Board of Adjustment — Agenda Packet
Portage County · Portage County · Board of Adjustment · meeting of Nov 16, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Portage County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PORTAGE COUNTY
MEETING AGENDA
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
PORTAGE COUNTY ANNEX
CONFERENCE ROOM 5
1462 STRONGS AVENUE
STEVENS POINT, WI 54481
Monday, November 16, 2026 4:00 PM
REMOTE ATTENDANCE & COMMENT
To attend this meeting by telephone : dial 1-872-242-7813, after dialing the number you will then be asked to enter in a
meeting number. Use the following meeting number: 863 694 895, then press #
To attend this meeting by video: Join the meeting now
Page 1 of 1
CALL TO ORDER
Committee Members enter Per Diem and Mileage
ROLL CALL
PLEDGE TO THE FLAG
CORRESPONDENCE
1. 2027 Meeting Calendar
REPORTS
2. Special Meeting Attendance Reports (Portage County Ordinance 3.1.47 & 3.1.48)
PUBLIC HEARING, DELIBERATION AND DECISIONS ON SPECIAL EXCEPTIONS AND VARIANCES. THE HEARING IS TO
DISCUSS AND TAKE ACTION ON THE FOLLOWING APPLICATION(S):
3. PET-2026-011, Special Exception request by WTTC Land Management Company, Owner, Tristan Gardger, Agent,
request to operate a nonmetallic mine located at 2909 Sunset Drive, Stevens Point, WI 54482, Parcel #014250725-
09.01, per provisions of the Portage County Zoning Ordinance section 7.1.3.1(C)(11). Property is zoned A4 General
Agriculture and is located in the Town of Dewey.
PUBLIC NOTICE
Members of the public who wish to address the Committee on specific agenda items must register their request at this time,
with such comments subject to the public comment ordinance and the reasonable control of the Committee Chair as set forth
in Robert’s Rules of Order.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
4. On-site Meeting Minutes from October 19, 2026
5. Meeting Minutes from October 19, 2026
NEXT MEETING DATE
ADJOURNMENT
Notice: Any person who has special needs and plans on attending this meeting in-person or remotely should contact the Facilities
Office at 715-346-1598 as soon as possible to ensure that reasonable accommodations can be made.
Notice: Remote comment by the public during the meeting will be at the discretion of the Chair.
Notice: A quorum of the Portage County Board of Supervisors, or any committee thereof, may be present at this meeting.
Page 1 of 45
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT - 2027 CALENDAR
MEETING DATE APPLICATION DEADLINE PUBLIC HEARING NOTICE DUE PUBLICATION DATES STAFF MEMO DUE PACKETS/AGENDAS OUT
January 18, 2027 (ALT 19) December 22, 2026 December 30, 2026 January 4 & 11, 2027 January 7, 2027 January 11, 2027
February 15, 2027 (ALT 16) January 25, 2027 January 27, 2027 February 1 & 8, 2027 February 4, 2027 February 8, 2027
March 15, 2027 (ALT 16th) February 22, 2027 February 24, 2027 March 1 & 8, 2027 March 4, 2027 March 8, 2027
April 19, 2027 March 26, 2027 March 31, 2027 April 5 & 12, 2027 April 8, 2027 April 12, 2027
May 17, 2027 April 27, 2027 April 29, 2027 May 3 & 10, 2027 May 6, 2027 May 10, 2027
June 21, 2027 May 25, 2027 June 2, 2027 June 7 & 14, 2027 June 10, 2027 June 14, 2027
July 19, 2027 June 24, 2027 June 30, 2027 July 5 & 12, 2027 July 8, 2027 July 12, 2027
August 16, 2027 July 23, 2027 July 28, 2027 August 2 & 9, 2027 August 5, 2027 August 9, 2027
September 20, 2027 August 25, 2027 September 1, 2027 September 6 & 13, 2027 September 9, 2027 September 13, 2027
October 18, 2027 September 24, 2027 September 29, 2027 October 4 & 11, 2027 October 7, 2027 October 11, 2027
November 15, 2027 October 25, 2027 October 27, 2027 November 1 & 8, 2027 November 4, 2027 November 8, 2027
Dec 13, 2027 (ALT 14th) November 22, 2027 November 24, 2027 Nov 29 & Dec 6, 2027 December 3, 2027 December 6, 2027
