Minutes
Ashland County · Ashland County · Minutes
Open the original document More from Ashland County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
MINUTES OF THE
ASHLAND COUNTY BOARD OF SUPERVISORS
GENERAL MEETING
Wednesday, March 8, 2023
Ashland County Courthouse, 201 Main Street West, Room 204, Ashland, Wisconsin
1. CALL TO ORDER
A General Meeting of the Ashland County Board of Supervisors was held on Wednesday,
March 8, 2023 by Remote/Zoom and in person at the Ashland County Courthouse, County
Board Room. Chairperson Dick Pufall called the meeting to order at 9:01 a.m.
a. Roll Call: Attendance
Roll Call: Present: Ellefson, MacKenzie, Metzinger, Campbell, Kinney, Pufall,
Franek, Starck, Berlin, Bussey, Vitek, Huber, Schutte, Carl,
Wiener, 15
Absent: 0
Excused: Nagro, Sztyndor, Ray, Mika and Mertig
b. Moment of Silence
A moment of silence was held.
c. Pledge of Allegiance
The Board recited the Pledge of Allegiance.
2. APPROVAL/ADOPTION OF THE AGENDA
Motion was made by Kathy Schutte and seconded by Blake Ellefson to approve and adopt
the Agenda as amended. Motion carried.
3. PUBLIC COMMENTS
No comments were made .
4. APPOINTMENT
a. Appointment
Motion was made by Elizabeth Franek and seconded by Pat Kinney to approve the
appointment of Laura Miranda to the fill the vacant seat in County Board Supervisory
District 13. Motion carried.
5. REGULAR AGENDA – DISCUSSION/ACTION ITEMS
a. Approval of the February 7, 2023 County Board Minutes
Motion was made by Rich Huber and seconded by Louis Carl to approve the minutes of the
February 7, 2023 County Board meeting. Motion carried.
b. Resolution R03-2023-1441 – A Resolution to Approve Acceptance of Opioid
Settlement
AUTHORIZING ASHLAND COUNTY TO ENTER INTO THE
SETTLEMENT AGREEMENTS WITH TEVA PHARMACEUTICAL
INDUSTRIES LTD., ALLERGAN FINANCE, LLC, WALGREEN CO.,
WALMART, INC., CVS HEALTH CORPORATION AND CVS
PHARMACY, INC., AGREE TO THE TERMS OF THE ADDENDUM TO
THE MOU ALLOCATING SETTLEMENT PROCEEDS, AND
AUTHORIZE ENTRY INTO THE MOU WITH THE ATTORNEY
GENERAL
WHEREAS, the Ashland County Board of Supervisors previously authorized the County
to enter into an engagement agreement with von Briesen & Roper, s.c., Crueger Dickinson LLC
and Simmons Hanly Conroy LLC (the “Law Firms”) to pursue litigation against certain
manufacturers, distributors, and retailers of opioid pharmaceuticals (the “Opioid Defendants”) in
an effort to hold the Opioid Defendants financially responsible for the County’s expenditure of
vast money and resources to combat the opioid epidemic;
WHEREAS, on behalf of the County, the Law Firms filed a lawsuit against the Opioid
Defendants;
WHEREAS, the Law Firms filed similar lawsuits on behalf of 66 other Wisconsin counties
and all Wisconsin cases were coordinated with thousands of other lawsuits filed a gainst the same
or substantially similar parties as the Opioid Defendants in the Northern District of Ohio, captioned
In re: Opioid Litigation, MDL 2804 (the “Litigation”);
WHEREAS, four (4) additional Wisconsin counties (Milwaukee, Dane, Waukesha, and
Walworth) hired separate counsel and joined the Litigation;
WHEREAS, since the inception of the Litigation, the Law Firms have coordinated with
counsel from around the country (including counsel for Milwaukee, Dane, Waukesha, and
Walworth Counties) to pre pare the County’s case for trial and engage in extensive settlement
discussions with the Opioid Defendants;
WHEREAS, the settlement discussions with Teva Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd.,
Allergan Finance, LLC, Walgreen Co., Walmart, Inc., CVS Health Corporation and CVS
Pharmacy, Inc.. (the “Settling Defendants”) resulted in a tentative agreement as to settlement terms
pending agreement from the County and other plaintiffs involved in the Litigation;
WHEREAS, copies of the various settlement agreements relating to the Settling
Defendants (collectively “Settlement Agreements”) representing the terms of the tentative
settlement agreements with the Settling Defendants have been provided with this Resolution;
WHEREAS, the Settlement Agreements provide, among other things, for the payment of
certain sums to Participating Subdivisions (as defined in the Settlement Agreements) upon the
occurrence of certain events detailed in the Settlement Agreements;
WHEREAS, the County is a Participating Subdivision in the Settlement Agreements and
has the opportunity to participate in the benefits associated with the Settlement Agreement
provided the County (a) approves the Settlement Agreements; (b) approves the Memorandum of
