RecordWell Data

Minutes (October)

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · meeting of Oct 20, 2025 · Minutes

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

This document is no longer listed on City of Lynchburg's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 Historic Preservation Commission Minutes of October 20, 2025 MEMBERS PRESENT: Peter Alexander Austin Englund, Vice-Chair Michael Erquiaga, Chair Palmer Ferguson Tracey Langseth Emmett Lifsey Dr. Gerry Sherayko MEMBERS ABSENT: OTHERS PRESENT: Ms. Eve Mergenthaler, Secretary to the Historic Preservation Commission; Ms. Natalya Murray, Planning Technician; and the public. ROLL CALL: After a quorum was established, Chair Erquiaga called the meeting to order at 4:00 p.m. 1. CONSENT AGENDA: Commissioner Lifsey made a moti on to accept the consent agenda, which was seconded by Commissioner Ferguson, and passed by a unanimous vote. 2. NEW BUSINESS a) ACTION (Advocate-Englund): Request of Cordelia Chandler to replace rear stairs and a handrail at 505 Washington Street. (HPC2509-0003) Ms. Cordelia Chandler was not present to represent the application. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler stated that Ms. Chandler was out of town but had requested that the Commission vote on the application to replace the back steps and the temporary wooden handrail. Two (2) options were provided for the handrail replacement. Commissioner Englund said that he did not see any problems with the application. Commissioner Sherayko agreed, noting that he was okay with either railing option. Commissioner Lifsey asked to see the front railings. Commissioners Englund and Lifsey noted that the less ornate railing would be more appropriate. Commissioner Englund asked if the Commission needed to choose one of the railing options. Chair Erquiaga replied that the motion could specify one or both. Commissioner Englund asked if the second option was in conflict with the Residential Design Review Guidelines. He noted that the choice could be left to the applicant. 2 Chair Erquiaga replied that both railings seemed to conform with the Guidelines. If both options were approved, it would be up to the applicant. Commissioner Alexander asked if there were any problems with the proposed stair color. Ms. Mergenthaler replied that the applicant would paint the steps to match. Commissioner Englund made a motion to approve the application as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 b) ACTION (Advocate-Sherayko): Request of Nancy and Kevin Brandt to replace basement windows and a door at 2021 Rivermont Avenue. (HPC2510-0002) Mr. Kevin Brandt and his contractor , Mr. Oliver Geoghegan , were present to represent the application. Mr. Brandt is in the process of refinishing the basement. T he basement windows need work. The majority of them are not functional. Using the 1913 drawings, they were able to determine which of the windows were original. O n the West elevation, two (2) windows are original. Those windows will be rehabilitated. The other three (3) aren’t original and will be replaced. On the South elevation, there is a door, which is structurally unsound and two (2) original windows, which no longer function. The windows have limited visibility from the street. These three (3) items will be replaced. On the east elevation, there are four (4) windows that will be replaced due to functiona lity. They are not visible from the street but three (3) of them are original. The main concern is that the majority of windows don’t function and serve as egress for bedrooms. He clarified for the Commission that the West elevation faces Loudon street, the South elevation faced the garage/backyard, and the East elevation faces the Seven Hills School next door. Commissioner Sherayko stated that he appreciated the level of detail in the submitted materials. Commissioner Englund asked what the reasoning was when deciding to restore only two (2) of the original wood windows . From the photos , the windows appear to be at the same level of deterioration. Mr. Brandt replied that on the western side, which is visible from the street, they had restored all of the windows on the first and second floor. Even with that work and weather stripping , the window sashes continue to rattle and the windows require additional maintenance. He wanted to save the original basement windows on th at side, but the others are not orig inal. The decision to replace the other windows is to provide functionality and safe egress. The rear door is not repairable and need s to be replaced. Only one (1) of the original windows proposed for replacement would be partially visible from Loudon Street. That window is located at the rear. Commissioner Englund stated that he was fine with replacing the non-original windows. Commissioners Alexander and Sherayko shared agreement. Commissioner Englund noted that he was unsure about approving the replac ement of the other original windows as it seemed that they could be restored. 