RecordWell Data

Board of Zoning Appeals — Agenda Packet

Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Board of Zoning Appeals · meeting of Mar 4, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Chesterfield County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CHESTERFIELD COUNTY BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS MEETING AGENDA WEDNESDAY, MARCH 4, 2026 Public Meeting Room 10001 Iron Bridge Road, Chesterfield VA 23832 NOTE: Attachments are generally available the Wednesday prior to the Board of Zoning Appeals meeting. Any subsequent changes to this agenda prior to the date of the meeting, and more detailed information regarding items on the agenda can be found at chesterfield.gov/plan, or by calling the Planning Department at 804-748-1050 during regular business hours, 8:30 a.m. to 5 p.m. Monday through Friday. A map of each case can be found at chesterfield.gov/plancases. Providing a FIRST CHOICE community through excellence in public service 12:00 p.m. Lunch/work session in Executive Session Room, 10001 Iron Bridge Road, Chesterfield, Virginia 23832 1. 1 p.m. Meeting called to order in the Public Meeting Room, Lane B. Ramsey Administration Building, Chesterfield, Virginia 2. Invocation 3. Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag of the United States of America 4. Election of Officers and Appointment of Secretary for 2026 A. Chair and Vice-Chair B. Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals 5. Adoption of the Board of Zoning Appeals Rules, Procedures, & Remote Attendance Policy 6. Approval of Minutes • December 3, 2025 7. Acknowledgements of Withdrawal or Requests for Deferral 8. Consideration of Variance and Special Exception Requests A. 25VA1345: In Midlothian Magisterial District, Michael Fahl requests one (1) foot ten and one half (10.5) inch variance to the seven (7) foot maximum fence height located within the rear yard and amendment of zoning district map in a Transition Residential (TR) District known as 9215 Groundhog Drive. The 0.07 acre property is developed with one single family dwelling. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Residential Neighborhood 8 use. Tax ID 752-715-5978. B. 25VA1373: In Bermuda Magisterial District, John Johnstone requests a variance to use a parcel of land which fronts on a dedicated, but unimproved Page 1 of 40 Chesterfield County Board of Zoning Appeals Meeting March 4, 2026 public road (Orlando Avenue) for dwelling purposes and amendment of zoning district map in Semi-Urban Neighborhood (SU) District located on the west line of Orlando Avenue measuring north 275 feet to the intersection of Maywood Street and Orlando Avenue and then measuring west 650 feet to the intersection of Seminole Avenue and Maywood Street. The 0.16 acre property is proposed for one single family dwelling. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Office, Light Production & Assembly uses. Tax ID 797-663- 7990. Access is proposed across portions of Maywood Street and Orlando Avenue both of which are dedicated but unimproved rights of way. C. 26SE2002: In Dale Magisterial District, Kristin Shreffler requests a special exception to permit personal dog keeping (continued keeping of four (4) personal dogs) and amendment of zoning district map in Semi-Urban Neighborhood (SU) District known as 5506 Swan Drive. The 0.41 acre property is developed with one single family dwelling. The Comprehensive Plan suggests the property is appropriate for Residential Neighborhood 4. Tax ID 773-690-1575. 9. Miscellaneous A. Select January 2027 Meeting Date 10. Adjournment Page 2 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 1 of 15 25VA1345 – Michael Fahl Magisterial District – Midlothian Applicant's Contact – Michael Fahl (804-875-1118) BZA Public Hearing – March 4, 2026 Time Remaining 90 Days Case Manager Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) Request Variance One (1) foot, 10.5 inch variance to the seven (7) foot maximum fence height located within the rear yard in a Transition Residential (TR) District. Staff Recommendation Denial The Property 9215 Groundhog Drive Site Size 0.07 Acre Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Rear View Image NOTE FOR THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Recommended condition, Applicant’s Concept Plan, and other exhibits are in this report. STAFF - DENIAL  There are no conditions, as required by the Zoning Ordinance, upon which this request is based that is unique to the property and is not applicable generally to other properties in the area.  No information has been provided by the applicant that would indicate there are unusual circumstances about this property such as adherence to the required fence height limitation in this area would cause undue hardship.  Alternative exists that would eliminate the need for this variance request. Recommendation Page 3 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 2 of 15 PLANNING  Topography in the vicinity may be challenging; however, the topography is not unique to the lot or subdivision. Adjacent properties have stepped down fence heights to address the topography concern.  Exceeding the ordinance requirement relative to fence height does not appear to provide additional privacy for the landowner.  Reduction in the fence height within the rear yard would be in character with adjacent properties while still maintaining privacy. Summary of Identified Topics Page 4 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 3 of 15 Background  The Ordinance states the following for the purpose of fences and walls: Residential fences and walls serve properties by providing privacy and security, defining private space and enhancing the design of individual sites. Fences also affect the public by impacting the visual image of the streetscape and the overall character of neighborhoods. The purpose of these regulations is to achieve a balance between the private concerns for privacy and site design and the public concerns for enhancement of the community appearance.  