RecordWell Data

Board of Supervisors Meeting - November 19, 2025 — Other

Chesterfield County · Chesterfield County · Board of Supervisors · meeting of Nov 19, 2025 · Other

Open the original document More from Chesterfield County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

11/19/2025 Page 1 of 1 Citizen Comments Received Through the Comment Portal November 19, 2025, Board of Supervisors Meeting Comment Type Comment Name District 25SN1239 - Meadowville Communicati on Tower I strongly OPPOSE 25SN1239 - Meadowville Communication Tower. This proposed tower would permanently alter the visual and economic character of our neighborhood, reduce nearby property values, introduce avoidable environmental risks, and contradict existing zoning priorities that protect residential aesthetics and open space. Given available alternatives such as co- location or small-cell technology, this freestanding tower is neither necessary nor compatible with the community’s long-term interests. Robert Zoppa Bermuda 23SN0113 - Shady Hill Rezoning and Exceptions The Shady Hill community still needs our help. While the County and Roseland Communities have improved the zoning exceptions to benefit the community, there are still several important items to minimize displacement, destruction and disruption. First, the community needs a more reasonable and flexible timeline. They also need more details about temporary housing. We need to prevent eviction, provide affordable replacement units and compensate affected residents justly and fairly. Finally, the community needs quarterly compliance meetings to ensure that these are all taking place. Melinda Lewis Midlothian Partnership for Smarter Growth 701 E. Franklin St. Suite 800 Richmond, VA 23219 To Chesterfield Board of Supervisors: My name is Finn Pollard, and I work for the Partnership for Smarter Growth. We’re a local non-partisan, non-profit, educating and advocating for a Chesterfield that plans sustainably, grows inclusively, and connects communities. We believe that local land use regulations should benefit people, not harm them. As such, we support the Shady Hill Association of Residents Empowered and ask the Board of Supervisors to take the time needed to continue to work with the Resident Association and the Applicant to honor the priorities of the people most affected by this code enforcement and rezoning process. In April of this year, I visited Shady Hill to door-knock and flyer about this zoning case. The first person we talked to there was a resident whose home was marked for removal. She had just had a major surgery and wasn’t mobile. I ended up standing rather awkwardly in the living room as someone informed her that the County had cited her home as being too close to her neighbors’ homes, and the landowner had requested a re-zoning to remove out of compliance homes and put other homes in the area. This was the first she’d heard of any of this, and she had no idea what was going to happen to her home and her family. To stay in the neighborhood, families like this woman’s have a couple of options: they could pay a lot of money that they don’t necessarily have to fix an issue they didn’t necessarily create, the property owner could help with the costs, the county could be flexible in their enforcement of the zoning, or some combination of these three options. The county has the legal power to create and enforce a zoning code to protect public health and safety. However, aspects of the MH-1 and MH-3 zoning districts in the existing code are deeply inflexible, especially when it comes to residents’ homes, and overstep a line between protecting public health and weaponizing zoning. While accountability is needed to ensure the park-wide infrastructure is safe, such as with the sewer/water systems, and residents have healthy living conditions, requiring residents alone to bring their homes into compliance on the current timeline is not the answer. It would break apart the neighborhood and leave many families without a home. That kind of inflexible zoning and enforcement does not lead to better public health or safety and is contradictory to smart growth outcomes. PSG applauds the work that the county has put in supporting Shady Hill residents and collaborating with them to make the code work. We ask the Board of Supervisors to continue this commitment to help secure a safe and fair result for Shady Hill. Thank you for your time, Finn Pollard Partnership for Smarter Growth 11/17/2025 This letter and all attachments transmitted with it may contain legally privileged and confidential information intended sole ly for the use of the addressee. