2,186,608 20,215,434 2045 153,109 383 153,491 - - - 18,153,109 1,419,384 19,572,493 2046 - - - - - - 9,285,000 867,796 10,152,796 2047 - - - - - - 9,705,000 533,053 10,238,053 2048 - - - - - - 7,265,000 225,056 7,490,056 2049 - - - - - - 2,860,000 45,560 2,905,560 Total 93,639,682 839.788 94,479,469 279,054 2,974 282,028 1,392,840,443 380,367,866 1,773,208,309 General Fund Revenues This page intentionally left blank General Fund Revenue Summary 103 GENERAL FUND REVENUE SUMMARY Revenue Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2023 Y ear-End Projection FY 2024 Adopted GENERAL PROPERTY TAXES Real Property Taxes Current 255,667,825 275,137,300 277,907,300 299,138,000 Delinquent 5,741,253 5,450,000 5,000,000 6,267,000 Interest 547,525 440,000 440,000 506,000 Real Estate Tax Refunds 0 -10,000 -10,000 -10,000 Subtotal - Real Property Taxes 261,956,603 281,017,300 283,337,300 305,901,000 Downtown Improvement District Current, Delinquent, and Interest 2,237,985 2,230,000 2,030,000 2,156,700 Public Service Corporations Current, Delinquent, and Interest 11,413,957 11,308,000 11,353,000 11,408,000 Total All Real Property Taxes 275,608,545 294,555,300 296,720,300 319,465,700 Personal Property Current 51,634,679 39,959,000 45,959,000 45,077,000 Delinquent 11,504,705 13,730,000 13,730,000 12,800,000 Interest 627,116 770,000 770,000 717,000 Personal Property Tax Refund 0 -200,000 -200,000 -200,000 Subtotal - Personal Property 63,766,500 54,259,000 60,259,000 58,394,000 Public Service Corporations Current, Delinquent, and Interest 41,723 41,000 41,000 41,000 Total All Personal Property Taxes 63,808,223 54,300,000 60,300,000 58,435,000 Mobile Home Current, Delinquent, and Interest 12,276 14,500 14,500 14,500 Machinery and Tools Current 6,258,732 6,145,000 6,250,000 6,300,000 Delinquent 181,427 100,000 100,000 150,000 Interest 10,219 4,000 4,000 4,000 Subtotal - Machinery and Tools 6,450,378 6,249,000 6,354,000 6,454,000 Total General Property Taxes 345,879,422 355,118,800 363,388,800 384,369,200 OTHER LOCAL TAXES Sales and Use 42,726,193 43,106,200 43,877,000 44,790,000 Utility Taxes Water 5,997,194 5,778,000 6,050,000 6,114,000 Electric 12,122,049 12,440,000 12,150,000 12,187,000 Gas 2,872,021 2,746,000 2,800,000 2,909,000 104 General Fund Revenue Summary Communications Sales Tax 12,075,639 11,500,000 11,500,000 11,050,000 Business Taxes Other Local Tax Refunds -5,431,320 -42,000 -42,000 -42,000 Business License 32,645,360 30,332,000 31,400,000 32,057,000 Franchise 296,257 190,000 190,000 190,000 Bank Franchise 2,564,683 2,300,000 2,500,000 2,500,000 Licenses and Decals Motor Vehicle1 2,121,193 3,617,000 3,617,000 3,658,500 Boats 115,461 122,000 122,000 122,000 Other Taxes Recordation 4,689,999 3,000,000 2,800,000 3,000,000 Cigarette 6,388,731 6,777,000 5,900,000 5,897,000 Admissions 3,985,616 3,500,000 4,200,000 4,200,000 Hotel/Motel Room 9,757,045 8,810,270 9,600,000 9,625,000 Hotel (flat tax per room night) 3,392,853 3,316,920 3,375,000 3,402,000 Food and Beverage 36,864,143 34,317,635 38,647,000 39,270,000 Estate Probate 44,887 45,000 45,000 45,000 Short-term Rental 109,189 110,000 100,000 110,000 Total Other Local Taxes 173,337,193 171,966,025 178,831,000 181,084,500 PERMITS, FEES AND LICENSES Animal License 35,326 50,000 35,000 20,000 Burglar Alarm License 1,760 2,000 2,000 2,000 Building Permit2 919,069 984,000 1,035,000 1,027,000 Electrical Permit2 295,514 280,000 387,000 290,000 Plumbing Permit2 217,845 250,000 320,000 255,000 Plan Review Fee2 85,275 85,000 125,000 85,000 Mechanical Code Inspection Fee2 151,256 220,000 250,000 232,000 Elevator Inspection Fee 32,476 40,000 40,000 40,000 Permit Application Fee2 135,100 160,000 215,000 175,000 Wetland Permit 6,720 6,000 6,000 8,000 Zoning Fees 211,476 325,000 270,000 325,000 Driveway Permit 30,200 31,200 31,200 31,900 Utility Cut Permit 536,084 505,800 505,800 516,400 Special ROW/ Parking Permit 429,769 278,900 470,000 384,700 Street Construction Permit 1,500 3,000 600 4,000 Fire Permit 287,029 250,000 217,000 210,000 Fire Inspection 242,530 200,000 145,000 170,000 Revenue Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2023 Y ear-End Projection FY 2024 Adopted General Fund Revenue Summary 105 Precious Metal Dealer Permit 6,800 8,000 6,000 8,000 Excessive Size and Weight Permit 237,840 254,000 240,000 259,000 Taxi Operator Permit 4,910 10,000 4,900 10,000 Foot Race/Bicycle Race Permit 400 500 400 500 Registration Vacant Buildings Fee 7,000 15,000 7,000 7,000 Transfer Fees 7,565 6,000 6,000 6,000 Permits - Other 50 1,500 200 1,500 Total Permits and Fees 3,883,494 3,965,900 4,319,100 4,068,000 FINES AND FORFEITURES Fines and Forfeitures 451,323 625,000 500,000 625,000 Fines - Red Light Cameras 802,405 620,000 800,000 800,000 Fees - Returned Checks 8,277 9,000 8,000 9,000 Excess Weight Penalties 0 1,000 500 1,000 Fines - False Alarm 85,017 60,000 68,000 60,000 Fines - Short-term Rental 6,200 25,000 10,000 10,000 Total Fines and Forfeitures 1,353,222 1,340,000 1,386,500 1,505,000 USE OF MONEY AND PROPERTY Interest on Investments -281,920 625,000 625,000 6,000,000 Other Interest 40,566 75,000 75,000 60,000 Rent - General Properties 4,248,337 4,804,135 4,487,000 4,353,449 Rent - Cultural Convention Center 624,083 450,000 450,000 450,000 Rent - Chrysler Hall 407,165 375,000 375,000 400,000 Rent - Virginia Stage Company (Wells Theatre) 0 18,000 18,000 18,000 Rent - Harrison Opera House 79,914 75,000 75,000 100,000 Rent - Harbor Park-Other 191,259 185,000 185,000 10,000 Rent - Special Programs 30,913 15,000 30,000 30,000 Sale of Salvage Materials 13,572 2,000 15,000 2,000 Sale of Fixed Assets 393,589 115,000 175,000 115,000 Rent - Equipment 18,804 73,685 10,000 73,685 Ticket System- Cultural Center 865,726 650,000 800,000 800,000 Rent - Picnic Shelters 24,455 18,300 20,000 18,300 Commissions - Jail Telephone 1,201,101 1,200,000 800,000 800,000 Commissions - Other 44,504 53,500 53,500 60,000 Advertising 800 20,000 22,000 30,000 Rent - Selden 65,870 109,000 75,000 109,000 Commissions - Slover 23,830 0 24,000 24,000 Rent - Slover 2,455 150,000 27,000 150,000 Revenue Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2023 Y ear-End Projection FY 2024 Adopted 106 General Fund Revenue Summary Total Use of Money and Property 7,995,023 9,013,620 8,341,500 13,603,434 CHARGES FOR SERVICES Court Costs 41,097 70,000 38,000 70,000 Courthouse Security Assessment 119,135 200,000 90,000 200,000 Courthouse Construction Fee 107,951 160,000 120,000 160,000 DNA Charges 2,085 2,500 2,000 2,500 Fees - High Constable 157,463 265,000 260,000 265,000 Jail Processing Fees 14,082 30,000 20,000 30,000 Fees - Court Officers 17,423 30,000 18,000 30,000 Fees - Excess 206,718 14,000 14,000 14,000 Fees - City Sheriff 36,616 38,100 38,100 38,100 Detention Home Charge For Ward 309,138 350,000 350,000 350,000 Fees - Jail Booking 2,532 3,000 1,000 3,000 Miscellaneous School Fees 3,199,163 4,040,000 4,040,000 3,800,000 Paramedical Rescue Service 7,083,385 7,100,000 7,100,000 7,100,000 Charges - Insurance 100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000 Charges - Animal Protection 19,002 30,000 15,000 30,000 Police Records And Reports 127,662 170,000 140,000 170,000 Public Vehicle Inspection Certification 7,324 15,000 15,000 15,000 Non-Emergency Traffic Escort 20,007 20,000 20,000 20,000 Fees - Library Fines 152,820 40,000 80,000 48,000 Charges - Public Works 344,621 505,000 350,000 505,000 Charges - Materials - Street and Bridges 195,110 491,000 300,000 491,000 Charges-Reprographic Printing 15,279 10,000 25,000 25,000 Zoo Admission 2,507,481 2,077,000 2,200,000 2,077,000 Charges - Transient Yacht 146,493 140,000 110,000 140,000 Sales Surveys/Blueprints/Maps 37,950 40,000 45,000 40,000 Fees - Tax Abatement 500 4,000 3,000 4,000 Recreation/Parks Fees 80,728 100,000 100,000 125,000 Recreation/Parks Classes Fees 90,934 55,000 180,000 200,000 Recreation/Parks Rental Fees 72,879 60,000 90,000 90,000 Recreation/Parks Camp Wakeup 100,295 80,000 80,000 100,000 Cruise Ship Terminal Fees 689,471 1,557,000 1,900,000 2,150,000 Fees - Nauticus Admissions 1,924,378 1,950,000 2,150,000 1,975,000 Program Fees - NCSB 5,651,173 5,745,131 5,700,000 5,805,140 Total Charges for Services 23,580,895 25,491,731 25,694,100 26,172,740 MISCELLANEOUS REVENUE Revenue Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2023 Y ear-End Projection FY 2024 Adopted General Fund Revenue Summary 107 Payments In Lieu Of Taxes 4,870,465 3,810,795 3,810,795 3,878,730 Navy PPV Payment 3,444,749 4,127,700 4,127,700 3,634,630 DMV Select Fees 57,573 100,000 44,000 100,000 Administrative Fees - Real Estate Tax 27,405 25,000 25,000 25,000 Administrative Fees - Personal Property Tax 533 3,000 1,000 3,000 Administrative Fees - DMV Stop 601,706 580,000 600,000 600,000 Other Miscellaneous Revenue 489,346 266,250 416,250 377,250 Community Development Fund 1,365 1,000 1,400 1,000 Proceeds from Sale of Land 1,396,813 314,221 450,000 50,000 Total Miscellaneous Revenue 10,889,955 9,227,966 9,476,145 8,669,610 RECOVERED COSTS Utilities 42,431 40,000 40,000 40,000 Transport of Prisoner 62,098 135,000 135,000 135,000 Nuisance Abatement 430,937 342,000 342,000 342,000 Retirement Bureau 650,369 855,045 735,045 946,428 Insurance -2,800 2,000 7,900 2,000 Benefits Program Administration 0 5,000 5,000 5,000 Miscellaneous Salaries (Police) 294,700 400,000 350,000 400,000 Healthcare Consortium Contribution 100,241 190,000 100,000 140,000 General Overhead - Water Utility Fund 2,246,105 2,274,152 2,274,152 2,257,460 Debt Service Recovery 2,007,984 1,893,454 1,577,000 1,775,217 Telephone Charges 332,275 372,200 330,000 372,200 Public Information 23,856 18,750 20,000 21,500 Recoveries and Rebates 480,659 149,150 451,000 300,000 General Overhead - Wastewater Utility Fund 600,357 1,144,279 1,144,279 716,843 Information System Support 1,350,592 1,350,000 1,350,000 1,350,000 Jail