Subject property was recorded on May 9, 1972, as part of Edgehill Townhouses Subdivision (Lot 2). Subdivision Plat  The Townhouse was built in 1974.  The applicant purchased the property on July 7, 2023.  The applicant built the fence and retaining wall in 2024 with Homeowners Association approval relative to the fence design.  The applicant’s intent with the construction of the fence is to provide privacy for the Property from a harassing neighbor.  This request is a result of a zoning complaint. Planning Page 5 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 4 of 15 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Summary of Identified Topics ................................................................................................................................................. 2 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Aerial ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 8 Supplemental Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................ 9 Environmental Engineering ................................................................................................................................................. 9 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................... 9 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................... 9 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................... 9 Utilities – Water and Wastewater ...................................................................................................................................... 9 Virginia Department of Health ............................................................................................................................................ 9 Real Property ...................................................................................................................................................................... 9 Applicant’s Concept Plan ...................................................................................................................................................... 10 Applicant’s Concept Plan - Continued................................................................................................................................... 11 Fence and Wall Construction View ....................................................................................................................................... 12 Condition ............................................................................................................................................................................... 13 Subdivision Plat ..................................................................................................................................................................... 14 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 15 Table of Contents Page 6 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 5 of 15 Proposal The applicant is requesting approval for an eight (8) foot, 10.5 inch privacy fence in the rear yard. The applicant indicates the following as justification for this request: “Due to the geography of the rear of the property, it was determined that a retaining wall (below 3' of height) was required to fully utilize the exterior property for a yard. Due to the retaining wall, in order for the fence to be a complete privacy fence along the lengths of the property, the fence needed to exceed 7' in height. There is little to no effect on adjoining properties. The fence height does not obstruct any views, nor does it cast undue shadow on adjoining properties. Both immediate neighbors have commented on how much they appreciate our creating additional privacy for them. The hardship that requires us to retain the height of the fence is that we have been subject to constant harassment and ridicule from our neighbor at 9209, whose outdoor area looks directly at our property due to the orientation of the homes. Since we moved in, we have faced constant homophobic behavior, this neighbor has spent much of their time spying on us to understand what we are doing while we update and renovate our home. They have filed numerous false reports with the county to harass us, made libelous and slanderous claims about us, and they have even made threats of physical violence toward myself during an HOA board meeting. Currently, we are able to enjoy the back area of our property, where we have privacy thanks to the fence, and sit by our firepit and enjoy the creek area in peace. If we are forced to decrease the height of our fence, we will be in clear view of our neighbor’s property, and we will no longer feel safe spending time there, rendering that portion of our yard, which we have spent tens of thousands of dollars renovating to make it usable Aerial Planning Groundhog Drive 9209 Groundhog Drive Page 7 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 6 of 15 space, rendering this area useless and a waste of money. To force us to reduce the height of the fence is to knowingly and willingly subject us to harassment of a protected class, I want to make that abundantly clear.” Examination of Request The Zoning Ordinance sets forth approval criteria (19.2-66.E) for granting a variance if the applicant provides evidence that:  A strict application of this chapter would unreasonably restrict use of the property, or the variance would alleviate a hardship due to the physical condition of the property or improvements on the property at the time of the effective date of this chapter, as amended from time to time, or the variance would alleviate a hardship by granting a reasonable modification to a property or improvements thereon requested by, or on behalf of, a person with a disability;  The property was acquired in good faith and any hardship was not created by the applicant;  Substantial detriment will not occur to adjacent and nearby properties in the proximity of the geographic area in which the property is located;  The condition, situation or the intended use of the property is not of so general or recurring a nature as to make reasonably practicable the formulation of a general regulation to be adopted as an amendment to this chapter;  The application will not allow a use that is not otherwise permitted on the property, or change the zoning district classification for the property; and  The relief is not available through an administrative modification or special exception. Staff’s inspection of the property revealed the following:  The Property contains both a retaining wall and a wood privacy fence.  