RecordWell Data

Minutes (December)

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Dec 15, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Historic Preservation Commission Minutes of December 15, 2025 MEMBERS PRESENT: Peter Alexander Austin Englund, Vice-Chair Michael Erquiaga, Chair Palmer Ferguson Emmett Lifsey MEMBERS ABSENT: Tracey Langseth Dr. Gerry Sherayko OTHERS PRESENT: Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission; and the public. ROLL CALL: After a quorum was established, Chair Erquiaga called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m. 1. CONSENT AGENDA: Commissioner Lifsey made a moti on to accept the cons ent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner Ferguson, and passed by a unanimous vote. 2. NEW BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate -Alexander): Request of Elsa Duran to do extensive work at 819 Federal Street. (HPC2511-0006) Ms. Elsa Duran was present to represent the application. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler suggested that they go through the items one by one. Chair Erquiaga agreed. He asked Ms. Duran to summarize the request for a four-foot-tall wood picket fence and a six-foot-tall wood privacy fence. Ms. Duran replied that the picket fence would be placed along Federal Street and 9 th Street. The privacy fence would be placed at the side and rear of the property to prevent trespassing . The fence placement was detailed in the materials based on Zoning allowances. The fe nces will be similar to other fences in the neighborhood. Commissioner Lifsey asked if the fences will be painted white. Ms. Duran replied yes. Commissioner Lifsey commented that both fences seem to conform with the Residential Design Review Guidelines. Ms. Mergenthaler asked Ms. Duran if both fences, or just the picket fence, will be painted white. Ms. Duran replied that she plans to paint only the picket fence. Commissioner Lifsey asked what the Guidelines allow regarding painting or not painting. 2 Ms. Mergenthaler read from the Guidelines that fences, “should be stained or painted to blend with the building.” Commissioner Lifsey noted that the privacy fence could be stained rather than painted. Ms. Duran responded she would do whatever fulfilled the requirement. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the installation of a 4 -foot-tall wood picket fence, to be painted white, and the installation of a 6 -foot-tall wood privacy fence, to be painted white or stained, in the locations shown on the meeting materials. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Englund, Ferguson, Lifsey 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Langseth, Sherayko 2 Ms. Duran continued on to the removal of the balcony railing and installation of a wood staircase with a landing. S he originally wanted to put a deck on the back of the house, but a deck would not meet setback requirements . Instead, she plans to install a small four ( 4) foot landing with stairs off of the existing balcony at the rear of the house. Ms. Mergenthaler clarified that per Zoning, the landing could only extend a maximum of three (3) feet from the building. Ms. Duran noted that the stairs would also need to be three (3) feet wide then. Chair Erquiaga asked if the style of railing would be similar to what wa s on the balcony, or if it would be simpler, as shown in the mock up. Ms. Duran said she would do whatever was requi red. She would prefer to install a railing similar to the mock up. When she originally moved into the house , it was in disrepair and the railings needed to be recreated. Commissioner Lifsey noted that the staircase would be located at the rear of the hous e so simpler, two - by-two pickets could be acceptable as opposed to the ornate ones on the balcony. Commissioner Englund recommended that she save the balcony railing after removing it and use it on the new landing. Ms. Duran replied that she would be able to do that. Commissioner Englund asked if that profile was located anywhere else on the house. Ms. Duran replied yes, it is also on the front of the house. Commissioner Englund stated that it is a significant part of the house and every effort should be made to save the railing and extend its use. Ms. Duran said that the railing in the front was done four to five years ago. The original railing was in poor condition and she had it redone in the same style as what was there . Her neighbors ha ve generic pickets on their stairs. 3 Commissioner Alexander stated that the reuse of the railing was a recommendation, not a requirement. Commissioner Englund agreed that it would be valuable to reuse the railing as it is significant. Commissioner Englund asked if she had a carpenter working on this with her. Ms. Duran replied she had a carpenter at one point, but it was expensive. Commissioner Englund noted that a carpenter could use the picket to create a template of what is already there. It would be a cost -effective way to do it. Though this was all in the realm of recommendations and offered to be a contact if she had any questions. What is there is a nice profile and would be nice if she continued it onto the stairs. Ms. Duran asked for clarification that he meant that she should take the balcony railing that is there and extended it out onto the landing and down the stairs. Commissioner Englund replied that at minimum she should save the existing balcony railing. Commissioner Lifsey agreed that she could reuse it on the landing and then install square pickets going down the stairs. Commissioner Alexander agreed with that recommendation. There are experienced carpenters who could fabricate the railing for her. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the removal of the existing rear balcony railing and the installation of a wood staircase with a landing extending a maximum of 3 feet with the recommendation to reuse the existing balcony railing for the landing and square pickets for the stairs. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Englund and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Englund, Ferguson, Lifsey 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Langseth, Sherayko 2 Ms. Duran moved on to the next item, the concrete sidewalk. Commissioner Lifsey asked if it was supposed to be a driveway or a sidewalk, based on the sketch. Ms. Mergenthaler said the sidewalk would wrap around to the back to meet the patio area. Commissioner Alexander asked if it was on the left side of the property. Commissioner Lifsey said it was coming off of Federal street and then going around the back. He asked how wide it would be. Chair Erquiaga replied that the request stated approximately thirty (30) inches. Ms. Duran said that she wants a path or sidewalk on the side of the house so they don’t have to walk in the dirt. Commissioner Alexander asked if she was installing a sidewalk and a smaller walkway. 4 Ms. Duran clarified she is requesting one walkway along the side of the house. Commissioner Alexander asked if the walkway would be the thirty (30) inches. Ms. Duran replied yes. Commissioner Alexander asked if it would be poured concrete. Ms. Duran replied yes. Commissioner Lifsey noted that the request seemed appropriate. Commissioner Ferguson made a motion to approve the installation of an approximately 30” wide concrete sidewalk from the front of the property to the back of the house as indicated. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Englund, Ferguson, Lifsey 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Langseth, Sherayko 2 Ms. Duran moved on to the next item, the rear patio. Chair Erquiaga asked if there were proposed dimensions for the patio, as it was not stated in the request. Ms. Duran replied that she didn’t have exact measurements, but it would be big enough for entertaining. Commissioner Englund suggested an approximation of 12’x12’. Ms. Duran replied that would be likely. Ms. Mergenthaler asked if the patio area would extend to the cooking structure. Ms. Duran replied it would extend to the frontside of the cooking area and she may want to install pavers instead of concrete. Commissioner Alexander asked if the patio will be a step down from grade. Ms. Duran replied yes, it would be a step down. The stairs from the balcony will land on the patio. Commissioner Lifsey commented that the Guidelines do not necessarily limit patio sizing. Both pavers and concrete would be appropriate materials. Ms. Mergenthaler noted that if the Commission finds it appropriate, they could approve both options. Commissioner Ferguson made a motion to approve the installation of a rear concrete or paver patio at a maximum of 12’x12’. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Englund, Ferguson, Lifsey 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Langseth, Sherayko 2 5 Ms. Duran moved on to the last item, the permanent cooking structure. Chair Erquiaga asked if the cinder blocks, shown in the photo, were the beginning of the structure. Ms. Dura n responded yes. She continued, stating that th e cooking structure would be similar to the example images, but instead of brick it will be covered with white/beige stone . The inside will be fire resistant brick. Commissioner Alexander asked if the dimensions will be the same as in the examples. Ms. Duran replied that it be taller because one side will be for barbeque and the other a rotisserie. Chair Erquiaga asked if it would be visible from the street. Ms. Duran replied it will be in the back of the house. Commissioner Englund said that it is likely that the six (6) foot fence and the house will eclipse most visibility. Ms. Duran agreed that people wouldn’t be able to see it from Federal Street, though there may be a chance that someone could see it from 9th Street. Commissioner Alexander asked if there were any direct sight restrictions for the type of stone. Chair Erquiaga replied not that he was aware of. Commissioner Lifsey commented that the Guidelines do not address cooking structures. Ms. Mergenthaler noted that typical barbeques or grills aren’t perman ent structures, which differs from this proposal. Commissioner Alexander asked if the stone facade would be appropriate. Commissioner Lifsey responded that there are no Guidelines or restrictions to reference. Chair Erquiaga agreed , noting that if this was a shed they would say it should match the house. This structure is a little different and they don’t have much guidance, it is more of an interpretation. Commissioner Englund s tated that this structure doesn’t hurt the historic fabric. He asked Ms. Duran if she planned to use a rock stone or brick paver for the exterior. Ms. Duran replied that it will be similar to the exterior shown in the example photo, but it will be a white/beige color. The inside will be fire brick. Ms. Mergenthaler clarified that the example image s were for the materials and not for the design. The Commission should reference them for the stone exterior and fire brick interior. Commissioner Lifsey replied that was understood. Commissioner Englund made a motion to approve the construction of a permanent cooking structure with a white/beige stone exterior. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote: 6 AYES: Alexander, Erquiaga, Englund, Ferguson, Lifsey 5 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: Langseth, Sherayko 2 3. NEXT MEETING: The next regular meeting is scheduled for January 26, 2026. 4. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at: 4:34 p.m. ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________ Secretary Chair

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.