Minutes (April)
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Apr 20, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Historic Preservation Commission
Minutes of April 20, 2026
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Peter Alexander
Austin Englund, Vice-Chair
Michael Erquiaga, Chair
Palmer Ferguson
Emmett Lifsey
Dr. Gerry Sherayko
MEMBERS ABSENT:
Tracey Langseth
OTHERS PRESENT:
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission ; Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning
Technician; and the public.
ROLL CALL:
After a quorum was established, Chair Erquiaga called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m.
1. CONSENT AGENDA:
Commissioner Lifsey made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by
Commissioner Sherayko, and passed by a unanimous vote.
2. NEW BUSINESS
a) ACTION (Advocate-Ferguson): Request of William Maddox of Eagles Nest Regeneration,
Inc. to modify the rear stair tower and sunroom at 405 Cabell Street. (HPC2603-0007)
Mr. Rich ard Morris of Richard Morris Architecture, LLC was present to represent the application. The
request includes reconfiguring the rear staircase tower and rebuilding the sunroom.
Chair Erquiaga asked the representative to expand on the proposed modifications to the rear stair tower.
Mr. Morris explained that the stair tower was not original and had been built sometime in the late 1970s
or early 1980s. The tower has experienced extensive water damage throughout. The plan would be to
rebuild the tower with some changes , such as lowering the height; adding a roof; rebuild ing the stairs;
realigning the windows to fit the new stairs ; and add ing a small, covered porch . The goal would be to
bring the tower to scale with the building. Originally, that side of the house had open porches. The tower
was built as a second means of egress.
Commissioner Sherayko said he looked forward to the house being restored as it had been deteriorating
for years.
Mr. Morris responded that the group that now owns the house wants to restore it.
Commissioner Sherayko commented that he was fine with the tower portion of the project proposal.
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item two: rebuild and modify the sunroom
Mr. Morris explained that the sunroom was also not original to the ho use and was added in the late
1800s or early 1900s. The whole sunroom is in poor condition with cut two (2) x twelve (12) support
2
joists, a broken glass ceiling, and the room is pulling away from the house and collapsing off to the left .
The cut support joists are unable to handle the combined weight of the concrete flooring and the glass
roof. To address this , the plan is to completely rebuild the sunroom with a combination of salvaged
materials and replacement materials. The windows will be replaced with newer, insulated ones that
replicate the look of the o riginals. The glass roof will be replaced with a metal roof to reduce the weight.
Having insulated glass will make the sunroom a livable space. If the glass windows are approved for
replacement, they could label and store the original windows for preservation.
Commissioner Englund asked if the sunroom will be used as an actual bedroom.
Mr. Morris replied no, the sunroom will be used as additional dining space.
Chair Erquiaga asked what type of specific materials would be used.
Mr. Morris replied that the sunroom would be a bronze -colored metal roof; replacement windows would
be insulated double panes and be the same configuration as the original windows ; and the paneling
would be replicated . The stair tower will be stucco and scored ; the windows w ill be replaced w ith
insulated double pane; the metal roof would match the proposed sunroom roof; and composite materials
would be used for the covered porch.
Ms. Mergenthaler noted that this could be a conceptual approval , which would require the applicant to
submit a new application when ready with a final design and materials.
Mr. Morris said that the concept plan also showed a ten (10) foot fence, which enclosed the exhaust vent
for the future commercial kitchen. The fence and exhaust vent will be the only thing s added to the
outside of the house.
Commissioner Sherayko stated that he was okay with the stair tower rebuild as proposed, but had issue
with the sunroom. Replacing the windows should be reconsidered. Changing the sunroom roof to metal
was not a bad idea. He asked Mr. Morris if the sunroom glass roof was where the broken glass was.
Mr. Morris replied that the roof had several broken glass sections and the weight of it was contributing to
the sunroom pulling away from the house.
Commissioner Englund asked if there was any separation of the brick room that sits below the sunroom
from the building.
Mr. Morris replied no, the brick was holding. The sunroom is collapsing into the basement and pulling
away from the house at the same time.
