Human Rights Commission Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Human Rights Commission · meeting of Oct 15, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville
This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Human Rights Commission Meeting Agenda Packet
October 15, 2026, 6:00 pm
Parks & Recreation Conference Room 130
501 E. Main Street
Charlottesville, VA 22902
I. Agenda
II. Martha’s Rules (for reference)
III. 08/20/2026 DRAFT HRC Regular Meeting Minutes
IV. 08/27/2026 DRAFT HRC Special Meeting Minutes
V. 09/17/2026 DRAFT HRC Regular Meeting Minutes
VI. OHR Monthly Report
VII. HRC Work Plan
Index
Attachment I
Human Rights Commission Meeting Agenda
October 15, 2026, 6:00 pm
Parks & Recreation Conference Room 130
501 E. Main Street
Charlottesville, VA 22902
Regular Meeting
I. WELCOME
• Call to order/Roll call
• Mission (recited by all): Act as a strong advocate for justice and equal opportunity by providing
citywide leadership and guidance in the area of civil rights.
II. MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
• Public Comment
i. To provide written public comment, please email humanrights@charlottesville.gov.
III. MINUTES
• 08/20/2026 HRC Regular Meeting Minutes*
• 08/27/2026 HRC Special Meeting – Case 2025-2 Administrative Appeal Hearing Minutes*
• 09/17/2026 HRC Regular Meeting Minutes*
IV. BUSINESS MATTERS
• Chair update
• OHR staff report
V. WORK SESSION
• Community Stakeholder Engagement
• Work Plan check-in
• New business
• Decision regarding next Work Session on 11/05/2026
VI. MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
• Public comment
i. To provide written public comment, please email humanrights@charlottesville.gov.
• Commission response to Matters by the Public
VII. COMMISSIONER UPDATES
VIII. NEXT STEPS & ADJOURN
* ACTION NEEDED
Please take Notice that this meeting of the Human Rights Commission is for the purposes of planning,
developing, and drafting management and administration documents for the Human Rights Commission. This
meeting will be a limited public forum to discuss the agenda items presented and to ensure the continuity of
services provided by the Commission. The Commission Chair may limit public comments or discussion points
that are unrelated to agenda items or that pertain to topics outside the scope of this Agenda.
The Commission welcomes comments and questions and commits to listening carefully and thoughtfully to what
is presented. A maximum of sixteen public comment time slots are allotted per meeting. Each speaker will have
three minutes to speak. The Commission requests that members of the public refrain from engaging in personal
attacks against Commissioners and staff members and asks that comments and questions focus on matters
related to human rights within the City.
Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting
may call the ADA Coordinator at (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The
City of Charlottesville requests that you provide a 48-hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made.
Attachment II
Rules & Procedures for Charlottesville Human Rights Commission Adopted: 2/20/14
Amended: 5/18/23
9
Martha’s Rules of Order
As adopted by the HRC on February 20, 2020
1. The proposal is presented. Clarifying questions are taken.
a. Proposal should always be in writing.
2. Friendly amendments are offered. Discussion is allowed only on the amendments.
a. Amendments should be prepared in advance when possible.
3. Speakers in favor of the proposal present their views.
a. This is not a time for debate.
b. Time limits should be set and enforced.
4. Speakers in opposition to the proposal present their views.
a. This is not a time for debate.
b. Time limits should be set and enforced.
5. General discussion and/or debate OR small group discussion time on the proposal is allowed.
a. Time limit on discussion is set by the group.
b. Facilitator helps group identify key issues.
c. Motion to table or refer is in order and requires ¾ vote.
6. First vote is taken.
a. People vote
i. In favor of the proposal, or
ii. Can live with the proposal, or
iii. Opposed to the proposal.
b. If a majority of those present votes “in favor” or “can live with,” proceed to Step 8.
c. If less than a majority of those present votes “in favor” or “can live with,” proposal dies.
7. Those voting in opposition are allowed to state their objections and concerns.
a. No discussion is allowed, only clarifying questions.
8. The second vote is taken as in Step 6.
a. It takes a majority of those present to override objections and pass the proposal.
Attachment III
Human Rights Commission
Meeting Minutes
Regular Meeting
August 20, 2026
Virtual/Electronic Meeting conducted on Zoom
6:00 pm
1. WELCOME
a. CALL TO ORDER
i. Chair, Heather Roberson Gaston, called the Zoom meeting to order at 6:05 pm.
b. ROLL CALL
i. Present
1. Heather Roberson Gaston
2. Elizabeth Stark
3. Callum McCain von Schill
4. Dawn Lawson (arrived 6:13 pm after review of minutes from 07/16/26)
5. Emily Currier
6. Jessica Cocciolone
7. Suzanne Lynn
ii. Absent
1. Mariane Asad Doyle
c. MISSION (recited by all): Act as a strong advocate for justice and equal opportunity by
providing citywide leadership and guidance in the area of civil rights.
2. MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
a. PUBLIC COMMENT
i. None.
b. COMMISSION RESPONSE TO MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
i. None.
3. MINUTES
a. Review of minutes from July 16, 2026.
i. Motion: Jessica Cocciolone moved to approve the July 16, 2026, regular meeting
minutes.
1. Second: Heather Roberson Gaston seconded the motion.
2. Vote:
a. In favor: 6
b. Can live with: 0
c. Opposed: 0
d. Abstained: 0
3. Motion to approve minutes passed unanimously.
4. BUSINESS MATTERS
a. CHAIR UPDATE
i. Legislative Recommendation Timeline
1. The chair reported that the Chair and staff sought to preserve or extend
the usual August 30 deadline for state legislative recommendations.
2. The Commission heard that the City requested recommendations by
Saturday, August 22, 2026, so they could be considered during the City’s
legislative process.
3. The chair suggested submitting a shorter, less granular slate of
recommendations than in some prior years due to the compressed
timeline and evolving stakeholder input.
4. The chair noted that state legislative recommendations were the
immediate focus and that City policy recommendations could be
addressed later.
b. OHR STAFF REPORT
i. Chief Prosperity Officer
1. Staff reported that Joshua Barr began as the City’s new Chief Prosperity
Officer.
2. Staff described the new reporting structure: the Office of Human Rights
reports to the Chief Prosperity Officer, then to the Assistant to the City
Manager, then to the City Manager.
3. Staff noted that the Chief Prosperity Officer has prior human rights office
leadership experience and is familiar with official human rights agency
work.
ii. Hiring and Staffing
1. Staff reported that the policy and impact analyst hiring process was near
completion and that reference checks were underway.
2. Staff anticipated that the selected candidate may attend a future
meeting, likely in October if the process proceeds as expected.
iii. IAOHRA Conference and Local Human Rights Work
1. Staff reported from the International Association of Official Human Rights
Agencies conference and noted that agencies are discussing limits and
uncertainties related to federal work-share enforcement and federal civil
rights protections.
2. Staff emphasized the importance of local and state human rights
agencies in handling complaints, identifying systemic issues, and
maintaining access to protections.
3. Staff distinguished outreach from engagement: outreach focuses on
education and sharing information, while engagement involves
stakeholder conversations that inform Commission recommendations
and policy work.
4. Staff reported participating in Soul of Cville and speaking with
approximately 25 community members.
5. Staff noted that the conference reinforced the need for staff capacity,
including the policy and impact analyst and potentially future community
outreach capacity.
iv. Office Work Plan and Three-Year Goals
1. Staff reported that an Office of Human Rights work plan and three-year
goals had been submitted to City management.
2. Staff stated that the office work plan is separate from the Commission
work plan and will be shared with the Commission after additional
feedback is received.
5. WORK SESSION
a. Annual legislative agenda recommendations
i. Recommendation Timeline and Process
1. The Commission focused on state legislative recommendations because
those recommendations were due to the City by August 22, 2026.
2. The Commission discussed using highlighted priorities and stakeholder
input to identify a proposed slate rather than drafting full final language
during the meeting.
3. Commissioners discussed that the compressed timeline limited the ability
to refine language as extensively as in prior years but agreed that a
timely submission was important.
ii. Implementation and Sustainable Funding
1. Commissioners discussed a broad theme that recently enacted human-
rights-related and housing laws must be implemented effectively, without
weakening, watering down, or creating loopholes before delayed
effective dates.
2. Discussion included the need for implementation structures, guidance,
sustainable funding, staffing, and capacity so new laws do not become
unfunded or unsupported mandates.
3. Commissioners discussed distinguishing between state-level legislative
asks, City-level implementation questions, and issues requiring further
investigation before a recommendation can be made.
4. Staff encouraged the Commission to frame recommendations with a
concrete “by” statement, such as by increasing funding, enacting
legislation, or creating enabling legislation, so City Council can
understand the requested action.
5. Commissioners discussed moving some implementation questions, such
as local use of property tax exemptions, right-of-first-refusal tools, LIHTC
or property registry issues, and rental property registries, into City-level
recommendations or an items-to-investigate category.
iii. Tenant Protections and Habitability
1. Commissioners discussed supporting implementation of recently enacted
housing and tenant-protection laws, including tenant assertion reforms,
anti-retaliation protections, ability to pay rent with legal tender, and
habitability defenses.
2. The Commission heard that implementation of the 14-day pay-or-quit
requirement appears to be proceeding smoothly based on available
tenant-facing experience.