Meals 232,632 250,000 100,000 250,000 General Overhead - Parking Fund 588,339 608,396 608,396 548,553 General Overhead - Towing Operations 68,135 100,526 100,526 95,294 General Overhead - Storm Water 636,493 540,530 540,530 497,926 General Overhead - Waste Management 1,002,864 1,338,648 1,338,648 752,762 General Overhead - Golf 9,000 9,000 9,000 9,000 Contract Revenue - NCSB 22,436 40,000 40,000 40,000 Total Recovered Costs 11,179,703 12,058,130 11,598,476 10,997,183 REVENUES FROM THE COMMONWEAL TH NON-CATEGORICAL AID Taxes - Rolling Stock 180,693 180,000 180,000 180,000 Revenue Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2023 Y ear-End Projection FY 2024 Adopted 108 General Fund Revenue Summary Taxes - Mobile Home Title 0 3,000 3,000 3,000 Taxes - Gaming 0 1,500,000 0 0 Rental of Passenger Cars 8,970,669 6,900,000 7,400,000 7,270,000 Law Enforcement (HB 599) 12,429,284 12,428,100 13,664,200 14,238,065 Grantor’s Tax on Deeds 1,268,146 800,000 800,000 800,000 Personal Property Tax Relief 16,871,056 16,871,100 16,871,100 16,871,100 Total Non-Categorical Aid 39,719,848 38,682,200 38,918,300 39,362,165 SHARED EXPENSES City Treasurer 578,470 610,300 606,000 643,300 Clerk of the Circuit Court 1,544,191 1,731,600 1,629,000 1,802,500 Commissioner of the Revenue 675,258 695,300 712,000 728,300 Commonwealth Attorney 3,100,021 3,184,300 3,172,000 3,341,300 Registrar/Electoral Board 120,788 146,000 146,000 146,000 Sheriff 16,760,714 17,176,700 17,867,700 18,457,700 Total Shared Expenses 22,779,442 23,544,200 24,132,700 25,119,100 CATEGORICAL AID Norfolk Interagency Consortium (NIC) 43,149 60,000 53,623 60,000 Public Assistance Grants 8,440,623 9,600,000 9,610,000 9,700,000 Social Services Administration 22,010,671 26,883,188 26,160,000 27,837,688 State Funds - NCSB 9,885,340 9,179,725 9,800,000 9,466,446 State Sales and Use Tax for Schools 42,835,232 40,242,034 40,242,034 39,319,527 State School Funds 167,984,870 188,213,881 188,213,881 200,280,219 Street and Maintenance 26,138,072 27,235,900 30,265,650 28,659,700 State Library Grant 212,528 200,900 241,259 240,114 Div. of Youth Services Facilities 2,303,346 2,217,000 2,270,000 2,270,000 Shared Expenses - Jail Support 1,656,237 1,940,000 1,380,000 1,600,000 Port Funding 513,652 513,700 526,783 526,783 Total Categorical Aid 282,023,720 306,286,328 308,763,230 319,960,477 REVENUE FROM THE COMMONWEAL TH 344,523,010 368,512,728 371,814,230 384,441,742 FEDERAL AID Federal School Funds 6,147,254 5,305,000 5,305,000 5,500,000 Federal Funds - NCSB 3,046,285 2,997,256 2,997,256 2,997,256 Juvenile Detention Center (food service) 81,664 70,000 70,000 70,000 Social Security Payments - Prisoners 40,800 48,000 48,000 48,000 Disaster Relief Aid 447,197 0 0 0 Total Federal Aid 9,763,200 8,420,256 8,420,256 8,615,256 OTHER SOURCES AND TRANSFERS IN Revenue Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2023 Y ear-End Projection FY 2024 Adopted General Fund Revenue Summary 109 Rollover from Last Year Carryforward - General Fund 24,117,000 19,483,577 19,483,577 33,182,363 Carryforward - NCSB Fund Balance3 2,000,000 2,000,000 2,000,000 2,000,000 Return from Wastewater Utility Fund 1,500,000 1,500,000 1,500,000 1,500,000 Return from Water Utility Fund 8,500,000 8,500,000 8,500,000 8,500,000 Transfer In from Tax Increment Financing Fund 5,268,400 5,700,700 5,700,700 7,036,000 Public Amenities Fund 3,500,000 3,500,000 3,500,000 3,500,000 Norfolk Public Schools Reversion Funds 0 2,556,191 2,556,191 0 Total Other Sources and Transfers In 44,885,400 43,240,468 43,240,468 55,718,363 General Fund Total 977,270,518 1,008,355,624 1,026,510,575 1,079,245,028 1The FY 2022 Actual and FY 2023 Adopted amount for the Motor Vehicle License reflects City Council ordinance 48,716 adopted on March 22, 2022 to temporarily suspend certain motor vehicle license fees for tax year 2022 only, which begins January 1, 2022 and ends December 31, 2022. The FY 2024 Adopted amount was adjusted down from the FY 2024 Proposed amount to reflect City Council ordinance 49,163 adopted on April 25, 2023 to temporarily suspend certain motor vehicle license fee for tax year 2023 only, which begins January 1, 2023 and ends December 31, 2023. 2The FY 2023 Year-End Projection includes the correction of the posting of revenues from prior years. 3Carryforward reflects re-appropriation from Norfolk Community Services Board (NCSB) fund balance. Note: FY 2022 amounts reflect figures in the city’s FY 2022 Annual Comprehensive Financial Report. Amounts may not sum to total due to rounding. Revenue Source FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2023 Y ear-End Projection FY 2024 Adopted This page intentionally left blank Adopted Fee Changes This page intentionally left blank Adopted Fee Changes 113 ADOPTED FEE CHANGES The Adopted FY 2024 Budget includes fee changes for a number of the city’s special revenue and enterprise funds. The fee increases for Cemeteries and Waste Management will help the city to be able to continue to offer the current levels of services as operating costs continue to increase. The fee increase for Storm Water will allow the city to invest more in resilience efforts that will reduce neighborhood flooding. Department and Description FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted CEMETERIES Additional right of interment $400 $700 Foundation installations (per square inch) $1.00 $1.25 Ash opening/closing: Monday-Friday $600 $800 Saturday $700 $900 Sunday and Holidays $800 $1,000 Grave opening/closing: Adult, Monday-Friday $1,000 $1,300 Adult, Saturday $1,200 $1,500 Adult, Sunday and Holidays $1,300 $1,700 Child, Monday-Friday $300 $500 Child, Saturday $400 $600 Child, Sunday and Holidays $500 $700 Private mausoleum opening/closing: Monday-Friday $500 $1,000 Saturday $600 $1,200 Sunday and Holidays $675 $1,300 Public mausoleum opening/closing: Monday-Friday $750 $1,000 Saturday $850 $1,200 Sunday and Holidays $950 $1,300 Public mausoleum ash opening/closing: Monday-Friday $600 $800 Saturday $700 $900 Sunday and Holidays $800 $1,000 Transfer of property rights $100 $200 Grave opening/closing (disinterments): Adult $1,300 $2,000 Child $500 $1,000 114 Adopted Fee Changes CEMETERIES (continued) Ash $800 $900 Regular crypt - public mausoleum $950 $2,000 Ash crypt - public mausoleum $800 $1,000 Grave plots: Single plot (price varies by location) $1,200-$2,200 $1,500-$2,400 Two plots (price varies by location) $2,000-$3,600 $2,400-$5,200 Ash niche (price varies by location) $1,800-$2,500 $1,200-$2,600 Crypt space (price varies by location) $2,850-$8,500 $3,400-$8,600 Child $300 $500 Reservation Fee $50 $200 Endowed Care Fee $100 $200 STORM WATER (rate calculated based on a 30 day month) Residential $13.05/month $13.57/month Commercial $13.05/month per 2,000 sq ft $13.57/month per 2,000 sq ft WASTE MANAGEMENT Refuse Disposal Residential Single or multiple units (less than five) $27.01/unit/month $28.51/unit/month Multiple units (five units or more) $45.94/container/month $47.44/container/month Department and Description FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted General Fund Expenditures This page intentionally left blank General Fund Expenditure Summary 117 GENERAL FUND EXPENDITURE SUMMARY Department FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted LEGISLATIVE City Auditor 1,078,273 1,042,808 1,214,892 City Clerk 1,559,413 1,778,547 1,932,740 City Council 364,389 386,839 395,607 City Real Estate Assessor 2,240,915 2,557,402 2,835,235 Total Legislative 5,242,990 5,765,596 6,378,474 EXECUTIVE Budget and Strategic Planning 2,337,309 2,587,555 3,562,058 City Manager 2,888,635 3,233,643 4,293,548 Communications & Marketing 2,557,629 2,106,434 2,572,850 Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion 0 644,931 1,393,649 Housing and Community Development1 2,745,420 5,374,169 6,341,473 Resilience 610,649 695,818 1,158,302 Total Executive 11,139,642 14,642,550 19,321,880 DEPARTMENT OF LAW 5,062,426 5,509,385 5,963,932 CONSTITUTIONAL OFFICERS City Treasurer 2,615,866 2,957,092 3,098,885 Clerk of the Circuit Court 2,879,473 3,324,301 3,470,939 Commissioner of the Revenue 2,899,754 3,355,447 3,483,443 Commonwealth's Attorney 6,229,373 6,828,146 7,085,084 Sheriff and Jail 36,500,059 41,891,450 45,655,414 Total Constitutional Officers 51,124,525 58,356,436 62,793,765 JUDICIAL Circuit Court Judges 983,925 924,547 958,303 General District Court 81,939 260,761 260,761 Juvenile and Domestic Relations Court 73,336 81,833 81,833 Magistrate 9,171 11,656 12,248 Norfolk Juvenile Court Service Unit 160,629 168,029 209,594 Total Judicial 1,309,000 1,446,826 1,522,739 ELECTIONS 1,108,609 1,031,721 1,179,525 GENERAL MANAGEMENT Finance 6,796,115 7,495,935 8,283,788 General Services 25,787,840 28,474,152 31,269,174 Human Resources 3,604,990 4,255,590 5,043,080 Information Technology 17,257,874 20,010,250 21,243,061 Total General Management 53,446,819 60,235,927 65,839,103 118 General Fund Expenditure Summary 1FY 2022 reflects the transitioning of eligible expenses to the Coronavirus State and Local Fiscal Recovery Funds (SLFRF) grant. Note: FY 2022 amounts may not sum to total due to rounding. Numbers may not add to total/subtotal due to rounding. COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT City Planning 5,187,204 6,479,106 6,416,205 Economic Development 2,726,262 2,945,437 3,375,939 Neighborhood Development 4,621,184 5,145,703 6,935,607 Total Community Development 12,534,650 14,570,246 16,727,751 PARKS, RECREATION AND CUL TURE Cultural Facilities, Arts and Entertainment 5,336,301 6,553,328 6,865,561 Libraries 7,994,010 9,765,433 10,981,220 Nauticus 3,563,710 4,253,414 4,776,144 Parks and Recreation 14,682,217 18,010,193 21,962,524 Slover Library 2,278,236 2,657,176 2,971,111 Virginia Zoological Park 4,398,271 4,566,764 5,042,106 Total Parks, Recreation and Culture 38,252,745 45,806,308 52,598,666 