RecordWell Data

Minutes (March 30)

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Mar 30, 2026 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Historic Preservation Commission Minutes of March 30, 2026 MEMBERS PRESENT: Peter Alexander Austin Englund, Vice-Chair Michael Erquiaga, Chair Tracey Langseth Emmett Lifsey Dr. Gerry Sherayko MEMBERS ABSENT: Palmer Ferguson OTHERS PRESENT: Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission ; Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning Technician; and the public. ROLL CALL: After a quorum was established, Chair Erquiaga called the meeting to order at 3:00 p.m. 1. CONSENT AGENDA: Commissioner Lifsey made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko, and passed by a unanimous vote. 2. NEW BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate -Alexander): Request of Ceason Morris to replace a portion of metal roofing at 1001 Jackson Street. (HPC2602-0005) Ms. Ceason Morris was present to represent the application. A rear portion of the roof , that is currently only a layer of ice shield membrane, will be replaced. The existing metal roofing will remain. Chair Erquiaga asked if she planned to only replace that section. Ms. Morris replied yes. Commissioner Alexander commented that it seemed there was metal being covered by the material near to the vent. Ms. Morris explained that there was a section of metal at the end of the membrane portion. The tall pipe vent will be removed since it is not connected to anything and sits over a hallway. There is also a small bathroom vent that will be removed. Commissioner Alexander asked for clarification from Ms. Morris about what she planned to do. Ms. Morris responded that c urrently water is pooling in this area of the roof. The contractor will be replacing the membrane and adding a small grade to allow for water runoff. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the new membrane will be put underneath the existing tin roof. Ms. Morris replied yes, the replacement will be the same as before , just with a slight sl ope down to the gutter. 2 Commissioner Lifsey said Ethylene Propylene Diene Monomer (EDPM) was an appropriate material for what is being done. Ms. Morris said over the years it has gotten worse . This portion of the roof is not viewable from the street, and the replacement will be painted to match the rest of the roof. Commissioner Englund asked if any of the existing metal sections of the roof would be removed. Ms. Mo rris replied that none of the existing metal roofing would be removed. The new EDPM will be tucked in under the existing metal sections of the roof. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 b) ACTION (Advocate -Alexander): Request of Orlanda Burks of OMS REITT, LLC to do extensive work at 1115 Jackson Street. (HPC2602-0008) Mr. Orlanda Burks of OMS REITT, LLC was present to represent the application. All the requested work that will be done will be to either repair or replace materials. Chair Erquiaga recommended that the Commission go through the items one at a time, starting with item one: alter the front porch . A portion of this item is after -the-fact. The spindles currently on the front porch are not correct. He asked why the original railing was removed. Mr. Burks replied that the original railing had been rotten and unsalvageable. Commissioner Lifsey said the railing that is currently installed was completely inappropriate for the historic district. Mr. Burks responded that when he purchased the house there was no railing on the porch. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler clarified that the house did have a porch railing in 2014 as shown in Google Street View, but at the time of Mr. Burks’ purchase there was no porch railing. The columns and stair railing were still intact when Mr. Burks purchased the house. Chair Erquiaga commented the new railing was not in-kind. Commissioner Lifsey said that the railing and columns that had been installed were not appropriate for the historic district. The railing and columns should be similar or match what had originally been there. Ms. Mergenthaler asked Mr. Burks if the stair railing had been intact. Mr. Burks replied that the stairs had been intact. He reiterated that the porch railings had not been intact. Ms. Mergenthaler asked if the stair railing had the same spindle design as the porch railing. Mr. Burks responded that he was unsure. 