3. Commissioners discussed that habitability protections should cover safe
and healthy housing conditions and not only immediately life-threatening
conditions or fire hazards.
4. Discussion included examples such as severe pest infestation, mold, and
other unsafe conditions that may not fall within a narrow survival-based
standard.
5. Commissioners discussed that a recommendation could support
implementation of enacted protections while also seeking to strengthen
or clarify the habitability defense.
iv. Housing Affordability, Deeply Affordable Housing, and Housing Stability
1. The Commission discussed state support for deeply affordable housing,
including housing affordable to people at or below approximately 30
percent of area median income and to workers earning minimum wage
or low hourly wages.
2. Commissioners discussed the distinctions among permanent supportive
housing, public housing, site-based subsidy, LIHTC-supported housing,
and other forms of affordable housing.
3. Discussion included the need to protect recent housing funding
increases and extend funding beyond single-year appropriations so
localities and providers can plan for capacity, development, and service
delivery over multiple years.
4. Commissioners discussed continued funding for eviction-prevention and
housing-stability programs, including the Virginia Eviction Reduction
Program, noting that recent funding increases should be sustained
beyond the current cycle.
v. Junk Fees and Housing Cost Burdens
1. Commissioners discussed junk fees as a state legislative priority
because mandatory fees can function as rent increases and worsen
affordability.
2. Examples discussed included trash collection or delivery fees, water
delivery fees, alarm system fees, mandatory internet packages, and
other charges that residents may not be able to avoid.
3. Commissioners noted that recent disclosure requirements are helpful but
do not eliminate the underlying burden of mandatory or predatory fees.
4. Discussion emphasized that voucher holders and lower-income tenants
may be especially affected when subsidies do not cover fees labeled as
utilities, services, or add-ons.
vi. Wage Theft and Access to Recourse
1. Commissioners discussed wage theft and enforcement barriers raised by
immigrant-community stakeholders.
2. Proposed language focused on strengthening enforcement mechanisms
and ensuring workers have access to recourse regardless of language
barriers or immigration status.
3. Commissioners noted that existing federal protections may apply in
some circumstances but that practical access to legal help and
enforcement remains a significant concern.
4. The Commission discussed that this issue may require additional
research to identify the best state-level legislative mechanism.
vii. Access to Counsel and Legal Aid Capacity
1. Commissioners discussed access to counsel as a recurring theme
across eviction, habitability, wage theft, and other civil legal issues.
2. Discussion included stakeholder input that right-to-counsel enabling
authority may already exist but that funding restrictions may limit when
legal aid attorneys can appear in eviction cases.
3. Commissioners discussed the need for attorney access at early eviction
stages, including first-return hearings, where tenants may need help
understanding whether to admit the debt, contest the case, or request a
trial.
4. Staff agreed to follow up with a stakeholder at a statewide human rights
gathering regarding legal-aid funding restrictions and representation at
first-return hearings.
viii. Anti-Rent-Gouging and Good-Cause Eviction Protections
1. Commissioners discussed whether to include anti-rent-gouging
legislation even though prior bill language may require revision.
2. Commissioners noted that rent increases and nonrenewal of leases
remain significant tenant-stability issues.
3. Discussion included support for including good-cause eviction or
nonrenewal protections among the issues reflected in the
recommendation slate, even if a current bill sponsor is uncertain.
ix. Proposed Slate and Final Draft Process
1. Commissioners agreed that the final recommendation document should
synthesize highlighted items, remove or park items better suited to City-
level recommendations, and present a focused state legislative slate.
2. Commissioners agreed that the Chair and Vice Chair would prepare final
language after the meeting and circulate a draft for commissioner review.
3. Commissioners discussed sharing a draft around 5:00 pm the next day,
accepting comments or suggestions, and finalizing the submission by
Saturday, August 22, 2026.
x. Motion: Jessica Cocciolone moved to adopt the proposed slate of legislative
recommendations and authorize the Chair and Vice Chair to create a final draft
for submission to City Council.
1. Second: Heather Roberson Gaston seconded the motion.
2. Vote:
a. In favor: 7
b. Can live with: 0
c. Opposed: 0
d. Abstained: 0
3. Motion passed unanimously.
xi. Key Decisions
1. The Commission adopted the proposed slate of legislative
recommendations and authorized the Chair and Vice Chair to create a
final draft for submission to City Council.
2. The Chair and Vice Chair will synthesize the highlighted
recommendation items into a final draft, with commissioner review by
email before submission.
3. City-level policy questions and items requiring additional research will be
set aside for later local policy work or follow-up investigation.
b. Work Plan check-in
i. Tabled.
c. New Business
i. No new business was recorded.
d. Decision regarding next Work Session on 09/03/2026
i. Key Decision
1. The Commission decided not to hold the September 3, 2026, work
session.
6. MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
a. PUBLIC COMMENT
i. None.
b. COMMISSION RESPONSE TO MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
i. None.
7. COMMISSIONER UPDATES
a. Free Bridge Encampment and Emergency Shelter Update
i. A commissioner reported that the Free Bridge encampment was scheduled to be
cleared as of September 1, 2026, and that community providers and advocates
were closely monitoring the process.
ii. Emergency Shelter Capacity and Related Housing Resources
1. The Commission heard that the emergency shelter is expected to have
120 beds, compared with 54 existing Salvation Army beds in the
community.
2. The commissioner reported that another shelter option may add capacity
later in the fall and that Vista 29 is expected to provide repurposed hotel
housing for people experiencing chronic homelessness beginning in
January.
3. The Commission heard that 42 of the 80 Vista 29 units are expected to
have vouchers set aside for people experiencing chronic homelessness.
iii. Encampment Assessments and Outreach
1. The commissioner reported that, as of June 8, 2026, approximately 118
people were at the encampment, though fewer people remained by the
meeting date.
2. The Commission heard that intakes had been completed with 42 people
and that assessments were expected to continue.
3. The commissioner stated that four outreach workers were being hired to
support the transition.
iv. Shelter Access and Harm Reduction Concerns
1. The Commission heard concerns about accessibility and shelter rules,
including top-bunk limitations, pets, couples, gender-separated sleeping
arrangements, respite beds, and access to bathrooms and showers
during renovations.
2. The commissioner reported that one pet is expected to be allowed per
person and that sleeping areas would be gender-separated, while day
space would allow mixed-gender use.
3. Concerns were raised about harm reduction, including whether the
shelter would have an amnesty box or secure process for drugs,
paraphernalia, needles, weapons, and tools that residents may not be
allowed to bring into the shelter.
4. The commissioner stated that pets, couples, and substance-use-related
concerns appear to be among the primary issues raised by community
members.
v. Community Care, Data Collection, and Follow-Up
1. The commissioner stated that, based on current information, the City
does not appear to be planning arrests, although community concerns
about police presence and encampment closure remain.
2. The Commission discussed the need to balance intake data collection
with trust-building, because intakes are required to connect people to
housing subsidies and services but can create fear among people who
have reasons to distrust systems.
3. The commissioner planned to attend a Continuum of Care meeting the
following day and share any substantive updates with commissioners.
8. NEXT STEPS
a. Key Decisions
i. The July 16, 2026, regular meeting minutes were approved by a vote of 6 in
favor, 0 can live with, 0 opposed, and 0 abstained.
ii. The Commission adopted the proposed slate of legislative recommendations and
authorized the Chair and Vice Chair to create a final draft for submission to City
Council.
iii. The Chair and Vice Chair will circulate draft recommendation language for
commissioner review before final submission.
iv. City-level policy issues and issues requiring more investigation will be carried
forward for later City policy work or follow-up.
v. The Commission will not hold the September 3, 2026, work session.
b. Action items
i. Heather Roberson Gaston and Elizabeth Stark
1. Draft and finalize the annual state legislative recommendation letter or
slate for submission to City Council based on the highlighted priorities
discussed by the Commission.
a. Deadline/timing: Draft to be circulated around 5:00 pm on Friday,
August 21, 2026, if feasible; final submission by Saturday,
August 22, 2026.
2. Incorporate commissioner comments and stakeholder-informed
language, where feasible, before final submission.
a. Deadline/timing: Before final submission on Saturday, August 22,
2026.
3. Separate state-level recommendations from City-level policy issues and
items requiring further research.
a. Deadline/timing: During drafting and before final submission.
ii. Elizabeth Stark
1. Share any substantive updates from the Continuum of Care meeting or
other Free Bridge encampment follow-up.
a. Deadline/timing: After the meeting as updates become available.
2. Add or provide VPLC/legal-aid notes regarding right-to-counsel funding,
first-return eviction hearings, and related access-to-counsel issues.
a. Deadline/timing: As available; before future recommendation
discussion if needed.
iii. Todd / staff
1. Support final submission of the legislative recommendations to the City
process, as needed.
a. Deadline/timing: By Saturday, August 22, 2026, or as soon as
the final draft is ready.
2. Follow up with Christy Morrow or other appropriate stakeholders
regarding legal-aid funding restrictions, right-to-counsel authority, and
representation at first-return eviction hearings.
a. Deadline/timing: At or after the statewide human rights
commissions gathering.
3. Share the Office of Human Rights work plan and three-year goals with
the Commission after receiving City management feedback.
a. Deadline/timing: In a future agenda packet.
