RecordWell Data

Police Civilian Oversight Board — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Police Civilian Oversight Board · meeting of Oct 8, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Regular Meeting Agenda Police Civilian Oversight Board October 8, 2026 CitySpace 100 5th St NE Charlottesville, VA 22902 Police Civilian Oversight Board Dr. Jeffrey Fracher, Chair Dr. Kyle Dobson, Vice Chair George Dillard Jr., LE Rep Andrew Frye, At Large Albe LaFave, At Large Caron LeNoir-Kelly, Community Nathalie Reaves, Community Ruairi Vaughan, At Large 6:30 PM Regular Session I. Call to Order | Roll Call II. Agenda | Minutes Approval III. Announcements IV. First Public Comment Period V. Making Connections: Listening to the Community's Voice VI. Budget Season: Recommendations for Fiscal Year 2028 VII. Case Review Initiation: Setting a Schedule VIII. Second Public Comment Period IX. Adjournment Notice: For members of the public participating virtually, if you experience technical difficulties, you may call (434) 970-3115, and a staff person will assist you. Individuals with disabilities who require assistance or special arrangements to participate in the public meeting may call the ADA Coordinator at (434) 987-1267 or submit a request via email to ada@charlottesville.gov. The City of Charlottesville requests that you provide a 48-hour notice so that proper arrangements may be made. Approval of agenda: October 8, 2026• Approval of minutes: September 10, 2026• Sunday, November 8 from 1:00 to 7:00 PM — Board Retreat at Hillsdale Conference Center• Reminder to check the Board calendar for event opportunities (more in fall time)• Community engagement goal and call to action• Available outreach and survey resources• Report on surveys collected to date• Budget recommendations for the Office of Police Civilian Oversight• Budget recommendations for the Charlottesville Police Department• Update on digital case file access and cases near to closure• Priority check on CPD General Orders most relevant to case review• Scheduling office hours for case review• -- 1 of 2 -- PCOB Meeting Public Participation Rules Please adhere to respectful conduct, treat other attendees with courtesy, listen actively, avoid interruptions, and refrain from personal attacks or inflammatory language. For the public comment periods, for which there will be two opportunities, please wait for the designated time on the agenda to provide your comments. There is a three-minute time limit for individual comments, but all public participants are welcome to speak during both opportunities. When you speak, we request that you clearly state your name, your organization affiliation, if any, and whether you're a resident of Charlottesville, Albemarle County, or another jurisdiction. During public comment, the Board will not enter into dialogue. The Board will listen carefully to all comments. If there are specific questions, please submit them in writing to the PCOB Office staff after the meeting. Questions or additional comments can be sent to: pcob@charlottesville.gov Using the “Email PCOB” form on the right side of our website homepage: https://www.charlottesville.gov/1440/Police-Civilian-Oversight-Board Acronyms & Abbreviations ADA- Americans with Disabilities Act CCS - Charlottesville City Schools CPD- Charlottesville Police Department FY - Fiscal Year LE - Law Enforcement MOU- Memorandum of Understanding PCOB- Police Civilian Oversight Board SOP - Standard Operating Procedure(s) SRO- School Resource Officer -- 2 of 2 -- CHARLOTTESVILLE POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD MEETING MINUTES Date: September 10, 2026 Scheduled Time: 6:30 p.m. Location: CitySpace – 100 5th Street NE, Charlottesville, VA 22902 Board Members Attending: Dr. Jeffrey Fracher (Chair), Dr. Kyle Dobson (Vice Chair), George Dillard Jr., Andrew Frye, Albe LaFave, Nathalie Reaves, Ruairi Vaughan. Board Members Not Attending: Caron LeNoir-Kelly. Staff Present: James Walker, Director. Guests: Joshua Barr, Chief Prosperity Officer, City of Charlottesville. Call to Order: • The meeting was called to order at 6:35 p.m. by Chair Dr. Fracher, who reviewed the ground rules for participation and public comment and noted that questions may be submitted in writing to pcob@charlottesville.gov. Dr. Fracher welcomed Mr. Joshua Barr, the City’s new Chief Prosperity Officer. • Mr. Walker called the roll. Seven Board members were present, constituting a quorum. Mrs. LeNoir-Kelly had notified the Office in advance of her absence. Agenda & Minutes Approval: • A motion was made by Mr. Frye to approve the agenda for the September 10, 2026 regular meeting. Motion seconded by Mr. LaFave and approved unanimously by members present. • A motion was made by Mr. Vaughan to approve the minutes from the August 13, 2026 regular meeting. Motion seconded by Mr. LaFave and approved unanimously by members present. Announcements: Board Retreat • Mr. Walker announced that the Board retreat is confirmed for Sunday, November 8, 2026, from 1:00 to 7:00 p.m., including dinner. The Office is finalizing a location. Digital Access to Internal Affairs Case Files • Mr. Walker reported that Internal Affairs has agreed to upload investigation case files, retroactive to January 2026, into the digital system used for body-worn camera footage, giving the Office direct access. Logistics will be discussed with the Chief and Internal Affairs the following Monday. The digital approach is more efficient and more secure than transferring paper files, though the transition has delayed case review scheduling. Dr. Fracher noted that the Board has sought this access for over a year and thanked the Chief and Internal Affairs. Operations and Engagement Specialist Hiring • Mr. Walker reported that the Office’s second staff position, redrafted as the Operations and Engagement Specialist (formerly Management Analyst), will focus on Board logistics and community engagement. Of 19 applicants, nine have advanced to a first-round panel (Dr. Fracher, Mrs. Reaves, and Mr. Walker), which is expected to narrow the pool to three or four finalists for a second round. Members interested in joining the second round should notify Mr. Walker. • Dr. Fracher stated the goal is to fill the position quickly, as Mr. Walker has carried the Office alone for over a year, and Dr. Dobson added that the single-staff arrangement creates inefficiency for the Board. Dr. Fracher thanked Mr. Walker for his work, including on the ordinance revision. Proposed Ordinance Revisions • Mr. Walker reported that he, Dr. Fracher, and Mr. LaFave attended the September 8 City Council meeting, where Council received the legally reviewed redline and clean copy of the proposed PCOB ordinance. The ordinance is on Council’s consent agenda for two readings, with a final vote anticipated on or around September 21, 2026. Dr. Fracher noted the presentation was warmly received, with no public comment or follow-up questions. Engagement with the Unhoused Community • Dr. Fracher reported that Councilor Oschrin asked about the Board’s engagement with the unhoused community. Dr. Fracher, Dr. Dobson, and Mr. Walker will meet