RecordWell Data

Board of Architectural Review Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Charlottesville · Charlottesville City County · Board of Architectural Review · meeting of Mar 17, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Charlottesville

This document is no longer listed on City of Charlottesville's website. We kept the copy we read.

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

March 2026 BAR Packet 1 Packet Guide City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Regular Meeting March 17, 2026 5:30 p.m. Hybrid Meeting (In-person at Council Chamber and virtual via Zoom) P re-Meeting Discussion [5 PM in the NDS conference room] R egular Meeting [5:30 PM in Council Chambers] A. Ma tters from the public not under items C through E on the agenda. B. Consent Agenda 1. Meeting minutes: January 21, 2026 [Link to meeting video.] C . Deferred Items - N/A D. Ne w Items 2. C ertificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0006 554 Valley Road; TMP 110053200 Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District Owners/Applicants: Lindsay & Evan Edwards Project: Addition on front elevation with other alterations 3. C ertificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0007 707-709 West Main Street; TMP 320156000 West Main Street ADC District Owner: Starr Hill Properties, LLC Applicant: Cliff Fox Project: Seasonal vestibule 4. C ertificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0009 208 3rd Street NE; TMP 330215100 Downtown ADC District Owner: Asharper, LLC [The Luck Group II, LLC] Applicant: Jennifer Batchelder, Glickman Design Studio Project: Window replacements and exterior modifications E. Pre-Application Conferences [Including continued, preliminary discissions] F. O ther Business [Including work sessions, staff questions/discussion, non-action items] March 2026 BAR Packet 2 5. Staff Discussion • Preservation Month - May • 218 W. Market Street Cultural Resource Assessment • Downtown Mall 50th Anniversary G. Adjourn (8:00) 1 BAR Meeting Minutes January 21, 2026 BAR MINUTES CITY OF CHARLOTTESVILLE BOARD OF ARCHITECTURAL REVIEW Regular Meeting January 21, 2026 – 5:00 PM Hybrid Meeting (In person at City Council Chambers & virtual via Zoom) Welcome to this Regular Monthly Meeting of the Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review. Staff will introduce each item, followed by the applicant’s presentation, which should not exceed ten minutes. The Chair will then ask for questions from the public, followed by questions from the BAR. After questions are closed, the Chair will ask for comments from the public. For each application, members of the public are each allowed three minutes to ask questions and three minutes to offer comments. Speakers shall identify themselves and provide their address. Comments should be limited to the BAR’s purview; that is, regarding only the exterior aspects of a project. Following the BAR’s discussion and prior to taking action, the applicant will have up to three minutes to respond. Members Present: Carl Schwarz, Ron Bailey, Roger Birle, James Zehmer, Jerry Rosenthal, Katherine Tabony, Cheri Lewis Staff Present: Patrick Cory, Remy Trail, Jeff Werner, Kate Richardson, Sarah Kim Pre-Meeting: There was discussion surrounding the Preliminary Discussion surrounding the proposed project on St. Charles Avenue. Mr. Schwarz did have questions about whether the BAR should be reviewing the project. Members of the BAR were given copies of the BAR bylaws to review. In the old ordinance, there was no pre-application conference for Historic Conservation Districts. The proposed project on St. Charles is in the Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District. There is one pre-application conference for proposed projects in Historic Conservation Districts and two pre-application conferences for ADC Districts. There was a question regarding snow days and delaying BAR meetings. Mr. Zehmer brought up what could possibly happen if a BAR meeting is canceled due to something out of control of the BAR. The meeting was called to order by Mr. Zehmer at 5:30 PM. A. Matters from the public not on the agenda. James Snyder (206 5 th Street SW) – At one of the last meetings, one of the members mentioned that an option for historic preservation for an area like Fifeville might be a different type of historic preservation overlay, not one that was so specific that it detailed every window, shutter, and paint color. I wonder if we could get some more information about that. Is there a way to nominate houses? There is a house that is 100 years old, that is a unique, stone bungalow on 5th Street that looks like it was built about the same time by the same contractor as Rock House. It has been restored and is in much better shape when it was nominated. Mr. Werner – Fifeville-Tonsler historic district is on the National Register and Virginia Landmarks Register as a historic district. The building that Mr. Snyder is talking about is contributing. A lot of them already are contributing. There is a National Register District overlay. The BAR only has purview only over what is locally designated. The city has the Architectural Design Control (ADC) Districts. We have 8 of those: West Main, Downtown, North Downtown, Wertland, etc. Those are the more rigid of the historic districts. In the city, we also have Individually Protected Properties (IPPs). For example, we have 2 houses on 7 th Street. The reason that we were reviewing that project is because they were IPPs. The work on IPPs follows the more rigid design 2 BAR Meeting Minutes January 21, 2026 review. The city also has 3 Historic Conservation Districts: Woolen Mills, Martha Jefferson, and Rugby Road. Those are a ‘historic district light.’ We look primarily at what is visible from the right-of-way. The way that I have explained it to people is that the design guidelines for ADC Districts are 150 pages. For historic conservation districts, it is maybe 3 pages. To get nominated as an ADC or Historic Conservation District, a community neighborhood can propose those. It would take overwhelming community support. For Council or staff to even consider taking it to Council, it is not a panacea. Council is very careful about it, given the last time they reviewed one, there was a lot of contention about it. It would take overwhelming support from the neighborhood. They would have to contact me. It would take a zoning text amendment and zoning map amendment to do an ADC district or IPP or historic conservation district. The overlay does not change the underlying zoning. The Board of Architectural Review gets a certain amount of purview. An overlay does not suddenly say that you cannot do something here if it is permitted by zoning. That is what I would offer given that area is already on the National Register. Mr. Zehmer – Mr. Snyder is referring to the Historic Conservation District that we had talked about. The second question was whether there was a way to list an IPP. It is a good segway into our first new item tonight. Mr. Werner – There are some additional IPPs in Fifeville. I am not sure if that house on 5 th Street is one. I know there are several there that were. I cannot speak about the Fifeville process. My understanding is that when that survey was done and the National Register District was discussed, I don’t know why local designation wasn’t pursued. I imagine it came up. Mr. Zehmer – If someone wanted to pursue creating an IPP for a property, they can do that. There is an avenue to do it. We have one on our agenda tonight. Does the owner have to be the person? Mr. Werner – We won’t consider an IPP unless it comes from the owner. We had a small conservation district proposed a couple years ago. It is somewhat still pending, the CH Brown HC District on 12 th and Rosser. It is only 6 buildings. One is already an IPP. I needed to hear from the 5 other property owners that they supported that designation. That has not occurred. I cannot move that forward Ms. Lewis – Didn’t we also have a potential IPP in the Greenbrier District? Mr. Werner – It was recently listed on the National Register. That has not been brought forward. It would take the owner. Genevieve Keller – I attended City Council meeting last night. There was a lot of discussion or at least an introduction of a topic of architectural review control for what they are calling the core neighborhoods, RNA neighborhoods. I did make some comments. I supported using a conservation district, which