Board of Adjustment Meeting Agenda Packet (PDF)
Door County · Door County · meeting of Nov 10, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Door County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Notice in compliance with the Americans with Disabilities Act: 1) Any person needing assistance to participate in this meeting should contact the Office of the
County Clerk at (920) 746-2200. Notification 72 hours prior to a meeting will enable the County to make reasonable arrangements to ensure accessibility to this
meeting. 2) Door County is committed to making its electronic and information technology (e.g., website and contents) accessible for all persons. If you
encounter difficulty accessing the posted materials for this meeting, located on-line at https://www.co.door.wi.gov/AgendaCenter under the committee name, or
have trouble accessing the virtual meeting, please call (920) 746-2323, or send a FAX to (920) 746-2387, or send an e-mail to Lriemer@co.door.wi.us so that we
may determine how to best assist you.
AGENDA
1.0 Call to order and declaration of quorum
2.0 Final disposition of the following case(s) considered by the Board
of Adjustment on October 27, 2026.
2.1 Mark Lebotte; side yard setback; Gibraltar; PIN
0140229312714 (9392 Cottage Row Rd.)
3.0 Read and act on minutes of October 27, 2026, meeting
4.0 Future meeting schedule:
• November 24th: Meeting canceled, no public hearings.
• December 8th: Meeting canceled, no public hearings.
• December 22nd: Meeting canceled, no public hearings.
5.0 Address scheduling
6.0 Vouchers
7.0 Adjournment
Deviation from order shown may occur.
Jeff Schmeckpeper, Chair
Door County Board of Adjustment
c/o Door County Land Use Services Dept.
Door County Government Center
421 Nebraska St.
Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235
Notice of Public Meeting
Tuesday, November 10, 2026
4:30 p.m.
DOOR COUNTY
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
Door County Government Center
Peninsula Room
(C121, 1st floor)
421 Nebraska Street, Sturgeon Bay, WI
USE THE 4TH STREET ENTRANCE, ACROSS FROM THE LIBRARY.
Applicants and others who wish to speak must attend
in person.
Members of the public who wish to simply monitor/observe
the hearings and meeting may attend in person or do so
remotely by using the link below, or via the Zoom
smartphone app, or by calling (312) 626-6799.
Link:
https://us02web.zoom.us/j/85978344125?pwd=Sb
QbYX1IitMK6I2gtkVfyFaarwQtBr.1
Zoom ID: 859 7834 4125
Passcode: 859340
1
1
DOOR COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
Decision – Side Yard Setback Variances
APPLICANT(S) NAME(S): Mark Lebotte
PROPERTY ADDRESSES / PIN: 9392 Cottage Row Rd/ 014-02-29312714
HEARING DATE: October 27, 2026
DECISION DATE: October 27, 2026
DESCRIPTION OF VARIANCE REQUESTED:
Mark Lebotte, on behalf of the David J Sterner Trust, is requesting a variance from Section 3.02(3)(a) of the
Door County Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance which requires principal structures on lots located in the Small
Estate Residential (SE) zoning district to meet a 20-foot side yard setback. The applicant proposes a new
house and 27’4” x 25’ attached garage with a portion of the garage being located close as 6’ 6” to the side lot
line. The proposed project will be located at 9392 Cottage Row Rd.
DECISION:
On the basis of the Decision-Making Worksheets (attached hereto and incorporated herein by reference as if
set forth in full) and the record in this matter the Board of Adjustment finds and determines that:
A. The requested variance from Section 3.02(3)(a) of the Door County Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance
does meet the criteria set forth in Section 59.694(7), Wisconsin Statutes. The Board of Adjustment voted
to approve the petition for grant of variance from 3.02(3)(a) of the Door County Comprehensive Zoning
Ordinance by the following vote.
Jeff Schmeckpeper: Aye
Monica Nelson: Aye
Brian Forest: Aye
Signed Signed
Chairperson Recording Clerk
Dated: November 10, 2026
Filed: November 11, 2026
Appeal: This decision may be appealed by a person aggrieved by this decision by filing an action in certiorari in the circuit
court for this county within 30 days after the date of filing of this decision. The County of Door assumes no liability for and
makes no warranty as to reliance on this decision if construction is commenced prior to expiration of this 30 day period.
The privileges granted by this decision shall become void one (1) year after the filed date unless the zoning
permits for the authorized project have been obtained within such time.
2
1
DOOR COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
DECISION-MAKING WORKSHEET
APPLICANT(S) NAME(S): Mark Lebotte
PROPERTY ADDRESSES / PIN: 9392 Cottage Row Rd/ 014-02-29312714
HEARING DATE: October 27, 2026
DECISION DATE: October 27, 2026
DESCRIPTION OF VARIANCE REQUESTED:
Mark Lebotte, on behalf of the David J Sterner Trust, is requesting a variance from Section
3.02(3)(a) of the Door County Comprehensive Zoning Ordinance which requires principal
structures on lots located in the Small Estate Residential (SE) zoning distric t to meet a 20 -foot
side yard setback. The applicant proposes a new house and 27’4” x 25’ attached garage with a
portion of the garage being located close as 6’ 6” to the side lot line. The proposed project will be
located at 9392 Cottage Row Rd.