3 Commissioner Lifsey said Mr. Burks should use the stair railing spindles as a guide for installing appropriate porch railings. The same should be done for the columns. Mr. Burks said that his contractor had replaced everything. Commissioner Lifsey explained that a four (4) x four (4) column was not appropriate. The column would need to be round like the historic column that had originally been on the porch. Ms. Mergenthaler suggested to Mr. Burks that he should recreate the columns by using some of the original columns he still had. Ms. Burks said he would do whatever the Commission wanted him to as he was there to get guidance. Commissioner Sherayko informed Mr. Burks that the goal was to preserve the historical integrity of these buildings. Even though the porch railing was missing , there was evidence that showcases what had been there. Mr. Burks should use the railings and columns that had been there as a template for replacements. Mr. Burks commented that the stair railing was not appropriate as that had been changed before he bought the house. He explained his contractor had used the stair railing as a guide for doing the porch railings but not the spindles. Commissioner Sherayko acknowledged that houses do evolve. For example, the asbestos siding currently on the house was not the original siding material. Commissioner Lifsey noted that there had also been skirting enclosing the bottom of the porch. Mr. Burks asked if he would need to do a wood or aluminum railing. Commissioner Lifsey responded that wood would be appropriate. The railing would need to be of scale with the original railing. Mr. Burks asked if that would be specified in the Commission’s requirements. Chair Erquiaga replied that Mr. Burks would need to submit a design. Commissioner Lifsey suggested that Mr. Burks observe neighbor ing houses for examples of appropriate railing options. Ms. Mergenthaler recommended that the Commission table the item, which would allow Mr. Burks time to submit additional information. Commissioner Lifsey reiterated that Mr. Burk s should look around the historic district at other simple Queen Anne style houses for materials and designs to consider. The Commission is there to review what applicants provide. Mr. Burks said he was under the impression that the Commission would tell him what to do. Commissioner Lifsey explained that the Commission reviews what applicants submit, they are not there to design elements for applicants. Commissioner Sherayko asked for clarification on whether Mr. Burks was the one who installed the new railings and columns. 4 Ms. Mergenthaler responded that Mr. Burks installed the new railings and columns. Commissioner Sherayko stated that the railing and columns on the porch would need to be removed. The commission would not be able to make a decision until they see what Mr. Burks planned to replace with. Commissioner Alexander recommended that Mr. Burks to get in touch with a contractor that has experience with historic preservation. Commissioner Englund suggested that Mr. Burks use past photos of the home that show the original railing and columns as a guide. He also recommended he look through the Residential Design Review Guidelines. The goal is to capture the character of the house, not necessarily restore it to exactly how it was given the limited information. Commissioner Sherayko said that even if he used the photos for the railing , Mr. Burks would still need to resubmit before doing any work. Mr. Burks asked if he could at least leave the new columns and just wrap them. Chair Erquiaga stated that Mr. Burks would need to submit appropriate column options. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table alterations to the front porch . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 Chair Erquiaga moved on to item two: replace the rear steps. Mr. Burks said he had his contractor install the steps as there had been none for the rear door when he purchased the home. Commissioner Englund asked if the stairs would need a landing to meet building code. Chair Erquiaga responded that he was unsure, and the stairs may also need a railing. Commissioner Alexander commented that Mr. Burks would need to discuss that with his contractor. Commissioner Lifsey explained that usually there is a landing area installed. The building code would also likely require that there be handrailing for the stairs. The Commission generally does not review items for building code compliance. The back stairs do not have to match the front in terms of design, as this part of the house is not visible from the street. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the replacement of the rear steps with the stipulation that the stairs meet building code requirements . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 5 Chair Erquiaga moved on to item three : replace damaged siding with non-asbestos siding. He asked Mr. Burks to elaborate further on how much of the siding would be replaced. Mr. Burks replied that roughly twenty-five percent of the siding would be replaced. Commissioner Langseth asked if he had submitted the type of material that he would be replacing the asbestos siding with. Mr. Burks replied that he had not. Chair Erquiaga stated that the Commission would not be able to review item three without materials. Mr. Burks said that the siding would be replaced with like materials. Commissioner Langseth recommended that Mr. Burks submit what materials he wanted to replace the siding with in his next application. Commissioner Lifsey recommended he speak with his contractor. The replacement siding would need to be the same size and should have a similar texture to what was already there. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table replacing damaged siding. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 Chair Erquiaga moved on to item four: paint the exterior in the existing color scheme. Commissioner Langseth commented that it would be helpful for the Commission if Mr. Burks specified what color each feature of house would be painted such as the trim, railing, and windows. Commissioner Alexander recommended he submit an actual color scheme to the Commission. Mr. Burks responded that he planned to paint the house the same way it was currently. What was green would stay green and so on. Chair Erquiaga said that he would need to be more specific as some areas were missing paint. Commissioner Lifsey reiterated that the Commission could not tell Mr. Burks what should be white, green, and so on. The Commission is a review body; he needs to specify in his submittal what color each feature of the home will be painted. Commissioner Langseth made a motion to table paint colors . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 6 Chair Erquiaga moved on to item five : repair and refasten existing gutters and install gutters where missing. Mr. Burks said the current proposal is to repair and/or replace the existing gutter s, so the Commission could strike out the part of the application that requests installing new gutters . Later on, he may install new gutters on the house where they are missing, if he is financially able to. Commissioner Lifsey said the gutter along the upper portion of the house appeared to be a half round gutter in either a galvanized or copper material. That gutter is completely different from the gutter on the front porch. He asked Mr. Burks to elaborate further on what type of gutter he planned to replace with. Mr. Burks said he planned to replace the half round gutter and match it to the gutter on the front porch. Commissioner Lifsey responded that the half round gutter along the upper part of the home is very different from the gutter on the front porch. It is a historically accurate element of the home as opposed to aluminum OGEE gutters, which is not appropriate on a historical home. Mr. Burks asked if he would need to replace the gutter on the front porch if he was able to repair it. Commissioner Lifsey replied that the Commission could not tell him he had to take it off. Commissioner Sherayko asked if there were any downspouts on the main portion of the home. Mr. Burks replied that there are not. Commissioner Lifsey commented that he should consider getting down spouts. The half round gutter should also be replaced. Without the down spouts, it will do major damage to the home in the long term due to rotting. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table gutter work . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 Chair Erquiaga moved on to item six: repair windows with broken glass. Mr. Burks said he would only be replacing the broken glass of certain windows. Commissioner Alexander asked if the front porch windows were being repaired as well. Mr. Burks replied no, they would be left alone. Commissioner Sherayko commented that as long as he doesn’t do any other work to the windows, it is fine. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve repair of windows with broken glass by replacing gla ss pa nes. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 Chair Erquiaga moved on to item seven: complete work to the roof (partially after-the-fact). Mr. Burks said the roof would be replaced with a slate like material. The porch roof had already been replaced. Chair Erquiaga asked him what he meant by slate like material. Mr. Burks replied he would need to confirm with his contractor as to the exact material used and would get the information to the Commission. Commissioner Englund commented that he would like more information on why the slate was proposed to be painted. Commissioner Lifsey agreed. Typically, that would not be done if the slate was in good condition. Mr. Burks said his contractor proposed it to make the slate appear more uniform , as some of the slate is weathered. Commissioner Englund said slate should not be painted. Commissioner Lifsey recommended Mr. Burks speak with his contractor regarding the specific material . Given the slope of the front porch roof, it appears that it would have been tin. Mr. Burks replied that the front porch roof had been asphalt shingles when he bought the home. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table roof work . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 Commissioner Sherayko explained that it is important to receive approval prior to doing any exterior work in a historic district. It is better to ask for permission than hope for forgiveness further down the line. Chair Erquiaga recommended to Mr. Burks that he look through the Residential Design Review Guidelines. c) ACTION (Advocate -Sherayko): Request of Jae Clebourne to paint 1361 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2603-0002) Ms. Jae Clebourne’s contractor, Mr. Alex Gilman, was present to represent the application. The request is for approval for three (3) paint colors. The main body of the house w ill be “Magic Wand”, a light purple . The soffits, freesias, and rakes w ill be “Second Pour ”, a dark purple . The window s and trim w ill be “Oxblood”, a burnt brown. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the columns, railings, and foundation would remain white. 