Understanding allocating proceeds from the Settlement Agreements among the various Wisconsin
Participating Subdivisions, a copy of which is attached to this Resolution (the “Allocation MOU”);
(c) approves the Memorandum of Understanding with the Wisconsin Attorney General regarding
allocation of settlement proceeds, a copy of which is attached to this Resolution (the “AG MOU”);
and (d) the Legislature’s Joint Committee on Finance approves the terms of the Settlement
Agreements and the AG MOU;
WHEREAS, 2021 Wisconsin Act 57 created Section 165.12 of th e Wisconsin Statutes
relating to the settlement of all or part of the Litigation;
WHEREAS, pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 165.12(2), the Legislature’s Joint Committee on
Finance is required to approve the Settlement Agreements and the AG MOU;
WHEREAS, pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 165.12(2), the proceeds from any settlement of all or
part of the Litigation are distributed 70% to local governments in Wisconsin that are parties to the
Litigation and 30% to the State;
WHEREAS, Wis. Stat. § 165.12(4)(b)2. provides t he proceeds from the Settlement
Agreement must be deposited in a segregated account (the “Opioid Abatement Account”) and may
be expended only for approved uses for opioid abatement as provided in the Settlement
Agreements;
WHEREAS, Wis. Stat. § 165.12(7) bars claims from any Wisconsin local government
against the Opioid Defendants filed after June 1, 2021;
WHEREAS, the definition of Participating Subdivisions in the Settlement Agreements
recognizes a statutory bar on claims such as that set forth in Wis. Stat. § 165.12(7) and, as a result,
the only Participating Subdivisions in Wisconsin are those counties and muni cipalities that were
parties to the Litigation (or otherwise actively litigating a claim against one, some, or all of the
Opioid Defendants) as of June 1, 2021;
WHEREAS, the Legislature’s Joint Committee on Finance is not statutorily authorized or
required to approve the allocation of proceeds of the Settlement Agreements among Wisconsin
Participating Subdivisions;
WHEREAS, the Law Firms have engaged in extensive discussions with counsel for all
other Wisconsin Participating Subdivisions resulting in the proposed Allocation MOU, which is
an agreement between all of the entities identified in the Allocation MOU as to how the proceeds
payable to those entities under the Settlement Agreements will be allocated;
WHEREAS, the proposed Addendum to the MOU (“ Addendum”) provided with this
Resolution provides for allocation of settlement proceeds among the Wisconsin Participating
Subdivisons according to the same percentages as that provided in the previously-approved MOU
allocating the settlement proceeds of th e settlements involving McKesson Corporation, Cardinal
Health, Inc., AmerisourceBergen Corporation, Johnson & Johnson, Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc.,
Ortho-McNeil-Janssen Pharmaceuticals, Inc., and Janssen Pharmaceuitca, Inc.;
WHEREAS, there is provided w ith this Resolution a summary of the essential terms of
the Settlement Agreements, the deadlines related to the effective dates of the Settlement
Agreements, the ramifications associated with the County’s refusal to enter into the Settlement
Agreements, the form of the Addendum, the form of the AG MOU, and an overview of the process
for finalizing the Settlement Agreements;
WHEREAS, the County, by this Resolution, shall deposit the proceeds of the Settlement
Agreements consistent with the terms of this Resolution and Wis. Stat. § 165.12(4)(b);
WHEREAS, pursuant to the County’s engagement agreement with the Law Firms, the
County shall pay up to an amount equal to 25% of the proceeds from successful resolution of all
or part of the Litigation, whether throug h settlement or otherwise, plus the Law Firms’ costs and
disbursements, to the Law Firms as compensation for the Law Firms’ efforts in the Litigation and
any settlement;
WHEREAS, the Law Firms anticipate making application to the national fee fund
established in the Settlement Agreements seeking payment, in whole or part, of the fees, costs, and
disbursements owed the Law Firms pursuant to the engagement agreement with the County;
WHEREAS, it is anticipated the amount of any award from the fee fund established in the
Settlement Agreements will be insufficient to satisfy the County’s obligations under the
engagement agreement with the Law Firms;
WHEREAS, the County, by this Resolution, and pursuant to the authority granted the
County in the applicable Order emanating from the Litigation in relation to the Settlement