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, any reading, dissemination, distribution, copying, or other use of this letter or its attachments is strictly prohibited. If you have received this message in error, please notify the sender immediately and destroy this letter and all copies and backups thereof. Thank you. 203 Richmond Way • University of Richmond, Virginia 23173 • (804) 289 -8921 November 5, 2025 Via Email Only Jim Ingle, Chair Chesterfield County Board of Supervisors P.O. Box 40 Chesterfield, VA 23832 IngleJ@chesterfield.gov Re: Shady Hill, 23SN0113, Rezoning and Exceptions Dear Chairman Ingle, Vice-Chairman Miller, and Members of the Board, We write on behalf of the Shady Hill Association of Residents Empowered (SHARE), the resident association for Shady Hill Manufactured Home Community, located in the Bermuda District of Chesterfield, Virginia. We are community organizers and attorneys from three firms, including a law school clinic, who are working collectively to assist the residents of Shady Hill in understanding and asserting their rights during the ongoing code enforcement and rezoning process between Shady Hill MHC, LLC (the property ow ners) and Chesterfield County. Shady Hill Manufactured Housing Community has existed as a mobile home park since the 1960s. In 2022, Roseland Communities, through Shady Hill MHC, LLC (hereinafter, the “Applicant”) purchased the property. In 2023, the Applicant applied for the property to be rezoned from MH1 to MH3 to address numerous zoning and building violations in the park. The residents, their advocates and allies, County staff, and the Applicant have met several times as part of this case, and the residents are appreciative of the support of County staff during this process. About one hundred families call Shady Hill home, and nearly all of these homes represent families’ only shelter and sole source of wealth. Over the past two years, their total rent has risen about 80% (almost doubled). Many of the families work hard but have limited incomes and have nowhere else to go if they are displaced. Residents are committed to helping bring their community into compliance while prioritizing health and safety and people's housing and property rights. We strongly believe a more reasonable plan will lead to better outcomes for all. 2 In light of the upcoming Board of Supervisors meeting on November 19, 2025, we write to share the following outstanding requests of the residents and their representatives and allies to the County and the Applicant: 1) More Reasonable and Flexible Timeline: Currently, the implementation timeline requires that residents begin relocating units and removing additions before the final Site Plan is completed and approved, meaning that some units or additions may be unnecessarily removed (or that we may learn of units or additions that need to be removed during this process) . We request that the timeline ensure that the final Site Plan must be approved before removal of any additions or units begins. To ensure transparency, we request that residents be given the opportunity to be present (or have a representative present) when final measurements are taken. Additionally, before any compliance work begins, we request that the Applicant coordinate a meeting with all affected residents and the relevant County staff , and that the County be involved before and during any removals/modifications of additions or relocations of units – to ensure residents are coming into compliance correctly and safely. a. Residents should be given the dignity and autonomy to come into compliance or move into a replacement unit on a timeline that actually works for them, not be subject to strict deadlines and arbitrary random drawings under threat of eviction. There is no need to mandate that 4 homes be removed every 6 months over the course of 36 months when there are only 10 homes in total designated to be removed, some of which will instead be relocated. b. We request that the County ensure that discretion for extensions to the deadlines provided to the Applicant identified in the Proffers shall also be provided to the residents, when necessary. For example, we suggest the following language be added to references of residents’ deadlines : i. Provided that the delay is not caused by the Applicant or the Owner/Occupant of the “Addition Removal Unit” or Relocation Unit, the deadlines provided in this phasing plan shall be extended day -for-day, if justified based on documentation from the Owner/Oc cupant of the unit regarding factors that necessitate the extension such as the time required to coordinate inspections, complete the work, conduct any repairs, contractors’ schedules, and availability of necessary materials and on-site housing. 2) Details of Temporary Housing: The temporary housing that the Applicant is required to provide is not sufficiently detailed . We request that the following additional details be incorporated into the plan to ensure that all residents affected have adequate housing: a. The Applicant must ensure that for each resident who is asked to relocate, whose unit is to be removed, and/or whose addition is to be removed or modified, it provides a unit in the community to ensure uninterrupted access to housing. b. This temporary housing should be at no cost to residents. c. The housing should be provided for at least 90 days , with more time provided as needed on a case-by-case basis, as agreed by the resident and the Applicant. 3 d. All tenants, including those whose homes are affected while modifying or removing additions or relocating homes at any point during this process, should be guaranteed on-site housing before they are expected to begin work on their homes. 