RecordWell Data

Board of Architectural Review Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Board of Architectural Review · meeting of Apr 21, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

April 2026 BAR Packet 1 Packet Guide City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Regular Meeting April 21, 2026 5:30 p.m. Hybrid Meeting (In-person at Council Chamber and virtual via Zoom) Pre-Meet ing Discussion [5 PM in the NDS conference room] Regul ar Meeting [5:30 PM in Council Chambers] A. Matters from the public not under items C through E on the agenda. B. Consent A genda [No minutes to review/approve at this month’s meeting.] 1. Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # 26-0008 320 West Main Street; TMP 290018000 Downtown ADC District Owner: 320 West Main LLC Applicant: Terry Hindermann/Mike Stoneking Project: Padel court 2. Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0012 410 2nd Street NE; TMP 330078000 North Downtown ADC District Owner: Rachel Lucy & Theodore Cisu, Trustees Applicant: Annie Mathot, Bluebird Design Company Project: Entry overhangs and site work 3. Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0013 408 Park Street; TMP 530117000 North Downtown ADC District Owner: RAF 408 LLC Applicant: Preston Hutter Project: Removal of exterior stairs at side entrance. C. Deferred I tems – N/A D. New Items – N/A [Any Consent Agenda item may be moved to the regular agenda.] E. Pre-Application Conferences – N/A F. Other Business [Including work sessions, staff questions/discussion, non-action items] April 2026 BAR Packet 2 3. Staff Discussion o DT Mall updates (vehicular crossings, fountains, lights) o Design Guidelines revisions – update & discussion G. Adjourn (7:00) April 2026 BAR Packet 4 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # 26-0008 320 West Main Street; TMP 290018000 Downtown ADC District Owner: 320 West Main LLC Applicant: Terry Hindermann/Mike Stoneking Project: Padel court Application components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to the report pages): • Staff Report • Historical Survey • Application Submittals April 2026 BAR Packet 5 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0012 410 2nd Street NE; TMP 330078000 North Downtown ADC District Owner: Rachel Lucy & Theodore Cisu, Trustees Applicant: Annie Mathot, Bluebird Design Company Project: Entry overhangs and site work Application components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to report pages): • Staff Report • Historical Survey • Application Submittals April 2026 BAR Packet 3 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0013 408 Park Street; TMP 530117000 North Downtown ADC District Owner: RAF 408 LLC Applicant: Preston Hutter Project: Removal of exterior stairs at side entrance. Application components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to report pages): • Staff Report • Historical Survey • Application Submittals 320 West Main Street – padel court– April 21, 2026 (3.27) 1 City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Staff Report April 21, 2026 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # 26-0008 320 West Main Street; TMP 290018000 Downtown ADC District Owner: 320 West Main LLC Applicant: Terry Hindermann Project: Padel court Background Year Built: c. 1890-1900 District: Downtown ADC District Status: Contributing Constructed as the Sparks-Garrett House, the property has been converted to commercial use. The stuccoed, frame structure is T-shaped with Victorian detailing in its wide frieze, cross-gabled roof with overhang eaves, and now enclosed porch with turned posts and brackets. [Historical survey attached.] Prior BAR Reviews July 16, 2020 – BAR approved exterior alterations and site work. Application • Applicant submittals: o 320 West Main St. Padel Court, Site Plan, Stoneking/von Storch Architects, 2 sheets. o Filux - Technical Sheet, 1 page. o Padel Letter 2, manufacturer responses, 2 pages. CoA request for installation of a padel court at rear of property. What is padel? (video) 320 West Main Street – padel court– April 21, 2026 (3.27) 2 Discussion For the purposes of this review staff identified the padel court as a non-supporting, accessory structure and therefore utilized criteria under Ch. 3, Section P (Additions) of the Design Guidelines in consideration of its compatibility. The structure’s placement at the rear of the parcel, where it is screened by both the primary building and existing fencing, significantly blocks visibility from West Main Street. Situated 117 ft. from the public right-of-way, the 2,178 sq.ft. padel court is a modular design without a traditional foundation. Installed on the existing asphalt parking surface, the steel frame and court surface will be raised off the ground up to 3.2 feet (1m) to accommodate changes in grade with no permanent ground anchors. Four angled poles with double headed LED light panels extend from each corner of the court and mounted at a height of 19’. Integrated glass panels surround the court’s exterior, with additional caging and netting in place towards the top of each, as a means of containing ball play. The installation is conceived as a fully reversible, non-permanent insertion that strategically activates an otherwise underutilized parking field, transforming it into a more dynamic and spatially engaged environment. Recommendation As this project meets the criteria outlined for additions within the ADC District Design Guidelines, staff recommends approval of the application as submitted with the condition that both the height of the light poles and lamping meet Code Sec. 34-4.12.3. Should a change in location, height or specification of the light posts or LED light panels be necessary, the applicant will submit an amendment with the alternative lighting plan for future BAR review if