Minutes (February 23)
City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Feb 23, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg
This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Historic Preservation Commission
Minutes of February 23, 2026
MEMBERS PRESENT:
Peter Alexander
Austin Englund, Vice-Chair
Michael Erquiaga, Chair
Dr. Gerry Sherayko
MEMBERS ABSENT:
Palmer Ferguson
Tracey Langseth
Emmett Lifsey
OTHERS PRESENT:
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission ; Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning
Technician; and the public.
ROLL CALL:
After a quorum was established, Chair Erquiaga called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m.
1. CONSENT AGENDA:
Commissioner Alexander made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by
Commissioner Sherayko, and passed by a unanimous vote.
2. NEW BUSINESS
a) ACTION (Advocate -Sherayko): Request of Harold and Sharon Wheeler to replace
windows at 2236 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2601-0011)
The applicants were not present to represent the application.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler stated that the applicants had planned to attend. The request consisted of
replacing eighteen (18) wood windows with aluminum-clad wood windows.
Commissioner Sherayko recommended that the Commission table the item.
Chair Erquiaga noted that the request seemed to be within the Lynchburg Historic Districts Residential
Design Review Guidelines, but he would like more information from the applicants.
Commissioner Alexander made a motion to table the item until the next meeting. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
b) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of James Warinner to install a concrete driveway,
a concrete walkway, and a wooden ramp at 844 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2602-0002)
Mr. James Warinner was present to represent the application. The request consisted of a partial concrete
driveway, an on-grade concrete walkway that runs along the side of the house, and a wooden ramp that
2
connects to the sidewalk and the front porch. A metal railing would be installed along the right-hand side
of the ramp to be ADA compliant.
Chair Erquiaga asked if Mr. Warinner had an image of what the railing would look like.
Mr. Warinner replied that along the front, the railing would match the wood front porch railing. Along the
side, he preferred to use a pipe metal railing since it would last longer and be easier for older individuals
to grasp. He continued to state that the gravel driveway had been there since about 2012. At the time he
didn’t know that the type of gravel used was not historically appropriate. He now wants to convert part of
it to concrete.
Chair Erquiaga asked if there were any photos of the original hand railing Mr. Warinner mentioned.
Mr. Warinner responded no, the railing has not been on the house for years. He was able to find most of
the original railing throughout the property and will be installing it along the front.
Ms. Mergenthaler clarified that installing the original railing on the front porch was approved as part of
Mr. Warinner’s previous petition.
Mr. Warinner said he had enough of the original pickets to install it along the front of the home.
Commissioner Englund asked if the ramp would be on the side of the house.
Mr. Warinner responded yes.
Commissioner Englund asked if the ramp would come up the front along Rivermont Avenue.
Mr. Warinner replied no, it would not. The concrete pad and the ramp would be located on the side of
the home. In part, the wooden ramp would be put in there to avoid installing concrete over top of the
home’s water and gas lines.
Commissioner Englund made a motion to approve the application with the stipulation that the
handrail at the front of the ramp match the front porch wood handrail. The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
c) ACTION (Advocate -Erquiaga): Request of Alexcia & Jacquelin Junior Lenis of LaKay
Capital, LLC to do extensive work at 414 Clay Street. (HPC2602-0003)
Mr. Jacquelin Junior Lenis was present to represent the application. The front porch has been rebuilt, and
the roof was previously approved for replacement. During this work, the hidden gutter system was
removed. The front porch roof was the only roof that still had hidden gutters. Standard black metal
hanging gutters will be installed on the front porch to match the rest of the house.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler asked for clarification. Based on the look of the roof line, the rest of the house
appeared to have hidden gutters.
Mr. Lenis replied no, the rest of the house did not have hidden gutters.
3
Commissioner Englund commented that the house may not have had any hidden gutters, instead having
the eaves terminate without gutters. He noted that the ridge did look different.
Mr. Lenis responded that the main roof of the house did not have any hidden gutters when he purchased
the property.
Chair E rquiaga noted that the extent of the hang of the eaves ma de it seem that there were hidden
gutters on the house at some point. Though the hidden gutters may have been covered up years ago.
There may have been a gutter that fell off at some point.
After reviewing street view photos, the C ommission agreed that the main portion of the house had a
modern hanging gutter at the time of purchase.
Commissioner Alexander asked if the front porch also had hanging gutters.
Ms. Mergenthaler responded no, the front porch had hidden gutters.