Commissioner Englund said he was fine with the concept of the stair tower. The concrete flooring is the
main culprit of damage to the sunroom and while it would be preferable that the roof stay glass , it would
be fine if it was replaced with metal . The sunroom is a unique feature to this neighborhood, and the
original windows should be restored instead of replaced. He asked if the room would be air conditioned .
Mr. Morris replied there was no air conditioning, a mini split unit will likely be installed.
Commissioner Englund said that the solar gain would make replacing the windows with double pane
negligible.
Commissioner Lifsey said he agreed with Commissioner Englund. Energy conservation is not a valid
reason to remove original historic material. Realistically , the glass roof should also stay as the Re sidential
Design Review Guidelines are clear that original material should stay. It is a tough space, but the
3
Commission has consistently said that energy efficiency and heating/cooling is a nonissue within the
historic districts when it comes to historic materials.
Commissioner Sherayko asked about the proposed ten (10) foot fence.
Ms. Mergenthaler clarified that the fence and exhaust vent were not on this application. The applicant will
need to submit a new application for the fence to be reviewed.
Commissioner Lifsey said the concept for the tower was fine. He did not agree with allowing the sunroom
windows to be replaced. Rebuilding the sunroom does make sense structurally.
Commissioner Alexander asked the Commission if they could consider just replacing the glass in the
windows for the sunroom.
Commissioner Lifsey responded that glass could be replaced without removing historic integrity.
Commissioner Englund recommended Mr. Morris consider Histoglass as an alternative to replacing the
windows.
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the concept of the stair tower as submitted,
with the stipulation that final plans and materials are to be submitted at a future date and
receive separate approval. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the
following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the concept of the sunroom, with the
stipulation that existing materials (windows, glass roof, etc.) are to be reused and final
plans and materials are to be submitted at a future date and receive separate approval . The
motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
b) ACTION (Advocate -Sherayko): Request of Gospel Community Church to replace roof
sections at 1216 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2604-0002)
Mr. Christian Slack was present to represent the application. The request includes replacing an existing
asphalt shingle roof with a new asphalt shingle roof and replacing the back portion of the roof that is flat,
tar and gravel with an EPDM roof system.
Chair Erquiaga asked for clarification regarding materials.
Mr. Slack replied that the front shingle roof would be replaced with shingles . The back, flat portion would
be regraded to drain properly. An EPDM roof system would then be installed in place of tar and gravel.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the application as submitted . The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
4
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
c) ACTION (Advocate-Englund): Request of Saeed Abedini to replace a front light fixture at
508 Washington Street. (HPC2603-0006)
Mr. Saeed Abedini was present to represent the application. The original front light fixture was broken by
his movers, and he replaced it with a light fixture that he already had . He still has the original light fixture
hardware.
Commissioner Sherayko said the light fixture there currently is too big and takes away from the beauty of
the door. He asked if only the glass was broken from the original fixture.
Mr. Abedini replied that only the glass had been broken. He still had the original fixture. He chose the
current fixture based on the light fixtures his neighbors have. He said he was happy to replace the glass
and reinstall the original light fixture or replace it altogether with a different, appropriate fixture.
Commissioner Englund commented that having a hanging light fixture would be fine, but it would need to
be smaller so that it would not cover up the view of the front door. The light fixture that is currently there
is not appropriate.
Commissioner Sherayko said that within the Residential Design Review Guidelines it states that light
fixtures should not be too “Williamsburgy”. The front door is beautiful, and a new smaller , hanging light
would be fine . Mr. Abedini would need to get in touch with a glass blower to replace the glass in the
original light fixture.
Commissioner Alexander asked Mr. Abedini how old the original light fixture was.
Mr. Abedini replied that from what he had been told, everything on the home was original from the time
it was built, including the light fixture. He commented that the best option would be to replace the glass
in the original light fixture and reinstall it.
Commissioner Lifsey agreed that doing so would be the best option.
