Board of Architectural Review Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Board of Architectural Review · meeting of Oct 20, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
October 2026 BAR Packet 1
Packet Guide
City of Charlottesville
Board of Architectural Review
Regular Meeting
October 20, 2025 5:30 p.m.
Hybrid Meeting (In-person at Council Chamber and virtual via Zoom)
P
re-Meeting Discussion
Regular Meeting
A. Matters from the public not on the agenda [or on the Consent Agenda]
B. Co
nsent Agenda
1. Meeting Minutes: June 16, 2026 & August 18, 2026
C
. Deferred Items – N/A
D. Ne
w Items
2. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 26-0046
123 Chancellor Street, Tax Parcel 090140000
The Corner ADC District
Owners: Lambda Gamma of Chi Omega House
Applicant: Garett Rouzer, DGP Architects
Project: Window replacements; sill repairs
3
. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 26-0039
221 E. Main Street, Tax Parcel 330235000
Downtown ADC District
Owners/Applicants: Guiseppe & Antonina Finazzo
Project: After-the-fact CoA/service counter in café space
E. P
re-Application Conferences [Including continued, preliminary discissions] – N/A
F. O
ther Business [Including work sessions, staff questions/discussion, non-action items]
4
. Staff Questions & Discussion - TBD
5. Mi
nor Historic Reviews – Monthly Reporting
• 110-112 E. Main Street – New Café Space CoA
• 1110 Wertland Street. Rear of building #1 – Fence at retaining wall (building code
requirement). [HST26-0042]
• 206 West Market Street – Window and door replacement (non-historic), exterior
alterations on non-historic components at rooftop patio. [BC-26-0172]
• 1600 JPA - Commercial awning and porch enclosure. [HST26-0045]
G. A
djourn
October 2026 BAR Packet 2
Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 26-0046
123 Chancellor Street, Tax Parcel 090140000
The Corner ADC District
Owners: Lambda Gamma of Chi Omega House
Applicant: Garett Rouzer, DGP Architects
Project: Window replacements; sill repairs
Components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to report pages):
• Staff Report
• Appendix
• Historical Survey
• Application Submittal
October 2026 BAR Packet 3
Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 26-0039
221 E. Main Street, Tax Parcel 330235000
Downtown ADC District
Owners/Applicants: Guiseppe & Antonina Finazzo
Project: After-the-fact CoA/service counter in café space
Com
ponents (please click a bookmark below to go directly to report pages):
• Staff Report
• Café Space Context Record
• Ch. 5 ADC Districts Design Guidelines
• Map - City of Charlottesville Outdoor Cafés
1
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
BAR MINUTES
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW
Regular Meeting
June 16, 2026 – 5:00 PM
Hybrid Meeting (In person at City Council Chambers & virtual
via Zoom)
Welcome to this Regular Monthly Meeting of the Charlottesville Board of Architectural
Review. Staff will introduce each item, followed by the applicant’s presentation, which
should not exceed ten minutes. The Chair will then ask for questions from the public,
followed by questions from the BAR. After questions are closed, the Chair will ask for
comments from the public. For each application, members of the public are each allowed
three minutes to ask questions and three minutes to offer comments. Speakers shall
identify themselves and provide their address. Comments should be limited to the BAR’s
purview; that is, regarding only the exterior aspects of a project. Following the BAR’s
discussion and prior to taking action, the applicant will have up to three minutes to
respond.
Members Present: Roger Birle, Carl Schwarz, Cheri Lewis, Ron Bailey, Jennifer Trompetter,
Katherine Tabony, James Zehmer, David Timmerman, Jerry Rosenthal
Staff Present: Patrick Cory, Kate Richardson, Jeff Werner, Remy Trail
Mr. Zehmer called the meeting to order at 5:31 PM.
Mr. Zehmer introduced the newest BAR member, Jennifer Trompetter (Landscape Architect). Ms. Trumpetter
provided a brief background about herself as a landscape architect in Charlottesville.
A. Matters from the public not on the agenda.
No Public Comments
B. Consent Agenda (Note: Any consent agenda item may be pulled and moved to the regular
agenda if a BAR member wishes to discuss it, or if any member of the public is present to
comment on it. Pulled applications will be discussed at the beginning of the meeting.)
1. Meeting Minutes – March 17, 2026
Motion to Approve Consent Agenda – Ms. Lewis – Second by Mr. Bailey – Motion passes 8-0 with one
abstention (Ms. Trompetter).
C. Deferred Items
N/A
D. New Items
1. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 26-0025
601-617 East Market Street; Tax Parcel 530100000
Downtown ADC District
Owners: Townsquare Associates
Applicant: Candance Smith
2
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Project: Installation of entry gate
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – CoA request for a metal gate with glass transom to be installed within an existing
entry on the Market Street elevation.
Candace Smith, Applicant – The proposed metal gate installation aims to minimize the alterations to the
existing structure. The arch transom completes that security closure. It is a glass transom and avoids altering
the existing opening shape. Other gates in the surrounding area were referenced to ensure the proposal fit
within the context of the building and East Market Street more broadly.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Questions from the Public
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Ms. Lewis – Will the Babar sconces on each side of this proposed gate remain?
Ms. Smith – They will. The only other external addition is this little thing on the left. That is a box for
emergency personnel. It balances the fire hydrant on the right. That is existing.
Mr. Werner – That is why I included in my staff report the sentence, ‘the design identifies the gate as non-
historic while contributing to the contemporary eclectic elements that have been added over the years to this
historic building.’
Ms. Lewis – I think the Babar lights are almost historic at this point. I think they have been there at least 30
years.
Mr. Rosenthal – Is the primary purpose of this gate security?
Ms. Smith – Yes. It will just be closed at night. It will be open during the day. It will lay back against the
opening and allow normal access to the business.
Mr. Bailey – Do you need the dark panel there? I noticed some other examples at the Monticello Hotel where
the gates are more open.
Ms. Smith – Yes. I think I will show you those 2 examples in the packet. The gate is secured with a keypad on
the outside for getting in. On the inside, it must be able to just pull the lever and escape. If we don’t put a
security panel of some kind, you can reach over and just lift it open and open the gate. Other more exotic
shapes were added to other places. We thought that square panel with an applied molding of a steel bar went
along with the rest of the rectangular images from those other windows and openings.
Mr. Werner – I suspect that, at least at the tavern, Monticello Hotel had it gotten the code. That was the first
question when Kenneth asked me. I went and talked to the code official. I assume you probably should have
something on that. That is the difference.
Ms. Smith – We talked to them and confirmed their gate could swing in even though the egress door swings
out.
Mr. Timmerman – I was curious about the glass panel. I am assuming it is glass. It is not some kind of
synthetic.
3
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Ms. Smith – It is clear glass tempered and maybe the address on it so people can identify it. There are two
businesses that currently go in and out that door.
Mr. Timmerman – You need that for security?
Ms. Smith – It would take a big effort to climb over. It is possible.
Mr. Timmerman – The door, that panel, and the frame is all one piece.
Ms. Smith – The transom and the frame are anchored to the building. The gate is set on hinges and opens.
Ms. Lewis – Did you say that it would swing inward when it is open? It would block one of the doors.
Ms. Smith – Yes. Those are fixed doors. They have desks and things up against them. They don’t have
handles. They do not open. It is just one door directly ahead.
Mr. Zehmer – Does the gate also swing out or just in?
Ms. Smith – The gate just swings in.
Mr. Schwarz – If you have a limited number of people, you can swing in.
Ms. Trompetter – There is something about applied decorative sticking.
Ms. Smith – That is just on the black metal panel. It is just using a picket to make a square as though it was a
raised panel. It is just an applied half inch square that will be black like the others. It will be more a textural
thing than a visible sign.
Ms. Trompetter – I wondered about the powder coated black mild steel and if that was consistent with the
other steel elements that you have. It looks like the light fixtures are quartan.
Ms. Smith – They are weathered copper. They were installed in the early 90s.
Ms. Trompetter – I was just curious if the powder coating would be consistent. With one picture, the sign is
hanging what looks like dark.
Ms. Smith – That is black. There are two signs on the arms for the two businesses, an architect’s office and the
Hartpine Company.
Ms.Trompetter – I was just ensuring that you are not adding another.
Ms. Smith – It is about the same color and metal as those two existing armed signs.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Comments from the Public
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
4
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Motion – Mr. Schwarz – Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the
ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed entry gate at 609 East Market Street
satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC
District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted. Second by Mr. Bailey. Motion passes
9-0.
2. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 26-0028
1410 Grady Avenue; TMP 050089000
Rugby Road-University Circle-Venable ADC District
Owner: Grady Apartments LLC
Applicant: Kassiah Skipwith, Woodard Properties
Project: Window replacements
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – CoA to replace existing, non-historic metal sliding windows with one-over-one
(single-lite), double-hung, vinyl windows.
Mr. Schwarz – Is there somewhere in the staff report that mentions the color?
Mr. Werner – It is like a dark bronze on the exterior, like what is there now.
Mr. Birle – What is the light division?
Mr. Werner – They are sliders right now, just side-by-side.
Mr. Birle – They are replacing it with a double-hung. Is it going to have divided lights?
Mr. Werner – No.
Ms. Lewis – Is this to replace all the windows in the building? I noticed some apartments were noted.
Mr. Werner – It is a question about that. It is to replace all the windows.
Ms. Lewis – I went by the other day. I did not take a picture. I thought there were some double-hung windows.
I am not seeing any of them in the existing.
Mr. Werner – It is possible. I believe there might be double hung windows on the second story.
Mr. Rosenthal – What has been the objection in general to the vinyl? Why do you suggest an alternative?
Mr. Werner – It has been in the guidelines for some time. The guidelines have not changed. If this was on a
historic building, it would be a different response to it. The objection previously had been the quality of the
material. Vinyl windows at that time were a builder grade product and not appropriate within a historic district.
Products have gotten better. This is a non-historic building with non-historic windows. You have approved
vinyl windows in some circumstances recently.
Kassiah Skipwith, Applicant – For this initial phase, we will be doing 36 of the windows. It is the 36 existing
aluminum windows throughout the building for the next 3 years until 2029. We do expect full window
replacement of all 130 of the windows. A few of those windows are already double hung. They are aluminum.
They are the windows in the bathroom. All the other existing windows are sliders. The proposed replacement
5
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
of the units consists of the bronze, vinyl, double hung windows that are consistent with the surrounding
neighborhood’s architectural context and ensuring a minimal visual impact with a cohesive refined exterior
appearance. We want to use vinyl rather than higher cost materials. It is a deliberate and value driven decision
that not only reduces upfront and long-term maintenance expenses but also allows us to help attainable rent
levels for residents while reinvesting those savings into meaningful, sustainable upgrades within the building’s
interior. Ultimately, enhancing both affordability and overall quality of living.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Question from the Public
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Ms. Lewis – Is the interest in replacing them have to do with any problems operating the windows at this
point?
Ms. Skipwith – No to the operation. We have been having a lot of concerns with tenants with ongoing
condensation buildup, thermal bridging, and water intrusion.
Mr. Zehmer – People have said the aluminum windows are not the original windows. Do you or anyone have
any idea when the aluminum windows were installed?
Ms. Skipwith – We are guessing a little after 1952. We don’t have an exact date though.
Mr. Zehmer – That would suggest they might be original.
Ms. Lewis – The building is 1952.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Comments from the Board
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Schwarz – My concern is that I feel like when we approve a vinyl window, we need to have some sort of
proof that it is a quality vinyl window. Looking at the marketing materials for this, there was not anything in
there that told me that it is commercial quality that is going to last for multifamily apartments. I found the
warranty online. The warranty explicitly excludes commercial properties or anything that is not owner
occupied. That right there makes me want you to pick a different vinyl window and prove to us why we should
accept that vinyl window. I am Ok with vinyl if I have some sort of assurance that it is quality. It is going to
last and not going to fall apart. I don’t feel like we have enough information right now. I don’t have enough
information to approve this. I know the building is not contributing. If it was new construction, I think I would
say the exact same thing. Just because it is a non-contributing and frankly ugly building, I don’t think it means
that we can just let them do whatever they want to it.
Ms. Lewis – The cut sheets did look like they were for single-family residential owner occupied in that picture
on the front.
Mr. Schwarz – There is a lot of marketing in there about the energy savings, which is great. I want you guys
to get energy efficient windows. There are 2 pages on the glass and one page on the window itself. I would like
to see some reassurance that it is a quality product. If you guys want to vote ‘yes,’ that is where I am standing
right now.
6
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Ms. Lewis – We are changing the profile of the aperture from side-by-side to double hung. In my opinion, the
side-by-side windows, which look like casement, are not a character-defining feature of the building. I want to
note that if I felt like those windows were, I would not want to replace them with a different profile. I don’t
think that the change impacts the building at all. We have properties in the city that have been designated on
our IPP list that are much newer than 1952. Saying that this building is not historical, we may not find it
interesting or 100 years old. It certainly is an old building. We have not talked about the profile of the windows
changing. If it was a different type of window, a more unique window, character defining, and defined the
facades of this, we would be discussing that now. I support it, except for the concerns raised by Mr. Schwarz.
Mr. Zehmer – I feel the fact that it is a non-contributing building lets me back off a bit. Since typically, we
don’t allow vinyl windows per our guidelines, there needs to be a good reason to do so. That is in step with Mr.
Schwarz’s thoughts of something quality just to ensure the integrity of the neighborhood that by the time you
are hallway through replacing them, they don’t start falling apart before you even finish the job. I was ready to
approve of this. To the applicant, what are your thoughts about doing some research on possibly a product that
is still affordable but maybe of higher-level quality that has a warranty that applies to commercial buildings.
That might be something you would be interested in regardless.
Ms. Skipwith – We can do some more research. For the ones that we did price out, it is not the Series 100,
which is the lowest grade. We did upgrade to a more premium style series. The series 200 is a little bit better.
Mr. Zehmer – If the warranty does not cover commercial properties, if something happens and it is damaged,
there is no warranty. That is for your own awareness.
There are a couple of different ways we can do this. We can make a motion and take a vote. The applicant can
request a deferral or we can defer it.
Motion – Ms. Lewis – Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the
ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed window replacements at 1410 Grady
Avenue satisfy the BAR’s criteria and are compatible with this property and other properties in this
ADC District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted. Second by Mr. Bailey. Motion
passes 7-2 with Mr. Schwarz and Mr. Rosenthal objecting.
3. Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 25-0095
835 West Main Street; Tax Parcel 310183000
843 West Main Street; Tax Parcel 310175000
847 West Main Street; Tax Parcel 310174000
West Main Street ADC District
Owners: Kim T. & Chris Dabney; Fluvanna Holdings, LLC
Applicant: Andree Sahakian & Brittani Sanders, LV Collective
Project: Multi-story housing development
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – CoA request for construction of multi-story apartment building and related site
improvements at 835, 843, and 847 West Main Street. The building will be eight stories at West Main,
stepping down to six stories at the rear (north) elevation. (Per the CX-8 zoning of the project site, the
maximum by right height is 11 stories/156-ft, with height bonus.)
7
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Zehmer – We are essentially ruling on the project and that walkway connector as designed. If I believe
what I read was if that was to get community involvement and a design flushed out, staff would look at it and
decide whether it needs to come to us in the future.
Mr. Werner – The caveat is that when you get a community led design, be careful. They have come up with
something to put in front of the BAR for a yes or a no. I cannot calibrate that at this point, at least to plant that
seed there.
Mr. Zehmer – The way you laid it out was clear. It is a good process. It would first go through staff review,
which is pretty much everything through you first. You can reach out to the Chair and Vice-Chair. We can help
determine whether it needs to come to the full BAR. The ‘marching orders’ for tonight are what are in front of
us tonight.
Mr. Werner – I had a good conversation yesterday with one of the individuals associated with the community.
It is a rather ‘dry’ paragraph in here. I was worried. I don’t want to say that this matter does not matter. As dry
as it is, it is simply saying, as a means to end here, we don’t have a design. We cannot approve something with
a ‘To Be Determined’ later. I needed something that you could either say that this is Ok, or this is not Ok. I
hope if this project is approved and moves forward, what has been shared with the neighborhood will be
realized. I don’t know how you all within your purview can compel that or require that. At the least, what we
can do is acknowledgement in the discussions that this has been raised, this has been promised. You all cannot
go so far as to say, ‘I am approving this only if this happens in the future.’ You don’t have the purview to do
that.
Mr. Zehmer – That is what we talked about at the end of the pre-application conference for this project at last
month's meeting. I think we are sticking to that.
In the staff report, there is a letter from the City of Charlottesville NDS to the Timmon’s Group 12 days ago. It
is talking about the plan being denied. Some clarity on that would be helpful.
Mr. Werner – We are planners. We don’t review site plans and development plans every day.
Mr. Zehmer – Does this bear on us or not?
Ms. Richardson – Development plans [and site plans] are either approved or denied. If there are comments,
whether zoning related or from engineering as on a site plan, if there are any revisions required, the plan is
simply denied. Every submission is on a timeline basis for review.
Mr. Werner – An approval of a development plan requires a CoA. That is something Ms. Richardson and I
are still ‘wrapping our heads around,’ how exactly to make that happen.
Mr. Birle – This is a little cart before the horse. Some of the requirements or some of the reasons for denial
impact us such as green space, tree requirements, and tree canopy.
Mr. Werner – It is a bit of ‘cart before the horse.’ I would even go so far as to say than simply state on the
development plan “I must get a CoA for this.” The circumstances with it are what we are saying with a site
plan, you look below grade. Ultimately, you need a site plan to build. Let’s say there is a giant lake 50 feet
under this property and we cannot build there. Without looking below grade, the development plan does not
identify a giant lake. It is more of a two-dimensional view looking down. The risk to the developer and the
applicant is that if you all approve a design and that becomes part of that approved development plan, they
move forward with the site plan and that giant lake and cannot build what was approved. They must come
8
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
back. It is at their risk that they are assuming that what is shown on that development plan and approved by the
CoA can be transferred successfully to an approvable site plan. If not, we then see them again with a revised
design. Does that make sense? It is as simple as it comes down to. This is on the applicant.
Ms. Lewis – I wanted to ask a question about The Memory Walk. If we could go back to the contextual plan
for clarification for us and for members of the public, on this contextual plan, there is no area designated as
Memory Walk. I believe it is item one, which is the pedestrian walk and the vehicular alley. I think that is how
it is described: vehicular drive aisle and pedestrian promenade. That is what is collectively called The Memory
Walk.
Mr. Werner – I shared an email with you today from Emily Dreyfus, who raised some questions. If you want
to address those questions, you can all discuss them. The Memory Walk exists as an aspirational idea.
Ms. Lewis – I am asking what it is and what we are asked not to look at it, except as it is presented.
Mr. Zehmer – We are looking at the vehicular driveway.
Ms. Lewis – That is all it is. It is not labeled as Memory Walk on the contextual plan. For members of the
public trying to make a connection about what the Memory Walk means, I am pointing out that it is number
one on that.
Mr. Werner – That was the space identified as available for that. It is possible whenever it occurs, it
surrounds the building. We are also not limiting what the community might come up with. It is a sidewalk on
the side, a driveway in and out of the parking garage, and where the number one is there, that is a continuation
of a semi-permeable paved surface, which allows vehicular traffic to the cell tower site number five on the east
side. As currently designed and as you are looking, that is what it will accomplish. Cars going in and out of the
garage, a path for occasional trucks to the tower site, and a sidewalk along the west boundary.
Mr. Rosenthal – Is the tower going to stay?
Mr. Werner – The tower is on a separate parcel. I imagine that the owner of that is quite happy with how it is
being used.
Mr. Zehmer – I want to compliment staff on the excellent staff report.
Brittani Sanders, Applicant – I wanted to say thank you for the feedback and to acknowledge that we spent a
lot of time trying to make sure that we responded to every single one. I know some of those will be done here
in the meeting with physical samples. I figured that was a little easier than the email back and forth. We have
made some big changes. One of them is wrapping the brick around the north and the west façade. I thought it
was a great suggestion and an appropriate suggestion. We went ahead and we did that. The majority of what
we have done is a commitment to the details that the rendering suggests. We show that we are committed to
providing the details, but also to making staff’s job easier during the site plan process, so that everybody is
clear what it is that we are proposing. I know staff mentioned the possibility of a deferral. I want to go on
record and say that it is our desire to hopefully get to a vote today no matter what that vote is. We are hopeful
for a vote. Touching on the Memory Walk, I want to publicly state that it is still LV Collective’s intent to
follow the process that is being discussed here today. What was discussed at the last meeting in terms of
having a productive community dialogue and following their lead in terms of how that Memory Walk is
designed.
9
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mohammed Mohsen, Applicant – I am going to pick up from where we left off the last time. We got some
great feedback. The direction that we presented at our meeting in May was received well in general in terms of
the adjustments that we have made since our meeting in August 2025. We have shown the renderings, the
depth, and the massing. We did get questions or were asked for more information related to how that depth is
going to translate into the two-dimensional elevations and the plans. What we have done working with staff is
we went back to the elevations and looked at all these renderings that we have done with the corbelling and the
brick and the depth that was presented. We identified five key wall sections around the perimeter that have
these changing conditions from the corbelling to the overhang of the building, entry into the garage, and main
lobby. We have identified those here where you see the red dots. These are the wall sections. We have 3 of
them along West Main given there were a lot of transitions that took place along that frontage. We have one
through the parking entrance on the west façade. We have another one along the east façade where we have
parking on the ground and the change of planes that is occurring further up with the residential levels.