with a group at The Haven to hear concerns and establish communication. Dr. Dobson noted that, as the Board’s profile grows, defining what falls outside its scope will be as important as defining what falls within it. Public Comment (First Period): • No public comment was received. Welcoming Joshua Barr, Chief Prosperity Officer: • Mr. Barr described his role in the City Manager’s Office as identifying and removing barriers that keep residents from moving up the socioeconomic ladder. He shared his background as a civil rights attorney in South Carolina and his shift from litigation to local government administration, pairing policy work with “hearts and minds” community dialogue. He offered to help remove barriers to the Board’s effectiveness. • Dr. Dobson welcomed Mr. Barr and noted that the Board’s focus is the quality of policing rather than “policing the police.” Mr. Barr responded that the goal is for police to be guardians rather than warriors, and that community trust grows when police protect the community well. • Mr. Walker noted that Mr. Barr is now his direct supervisor and thanked Steve King, Assistant to the City Manager, for his prior support. Mr. Vaughan suggested Mr. Barr assist with the specialist hiring process, and Dr. Fracher expressed hope that he will help the Board build a robust community engagement plan. Mr. Barr offered to assist. Community Connections: Survey Results • Mr. Walker reported that community survey responses increased from 14 to 20 over the past month; the sample is too small to support conclusions, and the visuals are prototypes. Dr. Dobson noted that trust scores skew high, possibly reflecting a convenience sample, and that more responses are needed. On values alignment, of 19 respondents, seven rated the community closer to their own values, two rated the police closer, and ten rated both about the same. Survey Outreach and Action Plan • Mr. Frye asked whether the Board has been actively surveying residents. Dr. Dobson stated that outreach should be more intentional and recommended attending meetings of established groups (such as the NAACP) to collect surveys and offering to return to present results. Dr. Fracher noted the new specialist will help coordinate this work. • Mr. Frye shared that a family member declined the survey for lack of confidence it would produce change, and Dr. Fracher acknowledged that perception exists. Dr. Dobson and Mr. Walker emphasized that resident input reaches decision-makers through the Board’s ordinance-based lines of communication with City leadership, City Council, and the Chief. • Mr. Walker presented an action plan: if staff and each member collect about four surveys per week, the Board would gather roughly 120 responses per month. The survey is four anonymous questions and can be completed by QR code, on paper, or verbally. Outreach cards with the survey and website QR codes were distributed. • Mr. Dillard asked whether responses have addressed the Board itself. Mr. Walker stated that he has seen little direct commentary and that members may request all individual responses. Police Foot Presence • Mr. Dillard noted that limited police foot presence was the top critical theme in survey responses, and Mr. Frye recalled former Chief Longo requiring two hours per shift on foot. Mr. Dillard stated that getting officers out of their cars, particularly in neighborhoods with more problems, is essential to building relationships, and that he has seen little foot presence in those neighborhoods. • In response to Mr. Vaughan, Mr. Dillard explained that each department sets its own foot patrol policy and that he believes CPD policy requires some. He recalled that when officers walked beats there were fewer problems and greater respect for officers, and offered to bring the Law Enforcement Code of Ethics to a future meeting. • Dr. Dobson proposed documenting resident concerns, advocating for a policy on time spent out of vehicles, and verifying compliance. Mr. Dillard recommended first reviewing the existing policy, and Mr. Walker will bring back both the written policy and current practice. Mr. Walker added that the same expectation applies to Board members being out in the community. Community Contact List • Mr. Walker reviewed the community contact list of approximately 150 entities (about 50 prioritized) and asked members to mark existing connections and ones they can commit to, write their names on the sheets, and copy him on contacts so the secure tracking spreadsheet can be updated. Mr. LaFave identified the White Feather Historical Society, and Mr. Walker noted he has spoken with that group. Grounding Review of CPD General Orders in the Data: Internal Affairs Case Data • Mr. Walker presented Internal Affairs case data from 2022 forward. External complaints average from the mid-30s to nearly 40 per year, mostly filed directly with CPD; the PCOB Office typically receives one or two per month (two in August). The top allegations were courtesy, unsatisfactory performance, unbecoming conduct, truthfulness, and conformance to laws, each tied to a General Order; for example, 23 of 43 unsatisfactory performance allegations were sustained. • Mr. Walker noted that most investigations originate internally and that internal allegations are sustained at a higher rate (approaching 70 to 80 percent) than external complaints. Fourth Amendment Analysis • Mr. Walker described CPD’s Fourth Amendment analyst position, which reviews searches, seizures, and detentions; over about five years, four incidents were classified as unconstitutional detentions. Mr. Frye asked about the analyst’s background, and Mr. Walker will follow up. Dr. Dobson suggested that even detentions deemed constitutional may warrant review where residents feel their rights were infringed. General Orders Priority Check • Mr. Walker distributed excerpts of the General Orders tied to the top allegation categories, plus two policies on temporary detentions, and asked members to rate each as low, medium, or high priority to focus the Board’s work. • Mr. Walker also shared CPD’s proposed update to its lieutenant and captain promotions policy, which adds alternative eligibility pathways, and invited informal feedback. Mr. Dillard stated that the requirements ask too much and that, in his experience, conduct on the street matters more than formal education. Mrs. Reaves asked whether preferred degree fields are specified; Mr. Walker stated they are not. Mr. Vaughan noted that CPD is nearly fully staffed and retaining officers, suggesting the process is not overly burdensome, while Mrs. Reaves noted cost and access barriers to obtaining a degree. Dr. Dobson stated that continued growth matters for leaders, whether gained through formal education or experience. Developing an Audit Framework: • Mr. Walker presented an early draft audit framework, part of the case review, audit, and monitoring processes being developed in weekly meetings among Mr. Walker, Dr. Fracher, and Dr. Dobson. He noted that an audit may yield positive findings as well as concerns, and will distribute the draft to the Board. Work Plan Project Status Updates: • Mr. Walker