Agreements and payment of attorney fees, shall authorize and direct the escrow agent responsible
for the receipt and distribution of the proceeds from the Settlement Agreements to establi sh an
account for the purpose of segregating funds to pay the fees, costs, and disbursements of the Law
Firms owed by the County (the “Attorney Fees Account”) in order to fund a local “backstop” for
payment of the fees, costs, and disbursements of the Law Firms;
WHEREAS, in no event shall payments to the Law Firms out of the Attorney Fees
Account and the fee fund established in the Settlement Agreements exceed an amount equal to
25% of the amounts allocated to the County in the Addendum;
WHEREAS, the int ent of this Resolution is to authorize the County to enter into the
Settlement Agreements, the Addendum, and the AG MOU, establish the County’s Opioid
Abatement Account, and establish the Attorney Fees Account; and
WHEREAS, the County, by this Resolution, shall authorize the County’s corporation
counsel to finalize and execute any escrow agreement and other document or agreement necessary
to effectuate the Settlement Agreements and the other agreements referenced herein;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED: the Ashland County Board of Supervisors
hereby approves:
1. The execution of the Settlement Agreements and any and all documents ancillary
thereto and authorizes the Board Chair or designee to execute same.
2. The final negotiation and execution of the Addendum in form substantially similar
to that presented with this Resolution and any and all documents ancillary thereto
and authorizes the Board Chair or designee to execute same upon finalization
provided the percentage share identified as allocated to the County is substantially
similar to that identified in the Addendum provided to the Board with this
Resolution.
3. The final negotiation and execution of the AG MOU in form substantially similar
to that presented with this Resolution and any and all documents ancillary thereto
and authorizes the [Board Chair] or designee to execute same.
4. The execution by the [Board Chair] or designee of any additional documents or
agreements for the receipt and disbursement of the proceeds of the Settlement
Agreements as referenced in the Addendum.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED: all proceeds from the Settlement Agreements not
otherwise directed to the Attorney Fees Account shall be deposited in the County’s Opioid
Abatement Account. The Opioid Abatement Account shall be administered consistent with the
terms of this Resolution, Wis. Stat. § 165.12(4), and the Settlement Agreements.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED: the County hereby authorizes the establishment of an
account separate and distinct from any account containing funds allocated or allocable to the
County which shall be referred to by the County as the “Attorney Fees Account.” An escrow agent
shall deposit a sum equal to up to, but in no event exceeding, an amount equal to 20% of the
County’s proceeds from the Settleme nt Agreements into the Attorney Fees Account. If the
payments to the County are not enough to fully fund the Attorney Fees Account as provided herein
because such payments are made over time, the Attorney Fees Account shall be funded by placing
up to, but in no event exceeding, an amount equal to 20% of the proceeds from the Settlement
Agreements attributable to Local Governments (as that term is defined in the Allocation MOU)
into the Attorney Fees Account for each payment. Funds in the Attorney Fees Acc ount shall be
utilized to pay the fees, costs, and disbursements owed to the Law Firms pursuant to the
engagement agreement between the County and the Law Firms provided, however, the Law Firms
shall receive no more than that to which they are entitled under their fee contract when considering
the amounts paid the Law Firms from the fee fund established in the Settlement Agreements and
allocable to the County. The Law Firms may make application for payment from the Attorney
Fees Account at any time and the County shall cooperate with the Law Firms in executing any
documents necessary for the escrow agent to make payments out of the Attorney Fees Account.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that all actions heretofore taken by the Ashland County
Board of Supervisors and other appropriate public officers and agents of the County with respect
to the matters contemplated under this Resolution are hereby ratified, confirmed and approved.