warranted by staff. Suggested Motions Approval Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed padel court at 320 West Main Street satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted with the following conditions… o That both the light poles and lamping meet code per Ch. 34 Div. 4.12.3 o Should a change in location, height or specification of the light posts or LED light panels be necessary, the applicant will submit an amendment with the alternative lighting plan for BAR review, if warranted by staff. Denial: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed padel court at 320 West Main Street does not satisfy the BAR’s criteria and is not compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that for the following reasons the BAR denies the request: […] Criteria, Standards and Guidelines Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34-5.2.7. Major Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34- 5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a building permit. Where a building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful 320 West Main Street – padel court– April 21, 2026 (3.27) 3 unless conducted in accordance with the required building permit and all applicable building code requirements.” Review Criteria Generally Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2: a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds: i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application. b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section. c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. […] Standards for Review and Decision Per Chapter 34, Div 5.2.7. D.1: a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features and factors: i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with the site and the applicable District; ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs; iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant; iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures; v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks; vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures; vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines. Links to ADC District Design Guidelines Chapter 1 Introduction (Part 1) Chapter 1 Introduction (Part 2) Chapter 2 Site Design and Elements Chapter 3 New Construction and Additions 320 West Main Street – padel court– April 21, 2026 (3.27) 4 APPENDIX Existing Conditions (Images by NDS staff) Rear yard fence – View Southwest Gate entrance from W. Main St. – View South 320 West Main Street – padel court– April 21, 2026 (3.27) 5 Rear parking area – View South Rear parking area – View North 320 West Main Street – padel court– April 21, 2026 (3.27) 6 Rear parking area – View East Rear alley, View North [~-.. --- 3 LANDMARK ----SURVEYBibb/Winter1979 IDENTIFICATION BASE DATA HistoricName:StreetAddress; ~1apandParcel: CensusTrack&Block: 320 ",estxaLn Street Spar~<:s-Gar::ett rIouse Date/Period: Style: Heightto Cornice: HeightinStories: PresentZoning: LandArea(sq.ft.): AssessedValue(land+ 29-18 1899 1-301 Vi=torian Vernac~ar PresentOwner: Address: Ferdinandand Judith A. Bazin 320 W. Main Street 2 PresentUse: OriginalOwner: OriginalUse: Restaurantand Residence Dr. B. H. Sparks 8-4 44' x 185' ave. (8140sq. ft.) imp.):Residenceand /'!edicalOffice ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION This 2-storey I 3-bay, stuccoed house set on a 10\1/ bz i.ckfoundation 1 c: in t~e ~-shape popular in che late 19tH cen- tury, with projecting side bays front and rear. The T-shaped ~edium-pitchedgable roof is covered with greenish compositionshingles. It has a boxed cornicewith returns and a wide cornice board. The gable ends are covered with wooden shinqlesabove the cornice, and each contains an attic window. The house is pa.irrcedwh i.t.ewith royal blue trim. A one-storey veranda covers the western two bays of ~~e facade. It has a low-?itc~ed hip roof cove~ed with the same greenish compositionshinglesand a boxed cornice. It has ceen enclosed with vertical'.•oodens i d.inq, leavingthe spool frieze and turnedposts and balustradeundisturbedon the outside. There is now a multi-light stationary-sash.window in each porch bay. The original entrance in ~~e central bay of the facade is now an interior door. Nindows are double-sash,2-over-2 light,with architravetrim.There i.s a one-storey semi-octagona" bay window in the eastern !Jayof the facade. Its low-pitchedhip roof is an extensionof the veranda'sroof. A door in one plane of ~'1ebay window originally'gave acces s to the doctor's office from the veranda. The ',,,{ndows match ~'1eothers in tr.ehouse. The one-storeyrear wing covering the two western bays is probably original. Its roof and windows match those in ~'1erest of the house. Side and back perches around it have been enclosed. The central chimney has been removed;a smaller one at the rear of ~'1ewing remains. A single-flightopen staircase wi~, simple turned balustrade rises from the central hall. Doors and wi ndowa ;a~ re svr:mne+- -i ••••r! l' To "'!'!-'Pt '-:er1 ;-. .