PUBLIC HEAL TH AND ASSTANCE Human Services 47,327,669 51,986,403 55,770,320 Norfolk Community Services Board 22,465,581 29,346,599 31,348,922 Public Health 3,078,419 3,243,521 3,400,665 Total Public Health and Assistance 72,871,669 84,576,523 90,519,907 PUBLIC SAFETY Fire-Rescue1 27,408,051 53,197,406 58,844,372 Police1 39,194,892 80,254,980 83,392,494 Total Public Safety 66,602,943 133,452,386 142,236,866 PUBLIC WORKS 16,978,181 22,366,099 22,188,536 TRANSPORTATION 11,338,517 11,564,407 12,119,902 CENTRAL AND OUTSIDE AGENCY APPROPRIATIONS Central Appropriations 15,408,020 23,215,132 23,132,668 Grant Providers on Behalf of City 815,201 220,524 300,000 Funds to Community Partners 1,980,861 2,676,602 2,912,595 Public-Private Partnerships for City-Owned Facilities 4,744,766 4,521,949 4,661,007 Public-Private Partnerships for Tourism and Special Event Organizations 8,716,229 8,770,635 9,829,134 Public Partnerships to Provide Services 21,226,248 22,962,639 23,587,396 Contractual Obligations 11,888,103 10,749,473 6,981,076 Memberships and Dues 797,672 806,909 830,633 Other Arrangements 2,180,900 2,230,000 2,156,700 Total Central and Outside Agency Appropriations 67,758,000 76,153,863 73,913,566 DEBT SERVICE 75,705,398 87,696,721 101,365,244 PUBLIC SCHOOL EDUCATION (Norfolk Public Schools) 343,066,532 385,180,630 404,575,172 Total General Fund 833,542,646 1,008,355,624 1,079,245,028 Department FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Adopted FY 2024 Adopted Strategic Goals and Objectives This page intentionally left blank Strategic Goals and Objectives 121 STRATEGIC GOALS AND OBJECTIVES IDENTIFYING THE CITY’S PRIORITIES THROUGH THE BUDGET In FY 2022, seven broad service objectives were defined to better understand how city funds are allocated across different functional areas. The objectives broadly capture common services in local government and Norfolk in particular . In an effort to demonstrate the alignment of resources allocated in the budget to these strategic objectives, each program in the Department Program Pages section of the document is mapped to one of the seven service objectives. Mapping programs to service objectives provides context to understand the city’s priorities as they are expressed in the budget through the allocation of funds. In the fall of FY 2023, the city undertook a resident survey in partnership with ETC Institute. The survey results regarding resident priorities and satisfaction with city services served as the basis for strategic funding decisions for the FY 2024 budget. This is the first resident survey conducted by the city since 2014. Moving forward the resident survey will be conducted every two years. The following section defines each of the seven service objectives, includes performance measures that directly address these objectives, select enhancements, initiatives and capital improvement projects that will continue to move the needle of success for each service objective. The performance measures include resident survey questions, as well as departmental performance measures. Resident Survey measures demonstrate the service objective’s ability to meet the demand of residents and other stakeholders. Departmental measures provide detail on the tasks departments perform toward improving the resident survey measures. Each department measure has an associated metric. The metrics are rooted in realistic expectations and serve as the target or goal for that measure. Departmental measures are assessed and updated annually, while Resident Survey measures are updated every two years to coincide with the Resident Survey schedule. Additional performance measures related to the city’s Strategic Objectives and Goals, as well as data stories related to these metrics can be viewed on the city’s open data portal. Resilient Norfolk Intentional planning and community investment that creates a desirable, inclusive community with a lasting built and natural environment. Resident Survey Questions FY 2023 Citizen Satisfaction Rate Percent of residents that are satisfied or very satisfied with the overall quality of emergency management during a natural or man-made disaster 43.4% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with storm-water management and flood control on major city streets 24.0% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with storm-water management and flood control on neighborhood streets 21.8% 122 Strategic Goals and Objectives FY 2024 Budget Action Highlights Increase Floodplain Mailings $16,800 is included in the FY 2024 Adopted Budget to increase flood mailings in support of FEMA Community Rating System (CRS) efforts. The City adopted an initiative for public information which outlines an enhanced outreach strategy in order to increase the number of flood insurance policies issued. These funds will be used to mail additional notifications to residents residing in VE zones, repetitive loss areas, and flood hazard areas. Enhance Street Sweeping The FY 2024 adopted budget includes $231,628 for a new Equipment Operator III position and one-time funds to purchase a new leaf vacuum truck. The vacuum truck removes the majority of the bulk of leaves on curb line to reduce the number of passes sweeper vehicles would need to make to clean curb lines. This enhancement will reduce the wear and tear of city equipment and reduce overtime hours in the division. Support Flood Wall Project The adopted CIP includes funding to support Phase 1 of the Coastal Storm Risk Management project which includes a large-scale extension of the Downtown Norfolk floodwall and the design and construction of storm surge barriers, levees, and pump stations. The FY 2024 Adopted CIP includes approximately $56,600,000 for this project. This investment will ensure the ongoing safety and prosperity of residents and businesses. The project will be completed in five phases over the next decade and ensure Norfolk is a resilient and sustainable coastal city. The FY 2024 adopted operating budget includes $271,508 for the addition of five new positions (one Design Construction Project Manager, two Senior Project Managers, one Accountant IV, and one Real Estate Coordinator) to manage the city's joint Coastal Storm Risk Management project with the Army Corps of Engineers to build the flood wall downtown as well as various other flood protection measures throughout the city. The positions will assist with managing grant requirements, and specific project management tasks associated with the project. Behind the Flood Wall The adopted budget and CIP will address “behind the wall” flooding by reallocating the dedicated Citywide Flooding Reserve from the Storm Water monthly fee to the support the Blue/Greenway and neighborhood drainage projects in various neighborhoods including: •Sylvan and Walnut Hill Street •East Ocean View Departmental Measures FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Projection FY 2024 Adopted Metric Number of participants in Emergency Preparedness and Response community outreach events, including for civic leagues and school groups 40,000 45,000 45,000 45,000 Number of environmental inspections performed 4,613 4,800 4,800 4,500 Total number of miles of curb line swept 36,300 36,000 36,000 36,000 FEMA community rating system score for floodplain management (rating is 1-10, with 1 being best) 7 5 5 5 Number of flood insurance policies 10,785 9,700 11,000 9,700 Strategic Goals and Objectives 123 •Overbrook/Coleman Place •Glenwood Park •Glenrock •Chesapeake Boulevard •Bruce’s Park •Lowery Road. $40 million is programmed in the CIP from FY 2024 through FY 2028 to address neighborhood flooding. Infrastructure And Connectivity To design, construct, and maintain city facilities and infrastructure to provide workable, livable, and sustainable space with a multi-modal transportation network that provides for the safe, efficient, inclusive, and reliable movement of people, goods, services, and information. FY 2024 Budget Action Highlights Citywide Nuisance Abatement Efforts $107,000 is included in the adopted budget to increase nuisance abatement in Right of Way areas. The funding will be used to addressed illegal dumping, construction debris, roadway defects, overgrown vegetation and other nuisances that are deemed a risk to public health and safety through contractual services. Contracting the work to an outside vendor will increase response times to abatement responses, improve the health, safety and aesthetics of an area. Resident Survey Questions FY 2023 Citizen Satisfaction Rate Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with condition of major streets 31.1% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with maintenance of public buildings and facilities 42.0% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with traffic flow on major city streets 35.1% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the accessibility of Norfolk trails and pathways 33.4% Departmental Measures FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Projection FY 2024 Adopted Metric Number of education campaigns for proper riding and parking of motorist, cyclist and pedestrian safety. 