E2 Transportation - BEB conversion cost comparison(PDF, 223KB)
Arlington County · Arlington County · Budget documents
Open the original document More from Arlington County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
E-2
Subject: DES: BEB conversion cost comparison
Related Department(s): DES
FY 2025 Proposed Capital Budget
CIP Work Session
The following information is provided in response to a request made by Ms. Cunningham
at the work session on 06/06/2024, regarding the following question:
Can you provide a cost comparison between the previous CIP and the proposed CIP for
the conversion to battery electric buses (BEBs)?
****************************************************************************************************
While it is difficult to do an apples-to-apples comparison between the two CIPs given that they cover a
different set of 10 years, the FY 2025 Proposed CIP includes close to $143m to transition the ART Fleet
to BEB versus $61m in the FY 2023 Adopted CIP. The higher cost reflects a more complete analysis for
land and build-out, as well as updated vehicle costs for Battery Electric Buses (BEBs) vs. Renewable
Natural Gas (RNG) buses. The detailed costs for both the Adopted FY 2023 – FY 2032 CIP and the
Proposed FY 2025 – FY 2034 CIP are included below. Both CIPs assume an annual inflation factor of 3%;
the inflation factor results in the cost differential between BEB and RNG buses increasing across the 10-
year CIP period. Costs continue to evolve, and assumptions will be refined following the pilot of BEBs on
ART routes.
The FY 2023 – FY 2032 Adopted CIP included approximately $61m in BEB-related cost for the ART Fleet.
It included the following cost components captured in three CIP programs (Total of 84 buses):
(1) ART Fleet Equipment & Replacement: $37m to replace 58 buses with BEBs instead of RNG buses.
It included a higher cost of about $323K per vehicle for BEBs (total of $1.0m per bus assumed for
BEB) vs. RNGs as well as 15 additional buses procured assuming a 2:1 ratio for FY 2024 bus
purchases (later years used a 1:1 ratio).
(2) Premium Transit Network (PrTN) ART Fleet Expansion: $4m for the incremental cost to purchase
BEBs vs. RNG buses for a total of 11 expansion buses.
(3) ART O&M Facility Electrification Phase 2: $20m for additional charging equipment.
All $ in 000s FY23 FY24 FY25 FY26 FY27 FY28 FY29 FY30 FY31 FY32 CIP Total
ART Fleet Replacement 20,440 2,824 2,908 5,014 5,728 36,914
ART Fleet Expansion 2,471 1,498 3,968
AOMF Ph 2 12,000 8,000 20,000
Total 0 20,440 0 17,294 10,908 1,498 5,014 0 5,728 0 60,883
E-2
In contrast, the Proposed FY 2025 – FY 2034 CIP includes $143m for BEB transition, including $134m in
the ART Fleet Transition to ZEB program and $8.6m in other CIP programs as noted below:
(1) $134m in the ART Fleet Transition to ZEB program, which includes (total 86 buses)
a. Vehicles: $73m for the incremental cost of ~$0.5m per bus (BEB vs. RNG bus cost;
$1.2m per bus assumed for BEB) to replace a total of 55 buses and for the 11
expansion buses needed to implement the TSP. It also includes the full BEB cost for
about 20 additional buses that need to be purchased owing to the 1.3:1.0 ratio
assumed for BEB:RNG (as noted earlier, this assumption could be revised after more
operational experience with BEBs occurs). Also captured are the mid-life battery
replacements after seven years of operations at $265K per battery.
b. Land: $28m – this is a placeholder and will depend on size and location.
c. Infrastructure build-out, charging, etc.: $34m
d. Please note the above costs in the table below are inflated annually by 3%.
(2) Additional costs included outside of the ART Fleet Transition to ZEB program (total 12 buses):
a. 4 pilot BEB buses (included in ART Fleet Expansion CIP): $4.5m
b. Incremental cost of BEB vs. RNG for 8 replacement buses for FY26 (included in ART
Fleet Replacement CIP): $4.1m
All $ in 000s FY25 FY26 FY27 FY28 FY29 FY30 FY31 FY32 FY33 FY34 CIP Total
Vehicles: Incremental Cost
BEB vs. RNG Cost (55 buses) 4,303 7,419 8,476 13,231 33,428
BEB vs. RNG Cost (11 buses) 3,995 2,422 0 6,416
BEB cost for 20 add'l buses 3,107 8,241 7,868 9,553 28,769
Battery Replacement 1,304 2,687 3,991
Total Vehicle Cost 0 0 7,410 0 19,654 0 18,766 1,304 2,687 22,784 72,605
Land 600 618 26,735 27,953
Build-out, charging, etc 300 312 3,775 1,104 10,889 5,474 2,508 2,459 2,533 4,264 33,618
Total 900 930 37,920 1,104 30,543 5,474 21,273 3,763 5,220 27,048 134,175
Source: Arlington County website. First collected Oct 18, 2026.