•.....;""'I wi~'1corner blocks. The modate a child's room in HISTORICAL DESCRIPTIONparlor mantel has 'I'uscancolumns reaching to the top of a'mirror over-mantel. To accom- the attic, a sectionof the floor has been lowered and a stair and two skylights added. For nearly half of its 80 years, this house has served as a doctor's resicence and office. Dr. B. E. S9arks bought the lot in 1899 and built the house the sw~ year (CityDB 10-115). George~. Harris bought it from Dr. Sparks in 1908 (DB 19-462)and sold it in 1919 to Susie J. Nebb (~lrs.James J. ;'ebb)who owned it until 1945 (DB 34-104,120-483). Dr. M. T. Garrett purchased it in 1947 (DB 132-35) and for 29 years lived and had hiscffice there. The present owners bought the house from Dr. Garrett'sestate in 1977 (DB 388-313). They live on the second level and have remodeled~~e first level for use as a restaurant. AdditionalDeed References: City DB 17-465, 18-85; IVB 20-554. GRAPHICS CONDITIONS City Records SOURCESl1rs.Ferdinand Bazin Mrs. M. T. Garrett Sanborn Maps - 1907, 1920, 1969 Good LANOMARK CO.MMISSION 'OEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, AUGUST,1974 Possibly 1979? . Progress Photo. by Jim Carpenter JUDITH AND FERDINAND BAZINSTANDIN FRONT OF LOCATIONOF LE SNAIL The Restaurant Featuring European Cuisine Will Be Located on West Main Street. .' \ ',' , \ ( Something Old, Some,thlngNew, ' . . . . · ' By CINDYKELLEY' by the Bazins has been the The Bazins consider them. , of The Progress Staff 'iL'changes they have had to make selves "pioneers of West Main The snail, according to Web- in order to follow the hand. Street." ster, is a slow-moving, worm-j: ..icapped code. "We had to raise There is a city plan in the like mollusk with a protective: the floor, which created quite a making for the upgrading of the shell. . hardship," said Mrs. Bazin. Starr Hill neighborhood, where · This definition, however, is The Bazins are seeking to ac- Le Snail will be located, not indicative of the service compIish a warm and comfort- The area has gained quite a Judith and .Ferdinand Bazin able atmosphere exemplifying disreputable I reputation over plan to offer customers of Le European culture. Parts of the the years, but the Bazins are Snail. interior of the future restaurant quite confident their business · Le Snail, a new restaurant -are being built with pieces from: won't be affected. In fact they 'planned for Charlottesville, is the castle oryNydrie Farm in. appear quite thrilled by the fact going to offer a European at~ Keene. , . .:. ", they are indeed "pioneers" of mosphere WIth a Continental. Th '11b th f the faceIift planned for the menu. The menu will be pre- ~re WIt e ree rooms fJor neighborhood. . dominantly French, but~willr'-du~e.- y Cdus °bme'!:~~m-Jw:Q..,,~c -A-common questio~' asked oC"'\ f t G an and Ita i mmz an ,a ar.. , ,,\ , ,,I) so ,ea ure. erm . -:;(_,i Tht back 'dining' room will:( the" Bazins concerns parking , • i uan dishes, as well as dally spe- h fit' space whereby they quickly. I ' ave a more orma a mos- , , cIa s. . . ' .phere than the one planned for .point out that the City Market Austrian-born Bazin has been . th f t Th b '11 t 18 parking lot just across thehead chef at the Boars Head e ron. e ar WI sea " S t Cl b h h' f d h people the total seating capaci- street, has 180spaces for autos,por s u: were. IS 00 as ty will' be 70. The equipment for the kit, already gamed quite a repu· , . . . 'chen area is all second-hand. tation, for four-and~a'half Lunch prices will range, from The cou Ie found this a nec.' years. His cont~act WIth the $2,50to $5,and dinners wllIav-essary W~yto go because of the sports club ends I~ February ~f ,erage about S?to $6: ,'difficultv in obtainins il hank1979.and t.hp nnerunc of I,pSnail R"f"rn ."tt,ntT nr.nnn Dnn," ' of Assistant City Attorney Paul C. Garrett. The Bazins moved into the upper floor of the building a little over a year ago. The lower level is in the process of being transformed into Le Snail. One of the most difficult and costly alterations encountered. reahsnc study." said Bazm. He worked with seating capacity to see how many people would have to be fed per day, then took apart the concept to see if it was workable and came up with a "conservative figure of 60 per day" in order to break even. ;'i.rs. Bazin IS a g;'doudle 01 Barnard College and a former systems analyst for IBM. Bazin began as an apprentice chef at the age of 14and has been cre- ating his masterpieces since that time. Le Snail will be located at 320 W. Main St. Site PlanA1320 West Main St. Padel CourtStoneking/ von Storch Architects434-295-4204 434.981.4382 mds@s-vs.comDecember 22, 2025 Permit ApplicationCharlottesville, VA332" =1'-0"Base Survey N.T.S.Site Plan EXIST BUILDINGEXIST RAMPEXIST STOOPEXIST PARKING EXIST DRIVEEXIST PATIOEXIST CONCRETE SIDEWALKWEST MAIN STREETEXIST ADJACENT BUILDING PADEL COURTNEW RAISED PORTABLEEXIST ASPHALT NEW PADEL COURT:FLOATS ABOVE EXISITNG ASPHALTNO CHANGE TO IMPERVIOUS SURFACENO CHANGE TO STORMWATERNO FOUNDATIONS NEW STEPS C:\Users\Mike\Desktop\padel court cds.dwg, 12/22/2025 11:04:25 AM, AutoCAD PDF (General Documentation).pc3 Photo ExampleA2320 West Main St. Padel CourtStoneking/ von Storch Architects434-295-4204 434.981.4382 mds@s-vs.comDecember 22, 2025 Permit ApplicationCharlottesville, VA ADJUSTABLE FEETSITS ON EXISTING SURFACE NOTE:EXISTING SURFACE FOR THISPROJECT IS ASPHALT ENTRY STEPS BY COURTMANUFACTURER INTEGRAL COURTLIGHTINGPREMANUFACTUREDPORTABLE COURTBY PADEL GALIShttps://padelgalis.com/en/court/elevated-platform/ C:\Users\Mike\Desktop\padel court cds.dwg, 12/22/2025 11:04:27 AM, AutoCAD PDF (General Documentation).pc3 DATA SHEET DATA SHEET FT-21200 LED FLOODLIGHT 200W Overview It is the perfect replacement for outdoor halogen spotlights. It can be tilted to direct the light according to the needs of the moment. The light it emits is of high quality as indicated by its CRI. The opening angle is very suitable as a general lighting element. General information The perfect substitute for outdoor halogen spotlights. It can be tilted to direct the light according to the needs of the moment. The light it emits is of high quality as its CRI indicates. The opening angle is very suitable as a general lighting element. Informações gerais É o substituto perfeito para holofotes de halogênio ao ar livre. Pode ser inclinado para direcionar a luz, dependendo da necessidades do momento. A luz que emite é alta qualidade como indicado pelo seu CRI. The results of the opening angle is very suitable as an element of general lighting. SMD Photometry | Photometry | Photometry -150 9252 7402 150 Model