RecordWell Data

Board of Adjustment - Regular Meeting — Agenda Packet

Chippewa County · Chippewa County · Board of Adjustment · meeting of Nov 18, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Chippewa County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Chippewa County Board of Adjustment Regular Meeting November 18, 2026 Chippewa County Courthouse, Room 302 1:00 PM Citizen Rep, Chair Jeff Bennesch Citizen Rep, Vice-Chair Roger McFarlane Citizen Rep Doug Matthews Citizen Rep Edmond Miniatt (Alternate) Citizen Rep Carolyn Kaiser Citizen Rep Douglas Olson Citizen Rep Vacant (Alternate) Page 1 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment Regular Meeting November 18, 2026 Chippewa County Courthouse, Room 302 1:00 PM 1. Call to Order 2. Roll Call 3. Members of the Public Wishing to Be Heard (Comments will be limited to 5 minutes per speaker.) 4. Consent Agenda (Unless separation of an item is requested, all items will be adopted under one motion.) 1. Approve the Agenda 2. Approve the Minutes: September 16, 2026 3. Schedule Next Meeting Date - December 16, 2026 (if needed) 5. Public Hearings - for Discussion and Action 1. Variance Request: 2026-0004 Kenneth Helland and Donna Hartman 6. Business Items 1. Review of Board of Adjustment Rules and By-laws 7. Agenda Items for Future Consideration 8. Adjourn Chippewa County shall attempt to provide reasonable special accommodations to the public for access to its public meetings, provided reasonable notice of special need is given. If special accommodations for a meeting are desired, contact the County Clerk’s Office at 715-726- 7980. Members of the Chippewa County Board of Supervisors who are not members of this committee are entitled to attend this meeting. It is possible that the attendance of one or more such nonmember Supervisors may create a quorum of some other county board committee, board or commission. Such a quorum is unintended and the nonmember Supervisors are not meeting for the purpose of exercising the responsibility, authority, power, or duties of any other committee, board or commission. Published:November 11, 2026 Page 2 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment Regular Meeting September 16, 2026 Chippewa County Courthouse, Room 016 12:00 PM 1. Call to Order Meeting Called to Order at 12:01pm. 2. Roll Call 3. Approve the Agenda 4. Site Inspection Board of Adjustment traveled to 5553 176th Street to view the site. 1. The Board of Adjustment will complete an onsite inspection for Administrative Appeal Request 2026- 0003 (Timothy Mazaur) located at 5553 176th Street. 5. Adjourn Motion to Adjourn. Motion: Approved Result: Passed (4 - 0) Mover: Jeff Bennesch Seconder: Roger McFarlane Ayes: Jeff Bennesch, Roger McFarlane, Doug Matthews, Carolyn Kaiser Nayes: None Absent: Douglas Olson, Edmond Miniatt Page 3 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment Regular Meeting September 16, 2026 Chippewa County Courthouse, Room 302 1:15 PM 1. Call to Order 2. Roll Call 3. Members of the Public Wishing to Be Heard (Comments will be limited to 5 minutes per speaker.) None 4. Consent Agenda (Unless separation of an item is requested, all items will be adopted under one motion.) Motion to Approve Motion: Approved Result: Passed (4 - 0) Mover: Roger McFarlane Seconder: None Ayes: Jeff Bennesch, Roger McFarlane, Doug Matthews, Carolyn Kaiser Nayes: None Absent: Douglas Olson, Edmond Miniatt 1. Approve the Agenda 2. Approve the Minutes: August 19, 2026 Site Inspections & Regular Meeting 3. Schedule Next Meeting Date - October 21, 2026 5. Public Hearings - for Discussion and Action 1. Administrative Appeal: 2026-0003 Thomas Mazur - Town of Lafayette General Discussion on the Administrative Appeal. A digital recording of the meeting is on file with the Department of Planning & Zoning. Motion to agree with the Administrator that the swingset would fall within the structure definition of the shoreland ordinance. Motion: Approved Result: (4 - 0) Mover: Roger McFarlane Seconder: None Ayes: Jeff Bennesch, Roger McFarlane, Doug Matthews, Carolyn Kaiser Nayes: None Absent: Douglas Olson, Edmond Miniatt 6. Reports Page 4 of 41 1. Review of Board of Adjustment Rules and By-Laws Clary asked the BOA to review the BOA Rules and By-Laws to see if modifications should be made. Furhter discussion will occur at the next meeting. 7. Agenda Items for Future Consideration 8. Adjourn Page 5 of 41 (Posted on November 3, 2026) Chippewa County Website & County Clerk’s Bulle�n Board CHIPPEWA COUNTY BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARING STATE OF WISCONSIN PUBLIC NOTICE is hereby given to all persons in the County of Chippewa, Wisconsin, that a public hearing will be held on November 18, 2026 beginning at 1:00 pm in Room 016 of the Chippewa County Courthouse, Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin, rela�ve to the following request: Administra�ve Appeal: #2026-0004 Appellant: Kenneth Helland To allow an a�er-the-fact deck not mee�ng the road right of way setback in accordance with sec�on 70-109 of the Chippewa County Zoning Ordinance. This request is for Lot 1, Cer�fied Survey Map 6364 (Parcel number (23007- 3041-76364001), which is located in the NE ¼ of the SE ¼, Sec�on 30, Township 30 North, Range 07 West. Town of Anson. Physical Address: 19834 County Hwy S. All persons interested are invited to atend. Specific informa�on regarding this hearing can be obtained at the Chippewa County Department of Planning & Zoning. Dated this 2nd day of Novem ber, 2026 Douglas Clary, Director Department of Planning & Zoning Chippewa County Page 6 of 41 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & ZONING  711 North Bridge Street, Chippewa Falls, WI 54729  Phone:715.726.7940  www.chippewacountywi.gov  Land Management Land Planning Land Records & G.I.S. POWTS & Wells CHIPPEWA COUNTY Date: November 2, 2026 To: Property Owner(s) From: Kirsten Lee, Zoning Inspector Re: Public Meeting & Public Hearing Dear Property Owner(s): The Chippewa County Department of Planning & Zoning has received a request for a variance and your property has been determined to be within the legal public hearing notification distance per county and state requirements. I have enclosed a map identifying the location of the parcel associated with this request. If you have any questions, please contact me at (715) 726- 7942. Variance Request: #2026-0004 Appellant: Kenneth Helland To allow an after-the-fact deck not meeting the road right of way setback in accordance with section 70-109 of the Chippewa County Zoning Ordinance. This request is for Lot 1, Certified Survey Map 6364 (Parcel number 23007-3041-76364001), which is located in the NE ¼ of the SE ¼, Section 30, Township 30 North, Range 07 West. Town of Anson. Physical Address: 19834 County Hwy S. Chippewa