City Plan Commission — Minutes
City of Stevens Point · Portage County · City Plan Commission · meeting of Dec 15, 2025 · Minutes
Open the original document More from City of Stevens Point
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES
CITY PLAN COMMISSION
Members
• Mayor Wiza
• Alderperson Kneebone
• Commissioner Arntsen
• Commissioner Beacom
• Commissioner Rice
• Commissioner Schuler
• Commissioner Stroik
Date and Time: December 15, 2025
5:00 PM
Location:
Community Room
933 Michigan Avenue, Stevens
Point, WI
OR
Zoom Teleconferencing
Opening Section:
1. Roll Call
• Meeting called to order at 5:00PM.
• Members present: Mayor Wiza, Alder Kneebone, Commissioners Arntsen,
Beacom, Rice, Schuler, Stroik
Chairperson welcomed Commissioner Laura Shady-Strike, noting this was her first
meeting serving on the Plan Commission.
Discussion and Possible Action on:
2. A request from Portage County to amend the Stevens Point Comprehensive
Plan. Said request amends the future land use designation of the property
located at 825 Whiting Avenue (Parcel ID 281230805101103) from
‘Institutional/Government’ to ‘Commercial/Office/Multi-Family.’
• Background: Staff provided background information regarding the request,
noting that a prior Plan Commission vote resulted in a tie, which required the
item to be brought back for a clear recommendation. Staff explained that the
amendment is necessary to align the Comprehensive Plan with zoning and
proposed use of the property following a potential sale to a private operator. Staff
further explained that state statute allows community facilities to be publicly or
privately operated and that inclusion of commercial uses provides consistency
with the existing R-4 zoning district. Staff recommended approval.
• Discussion:
• Commissioners discussed the relationship between the Comprehensive Plan
and zoning consistency.
• Questions were raised regarding the impact of privatization versus the limited
scope of the Plan Commission’s role.
• Commissioners discussed long-term flexibility of the site and whether the
amendment aligns with comprehensive planning goals.
• Public Hearing:
• Alan Buchanan, 1208 Black Bear Trail, spoke opposed to the amendment,
citing voter-approved referenda supporting public ownership of the facility.
He expressed concern that changing the future land use designation
undermines public trust and could lead to privatization inconsistent with
prior public commitments.
• Mary McComb, 2100 Elk Street, spoke opposed, stating the existing
Institutional/Governmental designation is appropriate and consistent with
long-standing City planning. She expressed concern that changing the
designation weakens the integrity of the Comprehensive Plan.
• Mildred Neville, 1709 Jefferson Street, spoke opposed, raising concerns
about procedural issues, accuracy of information presented regarding the
proposed buyer, and the pace of the process. She urged the Commission
to delay action until concerns are resolved.
• Maryanne Lasheski, 1209 Wisconsin Street, spoke opposed, citing
concerns related to environmental impacts, loss of green space, and
potential negative effects on nearby residents.
• Kevin Ramakrishna with Reinhart Boerner Van Deuren, spoke about
safeguards within the purchase agreement, including rights of first refusal
and provisions intended to maintain the site’s continued use as a nursing
facility.
• Eric Olsen, 2025 West River Drive, spoke opposed, emphasizing that the
Comprehensive Plan represents a long-term public agreement and that
referendum outcomes demonstrate strong public interest in maintaining
public ownership and institutional use.
• Alderperson Jackie Guthrie, District 2, raised concerns about whether the
proposed amendment aligns with the City’s stated goals of being livable,
connected, resilient, and sustainable, and questioned the broader
community impacts of the change.
• Nancy Roppe, 39 Angelo Court, spoke opposed, expressing concern about
the impact on emergency services and potential consequences of
privatizing healthcare-related facilities.
• John Pavelski, Portage County Executive, spoke in support of the
amendment, citing financial challenges associated with County ownership,
the vetting of the proposed buyer, and safeguards in place to ensure
continued operation of the facility.
• Karlene Ferrante, 1324 Portage Street, spoke opposed, stating the
applicant had not met the burden of proof required to demonstrate that the
amendment is in the public’s best interest under the Comprehensive Plan.
• Raymond Cal, Stevens Point, spoke opposed, urging the Commission to
honor referendum results and maintain public ownership and institutional
designation of the property.
• Dr. Ray Reser, Portage County Board Chair, spoke in support of the
amendment, stating that staff findings and recommendations were met and
emphasizing that the Plan Commission’s role is limited to land use
consistency.
• Dave Ladick, County Board Supervisor, 4517 Nickel Avenue, spoke in
support of the amendment, stating that staff analysis was thorough, the
request is consistent with zoning, and the amendment allows continuity of
the existing nursing facility use.
• Alex McCumber, 2633 Helen Street, spoke opposed, stating the
amendment was not adequately justified as being in the public interest and
expressing concern about long-term land use impacts.
• Discussion:
• Commissioners reiterated differing viewpoints on affordability, public
services, parking impacts, and long-term land use flexibility.
• Action:
• Motion: Commissioner Arntsen moves approval of the request to amend
the future land use designation of the subject property as presented.
• Second: Commissioner Stroik seconds the motion.
• Vote:
• Aye: Beacom, Rice, Schuler, Stroik, Wiza
• No: Arntsen, Kneebone
• Motion passes, 5-2.
Closing Section:
3. Adjourn
• Meeting adjourned at 6:32 P.M.
Source: City of Stevens Point website. First collected Oct 30, 2026.