I thought would be more appropriate. If that was to proceed, it would need to be handled in a different and more sensitive manner and still meet the state requirements for a historic district. I spoke about it. There was a lot of discussion last night. It is something Preservation Piedmont consistently recommended through the code revision and possibly in the Comp Plan, one of the parts of a solution for what they were initially calling sensitive neighborhoods. Since Mr. Werner was talking about National Register nominations, there is a bill being introduced in the General Assembly this session that would reduce the notification requirements for National Register nominations. I don’t know if you are aware of that. It is not something immediately of interest to the city, but down the pipe, it might be. What it is doing is removing the requirement that adjacent owners be notified by mail of a pending National Register nomination. DHR (Department of Historic Resources) is supporting that. It will make the notification requirements less onerous for them and for jurisdictions like Charlottesville. It contributes to a misunderstanding now. There is no role for adjacent property owners to play when something is nominated to the National Register. It would be if they were in a district. It is something that would streamline the process. It will also create a better understanding. People are notified and they think that they have a role. 3 BAR Meeting Minutes January 21, 2026 They don’t have any role. If it was to go to court, they would not have any standing. It might be something that the department would want to send letter saying we are in support of this. B. Consent Agenda (Note: Any consent agenda item may be pulled and moved to the regular agenda if a BAR member wishes to discuss it, or if any member of the public is present to comment on it. Pulled applications will be discussed at the beginning of the meeting.) 1. Meeting Minutes – December 16, 2025 Motion to Approve – Ms. Lewis – Second by Mr. Bailey – Motion passes 6-0 with 1 abstention (Mr. Schwarz) C. Deferred Items N/A D. New Items 2. Recommendation to City Council – IPP Designation Application for ZMA/ZTA pending 801 West Street; TMP 310042000 Owner/ Applicant: Richard H. Hunt, Jr. Project: Zoning amendment to designate property an IPP Kate Richardson, Staff Report – The BAR is asked to make a recommendation to City Council on the owner’s request to designate as an Individually Protected Property (IPP) an approximately 0.3-acre parcel located at the NW corner of West Street and 8th Street, NW, within the 10th & Page Neighborhood. On December 9, 2025, in response to a request from the property owner, the Planning Commission voted to initiate the necessary review to amend City Code Chapter 34, Section 2.9.3.B. to designate this parcel an IPP, and, per City Code Chapter 34, Section 5.2.5, amend the City Zoning Map to identify this parcel as having an IPP overlay. Designation of an IPP follows the process for an amendment to the City's zoning ordinance and zoning map, including a public hearing and notification. Ms. Lewis – Can staff summarize or address the emails that were exchanged this week about further work that was done on the property that are not represented in the pictures and the description? Ms. Richardson – This house was constructed around 1905. In 1905 and later in 1913, there was a dependency or garage at the rear of the property. That was demolished prior to the early 1960s. In some of these pictures, there has been some alteration of enclosing this porch area. I believe that Mr. Schwarz provided some documentation yesterday. These images are from the Virginia Department of Historic Resources survey in 2021. In our efforts, we would document the known changes and sequence as best we could. With what is there, there already have been some modifications in the 20 th century, the addition of stucco and replacement windows. We would put that into our full summary of the structure. Ms. Lewis – Is the widow’s walk original? Mr. Werner – To our knowledge, yes. Ms. Lewis – Is there roof access up there? 4 BAR Meeting Minutes January 21, 2026 Mr. Werner – I don’t know. I don’t know if that is a decorative feature or not. The gentleman that built the house was a well-known builder and craftsman. When you see the pictures of the interior, you certainly see the attention to detail. This section of 10th & Page, this northeast corner was originally the white section of 10th & Page. You see the ownership changing over in the 1930s and 1940s. That is when Mr. Hunt’s family acquired the home. They have lived in it and owned it ever since. The consultant identified it as one of the older homes in 10th & Page. We think that there are several 1880-era homes down near the Old Cox’s Row that was associated with the railroad. It is one of the older homes. To the best that we can determine, it is in pretty good condition from when it was constructed. Mr. Rosenthal – What was the original siding before the stucco? Mr. Werner – We assume that with a lot of houses that it was siding. Stucco in Charlottesville is like the aluminum siding that you saw all over Baltimore in the 1950s. Stucco was a thing that was added in the early 20 th century to a lot of homes around here. Presumably, it was a wood siding. It is probably still there. Ms. Lewis – What are the oldest pictures that we have? Does the owner have any early pictures? Ms. Richardson – I am looking for that. Mr. Hunt, the owner, shared the interior pictures that you see and some additional ones. This might be a good question for him. We are looking through our archives. I have 10 th & Page pictures from the 1970s and 1980s. Mr. Werner – Anything we have would not go back further than the 1970s. With the zoning text amendment and zoning map amendments, the best way to do something like this is to ask the Planning Commission to initiate it. That takes some of the burden off the applicant. That takes some of the burden off the applicant for something like this. Mr. Hunt approached me last summer with the idea. We have been talking about it. He is officially the requestor of this. Richard Hunt, Applicant – I am a son of Charlottesville I was born in the University of Virginia hospital. My grandparents are from Charlottesville. My grandmother taught at Jefferson School for 40 years. Much of my heart and soul and a lot of my money has gone into preserving the home that my grandparents purchased during the war. It stands there because I love Charlottesville. It is a monument to them and to my mother, who passed it down to me. I want to make sure that it is there for as long as it is standing and as an example to the community of the respect that the city would confer on the people of 10 th & Page. For the things that we went through, for the things that we have developed, for our contributions to the city’s culture, to our contributions to the city’s economy, it is a beautiful house. I hope that you will come by and look. To answer a previous question, I do have a picture of my grandfather holding me when I was 2 years old in front of that house. It looks exactly like it does now. It does answer the question in part about when the stucco was on. It has been there as long as I have been there. That makes it about 69 years and counting. QUESTIONS FROM THE PUBLIC No Questions from the Public QUESTIONS FROM THE BOARD No Questions from the Board COMMENTS FROM THE PUBLIC James Snyder – I want to congratulate Mr. Hunt. It is a beautiful house. Your family has been a great steward for it. It is houses like this that are kept up by the families and been there that make a community. That whole 5 BAR Meeting Minutes January 21, 2026 neighborhood could use your help if we can help preserve it and help it be enhanced and survive all the development that is going on around it. I live in an older neighborhood and appreciate older homes. Mr. Werner – Mr. Hunt and I have communicated back and forth on email. We have recently talked on the phone. We have had some email issues that we have hopefully resolved. The backstory of these places is what is always so amazing to me about Charlottesville and the connections that exist. This is a small town. When you piece together the names, I know the story of Mr. Hunt’s mother. I did not know the connection to Mr. Martin. I see these stories woven through this ‘quilt’ that is this town. It is amazing. In the HRC meetings, we talk about places in the city that are places