Adopted by the Ashland County Board of Supervisors, Ashland, Wisconsin on this 8th
day of March, 2023.
By Action of the Ashland County Board of Supervisors:
Signed: Richard Pufall
County Board Chairman
Motion was made by Clarence Campbell and seconded by Matt MacKenzie to adopt Resolution
R03-2023-1441. Motion carried.
c. Resolution R03-2023-1442 – A Resolution Supporting Joint Dispatch
COUNTY SUPPORT FOR A
CONSOLIDATED DISPATCH AND IMPLEMENTATION PLAN
WHEREAS, Ashland and Bayfield Counties each operate PSAPs (911 dispatch centers),
the centers are nine miles apart; and,
WHEREAS, Ashland and Bayfield Counties often have just one person working in the
PSAP; and,
WHEREAS, Emergency Medical Dispatch and s. DMA 2.04 (6) requires each PSAP to
have a minimum of two telecommunicators on duty to be available to receive and process
requests for emergency assistance, including life-saving medical instructions, while the
designated public safety answering point is in operation; and,
WHEREAS, Ashland and Bayfield Counties undertook a consolidated dispatch
feasibility study, the study concluded that consolidated dispatch was feasible and that the
counties would be better served by consolidating the two PSAPs; and,
WHEREAS, both counties applied for the Department of Military Affairs Consolidated
Dispatch Grant; and,
WHEREAS, although the grant was initially denied the DMA stated that if both counties
supported joint dispatch and agreed to complete an implementation/consolidation plan, funding
would be considered;
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ashland County Board of
Supervisors assembled this 8th day of March 2023, agrees to pursue an implementation plan and
pay 50%, ($11,000) of the cost; and,
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the Ashland County Board of Supervisors goes on
record supporting and endorsing a consolidated dispatch center.
Adopted by the Ashland County Board of Supervisors, Ashland, Wisconsin on this 8th
day of March, 2023.
By Action of the Ashland County Board of Supervisors:
Signed: Richard Pufall
County Board Chairman
Motion was made by Mike Berlin and seconded by Bill Metzinger to adopt Resolution R03-
2023-1442. Discussion followed. Motion carried.
d. Approve Spending $11,000 for Mission Critical Partner to Complete Implementation
Plans for Joint Dispatch
Motion was made by Elizabeth Franek and seconded by Mike Berlin to approve spending
$11,000 for Mission Critical Partner to complete Implementation Plans for Joint Dispatch.
Discussion followed. Motion carried
.
e. Resolution R03-2023-1443 - Approve County Hazard Mitigation Plan FEMA
Addendum
A RESOLUTION IN SUPPORT OF THE
ASHLAND COUNTY HAZARD MITIGATION PLAN ADDENDUM
WHEREAS, in recent years, 100-year, 500-year, and even 1,000-year storm events
have led to widespread flooding and significant damages to public infrastructure across Northern
Wisconsin, and
WHEREAS, storm-related damages to public infrastructure like roads, culverts, and
bridges can overwhelm and surpass the budgets of local government units, and
WHEREAS, in 2019, Ashland County received a FEMA Pre-disaster Advance
Assistance Mitigation Grant to identify fluvial erosion hazards upstream from areas of severe or
repetitive damage to roads, culverts, and bridges within a project area in the Marengo River
Watershed, and
WHEREAS, the grant project, Rebuilding Natural Infrastructure in Ashland County,
also evaluated and prioritized natural flood management practices to increase wetland storage,
reduce peak flows, and reduce damages to vulnerable infrastructure from future storms, and
WHEREAS, the project involved active engagement and participation from town
officials throughout the Marengo River Watershed, and
WHEREAS, a deliverable from Rebuilding Natural Infrastructure in Ashland County
includes adopting an addendum to the Ashland County Hazard Mitigation Plan that summarizes
project findings, goals, and strategies to implement natural flood management practices to reduce
damages from future storms, and
WHEREAS, the Public Property and Law Enforcement Committee met on January 30,
2023, and recommended the addendum be considered by the Ashland County Board of
Supervisors for review and action,
NOW, THEREFORE BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ashland County Board of
Supervisors, in consideration of this project, recommend that the Hazard Mitigation Plan
Addendum, “A Strategy for Natural Flood Management and Climate Resilient Infrastructure in
Ashland County,” be included to the Ashland County Hazard Mitigation Plan.