8 Mr. Gilman replied they would. Commissioner Lifsey said he was good with this. He suggested the window sashes stay white to give them more “pop”, and it would be historically appropriate. Mr. Gilman said he would let Ms. Clebourne know and commented that she was open to changes. Commissioner Lifsey suggested that she consider painting the upper gable a third, separate accent color. Commissioner Langseth asked if the Commission would consider the color choices garish. Commissioner Lifsey responded that for Queen Anne style dwellings the more color the better. Commissioner Englund commented that these were a good choice of colors. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the application as submitted with the stipulation that the sashes of the windows remain white and the upper gable wood shakes be a different accent color to be approved by the advocate. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 3. OLD BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate -Ferguson): Request of Teresa White to replace a window at 211 F Street. (HPC2601- 0003) The applicant was not present to represent the application. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler explained that Ms. Teresa White had not been in touch with her. The item cannot be tabled again so the Commission needs to make a decision. Ms. White installed a vinyl window when a wood window fell out. The only alternative window she offered was another vinyl window in a different style. Commissioner Alexander asked if all the windows were two-over-two. Ms. Mergenthaler replied that the majority of the windows appeared to be wooden and two-over-two. Commissioner Englund said that a two-over-two wooden window would need to be put back in. Commissioner Englund made a motion to deny the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 b) ACTION (Advocate -Sherayko): Request of Harold and Sharon Wheeler to replace windows at 2236 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2601-0011) 56:00 9 Mrs. Sharon and Mr. Bill Wheeler were present to represent the application. They would like to replace all twenty-three (23) windows in the home. The goal is to help combat the rising cost of electricity and to have fully functional windows. The replacement windows will be double-hung Pella windows. Commissioner Englund asked if the attic, crawl space, and walls of the home had been insulated. Mr. Wheeler replied yes, all insulation was done by Mr. Bill Cranks. Mrs. Wheeler elaborated that the home was a Cranks ’ house and that they had blown in loose insulation in the walls. Mr. Wheeler commented that due to the loose insulation in the attic they were unable to run fans , or the like, to help cool down the space and save on cooling costs. Add ing to the dilemma is that they are only able to open some of the windows a third of the way. Mrs. Wheeler said that not being able to open the windows has made maintenance problematic as well. Commissioner Lifsey said that this application does not follow the Residential Design Review Guidelines . The Guidelines say that existing windows should be repaired in place. Commissioner Englund stated that removing the windows would be removing a significant aspect of the home. Replacing the windows is a gamble also on whether they would actually save the Wheelers money on their electric bill. Mr. Wheeler stated that the Pella windows they wish to use would be aluminum clad wood windows and are the same type of windows that were approved for the Garland Rhodes Apartments when they replaced their windows. Commissioner Lifsey said he could not speak to the Garland Rhodes Apartments as that was before his time on the Commission. The Residential Design Review Guidelines, however, are clear. Commissioner Sherayko commented that instead of trying to replace the windows the Wheelers should consider looking into replacing the storm windows to increase efficiency. Commissioner Lifsey said that exterior or interior storm windows would be allowed. Commissioner Englund commented that from personal experience , storm windows help with comba tting drafts. The cost of replacing the original wood material would most likely outweigh any return benefit. Mr. Wheeler acknowledged that doing this would be costly but estimates for repairing the windows would be even more than what they are currently proposing. Commissioner Langseth asked if this type of window would even be approved. Commissioner Lifsey responded that b ased on the Residential Design Review Guidelines the proposed windows would not be approved because the existing windows are in place and repairable. Commissioner Englund agreed noting that if an applicant has the original material, it should be repaired or used as a template. Commissioner Lifsey agreed and said the Residential Design Review Guidelines say that original material stays. 