Sku Power C.Temp Lumens Input -120 5551 3701 120 -90 -60 -30 1850 0 90 60 30 0 AVERAGE BEAM ANGLE(50%):111.2 DEG 1/1 Dimensiones |Dimensions| Dimensões 110º Ángulo Apertura Beam Angle Ãngulo De Abertura 3,2kg FT-21200 F2140 200W 3.000K 26.000 110-240V, 50-60HZ F2143 4.000K F2144 5.700K Hi Terri, First of all, my apologies for the delayed response. Your message from a few days ago slipped past us while we were coordinating the technical information for the project. Attached you will find the wind load verification study for the FlexiPadel platform together with the padel court structure. This engineering report was prepared by an independent structural engineering firm and analyzes the structural behavior of the complete system under wind loads. It should help support the technical review process with the city. The report evaluates the combined structure of the FlexiPadel base and the M90 padel court, considering gravitational loads, wind action, structural resistance, and stability. The calculations verify that the system safely withstands the design wind loads analyzed in the study. Although the analysis was developed using the M90 court structure, the same structural concept also applies to our Wilson-type courts, since both systems follow the same general structural principles and connection logic to the FlexiPadel base. Therefore, either court model can be installed on the FlexiPadel platform. To further clarify the structural concept, the FlexiPadel system is designed as a removable modular platform intended to support a padel court without the need for permanent concrete foundations. Unlike traditional installations where the court structure is anchored directly to concrete footings, the FlexiPadel platform distributes loads through a grid of structural steel profiles supported by adjustable pedestals. These pedestals transfer the loads uniformly to the surface below while allowing the platform to remain fully reversible and removable. In practical terms, this means: • No deep foundations or permanent ground anchors are required • The structure is assembled on top of the ground surface using a modular steel platform • Loads from the court, glass panels, steel frame, and playing surface are distributed across multiple support points rather than concentrated in isolated footings • The court structure itself is mechanically connected to the platform frame, creating an integrated structural system • The system can be disassembled and removed without permanent alteration of the site This design approach minimizes ground disturbance and makes the system particularly suitable for locations where permanent foundations are not desirable or where reversible construction is preferred. Regarding your specific questions: Platform anchoring The FlexiPadel system does not rely on traditional ground anchors such as screws or deep foundations. The platform is a modular steel base supported by adjustable pedestals that distribute the loads across the surface. The padel court structure is then mechanically connected to the FlexiPadel platform through anchoring plates, forming a stable integrated system. System weight and stability The stability of the system comes from the total combined weight of the platform and the court structure together with the distributed pedestal support system. The structural calculations included in the report consider the self-weight of the steel structure, glass panels, mesh, ceramic tiles, artificial turf, and the pedestal system when verifying structural behavior under wind loads. Because the system sits on a modular platform rather than being permanently anchored into the ground, it can be understood as a removable recreational installation rather than a traditional permanent building structure. This is one of the main advantages of the FlexiPadel system and is often helpful in permitting processes where reversible site interventions are preferred. Regarding lighting, I sent you a separate email with the fixture specifications and technical datasheet for the standard lighting system we normally install on outdoor courts. If the city ultimately determines that lighting spill could be a concern due to the tight site conditions, we also have the option of using our perimeter lighting system. This system was originally developed for indoor courts but can also be adapted for outdoor installations. It concentrates the light more directly over the playing surface and reduces light dispersion beyond the court perimeter. This alternative solution does have a different cost structure, but if the city raises concerns with the conventional lighting approach, we can coordinate with our engineering team in Spain to evaluate and potentially fast-track the perimeter lighting solution for this project. Please let me know if Mike or the city reviewers need any additional documentation. We are happy to support with any technical information needed to move the approval process forward. Best regards, Ali Montilla Director Mid-Atlantic +1 703 8145752 amontilla@padelgalismidatlantic.com www.padelgalis.us 410 2nd Street NE – roof overhangs/site modifications – April 21, 2026 (3.30) 1 City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Staff Report April 21, 2026 Certi ficate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0012 410 2nd Street NE; TMP 330078000 North Downtown ADC District Owner: Rachel Lucy & Theodore Cisu Applicant: Annie Mathot, Bluebird Design Company Project: Entry overhangs and rear shed alterations Back ground Year Built: c.1896 District: North Downtown ADC District Status: Contributing Queen Anne style structure, two stories with a projecting pavilion on the north side and fronted by a single-story veranda supported by short Doric columns on piers. (Historical survey attached.) Prior BAR Reviews May 16, 2023 – Approved CoA for rear