reviewed the work plan board and noted that several foundational processes, including case review, are near implementation. In response to Mr. Dillard, he stated that case reviews will begin once Internal Affairs files are digitized in Axon. Public Comment (Second Period): • No public comment was received. Adjournment: • A motion to adjourn was made by Mr. LaFave and seconded by Mr. Frye. The motion was approved unanimously by members present. • Meeting adjourned at 8:06 p.m. CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE · POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD Survey Action Plan Name THE BOARD'S GOAL, AS A WHOLE 120 responses this month ÷ 4 weeks → 30 responses per week ÷ 8 members → 4 per member, per week 1MY GOAL I will personally help bring in completed surveys by 2WHAT I NEED FROM STAFF Paper surveys Flyers or palm cards with QR code Translated copies Talking points I can read from A staff member or fellow board member with me Other: 3WHAT MIGHT GET IN THE WAY 4COMMUNITY CONNECTORS TO REACH OUT TO COMMUNITY CONNECTOR WHO I'LL ASK I'LL MAKE A CONNECTION AND KEEP JAMES INFORMED 10th and Page Neighborhood Association Amalgamated Transit Union (City transit workers) Big Brothers Big Sisters of the Central Blue Ridge Blue Ridge Area Coalition for the Homeless (BRACH) Blue Ridge Commons Boys & Girls Clubs of Central Virginia Burnett Commons HOA Center for Non-Profit Excellence COMMUNITY CONNECTOR WHO I'LL ASK I'LL MAKE A CONNECTION AND KEEP JAMES INFORMED Charlottesville Pride Community Network City of Promise Commonwealth Justice Coalition Downtown Business Association of Charlottesville Fry's Spring Neighborhood Association Greenbrier Neighborhood Association Greenleaf Neighborhood Association IMPACT (Interfaith Movement Promoting Action by Congregations Together) International Rescue Committee - Charlottesville Islamic Society of Central Virginia Jefferson Area Board for Aging (JABA) Jefferson Park Avenue Neighborhood Association Jefferson School African American Heritage Center Kellytown Neighborhood Association Kiwanis Club of Charlottesville Love INC of Charlottesville/Albemarle Meadowbrook Hills Neighborhood Association NAMI Blue Ridge Charlottesville Network2Work On Our Own of Charlottesville One Stop Shop Cville PACEM PFLAG Greater Charlottesville PHAR - Public Housing Association of Residents COMMUNITY CONNECTOR WHO I'LL ASK I'LL MAKE A CONNECTION AND KEEP JAMES INFORMED Piedmont Housing Alliance Planned Parenthood - Charlottesville Health Center ReadyKids Rose Hill Neighborhood Association Rotary Club of Charlottesville Salvation Army Center of Hope Starr Hill Neighborhood Association The People's Coalition Thomas Jefferson Adult Career Education (TJACE) Thomas Jefferson Area Crisis Intervention Team (CIT) United Way of Greater Charlottesville University Neighborhood Association Venable Neighborhood Association Virginia Organizing (Charlottesville Chapter) Westhaven Tenants Association White Feather Willoughby Property Owners' Association Women's Initiative Woodhaven Neighborhood Association Woolen Mills Neighborhood Association BOARD MEMBER MESSAGING GUIDE Gathering the voice of the community What to say, and how to say it, when you talk with residents about the Board, our community conversations and the Community Understanding Survey. October 2026 01 WHY WE DO OUTREACH We listen first, then set our priorities Board members reach out to the community on a regular basis. We want to understand residents' experiences with the Charlottesville Police Department (CPD) and learn which policing topics matter most to them. What we hear shapes the Board's oversight work. Outreach goes both ways. We ask for input, and we share what the Board does and how residents can take part. INPUT CAN COME IN ANY FORM A conversation, a meeting, a table at an event or a quick chat on the street all count. In every case, offer the Community Understanding Survey. It works on its own or paired with a conversation. OUR MESSAGE IN ONE SENTENCE "The Police Civilian Oversight Board wants to hear about your experiences with the Charlottesville Police Department, good, bad or neutral, so our oversight work reflects what the community needs." Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 2 02 KEY MESSAGES Four points to come back to WHO WE ARE A City board of community members who provide civilian oversight of CPD. We are the eyes, ears and voice of the community. WHY WE'RE ASKING The Board is entering a new era. We want our work to be more meaningful for the community and to put community needs first. WHAT HAPPENS NEXT What we hear helps us adjust the Board's oversight priorities based on what the community needs and wants. YOUR VOICE IS HEARD The Board has a direct line to the City Manager, Chief of Police and City Council. Your input reaches the people who make decisions. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 3 02 KEY MESSAGES, CONTINUED How we sound Tone guide for every conversation Do Avoid Put the script in your own words Moving outside the framework of the script Welcome every kind of experience: good, bad or neutral Steering people toward only negative or only positive stories Listen more than you talk; ask who, what, when, where and how Debating, correcting or defending during a conversation Use plain words and spell out names: "Police Civilian Oversight Board" Acronyms and jargon without explanation Say clearly when you are taking notes or recording Recording anyone without their clear permission HOW WE TALK ABOUT PRIVACY ANONYMOUS BY DEFAULT Surveys and conversations are anonymous unless a person chooses to share information that identifies them. If they do, we protect it. Some oversight work is different. Formal complaints and reviews require us to share information with the Charlottesville Police Department. If someone wants to file a complaint, explain this before they share details, and connect them with the PCOB Director. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 4 03 BEFORE YOU REACH OUT Check the directory, then confirm with the Director Look up the organization, business or person in the Community Connections Directory. See whether anyone has made contact in the last 3 months. Then email the PCOB Director to confirm you will reach out. My connection is not on the list Email the PCOB Director to add the connection. Say whether you have already reached out or plan to, so the Director can log it. I don't know who to contact Pick a contact from the directory and email the PCOB Director. For help choosing, email the Director and Board Chair. I already talked with someone For impromptu outreach, such as at an event or on the street, email the PCOB Director to let them know if this contact represents a larger community connection that should be logged. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 5 04 OUTREACH MESSAGES Invite a community connection to work with us Send from your charlottesville.gov email. A phone call or in-person conversation is fine if it fits better. Aim to schedule about 30 minutes at a time that works for you both. FIRST MESSAGE · INTRODUCTION "Hi, I'm [Name], a member of the City of Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board. I'm reaching out because the Board is seeking conversations and survey responses from community members to understand their experiences with the Charlottesville Police Department. We recognize your organization is a community connector, and we made reaching out to you a priority. Do you have someone who could talk with us about working together on this? We're happy to set up a call or meet in person. Thank you." Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 6 04 OUTREACH MESSAGES, CONTINUED SECOND MESSAGE · FOLLOW-UP AFTER A REPLY "The City of Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board is entering a new era. Board members want to make our oversight work more meaningful for the community and put community needs first. Thank you for your interest in sharing your input and your experience with the Charlottesville Police Department. There are a few ways you could help: 1. Review the attached PCOB Community Connections One Sheet. It lists ideas for gathering input from you and your community or patrons. If something stands out, let us know. 2. Display the PCOB One Sheet somewhere prominent in your organization, and highlight the survey. 3. Host us at a table in your location from time to time, where we can talk with the public and share the One Sheet. 4. Share the survey with your connections, or post a QR code for the survey at your location. How would you like to connect in a way that is most convenient and helpful for your community? We want everyone in Charlottesville to be understood and represented as best we can. Thank you again." WHEN YOU REACH AN AGREEMENT Email the PCOB Director so they can update the connection in the Community Connections Directory. Forward the correspondence and share any details to know. Agree on the best next step: a conversation, attending a meeting or the survey on its own. Offer the survey either way. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 7 05 TALKING ABOUT THE SURVEY Offer the survey every time Use the survey on its own when time is short, or pair it with a conversation. Review the latest version before every outreach. The Director can provide 5x7 paper surveys, QR code survey cards, and other resources at the office. FOR COMMUNITY MEMBERS Community Understanding Survey A short survey residents can complete on paper or by QR code. Share it freely and highlight it on the One Sheet. COMPLETING A SURVEY FOR SOMEONE If a person prefers, you can fill out the survey on their behalf. In the survey notes, record who completed the survey, the date, and the location or event. QUICK SURVEY ASK · IN PERSON OR AT A TABLE "Hi, my name is [Name]. I'm a member of the City's Police Civilian Oversight Board, and we want to hear about your experiences with the Charlottesville Police Department. All we're asking for is a 3-minute survey, and it's anonymous unless you choose to share your name or other personal details. The Board has a direct line to the City Manager, Chief of Police and City Council, so we want to make sure your voice is heard." Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 8 06 COMMUNITY CONVERSATIONS Meet people where they are Conversation formats Format What it looks like Community location By invitation to a resident's home, neighborhood, an organization's meeting or event, or another place they choose Virtual Microsoft Teams, phone or another virtual option Focus group A PCOB-organized meeting of fewer than 8 residents, with food and refreshments, hosted at the Office of Police Civilian Oversight Post up A table in a brick-and-mortar space offered by a community connection, for a set period of time Offer the survey in every format, at the end of the conversation or for people who don't have time to talk. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 9 07 CONVERSATION SCRIPT Open with trust, let them lead, close with the survey Use this script for any format. Make it sound like you. Bring copies of the One Sheet (available as 8.5x11 and 5x7 cards). PART 1 · WELCOME "Thank you for taking the time to talk about your experiences with the Charlottesville Police Department. My name is [Name], and I am with the Police Civilian Oversight Board. If you haven't seen our One Sheet about who we are, I brought copies." PART 2 · PURPOSE "The goal today is simple. We want to give voice to the community and understand your experiences with the Charlottesville Police Department, good, bad or neutral. This helps us adjust the Board's oversight priorities for the next month based on what the community needs and wants." PART 3 · PRIVACY AND RECORDING "This conversation is anonymous unless you choose to share information that identifies you. If you do, we will protect it. One exception: if you want to file a formal complaint, or your story leads to a formal review, some information has to be shared with the Charlottesville Police Department. We'll tell you before that happens. "I'll take notes throughout, but we'd like to record the conversation so we don't miss anything or misunderstand what you say. It also helps us stay present and focused. May we record your voice?" For groups only: "If you aren't comfortable with the recording, we can meet with you privately at another time or place." Note: Recording is not required, but it helps when people are willing. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 10 CONVERSATION SCRIPT, CONTINUED PART 4 · OPENING QUESTION "To get us started, could you share your name and the neighborhood you generally live in? It's okay if you'd rather not share your name. What has been your experience with the Charlottesville Police Department? Specific stories, thoughts or feelings are most helpful." PART 5 · CLOSE WITH THE SURVEY "Thank you for sharing. Before we finish, would you take our 3-minute Community Understanding Survey? You can fill it out on paper or by QR code, or I can complete it with you." FOLLOW-UP PROMPTS Ask what helps you see the experience from their point of view. Who was involved? What happened? When did it happen? Where did it happen? How did it feel? Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 11 08 AFTER EVERY CONVERSATION Close the loop the same day 1. Always keep a record. Ask for a survey every time. Add notes, a recording with permission, or both. 2. Email the PCOB Director (unless they were there). Say when the conversation happened, and send your notes or recording. 3. Report survey responses. Tell the Director which connections completed the Community Understanding Survey. QUESTIONS ABOUT OUTREACH Contact the PCOB Director before reaching out, after every conversation, and any time you need help choosing a connection. For help with options, include the Board Chair. WHEN YOU DON'T HAVE THE ANSWER If a community member asks a question you can't answer, share contact information for the PCOB Director, or tell them you will find out and follow up. Do not make assumptions or set expectations that can't be met. Do not speak on behalf of other Board members, the office, City leadership or the police department. These areas have historically caused the most confusion and distrust of the PCOB. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Board Member Messaging Guide Page 12 CHARLOTTESVILLE POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD OCTOBER 2026 Community Survey Results A tabulation of all 41 survey responses received to date on trust in, experience with, and values alignment to the Charlottesville Police Department, with trends since July and differences between groups of respondents 41 +21 community members surveyed to date, 21 of them since the September report 56/100 average of the 0–100 trust ratings given; the September report showed 64 across 20 responses 1.0 point average amount respondents rated their values closer to the community than to the police, on a 1–7 scale Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey responses July 7 to October 5, 2026, including paper surveys collected September 28 and 30. COMMUNITY SURVEY · TRUST 19 of 41 rated their trust in CPD 70 or higher; 9 rated it 10 or lower 0 = No trust 25 50 75 100 = Full trust Each dot is one respondent (n = 41). New since September (21) In the September report (20) SINCE THE SEPTEMBER REPORT TOTAL RESPONSES 41▲ +21 was 20 in September AVERAGE TRUST 56▼ −8 was 64 of 100 MEDIAN TRUST 60▼ −15 was 75 of 100 RATED TRUST 70+ 46%▼ −14 pts 19 of 41; was 12 of 20 VALUES ALIGN WITH POLICE 3.8▼ −0.7 of 7; was 4.5 VALUES ALIGN WITH COMMUNITY 4.9▼ −0.6 of 7; was 5.5 “When I have needed help, they have been respectful and responsive.” Community respondent, September (paper survey) “Some really bad, and some okay.” Community respondent, September (paper survey) Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to October 2026 (n = 41) 02 / 8 MEAN 56 TREND TRACKING · BY COLLECTION PERIOD Average trust was lower in each new collection period JULY 7 TO JULY 29 14 responses mean 69 · median 82 AUGUST 11 TO SEPTEMBER 1 6 responses mean 52 · median 51 SEPTEMBER 28 TO OCTOBER 5 21 responses mean 49 · median 50 0 = No trust Online survey Paper survey 100 = Full trust AVERAGE TRUST, 0–100 Jul Aug–Sep Sep–Oct All periods combined: 56 RATED TRUST 70 OR HIGHER Jul Aug–Sep Sep–Oct All periods combined: 46% VALUES: COMMUNITY VS. POLICE, 1–7 Jul Aug–Sep Sep–Oct Upper line community, lower line police; shading is the gap Every response before September was online. Since then, 14 of 21 new responses came from paper surveys collected in person. Changes between periods may reflect who was reached, not a change in views. Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Trend tracking · responses grouped by collection date 03 / 8 69 52 49 71% 33% 33% 5.6 5.2 4.3 4.8 4.2 3.2 COMMUNITY SURVEY · VALUES ALIGNMENT Respondents rate their values closer to the community than to the police AVERAGE RATINGS ON ONE SCALE · two questions, 1 to 7 (7 = very similar to my values) All responses 39 answered both +1.0 point gap September report 19 answered both +0.9 point gap WHOSE VALUES EACH RESPONDENT RATED CLOSER TO THEIR OWN 10% 46% 44% 4 of 39 rated the police closer to their own values 18 of 39 rated the community and the police the same 17 of 39 rated the community closer to their own values AVERAGE RATINGS BY GROUP Police Community GROUP N POLICE COMMUNITY GAP COLLECTION METHOD Online survey 26 4.2 5.2 +1.0 Paper survey 13 3.2 4.2 +1.0 RESIDENCY Charlottesville resident 10 3.6 4.6 +1.0 Non-resident (works or visits)*3 4.0 5.7 +1.7 RACE White, non-Hispanic 22 4.5 5.2 +0.7 Black/African-American 9 3.1 4.8 +1.7 Asian/Pacific Islander* 2 2.0 2.5 +0.5 GENDER Man 20 3.8 4.6 +0.8 Woman 14 4.5 5.5 +1.0 AGE Under 35 10 3.4 4.8 +1.4 35 to 54 13 3.9 4.9 +1.0 55 and older 10 4.8 5.4 +0.6 INCOME Under $30,000 12 2.8 4.0 +1.3 $30,000 and over 8 4.1 5.0 +0.9 Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. n = 39 answering both questions · *fewer than 5 respondents · select a group to filter 04 / 8 Community 4.9 Police 3.9 Community 5.5 Police 4.6 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 COMMUNITY SURVEY · EXPERIENCE Experience with CPD: themes named in open- ended responses THEMES IN RESPONSES CODED POSITIVE Respectful, responsive help: after a theft, a home-safety call, and for a local worker NEW Visible presence: bike patrols and Mall rounds; one respondent feels safe seeing officers NEW Quick response to incidents and crimes Gratitude for the job itself, which respondents called difficult and dangerous NEUTRAL AND MIXED Little or no direct contact: 6 respondents said they had limited or no experience GROWING THEMES IN RESPONSES CODED CRITICAL Conduct and training: officers described as disrespectful; a call for more training in dealing with people NEW Unequal treatment: force toward the poorest residents, slow response to university parties NEW Little presence on foot in neighborhoods; slow non-emergency response Perceived inaction downtown on drug activity and encampments Bias in an investigation involving a Black man reporting a crime Police in schools: opposition to school resource officers “I feel safe when I see them.” Community respondent, October “They are mostly present, but disrespectful!” Community respondent, September (paper survey) “Pretty normal, no issues. I barely even see them for real.” Community respondent, September (paper survey) “When dealing with our poorest and most vulnerable community members, police are violent and swift, cruel even.” Community respondent, October “They need more training in dealing with people.” Community respondent, September (paper survey) “It made him question whether he could trust the people who are supposed to protect and help us.” Community respondent, August Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to October 2026 · responses coded for this report 05 / 8 COMMUNITY SURVEY · DIFFERENCES BY GROUP Trust was lowest among Black, lower-income, and paper-survey respondents These groups overlap: 7 of the 14 paper respondents are Black, and 10 of 14 reported income under $30,000. Select any group to filter pages 2 to 5 and 7. GROUP N AVERAGE TRUST, 0–100 (line = all, 56) POLICE VALUES GAP TRUST 70+ OVERALL All respondents 41 56 3.8 +1.0 46% COLLECTION METHOD Online survey 27 62 4.2 +1.0 59% Paper survey 14 44 3.1 +1.0 21% RESIDENCY Charlottesville resident 10 49 3.6 +1.0 40% Non-resident (works or visits)*3 78 4.0 +1.7 67% RACE White, non-Hispanic 23 69 4.5 +0.7 65% Black/African-American 10 37 3.0 +1.7 20% Asian/Pacific Islander* 2 40 2.0 +0.5 50% GENDER Man 22 59 3.7 +0.8 55% Woman 14 65 4.5 +1.0 50% AGE Under 35 10 60 3.4 +1.4 60% 35 to 54 14 51 3.8 +1.0 36% 55 and older 11 71 4.7 +0.6 64% INCOME Under $30,000 13 43 2.7 +1.3 23% $30,000 and over 8 65 4.1 +0.9 63% Police values: average 1–7 rating. Gap: community rating minus police rating, averaged per respondent. Trust 70+: share who rated trust 70 or higher. Gray rows have fewer than 5 respondents and are shown for completeness, not comparison. Groups only include respondents who answered that question. Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to October 2026 (n = 41) 06 / 8 COMMUNITY SURVEY · WHO RESPONDED Newer responses reached younger, lower- income, and more Black respondents In the September reportNew since September COLLECTION METHOD (n = 41) Online 27 · 66% Paper 14 · 34% RESIDENCY (n = 13) Resident 10 · 77% Non-resident 3 · 23% Added in the revised survey; earlier respondents were not asked. GENDER (n = 36) Man 22 · 61% Woman 14 · 39% RACE (n = 36) White, non-Hispanic 23 · 64% Black/African- American 10 · 28% Asian/Pacific Islander 2 · 6% Multiple/Other 1 · 3% No respondents selected Hispanic/Latino or Indigenous. AGE (n = 35) 65+ 7 · 20% 55–64 4 · 11% 45–54 5 · 14% 35–44 9 · 26% 25–34 3 · 9% 18–24 6 · 17% Under 18 1 · 3% INCOME (n = 21) Over $150,000 2 · 10% $100,000–$150,000 2 · 10% $75,000–$99,999 2 · 10% $50,000–$74,999 0 $30,000–$49,999 2 · 10% $15,000–$29,999 2 · 10% Under $15,000 11 · 52% Most earlier respondents did not answer the income question. Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to October 2026 · all demographic questions optional 07 / 8 COMMUNITY SURVEY · CLOSING COMMENTS Unhoused residents and the Downtown Mall came up from both directions Some respondents want more enforcement on the Mall. Others criticized how encampments were cleared. Both views appeared in experience answers and closing comments. ASKING FOR MORE ENFORCEMENT “While deeply compassionate to that community, I do not feel safe and always have to be on guard.” Community respondent, September (paper survey) “It could only be better if their hands werenʼt tied in regard to the vagrant [issue] on the Mall.” Community respondent, September CRITICIZING HOW IT WAS HANDLED “Iʼm disappointed in how you guys handled removing the displaced members of cville from their camps on the Rivanna. It was inhumane and could have been more thought through.” Community respondent, October “Venable should be the focus of CPD resources, not Free Bridge and other encampments.” Community respondent, October ABOUT THIS DATA The survey changed in September. The question on locations was removed, so the September map is not updated. A residency question was added; earlier respondents were not asked it. Paper surveys (14) were collected in person on September 28 and 30, then entered by Board staff on October 1 and 7. One duplicate removed. Two online responses on October 1 had the same start time and identical answers. We counted them once: 42 records, 41 respondents. Experience themes on page 5 group answers as positive, neutral, or critical. This grouping is a judgment call, so it is used only on that page and should be reviewed by the Board. Collection periods are grouped by when a survey was filled out: July 7 to 29, August 11 to September 1, and September 28 to October 5. Available in large print and other formats on request. Prototype visualization, not a statistical finding. Samples are too small to support conclusions about community sentiment. The goal is to pilot what to track and report as more data is collected. Community Survey, July to October 2026 (n = 41) 08 / 8 Reprioritizing the PCOB Budget How the FY27 current budget compared with the FY26 budget: Preparing for the FY28 budget proposal October 2026 01 PCOB BUDGET REVIEW The FY27 budget is $20.8K lower and moved $72.9K between accounts $125.4K FY26 adopted Starting point $104.6K FY27 current 16.6% less than FY26 +$26.1K Added to priorities Legal, training, equipment, rentals, parking −$46.9K Reduced elsewhere Mostly professional services, software, marketing 1 Legal and training nearly double their share Funding rises from $30K to $50K, from 23.9% to 47.8% of the budget. 2 Reductions are concentrated The top three reductions make up about 70% of all reductions. 3 Recurring costs stay the same Cell phone, dues, printing, and contracted services stay flat at $14.4K. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · PCOB budget, FY26 to FY27 02 PCOB BUDGET REVIEW 15 accounts changed; professional services saw the biggest cut CHANGE BY ACCOUNT, FY26 TO FY27 Increase Reduction Professional servicesProfessional services −$12.5K Computer softwareComputer software −$10.4K Legal feesLegal fees +$10K+$10K Education and trainingEducation and training +$10K+$10K MarketingMarketing −$10K Equipment and furnitureEquipment and furniture +$5K+$5K Office suppliesOffice supplies −$3.5K−$3.5K AdvertisingAdvertising −$3.5K−$3.5K TravelTravel −$2.5K−$2.5K MealsMeals −$2K−$2K Registration feesRegistration fees −$2K−$2K Equipment rentalEquipment rental +$1K+$1K Software licensesSoftware licenses −$300−$300 Awards and trophiesAwards and trophies −$100−$100 Monthly parkingMonthly parking +$50+$50 Largest moves Professional services dropped from $20K to $7.5K. Computer software dropped from $10.8K to $300. Training tripled, from $5K to $15K. Equipment and furniture was new at $5K. Not shown: 4 accounts stayed flat at $14.4K combined (cell phone, dues, printing, contracted services), and 4 accounts stayed at $0. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · PCOB budget, FY26 to FY27 03 Understandingthe Police Budget Five years of spending data ahead of the FY28 budget request October 2026 04 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING Purpose No decision is requested today. This briefing gives the Board a shared set of facts before the Charlottesville Police Department (CPD) sends its budget request for fiscal year 2028 (FY28). 1 Five years of spending Five full budget years show how much was spent, how much of the budget was used, and where spending kept missing the plan. 2 Gaps between budget and spending Spending above or below budget can have several causes. A gap alone does not show the budget is too big or too small. 3 Context for the FY28 request Past spending patterns offer a point of comparison when the FY28 request is released. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 05 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING CPD spending grew 34.6% from FY22 to FY26 Original budget Updated budget Actual spending $15M$15M $20M$20M $25M$25M $30M$30M FY22FY22 FY23FY23 FY24FY24 FY25FY25 FY26FY26 $18.4M$18.4M $18.8M$18.8M $21.8M$21.8M $23.8M$23.8M $24.7M$24.7M $18.4M → $24.7M CPD spending went up about 34.6% from FY22 to FY26. CONTEXT Growth may reflect pay, contracts, staffing, or one-time purchases. The original budget is what Council adopted. The updated budget adds carryover and changes made during the year. These figures are a baseline for the FY28 request. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 06 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING CPD spent a larger share of its budget in FY24 to FY26 Share of budget spent or committed 0%0% 25%25% 50%50% 75%75% 100%100% FY22FY22 FY23FY23 FY24FY24 FY25FY25 FY26FY26 89.3%89.3% 89.9%89.9% 97.4%97.4% 98.1%98.1% 95.5%95.5% FY26 EXAMPLE $1.2M left at the end of the year $806K of the FY26 budget sat in a set-aside fund (“Lump Sum Appropriation”). None of it was spent directly. Money left at year end may include carryover, commitments, delayed spending, or reserves. The budget report does not separate these. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 07 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING Pay and benefits are the biggest cost Pay and benefits Everything else $0M$0M $10M$10M $20M$20M $30M$30M FY22FY22 FY23FY23 FY24FY24 FY25FY25 FY26FY26 $14.4M $4.0M $14.9M $3.8M $16.1M $5.7M $18.4M $5.4M $19.1M $5.6M In every full year, about three out of every four dollars went to pay and benefits. $14.4M → $19.1M spent on pay and benefits, FY22 to FY26 Some pay costs are set by contract or policy. Others reflect department decisions. The budget report does not separate the two. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 08 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING In FY25, full-time pay use and overtime both peaked TOTAL OVERTIME SPENDING $0M$0M $0.5M$0.5M $1M$1M $1.5M$1.5M $2M$2M FY22FY22 FY23FY23 FY24FY24 FY25FY25 FY26FY26 $0.92M$0.92M $1.11M$1.11M $1.28M$1.28M $1.56M$1.56M $1.26M$1.26M SHARE OF FULL-TIME PAY BUDGET USED 70%70% 80%80% 90%90% 100%100% FY22FY22 FY23FY23 FY24FY24 FY25FY25 FY26FY26 84.5%84.5% 82.6%82.6% 92.5%92.5% 99.8%99.8% 94.8%94.8% In FY25, CPD used 99.8% of its full-time pay budget, and overtime reached $1.56M, the highest in five years. The budget data does not show overtime hours or reasons. Empty jobs are one possible cause among several. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 09 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING Some budget lines came in above or below budget over five years FIVE-YEAR TOTAL: SPENDING MINUS UPDATED BUDGET Spent more than budgetedSpent less than budgeted Vehicle repair and upkeepVehicle repair and upkeep +$447K+$447K Equipment and furnitureEquipment and furniture +$459K+$459K Special events overtimeSpecial events overtime +$348K+$348K General overtimeGeneral overtime +$41K+$41K Full-time payFull-time pay −$4,127K UniformsUniforms −$393K−$393K Software licensesSoftware licenses −$217K−$217K How to read this chart Spending more may mean an outdated budget, a new contract or pay rule, an emergency, or bill timing. Spending less may mean empty jobs, money held back on purpose, bill timing, or a budget line no longer needed. Over five years, full-time pay ran $4.1M under budget. Vehicle repair, equipment, and special events overtime ran over. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 10 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING Vehicle repair spending exceeded its budget in all five years Repair budget (updated)Repair spending $0$0 $200K$200K $400K$400K $600K$600K FY22FY22 FY23FY23 FY24FY24 FY25FY25 FY26FY26 $157K$157K $154K$154K $360K$360K $297K$297K $408K$408K$293K$293K $291K$291K $369K$369K $461K$461K $410K$410K Spent on new vehiclesOrdered, not yet paid $0$0 $500K$500K $1,000K$1,000K $1,500K$1,500K FY22FY22 FY23FY23 FY24FY24 FY25FY25 FY26FY26 $406K $82K$82K $186K $227K $1,089K $96K$96K $832K $25K$25K $634K $110K$110K Repair and purchase data alone do not show vehicle age, mileage, time out of service, or replacement timing. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 11 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING Payments to Axon roughly doubled from FY22 to FY26 SPENDING WITH AXON ENTERPRISE $0$0 $200K$200K $400K$400K $600K$600K $800K$800K FY22FY22 FY23FY23 FY24FY24 FY25FY25 FY26FY26 $361K$361K $381K$381K $457K$457K $497K$497K $748K$748K $361K → $748K paid to Axon, FY22 to FY26 This does not mean prices doubled. The total may include devices, video storage, equipment, add- ons, licenses, or when bills came due. The spending data does not show what the Axon contract covers, device counts, storage, camera activation rates, or equipment failures. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 12 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING Four months into FY27, CPD has spent 20% of its budget FIRST 4 MONTHS OF FY27 $28.07M Updated budget $5.60M Spent so far $1.14M Ordered, not yet paid $21.32M Left in budget READING PARTIAL-YEAR DATA Four months of data cannot be projected to a full year. Big purchases, pay schedules, grants, contracts, carryover, and year-end closing make spending rise and fall during the year. Whether FY27 trends are long-term, seasonal, or one-time is not yet known. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 13 PRE-BUDGET BOARD BRIEFING Six factors that help explain a budget request Change from FY27 Lines that went up or down, and the reason for each large change. Yearly or one-time Pay, contract price increases, large purchases, grants, carryover, or program changes. Required or discretionary Set by the union contract, benefit costs, other contracts, law, safety rules, or CPD leadership. Past pattern Whether the line has often come in above or below budget. Supporting workload Staff, overtime hours, cases, training, vehicles, reviews, calls, and complaints. Expected results Effects on services, safety, risk, or public accountability. These factors offer one consistent way to compare the FY28 request with past spending. Charlottesville Police Civilian Oversight Board · Pre-budget Board briefing 14 POLICE CIVILIAN OVERSIGHT BOARD CHARLOTTESVILLE, VIRGINIA CPD General Order Excerpts Based on your perspective and experience, select each topic's priority for the Board's Monitor, Audit, Review model of oversight. Choose one level per topic: 1 = Low, 2 = Mid, 3 = High. Levels may repeat. TOP FIVE SUSTAINED ALLEGATION TYPES PRIORITY Unsatisfactory Performance G.O. 320, §320.7.17(A) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Department members shall maintain sufficient competency to properly perform their duties and assume the responsibilities of their positions. Members shall perform their duties in a manner that will maintain the highest standards of efficiency in carrying out the functions and objectives of the Department. NOTES Courtesy G.O. 320, §320.7.36(A) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Department members shall be tactful in the performance of their duties, shall control their tempers, and exercise the utmost patience and discretion, and shall not engage in argumentative discussions even in the face of extreme provocation. In the performance of their duties, members shall not use coarse, violent, profane, or insolent language or gestures, and shall not express any prejudice concerning race, religion, politics, national origin, lifestyle, gender, or any personal characteristics. NOTES Unbecoming Conduct G.O. 320, §320.7.5(A) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Members shall conduct themselves at all times, both on and off duty, in such a manner as to reflect favorably on the Department. Conduct unbecoming shall include that which brings the Department into disrepute or reflects discredit upon the employee as a member of the Department, or that which impairs the operation or efficiency of the Department or member. NOTES Mobile Audio/Video Recording G.O. 424, §424.4(C)–(D), (I) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Officers shall activate the “record” function of the BWC when engaged in law enforcement activity. Officers may also activate BWC recording when they are in circumstances that cause them to reasonably fear for their own safety, or the safety of any other person(s). Activation shall occur at the commencement of law enforcement activity, or as soon thereafter as is practical and safe under the circumstances. An officer is not required to activate the