August 12, 2024 Architectural Review Historic Preservation Board Minutes
Village of Egg Harbor · Door County · meeting of Aug 12, 2024 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Village of Egg Harbor
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Meeting Minutes Page 1 of 3
Village of Egg Harbor
Architectural Review & Historic Preservation Board
Meeting Minutes - August 12th, 2024, at 1:00 PM
Paul J Bertschinger Center 7860 STH 42 Egg Harbor, WI 54209
Members of the public can also join the meeting by Zoom Video Conference
Chris Roedl, Chair
Kathy Navis, Member
Jim Vander Heiden, Member
Vacant, Member
Paul Brophy, Member
1. Call the meeting to order
• Chris Roedl called the meeting to order at 1:00pm.
• Board members attending: Chris Roedl, Kathy Navis, Paul Brophy, Jim Vander
Heiden (Zoom)
• Staff members attending: Megan Sawyer, Madison Dietzen (Zoom), Lynn
Ohnesorge (Zoom)
2. Approve the agenda
• Kathy Navis moved to approve the agenda, Chris Roedl seconded the
motion, motion carried.
3. Approve July 15th, 2024, Architectural Review and Historic Preservation meeting minutes
• Paul Brophy motioned to approve the July 15th, 2024, Architectural Review
and Historic Preservation meeting minutes, Kathy Navis seconded, motion
carried.
4. Open Session
• Paul Brophy asked if Village staff are working on adding another Board
member. Megan Sawyer answered that she has tasked John Heller with reaching
out a potential addition. She is currently building a house in the Village. Megan
can ask John for an update on his inquiry. Kathy Navis thought that the Village
Staff were going to ask a retired Architect. Megan Sawyer said she forgot to ask
Bob Zacharias if he would like to join the Board, so she will contact him.
5. Discussion, review, and possible action recommendation on proposed amendments to
Chapter 152 Zoning and Chapter 116 Architectural Review & Historic Preservation
Regulations to align with the requirements of the Certified Local Government Program
via the WI State Historic Preservation Office
• Megan Sawyer’s executive summary: Since the last meeting, I had an
opportunity to follow up with Jason Tish with the Wisconsin State Historic
Preservation Office regarding what was needed on the Village’ s end in terms of
modifying our ordinances to meet the requirements to be considered for
Certified Local Government status with the WI SHPO.
Jason reviewed our ordinances and did have some concerns that needed to
be addressed. I’ve prepared the attached ordinance amendments in response to
my conversation with Jason and have the proposed ordinance amendments lined
up for the Village Board’ s review at their meeting on Wednesday, August 12th,
2024.
The first ordinance amendment (2024-07) is very straight forward regarding
Meeting Minutes Page 2 of 3
the change in the body that has authority over the Historic District review. The
change from the Plan Commission to the Architectural Review and Historic
Preservation Board was intended in the past but must have been overlooked as
we worked through the ordinance approve process.
Jason also had concerns regarding our ordinances as it wasn’t clear to him
whether modifications or additions to locally designated historic structures
would be regulated under the historic district provisions outlined in Chapter 152
or the architectural requirements of Chapter 116. Jason suggested we create a
clear separation between what is allowed via the certificate of appropriate
section in Chapter 152 and the new construction standards outlined in Chapter
116. Jason also strongly suggested that we have a distinct agenda and process
for the review of certificate of appropriateness applications for locally
designated historic properties which we can discuss more at the meeting.
Therefore, I am proposing the attached ordinance 2024-08 as a starting point
for us to attempt to provide this clarification, while continuing to make the
necessary modifications to our ordinance to keep us on track with becoming a
certified local government so that we do not miss the intent to apply deadline for
grant funding in September.
We will need to complete the ordinance amendments and have the Village
Board pass the letter requesting the Village become and certified local
government. Jason said the ordinance amendments need to be completed prior
to the Village Board approving the letter. Jason said if we are unable to
complete the certified local government process by that deadline, he can be
flexible on that deadline if we are well within the process of completing the
requirements for certification, which I believe we will be. Final grant
applications are then due in December.
We may want to consider some additional amendments to our Historic
Designation section; however, I believe the attached ordinance amendments will
help address Jason’ s initial concerns.
The ARHP Board will need to review the proposed ordinance amendments
and make a recommendation to the Village Board for approval if appropriate.
After the ARHP Board and possible Village Board have a discussion and
possible passage of the ordinance amendments I will follow up with Jason.
Due to potential additional modifications to the Historic District section of
the ordinance I think the ARHP Board should pause on finalizing any additional
local property designations until we have these amendments completed.
I will provide additional details on my meeting with Jason at the meeting.
• Kathy Navis motioned to approve the change to Ordinance 152.027 Historic
District B, Historic Preservation Committee replacing Plan Commission
with Architectural Review and Historic Preservation Board, and modifying
116.05 as presented, Paul Brophy seconded.
• Jim Vander Heiden asked if it was okay to have the same Board doing both tasks
or should there be two separate Boards. Megan Sawyer said one Board could do
both tasks if the agendas are separated.
• The motion carried.
• The Architectural Review and Historic Preservation Board members continued
to discuss the option of having one body or separate the bodies to navigate the
jobs of the current Board. Megan Sawyer will be following up with Jason after
the meeting.
Meeting Minutes Page 3 of 3
6. Open Session
• No discussion.
7. Next Meeting
• The next meeting was scheduled for Wednesday, September 18th, 2024, at
1:00pm.
8. Adjournment
• Paul Brophy motioned to adjourn the meeting, Kathy Navis seconded the
motion, the motion carried.
• The meeting was adjourned at 1:50pm.
The meeting minutes were completed by Madison Dietzen on August 13, 2024. Meeting minutes
submitted for review and approval on September 18th, 2024.
Bold – Official Action
Source: Village of Egg Harbor website. First collected Oct 29, 2026.