10 Mr. Wheeler asked if the Commission would be amendable to allowing them to use replacement windows on the sides of the home that are not visible from the road. Chair Erquiaga commented that their home is highly viewable given where it sits. He then read from the Residential Design Review Guidelines , “windows should be repaired rather than replaced. If replacement is necessary due to severe deterioration, then it should be in kind.” Unfortunately, that is not the case here. Commissioner Lifsey suggested they consider storm windows and replacing the weights and cords that are missing on the windows. It is possible for the windows to be restored to increase their efficiency. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to deny the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 c) ACTION (Advocate -Erquiaga): Request of Alexcia & Jacquelin Junior Lenis of LaKay Capital, LLC to do work to the front porch and gutters at 414 Clay Street. (HPC2602 - 0003) Mrs. Alexcia Lenis was present to represent the application. She explained that their plan was to install concrete columns and a wooden railing to complete the front porch. The main body of the house ha d regular gutters. They plan to install gutters to match on the front porch in place of hidden gutters. Commissioner Sherayko stated that much of the style of the house was in the design features of the front porch. What has been rebuilt in place of the original porch is very plain. The front porch should have been restored rather than removed. The look of the porch has been removed. Mrs. Lenis asked what specifically he was referring to. Commissioner Lifsey responded that the front porch is dramatically different from the original. The trim pieces, the sizing, almost everything is different. The hidden gutter system is an element of the porch that should have been retained. It should have been relined with EPDM to make them functional. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler reiterated for the Commission that the original front porch had been completely removed and a modified porch had been built in its place. Commissioner Sherayko reiterated that the front porch should have been restored. Commissioner Alexander said the new porch is completely inappropriate. Ms. Mergenthaler reminded the Commission that discussion at the last meeting had touched upon whether anything could be done to the current porch to replicate the original or if it needed to be removed and rebuilt again. Commissioner Alexander commented that it was not possible for the rebuilt porch to replicate the original. Mrs. Lenis asked if adding more trim to the top portion of the roof would work. 11 Commissioner Englund responded that the first porch was based on classical design principles . The features of the porch, such as the pilaster and trim, are all scaled to each other. The old porch roof was built to be slightly out of bounds of the porch. The current roof does not match that scale and there is not a way to retro fit the roof to make it replicate the previous porch roof. That is why the Commission recommended the applicants get an architect to address the issue. Mrs. Lenis asked for clarification on what Commissioner Englund is referencing as she is unfamiliar with the terminology. Commissioner Englund replied that the sizing and scaling of the porch is what was important. Unfortunately, the new porch will need to be removed, as reworking it is highly unlikely. Mrs. Lenis responded that it is wood and they should be able to rework it. Ms. Mergenthaler said the Commission would need plans to show how that would be done. Commissioner Englund asked if the removal of the iron columns had been approved in the original application. Mrs. Lenis replied yes, it was decided that replacement columns would be an improvement. Ms. Mergenthaler responded that the Commission discussed that it would be more appropriate to replace the iron columns, but did not formally approve a replacement, which is why an additional application was required. Commissioner Englund said that the pilasters were fluted and the new cylindrical columns would need to match in order to keep the front porch architecturally cohesive . The porch is the defining feature of th is home. This house is significant as it was built in 1825 and it is one of the oldest within the City. He asked Mrs. Lenis if they still had the pilasters. Mrs. Lenis replied that she would need to check with her husband. Ms. Mergenthaler explained that the pilasters should have remained , even if they had approval to remove the iron columns. The Commission’s understanding from the first meeting was that the front porch was going to be restored piece by piece rather than completely removed. The discussion would have been much different if the Commission had known that complete removal was the plan. The problem now is recreating elements that are no longer there is much more difficult than restoring existing elements. The Commission could either make a motion or table for architectural plans to be submitted. Commissioner Sherayko said that the Commission would need to see plans for the restoration of the front porch. Ms. Mergenthaler asked the Commission which of the options available, retro fitting what is there or doing a full rebuild, was the more realistic option. Commissioner Lifsey responded that it was more realistic for them to remove the new porch. It would be virtually impossible for them to get the new porch to replicate the old one. Commissioner Alexander agreed with Commissioner Lifsey. Commissioner Lifsey asked if there had been any mention at the last meeting regarding the trim and gable of the porch. 