4. Continue the policy and impact analyst hiring process and update the
Commission when the process advances.
a. Deadline/timing: Ongoing; anticipated update before or at the
October meeting if feasible.
iv. All commissioners
1. Review the draft legislative recommendations when circulated and
provide comments or suggested edits promptly.
a. Deadline/timing: After the draft is circulated, with feedback
before final submission on Saturday, August 22, 2026.
2. Continue identifying City-level policy issues and questions that should be
moved into the later City policy recommendation process.
a. Deadline/timing: Ongoing before the City policy
recommendations discussion.
3. Share any concerns or information related to the Free Bridge
encampment transition, emergency shelter access, or community care
issues with Commission leadership or staff.
a. Deadline/timing: As information becomes available.
c. Items to verify
i. Verify statutory details, effective dates, and implementation status for recently
enacted tenant-protection and housing laws before finalizing detailed
recommendation language.
ii. Verify the appropriate state or local mechanism for junk fee regulation, wage-
theft enforcement, legal-aid/right-to-counsel funding, and good-cause eviction or
nonrenewal protections.
iii. Verify whether local implementation questions related to property tax
exemptions, right-of-first-refusal tools, rental property registries, and LIHTC or
property registry information should be addressed through City policy
recommendations or stakeholder follow-up.
iv. Verify updated information regarding the Free Bridge encampment transition,
shelter rules, accessibility, harm-reduction practices, and emergency shelter
capacity as additional information becomes available.
9. ADJOURN
a. Meeting adjourned at 8:06 pm.
Attachment IV
Human Rights Commission
Meeting Minutes
Special Meeting: Case 2025-2 Public Administrative Appeal Hearing
Thursday, August 27, 2026
City Space, 100 5th Street NE, Charlottesville, VA 22902
6:00 pm
1. WELCOME
a. CALL TO ORDER
i. Presiding member, Vice Chair, Elizabeth Stark, called the meeting to order at
6:03 pm.
b. ROLL CALL
i. Present
1. Elizabeth Stark, Vice Chair, presiding member
2. Callum McCain von Schill
3. Dawn Lawson
ii. Absent
1. The above commissioners comprised the entirety of the hearing panel,
as appointed by the full Commission during a public regular meeting on
February 19, 2026.
2. HEARING PANEL DISCUSSION
a. Procedural Review and Scope of Hearing
i. The presiding member reviewed the hearing procedures for the public
administrative appeal in Case 2025-2, including that the complainant requested
Commission review of the Director’s finding of no reasonable cause.
ii. Staff clarified that the case was filed under the version of the Human Rights
Ordinance in effect before the August 3, 2026, amendments.
iii. Staff explained that the hearing panel could uphold the Director’s finding,
overturn the finding, or identify additional information needed before a final
determination.
iv. Staff described possible next steps if the finding were overturned, including
recommending that the parties revisit alternative dispute resolution through
mediation, recommending further action by the City Attorney and City Council
where authorized, or making recommendations to the respondent.
v. Staff noted that mediation would remain voluntary for both parties and that the
Commission does not have authority to award damages, issue injunctive orders,
or compel a respondent to provide a remedy.
b. Review of Case Record and Investigation
i. The hearing panel acknowledged the detail, professionalism, and thoroughness
of the investigative record and staff work.
ii. The panel used the investigative report and determination as the framework for
discussion, focusing primarily on the two issues and elements identified in the
case record.
iii. The panel discussed that the absence of corroborating evidence created
evidentiary limits, but that the record also raised questions about whether
additional information could clarify the workplace context and the respondent’s
handling of the complainant’s concerns.
c. Issue One: Alleged Race-Based Hostile Work Environment
i. The panel discussed the allegation that the complainant was subjected to a
hostile work environment based on race, including alleged intentional
mispronunciation of the complainant’s name, comments about racial background
or family, culturally or racially insensitive remarks, differential treatment, and
ostracism.
ii. Discussion included the medication-cart shift-change incident, internal workplace
conflict reports, the role of witnesses, and the extent to which the record did or
did not corroborate specific alleged race-based comments.
iii. Panel members discussed concerns that workplace conflicts may have gone
undocumented or unresolved and that the complainant may not have felt safe
reporting all concerns through ordinary workplace channels.
iv. The panel discussed whether the record suggested broader workplace culture
concerns, clique dynamics, colorism or multiracial identity concerns, and whether
those dynamics could have affected how the complainant experienced the
workplace.
v. The panel also discussed workload, patient-safety concerns, medication
administration, charting, patient care duties, breaks, and whether the
complainant’s reports about other employees’ conduct or work performance were
investigated or addressed by the respondent.
vi. Panel members discussed whether the complainant was labeled as someone
who “runs to HR” and whether management or HR took steps to prevent that
label from contributing to isolation or retaliation.
d. Issue Two: Termination, Discipline, and Possible Retaliation or Pretext
i. The panel discussed whether the respondent had nondiscriminatory reasons for
termination, including medication administration and documentation concerns,
controlled-substance record issues, attendance or call-out issues, and other
workplace conduct.
ii. Discussion included whether progressive discipline, performance improvement
plans, rebuttal opportunities, call-out policies, medication-error policies, and
similar workplace rules were applied consistently to the complainant and to
similarly situated employees.
iii. The panel discussed evidence concerning text messages to a coworker’s spouse
and other interpersonal conduct, noting that some conduct raised legitimate
workplace concerns while also considering the broader workplace context in
which it occurred.
iv. The panel discussed whether the complainant may have engaged in conduct that
gave the respondent legitimate concerns, while still leaving unanswered
questions about differential treatment, possible retaliation, or whether the
respondent applied its policies consistently.
e. Additional Questions Identified for Follow-Up
i. The panel identified several areas where additional information could assist the
hearing panel before a final determination is made.
1. What action, if any, HR or management took in response to the
complainant’s reports about other employees’ work performance, patient
safety, medication handling, wound care, and staff conduct.
2. Whether those concerns were verified, resolved, or continued after they
were reported.
3. Whether HR or management knew that the complainant was being
characterized as someone who “runs to HR,” and how that issue was
addressed.
4. The timing of alleged race-based comments, harassment, or workplace
isolation relative to the complainant’s reports to HR or management.
5. Whether call-out, progressive-discipline, performance-improvement-plan,
medication-error, and rebuttal policies were applied consistently across
similarly situated employees.
6. Whether additional employees named or referenced in the record should
be interviewed to determine what they observed or knew.
7. Whether the respondent had received prior complaints of race-based
harassment, discrimination, or similar workplace concerns, and how any
such complaints were handled.
8. Whether the complainant had supervisory, lead-worker, or shift-lead
authority over other staff and how that affected expectations,
responsibilities, or discipline.
9. Whether additional context regarding the complainant’s communications
with a coworker’s spouse would clarify the record.
f. Panel Deliberation
i. The panel discussed whether to render a final determination during the hearing
or seek additional information first.
ii. One panel member stated an inclination to uphold the Director’s determination
based on the existing record, while the majority expressed that the unanswered
questions should be pursued before a final determination is made.
iii. The majority concluded that additional investigation and a follow-up hearing were
appropriate before the panel decides whether to uphold or overturn the Director’s
finding.
3. HEARING PANEL DECISION
a. Motion: Callum McCain von Schill moved to reopen the investigation into Case 2025 -2
and hold a follow-up public hearing after the questions raised in the discussion are
answered.
i. Second: Dawn Lawson seconded the motion.
ii. Vote:
1. In favor: 2
2. Opposed: 1
3. Abstained: 0
iii. Motion passed.
b. Key Decision
i. The hearing panel voted to reopen the investigation into Case 2025-2 and hold a
follow-up public hearing after additional questions are answered.
4. NEXT STEPS
a. Key Decisions
i. The hearing panel did not render a final determination on the Director’s finding of
no reasonable cause during this hearing.
ii. The investigation will be reopened for follow-up on the questions identified by the
hearing panel.
iii. A follow-up public hearing will be held after the additional information is available
for review.
b. Action items
i. Office of Human Rights staff
1. Reopen the investigation and coordinate follow-up on the questions
identified during the hearing panel discussion.
a. Deadline/timing: After the hearing and before the follow-up public
hearing.
2. Determine whether additional witnesses named or referenced in the
record should be interviewed.
a. Deadline/timing: During the reopened investigation.
3. Seek additional information regarding HR or management responses to
the complainant’s workplace concerns, policy application, prior
complaints, and other questions identified by the hearing panel.
a. Deadline/timing: During the reopened investigation.
4. Coordinate scheduling, notice, and materials for a follow-up public
hearing after additional information is gathered.
a. Deadline/timing: After additional information is available.
ii. Hearing panel members
1. Review additional information provided after the investigation is
reopened.
a. Deadline/timing: Before the follow-up public hearing.
2. Participate in the follow-up public hearing and make a final determination
based on the record and additional information received.
a. Deadline/timing: At the follow-up public hearing.
5. ADJOURN
a. Meeting adjourned at 8:11 pm.