Jan 17, 2028 (ALT 18th) December 22, 2027 December 29, 2027 January 3 & 10, 2028 January 6, 2028 January 10, 2028
* Meeting dates subject to change
Page 2 of 45
BOA NOTES
Petition PET-2026-011
WTTC Land Management Company
SPECIAL EXCEPTION
PET-2026-011, WTTC Land Management Company, Owner, Tristan Gardger, Agent, request to operate
a nonmetallic mine located at 2909 Sunset Drive, Stevens Point, WI 54482, Parcel #014250725-09.01,
per provisions of the Portage County Zoning Ordinance section 7.1.3.1(C)(11). Property is zoned A4
General Agriculture and is located in the Town of Dewey
Conditions:
1. ___________________________________________________________________
2. ___________________________________________________________________
3. ___________________________________________________________________
4. ___________________________________________________________________
5. ___________________________________________________________________
6. ___________________________________________________________________
7. ___________________________________________________________________
8. (If Applicable) Stormwater/Runoff plans submitted for approval by Land and Water
Conservation Division.
9. (If Applicable) Shoreland Vegetation Plans submitted for approval by Land and Water
Conservation Division.
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
_________________________________________________________________________________________
Page 3 of 45
PLANNING AND ZONING DEPARTMENT
1462 STRONGS AVENUE, STEVENS POINT, WI 54481 PHONE: 715-346-1334
PLANNING ZONING AND CODE ADMINISTRATION LAND AND WATER CONSERVATION ON-SITE WASTE
WATER RESOURCES LAND INFORMATION (GIS) ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT SURVEYOR
MEMORANDUM
TO: Portage County Board of Adjustment
FROM: Chris Mrdutt - Zoning Coordinator
DATE: November 2, 2026
RE: Special exception request by WTTC Land Management Company (Mathy
Construction Co.), owner, request a 20-year mining extension and to modify
conditions placed on the special exception approval to operate a nonmetallic mine
(A06-19) in the A4 – General Agricultural Zoning District.
Located at 2909 Sunset Drive, Parcel 014250725-09.01
Background
The petitioner has approached the Portage County Planning and Zoning Department regarding
continuing the operation of the hard rock quarry at 2909 Sunset Drive. On April 26, 2006, Keith
Cyran, obtained a special exception approval A06-19 for a 25 acre quarry area on the 50.63 acre
parcel 014250725-09.01. (See Conditions for A06-19 and subsequent Town Conditions). Proposed
Town of Dewey agreements for A06-19 indicated the nonmetallic mine was approved for 20 years,
had a maximum depth to 1035 mean sea level, and various other conditions that need to be
reviewed for relevance and enforcement capability going forward. This petition is for a 20-year
extension, within the current approved footprint of 25 acres, to a max depth of 985 msl (~120’
Deep), and to establish a new set of conditions to correspond with the 20-year extension.
Analysis
On September 13, 2006, a Portage County Zoning Permit was issued to start operation at the
Sunset Quarry (2909 Sunset Drive). The Quarry (per town agreement) was approved for 20 years,
and that approval will expire on September 13, 2026. The owner(s) have indicated there is a large
quantity of hard rock material left in the mine, and they seek to continue operations. The
approximate surface elevation is ~ 1120 msl. The quarry currently is ~ 50’ deep or around 1075
msl. On August 6, 2024, the owner(s) of this quarry obtained a Chapter 30 permit through the WI-
DNR to create an artificial unconnected pond via nonmetallic mining. WI-DNR is handling the
reclamation of this site through their Chapter 30 permit, and the proposed reclaimed land use is a
pond. There were 23 attached conditions of approval as well as references to town agreements.