To grant an area variance, all three of the standards enumerated below must be met. In
addressing each standard, express the reasons for the decision, i.e., why the facts did or
did not satisfy the standards, the weight and credibility of the evidence presented (or
lack thereof), and any other relevant considerations.
1. UNIQUE PHYSICAL PROPERTY LIMITATIONS.
Are there unique physical property limitations such as steep slopes, wetlands, or parcel shape
that prevent compliance with the ordinance? The circumstances of an applicant (growing
family, need for a larger garage, etc.) are not factors in deciding variances. Property limitations
that prevent ordinance compliance and are common to a number of properties should be
addressed by amending the ordinance. The variance is not warranted if the physical character
of the property allows a landowner to develop or build in compliance with the zoning ordinance.
In order for a variance to satisfy the unique physical property limitation test, the question
below must be answered affirmatively.
Does this property contain unique physical property limitations (e.g., wetland presence,
parcel shape, steep slope, etc.) that would prevent compliance with the ordinance?
YES __X__ NO _____
EXPLAIN: Unique physical property limitations exist due to the non-conforming lot size and the
bluff limiting the buildable area.
3
2
2. UNNECESSARY HARDSHIP.
Unnecessary hardship exists when a literal enforcement of the ordinance would unreasonably
prevent the owner from using the property for a permitted purpose or when conformity with
ordinance standards would be unnecessarily burdensome.
Considerations:
• Unnecessary hardship should be determined in light of the purpose and intent of the
zoning ordinance in question, as well as any statute or administrative rule upon which
the ordinance is based. (See page 4.) The facts of the case should be analyzed in light
of these purposes. Only after considering the purpose(s) of the statute and/or
ordinance, and the nature of the specific restriction(s) at issue, may a decision be made
as to whether or not failure to grant a variance will cause an unnecessary hardship.
• Unnecessary hardship may arise due to a unique property limitation of a parcel (see #1,
above). A variance is not warranted if the physical character of the property allows a
landowner to develop or build in compliance with the zoning ordinance.
• Unnecessary hardship does not include considerations personal to the property owner
(e.g., personal preference, desire to maximizing the economic value of the property, or
financial hardship caused by ordinance compliance).
• Any self-created hardship, and/or any hardship that existed irrespective of the zoning
ordinance in question are not proper grounds upon which to grant a variance.
• Alternatives to a variance (e.g., conditional use permit or restrictive covenant) may, as
neither runs with the land, be preferable to accommodate a disability of the owner or
owner’s dependent.
In order for a variance to satisfy the unnecessary hardship test, one of the questions
below (A or B) must be answered affirmatively.
A. Does denial of the variance -- i.e., requiring compliance with the strict letter of the
ordinance provision(s) in question (e.g., setbacks, height limitations, etc.) --
unreasonably prevent the owner from using the property for a permitted purpose?
YES _____ NO _____
EXPLAIN:
OR
B. Is conformity with the regulation(s) unnecessarily burdensome?
YES _X___ NO _____
EXPLAIN: Compliance would be unnecessarily burdensome as it would require
significant alterations to the property to accommodate the proposed structure and
ensure stability for the bluff.
4
3
3. PUBLIC INTEREST/SPIRIT AND INTENT OF THE ORDINANCE.
A variance may not be granted which results in harm to public interests, nor thwarts the spirit
and intent of the ordinance. In applying this test, the board should review the purpose
statements of the ordinance (and any statute or administrative rule upon which the ordinance is
based) in order to identify public interests. (See page 4.) The short-term and long-term impacts
of the proposal and the cumulative impacts of similar projects on the interests of the neighbors,
the community, and even the state, should be considered. Review should focus on the general
public interest, rather than just the narrow interests or impacts on neighbors, patrons, or
residents in the vicinity of the project.
Cumulative effects are a proper consideration. For instance, in the context of shoreland zoning,
the general availability of variances permitting the horizontal expansion of structures so close to
the water's edge may have the cumulative effect of enclosing our lakes within a wall of
impermeable surfaces to the exclusion of vegetation and impairing the ecological functions of
the shoreland buffer.
A variance is not a popularity contest. The mere fact of public support or opposition is not, in
and of itself, determinative of whether or not a variance is contrary to the public interest.
The board may grant only the minimum variance needed, i.e., the minimum variance necessary
to relieve the unnecessary hardship. For instance, if the request is for a variance of 30 feet from
the minimum setback, and a finding is made that a 10-foot setback reduction would allow the
petitioner to use the property for a permitted purpose, then only a 10-foot setback reduction may
be authorized.