3 6 6 6 Number of Neighborhoods reviewed for traffic calming 5 5 6 5 Number of Right of way concerns addressed 1,372 1,100 1,133 1,100 Number of roadway lane miles resurfaced per year 88 55 64 65 Feet of sidewalk repaired per year 2,500 24,171 25,000 25,000 124 Strategic Goals and Objectives Multi-modal Maintenance The FY 2024 adopted budget includes $212,688 to enhance multi-modal maintenance efforts. This includes the addition of two Traffic Maintenance Technicians that will assist with citywide maintenance and management related to e-scooters, e-bikes, bicycles, and pedestrian ways. Maintenance will consist of regularly scheduled reviews and repairs to bike lanes and scooter corrals. Additional repairs will be made to enhance pavement marking, signage, lane delineators and to replace bike racks throughout the city. In addition, the adopted budget includes $85,000 for a Traffic Operations vehicle that will be used to transport materials necessary for multi-modal maintenance, such as items used to repair bike lanes, install bike racks, and improve signage and roadway markings. Improve Neighborhood Streets project The adopted CIP includes continued funding to improve streets in neighborhoods identified through the city’s Complete streets initiative. $550,000 is included in FY 2024, to continue improving pedestrian safety through the installation of new curbs, sidewalks, and resurfacing. The project also includes street drainage improvements in various neighborhood locations. Improve Street Lights The city is working with Dominion Power to facilitate a complete conversion of streetlights to LED. Dominion estimates it can convert 1,000 streetlights every month. At roughly 34,000 streetlights, the project is expected to take around three years to complete. The conversion to energy efficient LED lights will also create substantial electricity savings and result in better lighting. $5,000,000 was appropriated to this project in FY 2023. An additional $100,000 of funding has been added for FY 2024 and will be used to expand the existing street light infrastructure. Chrysler Hall The FY 2024 Adopted CIP includes $1,000,000 to complete the design work for the renovation of Chrysler Hall. Granby Street Corridor An additional $2,000,000 is included in the five year CIP to construct pedestrian and vehicular safety improvements along the Granby Street corridor. The project will be done to support the federally funded Granby Bike Lanes project. Dredging of Lafayette River The CIP includes an additional $2,510,000 to dredge various sections of the Lafayette River. In FY 2024, Tanner’s Creek NW, Crab Creek, River Point Neighborhood, Crab Creek Cove Neighborhood and Talbot Hall Court Cove will be dredged. These sections will be dredged during the same fiscal year to reduce mobilization costs. Economic Opportunity For Residents And Businesses A strong tax base, a diverse economy, and a straightforward regulatory environment that enable businesses to flourish and create good jobs for residents who have access to training and workforce development designed to equip them with the skills needed to compete in a 21st century economy. Strategic Goals and Objectives 125 FY 2024 Budget Action Highlights Increase Small Business Assistance The adopted budget includes $35,000 in funding to activate the “Start and Grow a Business in Norfolk” website which provides tools to entrepreneurs looking to start and grow a business in the city. Resources include help with market research, business plans, calculating start-up costs, as well as help finding grants. The resources provided through the website help entrepreneurs create a business from the idea stage throughout planning, launching, managing, and growing the business. Entrepreneurs can access the website anytime to obtain the resources or request one on one assistance from city staff. The City has also established goals to increase spending with Small, Women and Minority owned firms. The Office of Diversity, Equity and Inclusion has an internal team to help individuals with navigating the city procurement process. Mi litary Liaison Program The Military Liaison program identifies and assists active-duty service members, military spouses, and veterans with finding employment with the City of Norfolk or other business within the city. The adopted budget includes the addition of one full time Management Analyst position to assist with the program and a total of $15,000 to expand the City's SkillBridge program. The funds will support a Career Progression Seminar through contractual service to provide relevant and current transition assistance training aimed to improve the professional work experience, networking opportunities and employability of the program participants. Resident Survey Questions FY 2023 Citizen Satisfaction Rate Percent of Residents that rate Norfolk as a good or excellent place to start a business 16.8% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with job opportunities that match their skills 17.6% Percent of residents that agree or strongly agree the city provides fair access to help small business start and grow 15.4% Percent of Residents that agree or strongly agree the city works to increase employment opportunities for all residents 25.5% Departmental Measures FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Projection FY 2024 Adopted Metric Number of residents served at employment and training events and initiatives N/A 100 125 200 Total number of residents connected with local employment opportunities that were hired 54 75 100 200 Total number of service members recruited and placed within the City of Norfolk and Virginia Values Veterans businesses 84 120 130 120 Number of small businesses receiving targeted case management to support resiliency, capacity, and stabilization 50 75 75 75 126 Strategic Goals and Objectives FY 2024 Budget Action Highlights Norfolk Public Schools Through the City/School Revenue Sharing policy, the city uses a revenue sharing formula to allocate a fixed share of non-dedicated local revenues to Norfolk Public Schools. The policy links economic growth to school funding to recognize the importance of schools to the economic success of the city. As of FY 2020, the city/school revenue sharing policy allocates a constant 29.55 percent of non-dedicated local revenues to Norfolk Public Schools. The adopted budget includes an additional $10,526,071 allocation to schools through the revenue sharing formula, when compared with the FY 2023 allocation. The adopted CIP includes an annual contribution of $1,000,000 in local funding to purchase school buses. It is anticipated this funding will purchase eight to nine schools buses a year . Also included in the five year planned CIP is funds for the construction of Norview Elementary School and Maury High School. $140,000,000 is planned to construct Maury High School in FY 2026 and $37,500,000 is planned for Norview Elementary in FY 2027. The FY 2023 CIP included funds to renovate Booker T. Washington High School. Learning and Enrichment Opportunities for Residents and Visitors Opportunities for lifelong learning and diverse arts and culture offerings that enhance social inclusion, active citizenship, and personal development for residents and visitors. Resident Survey Questions FY 2023 Citizen Satisfaction Rate Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the overall quality of public schools 14.3% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the number of opportunities to access city sponsorship activities and workshops that improve the quality of life 24.1% Percent of Residents satisfied or very satisfied with the overall value of Norfolk Libraries 55.4% Departmental Measures FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Projection FY 2024 Adopted Metric Total number of lifelong learning programs and outreach events offered through Norfolk Public Libraries 41 55 75 75 Number of school age children that attend educational programming for STEM learning through Nauticus 2,010 6,000 9,000 13,333 Number of participants in Norfolk Public Library’s early literacy and school-age programs 24,900 55,000 60,000 60,000 Total number of interns in Norfolk Emerging Leader program N/A 250 250 250 Strategic Goals and Objectives 127 Enhance Outdoor Programming In FY 2021, the Department of Parks and Recreation conducted a survey that served a road map for the creation of the department’s Master Plan. Among other programs, outdoor environmental/nature camps and programs were ranked in the top priorities for investment among survey participants. The adopted budget includes the addition of three Recreation Specialists and three Part-time Recreation Activity Instructors to enhance outdoor programming for all ages. These positions will instruct outdoor environmental and nature programming at recreation facilities and parks throughout the city. Norfolk Botanical Garden’s Capital Campaign The Adopted FY 2024 Budget includes $2,500,000 to support Norfolk Botanical Garden’s “The Garden of Tomorrow” capital campaign. The project will improve the entrance to the garden, construct a conservatory, and create a water education and rowing center . Funding for this project will be provided in FY 2024 and FY 2025. Enhanced Library Hours This year’s adopted budget includes additional temporary part-time staffing support for both Norfolk Public Libraries and Slover which will ensure that libraries are available to residents at least 40 hours a week. The increase in staffing will allow visitors full access to the building and collections. Tennis Court Improvements In FY 2023, the city conducted an assessment of all city tennis courts. $3,450,000 million is included in the FY 2024 adopted CIP to repair and renovate tennis courts in phases based on the final report and its recommendations. In FY 2024, the courts at Booker T . Washington and Lake Taylor High School will be improved. Safe, Engaged, and Informed Community People are safe anytime, anywhere in Norfolk. Our community is inclusive and welcoming to people of all backgrounds and beliefs. Residents connect in vibrant neighborhoods to build trust and a rich civic life. The city uses technology and rich community networks to share information, solicit feedback, and make it easy to utilize city services. Resident Survey Questions FY 2023 Citizen Satisfaction Rate Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the overall feeling of safety in Norfolk 14.2% Percent of residents that feel safe or very safe in their neighborhood 45.0% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the