The retaining wall is located along the southern portion of the Property. At its highest point, the retaining wall appears to be approximately two (2) foot nine (9) inches tall, meeting ordinance requirements relative to height. The applicant advised the retaining wall was constructed to achieve a level, usable rear yard.  A wood privacy fence with variable height is located within the rear yard of the Property and is constructed beside the retaining wall, not upon it (see Fence and Wall Construction View).  As depicted in the Applicant’s Concept Plan, only a small portion of the wood privacy fence exceeds the permitted seven (7) feet in height for a fence located within a rear yard.  The Property backs to a recreation/open space area that is recorded as part of the Edgehill Townhouses Subdivision. This open space is comprised of a natural setting and does not have additional recorded lots for single family dwellings in close proximity that would be impacted by the request. The Zoning Ordinance permits a fence located within the rear yard to be constructed up to seven (7) feet in height. Fence height is permitted to be higher in the rear yard to allow for privacy and security when constructed for the enjoyment of a single-family dwelling. Anything above seven (7) feet in height may impact the light and air on the adjacent properties especially when the fence is located along or close to the property line. Staff has examined the request as required by the Zoning Ordinance, and the property owner has not provided information which would serve as a basis for granting the variance. Variance criteria should be based on the physical conditions of the Property and relief given if a hardship exists that cannot be remedied by any other Page 8 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 7 of 15 means. The applicant constructed the fence not meeting Ordinance requirements; therefore, he has created his own hardship. The fence construction in 2024 was installed by the applicant to address harassment from a neighbor. This request is based on the applicant’s desire to block a neighbor’s view of the Property in hopes of eliminating the harassment. Although a visual barrier may seem appropriate to defuse harassing behavior, remedies for such situations may better be resolved through legal measures. Although the topography is challenging, neighboring fences have been constructed providing for privacy by stepping down the fence height as the land drops. The greatest impact of the request would be to the adjacent lots where the fence exceeds the permitted seven (7) feet in height. The view of the natural open space to the rear of the homes could be obstructed by the taller fence thus impacting the adjacent lots relative to reduced light and air since the fence appears to be located on or near the property line. However, the applicant has indicated the adjacent property owners are agreeable to the fence height and appreciate the additional privacy it gives to them. This request is not unique, and if approved, may set a precedent for other fences to be constructed within the rear yard greater than seven (7) feet in height. The fence could be altered to meet Ordinance requirements and continue to serve as a barrier from the harassing neighbor. Although the fence appears to be well constructed and visually pleasing, the fence is out of character with surrounding fences as adjacent fencing has been stepped down to adjust to the topography and achieve fence height requirements. For these reasons, staff finds that the requirements for granting a variance have not been satisfied. Page 9 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 8 of 15 Current Zoning Map Page 10 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 9 of 15 No comment on this request. No comment on this request. No comment on this request. No impact/comment on this request. No comment on this request. No comment on this request. A sewer line located within a sixteen (16) foot generic subdivision easement, with no drainage facility, exists on the property; however, no license agreement with the county is needed as fences are allowed in sewer easements. Supplemental Analysis Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Virginia Department of Health Real Property Page 11 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 10 of 15 Applicant’s Concept Plan Page 12 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 11 of 15 Applicant’s Concept Plan - Continued Page 13 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 12 of 15 Exterior View Interior View Fence and Wall Construction View Page 14 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 13 of 15 This variance to the fence height shall be limited to the height and location as depicted within the staff report in the Applicant’s Concept Plan. No other walls or fences shall be permitted except those in compliance with Zoning Ordinance requirements. (P) Condition Page 15 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 14 of 15 Subdivision Plat Page 16 of 40 Michael Fahl 25VA1345 Page 15 of 15 Applicant  Applicant’s Contact: Michael Fahl (804-875-1118) Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals  Thomas Jenkins (804-318-8898) jenkinsth@chesterfield.gov Staff  Planning Department Case Manager: Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) somervella@chesterfield.gov  Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov  Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Christopher