3 Mr. Geoghegan commented that the original rear window s (window D and E ) needed to be fully operational because they were bedroom windows. Window E was not visible from the street because it was located behind a pillar. Commissioner Englund reiterated that he questions removing original materials. Chair Erquiaga stated that he appreciated the information provided by Mr. Brandt and Mr. Geoghegan. He acknowledged Commissioner Englund’s concerns but noted that he is okay with the proposal for replacements given the location of the windows being replaced. Commissioner Ferguson asked if the replacement windows would be simulated divided light (SDL). Mr. Brandt replied that they would be. Commissioner Englund asked if egress supersedes the importance of maintaining original materials. Commissioner Lifsey replied that having an operational egress window was important. Based on building code the room wouldn’t be able to be classified as a bedroom without one. Commissioner Englund asked if they plan to keep the original windows with the property. Mr. Brandt replied yes , the original windows will be stored in the garage loft. When he bought the house, he found an original pocket door that had termite damage stored away. He couldn’t reuse the door itself but based on the design of the door, was able to recreate it and replace a nonoriginal swinging door. He understood the importance of storing original features. He was also able to find the 1913 drawings of the house in the library. Commissioner Sherayko made a motion to approve the application as submitted . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Alexander and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 c) ACTION (Advocate -Ferguson): Request of Cheyenne Kirk -Wheeler to install a prefabricated shed at 209 E Street. (HPC2510-0005) Ms. Cheyenne Kirk-Wheeler was not present to represent the application. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to table the application until the next meeting. The motion to table was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 d) ACTION (Advocate -Erquiaga): Request of Wesley DeVos, on behalf of Christ ina Delzingaro, to demolish and replace a rear deck at 300 Madison Street. (HPC2510-0004) Ms. Christina Delzingaro was present to represent the application. She propos ed demolishing and replacing a nonoriginal deck that was structurally unsound. The new deck would be approximately 4 the same size . New materials would include tigerwood decking and black aluminum railings with tempered glass panels. The deck is located at the rear and is obliquely visible from Madison Street. Chair Erquiaga commented that this was one of his favorite Frye designed homes. Ms. Delzingaro said that she had discovered the original porch floor under the deck. The original porch floor will be retained and the tigerwood would be installed around it. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the application as submitted. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 e) ACTION (Advocate -Erquiaga): Request of Alexcia Lenis of LaKay Capital, LLC to do extensive work at 414 Clay Street. (HPC2510-0006) Ms. Alexcia Lenis and Mr. Jacquelin Junior Lenis were present to repre sent th e application. They would like to replace the wood siding with smooth Hardie Board siding. The existing siding is a mix of rotten wood and other materials. There is a lot of damage visible on the inside due to extensive water damage. The roof has not been maintained and has caused the windows and siding to rot. The Hardie Board they are proposing will have the same exposure as the existing siding. The house has a number of windows. They are proposing the replacement of nineteen (19) total windows. Th ese include five (5) wood windows on the front and fourteen (14) windows on the sides and rear. There are two (2) existing vinyl windows located at the rear. They would like to replace the side and rear windows with vinyl. Only the front of the house is visible from Clay St reet. The windows on the front will be replaced with wood windows to match. The windows in the basement don’t have as much water damage and will be retained . The trim work around the windows has deteriorated and they plan to replace it with wood trim to match. For the main roof, they will replace with asphalt shingles to. The front porch roof will be replaced with a standing seam black metal roof to match the existing dimensions. The wood shutters will be repaired. Commissioner Sherayko commented that at one point, this home won an award from the Lynchburg Historical Foundation. Its unfortunate that since then the house has deteriorated to this degree. Ms. Lenis continued, stating that the front porch currently had orientated strand board (OSB) instead of the original tongue and groove flooring. T hey will replace the subflooring and put in tongue and groove. The dimensions will be approximately 3 3/8 inches by 8 feet. The replacement soffit will be wood and will match the original. Overall, the porch can’t be restored as it is too rotten. They plan to rebuild it to match the same dimensions and detailing as the original porch. For paint colors the house and the shutters will be a deep forest green, the trim will be an off white, and the foundation will be a concrete smear. Commissioner Alexander asked if they had any historic photos of what the house originally looked like. Ms. Mergenthaler replied there were no historical photos available on hand. Commissioner Englund commented that on google maps in 2012 the house looked to be in good condition. 