Next Slide
These are the five sections that we have identified. You can see that we have enlarged a couple of them that I
will run through in the following slides. The renderings show the design intent, what we were considering from
massing and transition and layering of materials. Here we have taken a step further with these wall sections to
understand constructability. Where do we identify these dimensional changes and the depth that has been
presented?
Next Slides
The next slides are zoom-ins on enlarged details in a couple of areas from those wall sections. On the screen
now, you are seeing the brick corbelling that is happening along West Main Street and as it wraps the corner
on the west façade fronting The Standard building. This is the condition at the amenities along West Main and
at the front door of the lobby.
These are a couple of other conditions where we have overhangs on the elevated levels; a couple of soffit
conditions. The bottom right is the soffit condition above that parking level that is fronting the east side and a
couple parapet conditions further up in the building. These are all coming from the wall sections enlarged and
dimensioned to give us more clarity about what is being proposed.
Here are a couple of parapet conditions that we are illustrating here. With the planned transitions, these are
enlarged floor plan details showing how we transition from the outside corner transition where we have fiber
cement panel brick transitions at the corner and transitions from brick to fiber cement. It is giving us a little
more information in that depth. This is the west façade on the ground level where we talked about a lot of the
service rooms. There were concerns about how we are going to address this area. It is where we have the
celebrated the Memory Walk and the connection. We have a lot of utilities located in this area. Part of it is just
the challenging access that we have to this development. There are very few areas where we can get these
vehicles and get access to the utilities and services that are necessary. We have pushed the design further here.
We are illustrating between brick texturing, a little bit of corbelling, and the brick pilasters that you are seeing.
It does start to give it a strong character even though it is not necessarily a transparent use. These are solid
doors, solid brick. You cannot see through the wall. On the right side, there is a little profile that shows how
we are stepping and that driven dimensional change.
Next Slide
This is a vignette. The colors here are not necessarily what we are after. It shows that northwest corner and the
beginning of the memory lane coming from Westhaven. Ms. Sanders talked about adding brick to the back of
the development. That was a comment that we heard last month. Treat portions of that back as if it is also the
front. Bring the brick and the materiality and the change of massing to the backside of the building. We have
10
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
done that. This is looking at that northwest corner where you see all the brick detailing coming together along
the Memory Walk and further up at that corner.
Next Slide
We talked about windows last week. We are proposing vinyl windows. We discussed that. There was an earlier
discussion about vinyl windows. I have a sample that I will pass around here. Vinyl windows have come a long
way. They are efficient, are thermally broken, and contribute to the sustainability & energy efficiency of the
building. The manufacturing and the process now allow for us to have a lot of colors. We are proposing black
vinyl windows along the perimeter of the building. We talked about the depth. With vinyl windows, the frame
needs to come close or flush if not project slightly beyond the fiber cement panel. That is the detail that we
need so we can caul around the perimeter and provide a proper seal. With the manufacturer that we are looking
at or similar manufacturers, some of them do have the ability to provide that deep back set, which is the frame
that we have at the top there. The frame does stay flush with the exterior. The glazing and the sash and the
window itself are pushed in to provide some additional depth. A typical frame would put the frame right at the
edge and put the glazing right at the face. The whole thing feels flat. With profiles like this, we can get the
glass pushed in so we can get a deeper shadow line within the window frame itself. It helps provide that depth.
We are proposing that on the West Main Street façade and the west elevation where we have the Memory
Walk knowing that is where the building is going to experience from close proximity people walking right
under those elevated levels where the vinyl windows are proposed. Along the east and north sides, we are
proposing to stick to the original frame, which is the one at the bottom. We have a couple of details here
showing that window profile in brick, showing in fiber cement, and the kind of range of depth that we can
achieve with that deep back set profile.
Next Slide
These are some images from the manufacturer that we are looking at as basis of design. It is hard to tell but
that is a vinyl window. It looks like a metal frame from an aesthetic standpoint. We have come a long way in
terms of being able to provide. It used to have a lot of curves and bends in these in the fabrication process.
With the higher end products, they are now able to get these profiles that are rectangular. From a distance, they
look like aluminum windows.
Next Slide
With the storefront, we have the details here. We did not hear concerns about this. We are keeping everything
at the ground where we have the amenities, the front lobbies, and where we touch the ground. We are using the
storefront.
Next Slide
Fiber cement is another one that we talked about last month. Like the vinyl windows, fiber cement has come a
long way. We are looking at James Hardy as the basis for the design here. A big part of the perception of the
fiber cement panel is typically where you might see the product looking like it is quickly aging. It typically
ends up being around at the joints where you have the panel conditions. We are proposing a reveal system.
Easier trim reveals that is a heavier gauge. It is a lot more durable than your typical aluminum hardware or the
reveals that you use with fiber cement installed. This is certainly far more superior. I will pass these around so
you can see the gauge that we are looking at. Compared to a batten installed, that tends to age quickly. It is
hard to keep those points straight. With this product here, we can get a cleaner joint. That typically is how the
fiber cement is perceived.
Next Slides
These are a couple example projects that LV Collective developed. This is in Columbus, Ohio. You can see all
the elevated panels there. That is a fiber cement panel. I believe that is using the easy trim reveal.
11
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
This next one is in Athens, Georgia. This is one I personally worked on with LV Collective. I can say that one
does have the easy trim reveal that I will pass around. However, this project did not have a deep-set frame.
This was the typical vinyl window where you can see in these pictures the face of the glazing is close to the
exterior finish. We are proposing a slightly different approach here.
Next Slide
This is the solar study. We have looked at it four times during the year to show how this building impacts the
surrounding area. I am happy to answer any questions on that.
Next Slide
Finally, here are the materials that we are proposing. I am happy to pass these around. This is that black vinyl
window that we are talking about. It is thermally broke. I have a couple of the Hardy fiber cement panels in
here. I will put them in that box as well. They click into the hardware if you want to see how it all comes
together. I also have a couple of brick samples here. We have not zeroed in on which products we are using.
You can see they are all in the same range of colors.
The applicant proceeded to pass the different examples of the materials to be used for this project.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
Emily Dreyfus – I am here on behalf of Legal Justice Center. Could you please clarify? Are these questions
for the developer or questions for the BAR members?
Mr. Zehmer – You need to address the questions to us.
Ms. Dreyfus - I sent an email yesterday that hopefully most of you have read. One of the concerns is about
asking their intentions for community dialogue. To my knowledge, there has been no attempted community
dialogue since the last BAR meeting. I work closely with the Public Housing Association of Residents. I would
have heard if there had been some follow-up. It is concerning that the last time they were here, they heard that
you were going to approve, and the dialogue seems to have stopped. If you could ask their intentions and set
up a timeline for check-ins, that is my question. Could you please do that? The perspective view that I
requested from 806 Hardy Drive is something that I think you all would benefit from as well. Understanding
how things will look from the street level, the plan for the Westhaven Redevelopment will ultimately have tall
buildings where it will be window-to-window on the lower floors. It would be helpful if we could get more
information. I would like to ask if you could request that perspective view and not approve until you get that
information. I have lots of questions about the solar study. You all probably know a lot more about solar
studies than I do. At a minimum, would you ask them to do one that reflects 9 AM, 3 PM, and 6 PM in
addition to the noon view? As the sun moves, it will change the shadow. The most impactful thing is whether
you could do more to ask them about greenery in the back. Currently from the street view, I don’t think most
people will be able to even see the greenery if it is low. It would need to be tall trees that could survive in the
shadow of the building with a lot of shade. Could you please take any ideas that you have and help ensure that
large trees or perhaps a hedge or other attractive materials could soften the view for residents of Westhaven,
the most harmed people with this development. Thank you for all that you did on The Mark. I don’t think I
have been back to the podium since then. We appreciated that.
Ms. Sanders – Multiple attempts were made via email. I can provide those emails for the public record. I can
also provide phone calls to where contact was attempted with all community members. They were all copied
but with a specific direction towards attending the Westhaven planners’ meeting. Two attempts were made.
Both times the day of, I was asked to attend virtually. When I asked for the details of the virtual meeting, I was
no longer invited. The purpose of that Westhaven planners’ meeting was to go through a lot of those questions.
12
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
The intent of the first one in my mind was to talk about the building overall. I was told by the leader of that
Westhaven planner meeting, who is not on behalf of Westhaven, (It is CRHA) I was told that the purpose of
the meeting was just for the ground level Memory Walk. I said ‘great.’ I was hopeful of attending that meeting
with some dialogue on that between us and the community. Two attempts were made in writing. There were
follow-up calls. We had the discussion with Mr. Sales and CRHA. Hopefully you can understand why I did not
want to get into that here. That is not the point of this meeting. At the same time, if a question is asked, I would
like to respond to that. I will go on public record and say again that our intent is to dialogue with the
community. I hope the community’s intent is to dialogue with us.
The trees in the back are a little tricky. We are happy to discuss that in detail right now and put on our plans
what is controllable within our property line. I am not evading that. If we just want to ignore the community
dialogue and put what you guys see fit, it is great. Let’s do that. The intent was a little fuzzy because the
property line is right in the middle between our building and the 6-story Westhaven building. Some of the
plans that I have seen from Westhaven have improvements on our property line, which is Ok. We are open to
that. How can I design landscaping without knowing what is on our property line? We are happy to provide
that. Without the opportunity to have that dialogue, it is a bit of a conundrum.
We did have 4 different times on the solar study.
Mr. Mohsen – We have different dates on the solar study. Noon is when the sun is high. Early in the morning,
it will be lower. In the afternoon, it will be lower. We picked one time in the day to show how it would be at
noon, recognizing that is probably when you are going to get the most sun because the sun is going to start
dropping as it gets early in the morning and further in the afternoon. That was 4 times in the year picking a
noon time just to see how it impacts the surrounding area.
Mr. Zehmer – You do have some landscape plans with proposed plantings at the back of the property.
Mr. Mohsen – That is correct.
Ms. Sanders – We did our representative landscape plans. It was a specific request from the community as a
part of negotiated community benefits agreement that has not been signed. It is still our public intent to work
towards that. It was the community’s request that we use Water Street Studios for the ground level or just
landscaping specifically on the Memory Walk and in between our 2 buildings. We committed to that. We
continue to commit to that. However, we are happy to adjust these representative plantings however any one of
you see fit.
Mr. Mohsen – We have a series of slides in the package. It is pages 7 through 12 in your packet that has the
trees, lighting, and furniture as a representation of what was proposed. The only other thing to address from a
massing standpoint is related to how the building feels from a couple areas around the site. We have a couple
of these studies that we have put together. Looking at the building from Hardy & 8
th Street, this is the view on
the screen. On page 25 in your packet, this is looking at it from 10th & Page. There are a couple other views
that are further up looking back towards Westhaven and our building in the backdrop from a progression of
scale and height. Those are also in your packet on pages 23 and 24.
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Zehmer – The two examples that you showed us are from Columbus, Ohio and Athens, Georgia. Can you
tell us when those were built?
13
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Mohsen – The Athens project was completed 2 years ago in August 2024. The Columbus project was
completed in August 2025.
Mr. Zehmer – I was asking in terms of the questions are maybe about the fiber cement panel and aging. They
are brand new. I think that I read that the bricks are still full thickness.
Mr. Mohsen – That is correct.
Mr. Zehmer – On the window depth sheet, I saw some were, I think it was plus or minus 3 inches to 4 inches
deep recessed. The others were plus or minus 1.5 to 3. That seems like a bigger range.
Mr. Mohsen – That is the 2 different options. We are proposing a deeper inset for where the glazing is going
to be located. That is the 3.5 inches along West Main and the Memory Walk. For the 2 other sides, we are
proposing to go with a conventional vinyl window, which would then be the reduced depth the inch, the inch
and a half.
Mr. Zehmer – That is what I was curious about. Right here, it says varies from inch and a half to three and a
half. That is a 2-inch variance. I did not know. Does that depend on the exact location on the building?
Mr. Mohsen – It is hard to see. With this frame here, you can see where the window itself and where the
glazing is going to be located right here. It is pushed a good bit from the outside face, the outside edge of the
frame. That would be three and a half inches. That would be proposed on the vinyl windows that are fronting
West Main Street and the ones that are fronting on the Memory Walk. The lower end of the range would be
this profile here. You can see the glazing sitting close to the outside edge of the frame. This is proposed for
those windows on the east side facing the rail and, on the side, facing the north side, facing the back. That
would be a shallower plane or depression from face of frame to face of glass.
Mr. Zehmer – The top image matches the two left-hand details. The bottom image matches the two middle
details.
Mr. Mohsen – They are drawn to handle both in a way. It is just saying from the face of the fiber cement to
the face of the glazing is going to be an inch and a half plus or minus what we have on the east side and the
north side. It is going to be three and a half on the south and the west.
Mr. Zehmer – Both of the images say an inch and three-eighths.
Mr. Mohsen – An inch and three-eighths is the overhang from the flange to the outside edge of the frame.
This is the outer edge from where the flange is installed to the outside edge of the frame. It is really the same
because the finish is the same. This is sheathing and the fiber cement panel. That frame extends out so that we
can haul around the perimeter for a seal. The inch and three-eighths are from the flange out as opposed to
where the glass is sitting.
Ms. Trompetter – I have several landscape related questions. I don’t know if we want to lump all those.
Mr. Zehmer – It makes sense to try and lump questions. We will get into comments as well.
Ms. Trompetter – Do you want to do architecture questions since you are discussing architecture?
Mr. Zehmer – Are there any other questions or comments on the windows?
14
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Rosenthal – On the previous one, Mr. Schwarz brought up the quality of these vinyl windows. Are these
commercial windows? Do they come with a warranty that will work in a commercial building?
Mr. Mohsen – Absolutely. This sample here is VPI. VPI is the window manufacturer that provides it. That is a
commercial grade vinyl window. Our preference is to keep it open. The specs are going to be calling out for
these quality windows. We would be looking to bid for the job at some point. We want to be able to keep it
open to other manufacturers. That is the level of detail and quality that we would be after. It would be a
manufacturer that can provide deeper frames so we can inset the glass further in from the outside frame.
Ms. Sanders – There are two things about the manufacturer. That comment is going to come from me. I have
developed projects where you commit to it and then they go out of business or it is not available due to lead
times. It is not that we are unwilling to commit. That is why we have tried to add the dimension here. We are
happy to commit to the dimensions. It is just trying to give ourselves a little flexibility when it comes to buyout
and scheduling and sequencing to have a little flexibility as it relates to manufacturer’s specs. I also wanted to
talk through the window color. One thing we talked through is that LV Collective does black windows on all
our buildings, which is a premium and limits the groups that we can go to.
Mr. Mohsen – Long ago, vinyl windows only came in two or three colors. As the manufacturing process
advanced, they were able to start to get an array of different colors. Typically, the higher end manufacturers,
higher end products are the ones that you are going to find that can offer these different colors, especially the
darker colors. That sample here is what we would be looking at doing along the perimeter. It is an indication
that it is a higher quality window. It is not a single-family product. There is a lot more to it than color. It is the
color, efficiency, and way it is thermally broken. There are a lot of aspects to it. This is a commercial window
where we would be able to offer the types of warranty that LV Collective is going to be expected on a project
like this.
Mr. Timmerman – I have a question about what you were showing on your details and this sample. They look
like two different kinds of windows. This looks like it is a bigger scale representing a facsimile of a storefront.
The ones you were showing on the screen, I don’t know if they are in our packet.
Mr. Mohsen – I believe that this section here is specifically sticking not at the frame. It is sticking at a sash
condition at an inside where you have the top panel and bottom panel there, the top and bottom sashes. It is not
necessarily showing the actual frame.
Mr. Birle – This is a storefront section that you are showing us here.
Mr. Mohsen – This is a vinyl window.
Mr. Birle – Is that a structural mall? I agree with Mr. Timmerman here. I don’t see that. I don’t see where that
is in the section.
Mr. Mohsen – That is because the section here that you are seeing, you are talking about these details. This
section here shows the frame and the sash. This is showing the top frame. This section would probably be just
this portion here at an intersection between the molians. If you have a double window, that would be that
intersection right here. This does not include the frame.
Mr. Schwarz – The steal and everything that is in there would be in bullion condition but not like your typical
condition.
15
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Mohsen – That is right. The frame does not need the stiffening. It is already attached to the studs. All of
this except for the stiffener in here is vinyl. The only metal in this is the little rectangular square, rectangular
tube.
Mr. Schwarz – I know that you have said this multiple times. West Main Street and west façade will be
deeper. What happens where you turn the corner with the brick from the West Main Street side to the east
side? Does the thick and thin only apply to the fiber cement? Does it apply to the brick?
Mr. Mohsen – Just the fiber cement. With the brick, we already have four inches of depth. We are assuming
that we are going to use the regular profile by our window.
Mr. Schwarz – That makes sense
Mr. Mohsen – I should have clarified that. Brick usually gives us a decent bit of depth anyways. We did not
think that we needed to go above and beyond there. The reasoning behind West Main and the west façade is
that is where a lot of the pedestrian traffic is happening. We figured let’s get that value. You are going to be
experiencing it from a close proximity. Let’s put the upgraded window there. On the other sides, you don’t get
that close to it. When you do, you are either under an overhang or tight to the building. You don’t get that
perspective of it.
Mr. Schwarz – It looks like there aren’t any conditions where you are turning a corner and you are switching
from one type to another.
Mr. Molsen – No. It is always separated with brick. The addition of the brick at the northwest corner gave us
that separation. Otherwise, that back corner would have been a transition. We don’t have that anymore.
Mr. Timmerman – I was noticing on the top of the southeast corner, which is probably the most visible, are
those storefronts up there up top?
Mr. Mohsen – Yes. This is an amenity space up at the top of the building. With the size window and the
configuration that we are doing there, we could not do that with vinyl. Vinyl still has some limitations on the
size of window. By the time we work through this, I would imagine we would have thickened mullions. It
would not be like this repetitive 2-inch or 3-inch mullion all the way through. Just for design loads and full
transparency, when we advance it some, there is going to be thickened volume. This will be a series of
storefront windows, not one continuous storefront. We are talking about a limited gap between them; enough
to get a stud so that you can brace it. From a design pressure standpoint, you are not designing for this long
window. You have some stiffeners every now and then to be able to support the window in the opening in case
of wind.
Mr. Timmerman – There is storefront on the top and down at the base.
Mr. Mohsen – Along the entire public realm would be storefront.
Mr. Timmerman – Is it a storefront or a curtain wall?
Mr. Mohsen – It would be the storefront. In this case here, we are seeing that darker band. That is the floor
level in there. That will provide support for that. We could not do 15- or 16-feet tall storefronts. You tend to be
limited to 10 to 10.5 feet and 11 feet maximum depending on the manufacturer. With this one, it would be
separated. At the lobby where we have double height, there is going to be a steel frame so that we can split the
vertical span into two storefront windows. That would be that opposite corner right here.
16
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Timmerman – What is the wider bands?
Mr. Molsen – That will be a metal cover.
Mr. Timmerman – Is part of the storefront system?
Mr. Mohsen – It might be some manufacturer’s offer that slap cover or a blank panel that matches exactly
what finish they have. In most cases, even if they cannot provide it, it is brick metal depending on the size. It is
either brick metal or some kind of a metal panel that we would install there. The intent here is to make the
bottom storefront and the top storefront feel like they are part of an assembly so it is not broken with some
other material in between. It would be metal to match the color and finish of the storefront.
Mr. Timmerman – What are the manufacturers you typically source?
Mr. Molsen – We use YKK as basis of design. For the same reasons that Ms. Sanders had mentioned, we tend
to keep it open from a specs’ standpoint. We must do the performance spec. I believe YKK do offer that cover.
For this project, there is going to be, from an energy standpoint, whether we must do rigid insulation, we are
probably going to do an energy model to understand that better. Depending on what we must do, whether we
must insulate the edge of slab or not, it can restrict some of the options we have available as well.
Ms. Trompetter – I apologize in advance. This is my first BAR meeting. I might say or do things out of order.
I might make comments when I am supposed to be asking questions. What is the Memory Walk? I would love
a little history on what that is. It does not come up.
Mr. Zehmer – We are not judging the Memory Walk this evening. All we are going to look at is the
vehicle/pedestrian connector that is to the west of the building that connects West Main Street to the
Westhaven Neighborhood behind as it is designed.
Ms. Trompetter – We should not call it the Memory Walk? We will call it a driveway because that is what it
feels like to me.
Mr. Zehmer – That is correct. It is a drive and pedestrian area. The applicant has made it clear that they would
like to continue a conversation about a future Memory Walk or some way to engage the community in the
design of the building. That will come to us later if staff determines that it is appropriate.
Ms. Sanders – I am happy to talk through the history. There is a lot if you would like.
Ms. Trompetter – The question related to that though is in the comment last month. In the conversation last
month, you mentioned the intention to make more out of this space in front of the building. That would extend
to the front. You also talked about a dedicated space between the buildings and between Westhaven. There is a
lot missing for me in this drawing. I am going to ask a lot of questions about the things that are missing.
Ms. Sanders – It is intentional. These are all spaces intended to be designed with the community.