County Board of Adjustment: The Chippewa County Board of Adjustment (BOA) will hold a PUBLIC HEARING on November 18, 2026 at 1:00 PM, in Room 016, of the Chippewa County Courthouse at 711 N. Bridge Street, Chippewa Falls, Wisconsin. The BOA will make a determination to approve or deny the request. Page 7 of 41 Page 8 of 41 Page 9 of 41 Page 10 of 41 Page 11 of 41 Page 12 of 41 Page 13 of 41 Page 14 of 41 Page 15 of 41 Page 16 of 41 Page 17 of 41 DEPARTMENT OF PLANNING & ZONING  711 North Bridge Street, Chippewa Falls, WI 54729  Phone:715.726.7940  www.chippewacountywi.gov  Land Management Land Planning Land Records & G.I.S. POWTS & Wells CHIPPEWA COUNTY Date: Wednesday, November 18, 2026 T o: Jeff Bennesch, Board of Adjustment Chair F rom: Kirsten Lee, Chippewa County Zoning Inspector R e: Appeal # 2026-0004 – Helland – Variance Request 1. Appellant Name: Kenneth Helland and Donna Hartman 2. Property Location/Address: Lot 1, Certified Survey Map 6364 (Parcel number 23007-3041-76364001), which is located in the NE ¼ of the SE ¼, Section 30, Township 30 North, Range 07 West. Town of Anson. Physical Address: 19834 County Highway S, Jim Falls, WI 54748. 3. Variance Request: To allow an after-the-fact open stoop within the front yard setback, or approximately 22’ 3” from the county road right-of-way. The stoop is 4’ x 6’ with two (2) steps to the east and serves as an entrance/exit to the house, a photo of the stoop is attached. (a) CONFLICT: The open stoop was built without obtaining a zoning permit and it is within the front yard setback to the county road right-of-way. 4. Ordinance Provisions: (a) Section 70-109(a)(2)a. of the Chippewa County Zoning Ordinance states that buildings and all other s tructures shall setback from streets and highways. Class B highways or county highways require a 40- foot setback from the right-of-way line. (b) Section 70-107(e)(3) of the Zoning Ordinance states uncovered porches and steps to building en trances may extend not more than eight (8) feet into any required front yard. This section of the o rdinance would allow the open deck to be a maximum of 32 feet from the right-of-way line. I have attached a copy of these sections for your review. 5. Variance Framework: In order to determine whether a variance should be granted, the Department of Planning & Zoning utilizes the Wisconsin State Supreme Court’s decision in State v. Ziervogel, (2004). I believe that the following questions need to be addressed to verify whether or not the request qualifies for a variance. (a) Is this an area variance such as a setback, height, bulk or density? (b) Did the applicant establish by burden of proof his or her eligibility for a variance? (c) In the BOA’s opinion, is it unnecessarily burdensome for the property owner to comply with the regulations? In other words, the question is whether a variance should be granted because living without it would be unnecessarily burdensome. (d) Is there unnecessary hardship associated with this particular piece of property? Does the property owner have an existing use already established on the property? (e) Are there unique physical limitations of the property that are preventing the property owner from complying with the regulations? (f) Is this a self-created hardship? Did the property owner start the project without the proper permits? Page 18 of 41 Helland - Variance Request BOA Appeal: 2026-0004 November 18, 2026 Page 2 (g) Does the variance, if granted, result in harm to the public interest? What are the impacts of the proposal and the cumulative impacts on similar projects on the interests of the neighbors, the community and the general public? (h) What are the objectives and the purposes of the ordinance? 6. Correspondence/Communication: Property owners within 400’ of the applicant’s property were notified of the variance hearing. In addition, a public hearing notice was posted in the Chippewa County Courthouse and on the County’s website per County requirements. 7. Staff Comments: On September 1, 2026, a zoning application was submitted by property owners, Kenneth Helland and Donna Hartman, for a new detached garage. On September 8, 2026, an onsite inspection was completed by me, Kirsten Lee, Zoning inspector. During the inspection I noticed a stoop and an open deck were added to the house without permits. The deck on the back side of the house meets all the required setbacks and I was able to permit it. The 2009 Google Street View image (see photo attached) and the submitted site plan show there was a covered front entrance in the center of the house. In the 2026 Google Street View image we can see the construction of the front stoop (see photo attached). According to Mr. Helland, the construction had been completed prior to him purchasing the property. The submitted site plan identifies the new stoop being 37’ 6” from the white line in the road. However, the Chippewa County GIS map identifies the stoop being approximately 38’ 3” from the white line and the right-of-way line approximately 16’ north of the white line. Based on these measurements, the stoop is approximately 22’ 3” from the road right-of-way. Section 70-109(a)(3)a. of the Zoning Ordinance states that all buildings and structures shall meet a 30-foot setback to Class C highway right-of-way lines. This includes town roads, public streets and highways and private roads not otherwise classified. If the front property line was a town road right-of-way line, it would meet the requirements of Section 70-107(e)(3) and allow the stoop to be a minimum of 22 feet from the right-of-way line. According to the October 2024 Google Street View images, the speed limit from the intersection of County Highway S South and County Highway S to the intersection of County Highway S and 198 th Street is 25 miles per hour. This stretch is approximately 1,600 feet long. If the property owner at the time of construction would have reached out to the Planning and Zoning Department and asked if the front stoop could be moved to a different location on the front of the house, the answer would have been “no” and steps could have been taken to identify a compliant location for the new stoop. 8. Staff Recommendation: I would recommend the BOA DENY the variance request. However, if the BOA feels that a variance should be granted, I would request further discussion on possible conditions/restrictions in addition to the following: (a) The property owner shall apply for a zoning permit and submit all applicable documentation, application fee ($75), plus after-the-fact fees ($375). The total amount of fees due would be $450. (b) Restrict any type of roof addition over the front stoop. 