that is important for a certain thing or certain event. COMMENTS FROM THE BOARD Mr. Schwarz – We have the item, the association of the building structure site with historic person or event. Is there a way to add to this? Mr. Werner – As this moves forward, I gave it as much. I was able to piece together from the census and from the directory some information. The evolution of this story is something we can work on as it moves forward to the Planning Commission and City Council. Mr. Schwarz – If there is some future owner and they want to do something; the text is there for that. Mr. Werner – One of the things we would have to in the GIS layer is the ability to show sites in this town that associated with these stories. In the future, we can at least connect that story to it that somebody may not know. Mr. Bailey – If this gets designated, does that mean it is preserved as it currently stands? Mr. Werner – That means that it is like any other house in a historic district. Alterations to the exterior, demolition, and new construction would require BAR review. Mr. Zehmer – Mr. Schwarz, your point is well taken that potentially a historic person associated at the local level would be a prominent educator lived in this house. Motion – Mr. Schwarz – Having reviewed the criteria for designation of Individually Protected Properties per City Code Chapter 34, Section 2.9.3., I move the BAR recommend that City Council approve the request to designate 801 West Street (Parcel 31-42) an Individually Protected Property. We request that staff supplement the record of this with current pictures and the history of those who have lived there and documentation of recent modifications. Second by Ms. Lewis. Motion passes 7-0. E. Other Business 3. Preliminary Discussion BAR # HST25-0119 705 St. Charles Ave, TMP 520155001 Martha Jefferson Historic Conservation District Owner: Kimberly and Galen Suppes Applicant: Marcelino Arroyo / Nola Builds Project: New residence on vacant parcel • Staff introduced this proposed project and new construction to the BAR. • With conservation districts when compared to ADC districts, it is a much lighter touch and fewer guidelines. 6 BAR Meeting Minutes January 21, 2026 • The guidance for materials in conservation districts to be typical. Staff do not find the proposed materials to meet that standard. • Staff does feel strongly about the proposed materials. • With the proposed design, there are some code issues that do need to be resolved with this proposed new construction. • If the overlay were to be removed, it would go to the Planning Commission and eventually to City Council. It would be publicly noticed. • Ms. Tabony had questions about the sight lines from St. Charles. • The parcel has been split, and the address has been assigned to the parcel. • With historic conservation districts, there are fewer guidelines as compared to ADC districts guidelines. • The applicant presented that it will not have vinyl siding and will use cement lap siding, dimensional shingles. • The applicant will not be putting metal on the roof. There will be no vinyl rails on the porches and there will be black metal. • The biggest part of this proposed house is the garage requirement. Garages in this neighborhood tend to be either in the rear or on the side. • The biggest issues for most members of the BAR were around the materiality of the project. The applicant was able to address those issues and answer those questions. • Members of the BAR were pleased with the answers to the questions. 4. Work Session • Review draft of changes and revisions to BAR bylaws o (4.3) Once a motion has been made, there is nothing about future conversation with the applicant. o There was a robust discussion surrounding having questions and comments from the public and whether there should be one opportunity for the public to ask questions and make comments. o Staff believe that the process of having separate questions and comments from the public, as it currently is. o Mr. Schwarz mentioned asking a member of the public could be a privacy issue. Staff are going to investigate whether members of the public need to provide their address when providing public comments. o Mr. Schwarz did bring up finding a solution to snow days and a lack of quorum for meetings. o The code does allow an appeal if a project is approved due to the lack of a BAR meeting. o Staff did go over the public notification process, timeline, and rules of the BAR regarding applications and other actionable items. o (2.2) Staff will no longer be handing the notices of BAR meetings as stated in the bylaws to the members. o The quorum requirement for BAR meetings to occur is a majority of the appointed members. With the current number of 8 members, a quorum is 5. o There was discussion surrounding items pulled from the Consent Agenda and the place in the meetings for those pulled items. o Staff did go over recusal from items. Unless a member stands to lose or make money based on a BAR decision, members do not need to recuse themselves. o It is each member’s decision on whether to recuse themselves voluntarily from an item on the agenda. o If a member recuses themselves for an item, they do need to leave the room for the deliberation on the item. Staff will bring member back into the room. 7 BAR Meeting Minutes January 21, 2026 The meeting was recessed for 5 minutes. The meeting was called back to order following a 5-minute recess. • Minor Historic Reviews – Scenario planning o Staff will no longer use the term ‘administrative approval’ going forward. o Staff did go over with the BAR the different types of minor development projects that staff receive on a regular basis. o Staff did present examples of the different kinds of minor projects that have been submitted. o There was discussion between staff and the BAR regarding the different projects that have been reviewed by staff. o With tree removal, staff does need to see a tree removal permit 5. Staff questions/discussion • BAR awards • Landscape Architect vacancy on the BAR F. Adjourn Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 8:36 PM. March 2026 BAR Packet 3 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0006 554 Valley Road; TMP 110053200 Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District Owners/Applicants: Lindsay & Evan Edwards Project: Addition on front elevation with other alterations Application components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to the report pages): • Staff Report • Application Submittal March 2026 BAR Packet 4 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0007 707-709 West Main Street; TMP 320156000 West Main Street ADC District Owner: Starr Hill Properties, LLC Applicant: Cliff Fox Project: Seasonal vestibule Application components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to report pages): • Staff Report • Application Submittal March 2026 BAR Packet 5 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # HST26-0009 208 3rd Street NE; TMP 330215100 Downtown ADC District Owner: Asharper. LLC [The Luck Group II, LLC] Applicant: Jennifer Batchelder, Glickman Design Studio Project: Window replacements and exterior modifications Components (please click a bookmark below to go directly to report pages): • Staff Report • Application Submittal Certificate of Appropriateness Application 554 Valley Road – Addition and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.12.26) 1 City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Staff Report March 17, 2026 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # 26-0006 554 Valley Road; TMP 110053200 Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District Owners/Applicants: Lindsay & Evan Edwards Project: Addition on front elevation with alterations Background Year Built: 1932 District: Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District Status: Contributing structure Constructed as a dependency of 1708 Jefferson Park Avenue (JPA), this 2-story, gabled roofed garage was built into a small rise above a swale at the rear of the parent property. The building has two components: stone walls for the lower half, and a framed upper half with stucco. Character defining features include double-leaf swinging garage doors, multi-light steel framed windows, stone stairs at both the front and north elevations, standing-seam metal roof and brick end chimney. According to census records this property has housed UVA employees and their families for over 70 years. Early residents include Charlotte Ray, a stenographer for UVA in the 1930’s and 40’s, and Nichelson Buchwalter, an alumnus who returned to Charlottesville after WWII with his Swiss wife, Elizabeth. [Historical survey attached.] Prior BAR Reviews – N/A Applicant Request  Submittal: o Building plans: Edwards, 554 Valley Drive; 12 sheets o Plat of TMP 52-53.1 o All Elevations, sheet A200 o Supplemental information and images, 6 pages CoA request for a two-story addition on the front (east) elevation and alterations to the house. 