overall transparency regarding the actions of the city 14.0% 128 Strategic Goals and Objectives FY 2024 Budget Action Highlights Enhance Community Outreach Efforts for Crime Reduction In FY 2022, the city contracted services to obtain a community violence intervention program. The vendor provides technical assistance and training support to the city as an effort to bring alternative strategies to combat rising levels of violence. The FY 2024 adopted budget includes $450,000 in additional contractual funding to develop and implement an ongoing grass root level street safety program. The budget also includes a position to oversee community outreach efforts for crime reduction, staffing a citizen review panel and implementing equity in policing. Increase Fire-Rescue Emergency Medical Services Operations Staff Three dedicated Emergency Medical Services (EMS) Transport Supervisors (one per shift) are included in the adopted budget to oversee operations, as well as a new response vehicle. These positions will perform quality assurance, patient care review, EMS training, liaise with long term care facilities, and ensure adherence to Virginia Department of Health Emergency Service Regulations. Additional Park Ranger Positions Park Rangers are responsible for patrolling and enforcing city code in all city parks and open spaces. The City of Norfolk has over 100 properties that require patrolling by Park Rangers. The adopted budget includes an additional four Park Ranger positions and vehicles to improve safety at parks throughout the city. The additional of these positions will also increase capacity for the division of Parks and Forestry to perform educational outreach programming for residents. Internal Communications Team The Resident Survey indicated that residents receive a significant amount of their information directly from city employees. The adopted budget includes the establishment of an Internal Communications program with four FTEs within the department of Communications & Marketing. This will enhance communication across the organization and ensure city staff are adequately equipped to communicate effectively and consistently both internally and with residents. Departmental Measures FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Projection FY 2024 Adopted Metric Number of participants in the crime prevention program 910 1,500 1,500 1,500 Number of residential contacts that lead to resident awareness and installation of smoke alarms 200 150 150 150 Percentage of 911 calls responded to within 10 seconds 60 65 65 90 Number of notifications communicated for CPR assistance needed in public areas in Norfolk N/A 120 120 120 Percentage of Advanced Life Emergency Medical Services calls with a total response time of nine minutes or less 97 95 95 90 Percentage of outreach event participants citing increased knowledge and awareness of emergency preparedness topics 90 90 90 90 Index crime levels for violent crime 1,350 1,350 1,350 1,350 Strategic Goals and Objectives 129 Animal Care Center Funding is included in the FY 2024 CIP for the design of a new Norfolk Animal Care Center (NACC). The new facility will be larger than the current facility, will include space for Police Animal Protection (Animal Control), and will be designed to reduce cross contamination between animals during disease outbreaks. Funding is planned in FY 2025 for construction of the facility. The adopted budget also includes $500,000 to support the addition of four positions including a licensed Veterinarian, two Veterinary Technicians, and a Veterinary Assistant. One-time and ongoing operational costs for veterinary services provided to animals housed at the Norfolk Animal Care Center Shelter is also included in the funding. Policing Smarter The Norfolk Police Department (NPD) is taking several measures as part of a concerted effort to police smarter. The adopted budget includes the addition of a the Public Safety Aide position. This community-focused position will enhance Police recruitment by bringing in new prospective officers as young as 18 years old, before they are able to enter the Academy. This will enhance Police presence in our communities while preparing our next generation of officers to serve the city once they reach the age at which they can progress to the position of Recruit and, subsequently, officer. Feedback from the Resident Survey confirms that the city needs to adapt and innovate the current approach to policing. The visibility of police and residents’ ability to engage with police in crime prevention activities were lower resident satisfaction areas. Given the current hiring environment, we know that we will not be able to fill all of our sworn Police vacancies in the next fiscal year . This is not an issue unique to Norfolk; Police departments around the nation are struggling to fill vacancies that have steadily increased since the pandemic. To meet demand for public safety, we are re-imagining what policing looks like and making a conscious efforts to police smarter and align these efforts with 21st Century policing. This budget provides funding for 652 sworn officer positions. Payroll savings in FY 2024 will be strategically redirected to three areas: 1. Continue the enhanced public safety salaries implemented in FY 2023 2. Invest in our Real Time Crime Center (RTCC) 3. Invest in a new Public Safety Aide classification The adopted budget gives all sworn personnel one step plus an additional 2.5 percent increase. This results in all sworn personnel receiving a minimum of a five percent increase, while 167 Police Officers and 190 other sworn positions will receive a pay increase of 7.5 percent as they reach key career progression steps. The adopted budget also allows for the continuation of the longevity bonuses for officers who commit to remaining with the city for five years. 9-1-1 operators also play a critical role in ensuring the successful operations of the city’s public safety efforts. The adopted budget moves Telecommunicator positions to the same pay plan as our sworn officers to recognize their efforts. This will result in an increase in starting salary and will provide Telecommunicators with steps to progress and realize future pay growth. 130 Strategic Goals and Objectives Real Time Crime Center The adopted budget includes the reallocation of funds to create a Real Time Crime Center. The Real Time Crime Center (RTCC) will serve as a central intelligence hub for Public Safety by providing 24/7 citywide real-time surveillance, emergency management, and crime analysis. RTCCs leverage multiple camera and data feeds to present a picture of what is taking place in real time; they also provide a centralized place to unite technology with intelligence and analysis by providing law enforcement the ability to respond quickly to developing situations. RTCCs efficiently enable even a single analyst or law enforcement officer to monitor several areas at once. This facility and its advanced technology will help fill the gap in policing exacerbated by our high vacancies and ensure effective crime prevention and emergency response. Community Support and Well-Being Access to recreation, health, social services, and basic utilities that create an active, healthy, socially thriving, and inclusive community that helps residents live a meaningful life, feel empowered to make change, and be happy, healthy, and connected to their community. Resident Survey Questions FY 2023 Citizen Satisfaction Rate Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the overall quality of life in Norfolk 40.3% Percent of residents that rate Norfolk as a good or excellent place to find affordable housing 19.8% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the availability of city recreation facilities in or near their neighborhood 33.7% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the overall quality of human services provided by the city (i.e adult services, family services, juvenile services, public assistance, homelessness) 15.3% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the availability and accessibility of healthy food they can afford 25.2% Departmental Measures FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Projection FY 2024 Adopted Metric Total number of households receiving eviction and utility cut off prevention assistance through rent ready program 175 190 150 150 Number of rental educational courses offered through Rent Ready program 19 22 30 30 Number of rental units committed for low- to moderate-income households through a conditional use permit 101 42 42 50 Total number of residents serviced through Senior Real Estate Tax Relief program 1,642 1,642 1,415 1,642 Total number of homeless persons sheltered 1,375 1,200 1,100 1,375 Number of participants in youth and adult sports 1,478 886 1,200 1,200 Strategic Goals and Objectives 131 FY 2024 Budget Action Highlights Fair Housing Education and Enforcement The FY 2024 Adopted Budget includes funds for an additional Fair Housing Compliance Specialist position in the Department of Housing and Community Development to address fair housing through education and enforcement activities. The position will be responsible for coordinating fair housing training and engagement efforts, and monitoring subcontracts with fair housing testing agencies. Additionally, this position will oversee the enforcement of a new fair housing training requirement incorporated into future Conditional Use Permits (CUPs) for property managers and rental agents. These efforts will strengthen the local, state, and federal fair housing protections for all protected classes including race, color, religion, national origin, sex, elderliness, familial status, disability, source of funds, sexual orientation, gender identity, or military status. Berkley Supermarket The adopted budget includes $100,000 grant to the Berkley Supermarket to help continue operations. In FY 2021, the city approved funding to help incentivize an independent grocery store in the Berkeley area of the city to help mitigate the lack of access to fresh, quality food for residents of the area. The Berkley Supermarket opened in September 2021. These funds will be the second installment of a five year agreement between the EDA and the City to provide conditional funds for the continued operation of the Supermarket. Commercial Grade Kitchen for Homeless Shelter The adopted five year capital improvement program has $700,000 in planned funding in FY 2025 for a commercial kitchen at “The Center,” a homeless shelter on Tidewater Drive. The Center is a 100-bed shelter that began operating in FY 2022 to support and provide services to homeless individuals as they work toward transitioning to permanent housing. Since opening, 484 people have been served. The adjacent property will be used to install a commercial kitchen facility and dining hall to cook on-site and host volunteer groups willing to donate meals. Affordable Housing To address the lower resident satisfaction rating with affordable housing, the city is working with a consultant to prepare a comprehensive housing study and recommendations for a set of affordable housing policies. The FY 2024 budget will fund one new Senior Design and Rehabilitation Specialist to enforce the requirements associated with the anticipated inclusionary zoning policy. Inclusionary Zoning is a policy tool that will allow City Council to implement mandatory or voluntary set-asides for affordable housing units within new multifamily projects across the city. Other efforts include the transformative redevelopment of the St. Paul's area, now known as Kindred. The physical redevelopment assists in the deconcentration of poverty with more than 90 percent of the residents moving to lower poverty neighborhoods with rental assistance and barrier removal offered through the city funded People First program. This program also provides assistance in job training, education and health and has resulted in a 74 percent employment rate and 100 percent of children having health insurance. The city is continuing to provide funds for Renovate Norfolk and Strengthening Neighborhoods’ owner-occupied rehabilitation and down-payment assistance programs, the Department of Neighborhood Services’ Rent Ready Norfolk education program and Norfolk Eviction Prevention Center. As of March 2021, $1,900,000 has been allocated and 469 households have been assisted through the Eviction Prevention. St. Paul’s Blue/Green Way The Blue/Green Way in Kindred will redevelop approximately 26 acres of public housing and other properties into an aesthetic open space designed to treat and store storm water runoff during storm events. This transformation will 132 Strategic Goals and Objectives create a water eco-center comprised of parks and green spaces. The FY 2024 CIP includes funds for the construction of Storm Water, Water, Wastewater infrastructure in the area as well as funds to construct recreational amenities. Blueway and Trail Connections The adopted budget includes $150,000 for the “Trail Assessment and Recreational Trail Connectivity Plan” which will be used as a framework to help the Department of Parks and Recreation decide how to best construct and connect blueways and trail networks throughout the city. Code Enforcement Expansion The adopted budget also includes an expansion of citywide code enforcement for private property maintenance. This expansion effort will add 12 Neighborhood Code Specialists and Neighborhood Code Specialist, Seniors to the Department of Neighborhood Services. Neighborhood Codes Specialists are responsible for enforcing city ordinances and the Virginia Maintenance Code (VMC) for private property in the city. These positions will increase engagement, education, and enforcement to improve the appearance of the city and its neighborhoods. The adopted budget also includes $100,000 for an abatement assistance program. These funds will provide one-time abatement assistance to eligible property owners with extenuating circumstances. Enhance Street Outreach Efforts The Street Outreach Team provides those experiencing homelessness with transportation to shelters, referral to benefits, services, and long-term planning to end their homelessness. $108,000 is included in the budget to enhance homeless street outreach by adding an additional permanent full-time Case Manager III position, and a temporary full-time Case Manager III position that will proactively connect with and offer services to individuals experiencing homelessness in Norfolk. These funds also include the addition of a vehicle. Increase Funding for Nighttime Basketball Program The adopted budget includes an additional $250,000 for a nighttime basketball tournament, for residents ages eighteen and up. The program has an emphasis on positive activities while providing additional assistance such as employment opportunities, professional development, G.E.D. enrollment, healthcare services, and more. The funds will be used to support costs including security, referees, uniforms, and additional programming outside of basketball to include dance and G.E.D. classes. Real Estate Tax Relief Program Updated Seniors and permanently disabled homeowners that meet certain requirements are eligible for real estate tax relief and/or deferment. The FY 2024 adopted budget includes an increase in the assessed home value of program participants. To qualify for tax exemption, household income cannot exceed $28,611 and net worth cannot exceed $350,000. The exemption now applies to the homes assessed value of up to $267,609. This is an increase from home assessed value of $203,386 in the FY 2023 Budget. Households with income exceeding $28,611 but does not exceed $67,000 may defer the real estate tax on their home up to the assessed value of $267,609. Efficient And Responsive Government A data-informed and innovative organization that delivers essential services efficiently and is responsive and accountable to the community. As good stewards of our resources, prudent budgeting and financial practices demonstrate fiscal responsibility and increase resilience to economic shocks. Strategic Goals and Objectives 133 FY 2024 Budget Action Highlights Information Technology Security Since 2020, the city has experienced an increase in malicious cyber-attacks and information technology security related incidents. The city blocked 16,000 malicious email attacks in 2020 and more than 7.8 million malicious email attacks in 2022. The adopted budget includes the addition of a Chief Information Security position to assist with keeping enterprise information, technical data, and resources protected against unauthorized access. This includes maintaining and updating software, hardware, and appliances that are involved with cyber security. Investing in Team Norfolk To continue to attract and retain talented employees, the adopted FY 2024 budget includes several investments in Team Norfolk. To maintain employees that provide core government services, a 5 percent general wage increase for all general, constitutional, and non sworn employees is included in the adopted Budget. Additionally, the adopted budget includes a step increase, plus a 2.5 percent increase (for a minimum of a 5 percent increase) for sworn employees on Pay Plan 5. In FY 2024, employees will receive improved coverage of healthcare benefits at no additional costs for employees. Lastly, approximately $60,000 is included in the adopted budget for staff development and training across various programs. Enhance Citywide Title VI Compliance Title VI of the 1964 Civil Rights Act prohibits discrimination based on race, color, national origin, or disability status in any program or activity that receives federal funds or other federal financial assistance. Since the city is a recipient of federal funds, the City is legally required to address Title VI compliance. This action will provide funds for a dedicated Management Analyst II position to manage and enhance citywide Title VI compliance. Resident Survey Questions FY 2023 Citizen Satisfaction Rate Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the overall value received for their city tax dollars and fees 19.0% Percent of residents satisfied or very satisfied with the overall enforcement of codes and ordinances 16.5% Percent of residents that agree or strongly agree the city responsibly manages resources to meet today's needs without sacrificing the ability to meet the needs of the future 20.1% Departmental Measures FY 2022 Actual FY 2023 Projection FY 2024 Adopted Metric Total customers contacting Norfolk Cares via phone, web portal, and email 189,682 195,000 210,000 290,000 Average wait times for Norfolk Cares call (minutes) 3 3 3 2 Maintain compliance with Virginia Statues and the city’s investment policy Yes Yes Yes Yes Number of datasets and data stories added to the city’s Open Data Portal 11 15 20 20 134 Strategic Goals and Objectives Supplemental Tables The following table provides a summary of resources allocated by service objective in the FY 2024 Adopted Budget. Table 1: Summary of FY 2024 Resource Allocation by Service Objective Service Objective FY 2024 Adopted FTEs FY 2024 Adopted Budget FY 2024 Adopted CIP Total Learning and Enrichment Opportunities 306.5 $460,979,593 $46,861,347 $507,840,940 Community Support and Well-being 1,134.4 $284,883,807 $84,430,000 $369,313,807 Efficient and Responsive Government 526.4 $269,072,396 $5,400,000 $274,472,396 Safe, Engaged, and Informed Community 1,652.0 $196,110,190 $77,217,000 $273,327,190 Infrastructure and Connectivity 443.0 $108,610,453 $108,676,022 $217,286,475 Economic Opportunity for Residents and Businesses 38.0 $22,704,477 $15,950,000 $38,654,477 Resilient Norfolk 159.0 $19,658,261 $57,078,800 $76,737,061 Council Appointee Offices, Constitutional Offices, Elections, and Courts 719.8 $77,838,435 $0 $77,838,435 Grand Total 4,979.1 $1,439,857,612 $395,613,169 $1,835,470,781 The following table provides a summary of programs by service objective. Table 2: Summary of Citywide Programs by Service Objective Service Objective Number of Programs FY 2024 Adopted FTEs FY 2024 Adopted Community Support and Well-being 33 1,134.4 $284,883,807 Economic Opportunity for Residents and Businesses 18 38.0 $22,704,477 Efficient and Responsive Government 86 526.4 $269,072,396 Infrastructure and Connectivity 25 443.0 $108,610,453 Learning and Enrichment Opportunities 31 306.5 $460,979,593 Resilient Norfolk 16 159.0 $19,658,261 Safe, Engaged, and Informed Community 39 1,652.0 $196,110,190 1Grand Total 1.Information in this table does not include Constitutional Officers or Appointees. 