Harding (804-971-0399) hardingc@chesterfield.gov  Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov  Transportation – Virginia Department of Transportation: Dustin Dunnagan (804-674-2384) Dustin.Dunnagan@vdot.virginia.gov  Utilities: Jamie Bland (804-751-4439) blandj@chesterfield.gov  Virginia Department of Health: Richard Michniak (804-748-1695) Richard.Michniak@vdh.virginia.gov Case Contacts Page 17 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 1 of 15 25VA1373 – John Johnstone Magisterial District – Bermuda Applicant's Contact – John Johnstone (434-808-5604) BZA Public Hearing – March 4, 2026 Time Remaining 90 Days Case Manager Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) Request Variance Variance to use a parcel of land which fronts on a dedicated, but unimproved public road (Orlando Avenue) for dwelling purposes. Staff Recommendation Approval The Property 10618 Orlando Avenue - Lots 11 and 12 Block 15 Site Size 0.16 Acre Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Figure 2: Access View Image NOTE FOR THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS: Recommended conditions, an access plan, a relocated access plan, and a subdivision plat are in this report. STAFF - APPROVAL  Strict application of the Ordinance requirements for public road frontage would unreasonably restrict use of the Property.  The request contains conditions that are unique to the Property.  No practical alternatives exist that would eliminate the need for this variance request. Recommendation Page 18 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 2 of 15 PLANNING The applicant has requested to convert this record from the requirements of Chapter 19.1 of the Zoning Ordinance (Residential R-7) to the development regulations provided in Chapter 19.2 of the Zoning Ordinance, specifically Semi-Urban Neighborhood (SU), Option 2. Since the Property consists of recorded lots within an existing subdivision, the applicant is permitted to use the least stringent bulk standards of the zoning district that the Property was converted to within Chapter 19.2. In this situation, the existing lots meet all bulk requirements of Option 2 with the exception of the required road frontage. Zoning Ordinance Update Page 19 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 3 of 15 Background  The Board of Zoning Appeals hears requests for no public road frontage for parcels meeting one of the following criteria:  Recorded prior to April 1976  Subdivided for a member of the property owner’s immediate family  Recorded through the plat validation process  The Zoning Ordinance requires a property being used for dwelling purposes to have a minimum of twenty- five (25) feet of public road frontage for properties zoned Semi-Urban Neighborhood (SU), Option 2.  Properties were created in December 1931 recorded as part of Bellmeade Subdivision, recorded prior to County road frontage requirements.  The applicant purchased the Property on October 24, 2025. The Property is encompassed as a zoning lot which is comprised of two (2) properties; Lots 11 and 12, Block 15 of Bellmeade Subdivision.  The applicant intends to rectify the deficiency in required road frontage to building one (1) single family dwelling.  The lack of public road frontage may be rectified by receiving a variance for no public road frontage. Planning Page 20 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 4 of 15 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Zoning Ordinance Update ....................................................................................................................................................... 2 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 4 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Aerial ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 5 Case 24SN1266 – Concept Plan .............................................................................................................................................. 6 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 9 Supplemental Analysis .......................................................................................................................................................... 10 Environmental Engineering ............................................................................................................................................... 10 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................. 10 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................. 10 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................. 10 Utilities – Water and Wastewater .................................................................................................................................... 10 Virginia Department of Health .......................................................................................................................................... 10 Real Property .................................................................................................................................................................... 10 Conditions ............................................................................................................................................................................. 11 Access Plan – Exhibit A .......................................................................................................................................................... 12 Relocated Access – Exhibit B ................................................................................................................................................. 13 Bellmeade Subdivision Plat ................................................................................................................................................... 14 Case Contacts ........................................................................................................................................................................ 