Mr. Schwarz – Whatever is there we need to approve something. If we make an approval tonight, we must
assume that if everything goes bad and you guys don’t work with the neighborhood, what is in these drawings,
we are Ok with being there.
Mr. Zehmer – It is within our guidelines.
17
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Ms. Lewis – I would encourage Ms. Trumpeter that if she sees things that are missing to bring it up.
Ms. Sanders – I agree. I would ask that we look at it.
Ms. Trompetter – Ms. Tabony did ask in that conversation last month for a diagram of the public space. Right
now, I don’t feel like I understand what it is.
Ms. Sanders – Consider that it is all public. We must ignore the Memory Walk. I would review it as if it was
all public.
Ms. Trompetter – The area in the front is all public. Where all the seating is located is public.
Ms. Sanders – Everything at the ground level is public for the purposes of this meeting.
Ms. Trompetter – The furnishings that are shown on Main Street are for everybody.
Ms. Sanders – Those are built-in furnishings. I would not weigh in on movable furnishings.
Ms. Trompetter – There are no furnishings shown on the west side or the back side.
Ms. Sanders – This was a question that was asked by the CRHA. For clarity, the gray is where it shows 22
feet. That is a true drive aisle into the deck. The area in green with the festoon lighting that is up above, that is
a service alley for two things. Legally, we must provide access for two things. That is our utility equipment
that is right behind the building in terms of transformers and to the cell tower. That is number 5 on this. That is
not a part of our property. It is outside of our property line and it will remain. Vehicles are running through
there. There will be bollards that are movable. You cannot put permanent furnishings. You also have fire
access. That is how they are getting back there. You cannot have any permanent furnishings that would
obstruct the Fire Department’s ability to provide services from a safety standpoint and from vehicles being
able to access the other side. The area where there is a trellis that is a built-in. It is representative if there are
any comments around the look or the placement. It is there because it clears the turn to get to the transformers
that are there and to get to the cell tower. That is the intent for the built-in space that serves as a transition from
those monumental stairs that we are aligning directly with. It would maybe be good to go to the site plan to
help her understand the context of this.
This shows you how the outdoor space connects directly between the two newly proposed Westhaven projects.
This is their new plan, not how it exists today. It is aligned. The intent is where the blue double-sided arrow is
there. That is where there is a moment to be designed with the community.
Ms. Trompetter – A lot of the things you just mentioned are not indicated at all; festoon lighting, bollards,
trellis, monumental stairs are not indicated anywhere.
Ms. Sanders – We did not include it, not to evade it. I was under the impression that we did not know that
there was going to be a new member. Our intent is not to evade or not provide information. The information
was just provided previously. We are happy to go through it again.
Ms. Lewis – As BAR members, if we are being asked to vote tonight, we only look at the submittal that we
have received for this meeting. We cannot look at anything that we received in May. I know it sounds
redundant.
18
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Mohsen – This is in your packet. It was just not in the presentation today.
Mr. Zehmer – Mr. Mohsen was picking up where he left off last month. It is in the packet. I saw some
lighting.
Ms. Trompetter – There is no festoon lighting, bollards, and trellis.
Ms. Sanders – The monumental stairs are not on our property. With the lighting, we don’t have a spec. This is
where it gets hard. We specifically discussed not getting into detail. The only reason I mentioned festoon
lighting is because the strings are overhead. I was just mentioning that for reference.
Ms. Trompetter – Those zigzags are intended to be festoon.
Mr. Mohsen – Part of what we are doing is the 22-foot-wide-lane is going to be used for parking up to the
parking entry. The section beyond that where we have the pavement patterns and the greenery, that is going to
be favored. We need to design it to withstand fire access and access to the cell tower and if needed access to
our transformers that are in the back. It is going to be designed to withstand that type of load. We have
changed the pattern, so it is a clear delineation between what is vehicular access to get to the deck versus
beyond that point it is only emergency services.
Ms. Sanders – What we have talked about with the community is even though we cannot do built-ins there, I
can provide the emails where we responded in writing saying that we are happy to do programming subject to
the Fire Department. If we wanted to have food trucks in there, if we wanted to have an art show, those are all
things if it is temporary and removable that are all open in discussion. I am happy to provide those
communications.
Mr. Timmerman – The daily use would be temporary.
Ms. Sanders – It would be up for discussion. We are open if it is not a permanent obstruction that would stop
the fire department from having access or from us meeting our legal obligations to allow access to the cell
tower and the transformers.
Ms. Trompetter – Is the walk shown there intended to be accessible?
Ms. Sanders – Yes. Everything must be accessible. We cannot control what is not on our property line.
Ms. Trompetter – Where will stormwater be collected on the site?
Mr. Mohsen – That is part of the civil engineering packet that is currently being reviewed. I believe that it is
going to be under the building in the parking area. I would need to confirm that with the civil engineering
teams.
Ms. Trompetter – I did not see any indication of any collection area on the site.
Mr. Mohsen – We have not included any civil engineering.
Ms. Sanders – It is going to be underground detention. That is a part of the site plan approval process, not
necessarily under BAR purview if it is underground.
Mr. Zehmer – It is out of view. If there were exterior downspouts, those would be under our purview.
19
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Ms. Trompetter – My next question is about archaeology. Given that this has never been developed, have you
considered in Phase I to look at that?
Ms. Sanders – We have taken care of that. We will adhere to all the requirements. The most we can do is start
construction. If something is found, we will stop construction. As it relates to the design of the building, I am
happy to answer any questions or concern around the design of the building.
Ms. Trompetter – Is it acceptable for us to request more?
Mr. Werner – It is very common particularly at a site like this that has not been developed to require a Phase I
examination. These are spaced test pits. It is an in-depth document and record evaluation by an archaeologist.
If they deem it necessary to do any kind of test pits, they might. This does not become an archaeological site.
Unlike where we had at the court’s expansion project where we had documentation of burials, none are
suspected here or at least not a record indicating burials here. Phase I would be appropriate. You could use
language that we used for The Mark, for the 218 West Market project. Simply to say, prior to the issuance of a
building permit, a Phase I archaeological investigation will be completed and provided to staff.
On the landscape discussion, I handed Mr. Schwarz a suggestion and he passed it down.
Ms. Tabony – We don’t normally talk about the interior of the building. I think this directly affects the
exterior space on the west side of the building. Is there interior access to the trash room from the parking side?
How are people bringing their trash down?
Ms. Sanders – There are chutes. You don’t come down. You are going to drop it in your chute on each floor.
Ms. Tabony – We are not going to have trash sitting outside the trash door. That will have weekly pickup
from a truck.
Ms. Sanders – We don’t know that yet. That is to be worked through with the city. We have started those
discussions. Weekly pickups would be the minimum.
Mr. Mohsen – The doors that we are going to have in the trash room at the ground level is going to be an
overhead door. When the chutes are being emptied, they are pulled out and put back in when that overhead
door closes. Usually, we would have a regular main door in there as well. Maintenance would not want to open
the overhead door every time just to get in and out of the room. Those could be designed to be facing the
parking area. We have shown one door currently in that design that we have done with the plasters and the
brick detailing. There is one door there. We have flexibility there in terms of how we maneuver these bins of
the sheets and all that to make it work.
Mr. Rosenthal – I wanted to get back to the solar study and the shade analysis. You have shown the noon
shadow. It would be helpful to show 9 AM and 5 PM on those same dates. That would help determine what
plantings are survivable or thriving at your property line. They may want to do plantings there seeing that
shade and solar study would be helpful for them.
Mr. Timmerman – I was curious about the trees that were shown in the shrubs. What was the selection
process for those? Were they done by your group? Was Water Street Studios involved? You mentioned Water
Street Studios having been involved in some of the planning at some point. I was wondering what the selection
process was.
20
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Mohsen – This was done by our in-house landscape group early as we were starting to advance on the
design and leading up to the submission that we made to meet with you in May. Since then, there have been
some updates in terms of the ongoing discussions and Water Street potentially coming back on board.
Ms. Sanders – We have not had any dialogue with Water Street since our August meeting.
Ms. Trompetter – Is there a reason why you have not engaged with them yet?
Ms. Sanders – Yes. It is a larger part of a community benefits agreement. It was a part of maybe about 200-
line items that I was presented with. I have not had the opportunity to sit with Westhaven specifically. That is
who we interact with the most. There has not been an opportunity to engage in that dialogue. I don’t want to
have conversations with Water Street Studios if I don’t know what the community is looking for me to say to
Water Street
Mr. Zehmer – Do you know if the plants that are shown on this plan adhere to the city’s tree list?
Mr. Mohsen – I would hope so. Unfortunately, I do not know.
Ms. Sanders – If there is a preference on the type of plants that specifically go back there, we don’t have any
preconceived notions of what goes back there-scale, height, width.
Mr. Birle – I have a follow-up question based on the June 4
th letter to Timmons from the city planner. It
sounds like there are still some issues with streetscape standards, green space, tree requirements, selections.
These are all reasons for denial, and they are looking for a resubmission. Is that resubmission going to change
the site plan that we are looking at? We are only able to comment or vote on what we see tonight.
Mr. Werner – This is the ‘rolling of the dice.’ If something significant or substantive changes, we then must
weigh whether that is necessary to get an approved site plan. That is why I made the note.
Mr. Birle – Basically, this would come back to us.
Mr. Werner – It is possible. A development plan is not the equivalent of a site plan. If what is approved for a
CoA, that must be reflected with what is in a development plan. Development plans are now requiring
elevations and a level of information. It is more information. If I was an applicant, I would be looking at my
site plan because I want to make sure I know where everything is going to go and where everything will fit. I
would make sure the building fits within that. The risk here is with the developers. If you approve the design as
presented and later a site plan or development plan cannot be approved without changes to that, the risk they
face is to come back and modify their design.
Ms. Sanders – We tried to do our best here in working with staff. We were in a site plan process before. That
is our intent to continue with the site plan process. We switched to the development process for the process of
transparency here so we can outline what does not match. That is typically a part of the process. We are in our
first round. You are always going to have comments in the first round. That is simply where we are. It is tough
to ask the development community to go all the way through to construction documents to get your site plan
without knowing if the BAR supports you. Just not sure how to move forward.
Mr. Birle – I appreciate that. It does not have to be fully construction drawings. We are usually presented with
more specific tree species, tree canopies. Those are things that matter a lot to us.
21
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Ms. Sanders – I completely understand. That is where I am in a bit of a hard place when it comes to
landscaping as well. It is all part of the community dialogue. The last thing I want is to design this in a silo and
do what the community thinks I am doing. I am trying to tell you that we are happy to put anything that is on
the list of requirements there. No matter what, we cannot get a permit without a site plan approval. You cannot
build this without getting to a site plan approval. You guys have comfort that something from the city’s list of
requirements is going to be there. That comfort is inherent because we cannot build it without doing that. What
I am suggesting is if there is something from the list that we must pick from either way that you would like to
see, please tell me.
Ms. Tabony – The planning requirements for this site, would that just be right along Main Street? Does that
apply to all 4 sides of the building?
Mr. Schwarz – The tree canopy is the whole site. There are streetscape requirements. There is a tree canopy
for the whole site.
Ms. Tabony – They will be overseeing all the planted trees.
Mr. Werner – What I want to make clear to everyone and to the public record. It has happened where
buildings are changed. Where there is a door, it might become a window. Where there is a window, it might
have to be shifted because a mechanical room wall must be built. If at some point in the future, they come back
and say these transformers are over here off this inset is not there. This wall continues. I am probably going to
work with them on that. I don’t say ‘no, you said this thing was going to be 12 feet, 6 inches. It had better be
12 feet, 6 inches and not 12 feet, 8 inches.’ You are looking at this at a step-back level from construction
drawings. When projects of this scale go in and figure out where the transformers are going to go, figure out
where the mechanical systems are going to go, things move around. I allow myself the freedom to work with
the applicant. If they come in and the plaza in front is infilled, the storefronts are only on the two ends, we are
going to have a conversation. I want to make that clear to everyone out there. When we talk about what
changes might occur, changes happen. A landscape plan is required for the site plan. A more robust landscape
plan than what you are seeing here. That is something that is detailed, something that meets the tree canopy
requirements. With the new ordinance, there is a lot more specificity in that they must meet. That is why I am
Ok with this. I know, for example, the lighting is addressed in the code. They cannot put bright lights in with a
lot of glare. I put in some conditions that address the parking lot. As far as the landscaping goes, if necessary, I
could omit the landscaping from this CoA. I know we don’t do incremental CoAs. That means we don’t say
that you like height, massing, and scale. We approve it and come back later with the design. The landscape (the
plantings) is a distinct piece that is separable from the design of this building. We want clarification on what is
planted, particularly on that north boundary. I see no problem if you were to approve a CoA for the design,
omitting the landscaping plan requiring that to come back for a CoA. That would be a separate application. It
would be something later. It would be a CoA specifically for the plantings or for whatever element of the
landscape that you chose. I am comfortable with that if it is a means to an end. There is also a section of the
code that refers to the type of screening between areas of different zoning. We don’t have that here. There is
not a required type of landscape screening. The code does lay out a series of transition screen high #2. It would
be helpful if you all are asking. I don’t know what the best species is to put there or what sequence of plantings
to put there. If there is an intent that we can establish and if it is an intent we can establish through reference to
these in the code, you don’t have the authority to say that you must meet the code. You have purview to say
that here is a good example in the code of development. Let’s refer to that. I am offering that if that is a helpful
way to express what you are hoping to accomplish.
Mr. Rosenthal – If we approve the massing as proposed and the shade makes this screening untenable, where
does that put us?
22
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Schwarz – There are species that will fit and will grow back there. There are trees growing on the north
side of The Flats that are living there. There are trees growing on the north side of lots of tall buildings in
town. They can find something.
Ms. Sanders – You are hitting on a good point. I want to make sure that I am saying that I am not asking for a
specific species. What we are happy to commit to is the bullet point list that staff put up earlier. If we want to
add a bullet point that says you must have plantings at 2 feet, 4 feet, 6 feet, or a plethora thereof, we are happy
to add that as an option. I am happy to outline exactly where that needs to be within the plan. I would ask that
the species is left open to pick from what is allowed within the code
Mr. Werner – It is trying to keep us from going down that path of designing this space knowing that tree
canopy and coverage is a requirement of the code. Using our code to express an intent. The goal back there is
to achieve X. If they came back and said ‘we couldn’t do this because of the height of our building. We can’t
meet the tree canopy requirements.’ They have avenues to request a remedy for that. The result may be ‘you
are not providing the screening type the BAR asked for.’ We can have a conversation about that. I am trying to
think of a means to move forward. Part of why at the end of the staff report, I took the Guidelines. Mr.
Schwarz sees this because I do it for the entrance corridor. I use a spreadsheet of all their guidelines. I say yes,
no, or here is what applies. I did that here. It is unusual. This is a lot of the discussion we have been having
internally. What are the Guidelines? What is the BAR purview? An explanation that is helpful is that our
Guidelines don’t say that you must provide building sections of a level of detail. A lot of these are because it
helps when we must review the building permit. The drawings are realizing what is shown in the renderings
and the elevations that you have looked at. I appreciate that there are times when we ask for more detail than
maybe the Guidelines suggest we ask for. There are also places where the Guidelines are general. I am trying
to illustrate that by adding it here. The intent with the landscaping back there is to create screening. What type
of screening can be expressed by you referencing the ordinance if what types of trees, spacing, and ultimately
what that landscaping will be back there. If you want to see that in specificity, you can omit that from the CoA
and say that it comes back. There is a distinction between a designed landscape where someone is achieving
something with the terrace and plants versus providing the trees as required by code. If this was intended as
this landscape that 100 years from now is a Lawrence Halprin landscape that is available for The National
Register, what are the trees necessary to provide shade and provide buffer. That distinction applies here. These
are not the gardens in front of the palace.
Ms. Trompetter – This is a vernacular landscape. This is a cultural landscape probably since the 1960s. This
has been a site where the community has access to West Main Street. We need to give it much more
consideration than just a sidewalk.
Ms. Sanders – That is where I need to speak to the history. The Memory Walk was on the other side of the
building. There was a detailed landscape plan designed by Water Street Studios. The community
understandably wanted a direct connection to Main Street. At that point, their location of the walkway was a
little closer to ours. They wanted a straight shot. Between August and today, Westhaven reimagined their plans
not to necessarily align with anything just conditions on their site. It moved to where it is now. In response to
that, we relocated ours to align with it so we could provide that direct straight access. We are even providing
the walkway all the way across Main Street to the southern side so that there is safe ADA access with a
signalized crosswalk to get to the bus stop. With that, there is about 6 feet of topography that does not show in
the plans running from our driveway all the way to the bridge. The bridge connection is right there. There is
only one place that the city will allow us to access our garage. It is right there. If we want the direct connection
to align with Westhaven per the community, how do you fit all of that within there? There are a lot of layers to
this. It is not meant to be an 8-foot sidewalk. That is why we are trying to figure out ways to wrap it all. The
intent is that it wraps all the way around the building. The reason that we cannot get to specificity on the
landscape plans is because the Westhaven plans show improvements on our property line. We want to be able
23
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
to do that. That is the right thing to do. We want that connection to happen. I know we are focused on the
historic district here, not the relation to Westhaven. That needs to be remembered. The intent is that it is
wrapping all the way around. We cannot get into specificity of the landscaping without having that community
meeting, which was attempted to have twice by the time we got here. Those meetings are bi-weekly. An
attempt was made at each meeting.
Ms. Trompetter – I appreciate that. I understand what you are saying. I want to go on record that this is not
just a planting plan. This is an important connection for the community that has been there as long as
Westhaven has been there. I am just saying that there is a connection to West Main Street from Westhaven.
Ms. Sanders – There is no connection right now.
Ms. Trompetter – There is an experiential connection that people make. They walk from Westhaven. I have
seen the paths. I have seen people walking. I am not talking about a design. I am talking about a vernacular, a
cultural landscape that exists. We need to be thoughtful about that.
Ms. Sanders – We are trying to be thoughtful and inclusive.
Mr. Zehmer – That level of community involvement has not yet happened for whatever reasons. That flushed
out full design is not what we are looking at tonight. We will have to grapple with that in a few minutes. We
are still in Questions phase. If we could table that, we will come back to it. That would be helpful. Let’s talk
about any other questions. We have talked about landscape and windows details. What topic do you want to go
to next?
Mr. Schwarz – You are going to use the James Hardy with the finish that comes with it. Is that the plan?
Mr. Mohsen – That is the intent. In some markets, we have found that painting the hardy is the way that it is
done in these specific markets. Our preference is always to find a color if it works with the palette. They have
limited colors. It has expanded over the years. Our preference is to find something that comes in prefinished. It
installs, is touched up as need be. That tends to age better than the paint onsite.
Mr. Schwarz – You are going to use the smooth finish, not the wood grain.
Mr. Mohsen – That is correct. Those are four colors here. We only have three on the building as it stands
currently. We have the light and the dark. These are the accents. The lighter of the two grays is what we would
use as the mid-gray. This one will be our darker gray. That would be dark.
Mr. Zehmer – This one is probably going in the trash. Those two are similar. One is a little gray and one is a
little green. There is a dark and there is a light gray and a white.
For the brick, is this just texture or all three colors?
Mr. Mohsen – The brick is just one color currently that we are now proposing. These are just alternatives that
we are weighing in proximity to the site, where it comes from. It is just to say that this is the tone and the
shade.
Mr. Schwarz – Back to the notes that zoning gave you guys, there are some modifications, variances, and
waivers that they are expecting you to address. These questions are me trying to understand the building better.
With the requirements of the streetscape, is it just where the trees are relative to the sidewalk? Is that the
24
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
question? In our packet, we see the trees against the street. I think there is a screenshot somewhere of a site
plan that shows the sidewalk between the trees and the street. What way are you going?
Mr. Mohsen – That is correct. That must go with the topography that we are working with. We are trying to
get that plaza as leveled as it can be against the building, provide these entry points as much as we can. There
is a 6-foot slope from one end to the other. By having the landscaping between the internal sidewalk and the
outer sidewalk, we can maneuver the grades a little bit better and provide stepping between the internal
sidewalk and the external sidewalk. It is working a little better. From a utility standpoint, we are talking to the
civil engineer. It was working a little bit better in terms of being able to run everything that needs to be run on
the ground.
Ms. Sanders – Remind me, The Landmark has the same condition against the street.
Mr. Mohsen – I believe the building across the street from The Standard had that same condition. It could be
that The Standard has the same outside. I believe there was also some utility benefit to it in terms of where the
trees are going to go relative to the utility lines.
Ms. Sanders – We are going to share our plan to make sure we are saying the same thing.
Mr. Schwarz – What we are voting on tonight would be those trees moving inward. That is what you are
telling me.
Mr. Mohsen – That is correct.
Ms. Lewis – Not what was submitted.
Ms. Tabony – They are moving toward the property line.
Mr. Birle – They are moving towards the building.
Ms. Sanders – This might be a timing issue because we are trying to get the development plans reviewed at
the same time. My apologies are that this is not showing.
Mr. Schwarz – With the ground story height and finished floor elevation, where are you guys going with that?
Mr. Mohsen – I will go back to the plans on that one. Where we are not meeting the active height, it is where
we have the amenities stacked. Where we have the lobby, where we have this double height space, we don’t
have issues there. As soon as we get into the amenities, because of the way the sidewalk is working, we are
depressed. Once we get past these steps, the finished floor inside the building is lower than the plaza. We have
another level above that. If we are measuring from the street level, that next amenity level up comes in quicker.