Attachment V
Human Rights Commission
Meeting Minutes
Regular Meeting
September 17, 2026
City Space, 100 5th Street NE, Charlottesville, VA 22902
6:00 pm
1. WELCOME
a. CALL TO ORDER
i. Chair, Heather Roberson Gaston, called the meeting to order at 6:03 pm.
b. ROLL CALL
i. Present
1. Heather Roberson Gaston
2. Elizabeth Stark
3. Callum McCain von Schill
4. Mariane Asad Doyle
ii. Absent
1. Dawn Lawson
2. Emily Currier (out of town)
3. Jessica Cocciolone (providing family care)
4. Suzanne Lynn (out of town)
iii. Staff noted that quorum was not present at the beginning of the meeting,
and the minutes review was moved later in the agenda.
c. MISSION (recited by all): Act as a strong advocate to justice and equal
opportunity by providing citywide leadership and guidance in the area of civil
rights.
2. MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
a. PUBLIC COMMENT
i. No public comment was received at the beginning of the meeting.
b. COMMISSION RESPONSE TO MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
i. No Commission response was required.
3. MINUTES
a. Review of minutes from 08/20/2026 HRC Regular Meeting
i. Vote tabled due to lack of quorum.
b. Review of minutes from 08/27/2026 HRC Special Meeting – Case 2025-2 Public
Hearing
i. Vote tabled due to absence of one of three panel members.
4. BUSINESS MATTERS
a. CHAIR UPDATE
i. State Legislative Recommendations
1. The Chair reported that much of the prior several months had
focused on preparing the Commission’s annual state legislative
recommendations.
2. The Chair noted that staff and Commissioners completed
significant behind-the-scenes work to identify pending legislation
and reliable legislative information sources.
3. The Chair stated that the recommendation package submitted to
City Council included more supporting information than in past
years and reflected extensive stakeholder input.
4. Discussion noted that several issues the Commission had
recommended in prior years have now become law, including
expansion of the pay-or-quit period from five days to fourteen
days.
ii. Commission Membership and Recruitment
1. The Chair noted that the Commission has one current vacancy
and that some Commissioners’ terms may end in the coming
months.
2. The Chair encouraged the Commission to think about recruitment
and future membership, particularly as more experienced
Commissioners may rotate off the Commission.
b. OHR STAFF REPORT
i. Board and Commission Appointment Cycle
1. Staff reported that additional applications for the Commission had
been received and that City Council is expected to consider
appointments during an upcoming appointment cycle.
2. Staff noted that one Commissioner may have been re-presented
for consideration because they were completing an unfinished
term.
ii. Recently Enacted Housing Legislation
1. Staff reported on a presentation by the City Attorney’s Office
regarding recently enacted state legislation affecting City services,
including matters likely to affect Neighborhood Development
Services.
2. Staff noted interest in new state-law language allowing localities to
set policies and take measures to support the creation of
affordable housing.
3. Discussion included that the breadth of that language may raise
future questions about what local affordable-housing measures
are permissible, including possible measures that could be tested
by localities and courts.
iii. Hiring Update
1. Staff reported that Haadiya Ahmed had been selected for the
Policy and Impact Analyst position and was expected to begin on
September 28, 2026.
2. Staff noted that the new staff member will support the Commission
after onboarding and may eventually take on some Commission-
related tasks currently performed by the Director.
iv. Legislative Recommendation Timeline
1. Staff reported that the City’s legislative recommendation timeline
has shifted over time and that the deadline may move earlier next
year, possibly to June.
2. Commissioners and staff discussed concern that a June deadline
would be difficult because the General Assembly session, budget
process, stakeholder availability, and legislator priorities may not
be settled by then.
3. A Commissioner stated that a substantially earlier deadline would
make it difficult for recommendations to be grounded in
stakeholder input, especially because many advocacy partners
and legislative leads are unavailable during early summer.
4. The Commission discussed that more conversation will be needed
with City staff and City Council about a workable timeline for future
legislative recommendations.
v. Meeting Location and Scheduling
1. Staff reported that the October 15, 2026, regular meeting will be
held at the Parks and Recreation location because City Space
was unavailable.
2. Staff and Commissioners discussed coordinating building access
and reminding Commissioners and guests of the location change
in advance of the meeting.
vi. Chief Prosperity Officer Introduction
1. Staff introduced Joshua Barr as the City’s Chief Prosperity Officer
and described the role as the position previously held by Ashley
Reynolds Marshall.
2. The Commission welcomed the Chief Prosperity Officer and noted
that his background is directly related to human rights and
community prosperity work.
vii. Outreach and Statewide Human Rights Collaboration
1. Staff reported plans to table at Cville Sabroso with a
representative from Albemarle County and to co-table at Pride the
following weekend.
2. Staff reported that representatives from human rights
commissions around Virginia are scheduled to gather in Richmond
on October 3, 2026, for a statewide convening.
3. The statewide gathering is expected to include representatives
from multiple commissions, speakers, and discussion of rebuilding
informal statewide human rights commission collaboration.
5. WORK SESSION
a. OHR Intern Presentation – Kattalin Bennett
i. Student Housing, Affordability, and Neighborhood Equity
1. Office of Human Rights Intern Kattalin Bennett presented research
on student-oriented luxury housing, student needs, affordability,
and neighborhood equity, prompted in part by community
concerns about The Mark and development impacts in Fifeville.
2. The presentation framed the issue as a fragmented housing
system rather than a simple conflict between students and long-
term residents.
3. The presenter described how UVA enrollment and on-grounds
housing capacity, City zoning and affordability policy, private
developer incentives, and student housing choices interact without
one coordinated process to determine what housing is needed, at
what price, and in which locations.
4. The research questions addressed how students are affected by
Charlottesville’s housing market, whether luxury student housing
meaningfully addresses student need, how The Mark could affect
Fifeville, and what actions may be available to the Commission.
5. Research methods included a student survey with approximately
48 usable responses, review of City documents and housing
policies, comparison of nearby student-housing developments,
and review of community testimony and available housing data.
6. The presenter noted that the survey sample was a convenience
sample weighted toward third- and fourth-year undergraduate
students and should not be treated as representative of all UVA
students.
ii. Student Survey and Tenant-Resource Findings
1. The survey indicated that price and location were the highest-
ranked student housing priorities, while amenities ranked lower.
2. The presenter reported that approximately 87 percent of
respondents said price mattered when choosing housing.
3. The presenter also reported that approximately 84 percent of
respondents were unfamiliar with UVA Student Legal Services or
other tenant resources available to students or renters.
4. Discussion noted that students often sign leases early in their first
year and may be first-time renters who review leases primarily
with family members rather than tenant-resource professionals.
5. The presentation described a perceived market choice between
expensive newer housing and older housing that may cost less
but may also involve maintenance or quality concerns.
iii. Student-Housing Design, Pricing, and Household Fit
1. The presentation used nearby student-housing floor plans and
pricing to illustrate why counting units or beds alone does not
show whom the housing serves.
2. Examples discussed included individual leasing models, four-
bedroom/four-bathroom units designed for unrelated student
roommates, and one-bedroom rents that appeared substantially
above a 2026 one-bedroom voucher payment benchmark used in
the research.
3. The presenter emphasized that student-oriented floor plans and
individual leasing models may not translate into usable housing for
families, lower-income students, long-term residents, or other
workers in the broader Charlottesville community.
iv. Neighborhood Impacts, Pipeline, and The Mark
1. The presentation discussed how student-oriented housing can
affect land values, redevelopment expectations, transportation
patterns, parking, and the availability of older or comparatively
lower-cost housing for non-student residents.
2. The presenter emphasized that these cumulative concerns are
particularly significant in Fifeville because of its history as a
historically Black neighborhood and existing economic and
demographic pressures.
3. The presentation discussed the broader student-housing pipeline,
including large developments near UVA, existing luxury buildings
with available leases or discounts, and UVA’s plans to increase
on-grounds housing for second-year students.
4. The presenter stated that The Mark would add 181 units,
contribute approximately $4.5 million to the affordable housing
fund, and retain and rehabilitate two protected historic houses, but
would provide no affordable units on site under its student-housing
designation.
5. The presenter raised concerns about the contested half-mile
boundary used for the student-housing designation, the lack of
final rent and bedroom-count information, and the absence of a
complete public picture of student demand, occupancy, rents, and
beds entering the market.
v. Student-Housing Recommendations Presented
1. The presenter recommended that the City and UVA collect and
publish data on enrollment, on-grounds capacity, private housing
capacity, occupancy, rents, fees, and demand at different price
levels.
2. The presenter recommended connecting development incentives
to public outcomes and evaluating whether student-housing
affordability exemptions produce sufficient public benefits.
3. The presenter recommended clarifying City and UVA
responsibility for housing impacts, evaluating cumulative
development effects, and including affected students and
surrounding neighborhoods earlier in development conversations.
vi. Discussion Following Student-Housing Presentation
1. Commissioners thanked the presenter and noted that the research
offered a helpful student perspective on housing affordability,
student demand, and neighborhood impact.
2. Discussion included whether assumptions that all new capacity
improves affordability may overlook specialized housing that is
expensive, student-oriented, and not usable by families or many
other households.
3. Commissioners discussed the need to share the research with
decision makers, student groups, community organizations, and
other stakeholders who are engaged in housing and development
conversations.
4. Discussion included that some students rely on family support,
loans, or other assistance to pay rent and that UVA tuition support
does not necessarily resolve food, housing, or other cost-of-living
barriers.
5. Commissioners discussed the possibility of a rental property
registry or similar tool to track units, bedroom counts, rents, rent
increases, property conditions, and related housing information.