15 Table of Contents Page 21 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 5 of 15 Proposal A variance to use a parcel of land which fronts on a dedicated, but unimproved public road (Orlando Avenue) for dwelling purposes in Semi-Urban Neighborhood (SU) District. Construction of a single-family dwelling is proposed. Access Staff’s inspection of the Property revealed the following:  Maywood Street, the dedicated but unimproved right-of-way, serves two (2) single family dwellings. o One (1) dwelling was built in 1962 prior to County road frontage requirements. o One (1) dwelling achieves their required road frontage from Seminole Avenue; however, benefits from the roadway within the unimproved portion of Maywood Street (10525 Seminole Avenue).  From Seminole Avenue, the unimproved portion of Maywood Street ranges from nine (9) feet to twenty-three (23) feet in width. o The roadway is approximately twenty-three (23) feet in width at the entrance of Seminole Avenue and then quickly narrows to approximately twelve (12) feet six (6) inches. The roadway then further narrows to approximately nine (9) feet to the unimproved portion of Orlando Avenue. Planning Aerial 10525 Seminole Avenue Built in 1962 End of State Maintenance Property Orlando Avenue Maywood Street Seminole Avenue Page 22 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 6 of 15 o This unimproved portion of Maywood Street consists of very little gravel and has a sandy surface. The existing base of Maywood Street has random potholes and ruts.  Orlando Avenue, the dedicated but unimproved right-of-way, is fully vegetated and will require full construction.  The Property lies approximately 690 feet from the State maintained portion of Seminole Avenue.  The access roads do not meet the standards typically imposed with similar requests relative to construction. Conditions ensure compliance with minimum access road standards from Point A to Point B (Access Plan – Exhibit A) and future Point B to Point C (Relocated Access – Exhibit B) to support fire equipment and/or ambulances, as requested by the Chesterfield County Fire Department. Zoning History On June 25, 2025, the Board of Supervisors approved a residential development known as Bellmeade Subdivision that will develop with a mix of townhouse and single family dwellings, on property located north and west of the Property (see Case 24SN1266 - Concept Plan). Conditions of approval regulate a portion of the proposed access this Property intends to use (Maywood Street) and is subject to approval through the development process related to an emergency access. Maywood Street, which is unimproved between the Property to Seminole Avenue is proposed for an emergency access only road. As part of this development a Proffered Condition has been accepted that requires an emergency access along Maywood Street unless otherwise determined by the Planning Commission at the time of Plans Review. An emergency access is typically gated and does not allow for free flowing traffic within the gated area. Therefore, upon roads being accepted into Virginia Department of Transportation’s (VDOT) system within this proposed development, the access for the Property will be relocated to access through the newly accepted roads within the development known as Bellmeade Subdivision (see Relocated Access – Exhibit B). Case 24SN1266 – Concept Plan Page 23 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 7 of 15 Examination of Request The Zoning Ordinance sets forth approval criteria (19.2-66.E) for granting a variance if the applicant provides evidence that:  A strict application of this chapter would unreasonably restrict use of the property, or the variance would alleviate a hardship due to the physical condition of the property or improvements on the property at the time of the effective date of this chapter, as amended from time to time, or the variance would alleviate a hardship by granting a reasonable modification to a property or improvements thereon requested by, or on behalf of, a person with a disability;  The property was acquired in good faith and any hardship was not created by the applicant;  Substantial detriment will not occur to adjacent and nearby properties in the proximity of the geographic area in which the property is located;  The condition, situation or the intended use of the property is not of so general or recurring a nature as to make reasonably practicable the formulation of a general regulation to be adopted as an amendment to this chapter;  The application will not allow a use that is not otherwise permitted on the property, or change the zoning district classification for the property; and  The relief is not available through an administrative modification or special exception. Staff has examined the request and as required by the Zoning Ordinance, conditions upon which this request is based are unique to the Property and do not apply generally to other properties in the area. The Property is comprised of two (2) lots (11 & 12), recorded as part of Bellmeade Subdivision. The landowner purchased the property in October 2025 and did not create the hardship of no public road frontage. Staff encourages any construction accessing from a dedicated but unimproved right-of-way be developed with the infrastructure to support the use as the expectation is that all lots have State road frontage. Staff evaluated the possible construction of the unimproved portions of Maywood Street and Orlando Avenue to State standards. The unimproved portion of each right-of-way allows for roadway construction. However, one of VDOT’s standards for road acceptance is that a minimum of three (3) occupied dwellings must be served by the improved portion of the right-of-way. In this situation, only the single family dwelling, constructed in 1962, is served by Maywood Street. Although 10525 Seminole Avenue enjoys the benefit from the use of Maywood Street, this property achieves their required road frontage off Seminole Avenue which does not count toward VDOT’s Public Service Requirements. The