12 Mrs. Lenis called Mr. Jacquelin Junior Lenis to speak more on the matter. Mr. Lenis stated that at the last meeting the C ommission told him that they would provide an architect who would give him an idea of how to move forward with the front porch. Ms. Mergenthaler disagreed and clarified that the Commission had stated the reason for tabling this item was so that the commission members who are architects could weigh in on the matter . It is the Lenis’ responsibility to hire their own architect to create plans for the Commission to review. The Commission is a review board not a design board. Mr. Lenis responded that they would not hire their own architect. Chair Erquiaga stated that the Commission was not there to be an applicant’s designer or engineer. Ms. Mergenthaler explained to Mr. Lenis that at this point , the Commission has said that it would be unrealistic to modify the current front porch enough to substantially replicate the original. The Commission at the present time does not see a path forward with the front porch that is in place. Mr. Lenis explained they are at risk of the house being foreclosed on. He reiterated that Ms. Mergenthaler told him at the last meeting that an Architect would provide them with a design to move forward. Ms. Mergenthaler reiterated that was not what was discussed at the last HPC meeting . The reality here is that unfortunately they chose to do work that was not approved by the Commission. The applicants have been through this process previously and still choose to do work without approval. Mr. Lenis said they had not done any work without approval. Chair Erquiaga said that the Commission was not there to argue with him. They were there to review the after-the-fact application. Mrs. Lenis responded that they had approval to remove the porch. Chair Erquiaga stated that they did not have approval to remove the original front porch. Mr. Lenis said that he made it clear in the previous meeting that the original porch had been unfixable. The reason that the current porch does not look like the original was because they were forced to stop working on it by stop work order. He reiterated that they are now at risk of foreclosure on the house. Ms. Mergenthaler said that at this point the Commission needed to consider the item that was before them and choose to table it or approve it or deny it. Mrs. Lenis asked the Commission if the columns could be approved. Chair Erquiaga said they could not approve the columns until the applicants provided a full design for the front porch. They cannot approve the columns without knowing what the rest of the porch will look like. Mrs. Lenis asked if the submitted railing falls within the same requirement. Commissioner Lifsey stated that the columns submitted are smooth , the pilaster had been fluted, and they will need to match that with the columns. What they have now does not fit the style of what was originally there in design and sizing . The previous front porch had over-the-top classical detailing. The 13 porch that is there now cannot be retro fit ted to match the previous porch . Along the roof the trim, hidden gutter, detailing is all gone. Everything that made this house historical has been stripped. Mrs. Lenis said that in the interest of moving forward with finishing renovating the house they would put the iron railings and columns back on. It will take too much time for them to obtain fluted columns. Ms. Mergenthaler clarified that even with putting the wrought iron back on , the applicants would still need to replicate and replace the fluted pilaster and the roof of the porch. Mrs. Lenis said they still had the fluted pilaster. Commissioner Lifsey said it would be unfortunate to put the iron columns back on the porch as they are not original. If they are going to spend the effort to restore the rest of the porch it would be sensible to go ahead and put in the fluted columns. Mrs. Lenis explained that there may have been some confusion on their part as they had assumed that the round columns in their color mockup had been approved by the Commission. Commissioner Sherayko explained that the Commission’s concern was regarding the features that were removed without approval. That being the pilaster and roofing of the original porch, those will have to be either put back up or replicated. Mrs. Lenis noted that they were unable to finish the work but had planned on adding porch roof trim. Commissioner Lifsey responded that even if what is there was finished , it would not be able to replicate the original porch in any way. Commissioner Englund said this is classical Roman architecture based on ancient rules of scaling. This style was very prolific during the time period the house was built. It is not that the new porch needs to look like the original, rather it needs to match it exactly in scale and sizing. That is why the Commission is doubting that what they have now could be made to replicate the original. Commissioner Lifsey elaborated that this house was the one of the premiere houses in