Ms. Sanders – It is halfway in between. You still see it. It just does not come all the way to the window line to
count. You still see that second mezzanine level up there. You still have the activity. It just does not come all
the way to that band that we were talking about.
Mr. Schwarz – With the pedestrian experience, we are still seeing double height spaces.
Mr. Mohsen – It is active use. It is 2 floors instead of one tall floor.
Mr. Schwarz – I understand the setback in the entrances. I get why that is an issue.
25
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Mohsen – It has been extended here to accommodate the plaza.
Ms. Sanders – The intent of the plaza is to serve as an extension of the Memorial Walk, not a plaza for our
residents per se. It is because I felt the same way in terms of having this Memory Walk to the left that I wanted
to bring it to the front of the building to make sure it was at the forefront. The intent is that you have your art
there. You have your signage there. It is celebrated front and center. That is why that is there.
Mr. Zehmer – I was trying to find in the staff report where the image was that somebody referenced the trees
along the street edge go away.
Mr. Schwarz – No. They shift towards the steps. There will be a sidewalk, street trees, steps down, and then
plaza.
Ms. Sanders – If you look at this, the rectangles are squares down at the bottom. Those go away. There are
already planters and planting boxes there. They now must meet city requirements. That is the idea.
Mr. Mohsen – You shift up and then you have the sidewalk against the curve. You then have the landscaping
strip with the steps that connect between the 2 sidewalks and then you have the plaza.
Ms. Sanders – From a variance perspective, if that is not approved, then this is the plan we must build. You
are looking at it both ways. If we don’t get approval for the variance, this is what is built. If we do get approval
from the variance during the site plan process, the rectangles at the bottom go away.
Mr. Schwarz – Is this buildable with the landscape against the curve?
Ms. Sanders – It is a civil question. Yas, as shown. You would run into utilities. We would have to investigate
utility reroutes because of the slopes. I cannot fully answer that question.
Mr. Mohsen – I cannot answer the civil portion of it. We do have the sidewalks internal on the plaza and the
sidewalk on the outside. At some point, the closer we get to the bridge, the more that elevation change occurs.
If we have them against each other, it makes that connection between the 2 a little more difficult. You would
have to work your way to the southwest corner to get closer to being leveled. Separating them allows that
landscape buffer to function as that zone that we can use to step up and down between the 2 sidewalks. It
improves the connection between the outer sidewalks and the plaza by having the landscape zone in there to be
able to grade it differently and give us enough room to be able to step between the two when we need more
than a couple of steps. By the time we get to the front door on the southwest corner, we are close to the
sidewalks. The sidewalks are close to being leveled. It is the bridge side. We have improved the condition with
the plaza stepping up the way it is. There are still grade differences to be worked out between the plaza and the
sidewalk. The sidewalk must be maintained as an accessible connection all along the front edge. The street
elevation is not changing. We don’t have any control over what grades that is going to be. That gives us that
ability to step up and down.
Mr. Zehmer – There is still a step here.
Mr. Mohsen – At that point, it ends up being nothing.
Mr. Zehmer – Why I asked is to your point about accessibility. It is important to have these grades right there
so people can get into the plaza if they have accessible needs.
26
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Mohsen – That is correct. That end by the front door is going to be leveled. Civil engineering is working
the grades for that to be leveled. Beyond that, it will start with a couple of steps and then up to 4 or 5 steps at
the most.
Mr. Zehmer – Because the street sidewalk maintains its grade, you don’t need to add in additional ADA
requirements. You don’t need a ramp at this step here.
Mr. Mohsen – That is correct. We have guardrails at the bridge. There is no connection to that sidewalk
anyway. The elevation is different. We are working the accessible means by having that zone in the middle to
wrap it.
Mr. Schwarz – With the north side on the elevation, I was expecting to see screens. It says textured brick. Is
that correct?
Mr. Mohsen – We have made that change between the presentation in May and this one. Part of that is there
was some feedback and some comments about thinking through how we are screening the lights from the
parking from bleeding outside. What happens to headlights? Based on the redesign over the last few months,
we have lost our ability to do natural ventilation anyways. We do not need these openings to be able to get
ventilation in the deck. If that is an issue and there is a concern there, we know and understand that it is going
to be residential on the north side of us. We have decided to take out the openings. We did not want to have a
flat brick wall. We have used that same patterning to create textured brick or a different running wall.
Mr. Schwarz – You have a metal parking screen example that looks like it is a wire grid. That would be on the
east side.
Mr. Mohsen – That is correct. It is only on the east side. That side is facing the rail.
Mr. Timmerman – You had some decorative brick shown on some of your renderings. It was unclear how it
was. It looked interesting on the renderings. I had no idea what it was and how it was detailed.
Mr. Mohsen – This is what we are doing. This one here is shown as a Flemish bond right now. What we are
doing is just with every other course, we are pushing it out half an inch. It creates that texture that you are
seeing in the screen. It is not a lot of depth. It is enough for when the sun hits it. It creates that shadow effect. It
elevates it a little bit beyond the typical flat running bonds. Part of that is we don’t have glazing on this side.
This is the Memorial Walk. We wanted to celebrate it. We are forced into having to put some of the utilities
there. It is the only way we can get vehicular access to them. This was a way to elevate the design along that
west base of the building.
Mr. Zehmer – You also have some rustication.
Mr. Mohsen – This is looking south. On the right side, there is the west façade. The Memorial Walk is on the
right side of this image.
Ms. Trompetter – You have a trellis in your plan. I don’t see it there.
Ms. Sanders – We are standing in front of it. There was a specific request at the last meeting to focus on
enhancements to the elevation. This image is just meant to focus on the enhancements to that elevation but you
are also standing in front of it.
27
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Mohsen – Even the patterning on the ground is not matching. I would reference this just for the purpose
of some of the detailing on the façade.
Mr. Zehmer – For the vertical brick striping on the upper floors, is that the same approach?
Mr. Mohsen – It is the same approach. It is a little more subtle. In a couple of areas along the perimeter, this is
one where the unit layouts come together. We are going to have bathrooms along the edge. We don’t have the
ability to put windows. This would be part of the typical running bond that we are doing. We will take a zone
in there. We will start to inset at a half-inch inset portion of it to create a little bit of texture along the façade.
Mr. Zehmer – You have some along West Main as well at least in one spot?
Mr. Mohsen – Currently on West Main, it is one spot. It is like these residential wings that project out, just the
design of the units at the end of that wing tend to put bathrooms against a center demising wall. Instead of it
being a flat wall, we are just coming in. We would not change the brick bond or anything. We would come in
inset in and out to create a little bit of shadow and some detail.
Mr. Timmerman – It looked like you had Flemish Bond in the other picture. What is creating the vertical
there? What is creating the horizontal?
Mr. Mohsen – I think this is just the pattern in the rendering. We have the corbel up top. This graphic here
shows you a lot better what we are proposing. That wraps the corner on the north end as well. It is the Flemish
Bond with the full bricks being pushed out. This right here is the silhouette or the profile of what the wall is
doing. You can see the in-and-out every course. By the time we get to the top here, we are doing half inch
corbeling. It is just a brick supporting itself. Horizontally, we have these projecting pilasters that come out 12
inches. This graphic here was to really assign a dimension to it. It is not just in the rendering. It shows what we
are proposing.
Ms. Tabony – What is the fencing on the roof?
Ms. Sanders – It is a glass rail.
Ms. Tabony – How tall is it?
Mr. Mohsen – It is 48 inches tall. Where we have the terraces up high, the brick comes up a couple of feet.
Behind that, the glazing extends. The height of the glazing is going to be 48 inches. You are not going to see
the full 48 inches. The masonry comes up some and you have glazing on top of that. We do have a detail that is
not super clear. On this diagram here, you can see that this is a terrace where the brick comes up. We have the
coping. That comes up 24 inches. The glass rail comes up 4 feet from finish. It extends up to 24 to 30 inches
above the brick.
It is not shown in this sketch. We talked about these brick masses. They celebrate the top of it some, not
necessarily a large crown. We started to think through that. You are seeing the soldier course and how the
coping is going to lap over the masonry. This might also be a great place where we can get a half inch
depression to give the top band of the masonry a little bit more of a profile. We talked about how with the
corbelling and some of the brick course that we are doing down at the base, it is giving it a lot of texture and
detail. This would be a more subtle approach to it up at the top where instead of just having the running ball all
the way up, we are doing a soldier course band at the top and letting the coping run down on itself.
28
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Ms. Tabony – With some of the soffit materials, some of the renderings you are showing wood. With your
details, I am only seeing fiber cement. What is your intention there for the public overhangs at the ground
story?
Mr. Mohsen – For the public overhangs at the front where we have this main entry along West Main? It is
going to be wood or the wood look and texture. It is not going to be a wood product. We use metal that has that
wood texture. It is durable and it lasts a long time. Beyond these main prominent entries where we have the
building overhanging on the east and the west, that would be sedentious product.
Mr. Zehmer – Are you having plantings on top of the corbelling?
Ms. Sanders – If it was up to my design team, internally, yes. That is something that would be desired
internally. Whether that depth can support it, it is questionable.
Mr. Mohsen – In that detail where we have shown the planters, this is one of the areas where we have a little
bit of a recess. We have a zone there behind the parapet where there could be planters that sit there. The plants
would spill over. The details have not been worked out. It is intentionally done in that location because we do
have the depth to be able to do it. It would be a potted type of setup.
Ms. Sanders – It was intentionally added by our leadership.
Mr. Timmerman – It does not look like you can get to it though.
Mr. Zehmer – How do you water it and maintain it?
Ms. Sanders – You might have to do irrigation there.
Mr. Mohsen – It is not high from a maintenance standpoint. I think you would get to it with a ladder when you
need to get to it. You would probably have irrigation.
Mr. Schwarz – For what it is worth, you do show some green roofs on your precedent images for the other
building projects.
Mr. Timmerman – I was thinking back to your wall sections. They look thin to me. I did not see any
continuous insulation on the outside. I am curious about the energy code and how that is working out.
Mr. Mohsen – We have not yet gotten there. We plan to run an energy model. If we go prescriptive, chances
are that we will have to provide rigid insulation. For this climate, even with the energy model, we might have
to. A lot of times in a lot of climates, when we run the energy model based on the performance of the windows
and the R values of the walls and the roof. Sometimes we can get out of needing to provide the continuous
insulation. We must prove it through an energy model before we can commit to that. We have not gone
through that exercise. It is an exercise that we plan to go through. If we need the energy model to comply with
the energy code requirements, it will be included in there. With all these profiles, the easy trim reveals come in
different depths. I think there is a brochure that comes with it. It shows all the dimensions. They come in all
dimensions. If we must do rigid insulation with the different profiles, it works with up to 3 inches with the
rigid insulation behind the fiber cement if we must do it.
Mr. Timmerman – If you must use that, it is fiber cement?
29
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Mohsen – Yes. It is Z Channels attached directly to the sheathing that are as deep as the rigid insulation
needs to be. The fiber cement is installed directly into that C Channel.
Mr. Timmerman – Why not use a material that returns easily and does not need a complicated clip system?
That is a little bit of a leading question. It is still a question that follows this train of thought.
Mr. Mohsen – The options that come to mind if it is not cementitious type board, it will be stucco type
system. If we find out that we need rigid insulation behind the stucco, it would be like an eave system. You can
still do a hardcode stucco on rigid insulation. I believe that we can do eaves. It is not allowed. I could be wrong
about that. If you don’t need insulation or you don’t need 2 inches of insulation, maybe that becomes an
overkill. From a maintenance and durability standpoint, LV Collective would prefer a product like this cement
board or in other markets, stucco as an alternative for this type of construction. When you get into other kinds
of construction, there are great eave systems that are durable. They have come a long way compared to some
of the old eaves installs that have caused a lot of issues over the years. For this type of construction, 90 percent
of it tends to be either fiber cement panel or stucco.
Mr. Zehmer – If you were to switch materials based on your energy model, that would have to come back to
us?
Mr. Mohsen – We would not switch materials. We would just be putting insulation behind the fiber cement.
That would just be to comply with energy requirements. It would thicken the assembly some instead of it being
towards the interior. Even if we cannot get out of it all together, I cannot imagine we would need more than an
inch, 1.5 inches maximum. If the stud holds firm where it is, if that means the fiber cement panel comes out, it
might reduce the change of plane between the masonry and the fiber cement from 4.5 inches to 3.5 inches. It
would not be anything that is noticeable.
Ms. Sanders – It would go to the inside. No change in the dimension.
The BAR meeting went into a 10-minute recess at 8:10 PM.
The BAR meeting returned from the 10-minute recess at 8:24 PM.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
Brandon Collins – I have the honor and privilege of working with our Westhaven resident planners. They are
coming up on 4 years of planning for their newly redeveloped community. There is a lot to say. Based on the
discussion, I will try to stick to design. Overall, our request is that you defer this. I know it is not necessarily
your concern that an agreement has not been fully reached between the community and LV Collective. That
agreement will determine the parameters for which resident planners can chime in on the design. It is not just
the so-called Memory Walk, which is a connection to West Main Street. We want to incorporate the Memory
Walk into that. Some of that will have an impact visually on the broader community. There are other aspects
about the building, particularly the facades on all 4 sides that our residents are going to want to have some say
on what that looks like, especially with the north side with the materials, colors, and the plantings. We had a
recent discussion with the residents about plantings back there. We have had past conversations about historic
plantings. Those are all things that need to be worked out. I don’t think the BAR should move forward with
approval without having answers to some of those questions, especially with the west side façade. When we
are talking about potentially having banners hanging down, that façade will interact with our connection to
West Main Street and the Memory Walk. With the feel and color of that, how can we create an openness there?
How do we deal with the turning into the parking area there? Those are all things that are visible from the
public from West Main. What if the residents decide that we want a whole lot of red brick to commemorate
30
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Westhaven? We might want to have that as some kind of incorporated memory. That is something that is
within the BAR’s purview to consider. There are a lot more reasons to defer. The whole thing is an eyesore.
We need an agreement and some parameters. We are this close. Our residents have tried to discuss certain
aspects and just cannot until they know what they are working with once there is an agreement with LV
Collective. We are close. The design changes that will happen as a result will impact this project a lot. You are
not ready to see those.
Emily Dreyfus – I want to roll back my communication about conversations with the community. I talked
with Ms. Sanders during the recess. Apparently, she tried hard to get to a resident planners meeting. She was
put off to some future point, which we will look forward to having happen. I also encouraged her to talk with
residents by being in the neighborhood and talking to PHAR and trying to get more dialogue going. The
connecting walkway is critically important. If you could please delay approving this for both the reasons of the
connecting walkway and the landscaping, it will help to keep you involved and have the residents’ quality of
life to have this body as a checkpoint. If you cannot do that, if you don’t feel like that is possible for you, I
think omitting the landscaping and the walkway to come back at a future point. I hope that you don’t
completely drop your role with the walkway. The solar study is the other thing that concerns me. Some of you
expressed concerns about that and getting more pictures. Assuming that Westhaven Redevelopment, like most
LI HTC processes, takes longer than a private development. There will be an impact on current residents for a
year to 18 months. Knowing more about what shadows are going to be cast for them and future residents
would be helpful.
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Rosenthal – I would hope that they could provide perspective from Westhaven to give staff to help with
the plantings and other aspects. That is something I would like to see from LV Collective in going to staff. I
don’t think it needs to come back to us. It would be a useful thing.
Mr. Schwarz – I hear the public in wanting us to defer. I also feel like if we approve, deny, or just vote on it
tonight with on what we have before us, the Westhaven residents do not have to rush and get something
figured out the next week to then come back to us. Something basic could be voted on. If it is approved, that
would mean that the applicant could work with the residents, take their time, come up with a good plan, and it
then comes back to us. The BAR gets to look at it again. I would hope that we would not put too heavy a hand
on whatever the residents come up with. It would still give us a chance to be involved again. We spent over an
hour asking questions. I am feeling more comfortable with what we have in front of us as being a complete
application. I would be in favor of having a vote tonight. Some conditions that I would put on there would
include:
• Hopefully, with the soon to be Memory Walk area, I think we approve the sidewalk, the driveway, and
the pedestrian lighting that shows up on the plan. With the bollards and the catenary lights, we assume
that it is not there. When it is added later, it comes back to us.
• With the trellis, we don’t have any information on it. We assume it is not there. When it is finally
designed, it comes back to us and we see it.
• I want to push for some shade trees in the back. I don’t know what site plan implications you have. I
emailed you all the transition screens.
Mr. Zehmer – There was a note passed to me that I was waiting until our comments period. In the
Development Code, Chapter 34, there are transition screens. In this case, it would not be required by code.
However, we can use this as what our intent might be. It was shown on the screen earlier this evening. The
potentially transition screen high-two is the tallest and deepest of a transition planting plan, which provides for
tall trees and larger shrubs with a 20-foot depth minimum.
31
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Schwarz – I would be Ok with a moderate two. What that gives you is two large trees per 50 feet, one
large tree every 25 feet, an evergreen tree every 25 feet, and 5 shrubs. I think spaced out matches a little bit
what the site plan was showing. That is my thought.
Mr. Zehmer – We will pass those around so that if people have not had a chance to pull up their email, they
can see them. This is a good mechanism for us to give guidance on that landscape area and address the
concerns we have heard from the community tonight about screening.
Mr. Werner – I want to make a clarification. When I was referring to the landscaping plan and omitting that if
necessary. I am not talking about a community designed Memory Walk. I am talking about the trees at that
back or the tree or plant selections. It is up to LV Collective if they want to engage and talk about what kind of
plants to put at the back. If we can’t decide the spacing of the trees or what type of trees or what screening
variation. When I say landscaping plan, I am not talking about hardscape.
Mr. Zehmer – We have a condition in there. They need to be native species and selected from the city’s
approved list.
Mr. Schwarz – There are some parts of it I would like to get ‘baked’ into the approval just in case. If it is
built, we need to have something there.
Mr. Werner – I want to make sure that happens.
Mr. Bailey – Wouldn’t we be able to just require them to come back with a landscaping plan to be required as
part of the condition as opposed to specifying any screening or anything like that?
Mr. Schwarz – My preference is not to. We can do that if others want to.
Ms. Trompetter – My preference would be for it to come back fully. Landscape is much more than just
plants. There is visual connection, spatial character, and circulation. Defining the number of plants within a
certain area feels very limiting.
Ms. Lewis – I don’t think we got enough information about the Memory Walk, about the bollards, about the
easement that goes around to the cell tower. I know it sounds extreme because we have been working on this.
There is a lot of support for this application. I would propose that we approve everything except for the
Memory Walk, a landscape plan, a hardscape plan, and even details in the plaza. You were basically calling
out verbally that were different than what was submitted. I am not criticizing. It is all connected in some way.
With The Memory Walk apron at the street front at West Main, the materials will continue and be the same as
used in the Memory Walk itself. Maybe the pedestrian walk will be contrasting. The easement will also need to
be connected. The landscaping in the back and even around the east side. I see it as one continuum of things
where I don’t know how we can approve one of those elements tonight. It would be a separate CoA later. That
would give the applicant options if the planning of the Memory Walk did not go forward quickly. It needs to
take more time for both parties. You could come back and give us some landscape and hardscape. That could
be a separate CoA. It is hard for us to approve something and say that we are approving a blank slate, or we are
approving the bare minimum or what the zoning code currently may require. That is not the best job that we
can do. We have some expertise on this board that I think, with more discussion and more time, could refine
those elements.
Mr. Werner – The development plan does include a landscape plan. I cannot sign off on the development plan
if there is not a CoA for the landscape plan. If it was an absolute impasse, that is a means to an end.
32
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Ms. Lewis – We don’t choose the development plan. We approve a Certificate of Appropriateness.
Mr. Werner – I cannot approve the development plan until there is an approved CoA.
Ms. Lewis – There are a lot of conditions on that development plan.
Mr. Werner – All those conditions must be met. I am trying to help with your discussion.
Ms. Sanders – We agree with everything that is being said.
Ms. Lewis – I would like to know why Mr. Werner personally objects to this why we couldn’t have a separate
CoA for the elements that I have named. We have done it before.
Mr. Werner – I am not objecting to anything. If you approve the CoA for the building, that is fine. They know
that they can move forward with that. That does not allow me to sign off on the development plan, which is a
piece of this. I want to be clear about that.
Mr. Schwarz – The development plan does not have to be finalized until they go for a building permit?
Mr. Werner – A site plan must be finalized. With a development plan, the way the ordinance is written, it is to
create a zoning compatibility document. It essentially is a document that says this thing meets the development
code.
Mr. Schwarz – If we take all the landscaping out of this, all the site planning, all the hardscapes out of this
application and it becomes a separate CoA, are we damaging the process? Is it still going to be something?
Mr. Werner – You are not damaging my process. It is simply that I could not sign off on the development
plan. My signature is necessary to say that this development plan is consistent with the CoA.
Mr. Timmerman – Sequentially, it is not going to disrupt the timing of the development of their project.
Ms. Sanders – We are switching from the development plan to the site plan anyway. There is no development
plan. We will be going for the site plan. We do not need that until the building permit. It allows us enough
time. This is a great in-between solution to allow for that community development and to hold LV Collective
accountable to get it on the plans before the building permit.
