RecordWell Data

City Council Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Lynchburg · Lynchburg City County · City Council · meeting of Sep 23, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Lynchburg

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY COUNCIL Tuesday, September 23, 2025 | 7:00 PM Council Chamber- City Hall 900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 AGENDA I. Invocation Councilmember Faraldi II. Recognitions III. Consent Agenda III.1. Consideration of approving the minutes from the June 10, 2025, City Council meeting. III.2. Consideration of approving the minutes from the June 23, 2025, Special Called City Council meeting. III.3. Consideration of approving the minutes from the June 24, 2025, City Council meeting. III.4. Consideration of approving the minutes from the June 30, 2025, Special Called City Council meeting. III.5. Consideration of approving the minutes from the July 8, 2025, City Council meeting. IV. Public Hearing IV.6. Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-25-065 approving the submittal of the FY25 Consolidated Annual Performance Report for the CDBG and HOME Program. IV.7. Consideration of introducing Ordinance #O-25-066 approving the FY 2025 Fourth Quarter and Ordinance #O-25-067 approving the FY 2026 First Quarter Adjustments. V. Public Comment V.8. Hear from a group representative regarding "keeping your word". (Greg Berry)(City Elders) V.9. Hear from a group representative regarding "indivisible with liberty and justice for all". (Susan Stengel)(Indivisible Lynchburg) VI. General Business VI.10. Consideration of introducing Ordinance #O-25-___ approving the funding for the Central Virginia Alliance for Community Living (CVACL) in the amount of $25,000 VI.11. Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-___ authorizing the payment of performance-based monetary bonuses to Benefit Programs Specialists employed by the City of Lynchburg's Department of Human Services. Page 1 of 208 VI.12. Consideration of introducing Resolution #R-25-___ amending the FY 2026 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $266,311 to address the damage from the opioid epidemic in the City of Lynchburg and amending the FY 2026 General Fund Budget and appropriating $443,826 from the City/Federal/State Aid Fund to establish four new positions within the Lynchburg Department of Social Services. VI.13. Consideration of introducing Resolution #R-25-___ amending the FY 2026 City/Federal/State Fund budget and appropriating $148,850 to purchase forensic and analytical technology for the Lynchburg Police Department. VI.14. Consideration of introducing Resolution #R-25-___ amending the FY 2026 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $30,000 to purchase a mobile device wellness application for the Lynchburg Police Department. VI.15. Consideration of introducing Resolution #R-25-___ amending the FY 2026 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $150,000 to purchase communication headsets and ergonomic office furniture and chairs for the Lynchburg Emergency Communications Center. VI.16. Consideration of adopting Ordinance #O-25-___ amending the meaning of "Plat" under Article I(C) of the non-exclusive franchise granted to Rosedale Investments, LLC and Rosedale Owners Association, Inc. VII. Closed Session Page 2 of 208 June 10, 2025 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 10th day of June, 2025 at 4:00 p.m. in the 2nd Floor Conference Room, City Hall, Larry Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #1, Council conducted a work session on the FY 2026 Budget. Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick introduced the work session items, including a discussion on reducing the vehicle personal property tax rate as proposed by Councilmember Faraldi. Special Assistant to the City Manager for Data Analytics and Innovation Hollie Jennings and Data Analyst Shaun Conway provided a presentation on the tax proposal, which would reduce the vehicle personal property tax to $1.30 per $100 of assessed value and provide 100% tax relief to the first $20,000 of a vehicle's value. To offset the loss in revenue, staff considered increasing the Real Estate Tax rate to $1.025 per $100 of assessed value, increasing the Lodging Tax rate to 8.5%, and increasing the per-night lodging fee to $3. Mr. Patrick said that the key takeaways of the plan were that more Lynchburg residents would benefit from a reduction of the vehicle personal property tax than they would from a reduction in the Real Estate Tax rate. He said that renters would benefit the most in the short-term, however, rent increases would likely slowly offset the savings. He said that homeowners, especially those who owned multiple or expensive vehicles, would see the most benefit. He said that commercial property owners and multifamily residential property owners would not see a benefit. He said that overall, the proposal shifted the tax burden from residents to commercial property owner. Councilmember Faraldi said the proposal met the City's budget needs and provided tax relief to residents. He noted that some people had already started paying tax bills, and he asked how the proposal would impact those people. Mr. Patrick said that a challenging aspect of the proposal was related to procedural issues, specifically regarding how vehicles were assessed annually and the budget was on a fiscal calendar. He said that the City would have the opportunity to find other temporary avenues for tax relief in the FY 2026 budget to offset the additional revenue collected from people who had already paid the tax bill. Page 3 of 208 June 10, 2025 2 Councilmember Misjuns raised a question about whether the impact of rising property values is fully reflected in the analysis. Mr. Patrick responded that the analysis uses current property values. Councilmember Misjuns asked whether higher costs for developers could reduce the housing supply. Mr. Patrick responded that he does not believe there would be any impact on supply or demand. Councilmember Faraldi asked about how recent car tax payments might affect the plan and what opportunities that could create in the next year. Mr. Patrick explained that the car tax is based on the calendar year, but the budget uses a fiscal year. This means the city gets some car tax money early, which could help extend tax relief. Councilmember Faraldi said that it would offer an opportunity to waive the trash fee and vehicle tag fee for the next year, resulting in estimated savings of $170. Councilmember Timmer asked what the projected revenue would be at an equalized Real Estate Tax rate and at the proposed tax rates. Mr. Patrick said the proposed tax plan provided the same level of revenue as the proposed budget, and the equalized Real Estate Tax rate resulted in $10 million less in revenue. Councilmember Timmer asked if the proposal would impact the composite index formula to determine state funding for schools. Councilmember Faraldi clarified that the City would still receive the state funding because the generated revenue was the same. Mr. Patrick explained that the local composite index was based on the assessed value of real properties, not the tax rate, so the proposal would have no impact. Vice Mayor Diemer asked Commissioner of the Revenue Mitch Nuckles about his perspective of the plan. Commissioner Nuckles expressed concern that changes to the car tax and possible elimination of the license fee could reduce local revenue and lead to unexpected tax bills for some vehicle owners. Vice Mayor Diemer said that there was a lot of uncertainty, especially with the upcoming gubernatorial race, so it may not be the best time to consider the proposal. He asked if changing the Real Estate Tax rate would impact the City's credit rating. Mr. Patrick said that it would not change the credit rating. Vice Mayor Diemer asked the Commissioner if now is a good time to add what he perceives as a more complicated plan that shifts the car tax to homeowners and businesses. Commissioner Nuckles said he will carry out the council’s plan but worry that lower car tax revenue could cause problems. Page 4 of 208 June 10, 2025 3 Councilmember Wilder said he was supportive of the proposal. He asked if it could be implemented in the necessary timeframe, before July 1. Mr. Patrick said there were some process concerns, and they needed to work with the City Attorney's office to determine a plan of action. He said that first, staff needed to determine if Council would support the proposal, after which they could work on implementation. Councilmember Misjuns expressed concerns about shifting tax revenue away from vehicles. He noted that if people could not afford the tax bill on a vehicle, it was easier to sell the vehicle when compared to selling a house. He asked the Commissioner about whether a state-driven formula or funding could replace the $122.2 million in revenue if the tax were eliminated. Commissioner Nuckles responded that it might cover some lost car tax revenue, but finding that money is hard. He expressed concerns about the impact on renters of increasing the Real Estate Tax rate, because landlords would likely pass the increased tax burden to renters rather than absorb the cost. Councilmember Faraldi suggested reducing the proposed Lodging Tax rate and per-night fee to accommodate the hotel industry. He said that the proposal offered an opportunity to provide relief to thousands of residents while meeting budget needs. Councilmember Reed said she agreed with the suggestion to reduce the Lodging Tax rate and the per-night fee. She suggested reducing the Lodging Tax rate to 7.5% and the per-night fee to $2. Vice Mayor Diemer expressed frustration with the Council's focus on massive tax increases, feeling that they had wasted too much time discussing this topic and not enough on reducing spending. He emphasized the need to have a conversation about cutting expenses, citing his own approach to managing household finances as an example. Councilmember Timmer emphasized that a true compromise required a reduction in the request for spending, not just a reduction in the proposed increase. She highlighted the importance of evaluating spending based on policy, rather than allowing spending to drive policy decisions. She stressed the need to prioritize and assess spending, comparing it to how businesses and individuals make decisions about their own finances. Councilmember Faraldi said that three members of the Council expressed support for this concept, two of whom indicated a lower lodging and per night bed fee. He believed that the adjustments Page 5 of 208 June 10, 2025 4 were not traumatic. He said that if a fourth member of Council supported the proposal, a majority of Council would support moving forward. Councilmember Misjuns said that they should take a formal vote on whether to pursue the proposal. Councilmember Faraldi said that his suggestion was to get a consensus from Council that staff should prepare the proposal for a formal action. Mayor Taylor said that he supported the tax proposal. Councilmember Timmer requested that Council hear Councilmember Misjuns' presentation on proposed budget reductions. Councilmember Reed asked staff if they had received enough direction from Council in consideration of the tax proposal given that four councilmembers supported it. Mr. Patrick said that if four members wanted to move forward with the proposal, they could determine a path forward to enact the plan. Mayor Taylor expressed frustration with the ongoing budget discussions, stating that they had been debating for months. He emphasized the need to move forward and take care of the citizens, particularly those in low-income neighborhoods who will benefit from tax relief on vehicles. He gave Councilmember Misjuns 10 minutes to provide his presentation. During Councilmember Misjuns’ presentation, Mayor Taylor, Councilmember Reed, and Councilmember Faraldi temporarily exited the room. Shortly thereafter, Councilmember Wilder also departed, resulting in a loss of quorum. Mayor Taylor later rejoined, reestablishing quorum. Councilmember Misjuns moved, with a second from Vice Mayor Diemer, to suspend the rules of procedure to allow consideration of the tax proposal. No vote was taken on the motion. Councilmember Misjuns continued with his presentation on City revenue based on an equalized Real Estate Tax rate. He proposed several options to close the revenue gap from setting an equalized Real Estate Tax rate, including increasing the ambulance service fee, adjustments to the meals and lodging tax revenue projections, removing the $500,000 in funding for tax relief, delaying the 3% pay increase for City employees to January, eliminating managed vacancy savings, defunding current vacancies (excluding public safety and mission critical positions in Water Resources and Public Works), Page 6 of 208 June 10, 2025 5 capping discretionary non-personnel spending to 110% of actual spending in 2024, and adjusting the fund balance to 10% of the general fund revenue. He said that this plan would allow the City to equalize the Real Estate Tax rate. Councilmember Reed asked if Councilmember Misjuns' proposal was viable. Ms. Witt said that she would not trust the presented figures until she could evaluate them herself. Councilmember Misjuns said that he derived the figures from the proposed budget and submissions of actual costs from 2024. Mr. Patrick said that Councilmember Misjuns' proposal would violate Council's financial policies by about $4.6 million by using one-time funds to balance an ongoing budget. He said that this would make the City's budget structurally unbalanced. He explained that if they delayed salary increases to January, it would cause issues in the next fiscal year as they would have to fund the annual cost, not just half. He said they were already projecting complications for the FY 2027 budget, and these would be exacerbated by delaying salary increases. Mr. Patrick noted that Councilmember Faraldi asked staff one week ago to vet the vehicle personal property tax reduction. He said that staff was able to do that and spent a significant amount of time vetting the proposal. He said that this was the first time staff had reviewed Councilmember Misjuns' proposal. Councilmember Reed noted that they had several months to review a plan, but it was only now just being presented. She asked if Councilmember Misjuns' proposal would impact the City's credit rating. Ms. Witt said that the rating agencies would not look favorably on using one-time funds to address operating needs. Councilmember Timmer asked about the primary revenue source for the adjusted fund balance in the revised general fund revenue. Mr. Patrick emphasized that using one-time funds, or fund balance, for ongoing expenses was a violation of Council's financial policies, and it was the worst financial decision Council could make. Vice Mayor Diemer expressed concerns about considering the tax proposal without a formal vote. He said that the hotel industry deserved an open discussion and a vote. He said that he was not able to Page 7 of 208 June 10, 2025 6 provide spending proposals because he had not received the necessary information from staff. He said they should be open to all proposals to make the budget work, which should include spending reductions. Councilmember Faraldi said a vote on eliminating the car tax is coming, highlighting its impact on residents, and believes staff now have direction to prepare for it. // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Wilder congratulated the recent graduates, and he expressed gratitude for the hard work of teachers, principals, and staff in helping the kids succeed. He announced the Juneteenth celebration details for June 21 from 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. at Miller Park. He thanked staff for their work during the budget session. Councilmember Misjuns expressed concern that Council was considering a Real Estate Tax rate increase beyond the advertised rate without a public hearing or new reassessment notices to property owners, which he stated was not compliant with state law. He noted that consensus among all seven Councilmembers had not been reached to consider a rate of $1.025 per $100 of assessed value. He further stated that the Rules of Procedure required a formal vote on questions before Council, and no vote had been taken on the tax proposal. He expressed that the plan lacked transparency and public input, would shift the tax burden, and could negatively affect the local economy, particularly the real estate industry. Vice Mayor Diemer said he believed the tax proposal should be addressed during a public hearing to comply with state code. He read a statement acknowledging and apologizing for defamatory remarks made against Sean Hunter of the Peacemakers during the November 28, 2023 Council meeting. He requested that duplicative copies of the defamatory remarks under City control must be redacted or removed. He introduced a resolution for Council to direct City staff to take all legally permissible actions to protect the rights and dignity of Sean Hunter, including reviewing City-controlled digital content and enforcing the Council's Rules of Procedure; to formally acknowledge that defamatory statements were made against Sean Hunter at the November 28, 2023 Council meeting and violated the Council's Rules of Procedure; and to direct staff to propose updates to the Rules of Procedure to strengthen enforcement procedures regarding personal attacks and to establish ethical standards for broadcast and camera control; and the City Manager should report back to Council within 30 days of adoption with a summary of actions taken. Page 8 of 208 June 10, 2025 7 Vice Mayor Diemer motioned to adopt the proposed resolution. Councilmember Misjuns called a point of order. He said that making motions during a work session were out of order. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to suspend the Rules of Procedure. Mr. Freedman noted that part of the resolution included language about the Parliamentarian enforcing the Rules of Procedure. He explained that according to the Rules of Procedure, under Section 3.3, the Parliamentarian interpreted the Rules of Procedure as directed by the presiding officer or as required as a point of order. He said that it did not require the Parliamentarian to enforce the Rules of Procedure. He continued that, regarding the motion to suspend the Rules of Procedure, a two-thirds majority vote of Council was required to suspend the rules, but he had never enforced that rule because realistically, Council controlled the rules, so a simple majority could decide to suspend the two-thirds majority requirement. He said that staff should be able to review the resolution before it was adopted, because he had not had the chance to review it, nor had the Clerk. Councilmember Misjuns called the question on the motion to suspend the Rules of Procedure. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Reed 2 Absent: Faraldi 1 Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to adopt the resolution proposed by Vice Mayor Diemer. Councilmember Misjuns apologized to Sean Hunter. He said that it should not have happened. Vice Mayor Diemer emphasized that the issue still deserved justice and respect, and they should remove any copies of the defamatory remarks from social media. Councilmember Wilder said that over the past two years, City Council had been the talk of the country because of its behavior, and they had been anything but nice to people, including dedicated staff members. He believed the motion was out of order. Page 9 of 208 June 10, 2025 8 Councilmember Reed said that the City Attorney had warned about discussing this matter at all, so she was not comfortable moving forward. Councilmember Timmer expressed concerns that there was no way for people to respond when accusations were made against them. She said she supported the resolution. Vice Mayor Diemer called the question. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Reed 2 Absent: Faraldi 1 Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to direct staff to set a public hearing regarding the vehicle personal property tax proposal and send out revised assessment notices. Councilmember Misjuns said it was important to hold a public hearing to maintain transparency. Vice Mayor Diemer stated that raising taxes without a public hearing was a clear violation of state code and emphasized the importance of compliance with the law. Councilmember Wilder said he believed they were only directing staff to prepare the necessary materials, not to formally adopt the proposal. Mr. Freedman stated that he did not believe City staff intended to violate any notice laws regarding the tax proposal. He anticipated that the public hearing and potential vote on the Transient Lodging Tax would occur that evening, and if the Real Estate Tax rate was not addressed, a budget would be brought forward in the near future to comply with Virginia law, with Council adopting a budget before July 1. He said that the plan would be noticed and presented before the public on July 8 or soon thereafter. Mr. Patrick clarified that staff was aware that it would be illegal to adopt a Real Estate Tax rate above $0.89 without proper notice. He explained that staff was asking for direction from Council to develop a plan that would meet Council's goals and the requirements of state code. Councilmember Misjuns expressed concerns about the lack of revised assessment notices being sent to property owners. He said that they needed to resend the assessment notices with information advertising the new tax rate. Page 10 of 208 June 10, 2025 9 Councilmember Faraldi called the question. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Councilmember Faraldi motioned to stand in recess until 7 p.m. // The meeting recessed at 6:30 p.m. // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 10th day of June, 2025 at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Mr. Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 // Councilmember Misjuns led the invocation followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #1, copies of the minutes of the May 6, 2025 City Council meeting were previously furnished to Council, and on the motion of Councilmember Timmer, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, Council, by the following recorded vote, approved the minutes as presented: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #2, Council conducted a public hearing in consideration of adopting an ordinance amending Section 36-223 of the Lynchburg City Code to increase the Transient Lodging Tax to 8.5% of the total amount paid for lodging and $3.00 per room per night, excluding any other taxes levied thereon, by or for any transient to any hotel. Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick provided a summary of the request. At the request of the City Council, the City's Transient Lodging Tax on each transient is proposed to increase from 6.5% to 8.5% of the total amount paid for lodging and from $1 to $3 per room per night, excluding any other taxes levied thereon, by or for any transient to any hotel. These increases are to provide additional revenue from visitors to Lynchburg and reduce the real estate tax burden on citizens. Page 11 of 208 June 10, 2025 10 Adam Hall, Ward 4, speaking in opposition, said he was a small business owner in the City. He expressed concern that a proposed transient occupancy tax hike would hurt local businesses, deter tourism, and penalize the short-term rental industry, which employed his family. He questioned why the City was targeting one industry to make up for budget shortfalls, rather than exploring ways to decrease spending. He urged Council to vote no on the proposal and work towards a sustainable solution for Lynchburg's future. Ed Virtue, representing Cornerstone Hospitality and speaking in opposition, wanted to remind Council that 3,000 of their constituents depended on hospitality and tourism in Lynchburg, with 7.9% of the workforce directly related to the industry. He noted that that Lynchburg was a declining occupancy town, with a 56% decline in occupancy compared to other cities like Roanoke, Charlottesville, and statewide. He said the proposed tax would put an undue burden on average daily rates and reduce the competitiveness of the City. He asked Council to work with the hospitality industry to find a solution that benefitted both the constituents and the industry. Eric Terry, President of the Virginia Restaurant, Lodging, and Travel Association and speaking in opposition, said the proposed tax increase would put an undue burden on the hospitality industry, which was already struggling with below-average occupancy rates. He emphasized the importance of tourism marketing and noted that the industry had not been adequately studied for its potential impact. He highlighted the high cost of credit card fees and the potential for out-of-state visitors to take business elsewhere. He asked Council to reconsider the proposal and engage with the industry to find a solution that would not harm the local economy. Cam Colquitt, Ward 1, speaking in opposition, presented two reasons why voting no was the best course of action for the City and its citizens. He argued that the proposed tax increase would not generate the expected revenue, as other cities had failed to achieve similar results. He estimated that the City would only collect 5% of the projected $13 million, and this revenue would be offset by a 15% reduction in short-term rental properties, a 10% reduction in prospective short-term guests, and a 5% reduction in prospective hotel guests. He projected that this would result in a $4 million reduction in local tourism. Blair Godsey, owner of the Virginian Hotel, speaking in opposition, expressed concern about the proposed increases to the lodging and occupancy taxes. The new proposal to raise the lodging tax from Page 12 of 208 June 10, 2025 11 6.5% to 8.5% and the occupancy tax from $1 to $3 would make the City one of the most heavily taxed markets in Virginia. He said the proposal risked losing lodging, restaurant, retail, and tourism revenue. He offered a compromise, suggesting that Council set the lodging tax at 7.5% and the occupancy fee at $2, which would keep the City competitive with other markets. Shelley Waldeck, Director of Sales and Marketing at the Virginian Hotel, speaking in opposition, cautioned against raising lodging taxes, citing the challenges facing downtown Lynchburg, including construction and vacant storefronts, and warned that a tax hike could risk deterring visitors and harming the local economy. Michael Nevarez, representing the Parry Restaurant Group and speaking in opposition, said that any measure that discouraged overnight stays, such as the proposed lodging tax increase, jeopardized the meals tax revenue. He urged Council to reconsider this proposal. A significant increase in hotel taxes risked making Lynchburg less attractive to visitors, which will have a direct and damaging impact on the broader hospitality economy, including restaurants, retail businesses, and the City's own tax base. David Marple, speaking in opposition, said these visitor taxes may seem harmless, but they carried real consequences. He said that when they raised lodging taxes, they risked driving those visitors elsewhere and hurting the local hotels, short-term rentals, restaurants, and shops. Grayson Ferguson, speaking in opposition, said he owned a woodworking operation which helped build the Virginian Hotel's interiors. He was concerned about the taxes he pays, including personal property tax on his aging equipment, water runoff on his 80,000 square foot roof, and insurance costs. He said it had been difficult to find qualified staff. Andrea Hurtt, speaking in opposition, expressed frustration and concern about the proposed tax increase, stating that it would have a significant impact on residents' lives and would be nearly 40% higher than the current rate. She questioned the lack of public notice and a public hearing, and felt that the City was not addressing the issue of waste, fraud, and abuse. She also highlighted the disparity in salaries, comparing the City Manager's salary to that of the Vice President of the United States. Megan Lucas, representing the Lynchburg Regional Business Alliance and speaking in opposition, urged reconsideration of the proposed lodging tax increase, citing its impact on business Page 13 of 208 June 10, 2025 12 travelers and the potential to discourage travel, limit growth, and increase costs for employers, which could jeopardize the regional economy and compromise fiscal responsibility. Clerk of Council Alicia Finney stated there were eight voicemails. Rebecca Neese, via voicemail and speaking in opposition, said she was a staff member at the Virginian Hotel, and she cited concerns that the proposed tax increase would deter guests and groups from staying at the hotel. Britt Burney, via voicemail and speaking in opposition, said she was the General Manager of the Craddock Terry Hotel. She expressed concern about the lodging cost increase, citing the hotel's slow season and the impact it had on staff, who have struggled to get by during previous slow periods. She questioned the accuracy of projected revenue numbers, suggesting they may be based on outdated data and ignoring the potential for diminishing occupancy and a higher tax rate. She asked Council to consider the concerns of hospitality professionals and to listen to their warnings about the potential negative impact on the community and businesses. Vicki Runk, via voicemail and speaking in opposition, expressed concerns that the proposed tax rates would harm the City's hospitality industry and deter future development. She pointed to Campbell County's more favorable tax environment, which had attracted new hotel projects, and argued that Lynchburg's proposed tax increase would create a competitive disadvantage and accelerate the relocation of new hospitality development outside the City. Linda Furry, via voicemail and speaking in opposition, said she was a business owner, and she expressed concern about the potential tax increase on business owners, particularly those in the hotel and short-term rental industries. She said it would hinder business growth and opportunity in the City. Charles Grant, via voicemail and speaking in opposition, expressed concerns about the proposed tax rates. Liz McCormack, via voicemail and speaking in opposition, said she owned an Airbnb, and she expressed concern about taxes going up. She mentioned that her business was barely making any money. Tom Brizzolara, via voicemail and speaking in opposition, said he owned two short-term rental properties. He expressed concern about the proposed tax increase, stating that there was no precedent Page 14 of 208 June 10, 2025 13 or data to support it. As a business owner with two properties and another business in Lynchburg, he feared that the tax will hinder his ability to rent his properties, and he may be forced to relocate his business to a different location. Emily Grant, via voicemail and speaking in opposition, argued that increasing taxes would negatively impact her long-term goals, including fixing up properties and providing for her children's retirement. She urged the consideration of keeping taxes the same. Councilmember Timmer encouraged fellow councilmembers to review Natasha Cohen's email because she was planning a lodging project in Ward 4. She said that Ms. Cohen suggested a more moderate proposal of a 7.5% Lodging Tax rate and a $2 nightly fee. She said that Ms. Cohen encouraged Council to consider reducing spending and the long-term impact on the City. There was no one else wishing to speak, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the revenue generated from the increased tax could be allocated specifically to the Office of Economic Development or other tourism related projects. He noted concerns that were expressed regarding the City's lack of tourism investment. Mr. Patrick said that they could earmark the funds for economic development or tourism projects, however, it would not help to address the funding gap. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to increase the Transient Lodging Tax to 7.5% of the total amount paid for lodging and $2.00 per room per night. Councilmember Reed asked if there was a way for the City to offer incentives to the hospitality industry. Mr. Patrick said that staff could follow up with that information at a later meeting. Councilmember Timmer expressed concerns over raising the Lodging Tax rate. She emphasized the importance of trusting the community's growth and investment, and not confiscating more than necessary, in order to maintain Lynchburg's prosperity. Councilmember Misjuns said he did not support the increase to the Lodging Tax rate because of the impacts on the hotel industry. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to deny the proposed lodging taxes. Page 15 of 208 June 10, 2025 14 Councilmember Misjuns said that Council needed to be cautious with the tax rates. He said they needed to decrease spending instead of increasing taxes. Councilmember Reed said the work session discussion centered on the lodging tax, with the goal of working together as good stewards of the community. She said a counteroffer was presented, which some stakeholders felt could lead to an agreement, and that was the proposal offered by Councilmember Faraldi. Vice Mayor Diemer said they needed to support the tourism industry because it brought business and outside revenue. He questioned why they would burden one industry rather than propose spending cuts. He noted that there had been no serious spending cuts proposed during the budget process, and he finally heard some suggestions at the work session. He said he would not support the proposed Lodging Tax rate increases. Councilmember Wilder said he did not support the substitute motion, and he did support the main motion. He emphasized the need to consider all of the revenue streams available to the City to ensure a certain quality of life for residents. Mayor Taylor called the question on the substitute motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 Vice Mayor Diemer called the question. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to deny the proposed Lodging Tax rates: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: Wilder 1 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #3, Council conducted a public hearing in consideration of adopting an ordinance amending Section 5-6 of the Lynchburg City Code to make technical changes, increase rates, and create a new rate for Ambulance and Related Services offered by the City of Lynchburg's Fire Department. Chief Financial Officer Donna Witt provided the presentation to Council. Page 16 of 208 June 10, 2025 15 Medicare allows for ambulance billing of up to 150% of Medicare rates. The City of Lynchburg has not changed ambulance rates since 2018 and currently charges well below the 150% allowed. These rate changes were provided by the third-party billing company contracted by the Lynchburg Fire Department and are being provided at the request of members of the City Council. Additional minor technical/grammatical changes have been made to the proposed ordinance since May 27, 2025. Rise Hayes, Ward 1, speaking in opposition, shared her personal experience of having to weigh her health against the cost of medical care due to unaffordable ambulance services. She contracted COVID-19 twice, developed a sinus infection, and caught RSV, resulting in permanent damage to her vascular system and the development of POTS. She emphasized that increasing ambulance rates would make it even more likely for people her age to prioritize money over their health, citing a personal experience of having to pay $1,500 for a one-block ambulance ride in 2012. There was no one else to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Wilder motioned to adopt the ordinance. The motion failed due to a lack of a second. Councilmember Faraldi asked why the matter was on the agenda if Council was not going to vote on it. He noted that Councilmember Misjuns requested to consider the item. Councilmember Misjuns said he had questions, but the motion was made before he could ask them. // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #4, Council conducted a public hearing in consideration of adopting Resolution #R-25-041 to approve the 2025-2029 Five-Year Community Development Block Grant and HOME Program Consolidated Plan and Program Year 2025 Annual Action Plan. Grants Manager Melva Walker provided a summary of the request. The Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) requires local governments, which receive federal community development funds, to prepare a five-year Consolidated Plan and an Annual Action Plan. The plans outline the City’s needs, goals, and objectives for community development (both housing and non-housing areas). The City’s 2025-2029 CDBG and HOME Program Consolidated Plan and Program Year 2025 (Fiscal Year 2026) Annual Action Plan consists of the following: Page 17 of 208 June 10, 2025 16 1. A housing and homeless needs assessment that describes the affordable housing needs of very low-income and low-income households, homeless families and individuals, and others with special needs. 2. A housing market analysis which profiles existing housing options and facilities to assist the homeless, identifies barriers to affordable housing, and reviews institutional and governmental capacities to develop and implement the Plan. 3. A Strategic Plan for addressing priority needs, including the priority non-housing community development needs eligible for assistance under the CDBG Program. 4. An Annual Plan which identifies the activities that will be undertaken to address priority needs and local objectives. The City will receive $750,979 in CDBG entitlement funds and $320,517.96 in HOME entitlement funds for the Program Year beginning on July 1, 2025. Two public notices were placed in The News and Advance on Friday, May 9, 2025, for the 30-day public comment period, and on Sunday, May 25, 2025, for the 15-day public hearing notice and through social media. In accordance with the Council-adopted Citizen Participation Plan, the Community Development Advisory Committee (CDAC) conducted a public meeting on May 20, 2025, to review and discuss these two Plans. CDAC recommended that the documents be approved by the City Council. City staff did not receive any public comments prior to, or after, the CDAC meeting. City Council and citizen comments received at the public hearing regarding the contents of the Consolidated Plan and Annual Action Plan will be incorporated into the final document and submitted to HUD for approval. There was no one to speak in favor or opposition, either by phone or in-person, so the public hearing was closed and the matter rested with Council. Councilmember Wilder motioned, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to adopt Resolution #R- 25-041. Councilmember Wilder expressed gratitude for CDAC's work, particularly in involving community members in the distribution of CDBG funds. He acknowledged the efforts of numerous non-profits in the community, providing a range of services including housing, job training, and resources to combat poverty and homelessness. Page 18 of 208 June 10, 2025 17 Councilmember Timmer said she was excited about the funds being applied to homeownership programs. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #5, Citizen Cynthia Via addressed Council regarding Lynchburg City Schools Board and Lynchburg City Schools health. She expressed her concerns about the safety and well-being of students at LCS schools, stating that the schools were not safe and that the current School Board was uncaring. She shared her daughter's near-death experience which had left her disabled, and she highlighted the need for the School Board to prioritize the schools' safety and well- being. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #6, Citizen Greg Berry, representing City Elders, addressed Council regarding the rainbow. He said that the rainbow belonged to God, and he encouraged everyone to share the true meaning of the rainbow and God's love. He asked Council to support the School Board's decision in banning a citizen from meetings for not following the rules of public comment. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #7, Citizen Tabatha Sprouse, representing GLTC, addressed Council regarding the GLTC Board of Director feedback on 2026 budget planning. She urged Council to read the submitted letter and expressed deep concern over the proposed 40% budget reduction, which would severely impact the community that GLTC served. She said the proposed cuts would result in a budget of roughly $7.7 million for 2026, leading to longer wait times, fewer routes, increased travel costs, and loss of access for residents. She emphasized that public transportation was an essential investment in the City's economy, health, and future. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #8, Citizen Amanda Smithson addressed Council regarding the School Board candidates. She advocated for the appointment of April Watson to the School Board. She emphasized the importance of experienced individuals, particularly those with a background in child development and social work. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #9, Citizen Peter Cefaratti addressed Council regarding doing the math. He expressed frustration over the last-minute revelation of a potential tax increase, which Page 19 of 208 June 10, 2025 18 he felt was unfair and confusing. He questioned why the discussion about the tax rate had not occurred earlier, and why it was being presented at the last minute. He also criticized the lack of discussion about cutting spending and being more efficient, suggesting that a group of rational citizens could have come up with solutions. He felt that the councilmembers were abandoning their responsibilities to the citizens of Lynchburg. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #10, Citizen Gary Taylor, representing Citizens for a Better Lynchburg, addressed Council regarding Bridges to Progress. He discussed the importance of reviving Bridges to Progress, a holistic approach to addressing poverty that was active in Lynchburg from 2013 to 2023. He said that Council should appropriate $25,000 to $50,000 to revive the program // In the matter of Business, Agenda Item #11, Council considered adopting an ordinance to set the Real Estate Tax rate effective July 1, 2025. City Attorney Matthew Freedman provided the presentation to Council. Following the April 22, 2025 Public Hearing and further discussions during City Council work sessions, City Council will vote to set the Real Estate Tax rate effective July 1, 2025. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to amend the agenda and approve the following: direct staff to present a budget at a June 17 special meeting with the no-car tax plan as discussed during the work session and including $1.4 million in budget cuts. Councilmember Faraldi explained that the proposed tax rate discussed at the work session worked mathematically and resulted in a tax cut for most people. He said it incorporated $1.4 million in spending reductions, a tax relief, and funding for increased teacher pay, saving schools, and increased step-pay for firefighters, police officers, and other public safety personnel. Councilmember Faraldi clarified that the change in tax rate did not require a second notice to property owners under state code, but a publicly posted announcement of a hearing on the proposed new rate and an opportunity for citizens to speak was still required. He said the proposed tax rate would enable the largest investment in public safety in the City's history, the largest investment in LCS in years, tax relief for the middle class, no additional burden on lodging, and a reduction in overall spending. He asked for someone to come up with a better proposal. He asked staff if the public hearing had to be held on the coming Tuesday or the following. Mr. Freedman said state code required advertisement for seven days before the public hearing. Page 20 of 208 June 10, 2025 19 Councilmember Faraldi amended his motion to hold the special meeting on June 19. Councilmember Reed agreed to the amendment. Councilmember Reed explained that the proposed changes would benefit households by eliminating the car tax for those with cars valued at $20,000 or less and reducing the rate for those with higher-valued cars, while also bringing back credits on the trash fee and DMV registration fee for a year. This, combined with $1.4 million in cuts, would meet the targets they had discussed, delivering on promises and providing relief to both renters and homeowners, with 91% of households seeing a benefit. Mr. Freedman said that Ms. Witt reminded him of an administrative waiting period required by the newspaper, which was typically three or four days in advance of the initial publication date. Ms. Witt explained that if they submitted the advertisement by June 12 at 3 p.m., it would be published in the paper on June 14. Mr. Freedman said they would be able to hold the public hearing on June 23 or June 24 if they advertised by June 14. Councilmember Faraldi amended the motion to hold the public hearing on June 23. Councilmember Reed agreed to the amendment. Councilmember Misjuns asked what Real Estate Tax rate would be advertised. Mr. Patrick said that they would advertise a Real Estate Tax rate of $1.025 per $100 of assessed value. Councilmember Misjuns said that a landlord in Ward 4 with 225 units would likely increase rent by $50 a month per unit, which would be unsustainable for many renters. He expressed concerns about the need for new notices to be mailed and a new public hearing to be held on the budget. Mr. Freedman said he believed that a public hearing was not required on the budget since the revenues and expenditures were not changing, only the rates were adjusted. He said that he could not speak to the notice requirements at this time. Councilmember Misjuns said that property owners should be notified of the proposed Real Estate Tax rate increase because it was so significant, from $0.89 to $1.025. He noted that the proposal was not a tax decrease because they were just shifting the burden around. He said that the tax increase would drive up rents and mortgage payments, and for him personally, he would pay more in taxes. He said that Page 21 of 208 June 10, 2025 20 personal property was a luxury, and if the taxes were too high, people could easily trade in a vehicle, but people could not easily trade in a house. Councilmember Faraldi said that for a home assessed at $250,000 and two cars assessed at $15,000, the property owners would receive a $147 tax cut, or a 5.47% reduction. He said for himself, he would receive a $37 tax reduction. He noted that at an equalized rate, property owners would still pay more in taxes. He also noted that Councilmember Misjuns had stated numerous times, on the record, that he wanted to eliminate the car tax. He said the proposal reduced taxes for more people in the City and reduced spending. Councilmember Timmer said that policy should drive spending, not the other way around, and it was traditional to set rates before approving the budget. She said it was essential to address deferred maintenance for schools. She also suggested pursuing public-private partnerships to address the pool renovations. She said that if they wanted to achieve a tax cut, they should set the Real Estate Tax rate to the equalization rate and then consider reducing the personal property tax on vehicles. She expressed concerns about the impact on renters of increasing the Real Estate Tax rate. Vice Mayor Diemer made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to set the Real Estate Tax rate at $0.767 per $100 of assessed value. Vice Mayor Diemer said that the proposed tax rates would only benefit government and City Hall and they should set an equalized tax rate. Councilmember Misjuns said that the proposal did not get rid of the car tax, and it only relocated the revenue source. He said that affordability was what brought events and attractions to the City, not its services or name. He pointed out that a 1% tax rate increase can reduce home values by 0.7% to 1.2%. He said that the proposal would negatively impact renters. He expressed concerns about the potential impact on the real estate market, citing the need for a more stable tax policy, and ultimately stated that he would support the motion for equalization. Councilmember Timmer said she supported equalization throughout the budget discussion, citing her mission to address housing instability in the community. She emphasized the need for a sustainable approach to budgets, considering the economic realities. Page 22 of 208 June 10, 2025 21 With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Councilmember Misjuns motioned to amend the original motion. Councilmember Faraldi called a point of order. He stated that a motion could be amended twice or substituted once, but not both. Mayor Taylor called a recess. Council recessed at 9:57 p.m. and reconvened at 10:03 p.m. Councilmember Misjuns motioned to amend the original motion. Councilmember Faraldi called a point of order. He stated that a motion could be amended twice or substituted once, but not both. Mr. Freedman explained that under Rule 8 of Section 6.7 of the Rules of Procedure, if the substitute motion failed, the original motion can then be voted upon, and he believed the reason was to maintain efficiency. Councilmember Misjuns stated that the Rules of Procedure did not prevent an amendment to a motion after a substitute motion was made. He said that since his amendment would not change the substance of the original language, it would not count as a substitute motion, so the amendment was in order. Councilmember Misjuns motioned to amend the motion to change the amount in spending cuts to $11.2 million and send out revised reassessment notices to property owners. Mr. Freedman explained that according to the Rules of Procedure, an amendment was improper if it would have the same effect as rejecting the original motion, leaving it up to the Mayor to determine if the amendment was a rejection of the original motion. Mayor Taylor ruled that the amendment was improper because the substance was a rejection of the original motion. Councilmember Misjuns appealed the ruling. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the appeal. Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Page 23 of 208 June 10, 2025 22 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 The appeal was rejected. Councilmember Misjuns motioned to amend the main motion, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to send out revised notices of reassessment to property owners. Councilmember Misjuns said they needed to notify property owners of the changes. Vice Mayor Diemer said that the proposal was a sneaky tax increase, and it was only fair to notify property owners. Councilmember Timmer said she was interested in a motion to divide the question. Mayor Taylor called the question on the motion to amend. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to amend: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Councilmember Faraldi called the question on the original motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to amend the agenda: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 // In the matter of City Code, Agenda Item #12, Council considered adopting Ordinance #O-25-042 amending Lynchburg City Code Section 11-160.1 to make technical changes and to allow the civil penalties described thereunder to apply to both residential and non-residential derelict structures. Clerk of Council Alicia Finney stated that the item was previously discussed by Council during the May 27 Business Item Briefings. Community Development Director Tom Martin provided the presentation to Council. The City of Lynchburg's 2025 Legislative Agenda requested that the General Assembly amend the Code of Virginia (§15.2-907.1) to remove the civil penalties exemption for derelict commercial or industrial buildings. Delegate Wendell Walker introduced HB2128 Derelict Buildings, removing the exemption for derelict commercial and industrial buildings and allowing cities to impose a civil penalty of $500 per month as is currently allowed for residential properties. The Bill was passed by the General Page 24 of 208 June 10, 2025 23 Assembly and signed by Governor Glen Youngkin. The amendments will become effective July 15, 2025, and technical changes were made to the proposed ordinance since 05/27/2025. Councilmember Misjuns motioned to deny adopting Ordinance #O-25-042. The motion failed because it did not receive a second. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to adopt Ordinance #O- 25-042. Vice Mayor Diemer asked about the current penalties, what they are changing from, and what they are changing to. Mr. Martin replied that homes without utilities for a year can be fined $500 a month to encourage repairs. This doesn’t apply to businesses. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Timmer 6 Noes: Misjuns 1 // In the matter of Business, Agenda Item #13, Council considered approving a standard procedure for voting on School Board appointments. Clerk of Council Alicia Finney stated that the item was previously discussed during the May 27 Business Item Briefings. Current Method: Motion / Second / Substitute Motion / Vote • A Councilmember makes a motion to appoint a nominee. • Another Councilmember must second the motion. • The Council then votes on the motion. • Only one substitute motion may be made at a time. Proposed Method: Ballot Voting • Councilmembers nominate candidates. • Discussion is held among Councilmembers. • Each member casts a single written ballot vote. • Ballots are read aloud, and each member’s vote is publicly announced. • A majority of votes is required to appoint a candidate. • If no candidate receives the necessary majority in the initial ballot, a runoff is initiated. The runoff includes the top two candidates with the highest vote counts. If there's a tie for the second-highest Page 25 of 208 June 10, 2025 24 votes, all tied candidates proceed to the runoff of their own before going up against the candidate with the first-highest votes. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to approve the current procedure. Councilmember Reed said that the procedure had worked in the past, so there was no need to change it. Councilmember Misjuns believed that School Board appointments, and all Council appointments, should be made transparently during open session, including setting salaries for Council appointees. He said he supported a process similar to how they elected the Mayor and Vice Mayor. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion to approve the proposed ballot voting procedure. The motion failed because it did not receive a second. Mayor Taylor called the question on the main motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the main motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Timmer 6 Noes: Misjuns 1 // In the matter of Business, Agenda Item #14, Council considered finalizing the list of School Board candidates to interview for appointments, or reappointments, to vacancies that will exist June 30, 2025, in School Board Districts I, II, III. At its May 27th meeting, City Council began its selection of candidates to interview. The list will be finalized and interviews will be conducted ahead of the June 24th City Council meeting where appointments will ultimately be made. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to adopt the list of School Board candidates. Councilmember Misjuns said he was excited about the slate of candidates. Clerk of Council Alicia Finney announced that interviews were scheduled for June 12, from 9 a.m. to 1:15 p.m. and on June 13, from 4 p.m. to 8:45 p.m. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Page 26 of 208 June 10, 2025 25 Noes: 0 // The meeting adjourned at 10:44 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 27 of 208 June 23, 2025 1 // A special meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 23rd day of June, 2025, at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Larry Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed to adjourn the meeting citing a predetermined understanding that there was insufficient support of the No Car Tax Plan. Mayor Taylor adjourned the meeting. // The meeting adjourned at 7:01 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 28 of 208 June 24, 2025 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 24th day of June, 2025 at 4:11 p.m. in the 2nd Floor Conference Room, City Hall, Larry Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of the Budget, Agenda Item #1, Council conducted a work session on the FY 2026 Budget. Chief Financial Officer Donna Witt and Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick provided a presentation to Council outlining several proposed budget scenarios, including the City Manager's proposed budget, an $0.86 Real Estate Tax rate proposal, an $0.83 Real Estate Tax rate proposal, and a $0.76 Real Estate Tax rate proposal. Vice Mayor Diemer expressed support for an equalized Real Property Tax rate because it kept tax dollars in the pockets of property owners. He said he wanted to introduce a motion to set the Real Property Tax rate at $0.767 per $100 of assessed value. City Attorney Matthew Freedman said that Council would have to suspend its Rules of Procedure before considering a motion during a work session. Councilmember Misjuns questioned the 14% increase for the City Manager's Office salaries and benefits, noting it was significantly higher than the 3% general wage increase for the rest of the City. Mr. Patrick said there were several factors at play, including a previously vacant position being filled and an additional increase for the City Manager provided by Council. He said that staff could follow up with more specific information. Councilmember Misjuns questioned the continued consideration of a 3% general wage increase for all City staff, given that four council members had publicly stated that the priority should be a public safety pay progression plan and teacher funding. Mr. Patrick said that if Council directed staff at a meeting not to fund the Cost of Living Adjustment for general City staff, they would remove it from the budget. He said that staff wanted to avoid stratifying the organization, and he stated that they should apply the same benefits across the organization. Page 29 of 208 June 24, 2025 2 Councilmember Misjuns expressed concerns about the staff assumption that salary increases should be automatically funded. He said that Council should have to vote to include salary increases. Mr. Patrick said that was not how the City Charter worked. He explained that the Charter appointed the City Manager as the budget commissioner and charged him with proposing a budget based on information submitted by City departments. He said that after the City Manager proposed the budget, it was up to Council to accept it, deny it, or change it. City Manager Wynter Benda said that if four councilmembers did not support the 3% general wage increase for City staff, they could remove it from the budget proposal. Councilmember Wilder believed that City workers deserved a 3% raise to reflect the increasing cost of living. He emphasized the importance of maintaining quality of life in the City, including its institutions, parks, and schools, and acknowledged that a raise would help keep city staff from leaving for other counties. He said he was willing to compromise on the budget, but he wanted to maintain the 3% raise for general staff. Councilmember Reed emphasized that the cost of living increase should not be limited to just the police and fire departments, but rather should be given to all essential departments, including IT, water, social services, and others, as they were equally important and played a crucial role in the City's operations. She pointed out that the City was not unique in facing cost increases, and that other businesses and individuals in the City had also seen increases. She said that the City's wasteful spending claims were unfounded because she had not seen any evidence. She explained that the City, like every business, was facing inflated costs for goods and services, which was affecting its budget. She emphasized that the City was not buying luxury items, but rather essential goods and services to function, and it was trying to balance the need for quality workers with the need to help taxpayers. Councilmember Faraldi said that if they reviewed the $0.83 proposal, he wanted to maintain funding for the City Manager's Office data analyst position, the Economic Development and Tourism support for the Lynchburg Regional Business Alliance, the Fire Pulse Point app, the library online cataloging, drop-off recycling sites, court preparation and expert testimony fees, and social services administration. He estimated the total cost to be around $660,000 if they maintained these items. He suggested deferring the Cost of Living Adjustment to January. He asked staff to provide information on Page 30 of 208 June 24, 2025 3 the total cost of the 15.89 vacant FTEs. He suggested that if Council had to remove currently filled FTEs, they should incorporate a minimum of 3 months’ severance pay, and this could be funded through contingencies. Councilmember Timmer expressed frustration with the missed opportunities for discussion on budget cuts, particularly the absence of a vote on a Real Estate Tax rate and the limited public dialogue. She reiterated her willingness to negotiate on rates, but felt disheartened by the missed opportunity to hear public comment, which she believed was an essential part of their job. Councilmember Misjuns asked if they had filled the Assistant Director of Tourism, Assistant Director of HR, or Assistant Director of Economic Development positions. Mr. Patrick said that the Assistant Director of Tourism position had been filled. He said they were undergoing recruitment for the Assistant Director of Economic Development and Assistant Director of HR positions. Councilmember Misjuns suggested stopping recruitment for those positions. He said that instead of cutting funding for filled positions, they should remove funding for vacant positions. Mr. Patrick emphasized the importance of considering the goals and objectives of each department when making decisions about reductions, and he encouraged Council to trust department directors and business managers to identify key resources critical to their success, rather than making arbitrary cuts based on position cost or vacancy. Councilmember Misjuns suggested that if the item were put to a vote, Council would likely support directing the staff not to eliminate positions with people in them and to find alternative solutions for vacant positions. Mr. Patrick warned that it would negatively impact the organization's ability to provide Council's desired level of service. He said that the departments had determined that several of the vacant positions were critical to their missions. He said that arbitrarily deciding which positions to eliminate without using staff expertise was a concern, as it could lead to unnecessary reductions rather than targeted cuts to the proposed budget. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to suspend the Rules of Procedure and direct staff to consider eliminating vacant positions before filled positions. Vice Mayor Diemer suggested that staff should prioritize eliminating vacant positions that had been vacant for more than six months. Page 31 of 208 June 24, 2025 4 Councilmember Misjuns amended his motion to suspend the Rules of Procedure and direct staff to consider eliminating vacant positions before filled positions and prioritize eliminating positions that were vacant for more than six months. Councilmember Faraldi said he did not support the motion because they were in a work session to understand the figures, not set policy. Vice Mayor Diemer said he hoped that Council could have a serious discussion about spending reductions. Councilmember Faraldi asked if the Rules of Procedure would be reinstated after the motion was voted upon. City Attorney Mr. Matthew Freedman said that the Rules of Procedure would be reinstated because the motion was limited to a specific purpose. He asked for clarification as to whether the proposed motion was specific to the positions listed in the materials before Council. He said that there may be departments that had not offered vacant positions because they were critical to operations. He noted that the motion may be encroaching on the Council/Manager form of government. Councilmember Reed expressed concerns about removing positions that were critical to departments. She said she did not support the motion on the floor if it would put departments at risk. Councilmember Timmer expressed concerns that they were having the first reading of the budget without setting the Real Property Tax rate first. She said she supported setting an equalized Real Property Tax rate. She said that she had discussed an $0.83 Real Property Tax rate and an audit committee with the Mayor, but she had not seen any progress with that discussion. Councilmember Faraldi said he was open to a discussion on prioritizing eliminating vacant positions or on setting an $0.83 Real Property Tax rate. He said he did not believe the motion on the floor was appropriate and expressed concerns regarding the way Council was conducting business. Councilmember Misjuns amended his motion to exclude public safety positions from consideration. Vice Mayor Diemer agreed to the amendment. Councilmember Wilder was disappointed with Council's micromanagement of the City Manager and the budget process. He said that Council should choose one of the scenarios presented by staff. Councilmember Misjuns withdrew his motion. Councilmember Misjuns said that if Councilmembers wanted to raise taxes, they should tell citizens where they should cut back on spending. Page 32 of 208 June 24, 2025 5 Councilmember Faraldi suggested compromising on an $0.83 Real Estate Tax rate. Vice Mayor Diemer said he was fully in favor of not funding the 3% cost of living increase. He said that the City needed to have a full, detailed audit that reviewed individual expenditures, and it needed to establish an audit committee. Councilmember Misjuns said he wanted to eliminate trash fees and DMV license fees for two years, or at least one, by reducing the fund balance from 11.8% to 10% of general fund revenue. He expressed concerns about the internal auditor working in the finance department, citing a charter requirement that the auditor be appointed by Council. He said that the capital improvement projects were concerning to him, and he mentioned the incomplete plaster repairs at RS Payne Elementary. He pointed to the example of the Miller Park pool project, where a $500,000 fix was an option, but it was not presented to Council, and instead, a $12 million rebuild was recommended by staff. He questioned the decision-making process and the lack of transparency, stating that it was hard to get answers from staff. Councilmember Reed said she wanted to include funding for items that were removed under the $0.83 Real Estate Tax rate proposal, including tools, equipment, contractual services, uniforms and apparel, and training equipment and props for Fire and Rescue as well as law enforcement supplies and protective wear for Police. She noted that the pool project presented by staff did not only address leaks in the pool itself, but it included a complete renovation and redesign of the facilities and grounds. She noted that the bathrooms needed to be renovated, and the City would realize cost savings by doing all of the repairs and renovations at once rather than piecemeal. Councilmember Faraldi said he did not support funding for conferences for Fire and Rescue. He said he did not support funding for third-party promotion assistance because department leadership should be able to make those decisions. He noted that the cost for investigation services and apparel and protective wear for the police were relatively minor and should be kept in the budget. He also proposed exploring the idea of an audit committee, but was skeptical about hiring an additional staff member to serve as an auditor. Councilmember Timmer suggested moving funding for one of the communications positions to support an auditor position directly reporting to Council. She noted that, regarding Miller Park pool, it Page 33 of 208 June 24, 2025 6 could be repaired for $500,000, but no repair projects were presented to Council. She said that an internal auditor could help improve City processes and keep them accountable. Councilmember Faraldi said he supported funding for the zoning enforcement position. He said he would rather remove funding for the online library cataloguing and other smaller items to keep funding for the position. He asked if staff needed any further direction from Council. Mr. Patrick said that if Council wanted to add back the items noted by Councilmembers, they were closer to an $0.84 Real Estate Tax rate than $0.83. He said that if Council wanted to establish an audit committee, staff needed to know whether it would require a new staff position. He noted that an auditor would also require support staff. Councilmember Timmer said that Council could fund an audit position for one year with one-time funds, or they could appoint the elected Treasurer to oversee the audit functions. Councilmember Faraldi said that Council could instruct the treasurer to perform such functions, according to the Charter. He said that Council should consider establishing an audit committee to work with the Treasurer rather than establish a whole new department. Mr. Patrick said that if they hired an auditor for one year with one-time funds, it would be difficult to recruit someone and have them complete an audit in that timeframe. Councilmember Reed said she supported starting with an audit committee. Councilmember Misjuns said he supported deferring the cost of living salary adjustments to January. Councilmember Faraldi said he would support deferring the Cost of Living Adjustment even though it would have budget implications for the following year. Councilmember Misjuns said he would support maintaining funding for GLTC over funding the Cost of Living Adjustment for City staff. He suggested that they could reduce the Cost of Living Adjustment from 3%. Councilmember Faraldi said he would support reducing it to 2% to maintain funding for GLTC instead of deferring the Cost of Living Adjustment to January. Councilmember Wilder said he supported a 3% Cost of Living Adjustment effective July 1. Councilmember Reed said she supported a 3% Cost of Living Adjustment effective July 1. Page 34 of 208 June 24, 2025 7 Mr. Patrick said that if they were to restore all of the reductions suggested by Council, including Fire and Rescue, Police, and GLTC, and move to a 2% cost of living salary adjustment, it would require an $0.84 to $0.845 Real Property Tax rate. He said that staff could draft an ordinance with that level of expenditure. Councilmember Faraldi suggested having staff present the expenditures and tax rate as the first item on the regular meeting agenda. Councilmember Misjuns said he would accept that proposal if Council agreed to adopt a rate. Mr. Patrick said that staff would present on the budget reductions that were restored and the corresponding tax rate to meet the expenditure requirements. Councilmember Faraldi emphasized that the conversation had been productive, and only four votes were required to make the proposal happen. He said the funds primarily benefited teachers, police officers, and firefighters. He proposed that Council recess until the regular meeting. // The meeting recessed at 6:25 p.m. // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 24th day of June, 2025 at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Mr. Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 // Vice Mayor Diemer led the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of Item Not on the Agenda, Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to amend the agenda to allow anyone who was present at the meeting on June 23 an opportunity to speak during Public Comment. Councilmember Faraldi said that if people wanted to speak during public comment, they should sign up prior to the meeting. He explained that the public hearing and item before Council at the meeting the night before failed and was no longer considered by Council. He said he would be voting against the motion. Page 35 of 208 June 24, 2025 8 Councilmember Wilder said he would vote against the motion because there had already been several opportunities for public comment. Councilmember Timmer voiced frustration over the lack of public input at the prior meeting. Councilmember Misjuns said that they had to prioritize listening to public comment. He explained the last meeting was not officially adjourned, so he seconded a tax rate motion before the work session. He supported letting people speak since they did not get a chance earlier. Councilmember Faraldi said the tax motion was not allowed because Council was in recess. He’s filing a FOIA request because Vice Mayor Diemer and Councilmembers Misjuns and Timmer met after the recess without public notice or minutes, which he says breaks state law. He believes the motion was an attempt to make that unofficial meeting seem official. Vice Mayor Diemer said it was right to stay and hear the public, even if the meeting was not official. He said no action was taken, just listening and prayer. He criticized those who left and said he would do it again, even if it broke the rules. He believes their rights come from God, not the government. Councilmember Reed explained the public hearing was legally required due to proposed tax increases, but it was not the first chance for public input since citizens had shared feedback for months. She said the meeting was adjourned early because the measure would not pass, no debate was planned, and Council would present and discuss the budget at tonight’s meeting instead. She called the question. Councilmember Timmer stated her desire to read an email into the record, addressed to the City Attorney, regarding the Rules of Procedure and the legality of the meeting the night before. Mr. Freedman advised that if the letter was addressed to him, it could have elements of attorney- client privilege, but he did not know the contents of the communication. Mayor Taylor permitted Councilmember Timmer to read the email. Councilmember Timmer read the email into the record. She expressed concerns about the violation of transparency and accountability rules during a public meeting on June 23, 2025, regarding a Real Property Tax proposal. She pointed out that a motion to adjourn was made without a recorded vote, violating the rules that require a vote for procedural motions, including adjournments. Mr. Freedman said the City Attorney represents the City, not individual members, and only the Council can waive privilege. He said the meeting ended properly when most members left, so no Page 36 of 208 June 24, 2025 9 business could happen. The Mayor’s adjournment was valid, and that the Rules of Procedure were for Council's convenience and efficiency. Mayor Taylor accepted full responsibility for the issues arising from adjourning the meeting the night before. He called the question. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 Mayor Taylor asked people in the gallery to raise their hands if they were present at the last meeting and wished to speak. He noted that five people raised their hands. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #1, Citizen Rise Hayes addressed Council regarding religious freedom violations. She raised concerns about promoting religious beliefs in public schools, saying it could violate the First Amendment. She noted the difficulty of choosing one religious viewpoint and pointed out that private schools already offer faith-based education. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #2, Citizen Jeff Rosner addressed Council regarding School Board Appointments. He noted School Board candidates who supported including Creationism in LCS curriculum. He said that teaching Creationism in LCS would violate the Constitution as well as Virginia's Standards of Learning and accreditation requirements. He submitted materials to the Clerk related to his comments. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #3, Citizen Greg Berry, representing the City Elders, addressed Council regarding evil. He expressed concern about the moral direction of the City. He opposed the proposed tax increase, called for equalizing the Real Estate Tax rate, and urged the Mayor to follow God’s guidance or step down. // Councilmember Misjuns called a point of order. He said that Council adopted a motion that allowed everyone who wished to speak at the previous meeting the opportunity to speak, not just five people. Councilmember Faraldi motioned to listen to five people who wished to speak at the previous meeting. The motion did not receive a second and failed. Mayor Taylor said that six people would be allowed to speak. Page 37 of 208 June 24, 2025 10 // In the matter of Public Comment, Item Not on the Agenda, Citizen Sam Howe addressed Council regarding vehicle personal property tax proposal. He argued that lowering the Real Estate Tax rate would mostly benefit large corporations, while lowering the vehicle tax would provide broader relief to local residents. // In the matter of Public Comment, Item Not on the Agenda, Citizen Peter Cefaratti addressed Council regarding concerns about the June 23, 2025 meeting. He said that the meeting could have been adjourned appropriately or handled differently. He said that Council should have listened to public comment, even if they were not considering the proposal. // In the matter of Public Comment, Item Not on the Agenda, Citizen Rise Hayes addressed Council regarding treatment of the City Manager. She said it was unfair to blame him for budget decisions made by Council and suggested the criticism could be grounds for legal action if it continued. // In the matter of Public Comment, Item Not on the Agenda, Citizen Ron Storer addressed Council regarding impacts of taxes. He expressed concerns about how a Real Property Tax increase would impact him since he was on a fixed income. He said he would be happy for corporations like Walmart to have lower taxes because it may mean that they reduce the price of groceries. // In the matter of Public Comment, Item Not on the Agenda, Citizen David Ream addressed Council regarding lowering the tax rates. He expressed concerns about the increases to his property taxes. He said he appreciated that Council would lower taxes for corporations because it encouraged business in the City. He said he was on a limited income, and he requested that Council eliminate the vehicle Personal Property Tax rate and lower the Real Property Tax rate below equalization. // In the matter of Public Comment, Item Not on the Agenda, Citizen Beth White addressed Council regarding concerns about the June 23, 2025 meeting. She said that the meeting felt hostile and intimidating. She called for more respectful dialogue, noting that many residents are struggling financially and hoping for practical solutions like vehicle tax relief. // In the matter of Water Resources, Agenda Item #4, Council considered adopting Resolution #R-25-043 to direct the notification of the Campbell County Utilities and Service Authority (CCUSA) of the City's intention to enter into a new water contract on July 1, 2027, while also reserving the right to renegotiate the terms of the City's current contract with the CCUSA. Clerk of Council Alicia Finney stated that the item Page 38 of 208 June 24, 2025 11 was previously introduced at the June 10 PDC meeting. Director of Water Resources Tim Mitchell provided the presentation to Council. The current water contract between the City of Lynchburg and Campbell County Utilities and Service Authority (CCUSA) expires on June 30, 2027. By contract, the City must notify CCUSA in writing by June 30, 2025, of our intent to renew or terminate the contract. Failure to notify will result in an automatic 10-year renewal under the current terms beginning July 1, 2027. Staff will provide an overview of the current contract and a previous Contract Supplement that is still in effect, along with recommendations for the contract extension. At its June 10, 2025 meeting, the Physical Development Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Timmer brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion to adopt Resolution #R-25-043. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Community Development, Agenda Item #5, Council considered introducing Resolution #R-25-044 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $15,000 to fund a wayfinding system for the Dunbar Community Schoolyard. Clerk of Council Alicia Finney stated that the item was previously discussed by the Finance Committee on June 24, 2025. Director of Community Development Tom Martin provided the presentation to Council. The Department of Community Development has been awarded a $15,000 Flagship Grant from the 2025 AARP Community Challenge Grant Program to fund a wayfinding system for the Dunbar Community Schoolyard. The Grant will provide funds for pedestrian-oriented wayfinding signs to be placed at entrances to the schoolyard. At its June 24, 2025 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Misjuns brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion to adopt Resolution #R-25-044. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 Page 39 of 208 June 24, 2025 12 // In the matter of Fire Department, Agenda Item #6, Council considered introducing Resolution #R-25- 045 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $12,269 to purchase Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) for the Fire Department. Clerk of Council Alicia Finney stated that the item was previously discussed by the Finance Committee on June 24, 2025. Fire Chief Greg Wormser provided the presentation to Council. The VDFP administers this grant to lessen the economic burden for localities. The Fire Department was awarded a grant for PPE. This grant is 100% reimbursable; no local match is required. Councilmember Misjuns noted that the turnout gear was specifically designed for hot weather, and there was no local match required. At its June 24, 2025 meeting, the Finance Committee recommended approval. As Chair of that committee, Councilmember Misjuns brought the committee’s recommendation for approval forward as a motion to adopt Resolution #R-25-045. No second was required, and Council, by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #8, Council considered appointing School Board members for terms beginning July 1, 2025, in Districts I, II, and III. Clerk of Council Alicia Finney stated that Council held interviews on June 12 and June 13. Section §22.1-50 of the Code of Virginia and Section §32-16 of the City Code provide that within thirty days preceding July 1st of each year, City Council shall appoint a successor for each school board member whose term expires on June 30th of that year. Additionally, due to a voluntary resignation effective June 30, 2025 from a member in District II, a forthcoming vacancy has been created that will also need to be filled. Mayor Taylor opened the floor for appointments for District I. Councilmember Faraldi motioned to appoint to Marques Bush for District I. There was no second, so the motion failed. Councilmember Wilder motioned to appoint Selina Morgan for District I. There was no second, so the motion failed. Page 40 of 208 June 24, 2025 13 Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to appoint Rev. Nigel Alleyne for District I. Councilmember Misjuns said he had known Rev. Alleyne for a long time, and he would be dedicated to the position. He noted his education experience through his church. Vice Mayor Diemer said he had known Rev. Alleyne for a long time. He said that Rev. Alleyne was a calming influence and would be good for the School Board. Councilmember Timmer said she supported Rev. Alleyne due to his background and capacity for collaborative approaches. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 5 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi 2 Mayor Taylor opened the floor for appointments for District II for a new term. Councilmember Reed motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to appoint Myke Barron to a new term for District II. Councilmember Reed said she had known Mr. Barron for a few years. She said he was a parent of LCS students and a former teacher, so he understood the issues within the schools. Vice Mayor Diemer made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to appoint Dr. Harvey Klamm for District II. Vice Mayor Diemer said that Dr. Klamm was his childhood soccer coach. He noted Dr. Klamm's extensive experience, wisdom, and administrative expertise. He said that Dr. Klamm would bring success to LCS. Councilmember Timmer said that Dr. Klamm's experience was essential for the School Board. She encouraged everyone to watch his interview. Councilmember Wilder said he did not support the appointment of Dr. Klamm. He said that School Board members should have public school experience, and Dr. Klamm did not have any. Councilmember Reed maintained her support for Mr. Barron because he had children in LCS. She noted that Dr. Klamm had private school experience, but he did not have public school experience, which was necessary to address the issues LCS was facing. Page 41 of 208 June 24, 2025 14 Mayor Taylor said he supported Mr. Barron because of his ties to the community. Councilmember Faraldi said he would be voting against the substitute motion because he believed Mr. Barron should be considered for a full term. Councilmember Misjuns said he supported Dr. Klamm. He expressed concerns about an after- school program Mr. Barron ran called Hot Topics, where students discussed various topics, including politics. He said that parents had stated they did not want teachers discussing those things with students, and as a parent, he did not want teachers or anyone discussing topics such as politics, gender, or sexuality with students. Mayor Taylor called the question on the substitute motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Councilmember Faraldi clarified that Mr. Barron facilitated an after-school program in Texas where students could debate various topics. He noted that the program did not include any instruction. He shared a similar experience from when he was in high school, where he engaged in debates with peers, and it led to valuable discussions and learning how to remain civil. Vice Mayor Diemer said he questioned each applicant about the $10,000 grant E.C. Class received for an LGBTQ-friendly safe room, asking if they would have accepted it. He said that he did not intend for the question to be a litmus test, but he thought it would show a candidate's character. He said that he thought the School Board was right in denying the grant because it did not pertain to education. He said he could not support a candidate who would accept the grant. Councilmember Timmer said she respected Mr. Barron's leadership and dedication to the community, but she would support other candidates. Councilmember Misjuns asked how being appointed to the School Board would impact Mr. Barron's job as a bus driver. City Attorney Matthew Freedman said that they would have to look into it since all LCS employees were appointed by the School Board, so Mr. Barron may not be able to maintain his position. Page 42 of 208 June 24, 2025 15 Councilmember Misjuns said he was afraid of people creeping into the school system to indoctrinate students. He noted that the grant for E.C. Glass was funded by the It Gets Better Project, which was associated with an organization called the Trevor Project. He expressed concerns about the source of funding because the projects supported gender affirming care. He encouraged Mr. Barron to protect the students of LCS like they were his own kids. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to appoint Myke Barron to a new term for District II: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to appoint Jibri Poe to the vacant position on the School Board for District II. Councilmember Timmer made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, to appoint Dr. Harvey Klamm to the vacant position on the School Board for District II. Councilmember Timmer acknowledged the need to balance various factors within the school division, and she highlighted the strengths of Dr. Klamm, including his outside perspective and experience. Councilmember Faraldi said he supported Mr. Poe for his dedication, for being a parent of LCS students, and for his community engagement. He noted that Dr. Klamm had no experience in LCS, and the School Board needed more members who were parents of LCS students. He said he would be voting against the substitute motion. Councilmember Misjuns supported Dr. Klamm because he was a Virginia State certified superintendent and had an exceptional background in policymaking. He said that LCS needed a fresh perspective, and Dr. Klamm offered that. Councilmember Reed noted that Mr. Poe worked part-time in the City's group-home, and he understood the needs of students. She said that working with and mentoring students was a valuable strength when addressing issues like truancy, behavior, and academic problems. She said that Dr. Klamm lacked relatability to the specific problems students in the school system faced. Page 43 of 208 June 24, 2025 16 Councilmember Wilder questioned the motives of people who had not volunteered for LCS but wanted to serve on the School Board. He said that School Board members should have a vested interest in LCS. Vice Mayor Diemer said that Dr. Klamm had public school experience because he supervised Liberty University students who worked as student teaches in LCS. He noted that this was the same thing his mom did. He said that Dr. Klamm had a proven track record of improving academic scores and had the support of teachers. He said that the School Board needed an older, wiser voice, and Dr. Klamm had that voice. Councilmember Faraldi said that the School Board did not need more administrators, professors, teachers, or doctors. He said that they needed parents on the School Board. He said he would vote against the substitute motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Councilmember Timmer said she would support Mr. Poe's nomination. She encouraged people to watch Mr. Poe's interview, because having children in LCS was not part of the questioning. She said that Mr. Poe would bring a culture of honor to the School Board. Councilmember Misjuns said he would support Mr. Poe's nomination because Mr. Poe had proposed consolidating the City Government and LCS IT departments since they were located in the same facility. He noted that he had advocated for consolidation for years. Vice Mayor Diemer said he would support Mr. Poe's nomination. Councilmember Wilder said he would support Mr. Poe's nomination. Ms. Finney stated that she had received Councilmember Misjuns' statement of disclosure that he was the member of a group representing spouses of teachers employed by LCS, but he was able to consider the matter impartially. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to appoint Jibri Poe: Page 44 of 208 June 24, 2025 17 Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 Mayor Taylor opened the floor for appointments for District III. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to appoint Dr. Brenda Farmer for District III. Councilmember Wilder made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to appoint Gloria Preston for District III. Councilmember Wilder said he appreciated Ms. Preston's experience as a former principal, administrator, and School Board member. He noted her continued involvement in the school system. He highlighted the need for her insight and dedication to support the new superintendent. Councilmember Faraldi said that while he strongly disagreed with Ms. Preston's voting record, he recognized the value of her experience, which he believed was crucial for effective governance. Councilmember Timmer praised Dr. Farmer's heart, ability to hold people accountable, and kindness. Councilmember Reed believed that Ms. Preston's experience and continuity would be necessary for the School Board. Councilmember Misjuns said he would be voting against the substitute motion. He said that Dr. Farmer brought a new perspective to the School Board. Vice Mayor Diemer said that Dr. Farmer was his assistant chief at the Liberty University voting precinct, and he commended her for preparing students to vote. He said the truancy problem was getting worse, and they needed to address the school-to-prison pipeline, and Dr. Farmer would be able to address those issues. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion to appoint Gloria Preston for District III: Ayes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 Noes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to appoint Dr. Brenda Farmer for District III: Page 45 of 208 June 24, 2025 18 Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 5 Noes: Faraldi, Wilder 2 // Council recessed at 9:15 p.m. and reconvened at 9:25 p.m. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to reconsider the appointment of Jibri Poe to the School Board after regular business. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: Wilder 1 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #7, Council conducted a first reading on the adoption of the FY 2026 Budget. Chief Financial Officer Donna Witt presented to Council. Following the April 22, 2025 Public Hearing and further discussions during City Council work sessions, including staff adjustments, the Proposed FY 2026 General Fund Budget was reconciled as follows: Fund Balance With the adjustments noted above, the Unassigned General Fund Balance as of June 30, 2026 is projected to be $24,349,125 or 10.4% of revenues. City Council’s target for Unassigned General Fund Balance is a minimum of 10% of General Fund revenues with a goal of 15% as the City strives to grow incrementally each year subject to revenues available. Page 46 of 208 June 24, 2025 19 Ms. Witt reviewed the budget items which were added as a result of the work session discussion: a data analyst position in the City Manager's Office; the short-term rental monitoring service and zoning official position in Community Development; Lynchburg Regional Business Alliance partnership funding; the Pulse Point app, the reduction for minor tools, equipment, and contractual services, training equipment and props, conference funding, and uniforms and apparel for the Fire Department; apparel and protective wear, the reduction in investigation services, and law enforcement supplies for the Police Department; online cataloguing for the Library; drop off recycling for Public Works; court preparation and expert testimony fees for Social Services; GLTC component funding; and the 3% COLA for City staff was reduced to 2.5% effective July 2. Councilmember Misjuns asked if the figures included the waiver of trash fees, DMV license fees, and the reduction of fund balance to 10% of general fund revenues. Ms. Witt said they included a one-year waiver of the trash and DMV license fees with one-time funds by reducing the fund balance. Councilmember Wilder expressed concerns about the programs and services which remained unfunded in the budget, such as the senior citizen center, the Jackson Heights Center, the naturalist program, and the downtown library closure. He said he wanted citizens to understand the budget impacts. Councilmember Faraldi noted the desire for a staffed position for the proposed audit committee. He suggested removing $100,000 from the unassigned fund balance to align it with the audit committee. He said they could then fully define the role of the auditor position and use the funds to support the position with full knowledge of what they would be used for. He asked if Councilmember Timmer supported this proposal as a compromise. Councilmember Timmer said she continued to support an equalized Real Property Tax rate. She emphasized the value of establishing an audit committee to check growth in City government. She said she was worried that the audit committee would not amount to what they intended for it to be. Councilmember Faraldi suggested that the Mayor appoint Councilmember Timmer and himself to serve on the committee to ensure it was established properly. Councilmember Wilder expressed interest in serving on the committee. Page 47 of 208 June 24, 2025 20 Councilmember Faraldi said he would support Councilmember Wilder in his place. He said he would second a motion from Councilmember Timmer to set the Real Estate Tax rate and approve the audit committee appropriations as proposed. Councilmember Timmer said she was not willing to make that motion. Councilmember Faraldi said he did not want to appropriate funds for a position without establishing what the position would entail. He said he did not agree with an audit committee because the City already had an audit process, but he was willing to compromise. He noted that during the work session and private conversations, Councilmember Timmer needed funds to support the audit committee. He asked if Councilmember Timmer supported an $0.84 Real Property Tax rate. Councilmember Timmer said she did not support an $0.84 Real Property Tax rate, partially due to the nature of the conversation. Councilmember Faraldi noted that Councilmember Timmer had expressed support for an $0.83 Real Property Tax rate. He said he was compromising on the audit committee, and there were $3.1 million worth of spending cuts to the budget, yet Councilmember Timmer was backing out of the compromise. Councilmember Timmer said the audit committee stood on its own merits, and she supported an equalized Real Estate Tax rate. She said she was concerned about the follow-through from Council, but she hoped their conversations would continue. Councilmember Faraldi asked what he could do to alleviate the concerns over trust. Councilmember Timmer said that was a discussion she would have behind closed doors, but she would not have it in public. Councilmember Faraldi asked at what rate the vehicle Personal Property Tax rate would have to be set to effectively have an $0.84 Real Property Tax rate. Mr. Patrick said that the vehicle Personal Property Tax rate would have to be set to $3.00 to provide the same value of tax relief as an $0.84 Real Property Tax rate. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to set the Real Property Tax rate to $0.767. Page 48 of 208 June 24, 2025 21 Mayor Taylor ruled Councilmember Misjuns out of order. He said that Councilmember Faraldi retained the floor. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to hold a special meeting on the night of June 30, 2025 for the second reading of the budget and to consider setting the vehicle Personal Property Tax rate to $3.00 per $100 of assessed value. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion to hold a special meeting at 10 a.m. on June 30, 2025 for the second reading of the budget and to consider setting the vehicle Personal Property Tax rate to $3.00 and the Real Estate Tax rate to $0.82. Mr. Patrick said that if the vehicle personal property tax was reduced to $3.00, and Council wanted to maintain sufficient funds for the budget, the Real Estate Tax rate would need to remain at $0.89. Councilmember Misjuns said that setting the vehicle Personal Property Tax rate to $3.00 and the Real Estate Tax rate to $0.82 would further reduce the tax burden by $1.8 million below equalization. Councilmember Reed expressed concerns about the games that other councilmembers were playing with the budget process. She noted that they were being accused of being untrustworthy, yet all attempts at negotiation and compromise were now being reneged. She said that staff had been abused by councilmembers for three months during the budget process. Councilmember Misjuns withdrew his substitute motion. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to hold a special meeting at 10 a.m. on June 30, 2025 for the second reading of the budget and to consider setting the vehicle Personal Property Tax rate to $3.00 and the Real Estate Tax rate to $0.84. Councilmember Faraldi said he would oppose the substitute motion. Councilmember Misjuns said the budget included $249,663,000 in expenditures, a $14 million increase from last year's budget. He emphasized the need to rein in spending and proposed a substitute motion that would create a revenue-neutral budget, reducing spending by about $11.2 million. He pointed out that this is a historic tax increase. He reiterated his commitment to smarter spending, stating that he opposed projects such as amphitheaters, reimagined municipal projects, or moving the municipal Page 49 of 208 June 24, 2025 22 complex and courts, and he did not support $14 million in new spending. He emphasized that his substitute motion aimed to put citizens first and protect their wallets. Councilmember Timmer said she supported an equalized real estate tax rate. She said they should consider the opportunities before them. Councilmember Faraldi said he would be voting against the substitute motion. Vice Mayor Diemer reiterated his proposal for a $0.767 equalized rate, which he had tried to implement, and he expressed frustration that the City was now considering a different approach. He said his original proposal was a $0.75 Real Estate Tax rate, but he compromised on the equalized tax rate. He said that an equalized tax rate would not defund critical programs or services, and the City would receive the same, if not more, revenue. Councilmember Reed said lowering the Real Estate Tax rate equally would cause 32 job losses, including 16 filled positions, within a week. It would also mean cutting the 3% cost of living raise, reducing school funding, and cutting $9.3 million from city services like public safety, schools, and social services, which would greatly affect residents. Councilmember Wilder expressed his opposition to the substitute motion, citing a broken process. He thanked his former colleagues for successful past budget processes. He said he had never experienced a budget process like the current one. Councilmember Timmer offered an amendment to the substitute motion to set the vehicle personal property tax to $2.95 and the Real Estate Tax rate to $0.83. She said that she supported a revenue-neutral budget. She expressed concerns over the difficulty of accessing information from department leadership, debating budget line items, and reviewing the impacts of an equalized Real Estate Tax rate. She suggested amending the budget process to align it more with past processes. Mayor Taylor called the question on the substitute motion. Ms. Finney clarified that the motion proposed holding a special meeting on Monday, June 30, 2025 at 10 a.m. to conduct a second reading of the budget, reduce the vehicle personal property tax to $2.95, and set the Real Property Tax rate to $0.83. Mr. Patrick said that the proposed rates were equivalent to a rate lower than equalization, so Council would need to find $5 million in additional reductions. Page 50 of 208 June 24, 2025 23 With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the original motion to hold a special meeting on June 30, 2025 at 10 a.m. to conduct a second reading of the budget and set the vehicle Personal Property Tax rate to $3.00: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: Diemer 1 Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to set the Real Property Tax rate to $0.767 per $100 of assessed value. Councilmember Misjuns expressed frustration with the budget process. He specifically pointed out $14 million in new spending, a 5.6% increase, which he could not support. Councilmember Wilder opposed the motion. He noted that the $0.89 Real Estate Tax rate also resulted in budget cuts to vital community resources, such as the senior center. Councilmember Timmer said she hoped they could craft a budget that grew at the rate of inflation. Councilmember Reed said she could not support an equalized Real Estate Tax rate because of the budget cuts which would be required. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to set the Real Property Tax rate to $0.767: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to adopt Ordinance #O- 25-046 increasing the Water, Sewer, and Stormwater Rates. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Reed, Timmer 4 Noes: Diemer, Faraldi, Misjuns 3 Page 51 of 208 June 24, 2025 24 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to consider introducing Ordinance #O-25-047 appropriating the FY 2026 General Fund Operating Budget (excluding Discretionary External Service Providers and Schools Operating Budget). Councilmember Faraldi said they eliminated the $10 trash fee and $35 DMV fee, cut $3.1 million in spending, and funded teacher pay raises and public safety increases. Depending on Monday’s meeting, they would also reduce personal property tax significantly. He supported funding police, firefighters, and teachers and was okay losing votes over it. Some jobs would be cut, but he aimed to provide severance and consider affected employees for other city roles. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to adopt the Public Safety budget of $58,826,627, and the Judicial Administration budget at $7,171,390. Councilmember Misjuns said this would fully fund the requests for public safety and the criminal justice system. He noted that the proposed budget included about $450,000 less in funding for public safety and judicial administration, which he could not support. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 5 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi 2 Councilmember Misjuns clarified that the motion was to appropriate funds for public safety and judicial administration at the original FY 2026 request in the operating budget and the general fund expenditures as shown in the ordinance. Councilmember Faraldi said he would be voting against the motion, and he would renew his motion to pass the proposed budget once the motion on the table failed. He expressed concerns about restoring funding for apparel, conferences, and third-party promotional assistance when they had to consider cuts elsewhere. Mr. Patrick clarified that Council would need to find almost $634,000 in reductions in other areas of the budget. Councilmember Misjuns stated that the judicial administration funding was a relatively small cost of $50,000, and emphasized the importance of maintaining previous investments in the Sheriff's Office Page 52 of 208 June 24, 2025 25 and the Commonwealth Attorney's Office. He also highlighted the critical role of the Fire Department's administrative and emergency management positions. He noted that his proposal restored a $100,000 match for capital equipment, and it was typically better to have a neutral third-party be involved in public safety promotional processes. He said that part-time personnel for the Sheriff's Office were force- multipliers. He said that apparel funds were important because they needed to ensure firefighters and officers were not doing their jobs with holes in their clothes. Councilmember Wilder said he did not support the new motion because it added an additional $600,000 to the budget that needed to be addressed. Mayor Taylor called the question. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 Councilmember Faraldi asked the Mayor where he would find $600,000 to address the delta. Mayor Taylor said that they would find the revenue through an $0.84 Real Property Tax rate. Councilmember Faraldi said he would not support an $0.84 Real Estate Tax rate, so they needed to find another means of closing the $600,000 budget gap. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to consider introducing Ordinance #O-25-048 appropriating the FY 2026 Discretionary External Service Providers Budget for Impact Living Services. Councilmember Misjuns said that this was a great investment because it provided mental health support for first responders. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed to approve the rest of the FY 2026 General Fund Operating Budget. With no further discussion from Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Page 53 of 208 June 24, 2025 26 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to consider introducing Ordinance #O-25-049 appropriating the FY 2026 Operating Fund Budgets for all other funds. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 Ms. Finney noted she received Councilmember Misjuns' disclosure that he was a member of a group called Spouses of Teachers employed by LCS. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to consider introducing Ordinance #O-25-050 appropriating the FY 2026 Schools Operating Budget by major classification. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion, seconded Councilmember Timmer, to fund LCS at the operating request of the School Board of $119,913,199 in accordance with the submitted FY 2026 line item. Councilmember Misjuns said that this would fully fund the request from LCS. Councilmember Faraldi called a point of order. He said his motion was to adopt the LCS operating budget by major classification, but the substitute motion provided uncategorized funding, which was different from the nature of his motion. Councilmember Misjuns clarified that he was discussing a discrepancy between the FY2026 budget and the ordinance, specifically a $840,000 difference between the two. Ms. Witt said that the difference was attributed to state revenue. Mr. Patrick explained that LCS originally requested an additional $5.4 million in local funding, but the City Manager proposed $2.7 million to cover salary increases. The state provided an additional $1.9 million, and the School Board adopted a final budget that included this extra revenue. He said that as a result, the school was now receiving about $2.7 million less from the City than originally requested, but $2 million more from the state. Councilmember Misjuns said he wanted to fully fund the original request by category. He said that page 187 in the budget, the agency submitted column. Page 54 of 208 June 24, 2025 27 Mr. Patrick said that this would require Council to find another $900,000 in budget reductions, and it would provide $900,000 more than the School Board requested. He said that in total, Council had to find $1.5 million in additional cuts. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to appropriate the FY 2026 Schools Operating Budget by major classification: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to consider introducing Ordinance #O-25-051 adopting the FY 2026 - 2030 Capital Improvement Program and appropriating the FY 2026 Capital Budget. Ms. Witt stated that there was an added signal project at Enterprise Drive and Duncraig. Wiggington Road intersection improvements were also included. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to repair the Miller Park pool project with $500,000 and eliminate the library renovation project funding. Councilmember Timmer suggested an amendment to increase the pool renovation funding to $1 million and provide funding to repair plumbing issues at the library. Councilmember Misjuns amended his motion, agreed to by Vice Mayor Diemer, to provide $1 million for Miller Park pool repairs and $1 million for library repairs. Councilmember Misjuns expressed frustration with the proposed budget, citing $25-30 million for a reimagination of the Miller Park pool and the public library, which he deemed unnecessary. He argued that the library should be left to the library board to make decisions, and that the funds could be better spent addressing the financial struggles of citizens, such as rising real estate taxes and grocery prices. He specifically pointed out the $600-a-year increase in real estate taxes, which would add $75 a month to a homeowner's mortgage payment. Page 55 of 208 June 24, 2025 28 Vice Mayor Diemer expressed his concerns about the proposed pool and library projects, stating that most people in Ward 3 will not benefit from them and that he was not convinced about the necessity of the projects. He wanted to vote in a way that did not meet the promises made by other people. He said that they had to stop making promises. He questioned the decision-making process, suggesting it was a last-minute, knee-jerk reaction, and expressed doubts about the effectiveness of the proposed solutions. Councilmember Reed noted that they were about to allocate $2.6 million to benefit a development project, but they were only allocating a combined $2 million to address the library and pool projects. She did not support the substitute motion. Councilmember Timmer said she supported the substitute motion. She said she supported keeping Miller Park pool open through alternative routes, such as public-private partnerships or repairs. She emphasized the need to reduce debt service. She said that additional funds could be added to the CIP if needed. Mayor Taylor called the question on the substitute motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Councilmember Timmer motioned, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, to suspend the Rules of Procedure and divide the question on the main motion to address Wiggington Road separately. Councilmember Faraldi called a point of order. He said that it was not in their Rules of Procedure to divide the question. Councilmember Misjuns said that the motion was to suspend the Rules of Procedure. Councilmember Timmer said she supported the road improvement project. She encouraged people to attend her town hall to discuss the budget process. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to suspend the Rules of Procedure: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 Page 56 of 208 June 24, 2025 29 Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to adopt the Wiggington Road improvement project funding in the CIP. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to adopt the FY 2026 - 2030 Capital Improvement Program and appropriating the FY 2026 Capital Budget. Councilmember Misjuns said he would be voting against the motion because of the pool and library project funding. He said they did not need to be doing exorbitant projects with tax payer dollars. He said he supported school infrastructure funding. He would not oppose repairing the library and pool to keep them operational, but he could not support the whole CIP. Councilmember Timmer said she supported the schools and keeping the pool and library open. She said what had been represented in various capacities was incongruent, so she would not support the CIP. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to consider introducing Ordinance #O-25-052 appropriating $50,000 of the FY 2026 Reserve for Contingencies for use by the City Manager. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Timmer 5 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns 2 Mr. Patrick suggested holding the next item, “Consideration of adopting an ordinance setting the Personal Property Tax Relief Rate at 100.00% for January 1, 2026 through December 31, 2026”, until Council addressed the property tax rate on Monday. There was a consensus from Council. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to consider adopting Ordinance #O-25-053 prohibiting charging certain trash collection fees in the City for FY 2026. Page 57 of 208 June 24, 2025 30 With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Faraldi, to consider adopting Ordinance #O-25-054 prohibiting charging motor vehicle license fees in the City for FY 2026. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 Ms. Finney stated that Agenda Item, “Consideration of adopting an ordinance prohibiting charging motor vehicle license fees in the City for FY 2027” was pulled. // In the matter of Appointments and Vacancies, Agenda Item #16, Mr. Freedman suggested that if Council were to reconsider the appointment of Jibri Poe for School Board, they should conduct a brief closed session. Councilmember Faraldi motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to table the item to reconsider. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to enter into a closed session pursuant to Virginia Code § 2.2-3711-A(8) to receive legal advice regarding a School Board appointment. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 The substitute motion became the main motion and the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Misjuns made the following motion: Page 58 of 208 June 24, 2025 31 WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Councilmember Timmer, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: 0 Absent: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 // Councilmember Misjuns withdrew his motion to reconsider. Councilmember Misjuns motioned, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to adjourn. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: 0 Absent: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 // The meeting adjourned at 12:12 a.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 59 of 208 June 30, 2025 1 // A special meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 30th day of June, 2025 at 9:30 a.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Larry Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Agenda Item #1, Vice Mayor Diemer motioned, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, to direct staff to create an ordinance to set the Real Estate Tax rate at $0.84 per $100. Councilmember Faraldi said the point of this called meet was to set the real estate rate, not to direct staff. Mayor Taylor said the ordinance has already been set and was included in their packets. Vice Mayor Diemer revised his motion to state that he would like to set the Real Estate Tax rate at $0.84. Councilmember Timmer supported the revision and stated that she has been a big proponent of equalization, which means the City would receive more revenue but is less than the proposed budget, so it is a reduction in the proposed increase. She recognized that this is a body of equals, and they all have to come to the table to determine where compromise can occur. Councilmember Reed expressed frustration with the budget process, stating the City Manager’s proposed $0.89 tax rate reflected shared priorities. She believed Council was moving toward a compromise at $0.86, preserving most citizen priorities. She was disappointed when some members pushed for an $0.83 rate and called a special meeting without broader input. She criticized the lack of transparency, exclusion of other members, and attacks on staff, saying it undermines trust and safety. She would not support the $0.84 rate due to how the process was handled and urged a return to the 86- cent compromise. Vice Mayor Diemer stated he supports equalization for increased revenue and noted the Templeton Center’s option to buy back its facility. While appreciating efforts to keep facilities open, he stressed prioritizing needs over wants. He agreed with Councilmember Reed about process issues and Page 60 of 208 June 30, 2025 2 last-minute proposals lacking full revenue details. Despite supporting equalization, he backs the $0.84 tax rate to avoid burdening residents. Councilmember Misjuns said he has supported equalization, noting the City received more revenue than projected in 2024. He called the original $11.2 million tax increase challenging to reduce and stated that the $0.84 rate cuts $4.5 million of it. He stated how Social Services cuts were misrepresented, pointing out most funding is from state and federal sources. He also highlighted an unjustified 14.1% salary increase in the City Manager’s budget and said his questions on this and Jackson Heights revenue went unanswered. He supports the $0.84 rate as the lowest achievable to restore priorities. Councilmember Timmer stated she supports the $0.84 rate, though she has backed equalization. She appreciated the collaboration over the weekend, especially Councilmember Misjuns’ effort in restoring funding to key programs. She noted discussions about reducing the City Manager’s proposed salary increase from 14.1% to 4% to help preserve the downtown library. She criticized the late timing of budget details, calling it an inappropriate process, but was glad for the time between readings to make adjustments. She will support the $0.84 rate, though she prefers option B. Councilmember Wilder said he did not support the $0.84 nor all the other cuts from last week. He asked how much additional funding would be cut by adopting $0.84 and where those cuts would come from. Deputy City Manager Greg Patrick explained that the $0.84 rate generates the same revenue as the first budget reading, assuming the car tax remains unchanged. He noted Councilmembers have expressed interest in restoring about $480,000 in services, including Jackson Heights, the Templeton Center, Social Services, and others. Councilmember Wilder asked if they have identified funding sources for the additional $600,000 for the police department. Mr. Patrick responded that it’s already built into the budget as reflected in their packets. Chief Financial Officer Donna Witt said that was done with the 2.5% instead of 3% for City staff. Councilmember Wilder noted school staff are getting a 3% raise, while City staff get 2.5%. He listed key cuts from the latest budget, including closures of the downtown library, Jackson Heights art Page 61 of 208 June 30, 2025 3 studio, Templeton Senior Center, the Nature Zone, the DSS burial program, two DSS Family Service jobs, juvenile services, case manager jobs, reduced museum hours, reduced advertising for tourism, and various other cuts. He emphasized Lynchburg’s growth is due to past investments and that staff warned for months that reducing the tax rate would harm services. He opposed the $0.84 rate and supported 89 cents, questioning how the City can maintain services without increased funding. Councilmember Faraldi called the question. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion to set the Real Estate Tax rate at $0.84: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 // In the matter of Council’s advertised schedule, Councilmember Faraldi motioned to cancel the 10:00 a.m. meeting for June 30. Councilmember Reed seconded the motion. Councilmember Faraldi clarified that the agenda included the second reading of the budget. Council agreed by consensus. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Ordinance #O- 25-048 appropriating the FY 2026, Discretionary External Service Providers Budget. On motion of Councilmember Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Reed, Council by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Consent Agenda, Ordinance #O-25-050 appropriating the FY 2026 Schools Operating Budget by major classification. On motion of Councilmember Faraldi, seconded by Councilmember Reed, Council by the following recorded vote approved the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 //In the matter of Budget, Council conducted a second reading and adopted Ordinance #O-25-047 appropriating the FY 2026 General Fund Operating Budget (excluding Discretionary External Service Providers and Schools Operating Budget). Page 62 of 208 June 30, 2025 4 Councilmember Faraldi asked if staff had recommendations on how to reconcile some of the differences. Mr. Patrick said that staff’s recommendation at this point would be that Council adopt the second reading of the budget at the same level of expenditure and the same level of revenue and include these services for restoration, then allow staff to come back on August 26 with recommendations to either lower expenditures at that point or look at revenue increases to fit them within the budget, which will allow these services to be restored in the budget beginning July 1. Councilmember Faraldi said his recommendation would be to do an offset on the cost of living to whatever is needed for the Jackson Arts Center and the Templeton Center at bare minimum, if that is an approach that could still be included on August 26. Mr. Patrick responded that it could not, and they would need to make adjustments to the cost of living adjustment prior to today because it would go into effect on July 2; if they want to lower the cost of living adjustment, they would have to do so today. He said what they would recommend on August 26 would not include adjustments to personnel, only non-personnel savings, and they are currently at a difference of less than half a million dollars. He clarified that the items listed would be held over for now, and in August they would come back and find ways to keep them going in the future. Councilmember Faraldi motioned that Council adopt Ordinance #O-25-047 appropriating the FY 2026 General Fund Operating Budget (excluding Discretionary External Service Providers and Schools Operating Budget). Councilmember Reed seconded the motion. Councilmember Misjuns offered a substitute motion to adopt Option A, which has been shared with all members and reviewed by staff. He noted that staff confirmed its viability in an email earlier that morning, stating it offers a workable way to balance the budget. He emphasized that Option A clearly outlines what is included and excluded, and ensures restoration of funding for the Jackson Heights Art Center, Templeton Senior Center, and key Social Services positions. Vice Mayor Diemer seconded the motion. Page 63 of 208 June 30, 2025 5 Councilmember Misjuns said what he had provided to staff over the weekend was intended to ask them first if it was viable, prior to it coming before Council. He noted that staff had confirmed in their memorandum response earlier that morning that this would work at $0.84. City Attorney Matthew Freedman asked for clarification of the changes reflected in the ordinance before them in the substitute motion. Mr. Patrick stated that it was what Councilmember Misjuns outlined and includes restoration of Jackson Heights, the Templeton Center, and human services positions and social services administration. Councilmember Misjuns confirmed that and noted that he had provided a copy of this to the clerk to include for the record, reflected in Option A. Councilmember Misjuns asked if he could incorporate the email and memorandum response from staff this morning to include that with the record. Vice Mayor Diemer voiced support for preserving the Jackson Heights facility and its equipment, expressing hope for a future public-private partnership. He clarified he did not propose cutting the program. He also visited the Templeton Center and noted that, under the MOU, the center could purchase the building for $1 if the City relinquishes it – an option some board members might prefer. He emphasized that Option A keeps the center open and restores Social Services cuts. While he wished these issues had been addressed sooner, he supports the substitute motion. Councilmember Reed noted the proposed 2% cost of living adjustment rather than 3% and begins in January instead of July. She emphasized that the City Manager did not make cuts to the departments; when he found out that the proposed rate of $0.89 was going to be lowered, he had to ask department heads to submit what they would cut if equalization became a reality. She said that in an effort now to save what some of those cuts will need to be, some of her colleagues are advocating for lowering the pay raises. She stated that she would be supporting the original motion, which is to give staff the full increase or at least the 2.5%. Councilmember Timmer voiced strong support for Option B, which restored the Templeton Senior Center, Jackson Heights Art Studio, Social Services positions, and the downtown library. She noted it achieved this through a 3% cost-of-living adjustment, aligning with inflation and benefiting pensions. She Page 64 of 208 June 30, 2025 6 explained the additional revenue would come from under-projected meals and lodging taxes and new development not factored into equalization. She also highlighted the City Manager’s Office proposed 14.1% salary increase, suggesting reducing it to 4% to help fund the library. While she preferred Option B due to her involvement, she supported the substitute motion for Option A. Councilmember Faraldi said he would be voting against the substitute motion. Mr. Freedman clarified that the motion on the table is to adopt Ordinance #O-25-047 appropriating the FY 2026 general fund operating budget, excluding discretionary external service providers and schools operating budget, with the caveat that Option A is now included which has been made part of the record; Option A reduces City staff cost of living cost of living adjustment to 2% effective January 1, 2026 to achieve significant savings: $1,068,816 balances the budget by fully funding public safety and judicial administration, restoring social services administration cuts, and reinstating the Jackson Heights Art Studio; $68,499 and Templeton Senior Center, $92,860, contingent on finding; $40,034 in addition to revenue or savings. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Councilmember Faraldi stated that he would be supporting his initial motion and asked that they vote on that and move onto the next item. Councilmember Misjuns said he would vote against the motion, expressing concern over the lack of written financial details. He emphasized the need for assurance that funding for public safety would not be reduced to cover other priorities. Mayor Taylor asked Mr. Patrick to make every effort to preserve key programs and jobs following the budget vote. Mr. Patrick confirmed that a vote in favor of the motion would keep the listed programs intact and that none of the recommendations for cuts were coming from public safety. Page 65 of 208 June 30, 2025 7 Councilmember Misjuns offered an amendment to the motion, including the restoration of the items as mentioned but reducing the increase in the City Manager's office that was proposed at 14.1% increase down to 4%, totaling $123,202. Vice Mayor Diemer seconded the amendment to the motion. Councilmember Misjuns supported reducing the City Manager’s Office increase to align with other departments as a fair way to recover funds. Vice Mayor Diemer stressed that it is Council’s responsibility to decide how money is spent. He urged voting on the amendment now and taking full responsibility for the final budget. Councilmember Reed urged trust in staff’s plan to keep programs open, with final approval by Council in August. She opposed cutting worker pay and rejected the “witch hunt” motion. Councilmember Timmer clarified that the funding change for the City Manager’s Office involves reducing a 14.1% salary and benefits increase down to 4%. Councilmember Faraldi asked staff to confirm the salary increase percentage if Council approved a 2.5% raise. City staff confirmed it would be 2.5%. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Councilmember Faraldi asked that the Mayor call the question on the original motion. Councilmember Timmer expressed support for restoring the list items but opposed the motion due to the lack of clear funding path. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the original motion: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 // In the matter of Budget, Council conducted a second reading of Ordinance #O-25-049 appropriating the FY 2026 Operating Fund Budgets for all other funds. Page 66 of 208 June 30, 2025 8 Councilmember Faraldi motioned to adopt the ordinance #O-25-049 appropriating the FY 2026 Operating Fund Budgets for all other funds. Councilmember Reed seconded the motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // In the matter of Budget, Council conducted a second reading of Ordinance #O-25-051 adopting the FY 2026–2030 Capital Improvement Program and appropriating the FY 2026 Capital Budget. Councilmember Misjuns offered a motion to adopt the school improvements portion of the FY 2026–2030 Capital Improvement Program and associated budget. Vice Mayor Diemer seconded the motion. Councilmember Misjuns said he wanted to go on record for his support of school infrastructure and wanted to vote on this as a standalone item. Vice Mayor Diemer said he agreed it should be a standalone vote, as they definitely need to support their schools and repair their crumbling infrastructure, which has been neglected for years. Councilmember Faraldi offered a substitute motion to approve the capital improvement program as a whole. Councilmember Reed seconded the motion. Councilmember Faraldi said those wanting a separate schools vote missed negotiation chances and should simply vote against the entire budget if opposed. He criticized last-minute presentations blamed on staff and urged Council to decide and vote on the full package. Councilmember Reed pointed out that the first reading—which included the schools, the pool, and the library—was what they voted on and agreed to do. She said in the second reading, they also included the Wiggington Road project, and whether that was broken out or not, they should consider the CIP as a whole based on what they’ve already discussed. Councilmember Misjuns opposed the substitute motion, supporting the $10.95 million school infrastructure funding, which matches both the budget and the ordinance. He highlighted a $6 million discrepancy between the CIP ordinance ($68.3 million) and proposed budget ($62.6 million) for total City Page 67 of 208 June 30, 2025 9 capital projects. He read into the record matching amounts for the airport ($4.5 million), water ($12.8 million), sewer ($11.6 million), and stormwater ($2.9 million). He urged opposing the substitute to vote separately on schools first, then the rest of the CIP. Councilmember Faraldi said the updated proposed CIP was dated March 11, 2025, and it is right there on the website. Ms. Witt confirmed the Wiggington Road projects were added, as well as a signal on Enterprise Drive based on a new development in that area Councilmember Misjuns said he has not seen all of this together in the proposed CIP. Vice Mayor Diemer urged the Mayor to allow separating the CIP votes as in the first reading, expressing concern about rushing to combine them. He supports voting on schools separately due to issues with the full CIP. Councilmember Timmer supporting keeping the pool open but opposed the $10.4 million repair cost, citing alternate, cheaper repair estimates around $3 million. She agreed with reducing debt service for budget flexibility and fully backed the $60 million school CIP allocation and operating budget. She emphasized the importance of separating votes for clarity, especially on Wiggington Road improvements, which she supported due to increased traffic and past CIP plans. She urged those who approved the development to support road safety improvements and appreciated voting on items individually to show clear positions. Councilmember Reed said when it comes to the library project in the CIP and the Miller Pool project, they have not sent out RFPs for either one of those projects, and the figure they are working with is a projected cost for improvements and could come in less for that. She said she supported the substitute motion, to do what they said they were going to do and keep moving forward. Vice Mayor Diemer opposed the CIP plan, calling the pool projects costly rebuilds rather than improvements. He emphasized the need for clearer details and refused to approve funding without more thought. Councilmember Faraldi renewed his substitute motion to approve the CIP and asked that it be put on the table for a vote. Page 68 of 208 June 30, 2025 10 With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 The substitute motion becomes the main motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the original motion: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 // In the matter of Budget, Council conducted a second reading of Ordinance #O-25-052 appropriating $50,000 of the FY 2026 Reserve for Contingencies for use by the City Manager. Councilmember Misjuns made a motion to deny Ordinance #O-25-052 appropriating $50,000 for the reserve for contingencies for use by the City Manager. Vice Mayor seconded the motion. He said the significant increase in the City Manager’s Office budget is his reason for voting to deny. Councilmember Faraldi asked Mr. Patrick about last year’s reserve for contingencies in the manager’s budget, which was $50,000 – the same as this year. He said he would not submit a substitute motion, preferring to vote against the current motion. Councilmember Timmer opposed the 14.1% increase but supported the $50,000 contingency, criticizing inflated budget numbers for reducing spending accountability. Councilmember Reed did not support the motion to deny, believing there is a valid reason to appropriate the funds and will support the appropriation. Councilmember Misjuns confirmed that the $50,000 contingency fund budgeted last fiscal year was not spent during the year. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the original motion: Ayes: Diemer, Misjuns 2 Noes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Timmer 5 Page 69 of 208 June 30, 2025 11 Councilmember Faraldi made a motion to approve Ordinance #O-25-052 appropriating for the $50,000 reserve for contingencies for use by the City Manager. Councilmember Reed seconded the motion. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the original motion: Ayes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Timmer 4 Noes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns 3 // In the matter of the City Council’s meeting schedule and rules of procedure, Councilmember Faraldi motioned to affirm that the special meeting for today was warranted related to budgetary matters. Mr. Freedman stated that this action was not warranted because the meeting was not called within 12 hours of the meeting convening; it had been announced the previous Friday. Councilmember Faraldi withdrew his motion. // In the matter of Budget, Council conducted a first reading of Ordinance #O-25-056 setting the Personal Property Tax Relief Rate at 30.64% for January 1, 2025 through December 31, 2025. This Resolution shall apply retroactively as of January 1, 2025. Councilmember Faraldi motioned to adopt Ordinance #O-25-056, setting the Personal Property Tax Relief Rate at 30.64% for January 1, 2025 through December 31, 2025, applying it retroactively. Councilmember Misjuns seconded the motion. Ms. Witt clarified that this action is for the 30.64%, which is based on a $3.80 personal property tax rate. Councilmember Reed clarified that during the first reading, the potential car tax rate was going down from $3.80 to $3.00, and that rate will now be staying at $3.80. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting adjourned at 11:15 a.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 70 of 208 July 8, 2025 1 // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 8th day of July, 2025 at 4:00 p.m. in the 2nd Floor Training Room, City Hall, Mr. Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 // In the matter of Virginia Freedom of Information Act Biennial Training, Agenda Item #3, Council conducted a work session/training on FOIA. City Attorney Matthew Freedman introduced Joe Underwood, of the Virginia FOIA Advisory Council. Joe Underwood provided a presentation on the Virginia Freedom of Information Act. Councilmember Misjuns mentioned an update that required an electronic management system and a requirement to obtain specific software. Mr. Freedman responded that it was a discretionary decision, and he recalled a requirement for localities to create a standard policy for charges on items such as USB drives and paper copies, but he did not remember anything specific to software. Mr. Underwood said they could set a standard policy, such as charging 5 cents for black and white copies and 20 cents for color copies, then providing flash drives for large volumes of records. He emphasized the importance of safety and security and recommended that files be stored on flash drives to prevent viruses, charging a minimum allowable cost for this service. Mr. Freedman said it is fairly common with localities to incorporate software, and Lynchburg did it for administrative purposes to better manage the requests and responses. Councilmember Misjuns suggested that they just publish frequent requests so people could go in and search on their own. Councilmember Misjuns mentioned a recent City Council meeting wherein four members left without an adjournment vote and three of them stayed and listened to the public — and the three of them took a vote to adjourn that public hearing. Mr. Underwood pointed out that FOIA does not stipulate how you adjourn meetings. He said the only requirements are that you must give notice of the meeting, make it open to the public, and record Page 71 of 208 July 8, 2025 2 minutes. He said when there is no longer a quorum, there is technically not the ability to take actions. He said that FOIA also does not require public comments, but that violates Virginia Code Section 15.2, which stipulates that you must have public comments quarterly. He noted that Virginia sometimes deals with Jefferson Rules, but most boards use Robert’s Rules — and neither is mentioned in FOIA. He clarified that meeting notice for regular meetings must include date, time, and location; it must be posted in three locations, including on the website, in a prominent public location, and at the office of the administrator. He said the meeting notice must be posted at least three working days prior to the meeting, and special or emergency meetings must be reasonable under the circumstances, and meetings may be continued to a future date and time, also under Section 15.2. He added that for special, emergency, or continued meetings, the notice must be posted at the same time the members are notified. He stated that public meetings are allowed to be filmed and photographed. Mr. Underwood reported that minutes are required to be taken for open meetings and are very important, as well as being a “very thankless task.” He said the minutes serve as the official record of the meeting, and the first thing people do is look at the minutes to determine what actually occurred. He said they must be posted on the website or in a public location and must include specific information such as meeting date, time, location, members present and absent, a summary of matters discussed and decided, and a record of any votes. He also emphasized the importance of recording votes and motions, including closed session motions, and noted that even with live streams, formal written minutes are still necessary. Mr. Faraldi commented that it would be more prudent to have the General Assembly put limits on what local elected bodies can do, rather than enacting a blanket provision that says they can’t do anything. Mr. Underwood responded that the only exception would likely be matters requiring timeliness, such as grant application deadlines. Mr. Misjuns asked at what point they could exempt the proposed agenda and packet. Mr. Underwood responded that there is currently no requirement beyond the basics of date, time, location, and brief description of the meeting; currently, they can add things to the agenda during the meeting, such as under the “adopt the agenda” item. He noted that materials supporting the agenda may be exempt, such as sensitive personnel items pertaining to specific employees. Page 72 of 208 July 8, 2025 3 Vice Mayor Diemer mentioned that in his work with an electronic government implementation division, they addressed digital government meetings and the ability to have a chain electronic meeting whereby a staff member calls all seven Council members and asks whether they want to do something as a body. He asked if that constituted a public meeting. Mr. Underwood responded that he could not weigh in on that particular issue, but there was a case in which citizens brought suit against a public body because they found out they had a chat box set up over a document. He said the court decided that while they were having a conversation and creating a public record, it wasn’t in real time like a Zoom call. He said that with responses to meeting schedules, they must respond individually — not in group emails. Mr. Freedman asked if there were an issue with staff reaching out to Council members individually to seek guidance on how to proceed with a matter. Mr. Underwood responded that it wouldn’t violate FOIA policies or public meeting requirements, but it would be up to their own policies and would typically go through the chair. He also noted that use of social media to conduct or transact business, that can create a public record and hence be subject to FOIA. Mr. Faraldi mentioned that Facebook scrubs its videos and comments made about those videos every 30 days. Mr. Underwood cautioned that it is not recommended to use a private entity to conduct public business, and retention of any video is a Library of Virginia issue. Mr. Freedman pointed out that they have software that helps archive records that they need to archive as part of the public Facebook they use for official City business. Mr. Underwood reiterated that the requirement for public meeting records is the minutes. He said that the only remedy for a violation is to go to court. He clarified that the courts do not enforce compliance; the public body must show they are following the law. He said there are civil penalties, which go to the literary fund, and most citizens do not want to sue their government but would rather just receive the records they requested. He stated that the court would have to demonstrate an intent to avoid FOIA laws or the Record Retention Act. He also mentioned that the Working Papers Correspondence Page 73 of 208 July 8, 2025 4 Exemption is limited to offices such as the governor, his legal counsel, cabinet secretaries, and staff members, and it covers not just his records but also correspondence and written communication. Mr. Underwood pointed out that once a local body adopts its rules, those apply to all subcommittees and other groups. // In the matter of Lynchburg City Council Rules of Procedure Discussion, Agenda Item #4, Setting Meetings for CY2026 and Work Session Changes for CY2025, Councilmember Timmer said she would be willing to hold off on her presentation, given the timing of this meeting. Mayor Taylor stated that she could present at their work session on August 26, 2025. Councilmember Misjuns suggested deferring the entire rules discussion until that time, and Council agreed that they would need to move forward with the calendar item. Clerk of Council, Alicia Finney stated that the calendar for this year would need to be adjusted, with work sessions moved to the Second Floor Training Room to allow for live streaming of committee meetings. Councilmember Misjuns suggested moving all meetings, including work sessions, to Council Chamber, as there was also more room for citizens there. Councilmember Reed spoke in favor of staying in the informal setting as they worked through things, then going to the formal chamber for further discussion and vote. Councilmember Wilder said he would like whatever is easiest for staff. Councilmember Timmer commented that she didn’t like informal polling at the work sessions but was otherwise fine with wherever they decided to meet. Mr. Freedman said if the room were to become overcrowded, there would be no issue with recessing the meeting and moving to the larger City Council Chamber. // In the matter of Roll Call, Councilmember Faraldi recognized Dr. Martin Day, Captain Anthony Andrews, and Colonel Mark Tinsley for their service on the School Board. Councilmember Reed acknowledged City staff for their work on the Fourth of July events. She also expressed appreciation for the prayers sent to those affected by the flooding in Texas, noting the efforts of Virginians and others nationwide to support search and relief. Page 74 of 208 July 8, 2025 5 Councilmember Wilder recognized Clyde Clark, former principal and guidance counselor at E.C. Glass, who recently passed away. He also mentioned Gloria Preston, who served the community for over 30 years. He also commended the Downtown Association for hosting the Fourth of July event and for keeping the downtown alive. Councilmember Timmer thanked everyone who had attended the recent town hall, noting that there were 75–100 people present and stating that it was beneficial to clarify issues around the budget and recent developments. Mayor Taylor thanked everyone for a pleasant and productive work session. // On the motion of Councilmember Misjuns, seconded by Councilmember Timmer, by the following recorded vote, Council elected to hold a closed meeting to discuss appointments for vacancies to the following Boards and Commissions: Central Virginia Community College Board, City Employee Appeals Board, Economic Development Authority, Historic Preservation Commission, Martin Luther King, Jr./Lynchburg Community Council, Museum Advisory Board, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority, and Building Code of Appeals Board, pursuant to Section § 2.2-3711-A(1) of the Code of Virginia, 1950, as amended. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting was reopened to the public. // Councilmember Wilder made the following motion: WHEREAS, the Council of the City of Lynchburg has convened a closed meeting on this date, pursuant to an affirmative recorded vote and in accordance with the provisions of The Virginia Freedom of Information Act; and WHEREAS, Section 2.2 3712 of the Code of Virginia requires a certification by City Council that such closed meeting was conducted in conformity with Virginia law; NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED that the Council of the City of Lynchburg certifies that, to the best of each member's knowledge, (i) only public business matters lawfully exempted from open meeting requirements by Virginia law were discussed in the closed meeting to which this certification Page 75 of 208 July 8, 2025 6 resolution applies, and (ii) only such public business matters as were identified in the motion convening the closed meeting were heard, discussed or considered by Council. The motion was seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, and Council, by the following recorded vote, adopted the motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Timmer 6 Noes: Misjuns 1 // On motion of Councilmember Wilder, seconded by Mayor Taylor, Council by the following recorded vote appointed the following members to the respective boards and commissions: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Timmer 6 Noes: Misjuns 1 // Councilmember Misjuns made the motion to appoint Toby Tomko to the Economic Development Authority for a new term ending June 30, 2029, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer. Councilmember Faraldi made a substitute motion to reappoint Kim Sorensen, seconded by Councilmember Wilder. The following vote was recorded on the substitute motion. Ayes: Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 3 Page 76 of 208 July 8, 2025 7 Noes: Taylor, Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 4 With the substitute motion failing, the following vote was recorded on the main motion: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 5 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi 2 // Councilmember Misjuns made the motion to appoint Barry Wingard to the Historic Preservation Commission for a new term ending June 30, 2028. There was no second and the motion died. Councilmember Timmer made a motion to appoint Palmer Ferguson, seconded by Councilmember Reed, for a term ending June 30, 2028. The following vote was recorded on the motion. Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Timmer 6 Noes: Misjuns 1 // Councilmember Wilder made the motion to appoint Angela Cox to the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority for an unexpired term ending September 30, 2026, seconded by Councilmember Reed. Councilmember Misjuns made a substitute motion to appoint Jennifer Wills to the unexpired term ending September 30, 2026, seconded by Councilmember Timmer. The following vote was recorded on the substitute motion. Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 5 Noes: Wilder, Faraldi 2 With the affirmative vote, the substitute motion became the main motion and the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 Councilmember Misjuns made the motion to appoint Taormina Howard to the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority for an unexpired term ending September 30, 2028, seconded by Councilmember Timmer. Councilmember Reed made a substitute motion to appoint Angela Cox to the unexpired term ending September 30, 2028, seconded by Councilmember Wilder. The following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 Page 77 of 208 July 8, 2025 8 With the affirmative vote, the substitute motion became the main motion and the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 // Councilmember Timmer made the motion to appoint Roman Franklin to the Central Virginia Community College Board of Directors for a new term expiring June 30, 2028, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns. The following vote was recorded on the motion. Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: Faraldi 1 // The meeting recessed at 6:54 p.m. // A regular meeting of the Council of the City of Lynchburg was held on the 8th day of July, 2025 at 7:00 p.m. in the Council Chamber, City Hall, Larry Taylor, President, presiding. The following Members were present: Present: Larry Taylor, Curt Diemer, Sterling A. Wilder, Chris Faraldi, Stephanie Reed, Martin Misjuns, Jacqueline Timmer 7 Absent: 0 // Mayor Taylor led the invocation, followed by the Pledge of Allegiance. // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #1, Council adopted Resolution #R-25-044 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $15,000 to fund a wayfinding system for the Dunbar Community Schoolyard. On the motion of Vice Mayor Diemer, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Wilder 1 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #2, Council adopted Resolution #R-25-045 amending the FY 2025 City/Federal/State Aid Fund budget and appropriating $12,269 to purchase Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) for the Fire Department. On the motion of Vice Mayor Diemer, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Page 78 of 208 July 8, 2025 9 Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Wilder 1 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #3, copies of the minutes of the May 13, 2025 meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on the motion of Vice Mayor Diemer, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Wilder 1 // In the matter of the Consent Agenda, Agenda Item #4, copies of the minutes of the May 27, 2025 meeting have been previously furnished to Council, and on motion of Vice Mayor Diemer, seconded by Councilmember Misjuns, Council by the following recorded vote approved the adoption: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 6 Noes: 0 Absent: Wilder 1 // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #5, Citizen Gregory Berry of Ward 3 addressed Council regarding salt and light. He raised concerns about council misconduct, including enabling slander, intimidation, and efforts to silence public input. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #6, Citizen Peter Cefaratti of Ward 1 addressed Council regarding we can do better. He criticized the Council’s budget process as disorganized and urged better planning, transparency, and professionalism. // In the matter of Public Comment, Agenda Item #7, Citizen Ronald Storer of Ward 4 addressed Council regarding consequences. He accused Councilmember Faraldi of unprofessional, divisive behavior and called for his resignation, citing a lack of Council collaboration and personal attacks on a colleague’s family. // In the matter of Item Not on the Agenda, Councilmember Misjuns made a motion, seconded by Vice Mayor Diemer, to propose reconsideration of the Ordinance #O-25-055 to remove language that creates a “magic tax increase,” Section 58.1-3321, which requires a locality to reduce its real estate tax rate to Page 79 of 208 July 8, 2025 10 produce no more than 101% of the previous year’s levy unless specific actions are taken, as noted in the document marked up and provided to Council. Vice Mayor Diemer said the Virginia Code aims to ensure localities cannot raise real estate taxes without first informing the public through their elected officials. Councilmember Timmer said Council was told that without a vote, the tax rate would default to 0.89 cents. She argued this violates state law, specifically the intent behind Virginia Code 58.1-3321, and supported Councilmember Misjuns’ proposed revision to set the rate at 0.84 cents. Councilmember Faraldi argued that the proposal adds new language not in the original ordinance, improperly mixes Personal and Real Estate Tax issues, and lacks a finalized document for review. He stated it should be ruled out of order. Mr. Freedman said he could not find anything in Virginia Code Section 58.1-3321 that supports Councilmember Timmer’s claim about equalization plus 1%. Mayor Taylor asked Councilmember Faraldi if his point of order was under germaneness. Councilmember Faraldi confirmed that it was, as they cannot reconsider something with entirely new language being added in. Mayor Taylor stated that Councilmember Misjuns was out of order. Mr. Freedman said the language has been in the ordinance for years to ensure continuity if a tax rate is not set or Council cannot meet. He noted in 2019, the language was used because no tax rate was adopted. He suggested that instead of a motion to reconsider, Council should ask the City Attorney to prepare a clear ordinance requiring a yearly tax rate. He stressed the public must see any changes before meetings and that ordinances should be amended through new ordinances. Councilmember Misjuns said a motion to reconsider must be made by the Councilmember who voted with the prevailing side no later than the next regular meeting, and that's why it was brought up today. He stated that he is open to amending the language, and if a majority supports it, he is willing to revisit the issue in August and potentially withdraw his motion to reconsider, provided the Council is willing to consider the City Attorney's recommended language to annually vote on a tax rate. Councilmember Faraldi stated that a motion to reconsider is only to reconsider — then, a motion for a new item may be presented for consideration. Page 80 of 208 July 8, 2025 11 Mayor Taylor stated that after Council makes comments, they can direct the City Attorney to draft language to bring back in August for consideration, with Councilmember Misjuns given the opportunity to withdraw his current motion. Councilmember Faraldi said if the motion is withdrawn, there needs to be clear direction about what they are voting on. He stated that he believes this will be an attempt to change this outside of what they are allowed to do. Councilmember Timmer stated that she supports the City Attorney’s advice to bring forward another ordinance and strike the language. She read aloud the code section she had previously referenced, noting that it was 58.1-3321, Section A and Section B: “§ 58.1-3321. Effect on rate when assessment results in tax increase; public hearings; referendum. A. When any annual assessment, biennial assessment, or general reassessment of real property by a county, city, or town would result in an increase of one percent or more in the total real property tax levied, such county, city, or town shall reduce its rate of levy for the forthcoming tax year so as to cause such rate of levy to produce no more than 101 percent of the previous year's real property tax levies, unless subsection B is complied with, which rate shall be determined by multiplying the previous year's total real property tax levies by 101 percent and dividing the product by the forthcoming tax year's total real property assessed value. An additional assessment or reassessment due to the construction of new or other improvements, including those improvements and changes set forth in § 58.1-3285, to the property shall not be an annual assessment or general reassessment within the meaning of this section, nor shall the assessed value of such improvements be included in calculating the new tax levy for purposes of this section. Special levies shall not be included in any calculations provided for under this section. B. The governing body of a county, city, or town may, after conducting a public hearing, which shall not be held at the same time as the annual budget hearing, increase the rate above the reduced rate required in subsection A if any such increase is deemed to be necessary by such governing body.” Page 81 of 208 July 8, 2025 12 Mr. Freedman explained that Council had complied with Section B, once the public hearing was held and rates were proposed, and he has never seen the instance as described by Councilmember Timmer. Vice Mayor Diemer said that this section of the ordinance goes against the intent of the Code of Virginia, and it requires advertising of a proposed tax rate as well as a public hearing. He stated that what has occurred is an increase in taxes without a vote, and he did not want a “magic tax increase” without them taking responsibility for their actions. Councilmember Reed stated that the budget is finished and there is no reason to revisit it in August, calling it a waste of time. Councilmember Wilder said he was surprised because the issue was not on the agenda and the Mayor did not know. He said some Councilmembers were meeting secretly and surprising others. He said the tough budget is done and should not be reopened, and reminded everyone to work together. Councilmember Misjuns withdrew his motion to amend the ordinance and made a new motion to come back in August and remove perpetual tax increase language from the ordinance. Mr. Freedman stated that if they wanted to do something in this regard, they would need to have a new ordinance that showed the proposed amendment to the already adopted ordinance on June 30th. He emphasized that he has always known the City to do the required notice as part of the budget process, although there may be instances where Section A has been followed — but he is aware of none where that has happened. He emphasized that people have not been made aware of this proposed change, and they would need an entirely new ordinance. Vice Mayor Diemer asked the City Attorney if an ordinance with strike-through text is valid or if it needs to be a clean, final version to be official. Mr. Freedman stated that the adopted ordinance was altered by striking out sections not included in the original proposal, and the change was introduced unexpectedly without prior public notice. Vice Mayor Diemer raised a question about whether, if the ordinance is adopted, the adopted date and the clerk’s signature could be updated. Clerk of Council Ms. Alicia L. Finney confirmed that this ordinance has been adopted and filed through the appropriate channels, and she could not simply go back and replace it in the record. Page 82 of 208 July 8, 2025 13 Councilmember Misjuns clarified that the motion would be to return in August with a properly prepared ordinance by the City Attorney to remove the redlined language from the existing ordinance, presenting a clean version without underlines. Vice Mayor Diemer seconded the motion. Mayor Taylor pointed out that Councilmember Misjuns is essentially wanting to change the entire ordinance. Councilmember Misjuns claimed that he wanted Council to be accountable for its actions, and the way the language is currently stated is a perpetual, permanent tax increase. He said that state law is clear that the rate would become equalized with a maximum 101% over prior year rate. Councilmember Timmer said she did vote on the 0.84-cent rate, but she felt that the local ordinance is in conflict with state code. Mr. Freedman said if the intent is not to vote every single year on a tax rate, the date would need to be modified to follow the assessment years. He stated that he is also not sure if there is another public hearing requirement, as this is uncharted territory, and there was also uncertainty about how this would be assessed in the non-assessment years. He added that this is creating a legal quandary. Councilmember Reed made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Wilder, to leave everything as it was and not bring this back in August as an amended ordinance. Councilmember Misjuns expressed disappointment over a substitute motion that he believed would lead to a "magic tax increase," which he argued was in opposition to state law and the citizens' wishes. He pointed to a 1996 ordinance in Lynchburg as an example of a similar tax increase, and stated that he would be rejecting the substitute motion to ensure accountability and transparency in the City's actions. Vice Mayor Diemer said he was proud of his vote for 0.84 cents, which saved them from 0.89 cents, and his constituents were also pleased. He said he tried to introduce an equalization rate that would have been better for taxpayers, but he was proud of his vote and was glad to spend more time discussing this, as it affected citizens. He reiterated that this was a “magic tax increase” with “no representation,” and the General Assembly put it in state code which this is in direct conflict with. He confirmed with the City Attorney that any conflict between those things ultimately favors state code. Page 83 of 208 July 8, 2025 14 Councilmember Faraldi said the section being cited here may be how counties operate, because there are clarifications in state code about what cities versus counties can do. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded on the substitute motion. Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Reed 3 Noes: Diemer, Faraldi, Misjuns, Timmer 4 Ms. Finney asked for clarification of the main motion, stating that she had recorded the motion to direct the City Attorney to prepare an ordinance based on what was presented by Councilmember Misjuns, to be brought back to their August 26 meeting. Councilmember Misjuns clarified that the goal is to remove the perpetual tax increase caused by the ordinance adopted last week, with the red line adjustments, and he is open to adding language that the City Attorney deems necessary for continuity of government, including any requirement to vote on a rate annually. He confirmed that the rates would not be changed from 0.84 cents, from July 1, 2025 to June 30, 2026. Mr. Freedman clarified that he would just be removing the redline text. Mayor Taylor stated that in living here 30 years, City Council has always come together to vote on the tax rate sometimes raising it, sometimes lowering it. He emphasized that this year, Council took action, and this was a bunch of nonsense intended to get ahold of something to make themselves look good, when they were supposed to be here for the citizens. He said that no one was going to sneak in here and set the tax rates. Councilmember Faraldi noted that according to Council’s own Rules and Procedures, this must be submitted to staff to be placed on an agenda. Mr. Freedman clarified the policy pertaining to placing items on the agenda, and without that having been done, Councilmember Faraldi’s point of order is correct. Councilmember Misjuns withdrew his motion and made a new motion to reconsider the previous ordinance to strike the perpetual tax increase out of it. Vice Mayor Diemer seconded the motion, stating that it is a critical opportunity to change the ordinance and prevent tax increases without a vote. He argued that the current proposal is a necessary Page 84 of 208 July 8, 2025 15 step to protect the power of the people and prevent future tax hikes, citing the risk of an 0.89-cent tax increase if no action is taken. Councilmember Faraldi made a substitute motion, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to immediately consider Item #8 under General Business, “Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-25-057 to set the City Council's regular meetings for CY2026 and to move the City Council's remaining work sessions for CY2025 to the City Hall's second floor training room”. Mr. Freedman clarified that a substitute motion allows a proposed alternative to replace any existing motion on the floor, taking precedence over it; it can be discussed before being voted on, and if it passes, it replaces the main motion, which is then considered and acted upon by the Council. Councilmember Faraldi suggested that they vote on the agenda items as presented, and then go home and regroup. He emphasized that this still affords them the opportunity to review this if one of them wants to request it for the next meeting. Councilmember Misjuns raised a point of order, stating that the substitute motion violates Section 1.2 of Council's basic principles, which dictates that actions should be the result of a decision on the merits, not a manipulation of procedural rules. He argued that the substitute motion blocks consideration of an item and is a manipulation of the rules, as it presents a different subject and does not allow for full and free discussion of the original item. He said there were two motions, one of which needed to be ruled on due to it being a point of order. He said his substitute motion was deemed out of order because it violated the rules of procedure, specifically because it was a different subject (1.2.D) and it is a manipulation of the procedural rules (1.2.C). Mayor Taylor ruled against the point of order. Councilmember Reed said she agreed with the substitute motion, suggesting they move forward and allowing the option to revisit it in the work session on the 26th Councilmember Timmer clarified that the City’s tax rate cannot automatically roll over to 0.89 cents without a vote, as that would violate state code, which requires a rate based on equalization plus 1%. She said the City’s current ordinance conflicts with state code, and the goal is to fix that conflict and remove confusion. She also expressed concern that Council rules make it harder to get items on the agenda then to be censured, and supports changes to make the process more transparent and Page 85 of 208 July 8, 2025 16 accessible. She emphasized that this not about changing tax rates, but about following state law and clearing up ambiguity. Councilmember Misjuns opposed the substitute motion, calling for accountability, and adherence to budget procedures. Councilmember Faraldi clarified that the tax rate does not automatically increase under state law; if no action is taken, the previous rate of 0.89 cents remains. The recent tax increase was the result of a Council vote, not a legal default. Councilmember Timmer re-explained that Section 58.1-3321, Section A, states ““When an annual assessment, biannual assessment, or general reassessment of real property by a county, city, or town, would result in an increase of 1% or more increase in the total real property tax levied, such county, city, or town shall reduce its rate of levy for the forthcoming tax year, so as to cause such rate of levy to produce no more than 101% of the previous year's real property tax levies, unless Subsection B is complied with. Which rate shall be determined by multiplying the previous year’s total real property tax levies by 101% and dividing the product by the forthcoming tax year’s total real property assessed value. An additional assessment or reassessment due to the construction of new or other improvements, including those improvements and changes set forth in 58.1-3285, to the property shall not be an annual assessment; assessed value of such improvements be included in calculating the new tax levy for purposes of this subsection. Special levies shall not be included in any calculations provided for under this section.” She said that Section B states, “The governing body of a county, city, or a town may, after conducting a public hearing, which shall not be held at the same time of the annual budget hearing, increases the rate above the reduced rate required in Subsection A, if any such increase is deemed to be necessary by such governing body.” Ms. Finney clarified that the vote before them is on the substitute motion to move to Agenda Item #8. Council approved the motion by the following recorded vote: Ayes: Taylor, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed 4 Noes: Diemer, Misjuns, Timmer 3 // In the matter of Agenda Item #8, Vice Mayor Diemer motioned, seconded by Councilmember Reed, to adopt Resolution #R-25-057 to set the City Council's regular meetings for CY2026 and to move the City Page 86 of 208 July 8, 2025 17 Council's remaining work sessions for CY2025 to the City Hall's 2nd Floor Training Room, as presented to City Council at the work session this afternoon. With no further discussion from the Council, the following vote was recorded: Ayes: Taylor, Diemer, Wilder, Faraldi, Reed, Misjuns, Timmer 7 Noes: 0 // The meeting adjourned at 8:37 p.m. ____________________________ Clerk of Council Page 87 of 208 City Council Agenda Item IV.6. Action AGENDA ITEM SUMMARY MEETING DATE PRESENTED BY September 23, 2025 Melva Walker, Grants Manager AGENDA ITEM # IV.6 Consideration of adopting Resolution #R-25-065 approving the submittal of the FY25 Consolidated Annual Performance Report for the CDBG and HOME Program. RECOMMENDATION Hold a public hearing to receive comments regarding the Program Year 2024 (PY 2024) Fiscal Year 2025 (FY 2025) Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program and adopt a resolution approving the CAPER for submission to the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development. SUMMARY The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) requires each jurisdiction receiving HUD-administered grants (CDBG and HOME Program) to draft a CAPER and submit it for public review and comment. The CAPER describes the City’s progress towards the housing and community development goals established within the 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan and the PY 2024 (FY 2025) Annual Action Plan. This CAPER is for the period of July 1, 2024 through June 30, 2025. With the City Council’s approval, the CAPER, including a summary of any public comments, will be submitted to the HUD Richmond Field Office for review to meet compliance regulations for the CDBG and HOME Program. A public notice for the public comment period and public hearing was published in The News and Advance on September 5, 2025. PRIOR ACTION(S) February 11, 2020: City Council approved the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program Housing and Non-housing Goals for the Five-year 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan June 23, 2020: City Council approved the Five-year 2020-2024 Consolidated Plan July 9, 2024: City Council approved the Program Year 2024 (FY 2025) Annual Action Plan September 23, 2025: Finance Committee Meeting FISCAL IMPACT N/A CONTACT(S) Melva Walker, Grants Manager ATTACHMENT(S) Page 88 of 208 1. R-25-065 2. Presentation 3. CAPER PY24FY25 REVIEWED BY Date: September 15, 2025 William Martin, Community Development Director Date: September 16, 2025 Kent White, Assistant City Manager Date: September 18, 2025 Alicia Finney, Clerk of Council Page 89 of 208 RESOLUTION: #R-25-065 BE IT RESOLVED BY THE COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF LYNCHBURG, VIRGINIA: That the Program Year 2024 (FY 2025) Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) is approved and shall be submitted to U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD). Such report is expressly incorporated herein by reference. Adopted: September 23, 2025 Certified: Clerk of Council Page 90 of 208 CONSOLIDATED ANNUAL PERFORMANCE AND EVALUATION REPORT (CAPER) FOR THE COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBG) AND HOME PROGRAM FISCAL YEAR (FY) 2025 ● PROGRAM YEAR (PY) 2024 (JULY 1, 2024 – JUNE 30, 2025) PUBLIC HEARING September 23, 2025 Page 91 of 