Lynchburg in the amount of detailing it had. Mrs. Lenis said the Commission seemed to approve the columns that were in the mockup she presented at the first meeting. Commissioner Englund responded that the Commission was not approving the columns within the mockup. They discussed that it would be more appropriate to install accurate columns instead of keeping the iron columns. Ms. Mergenthaler said that the recommendation at the time was that it would be more appropriate to remove the iron and replace them with columns that match the house. The Commission was not approving the columns in the mockup. It was also stated that the applicants would have to come back for approval if they decided to replace the columns. The work that was done did not have approval and now the applicants must go back and fix it. The mockup that was submitted was only to gain approval for the exterior paint colors of the house. Things may come up in discussion during the meeting , but if an item is not on the Certificate of Appropriateness (COA), then it has not been formally approved by the Commission. 14 Mr. Lenis asked if it was possible to continue work on the porch without hiring an architect or submitting additional plans. He reiterated that he was told the City would provide an architect. He said that he would be in constant communication with Ms. Mergenthaler if the Commission would allow it. Ms. Mergenthaler responded that within an email she sent to the applicants, she stated clearly that “it is recommended that you get input from an architect and/or provide additional information regarding how you plan to address the style of the front porch. If you would like to submit additional materials, please send that to me by March 30 th.” There was no response to that email. No where in there was it stated that a City architect was going to get in touch with them. It is unfortunate that he misunderstood, but it has gotten to the point in which a decision needs to be made by the Commission to either table the item and ask for plans or deny the item and ask for a new application . No matter the decision , plans will have to be provided. Commissioner Englund asked if there was a way for Mr. Lenis to complete the other approved work to keep their project moving forward. Mr. Lenis said that they had a short-term loan, and they were now at risk of foreclosing on the house. He again requested that the stop work order be removed so that he could continue working on the porch. He said he would stay in constant communication with Ms. Mergenthaler. Ms. Mergenthaler addressed Commissioner Englund’s question , stating that all the work that was approved in the last meeting could be completed. The only item s currently on hold are the gutters and front porch, as they are still under consideration. Chair Erquiaga said that the Commission must see a design plan for the front porch . Without one they would not be able to approve anything. Mrs. Lenis asked if it was possible for them to gain approval for the work by submitting photos. Chair Erquiaga reiterated that the Commission needs a drawing or rendering of the design for the front porch. Ms. Mergenthaler asked Mrs. Lenis if they would be able to submit plans for the next HPC meeting. Once an item is tabled it has a sixty (60) day limit. The Commission could table this item until the next meeting, but the Commission would have to make a decision at that meeting. Alternatively, the Commission could deny the application, which would mean that the applicants would need to submit a new application with a design plan for the porch. Those are the options at this time. Mrs. Lenis asked if a photo would work. Ms. Mergenthaler responded that at this point the Commission would need architectural plans. Commissioner Lifsey explained that what has been done is in violation . The porch was not supposed to be removed wholesale. It was supposed to be repaired. Ms. Mergenthaler said that the Commission could also address the issue of the hanging gutters as that was also part of the application. The Commission was told there were no hidden gutters, but it clearly appears like there should have been. Commissioner Lifsey said that hidden gutters were absolutely on this house, both on the upper roof and porch. It is clear by the way the downspouts come out of the bottom of the overhang. The photographic evidence is there. 15 Mrs. Lenis said that they did not touch the roof on the main house and there was no hidden gutter on the main house. Commissioner Lifsey responded that the hidden gutters were there and most likely were just covered up at some point. Ms. Mergenthaler said they would also need to specify what type of gutters they plan to install. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table the item until the next meeting . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 6 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Ferguson 1 4. NEXT MEETING: The next regular meeting is scheduled for April 20, 2026. 5. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at: 5:01 p.m. ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________ Secretary Chair

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.