5 Commissioners discussed and agreed that wooden columns would be more appropriate than the existing iron columns and would better support the weight of the roof. Mr. Lenis said that the metal co lumns were currently bending under the weight, they would need to replace them with something strong enough to support the porch. Commissioner Lifsey commented that the little trellis area that can be seen on the front of the porch is original and should remain. It also provides airflow. Chair Erquiaga agreed, especially since they said they would be replacing the porch given its structural issues. He encouraged them to look at wood options for the columns. Commissioner Sherayko said the metal railing wa s most likely a later addition and they should consider replacing it with wood. Ms. Lenis replied they would like to remove the metal if they are able to. Commissioner Englund asked about the medium density fiberboard (MDF) siding. Mr. Lenis replied the existing siding is a mix of MDF and wood. Commissioner Englund asked if the MDF was exterior grade or if it was cabinetry grade. Mr. Lenis replied he was unsure. Commissioner Englund asked if they were able to differentiate between the original wood and the MDF to see which one was rotting more. Based on the images of the home, it appeared more to be an issue of paint failure. The siding itself looked to be in good condition. Mr. Lenis replied that there was a large amount of water damage inside the home. The MDF on the sides and front of the house is extremely rotted. Commissioner Alexander asked if their preference was to replace all of the siding. Mr. Lenis replied yes, they would like to replace all of the siding with Hardie Board. Ms. Lenis added that the damage is more obvious when inside the home. Commissioner Englund suggested that they take any good wood siding they find when they remove it and put it on the front of the home rather than do a complete replacement. Commissioner Sherayko agreed, and noted that it had been done before. They should try to salvage as much good wood as possible to put on the front façade. Its not required, but it is a good suggestion. Commissioner Englund said that the siding from the photos looks to be in good condition and since they are restoring the shutters it would be good to have salvaged siding on at least the front of the home. He asked if a half inch overlap was enough for the Hardie Board installation. Mr. Lenis replied yes, that it would have five and a half (5.5) inches of space between each piece. Commissioner Alexander said that they would need to check with the manufacturer because it’s a system. There are specifications for installation to maintain the warranty. 6 Commissioner Lifsey said that the six (6) inch siding would leave five and a half (5.5) inches exposed. There would only be a half (½) inch available to be covered. The manufacturer may want more than that, so they may need to use seven (7) inch Hardie Board to get one (1) inch of overlap. Mr. Lenis replied that was what they planned to do, they will be using the seven (7) inch siding. They have done similar work before on their house on Rivermont Avenue. Commissioner Englund commented they should maintain the same spacing as that of the original siding. Commissioner Englund made a motion to approve the replacement of the existing siding with smooth Hardie Board siding to match existing spacing, with the option to reuse existing wood siding on front of the house if possible . The motio n was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the in-kind replacement of the five (5) front wood windows with wood windows to match (light configuration, sizing, profile, exterior muntins, etc.). The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Commissioner Lifsey noted that the Commission had approved replacing side and rear windows with vinyl before. Commissioner Sherayko recommended that the applicant save and store the original windows. Commissioner Lifsey commented that some of the windows were very deteriorated. Ms. Eve Mergenthaler asked if they had considered other replacement materials such as aluminum clad wood windows or composite windows. Mr. Lenis replied no, for economic reasons they have only considered vinyl. Commissioner Ferguson stated that th ey should look a t getting vinyl windows that have a brick profile. As most common vinyl windows have a bevel profile that sticks out. Mr. Lenis replied that th ey plan to have the replacement windows look the same as the wood windows, including the grid pattern. Commissioner Alexander suggested that they considered the quality of windows they will install. Chair Erquiaga shared agreement and stated that certain kinds of composite windows had been approved in historic districts before. It could be another option to consider. 