RecordWell Data

Minutes (June)

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Jun 15, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Historic Preservation Commission Minutes of June 15, 2026 MEMBERS PRESENT: Peter Alexander Austin Englund, Vice-Chair Michael Erquiaga, Chair Palmer Ferguson Emmett Lifsey Dr. Gerry Sherayko MEMBERS ABSENT: Tracey Langseth OTHERS PRESENT: Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission ; Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning Technician; and the public. ROLL CALL: After a quorum was established, Chair Erquiaga called the meeting to order at 4:06 p.m. 1. CONSENT AGENDA: Commissioner Lifsey made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko, and passed by a unanimous vote. 2. OLD BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate -Englund): Request of Oscar Rodriguez to install front porch lighting at 617 Washington Street. (HPC2605-0003) Mr. Oscar Rodriguez was present to represent the application. He was requesting approval to install lighting on the front porch of the home. S everal different options had been submitted to the Commission. He did not have a preference on the type of light fixture. Commissioner Englund said that the flush mount light fixture s would be safe options to install and he would be fine with any of the options that were presented. Commissioner Ferguson shared agreement. Commissioner Sherayko agreed that the flush mount light fixtures would work. None of the other light fixtures presented would be suitable. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the use of one of the four flush mount light options for the front porch as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Ferguson and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Langseth 1 2 3. NEW BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate-Alexander): Request of Ceason Morris to install rear fencing at 1001 Jackson Street. (HPC2605-0002) Ms. Ceason Morris was not present to represent the application. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler explained that the applicant would like to install a fence at the rear of the property. The fence would sit above the existing stone wall and would be wood, have a flat top, and be painted a stone-like color to match the stone wall. Commissioner Englund made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Langseth 1 b) COMMENT: Discuss the proposed demolition of the front half of the Downtown YMCA structure and the construction of a new addition that includes façade improvements, a second story, redefined primary entrance, updated exterior materials, and signage. Mr. Jason Burger and Ms. Hannah Marin of Dominion Seven Architects were present to represent the application. Mr. Burger explained that they were there to gain in put and direction from the Commission for moving this project forward. It has been ongoing since 2019 but Dominion Se ven Architects got involved in 2022. The Downtown YMCA structure is a non -contributing mid-century institutional community building. The structure does not represent the surrounding neighborhood and should not be evaluated in the same way as other historical structures. The Downtown YMCA is considered an anchor of the Downtown area, yet the front façade of the building is not the most welcoming . One of the main goals of this project would be to enhance the curb appeal of the building to make it more approachable and draw the community in. For the interior, the plan would be to improve the circulation of the building by adding a central staircase and natural lighting throughout. The front third of the building would be demolished and rebuil t with additional stories to allow for more flexibility. The existing structure cannot structurally support additional stories, which was an unexpected added cost to the project. Currently, two potential new front facades are being considered. Façade option B has a mix of materials, which is not the final intent. It was a way to show all the possible options at once. The final product will be symmetrical, rather than contain different configurations and materials. This is the preferred option by the YMCA. Option A is more restrained . It is likely that t he YMCA was included in the Diamond Hill Historic District boundary because of the houses surrounding it. The YMCA does not have similarities to the other surrounding buildings and homes within the district . He then asked for clarification as to how historic district boundar ies are created and what the process to remove a property from the historic district is. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler responded that removing a property from the historic district is a public hearing process and final decision by City Council. It is the same process to establish historic district boundaries. Mr. Burger continued with his presentation, reiterating that the YMCA’s goal is to create a more inviting exterior. He asked if the Commercial Design Review Guidelines were the correct framework that should be used when considering the design for this project and if there were any elements within the two proposed facades that presented an issue. The budget for this project is limited and the YMCA would like guidance and a clear path forward. 3 Chair Erquiaga explained that the Commission does not typically comment on preliminary designs and the conversation may not indicate how a formal vote would go. The YMCA building was built in 1955 and was non-contributing. The structure was different from the other buildings in the Diamond Hill Historic District and was located at the edge of the district. Commissioner Lifsey said that when the Diamond Hill historic district was established the building had not been old enough to be considered contributing. Ms. Mergenthaler responded that the age of the building was not the only factor in its status as non- contributing. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the district nomination had any specific language regarding the YMCA building. Commissioner Sherayko commented that when considering the border of the historic district it seemed that the building was only added so that a few more houses could be included within the district. Ms. Mergenthaler elaborated that the nomination stated that, “this building does not contribute to the historic character of the district.” Mr. Burger commented that if it were not for the homes beside the YMCA then the building would likely not be within the historic district boundary. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the district were to be established today, would the YMCA building still be considered non-contributing. At its current age , the building is old enough to be considered contributing and there is often a wide range of historic styles within every district. Ms. Mergenthaler replied that the building was specifically called out for being non -contributing to the historic character of the district, which isn’t always done when age is the main reason. Commissioner Lifsey agreed. Ms. Mergenthaler stated that from staff’s perspective the demolition is not necessarily the question at hand, the new construction should be the Commission’s focus. Commissioner Sherayko stressed that the YMCA should not be trying to recreate an old look as it would be too artificial. The building is in the historic International style of the 1950s. He would be comfortable with the design concept of façade B once the design materials were finalized. Commissioner Lifsey said that façade B was fine for the most part. There were a few items that should be considered; wood should not be used as a material ; the middle section should be shorter in height; and the colors should lean more toward gr ay tones. Façade A was too stark and too white; it was not a “quiet” enough design. Commissioner Sherayko asked Mr. Burger which façade was the preferred option for them. Mr. Burger replied that there had been a bit of indecision within the YMCA board, which is why they had presented two façade options. At the current moment façade B is the preferred option. Commissioner Ferguson agreed with several of Commissioner Lifsey’s points and was inclined to support façade B. He recommended that they consider treating this as an entry and background building an d make the background section quieter. 4 Commissioner Englund said that façade B paid homage to the original international style of the building and liked how the front was broken into sections instead of being one large mass. He recommended that they have more windows and should consider finding a building material that ties in more with the original building to use as a repeating theme . The structure was within the Diamond Hill Historic District and is one of the first buildings that introduces people to the district. He was fine with the colors, and he noted that the Diamond Hill Historical Society did not generally note problems with the more colorful aspect of façade B. Commissioner Sherayko agreed that façade B does lean into the original international style. Commissioner Englund s uggested that they add some subtle details to the design to connect back to aspects of the original building. He said façade B was a good option. Commissioner Alexander stated that he had spent significant time looking at this proposal as he had done work at the YMCA . Several years back the building had some structural issues due to water intrusion coming from Washington St reet. He asked Ms. Mergenthaler to forward his initial recommendations to Mr. Burger and proceeded to give his prepared remarks: “After careful review of the revised redevelopment options presented for the Downtown YMCA, it is my professional opinion that Option B should be selected as the preferred architectural direction , subject to modest refinement of the entry portal composition. While both schemes demonstrate thoughtful consideration of contextual compatibility and institutional function, Option B ultimately provides the stronger long -term solution for the YMCA's mission, visibility, and civic presence within the City of Lynchburg. The fundamental responsibility of the YMCA extends beyond that of a traditional building occupant. For more than a century, YMCA facilities have served as community anchors dedicated to health, wellness, youth development, education, recreation, and civic engagement. As such, architecture must communicate openness, accessibility, vitality, and public welcome while simultaneously respecting the character of the surrounding historic environment. Option A succeeds in providing a dignified and restrained architectural composition. Its symmetrical organization, masonry expression, and institutional character contribute positively to the streetscape and demonstrate an understanding of traditional civic design principles. The scheme possesses a timeless quality that would likely age gracefully and remain visually appropriate for decades. From a purely preservation -oriented perspective, Option A represents the more conservative and predictable solution. However, preservation alone should not be the sole measure of success. Historic districts are living environments, not static museums. The challenge presented by this project is not merely to preserve context, but to create a facility capable of serving future generations while maintaining respect for its surroundings. In this regard, Option B demonstrates a more successful synthesis of contemporary civic architecture and institutional identity. The design establishes a stronger public presence, greater visual transparency, improved wayfinding, and a more welcoming relationship with the community. The enhanced glazing, clearly articulated entrance sequence, and distinctive architectural framing create a building that is immediately recognizable as an active civic destination rather than simply a renovated structure.” Mr. Burger stated that the YMCA was anxious to move forward and asked about next steps. Ms. Mergenthaler replied that the next step would be to revise the design and create building plans. The Commission will need to review finalized building plans showing materials, the locations of all windows, lighting, doors, and other aspects . It is not just the front façade that will need to be reviewed, but the whole building. Mr. Burger said that they had a design plan ready to go. Ms. Mergenthaler noted t hat the YMCA board should be aligned with the final design before it is submitted for formal review by the Commission . Any design changes after an initial approval would require additional review. 5 Mr. Burger replied that he did not foresee that as being a problem. 4. NEXT MEETING: The next regular meeting is scheduled for July 20, 2026. 5. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 4:56 p.m. ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________ Secretary Chair

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.