These conditions / Town agreements have been followed.
Portage County Planning, Zoning, and Land Conservation Staff have reviewed the previous Board
of Adjustment (BOA) Conditions and the Town of Dewey agreement. BOA conditions must be
pertinent to the request, be enforceable by the Department, and meet measurable standards. In
review of the previous conditions and Town of Dewey agreement documentation, staff will be
recommending to BOA to amend some of the conditions and the Town of Dewey agreement. Our
Page 4 of 45
department will evaluate conditions proposed by the Town to make sure they meet the criteria
mentioned above. Other previous conditions are recommended to be removed because the
petitioner/operator is varying from the original request, and BOA will weigh the merits of the new
request. Some conditions have been met before this request and are not necessary in the time
extension proposal. Other conditions are handled through the enforcement of the non-metallic
mining ordinance and would be redundant.
Listed below is a summary of the required evaluations, potential conditions, and other applicable
Ordinance standards BOA should use to review the request.
Review Requirements
In addition to the BOA review criteria, all commercial development is subject to site plan review by
Portage County Planning and Zoning Department staff prior to issuance of a Zoning Permit. An
overview of the proposed business and preliminary site plan has been submitted by the applicant (see
narrative and attached maps). The Ordinance defined site plan review criteria, and some details of the
request are highlighted below:
Road access
This site is accessed off Sunset Drive. Current BOA Condition #4 states the operator is to meet with
the Portage County Highway Committee and Commissioner, and the Town of Dewey for
recommendations regarding cost sharing, maintenance, and upgrades for haul roads. A modification
of this condition will be proposed for this petition after listening to Town input and consulting Mathy
Construction Co and is represented as conditions #4 below. This condition takes into account the
concern the Town has with maintenance of sunset road while allowing the Quarry operation to ingress
and egress both directions out of the quarry. Haul route concerns should be mitigated with the
knowledge learned from a traffic study and the maintenance agreement that Mathy and the Town can
establish for the long-term maintenance of Sunset Drive.
Stormwater Control Plan and/or Construction Site Erosion Plan
A DNR stormwater control, and dewatering plan is on file for this property. This requirement would
remain intact with the proposed extension.
Parking and paving
Parking and vehicle maintenance areas are provided above the quarry within the designated project
area. There is ample space for these activities where vehicles do not have to park on Sunset Drive.
Landscaping and screening
A new 15-foot-tall berm shall be constructed and seeded with native grasses along the north side of the
quarry. Trees shall be planted along the north side of the berm as well as additional trees planted for
screening along sunset drive. A 15-foot-tall, vegetated berm, per condition #9 has been constructed on
the West side of the pit and will remain in natural vegetation. Existing trees outside the excavation
area will remain in woody vegetation and will be managed under best forest management practices.
Lighting
All lighting is directed into the quarry and does not illuminate surrounding properties or Sunset Drive.
This will have to remain in effect.
Page 5 of 45
Adequacy of setback for structures and storage. Setbacks required by specific zoning districts may
need to be modified based on site specific conditions. Commercial structures 100 feet tall or greater
shall be set back from the nearest property and/or right-of-way line a distance equal to the height of
the structure.
This property is zoned A4 General Agriculture and Conservancy and the required setback to side
property lines is 10 feet and 25 feet to the rear property line. All structures are set far enough back
from the road (63’ feet from centerline) and meet all other required setbacks.
An approved Stormwater Control Plan from the WI-DNR must be on file prior to issuance of a Zoning
Permit if the development is equal to or larger than one (1) acre.
A stormwater control plan from the WI-DNR and a clean water discharge permit has been issued for
this property.
Other Relevant Facts
The Town of Dewey held a meeting on October 14, 2026, and discussed this petition.
