RecordWell Data

Committee of the Whole Agenda & Packet (PDF)

City of Plymouth · Sheboygan County · meeting of Nov 10, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Plymouth

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

CITY OF PLYMOUTH, WISCONSIN TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2026 COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING, IMMEDIATELY AFTER FINANCE & PERSONNEL COMMITTE COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ROOM 302 CITY HALL, 128 SMITH STREET AGENDA 1. Call to Order and Roll Call 2. Approve the Minutes from October 27, 2026 3. GIS Presentation 4. WPPI Renewal Discussion 5. Adjourn It is likely a quorum of members of other governmental bodies of the municipality may be in attendance at the above stated me eting to gather information. No action will be taken by any governmental body at the above stated meeting other than the governmental body specifically referred to above in this notice. Please note that, upon reasonable notice, efforts will be made to accommodate the needs of disabled individuals through appro priate aids and services. For additional information or to request this service, please contact the City of Plymouth Clerk’s Office, located at Plymouth City Hall at 128 Smith St., Plymouth, WI or call (920) 893-1271. CITY OF PLYMOUTH, WISCONSIN TUESDAY. OCTOBER 13, 2026 COMMITTEE OF THE WHOLE MEETING, COUNCIL CHAMBERS, ROOM 302 CITY HALL, 128 SMITH STREET UNOFFICIAL MINUTES 1. Call to Order and Roll Call: Mayor Pohlman called the meeting to order. On the call of the roll, the following were present: Dave Herrman, Mike Penkwitz, Jeff Tauscheck, John Binder, Kevin Sande, Angie Matzdorf, Diane Gilson, and Dana Haucke. Staff present: City Administrator/Utilities Manager Tim Blakeslee, Police Chief Ken Ruggles, and City Clerk/Deputy Treasurer Anna Voigt. 2. Approve the Minutes from September 15, 2026: Motion was made by Tauscheck/Herrmann to approve the minutes from September 15. A unanimous aye vote was cast. Motion carried. 3. Discussion regarding property appraisal when selling property – Alderperson Sande: Alderperson Sande explained that he thinks it’s important to understand that real estate property has value and many times it may have improvements like water, gas, or sewer. He explained that the City should be careful when buying a piece of property for $30,000 and putting a street in front of it, power to it, gas to it and a sewer lateral to it the City shouldn’t sell it for the same price it was purchased at. He explained he didn’t find any City the size of Plymouth didn’t have an ordinance regarding how they sell property. He asked about the Plymouth Industrial Development Corporation. Mayor Pohlman explained the Plymouth Industrial Development Corp is a separate entity from the City and does hold land adjacent around the City. The city works closely with the PIDC. Pohlman gave an example of a property that sat vacant for 20-30 years that took a large investment of a manufacturer in order to afford the infrastructure and offset the tax in a TID. In the past the Council has relied on the Administrator and Financial Advisor to give the best alternatives. Pohlman explained that you also have to look at the long-term tax impact of what’s going on that property from a corn field to a manufacturing facility. Pohlman agreed there are other City’s with ordinances for selling property, but other cities also don’t have a PIDC that work with them. He explained that ordinance sometimes locks you into a situation. Tauscheck agreed to look into an ordinance, but doesn’t want the Council to handicap themselves so strict that you may lose some sales. Gilson asked if the City actually sells properties for less than what they are purchased at? Blakeslee stated no not since he has been there. Pohlman stated he can only think of one and it was part of a negotiation. Pohlman stated that he has read an ordinance from another municipality that you get an appraisal and that’s the price you get and it could be more or less than what you paid. Herrmann asked how many properties the city owns that aren’t PIDC? Blakeslee stated it’s a handful. Herrmann asked if it would only be for the handful of cities owned properties. Pohlman added also future city owned properties as well. Herrmann stated he would be interested in looking at an ordinance, but added the city shouldn’t be in the business of making money on the sales but at least break even. Sande explained he is asking to do an appraisal for a fair market value based on current conditions. If a property has improvements to the land, he would like to see the developer pay for it. Pohlman added that improvements are not to the land, they’re to the middle of the roadway. The developer has to go to the middle of the roadway to their land. Gilson suggested doing a resolution or policy instead of an ordinance. Binder asked if the city’s properties were included in the city-wide reevaluation. Blakeslee stated that city properties are assessed at 0 because the are tax exempt. Pohlman explained Alder. Sande can bring something to Council for further discussion. 