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the addendum, “A Strategy for Natural Flood
Management and Climate Resilient Infrastructure in Ashland County” shall be available to the
public as a link on the Ashland County Hazard Mitigation Plan website.
Adopted by the Ashland County Board of Supervisors, Ashland, Wisconsin on this 8th
day of March, 2023.
By Action of the Ashland County Board of Supervisors:
Signed: Richard Pufall
County Board Chairman
Motion was made by George Bussey and seconded by Mike Starck to adopt Resolution
R03-2023-1443. Kyle Magyera, Local Government Outreach Specialist with the Wisconsin
Wetlands Association and MaryJo Gingras, Ashland County Land Conservationist commented
on the resolution. Discussion followed. Motion carried.
Mike Berlin was excused from the meeting at 9:43 a.m.
f. Resolution R03-2023-1444 - Approval of Ashland County Species and Habitat
Conservation Agreement
APPROVAL OF ASHLAND COUNTY SPECIES AND HABITAT
CONSERVATION AGREEMENT
WHEREAS, Ashland County manages approximately 40,500 acres of County Forest
Lands along with numerous recreational trails and facilities which are managed for multiple
benefits; and
WHEREAS, the Northern Long-eared Bat and Tri-colored Bat are expected to be listed
as federally endangered in 2023 and the Little Brown Bat is under review for listing; and
WHEREAS, the states of Wisconsin, Minnesota and Michigan have jointly developed
the Lakes States Forest Management Bat Habitat Conservation Plan in order to receive an
incidental take permit for forest management activities issued by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife
Service; and
WHEREAS, Ashland County plans to engage in activities that could result in the
incidental take of the bats and seeks to be included in under the Incidental Take Permit issued to
the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources; and
WHEREAS, Ashland County will comply with the terms of the Species and Habitat
Conservation Agreement.
THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, that the Ashland County Forestry and Recreation
Committee and the Ashland County Board of Supervisors, in consideration of the needs to
conserve the bat populations in Wisconsin while continuing multiple use management consistent
with the Ashland County Forest Comprehensive Land Use Plan, hereby agree to enter into a
Landowner Agreement and Certificate of Inclusion into the Lakes States Forest management Bat
Habitat Conservation Plan; and
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED, that the County Forest Administrator be authorized to
sign the agreement and submit this document to the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources.
Adopted by the Ashland County Board of Supervisors, Ashland, Wisconsin on this 8th
day of March, 2023.
Signed: Richard Pufall
County Board Chairman
Motion was made by Matt MacKenzie and seconded by John Wiener to adopt Resolution
R03-2023-1444. Motion carried.
g. Notice of Claims – La Pointe – Removed from agenda.
h. Resolution R03-2023-1445 – Resolution Providing for the Issuance, Sale and
Delivery of a $170,000 General Obligation Promissory Note, Series 2023, of Ashland
County, Wisconsin; Establishing the Terms and Conditions Therefor; Directing its
Execution and Delivery
RESOLUTION PROVIDING FOR THE ISSUANCE, SALE AND
DELIVERY OF A $170,000 GENERAL OBLIGATION PROMISSORY
NOTE, SERIES 2023, OF ASHLAND COUNTY, WISCONSIN;
ESTABLISHING THE TERMS AND CONDITIONS THEREFOR;
DIRECTING ITS EXECUTION AND DELIVERY
BE IT RESOLVED, by the Board of Supervisors (the “Board”) of Ashland County,
Wisconsin (the “County”), as follows:
1. Under and pursuant to the provisions of Wisconsin Statutes, Chapter 67 and
Sections 67.045 and 67.12(12), the County is authorized to issue and sell its general obligation
promissory notes for any public purpose.