Mr. Zehmer – With that in mind, it sounds like if we want to move ahead with kind of motion or vote, we
would essentially be excluding the site plan.
Mr. Birle – It would include the Memory Walk at that point?
Mr. Werner – The Memory Walk does not exist.
Mr. Birle – Do we never look at the Memory Walk?
Mr. Zehmer – We don’t look at the Memory Walk tonight. We will have to approve a site plan.
Mr. Schwarz – We will look at it when they come back.
Mr. Zehmer – We will have to approve a site plan.
33
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Birle – That is a doable compromise.
Mr. Werner – You used to say that you are approving the height but not the design. These are separate things.
There is a reasonable approach here.
Mr. Zehmer – We had a lot of questions that we asked. We did not necessarily say what we felt about those
things. For example, the brick in terms of our palette. Some of you were looking at those. I like the yellowish
tone brick.
Mr. Birle – I have no issues with the palette in general. I am Ok with there being some flexibility as long as it
is within that range.
Ms. Lewis – I did not care for the butter and yellow. I just don’t know where else we see that color in the city
of Charlottesville. It reminds me of an old federal institutional building. It looks DC to me.
Mr. Zehmer – I am not hearing objections to the palette. Stylistically, I like where you are going with the
building. I like the articulation of some of the brick work, especially the vertical in the field where you have
restrooms or bathrooms. That is helpful to help give the façade some texture. There are some hints of art deco
detailing happening, which I would encourage. In some of the storefront openings, you had a curved edging at
those openings. I thought that was handsome. I appreciate you adding and sprinkling in some of those levels of
details like we talked about last time with corbel brick. You picked up on my request a little bit for the cornice
up higher by switching to the soldier course. If you could step it out a little bit to give some shadow line, that
would be great.
Mr. Schwarz – I appreciate the fact that people are going to see the building up close as brick. I hate fiber
cement. The hardy plank stuff, even when it is prefinished, we have other buildings around town where it is
not. It gets ‘wonky’ over time. Your reveal system will help. I don’t know if it collects dirt and the dirt then
mildews or if the material mildews. With The Lark on 10
th Street, that siding has mildew all over it. It is less
than 10 years old. I am going to back down on that. I appreciate that you are wrapping most of the building
with brick, at least for the lower levels.
Mr. Birle – There are two elements to that you have working in your favor. If you use the smooth, that holds
up a lot better as far as picking up. I have seen that too picking up dust and mildew. The channel system that
you are using is a good one. That is where you usually see these things looking cheesy, when the extrusions are
not big enough.
Mr. Timmerman – It goes back to your point in the previous project. There are different qualities in all these
products. The Hardy is a residential product. There are better cement panels that you can choose from. I
certainly prefer them. I want to applaud you for being open to the process. You have listened and you have
come back and tried to respond to the feedback.
I was sorry to hear that there was not more communication between you and the community. When we left the
last time, I felt that since both sides were here and heard each other. I felt like it was the start of that. I was
looking forward to hearing what would come of that. I was a little disappointed when I heard that nothing had
come of it. When we took our break, there was a re-engagement of communication, which was fantastic. It
sounds like there is a path forward to that. In a way, that led to this willingness and what seems right from all
of us to separate the landscape to give that more of a chance to develop so we don’t have to make decisions
about the landscape or recommend a standard and not sensitive solution. That is not what we want to do here.
34
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
We want this to be as rich as it can be. That is only going to come from communicating with one another. That
is not our purview.
We are just looking at the building now. I agree with Mr. Schwarz. I don’t like the fiber cement, especially on
what should be class A building. This is our Main Street. It is a piece of civic architecture. Everybody is going
to see it all the time. It is a big building. For me, the vinyl window is also an issue. I grudgingly approved the
previous one. That was a 2-story 1950s building. They needed new windows. In this case, I wish there was a
sense of appreciation of quality that would be instilled in these kinds of projects and public facing projects.
The priority for me is that you did listen. You did provide a good amount of good material, true brick. You
have come up with some interesting detailing that adds to the richness of this experience. I appreciate that.
This is a process that we want to work. We want it to work for the betterment of the community.
If we do vote on it, as a condition that I would like to apply, would be the sun studies. Make sure that those are
included in the follow-up report. That is an important issue that we should delved into a little bit more. There
was some more information that probably could have been looked at in that regard.
Ms. Tabony – I agree that deferring the landscape plan is the right move. I don’t feel comfortable with the
level of detail for any of the landscape, particularly the front of the building on Main Street. When you come
back with those details, it would be helpful to see detailed sections through the stairways, the seats, and the
plantings there. The amount of talking that happened and not just reviewing drawings about that was a tip off
for me that was just not enough information. It is the same with the elements that you are proposing in the
back, the trellis, the specific trees, or at least a detailed description of the kind of massing of trees that you are
planning on planting there.
With the sun studies you have provided, community members have spoken about that already. It is hard to read
those, especially because of the slope behind the building. You are just showing that in plan. What would
really be helpful is to show façade studies of the massing of the proposed Westhaven buildings. I am not sure
how solidified that is. Assuming there are several stories that they plan to have there, it would be nice to see
how the shadows from the LV Collective building will pass across those facades.
Ms. Sanders – I have an important comment on the sun studies. If we get to a vote and we are separating the
site plan from it how will the sun studies be impacted?
Ms. Tabony – It will help them with whatever planning they are doing. That would be part of the process of
engagement.
Mr. Zehmer – It potentially could impact planting selection.
Ms. Sanders – If it is going to be a formal condition, I would want to make that clear. That could mean a lot of
things.
Ms. Tabony – I am not suggesting that you change the massing of the building, just landscaping and planting.
Mr. Werner – As I wrote it, a shade study is to be provided. You can all decide whether to show at 9 AM,
noon, 3 PM, and 6 PM. To assist with plant selection on site and provide information for the Westhaven
landscaping plan.
Mr. Schwarz – You can leave off March or September.
Ms. Tabony – I guess you have already done the Phase I archaeological study. Has that been provided to staff?
35
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Ms. Sanders – I am not sure. It may have been before my time. We do intend to provide it as a part of the site
plan.
Ms. Tabony – I am in support of the architecture of the building. I agree with my colleagues with the
comments about materials, vinyl windows, and fiber cement. This is an important building. It is on the corner
of a major thoroughfare. We see all the sides of the building. It is an important moment in our city. It should
respond to that position appropriately with materials.
With the sections that you have provided, the one with the red line of section cut showing the hill is helpful. I
would like to see more detailed sections through the pedestrian walkway on the west side of the building and
where the property line is, where the roadway lands in that sloped section back there. It is hard to understand
that right now.
Ms. Trompetter – I am excited that we have all come to this conclusion about the site plan. I appreciate that
you are on board with that. I appreciate your intent. We cannot vote on the intent. I am pleased that it has come
down to this. I was noting this robust conversation about architecture, brick, and windows. I was sad sitting
here wishing I could talk about the planting or the sidewalk. I am excited that you will be looking into and be
able to provide more details on that. I just want to emphasize that more study and collaboration occur between
the two spaces. There is a wedge of planting. That is an opportunity to look at accessibility. There is a
switchback walk at Westhaven. It would be cool if that walk could continue to create up into the space. I am
worried that there is going to be this effort on Westhaven’s part to make it accessible and it is going to come
into the site and not be accessible. I want to see some effort to collaborate. It is great that Water Street Studios
is on both and that you can do that. I really encourage that collaboration at that interface between those spaces
and that transition space. In the spirit of collaboration, there should be some connectivity between things like
lighting, furnishings, plantings, paving for both spaces so it feels more connected with Water Street. Doing
both, you have a great opportunity and efficiency to be able to do that.
I think there is a bus stop on West Main Street in front of the building. It will be great when you are looking at
the landscape in front to think about accommodation for people waiting. People will be coming up and
considerations for that. I am excited there is going to be Phase I work done. I am curious to see if there are any
findings in the Phase I sections and perspectives. I would like to see, when you come back, a section through
that west side on a more detailed scale. I cannot see what the conditions will be between the sidewalk, the
street, and the wall. I would like to see more sections. I am concerned about the grass pavers on that west side.
That is going to be mostly in the shade. Grass pavers often do not work. With it in the shade, it will make it
even less likely. I want to encourage you to revisit that. The planting is a suggested plant palette. I am not
going to comment on the plant palette because it is not the plant palette. Water Street Studios is going to be a
great asset to you when it comes to planting. I hope there is a significant budget for the landscape. I worry
when I see site plans like this in my own work that it means all the money is going to the building and none of
it is going to the landscape. I hope that a good budget is being set aside for the landscape for the Memory
Walk. There needs to be larger trees on the back. There needs to be screening. Viewshed studies are important.
The model views were done from far back. I would like to see a view of the back of the building. You could
combine a viewshed study and a solar study together to look at how the shade conditions will be. I am not
commenting on the building itself. I think those shade studies are important. The intention is to have a clear
view to West Main. I want to see what that looks like. This section on West Main is more open. It has more
open space than other sections of West Main. I know the intention is to build up more building, more residents
there. I want to emphasize the importance of open space, that Memory Walk, and that opening can be beautiful
and celebrated and bring Westhaven people out to the street. It can encourage the public to go back into that
space and be a place where the community can engage. I want to emphasize that open space is important.
36
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Zehmer – Thinking about the site plan, at that northwest corner, you mentioned the need for vehicular
access to the cell tower and potentially emergency vehicles. I am just making sure you have the turning radius
for a firetruck. That may impact on the site plan. There are a couple of suggested conditions from staff talking
about ground level mechanical equipment and making sure those are screened per the design guidelines. That
is part of the site plan. I don’t think we will put those in this. It is just a reminder in making sure those things
are properly screened. Can meters, panel boxes, and cable connectors be put in the garage as much as possible?
We would like to see those things in the garage. If not, it needs to be screened per the design guidelines. Any
signage would have to go through the approval process for a sign permit. That is not through us. The glass at
the street level storefronts, doors, transoms, and windows must be clear with a VLT of not less than 70 percent.
We would probably work that into our motion.
Ms. Lewis – With the second bullet on page 3, they have addressed that with the solid brick wall outside the
garage on the Westhaven side. There is also a suggestion that anything be dimmable if it is shining towards
that area.
Ms. Sanders – We are happy to do that. It was more so the second part of the statement that was a little
troubling. I would ask if we could work through any resolution with staff if there are any concerns expressed
but also with the brick. I don’t know how that works. The dimmable is easy.
Ms. Lewis – I meant to talk about any exterior lights on that back portion; public complaints that are outside of
purview.
Mr. Zehmer – With site lighting, does that include exterior building lights?
Mr. Werner – I would suggest that all the conditions that I have suggested that they become associated with
this project. Mention them now. With the lighting, it is a unique set of conditions that we have applied on
entrance corridors and on BAR large scale projects. The ground level equipment, utility meter boxes, and
screening are boilerplate stuff. It puts in there on record. With the lighting, I don’t mind if you all want to
reword this. It is from what we used for The Verve, 2005 JPA. Our code now requires lighting with the color
temperature that we have had no issues with glare. It solves some of that. It is the applicant and developer
acknowledging that if you built your garage and light is blasting out of it and people are having an issue with
it, they are acknowledging that they will work with us. Maybe it is a goodwill statement. The fact that those
garage openings on the east are going to be closed. It is one thing if you have vehicle lights coming in and out.
Mr. Zehmer – They are closed everywhere but the east.
Mr. Werner – There is the interior lighting on those. Our code does not regulate interior lighting.
Mr. Zehmer – Part of my question was more related to the light fixtures themselves. I know that site lighting
will be part of the site plan. Are exterior building mounted lights part of the site plan?
Mr. Werner – They are if they are like the light packs. There are required light packs. Most of what we have
seen are canned lights. Nothing is shown here.
Ms. Tabony – They had some in the renderings were decorative.
Mr. Werner – There is the light fixture and the lamping. This condition here addresses the lamping. With the
light fixtures, we don’t go to the guidelines
Ms. Tabony – Can that be a staff level review item?
37
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
Mr. Werner – I just look at the lamping. If they come in with ornate chandeliers dangling from these
openings, I am going to have a question about that. It has not been an issue. It is something we will see. It will
be on the building permit.
Mr. Birle – There is something in the ordinance about Night Sky.
Mr. Werner – That is about the lamping. If they do something ornamental on those canopies on the front and
it is egregious, I might ask you guys about this.
Ms. Trompetter – It seems like site lighting and furnishings are not part of this.
Mr. Werner – My suggestion is that we omit the planting pallet, the paving pallet, and the site furniture. I
want to be specific. I am referring to the sample plant pallet, the paving pallet, external lighting, and site
furnishings as indicated on sheets 8, 9, 10, 11 and 12.
Ms. Tabony – We should include something about the stairs. It is not just the palette of the paving like
meaning color selection but the design of the stairs.
Mr. Werner – How much detail do you want to get into and referring to the guidelines?
Ms. Sanders – I am Ok with everything outside the building footprint.
Mr. Werner – If I keep it in a small box, someone will not yell at me for excluding a lot of stuff.
Ms. Lewis – It is our action and our choice. Mr. Werner and Ms. Richardson should not be blamed for
something that we did that was not in the guardrails. If we make an error tonight, it is on us.
Mr. Werner – Recess wall lighting, pedestrian pole lights. That is the only site lighting I see.
Mr. Timmerman – That is the applicant’s suggestion. I would not mind the pedestrian level building lighting
to be included. I can think of some examples close to this project.
Mr. Zehmer – We typically see a cut sheet of a proposed exterior light fixture. We did not see one tonight. It
would be great to see that. If it is easy to include it in the site plan package, great. Let’s weave into that.
Mr. Rosenthal – I would like to commend staff. It was a lot of work that you had to do. I would like to
commend LV Collective. You did listen and brought back reasonable stuff for us to deal with. You are being
flexible with our suggestions here. I go back to Ms. Lewis’ idea of separating out those items that we approve
of the building and leave out these other things. The ideas that Mr. Werner has articulated need to be put in our
CoA that we do. I want to commend the members of the BAR for their thoughtful comments and helping to
move this forward in a positive way.
Mr. Zehmer – I want to compliment and thank the public, especially the Westhaven community for coming
out at both pre-application conferences and tonight. It has been a tough one. We are starting to get to a good
place. I appreciate LV Collective. Between the first meeting and second and reducing the height of the building
from 11 stories to 9 stories on the front and down to 6 stories on the rear. That was helpful. There might be
some members of the public who wish it was lower. That is a compromise.
Motion – Mr. Zehmer – Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including
City’s ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find that the proposed development at 835, 843, and
38
BAR Meeting Minutes June 16, 2026
847 West Main Street satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other
properties in this ADC District, and that the BAR approves the application with the following conditions
and omissions:
• Ground level mechanical equipment, utility meter boxes/panels, transformers, etc., will be
appropriately screened per the design guidelines (Chapter 2, Section H). Screening will be
indicated on the Final Site Plan and approved by BAR staff.
• Meters and panel boxes for utility, communications, and cable connections will be located
preferably within the garage; if not, then in non-prominent locations on the side elevations only
and appropriately screened. Screening will be indicated on the Final Site Plan and approved by
BAR staff.
• Glass at street level storefronts (doors, windows, and transoms) must be clear, with a VLT of not
less than 70%.
• Prior to a Permit allowing disturbance associated with the proposed development, a Phase I
Archaeological Investigation of the three (3)-parcel site will be completed and provided to Staff
for BAR’s archive and recorded with the Virginia Department of Historic Resources.
• The following design elements are to be considered as removed from the applicant’s submittal
and are omitted from this CoA:
o site plan;
o sample plant pallet;
o sample paving pallet;
o site furnishings; and
o site lighting.
o The aforementioned site details [as indicated] on sheets 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, and 12 of the submittal.
• The omitted site elements (above) will be reviewed at a later date as a separate CoA request.
• Prior to BAR approval of the omitted site elements (and within the separate CoA request), the
applicant will provide a new shade study examining the hours of 9AM, Noon, 3PM, and 6PM.
The intent is to advise plant selection for the site, and to provide information to the public and
Westhaven Citizen Planners to assist the selection of plantings within the Westhaven community.
The hours listed should be added to the dates already submitted within the solar plan [sheet 13 of
the submittal].
• To prevent bright light and glare emanating from the garage openings, lamping for the garage
lighting [immediately inside any opening] will be dimmable, have a Color Temperature not
exceeding 3,000K, and have a Color Rendering Index not less than 80, preferably not less than
90.
Second by Mr. Schwarz. Motion passes 9-0.
4. Staff questions/discussion
• Bylaws revision update: second draft for review & comments.
5. Adjourn
Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 9:32 PM.
1
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
BAR MINUTES
CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE
BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW
Regular Meeting
August 18, 2026 – 5:00 PM
Hybrid Meeting (In person at Council Chambers & virtual via
Zoom)
Welcome to this Regular Monthly Meeting of the Charlottesville Board of Architectural
Review. Staff will introduce each item, followed by the applicant’s presentation, which
should not exceed ten minutes. The Chair will then ask for questions from the public,
followed by questions from the BAR. After questions are closed, the Chair will ask for
comments from the public. For each application, members of the public are each allowed
three minutes to ask questions and three minutes to offer comments. Speakers shall
identify themselves and provide their address. Comments should be limited to the BAR’s
purview; that is, regarding only the exterior aspects of a project. Following the BAR’s
discussion and prior to taking action, the applicant will have up to three minutes to
respond.
Members Present: Carl Schwarz, Kate Tabony, Cheri Lewis, Ron Bailey, Jennifer Trompetter, David
Timmerman, Jerry Rosenthal, Roger Birle,
Staff Present: Patrick Cory, Kate Richardson, Jeff Werner, David Dillehunt
Pre-Meeting:
The chairman called the meeting to order at 5:30 PM.
A. Matters from the public not on the agenda.
No Public Comments
B. Consent Agenda (Note: Any consent agenda item may be pulled and moved to the regular
agenda if a BAR member wishes to discuss it, or if any member of the public is present to
comment on it. Pulled applications will be discussed at the beginning of the meeting.)
1. Meeting Minutes – April 21, 2026 & May 19, 2026
Mr. Schwarz asked to pull BAR #24-0042 from the Consent Agenda.
Motion to Approve remainder of Consent Agenda – Ms. Lewis – Second by Mr. Bailey – Motion passes
9-0.
C. Deferred Items
1. Certificate of Appropriateness [*Deferred by applicant January 22, 2025] BAR #24-0042
116 West Jefferson Street, Tax Parcel 330183000
Downtown ADC District
Owner: West Jefferson Properties, LLC
Applicant: Joshua Batman
Project: Rear porches & exit stairs
2
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
Jeff Werner, Staff Report – Request CoA for approval of rear porches and modified trim details due to
alterations necessary to accommodate code-required egress stairs. The applicant’s submittal reflects the
entirety of the planned rehabilitations and alterations to the original house and the contemporary structure
behind it. The BAR has previously approved CoA’s for that work. This review is singularly limited to the
modifications to the balconies at the rear (south) elevation of the 1913 house.
QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Questions from the Public
QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Schwarz – It might help to look at sheet eight, which is page 57 of the agenda packet. That corner post
that sticks out ‘funny’ on the roof. It will stick out ‘funny’ on the west and south side symmetrically around the
corner. When it meets the floor below, does it start aligning again how the drawing shows?
Mr. Batman – Yes. It is the width of the stairs.
Mr. Schwarz – The trim and everything on the new construction is going to look normal.
Mr. Batman – That is correct.
Mr. Zehmer – On the column on the detail on sheet 14, page 63 on the agenda packet, the beam on top of the
column is not centered on the column
Mr. Batman – Up at the top, that is correct. It is the only way we can get the required egress width for the
stairs.
Mr. Zehmer – Is that an existing beam?
Mr. Batman – That is correct. I don’t want to mess with the cornice work since it is so pretty. We don’t want
to mess with that.
Mr. Schwarz – When it was a smaller column, it used to line up. They had to switch to a 6-by-6 to hold it up
because of the egress component.
Mr. Batman – That is correct. The width of the stairs is that close. It is as close as we could possibly squeeze
it to get it to work.
COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC
No Comments from the Public
COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD
Mr. Schwarz – I personally would be Ok with both options. I think the unfinished wood is atypical for this
location. I just want to see it painted.
Mr. Batman – That is fair.
Mr. Schwarz – If you guys agree or disagree, that was my thought. Option two shows an unfinished cedar. I
want to see that painted if that is something you guys want to go with.
3
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
Mr. Batman – I did not put all the mockups. I agree. It should be painted.
Mr. Zehmer – You indicated that you preferred option two. Is there a particular reason why?
Mr. Batman – We are worried that it might feel like a birdcage underneath that porch. There is a little unit that
you access under there.
Mr. Zehmer – Is it a mechanical unit?
Mr. Batman – No. It is a room. It is like a suite. It has a kitchen and stuff there.
Mr. Zehmer – Out from under the steps is an exterior space just outside of that?
Mr. Batman – It is like a patio.
Mr. Zehmer – This would be a privacy screen.
Ms. Lewis – It is enclosed. There are a lot of conditions downtown where you have porches and space
underneath. I did not realize it was an entrance. I prefer the lattice. I cannot give you a good design guideline
reason. I will be transparent about that.
