Library Board Meeting — Other
City of Lake Geneva · Walworth County · Library Board · meeting of Nov 19, 2026 · Other
Open the original document More from City of Lake Geneva
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
TE22: Freedom of Expression and Inquiry 85
TE22: Freedom of Expression and
Inquiry
Free access to ideas and freedom of expression are bedrock principles of this country.
These principles must be upheld for democracy to survive and thrive. Public libraries are
institutions dedicated to the ideal of freedom of expression and inquiry. The public library
is the provider of access for all citizens to the full range of ideas, including controversial or
unpopular ideas.
If we all knew for sure what the right answers were for important questions, there would
be no controversies and no need to foster freedoms of inquiry and expression. But,
because we cannot know for sure, our survival and progress as a culture and as a species
require that we actively promote wide-ranging inquiry and the freest possible expression
of ideas so that we may correct errors and continue to progress toward better answers.
This requires that your library, within the limits imposed by budget, time, and space, seeks
to represent the widest range of materials and to provide unrestricted access to electronic
resources—so that inquiry is encouraged and creativity stimulated.
In Wisconsin, as in most states, citizen boards govern public libraries. Citizen governance
partially isolates the operation of the library from political pressure— an important
concern especially in the development of your library’s collection and policies. Citizen
control is designed to help your library support the ideals of freedom of expression and
inquiry—free from partisan and political pressure.
The federal and state Constitutions support the ideals of freedom of expression and
inquiry, as do the Wisconsin statutes. The very beginning of Chapter 43 (Wisconsin’s
library law) says: “The legislature recognizes: (a) The importance of free access to
knowledge, information and diversity of ideas by all residents of this state; (b) The critical
role played by public, school, special and academic libraries in providing that access; (c) The
major educational, cultural and economic asset that is represented in the collective
knowledge and information resources of the state’s libraries; (d) The importance of public
libraries to the democratic process.”
Collection Development Policy
Every public library should have a collection development policy that supports the ideals
of freedom of expression and inquiry. A sound collection development policy assures the
continuous growth of a collection appropriate to your library’s defined mission and goals,
while recognizing the cultural diversity and pluralistic nature of your community. It is
recommended that, at a minimum, the policy cover the following points:
TE22: Freedom of Expression and Inquiry 86
• purpose and scope of collection (separately defined for the adult and children’s
sections)
• types of materials to be purchased
• staff responsibility for selection; use of professional selection tools
• basis and method of withdrawing and disposing of materials
• acceptance of gift materials (usually with the understanding that the same selection
standards will be applied to gift materials as to those purchased and that staff will
have discretion in judging what gift materials will actually be added to the collection)
• affirmations of intellectual freedom, such as an endorsement of the American
Library Association (ALA) Library Bill of Rights and the Freedom to Read Statement
issued jointly by ALA and Association of American Publishers.
See Trustee Essential 10: Developing Essential Library Policies for guidelines on the
process to follow when developing library policies. The collection development policy
should include a procedure to follow if materials in the library collection are challenged.
(See Trustee Essential 23: Dealing with Challenges to Library Materials and Policies.)
Internet Access Policy
The Internet brings a wealth of information to even the smallest library. It is recommended
that every library develop an Internet “acceptable use policy.” The following questions may
help your library in developing an “acceptable use policy.”
• Can children use the Internet independently, or do they need parental supervision
or permission?
• Will the library adopt a code of conduct that must be signed by a parent and child
before the child accesses the Internet?
• Will the library adopt a clear Internet use policy?
• Will users have to sign up to use Internet terminals?
• Will there be time limits on the use of Internet terminals?
• How does the library staff handle being a “go to” place to help troubleshoot devices?
• Will the results of users’ research be visible to other users or will the library install
privacy screens or other means to restrict public viewing?
• What does the library do when a user is discovered using an Internet terminal for
illegal or improper purposes?
• How does the library handle user and staff complaints about others gaining access
to illegal or objectionable sites?
• How will the library handle false accusations about illegal or improper use?
TE22: Freedom of Expression and Inquiry 87
• How will the library handle access to functions such as social media sites, peer-to-
peer file sharing sites and email?
• How do the library and its governing board transmit concerns about Internet access
to its funding authority?
• How will the library seek legal review of its Internet policy, both from its own legal
counsel and from other legal experts?
Internet Filtering
Library boards should be aware that certain Internet filtering polices have been found by
federal courts to violate First Amendment guarantees. On the other hand, Congress
passed the Children’s Internet Protection Act (or CIPA) requiring library filtering in order
to qualify for certain uses of federal aid (such as E-rate funding). That law has been
challenged on First Amendment grounds. Libraries need to stay informed as cases are
decided and as possible new legislation develops. See below for resources to help you stay
informed about these issues.