2. The Board hereby directs the issuance and sale of its $170,000 General Obligation
Promissory Note, Series 2023 (the “Note”) for the public purpose of financing a used
groomer/tucker and plow for use by the Ashland County Snowmobile Alliance. The Ashland
County Snowmobile Alliance shall be responsible for making the payments and shall sign the
Note with Ashland County.
3. The County and Ashland County Snowmobile Alliance has solicited a proposal
for the sale of the Note and received a proposal from Northern State Bank, located in Ashland,
Wisconsin (the “Purchaser”), to purchase the Note to pay or provide for costs of the purchase.
4. The Note shall bear interest on the unpaid principal balance at the rate of 5.5% per
annum, and the note will mature with the principal and interest payable in 2 yearly installments
for a period of 6 year after issuance.
5. The County, after due consideration, finds such offer reasonable and proper and
the offer of the Purchaser is hereby accepted. All actions of the Chairperson, the County Clerk
and the Administrator taken with regard to the sale of the Note are hereby ratified and approved.
Adopted by the Ashland County Board of Supervisors, Ashland, Wisconsin on this 8th
day of March, 2023.
By Action of the Ashland County Board of Supervisors:
Signed: Richard Pufall
County Board Chairman
Motion was made by Matt MacKenzie and seconded by Kathy Schutte to adopt Resolution
R03-2023-1445. Pat Daoust from the Ashland County Snowmobile Alliance commented on the
resolution. Discussion followed. Motion carried.
6. ENTER INTO CLOSED SESSION
Motion was made by George Bussey and seconded by Clarence Campbell to go into Closed
Session Pursuant to §19.85(1)(e) Deliberating or negotiating the purchasing of public properties,
the investing of public funds, or conducting other specified public business, whenever
competitive or bargaining reasons require a closed session.
Roll Call: Yes: Ellefson, Metzinger, Campbell, Kinney, Franek, Starck, Berlin,
Bussey, Vitek, Huber, Schutte, Carl, Wiener, 13
No: 0
Abstain: MacKenzie and Pufall 2
Excused: Nagro, Ray, Sztyndor, Berlin and Mika
Closed session commenced at 9:53 a.m.
7. RECONVENE TO OPEN SESSION
Motion was made by George Bussey and seconded by Kathy Schutte to revert to County Board.
Roll Call: Yes: Ellefson, Metzinger, Campbell, Kinney, Franek, Starck, Berlin,
Bussey, Vitek, Huber, Schutte, Carl, Wiener, 13
No: 0
Abstain: MacKenzie and Pufall 2
Excused: Nagro, Ray, Sztyndor, Berlin and Mika
The Board reconvened in open session at 10:25 a.m.
a. Possible Action from Closed Session – Offer to Purchase 514 Main Street West
Building
Motion was made by Bill Metzinger and seconded by George Bussey to accept the offer from the
City of Ashland for the purchase of the county building located at 514 Main Street West,
Ashland, WI. Discussion followed.
Roll Call: Yes: Ellefson, Metzinger, Campbell, , Franek, , Berlin, Bussey, Vitek,
Huber, Schutte, Carl, Wiener, 11
No: Kinney and Starck. 2
Abstain: MacKenzie and Pufall 2
Excused: Nagro, Ray, Sztyndor, Berlin and Mika
John Wiener was excused from the meeting at 10:42 a.m.
8. REPORTS/UPDATES
a. Administrator Updates
County Administrator Dan Grady gave an update on the meetings he attended recently in
Madison.
b. Staffing/Personnel
County Administrator Dan Grady updated the Board on personnel changes that have
occurred since the February 7, 2023 County Board meeting.
c. County Board Supervisors
Board members commented.
9. ADJOURN
There being no further business, a motion to adjourn was made by Blake Ellefson and seconded
by Martin Vitek. Motion carried. County Board adjourned at 10:55 a.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Heather W. Schutte
Ashland County Clerk
Source: Ashland County website. First collected Oct 31, 2026.