The Town was unable to make a recommendation for or against. The Town did discuss
and recommend BOA attached 16 conditions to the approval of this petition. (these
proposed conditions are included in this packet)
Previous BOA conditions stated a maximum depth of 70’ to a depth of 1035 msl. This
petition is seeking the ability to excavate 120’ deep to a depth of 985’ msl. Mathy
Construction has agreed to mine to the original approved depth of 70 feet or 1035 msl.
Multiple blasting has occurred at this site without issue or substantiated complaints from
surrounding property owners.
Over the twenty years this quarry has been in operation no neighboring property owners
have raised concerns regarding the operation of their wells.
The current operation consists of 25 acres previously approved, and this request does not
increase the acreage footprint.
Mathy Construction Company has agreed to the hours of operation proposed by the Town.
The Portage County Highway Department has been informed of this petition and have no
conditions they would want attached to this petition due to this quarry being located on a
Town Road.
The closest neighboring residence other than to previously property owner is ~570’ north.
Required Evaluations.
In passing upon any special exceptions, the BOA shall make the following applicable evaluations,
where appropriate, in addition to those required elsewhere in the Ordinance and base its decision
thereon: The Town should use the below evaluations to aid in their decision making.
Evaluate the effect of the proposed use upon:
The maintenance of safe and healthful conditions;
The prevention and control of water pollution including sedimentation;
Existing topographic and drainage features and vegetative cover on the site;
The location of the site with respect to floodplains and floodways of rivers or streams;
The location of the site with respect to existing or future access roads;
The compatibility of the proposed use with existing development and development anticipated
in the foreseeable future;
Page 6 of 45
The importance of the services provided by the proposed facility to the community;
The availability of alternative locations;
Such other factors as are relevant to the purposes of this Ordinance.
Required Findings.
No special exceptions shall be granted by the Board of Adjustment unless it finds the following
conditions exist:
(1) The use would not substantially harm the public health, safety, and general welfare, and would
not be contrary to State Law or Administrative Code.
(2) The use would be consistent with surrounding uses and the neighborhood would not be injured
thereby.
(3) The use is consistent with this Ordinance and any County or municipal plan which is based on
historic, geographic, and socio-economic facts.
If the Board determines the petition has merit, the Board may want to consider recommending
conditions be attached to the request to the BOA. Conditions should be reasonably related to the
request and enforceable. Such conditions may include, but not be limited to, the following:
Increased setbacks and yards.
Landscaping and planting screens.
Period of operation.
Operational control.
The Planning and Zoning Department will likely recommend the following conditions to the BOA if
the use is approved:
1. A Portage County Zoning Permit must be obtained.
2. This approval is good for 20 years upon issuance of the Portage County Zoning Permit.
3. Approval is for the current ~ 25-acre quarry site with a maximum quarry depth of 1035 msl.
4. The Owner shall, at its expense, conduct a traffic study of Sunset Drive during the summer of
2027 and provide the results to the Town of Dewey and the Portage County Planning and
Zoning Department. The owner shall offer to enter into a road maintenance agreement with
the Town based on the findings of the study.
5. A copy of the DNR stormwater plan and clean water discharge permit shall be supplied to the
Planning and Zoning Department prior to the issuance of the Zoning Permit.
6. The Owner shall revise the reclamation plan to include a gradually sloped (at least 3:1) egress
from the final water elevation to a depth of 6 feet. The revision shall be incorporated into the
next applicable Chapter 30 permitting action or implemented as part of reclamation, which
ever occurs first.
7. Remaining land outside the established ~25-acre quarry must remain in natural woody
vegetation. Management of this woody vegetation should follow best forest management
practices approved by a State Forester. The completed 15-foot-tall berm along the western
side of the quarry must remain. A new 15-foot-tall berm shall be constructed and seeded with
native grass, on the north side of the quarry. This new berm must be at least 75’ from any
navigable streams located on the north side of the property. Treese shall be planted on the
north along the north side of the berm. Additional trees shall be planted along sunset drive to
provide screening for the quarry.