addition and alterations. Application • Applicant submittals: o Lucy-Cisu Residence – 410 2nd St. NE, Charlottesville, Virginia dated April 10, 2026. Bluebird Design Company, project description,4 sheets. o Lucy-Cisu Residence – 410 2nd St. NE, Charlottesville, Virginia dated March 25, 2026. Grounded Landscape Architecture & Design, project description, 7 sheets. Requ est CoA for addition of two bracketed door overhangs on the East elevation of recent addition, and the following proposed site work: 410 2nd Street NE – roof overhangs/site modifications – April 21, 2026 (3.30) 2 o Removal and replacement of front concrete stairs at sidewalk o Patch and repair existing stone retaining wall at front sidewalk o Remove portion of broken concrete wall on north property line o Replacement of concrete entry path with bluestone pavers o Remove stone and wood bordered planting beds in front and side yards o Replace concrete stairs at front porch with wooden treads/risers o Construction of low wooden deck in front yard (SW corner) o Tree removal at SW corner o Tree plantings (one in front yard; multiple in rear yard) o Wood surround for HVAC at south elevation o New decorative metal fencing in the front and side yards o New wood privacy fencing in the rear yard Discussion & Recommendation Two entrance overhangs on the East (rear) elevation are to be added to the 2024 addition. The form is simple– a shed-style overhang supported with wooden brackets and standing-seam roofing in copper. A comprehensive landscaping plan aims to revitalize the property’s outdoor spaces. Much of the existing hardscape (entry path, stairs, planting borders, gravel and brick walkways) show signs of degradation and are to be replaced. While the primary stone retaining wall at the sidewalk will be patched and repaired, a smaller section of concrete wall at the north side of the property is to be completely removed. Landscaping submission, sheet L0.02; front yard features to be removed indicated in red. 410 2nd Street NE – roof overhangs/site modifications – April 21, 2026 (3.30) 3 The use of bluestone anchors this redesign, enhancing connectivity between the front porch, a new deck, and rear yard spaces. At the front porch, the existing concrete pavers will be replaced with wooden stairs painted to match the 2024 renovation. At the rear, a bluestone terrace replaces the existing pea gravel with new trees providing additional privacy. There are two fencing selections proposed. At the front and side yards, a 36” tall wrought iron fence will now enclose these areas. At the rear, the exiting wooden fence will be replaced-in-kind, maintaining gate access to both side yards and rear lot. Nearly all site alterations in this scope of work are consistent with the design guidelines for Site Design and Elements. BAR has approved similar fences, hardscaping, and material selections within this ADC district, including most recently at neighboring 422 2 nd St. NE. BAR may wish to discuss removal of the dogwood tree and construction of the low deck platform in the SW corner, as these are the only atypical modifications staff identified. Suggested Motions Approval: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find that the proposed rear door overhangs and site modifications at 410 2nd Street NE satisfy the BAR’s criteria and are compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that the BAR approves the application [as submitted]. […as submitted with the following conditions: …]. Denial: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find that the proposed rear door overhangs and site modifications at 410 2nd Street NE do not satisfy the BAR’s criteria and are not compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that the BAR denies the application [for the following reasons…]. Criteria, Standards and Guidelines Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34-5.2.7. Major Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34- 5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a building permit. Where a building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful unless conducted in accordance with the required building permit and all applicable building code requirements.” Review Criteria Generally Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2: a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds: i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application. 410 2nd Street NE – roof overhangs/site modifications – April 21, 2026 (3.30) 4 b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section. c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. […] Standards for Review and Decision Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1: a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features and factors: i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with the site and the applicable District; ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs; iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant; iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures; v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks; vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures; vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines. Links to ADC District Design Guidelines Chapter 2 Site Design and Elements Chapter 3 New Construction and Additions Chapter 2 – Site Design and Elements B. Plantings 1) Encourage the maintenance and planting of large trees on private property along the streetfronts, which contribute to the “avenue” effect. 2) Generally, use trees and plants that are compatible with the existing plantings in the neighborhood. 3) Use trees and plants that are indigenous to the area. 4) Retain existing trees and plants that help define the character of the district, especially street trees and hedges. 