Chair Erquiaga asked Mr. Lenis if he was requesting to put the hidden gutters back on the front porch.
Mr. Lenis replied no, he was requesting approval to remove the hanging gutter system and install
hanging gutters that match the main part of the house. This would make it look uniform.
Commissioner Alexander asked for clarification that they were requesting to remove the hidden gutters
from the front porch.
Mr. Lenis replied yes.
Ms. Mergenthaler explained that this was part of item one , as listed in the materials . Item one includes
removing the hidden gutters from the front porch, altering the roof line , and installing hanging gutters on
the front porch. It also sounds like the applicant would like to replace the hanging gutters on the
remainder of the house as well.
Commissioner Sherayko stated that it was a shame that the rebuilt front porch has less detail and style
than the original. What is in place now is very plain.
Commissioner Englund added that the disrepair was mainly paint as wood is never quite as far gone as it
may appear. The architectural elements of the pilaster and the entablature of the portico are defining
features of the house. That is a significant feature of the house and should be put back in place.
Mr. Lenis said that they had been unable to finish the porch because of receiving a stop work order. Their
plan is to have the new front porch match the original as close as they can. The dimensions will match,
including the face of the porch. They will also add molding.
Commissioner Sherayko responded that it still means that all the original features are in a landfill
somewhere. It is important to recreate the front porch as it was a defining feature of this house.
Replicating the look is important. What is there now is very plain.
Mr. Lenis said that they plan to add crown molding and make a nice, finished design.
Commissioner Englund stated that the front porch ought to be restored and brought back to the original.
Without that front porch , there is little showing the original character of the house, particularly the
pilasters, the flat column against the wall.
4
Mr. Lenis commented that they still had the pilasters.
Ms. Mergenthaler clarified to the Commission that the columns Mr. Lenis referenced were not the original
ones from this house.
Mr. Lenis agreed that the columns he had were not the original ones.
Commissioner Alexander asked what type of work was done to the roof line of the front porch.
Mr. Lenis replied that the original porch had been falling apart so it had been completely replaced.
Commissioner Alexander asked for clarification that the current front porch was a complete rebuild.
Mr. Lenis responded yes, which is what they had agreed on. It was dangerous to even work on the
porch.
Commissioner Alexander stated that as the other Commissioners had said, the front porch was a defining
feature of the home.
Mr. Lenis reiterated that they plan to keep the front porch as close to the original as possible.
Commissioner Englund asked for clarification on what Mr. Lenis meant by that. Did that mean he planned
to return the entablature portico in full. He noted that he understood if it was all too far gone, but the
architectural style needs to be reflected and restored, including the architrave and the cornice . The style
may still be obtained, even without hidden gutters. The appearance from the street is very important.
Mr. Lenis reiterated that the porch was not finished yet and installation of the posts would improve the
look.
Commissioner Sherayko stated that even without hidden gutters, the porch still needs to have the original
detail.
Mr. Lenis replied that it will.
Commissioner Englund stated that the slope of the current roof was incorrect. It needs to be some type
of flat roof. He asked if the original roof was metal.
Mr. Lenis replied the roof was never flat, it had a slope.
Commissioner Englund noted that the exposure on the entablature was uniform around, which means the
slope was maintained.
The Commission discussed the look of the front porch and noted that if there was a slope, it was likely
minimal.
Commissioner Alexander asked if the roof was originally soldered seam.
Mr. Lenis replied that they had removed the metal porch roof. He did not know if it was soldered seam.
Commissioner Alexander noted that the aerial photos showed a roof that barely had a pitch.
Mr. Lenis admitted that the new roof had more slope than the original.
5
Chair Erquiaga agreed that the original roof had a much less defined slope than what is in place now.
Commissioner Englund stated that there was no good way to build the necessary architectural details
around the new porch. The new roof is already out of bounds from the original roof’s profile . He
recommended that Mr. Lenis consult someone on how to correct it.
Mr. Lenis said he would be able to trim it in a way to make it look the same as the original.
Commissioner Alexander asked Mr. Lenis if he understood that the roof had to match the dimensions of
the original.
Mr. Lenis replied yes.
Ms. Mergenthaler recommended that the Commission table this portion of the application until the next
meeting, which would allow for additional input from the Commissioners who are architects.
Commissioner Alexander agreed but added that it was incumbent on the owner to hire an architect.
Mr. Lenis noted that they bought the property as an investment and they need to finish the project so
that they can sell it.