Property being the possible second dwelling to be served by Maywood Street would not meet VDOT’s standards for State acceptance. Furthermore, no single family dwelling currently uses Orlando Avenue as access. Since the access would not meet VDOT’s Public Service Requirements, staff has determined no practical alternative exists that would eliminate the need for this variance request. Should this variance request be approved, the construction and maintenance responsibility of the proposed roadway located within the unimproved rights-of-way from Point A to Point B would fall on the landowner of the Property. Additionally, the public would have the benefit of using this future roadway since it is located within right-of-way. The landowner will be responsible for construction and maintenance until such time as the development known as Bellmeade Subdivision provides the road infrastructure relocating and shortening the maintenance responsibility for the Property owner between Point B to Point C. It should be noted that the landowner will not be responsible for any required road construction associated with the development of Bellmeade Subdivision, Case 24SN1266. Staff is supportive of requests where VDOT standards cannot be met; however, upon the third single family dwelling enjoying the use of this portion of Maywood Drive and/or Orlando Avenue staff will recommend the right-of-way be improved to State standards. Incrementally improving the street network provides for orderly development. Among other things, the applicant received the Property in good faith and did not create the Page 24 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 8 of 15 hardship. Given VDOT would not accept the road construction without three (3) occupied dwellings being served by the roadway, it is reasonable to support this request. As such, the strict application of the Zoning Ordinance requirements for road frontage would unreasonably restrict the use of the Property. Page 25 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 9 of 15 Current Zoning Map Page 26 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 10 of 15 A Resource Protection Area Designation (RPAD) is to be submitted prior to applying for a residential building permit on this property. A preliminary resource protection area (RPA) is shown to the south from Proctors Creek and along Orlando Avenue. The Fire Department recommends the owner provide a fifteen (15) foot all-weather road capable of supporting 75,000 pounds in order to provide access for fire apparatus and ambulances. This road should extend from the improved public road to the proposed dwelling. Traffic generated by this request will access via a section of Orlando Avenue and Maywood Street, which are dedicated but unimproved county rights of way (i.e., not in the State Highway System for maintenance). To use county rights of way, a license agreement must be obtained from the county. The license agreement usually requires the applicant to maintain the access road within the right-of-way. In similar situations throughout the county, residents often request the county to perform maintenance on the right-of-way even though a private maintenance agreement exists. County funds are not budgeted for this service. The unimproved section of Orlando Avenue and Maywood Street should be improved and accepted into the State System; therefore, a variance would not be required. No comment. Public water and sewer are not available. No adverse comments regarding the variance request. As summary states the property will be served by private septic and private well, applicant is made aware that prior to issuance of a building permit, owner shall apply (and obtain) a valid septic and well permit from the Health Department (HD). After septic and well permit issuance, the owner shall have the permitted well installed and subsequently inspected by the Health Department prior to obtaining HD release of the building permit. A license agreement is required for construction of a driveway to be built on county right-of-way. Contact Jeffrey Griggs for the application and processing information at (804) 748-1362. Supplemental Analysis Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Virginia Department of Health Real Property Page 27 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 11 of 15 1. License Agreement. Prior to approval of a building permit, the property owner shall provide a copy of the approved license agreement with the County to use the dedicated and unimproved County right- of-way from Point A to Point B, as shown on the plat attached to the staff report. The license agreement shall include a condition that requires the landowner of the Property to be responsible for maintenance of the access in accordance with Condition 2 of the Staff Report and that no structure or fence shall be constructed to block the access which shall extend to the proposed house location. (P) 2. Roadway Standards. A fifteen (15) foot wide roadway shall be constructed and maintained to all weather standards from Point A to Point B (Exhibit A), extended to the proposed house once the location has been determined, in accordance with the following standards: (a) This roadway shall consist of not less than the following: compacted soil sub-base with six (6) inches of compacted 21-B crushed stone or equivalent approved by Planning and Fire Departments, if an asphalt based surface is to be applied, it shall be designed and constructed to Chesterfield County subdivision street requirements or an equivalent design approved by the Subdivision Team, capable of supporting the projected 75,000 pound vehicle weight and shall be maintained to this standard. The roadway shall not be approved if it is rutted or potholed. (b) There shall be an additional three (3) foot clear area beyond the edge of the roadway. (c) There shall be a minimum vertical clearance of fourteen (14) feet of area above the roadway. (d) The roadway shall have a maximum grade of ten (10) percent with an appropriate transition at the street