Commissioner Englund commented it may not be worth it , as Mr. Abedini would need to find a
replacement through salvage, a secondhand shop, or by hiring a glass blower.
Commissioner Ferguson made a motion to deny the application as submitted . The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
Mr. Abedini asked what the process would be to repaint the house.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler replied that Mr. Abedini would need to submit a new application and that it would
the same process and time frame as what he did for this meeting.
5
Commissioner Lifsey recommended that his contractors not use a high-pressure wash to strip the paint.
The wood will absorb that water and cause any new paint to peel off. Stripper can be used, but it needs
to be scraped off rather than high pressure washed off.
Mr. Abedini asked what he would need to do to build a new home on an empty parcel in the historic
district.
Commissioner Alexander explained that he would need to speak with Community Development to find out
if it is a buildable lot.
Chair Erquiaga added that Mr. Abedini would need to utilize the Residential Design Review Guidelines
when it came to design concepts for a new home in the historic district.
3. OLD BUSINESS
a) ACTION (Advocate -Alexander): Request of Orlanda Burks of OMS REITT, LLC to do
extensive work at 1115 Jackson Street. (HPC2602-0008)
Mr. Orlanda Burks of OMS REI TT, LLC was present to represent the application along with his general
contractor Dre’Quan Mabins and designer Payton Mabins . He said they would like to go item by item to
address each one, starting with the siding. Their request is to keep the color of the siding white and
replace broken asbestos siding with non-asbestos siding.
Mr. Mabins added that a previous owner of the home had replaced a large portion of siding with vinyl on
the back of the house. He asked if that siding would need to be removed or if it could remain.
Chair E rquiaga replied that the Commission could not require them to take that siding down, though
overall, the house would look better if they did.
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item one: alter the front porch.
Mr. Burks asked if a column made from composite material would be approvable.
Chair Erquiaga asked what type of composite material it would be.
Ms. Mabins replied that it is called Endura Stone. The material is fiberglass and is not prone to rot or
weather. The composite would have a smooth, wood-like appearance.
Mr. Burks continued and said that they plan to repair the two (2) half columns on the front of the house.
Commissioner Lifsey asked Ms. Mergenthaler if the new columns matched the original columns.
Ms. Mergenthaler replied that the submitted columns appeared to have different dimensions from the
original existing columns.
Mr. Mabins responded that the original columns had a taper, starting small at the top and getting larger
at the bottom. The original columns had been unsalvageable.
Ms. Mergenthaler asked if the new columns could be created using the original columns as a template.
Mr. Burks replied that he would need to gather more information on that. Recreating the original columns
would need to be a special order.
6
Commissioner Englund asked where they found the designs for the wood columns.
Ms. Mabins responded that the company was called Pacific Columns. They custom build columns based
on the dimensions they are supplied with.
Commissioner Lifsey said that the columns would need to match the original taper, which seemed to be
ten (10) inches at the bottom and eight (8) inches at the top . He recommended that they use the
pilasters on the house as a template for the design of the new columns for the porch.
Mr. Burks asked if he would be able to remove the pilasters and replace them with eight (8) inch
columns.
Commissioner Lifsey replied that the pilasters were original and should not be removed. He asked if there
was a pilaster on the other end of the porch.
Mr. Burks replied yes, there was.
Chair Erquiaga asked Mr. Burks for more information regarding replacing the railing on the front porch.
Mr. Burks responded that the proposal was to replace the spindles, leave the top railing and add a fascia
board to the front to hide nails and the like.
Commissioner Lifsey said that the result of adding the fascia board would be a much larger profile than
the historical element that had been there. He explained to Mr. Burks that he can purchase a board that
has pre-done holes that the spindles will fit in cleanly.
Mr. Burks responded that they had submitted what Commissioner Lifsey was talking about but wanted to
know if they could modify their submittal to do the fascia board instead.
Commissioner Lifsey recommended they go with what had been submitted to the Commission for review.
Chair Erquiaga asked what type of flooring would be installed on the porch.