8. Machinery used onsite, especially crushing and hydraulic rock hammer equipment, is to be
kept at the bottom of the pit whenever possible for noise reduction.
Page 7 of 45
9. Access roads are to be watered as needed to keep dust to a minimum.
10. The established containment area to service vehicles and equipment must be maintained to
prevent groundwater contamination. All petroleum products stored on site shall be kept inside
of a concrete containment that is large enough to contain 150% of the maximum volume of
product stored or contained in an approved D.O.T fuel trailer.
11. The blaster must be Wisconsin certified and license on file with the Planning and Zoning
Department. Planning and Zoning Department staff, Sheriff’s Department, and Town
Chairperson, and any landowners within a one-mile radius of the quarry who request
notification, must be notified at least 24 hours prior to a blast. A list of landowners requesting
notification shall be on file with the Town. Landowners may request to be removed from the
list at any time. In January of each year the quarry owner shall contact the Town requesting
information on any new homes built within the on-mile radius of the quarry. The quarry owner
shall contact the new homeowners and obtain verification as to whether they do or do not want
to be on the notification list and provide that information to the town. By February 1st of each
year the Town shall provide the quarry owner with an updated notification list.
12. Crushing, grinding, splitting, pulverizing or any other mining activity that reduces that size of
material my take place year-round.
13. The only quarry activity allowed on Saturday will be truck loading from 6:30 a.m. to 12:00
p.m. NO quarry operations will be allowed on Sunday.
14. Clean fill and asphalt can be brought into the site to be recycled. Quarry operator will be
allowed to bring crushed granite into the site to be sold.
15. Hours of operation shall be between 6:30 a.m. and 6:30 p.m., Monday through Friday, for
mining activities. Maintenance and repairs of equipment may take place between 5:30 a.m.
and 7:30 p.m., Monday through Friday. Extended hours can be approved by the Town
Chairperson for specific projects that may have time constraints. Such request needs to be
made at least 1 week prior to the start date that extended hours are being requested for, except
for cases of emergencies. The Town Chairperson will provide documentation of the extended
hours of operation, the reason for the extension, and the duration of the project to the Portage
County Planning and Zoning Department.
16. The gate must be closed and locked before and after hours of operation. The quarry operator
shall notify the Town Chairperson and Portage County Planning and Zoning Department when
the gate is out of order and provide an expected timeframe for it to again be operational. The
quarry operator shall provide notice when the gate is operational. The manual gate shall be
used if electronic gate is not operational.
If you have any questions regarding this memo, please contact me at 715-346-1334 or
mrduttc@co.portage.wi.gov.
Chris Mrdutt
Zoning Coordinator
Portage County Planning and Zoning Department
Page 8 of 45
Page 9 of 45
Page 10 of 45
Page 11 of 45
Page 12 of 45
Page 13 of 45
Page 14 of 45
Page 15 of 45
Page 16 of 45
Page 17 of 45
Page 18 of 45
Page 19 of 45
Page 20 of 45
Page 21 of 45
Page 22 of 45
Page 23 of 45
Page 24 of 45
Page 25 of 45
Page 26 of 45
Page 27 of 45
Page 28 of 45
Page 29 of 45
Page 30 of 45
£¤
10
§¨¦
39
Ridge Road
Dubay Drive
S
c
e
n
i c
D
r
i
v
e
Blue Jay Lane
Quartz Lane
Cliff's Lane
Bittersweet Lane
P i n e w o o d D r i v e
U
n
i t e
d
S
t a
t e
s
H i g h w a y 1 0 w e s t b o u n d
Dewey Drive
F o r e s t
L
a
n
e
Dam Road
Hollow Lane
P
a
r
k
R
o
a
d
Private
Maple Drive
Westwoods Lane
R
i
v
e
r
R
o
a
d
L i l a c D r i v e
C
a
m
p
s
i t
e
D
r
i
v
e
U n i t e d S t a t e s H i g h w a y 1 0 e
a
s t b
o
u
n
d
Rocky Ridge Drive
B l a c k b i r d L a n e
Maple Drive West
Oakwood Drive West
Oakwood Drive
Miller Lane
Peterson Road
Mayflower Road
Maple Road
Sunset Drive
")
E
")
H
")
X
")
DB
0 0.5 1
Miles
´
Prepared by Portage County Planning and Zoning: November 03, 2026 RPS
This map shows the approximate relative location of property boundaries but was
not prepared by a professional land surveyor. This map is provided for
informational purposes only and may not be sufficient or appropriate for legal,
engineering, or surveying purposes.