4. Adjourn: Motion was made by Herrmann/Tauscheck to adjourn the meeting. A unanimous aye vote was cast. Motion carried. City of Plymouth 128 Smith St. - P.O. Box 107 Plymouth, WI 53073-0107 Telephone: (920) 893-3745 Facsimile: (920) 893-0183 Web Site: plymouthgov.com DATE: November 5, 2026 TO: Committee of the Whole FROM: Tim Blakeslee, City Administrator/Utilities Manager RE: WPPI Energy Long-Term Power Supply Contract Extension Background: WPPI Energy has requested that its 51 member utilities consider an 18-year extension of their existing long-term power supply agreements, moving the expiration date from December 31, 2055, to December 31, 2073. WPPI President and CEO Mike Peters presented information regarding the proposed extension to the City on August 24, 2026. The City’s current agreement remains in effect through 2055 regardless of whether the proposed extension is approved. The City joined WPPI in 2001 and in 2015 approved an 18-year extension through 2055. WPPI is a member-owned, not-for-profit organization that provides wholesale electricity, shared utility services, and other resources to its members. WPPI’s primary objective is to provide reliable electricity at low and consistent costs while maintaining manageable fluctuations in wholesale power prices. Through its joint purchasing model, WPPI has developed a diversified portfolio of generation resources, including natural gas, coal, nuclear, wind, and solar. According to information provided by WPPI, its average wholesale power cost to members was $76.92 per megawatt-hour in 2012 compared to $78.72 in 2025 ($56.11 adjusted for inflation). While costs have fluctuated during that period, WPPI has maintained relatively consistent wholesale pricing. WPPI has also provided information demonstrating that its members’ average retail electric rates remain competitive and typically lower than other regional and investor owned utilities. Proposed Extension: WPPI’s primary justification for requesting the extension now is the need to make long-term investments in generation and transmission infrastructure. Many of these projects require financing arrangements extending 30 years or more. With fewer than 30 years remaining on existing member agreements, WPPI believes extending the contracts will allow it to secure more favorable financing and power supply arrangements. WPPI has specifically identified several upcoming opportunities, including new natural gas peaking generation, energy prepayment transactions, transmission investments through American Transmission Company (ATC), and the Grid Forward and Project WISE transmission projects. WPPI has indicated that these investments are intended to maintain reliable service, reduce long-term costs, and preserve the shared wholesale rate structure for its members. The proposed extension would also preserve the existing member equity structure and continued access to shared services, including customer information systems, outage management technology, financial modeling, joint purchasing, and other utility support functions. Financial Considerations: The City of Plymouth currently purchases approximately $20 million in wholesale electricity annually from WPPI. Using this amount as a baseline, the proposed 18- year extension would represent approximately $360 million in additional power purchases over the period from 2056 through 2073, assuming today’s annual costs remain unchanged. While this is not a true projection of actual future expenditures, it illustrates the size of the decision under consideration. Our financial advisors have noted, that it is essentially impossible to accurately predict electricity prices this far into the future. Changes in technology, energy markets, environmental regulations, generation resources, customer demand, and other factors will undoubtedly influence future costs. For that reason, no provider can reasonably guarantee that its pricing will be the lowest several decades from now. The decision is therefore less about identifying which provider can offer the lowest electricity price in 2056 and more about determining if the long-term arrangement provides a balance of cost, reliability, price stability, and flexibility for Plymouth Utilities customers. WPPI’s historical performance is an important consideration, particularly its ability to maintain relatively stable and competitive pricing. Other Member Communities: Other WPPI member communities have considered similar questions as part of their review processes. Currently 40 of the 51 members have extended their contract. WPPI has established a target date of December 31, 2026, for member approvals, with a final deadline of February 26, 2027. Options for Consideration: The Committee of the Whole should consider the following options and provide direction to staff: 1. Recommend Approval of the Contract Extension: Recommend that the Common Council authorize the proposed 18-year extension through 2073 based on WPPI’s historical performance, competitive power costs, and anticipated benefits of long-term planning and financing. 2. Request Additional Information from WPPI: Request that staff obtain additional information requested by the Committee. 3. Evaluate Alternative Wholesale Power Providers: Request that staff explore or engage an independent consultant to review other wholesale power suppliers. 4. Decline or Defer the Extension: Recommend continuing under the existing agreement through 2055 without committing to the additional 18 years at this time. WPPI has indicated that members declining the extension would have no contractual right to WPPI power or services beyond 2055, and future opportunities to extend membership are not guaranteed. Staff Recommendation: WPPI has been a valuable partner to Plymouth Utilities and has demonstrated an ability to provide reliable power at competitive and relatively stable costs. Staff is requesting direction from the Committee of the Whole regarding whether to proceed with the proposed extension, obtain additional information from WPPI, evaluate potential alternatives, or pursue another course of action before making a final decision. Attachments: • WPPI Energy At a Glance • WPPI Contract Extension - Information for Local Officials • WPPI Member Contract Extension Presentation (August 24, 2026)

Source: City of Plymouth website. First collected Nov 7, 2026.