6. Commissioners also discussed revisiting student-housing zoning
provisions, the interpretation of the relevant boundary, and
whether current rules allow student-oriented developments to
affect neighborhoods in ways that do not match the housing needs
of students or residents.
b. OHR Intern Presentation – Shounak Reza
i. Mental Health Care Access and Co-Occurring Needs
1. Office of Human Rights Intern Shounak Reza presented research
on access to mental health care in Charlottesville, informed by
case-history review, stakeholder conversations, and personal
experience with different forms of insurance and payment.
2. The presentation emphasized co-occurrence, meaning that mental
health needs often intersect with substance use, discrimination,
loss of income, housing insecurity, food insecurity, physical health,
and other challenges.
3. The presenter noted that although the Office of Human Rights
focuses on discrimination, complainants may also need support
addressing related needs that affect their ability to navigate
discrimination, housing, employment, and health challenges.
ii. Community Mental Health Resources Discussed
1. The presenter described Partner for Mental Health as an
organization that recognizes co-occurring needs and provides
holistic supports, including reentry-related support, employment
and housing connections, medication support, and related
services.
2. The presentation discussed the mental health therapeutic docket
as a restorative model for people charged with misdemeanors or
lower-level felonies whose conduct may be informed by mental
health or substance-use issues.
3. The presentation also discussed HART and ANCHOR as
programs that involve EMTs and mental health providers in
responding to mental health needs without necessarily relying on
law enforcement.
4. The presenter discussed Region 10 services, including case
management, needs assessment, referral support, short-term
therapy, the Blue Ridge Center, and the Wellness Recovery
Center.
5. The presenter noted that the Blue Ridge Center offers low-barrier,
free support such as support groups and walk-in therapy, while
some other services may accept Medicaid or operate on a sliding
scale.
6. The presentation also discussed On Our Own as a nonprofit
resource offering free or low-barrier peer support, creative-writing
opportunities, and related services.
iii. Mental Health Access Barriers and Recommendations Presented
1. The presenter identified barriers including Medicaid eligibility and
coverage disruptions, limited acceptance of private insurance for
some services, inability to pay out of pocket, funding restrictions,
administrative burdens, licensing requirements, and provider
retention challenges.
2. The presenter recommended that Council and policymakers
recognize co-occurring needs and consider administrative,
logistical, and funding gaps when developing policies or
recommendations.
3. The presenter also recommended increasing public awareness of
community mental health resources and alternatives to
emergency services or 911 when people need support.
iv. Discussion Following Mental Health Presentation
1. Commissioners thanked the presenter and connected the
presentation to prior stakeholder conversations with Region 10,
including issues related to behavioral health workforce gaps,
licensing requirements, Medicaid coverage, and funding.
2. Discussion included that Medicaid navigation may be important
because some people lose coverage or believe they remain
covered when they no longer do.
3. A Commissioner suggested adding the Women’s Initiative to the
resource discussion because it offers free services focused on
women, transgender clients, and people of color, and because
domestic violence and eviction risk can intersect with mental
health needs.
4. Discussion also included the community street sheet as a
resource guide that may be useful beyond people experiencing
homelessness if more widely distributed and better understood.
5. The Chief Prosperity Officer reported checking the statewide 2-1-1
call system during the discussion and finding that local
Charlottesville resources referenced in the presentation did not
appear, raising a possible resource-mapping or data-entry gap.
6. The Chief Prosperity Officer offered to follow up with colleagues to
understand why Charlottesville resources may not be appearing
through 2-1-1 and how the issue might be corrected.
7. Commissioners discussed inviting Sue Hess from Partner for
Mental Health, who is also connected with ANCHOR and HART,
to participate in future stakeholder engagement.
c. City Policy community stakeholder engagement planning
i. Local Recommendation Timeline and Stakeholder Meeting Planning
1. The Commission discussed preparing for local policy
recommendations and noted that prior stakeholder meetings and
Commissioner notes have already generated potential local
recommendation topics.
2. Commissioners discussed using the October 15, 2026, regular
meeting as a stakeholder-focused meeting to gather additional
input before developing or finalizing City policy recommendations.
3. The Commission discussed that City policy recommendations may
allow more flexible timing than state legislative recommendations,
particularly where recommendations are not tied to the General
Assembly calendar.
4. Commissioners discussed that some City-level recommendations
may need to be raised earlier if they are tied to the City budget or
urgent local decisions, while other issues may require additional
research before submission.
ii. Potential Stakeholders and Presenters
1. Potential stakeholder invitees discussed included PHAR, the UVA
Office for Equal Opportunity and Civil Rights, Partner for Mental
Health, ANCHOR, HART, Neighborhood Development Services,
Charlottesville Low Income Housing Coalition, and additional
housing or economic-development stakeholders.
2. Commissioners discussed inviting a representative connected to
the Commonwealth Housing Coalition or YIMBY Action to learn
more about affordable-housing legislation and statewide housing-
policy proposals.
3. Commissioners discussed inviting City staff or related
stakeholders who could address student housing, UVA housing
coordination, economic development, short-term rentals, vacant
properties, rental registries, and the relationship between job
growth and housing affordability.
4. Discussion included possible UVA contacts related to student
housing, the UVA Foundation, or real-estate planning, with the
goal of understanding how UVA and private-development
decisions affect the City housing market.
iii. Right to Counsel and Civil Legal Access
1. A Commissioner summarized a conversation with the Virginia
Poverty Law Center regarding right to counsel and effective right-
to-counsel efforts related to eviction defense.
2. Discussion included that prior local efforts increased eviction
engagement but were limited because implementation did not fully
align with the legal partners who would provide counsel and
because sufficient funding remained a challenge.
3. The Commission discussed whether local authority or the City
charter may allow a locality to enact or fund a stronger right-to-
counsel program and whether the Richmond model should be
reviewed.
4. A Commissioner committed to researching the Richmond right-to-
counsel or effective right-to-counsel program and sharing findings
with the Commission.
iv. Rental Registry, Vacant Properties, Short-Term Rentals, and Zoning
1. Commissioners discussed a rental property registry as a potential
City-level recommendation to help track housing units, bedroom
counts, rents, rent increases, property conditions, and related
data.
2. Discussion included that rental registries in other localities may be
connected to inspection systems and may be piloted in areas with
reported conditions concerns or violations.
3. The Commission discussed vacant or underused houses, short-
term rental or Airbnb enforcement, and the need to understand
existing City ordinances and enforcement practices before making
recommendations.
4. Commissioners discussed zoning-code issues, student-housing
exemptions, impacts on historically Black neighborhoods, and the
need to create a public record of the concerns the Commission
has heard from residents and community stakeholders.
v. Economic Development, UVA Coordination, and Housing Need
1. The Commission discussed whether City economic development
strategies are being coordinated with housing affordability,
especially if new jobs are attracted to the area without sufficient
affordable housing for workers.
2. Discussion included whether Economic Development,
Neighborhood Development Services, and UVA representatives
could help the Commission understand how business recruitment,
student housing, medical-center employment, and private
development interact.
3. Commissioners discussed whether student-oriented housing can
serve other groups, such as medical-center workers, graduate
students, or families, and raised concerns that some floor plans
are too specialized to meet broader housing needs.
vi. Potential Drafting Approach
1. The Chair offered to draft and circulate a synthesis of community
testimony and potential local recommendations related to zoning,
development impacts, Fifeville, 10th and Page, and other
historically Black neighborhoods.
2. The Chair stated that the draft could include more detail than may
ultimately be used so the Commission can narrow and refine
recommendations during later discussion.
3. Commissioners discussed the possibility of using the November
19, 2026, regular meeting for additional City staff or stakeholder
input and, if feasible, recommendation discussion or adoption.
d. Work Plan check-in
i. The Commission discussed the work plan in connection with the City
policy stakeholder engagement planning described above.
ii. Discussion focused on using the October and November regular
meetings for stakeholder input, drafting, and possible action on local
policy recommendations.
e. New business
i. No additional new business was recorded.
f. Decision regarding next Work Session on 10/01/2026
i. Commissioners present discussed not holding the October 1, 2026, work
session and proceeding to the October 15, 2026, regular meeting instead.
6. MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
a. PUBLIC COMMENT
i. No public comment was received at the end of the meeting.
b. COMMISSION RESPONSE TO MATTERS BY THE PUBLIC
i. No Commission response was required.
7. COMMISSIONER UPDATES
a. Holiday Drive Shelter, Family Shelter, and Related Housing Updates
i. A Commissioner reported that the Holiday Drive shelter had reached
approximately 64 residents and had needed to expand beyond its initially
anticipated capacity.
ii. The Commissioner stated that the shelter appears to be meeting a
significant community need, but that intakes had slowed and the shelter
could not accept everyone seeking placement.
iii. Discussion noted that additional seasonal shelter capacity is expected to
come online later in the fall and that it is likely to fill as well.
iv. The Commissioner reported that the Salvation Army family shelter had
opened, but that available family units are far below the need, with one
family reported as being number 37 on the waitlist.
v. Discussion included the long-term Salvation Army redevelopment, the
Cherry Avenue site as a possible family shelter location, and the need for
additional family shelter capacity.
vi. Commissioners also discussed that Vista 29 is expected to come online
in January and that some units will be subsidized and prioritized for
people experiencing chronic homelessness.