9. BOA Decision: (a) I would ask the BOA to make a simple motion to either grant or deny the request and then after a Page 19 of 41 Helland - Variance Request BOA Appeal: 2026-0004 November 18, 2026 Page 2 second is obtained, have a discussion on the merits of the application. After the discussion in complete, I would ask that a vote be taken by all members on the motion. (b) Please note that the BOA should not simply grant or deny an application with ending statements that the application does or does not satisfy the statutory criteria. It shall express, on the record it’s reasoning why an application does or does not meet the statutory criteria. The record will be the discussion the board partakes after the motion is made. (c) Please discuss the specific “Findings of Facts” behind your decision, so that they can become part of the record and the motion. Attachments: Chippewa County Zoning Ordinance – 70-109(a), 70-107(e)(3) Photos Page 20 of 41 Chippewa County Code of Ordinances Chapter 70 – Zoning July 8, 2025 Page 63 of 109 ( 12) Any other conditions determined necessary by the Committee. ( d) Termination and revocation. The conditional use permit shall lapse and is void: (1 ) Twelve (12) months after approval by the Committee unless the use is fully established and improvement to the property described in the permit is implemented. (2 ) On the date of expiration set forth in the conditional use permit. (3 ) At such time as the conditional use for which the permit was granted shall cease or be abandoned for twelve (12) consecutive months. (4 ) If any condition of the permit is violated or if the conditional use is substantially detrimental to persons or property in the neighborhood, the Committee, following notice to all parties listed in 70-108(b)(2), shall hold a public hearing on the revocation of the conditional use permit. If, upon finding of facts, any material condition of the conditional use permit has been violated or if the character and quality of the area has been substantially and adversely affected by the continuation of the conditional use permit, the Committee may revoke or modify the conditional use. The Committee may thereafter direct counsel for the county to initiate such legal actions as are necessary to ensure compliance with this chapter. (e ) Effect of revocation. In the event of revocation or termination, the conditional use is void and the property shall be governed thereafter by the rules of the zoning district to which the p roperty is zoned at the time of the termination. ( f) Binding effect. The applicant shall acknowledge in their application and the conditional use permit shall recite that the use is conditional and binding upon the applicant, his successors, assigns and personal representatives and is a restriction that runs with the land. ( Code 1980, § 17.35) S ec. 70-109 Setbacks from Highway ( a) Lots that abut on public highways. For the purpose of determining the distance that buildings and other structures shall be setback from streets and highways, the highways of the county are divided into the following classes: (1 ) Class A highways. All state and federal highways are designated as Class A highways. a. T he setback from Class A highways shall be 50 feet from the right-of-way line. (2 ) Class B highways. All county trunks are designated as Class B highways. For the purpose of this chapter, any road shall be considered a county trunk after it has been placed on the county trunk system by the County Board and approved by the Chippewa County Highway Department. a. T he setback from Class B highways shall be 40 feet from the right-of-way line. Page 21 of 41 Chippewa County Code of Ordinances Chapter 70 – Zoning July 8, 2025 Page 64 of 109 (3) Class C highways. All town roads, public streets and highways and private roads not otherwise classified, are designated Class C highways. a. The setback from Class C highways shall be 30 feet from the right-of-way line. (b) Visual clearance triangle. In each quadrant of every public street intersection, there shall be a visual clearance triangle bounded by the street centerlines and a line connecting points on them 300 feet from a Class A highway intersection, 200 feet from a Class B highway intersection and 125 feet from a Class C highway intersection. (1) The Administrator, in conjunction with the authority having jurisdiction over the road right-of-way, may allow a vision clearance triangle on highways to be reduced to no less than 75 feet based on a reduction in the speed limit, the elevation of the existing land and the ability to control traffic at the intersections. (c) Structures prohibited within setback lines and visual clearance triangles. No new structure or part thereof shall be placed within the required setback lines, unless specifically allowed by this ordinance. (d) The following shall be structures allowed within setback lines and visual clearance triangles. (1) Open fences and at-grade structures such as sidewalks and patios as long as there is no obstruction to the view through the visual clearance triangle from items placed on such structures. (2) Telephone and power transmission poles, lines and portable equipment as long as there is no obstruction to the view through the visual clearance triangle. (3) Field crops, shrubbery and trees, except that no trees, shrubbery or crops may be planted within a visual clearance triangle so as to obstruct the view through the visual clearance triangle. (4) Access or service road construction according to plans approved by the authority having jurisdiction over the adjacent highway. (5) Signs placed by the authority having jurisdiction over the road right-of-way for the guidance or warning of traffic. (e) Access driveways. (1) Access driveways to highways from adjacent properties shall comply with the following requirements: a. Access driveways to Class A highways shall be approved and permitted by the authority having jurisdiction over said highway. b. Access driveways to Class B highways shall have a separation distance between each other of at least 75 feet, but no more than three (3) access points, including public and private streets, may be located within 600 feet of each Page 22 of 41 Chippewa County Code of Ordinances Chapter 70 – Zoning July 8, 2025 Page 58 of 109 (d) When a structure is proposed to be constructed or created across a property line, within the required setbacks, or on a contiguous lot, the 2 parcels must be resurveyed as one lot by certified survey map procedures prior to the issuance of any permits. (Code 1980, § 17.16) Sec. 70-106 Height Regulations (a) Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, the height of any building erected, converted, enlarged or structurally altered after the effective date of the ordinance from which this chapter is derived shall be in compliance with the regulations established in this chapter for the district in which such building is located. (b) The height