Mr. Mabins replied that most of the porch flooring was fine and would be cleaned and painted . The
ceiling of the front porch is falling down and they would like to remove it.
Commissioner Lifsey responded that if the ceiling of the porch was that rotted then they c ould remove
and replace it. The ceiling was most likely a four (4) inch beadboard. He said that any patching to the
porch floor should match what is there.
Ms. Mergenthaler clarified to Mr. Burks that before they remove and dispose of the ceiling materials, they
must measure them so that the new materials will match.
Commissioner Lifsey commented that they should use a different type of lattice for the front porch
skirting, as the one they were proposing is basic, off the shelf materials. They should be using a
horizontal or vertical as opposed to a diagonal design. The wood should also be chunkier as well.
Mr. Burks commented that originally it had been tin.
Ms. Mabins asked Commissioner Lifsey if they would be able to purchase the material premade as she
had not been able to find anything to match that.
Commissioner Lifsey said he was unsure if it could be purchased, but it was a simple one (1) by two (2).
7
Commissioner Englund said that the lattice could be DIY’d , though it would be a fair amount of work. He
suggested they check with Taylor Brothers or 84 Lumber.
Mr. Burks asked if they could leave the aluminum sheets there.
Ms. Mergenthaler clarified that the aluminum skirting had already been removed from the home and was
not currently in place.
Commissioner Lifsey commented that the important aspect is to have the dimensions correct. Visually the
wood pieces should be ¾ of an inch thick. The columns could be composite if they are the right
dimension.
Commissioner Sherayko asked if the porch could be left to be open air with no skirting.
Commissioner Englund recommended that the applicants look at ProWood as an appropriate material
option.
Ms. Mergenthaler responded that , per the foundation Guidelines within the Residential D esign Review
Guidelines, foundations “should be filled as traditional for the type and style of the house. Appropriate
materials include wood lattice, frame panels, and/or decorative wood boards. Many commercially
available lattice panels, particularly those with lighter weight, rough finish, and stapled slats are not
appropriate. Lattice panels should be set back from the fronts of the piers and should be painted with
colors that complement the exterior colors and appearance of the structure. ” She said it should not be
left open.
Mr. Burks responded that there was nothing there when he purchased the home.
Ms. Mergenthaler recommended that the commission table this portion of the application to allow the
applicants to come back with different materials.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve alterations to the front porch to include:
replacement of front porch columns with wood or composite (fiberglass) columns to match
the sizing and design of existing pilasters; repair the two existing pilasters; install 2 -in. x 4-
in. wood handrails and 2 -1/4-in. x 36 -in. wood turned spindles as submitted on the front
porch and stairs; repair wood porch flooring to match existing material, dimensions, etc.;
replace wood porch ceiling with beadboard to match existing material, dimensions, etc.; and
replace the metal underpinning with square -pattern wood lattice with a ¾ -in. profile as
discussed. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve replacing damaged siding with GAF
WeatherSide Purity Straight Fiber Cement Siding (12 -in. x 24-in.). The motion was seconded by
Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
8
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item three: Paint the exterior a new color scheme.
Mr. Burks said he would like to paint the house plum brown.
Commissioner Lifsey commented that with these historic homes the porch ceiling was typically painted an
eggshell blue color and the front porch flooring and stairs were a different color than the rest of the
house, usually dark grey. He likes the plum brown color, but not as the color for the whole house.
Mr. Burks responded that everything that had previously been painted green w ould be painted plum
brown. That would include the trim, railing, and flooring.
Commissioner Lifsey asked what color the main body of the house would be.
Ms. Mabins replied that it would be white.
Commissioner Lifsey responded that the house painted white with the trim plum would look stunning. He
did not think the porch floor being plum would be a wise choice. They would get less milage with a trim
color on the floor and steps as it would have more wear and tear. He asked if the handrails and spindles
would all be painted white.
Mr. Burks replied that they would like to paint the upper and lower railing plum.
Commissioner Lifsey asked what color the lattice under the porch would be.
Mr. Burks replied that it would be plum.