554 Valley Road – Addition and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.12.26) 2 Discussion The buildings within the Oakhurst Circle-Gildersleeve Wood ADC District have great architectural integrity and represent styles popular during the first quarter of the 20th- century: Tudor Revival, Craftsman, and Dutch Colonial Revival. By contrast, later homes (post-1950) on Valley Road almost predominately feature the Cape Code style or are Minimalist in expression. 554 Valley Road and the neighboring homes closest to the intersection of JPA date to the earlier period, all of which feature stone as a quintessential architectural feature. When evaluating an addition made to the front façade, Ch. 3, Sect. P of the Design Guidelines states the proposal should be treated as new construction and assessed for compatibility with the district as such. However, in this situation, it may be appropriate to consider this property’s initial purpose. The former garage dependency was never intended as a primary residence, nor was the building given a significant position on the landscape or improved access to the street. It is essentially a secondary structure or utilitarian outbuilding. Applicant’s objective is to stabilize the structure and make necessary improvements to provide additional bedrooms. Meeting egress requirements includes expansion of some window openings. Stone salvaged will be used on the addition. The proposed alterations include: o Construction of a two-story front addition with cross-gable roof o Removal of the garage doors at the front elevation o Door and overhang replacement, north elevation o Removal of triple-light metal casement windows, and enlargement of openings at the first floor, front elevation* o Replacement of first floor triple-light metal casement window at north elevation* o Removal of eight-light metal casement window at west elevation* o Replacement of two triple-light metal casement windows at second story, south elevation* o Replacement of second story vinyl windows o Installation of new roof, with asphalt shingles, new fascia boards, gutters and downspouts o Replacing entry stairs and metal railing * That applicant has stated the steel casements are not salvageable. ** It appears the attic windows will be removed; BAR should request clarification. Doors and windows: Exterior doors will be fiberglass. On the addition: Jeldwen fixed windows. Replacement of vinyl windows: Pella Lifestyle and Jeldwen, a combination of fixed and casement windows that replicate the functionality of the originals. Replacement of casement windows: Pella Lifestyle and Jeldwen, fixed, casement (single and double light) with a Pella hopper window at the west (rear) elevation. Front addition: 554 Valley Road – Addition and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.12.26) 3 The addition will have stone at the first level, with stucco above. Railings, deck, stairs: Aluminum railing (color to be determined) & Trex. Roof: Replacement with asphalt shingles. [Gutters and downspouts are not yet selected. Current K- style gutters are not original.] North entry canopy: Repair and replace with asphalt shingles. Recommendation The contemporary design of the addition distinguishes it from the historic core. Staff recommends approval of the CoA with the following conditions:  The garage doors be retained and stored on-site.  The window and door trim be installed flush with or slightly proud from the stucco; Windows in the stone wall should be recessed.  New gutters should be half round  The standing-seam metal roof should be replaced in kind. The Design Guidelines make this recommendation: Avoid replacing a standing-seam metal roof with asphalt shingles.  Note on Sheet AD101: Remove or repair chimney. BAR should require it be retained. Suggested Motions Approval: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed addition and alterations at 554 Valley Road satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted with the following conditions:  The garage doors be retained and stored on-site.  The window and door trim be installed flush with or slightly proud from the stucco; Windows in the stone wall should be recessed.  New gutters should be half round  The standing-seam metal roof should be replaced in kind  The existing chimney will be retained. Denial: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed addition and alterations at 554 Valley Road does not satisfy the BAR’s criteria and is not compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that for the following reasons the BAR denies the request: […] Criteria, Standards and Guidelines Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34-5.2.7. Major Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34- 5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a building permit. Where a building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful unless conducted in accordance with the required building permit and all applicable building code requirements.” 554 Valley Road – Addition and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.12.26) 4 Review Criteria Generally Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2: a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds: i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application. b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section. c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. […] Standards for Review and Decision Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1: a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features and factors: i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with the site and the applicable District; ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs; iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant; iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures; v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks; vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures; vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines. Links to ADC District Design Guidelines Chapter 1 Introduction (Part 1) Chapter 1 Introduction (Part 2) Chapter 2 Site Design and Elements Chapter 3 New Construction and Additions Chapter 4 Rehabilitation 554 Valley Road – Addition and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.12.26) 5 APPENDIX c.1960’s Sanborn Map – 554 Valley Road Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/8" = 1'-0" 2/12/2026 2:48:18 PM G001 Cover Sheet 12FEB26 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Elevation 5 - a Sheet List Sheet Number Sheet Name G001 Cover Sheet AD100 Demo Plan Basement AD101 Demo Plan Floor 1 A100 Foundation A101 Basement Level A102 Floor 1 A103 Reflected Ceiling Plans A104 Interior Layout & Elevations A105 Roof Plan A200 Elevations A201 Window Schedule A202 Door & Room Schedules 29' - 8 15/32" 4' - 1" DEMO AND DISCARD CARRIAGE DOORS, AND WALL DEMO PORTION OF WALL FOR NEW DOOR, ADD LINTEL RELOCATE POSTS TO WITHIN WALL REMOVE WINDOW, SILL HEIGHT REMAINS SAME REMOVE WINDOW, REMOVE WALL/STONE BELOW WINDOW TO ACCOMMODATE NEW WINDOW SIZE AND LOWER SILL HEIGHT REMOVE WINDOW. REMOVE WALL/STONE BELOW WINDOW TO ACCOMMODATE NEW WINDOW SIZE AND LOWER SILL HEIGHT DEMO AND DISCARD EXISTING SHIPS LADDER DISCONNECT AND RELOCATE HEAT PUMP TO ATTIC FOR REINSTALL REMOVE CONC CURBS THROUGHOUT ROOM - --- DEMO EXISTING SLAB Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/4" = 1'-0" 2/12/2026 2:48:17 PM AD100 Demo Plan Basement 12FEB26 1/4" = 1'-0"1 Basement Existing Demo - - 10' - 2" 10' - 9" 2' - 5"4' - 10" 6' - 7" 3' - 2" 21' - 6" 10' - 9" 1' - 6" 10' - 8" 1' - 6" 3' - 6" 8' - 3" 7' - 6" REMOVE DOOR & FRAME, INFILL AND WALL OFF EXISTING OPENING DEMO REPLACEMENT WINDOW DEMO FRONT DOOR, FRONT PORCH, EXT RAILING, STAIRS & OVERHANG. CREATE NEW OPENING (DEMO WINDOW AND WALL). REMOVE FRAMING, INSTALL FLOOR JOISTS TO EXPAND ROOM, RELOCATE ELECTRICAL 6' - 4 7/8" REMOVE FRAMING, REMOVE AND STORE DOOR FOR REFINISHING/RESUSE