of any of the following structures may exceed zoning code limits for the district in which it is to be located with the approval of the Committee: cooling towers, penthouses, stacks, lookout towers, water towers, spires, radio and television aerials, masts, antennae, conveyors or other equipment required for natural mineral extraction and any other necessary mechanical appurtenances. (c) Churches, schools, hospitals, sanatoriums and other public and quasi-public buildings may be erected to a height not exceeding 75 feet, provided the front, side and rear yards required in the district in which such building is to be located are each increased at least one foot for each foot of additional building height above the height limit otherwise established for the district in which such building is to be located. (d) In airport safety zones the maximum height of any object located within 125 feet of either side of the centerline of a landing strip, and extended to a distance of two miles from the end of the runway shall be no higher than 1/34 of the distance of the object to the landing strip, except for field crops and fences under four feet high. All utilities shall be placed underground when located at the end of the landing strip. The height restrictions contained in this subsection shall apply to all airports or landing strips in the county except the Eau Claire Municipal Airport, which may require more restrictive height regulations. See Wis. Stats. § 114.136(2) and (3). (e) Farm buildings and structures not for human habitation, radio and television towers, telephone and power transmission poles, microwave radio relay structures and accessory structures essential to the use or protection of a building or to a manufacturing process carried on therein are exempted from the height regulations of this section, except in the airport safety zones as set forth in subsection (d) of this section. (f) Residences may be increased in height by not more than ten feet when all yards and other required open spaces are increased by one foot for each foot by which such building exceeds the height limit of the district in which it is located. (Code 1980, § 17.17) Sec. 70-107 Front, Side and Rear Yard Regulations Page 23 of 41 Chippewa County Code of Ordinances Chapter 70 – Zoning July 8, 2025 Page 59 of 109 (a) No part of a yard or other open space provided about any building for the purpose of complying with the provisions of this chapter shall be included as part of a yard or other open space required for another building. (b) No, stock pile, waste or salvage pile, equipment storage yard or other accumulation of material or equipment in the open shall be stored or placed in a minimum side and rear yard except in the industrial district where a loading platform may be established if it abuts on a railroad. (c) Except as otherwise provided in this chapter, any side yard, rear yard or court abutting a district boundary line shall have a minimum width and depth in the less restricted district equal to the average of the required minimum widths and depths for such yards and courts in the two districts which abut the district boundary line. (d) Buildings on through lots and extending from street to street may waive the requirements for a rear yard by furnishing an equivalent open space on the same lot in lieu of the required rear yard provided that the setback requirements on both streets are complied with; and provided further that no accessory building shall extend within the setback lines on either street. (e) Every part of a required yard or court shall be open and unobstructed by a building or structure or object from its lowest point upward, except as follows: (1) Detached accessory buildings may be located in the rear yard or in the side yard of a principal building provided that an additional side yard, with dimensions equal to that otherwise required for the main building, is provided. (2) Sills, cornices, buttresses, and eaves shall not extend more than two (2) feet into a required yard. Open-work fire balconies and fire escapes, chimneys, flues and similar buildings appurtenances shall extend not more than four (4) feet into a required yard. (3) Uncovered porches and steps to building entrances may extend not more than eight (8) feet into any required front yard or rear yard and not more than three (3) feet into any required side yard or court. (4) Structures utilized for the sole purpose of farming shall be exempt from the setback requirements between other farming structures. All other required setbacks shall be met. (f) Structures in yards and courts. Walks, steps on ground slopes, retaining walls, paved terraces and paved areas shall be allowed in yards and courts, provided that the following requirements are satisfied: (1) At-grade structures including, but not limited to, sidewalks, steps or patios or individual access driveways shall be set back at least five (5) feet from all property lines. Note: Driveways through the road right-of-way shall meet the setback and separation requirements of 70-109(e). (2) Shared Access driveways shall be allowed within five (5) feet of the property line under the following regulations: Page 24 of 41 Photo taken September 8, 2026 by Kirsten Lee Page 25 of 41 Image capture: Jul 2009 © 2026 Google 11/10/26, 11:15 AM 19762 County Hwy S - Google Maps https://www.google.com/maps/@45.0495696,-91.2710651,294a,75y,2.23h,84.74t/data=!3m8!1e1!3m6!1sbgTDJBEVpANifgTyoDXEJg!2e0!5s20090701T000000!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.clie… 2/3 Page 26 of 41 Image capture: Jul 2023 © 2026 Google 11/10/26, 11:13 AM 19762 County Hwy S - Google Maps https://www.google.com/maps/@45.0495833,-91.2710857,294a,60y,0.89h,81.31t/data=!3m8!1e1!3m6!1scEeui4R48ElN0mRoy1B72w!2e0!5s20230701T000000!6shttps:%2F%2Fstreetviewpixels-pa.clie… 2/3 Page 27 of 41 Statement of Explanation Review of Board of Adjustment Rules and By-laws 1 Page 28 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 1 of 13 September, 2009 ARTICLE I. GENERAL PROVISIONS.................................................................................................. ...............................3 Sec. 1-01 Title............................................................................................................... ..........................................................3 Sec. 1-02 Authority........................................................................................................... ......................................................3 Sec. 1-03 Changes & Amendments ........................................................................................................................................3 Sec. 1-04 Office of the Board................................................................................................. ................................................3 