connection. (e) The minimum inside turning radius for any curve shall be approved by the Fire Department prior to building permit approval. (f) Any cross drains shall be designed per County standards and approved by the Department of Environmental Engineering. (P) 3. Roadway Inspection. Prior to Certificate of Occupancy, the Planning Department shall inspect this roadway to determine compliance as set forth above. (P) 4. House Numbers. The house number shall be installed on the mailbox or a pole and located at the driveway entrance of the State maintained road as well as at the driveway entrance to the property. The house numbers shall be displayed in at least four (4) inch high numbers. (P) 5. No Further Subdivision. The subject property shall not be further subdivided, including any family subdivisions, unless public road frontage is provided. (P) 6. Relocated Access. The relocated access as shown from Point B to Point C on Orlando Avenue shall be considered the new access plan when the development known as Bellmeade Subdivision, subject to Case 24SN1266, redevelops. This will provide for an alternative access within the newly constructed road network to connect to a nearby State road, as generally shown in the Relocated Access (Exhibit - B). The relocated access shall continue with the same conditions, construction and maintenance requirements as the original access. (P, F and T) 7. Roadway Inspection. Within thirty (30) days of the relocated access being installed, the Planning Department shall inspect this roadway to determine compliance as set forth above. (P) Conditions Page 28 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 12 of 15 Access is proposed across portions of Maywood Street and Orlando Avenue, which are dedicated but unimproved rights-of-way. Access Plan – Exhibit A Page 29 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 13 of 15 Relocated Access – Exhibit B Page 30 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 14 of 15 Bellmeade Subdivision Plat Page 31 of 40 John Johnstone 25VA1373 Page 15 of 15 Applicant  Applicant’s Contact: John Johnstone (434-808-5604) Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals  Thomas Jenkins (804-318-8898) jenkinsth@chesterfield.gov Staff  Planning Department Case Manager: Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) somervella@chesterfield.gov  Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1030) dunns@chesterfield.gov  Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Christopher Harding (804-971-0399) hardingc@chesterfield.gov  Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov  Transportation – Virginia Department of Transportation: Dustin Dunnagan (804-674-2384) Dustin.Dunnagan@vdot.virginia.gov  Utilities: Jamie Bland (804-751-4439) blandj@chesterfield.gov  Virginia Department of Health: Richard Michniak (804-748-1695) Richard.Michniak@vdh.virginia.gov Case Contacts Page 32 of 40 Kristin Shreffler 26SE2002 Page 1 of 8 26SE2002 – Kristin Shreffler Magisterial District – Dale Applicant's Contact – Kristin Shreffler (804-366-2361) BZA Public Hearing – March 4, 2026 Time Remaining 90 Days Case Manager Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) Request Special Exception Special exception to permit personal dog keeping (continued keeping of four (4) personal dogs) in a Semi-Urban Neighborhood (SU) District. Staff Recommendation Denial The Property 5506 Swan Drive Site Size 0.41 Acre Figure 1: Aerial of Request Area – Click Image for Link to GIS Street View NOTE FOR THE BOARD OF ZONING APPEALS Recommended conditions and a fence exhibit are located within this report. STAFF - DENIAL  The proposed use may have an adverse effect on the health, safety or welfare of persons residing on adjacent property or in this neighborhood.  The keeping of four (4) dogs is incompatible with the permitted uses in the Semi-Urban Neighborhood (SU) District.  There are no conditions that will be adequate to address the negative impacts that keeping four (4) dogs on the Property may have on this residential area. Recommendation Page 33 of 40 Kristin Shreffler 26SE2002 Page 2 of 8 Recommendation .................................................................................................................................................................... 1 Table of Contents .................................................................................................................................................................... 2 Aerial – Fence Construction .................................................................................................................................................... 3 Planning................................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Current Zoning Map ................................................................................................................................................................ 5 Supplemental Analysis ............................................................................................................................................................ 6 Environmental Engineering ................................................................................................................................................. 6 Fire & Emergency Medical Services .................................................................................................................................... 6 Transportation - County Department of Transportation .................................................................................................... 6 Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation ................................................................................................... 6 Utilities – Water and Wastewater ...................................................................................................................................... 6 Virginia Department of Health ............................................................................................................................................ 