7 Commissioner Lifsey agreed and recommended that th ey consider some of the newer composite windows. Other options may be a better window for relatively the same price as vinyl. Ms. Mergenthaler asked the Commission if they would like to consider and discuss simula ted divided lights (SDL) as a requirement for approval. The applicant did not specify. Commissioner Lifsey asked if that had been considered for vinyl windows that they had approved in the past. Ms. Mergenthaler replied that vinyl approval is so infrequent and usually done for simple windows. Chair Erquiaga noted that from what he could recall, requirements had always been exterior muntins. Commissioner Lifsey replied he thought that was true as well. Commissioner Englund clarified that there were nine teen windows in total (19) to be replaced, with five (5) in the front and fourteen (14) on the sides and rear. Ms. Lenis replied yes, the basement windows are not included in that count. Commissioner Lifsey asked if all the trim for the windows will be the same as before. Ms. Lenis replied yes. Commissioner Langseth asked if they specified if the windows were double hung. Commissioner Lifsey stated they needed to be consistent with the window replacements. Ms. Lenis replied they would be. Commissioner Langseth asked if they be doing the six over six (6-over-6) windows throughout. Ms. Lenis replied yes. Commissioner Englund asked what condition the windows were in throughout the rest of the house. Mr. Lenis replied that the bottom of all the window s were heavily damaged by water and none of them could be opened. Commissioner Englund said the windows did seem to be in bad shape and needed to be replaced. If they found windows that could be saved, they should put them in on the sides or front of the home. Ms. Lenis replied it was important to them for everything to look exactly the same. The house is beautiful and has a lot of potential. Commissioner Englund stated that anywhere that has the trim with the corner block should be saved. In his opinion, the wood siding looked pretty good. He suggested they at least save the wooden trim around the windows. Commissioner Lifsey elaborated that the corner block design keeps water from getting into the ends of the trim pieces. 8 Mr. Lenis replied they will do their best to save the corner blocks. Commissioner Lifsey responded that the little circle in the middle was a standard off the shelf design from that time period. It would be a wonderful detail to repeat. Commissioner Alexander said they shouldn’t use something out of a box store as it won’t be exterior grade. Commissioner Lifsey commented it would need to be a good material and painted before they were put back up. Commissioner Englund made a motion to approve the replacement of fourteen (14) side a nd rear windows with vinyl windows with a six -over-six light configuration, to match existing sizing and profile, and to have true or simulated divided lights (SDL) (exterior muntins); and to reuse existing wood trim if possible or replace in-kind to match existing if not reusable . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Lifsey and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Chair Erquiaga stated that the roof replacement would be shingles for shingles and the Commission cannot require them change it to slate, tile, or metal. Mr. Lenis replied they would like to change it to metal if the Commission would allow it. Chair Erquiaga asked if they were suggesting to put standing seam, like what they plan to use on the front porch roof. Ms. Lenis replied yes. Chair Erquiaga stated that would be an appropriate replacement. Commissioner Lifsey said that the replacement will need to be with the right material. They shouldn’t use 5V metal roofing, like what is used on farm buildings. A standing seam metal with seam spacing to match the porch roof would be appropriate, and was likely on the house originally. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the replacement of the existing main shingle roof with a black 3-tab asphalt shingle roof or a black standing seam metal roof that matches the dimensions, seam crimping, and seam spacing of the existin g metal porch roof. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Commissioner Ferguson made a motion to approve the replacement of the metal porch roof with a black standing seam metal roof to match the dimensions, seam crimping, and seam spacing (17 ½”). The motion was seconded by Commiss ioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: 9 AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Commissioner Sherayko asked for clarification on what they will use to replace the porch floor. Ms. Lenis replied it would be wood tongue and groove flooring. All that is there now is rotted OSB. There is nothing to salvage. Commissioner Langseth made a motion to approve the in -kind replacement of rotten wood elements on the front porch to match existing elements, including the wood tongue and groove porch flooring (approximately 3 3/8 in x 8 ft) . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Commissioner Lifsey asked for clarification that they would be refurbishing the shutters if possible and replacing those that were too far gone. Commissioner Alexander asked if they would keep the same dimensions as the existing ones. Mr. Lenis replied yes, the plan is to scrape and repaint them. Chair Erquiaga specified that they would use wood, not vinyl, for any replacements. Ms. Lenis replied they would replace with wood to match. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve the repair of existing wood shutters if possible, and the in -kind replacement of wood shutters to match existing if not salvageable or missing. The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Ms. Mergenthaler explained that the color listed for the shutters needed to be corrected . The applicant wants to paint the shutters green, not black. Commissioner Sherayko asked if it would be a different green from the body of the house. Ms. Lenis replied no, it would be the same green. The color on the mock up looks darker. Commissioner Lifsey recommended the do a darker shade of green on the shutters. He asked what color the front door would be. Ms. Lenis replied she would like to do a lacquer black. 10 Mr. Lenis said that the front door was vinyl and not original. Commissioner Lifsey asked if they were going to keep that door or replace it. Mr. Lenis replied that they would like to replace it with something that stands out more. They would keep the side lights if they changed it. Commissioner Lifsey asked Ms. Mergenthaler if she could administratively approve a different door. Ms. Mergenthaler replied no, it would have to come to the Commission for approval. Commissioner Alexander asked if they were considering a multi-panel door. Mr. Lenis responded yes, they were considering one with glass. Commissioner Lifsey stated that a glossy black would work well on the front door. Commissioner Alexander asked if the Commission could approve the door now instead of having them come back. Ms. Mergenthaler replied there is no reference and the applicants aren’t certain of what they want. Commissioner Langseth commented that, on the mock up, the shutters do look darker. Commissioner Lifsey said that a few shades darker on the shutters would be perfect. Commissioner Lifsey made a motion to approve painting the siding with “Deep Forest” (green); the trim with “White Duck” (cream); the windows and front door with black; and the shutters with a shade of green that is darker than the siding . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Langseth and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 Chair Erquiaga clarified that any additional work, like replacing the front door and replacing the front porch columns and railing, would require additional COA approval. f) COMMENT: Court House Hill/Downtown Historic District 2025 Boundary Increase for recommendation to the National Register of Historic Places and inclusion in the Virginia Landmarks Register Ms. Eve Mergenthaler stated that the Commission has the opportunity to voice any concerns or comments regarding the Court House Hill/Downtown Historic District 2025 Boundary Increase nomination to send to the Virginia Department of Historic Resources (DHR). DHR will also receive comments from the general public and host a public hearing on October 30, 2025. T his boundary expansion nomination was owner-initiated, likely so that they could utilize tax credits and restore the building. 11 Commissioner Sherayko commented that the original historic district didn’t include this building . There are modern buildings surrounding it, making it an outlier. It is an impressive older building that could benefit from the use of tax credits for restoration. Chair Erquiaga said that it looked like it was made to connect to the Bank of the James building. Commissioner Lifsey replied that he thought it was connected internally at some point , and used for storage. Commissioner Sherayko stated that he was in favor of extending the boundary to include this building. Chair Erquiaga agreed and said he applauded the restoration of older buildings . From what has already been revealed, this building certainly has character. Commissioner Alexander made a motion of support for the Court House Hill/Downtown Historic District 2025 B oundary Increase nomination to the National Register of Historic Places and inclusion in the Virginia Landmarks Register . The motion was seconded by Commissioner Sherayko and passed by the following vote: AYES: Alexander, Englund, Erquiaga, Ferguson, Langseth, Lifsey, Sherayko 7 NOES: 0 ABSTENTIONS: 0 ABSENT: 0 3. NEXT MEETING: The next regular meeting is scheduled for November 17, 2025. 4. ADJOURNMENT: There being no further business, the meeting was adjourned at 5:21 p.m. ATTEST: ____________________________________ ATTEST: _________________________________ Secretary Chair

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.