Meeting Room, Exhibit, and Display Policies
Public library meeting room and display policies should also support the ideals of freedom
of expression and inquiry. In fact, federal courts have ruled that certain public library
meeting room and display policies are contrary to the First Amendment.
In an April 2000 case, a federal court ruled that a Wisconsin library violated an individual’s
First Amendment rights when it refused him permission to use the public library’s meeting
room for a program about creationism. The library’s policy prohibited use of the meeting
room for religious services, religious instruction, and partisan political meetings.
The Federal District judge ruled that the library’s policies and practices permitting the use
of the meeting room for various groups had created a “designated public forum.” In a
designated public forum, content-based restrictions on speech are permissible only if they
are the least restrictive means to a compelling government interest. The judge ruled that
the city failed to show a compelling government interest in excluding the plaintiff from use
of the meeting room.
“It may be that the exclusion of partisan political meetings and religious services or
instruction is based on the library’s desire to avoid controversy,” the judge said. “However,
the avoidance of controversy is not a valid ground for restricting speech in a public forum.”
Reasonable regulations on time, place, and manner of speech are permissible in a
designated public forum. For example, the judge implied that the library’s prohibition on
the use of the meeting room for regular meetings of clubs and other organizations was
probably a constitutional regulation because it was intended to make the room available to
a wide variety of organizations. The judge also suggested that the policy excluding use of
TE22: Freedom of Expression and Inquiry 88
the meeting room for “commercial sales or presentations promoting specific companies or
products” was also constitutionally acceptable.
Library exhibit and display policies must conform to the same basic constitutional
principles that apply to meeting room policies. Libraries may wish to review their meeting
room, exhibit, and display policies for conformance with constitutional requirements.
Staff Development and Public Information
One of the keys to staff and community support for the principles of intellectual freedom is
continuing education and public information on this topic. The better informed all parties
are regarding the importance of freedom of expression and inquiry, and related library
policies and practices, the less likely it is that your library will be required to defend the
library’s collection or policies.
Discussion Questions
1. How does your library support the democratic ideal of a well-informed citizenry?
2. Does citizen (library board) control of the library help your library support the
ideals of freedom of expression and inquiry? How else does citizen board control
benefit your library?
3. Can the use of library Internet filters be consistent with the ideals of freedom of
expression and inquiry, and the First Amendment? Why or why not?
Sources of Additional Information
• Intellectual Freedom Manual, latest edition, published by the Office for Intellectual
Freedom, American Library Association
• Wisconsin Public Library Policy Resources on WISELearn
• Your library system staff
• Wisconsin DPI Bureau of Libraries staff
TE23: Dealing with Challenges to Materials and Policies 89
TE23: Dealing with Challenges to
Materials and Policies
One of the most difficult tasks you may face as a public library trustee is that of dealing
with an objection to materials in the library’s collection, or an objection to library policies.5
This is why it is essential for every library to have a written policy in place that specifies
how complaints will be handled, including a procedure to be used by concerned citizens.
The Challenge Policy
The policy should be written so that it calls for at least the initial steps of the process to be
handled by staff; and in many, if not most, instances the issue can be resolved at that level.
However, there may be times when the library board becomes involved more directly.
Again, what is most important is for the board to have a policy and a corresponding
procedure for dealing with either circumstance.
Regardless of the level of board involvement, it is important for you as a trustee to be
committed to the principles of freedom of expression and inquiry that are fundamental to
the role of public libraries. The entire community benefits collectively when democratic
institutions uphold the right of access to information. Public libraries are for everyone and
for every inquiry, and as such must include materials with varying points of view and a
wide range of subjects. However, throughout history there have always been those who
seek to limit what others may read, see, or listen to, and when this occurs in a public library
setting it must be addressed thoughtfully and carefully by those ultimately responsible for
all library operations, i.e., the library board.
When you became a library trustee, you may already have had considerable knowledge
about intellectual freedom and censorship. However, many trustees need to learn more
about these issues so that if an objection is raised they will be prepared. There are many
resources; one of the most complete is the Intellectual Freedom Manual published by the
Office for Intellectual Freedom of the American Library Association. The manual is
updated frequently, and your library should have a copy of the latest edition. Other
resources are listed at the end of this Trustee Essential. (See also Trustee Essential 22:
Freedom of Expression and Inquiry.)