Mr. Batman – It is more traditional. That is why I have it. We don’t mind it.
Ms. Lewis – If it is a used space, I would believe that someone would enjoy the sunlight too and the openness.
Mr. Zehmer – I agree with Mr. Schwarz if they go with the solid panel. That should be painted. Personally, I
have a little preference for the lattice. Even a diagonal lattice might work. Both are probably within our
guidelines.
Mr. Schwarz – I have a preference. I don’t think that the solid violates our guidelines.
Mr. Bailey – I don’t think it is for us to choose. I also have a preference. The lattice looks better.
Mr. Werner – There is Hedge Street just south of the hospice. They have lattice on the back. In the large
picture there, I would not have an opinion as far as a staff opinion of having lattice above. That is where we
felt the strongest that lattice on the upper panels if privacy enclosure made sense at the bottom. That was where
we were looking at. What was on the building at your place and that place on Hedge Street, those were two
examples we could fall back on.
Ms. Lewis – Since your presented options to us, are you asking us to choose? For staff, do we need to choose?
Could we say either as long as the panels are painted?
Mr. Batman – We would be happy with that. With the solid, in the porch entablature, they look like little
cutouts and solid pieces like a floral thing. I did not have time to put together the mockups for that. I agree. It
does not want to be unstained. It should be painted. You are right. We are honestly happy for either option.
Either option will look good. If you give a little leeway, I would like to try doing something with the cutouts
and get a little bit more in depth on it.
Ms. Lewis – Would staff need to approve that?
4
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
Mr. Werner – I am thinking about First Street North. There is a gate that is rounded out grape vine and leaves.
I am fine with that as long as it is not a dragon or a bright green.
Mr. Batman – I would love your input on it when we get to that point.
Mr. Werner – A serious way to look at it would be some of the railings on the café spaces on The Mall. I
recently worked with people at The Paramount. I encouraged them to be creative. Something of that nature,
that would be great if there was a way to be expressive about it. It would be nice if you asked.
Mr. Batman – I would be happy to run it by you guys.
Ms. Tabony – I want to say how great it is to see these renderings from the evolution since the last time we
looked at this project is phenomenal. Thanks for doing that. In terms of my opinion, I like the solid. It brings
the new building’s materiality a little. It mixes in the center there, which I think is nice. I would like to see the
cutouts.
Mr. Barman – As I was thinking about this, you can see it. Those porches downtown have it. That is where I
was leaning towards. I did not get a chance to put it all in this packet. I am happy to run it by you. Either
option is fine with us at this point.
Mr. Zehmer – It seems like we are Ok with either option. If you choose option two, it should be painted. If
you want to articulate option two, just submit the final to the staff for record. One thing that staff brought up
was the mechanical units along the side yard. Are they on the street side?
Mr. Batman – It is between two houses. We are putting it on the front porch right now. We transplanted all
the bushes in front around and screened the HVAC unit with it. We got it after the drought. They have taken
well. It is already screened quite well with the existing bushes.
Mr. Zehmer – I don’t think we can require a condition of this CoA. On sheet five, you have some screening.
That is basically what you said that you did.
Mr. Batman – They are nice and big, mature bushes.
Motion – Ms. Lewis – Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the
ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed treatment for the rear exit stairs at 116
West Jefferson Street satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other
properties in the District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted with the conditions
that the applicant may opt for option one or option two as presented in the materials with the caveat
that option two would need to have the panels painted. The applicant preserves the option to do
carpentry cutouts on those solid wood panels. As a condition of approval, we will require that the
original rear porch columns be retained on site for a potential reuse and reinstatement as part of the
future restoration of the property. Second by Mr. Schwarz. Motion passes 9-0.
D. New Items
N/A
E. Pre-Application Conferences
2. Pre-Application Conference – Certificate of Appropriateness
Continued discussion from December 2023
5
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
No formal action will be taken
915 East High Street, Tax Parcel 530247000
Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District
Owner: LO-HI, LLC
Applicant: Dan Bracey, Two Street Studio
Project: Construction of multi-story, mixed-use building.
• Staff introduced the project to the BAR. It is currently a vacant parcel and a parking lot.
• There were concerns about the length of the structure as it faces Lexington Avenue and breaking it up.
There was support for the materials.
• This project is being reviewed under the old code. There is nothing in the code that limits the length of
the proposed building.
• There was a question about The Taylor Walk. Taylor Street went all the way through to Locust. City
Council in 1988 voted to vacate that last section of Taylor Street on the west end. Council requested
that there be a continuous pedestrian path through to Locust Avenue.
• There is a path that was established. It goes through the 2-level parking garage at the hospital.
• The planner is not aware of any legal provision for Taylor Walk. The Taylor Sidewalk has been moved
off the property. The new plat has been recorded.
• There has not been much work done on the project since 2023. Most of the work has been focused on
site plan approval.
• There has been the creation of the lot along Lexington Avenue.
• The new zoning would allow the building height to be 12 stories.
• The deck is oversized because it needs to serve the office use and the residential use. The applicant
would like to keep the deck concealed from view.
• The height on Lexington Avenue is proposed to be 1 story.
• Mr. Zehmer did not have a big issue with the overall length of the building.
• The proposed building is not a tall building, and it is following the grade.
• Mr. Zehmer did bring up that with there being a cemetery across the street, there will not be the
possibility of a canyon effect with another building across the street.
• Ms. Tabony did recommend breaking down the volume of the building.
• Mr. Schwarz did recommend seeing this proposed project in 3-D and 3-D views due to not
understanding the elevation.
• Members of the BAR provided feedback and constructive criticism on what the applicant can do to
improve the project for a formal CoA application.
• Ms. Trompetter did ask if the applicant had done extra historic research on the parcel. The cemetery
boundaries have not changed historically.
• Ms. Trompetter did make recommendations for possible trees, bushes, and shrubs.
• Mr. Schwarz did ask the applicant to consider large trees along the sidewalk. The applicant does
believe that the power lines there might be buried underground.
• There was a question of whether this project fell under Entrance Corridor or Conservation District.
According to staff, it fell under Conservation District.
• Ms. Lewis did emphasize the importance of elevations on High Street. The elevations will need to be
shown in 3-D.
• There were confusion and discussion surrounding the tiny building at the corner of the property. The
applicant needs to show that the lot is a buildable lot.
• The tiny 2-story building is included in the site plan and will need to be designed.
• Staff would like to see a formal CoA application the next time this project comes before the BAR.
• Mr. Schwarz provided his comments and feedback surrounding the project. Having residential units
open on East High Street feels inappropriate according to Mr. Schwarz.
6
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
• The zoning along this corridor does provide increased height up to 8 and 10 stories.
The BAR meeting was recessed five minutes before the next Pre-Application Conference.
Mr. Timmerman recused himself for the next Pre-Application Conference due to a conflict of interest.
3. Pre-Application Conference – Certificate of Appropriateness
No formal action will be taken
BAR #26-0034
301 East Hight Street, Tax Parcel 330070000
North Downtown ADC District
Owner: Village School
Applicant: Design Develop
Project: Addition
• Staff introduced this project and the different aspects of this project.
• The Head of The Village School did present a brief history and the purpose of the school to members
of the BAR.
• The Village School has made use of city of Charlottesville and Albemarle County facilities and parks.
• The applicant presented the proposed project and the addition to The Village School to the BAR.
• The proposed addition would be an outdoor sports court and an outdoor classroom.
• The applicant is proposing a new crosswalk across 3
rd Street Northeast to the new sports court and
outdoor classroom.
• The applicant is also proposing some street art on 3rd Street Northeast in addition to the proposed
crosswalk.
• The applicant did have some concern about the height of the fence given the height requirements
according to the code. The applicant would like a taller fence or a creative solution.
• Mr. Zehmer did express the possible concern of a taller fence preventing balls from going out into the
street. Mr. Zehmer also brought up the possibility of a speed bump to slow drivers down near the
proposed crosswalk.
• Staff recommended the fence be an aesthetic fence with a netting feature on top of the fence.
• The applicant would have the same signage that was in front of the building. It would be a hanging
sign in front of the building. The proposed signage would require a sign permit.
• There was agreement about possibly having a couple possible shade trees next to fence.
• There were questions and feedback from members of the BAR regarding the different aspects of the
project.
• Ms. Tabony had some concerns surrounding the astroturf/playing surface for the sports court. There is
precedent for use in front of some of the Greek houses.
• Mr. Schwarz, Ms. Lewis, and Ms. Trompetter did recommend exploring some other play surfaces
given the failure of astroturf at the Greek houses.
• Ms. Lewis did recommend preserving the historical features such as the railings on the front.
• Ms. Lewis also recommended rumble strips or speed bumps to reduce the speed of drivers going up or
down 3
rd Street Northeast.
• There was overall support for this proposed addition project with The Village School.
F. Other Business [Including work sessions, staff questions/discussion, non-action items]
4. BAR Training
• Roles & Responsibilities (per City Code 34-5.1.5)
7
BAR Meeting Minutes August 18, 2026
• At least one hour of BAR training is required by the state each year. This training will be about 30
minutes.
• Staff did go over the history of historic preservation and the role of the BAR. It is through the National
Park Service and administered by the Virginia Department of Historic Resources.
• Staff did go over the different individual roles of every person on the BAR. Staff went over the makeup
of the BAR membership.
• Staff did go over the process for how neighborhoods can become a locally recognized neighborhood.
Several neighborhoods are in the national register but don’t have designation locally.
• There are 8 local ADC Districts and 3 Historic Conservation Districts.
• Staff did remind the members of the BAR what falls under the purview of the BAR for CoA
applications. There are specific review criteria that the BAR must use in reviewing projects.
• Staff emphasized the importance of following the guidelines in reaching a decision on CoA
applications.
• The Guidelines did and should correspond to the Secretary of Interior Guidelines. The Design
Guidelines are approved by the City Council and interpreted by the BAR.
5. Staff Updates
• Minor Historic Reviews
• Staff did go over the responsibilities and other job duties that staff are doing in addition to getting
materials ready for BAR meetings.
• DT Mall café spaces
o Ms. Lewis asked about café spaces that operated without approval and non-compliance.
o There was discussion surrounding the non-compliance with the café spaces.
o There has not been enforcement of the café spaces guidelines passed by the BAR and approved
by the City Council.
G. Adjournment
The meeting was adjourned at 9:38 PM.
123 Chancellor Street – October 20, 2026 (10.16) 1
City of Charlottesville
Board of Architectural Review
Staff Report
October 20, 2026
Certificate of Appropriateness
BAR # HST26-0046
123 Chancellor Street; TMP 090140000
The Corner ADC District
Owner: Lambda Gamma of Chi Omega House
Applicant: Garret Rouzer, DG&P Architects
Project: Window replacements
Background
Year Built: 1908 - 1912 (Not on 1907 Sanborn Maps; on 1913 Maps.)
District: The Corner ADC District
Status: Contributing
Likely built by William E. Peters for use as a boarding house. One of the first dwellings on Chancellor
Street; at one point known as Miss Palmer’s Boarding House; between 1941 and 1969 known as the
Colonial Inn; since 1979, the home to the Lambda Gamma Chapter of Chi Omega sorority. Reflecting
an eclectic blend of Colonial Revival and Second Empire styles, its mansard roof is unique to district.
[Historical survey attached.]
Prior BAR Reviews
[See Appendix.]
Application
• Submittal received September 29, 2026: 123 Chancellor Street, 5 pages.
Request CoA for removal of window sash in 21 openings of the first and lower floors and installation
of Pella Reserve (metal-clad wood) frame inserts with 1/1 sash to match existing. (Lite arrangement at
lower windows—20, 21, 22, and 23—will match existing.) Sills and brick mould will be retained and
repaired where necessary. Note: The existing sidelights at the entry door will remain.
123 Chancellor Street – October 20, 2026 (10.16) 2
Of the 21 openings: 12 windows are believed to be original; four are associated with a later addition;
four (at the lower level) are not original; one (on the porch) is from the BAR-approved replacement of
an entry door. Staff cannot determine if the remaining are original to the house; however, if not
original, they are likely mid-20th century replacements, no later.
Discussion
The applicant has provided photos of one window that represent the typical condition of all the
windows. Staff cannot confirm whether the windows are irreparable.
Per Chapter 4, Section C of the ADC District Design Guidelines for Rehabilitations: Retain original
windows when possible; and Replace entire windows only when they are missing or beyond repair.
Comment: Recently, for similar requests associated with 20
th-century windows, the BAR has
applied a flexible interpretation of the recommendation to retain original windows. (See
summary in Appendix.)
Per Chapter 4, Section C of the ADC District Design Guidelines for Rehabilitations: If a window on
the primary façade of a building must be replaced and an existing window of the same style, material,
and size is identified on a secondary elevation, place the historic window in the window opening on the
primary façade.
Comment: Staff has encouraged the applicant to consider this option, if conditions allow, for
the three windows at the front porch (W08, W09, and W13). Staff suggests the BAR consider
as a condition either a requirement to reuse original sash at the front elevation windows or that
applicant demonstrate this is not a feasible alternative.
Per Chapter 4, Section C of the ADC District Design Guidelines for Rehabilitations: Do not use
inappropriate materials or finishes that radically change the sash, depth of reveal, muntin
configuration, reflective quality or color of the glazing, or appearance of the frame; and If windows
warrant replacement, appropriate material for new windows depends upon the context of the building
within a historic district, and the age and design of the building. Sustainable materials such as wood,
aluminum-clad wood, solid fiberglass, and metal windows are preferred.
Comment: The proposed frame inserts and sash are single-lite, except as noted at the lower
floor, matching the existing lite arrangements. The Pella sash dimensions replicate the thin rails
and stiles of the assumed-original windows. The frame inserts and sash are metal-clad wood,
consistent with the recommendation for replacement windows.
123 Chancellor Street – October 20, 2026 (10.16) 3
Chancellor Street façade, 1983 after porch expansion.
(Door to right of entrance was replaced with a window in 2014.)
Location on Chancellor Street, view West
Staff Recommendation
A rigid application of the guidelines would recommend repair in lieu of replacement; however, the
BAR has in recent years approved window replacements for 20th-century buildings when the new meet
the criteria in the design guidelines, as these do. While repairing and retaining the original would be
preferable, the new sash/frame inserts are visually and architecturally compatible with this building
and this historic district. By the late 1910s, standardized, commercially manufactured windows were
becoming common. Plate glass was produced without visible imperfections. And, while wood sash and
frames were still assembled by hand, the individual components were mass produced allowing
standardized window dimensions. (By the mid-20th century, assembly of complete windows had
become automated.)
123 Chancellor Street – October 20, 2026 (10.16) 4
If the frame inserts and sash are acceptable, the BAR should also determine if the treatment of the
space between the new frames and the existing brick mould and existing sills is acceptable. (See green
arrows below.) Photos below show similar conditions with replacement windows at City Hall and the
Levy Building. This isn’t evident in the photos below, but At the Levy Building the widths at the edge
of the frame insert vary. This is due to the wide in the original masonry opening. The frame inserts are
all the same size, but at a size that is just slightly smaller than the smallest opening. This allows for
consistently sized windows and efficiency in installation, but results in variation in the width of the
necessary blocking and of the new trim--or caulking or flashing–applied to cover it. Staff suggests a
condition requiring this space not exceed ¾” on any given side.
123 Chancellor Street – October 20, 2026 (10.16) 5
Suggested motions
Approval: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including City’s ADC
District Design Guidelines, I move to find that the proposed window replacements at 123 Chancellor
Street satisfy the BAR’s criteria and are compatible with this property and other properties in the
District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted.
Or with the following conditions: […]
Suggested:
• Where existing, the sash weights and pulleys will be left in situ.
• For sash with simulated divided lites, the applied muntins will have a maximum width of 7/8”
and internal spacer bars within the glass aligned with the muntins.
• Width of necessary blocking [reduction in overall height and width of window sash] shall not
exceed ¾” at tops, sides, or sills.
• [Any conditions related to the lite arrangement of the lower floor windows].
• [Any conditions related to using salvaged sash in the front elevation windows.]
Denial: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District
Design Guidelines, I move to find that the proposed window replacements at 123 Chancellor Street do
not satisfy the BAR’s criteria and are not compatible with this property and other properties in the
District, and that for the following reasons the BAR denies the application as submitted…
Criteria, Standards, and Guidelines
Review Criteria Generally
Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a
design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34-5.2.7. Major
Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34-
5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction, reconstruction,
alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a building permit. Where a
building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful unless conducted in accordance
with the required building permit and all applicable building code requirements.”
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2:
123 Chancellor Street – October 20, 2026 (10.16) 6
a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds:
i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable
provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and
ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the
district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application.
b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of
Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section.
c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or
desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character
of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic
Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given
to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive
Plan. Conditions may require a reduction in height or massing, consistent with the City’s design
guidelines and subject to the following limitations: [not germane to this request]
Standards for Review and Decision
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1:
a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or
structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features and
factors:
i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed
addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with the
site and the applicable District;
ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and
placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs;
iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of
Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant;
iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures;
v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as
gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks;
vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an
adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures;
vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the
standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and
viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines.
Pertinent ADC District Design Guidelines
Pertinent Design Review Guidelines for Rehabilitations
Link: Chapter 4 Rehabilitation
C. Windows
1. Prior to any repair or replacement of windows, a survey of existing window conditions is
recommended. Note number of windows, whether each window is original or replaced, the material,
type, hardware and finish, the condition of the frame, sash, sill, putty, and panes.
2. Retain original windows when possible.
[…]
5. Repair original windows by patching, splicing, consolidating or otherwise reinforcing. Wood that
appears to be in bad condition because of peeling paint or separated joints often can be repaired.
6. Replace historic components of a window that are beyond repair with matching components.
123 Chancellor Street – October 20, 2026 (10.16) 7
7. Replace entire windows only when they are missing or beyond repair.
8. If a window on the primary façade of a building must be replaced and an existing window of the
same style, material, and size is identified on a secondary elevation, place the historic window in the
window opening on the primary façade.
[…]
10. Avoid changing the number, location, size, or glazing pattern of windows by cutting new openings,
blocking in windows, or installing replacement sash that does not fit the window opening.
11. Do not use inappropriate materials or finishes that radically change the sash, depth of reveal,
muntin configuration, reflective quality or color of the glazing, or appearance of the frame.
12. Use replacement windows with true divided lights or interior and exterior fixed muntins with
internal spacers to replace historic or original examples.
13. If windows warrant replacement, appropriate material for new windows depends upon the context
of the building within a historic district, and the age and design of the building. Sustainable
materials such as wood, aluminum-clad wood, solid fiberglass, and metal windows are preferred.
Vinyl windows are discouraged.
14. False muntins and internal removable grilles do not present an historic appearance and should not
be used.
15. Do not use tinted or mirrored glass on major facades of the building. Translucent or low (e) glass
may be strategies to keep heat gain down.
[…]
123 Chancellor Street – October 20, 2026 (10.16) 8
APPENDIX
Prior BAR Reviews
• August 2014 - CoA for demolition of garage and rear stairs.
• September 2014 - CoA for second story rear addition, new rear and side porches, and
replacement of secondary front entrance/transom with window.
• March 2015 - CoA for synthetic slate roof.
• February 2016 - Denied application to replace the second-floor exterior door/transom with
double hung window.
Recent BAR actions re: replacement windows
5 Gildersleeve Wood, June 2021
Replace 1980 windows in 1921 dwelling.
Sash/frame inserts. Pella Reserve to replicate original.
CoA approved 7-0.
5 Gildersleeve Wood
Courts Office Building, September 2023
Replace wood windows in 1938 office building.
Sash/frame inserts. Marvin.
CoA approved 5-0.
410 East High St
712 Ridge Street, May 2024
Replace wood windows in 1922 dwelling.
Sash/frame inserts. Pella Lifestyle.
CoA approved 7-1.
712 Ridge Street
540 Park Street, June 2025
Replace wood windows in 1900 dwelling.
New wood sash, custom, installed into existing frames.
CoA approved 7-0.
540_Park_St
701-707 West Main Street, February 2026
Replace wood windows in 1922 commercial building.
Sash/frame inserts. Marvin Ultimate.
CoA approved 7-0.
701-707 West Main St
554 Valley Road, March 2026
Replace steel casement windows in 1932 dwelling (with other alterations).
New windows. Pella Lifestyle.
CoA approved 6-0-1.
554 Valley Road
Original
Not Original
Windows to be replaced: 123 Chancellor Street (BAR Staff, 10-15-2026)
123 Chancellor Street - Applicant photo: Typical window, 10-12-2026
Exterior
Interior
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
123 CHANCELLOR STREET
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
206 Fifth Street NE
Charlottesville Virginia 22902
T 434 977 4480
F 434 296 8720
info@dgparchitects.com
CHI OMEGA - UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA
FIRST FLOOR A-23/32" = 1'-0"
DW DW
DW
W01
W14
W15
W16
W17
W19
W18
W13W09 W10 W11 W12
W08
W04
W05
W07
W06
W03
W02
R
R
FRONT PORCH
101
FOYER
103
PIANO ROOM
102
LIVING ROOM
104
MENS
106
WOMENS
107
KTTE.