8. NEXT STEPS
a. Key Decisions and Procedural Outcomes
i. Review and approval of the August 20, 2026, regular meeting minutes
were tabled due to lack of quorum.
ii. Review and approval of the August 27, 2026, special meeting minutes
were tabled due to the absence of one of the three hearing panel
members.
iii. The Commissioners present discussed not holding the October 1, 2026,
work session and focusing on the October 15, 2026, regular meeting;
confirm the formal status as needed because quorum was not present.
b. Action items
i. Heather Roberson Gaston
1. Reach out to potential local-policy stakeholders for the October
15, 2026, meeting, including FAR, the UVA Office for Equal
Opportunity and Civil Rights, Partner for Mental Health, and other
community stakeholders discussed during the meeting.
a. Deadline/timing: Before the October 15, 2026, regular
meeting.
2. Draft and circulate a synthesis of community testimony and
potential local recommendations related to zoning, student
housing, development impacts, Fifeville, 10th and Page, and other
historically Black neighborhoods.
a. Deadline/timing: Before the October 15, 2026, regular
meeting, if feasible.
ii. Elizabeth Stark
1. Research the Richmond right-to-counsel or effective right-to-
counsel program, including the City charter question, funding
model, legal-partner structure, and implementation lessons.
a. Deadline/timing: Before future local recommendation
discussion, if feasible.
2. Reach out to the Charlottesville Low Income Housing Coalition
representative discussed during the meeting, if the Commission
proceeds with that stakeholder invitation.
a. Deadline/timing: Before the October 15, 2026, regular
meeting, if feasible.
3. Continue tracking Holiday Drive shelter, family shelter, and Vista
29 updates relevant to local policy recommendations.
a. Deadline/timing: Ongoing as updates become available.
iii. Todd / staff
1. Send Commissioners the October 15, 2026, meeting-location
reminder and related access information for the Parks and
Recreation location.
a. Deadline/timing: Before the October 15, 2026, regular
meeting.
2. Coordinate building access for the October 15, 2026, meeting,
including any door-access arrangements needed for
Commissioners, stakeholders, and members of the public.
a. Deadline/timing: Before the October 15, 2026, regular
meeting.
3. Support stakeholder outreach and help identify appropriate City or
UVA contacts for Neighborhood Development Services, Economic
Development, UVA student housing, UVA Foundation or real-
estate planning, short-term rental enforcement, and related
housing topics.
a. Deadline/timing: Before or in preparation for the October
and November regular meetings.
4. Share the City Attorney’s Office legislative presentation or relevant
information about recently enacted affordable-housing authority if
useful for local recommendation development.
a. Deadline/timing: As local policy recommendation work
continues.
5. Continue onboarding the Policy & Impact Analyst and update the
Commission as the new staff member begins supporting
Commission work.
a. Deadline/timing: After the September 28, 2026, start date
and as onboarding proceeds.
iv. Joshua Barr
1. Follow up on why Charlottesville mental health and related
community resources discussed during the Intern presentation did
not appear in 211 search results and whether the resource data
can be improved.
a. Deadline/timing: As time permits; before or during local
policy recommendation development if feasible.
v. All Commissioners
1. Review local policy recommendation topics and send additional
stakeholder names, policy ideas, or priority areas to Commission
leadership and staff.
a. Deadline/timing: Before the October 15, 2026, regular
meeting, if feasible.
2. Continue identifying City-level policy issues that may warrant
recommendations, including rental registries, zoning and
development impacts, short-term rental or vacancy enforcement,
family shelter capacity, mental health resource access, and civil
legal access.
a. Deadline/timing: Ongoing before City policy
recommendations are finalized..
9. ADJOURN
a. Meeting adjourned at 8:06 pm.
Rethinking Charlottesville’s Student
Housing System
Affordability, Student Needs, and
Neighborhood Equity
Office of Human Rights
Kattalin Bennett September 17th, 2026
Introduction
The conflict lies in a poorly designed system, not between
students and long-term residents
Research Process
Questions
How are students affected by Charlottesville’s housing market?
Does luxury student housing meaningfully address student need?
How could The Mark affect Fifeville?
What actions are available to the Human Rights Commission?
Methods
Student survey
Review of city documents and housing policies
Comparison of nearby student -housing developments
Analysis of community testimony and available housing data
Information in Need of Uncovering
~ Total private and university bed capacity
~ Net-new beds rather than gross development totals
~ Occupancy and pre-leasing rates
~ Expected enrollment growth
~ Rents and mandatory fees
~ Demand at different price levels
~ Which students cannot access existing housing
~ Effects on surrounding neighborhoods
Student Voiced Data
Primary Considerations
Students were asked to rank Price,
Location, Floorplan, Amenities, and
Safety. Price and Location were among
the highest first picks.
Does Price Matter?
Students were asked if the cost of
rent was something they considered
when choosing housing
Awareness of Tenant
Resources
Students were asked if they were
familiar with UVA's Student Legal
Services or other local Charlottesville
tenant resources
Student Voiced Concerns
"CBS Rentals has
raised prices about
10% every year."
""
"The quality of the
buildings for the
price is very low."
"The flats suck they're a scam but
my room is big."
"The flats suck
they're a scam but
my room is big."
"Way too expensive
for decent quality
housing that has in
unit laundry and
relatively new
appliances"
"Just everything
is sooo
expensive even
for bad
housing."
"Off Grounds housing
monopoly is insane.
$1100/month not
including anything,
central A/C, mold issues,
and more."
Specialized
Housing
Yugo Crestline
Apartment:
Dover Layout
4bed/4bath
Individual Rent:
$1,299/month
Yugo Crestline
Apartment:
Avondale Layout
1bed/1bath
Rent:
$2,365/month
Neighborhood Impacts
Land Values
Redevelopment
Expectations
Accessibility to Housing
for Non-Student
Residents
Transportation
Larger Housing Pipeline
Considering the newest development plans, and UVA's 2030 Plan, the purpose of the Mark
as an addition of beds becomes less necessary.
Development Approximate Capacity Anticipated Opening
VERVE 1,332 Beds Summer 2027
Blume on Ivy 640 Beds Fall 2027
UVA Ivy Corridor 750-800 Beds 2027
The Mark 730-770 Beds (181 Units
confirmed)
TBD
The Mark
as an
Illustration
Recommendations
1)Define the Need
Collect data on enrollment, capacity, occupancy, rents, and demand by price.
2)Connect Incentives to Outcomes
Reevaluate whether affordability exemptions produce the public benefits they are
intended to produce.
3)Clarify Responsibility
Establish regular coordination between UVA and the City.
4)Evaluate Cumulative Effects
Consider the complete development pipeline and neighborhood conditions as
opposed to individual projects.
5)Include Affected Communities
Engage students and residents before policies and projects are effectively
finalized.
Accessing Mental Health in
Charlottesville
Shounak Reza
Co-Occurrence
Partner for Mental Health
Staff in:
- Prisons
- The Mental Health Therapeutic Docket: Restorative
justice
- HART
- ANCHOR
Difficulty in accessing care:
Having an advocate in the
community helps.
Services Offered by Region 10
- Case management
- Short-term therapy
- The Blue Ridge Center: Low-barrier support; free
support
- Wellness Recovery Center: Short-term residential
service– accepts Medicaid, but very limited options
when it comes to private insurance. Sliding scale
applies.
On Our Own: Peer support services
Challenges Experienced by Organizations
-Funding (Medicaid)
-Flexibility in funding
-Administrative hurdles
-Providers leaving Charlottesville
-License requirements
-How can the issues be addressed?
-How can people be made more aware?
Attachment VI
City of Charlottesville Office of Human Rights
Monthly Report: October 2026
HRC Work Summary
The table below provides an overview of the work done by the Human Rights Commission in the current calendar year.
Date Roles (Sec. 433) Primary Action Summary & Analysis
2/9/2026
Sec. 2-433. (b) Community
Outreach & Engagement Public Poll
The HRC released a public poll to solicit feedback on human and civil
rights issues that are important to the community. The poll ran from
02/09/26 to 02/23/26 and received 103 responses. Commissioners will use
this information to inform their annual planning for CY2026.
2/19/2026 Sec. 2-433. (a) Individual
Assistance
Public
Discussion
The HRC voted to hold the Appeal Hearing for case 2025-2 by a panel of 3
Commissioners.
4/16/2026 Sec. 2-433. (f)
Commission Policies Policy Review
The HRC reviewed proposed amendments to the Charlottesville Human
Rights Ordinance and voted unanimously to adopt the amendments for
recommendation to City Council. The amendments included minor wording
changes for clarity, changes to membership criteria, updates to the
complaint process procedures, clarification on contracted services for
housing cases, and the addition of a conflict-of-interest clause to the
Commission enforcement section. These changes will be presented to City
Council on June 15, 2026.
4/16/2026 Sec. 2-433. (f)
Commission Policies Policy Review
The HRC reviewed proposed amendments to the HRC Rules & Procedures
and voted unanimously to adopt the changes. The amendments included a
clarification about public notice for emergency meetings and detailed
protocols for the HRC public administrative hearing process.
Date Roles (Sec. 433) Primary Action Summary & Analysis
4/16/2026 Sec. 2-433. (b) Community
Outreach & Engagement
Public
Discussion
The HRC invited Abi Matthew Wade, Economic Mobility Officer, to present
a summary of her work and share data pertaining to key issues of interest
to the HRC including the benefits cliff, challenges faced by asset-limited
income-constrained employed (ALICE) residents, childcare accessibility,
and barriers to economic stability for people with disabilities.