248 4,259.3 $1,362,019,177 Annual Grants Plan This page intentionally left blank Annual Grants Plan 137 ANNUAL GRANTS PLAN The City of Norfolk receives annual grant funds dedicated for specific purposes from federal, state, and other organizations. These grants are an important part of the city’s annual spending plan and are used to provide programs and services for Norfolk residents that complement programming supported by the General Fund and other city operations. The Annual Grants Plan identifies city program information for each grant. This provides context for all grants received by identifying the city program areas the grant resources enhance. The grants and special revenues in this section are funds the city receives every year. Appropriating recurring grants as part of the annual budget gives readers a more complete picture of the resources available to provide programs and services for residents. It also supports the grant lifecycle process and ensures these funds are quickly accessible to departments and residents, thereby ensuring the programming supported by grants is immediately available after receiving a grant award letter. The following grants represent grants received in the past and/or that the city is confident will be awarded in the upcoming fiscal year. Grant amounts on the subsequent pages reflect an “up to” amount and are based on the estimated award the city expects to receive in FY 2024. Annual grant awards will vary year to year. In FY 2024, the city expects to receive $78,351,609 in annual grant awards. The City of Norfolk will be providing $5,340,632 matching funds for these grants. An additional $2,806,000 reflects fees and other income the departments generate. This totals $86,498,241 and will support 118 full time equivalent positions. The grant awards are across seventeen city departments. U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Community Block Grant entitlement grants are not included in this section and can be found in the Annual Plan section. 138 Annual Grants Plan ANNUAL GRANTS PLAN Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program Circuit Court Judges Supreme Court of Virginia Adult Drug Court Program 240,000 78,500 30,000 348,500 5 Circuit Court Judges Subtotal 240,000 78,500 30,000 348,500 5 City Manager U.S. Department of Health and Human Services/HRSA Ryan White HIV/AIDS Program Part A HIV Emergency Relief 6,500,000 0 0 6,500,000 6 N/A 1 Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Comprehensive Community Corrections Act Program 1,375,000 88,932 0 1,463,932 17 Community Initiatives Subtotal 7,875,000 88,932 0 7,963,932 23 City Planning Virginia Department of Historic Resources Certified Local Government Grant 60,000 20,000 0 80,000 0 City Planning Subtotal 60,000 20,000 0 80,000 0 Clerk of Circuit Court Commonwealth of Virginia Compensation Board Technology Trust Fund 247,000 0 0 247,000 0 Clerk of the Circuit Court Subtotal 247,000 0 0 247,000 0 Commonwealth’s Attorney Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Virginia Sexual and Domestic Violence Victims Fund (VSDVVF) - Paralegal 45,000 0 0 45,000 1 Commonwealth’s Attorney Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Violence Against Women Act (VAWA) - VSTOP Program - Prosecution 87,000 29,000 0 116,000 2 Commonwealth’s Attorney Annual Grants Plan 139 Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Victims of Crime Act (VOCA) Victims Services Grant Program 114,000 0 0 114,000 2 Commonwealth’s Attorney Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Victims of Crime Act (VOCA) Victims Services Grant Program- restoration funding 190,000 0 0 190,000 1 Commonwealth’s Attorney Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Victim Witness Assistance Grant Program - Victim Services 730,000 0 0 730,000 14 Commonwealth’s Attorney State and Federal Asset Forfeiture Collections Asset Forfeiture Collections 0 0 65,000 65,000 0 Commonwealth’s Attorney Subtotal 1,166,000 29,000 65,000 1,260,000 20 Communications COX Communicatio ns Hampton Roads LLC Public Education Grants (PEG) 100,000 0 0 100,000 0 Creative Services Subtotal 100,000 0 0 100,000 0 Emergency Preparedness and Response Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) Flood Mitigation Assistance Grant 2,015,000 179,000 0 2,194,000 0 FEMA Hazard Mitigation Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) Local Emergency Management Program Grant (LEMPG) 114,000 114,000 0 228,000 1 Emergency Management Commonwealth of Virginia, Virginia 9-1-1 Services Board Virginia Information Technologies Agency (VITA) - Public Safety Answering Point (PSAP) Grant 3,000 0 0 3,000 0 Training, Outreach, and Data Services Subtotal 2,132,000 293,000 0 2,425,000 1 Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program 140 Annual Grants Plan Fire-Rescue U.S. Department of Homeland Security, Federal Emergency Management Assistance Assistance to Firefighters Grant 1,182,000 118,200 0 1,300,200 0 Fire-Rescue Services Virginia Department of Fire Programs Aid to Localities 1,200,000 0 0 1,200,000 0 Fire-Rescue Services Virginia Department of Health (VDH), Department of Emergency Medical Services Four for Life - Emergency Medical Services (EMS) 200,000 0 0 200,000 0 Emergency Medical Services Virginia Department of Emergency Medical Services Rescue Squad Assistance Fund 35,000 35,000 0 70,000 0 Emergency Medical Service Virginia Department of Emergency Management Homeland Security Grant 35,000 0 0 35,000 0 Fire-Rescue Services Revenue from fines and fees for hazmat related incidents Hazmat Special Revenue 0 0 100,000 100,000 0 Fire-Rescue Services; Fire Code Enforcement; Fire Investigations Subtotal 2,652,000 153,200 100,000 2,905,200 0 Human Services Commonwealth of Virginia Children’s Services Act (CSA) Program Virginia Children’s Services Act (CSA) 8,640,000 3,360,000 0 12,000,000 0 Family Services and Foster Care Virginia Department of Juvenile Justice Virginia Juvenile Community Crime Control Act (VJCCCA) 640,000 640,000 0 1,280,000 4 Juvenile Detention and Court Services Subtotal 9,280,000 4,000,000 0 13,280,000 4 Libraries Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program Annual Grants Plan 141 Schools and Libraries Division of the Universal Service Fund E- Rate Reimbursement Program E-Rate Reimbursemen t Program 0 0 105,000 105,000 0 Collection and Support Services and Lifelong Learning Hampton Roads Community Foundation Hampton Roads Community Foundation Grant 25,500 0 0 25,500 0 Branch Operations, and Director’s Office Norfolk Public Library Foundation Various: Sargeant Memorial Collection (SMC) and Maker Studio 0 0 15,000 15,000 0 SMC and Branch Operations Library Gift Account Various Donations/ Gifts 0 0 25,000 25,000 0 Branch Operations, Director's Office Friends of Norfolk Public Library Various 0 0 15,000 15,000 0 Programming Services Friends of Norfolk Public Library Summer Reading Program (SRP) 0 0 30,000 30,000 0 Programming Services Subtotal 25,500 0 190,000 215,500 0 Norfolk Arts Virginia Commission for the Arts Creative Communities Partnership Grant 4,500 4,500 0 9,000 0 Norfolk Arts Various Donations/Gifts Various Projects 0 0 50,000 50,000 0 Norfolk Arts Subtotal 4,500 4,500 50,000 59,000 0 Norfolk Community Services Board Supreme Court of Virginia/ VDBHDS Vivitrol Program 50,000 0 0 50,000 0 Crisis, Acute and Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Regional funds for Crisis Stabilization 310,000 0 0 310,000 1 Crisis, Acute and Recovery Services Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program 142 Annual Grants Plan Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) and Hampton Newport News CSB (HNNCSB) Emergency Services Grant 100,000 0 0 100,000 1 Crisis, Acute and Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Forensic Program of Assertive Community Treatment (PACT) 200,000 0 0 200,000 3 Behavioral Health Community Support Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS), Chesapeake CIBH) HRRJ Discharge Case Manager Grant 230,000 0 0 230,000 2 Crisis, Acute and Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health System Transformatio n Excellence and Performance in Virginia (STEP- Virginia) - Outpatient Services 620,000 0 0 620,000 3 Crisis, Acute and Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health System Transformatio n Excellence and Performance in Virginia (STEP- Virginia) - Primary Care 283,000 0 0 283,000 3 Medical and Psychiatric Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health System Transformatio n Excellence and Performance in Virginia (STEP- Virginia) - Same Day Access 270,000 0 0 270,000 3 Behavioral Health Community Support Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program Annual Grants Plan 143 Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health System Transformatio n Excellence and Performance in Virginia (STEP- Virginia) - Peer Recovery Center 145,000 0 0 145,000 1 