Ms. Mergenthaler noted that the Commissioners may not tell Mr. Lenis how to build it but it would be
helpful to have their input.
Commissioner Sherayko said that property owners should always come and speak with the Commission
before removing historical features. Repairing the porch that was already there may have been doable
but now it is gone and will need to be recreated, which is much more difficult.
Ms. Mergenthaler added that the Commission would not have approved a complete tear down and rebuild
of the front porch. The work was not represented as such to the Commission at the previous meeting.
Mr. Lenis said that a complete tear-down was always what they planned to do.
Ms. Mergenthaler replied that had that been discussed previously , the Commission would have advised
him not to do so.
Commissioner Sherayko agreed that the Commission would not have recommended tearing down the
front porch.
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to table alterations to the front porch and installation of
hanging gutters until the next meeting . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and
passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
Mr. Lenis continued on to item two, replacing elements of the rear porch. He stated that they had not
planned to demolish anything, but one of their contractors fell through the stairs because they were
rotten. The stairs will be rebuilt to match what was in place previously.
6
Ms. Mergenthaler clarified that they will be replacing the railing and stairs of the rear porch; replacing a
single door with a new double door; and replacing the ceiling. She asked if the new railing and stairs
would be wood.
Mr. Lenis replied yes, both would be wood. He said this side of the house was not visible from Clay Street
and the double door allows for more light into the home. It is a good option since they can not add more
windows to the home.
Chair Erquiaga said he could understand wanting more light. The problem with portions of this
application is that Mr. Lenis knows the process and yet still chose to do work without applying and
without approval.
Commissioner Englund stated that when replacing the railing, it should have four (4) inch spacing and be
brought up to code. The one that was in place did not look to be original. Regular pickets may be used.
The stairs should be treated the same.
Commissioner Alexander asked if there were any issues with the double door.
Commissioner Sherayko agreed with Chair Erquiaga , noting that the applicant knew the correct process,
and yet still completed work without approval however the double door is located at the rear.
Chair Erquiaga agreed and noted that the double door may have been approved if included in the original
application.
Commissioner Englund s tated that he was fine with the replacement ceiling as it appears to be
beadboard.
Mr. Lenis said that originally the ceiling was OSB board that had been painted. The replacement is tongue
and groove.
Commissioner Englund asked how they plan to finish the ceiling.
Mr. Lenis replied that they plan to stain it.
Commissioner Englund made a motion to approve the replacement of the rear porch ceiling,
flooring, stairs, and railing as well as the installation of a double door, with the stipulation
that the wooden railing and stairs be rebuilt to meet code requirements and use square
pickets. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item three, replacement of two (2) basement windows.
Ms. Mergenthaler asked for clarification. Two (2) basement windows had been replaced without approval
but the after-the-fact application listed replacement windows to match the originals.
Mr. Lenis said originally, they had not planned to replace the two (2) basement windows. When they
were doing work, they found them rotted due to water damage. They will be putting in six over six
windows that match the rest of the house.
7
Ms. Mergenthaler commented that one of the windows was previously a two (2) over two (2).
Mr. Lenis responded that the previous approval was for six (6) over six (6) window replacements.
Ms. Mergenthaler replied that was for the windows that were proposed for replacement at that time .
These basement windows weren’t originally proposed to be replaced. She stated that she wants to clarify
the intent.
Mr. Lenis explained that they were not trying to gain approval for the windows that are currently in place.
Commissioner Alexander asked for more information.
Mr. Lenis responded that they will install windows to match what w as there before. The windows they
have in place at this time are temporary as they had to remove the original s and didn’t want to leave the
house open. He still has the original window in the basement.
Ms. Mergenthaler asked if he planned on repairing that window.
Mr. Lenis responded that he currently has a contractor working on repairing the window.
Ms. Mergenthaler asked if he had the other window as well.
Mr. Lenis replied he did and it was being repaired as well.
Commissioner Englund asked Mr. Lenis to clarify that he planned to repair and put back in the original
windows and not fully replace them.
Mr. Lenis replied yes they plan to repair the windows.
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the repair and reinstallation of two (2)
basement windows. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the
following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item four, resizing a rear window after-the-fact.
Commissioner Sherayko asked why one of the windows was so large.
Mr. Lenis said it had always been a window. In the first meeting , his wife mentioned that they would be
changing the window to match. What may have been unclear was which window they had planned to
keep. The kitchen is now along that back wall, which is why they made the window smaller.