5/21/2026 Sec. 2-433. (f)
Commission Policies Policy Review
The HRC adopted changes to the Rule & Procedures to remove sections
that duplicated language from the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance
and a section about membership terms that was not part of City code.
6/18/2026 Sec. 2-433. (b) Community
Outreach & Engagement
Public
Discussion
Residents of the Fifeville neighborhood spoke to the HRC regarding
concerns about the proposed development at the corner of 7th Street SW
and Delevan Street.
6/18/2026 Sec. 2-433. (e) Legislative
Program
Public
Discussion
The HRC hosted a question-and-answer session with Delegate Katrina
Callsen and Senator Creigh Deeds regarding legislative actions impacting
economic stability.
7/14/2026 Sec. 2-433. (b) Community
Outreach & Engagement
Stakeholder
Meeting
The HRC Chair and HRC Director met with the Executive Director and Sr.
Director of Clinical Operations of the Region Ten Community Services
Board to discuss legislative priorities related to supporting individuals with
disabilities including substance use and mental health.
7/16/2026 Sec. 2-433. (b) Community
Outreach & Engagement
Public
Discussion
The HRC hosted a panel that included representatives from the 10th and
Page Neighborhood Association, Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the
Homeless (BRACH), Legal Aid Justice Center (LAJC), and Sin Barreras.
Commissioners will use the information from this panel to inform their
legislative and City policy recommendations to City Council.
7/19/2026 Sec. 2-433. (b) Community
Outreach & Engagement
Stakeholder
Meeting
The HRC Vice Chair and the HRC Director met with representatives from
the Virginia Poverty Law Center to discuss legislative priorities related to
housing.
Date Roles (Sec. 433) Primary Action Summary & Analysis
8/11/2026 Sec. 2-433. (b) Community
Outreach & Engagement
Stakeholder
Meeting
The HRC Chair, one Commissioner, and the HRC Director met with the
Executive Director of Piedmont Housing Alliance and a representative from
Virginia Housing Alliance to discuss legislative priorities related to Housing.
8/19/2026 Sec. 2-433. (b) Community
Outreach & Engagement
Stakeholder
Meeting
An HRC Commissioner and the HRC Director met with the President of the
Charlottesville Pride Network to learn about the organization, share
information about the HRC, and discuss legislative and City policy priorities
related to the LGBTQIA+ community.
8/20/2026 Sec. 2-433. (e) Legislative
Program
Public
Discussion
Commissioners reviewed consolidated notes from multiple stakeholder
meetings and voted to adopt a slate of legislative recommendations for
submission to City Council.
8/24/2026 Sec. 2-433. (e) Legislative
Program
Council
Recommendati
on
The HRC Chair and Vice Chair finalized the legislative recommendation
document and submitted it to City Council on 8/24/2026.
8/27/2026 Sec. 2-433. (a) Individual
Assistance
Public Hearing
A panel of three Commissioners held a public administrative appeal
hearing on the Director's finding of no reasonable cause in Case 2025-2.
The panel voted 2:1 to reopen the investigation to answer several
questions raised during the hearing discussion.
9/17/2026 Sec. 2-433. (c) City
Policies and Practices
Research
OHR Intern Kattalin Bennett presented her research on the impacts on the
development of off-grounds, luxury student housing on the neighborhoods
adjacent to the University of Virginia.
9/17/2026 Sec. 2-433. (c) City
Policies and Practices
Research
OHR Intern Shounak Reza presented his research on the landscape of
mental health services in Charlottesville and the challenges of availability
and access.
W
Federal Workshares
Fair Housing Assistance Program (FHAP) workshare agreement
o September 5, 2025: Certification was denied because of local, state-authorized protections against housing discrimination on the bases
of gender identity, sexual orientation, and source of funds, as well as HUD’s shift to only approving FHAP workshares for state agencies.
o With the continued decline in federal protection for fair housing rights, state and local human and civil rights agencies must assume the
full responsibility for protecting Virginians from housing discrimination.
Fair Employment Practices Agency (FEPA) workshare agreement
o On hold until the FHAP certification is complete.
o The FHAP agreement provides substantial opportunities and resources to expand and improve the OHR, whereas the FEPA increases
workload with insufficient support to increase staffing or training.
o Additionally, the federal government has directed both HUD and the EEOC to exclude gender identity and sexual orientation as
protected classes, and neither agency supports disparate impact as a legitimate theory of discrimination. Engagement in either
workshare at this time would leave people who live and work in Charlottesville with less robust protections against discrimination than
they currently have under state law and the Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance.
Outreach
The table below provides an overview of community outreach activities during the current calendar year. The volume and consistency
of community outreach have been significantly impacted due to the vacant and unfunded status of the Community Outreach Specialist
position since August 2025. Nonetheless, staff attended a few strategically selected events to maximize community contact.
Measures Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec TOTALS
Open office days in the month 20 19 21 22 20 21 22 21 21 22 18 21 241
Total service provision events 2 0 0 1 0 0 0 1 3 0 0 0 7
Total education & awareness events 1 0 0 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 2
Total collaboration & leadership events 8 7 6 7 9 5 9 9 5 2 0 0 67
Total outreach activities 11 7 6 9 9 5 9 10 8 2 0 0 76
Total attendees at service provision events 42 0 0 5 0 0 0 24 177 0 0 0 248
Total attendees at education & awareness events 20 0 0 20 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 40
Total attendees at events 62 0 0 25 0 0 0 24 177 0 0 0 288
Service Provision
Intake Trends
The table below presents a snapshot of intake data trends over the last 12 months.
Service Type Sep '25 Oct '25 Nov '25 Dec '25 Jan '26 Feb '26 Mar '26 Apr '26 May '26 Jun '26 Jul '26 Aug '26 Sep '26
Complaints 1 1 1 0 2 1 1 2 2 1 2 0 1
Inquiries 5 1 4 3 1 3 8 11 8 16 8 9 4
Referrals 11 3 7 12 6 7 5 4 6 7 4 5 5
Av. Incoming
Contacts/Day 8 6 6 8 8 11 6 6 8 7 4 6 9
The chart below shows the same data in the table above but in a graphic format.
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
Sep '25 Oct '25 Nov '25 Dec '25 Jan '26 Feb '26 Mar '26 Apr '26 May '26 Jun '26 Jul '26 Aug '26 Sep '26
Monthly Service Trends
Complaints Inquiries Referrals Av. Incoming
Contacts/Day
Active Complaints
The table below provides a summary of the complaints currently open with the Office of Human Rights. While cases continue to move
forward, the Office is currently struggling to keep up with new investigations due to the volume of cases, limited staffing, and the cost of
contracted investigative services. With the recent departure of our Investigator, the Office will be temporarily pausing the opening of
new complaints while the Intake Specialist and Director focus on advancing current cases toward closure and the hiring process begins
to refill the Investigator position.
Case # Protected Activity Protected Class(es) Status
2021-5 Employment Sexual Orientation, Race Investigation in progress.
2024-3 Public Accommodation National Origin, Sexual Orientation Investigation in progress.
2024-3R Public Accommodation Retaliation Investigation in progress.
2024-8 Employment Race, National Origin Determination in progress.
2024-11 Employment Sex, Marital Status Determination in progress.
2025-2 Employment Race Appeal in progress.
2025-4 Housing Source of Funds Alternative dispute resolution in progress.
2025-6 Employment Disability, Sex Determination in progress.
2025-7 Public Accommodation Disability, Race Determination in progress.
2025-9 Public Accommodation Race Determination in progress.
2025-10 Employment Sexual Orientation, Gender Identity Determination in progress.
2025-11 Employment Disability Investigation in progress.
2025-13 Housing Disability Determination in progress.
2025-14 Housing Race Determination in progress.
2025-16 Housing Race Determination in progress.
2026-2 Housing Disability, Elderliness Investigation in progress.
2026-3 Housing Disability Investigation in progress.
2026-4 Employment Race, Retaliation Investigation in progress.
2026-5 Employment Disability, Sex, Marital Status Alternative dispute resolution in progress.
2026-6 Housing Disability, Retaliation Investigation in progress.
2026-7 Employment Disability Investigation in progress.
2026-8 Housing Race, National Origin Alternative dispute resolution in progress.
2026-9 Public Accommodation Disability Alternative dispute resolution in progress.
2026-10 Housing Disability Alternative dispute resolution in progress.
2026-11 Housing Disability Alternative dispute resolution in progress.
2026-12 Housing Disability Alternative dispute resolution in progress.
Multi-year Complaint Case Overview
The table below provides a summary of case status over the past 8 years.
Measure CY2019 CY2020 CY2021 CY2022 CY2023 CY2024 CY2025 CY2026 Totals
Currently open cases 0 0 1 0 0 4 10 11 26
Open cases awaiting response 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Open cases in ADR 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 6 7
Open cases under investigation 0 0 1 0 0 2 1 5 9
Open cases pending determination 0 0 0 0 0 2 7 0 9
Open cases in HRC public hearing 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 1
Total Opened 5 2 12 9 7 13 16 11 75
Total Closed 4 1 8 5 11 7 9 4 49
Reporting
The table below provides a summary of reports submitted to City Council during the current calendar year.