DEMO WINDOW DEMO WINDOW DEMO EXTERIOR DOOR A1042 Bath REMOVE OR REPAIR CHIMNEY Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/4" = 1'-0" 2/12/2026 2:48:17 PM AD101 Demo Plan Floor 1 12FEB26 1/4" = 1'-0"1 Level 1 Existing-Demo A2001 - --- 3 A100 NEW FOOTER NEW FOOTERS NEW WALL EXISTING WALL EXISTING HOUSE ADDITION 9' - 4" (10) NEW FOOTERS FOR DECK STONE VENEER TO MATCH EXISTING STONE 4" CONC SLAB, 2500 PSI FIXED WINDOWS STUCCO ON 2X6 FRAMING, INSULATION, WATERPROOFING, 1/2" OSB SHEATHING ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOF CONC FOOTER INBOARD HEADER (2) 2X10 LVL 2X6 RR 16" OC , NEW RAFTERS AT GABLE CRUSHED STONE PRESSURE TREATED SILL PLATE 1'-6" MIN 8" MIN MONOPITCH EYEBROW , MTL STANDING SEAM 2X6 CJ 16" OC, CEILING, GYP 2" INSULATION BD 2X8 FJ 2X8 RIDGE HOR. RAIL Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/4" = 1'-0" 2/12/2026 2:48:13 PM A100 Foundation 12FEB26 1/4" = 1'-0"1 Foundation Plan 1/4" = 1'-0"3 Section 3 - - - - G0011 125 SF BDR 3 2 144 SF BDR 4 3 165 SF ENTRY 1 9' - 11 13/16" 19' - 2 21/32" A2001 - --- 3 A100 WB10 B21 B24 51 SF BATH 6 14 SF COAT 5 14' - 11" 3' - 9" 32 SF BDR 4 CL 4 2' - 8" EXISTING HOUSE ADDITION NEW WALL EXISTING WALL WH 2' - 0" - --- ADD 2X4 WALLS W/ R15 INSULATION B23 B22 B25 B27 B28 8' - 11 19/32" 10' - 7" W35 W36 HEAT PUMP ELEC PANEL UNFINISHED SPACE EQEQ EQEQ EQ EQ B26 FRENCH DRAIN TO DAY LIGHT ONE PIECE ACRYLIC TUB Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/4" = 1'-0" 2/12/2026 2:48:13 PM A101 Basement Level 12FEB26 1/4" = 1'-0"1 Basement Refrigerator G0011 9' - 10 25/32" 11' - 6 15/32" 102 SF BDR 1 11 275 SF LIVING 10 108 SF BDR 2 12 9' - 2" A2001 EXISTING NEW 3 A100 19 20 21 22 W10 W05 24 W15 25 A102 1 113 SF KITCHEN 13 37 SF BATH 2 14 W16W17 W18 NEW WALL EXISTING WALL 9' - 3" SEE A103 FOR CABINETRY LAYOUT W14 TREX DECKING AND STEPS HORIZONTAL ALUM RAIL SYSTEM 26 R15 INSULATION, 1/2" DRYWALL EQ EQ EQEQ W40 W39 W47 W46 26 SF MAIN ENTRY 15 A1042 Bath A104 1 Living Room Elevation (2) 10" LVL DROPPED OPEN TO BELOW 2' - 8" 0' - 4"0' - 4" 1' - 4" Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE As indicated 2/12/2026 2:48:14 PM A102 Floor 1 12FEB26 1/4" = 1'-0"2 Level 1 New 1/2" = 1'-0"1 Level 1 New - Callout 1 EXHAUST FAN/ LIGHT Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/8" = 1'-0" 2/12/2026 2:48:14 PM A103 Reflected Ceiling Plans 12FEB26 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Level 1 New 1/8" = 1'-0"2 Basement EXISTING BRICK SURROUND & MANTEL TO REMAIN NEW VENTLESS GAS FIREPLACE INSERT (BY OTHERS) 9/16" X 3" WINDOW CASING, TYP (#2253 BY MOULDINGS ONE OR EQ) NEW BASEBOARD, 3/4" X 5-1/4" TYP. (# 2139 BY MOULDINGS ONE OR EQ) FULL HEIGHT, WALL CERAMIC TILE, STACKED, 10 X 2-1/2" 4' - 10" 6' - 0" DREAMLINE UNIDOOR MATTE BLACK (57-in to 58-in W x 72-in FRAMELESS CLEAR GLASS HINGED SHOWER DOOR OR EQ CABINETS & APPLIANCES FURNISHED BY OWNER, INSTALLED BY CONTRACTOR COUNTERTOPS FURNISHED AND INSTALLED BY OTHERS Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/4" = 1'-0" 2/12/2026 2:48:14 PM A104 Interior Layout & Elevations 12FEB26 1/4" = 1'-0"1 Living Room Elevation KITCHEN LAYOUT NTS3 1/4" = 1'-0"2 Bath DN G0011 REPLACE EXISTING STANDING SEAM MTL ROOF NEW ROOF, 2X6 RAFTERS AT 16" OC 24' - 0" 31' - 8" REPAIR CHIMNEY, CAP OFF NEW GUTTERS & DOWNSPOUTS, NEW FASCIA BOARDS (TYP) NEW GUTTERS & DOWNSPOUTS, NEW FASCIA BOARDS, (TYP) 2X10 VALLEY PLATE2X8 RIDGE Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/8" = 1'-0" 2/12/2026 2:48:14 PM A105 Roof Plan 12FEB26 1/8" = 1'-0"1 Roof Plan ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOF NEW CASEMENT, EGRESS WINDOW EXISTING STONE NEW STONE, MATCH EXISTING EXISTING STUCCO NEW STUCCO NEW CASEMENT, EGRESS WINDOW NEW FIXED WINDOWS 3 A100 NEW WINDOW NEW WINDOW NEW GABLE 5/8" OSB SHEATHING Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/8" = 1'-0" 2/12/2026 2:48:16 PM A200 Elevations 12FEB26 1/8" = 1'-0"1 FRONT ELEVATION NEW ADDITION Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 2/12/2026 2:48:16 PM A201 Window Schedule 12FEB26 Window Schedule Level Mark Comments Width Heig ht Sill Heig ht Other Basement W35 PELLA CASEMENT 3' - 0" 4' - 0" 2' - 6" CFCI, MAX SILL HEIGHT 44" AFF Basement W36 PELLA CASEMENT 3' - 0" 4' - 0" 2' - 6" CFCI, MAX SILL HEIGHT 44" AFF Basement W43 JELDWEN FIXED 24"X48" 2' - 0" 4' - 0" 4' - 6" FBO, CONTRACTOR INSTALLED Basement W44 JELDWEN FIXED 24"X48" 2' - 0" 4' - 0" 4' - 6" FBO, CONTRACTOR INSTALLED Basement W48 JELDWEN FIXED 24"X48" 2' - 0" 4' - 0" 4' - 6" FBO, CONTRACTOR INSTALLED Basement WB10 PELLA FIXED 3' - 0" 4' - 0" 3' - 0" CFCI Level 1 New W05 JELDWEN FIXED 24"X24" 2' - 0" 2' - 0" 5' - 2" FBO, CONTRACTOR INSTALLED Level 1 New W10 JELDWEN FIXED 24"X48" 2' - 0" 4' - 0" 1' - 2" FBO, CONTRACTOR INSTALLED Level 1 New W14 PELLA DOUBLE CASEMENT 4' - 0" 5' - 0" 2' - 0" CFCI Level 1 New W15 PELLA DOUBLE CASEMENT 4' - 0" 5' - 0" 2' - 0" CFCI Level 1 New W16 PELLA CASEMENT 1' - 6" 3' - 4" 3' - 6" CFCI Level 1 New W17 PELLA CASEMENT 1' - 6" 3' - 4" 3' - 6" CFCI Level 1 New W18 PELLA HOPPER 3' - 0" 1' - 6" 6' - 0" CFCI Level 1 New W39 JELDWEN FIXED 24"X48" 2' - 0" 4' - 0" 1' - 2" FBO, CONTRACTOR INSTALLED Level 1 New W40 JELDWEN FIXED 24"X24" 2' - 0" 2' - 0" 5' - 2" FBO, CONTRACTOR INSTALLED Level 1 New W46 JELDWEN FIXED 24"X48" 2' - 0" 4' - 0" 1' - 2" FBO, CONTRACTOR INSTALLED Level 1 New W47 JELDWEN FIXED 24"X24" 2' - 0" 2' - 0" 5' - 2" FBO, CONTRACTOR INSTALLED Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 2/12/2026 2:48:17 PM A202 Door & Room Schedules 12FEB26 Door Schedule Level Mark Width Height Comments Basement B21 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR COAT CLOSET Basement B22 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BDRM Basement B23 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BDRM Basement B24 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BDRM CLOSET Basement B25 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BATH Basement B26 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL HALL Basement B27 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BDRM CLOSET Basement B28 2' - 6" 6' - 8" EXTERIOR ENTRY DOOR, FIBERGLASS Level 1 New 19 2' - 0" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BDRM CLOSET Level 1 New 20 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BATH Level 1 New 21 2' - 0" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BDRM CLOSET Level 1 New 22 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BDRM Level 1 New 24 2' - 10" 6' - 8" NEW EXTERIOR KITCHEN DOOR, FIBERGLASS Level 1 New 25 2' - 6" 6' - 8" INTERIOR 5 HOR. PANEL BDRM Level 1 New 26 2' - 6" 6' - 8" EXTERIOR ENTRY DOOR, FIBERGLASS Room Schedule Number Name Area Floor Finish Base Finish Wall Finish Ceiling Finish 1 ENTRY 165 SF LVT WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 2 BDR 3 125 SF LVT WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 3 BDR 4 144 SF LVT WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 4 BDR 4 CL 32 SF LVT WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 5 COAT 14 SF LVT WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 6 BATH 51 SF LVT WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 7 UNFINISHED 124 SF NA PT GYP PT GYP 10 LIVING 275 SF REFINISHED EXISTING WD WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 11 BDR 1 102 SF REFINISHED EXISTING WD WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 12 BDR 2 108 SF REFINISHED EXISTING WD WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 13 KITCHEN 113 SF REFINISHED EXISTING WD WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 14 BATH 2 37 SF CERAMIC TILE WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP 15 MAIN ENTRY 26 SF WD FL TO MATCH EXISTING WD BASE PT GYP PT GYP BASE BOARD PROFILE TO BE SELECTED AND APPROVED BY OWNER. BASIS OF DESIGN: 3/4" X 5-1/4" TYP. (#2139 BY MOULDINGS ONE OR EQ) ALL PAINT COLORS TO SELECTED AND APPROVED BY OWNER. INTERIOR DOORS: INTERIOR SLAB DOOR WITH MDF SOLID CORE. 5 PANEL SHAKER DOOR. WINDOW AND DOOR CASEMENT BASIS OF DESIGN: #2253 BY MOULDINGS ONE OR EQ) New Addition sideyard setback 12ft ASPHALT SHINGLE ROOF NEW CASEMENT, EGRESS WINDOW EXISTING STONE NEW STONE, MATCH EXISTING EXISTING STUCCO NEW STUCCO NEW CASEMENT, EGRESS WINDOW NEW FIXED WINDOWS 3 A100 NEW WINDOW NEW WINDOW NEW GABLE 5/8" OSB SHEATHING INTERIOR STAIR ADDITION STUCCO TO MATCH REPLACE EXISTING WINDOW STONE BASE TO MATCH EXISTING NEW ROOF SHINGLES & SUBSTRATE EXISTING REPAIRED AND REROOFED OVERHANG NEW INSULATED EXT. DOOR