5) Replace diseased or dead plants with like or similar species if appropriate. 6) When constructing new buildings, identify and take care to protect significant existing trees and other plantings. 7) Choose ground cover plantings that are compatible with adjacent sites, existing site conditions, and the character of the building. 410 2nd Street NE – roof overhangs/site modifications – April 21, 2026 (3.30) 5 8) Select mulching and edging materials carefully and do not use plastic edgings, lava, crushed rock, unnaturally colored mulch or other historically unsuitable materials. C. Walls and Fences 1) Maintain existing materials such as stone walls, hedges, wooden picket fences, and wrought- iron fences. 2) When a portion of a fence needs replacing, salvage original parts for a prominent location. 3) Match old fencing in material, height, and detail. 4) If it is not possible to match old fencing, use a simplified design of similar materials and height. 5) For new fences, use materials that relate to materials in the neighborhood. 6) Take design cues from nearby historic fences and walls. 7) Chain-link fencing, split rail fences, and vinyl plastic fences should not be used. 8) Traditional concrete block walls may be appropriate. 9) Modular block wall systems or modular concrete block retaining walls are strongly discouraged but may be appropriate in areas not visible from the public right-of-way. 10) If street-front fences or walls are necessary or desirable, they should not exceed four (4) feet in height from the sidewalk or public right-of-way and should use traditional materials and design. 11) Residential privacy fences may be appropriate in side or rear yards where not visible from the primary street. 12) Fences should not exceed six (6) feet in height in the side and rear yards. 13) Fence structures should face the inside of the fenced property. 14) Relate commercial privacy fences to the materials of the building. If the commercial property adjoins a residential neighborhood, use a brick or painted wood fence or heavily planted screen as a buffer. 15) Avoid the installation of new fences or walls if possible in areas where there are no are no fences or walls and yards are open. 16) Retaining walls should respect the scale, materials and context of the site and adjacent properties. 17) Respect the existing conditions of the majority of the lots on the street in planning new construction or a rehabilitation of an existing site. D. Lighting 1) In residential areas, use fixtures that are understated and compatible with the residential quality of the surrounding area and the building while providing subdued illumination. 2) Choose light levels that provide for adequate safety yet do not overly emphasize the site or building. Often, existing porch lights are sufficient. […] E. Walkways and Driveways 1) Use appropriate traditional paving materials like brick, stone, and scored concrete. 2) Concrete pavers are appropriate in new construction, and may be appropriate in site renovations, depending on the context of adjacent building materials, and continuity with the surrounding site and district. 3) Gravel or stone dust may be appropriate, but must be contained. 4) Stamped concrete and stamped asphalt are not appropriate paving materials. 5) Limit asphalt use to driveways and parking areas. 6) Place driveways through the front yard only when no rear access to parking is available. 7) Do not demolish historic structures to provide areas for parking. 410 2nd Street NE – roof overhangs/site modifications – April 21, 2026 (3.30) 6 8) Add separate pedestrian pathways within larger parking lots, and provide crosswalks at vehicular lanes within a site. APPENDIX Sanborn Map 1907 From Survey, date unknown LANDMARK SURVEY IDENTIFICATION BASE DATA Street Address: 410 Second Street, NE Historic Name: Robinson House Map and Parcel: 33- 78 Date/Period: 1896 Census Track & Block: 3-504 Style: Victorian Vernacular Present Owner-: Address: Present Use: Original Owner: Original Use: Alberta Shannon c/o Virginia �ational Bank Residence Jessie w. RoCinson Height to Cornice: Height in Stories: Present Zoning: Land Area (sq.ft.): 2 R-3 3 7 x: 10 3 Residence Assessed Value (1and + imp.): 1soo ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPTION + 3'790 = 10,290 This house is a simplified version of the Queen Anne style po_?ular 1.n 4 e city from 1885 to about 1920. It is two stories high, with a projecting pavilion on � e right or north side, and fronted by a single story veranda supported by short Doric co umns on piers. The tin roof,· two over two glazing, blinds, and door are all original. HISTORICAL DESCRIPTION In 1896, 'Jessie W. Robinson bought the lot from Hugh T. Nelson for $750. At that t me the present structure was begun. The tax records £or the year 1897 indicate that � e lot was valued at $300 and t�e house $1,200. The current owner inherited the property ram the estate of Robinson. Deed references: 7-30·4, l.i.6-474, 237-305. GRAPHICS CONDITIONS SOURCES Average City Records LANDMARK COMMISSION-DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT ____________________________________________________________________________________ 32 Woodland Drive – Staunton, Virginia 24401 540.462.7318 – bluebirddesigncompanyplc.com bluebirddesign company April 10, 2026 Application for Certificate of Appropriateness 410 Second Street NE, Charlottesville Description of Existing Property The existing residence located at 410 Second Street NE was constructed around 1896 and is a two-story, three bay frame structure with intersecting gables, exposed rafter ends, and a hip standing seam copper roof. The projecting left front bay has wood shingles in the gable and a decorative panel in the roof peak; the south elevation has a bay with similar shingled gable and decorative panel. The house has a single-story