Report Status
CY2025 Fourth Quarter Report to Council Submitted February 25, 2026.
CY2025 HRC & OHR Annual Report Published May 20, 2026 (Presented to City Council on June 1, 2026).
CY2026 First Quarter Report to Council Submitted April 14, 2026.
CY2026 Second Quarter Report to Council Submitted August 11, 2026.
CY2026 Third Quarter Report to Council To be submitted in October 2026.
CY2026 HRC & OHR Annual Report Projected completion February 2027.
Attachment VII
Human Rights Commission
Annual Work Plan: Focus and Goals
March 2026 – February 2027
Date of last revision: 10/13/2026
This document serves as a tool for use during the annual planning meeting and throughout the year to assist with the
identification of focus areas and goals and the development of a monthly calendar.
Human Rights Ordinance Reference
The Charlottesville Human Rights Ordinance (City Code Chapter 2, Article XV) is the roadmap for the work of both the
Human Rights Commission and Office of Human Rights. Sec. 2-433. (a) – (f) of the Ordinance includes details of the roles
of the Commission and Office. The subsections are given shortened titles here for easier reference.
Human Rights Commission Roles General Actions and Timeframes
Sec. 2-433. (a) Individual assistance
• Timing is dependent upon individual complaints and findings
• Could include training on:
o Public administrative hearings
o Human and civil rights protections
Sec. 2-433. (b) Outreach and
engagement
• Timing is throughout the year in response to community issues
• Could include community events, presentations, or public polls
• Could include community dialogue or other informational programs
• Could be expanded with additional staffing and Commission support
Sec. 2-433. (c) Systemic issues,
policies, and practices
• Plan to submit recommendations to Council in October or November
• Could include single events like panels, forums, and town halls
• Could also include long-term multi-year research or reviews of policy
• Additional staffing and Commission support could expand the work
Sec. 2-433. (d) Federal workshares
• Timing is dependent upon workshare requirements
• May include review and adoption of Ordinance amendments
• May include community engagement activities
Sec. 2-433. (e) Legislative program
• Plan to submit legislative recommendations to Council by August 31st
• Could include public polls, panels, forums, and town halls
• Could include research related to Sec. 2-433. (c)
Sec. 2-433. (f) Commission policies
• Plan to submit recommendations to Council in October or November
o May include requests for funding for programs or staffing
• Changes to the Commission’s Rules & Procedures are not timebound
• Changes to the Human Rights Ordinance can take multiple months
Annual Focus Areas
Each year the Commission identifies focus areas for its work from March – February. These are informed by current
events, public input, data from the Office of Human Rights, and Commissioner knowledge.
Primary Focus Area(s)
1. Economic stability across protected classes.
Annual Goals and Alignment
Specific, measurable, achievable, relevant, and time-bound goals that align with focus areas and HRC roles under the
Human Rights Ordinance.
Goals Ordinance Alignment Added to
Work Plan
Commission holds a stakeholder discussion at
the July 16, 2026, regular meeting and one-on-
one stakeholder meetings prior to August 14,
2026.
• Sec. 2-433. (b) Outreach and engagement
☒
Commission reviews information learned
regarding legislative priorities and begins
drafting recommendations for City Council by
August 1, 2026.
• Sec. 2-433. (c) Systemic issues, policies, and practices
• Sec. 2-433. (e) Legislative program
☒
Commission finalizes and adopts legislative
priorities recommendations for City Council by
August 20, 2026.
• Sec. 2-433. (c) Systemic issues, policies, and practices
• Sec. 2-433. (e) Legislative program
☒
Commission submits legislative
recommendations to City Council by August 22,
2026.
• Sec. 2-433. (b) Outreach and engagement
• Sec. 2-433. (e) Legislative program
☒
Commission holds an additional stakeholder
meeting to inform City policy recommendations
on September 17 and November 19, 2026.
• Sec. 2-433. (b) Outreach and engagement
• Sec. 2-433. (c) Systemic issues, policies, and practices ☒
Commission reviews information learned
regarding City policies and begins drafting
recommendations for City Council by DATE
• Sec. 2-433. (b) Outreach and engagement
• Sec. 2-433. (c) Systemic issues, policies, and practices ☐
Commission finalizes and adopts City policy
recommendations for City Council on DATE
• Sec. 2-433. (b) Outreach and engagement
• Sec. 2-433. (c) Systemic issues, policies, and practices
☐
Commission submits City policy
recommendations to City Council by DATE
• Sec. 2-433. (b) Outreach and engagement
• Sec. 2-433. (c) Systemic issues, policies, and practices ☐
Human Rights Commission
Annual Work Plan: Calendar
March 2026 – February 2027
Month Actions
March ☒ Annual Meeting (3/5: Parks & Recreation Conference Room)
☒ Actions Between Meetings
☒ Contact state legislators for May panel
☒ Contact Economic Mobility Officer for 4/16 Regular Meeting
☒ Contact Assistant to the City Manager for 4/16 Regular Meeting
`April ☒ Work Session (4/2: City Space) - Not scheduled
☒ HRC Leadership Meeting (4/8 at 5:00pm)
☒ Regular Meeting (4/16: City Space)
☒ Closed session consultation with City Attorney’s Office
☒ Review and potentially adopt amendments to the Human Rights Ordinance
☒ Expert panel and community engagement planning
☒ Actions Between Meetings
☒ Upload CY2025 annual report to 6/15 City Council agenda (on or before 5/18)
☒ Upload Ordinance amendments to 6/15 City Council agenda (on or before 5/18)
☒ Expert panel collaborative planning document to identify possible panelists
☒ Reach out to content experts for June or July panel
☒ Review HRC Rules & Procedures for any language changes per 2-432
☒ Plan next steps and timeline with hearing panel
May ☒ Work Session (5/7: City Space) – Not scheduled
☒ HRC Leadership Meeting (5/13 at 4:00pm)
☒ Regular Meeting (5/21: City Space)
☒ Review list of possible panelists for June or July
☒ Actions Between Meetings
☒ Contact potential panelists by June 1st
☒ Questions for Legislators
☒ Present CY2025 annual report to City Council (6/1)
☒ Present Ordinance amendments to City Council (6/15)
June ☒ Work Session (6/4: City Space) – Not scheduled
☒ HRC Leadership Meeting (6/10 at 4:00pm)
☒ Regular Meeting (6/18: City Space)
☒ Legislator Dialogue
☒ Actions Between Meetings
☒ 2:1 Stakeholder meetings
July ☒ Work Session (7/2: City Space) – Not scheduled
☒ HRC Leadership Meeting (7/8 at 4:00pm) – Not convened
☒ Regular Meeting (7/16: City Space)
☒ Stakeholder Panel
☒ Actions Between Meetings
☒ 2:1 Stakeholder meetings (to be completed by 8/14)
☒ Begin Draft of Legislative Recommendations
Month Actions
August ☒ Work Session (8/6: City Space) – not scheduled
☒ HRC Leadership Meeting (8/12 at 4:00pm)
☒ Regular Meeting (8/20: City Space)
☒ Review, revise, and adopt state legislative recommendations
☒ Actions Between Meetings
☒ Case 2025-2 Public Administrative Appeal Hearing (8/27 at 6:00pm: City Space)
☒ Draft and submit state legislative recommendations to City Council by 8/30
☒ Review HRC application for any language changes per 2-432
September ☒ Work Session (9/3: City Space) - not scheduled
☒ HRC Leadership Meeting (9/9 at 4:00pm)
☒ Regular Meeting (9/17: City Space)
☒ Discuss City policy recommendations
☒ Discuss potential second stakeholder meeting
☒ Intern presentations
☒ Actions Between Meetings
☒ City policy stakeholder outreach
October ☒ Work Session (10/1: City Space) – not scheduled
☒ HRC Leadership Meeting (10/7 at 4:00pm)
☐ Regular Meeting (10/15: City Space)
☐ Form Officer Nomination Committee (minimum of three Commissioners)
☐ City Policy stakeholder meeting – Community Partners
☐ Actions Between Meetings
☐ Nominating Committee begins nomination process
☐ Chair begins draft of City policy recommendations to Council
November ☐ Work Session (11/5: City Space)
☐ HRC Leadership Meeting (11/11 at 4:00pm)
☐ Regular Meeting (11/19: City Space)
☐ Meet with City staff (NDS, EMO, DHS, DSS)
☐ Actions Between Meetings
December ☐ Work Session (12/3: City Space)
☐ HRC Leadership Meeting (12/9 at 4:00pm)
☐ Regular Meeting (12/17: City Space)
☐ Officer Nominating Committee presents slate of nominees (or in January?)
☐ Adopt City policy recommendations
☐ Actions Between Meetings
January ☐ Work Session (1/7: City Space)
☐ HRC Leadership Meeting (1/6 at 4:00pm)
☐ Regular Meeting (1/21: City Space)
☐ Officer elections
☐ Plan date for Annual Meeting in March
☐ Actions Between Meetings
Month Actions
February ☐ Work Session (2/4: City Space)
☐ HRC Leadership Meeting (DATE)
☐ Regular Meeting (2/18: City Space)
☐ Planning for Annual Meeting
☐ Actions Between Meetings
☐ HRC leadership begins draft of annual focus and goals
Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.