EXISTING WINDOW TO REMAIN NEW CASEMENT PELLA WINDOW INTERIOR STAIR ADDITION REPLACED DECK AND ENTRY STAIR EXISTING WINDOW REMAINS NEW REPLACEMENT WINDOW NEW ROOF, SUBSTRATE, FASCIA BOARD, AND GUTTER SYSTEM Scale Project number Date EDWARDS 554 VALLEY DRIVE 1/8" = 1'-0" 2/28/2026 4:47:35 PM A200 Elevations 12FEB26 1/8" = 1'-0"1 EAST ELEVATION NEW ADDITION 1/8" = 1'-0"2 NORTH ELEVATION 1/8" = 1'-0"3 SOUTH ELEVATION 1/8" = 1'-0"4 WEST ELEVATION 554 Valley Supplemental Information per request received 25 Feb 2026. Reference: HST26-0006 & BR-26-0039 • Request: Site photographs and of each elevation of the house. Response: Please find photographs of each elevation below with plan indicator adjacent. • Request: Scope of work includes roof replacement and chimney repair/capping... need images of existing conditions. Response: Please find images of existing brick chimney below. Existing chimney is cracked and listing. Masonry repair, repointing , and new cap will be provided. • Request: Materials/spec sheets selected for: roof (*asphalt proposed to replace metal), gutters, exterior trim, exterior treatments (stone to match existing/stucco), windows, door, stair details and railings (Trex and aluminum) Response: Windows: The previous owners of the property replaced the two windows at the front of the house on the upper level with cheap vinyl windows that are not in keeping with the historic elements of the house. This renovation will replace 2 of those vinyl windows on the upper floor with double casement windows (see attached cut sheet from Pella) that are more in keeping with the historic windows at the house. The middle vinyl window will be removed as part of the new opening for the addition at the front of the house. The lower level windows will be replaced by single casement windows to create a visual hierarchy of the two levels. The windows on the basement level will need to be larger than the existing windows in order to fulfil egress requirements and sill height requirements for the two bedrooms that are being added to the basement level. Existing stone that is removed from below the windows will be salvaged and used for the new stone veneer at the new bump out. Restoring the existing windows was investigates, however the steel of the single pane windows was significantly deteriorated due to rust and neglect and restoration was determined to be cost prohibitive. Main Level Front Window Replacement: Basement Level Front Window Replacement: Stone: The stone at the new bump out will be matched as closely as possible by a local stone mason and will mix the salvaged stone from the new openings as well as stone available on the site (demoed stone planter wall at front of house, as well as loose site stone that matches the house. The masonry contractor selected for the project is Flint Masonry. Roof: The metal roof is deteriorating. The existing fascia boards are rotting, and the gutters are missing as shown in these existing images: The roof will be replaced with a new dimensional shingle asphalt roof, new painted fascia boards, and new gutters and downspouts. Railing: The existing railing is a combination of wrought iron at the steps and wood at the front porch. The wood is rotted through and does not meet code for various dimensional reasons (e.g. rail height is too low). The proposed railing is a continuous horizontal aluminum railing (color, TBD). The railing contractor selected is Quality Welding. The decking will be Trex, Enhance (color Toasted Sand, Golden Hour, Honey Grove to be coordinated with railing and Pella window color). • Request: Exterior elevations and/or section of the addition (currently we have a front elevation, and interior plan). Response: Please find updated A200 with all elevations. Also, there is a section provided of the addition on 3/A100. 707-709 West Main Street – seasonal vestibule – March 17, 2026 (3/12) 1 City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Staff Report March 17, 2026 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # 26-0007 707-709 West Main Street; TMP 320156000 West Main Street ADC District Owner: Starr Hill Properties, LLC Applicant: Cliff Fox Project: Seasonal vestibule Background Year Built: 1925 District: West Main ADC District Status: Contributing structure 707-709 West Main Street is a 6-bay, 2-story duplex commercial building constructed in 1925. A wide cornice runs across the top of the storefront and divides the building’s two stories; six compass-headed metal sash windows overlook West Main Street on the second floor. A.G. Carter purchased and developed the building in 1925 on what had previously been a residential site. Carter also developed the neighboring building, 701-705 West Main Street. The building housed furniture stores for much of the twentieth century. Prior BAR Reviews (See Appendix.) Application • Applicant submittals: o Vestibule specifications with photographs, 7 pages. CoA for seasonal, temporary vestibule at doorway to commercial address 707 W. Main Street currently in operation as Smyrna Restaurant. (Note: Applicant has replaced the operable door with a cloth and clear-vinyl curtain. See Discussion and Recommendation.) 707-709 West Main Street – seasonal vestibule – March 17, 2026 (3/12) 2 Discussion Historic survey forms identify this property and the neighboring building at 701-705 West Main Street as the best-preserved stretch of historic commercial buildings on West Main Street. At the subject building, the storefront glazing does not appear to be original, but other elements retain integrity; including the prism-glass transom and pressed-metal cornice above the transom; the recessed entry door and trim; and the stone curbing below the display window bulkhead. August 2024: Applicant requested guidance from staff re: possible installation of a temporary, seasonal vestibule at the front entrance to the restaurant at 707 West Main Street. The information provided showed a metal-framed vestibule with plexiglass side panel and front door with transom. The plexiglass was clear, except for the translucent panels at the lower portion of the door and the side panel. (See images 1, 2, and 3.) Staff advised that, while intended as temporary and seasonal, installation of the vestibule would require a CoA. December 2024: Staff was notified that a temporary, seasonal vestibule had been installed at the front entrance to the restaurant at 707 West Main Street. (See images 4 and 5.) In January 2025, staff informed the applicant that the vestibule had been installed without a CoA and without review for Building Code and Fire Code compliance. Being a seasonal installation, staff stated the vestibule should be removed after the winter season and could be reinstalled later only with the necessary approvals. In February 2026, the vestibule the door had been removed and replaced with a cloth and clear- vinyl curtain. (See images 6 through 12.) The applicant was notified and issued a zoning violation. [Staff cannot determine if the vestibule remained in place throughout 2025. There is evidence to suggest it was; however, that is moot at this point.] If a CoA is approved, the vestibule, as currently installed, will be allowed to remain pursuant to conditions of the CoA. However, a CoA does not exempt this vestibule from complying with any Building Code and/or life safety requirements. If a CoA is denied, the vestibule must be removed pursuant to the requirements of the Zoning Violation Notice 707_Feb_2026_20260213_0001. Recommendation In reviewing this request, staff applied the temporary tent guidelines (Ch.V, Sect. G) In general, temporary installations are “Not appropriate in front of a contributing building”. Under the circumstances, staff recommends the following: • BAR approve this CoA request with the condition that by April 1, 2026 the vestibule, in its entirety, be removed and impacts of its installation be repaired. • BAR instruct staff to examine and submit a recommendation by September 1, 2026 regarding how similar and related temporary, weather proofing components should be evaluated and considered, consistent with the BAR review criteria. The recommendations should include possible conditions of approval, including suggested time periods when temporary 707-709 West Main Street – seasonal vestibule – March 17, 2026 (3/12) 3 components will be permits, and/or the color, size, placement, even installation methods for such components. If the applicant seeks a permanent solution for a weather entrance, they