Sec. 1-05 Definitions ..............................................................................................................................................................3 Sec. 1-06 General Powers...................................................................................................... .................................................4 Sec. 1-07 Limitations of Power ..............................................................................................................................................4 Sec. 1-08 Appeals are Specific to a Property.................................................................................. ........................................4 Sec. 1-09 Appeals are to be Determined Individually ............................................................................................................4 ARTICLE II. BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT............................................................................................... ............................5 Sec. 2-01 Members .................................................................................................................................................................5 Sec. 2-02 Appointments & Terms of Office...................................................................................... .....................................5 Sec. 2-03 Officers...................................................................................................................................................................5 Sec. 2-04 Conflicts of Interest ................................................................................................................................................6 Sec. 2-05 Ex Parte Disqualification........................................................................................... .............................................6 ARTICLE III. COUNTY DEPARTMENTS............................................................................................... ...........................6 Sec. 3-01 Planning & Zoning Department..............................................................................................................................6 Sec. 3-02 County Corporation Counsel ..................................................................................................................................6 ARTICLE IV. REGULAR MEETINGS ................................................................................................................................6 Sec. 4-01 Meetings Called..................................................................................................... .................................................6 Sec. 4-02 Quorum.............................................................................................................. .....................................................7 Sec. 4-03 Order of Business ...................................................................................................................................................7 Sec. 4-04 Continuance of Public Hearings .............................................................................................................................7 Sec. 4-05 Robert’s Rules of Order..........................................................................................................................................7 ARTICLE V. APPEAL PROCEDURES................................................................................................... ..............................8 Sec. 5-01 Limited Appeal Period............................................................................................... .............................................8 Sec. 5-02 Who May File........................................................................................................ .................................................8 Sec. 5-03 Required Forms ......................................................................................................................................................8 Sec. 5-04 Owner’s Consent ....................................................................................................................................................8 Sec. 5-05 Reasons to be Stated ...............................................................................................................................................8 Sec. 5-06 Required Fee........................................................................................................ ...................................................8 Sec. 5-07 Refusal to Hear an Appeal........................................................................................... ...........................................8 Sec. 5-08 Stays .......................................................................................................................................................................8 Sec. 5-09 Copies to Be Sent ................................................................................................... ................................................9 ARTICLE VI. PUBLIC HEARINGS .....................................................................................................................................9 Sec. 6-01 Timeframe for Hearing...........................................................................................................................................9 Sec. 6-02 Notice of Hearing ...................................................................................................................................................9 Sec. 6-03 Postponement of Hearing .......................................................................................................................................9 Sec. 6-04 Order of Public Hearings........................................................................................................................................9 Sec. 6-05 Question of Jurisdiction............................................................................................ ............................................10 Sec. 6-06 Testimony .............................................................................................................................................................10 Sec. 6-07 Parties not to Interrupt ..........................................................................................................................................10 Sec. 6-08 Questions & Debate.................................................................................................. ............................................10 Sec. 6-09 Evidence ...............................................................................................................................................................10 Sec. 6-10 Withdrawal of an Appeal............................................................................................. .........................................11 Sec. 6-11 Record of Hearing ................................................................................................................................................11 ARTICLE VII. DECISIONS OF THE BOARD........................................................................................... .......................11 Sec. 7-01 Majority Vote Required.............................................................................................. ..........................................11 Sec. 7-02 Findings of Facts ..................................................................................................................................................11 Sec. 7-03 Decisions to be Written ........................................................................................................................................11 Sec. 7-04 Decisions to be Mailed .........................................................................................................................................11 Page 29 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 2 of 13 September, 2009 Sec. 7-05 Order for Permit Valid for One (1) Year..............................................................................................................12 Sec. 7-06 Writ of Certiorari.................................................................................................. ................................................12 ARTICLE VIII. REFILING & REHEARING OF APPEALS ..........................................................................................12 Sec. 8-01 One Year Refiling Rule ........................................................................................................................................12 Sec. 8-02 Reopening & Rehearing is Limited ......................................................................................................................12 Sec. 8-03 Closure of Appeals ...............................................................................................................................................12 ARTICLE IX. RECONSIDERATION OF APPEALS .......................................................................................................13 Sec. 9-01 Board Motion........................................................................................................ ................................................13 Sec. 9-02 Party in Interest................................................................................................... ..................................................13 Sec. 9-03 Delay in the Appeal Period.......................................................................................... .........................................13 Sec. 9-04 Majority Vote Required.............................................................................................. ..........................................13 County Board Approval: On February 2nd, 1985, the Chippewa County Board of Supervisors adopted resolution number 1985-011, which were the Rules & By-Laws for the Board of Adjustment. Amendment(s): Resolution 2009-031 – Revisions to a majority of the sections of the Rules and By-Laws. Please see resolution for exact changes. (Adopted by the County Board on 09-08-2009). Page 30 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 3 of 13 September, 2009 ARTICLE I. GENERAL PROVISIONS Sec. 1-01 Title The official title of this Board is “The Chippewa County Board of Adjustm ent”. Sec. 1-02 Authority The C hippewa County Board of Adjustment is established under the authority of section 59.694 of the Wisconsin Statutes, and as from time to time amended. The Board assumes all responsibilities, duties and powers as provided within Wisconsin Law, county ordinances and these rules. These rules are supplementary to the provisions of any county ordinances as they relate to the procedures of the Board. Sec. 1-03 Changes & Amendments The C ounty Board may from time to time alter, supplement or change the provisions of these by-laws and rules in accordance with the requirements of Wisconsin State Statute 59.694(3). Sec. 1-04 Office of the Board The offi ce of the Board shall be located in the Chippewa County Planning & Zoning Department. All records of the Board shall be available for public inspection between the hours of 8:00 A.M. and 4:30 P.M. Monday through Friday, except for when the county courthouse is not open for public business. Sec. 1-05 Definitions (1) Administrator m eans the Planning & Zoning Administrator appointed by the County Administrator or an agent designated by the Planning & Zoning Administrator. (2) Agent means an individual who represents an appellant either by filing the necessary paperwork for an appeal or appears on their behalf at a required hearing in which the Board is authorized to act upon. (3) Appellant means the person entering an appeal for Board consideration. (4) Board means the Chippewa County Board of Adjustment and each and every member thereof. (5) Chair means the member actually presiding over the meeting or hearing. (6) Committee means the Planning & Zoning Committee. (7) Corporation Counsel means the attorney designated by the County Board of Supervisors to furnish legal assistance for the County Departments. (8) County Administrator means the Chippewa County Administrator as hired by the County Board. (9) County Board means the Chippewa County Board of Supervisors. (10) Department means the Chippewa County Planning & Zoning Department. (11) Meeting also means “hearing” where appropriate and shall include on-site inspections where applicable. (12) Member means a person who has been duly appointed to serve regularly in all proceedings of the Board. (13) Ordinance means any applicable ordinance adopted by the Chippewa County Board in which the Board of Adjustment is authorized to act. Page 31 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 4 of 13 September, 2009 Sec. 1-06 General Powers (1) The powers of t he Board of Adjustment are identified in 59.694(7) of the Wisconsin Statutes and in the ordinances that have been adopted by the County Board. The Board shall have the following general powers: (a) Administrative Appeals. To hear and decide appeals where it is alleged there is error in any order, requirement, decision or determination made by an administrative official in the enforcement of secs. 59.69, 59.692, 87.30 or 281.31, Wisconsin Statutes, as amended, or of any ordinance. (b) Conditional Use Appeals. To hear and decide requests for conditional uses permits that are authorized and listed within the ordinances and upon which the Board is authorized to act. (c) Variances. To authorize, upon appeal in specific cases, such variance from the terms of any ordinance which will not be contrary to the public interest where, owing to special conditions, a literal enforcement of the provision of the ordinance will result in unnecessary hardship and so that the spirit of the ordinance shall be observed, public welfare and safety secured and substantial justice done. A variance shall: 1. be consistent with the spirit and intent of the ordinance. 