6 Conditions ............................................................................................................................................................................... 7 Case Contacts .......................................................................................................................................................................... 8 Table of Contents Page 34 of 40 Kristin Shreffler 26SE2002 Page 3 of 8 History  This is the initial request for personal dog keeping by the applicant.  This request is a result of a zoning complaint. Proposal The applicant desires to keep four (4) adult dogs; therefore, a special exception to permit personal dog keeping is necessary.  The applicant indicates she has one (1) neutered male Lab mix; two (2) spayed female Siberian Husky’s and one (1) spayed female Golden Retriever/Borzoi mix.  The dog’s range in age from one (1) to twelve (12) years old. The applicant states: “My four (4) dogs are either spayed or neutered. All dogs are up to date on their shots and well taken care of. Due to age and health conditions of two (2) of the dogs we take shorter walks on leash. The other two (2) dogs, I will take for long walks in our neighborhood on leash. There are days where I will take one (1) of Aerial – Fence Construction Planning Missing fence Page 35 of 40 Kristin Shreffler 26SE2002 Page 4 of 8 the dogs to the dog park and let her run around off leash. The time we spend at the dog park is weather dependent. The dogs are well taken care of and well loved. They are friendly, loving, and spoiled. Last year we had to have a section of the fence removed so that two sheds and a tree could be removed from the property. It is my intent to have the entire fence redone and instead of the chain-link fence, put up a taller wooden fence. The fence is in good condition overall; that section [that is missing] unfortunately had to be removed to accommodate the equipment needed to remove the tree and sheds. I am asking for a private kennel permit to keep my four family dogs. There would be no impact on my neighbor’s or community.” Examination of Request Staff’s inspection of the property revealed the following:  The property is surrounded by single-family dwellings.  The dwelling is located approximately 130 feet from Swan Drive, with existing mature vegetation that provides for a visual barrier from the right-of-way. However, the applicant intends to allow the dogs access to the rear yard, which may adversely impact adjacent properties.  The rear yard is partially fenced with a four (4) foot chain-link fence. The existing fence has vines and growth along the majority of the fence line; therefore, staff is unable to assess the condition of the fence. A portion of the rear western fence line is missing and does not provide for containment of the dogs. This is addressed in Condition 7 of the report should the request be approved (see Aerial – Fence Construction).  Staff did not observe any dogs at the time of the inspection.  The fence needs maintenance to provide a secure outdoor area for the dogs.  Use is not in character with the residential district. The keeping of four (4) dogs within the residential district may have negative impacts on adjacent property relative to barking and smell. Page 36 of 40 Kristin Shreffler 26SE2002 Page 5 of 8 Current Zoning Map Page 37 of 40 Kristin Shreffler 26SE2002 Page 6 of 8 No comment. No comment. No comment. No comment. No comment. N/A Supplemental Analysis Environmental Engineering Fire & Emergency Medical Services Transportation - County Department of Transportation Transportation - Virginia Department of Transportation Utilities – Water and Wastewater Virginia Department of Health Page 38 of 40 Kristin Shreffler 26SE2002 Page 7 of 8 1. This special exception shall be granted to and for Kristin Shreffler, exclusively, and shall not be transferable nor run with the land. (P) 2. This special exception shall be granted for a period of three (3) years from the date of approval and may be renewed upon satisfactory reapplication and demonstration that the keeping of these four (4) dogs has not proved a detriment to the adjacent property or the area in general. (P) 3. All dogs shall be kept in the existing dwelling. Whenever the animals are allowed outside the dwelling, they shall be on a leash or within the fenced area under appropriate supervision. (P) 4. Should any one (1) of the dogs be given, sold or pass away, it shall not be replaced. (P) 5. All areas associated with the keeping of the dogs shall be cleaned and made free of waste on a daily basis. In addition, the property owner shall dispose of the waste in a proper manner. (P) 6. The applicant shall provide a history of each dog, such as age, sex, color, and size as well as a photo to the Planning Department upon request of the approval of the special exception. (P) 7. Within thirty (30) days of approval of this request, the applicant shall complete the construction of a fence that provides for containment of the dogs. (P) Conditions Page 39 of 40 Kristin Shreffler 26SE2002 Page 8 of 8 Applicant  Applicant’s Contact: Kristin Shreffler (804-366-2361) Secretary to the Board of Zoning Appeals  Thomas Jenkins (804-318-8898) jenkinsth@chesterfield.gov Staff  Planning Department Case Manager: Amy Somervell (804-748-1970) somervella@chesterfield.gov  Environmental Engineering: Scott Dunn (804-748-1083) Dunns@chesterfield.gov  Fire & Emergency Medical Services: Christopher Harding (804-971-0399) hardingc@chesterfield.gov  Transportation - County Department of Transportation: Steve Adams (804-751-4461) adamsst@chesterfield.gov  Transportation – Virginia Department of Transportation: Dustin Dunnagan (804-674-2384) Dustin.Dunnagan@vdot.virginia.gov  Utilities: Jamie Bland (804-751-4439) blandj@chesterfield.gov  Virginia Department of Health: Richard Michniak (804-748-1695) Richard.Michniak@vdh.virginia.gov Case Contacts Page 40 of 40

Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.