Town Proposed Haul Route for Sunset Drive Quarry
Page 31 of 45
Page 32 of 45
Page 33 of 45
698983
07/01/2026
Page 34 of 45
Page 35 of 45
Page 36 of 45
Page 37 of 45
Page 38 of 45
Page 39 of 45
Page 40 of 45
Page 41 of 45
Page 42 of 45
PORTAGE COUNTY
MEETING MINUTES
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
PORTAGE COUNTY ANNEX
PLANNING & ZONING DEPARTMENT
1462 STRONGS AVENUE
STEVENS POINT, WI 54481
Monday, October 19, 2026 2:15 PM
Page 1 of 1
CALL TO ORDER
Committee Members enter Per Diem and Mileage
The Board of Adjustment meeting was called to order at 2:15PM
ROLL CALL
Members Present: Jim Garbe, Todd Knepfel, Barb Brilowski, Jason Pingel
Members Excused: Dennis Meis, Paul Cieslewicz
Staff Attending: Jenna Hake
PLEDGE TO THE FLAG
PUBLIC NOTICE
Members of the public who wish to address the Committee on specific agenda items must register their request at this time,
with such comments subject to the public comment ordinance and the reasonable control of the Committee Chair as set forth
in Robert’s Rules of Order.
None.
ON-SITE TOUR - The Committee will depart from the Portage County Annex Building, 1462 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point,
WI 54481 and then proceed on a road tour throughout the County to observe parcel(s). A quorum of the Portage County
Board of Adjustment Committee or Board of Supervisors, or any committee thereof, may be present at this meeting;
however, no action will be taken by any committee on this topic. Committee members will not discuss government business
while in the vehicle during the road tour nor afterward before adjournment. Stopping points, in which the Committee may
convene and discuss the on-site tour, are noted below.
1. PET-2026-013, Special Exception request by Richard Mitchell to build an accessory building exceeding the maximum
square footage of 3,200 sq ft in the R1- Rural and Urban Fringe Residence District per ordinance section 7.1.2(b)4.a.
Accessory buildings(s) not meeting the provision set forth in section 7.1.2(1)(b)(4)a.ii on parcel 034230917-16.01,
located at 4144 Custer Rd, in the Town of Stockton.
The Committee completed a site visit.
2. PET-2026-014, Special Exception request by Rod and Jennifer Marquette to build an accessory building exceeding the
maximum square footage of 3,200 sq ft in the R1- Rural and Urban Fringe Residence District per ordinance section
7.1.2(b)4.a. accessory building(s) not meeting the provision set forth in section 7.1.2(1)(b)(4)a.ii and to build an
accessory building exceeding the maximum height of 20ft per section 7.1.2(3)(C)1-2. Accessory building(s) not meeting
the provision set forth in section 7.1.2(1)(b)(4)d on parcel 030230727:06.06, located at 1590 Biron Drive East, in the
Town of Plover.
The Committee completed a site visit.
ADJOURNMENT
Meeting adjourned at 3:45PM
Page 43 of 45
Page 44 of 45
Page 45 of 45
Source: Portage County website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.