109
BATH
108
LIVING
110
BEDROOM (1)
112
FORMAL DINING
105
DINING
115
KITCHEN
114
STUDY
117
BACK HALL
111PORCH
119
VESTIBULE
122
FIRST FLOOR
1. REPLACE ALL SASHES ON FIRST AND LOWER FLOORS.
2. REPAIR EXISTING BRICK MOULDS AND SILLS.
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
123 CHANCELLOR STREET
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
206 Fifth Street NE
Charlottesville Virginia 22902
T 434 977 4480
F 434 296 8720
info@dgparchitects.com
CHI OMEGA - UNIVERSITY OF VIRGINIA
LOWER LEVEL A-13/32" = 1'-0"
W21
W20
W D W D
LAUNDRY
004
MECHANICAL
001
MECHANICAL
002
STORAGE
009
CLOSET
008
HALL
006
HALL
003
OUTDOOR STORAGE
007
W22
W23
LOWER LEVEL
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
123 CHANCELLOR STREET
1 7/8"
[48]
1 7/8"
[48]
1 9/16"
[39]
3 1/16"
[78]
4 1/4"
[107]
2 13/16"
[72]
2"
[51]
FRAME HEIGHT
5"
[127]
1 7/8"
[47]
1 9/16"
[40]
1 5/16"
[34]
FRAME WIDTH
1 1/16"
[27]
5"
[127]
FRAME WIDTH
1 1/16"
[27]
CR
UJ
LJ
VH
VS
VENT HEADVH
CR CHECK RAIL
VENT SILLVS LJ LOWER JAMBS
UJ UPPER JAMBS
1 1/2"
[39]
2 15/16"
[75]
1 7/8"
[48]
2 15/16"
[75]
1 1/2"
[38]
1 7/8"
[48]
CHECKRAIL HEIGHT
Dimension required for ordering
units with unequal sash.
Pella ® Reserve
TM
Traditional Clad Double-Hung
Frame Depth 5" - Exterior Sash Putty STANDARD GLAZING, PRODUCT DIMENSIONS, AND ATTRIBUTES SHOWN. QUOTE MAY VARY.1
ELEVATION DRAWING FOR
OF
317450
Project No.:
SHEET:
CHECKED BY: ----
LOCATION: CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA
ARCHITECT: ----
ORIGINAL: 7/28/26
DRAWN BY: DRD
1/8/19
CHI OMEGA HOUSE UVA
02 02
11
10
9
8
-
-
-
-
-
REV: DATE:
7
- 6
5
4
3
2
-
-
-
-
-
REV: DATE:
1
-12
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
123 CHANCELLOR STREET
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
123 CHANCELLOR STREET
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
123 CHANCELLOR STREET
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
123 CHANCELLOR STREET
EXTERIOR
EXTERIOR
W01
W02
W03
W04
W05
W06
W23
W22
W21
W20
W07
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
123 CHANCELLOR STREET
ARCHITECTURE + HISTORIC PRESERVATION + PLANNING + INTERIOR DESIGN
123 CHANCELLOR STREET
EXTERIOR
EXTERIOR
W09
W12
W11
W10
W13
W14
W15
W16
W17
W18
W19
W08
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 1
City of Charlottesville
Board of Architectural Review
Staff Report
October 20, 2026
Certificate of Appropriateness Application
BAR # 26-0039
Leased cafe space on Downtown Mall
Associated business: Sal’s Café, 221 East Main Street; TMP 330235000
Owner/Applicant: Guiseppe Finazzo
Project: After-the-fact CoA/serving counter in café space
Background
Year Built: Downtown Mall, 1976
District: Downtown ADC District
First phase of the City's Downtown Pedestrian Mall - from 1st Street to 6th Street East – was
completed in 1976. Designed by Lawrence Halprin & Associates, the composition of trees, open
spaces, and fountains encourages movement, while providing opportunities for reflection, respite,
and social interaction. Later extensions of the Mall and the 2008 rebricking reflect the intent and
elements of the original design.
Brief Summary
CoA request for a serving counter of approximately 26 square feet, 9-6” long, and 3’-3” tall
constructed within a Mall café space assigned to the applicant. CoAs for café spaces are typically
reviewed as a Minor Historic Review, per City Code section 34-5.2.6., and can be approved by staff
if consistent with the design guidelines. However, this serving counter is not consistent with the
review criteria, therefore the CoA application is referred to the BAR for a Major Historic Review,
per City Code section 34-5.2.7., with a recommendation for denial due to size and materiality.
Prior BAR Reviews
May 28, 1985 – Café Space delineation. CoA request denied pending City Council approval to
remove existing seating area on the Mall.
May 28, 1985 – Remodeling of front façade. Request tabled due to insufficient plans.
June 11, 1985 – Remodeling of front façade. Approved with conditions.
February 16, 1999 – Approval of café furniture.
March 18, 2003 – Approval of café furniture.
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 2
December 12, 2007 – Approved partial demolition and façade alterations; replacement of storefront
window and door framing.
Application
• CoA application for a serving counter within the café space assigned to the applicant. The
serving counter is approximately 26-square feet (approximately 9’-6” long, 2’-8” wide, and 3’-
3” high), made of plywood and lumber, painted black, topped with a stone or composite
countertop. Note: This café space is within a tree bosque. The serving counter is installed over a
tree grate and abuts the tree within it.
Discussion
Sidewalk Cafes on the Downtown Mall are regulated by City Code Chapter 28 Article VI. Sidewalk
Cafes. Per Sec. 34-213, in addition to the required annual permit, on the Downtown Mall “the
design and appearance of the café structures and furnishings shall be reviewed [by the BAR]” and
must have an approved Certificate of Appropriateness (CoA).
CoAs for elements within leased cafe spaces are reviewed as Minor Historic Reviews, under 34-
5.2.6., and can be approved by staff if the request is consistent with the review criteria. If a
requested CoA cannot be approved by staff, the matter can be referred to the BAR for formal
review as a Major Historic Review, under 34-5.2.7.
Staff determined that, per the ADC District Design Guidelines, Chapter 5, Section E. Outdoor
Cafes, the serving counter constructed at this café space does not meet the design criteria, therefore
a CoA could not be approved via a Minor Historic Review. The request is therefore presented to the
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 3
BAR for Major Historic Review, with staff recommending denial for the reasons stated below
(under Compatibility with the ADC District Design Guidelines.)
The applicant has operated an outdoor café on the Downtown Mall since 1987. For the 2026
operating season, the total available café space is 1,224 square feet, separated into two spaces: one
located immediately in front of the building (221 E. Main Street); the other, larger space is centrally
positioned within the Mall. This CoA application applies to a serving counter within the latter
space. As this is an after-the-fact application, a timeline of activities follows.
• May 26, 2026: Staff observed construction of a U-shaped serving counter within the café space
for which there was no approved CoA. The Zoning inspector informed the business to stop work
immediately and meet with the appropriate staff members who would guide them through the
review process.
• June 1, 2026: The Zoning Administrator and Preservation & Design Planner met with Mr.
Finazzo to discuss current conditions. Mr. Finazzo was told the serving counter did not meet the
necessary guidelines and a CoA could not be approved as a Minor Historic Review. He was
instructed to either remove the counter or submit an application for a Major Historic Review. At
that time, Mr. Finazzo was informed that for the same reasons the counter could not be
approved by staff the recommendation to the BAR would be to deny the CoA.
• June 9, 2026: The serving counter had been completed.
• October 5, 2026: City Parks & Rec removed a tree within the leased space due to word-boring
bark beetle infestation. To accommodate that work, the applicant dissembled the U-shaped
serving counter, removing the two approximately 6-ft long sides. Subsequently, they decided the
sides would not be reinstalled, resulting in the configuration currently presented. (Note: While
not the direct cause for its necessary removal, the tree’s condition had been further stressed by
thermal scorching from a portable, propane heater placed near the trunk and possibly by the
unauthorized application at its base of a rodent repellant foam. See photograph in Appendix.)
Compatibility with the ADC District Design Guidelines, Chapter. 5 Section E. Outdoor Cafes.
1. Guiding Principles for Outdoor Cafes
Leased café spaces are not permanent: All elements–including but not limited to
furniture, railings, or planters – should be portable and easily moved manually.
Staff comment: A conservative estimate for a wood cabinet with stone top of this size
suggests a minimum weight in excess of 650 pounds. The serving counter does not
appear to be portable and easily moved manually.
Materials must be durable, high-quality. (Preference for metal; no plastic.)
Staff comment: Plywood is not a durable or high-quality material for exterior uses.
Prioritize pedestrian experience: Size and placement of railings, furniture, planters,
plantings, and other elements should not create visual barriers.
Staff comment: With the plywood front and side panels, the serving counter reads as a
solid element.
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 4
Specific to the Mall:
Placement of café elements should avoid, and not cause damage to, the Mall trees.
Staff comment: The serving counter on the tree grate, less than one foot from the tree.
2. Guidelines for Design Elements
c. Service Furniture and Equipment
Materials and color: Metal frame and shelves. Other material requires BAR approval.
Black or silver tone. Other colors require BAR approval.
Dimensions:
• Max height: Shelves 6-ft; cabinets and serving counters 3-ft.
• Max length (furniture and equipment): 4-ft.
Design: Shelves are open (framed; no solid sides or back). No permanent, enclosed
storage cabinets. Rolling carts permitted, but not higher than 36", color is black, must be
removed when café is closed.
Staff comment:
• The materials used are plywood, lumber, and stone (or stone composite). Metal is
preferred. The use of wood elements require BAR approval. If approved, wood be
painted or stained.
• The outfacing surfaces of the cabinet are painted black with a white countertop, similar
to other elements in this space.
• The serving counter is 3’-3” tall. This exceeds the recommended 3’-0” maximum.
• The length of the serving counter at the front is 9’-6” at the front. This exceeds the
recommended 4’-0” maximum length.
• Due to its design and estimated weight, this is effectively a fixed cabinet with storage
shelving enclosed behind solid panels. This conflicts with the recommendation against
permanent, enclosed storage cabinets.
h. All elements, generally:
Well-made, quality material. Kept well-maintained; easily removed, will not stain or
damage Mall floor. No elements may be anchored (permanently or temporarily) to the
Mall floor or City property.
Staff comment: The serving counter was built in-place and is not a manufactured product.
While the cabinet is not anchored to the Mall, its size, scale, and estimated weight suggest
it cannot be easily removed.
i. Wood elements, generally:
Materials and color: Painted or stained. No unfinished wood.
• Staff comment: The outfacing plywood surfaces of the cabinet are painted black. The
interior including framing and shelves are unpainted.
n. Trees in Bosques
No tables or service furnishings permitted within two feet of a tree trunk. Nothing may be
attached to or wrapped around [contacting] the trees.
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 5
Staff comment: The serving counter is within one foot of the tree trunk.
Recommendation
Staff recommends denial of the requested CoA for the serving counter due to its materiality
(plywood and lumber), its height and length exceed recommendations of the design guidelines, its
scale and configuration suggest it is not portable or easily moved, its placement is immediately
adjacent to a Mall tree, its solid front and side panels create a visual barrier, and it effectively serves
as a permanent, enclosed storage cabinet.
Scale of proposed service counter (left) compared with recommendations of the Design Guidelines.
Note: If the proposed serving counter were constructed with the current countertop reduced to a
length of 4-ft and fixed to an open, metal frame, painted black, and not taller than 3-ft, staff would
recommend approval of the requested CoA.
By motion and vote the BAR may defer action until the November 17, 2026 meeting. (If no action
is taken then, the CoA would be deemed approved by default.) However, this being an after-the-fact
review, staff recommends the BAR not accept from the applicant a request to defer action on this
matter.
Suggested Motions
Denial: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District
Design Guidelines for Outdoor Cafes, I move to find the new serving counter constructed within the
leased café space on the Mall assigned to 221 East Main Street does not satisfy the BAR’s criteria
and is not compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and for the
following reasons the BAR denies the request: […]
• The height exceeds the maximum 3-ft recommended in the Design Guidelines.
• The length exceeds the maximum 4- ft recommended in the Design Guidelines.
• The cabinet is constructed with wood. Per the Design Guidelines, metal is the preferred
material for service furniture.
• The front and sides of the cabinet are solid. Per the Design Guidelines, this should be an
open frame.
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 6
• The service counters is located too close to a Mall tree.
• The size, scale, and estimated weight suggest the cabinet is not portable and is not easily
moved manually.
• The service counter is effectively a fixed cabinet with storage shelving enclosed behind solid
panels. This conflicts with the recommendation against permanent, enclosed storage
cabinets.
Approval: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC
District Design Guidelines for Outdoor Cafes, I move to find the new serving counter constructed
within the leased café space on the Mall assigned to 221 East Main Street satisfies the BAR’s
criteria and is compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and the BAR
approves the request as submitted.
Criteria, Standards and Guidelines
Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a
design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34-5.2.7. Major
Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34-
5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction,
reconstruction, alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a
building permit. Where a building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful
unless conducted in accordance with the required building permit and all applicable building code
requirements.”
Review Criteria Generally
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2:
a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds:
i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable
provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and
ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the
district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application.
b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of
Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section.
c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or
desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and
character of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or
Historic Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration
will be given to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the
Comprehensive Plan. Conditions may require a reduction in height or massing, consistent with
the City’s design guidelines and subject to the following limitations: [not germane to this
request]
Standards for Review and Decision
Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1:
a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or
structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features
and factors:
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 7
i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed
addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with
the site and the applicable District;
ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and
placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs;
iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of
Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant;
iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures;
v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as
gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks;
vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an
adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures;
vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the
standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and
viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines.
L
inks to ADC District Design Guidelines
Chapter 1 Introduction (Part 1)
Chapter 1 Introduction (Part 2)
Chapter 2 Site Design and Elements
Chapter 5 Signs, Awnings, Vending, and Cafes
A
ttachments:
• C
afé Context Record dated May 15, 2025
• Ch. 5 of the Charlottesville ADC Districts Design Guidelines
• Map - City of Charlottesville Outdoor Cafés
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 8
APPENDIX
Existing Conditions
Small café space at building façade
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 9
Large café space at Mall Tree Bosque
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 10
New serving counter (BAR #26-0039)
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 11
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 12
Service furniture near tree.
Damage to trunk caused by space heater and to base by foam rodent repellant.
(Tree removed Oct 5, 2026)
221 E. Main Street – serving counter/café space – Oct 20, 2026 (10-15) 13
Additional Issues
Note: These items are being noted for information only, not for any BAR action. Enforcement of
the City Code is the responsibility of City Staff.
Staff conducted an extensive inventory of all Downtown Mall café spaces between September 2024
and May 2025 coinciding with the update to the ADC District Design Guidelines, Ch. V. Sect. E,
Outdoor Cafes, approved by City Council on December 16, 2024. A context record was completed
for each café space, noting general conditions, compatible features and elements, and which
components had obtained CoA approvals. Multiple design elements (i.e.: furniture, equipment,
lighting, objects) within the café spaces assigned to Sal’s Caffe Italia did not have CoA approvals
prior to adoption of the revised Guidelines in late 2024.
Recent alterations/additions without a required CoA:
• 2026 – Installation of plywood within and surrounding the two other tree grates within café
space (removed as of September 1, 2026)
• 2026 – Application at base of Mall trees of spray foam rodent repellant (removed as of
September 1, 2026).
• 2026 – Decorative lights attached to one Mall tree.
• 2025 – Awning at front façade of building.
• 2025 – Trellis arch at large café space entrance.
• 2022 – Two dining counters with stone tops installed along café railings
• 2021 – Bar and service counter with stone tops installed at small café space.
• 2021 – Light fixtures installed on front façade of building.
Signs
Per the ADC District Design Guidelines for signs, Chapter 5, Section A, in commercial areas there
should be no more than two permanent signs, which can be different types. Sal’s Caffe Italia
currently has five signs:
o Awning signage
o Café railing/enclosure sign at front façade
o Café railing/enclosure sign at additional café space
o Sign suspended from trellis arch
o Sign affixed to the new serving counter
Sal’s Caffe Italia does not have a sign permit (or permits) for the current, collective signage. Per
code section 34-4.11.3, sign permits are required for commercial signage, which requires signs in an
ADC District be harmonious with the structure and surrounding buildings. In other words,
consistent with the design review criteria.
Sal's Pizza - D-03 - May 15, 2025 1
City of Charlottesville
Board of Architectural Review
Café Context Record
May 15, 2025
Sal's Pizza - D-03
221 E. Main Street
Area (sq.ft.): 1,224
Visibility Rating: Failed – Reconstruction required.
General Condition Rating: Basic maintenance required. (Lighting and umbrella stands require
upkeep, staining on Mall bricks must be addressed. Staff review required.)
Compliance Issues:
*Elements not approved in this CoA must be removed from the operator’s two café spaces until a
separate CoA for those elements is approved.
• Planters cannot be utilized to create visual barriers.
• Décor cannot be stored off-hours in the café spaces.
• Maintain two feet of clearance on all sides of the Mall trees.
• Furniture cannot be placed on tree grates.
• Undercounter lighting must be flush/attached to the counter. (Cannot dangle.)
• Operator is under warning for installing multiple permanent elements without prior
approval.
Sal's Pizza - D-03 - May 15, 2025 2
Inventory of Café Design Elements
Enclosure
Are Planters part of the Enclosure? Railing Design?
Solid Panels? Enclosure height below 36in?
Comments:
Permanent enclosures including dining counters with stone tops, metal railings
covered with banners and signs seasonally, including barred/chained entrance
when off-hours.
Dinning Furniture
Types
Present: Standard Tables, Standard Chairs, Counters, Bar Chairs/Stools
Material: Metal, Mixed Material, Stone
Color: Black, Grey, Stone counters (white, grey, black)
Comments: Dining counters obscure trees. Permanent furniture installed in public right of
way.
Service Furniture
Types
Present:
Shelves, Serving Counter, Storage Cabinet, Host Stand, Numerous styles and
types of cafe equipment, all stored in the cafe permanently.
Material: Metal, Composite, Wood, Materials generally metal, with wood and composite.
(signage, serving tubs, etc.)
Color: Black, Bright
Comments: See photo documentation. Excessive use of equipment that is not removed
from the cafe off-hours and stands against trees.
No
Yes
Yes
No
Sal's Pizza - D-03 - May 15, 2025 3
Umbrellas and Stands
Umbrella(s)
Type: Market Stand(s)
Material: Plastic, Composite
Stand Color: Black, Grey Umbrella
Design: Solid
Umbrella
Color: Bright Pole
Material(s): Metal
Comments: Cream and red umbrella cloths. Large plastic or composite stands, some in poor
condition. Must comply with Zoning and be contained within cafe enclosure.
Lighting
Catenary: Other
Lighting: On Railings, Under Counter
Comments:
Lighting needs further attention. Under counter lighting should be flush (with
counter) and not dangling. Any new lighting must be documented and approved
by staff.
Heaters
Are Heaters
Present?
Permanently Stored in Café Space?
Comments: At time of documentation, no heaters were observed.
Planters
Location: On Floor, Trellis
Material: Ceramic, Plastic
Description: Planters used to create visual
barrier.
Planter(s) Height Below
36inches?
Comments: Urn style planters contain tall palms that exceed enclosure height.
Yes
No
No
No
Sal's Pizza - D-03 - May 15, 2025 4
Trees
Are Trees
Present?
Equipment of Furniture Close
Proximity to Trees/Grates?
Comments: Many issues with furniture and equipment on tree grates and close to tree
trunks. (See images attached)
Other Elements/Notes to the Future
Comments:
Generally maintained, but some work required. Need to inspect inside of
cafe- limited access due to chain or barricade during off-hours. Stains visible
in some locations due to planters, or umbrella stands.
Notes to the
Future:
Staff note: While this CoA shall include existing furniture and enclosure
design, the cafe spaces for Sal's Pizza include permanent installations, entirely
obstruct visibility, and are not compatible with the Mall as a historic resource.
No installations
were done with staff consultation, or BAR review.
Character/Maintenance/Materiality
Stain or Damage
to Mall Floor:
Coverings on
Mall Floor:
Comments:
Generally maintained, but some work required. Need to inspect inside of
cafe- limited access due to chain or barricade during off-hours. Stains visible
in some locations due to planters, or umbrella stands.
Yes Yes
Yes
Sal's Pizza - D-03 - May 15, 2025 5
Sal's Pizza - D-03 - May 15, 2025 6
CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES 1
V Signs, Awnings, Vending & Cafes
CHARLOTTESVILLE
ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICTS
DESIGN GUIDELINES
Approved by City Council, September 17, 2012
Sect. E adopted December 17, 2024
V
Signs, Awnings,
Vending & Cafes
A. Signs...............................5
B. Temporary
Signs...............................8
C. Awnings,
Marquees,
& Canopies....................9
D. Vending
Structures.................11
E. Outdoor
Cafes............................12
F. Tents for
Weekend Events
(up to 5 days).............13
G. Tent Canopies
for Extended Use
(more than 5 days)..14
V Signs, Awnings, Vending & Cafes
A. Signs
Signs are a vital part of commercial areas. A balance should
be struck between the need to call attention to individual
businesses and the need for a positive image of the entire
district. Te character of signs shall be harmonious to the
character of the structure on which they are placed. Consider
the relationship of surrounding buildings, compatible colors,
appropriate materials, the style and size of the lettering and
graphics, and the type of lighting. Signs can complement
or detract from the character of a building depending on
their design, placement, number, and condition. Historically
signifcant signs on buildings should be retained if possible,
even if the business is no longer in existence. See the Zoning
Ordinance for specifc sign regulations in each historic
district. Te following are recommended guidelines.