3) Prevent Evictions: The current plan encourages rather than prevents the Applicant from forcibly removing residents from their homes through the courts. We request that the County ensure the Applicant does not evict people from their homes due to the County’s code enforcement and the related rezoning process while residents attempt to come into compliance. We understand that the Applicant will retain the authority to evict residents for lease violations unrelated to the rezoning process. The Applicant should commit to allow residents to voluntarily comply under reasonable deadlines, with a written commitment to not use the courts to forcibly remove people from their homes. We further note that while revising this plan, the Applicant has already evicted residents, including families with children, disabled residents, and elderly residents – some who are now homeless. They are actively trying to evict more residents later this month. 4) Allow Affordable Replacement Units: We request that the plan allow residents to purchase homes regardless of the unit's age, so long as the unit is certified by the Department of Housing and Urban Development and meets minimum life and safety requirements. Although we appreciate the increase from 10 years to 20 years, this limitation continues to unnecessarily limit residents’ affordable options. a. The Applicant has shared with residents that replacement units may be used as rentals, sold through rent-to-own arrangements, or financed through a 3rd party For transparency with residents, the Board, and the public, we ask for the Applicant to provide specific details on these terms, or at the very least, make a commitment to negotiate these terms with SHARE. 5) $5,000 for Costs of Removal/Relocation: Currently, only those owners of the 17 units specifically identified on sheet C4 will be paid the $5,000 by the Applicant. If someone’s home needs to be demolished, we request that the Applicant commit to covering that cost. We request that the Applicant pay any owners of units who, as part of the process of coming into compliance, are required to remove their unit or addition in the future and who may have not yet been identified (for ex ample, those affected by item 12 of the Textual Statement). 6) Quarterly Compliance Meetings with County and Applicant: In addition to the quarterly reports, we request that the County and Applicant commit to offering quarterly meetings with residents affected by the rezoning to discuss how they can come into compliance and strategize all available options for them to avoid displacement. 7) Safety from Route 1 and Recreation Areas: The County must ensure that the Applicant incorporates significant safety measures. There have been several high-speed moving accidents that entered the community, which caused property destruction and even fatalities. Much of the Applicant’s proposed Recreation Areas are within dangerous proximity to the highway, with only some light landscaping in between. The current plan 4 does not require any safety improvements along Route 1. More generally, the Applicant and the Planning Director should incorporate resident input for the Recreation Areas. 8) Fences: The Applicant should commit to allowing residents to keep fences so long as they are no more than 4’ tall and made with appropriate construction materials. It is our understanding that similar communities have fences and will be permitted to have fences. These structures are important to residents’ privacy, safety, and enjoyment. They keep children and pets safe. We sincerely appreciate the support of Chesterfield County staff, Planning Commission, and Board of Supervisors members during this process, as well as the willingness of the Applicant to improve the plan. If either party is open to any of the above suggestions in concept, we would be more than happy to supply specific legal language to amend the relevant Proffer. Additionally, ahead of the Planning Commission meeting, we sent some suggested Proffer language to the Planner, Rich Saunders, and the Applicant, which we are happy to provide. Thank you so much for your time and consideration. Should you have any additional questions, please do not hesitate to contact us at Cassie.Powell@richmond.edu / (804) 215-6754 and Gustavo@justice4all.org / (757) 613-3514. Sincerely, ACCESS TO JUSTICE CLINIC, UNIVERSITY OF RICHMOND SCHOOL OF LAW Cassie A. Powell, Esq., MSW Assistant Professor of Law for Legal Practice Director, Access to Justice Clinic LEGAL AID JUSTICE CENTER Catherine Cone Legal Director, Housing and Consumer Justice Program Gustavo H. Espinosa Senior Community Organizer / Policy Advocate, Housing and Consumer Justice Program VIRGINIA POVERTY LAW CENTER Daniel Rezai, Esq. Housing Attorney, Manufactured Housing Law Specialist SHADY HILL RESIDENT ASSOCIATION EMPOWERED CC: Dr. Mark Miller | Supervisor, Midlothian District (millermark@chesterfield.gov) Jessica Schneider | Supervisor, Clover Hill District (schneiderjes@chesterfield.gov) 5 Kevin Carroll | Supervisor, Matoaca District (CarrollKevin@Chesterfield.gov) Rich Saunders | Principal Planner, Chesterfield (SaundersRi@chesterfield.gov) Shady Hill Association of Residents Empowered ( shadyhillresidentes@gmail.com) Tim Henderson | Manager, Roseland Communities (tim@roselandcommunities.com) Kerry Hutcherson, Esq. | Counsel for Roseland Communities & Shady Hill MHC, LLC (kerry@johnsonlawva.com) Please forward to other parties as needed.

Source: Chesterfield County website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.