front porch with Tuscan columns set on brick piers with a bracketed cornice. The variety of shape and materials exhibit Queen Anne characteristics. The front entrance is a double door with louvered shutters; windows are typically two-over-two wood sash. The home was renovated in 2024, and a two-story frame addition was constructed at the rear of the original house. The addition has composite lap siding, a flat roof, and two-over-two windows. Description of Proposed Exterior Work The proposed scope of work includes the addition of two bracketed door overhangs on the East elevation of the existing house. The construction of bracketed overhangs will protect the exterior doors and provide shelter from the weather when entering the home. The overhangs will be constructed of wood, with copper standing seam metal roofs. Proposed Materials House overhang brackets: wood House overhang roof: standing seam copper bluebird design company 410 2nd St NE, Charlottesville, Virginia - April 10, 2026 Lucy-Cisu Residence SCALE: 3/16" = 1'-0"1 HOUSE: EXISTING SOUTH ELEVATION 0 4' 8' 12' SCALE: 3/16" = 1'-0"2 HOUSE: EXISTING EAST ELEVATION 0 4' 8' 12' bluebird design company 410 2nd St NE, Charlottesville, Virginia - April 10, 2026 Lucy-Cisu Residence NEW ROOF OVERHANG NEW OVERHANG NEW OVERHANG: STANDING SEAM COPPER ROOF AND WOOD BRACKETS, PAINTED SCALE: 3/16" = 1'-0"1 HOUSE: PROPOSED SOUTH ELEVATION 0 4' 8' 12' SCALE: 3/16" = 1'-0"2 HOUSE: PROPOSED EAST ELEVATION 0 4' 8' 12' Lucy-Cisu Residence 410 2nd St NE, Charlottesville, Virginia - April 10, 2026 bluebird design company Existing house, east facadeExisting house, view from southwest Proposed house roof overhangs, view from North Proposed house roof overhangs, view from East BAR REVIEW 410 2ND St. NE Charlottesville, VA March 31, 2026 DESCRIPTION OF EXISTING SITE The existing site has a mix of concrete and railroad tie retaining walls. Concrete stairs from the sidewalk and a concrete entry path and front stairs are cracked and sunken in areas. A large 33” caliper oak is the cornerstone of the yard and sits in the northwest quadrant. To the rear, a small gravel patio and partial wood privacy fence sit between the existing house, porches and garage. DESCRIPTION OF PROPOSED SITE WORK The proposed site work includes removal and replacement of the front concrete stairs off the sidewalk with monolithic bluestone treads, removing the broken concrete entry path with dry laid bluestone, and replacing existing sunken concrete stairs to the front porch with painted wooden treads and risers to match the 2024 renovation. The stacked stone planters below the porch will be replaced with thermaled bluestone slab planters. To the south side of the front yard, a wooden deck set on existing grade will provide additional usable space while avoiding damage to the oak tree. One dogwood will be removed and replaced by a redbud to the front with 10 fastigiate hornbeam or ginkgo trees proposed along the fence to the rear. The front and south side yard will be enclosed with a 3’ high metal fence. The rear yard will be contained by a wood privacy fence stained to match the black or darker green paint of the 2024 house renovation. PROPOSED SITE MATERIALS Front fencing and gate: wrought iron, 36” high Front entry path: cleft variegated bluestone in ashlar pattern, dry laid Front entry stairs: monolithic thermaled bluestone Front retaining walls: parged concrete Front planters: thermaled bluestone slabs Front deck: wooden, cedar or ipe TBD on floating frame system Rear fencing: rough-sawn cedar +/- 7’ high privacy fence, stained to match architecture Rear paving: cleft variegated bluestone in ashlar pattern, mortared Rear planters: thermaled bluestone slabs L0.00 RETAINING WALL & BOXWOODS TO REMAIN. RAILROAD TIE & DRY-STACKED STONE RETAINING FOR REPLACEMENT. FRONT OF HOUSE. EXISTING FRONT STAIR CHEEK WALLS & PATH. CONCRETE STAIRS & PATH FOR REMOVAL. BROKEN CONCRETE WALL FOR REMOVAL. PATCH & REPAIR REMAINING RETAINING WALL. EXISTING WALL & COLUMNS TO REMAIN. NEW CHEEK WALL & STAIRS TO REPLACE EXISTING. L0.01 EXISTING PRIVACY FENCE FOR REPLACEMENT. EXISTING TRASH STORAGE & SIDE ENTRY AT EASEMENT. EXISTING FENCING. EXISTING REAR PRIVACY FENCE & GATE TO SIDE OF HOUSE. EXISTING OAK AND DOGWOOD TREES. EXISTING REAR PORCHES & GRAVEL TERRACE. DEMO PLAN L0.02 LUCY-CISU RESIDENCE 410 2ND ST NE CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA 22902 434.249.7779 03.31.2026 BAR SUBMITTAL 0248 SCALE 14 "= 1' DRIVEWAY EASEMENT 2ND ST NE BROKEN PORTION OF STONE WALL TO BE REMOVED EXISTING 33" OAK TREE TO REMAIN; AVOID CUTTING OR COMPACTION OF ROOT ZONE EXISTING STONE WALL TO REMAIN EXISTING CONCRETE PATHWAY TO BE REPLACED EXISTING CONCRETE STAIRS TO BE REPLACED EXISTING CONCRETE CHEEK WALL TO BE REPLACED EXISTING STONE WALLS TO REMAIN EXISTING RAILROAD TIE WALL FOR REMOVAL EXISTING STACKED STONE WALL TO BE REMOVED EXISTING RAILROAD TIE WALL FOR REMOVAL; LOCATION OF AC UNIT TO STAY THE SAME EXISTING BRICK PATH TO BE REMOVED STAIRS TO BE REPLACED 7" CAL. DOGWOOD FOR REMOVAL STONE BED & GRAVEL FOR REMOVAL EXISTING FENCE TO BE REPLACED EXISTING DECK TO REMAIN RENOVATED GARAGE BY ARCHITECT EXISTING RESIDENCE PROPERTY LINE PROPERTY LINE SETBACK SETBACK 11 2" 10'-0" 3'-0" FENCE DETAILS LUCY-CISU RESIDENCE 410 2ND ST NE CHARLOTTESVILLE, VA 22902 434.249.7779 03.31.2026 BAR SUBMITTAL WROUGHT IRON FENCE 1 WROUGHT IRON GATE 2 PRIVACY FENCE 3 2.00 SCALE 1"= 1' 1 X 6 ROUGH-SAWN CEDAR CLADDING 2 X 8 ROUGH-SAWN CEDAR CAP 2 X 6 P.T., 18" O.C. 6 X 6 P.T. POST 1 X 6 ROUGH-SAWN CEDAR CLADDING NOTE: FENCE TO BE STAINED DARK GREEN OR SOFT BLACK TO MATCH ARCH. 2 X 8 ROUGH-SAWN CEDAR CAP PRIVACY GATE 4 2.00 SCALE 1"= 1' 6 X 6 P.T. POST 6 X 6 P.T. POST NOTE: GATE TO BE STAINED DARK GREEN OR SOFT BLACK TO MATCH ARCH. 2 X 8 ROUGH-SAWN CEDAR CAP 1 X 6 ROUGH-SAWN CEDAR CLADDING SS KEYED KNOB