2. not permit any change in the uses in the established zoning districts. 3. not be granted unless it is demonstrated that the variance will not be contrary to the public interest or damaging to the rights of other persons or property values in the area. 4. not be granted for actions, which require an amendment to the ordinance in question. 5. not have the effect of allowing a use or structure, which is prohibited by an ordinance unless the Board determines that no feasible use of the property can be made without such variance or strict conformity with the ordinance is unnecessarily burdensome and provided that a use variance may be granted in a floodplain, shoreland-wetland or conservancy district. 6. not be granted on the basis of economic gain or loss. 7. not be granted for a self-created hardship. (2) In exercising the powers under section (1) above, the Board may reverse or affirm, wholly or partly, or may modify an order, requirement, decision or determination appealed from, and may make such order, requirement, decision or determination as ought to be made and may direct the issuance or denial of a permit by the Department. Sec. 1-07 Limitations of Power Not hing herein shall be construed to give or grant to the Board, the power or authority to alter or change the ordinances or zoning districts or other official maps of the county, which authority is reserved to the County Board. Sec. 1-08 Appeals are Specific to a Property The deci sion of the Board shall be deemed as applying to the property rather than to the individual and is valid only for the specific premises in the appeal and is not transferable to other properties. Sec. 1-09 Appeals are to be Determined Individually No action of the Board shall set a binding precedent. Each appeal shall be decided upon its m erits and upon the attendant circumstances, provided the Board shall not act arbitrarily or capriciously. Page 32 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 5 of 13 September, 2009 ARTICLE II. BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT Sec. 2-01 Members (1) Members. The B oard shall consist of five (5) voting members and two (2) alternate members for a total of seven (7) members. The members shall all reside within the county and outside the limits of incorporated cities or villages; provided, however, that no two (2) members shall reside in the same town. (2) Alternate Members. Alternate members may participate in the discussion during a meeting, but are limited to voting as follows: (a) The first alternate shall act, with full power only when a voting member of the board refuses to vote because of a conflict of interest or when a voting member is absent. (b) The second alternate shall act, with full power, only when the first alternate refuses to vote because of a conflict of interest or if more than one voting member of the board refuses to vote because of a conflict of interest or is absent. Sec. 2-02 Appointments & Terms of Office (1) Appoi ntment. All members of the Board shall be appointed by the County Administrator with County Board approval. Vacancies to unexpired terms shall be appointed in the like manner and shall be for the term remaining, unless otherwise approved. Alternates shall be appointed to an alternating schedule between first alternate and second alternate. (2) Terms of Office. Beginning on September 8th, 2009, the terms of the voting and alternate members shall be staggered as follows: (a) Three (3) voting members and one (1) alternate member shall be appointed for three (3) year terms. Successors shall be appointed in a like manner at the expiration of each term. (b) Two (2) voting members and one (1) alternate member shall be appointed to two (2) year terms. Successors shall be appointed to a three (3) year term at the expiration of the initial two (2) year term. Sec. 2-03 Officers (1) El ection. The Board shall elect a Chair and Vice-chair from amongst its members. These officers shall hold the position until their successors are elected. The Board may, at any meeting or hearing, elect from among the members the replacement for an officer, who dies or for any other reason is unable to perform the duties of their office. The officer, so elected as a replacement, shall serve until their term is up or until a successor is elected. (2) Chair Duties. The Chair shall: (a) Preside over and direct the conduct of all meetings and hearings of the Board. (b) Administer oaths. In the absence of both the Chair and the Vice-chair, the present members shall appoint a Chair to preside over that particular meeting. (c) Report on all official transactions that have not otherwise come to the attention of the Board. (d) Direct the official business of the Board, subject to these rules and further instructions from the Board. (e) Supervise the work of the Board and request necessary help when required. (f) The presiding officer Decide all points of procedure or order, unless otherwise directed by a majority of the members in attendance on motion duly made and approved. Page 33 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 6 of 13 September, 2009 (3) Vice-Chair Duties. Assumes the Chair duties in the absence of the Chair. (4) Presiding Officer Duties. Assumes the Chair duties in the absence of the Chair and Vice-Chair. Sec. 2-04 Conflicts of Interest Any member who has any direct or indirect interest, personal or financial, in an appeal before the Board shall not vote thereon or participate in the deliberation of such appeal at any meeting or hearing which it is under consideration. A disqualifying conflict of interest shall be deemed to exist when the member: (1) is the appellant; or (2) is the spouse of the appellant; or (3) is related to the appellant within the third degree of consanguinity, or is the husband or wife of someone so related; or (4) is the employer, employee or partner of the appellant; or (5) is a major shareholder in a corporation for which the appeal is being considered; or (6) has a major financial interest in the appeal; or (7) owns property within 300 feet of the property which is the subject