208 FY 2025 ANNUAL ACTION PLAN — CAPER RESOURCES AND EXPENDITURES *Includes FY 2025 entitlement, reprogram, and program income funds for CDBG and HOME Program. **CDBG-CV funds allocated in FY 2020 (Resources Made Available were remaining funds from original allocation). ***FY 2025 expenditures as recorded in HUD’s data system, Integrated Disbursement Information System (IDIS), from FY 2025 and prior years’ allocations. Source of Funds Resources Made Available Amount Expended During Program Year*** CDBG $722,642* $866,762 HOME $308,608* $182,609 CDBG-CV $106,311** $42,177 Page 92 of 208 FY 2025 ANNUAL ACTION PLAN CAPER PERFORMANCE ACCOMPLISHMENTS Public Facilities (Neighborhood Improvements) – Jefferson Park The construction of the Plaza improvements included: - A Shelter, minor furnishings fencing and some lighting; and walkway improvements to and around the plaza; - A walking path around the perimeter of the park area, landscaping, storm water measures and some lighting; and - Improvements including new stairs and rails to the amphitheater seating area and cleanup and repair of that space. This revitalization project has been completed in FY 2025. There were $562,395 of CDBG funds expended during this program year for this project. Page 93 of 208 FY 2025 ANNUAL ACTION PLAN CAPER PERFORMANCE ACCOMPLISHMENTS Through the Central Virginia Continuum of Care’s Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) in this program year there were 2,637 people assisted and $54,706 of CDBG funds expended for persons about to be homeless or are already experiencing homelessness. Through CDBG funding, the Extreme Weather Center, at the Salvation Army, served 105 people seeking shelter during the winter season from January 2025 through March 2025. The Extreme Weather Center expended $24,796.09 in CDBG funds during this program year. Page 94 of 208 FY 2025 ANNUAL ACTION PLAN CAPER PERFORMANCE ACCOMPLISHMENTS Homeownership and Rental: • A total of $57,968 in HOME funds was expended by Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) providing down payment assistance and gap financing assistance to three households for homeownership on Knott Street. GLHFH has completed the construction of five homes in the Knott Street development project. There are four homes under construction. • Florida Terrace Apartments have been completed. There are 31 affordable housing units for persons with disabilities and low income. In PY 2024 the 11 HOME units were leased and are occupied. Florida Terrace Apartments 1507 Knott Street 1517 Knott Street Page 95 of 208 FY 2025 ANNUAL ACTION PLAN — CAPER RESOURCES AND EXPENDITURES Project – CDBG-CV Subrecipient Category CDBG - CV Funds Expended Safe at Home Emergency Assistance Interfaith Outreach Public Service Activities- Round 3 $31,374 Emergency Housing & Utility Program Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) Public Service Activities- CDBG-CV – Round 3 $5,213 Page 96 of 208 DRAFT Page 97 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 1 Executive Summary The City receives formula grants from the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development("HUD”) for housing and community development activities, specifically the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program. Federal law requires that the CDBG and HOME Program grant funds primarily benefit low-and moderate-income persons in accordance with the following HUD goals: Provide a suitable living environment This includes improving the safety and livability of neighborhoods; increasing access to quality facilities and services; reducing the isolation of income groups within areas by de-concentrating housing opportunities and revitalizing deteriorating neighborhoods; restoring and preserving natural and physical features of special value for historic, architectural, or aesthetic reasons; and conserving energy resources. Provide decent housing Included within this broad goal are the following: assist homeless persons in obtaining affordable housing; retain the affordable housing stock; increase the availability of permanent housing that is affordable to low- and moderate-income Americans; and increase supportive housing that includes structural features and services to enable persons with special needs to live with dignity. Expand economic opportunities These goals encompass creating jobs accessible to low- and very low-income persons; providing access to credit for community development that promotes long-term economic and social viability; and empowering low-income persons in federally assisted and public housing to achieve self- sufficiency. The City is required by law every five years to prepare a Consolidated Plan to receive federal funds from HUD. The Consolidated Plan combines in one report important information about Lynchburg’s demographics and economic activity as well as detailed information on the housing and job needs of its residents. The Plan also includes comments from the public received during public hearings, stakeholder meetings and in writing. As a recipient of federal funds from HUD, the City is required to publish an annual performance report, Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER), detailing activities that took place during the most recent program year. The purpose of this report is to measure Lynchburg’s success in meeting the priority needs, goals, and strategies described in Lynchburg’s 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan. This report covers the Fiscal Year (FY) 2025/Program Year (PY) 2024 Annual Action Plan and is for the period from July 1, 2024 through June 30, 2025. * The CAPER is presented in a format that is prescribed by HUD. Data and narratives are entered into a federal database system called the Integrated Disbursement and Information System (IDIS) and the CAPER report is then downloaded into a Word format. The CAPER template in IDIS has a series of prescribed questions that align with the CDBG and Page 98 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 2 HOME Program Consolidated Plan program regulations. The report you are reviewing is the result of that data entry process and is the prescribed and recommended format by HUD. Citizen Participation HUD requires the City to provide the public an opportunity for input. The City will provide an opportunity to comment on the CAPER at a public hearing scheduled before City Council on September 23, 2025 at 7:00 p.m. in the City Council Chambers at City Hall, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, Virginia. Copies of the draft CAPER is available for public review at the following locations: • Grants Administration Office, City Hall, Second Floor, 900 Church Street, Lynchburg, Virginia 24504; • Lynchburg Public Library, 2311 Memorial Avenue, Lynchburg, Virginia; • Downtown Branch Library, 216 12th Street (former Visitor Center) Lynchburg, VA; and City website at http://www.lynchburgva.gov/grants-administration For More Information Contact the Grants Administration Office with any questions about this report or the funded programs/activities. Melva Walker, Grants Manager Office of Grants Administration City Hall Second Floor 900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 melva.walker@lynchburgva.gov Gabbi Bateman Community Development Grants Coordinator Office of Grants Administration City Hall Second Floor 900 Church Street Lynchburg, VA 24504 Gabrielle.Bateman@lynchburgva.gov * Fiscal Year (FY) 2025 and/or Program Year (PY) 2024 refer to the City’s fiscal year and HUD’s program year of July 1, 2024 through June 30, 2025. Fiscal Year (FY) 2024 and/or Program Year (PY) 2023 refer to the Cit y’s fiscal year and HUD’s program year of July 1, 2023 through June 30, 2024. Fiscal Year (FY) 2023 and/or Program Year (PY) 2022 refer to the City’s fiscal year and HUD’s program year of July 1, 202 2 through June 30, 2023. Fiscal Year (FY) 2022 and/or Program Year (PY) 2021 refer to the City’s fiscal year and HUD’s program year of July 1, 202 1 through June 30, 2022. Fiscal Year (FY) 2021 and/or Program Year (PY) 2020 refer to the City’s fiscal year and HUD’s program year of July 1, 2020 through June 30, 2021. These references are made throughout the CAPER for Program Years (PY) 2023, 2022, 2021, and 2020, which are the Program Years within the 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan. Page 99 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 3 CR-05 - Goals and Outcomes Progress the jurisdiction has made in carrying out its strategic plan and its action plan. 91.520(a) The primary objective of the CDBG and HOME Program is to continue to develop viable urban communities through decent housing, suitable living environments and expanded economic opportunities for low- and moderate-income persons; the City supports assisting individuals with disabilities, substance abuse or addiction, persons with AIDS, persons that are homeless, and elderly persons. Within the City’s Five-Year Consolidated Plan and Program Year (PY) 2024 Annual Action Plan, the City committed to the overarching goal of undertaking activities that would result in substantial public benefit through the revitalization of depressed areas and in assistance to low and moderate-income residents. These are the central City neighborhoods that surround the downtown business district and are the six contiguous census tracts that comprise the CDBG target area: Census Tracts 4, 5, 6, 7, 11, and 19. Population, demographics, and surveys of the target areas show that these neighborhoods have the highest degree of housing need and are where many of the City’s very low and low-to- moderate- income persons reside. CDBG and HOME funds were allocated City-wide providing persons and/or households with assistance who met the eligibility criteria of the applicable program. These funds were allocated to projects and activities classified as housing (homeownership [down payment assistance],homeownership development, rental housing development and rehabilitation), public facilities improvements (infrastructure), and public services (community and homeless service organizations). The project accomplishments, as well as an analysis of expenditures, are provided throughout the Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER). In Program Year 2019, CDBG-CV funds were allocated to City departments and local non-profits to prevent, prepare for, and respond to COVID-19. The project accomplishments and expenditures for Program Year 2024 are provided within the CAPER. Comparison of the proposed versus actual outcomes for each outcome measure submitted with the consolidated plan and explain, if applicable, why progress was not made toward meeting goals and objectives. 91.520(g) Categories, priority levels, funding sources and amounts, outcomes/objectives, goal outcome indicators, units of measure, targets, actual outcomes/outputs, and percentage completed for each of the grantee’s program year goals Page 100 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 4 Table 1-Accomplishments-Program Year & Strategic Plan to Date *See Narrative regarding accomplishments on pages 5 through 9 and goals not achieved. GOAL CATEGORY SOURCE/AMOUNT FUNDING TOTALS FOR THE 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan INDICATOR UNIT OF MEASURE EXPECTED 2020-2024 EXPECTED PROGRAM YEAR 2024 ACTUAL PROGRAM YEAR 2024 Increase permanent affordable housing (rental market) Affordable Housing HOME: $413,140 Rental units constructed Household Housing Unit 48 31 31 Increase the Number of Owner- Occupied Units Affordable Housing HOME: $413,140 Direct Financial Assistance Households Assisted 26 10 6 Rehabilitation of Substandard Housing Units Affordable Housing HOME: $413,140 Housing Rehabilitation Household Housing Unit 0 0 1 Improve the City’s Public Facilities Non-Housing Community Development CDBG: $110,000 Public Facilities Improvement Public Facilities Improvements 5 1 1 Promote Public Service Activities Non-homeless Special Needs CDBG: $42,230 Public service activities other than Low/Moderate Income Housing Benefit Persons assisted 50 50 47 Promote Public Service Activities Homeless CDBG: $65,000 Homelessness Prevention Persons assisted 900 5,000 2,637 Promote Public Service Activities Homeless CDBG: $42,000 Homeless Housing and Services Persons assisted 45 45 105 Page 101 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 5 Assess how the jurisdiction’s use of funds, particularly CDBG, addresses the priorities and specific objectives identified in the plan, giving special attention to the highest priority activities identified. This section of the CAPER examines the similarities and differences in the proposed and actual accomplishments of the goals identified in Table 1 within the 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan for the Community Development Block Grant (CDBG) and HOME Program. These goals helped to form the priorities identified in the City’s Fiscal Year (FY) 2024 Consolidated Annual Action Plan and the strategies to be used or implemented in order to achieve the stated goals. To provide this comparison, City staff has narrated the actual achievements for each program/activity in which funds were expended during the Program Year (PY) 2024/Fiscal Year (FY) 2025, which is the fourth reporting period of the 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan. The Goals within the 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan and PY 2024 Annual Action Plan included: increasing the number of owner-occupied housing units; rehabilitation of substandard housing units; improve the City's Infrastructure; improve the City’s public facilities; increase permanent affordable housing in the rental market; providing homeless services; and promoting public service activities. Below is an assessment of the use of funds for PY 2023 and the projects underway or completed from prior years’ allocations. Planning and Administration: There was $137,537 in CDBG funds allocated for Planning and Administration for PY 2024, and $152,708.25 was expended with PY 2024 and prior year funding for the administration of the CDBG program. Within the HOME Program, there was $30,000 allocated for administration and $63,354 was expended with PY 2024 and prior year funding. Staff continues to utilize these funds for administration and oversight of the CDBG and HOME Programs. There was $23,000 in CDBG funds allocated to the Dearington Neighborhood Plan in PY 2019. The funding provided City staff the opportunity to develop a neighborhood plan to address vacant housing and vacant lots, historic landfills, park programming and development, infrastructure needs, and other neighborhood needs as identified in the planning process. This funding was leveraged with other City funding and grants to complete a comprehensive neighborhood plan. The Plan has been completed and a total of $23,000 has been expended for this activity. The Jefferson Park Improvements Project is a project that is included in this plan. In addition, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) has completed the strategic plan for the redevelopment of the public housing Dearington Apartments. In PY 2022, there was $5,879 in CDBG funds allocated to assist with the development of the Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan. The Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan was adopted into the City Comprehensive Plan on December 10, 2024. City staff engaged neighborhood stakeholders in the development of the plan -- through workshops, meetings, and events -- for eighteen months. The resulting plan envisions a future for Diamond Hill as an identifiable, serviced, diverse, and connected geographic neighborhood. The plan's recommendations build upon recent public investments in the neighborhood and seek to celebrate the unique neighborhood character while also recognizing areas for improvement. There was $2,750 of CDBG funds expended to complete the Plan in Program Year 2024. Page 102 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 6 LRHA maintains a CDBG Property Inventory that includes properties acquired with the use of CDBG funds. During PY 2024 there were no properties acquired and none disposed. There are three (3) properties remaining on the CDBG Property Inventory. LRHA staff continues to monitor the disposition of these properties. Improve the City's Infrastructure: The City has committed CDBG and Capital Improvement funds to a variety of public infrastructure projects in the targeted neighborhood areas and is recognizing considerable private development interest as a result. The Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan builds upon recent public investments in the neighborhood – Diamond Hill Neighborhood Center Renewal Project (Fiscal Year 2019), Strong Neighborhood Alliance project (Fiscal Year 2022), and Grace Street Retaining Wall Project (Fiscal Year 2022) – and seeks to celebrate the unique neighborhood character while also recognizing areas for improvement. There were CDBG funds allocated for the Diamond Hill Improvement Project on Pierce Street within the Diamond Hill Neighborhood. This project is being completed in conjunction with the City’s combined sewer overflow project on Pierce Street. Once the overflow project has been completed, the CDBG funds allocated for the Diamond Hill Improvement project will provide for the installation of pedestrian and landscaping improvements on Pierce Street. There was $3,937 expended in CDBG funds for the design of these improvements in PY 2024. The Water Resources Department operates the Combined Sewer Overflow (“CSO”) Program, the largest of all the City’s capital improvement programs. This program reduces the volume and frequency of overflows from the City’s combined sewer system. Thus far, the Program has spent $48 million of local funding (provided by sewer fees); $171 million in State funding (VCWRLF loans); $96 million in federal and state grants; and $19 million in American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) stimulus funding. Based on the approved Long-Term Control Plan it is estimated that the remaining cost to complete the program is approximately $91 million. City of Lynchburg has been awarded two grants totaling $50 million from the American Rescue Plan (ARPA) to be used for the CSO Program. Although the Consent Special Order does not specify a completion date, Lynchburg’s CSO Program could be complete as soon as December, 2029. Actual completion date will be largely dependent on available funding and project schedules. Other notable Water Resources Department projects that is currently under construction or construction beginning in FY 2026 are the following: 1) Blackwater CSO Tunnel, $104 million 2) Water Service Line Lead and Copper Inventory and Replacement - $11.4M 3) Downtown Area Business Improvements Phase IV - $6.9 million, 4) Richland Hills Sewer Extension - $10.9 million 5) Water Resource Recovery Facility Sludge Holding Tank - $6.1 million 5) College Park Stormwater Improvements - $3.0 million. Page 103 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 7 Improve the City's Public Facilities: The City has committed CDBG funds to improving and enhancing public facilities in the neighborhoods and city-wide. In PY 2024 there was $478,105 of CDBG funds allocated for the Diamond Hill Neighborhood Plan – Phase 1 Improvements project (Diamond Hill Schoolyard). The Dunbar Community Schoolyard project is a common-sense and cost-effective solution to increasing access to park space in the neighborhood. A community schoolyard is a safe, green, and inviting campus, open to the public after school and on weekends. By establishing Dunbar campus as a community schoolyard, the shared public space is transformed into a positive place for youth, families, and neighbors. The addition of Dunbar campus as a community schoolyard would result in access to park space within a 10-minute walk of 75% of Diamond Hill Neighborhood residences. The CDBG funds will be used to increase the community park space and improve the school campus by creating safe pedestrian walkways, incorporating seating, investing in low-maintenance landscaping, and enhancing recreational opportunities. In PY 2024 there was $16,374 expended on design for this project. In PY 2021, there was $512,607 allocated for the Jefferson Park Revitalization Improvements project. During PY 2021, the design for Phase I of the park improvements was completed. Phase I focused on the southeast side of the park, the part that is most accessible to the neighborhood, and included improvements that will have an immediate impact. Design included a new basketball court, stair improvements to the old amphitheater, a small loop trail in the park, neighborhood “patio” with a pavilion on the former tennis court, park lighting, and the required stormwater management. Additionally, a new basketball court with a community-chosen mural on the surface was installed. During PY 2023, the design for the Court Plaza construction project was completed, sent out to bid, and a contractor was chosen. The following items are planned to be completed: plaza improvements to include shelter, minor furnishings, fencing and lighting; walkway improvements to and around the plaza, main park improvements to include a walking path around the perimeter of the park area, landscaping, stormwater measures, and some lighting; and improvements including new stairs and rails to the amphitheater seating area and cleanup and repair of that space. Construction on the project began in Spring 2024 and was completed in Spring 2025. There was $562,395 expended for this activity in PY 2024. In PY 2022 the City expended $1,450,693 of CDBG Section 108 loan proceeds for the acquisition of 3413 and 3415 Odd Fellows Road. This City project consisted of land acquisition, design and construction of a modern, state of the art building to meet the current and future law enforcement needs for the City. The main building is three stories tall and is 93,991 square feet in area. The scope of work included the entire site development – stormwater, utility infrastructure, site grading, parking facilities (including a separate rolling asset building), site security, lighting, landscaping, and building construction – foundation and structure to the roof including all systems and finishes necessary to operate the building as a Police Department. The project was completed in February 2025. The Police Department employees have occupied the building and it is now operational. The total project costs were approximately $50 million. Page 104 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 8 Increase permanent affordable housing in the rental market: The City recognizes the need to increase the availability of affordable housing for renters, especially housing that meets the varied needs of the City’s lower-income population. The City continues to support and partner with housing and public service providers to meet the needs of low-to-moderate income persons, homeless persons and families, and persons with disabilities or other special needs. Rush Homes received $95,000 of PY 2018, $70,000 of PY 2019, $413,140 of PY 2020, $150,000 of PY 2021, and $200,000 of PY 2022 of HOME Program funds for its Community Housing Development Organization (CHDO) rental housing project. Florida Terrace was a new construction, affordable multifamily housing development. The subject property is located at 2117 Florida Avenue directly off of the Campbell Avenue corridor. The construction of this project was completed in Program Year 2023; however, the leasing of the 11 HOME units were completed in Program Year 2024. There are three (3) “low” income and eight (8) “high” HOME units. This project provides 31 additional housing units for special needs persons and low income. In addition, the Florida Terrace Apartments project, located in Census Tract 19, greatly improved the sustainability and appearance of the neighborhood. This project is not only an asset to the neighborhood and the persons it will serve but was an excellent public/private partnership that will benefit the community for many years to come. The project provides housing and an independent lifestyle for people with disabilities in an accessible residential portion of the City. Affordable housing in urban areas remains a challenge in Central Virginia, especially so for disabled citizens, and the housing units within this project provide updated housing options for City residents in a relatively commercial portion of the City. Increase the number of owner-occupied units: To the degree that predominance of rental units in a neighborhood is seen as destabilizing, the City wants to provide incentives for qualified persons and low- and moderate-income to consider the benefits of homeownership, especially if it is more cost-effective than renting and if it builds wealth for the individual household. Several programs are supported by the City that incorporates these elements. Funding for the Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity’s (GLHFH) Knott Street Development project subsidized the development costs for nine (9) parcels and homes, all of which will be sold to income- eligible families. There was $270,000 allocated of PY 2020, $208,425 of PY 2021, and $152,865 of PY 2022 HOME Program funds for this project. The development for this project has been completed and included the costs for building the streets, sidewalks, waterline and sewer connections, clearing of trees and other required appurtenances. All of the HOME funds allocated for this project have been expended. Habitat for Humanity began construction of the housing units within this development in PY 2023. In Program Year 2025 there will be $10,000 of HOME Program funds provided to GLHFH to assist with the construction of four (4) of the remaining housing units within this development. The City increased the number of owner-occupied units by six (6) during PY 2024. The City's partnership with GLHFH provided Homebuyer Homeownership for three (3) units through its Down Payment Assistance project to eligible clients for the purchase of homes constructed at 1511, 1517, and 1519 Knott Street. In PY 2024, $114,304 in HOME Program funds allocated to GLHFH for down payment assistance. During this reporting period, GLHFH expended $57,968 for down payment assistance to the Page 105 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 9 homebuyers. The City's partnership with Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) provided Homebuyer Homeownership for three (3) units through its First Time Homebuyer Down Payment Assistance project to eligible clients for the purchase of homes at 1 Powhatan Street, 1943 Cleveland Avenue, and 314 Bay Street. In PY 2024, there were $89,304 in HOME Program funds allocated to Lyn- CAG for down payment assistance. During this reporting period, Lyn-CAG expended $34,529 for down payment assistance to the homebuyers. Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) has acquired the property at 302 Smyth Street to construct a new affordable housing unit. During Program Year 2024 the environmental review record was completed. LRHA plans to construct the new housing unit in Program Year 2025 with HOME Program funds and other financial resources. Rehabilitate substandard housing units: To achieve the objective of making all housing units safe, decent, and affordable it is necessary to extend assistance to private property owners, particularly low and moderate-income homeowners. This goal also provides the opportunity for the homeowners to have their homes rehabilitated and retain ownership. The City is accomplishing this goal by investing in existing housing stock through renovations and rehabilitation of properties in the target neighborhoods. As a direct result of these improvements, the neighborhoods retain and attract residents thereby positively affecting the stability of the neighborhood and increasing property values. Specific housing characteristics of the target area support the need for rehabilitation and revitalization. In PY 2022 Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) was allocated $100,000 in CDBG funds for the LRHA Enhance and Preserve (LEAP) Revitalization Project. This project addresses neighborhood properties in need of renovation and/or rehabilitation to provide affordable housing within the neighborhood. During PY 2023, LRHA acquired the property at 1704 2nd Street for $100,000. The housing unit on this property has been rehabilitated and is rented to a low-to-moderate income household. During this reporting period, there was one (1) rental unit rehabilitated by private landlords through the Rental Rehabilitation Program at LRHA. The property was located at 212 Amherst Street. In Program Year 2024, $4,411 of CDBG funds were expended for the rental rehabilitation of this property. The landlord successfully rehabilitated the unit at a total cost of $8,823, and the housing unit on this property is now occupied by an eligible, low-to-moderate income household. Promote Public Service Activities: The Scoutreach program is a partnership between the Boy Scouts of America and Lynchburg Parks and Recreation Department. This program provides programming at the City Neighborhood Centers to offer an opportunity for school-age youth to broaden their experiences inside and beyond the neighborhood setting. The Scouting groups operated at two centers: Yoder and Fairview Heights. The Scoutreach program was allocated $19,160 of PY 2023 CDBG funds. In PY 2024, 47 youth have been served and $5,374 was expended. Provide Homeless Services: The Coordinated Homeless Intake and Assessment (CHIA) project was allocated $65,000 in Program Year 2024 funds. The City supports efforts to develop, sustain, and Page 106 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 10 coordinate a comprehensive, seamless system of services for homeless citizens in order to move the homeless population toward obtaining permanent housing. Through the CHIA Coordinator, a uniform intake tool has been developed to quickly assess individual and family needs and assure they are diverted from the homeless response system or expeditiously placed in the most appropriate housing program. CHIA diverts households from homelessness, understands the clients’ needs and eligibility for existing programs, and identifies the needs through the consistent use of a uniform assessment tool. In Miriam’s House, as Lead Agency for the Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) employs a full-time Coordinated Entry Specialist (CES) to operate the CHIA hotline during business hours. CHIA assisted 2,637 people (though only 1,826 individuals provided demographic information) and expended $54,706 during Program Year 2024. This activity has greatly enhanced the coordination of housing and services for the homeless. This program is ongoing and CDBG funds have been allocated in PY 2025 for the continuation of this project. The Lead Agency for the Central Virginia Continuum of Care, Miriam's House, in partnership with the City Department of Human Services, utilized CDBG funds in support of services to assist individuals experiencing a housing crisis that are further complicated by extreme temperatures. The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) Homeless Management Information Center identified a 322 percent increase in unsheltered homelessness from 2019 to 2023 in Lynchburg. The CVCoC through Miriam’s House published a notice to request proposals for the warming shelter in Fall 2024. The Salvation Army applied and were approved by the CVCoC Board to begin providing a warming shelter in January 2025. Through CDBG funding, the Extreme Weather Center served 105 people seeking shelter during the winter season from January 2025 through March 2025. The Extreme Weather Center expended $24,796.09 in CDBG funds during Project Year 2024. Community Development Block Grant: Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES ACT) (CDBG-CV) Rounds 1 and 3 Program Funds In Program Year (PY) 2019 (Fiscal Years [FYs] 2020 and 2021) the City received special allocations of Community Development Block Grant funds to be used to prevent, prepare for, and respond to the coronavirus (COVID-19). This allocation was authorized by the Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security Act (CARES Act), which was signed by President Trump on March 27, 2020, to respond to the growing effects of this historic public health crisis. Lynchburg’s allocation totaled $809,630. The first round of funding was $420,487 and Round 3 funding was in the amount of $389,143. Utilizing the CDBG application process and the guidelines from HUD for eligible projects/activities, City staff solicited and accepted applications for the CDBG-CV funds. These projects/activities will benefit the citizens of Lynchburg that have been or will be affected by COVID-19. In accordance with the CDBG Citizen Participation Plan’s “In the Event of an Emergency” section, the public comment period was reduced to five (5) days and public hearings were conducted on May 26, 2020 and April 13, 2021. City Council resolutions were approved on June 9, 2020 and April 27, 2021. For receipt of these funds, in accordance with HUD regulations; the City submitted two "Substantial Amendments" to its FY 2020 and 2021 (PY 2019) CDBG Annual Action Plans to HUD. These Amendments Page 107 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 11 included the projects/activities that were approved by City Council and would prevent, prepare for, and respond to the Coronavirus (COVID-19). Safe at Home Emergency Assistance (Interfaith Outreach) - $74,171.62 (Rounds 1 and 3) Interfaith Outreach’s Safe at Home Emergency Assistance aided households with verified financial needs due to COVID-19 in the form of delinquent mortgage assistance payments, delinquent rent assistance payments, and delinquent utility payments made directly to the vendors. Loss of shelter, power, and water posed an immediate threat to the health and welfare of the Lynchburg community. PY 2024 Accomplishments During this program year Interfaith Outreach expended $31,374 and provided rental assistance to 18 households. Community Development Block Grant-Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES ACT) (CDBG-CV) Round 3 Program Funds ($389,143) Below are summaries of these project/activities for local nonprofits and City departments and the program accomplishments for Program Year 2024 for Round 3 of the CDBG-CV funds. City Administration (Grants Administration) - $18,448 Funding will be utilized for personnel and operating costs associated with managing and monitoring the CDBG-CV projects. PY 2024 Accomplishments During this reporting period, there was $5,590.38 expended for personnel and operating costs for the oversight and administration of the CDBG-CV projects from this activity. Emergency Housing Assistance (Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) - $75,000 The COVID-19 Emergency Housing Assistance Program will assist clients, whose income was impacted by the pandemic, with up to three (3) months of past due rent or mortgage payments. Through this program it is Lyn-CAG's goal to keep households housed, which will prevent exposure to congregate settings (shelter) where the likelihood of contracting the virus is higher. Through this program Lyn-CAG is preparing for increased needs to address the lasting impacts of the virus and unemployment. This program is a direct response to the coronavirus and efforts to alleviate its impact. As the loom of ending moratoriums and forbearance approaches the security of a home is in jeopardy. This could result in an eviction or foreclosure which places a household in danger of contracting the virus. Lyn-CAG's Emergency Housing Assistance Program aims to prevent both evictions and foreclosures due to the pandemic. PY 2024 Accomplishments During this reporting period, Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) assisted two (2) household by providing mortgage, rental and utility assistance to a client affected by COVID-19. Lyn-CAG expended $5,213 for this activity. Page 108 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 12 CR-10- Racial and Ethnic composition of families assisted Describe the families assisted (including the racial and ethnic status of families assisted). 