The Trustee Role in Dealing with Challenges
So what is your role when a complaint against a specific book, music CD, DVD, or policy is
made? In many communities (especially smaller ones) you may receive the complaint
5 While this Trustee Essential focuses primarily on complaints or challenges to materials, a similar
procedure can be used for objections to library policies such as those governing use of meeting
rooms, the Internet, etc.
TE23: Dealing with Challenges to Materials and Policies 90
personally through a phone call or a face-to-face conversation rather than as an item of
business at the next board meeting. If this happens, you will be better able to respond
appropriately if there is a policy and procedure already in place.
An important first step is to communicate with the library director about the complaint,
since you and your fellow trustees have, no doubt, delegated to the director the
responsibility for selecting materials. This means that you should not express your own
personal views to an individual citizen, but should instead refer the complaint to the
director promptly. Inform the citizen that there is a policy for handling objections, and
explain that you are not individually responsible for deciding what will be done. Make sure
the objector understands there is a process, and that he/she has the right to use that
process. See the attached Sample Complaint/Concern Form, which includes a sample
policy for dealing with complaints.
In other instances, the complaint may be made directly to the library director, either orally
or in writing. In both cases, the objection may become a formal challenge if it cannot be
resolved through informal dialog. You and your fellow trustees should be informed by the
director that a challenge has been received and kept informed of the steps in its resolution.
Or the trustees may receive a challenge as a formal item of business, and the process will
start from that point.
If a formal challenge has been received, it may become known to the general public,
sometimes generating debate in the media and among other public officials. This can
create great stress for library trustees, for you may be contacted for your opinion by
members of the public or by the media, or even by members of the municipal board which
confirmed your appointment. Again, it is your responsibility not to engage in public debate
as an individual. Your library’s policy for dealing with challenges should specify that all
deliberations involving trustees will be made at open board meetings; it should also specify
that there is an official spokesperson (often the library director, sometimes the board
president) through whom all information will be given out, especially to the media.
Public Hearings
Most challenges are resolved before they become issues of public debate. Depending on
your challenge policy, occasionally the library board may decide to hold a public hearing at
which testimony is taken. This process must be carefully and thoroughly crafted to allow
both sides of the issue to be heard, and to prevent (as much as possible) undue
sensationalism. (The Intellectual Freedom Manual has an excellent section on planning a
public hearing.) While the steps of this process need not be spelled out in your library’s
policy, there should be a statement that refers to the process.
If a hearing is held, it is important for trustees to listen as carefully as possible and not to
participate in the debate. They should also defer any decision on the challenge until a later
meeting. This meeting should be scheduled fairly soon after the hearing but allow enough
TE23: Dealing with Challenges to Materials and Policies 91
time for trustees to consider the issues that have been raised in a less emotional
atmosphere.
Regardless of how the challenge ultimately arrives before the trustees, it is probable that
you will eventually make your views known through a vote that will decide the outcome.
This is the time to make a public statement giving the reasons for your vote. Such a
statement is not obligatory, but it gives trustees a forum to reiterate the principles of
intellectual freedom, and why you do (or do not) support them in this instance. Once the
board has decided the outcome, there is usually no further recourse for action by the
challenger except a court case.
A formal challenge can be an opportunity for growth for all parties: the challenger, the
library director and staff, and perhaps most of all for trustees. Having a policy in place that
describes the process to be followed and the responsibilities of the various participants in
a challenge will make it much easier for you and your fellow board members to deal with
attempts at censorship.
Discussion Questions
1. Why is it important for a library to have a policy for dealing with challenges to
library materials and policies?
2. Does your library have an adequate policy and procedure for handling challenges?
Are there any ways your policy and procedure could be improved?
Sources of Additional Information
• Appendix H: Sample Request for Reconsideration Form
• Intellectual Freedom Manual, latest edition, published by the Office for Intellectual
Freedom, American Library Association
• Your library system staff
• Children’s Cooperative Book Center Intellectual Freedom Services, University of
Wisconsin-Madison (for challenged children’s materials)
• Wisconsin DPI Bureau of Libraries staff
Comparison: DPI Sample Request for Reconsideration Form (Appendix H)
and Lake Geneva Public Library Statement of Concern About Library
Materials
DPI sample (Appendix H)
Lake Geneva Public Library
Who may file
Anyone; no eligibility requirement
Requester must hold an active LGPL card in good
standing
Reading requirement
None stated
For books and magazines, the entire work must be
read; the form asks for every item whether it was
read or viewed in full
Completeness
Open-ended; asks the requester to share as
much as possible
All fields required; incomplete, cursory, or
copy-and-paste responses will not be considered
Filing limits
None stated
One item per form; one pending form per household
at a time
What can be
challenged
Books, audio, video, websites, library policies,
other
Books, magazines, newspapers, audio-visual
resources, programs, art exhibits, displays, other
Detail requested
A single question about the concern
Specific page numbers or locations and quoted
passages, suggested alternative resources, and, if
removal is requested, why it should outweigh other
patrons’ freedom to read
Requester
information
Name, address, signature, date
Name, address, phone, email, date, contact
preference, and whether the requester represents
an organization
Process described
on the form
Yes. The sample board policy has the director
review the item and respond in writing within a
set number of days, with appeal to the board, a
review committee, and an optional public hearing.