Peer Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health System Transformatio n Excellence and Performance in Virginia (STEP- Virginia) - Veterans Services 85,000 0 0 85,000 1 Crisis, Acute and Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Peer Recovery Center 131,000 0 0 131,000 1 Peer Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Permanent Supportive Housing (PSH) 2,610,000 0 0 2,610,000 12 Housing and Homeless Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Pharmacy and Medication Support Program 570,000 0 0 570,000 0 Medical and Psychiatric Services Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program 144 Annual Grants Plan Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHD) Psychiatry Services for Children and Adolescents 25,000 0 0 25,000 0 Development and Youth Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) State Opioid Response (SOR): Opioid Prevention 200,000 0 0 200,000 0 Development and Youth Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) State Opioid Response (SOR): Opioid Recovery 443,000 0 0 443,000 8 Peer Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) State Opioid Response (SOR): Opioid Recovery 100,000 0 0 100,000 1 Crisis, Acute and Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHD) Virginia State General Fund- Medication Assisted Treatment for Opioid Use Disorder 130,000 0 0 130,000 2 Crisis, Acute and Recovery Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health System Transformatio n Excellence and Performance in Virginia (STEP- Virginia) - IT Infrastructure 140,000 0 0 140,000 0 Administrative Support Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health System Transformatio n Excellence and Performance in Virginia (STEP- Virginia) - Care Coordination Services 200,000 0 0 200,000 3 Behavioral Health Community Support Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program Annual Grants Plan 145 Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health System Transformatio n Excellence and Performance in Virginia (STEP- Virginia) - Psychiatric Rehabilitation Service 60,000 0 0 60,000 1 Behavioral Health Community Support Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health System Transformatio n Excellence and Performance in Virginia (STEP- Virginia) - Case Management Services 80,000 0 0 80,000 1 Behavioral Health Community Support Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Problem Gambling Prevention Services 40,000 0 0 40,000 1 Development and Youth Services Virginia Department of Behavioral Health and Developmental Services (VDBHDS) Mental Health First Aid and Suicide Prevention 20,000 0 0 20,000 0 Development and Youth Services Subtotal 7,042,000 0 0 7,042,000 53 Police U.S. Department of Justice Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant (JAG) Program 200,000 0 0 200,000 0 Patrol Services and Crime Investigations Virginia Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) DMV Selective Enforcement - Alcohol, Occupancy Protection, Speed 105,000 52,500 0 157,500 0 Crowd, Traffic, and Special Events Management Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) Port Security Grant 325,000 110,000 0 435,000 0 Crowd, Traffic, and Special Events Management and Crime Investigations Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program 146 Annual Grants Plan Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) Homeland Security Grant Program - Urban Area Security Initiative 150,000 0 0 150,000 0 Crowd, Traffic, and Special Events Management; Crime Investigations Virginia Department of Emergency Management (VDEM) Homeland Security Grant 100,000 0 0 100,000 0 Crowd, Traffic, and Special Events Management; Crime Investigations Virginia State Police Annual Training and Equipment Grant 15,000 0 0 15,000 0 Crime Investigation s Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Firearm Prevention and Intervention 1,500,000 0 0 1,500,000 0 Crime Investigation s Virginia Department of the Attorney General Project Safe Neighborhoods 300,000 0 0 300,000 0 Crime Investigation s Virginia Department of the Attorney General Hampton Roads Human Trafficking Task Force 25,000 0 0 25,000 0 Crime Investigation s Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Operation Cease Fire 500,000 0 0 500,000 0 Crime Investigation s Revenue from the Clerks of the Norfolk Circuit Court, General District Court, and Juvenile Domestic Relations Court from defendants with felony, misdemeanor, or traffic charges Support of Local Police Training Academy and Training Division 0 0 150,000 150,000 0 Training General donations received from citizens and organizations Donations to Norfolk Police 0 0 100,000 100,000 0 Community Relations; Office Of Police Chief Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program Annual Grants Plan 147 U.S. Department of Justice and U.S. Department of the Treasury Federal Forfeiture Collections 0 0 75,000 75,000 0 Crime Investigation s Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) State Forfeiture Collections 0 0 255,000 255,000 0 Crime Investigation s Subtotal 3,220,000 162,500 580,000 3,962,500 0 Public Works U.S. Department of Environmental Protection Agency Chesapeake Bay Program Partnership 400,000 0 0 400,000 0 Chesapeake Bay Program Partnership Virginia Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) Keep Norfolk Beautiful 60,000 0 0 60,000 0 Keep Norfolk Beautiful Subtotal 460,000 0 0 460,000 0 Sheriff and Jail2 Income from Inmate Commissary Accounts 811 Market Place Program- Inmate Commissary Program 0 0 350,000 350,000 5 Sheriff and Jail Income from Inmate Commissary Accounts Inmate Classification Specialists 0 0 235,000 235,000 3 Sheriff and Jail Income from Sheriff’s Community Corrections Program (Work Release, Inmate Work Force, and Electronic Monitoring) Sheriff’s Community Corrections Program 0 0 586,000 586,000 2 Sheriff and Jail Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Addiction Recovery Program 39,000 0 0 39,000 0 Sheriff and Jail Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services (DCJS) Residential Substance Abuse Treatment Program 151,000 51,000 0 202,000 2 Sheriff and Jail Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program 148 Annual Grants Plan U.S. Department of Justice State Criminal Alien Assistance Program (SCAAP) 40,000 0 0 40,000 0 Sheriff and Jail U.S. Marshals Services U.S. Marshals Services Program 0 0 250,000 250,000 0 Sheriff and Jail Income from Project Lifesaver Program Project Lifesaver Program 0 0 20,000 20,000 0 Sheriff and Jail State and Federal Asset Forfeiture Collections Asset Forfeiture Collections 0 0 350,000 350,000 0 Sheriff and Jail Subtotal 230,000 51,000 1,791,000 2,072,000 12 Transit Virginia Department of Transportation SMART SCALE Reimbursable VDOT Funding Program 18,501,009 0 0 18,501,009 0 VDOT Project Management Virginia Department of Transportation Highway Safety Improvement Program (HSIP) Reimbursable Funding Program 7,704,605 0 0 7,704,605 0 VDOT Project Management Virginia Department of Transportation Primary Extension SGR Reimbursable Funding Program 1,499,995 0 0 1,499,995 0 VDOT Project Management Virginia Department of Transportation Bridge Formula (#BF) of IIJA For Off- System Bridges Reimbursable Funding Program 1,000,000 0 0 1,000,000 0 VDOT Project Management U.S. Department of Transportation Safe Streets and Roads for All - Multi-modal Transportation Action Plan 240,000 60,000 0 300,000 0 VDOT Project Management U.S. Department of Transportation Reconnecting Communities Project - Planning Grant 1,600,000 400,000 0 2,000,000 0 VDOT Project Management Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program Annual Grants Plan 149 1 The Ryan White HIV Part A Program is a regional project which provides medical and supportive services accross Hampton Roads. It is not part of a City Program. 2 Sheriff’s FTE’s are non-city employees. Department of Housing and Urban Development Community Project Fund- Neighborhood Safety LED Streetlight Upgrades 3,000,000 0 0 3,000,000 0 VDOT Project Management Department of Energy Energy Efficiency and Conservation Block Grant (EECBG) 272,000 0 0 272,000 0 VDOT Project Management Subtotal 33,817,609 460,000 0 34,277,609 0 Utilities U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Community Project Funds - River Oaks Water and Sewer Replacement 2,500,000 0 0 2,500,000 0 EPA Project Management U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Community Project Funds - West Ocean View Water and Sewer Replacement 2,300,000 0 0 2,300,000 0 EPA Project Management U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Community Project Funds - Ballentine Place Water and Sewer Replacement 1,600,000 0 0 1,600,000 0 EPA Project Management Virginia Dept of Environmental Quality ARPA Wastewater Funds Program 3,400,000 0 0 3,400,000 0 VDEQ Project Management Subtotal 9,800,000 0 0 9,800,000 0 Total 78,351,609 5,340,632 2,806,000 86,498,241 118 Department Awarding Agency Grant Name Grant Amount Match Amount Fees/ Other Revenues Total Funding FTE City Program This page intentionally left blank Program Budget Pages This page intentionally left blank Program Budget Pages 153 PROGRAM BUDGET PAGES INTRODUCTION The city transitioned to program-based budgeting in FY 2022 as an effort to develop a public budget document that clearly communicates the programs offered by the city; the resources it takes to provide those services; and the level of services stakeholders can expect to receive based on the resources allocated to each program. FY 2024 marks the third year the City of Norfolk presents the operating budget by program. The program budget pages outlined in this section showcase departmental expenditures, personnel resources, goals, performance measures, and ability to meet stakeholder

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Norfolk website. First collected Oct 6, 2026.