91.520(a) CDBG HOME White 816 7 Black or African American 1,036 10 Asian 0 0 American Indian or American Native 20 0 Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander 0 0 American Indian or Alaska Native and White 15 0 Asian and White 0 0 Black or African-American and White 37 0 American Indian or Alaska Native and Black or African American 0 0 Total 1953 17 Hispanic 75 0 Not Hispanic 1878 17 Table 1- Table of assistance to racial and ethnic populations by source of funds Narrative The Table above provides a total racial and ethnic summary of the number of households served with the CDBG and HOME Program funds. CDBG funds assisted a total of 1,953 households. Through its Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) program, Miriam’s House assisted 787 white households, 969 black or African American households, zero (0) Asian households, 19 American Indian or American Native households, zero (0) Native Hawaiian or other Pacific Islander households, and 74 Hispanic households. Additionally, CHIA assisted the following multiple race categories: 14 American Indian or American Native and white households; zero (0) Asian and white households; 37 black or African American and white households; and zero (0) American Indian or American Native and black or African American households. Through the private landlord housing rental rehabilitations, LRHA assisted one (1) black or African American households. Through its Extreme Weather Center project, Miriam’s House assisted 20 white households, 27 black or African American households, one (1) American Indian or American Native and white households, and one (1) Hispanic households. Through its Scoutreach program, Boy Scouts of America assisted 9 (nine) white households and 38 black or African American households. HOME Program funds assisted a total of 37 households. Rush Homes assisted a total of 31 households (11 HOME units) through the Florida Terrace Rental Housing Project; of the 11 households who were assisted with HOME units, six (6) white households and five (5) black or African-American households were assisted. Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) assisted three (3) black or African American households through the Homebuyer Down Assistance project. Lynchburg Community Action Page 109 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 13 Group (Lyn-CAG) assisted one (1) white household and two (2) black or African-American households through the First Time Homebuyer Down Payment Assistance project. CR-15- Resources and Investments 91.520(a) Identify the resources made available Sources of Funds Source Resources Made Available Amount Expended During Program Year CDBG CDBG $722,642 $ 866,761.89 HOME HOME $308,608 $182,608.70 Table 2-Resources Made Available Narrative In Program Year (PY) 2024/Fiscal Year (FY) 2025, the City received $722,622 in CDBG entitlement funds and $302,774 in HOME Program entitlement funds. Along with these entitlement funds, reprogrammed prior year funds of $20 for CDBG were allocated to eligible projects, and in reprogrammed funds of $5,834 for the HOME Program. The total amount of CDBG and HOME funds the City allocated for projects and activities in PY 2024 was $1,031,250. This represented a total of $722,642 in CDBG and $308,608 in HOME Program dollars. In Program Year 2024, 97.31% ($694,852.71) of the CDBG funds were expended on activities that benefited Low-to-Moderate (LMI) persons within the City. With this amount the City was above the minimum threshold of 70% set in Section 24 Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) 570.901(a). There was 19.86% ($152,708.25) of Lynchburg’s CDBG allocation and prior years' funding expended on Planning and Administration, which was under the maximum of 20% allowed according to Section 24 CFR 570.206(g). There was 10.75% ($63,328.57) of Lynchburg’s CDBG allocation and prior years' funding expended for Public Service activities; therefore, the City was under the maximum of 15% mandated by Section 24 CFR 570.201(e). In FY 2025, there was $866,761.89 of CDBG entitlement funds and $182,608.70 of HOME Program funds expended for projects, and activities. Narratives for the various projects and activities during PY 2024 have been included in the Goals and Outcomes Section of the CAPER (see pages 5-9). In Program Year 2024/Fiscal Year (FY) 2025, there was $106,311.46 of Coronavirus Aid, Relief and Economic Security Act (CARES Act) (CDBG-CV) Program Funds available to be used to prevent, prepare for, and respond to the coronavirus (COVID-19). City staff and various subrecipients expended $42,176.95 on activities related to COVID-19. Identify the geographic distribution and location of investments Page 110 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 14 Target Area Planned Percentage of Allocation Actual Percentage of Allocation Narrative Description CENSUS TRACTS 4,5,6,7,11 and 19 (CDBG) 55 81 Public improvements, housing services, and public service, Citywide (HOME) 45 19 Homebuyer, rental housing development Table 3—Identify the geographic distribution and location of investments Narrative The City invested 81% of CDBG project funds for PY 2024 (FY 25) in the Census Tracts 4, 5, 6,7,11 and 19 for Diamond Hill Improvement Project. The City invested 19% of CDBG funds in services Citywide for the Centralized Homeless Intake services to assist those in need of homelessness prevention. All of the HOME Program funds were allocated for housing related projects (i.e. homeowner, rental housing, and homebuyer assistance). Leveraging Explain how federal funds leveraged additional resources (private, state and local funds), including a description of how matching requirements were satisfied, as well as how any publicly owned land or property located within the jurisdiction that were used to address the needs identified in the plan. The utilization of CDBG, HOME Program, and other federal grant funds has had a substantial impact on the City’s ability to leverage other resources to redevelop economically distressed neighborhoods and provide renewed opportunities for our residents. The City, through the Office of Economic Development & Tourism (OEDT) and the Economic Development Authority (EDA), offers various programs and incentives, to leverage public investment to address the needs of our community. The section below provides a summary of this leverage from the EDA, and local, state and federal resources: • The City’s two Enterprise Zones, coupled with expanded small business financing continue to produce substantial results. In 2024, investments in commercial real estate included Real Property Improvement Grants totaling $1,017,249.60 leveraged private commercial property investments of more than $14,652,980 in Zone 2 and $3,083,262 in Enterprise Zone 46. Enterprise Zone 2 was approved by the Governor’s office for another 5 years, beginning on January 1, 2024. • The Local Redevelopment Program provides an investment overlay district that includes existing Enterprise Zone boundaries. Designed to support small business real property investments and expand real estate tax receipts for the city, the grant has been effective in incentivizing public- private partnerships and private investments. $141,250 was awarded to support 13 local businesses through the Local Redevelopment Program, creating 189 new jobs and leveraging $8,404,661 million in capital investments across the City. Page 111 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 15 • In 2024, The City began the process of reviewing and updating the comprehensive plan, a 20 year vision document that will help to guide and shape the development and growth trajectory of the City in the coming decades. Public meetings were held and public comment collated; the plan is now in the drafting and review process. • The City Real Estate Rehabilitation Program encourages the renovation of older structures and helps to revitalize commercial neighborhoods. In 2024, 45 properties in the City Enterprise Zones are currently participating in the program, resulting in just over $47,067,150 million in improvements to the City’s tax base. • The Economic Development Authority of the City (EDA) received a $500,000 Assessment and Planning Grant award from USEPA in the Fall of 2022 to perform environmental site assessments, cleanup, and redevelopment planning, among other efforts toward redevelopment of Brownfields in the City. In Calendar Year 2024 Lynchburg EDA spent approximately $184,283 of the current EPA Assessment and Planning Grant. To date, the City has received more than $1.2 Million in Brownfields Assessment, and Cleanup and Redevelopment Planning Grants from EPA. To date, the City has received more than $315,000 in Brownfields Assessment, and Cleanup and Redevelopment Planning VBAF Grants from VEDP/DEQ. • On January 16, 2023, the City was awarded $261,750 towards site development for “Sites A & B” in the Ivy Creek Innovation Park, which are currently owned by the Economic Development Authority of the City. In addressing the low inventory of business-ready sites within the City and region, the City reviewed all sites owned publicly or by the Economic Development Authority, and determined these two sites to be the most viable and “prospect ready,” as these sites are within an existing, vibrant industrial park. Now that that project has been completed, we have applied for additional funding to further develop this site, with the goal of bringing it to ‘pad-ready’ (Tier 5). • During the last year, the City completed various administrative activities, including past and ongoing programmatic reporting, expansion and review of brownfields inventory, and selection of sites for the investment of the grant funds. Projects including completing a Phase I and Phase II Environmental Site Assessment (ESA) and beginning a remediation plan for 2307 Bedford Avenue, a former drycleaner’s that will now be a mixed-use development. GO Virginia also awarded the Economic Development Authority of the City a $190,000 grant for site development at the Airport Commerce Park. The project funding will advance the Airport Commerce Park site from a Virginia Business ready Sites Program characterization of Tier 2 to a Tier 3 (Tier 5 being pad ready). • The City’s Brownfields Program helps attract new development and business to the city. The grant funds are deployed and leveraged throughout the community to maximize investments from others. The Brownfields grant program has spurred public and private investment in our community, including the newly repurposed building at 1217 Church Street. In October 2021, the building was purchased, and development began on 29 residential units and a 1,650-square-foot commercial space. Following a total capital investment of approximately $5 million combined with state & federal tax credits, White Star Flats opened in May of 2023 and is currently 50% leased. • In October 2021, the Office of Economic Development and Tourism also launched the LYH Jobs Portal, in partnership with Chmura and Jobs EQ. One of only a handful in the country, this jobs portal collates job postings from over 900 websites, enabling job seekers to have a ‘one stop shop’ Page 112 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 16 for all of their job seeking needs. The portal also provides employers with an easy website to reference for job seekers, and the Office of Economic Development and Tourism assists them in posting their jobs with the local Virginia Career Works and Virginia Workforce Connection. This tool continues to assist local businesses and job seekers alike. In 2023, the Office of Economic Development and Tourism continued partnering with other City departments to get this tool into the hands of more citizens, and currently have active programs with the Library system, Human Services and our Parks and Rec departments. • In FY 2025, finalized commercial building permits totaled more than $121,240,437 in real property investment in the City. Of the licensed businesses in the City, 50% have been in business 10 years or more. Downtown revitalization continues with 7 new businesses in FY 2025. • The Launch LYH program, started in January of 2023, provided funding to seven (7) new businesses that opened in 2023. The program was renewed in 2024 and provided funding for five (5) additional new businesses in downtown LYH. The City began construction on Riverfront Park in downtown Lynchburg as a concert, festival and park venue with an amphitheater, restrooms and a playground. • The Water Resources Department operates the Combined Sewer Overflow (“CSO”) Program, the largest of all the City’s capital improvement programs. This program reduces the volume and frequency of overflows from the City’s combined sewer system. Thus far, the Program has spent $48 million of local funding (provided by sewer fees); $171 million in State funding Virginia Clean Water Revolving Loan Fund (VCWRLF) loans; $77 million in federal and state grants; and $19 million in American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA) stimulus funding. Based on the approved Long- Term Control Plan it is estimated that the remaining cost to complete the program is approximately $125 million. The City has been awarded two grants totaling $50 million from the American Rescue Plan (ARPA) to be used for the CSO Program. Although the Consent Special Order does not specify a completion date, Lynchburg’s CSO Program could be complete as soon as December, 2028. Actual completion date will be largely dependent on available funding and project schedules. Other notable Water Resources Department projects that is currently under construction or construction beginning in FY 2025 are the following: 1) Blackwater CSO Tunnel, $104 million 2) Downtown Area Business Improvements Phase IV - $5.3 million, 3) Richland Hills Sewer Extension - $6.3 million 4) Golf Park CSO - $3.8 million 5) College Park Stormwater Improvements - $2.2 million. • The City’s Division of Social Services provides: Child Care Services, Prevention Services, Employment Services, Services to Adults, Energy Assistance Program, Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), Medicaid, Temporary Assistance for Needy Families (TANF), Virginia Initiative for Education and Work (VIEW), Protective Services to Children, and Foster Care/Adoption. • The City’s Department of Community Development operates and enforces the Virginia Maintenance Code of the Uniform Statewide Building Code (USBC), in which the Rental Inspections Program is operated. This program provides protection for citizens and neighborhoods by ensuring sub- standard living conditions are reduced in order to produce thriving, attractive, safe neighborhoods and enhance citizen’s quality of life. In PY 2024, there were 162 rental inspections and 1,219 housing inspections conducted. • Numerous non-profit subrecipients and community partners used resources, both public and private to complement the investments from the entitlement allocations. Page 113 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 17 HOME Match The HOME program specifically requires that participating jurisdictions (PJs) provide match funds in amounts equal to no less than 25% of the total HOME funds drawn down from the jurisdiction’s HOME program account for project costs. Allowable reductions are made for PJs that experience fiscal distress or major disasters in accordance with the Stafford Act. Fiscal distress can be categorized by the following criteria: 1) the family poverty rate is 125% or more of the national poverty rate; and 2) the per-capita income is less than 75% of the national average. When a PJ meets one of these distress criteria, it is determined to be in fiscal distress average and thereby receives a 50% reduction of its match requirement. If a local jurisdiction satisfies both of the distress criteria, it is determined to be in severe fiscal distress and receives a 100% reduction of its match requirement. The City meets the criteria to be classified as severely distressed and has been determined to be in fiscal distress and received the 100% reduction of its match requirement for PY 2023. HUD calculates the match liability according to the most recent completed Federal fiscal year. A total of $90,495.76 of HOME funds were disbursed from October 1, 2023 to September 30, 2024 (Federal Fiscal Year), of which $60,273.23 would have been subject to the match requirement; however, due to the fiscal distress determination the Match Liability Amount for the City was $0. The HOME Program Match Liability Report (PR33) from the Integrated Disbursement and Information System (IDIS) for PY 2024 indicates that the City had no Match Liability for Program Year 2024. While the City had no match liability during this reporting period, the City accrued $626,980 in additional match credit from Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) through the HOME-assisted housing units constructed by GLHFH. There was no publicly owned land or property located within the jurisdiction that was used to address the needs identified in the Plan. The City began PY 2024 with $4,800,975 in excess match carried over from prior years. As stated above, during PY 2024, the City accrued $626,980 in additional match credit from Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH) from the construction of four (4) HOME-assisted units. This match was accrued through volunteer labor and construction material costs. As depicted in the chart below, a balance of $5,427,955 in excess match is available to be carried over to PY 2025 and remains available for future years. Fiscal Year Summary – HOME Match 1. Excess match from prior Federal fiscal year 4,800,975 2. Match contributed during current Federal fiscal year 626,980 3. Total match available for current Federal fiscal year (Line 1 plus Line 2) 5,427,955 4. Match liability for current Federal fiscal year 0 5. Excess match carried over to next Federal fiscal year (Line 3 minus Line 4) 5,427,955 Table 1 – Fiscal Year Summary - HOME Match Report Page 114 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 18 Match Contribution for the Federal Fiscal Year Project No. or Other ID Date of Contribution Cash (non-Federal sources) Foregone Taxes, Fees, Charges Appraised Land/Real Property Required Infrastructure Site Preparation, Construction Materials, Donated labor Bond Financing Total Match 1511 Knott Street 08/24/2024 0 0 0 0 175,421 0 175,421 1519 Knott Street 11/23/2024 0 0 0 0 161,539 0 161,539 1517 Knott Street 09/28/2024 0 0 0 0 176,411 0 176,411 1500 Knott Street 03/26/2025 0 0 0 0 113,609 0 113,609 Table 2 – Match Contribution for the Federal Fiscal Year HOME—Program Income As the Table below indicates, there was no program income receipted for the HOME Program during PY 2024. Program Income – Enter the program amounts for the reporting period Balance on hand at beginning of reporting period $ Amount received during reporting period $ Total amount expended during reporting period $ Amount expended for TBRA $ Balance on hand at end of reporting period $ 0 0 0 0 0 Table 3 – Program Income Minority Business Enterprise (MBE)/Women-owned Business Enterprise (WBE) Report There were no construction contracts issued during PY 2024 within the HOME Program. Page 115 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 19 CR-20- Affordable Housing 91.520(b) Evaluation of the jurisdiction’s progress in providing affordable housing, including the number and types of families served, the number of extremely-low income, low-income, moderate-income, and middle-income persons served. This section includes an evaluation of the City’s progress in meeting its specific goals of providing affordable housing, including the number and types of families served by income level and the number of homeless, non-homeless persons assisted. HUD funding received for HOME is used to provide a range of housing for a wide variety of low-to-moderate income populations throughout the City. The CDBG program does not fund affordable housing development projects. However, the City’s CDBG program did fund rental rehabilitations through Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority’s (LRHA) Rental Rehabilitation Program. Projects funded with CDBG funds are mainly to serve the low and moderate- income persons in the targeted census tracts. HOME Program funds are allocated to affordable housing projects Citywide and within the targeted census tracts. In PY 2024, Tables 10 and 11 below list the goals and actual number of persons and households served by the CDBG and HOME Program for each type of population. One-Year Goal Actual Number of Homeless persons to be assisted through CDBG activities (Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access) 5,000 2637 Number of Special-needs persons to be provided affordable housing units (Florida Terrace Apartments) 31 31 Total 5,031 2,668 Table 10—Number of Persons Assisted One-Year Goal Actual Number of households supported through Rental Assistance 0 0 Number of households supported through The Production of New Units (Down payment assistance) 10 6 Number of households supported through Rehab of Existing Units (Rental Rehabilitation) 0 1 Number of households supported through Acquisition of Existing Units 0 0 Total 8 7 Table 11—Number of Households Supported Page 116 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 20 Discuss the difference between goals and outcomes and problems encountered in meeting these goals Number of homeless to be provided assistance: There were 2,637 individuals were served through CHIA Hotline. This did not meet the anticipated goal for number of homeless persons to be provided assistance however, Miriam’s House did adjust the way in which they reported call numbers in order to more accurately reflect the calls they received which were related to housing instability resulting in lower numbers reported overall. Number of Non-Homeless persons assisted through CDBG activities: Goal achieved. Number of special-needs to be provided affordable housing units (number of persons served): There was a goal in the Annual Action Plan for this reporting period to provide additional special needs affordable housing. Within the 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan, there is an overall goal of increasing rental housing units for special needs persons by 31 housing units. (NOTE: Rush Homes had to revise the design of this new rental development housing project.) Rush Homes completed the construction of the Florida Terrace project and developed the 31 apartment units of which all have been occupied. e units provide housing for persons with and without disabilities, all with low incomes. At least 25 percent of tenants have disabilities. There is a set aside of seven (7) units for Permanent Supportive Housing (persons who are exiting homelessness who also have disabilities). This goal has been achieved. Number of households supported through Rental Assistance: There is no rental assistance project within the CDBG and HOME Program. Number of persons supported through the production of new units: This goal was not attained in PY 2024. There were three (3) households assisted through direct homebuyer assistance through Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH). GLHFH’s Knott Street development infrastructure has been completed. These infrastructure funds were used to subsidize development costs for nine (9) parcels and homes, all of which will be sold to Habitat-qualified families. This goal will be attained once the homes are constructed in the Knott Street Development. In addition, there were three (3) households assisted through direct homebuyer assistance through the Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn- CAG). These projects are ongoing. Number of persons supported through rehabilitation of existing units: During PY 2024, there was no set goal for rental rehabilitation; however, Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority’s (LRHA) Rental Rehabilitation program supported one (1) households through rental property rehabilitation bay private landlords. Page 117 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 21 Discuss how these outcomes will impact future annual action plans. The completion of these projects/activities will assist the City in meeting the goals established in the 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan (CP) and Annual Action Plans within the CP. City Council will continue to allocate CDBG and HOME Program funds to cooperative ventures that will assist in addressing barriers to affordable housing and meeting community public and private neighborhood and infrastructure needs. Include the number of extremely low-income, low-income, and moderate-income households/persons served by each activity where information on income by family size is required to determine the eligibility of the activity. Number of Households Served CDBG Actual HOME Actual Extremely Low-Income 2,756 31 Low-income 28 3 Moderate-income 8 3 Total 2,792 37 Table 12—Number of Households Served Narrative Information Using CDBG funds, 2,792 households were served. The Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) Coordinator assisted 2,637 households that were extremely low-income in assessing the household’s needs and providing available information and resources to divert homelessness. The Extreme Weather Center assisted 105 extremely low-income households by providing shelter during extreme low temperature nights. Boy Scouts of America’s Scoutreach project assisted 14 extremely-low-income household, 28 low-income households, and eight (8) moderate income household. There were 37 households assisted with the use of HOME Program funds. Rush Homes served 31 extremely low-income households (11 HOME units) through their Florida Terrace project. Greater Lynchburg Habitat for Humanity (GLHFH)’s Down Payment Assistance project provided assistance to three (3) low income households. Lynchburg Community Action Group (Lyn-CAG) First Time Homebuyer Down Payment Assistance project provided assistance to three (3) moderate income households. A total of 2,829 households were assisted with CDBG and HOME funds. Of the households assisted, 2,787 of the households were within 0 to 30% of area median income (AMI); 31 were within 30 to 50% of AMI; and11 households were within 50 to 80% of AMI. CR-25- Homeless and Other Special Needs 91.220(d, e); 91.320(d, e); 91.520(c) Evaluate the jurisdiction’s progress in meeting its specific objectives for reducing and ending homelessness through: Reaching out to homeless persons (especially unsheltered persons) and assessing their individual needs The Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) operates a primary access point for homeless persons with satellite access points for special populations. The primary access point for the homeless response Page 118 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 22 system is Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA). The homeless hotline, CHIA, provides a phone-based assessment and referral to diversion, homeless prevention, shelter and appropriate housing interventions and services. This access point covers the entirety of the CVCoC’s geographic region (Lynchburg and the surrounding counties) by providing assessment and referral through a phone- based system. All coordinated entry staff are trained on diversion strategies, addressing the needs of domestic violence victims and the coordinated entry process. Every caller in a housing crisis is provided with consistent and standard assessment tools - safety screening, diversion screening, and basic assessment of housing barriers and vulnerability. An additional access point to the homeless response system is through Homeless Outreach and Mobile Engagement (HOME), the CVCoC’s street outreach program. This program, operated through a local health clinic, Community Access Network, provides a dedicated full-time staff person to identify and build rapport with unsheltered persons and conduct the CVCoC’s standard assessments in order to ensure unsheltered clients receive access to the homeless response system and are quickly connected with housing resources. Intake staff at CHIA and street outreach workers use the CVCoC initial assessments to review clients’ needs and determine eligibility for services. Initial assessment includes an immediate safety screening, diversion and prevention screening, homelessness verification, basic assessment for shelter intake and release of information for the CVCoC’s Homeless Management Information System (HMIS) and Community Case Review (case conferencing). After the initial assessment, there is a prioritization assessment for individuals experiencing literal homelessness, who have been unable to be prevented or diverted from shelter or a place not meant for human habitation. The prioritization tool and the CVCoC Housing Barrier Assessment are completed by trained assessors after initial assessment identifies a household as literally homeless. A CVCoC Coordinated Entry form is also used to identify whether the household belongs to one (or more) of the four subpopulations prioritized by the CVCoC for additional services: veterans, chronically homeless, households with children and youth (unaccompanied young people, age 24 and under). All households belonging to a priority subpopulation are placed on the By-Name List, maintained through the Continuum of Care Lead Agency, Miriam’s House, for prioritization and referral to rapid re- housing, permanent supportive housing and other permanent housing opportunities available through the Continuum of Care. The agency completing the assessment notifies the CVCoC Lead Agency, through either faxing or emailing the Coordinated Entry Referral form for the assessed household. The CVCoC Lead maintains the By-Name List and through a coordinated entry process, each household is matched with the appropriate housing and service intervention. Homeless households that do not belong to a priority subpopulation are provided with housing focused case management and linkages to mainstream resources to promote self-resolution directly from shelter or through street outreach. Addressing the emergency shelter and transitional housing needs of homeless persons: Over the course of a year (January 1, 2024 – December 31, 2024), 372 persons experienced homelessness within the Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC). Of those 372 persons, 58% were unsheltered and sleeping in tents, vehicles, benches and parks while 38% remained exclusively in homeless shelters during their homeless episode and 4% stayed in both unsheltered situations and Page 119 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 23 shelter. Since 2019, there has been a 273% increase in unsheltered homelessness in the Lynchburg area. The high prevalence of unsheltered persons in the Lynchburg community is reflective of the need for an increase in emergency shelter beds. Over the course of 2021 to 2025, there was a 51% decrease in emergency shelter bed capacity in the Lynchburg community. Through a 2021 renovation the largest emergency shelter, Salvation Army, decreased its shelter beds from 70 total beds to 57 total beds and in 2022, the only other shelter, Hand Up Lodge, closed its doors. This shelter was replaced in December 2022 with a new emergency shelter, The Shelter at Reset, but this shelter was only able to provide 16 beds. These changes resulted in a decrease from 98 emergency shelter beds to 73 shelter beds. In July 2024, The Shelter at Reset, closed and The Salvation Army decreased their bed capacity further which leaves only 48 shelter beds available in the community to meet the emergency housing needs of those experiencing homelessness. The Central Virginia Continuum of Care and the City are working alongside a local church, The Ramp Church, to open a new emergency shelter in 2025 that will provide 50 beds for those experiencing homelessness. The Homeless and Housing Services (HHS) Committee of the CVCoC meets bi-monthly to discuss improvements to the homeless response system, including ensuring all persons needing shelter or other homeless interventions are able to access them. This committee reviews gaps in services and specifically addresses any barriers to services. Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) provides a bi- monthly report out regarding any households who were unable to be served and the reason for service denial. The HHS Committee regularly reviews eligibility guidelines for each program to ensure that there are no barriers to program admission or maintenance. The Committee identifies barriers to access that are contained in program rules and eligibility criteria and makes recommendations to the CVCoC Board regarding how those barriers can be reduced. At this time, all CVCoC-funded programs have instituted low- barrier admission policies. Funded projects removed all admission requirements related to drug testing, income, criminal history, identification, custody or family composition restrictions, treatment compliance, medication compliance, or any other barrier to access. An additional way that the CVCoC ensures that services are offered without barriers is through regular training to front-line staff and program managers on Housing First, harm reduction, motivational interviewing, and other best practices. The Monitoring and Evaluation Committee of the CVCoC performs an annual site audit of each CVCoC- funded project to ensure adherence to the CVCoC policies and procedures, which require no barriers to project admission or maintenance. The CVCoC provides annual training for homeless service providers on the Prohibition Against Involuntary Family Separation, Equal Access, and Prohibited Inquiries requirements. This training includes building capacity for shelter staff around creating safe spaces and providing services that promote inclusive policy standards, provide safety for shelter residents, respect diversity and protect the rights of all homeless individuals and families. The CVCoC monitors projects’ nondiscrimination policies to ensure that family composition, gender identity and gender expression are included in the language. Projects are also expected to maintain confidentiality standards that protect sex assigned at birth information. Eligibility criteria are reviewed to address any exclusionary criteria such as requirement of a marriage license or restrictions regarding the ages of children. The CVCoC also provides sample documents that can be publicly posted or handed out to inform clients of their rights under the Page 120 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 24 Equal Access rule. To further ensure compliance, the CVCoC has instituted regular consumer surveying which allows for program participants to report any discrimination. In 2023, the CVCoC expanded the surveying to also include a digital survey. This expansion has allowed for greater consumer input. The CVCoC policies require all projects to have a grievance policy which they provide to all program participants at intake. Helping low-income individuals and families avoid becoming homeless, especially extremely low- Income individuals and families and those who are: likely to become homeless after being discharged from publicly funded institutions and systems of care (such as health care facilities, mental health facilities, foster care and other youth facilities, and corrections programs and institutions); and, receiving assistance from public or private agencies that address housing, health, social services, employment, education, or youth needs All unstably housed households assessed through Coordinated Homeless Intake and Access (CHIA) are referred to the CVCoC’s targeted homeless prevention program if a diversion screen demonstrates that the household cannot be diverted from homelessness and that more intensive homeless prevention services are needed. All households referred to the targeted prevention program are screened with the CVCoC Targeted Prevention Screening Tool. The targeting screening was developed through research conducted by Veteran Affairs as well as peer reviewed research which demonstrates that specific household characteristics make a household more likely to become literally homeless. Some of these characteristics include frequent moves, history of homelessness, fleeing domestic violence, youth, youth identifying as LGBTQ, persons with disabilities and others. Households scoring a 10 or above on this screen are served through housing focused case management and rental assistance, rental arrears and housing stabilization financial assistance. The CVCoC’s Targeted Prevention Tool has been in use since late 2017 and has ensured that services are provided to those most likely to become homeless but for intervention. The CVCoC Policies and Procedures require that systems of care and correctional institutions conduct discharge preparation in order to prevent households exiting their programs from becoming homeless. These policies ensure that the burden on discharge planning, that does not include discharges to homelessness, is on other systems of care rather than primarily on the homeless response system. Helping homeless persons (especially chronically homeless individuals and families, families with children, veterans and their families, and unaccompanied youth) make the transition to permanent housing and independent living, including shortening the period of time that individuals and families experience homelessness, facilitating access for homeless individuals and families to affordable housing units, and preventing individuals and families who were recently homeless from becoming homeless again The implementation of the coordinated entry system provides a framework that assists households in moving quickly into permanent housing. Housing-focused conversations are built into initial assessment and incorporated into shelter case management from the point of intake. Momentum toward housing is maintained by setting timeframes within which housing plans are developed and prioritization assessment should be completed. Shelter case managers offer each household housing-focused case Page 121 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 25 management and housing location services, including assistance with employment, benefits access, referrals to wrap-around services and affordable or subsidized housing identification. Efforts to recruit landlords and share landlord network information across the CVCoC has expedited housing attainment for all program participants. For households that are prioritized for permanent housing interventions, there is a warm hand-off between the shelter or street outreach case manager and the assigned rapid re-housing (RRH) or permanent supportive housing (PSH) case manager, who spearheads housing location alongside the referred household. This hand-off allows shelter case managers and street outreach workers to focus on providing housing focused case management to households with lower barriers who are not prioritized for RRH or PSH. Expanding permanent housing interventions such as RRH and PSH, as the CVCoC does year over year, also ensures that households becoming homeless can be re-housed quickly. There are currently more slots available for permanent housing within the CVCoC than temporary slots such as emergency shelter. This shifting of bed availability ensures that those with the highest needs can receive the highest level of housing intervention. The implementation of a By-Name-List of every homeless households allows the homeless response system to better understand who is homeless in real time. These households are staffed at Community Case Review in order to expedite their permanent housing placement. The CVCoC’s written standards prioritize households with long episodes of homelessness (identified through the prioritization tools) for permanent housing interventions. In 2020, the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) received 79 Mainstream Vouchers. In 2021, the CVCoC received access to 25 Emergency Housing Vouchers and in 2022, LRHA received an additional 30 Mainstream Vouchers. The CVCoC created Memorandums of Understandings with LRHA and Virginia Development and Housing Authority for the voucher programs to ensure that chronically homeless persons are prioritized for vouchers. To increase availability of PSH for chronically homeless households, Miriam’s House created a new supportive services program to pair vouchers with supportive services. Central Virginia Supportive Housing launched in April 2022 to provide supportive services to chronically homeless households who have a housing voucher but do not have supportive services in place to ensure housing stability. Once housed, in-home housing stabilization case management is provided to rapid re-housing and permanent supportive housing clients to prevent returns to homelessness. Housing stabilization case management services include tenancy skills, budgeting and financial literacy education, referrals to employment and training opportunities and coordination with long-term service providers such as mental health skill building services, home-based family strengthening programs, recovery resources or other services that will address stability needs. Through extensive training on and implementation of Housing First strategies and housing focused case management best practices, the CVCoC has equipped homeless service providers to serve and house homeless households rapidly without predicating services on housing readiness. Page 122 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 26 CR-30- Public Housing 91.220(h); 91.320(j) Actions taken to address the needs of public housing LRHA advanced the Dearington Hills Apartments redevelopment (DRP1 – Blackwater Hills). In partnership with its development partner, LRHA submitted a successful 9% Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC) application, resulting in an award of $18.4 million in competitive credits to fund the first phase of redevelopment. Planning for subsequent phases is underway, with financing strategies including future LIHTC applications and loans through the Virginia Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD). As funding is secured, LRHA will implement its relocation plan in close coordination with families, beginning with one-on-one meetings in the winter of 2025/2026 to ensure smooth transitions. These activities demonstrate LRHA’s commitment to collaboration and partnerships while strengthening communications and advocacy with residents. In addition to large-scale redevelopment, LRHA continues to invest in site-specific improvements and planning. This includes environmental reviews and architectural design work for 302 Smyth Street, advancing modular housing feasibility on Pulaski Street, and completing portfolio-wide physical needs assessments to guide capital planning and ensure financial sustainability. LRHA also maintains strong partnerships with local and statewide agencies to respond to resident needs. Based on more than 220 resident survey responses, LRHA is focusing on expanding resident services in education, training, and job placement. The Authority recruited and onboarded a new Resident Opportunities and Self-Sufficiency (ROSS) Coordinator to strengthen outreach, connect families to resources, and relaunch programming. LRHA was awarded a new three-year ROSS grant for FY 2025– 2028 to support this work. This aligns with the Strategic Plan’s focus on succession planning by strengthening staff capacity and ensuring continuity of resident services. Community engagement remains central to LRHA’s approach. The Authority continues to host community events and resource fairs at its sites, bringing together partners and service providers to share information and offer direct support to families. These events advance the Strategic Plan priorities of communications, advocacy, and partnerships. Finally, in 2025, LRHA completed the development of a new Strategic Plan for 2025–2029, adopted by the Board of Commissioners. This plan establishes five core priorities: Preservation & Development of Affordable Housing, Succession Planning, Communications & Advocacy, Collaboration & Partnerships, and Long-Term Sustainability. Actions taken to encourage public housing resident s to become more involved in management and participate in homeownership LRHA continues to share homeownership resources and counseling opportunities with public housing and voucher families through partnerships with local counseling agencies and financial educators. These efforts are part of LRHA’s broader strategy to help families achieve greater housing stability and, when possible, move toward long-term self-sufficiency and homeownership. This supports the Strategic Plan’s priorities around resident empowerment, sustainability, and advocacy. Page 123 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 27 Actions taken to provide assistance to troubled PHAs N/A- Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority is not a troubled PHA. Page 124 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 28 CR-35 - Other Actions 91.220(j)-(k); 91.320(i)-(j) Actions taken to remove or ameliorate the negative effects of public policies that serve as barriers to affordable housing such as land use controls, tax policies affecting land, zoning ordinances, building codes, fees and charges, growth limitations, and policies affecting the return on residential investment. 91.220(j);91.320(i) A primary barrier to affordable housing in the target areas is the very low property values in the targeted census tracts. This is a large disincentive to development through renovation because the cost of repair typically exceeds the value of the renovated property. Therefore, only non-profit organizations that can access soft costs funds (i.e. finance and construction related costs) and grant funds are able to conduct rehabilitation projects in these areas. The for-profit developers are unable to conduct the extensive renovations necessary to make the houses in the target market amenable to modern housing demands. However, the City did allocate CDBG and HOME Program funds to non-profit entities to address the needs of extremely low and low-income families and persons. Lynchburg is a City of relatively low housing costs. Therefore, average income and cost-of-living reflect these somewhat lower housing costs. Development in the CDBG target areas remain limited to non- profit and subsidized activity. This is due in part to the very low property values in these census tracts and a greater value being placed on improvements to property than to the land itself. In the target areas, this high value on improvements, or buildings, had the effect of costing more than clearing land outside of the target areas, and thereby, negating the opportunities of redevelopment. This is also a large disincentive to development through renovation because the cost of repair typically exceeds the value of the renovated property. However, recently there has been more development in the CDBG targeted census tracts. The reason has been that the supply of homes for sale everywhere is down so buyers are pushed into areas not traditional to their socio-economic status. The usual barriers, zoning, building code, and density issues for the targeted census tracts have been interpreted to encourage appropriate development in these areas. This is especially true in the development by non-profit housing providers where the City has waived or offset utility and other fees for making the project more affordable for the very low and low-income residents. The Lynchburg Zoning Ordinance was adopted in February 2016. The Zoning Ordinance promotes higher density development, more flexibility in the development of smaller urban lots and reduced setbacks in higher density residential zoning districts. The Ordinance also allows for more opportunities for mixed- use development, helping promote transit-oriented development in lower income neighborhoods. Finally, one major principle carried on throughout the Ordinance is greater connectivity amongst neighborhoods, especially through the requirement of sidewalks in all high-density residential zoning and commercial districts. The Lynchburg Regional Housing Collaborative completed and distributed to the public through the Lynchburg City Council a Study “Opportunity Profile: Housing Stability in Lynchburg, VA” through a Community Impact Grant from the Virginia Housing Development Authority (VHDA). The Study stated that there is a need for additional affordable housing units and the relation of these housing needs to Page 125 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 29 low-income persons/households. As a result of this Study, City Council is focused on addressing affordable housing and is continuing to discuss with the Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) what an affordable housing policy would be and to discuss resources and options to create and further encourage the development of affordable housing in Lynchburg. Affordable housing has long been a topic of discussion. Lynchburg has a long history of administering programs that are designed to assist residents with housing opportunities. Lynchburg residents have access to outcomes from housing funds administered by the City and the LRHA from programs like the Housing Choice Voucher Program, the Community Development Block Grant, the federal Low-Income Housing Tax Credit, and the HOME Investment Partnership Program. The City has also engaged in a variety of initiatives designed to improve the quality of the housing stock while still ensuring attainability and affordably, such as the Real Estate Rehabilitation Program and the Rental Inspection Program. Additionally, the City has partnered with a variety of public, private, and non-profit organizations that are dedicated to improving housing opportunities for people who live in Lynchburg. In order to continue addressing barriers to affordable housing, City Council has taken the appropriate role of supporting cooperative ventures and initiates cooperation where it is needed. City Council has also exercised this coordinating role in its allocation of CDBG and HOME Program funds to nonprofit organizations and LRHA for housing related projects. All of homeownership programs funded with federal dollars include an educational component for potential homebuyers about mortgage financing, credit and budgeting issues, and the responsibilities of homeownership. Actions taken to address obstacles to meeting underserved needs. 91.220(k);91.320(j) To assist in addressing the housing and community development needs of underserved citizens, the City focused a significant amount of federal resources on new construction, homebuyer activities, public facilities, and public infrastructure in the CDBG targeted areas. Several non-profit agencies were funded with CDBG and HOME Program funds to undertake new construction and homeownership activities. The City focused a majority of the CDBG funds for public facilities and public infrastructure within the CDBG- targeted census tracts. Financing availability continues to be one of the main obstacles in addressing underserved needs of the City’s residents. With declining government program support, the private sector will have to play a key role in making up for this loss. The City, particularly through its partnership with local non-profits, has continued to promote the involvement of private citizens, banks, corporations, and others in community development activities. As more people become involved the proper and effective coordination of this involvement will become even more challenging. Shared responsibility also implies the open exchange of information and the combination of scarce resources. The City maintains a leadership role in this regard, while opening the process to all interested parties, including low- and moderate-income citizens. Page 126 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 30 The City continues to seek reduction in the number of households with incomes below the poverty line each year through long-term solutions such as education (including adult education and job skill training), economic development, and supportive services. These areas are traditionally within the local government’s sphere of influence and the City Council has placed significant emphasis and funding in these areas through the allocation of CDBG and HOME Program funds. Actions taken to reduce lead-based paint hazards .91.220(k);91.320(j) In Lynchburg, approximately 85% of the homes built prior to 1978 contain some lead. Children, particularly those under the age of six, are at risk of lead poisoning if living or repeatedly being in a housing unit containing lead-based paint. Research suggests that lead poisoning has societal costs that include medical care, special education, behavioral problems, reduced long-term educational attainment, reduced long-term income attainment, increased criminal behavior, and increased hypertension in adolescents and adults. In accordance with applicable requirements, lead-paint assessments, treatments, and/or clearances are conducted on each structure built prior to 1978 in which CDBG and HOME Program funds are expended. City staff provides subrecipients, through the written agreements, a copy of the lead-based paint regulations that are to be completed according to the scope of work for the various activities. To protect against this risk, on April 22, 2008, EPA issued a rule requiring the use of lead-safe practices and other actions aimed at preventing lead poisoning. Under the rule, beginning April 22, 2010, contractors performing renovation, repair and painting projects that disturb lead- based paint in homes, child care facilities, and schools built before 1978 must be certified and must follow specific work practices to prevent lead contamination. Contractors are certified through the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). This agency provides training programs across the State of Virginia and allows for contractors to submit their application or certification online. As applicable, subrecipients are required to ensure that all contractors obtain the proper certification prior to completing a renovation or repair project utilizing CDBG and HOME Program funds. Actions taken to reduce the number of poverty-level families.91.220(k);91.320(j) Lynchburg continues to strive toward the mark of poverty reduction and increased median household income through civic engagement. Some of the goals are: Early education tutoring assistance, building a grocery store in an identified food desert, creating an alliance to increase affordable childcare options, improving kindergarten readiness, increasing affordable housing opportunities, developing easier access to health resources, implementing a community-subsidized transportation application, and revamping local public transportation. Each of these items require an immense level of engagement, collaboration and cooperation in which various community organizations focus on daily in their services and outreach. Below are resource links that indicate the focus of the organization and the services that are provided to citizens to aid in the reduction of poverty for Lynchburg and the Central Virginia area. Page 127 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 31 Beacon of Hope: The purpose of Beacon of Hope is to instill in ALL Lynchburg City Public School students the aspiration to pursue AND to provide them with the tools and resources to attain a post-secondary education. Central Virginia Community College - Workforce Solutions: The resource of choice for comprehensive employment and workforce education throughout the Lynchburg region. Goodwill Industries of the Valleys: Goodwill Industries of the Valleys is dedicated to helping people with disabilities and disadvantages overcome barriers to employment. Old Dominion Job Corps: Job Corps is the largest free residential education and job training program for young adults ages 16–24. Lynchburg City Schools – Career Tech Program: Lynchburg City Schools offers a wide array of career- tech courses beginning in middle school. Lynchburg Community Action Group Employment Training: Employment Training program offers training in job search skills, resume writing, certified nursing assistant training, medical technician training, and basic computer skills. TechHire – Lynchburg Office of Economic Development and Tourism: TechHire provides a path to expand training opportunities that prepare under-skilled workers for careers in Lynchburg’s middle and high skill jobs. Virginia Career Works: The Workforce Development Center is co-located with the Virginia Employment Commission and offers a free assortment of career planning services. Social Services and Juvenile Services: Lynchburg's division of Social Services administers Virginia's state- supervised, locally-administered public social services including federal, state and local public assistance and social work services programs. Juvenile Services serves at-risk youth and families who are before a Juvenile and Domestic Relations Court by providing a continuum of assistance that include prevention, early intervention, residential services, home- based services, and secure detention. Call 211: 2-1-1 is an easy to remember phone number connecting people with free information on available community services. When you dial 2-1-1, a trained professional listen to your situation and suggests sources of help using one of the largest databases of health and human services in Virginia. Opportunity 360: Opportunity 360 is a comprehensive approach to understanding and addressing community challenges by identifying pathways to greater opportunities using cross-sector data, community engagement and measurement tools. With this insight, partners in community development will be better positioned to make smart investments and create collaborative solutions that transform communities across the country. Lynchburg Feeds: Lynchburg Feeds is a campaign organized by the Blue Ridge Area Food Bank, in partnership with local partners and community advocates. Lynchburg Feeds is designed to help people Page 128 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 32 find nonprofit food pantries and other food programs in the Lynchburg area. Food pantries provide groceries to people, free of charge. Parkview Community Mission: Parkview's mission is to restore the lives of families and communities by building relationships and providing life-changing resources. Central Virginia Addiction and Recovery Resources (CVARR): Central Virginia Addiction and Recovery Resources (CVARR) believes in the power of collaborative problem solving and grassroots efforts to solve our community’s substance use challenges. By bringing organizations, and citizens from across sectors together, CVARR helps our community maximize resources, support, and solutions. With community support and interest, CVARR is positioned to become the lead resource for advancing community conditions, norms, systems and policies for substance use prevention, treatment and recovery in Central Virginia. Horizon Behavioral Health: Horizon Behavioral Health is the premier provider of mental health, substance use and intellectual disability services in Central Virginia. Horizon's mission is to support and promote the health, independence and self-worth of individuals and families in Central Virginia by providing a continuum of community-based prevention, early intervention, aftercare, and psychosocial rehabilitation services for persons affected by mental health, intellectual disabilities, substance abuse and co-occurring disorders. Our vision is to provide behavioral healthcare services that are accessible, consumer-centered, cost effective, and quality outcome-based. Groups Recover Together is an outpatient opioid use disorder treatment provider dedicated to delivering evidence-based addiction treatment. Everyone who joins Groups gets Suboxone from a doctor right away, so no one needs to worry about being sick. The team understands that simply replacing pills or heroin with Suboxone isn’t the long-term answer. The agency does not just enroll people in treatment, they help members build a life worth being sober for. Partnership for Healthy Communities: This agency’s vision is to focus on a region in which long-lasting positive social change and optimal health outcomes are achieved through successful community collaborations. Be a driving a focus on equity while promoting: 1) successful collaboration; 2) resources and learning; and 3) leadership and governance practices for the organizations impacting the community. The foundation for this work includes five key conditions of the collective impact model. By encouraging a shared vision for change, measuring results, promoting mutually reinforcing activities, and ensuring consistent open communication among all stakeholders Partnership for Healthy Communities can build an engaged, inclusive, and vibrant community. Actions taken to develop institutional structure. 91.220(k);91.320(j) To minimize gaps and to ensure coordination of the Federal CDBG and HOME Program funds, as well as the City’s General Fund, these funds continue to be overseen by several City committees, commissions, and City departments. The City Council, as the governing body of the City, is responsible for all policy decisions and approves all City funding recommendations. Ultimately, funding for housing and non- profit providers is coordinated through City Council. The coordinated entry system for the homeless used by the Central Virginia Continuum of Care (CVCoC) provides communication between area service providers to ensure people applying for services are not Page 129 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 33 caught in gaps in program and funding limitations. Use of standard assessment tools helped align appropriate services with resources to fit personal needs. Through a network of case management, community-based support systems, financial and rent assistance, and Self-sufficiency opportunities, CDBG staff, and CVCoC service providers worked intensely with recipients and their sub-grantees to assure compliance. City staff attended HUD trainings and webinars, and provided grant management, labor standards, environmental reviews, and project administration assistance to subrecipients to strengthen the overall performance and accomplishments for the CDBG and HOME Program. Actions taken to enhance coordination between public and private housing and social service agencies. 91.220(k);91.320(j) City staff uses its network of housing non-profit and community service organizations to deliver both Homeless and anti-poverty services. This network provides strong coordination at the local level with multiple federal, state and local housing and social service programs. These agencies provide direct service for key programs such as: child care, community and economic development, employment training, energy and weatherization assistance, food assistance, Head Start, housing, self-sufficiency programs and training, transportation, veteran’s services, and senior and youth services. A number of the non-profits and social service organizations/agencies are active participants in the Central Virginia Homeless Continuums of Care (CVCoC). This strong engagement with the CVCoC provides another avenue for developing strong partnerships with homeless and housing providers including, the public housing authority, domestic violence providers, and state, county and local social, health and education service providers. Lynchburg Community Action Group’s (Lyn-CAG) Housing Opportunities for People with Aids (HOPWA) program addresses poverty by providing decent, affordable housing to its clients, a major first step in financial stability. The HOPWA program staff provides educational counseling, needs assessment, case management, supportive services, and facilitates the support group for the HIV/AIDS clients. Staff maintains a partnership with the Infectious Disease Physicians in Lynchburg to provide the much-needed health and medical services for the HIV/AIDS clients. Lyn-CAG receives funding from the State Department of Housing and Community Development (DHCD), through its Virginia Housing Solutions Program (VHSP) to financially support this program. Identify actions taken to overcome the effects of any impediments identified in the jurisdiction’s analysis of impediments to fair housing choice. 91.520(a) The City works to affirmatively further fair housing for Lynchburg’s populations. In 2020, the City developed and finalized an Analysis of Impediments to Fair Housing Choice (AI). Based on the AI, the City developed a Fair Housing Action Plan (FHAP) that identified the impediments Lynchburg would focus on over the 2020-2024 Five-Year Consolidated Plan period. Page 130 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 34 Addressing the impediments is a joint effort between the City and its housing and community organizations/agencies. Below are highlights of the impediments identified and the actions taken by the City and community partners during PY 2023 to address these impediments: 1. Impediment/Action - Barriers to housing choices for members of the protected class - The City should specify procedures, training, and monitoring process for implementing the Language Access Plan (LAP) to streamline services and better accommodate persons with limited English proficiency (LEP). This is especially important for when the LEP Spanish-speaking population reaches the safe harbor threshold. • Program Year 2024 Accomplishments – City staff updated the Language Access Plan (LAP) in Program Year 2020, which included specific procedures, training, and monitoring process for the Plan to accommodate persons with limited English proficiency (LEP). 2. Impediment/Action - Location and type of affordable housing - The City and other local organizations continued to address the diverse housing needs for the City's various subpopulation, including students, low- and moderate-income households, persons with disabilities, and elderly persons. • Program Year 2024 Accomplishments – There were three (3) low-to-moderate income household who purchased an affordable housing unit through down payment assistance with HOME Program funds. There were 31 new rental housing units completed during this program year. These units provide accessible, affordable housing for persons with disabilities and low- income households. • Providing more housing in more areas across the City could increase the accessibility and affordability of housing in Lynchburg. While households in Lynchburg are almost evenly split between renters and homeowners, the average age of the community is in the early 30’s, a demographic unable to afford homeownership and so rental choices and opportunities are needed. Along with the increased service industry sector in Lynchburg, affordable housing for families making $15.00/hour is seriously missing. Lynchburg Redevelopment and Housing Authority (LRHA) has decided and committed to a multi-phase project on its Dearington Public Housing property that will increase affordable housing options by over 50% when all phases are complete. LRHA continues to work with the City on vacant lots and properties going up for back taxes sales to renovate and bring back the neighborhood and add property value to the lower opportunity areas missing such CDBG and HOME investment. 3. Impediment/Action – Location and type of affordable housing - LRHA should expand Section 8 HCV Program to higher opportunity areas. • Program Year 2024 Accomplishments – - While the city has invested funds, such as CDBG and HOME, in higher opportunity areas in Fiscal Year (FY) 2024, challenges remain. These include a lack of public transit access and the fact that units in higher opportunity areas demand higher rents which are not affordable to participants, specifically those rents are higher than 120% of fair market rents. LRHA continued to implement several initiatives to address these issues, Page 131 of 208 The City of Lynchburg | Consolidated Annual Performance and Evaluation Report (CAPER) 2024 35 namely, a Landlord Incentive Program and Landlord Orientation and Open House event to recruit new participants. The number of active landlords has increased nearly 16% in FY 2024. These activities, though modest, have demonstrated strong incentives to improve location outcomes. Although LRHA continues to reduce their share of voucher families living in extreme-poverty areas and increase the share in low-poverty, high-opportunity areas, many of LRHA families will choose to remain in their current neighborhood in order to remain close to their job, family, or child care, for example — even if they face fewer barriers to moving to areas with more opportunities. 5. Impediment/Action - Location of community assets - The City should collaborate with GLTC to improve access to GLTC routes in higher opportunity areas and employment centers in the City and for individuals working unconventional hours. • Program Year 2024 Accomplishments - As a component of the Fair Housing Plan, the City has committed to helping GLTC increase the breadth of service options by increasing service levels and expanding system reach to increase access to community assets including employment centers and higher performing schools. GLTC deployed its Flex Microtransit service to replace the Route 6, 7, and weekend 6/7X fixed routes which allowed for expansion of service to areas previously unable to be serviced by traditional fixed routes due to low density, low demand, or inability to navigate the road network in the first quarter of Fiscal Year (FY) 2025. • During the most current year

Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.

Source: City of Lynchburg website. First collected Oct 17, 2026.