should prepare and submit a design for appropriate alterations to the storefront and entry that are appropriate to this historic resource and consistent with the ADC District Design Guidelines. Regarding the air current heater above the entry door. While visible in the applicant’s photos, the heater was not identified as part of this CoA request, nor was it the subject of any prior CoA request. Furthermore, the installation of a temporary vestibule does not result in that area becoming an interior space: the heater is an exterior alteration that requires a CoA. Additionally, staff is not aware if the installation was completed under an appropriate building permit. Staff will consult with Building Code Official and Zoning, and advise the BAR accordingly at a later date. Suggested Motions Approval: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed seasonal vestibule, as currently installed, at 707-709 West Main Street satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted. Or, [as submitted with the following conditions…] Denial: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed seasonal vestibule at 707-709 West Main Street does not satisfy the BAR’s criteria and is not compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that for the following reasons the BAR denies the request: […] Criteria, Standards and Guidelines Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34- 5.2.7. Major Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34-5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a building permit. Where a building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful unless conducted in accordance with the required building permit and all applicable building code requirements.” Review Criteria Generally Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2: a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds: i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application. 707-709 West Main Street – seasonal vestibule – March 17, 2026 (3/12) 4 b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section. c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. Conditions may require a reduction in height or massing, consistent with the City’s design guidelines and subject to the following limitations: [not germane to this request] Standards for Review and Decision Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1: a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features and factors: i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with the site and the applicable District; ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs; iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant; iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures; v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks; vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures; vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines. Links to Pertinent ADC District Design Guidelines Chapter 3 New Construction and Additions Chapter 5 Signs, Awnings, Vending, and Cafes G. Tents (Including Tent Canopies) for The Winter Cafe Season or Year- Round Use 1. Tents are generally not appropriate in historic districts that are primarily residential (North Downtown, Wertland Street, Ridge Street, Oakhurst-Gildersleeve, Rugby Road-Venable, most of Martha Jefferson). 2. Tents may be appropriate in the Downtown, the Corner, and the West Main Street ADC districts, and in the mixed use/commercial areas of Martha Jefferson Conservation District, except tents are not appropriate on the Downtown mall portion of East and West Main Streets, including Central Place, and on the side streets leading to the mall. 3. Traditional solutions such as patio umbrellas and tree shade are encouraged. 4. Tents are not appropriate on the upper floors or roof of buildings. 707-709 West Main Street – seasonal vestibule – March 17, 2026 (3/12) 5 5. Tents are not appropriate in front of a contributing building. 6. Tents may be appropriate in front of a non-contributing building, depending on the tent materials, and the impact of its footprint and massing on the streetscape and building. 7. Tents may be appropriate on the rear or side of a building. 8. Tents should not permanently alter significant landscaping or site features. 9. Tents should be a solid color, without any text or logos. APPENDIX Prior CoA Applications & BAR Review August 14, 2002 – CoA request to remove existing storefront and replace with aluminum storefront system. Staff did not recommend approval; the application was withdrawn prior to BAR discussion. October 19, 2004 – CoA request to remove the storefront windows at 705 and 707 W. Main and install in their place movable, operable glass panels. The CoA was approved with a condition, but the project was abandoned. October 4, 2013 – Administrative CoA approved for installation of an air intake and exhaust fan on the rear elevation at 709 W. Main Street. April 19, 2022 – CoA request to install metal-framed folding windows at storefront and a new single-light glass panel at adjacent entry. BAR majority did not support request; granted (6-0) applicant’s request for deferral. Applicant did not return matter to the BAR for later consideration. 707-709 West Main Street: Temporary vestibule. BAR March 17, 2026 Pg 1 of 7 Image #1 Front Elevation West Elevation 707-709 West Main Street: Temporary vestibule. BAR March 17, 2026 Pg 2 of 7 Image #2 Image #3 NDS photo, December 16, 2024 - Vestibule with operable door. 707-709 West Main Street: Temporary vestibule. BAR March 17, 2026 Pg 3 of 7 air curtain heater unit installed over entry door Image #5 Image #4 707-709 West Main Street: Temporary vestibule. BAR March 17, 2026 Pg 4 of 7 Applicant photos. Image #6 Image #7 707-709 West Main Street: Temporary vestibule. BAR March 17, 2026 Pg 5 of 7 Applicant photos. Image #8 Image #9 March 3, 2026 - Vestibule with weather flaps and air curtain heater unit; photo by NDS 707-709 West Main Street: Temporary vestibule. BAR March 17, 2026 Pg 6 of 7 Image #10 March 3, 2026—Photos by NDS 707-709 West Main Street: Temporary vestibule. BAR March 17, 2026 Pg 7 of 7 air curtain heater unit installed over entry door Image #11 Image #12 Image #13 Image #14 208 3rd Street NE – Window replacements and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.5) 1 City of Charlottesville Board of Architectural Review Staff Report March 17, 2026 Certificate of Appropriateness Application BAR # 26-0009 208 3 rd Street NE; TMP 330215100 Downtown ADC District Owner: Asharper, LLC [The Luck Group II, LLC] Applicant: Jennifer Batchelder, Glickman Design Studio Project: Window replacements and exterior modifications Background Year Built: 1960 District: Downtown ADC District Status: Contributing structure Documented as having “no identifiable style” on the city’s 1974 Landmarks survey, this 1-story 1960’s brick commercial building has a flat roof and rear cinderblock addition completed in 1980. The two 25-light front windows are flanked by simple fluted pilasters. The recessed entry has a double entry door (non-original) and a six-light transom. Wooden paneling is laid horizontally below the front windowsills but laid vertically inside the entrance vestibule. (See photographs in the Appendix.) Prior BAR Reviews N/A Application • Applicant submittals: o glickman design studio 208 Third Street NE Exterior Rendering, 3 pages. o GDS Studio, Renovation Plan, sheet A-1. CoA for replacement windows, new windows within entry alcove, and other alterations at the front façade. 