Commissioner Englund commented that the change makes the windows look proportional.
Commissioner Sherayko asked if the window on the left was original.
Ms. Mergenthaler replied both windows in the back had already been previously replaced. Neither were
original.
8
Mr. Lenis agreed and stated that both windows had already been vinyl.
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the resizing of the rear window. The motion
was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item five, replacing the front door.
Mr. Lenis explained that they would only be replacing the slab. They would be keeping the structure of
the door itself.
Commissioner Sherayko asked if the current door was original.
Mr. Lenis replied that it was not. It is a fiber glass door.
Commissioner Englund commented that both door styles seemed in line with the Lynchburg Historic
Districts Residential Design Review Guidelines . He asked if the darker door option was available with
different window insert styles, like a solid pane.
Mr. Lenis replied yes, it does.
Commissioner Englund stated that either door would be a nice option. Though the Lenis’ should consider
a different window insert or configuration, particularly one that matches the side lights better. Usually,
the rails match the joinery around it. The muntins would have lined up with the muntins on the side
lights.
Commissioner Sherayko stated that the window would need to have clear glass.
Commissioner Englund said that the two doors presented were safe options. If they decide to change to
a different style, they would need to come back.
Commissioner Englund made a motion to approve the replacement of the front door with either
option presented or the first option with a solid pane of glass and the stipulation that the
glass be clear for whichever option is installed. The motion was seconded by Commissioner
Alexander and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
Chair Erquiaga moved on to item six, repairing the deteriorated foundation.
Mr. Lenis said they would like to fix the front porch foundation by redoing the stucco where it already is.
Where the foundation is just rock or brick, on the sides of the home, they will leave it as is.
Chair Erquiaga asked if they will be doing work on the actual foundation of the home.
Mr. Lenis replied no.
9
Ms. Mergenthaler asked Mr. Lenis if they planned to do any work on the foundation elsewhere.
Mr. Lenis replied that the work would only be the front porch foundation. There’s no plan to change
anything else.
Commissioner Alexander asked if they would leave the brick bare.
Mr. Lenis responded that they would. The only thing that would be done may be some repointing.
Commissioner Alexander asked if they plan on painting the brick.
Mr. Lenis replied that they would paint it to match the color of the house that was approved in their last
submission.
Commissioner Englund advised Mr. Lenis not to paint any brick that was not previously painted. He
recommended either a limewash or silicate paint for brick.
Mr. Lenis responded that mainly they want to resurface the front porch foundation and paint it to match
the house.
Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the repair of the stucco foundation of the
front porch with the stipulation that the brick and rock foundation on the remainder of the
house remain exposed . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the
following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
Mr. Lenis asked if they would be allowed to put down the front porch flooring.
Ms. Mergenthaler said that the front porch flooring had been approved with the previous submittal. Work
that was approved at that meeting and at this meeting could proceed. She reiterated that i f something is
not specifically outlined on the Certificate of Appropriateness (COA), then it has not been approved.
d) COMMENT: Randolph -Macon Woman’s College Historic District nomination for
recommendation to the National Register of Historic Places and inclusion in the Virginia
Landmarks Register
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler stated that the Commission has the opportunity to voice any comments regarding
the Randolph-Macon Woman’s College Historic District nomination to send to the Virginia Department of
Historic Resources (DHR).
Commissioner Sherayko commented that he was surprised that Randolph College hadn’t already done
this.
The Commission shared general support.
Commissioner Alexander made a motion of support for the Randolph -Macon Woman’s College
Historic District nomination to the National Register of Historic Places and inclusion in the
10
Virginia Landmarks Register . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by
the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
3. OLD BUISNESS
a) ACTION (Advocate -Ferguson): Request of Teresa White to replace a window at 211 F
Street. (HPC2601- 0003)
The applicant was not present to represent the application.
Ms. Eve Mergenthaler stated that the applicant had not submitted any additional information and may still
be looking for an alternative window option. The Commission had the option to table the item again.
Chair Erquiaga stated that he was in favor of tabling the item again as he still wanted to discuss the item
with the applicant.
Commissioner Alexander made a motion to table the item until the next meeting . The motion was
seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote:
AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Sherayko 4
NOES: 0
ABSTENTIONS: 0
ABSENT: Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey 3
4. NEXT MEETING:
The next regular meeting is scheduled for March 16, 2026.
5. ADJOURNMENT:
There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at: 4:58 p.m.
ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________
Secretary Chair
Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.