Distinguish between hardships that are unnecessary in light of the unique conditions of the
property and the purpose of the zoning ordinance from hardships that are inconsequential or not
unique or because a variance would unduly undermine the purpose of the ordinance or the
public interest.
In order for a variance to satisfy the public interest test, the question below must be
answered negatively.
Does the granting of the variance result in harm to the public interest?
YES _____ NO __X__
EXPLAIN: There is no harm to public interest as there is no public exposure of the portion of the
structure requiring the variance. The variance requested is limited to what is necessary form the
applicant to continue to utilize the property for a permitted use. Granting of the variance will be
in accordance with the town recommendation and the adjacent neighbors.
Has the applicant seeking a variance demonstrated that each of the three standards has
been satisfied in this case? YES __X__ NO _____. If yes, then substantial justice will be
done by granting the variance.
Dated this: October 27, 2026
5
4
Door County Zoning Ordinance Purpose Statements
"1.04 Purpose. The purpose of this Ordinance is to promote and protect public health, safety,
aesthetics, and other aspects of the general welfare. Further purposes of this Ordinance are to:
(1) Aid in implementing the county development plan.
(2) Promote planned and orderly land use development.
(3) Protect property values and the property tax base.
(4) Fix reasonable dimensional requirements to which buildings, structures, and lots shall
conform.
(5) Prevent overcrowding of the land.
(6) Advance uses of land in accordance with its character and suitability.
(7) Provide property with access to adequate sunlight and clean air.
(8) Aid in protection of groundwater and surface water.
(9) Preserve wetlands.
(10) Protect the beauty of landscapes.
(11) Conserve flora and fauna habitats.
(12) Preserve and enhance the county's rural characteristics.
(13) Protect vegetative shore cover.
(14) Promote safety and efficiency in the county's road transportation system.
(15) Define the duties and powers of administrative bodies in administering this Ordinance.
(16) Prescribe penalties for violation of this Ordinance."
Wisconsin Statutes Purpose Statement
281.31. Navigable waters protection law
"(1) To aid in the fulfillment of the state's role as trustee of its navigable waters and to promote
public health, safety, convenience and general welfare, it is declared to be in the public interest
to make studies, establish policies, make plans and authorize municipal shoreland zoning
regulations for the efficient use, conservation, development and protection of this state's water
resources. The regulations shall relate to lands under, abutting or lying close to navigable
waters. The purposes of the regulations shall be to further the maintenance of safe and
healthful conditions; prevent and control water pollution; protect spawning grounds, fish and
aquatic life; control building sites, placement of structure and land uses and reserve shore cover
and natural beauty." (Emphasis added.)
Examples as to how to use the above in conjunction with analysis of a variance request
When considering a variance request to relax the required ordinary high water mark setback,
county zoning ordinance purposes (8), (10), (11), and (13) are likely relevant to consider.
Purposes (2), (3), (4), and (5) may also be relevant. Depending upon the nature of the variance
request, any of the components of the statutory purposes behind shoreland zoning (above) may
be relevant to consider.
When considering a variance request to relax a required yard (setback), county zoning
ordinance purposes (2), (3), (4), and (5) are likely relevant to consider.
6
MINUTES OF MEETING
DOOR COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
October 27, 2026
1.0 Call to order and declaration of quorum.
The meeting was called to order by Schmeckpeper at 4:30 p.m. on Tuesday, October 27, 2026, in the Peninsula Room
(C-121) of the Door County Government Center, Sturgeon Bay, Wisconsin.
Present: BOA Members Staff
Jeff Schmeckpeper Adam Ferrell, Code Administrator
Brian Forest Tara McKeefry, Code Administrator
Monica Nelson Colleen McCauley, Planner
2.0 Discuss and arrive at a decision on Petition for Grant of Variance.
2.1 Mark Lebotte; side yard setback; Gibraltar; PIN 0140229312714 (9392 Cottage Row Rd)
Motion by Nelson, seconded by Forest, to approve the variance. Motion carried unanimously (3-0).
The basis for the decision is set forth in the Board of Adjustment decision document.
3.0 Read and act on minutes of September 22, 2026, meeting.
Motion by Nelson, seconded by Schmeckpeper, to approve the minutes as presented. Motion carried unanimously (3-0).
4.0 Future meeting schedule:
• November 10th: Business Meeting
• November 24th: Meeting Canceled
• December 8th: If Necessary; possible Public Hearing
5.0 Vouchers.
All BOA members’ vouchers reflect a 1-hour meeting.
6.0 Adjournment.
Motion by Forest, seconded by Nelson, to adjourn. Motion carried unanimously (3-0).
Schmeckpeper declared the meeting adjourned at 5:36 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by Adam Ferrell, Code Administrator
7
Source: Door County website. First collected Nov 6, 2026.