BLUESTONE PLANTER BLUESTONE LANDING 2.00 2.00 L2.00 408 Park Street – stair removal – April 2026 (4.10) 1 City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Staff Report April 21, 2026 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0013 408 Park Street; TMP 530117000 North Downtown ADC District Owner: RAF 408 LLC Applicant: Preston Hutter Project: Removal of exterior stairs at side entrance. B ackground Year Built: c.1854; north bay c.1923 District: North Downtown ADC District Status: Contributing “T he Tower House” is a unique example of an Italianate, Pilastered-style façade, featuring prominent scrolled brackets along the cornice and a double arched window at the uppermost level of the tower. The north portion of the building was constructed after 1923, utilizing the foundations of a previous veranda. [Historical survey attached.] P rior BAR Reviews July 17, 2014 – Administrative approval for tax credit work: roof replacement; rehabilitation. August 18, 2015 – CoA for curbing replacement and site work. September 3, 2015 - Staff approved revisions to the August 15, 2015 CoA. A pplication • Applicant submittals: o 408 Park Street – BAR Application April 2026, 13 pages. R equest CoA for removal of non-contributing cement stairs at the side entrance on the north elevation. 408 Park Street – stair removal – April 2026 (4.10) 2 Discussion and Recommendations The stairs on the north side of the house are no longer utilized as an entrance by the current owner/occupants. As this portion of the structure was constructed sometime after 1923, the concrete staircase, entrance stoop, and railings are not associated with the historic core. The doorway itself is no longer serviceable from the interior and has been walled off for conversion to storage space. Removal of the staircase would improve access along the walkway between the front entrances of the building and its rear parking area. Only the staircase and its metal handrail are to be removed. The raised stoop, its support piers, and metal perimeter railing will remain. (See images below.) Where the stairs meet the concrete path there is a change in grade; an approximate 6” step will be revealed across the walkway at this location. Where the staircase interacts with the brick façade, repairs will be made as necessary to maintain the exterior in good condition. There are no changes proposed to the window at the basement level. Staff recommends approval and requests the applicant pay particular attention to protecting the north elevation during demolition of the staircase to ensure no damage to the bricks or basement window occurs. Suggested Motions Approval [with approval of the consent agenda]: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed stair removal at 408 Park Street satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted. Or, [as submitted with the following conditions…] Criteria, Standards and Guidelines Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34-5.2.7. Major Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34- 408 Park Street – stair removal – April 2026 (4.10) 3 5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a building permit. Where a building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful unless conducted in accordance with the required building permit and all applicable building code requirements.” Review Criteria Generally Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2: a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds: i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application. b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section. c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. Conditions may require a reduction in height or massing, consistent with the City’s design guidelines and subject to the following limitations: i. Along the Downtown Mall, the BAR may limit story height to within 2 stories of the prevailing story height of the block; ii. In all other areas subject to review, the BAR may reduce the allowed height by no more than 2 stories; and iii. The BAR may require upper story stepbacks of up to 25’. Standards for Review and Decision Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1: a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features and factors: i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with the site and the applicable District; ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs; iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant; iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures; v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks; vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures; vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines. 408 Park Street – stair removal – April 2026 (4.10) 4 Links to ADC District Design Guidelines Chapter 1 Introduction (Part 1) Chapter 1 Introduction (Part 2) Chapter 2 Site Design and Elements Chapter 3 New Construction and Additions Chapter 4 Rehabilitation Chapter 5 Signs, Awnings, Vending, and Cafes Chapter 6 Public Improvements Chapter 7 Demolition and Moving APPENDIX Sanborn Map Evidence This series of Sanborn Maps from 1913 onwards corroborates statements from the historical survey regarding alterations to the historic core after 1923, in particular the addition of the northern bay. 1913 Sanborn Map (prior to addition of north bay) 408 Park Street – stair removal – April 2026 (4.10) 5 1920 Sanborn Map (no change from 1913) 1965 Sanborn map (Alteration/additions in place) 1 408 Park Street - BAR Application April 2026 North Elevation - existing conditions 2 3 Stairway to be removed (street view) 4 5 Attachment points to be repaired 6 Attachment points to be repaired Existing Railing Step to be completed Basement window to the right of the stairs. 7

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.