BWC if activation would jeopardize the safety of themself or any other person(s). […] If an officer fails to activate the BWC, fails to record the entire law enforcement activity, or interrupts/mutes a recording, the officer shall document that within written reports (e.g., incident, arrest, and related reports) with an explanation. NOTES Conformance to Law G.O. 320, §320.7.6(A) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Members shall obey all federal, state laws and regulations. They will also obey all laws and ordinances of the City of Charlottesville and any other jurisdiction in which they are present, whether on-duty or off-duty. NOTES Source: CPD General Orders (provided compilation). Selected excerpts; consult full policies for context. PCOB Priority Worksheet · Page 1 of 3 FIVE ADDITIONAL HIGH-FREQUENCY ALLEGATION TYPES PRIORITY Bias-Based Policing G.O. 401, §401.4; §401.5.1 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Bias-based policing is strictly prohibited. However, nothing in this policy is intended to prohibit an officer from considering protected characteristics in combination with credible, timely and distinct information connecting a person or people of a specific characteristic to a specific unlawful incident, or to specific unlawful incidents, specific criminal patterns, or specific schemes. […] Officers contacting a person shall be prepared to articulate the reason for the contact, independent of the protected characteristics of the individual. NOTES Truthfulness G.O. 320, §320.7.45(A) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Department members are to speak the truth at all times and under all circumstances. In cases where it is not allowed by law or by Department regulations to divulge facts and/or opinions within their knowledge, they will not speak on the subject. The only exception to this rule is during undercover investigations or toward lawful objectives during an investigation. NOTES Constitutional Procedures G.O. 348, §348.2 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High It is the policy of the Charlottesville Police Department to respect the rights of citizens of the United States of America as well as visitors and citizens of other countries. As such, all members shall observe and comply with every person’s clearly established rights under the United States and Virginia constitutions and shall follow professional policing standards as promulgated within this policy. NOTES Respect G.O. 320, §320.7.47(A) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Department members shall treat superiors, subordinates, and associates with respect. They shall be courteous and civil at all times in their relationships with one another. When on duty and in the presence of the public, officers shall be referred to by rank. Supervisors are forbidden to injure or discredit those under their authority by tyrannical or capricious conduct or by abusive language. Members shall work in harmony with each other and will not engage in disputes or altercations. NOTES Excessive Force G.O. 300, §300.4.1(A)–(B) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Officers shall use only that amount of force that reasonably appears necessary given the facts and circumstances perceived by the officer at the time of the event to accomplish a legitimate law enforcement objective/purpose. The reasonableness of force will be judged from the perspective of a reasonable officer on the scene at the time of the incident. Any evaluation of reasonableness must allow for the fact that officers are often forced to make split-second decisions about the amount of force that reasonably appears necessary in a particular situation, with limited information and in circumstances that are tense, uncertain, and rapidly evolving. NOTES Source: CPD General Orders (provided compilation). Selected excerpts; consult full policies for context. PCOB Priority Worksheet · Page 2 of 3 ADDITIONAL OVERSIGHT FOCUS — INVESTIGATIVE DETENTIONS Additional provisions relevant to the Board's Monitor, Audit, Review model of oversight. Assign a priority level as above and use the notes area to record observations and questions. Temporary Detention (Terry Stop) G.O. 348, §348.8.1(A)–(D) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Police officers are allowed to stop a person and detain them briefly for questioning upon a reasonable articulable suspicion that they may be involved in criminal activity. To lawfully stop an individual, an officer must be able to articulate reasonable suspicion that the person stopped has committed, is committing or is about to commit a crime. Reasonable suspicion exists when an officer can articulate facts sufficient to cause a reasonably prudent person to suspect that criminal activity is, has or is about to occur. The scope of activities permitted during an investigatory stop is determined by the circumstances that initially justified the stop. NOTES Encounters Leading to Detention — Reporting & Review G.O. 348, §348.8.17(B)–(F) 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High Whenever a person is stopped based on reasonable articulable suspicion or probable cause and property is not seized, the reasonable suspicion or probable cause must be fully articulated in a Temporary Detention Report. Whenever property is seized or the person is arrested as a result of a detention, an Incident (IBR) report and a Temporary Detention report must be completed. The narrative must articulate the officer's reasonable suspicion leading to the stop/frisk/search and the events surrounding the incident. The reviewing Supervisor and Shift Commander shall ensure that the facts and circumstances provided by the officer meet the requisite legal standard prior to approving the report. The Department's 4th Amendment Analyst will review all temporary detention reports and related incident reports, as well as all related BWC footage and evidence to ensure the officer and Department are adhering to the requisite legal standards. NOTES ADDITIONAL OVERSIGHT FOCUS — FOOT PATROLS PRIORITY Foot Patrol and Community Engagement G.O. 208, §208.6.1, OBJECTIVE 6 1 Low 2 Mid 3 High G.O. 208, Mission Statement, Goals, and Objectives, identifies strengthening community relationships as a departmental objective. It calls on CPD to: “Deploy more foot and bicycle patrols in the communities to engage with community stakeholders during non- enforcement actions.” “Increase ‘Walk & Talks’ weekly in each geo-sector led by the geography’s Commander.” These provisions establish foot patrols and informal, non-enforcement interactions as components of CPD’s community- policing strategy. However, the General Order does not specify how frequently individual officers must leave their vehicles or establish a required number or duration of foot patrols or community contacts. Source: G.O. 208, §208.6.1, Objective 6, “Strengthen Relationships” (PDF page 18; G.O. page 4). NOTES Source: CPD General Orders (provided compilation). Selected excerpts; consult full policies for context. PCOB Priority Worksheet · Page 3 of 3

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.