Tis sign painted on a masonry wall is typical of many historic
signs on a warehouse building.
CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES 5
6 CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES
VSigns, Awnings, Vending & Cafes
Placement
1. Place signs so that they do not obstruct architectural elements
and details that defne the design of the building. Respect the
signs of adjacent businesses.
2. Projecting signs for commercial buildings are limited to
one per storefront. Tey should be no lower than 8 feet from
the sidewalk,and no more than 3 feet from the surface of the
building. Tey should not be placed above the second story sill
line. For residential buildings, small projecting signs attached
to the wall at the frst foor or porch column are appropriate.
3. Window signs should be approximately 5.5 feet above the
sidewalk at the center point for good pedestrian visibility.
Optional locations could include 18 inches from the top or
bottom of the display window glass. Window signs are also
appropriate on the glazing of doors.
4. Flat wall signs for commercial buildings can be located above
the storefront, within the frieze of the cornice, on covered
transoms, or on the pier that frames the display windows or
generally on fat, unadorned surfaces of the façade or in areas
clearly designed as sign locations. Flat wall signs for residential
buildings can be appropriate if attached to the wall at the frst
foor or between porch columns.
5. Awning and canopy signs should be placed on the valance area
only. Te minimum spacing between the edge of the letter and
the top and bottom of the valance should be 1.5 inches.
6. Freestanding signs, in general, are not an appropriate sign type
in commercial areas of Downtown and the West Main Street
corridor except for use in the front yard of a residence that has
been converted to commercial or ofce use on a site where the
building is set back deeply on the lot. In this case, freestanding
signs should be no higher than 12 feet.
Number of permanent signs
1. Te number of signs used should be limited to encourage
compatibility with the building and discourage visual clutter.
2. In commercial areas, signs should be limited to two total,
which can be diferent types.
3. A buildings should have only one wall sign per street frontage.
4. In addition to the existing permitted signs, each business in a
building with rear entrances may have one small fat mounted
sign not to exceed 6 square feet.
Flat, wall-mounted directory
signs identify the multiple
businesses within a building
in a coordinated design.
Projecting signs help direct
pedestrians towards a
business.
A. Signs
Window signs should be
concise and not obscure the
storefront.
Freestanding signs are
acceptable in historic districts
where residences have been
converted to professional use
and can be adapted for use by
more than one tenant.
V Signs, Awnings, Vending & Cafes
A. Signs
Size
1. All the signs on a commercial building should not exceed 50
square feet.
2. Average height of letters and symbols should be no more than
12 inches on wall signs, 9 inches on awning and canopy signs,
and 6 inches on window signs.
3. Projecting signs should be a maximum of 10 square feet per
face.
4. Window signs should obscure no more than 20 percent of the
window glass.
5. Flat wall signs should not exceed 18 inches in height and
should not extend more than 6 inches from the surface of the
building.
Design
1. Signs should be designed and executed by sign professionals
who are skilled at lettering and surface preparation.
Shape
1. Shape of signs for commercial buildings should conform to
the area where the sign is to be located.
2. Likewise, a sign can take on the shape of the product of
service provided, such as a shoe for a shoe store.
Materials
1. Use traditional sign materials, such as wood, glass, gold leaf,
raised metal or painted wood letters, and painted wood letters
on wood, metal, or glass.
2. Newer products, such as painted MDO may also be used.
3. Do not use shiny plastic products.
4. Window signs should be painted or have decal fat letters and
should not be three-dimensional.
Color
1. Use colors that complement the materials and color of the
building, including accent and trim colors.
2. A maximum of three colors are recommended, although
more colors can be appropriate.
Illumination
1. Generally, signs should be indirectly lit with a shielded
incandescent light source.
2. Internally lit translucent signs are not permitted.
Buildings with Multiple Tenants
1. A comprehensive sign plan should be submitted for multi-
tenant buildings.
2. Upper-foor tenants should be represented at each primary
entrance by a fat, wall-mounted directory sign.
Other Signs
1. Banners should be temporary and wall murals should be
carefully reviewed for compatibility with district character.
2. Halo-lit signs with opaque letters may be appropriate.
Neon Signs
1. Neon signs are ofen associated with early- to mid- twentieth
century commercial design and are currently prohibited within
the historic districts unless mounted inside windows.
Sign Maintenance
1. Signs that are not properly maintained should be removed.
2. Signs of a business no longer occupying a building or
storefront should be removed unless it is historically signifcant.
PRESERV ATION BRIEFS
#25: Te Preservation of Historic Signs
Publications are available at
www2.cr.nps.gov/tps/briefs/presbhom.htm
Lettering on signs
CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES 7
8 CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES
VSigns, Awnings, Vending & Cafes
B. Temporary Signs
1. Sandwich board-type signs should be:
a. a maximum of four feet high.
b. a maximum of ten square feet.
c. constructed of metal or painted wood.
2. Wood signs should be constructed of medium density
overlay (MDO) board or a similar quality material and not
grained plywood.
3. All edges should be covered with molding or otherwise
fnished.
4. Sandwich board-type signs should have a maximum of
four colors that relate to the colors of the associated building.
5. Letters should be scaled to the size of the sign.
6. No national advertising trademarks or logos should be a
part of the sign other than that of the business.
Tis sandwhich board directs customers to parking while
highlighting two businesses that are located in the rear of the
building.
Temporary signs provide the opportunity to give more
information about a business’s products.
Te simple design of this sandwich board uses bright colors and
bold lettering to attract attention to this business.
V Signs, Awnings, Vending & Cafes
C. Awnings, Marquees & Canopies
Awnings can contribute to the overall image of the
Downtown, Te Corner, and West Main Street by providing
visual continuity for an entire block, helping to highlight
specifc buildings, and covering any unattractively remodeled
transom areas above storefronts. Tey also protect pedestrians
from the weather, shield window displays from sunlight,
and conserve energy. Marquees are usually associated
with theaters and contain areas for changing information.
Canopies are more permanent structures.
Tese metal fxed canopies blend in well with this contemporary
storefront design.
Te Nook’s canopy design integrates well with the period
storefront.
Ty pes
1. Fixed, sloped fabric awnings are the traditional awning type
and are appropriate for most historic buildings, both residential
and commercial.
2. Boxed or curved fabric awnings; a more current design
treatment, may be used on a non-historic or new commercial
building.
3. Marquees and canopies fabricated from rigid materials are
appropriate on some commercial buildings, however, they must
ft the storefront design and not obscure important elements
such as transoms or decorative glass.
4. Historic marquees and canopies should be retained and
maintained on historic building facades.
5. Backlit awnings or canopies used as illuminated signs are
inappropriate.
Placement
1. Place awnings carefully within the storefront, porch, door, or
window openings so they so not obscure elements of damage
materials.
2. Choose designs that do not interfere with existing signs or
distinctive architectural features of the building, or with street
trees or other elements along the street.
3. Choose an awning shape that fts the opening in which it is
installed.
4. Make sure the bottom of the awning valance is at least 8 feet
high, or consistent with the current building code.
Color and Materials
1. Coordinate colors with the overall building color scheme.
Solid colors, wide stripes, and narrow stripes may be appropriate,
but not overly bright or complex pattern.
2. Aluminum, vinyl plastic, or overly ornate fabric awnings are
generally inappropriate for any buildings within the historic
districts.
3. Contemporary marquees or canopies may be constructed of
combinations of metal, wood, and glass; some types of plastic
may be appropriate.
CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES 9
10 CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES
VSigns, Awnings, Vending & Cafes
C. Awnings, Marquees & Canopies
Coordinated awning types and color help unify the redesigned multiple storefronts of this long brick building.
Traditional fabric awnings help screen the sun and provide color
for these West Main Street businesses.
A modern awning with no fabric on the sides can be an
alternative to more traditional designs.
V Signs, Awnings, Vending & Cafes
D. Vending Structures
A vending structure is defned as any stand, rack, cart, prop,
table, frame, pedestal or container used for display of goods
and services. Tese standards shall apply to all vendors
whether regular mall vendors, Christmas Market vendors,
or City Market vendors when permitted on the Mall. See
Section 28-119 of the City Code.
1. Design
a. Preference for mobility of the structure will be given.
b. All vending stands should have a tailored black (preferred),
dark green, purple, navy, charcoal gray, or maroon cloth skirt
that is long enough to touch the ground and hide the structure
of the table and ancillary equipment for all four sides of the
table.
c. All skirts must be properly maintained and kept clean and in
good repair.
d. All tables must be at least 30 inches high and comply with
applicable ADA standards.
e. Only items for sale should be visible.
f. Trailer hitches must be removed from carts.
2. Materials
a. Vending cart materials other than black or silvertone metal
require BAR approval.
b. All wood must be fnished or painted.
3. Color
a. Colors on vending structures should be in keeping with the
character of the surrounding area.
b. No primary or bright colors shall be allowed.
c. Dark colors or silver are preferable.
4. Size
a. All vending structures shall be within a space limited to either
5 feet by 10 ½ feet, or 10 ½ feet in length and width, and 6 feet
in height.
5. Signs
a. No signs should be located on or within any vendor structure,
except a price sign, and a sign or logo identifying the name of
the vendor or the product, which signs shall lay fat on the table.
b. Te vendor’s license and peddler’s license shall be displayed
on the structure.
c. No sign shall be greater than 2 square feet in area.
6. Umbrellas
a. Only single pole umbrellas can be used to cover vending
structures and should not obscure surrounding businesses.
b. No permanent canopies or tents are allowed.
c. Umbrellas should be of only one dark or neutral color that is
compatible with the vending structure.
d. Te size of the umbrella should be in scale with the vending
structure and ft within the space limits as stated in #4. Umbrella
clearance shall be minimum 7 feet.
e. No text is permitted on a vending structure umbrella.
7. Racks and bookcases
a. Only one vending rack shall be allowed per vendor.
b. Te rack shall be no longer than four feet not more than six
feet high.
c. No rack shall be allowed unless it is associated with a stand
with table(s).
d. All racks must be within the space allotted for a vendor stand.
e. Racks shall be black or silvertone.
f. A bookcase located adjacent to a storefront shall be maximum
four feet high, constructed of metal.
8. Merchandise
a. All merchandise must be located on a vending table or on a
rack.
b. No merchandise shall be placed on the ground nor shall it be
visible on the ground under the table.
9. Stands and Chairs
a. Each vendor must furnish his/her own stands and chairs.
b. Chairs must be located within the square footage allowed for
the vendor area.
Tis vending stand’s skirt and umbrella comply with the
standards.
CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES 11
Amended December 17, 2024
lkr
1.GuidingPrinciplesforOutdoorCafes
• The Downtown Mall NRHP District is individually listed
on the Virginia Landmarks Register (VLR) and the
National Register of Historic Places (NRHP).
• The Corner is within the VLR/NRHP-listed Rugby Road-
University Corner Historic District.
• The brick-paved Mall and the sidewalks at The Corner
are City-owned and important public spaces.
• Leased café spaces are not permanent: All elements–
including but not limited to furniture, railings, or plant-
ers –should be portable and easily moved manually.
• Within a café space the furniture, elements and materials
should be compatible.
• Materials must be durable, high-quality. (Preference for
metal; no plastic.)
• Prioritize pedestrian experience: Size and placement of
railings, furniture, planters, plantings, and other
elements should not create visual barriers.
• For unleased café spaces or when leased but not used for
prolonged periods, all elements—including but not
limited to furniture, railings, planters-- should be
removed from the public right of way.
• Specific to the Mall:
Elements of the café spaces must respect the design
intent of the Mall. The Mall is Charlottesville's living
room.
Maintain sight lines on the Mall by minimizing visual
obstructions within café spaces.
The fountains should be accessible, with clear space
on all sides.
Placement of café elements should avoid, and not
cause damage to, the Mall trees.
Note: Intent of the design guidelines for Outdoor Cafes
is to allow administrative (Minor) review and approval
by staff. Applicants may apply to the BAR for a formal
(Major) review of: elements not expressly prohibited by
the guidelines; elements that require BAR approval; and/
or when interpretation is necessary to resolve a Minor
review.
Minor Historic Review, ref: City Code Ch. 34 Sec. 5.2.6.
Major Historic Review, ref: City Code Ch. 34 Sec. 5.2.7.
2.Guidelinesfor Design Elements
(Note: Non-compliant elements under a, b, and c may
remain, if in place on 12/31/2024 and have an approved
CoA, provided those elements meet ADA and ABC
requirements.)
a.Café enclosures: Railings, bollards, chains, planters.
• Materials and color: Wrought iron or metal. Black.
(Color for planters not used as enclosure, see d.)
• Dimensions: Maximum36” height. Meet ADA and
ABC requirements. Chains: 2" minimum link
length. Bollard/Post (width): No minimum; 6"
maximum.
• Design: No solid panels between top and bottom
rails, including where dining counters are located
at the railing.
b.Dining Furniture: Tables and chairs; dining counters;
bar-height counters and chairs.
• Materials and color: Wrought iron or metal
preferred. Other material requires BAR approval.
Black or silver tone preferred. Other colors require
BAR approval.
• Dimensions: Furniture should be standard
heights: Tables and dining counters (28" to 30");
chairs (16" to 18"); bar counters (41" to 43"); and
bar chairs/stools (30"). Maximum table or counter
length: 8-ft.
• Design: Shapes, colors, and designs should be
generally compatible. No solid panels below
dining furniture. Bar-height counters should not
be located at the railings to create a visual barrier.
c.Service Furniture and Equipment: Shelves; cabinets;
serving counters; host stands.
• Materials and color: Metal frame and shelves.
Other material requires BAR approval. Black or
silver tone. Other colors require BAR approval.
• Dimensions: Max height: Shelves 6-ft; cabinets
and serving counters 3-ft. Max length (furniture
and equipment): 4-ft.
• Design: Shelves are open (framed; no solid sides
or back). No permanent, enclosed storage
cabinets. Rolling carts permitted, but not higher
than 36", color is black, must be removed when
café is closed.
12 CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES
Amended December 17, 2024
lkr
d.Planters: On railing or free standing, including use as
café enclosure.
• Materials and color: Avoid bright colors. (Black, if
an enclosure.) Quality, durable material. Wood, if
painted or stained. No plastic. No feed troughs/bunks.
No unfinished wood barrels.
• Dimensions: Maximum 36" height, 30" width or
diameter. If elevated, top of planter cannot exceed 36"
above Mall floor.
• Design: Compatible with other elements of the café.
If mounted on railings, top of planter cannot extend
above railing. Empty planters may be permitted for
decorative purpose, with approval. No lighting in
planters.
e.Plants: In planters.
• Live only. No artificial plants.
Recommend non-invasives.
• Preferably not taller than 5-ft above Mall floor;
however, plants cannot be used to create a hedge.
f. Umbrellas:
• Materials and color: Umbrellas: Cloth. Stands: metal.
Poles: wood or metal. Prefer solid colors. Variation
requires BAR approval. Stands and weights must be
black. Stands: metal. Poles: wood or metal.
• Dimensions: Contained entirely within the café space.
• Design: No designs, signage, or text allowed on
umbrella. Weights must be appropriate for the use.
Shade cloths are not permitted.
g.Trash Containers:
• Materials and color: Metal. Black.
h.All elements, generally:
• Enclosures must avoid contact with trees.
• Furniture will be of same material and design
character.
• Black is preferred, but additional colors must be
compatible. No bare galvanized metal.
• Well-made, quality material. Kept well-maintained;
easily removed, will not stain or damage Mall floor.
No elements may be anchored (permanently or
temporarily) to the Mall floor or City property.
• Entirely within leased café enclosure/space (per City
Code). No logos, text, or branding, except as allowed
by Sign Ordinance.
• Coverings on the Mall floor—including rugs, mats,
faux turf--are not permitted. No electrical wires or
cords on the Mall floor.
i.Wood elements, generally:
• Materials and color: Painted or stained.
No unfinished wood.
j.Temporary decorations, non-tabletop: Items such as flags,
banners and pennants (where permitted by City Code).
• Not permanent, temporary only for holidays and
special events. (SeeAll Elements.)
k.Heaters:
• Materials and color: Metal. Black or silver tone.
• Dimensions: Pole mounted only. Maximum
height 90”.Maximum width36”.
• Removed from café space when not in use,
including propane tanks.
• Comply with Charlottesville Fire Department
(CFD) and City requirements re: spacing from
trees and umbrellas.
• No open flames permitted.
• Firepits and fire tables are not permitted.
l.Attachments to railings (café enclosures) and poles:
Includes but is not limited to straps or wires that can
be used to attach items to poles and rails.
• Preferably metal, black. Zip-ties, if black. No
tape, string, or rope.
• Neatly installed—no sharp edges, such as that
the ends of zip-ties are trimmed.
• No hanging planters that extend outside the
enclosures.
m.Art pieces, statuary, and other similarly designed
objects: (Where permitted by City Code.)
• May be permitted for decorative purposes, with
BAR approval.
• No columns or posts. No inflatable objects.
• Small decorative items: (Where permitted by City
Code.)
• On tabletops only. Removed when café is closed.
• Not permitted: Decorations suspended from poles,
umbrellas, or railings.
12-a CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES
lkr
Amended December 17, 2024
n.Trees in Bosques
• No tables or service furnishings permitted within two feet of a tree trunk. Nothing may be attached to or
wrapped around [contacting] the trees.
• Enclosures must avoid contact with trees.
o.Lighting, generally:
• White lighting only.
• Tabletop: Free standing, removable. Solar or battery. Candles, if allowed by CFD. Removed when café is
closed.
• Lighting/luminaries permitted: under counters.
• Lighting/luminaries not permitted: On railings/café enclosures, up-lighting, in planters
p.Catenary Lights: Overhead, on poles. [See reference diagrams on page 12-c.]
• Poles will be straight, , painted black, and installed within the café enclosure; preferably attached to the café
railing.
• Poles will have either shepherd's hooks or rings to support the lights.
• Pole heights will be at a sufficient height* such that suspended light cables will not be lower than7’-0” at
mid-span. (* Preferably not exceeding 9-ft.)
• Light cables will have black wire and sockets with bare bulbs (clear globes, either round or elongated);
noholiday mini-lights, no LED tapes.
• Lights will have lamping that is dimmable, have a Color Temperature not exceeding 3,000K, and a Color
Rendering Index not less than 80, preferable not less than 90. Colored [not white] and/or blinking lights are
not permitted.
• Light cables will be connected only to the poles indicated on the CoA and generally follow a diagonal pattern
(see below).
• Light cables will not contact or be connected to the trees, café umbrellas, or City lamp posts.
• Installed lengths (light sets connected in series) will not exceed manufacturer’s specifications.
• Power sources (for ex., batteries) for the lights will be provided by café space licensee and located within the
leased space. Power source will be screened, secure from tampering, silent, meet applicable code requirements,
and will be removed from café space when not in use or when being charged. Connection to City lamp posts/
outlets and/or extension cords crossing the Mall from outside the café space are not permitted.
• Anchors, support cables, wires, cords, railing connectors, and other similar attachments not addressed above are
not permitted without approval.
q.Elements not permitted (if not noted above):
• Screening: Trellis. Lattice.
• Upholstered or oversized furniture.
112-b CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES
Amended December 17, 2024
lkr
Reference Diagrams for Catenary Lighting
Preferred light string alignment
Dimensions Appropriate pole types
12-c CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES
V Signs, Awnings, Vending & Cafes
F .Tents for Temporary Events (up to 5 days)
1. T ents should preferably be located in a rear or side yard.
2. Tents should not permanently alter signifcant
landscaping or site features.
3. Tents should be a solid color, without any text or logos.
4. Tents are not appropriate on the Downtown mall portion
of East and West Main Streets, except at Central Place, on
the side streets leading to the mall, and on the upper foors
or roofs of buildings.
G. Tents (Including Tent Canopies) for The Winter Cafe Season
or Year- Round Use
(Amended October 21, 2013)
1. Tents are generally not appropriate in historic districts that
are primarily residential (North Downtown, Wertland Street,
Ridge Street, Oakhurst-Gildersleeve, Rugby Road-Venable,
most of Martha Jeferson).
2. Tents may be appropriate in the Downtown, the Corner,
and the West Main Street ADC districts, and in the mixed
use/commercial areas of Martha Jeferson Conservation
District, except tents are not appropriate on the Downtown
mall portion of East and West Main Streets, including Central
Place, and on the side streets leading to the mall.
3. Traditional solutions such as patio umbrellas and tree
shade are encouraged.
4. Tents are not appropriate on the upper foors or roof of
buildings.
5. Tents are not appropriate in front of a contributing
building.
6. Tents may be appropriate in front of a non-contributing
building, depending on the tent materials, and the impact
of its footprint and massing on the streetscape and building.
7. Tents may be appropriate on the rear or side of a building.
8. Tents should not permanently alter signifcant landscaping
or site features.
9. Tents should be a solid color, without any text or logos.
CHARLOTTESVILLE ARCHITECTURAL DESIGN CONTROL DISTRICT DESIGN GUIDELINES
A clear tent may be appropriately used to provide shelter for a
temporary event.
A tent that is appropriate for temporary use may not be
appropriate for longer term use.
Low sheen subtle colors and intentional design complement the
building.
13
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.