Commissioner Lifsey recommended that they use a dark color deck paint for the porch floor.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve painting the exterior in a new color scheme to
include: siding, columns, and spindles in “Ultra White”; window trim, handrails, and lattice in
“Plum Brown”; porch flooring in either “Plum Brown” or a dark gray color; and porch ceiling
in either an eggshell blue (light blue) or “Plum Brown”. The motion was seconded by
Commissioner Ferguson and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item four: Replace existing gutters on the front porch and upper roof with
white aluminum K-style gutters.
Mr. Burks explained the gutters on the house were not half round but had been damaged and flattened.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the repair and/or replacement of existing
gutters on front porch and upper roof with white aluminum K style gutters . The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
9
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item five: complete work to the roof.
Commissioner Lifsey asked if the roof was already slate on the main house and asphalt on the porch roof.
Ms. Mabins replied that it was.
Commissioner Englund asked what they meant by realigning the roof.
Mr. Mabins replied that the slate shingles near the edge need to be realigned and nailed down.
Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the in -kind replacement of the front porch roof
with black asphalt shingles and the realignment of slate on the main slate roof . The motion
was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
b) ACTION (Advocate-Erquiaga): Request of Alexcia & Jacquelin Junior Lenis of LaKay Capital, LLC to do
work to the front porch and gutters at 414 Clay Street. (HPC2602-0003)
Mr. Jacqueline Junior Lenis was present to represent the application. He had architectural plans drawn for
the front porch design plan with materials included. The front porch that is currently on the house will be
taken down and if approved, they will build the new front porch based on this design.
Commissioner Alexander said the design plan that was submitted looks different from the original porch.
He commented that the columns look to be fluted and tapered.
Ms. Mergenthaler asked Mr. Lenis if they still had the original pilasters.
Mr. Lenis replied that he did.
Commissioner Lifsey said that the design for the front porch roof was missing several elements that the
original roof had. The original roof had a monumental scale, and the submitted drawing does not match
those dimensions.
Commissioner Englund commented that counting the siding could be a way to determine the scale of the
original front porch roof. He said that the original front porch roof was “beefier” than what is being
shown on the drawings. The design lends itself to being heavier with the moldings. He advised that they
take the photo and use it to recreate the new front porch.
Mr. Lenis responded that the architect did not have the exact measurements to scale the drawing. He
commented that it would be a good idea to use the siding to scale the roof.
Commissioner Englund commented that they could also use the pilasters for the scale as well. He
recommended that they get in touch with an architect who knows how to do scaling for classical Roman
architectural design.
Commissioner Lifsey stated that the original porch was there to start with and the fact the whole porch
was demolished is the issue.
10
Commissioner Sherayko said the porch was in rough shape, but it was there. The new porch needs to
look like the original and the drawing provided does not match the original.
Commissioner Alexander said that this should be denied.
Mr. Lenis asked if the column design could be approved.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler replied that the commission had already determined that the columns do not
match the pilasters. Any design that the Lenis’ submit will need to match the pilasters.
Commissioner Lifsey recommended they use the pilasters as a template to replicate the columns.
Mr. Lenis asked if they could just put the iron columns back on since they don’t have the original
columns.
Ms. Mergenthaler explained that Commissioner Lifsey was recommending they use the original pilasters
that they do have as a template to create new columns that will match.
Commissioner Lifsey commented that there were plenty of companies who make columns for historic
homes.
Commissioner Alexander made a motion to deny the front porch portion of the application as
submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Lifsey, Sherayko 6
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Langseth 1
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item two: install hanging gutters on the main house.
Ms. Mergenthaler said that the applicant had not submitted any additional materials for the gutters. She
asked what style of gutter they planned to install on the main house.
Mr. Lenis said he was withdrawing the gutter portion of the application. They will include the gutters in
their next application.
4. NEXT MEETING:
The next regular meeting is scheduled for May 18, 2026.
5. ADJOURNMENT:
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:44p.m.
ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________
Secretary Chair
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.