208 3rd Street NE – Window replacements and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.5) 2 Discussion The applicant proposes the following changes to the front elevation: Windows: • Replacement of both original 25-light front windows with new 4-over-1 glass inserts. Window specs not provided. • Addition of two sidelights within alcove, in a 2-over-1 pattern. Alcove: • Installation of tile on entry floor- not specified. • Replace wall sconces. Exterior Paint: • All trim and wood panels to be painted Farrow and Ball: Inchrya Blue. [Maintenance and repair which would not require a CoA, but is part of the proposal.] While the property was remodeled in 1968, based upon the 1974 photograph the windows, brick and surrounds have been retained at the front elevation. The original door has been replaced, and crown mold added to the transom and door frame. The 25-lite arrangement of the storefront windows appears original to the building; however, they are not historic in the context of the late-19th and early-20th century commercial storefronts predominant in the Downtown ADC District. They were likely intended to reflect a Colonial- Revival “Willaimsburg-esque” storefront with a false historicity. Staff notes that there are other 1-story brick commercial buildings dating to the early 1960’s on Little High Street, some with multi-light storefronts. (See sample in the Appendix.) Recommendation As the proposed represents adaptive reuse of a now vacant building, staff recommends approval of the replacement windows, with a conditon the applicant works with staff to document the existing glazing, widths and profiles. Staff recommends approval for the new windows at the alcove, tile entry floor, wall sconces, and painted exterior trim, with the condition that staff review the alcove tile when selected. Suggested Motions Approval: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed window replacements and alterations at 208 3rd Street NE satisfies the BAR’s criteria and is compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that the BAR approves the application as submitted with the following conditions: o The applicant will work with staff to document the existing glazing, widths and profiles of the 25-light windows. o Glass have VLT of not less than 70%. 208 3rd Street NE – Window replacements and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.5) 3 o All orphaned service lines, cables, wires or unncessary attachments on the exterior of the building are removed. o Appropriate screening is designed for litter receptacles at side of building. o Staff review and approval of tile for the alcove. Denial: Having considered the standards set forth within the City Code, including the ADC District Design Guidelines, I move to find the proposed window replacements and alterations at 208 3rd Street NE does not satisfy the BAR’s criteria and is not compatible with this property and other properties in this ADC District, and that for the following reasons the BAR denies the request: […] Criteria, Standards and Guidelines Note re: BAR authority: Per Code, the BAR is charged only with the authority to approve or deny a design review CoA, following an evaluation applying the criteria under Code Sec. 34-5.2.7. Major Historic Review. The BAR does not evaluate a proposed use. Additionally, per Code Sec. 34- 5.2.7.E.2., the issuance of a CoA “cannot, in and of itself, authorize any construction, reconstruction, alteration, repair, demolition, or other improvements or activities requiring a building permit. Where a building permit is required, no activity authorized by a [CoA] is lawful unless conducted in accordance with the required building permit and all applicable building code requirements.” Review Criteria Generally Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. C.2: a. In considering a particular application the BAR will approve the application unless it finds: i. That the proposal does not meet specific standards set forth within this Section or applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines; and ii. ii. The proposal is incompatible with the historic, cultural or architectural character of the district in which the property is located or the IPP that is the subject of the application. b. The BAR will approve, approve with conditions, or deny applications for Certificates of Appropriateness in accordance with the provisions of this Section. c. The BAR, or City Council on appeal, may require conditions of approval as are necessary or desirable to ensure that any new construction or addition is compatible with the scale and character of the Architecture Design Control District, Individually Protected Property, or Historic Conservation District. Prior to attaching conditions to an approval, due consideration will be given to the cost of compliance with the proposed conditions as well as the goals of the Comprehensive Plan. […] Standards for Review and Decision Per Chapter 34, Div. 5.2.7. D.1: a. Review of the proposed construction, reconstruction, alteration or restoration of a building or structure is limited to exterior architectural features, including signs, and the following features and factors: i. Whether the material, texture, color, height, scale, mass, and placement of the proposed addition, modification or construction are visually and architecturally compatible with the site and the applicable District; ii. The harmony of the proposed change in terms of overall proportion and the size and placement of entrances, windows, awnings, exterior stairs, and signs; iii. The Secretary of the Interior Standards for Rehabilitation set forth within the Code of Federal Regulations (36 C.F.R. §67.7(b)), as may be relevant; 208 3rd Street NE – Window replacements and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.5) 4 iv. The effect of the proposed change on the adjacent building or structures; v. The impact of the proposed change on other protected features on the property, such as gardens, landscaping, fences, walls, and walks; vi. Whether the proposed method of construction, renovation, or restoration could have an adverse impact on the structure or site, or adjacent buildings or structures; vii. When reviewing any proposed sign as part of an application under consideration, the standards set forth within Div. 4.11. Signs will be applied; and viii. Any applicable provisions of the City’s design guidelines. Links to ADC District Design Guidelines Chapter 3 New Construction and Additions APPENDIX Landmarks Commission Photographs [formerly 206 3 rd St. NE] ‘Shapero Office’, August 1974 208 3rd Street NE – Window replacements and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.5) 5 ‘Walston & Co., Inc.’, Undated Early-1960’s Commercial Brick structures, Little High 208 3rd Street NE – Window replacements and alterations – March 17, 2026 (3.5) 6 LANDMARK SURVEY a1. BASE DATA StreetAddress: 206 Third Street HistoricName: Date/Periad: Shapero Office IDENTIFICATION ~lapandParcel: 33-215.1 CensusTrack& Block: 1-110 1960 PresentOwner: Address: PresentUse: OriginalOwner: OriginalUse: Cecil C. Shapero et. c/o M. c. Curran 414 East Jefferson Offices Maurice B. Shaper~ Offices Style: HeighttoCornice: HeightinStories: PresentZoning: LandArea(sq.ft.): AssessedValue(land+ No identifiable style 1 B-3 36.6 x 55 imp.):5090 + 9510 = 14600 Typical commercial building of the 1960's. It is brick faced, simplified to of having no apparent roof, and has a recessed entrance flanked by two large five over five glazing. " - J.- i:ne po~n •.. windows with II i• ARCHITECTURAL DESCRIPT!ON HISTORICALDESCRIPTION The building was built in 1960 by Maurice Shapero for the present occupants, Shields and Company. It was remodeled in 1968. Deed references: 103-397, 347-72. ~. GRAPHICS .../ \. Good SOURCESCONDITIONS City Records Mr. York LANDMARK COMMISSION-OEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY OeVELOPMENT 4099 Lofton Lane North Garden, V A 22959 Sarah: 304-224-4110 Jennifer: 617-840-5560 GDS STUDIO 208 THIRD STREET NE CHARLOTTESVILLE,V A REVISION DATE DRAWING TITLE DRAWING NUMBER DATE SCALE 02/24/26 RENOV ATION PLAN A-1 1/4”=1’ LIBRARY BATHROOM MECH. ROOM MILLWORK/DISPLAY VIGNETTE/DISPLAY MILLWORK/DISPLAY VIGNETTE/DISPLAY KITCHENETTE STORAGE ROOM 2 STORAGE ROOM 1 24" Fridge W/H MILLWORK/CHECK OUT COUNTER STORE AREA (365 SF) Xerox Machine Office Supplies Office Supplies TV Open Shelves (Client Bins, Design Books) OFFICE 33'-1" 15'-10 1/16"6'-3" 12'-1 1/2" 8'-9 1/2" 3'-0" 5'-0 1/2" 6'-6 1/4" 4'-0" 3'-0" 6'-1 5/8" 6'-0" 5'-0"12'-11 7/16" 9'-6" 3'-6" 4'-9" 4'-9" 23'-1 3/16" 16'-3 1/2" 3'-0"7'-1" 4'-5" 2'-0" 6'-7" 7'-11" 3'-0" 5'-10 3/4" 4'-7 1/2" 3'-11" 3'-3" 2'-6" 12'-1 3/4" 6'-1 5/8" 4'-9" 2'-6"3'-0" 6'-2" 7'-6" 6'-5 1/8"3'-0" 5'-4" 9'-11" 7'-8 1/2" 6'-6 1/2" 8'-10"2'-4" 10'-8 1/2" 5'-8" 2'-9" 6'-0" 2'-9" 11'-2 1/4"2'-4" 10'-8 1/2" 7'-10 3/8" 3'-11 1/2"1'-3" GDS Office 208 Third Street 02.25.2026 208 Third Street NE Exterior Rendering *From applicant: No change to transom window in alcove. GDS Office 208 Third Street 02.25.2026 208 Third Street NE Exterior Rendering: Tile Information Appropriate exterior tile to be installed within the red-outlined area GDS Office 208 Third Street 02.25.2026 208 Third Street NE Exterior Rendering Exterior Wall Color Farrow and Ball: Inchrya Blue Exterior Lanterns Visual Comfort: Galena Pocket Wall Lantern

Source: City of Charlottesville website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.