A footnote cites the U.S. Supreme Court’s limit
on removing materials because officials dislike
the ideas in them
Directs submission to the Library Director and
mentions action by the Library or Library Board; the
review process itself is not described on the form
Summary: Both forms collect the basic information needed to identify the item and the concern. DPI’s sample
is intentionally minimal and pairs the form with a written review-and-appeal policy. Lake Geneva’s form is more
detailed and sets threshold requirements before a concern will be considered: cardholder status, a full reading,
complete answers, and limits on volume. It also asks the requester to explain why removal should take
precedence over other patrons’ access.
Appendix H: Sample Request for Reconsideration Form 139
Appendix H: Sample Request for
Reconsideration Form
Your complaint or concern is about (please check):
Book
Audio item
Video item
Internet website
Library policy
Other, please explain:
Please indicate (if relevant):
Title: ___________________________________________________________________________
Author/Producer/URL: ________________________________________________________
What is your concern about this material, resource, or policy? (Please tell us all you can to
help us understand your concerns.)
Please print your name and address:
_____________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________
Signature: _____________________________________________________ Date: ________________
[On the back of the form, include the board-approved policy for dealing with written
complaints about materials. See the next page for an example.]
Appendix H: Sample Request for Reconsideration Form 140
Sample Board Policy for Handling Requests for Reconsideration
The library director (or staff responsible for selecting materials in this area) will:
• Examine the material, reviews, and other information about this title or similar titles.
• Decide whether the item should be kept, moved to another section of the library, or
withdrawn.*
• Write the person who filed the complaint with a decision and explanation within
_____ days of receiving the complaint.
If the person who filed the complaint is not satisfied with the decision, he/she can appeal to
the library board. Upon receiving an appeal, the board will:
• Set up a committee with board members, library staff, and/or community members
to examine the material.
• Consider the committee’s recommendation to the board.
• Hold a public hearing if deemed desirable by the board.
• Make a final decision on the material.6
6 The U.S. Supreme Court has ruled that officials may not legally remove materials from a library
collection “simply because they dislike the ideas contained in those books and seek by their removal
to prescribe what shall be orthodox in politics, nationalis m, religion or other matters of opinion.”
Lake Geneva Public Library
Statement of Concern About Library Materials
Requirements: The requester must hold an active, valid LGPL card in good standing. For
books or magazines, the entire work must be read and reviewed by the requester, and all
fields must be completed; incomplete, cursory, or copy-and-paste responses will not be
considered. Submit a separate form for each item (items may not be combined). Only one form
per household may be pending at a time; additional statements may be submitted one at a
time after the Library or Library Board acts on the pending statement. Submit the completed
form directly to the Library Director.
Requester Information
Date:
Name:
Address:
Phone:
Email:
I wish to be contacted regarding my expressed concern:
Yes
No
Who do you represent?
Self
Organization
If an organization, name:
Resource Information
Resource type (select one):
Book
Magazine
Newspaper
Audio-visual resource
Library program
Art exhibit
Lake Geneva Public Library | 918 W Main Street, Lake Geneva, WI 53147 | (262) 249-5299 | lglibrary.org
Page 1
Display
Other
If other, describe:
Title:
Author / Publisher / Artist:
Barcode / Call #:
Your Concern
What brought this resource to your attention?
Have you read/viewed this resource in its entirety?
Yes
No
What are your concerns about this material?
Please cite the page numbers or location and quote specific passages that demonstrate
your concerns:
Are there other resources you suggest to provide additional attention to this topic?
Lake Geneva Public Library | 918 W Main Street, Lake Geneva, WI 53147 | (262) 249-5299 | lglibrary.org
Page 2
If you are requesting removal, why should this resource not be available to other
patrons who may wish to read/view it, and why does this request supersede their
freedom to read?
Lake Geneva Public Library | 918 W Main Street, Lake Geneva, WI 53147 | (262) 249-5299 | lglibrary.org
Page 3
Source: City of Lake Geneva website. First collected Nov 11, 2026.