of theappeal. Sec. 2-05 Ex Parte Disqualification M embers may disqualify themselves from participating in any appeal whenever the appellant has sought to influence the vote of the member on that matter outside of the public hearing. ARTICLE III. COUNTY DEPARTMENTS Sec. 3-01 Planning & Zoning Department The Departm ent shall record and maintain permanent minutes of the Board's proceedings, showing the vote of each member upon every question, or if absent or failing to vote, indicating that fact; shall keep records of its official actions; shall summarize accurately the testimony of those appearing before the Board and keep a verbatim recording of all hearings; shall record the names and addresses of all persons appearing before the Board in person or by an agent; and shall, subject to the Board and Chair, conduct the correspondence of the Board and have published in a local newspaper, public notices of meetings or hearings as required by law and these rules of procedure; shall file said minutes and records in the office of the Board, which minutes and records shall be a public record; and shall be the custodian of the files of the Board and keep all records. Sec. 3-02 County Corporation Counsel The C ounty Corporation Counsel may act as legal counsel for the Board. Under circumstances in which a conflict of interest exists between the County Corporation Counsel and the Board, the County Administrator may, in his sole discretion, retain independent legal counsel for the Board. Notwithstanding the foregoing, the Board may retain independent legal counsel of its choice at its own expense. ARTICLE IV. REGULAR MEETINGS Sec. 4-01 Meetings Called M eetings of the Board shall be held or cancelled at the call of the Chair and at such other time as the Board may determine, provided that all members are given at least 48 hours prior to such meeting. All meetings shall be open to the public and in accordance with the Wisconsin Open Meeting Law. Page 34 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 7 of 13 September, 2009 Sec. 4-02 Quorum A quorum shall consist of a majority of voting members, i.e. 3 members present and voting. No action may be taken except by a majority vote of such quorum except a lesser number may meet and adjourn any meeting duly called and noticed to a date, time and place certain. Sec. 4-03 Order of Business (1) The Departm ent, with Chair approval, shall prepare an agenda for each Board meeting listing the matters of business in the general following order: (a) Call to order and roll call. (b) Statement by the presiding officer concerning notice in accordance with the Wisconsin Open Meeting Law. (c) Approval of the Agenda as posted. (d) Site inspections, if warranted. (e) Public Wishing to be Heard (f) Unfinished business. (g) New business. (h) Approval of the previous meeting minutes. (i) Public Hearings. (j) Deliberations and decisions on appeals to the Board. (k) Communications and miscellaneous. (l) Other business that may come before the Board as permitted by law. (m) Closed Session (n) Adjournment. (2) The order of business under (1)(a) – (n) may be varied at any meeting or hearing upon consent of the members present. Sec. 4-04 Continuance of Public Hearings W hen all appeals cannot be properly heard, the Board may adjourn to a date, time and place certain and such adjourned day shall be construed as a continuance of the hearing. Notice of such adjournment shall be given to the absent members of the Board. Please see section 6-02(2). Sec. 4-05 Robert’s Rules of Order R obert's Rules of Order shall govern actions of the Board and conduct of its meetings if not covered by these rules and regulations or ordinances. Page 35 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 8 of 13 September, 2009 ARTICLE V. APPEAL PROCEDURES Sec. 5-01 Limited Appeal Period Appeal s from a decision of the Administrator or Committee must be filed within 30 days after the decision in writing is made and filed within the Department. Sec. 5-02 Who May File Appeals shall be accepted from any person aggrieved, or agent thereof, or from any officer, department, board or bureau of the municipality affected, or agent thereof. An aggrieved person may be any person or legal entity, including a corporation or partnership, holding an interest in the property involved in the action, including a potential purchaser who has made an offer to purchase or a purchaser under a land contract or a tenant for one year or more. Neighbors and residents or other property owners near the property involved may also appeal on a showing of injury to themselves or to the use and enjoyments of property they own or occupy. The Board may dismiss appeals in which persons do not have standing as described herein. Sec. 5-03 Required Forms Appeal s shall be made on forms provided by the Administrator. Any communication, except on prescribed forms, purporting to be an appeal shall be deemed a mere notice of intention to file and shall not be deemed a filing to comply with requirements of timely filing. An appeal will not be placed on the Board’s agenda unless all requested information, including all required forms and all applicable fees, are filed in the Department by the appropriate deadline. Sec. 5-04 Owner’s Consent The form shall bear the signature of the owner of the property affected or the signature of their agent which shall be accompanied by a letter from the owner acknowledging the filing of the appeal by the agent. Sec. 5-05 Reasons to be Stated The reason for t he appeal must be stated and the reasons why the request should be granted must also be stated by the appellant: (1) Variance. If a variance is requested, facts should be stated upon which findings may be made by the Board to justify the granting of the variance. See 1-05(3). (2) Administrative Appeal. If an appeal is based upon a disputed interpretation of the ordinance, the specific section of the ordinance in question must be identified, along with the appellant’s interpretation and supporting rationale. If an appeal is based upon an alleged error or abuse of discretion of the Administrator or Committee, facts should be stated as to the nature thereof. Sec. 5-06 Required Fee The appellant shall pay such fees as established by the County Board, which am ount shall be paid to the Department for each appeal filed before a public hearing will be scheduled. Sec. 5-07 Refusal to Hear an Appeal The B oard may refuse to hear a case upon the failure of the appellant to supply the required fees or information called for on the appeal form and as further reasonably required by the Administrator or Board. Sec. 5-08 Stays An appeal to the Board shall stay all enforcem ent actions appealed from, unless the Administrator shall certify to the Board, after the notice of appeal has been filed with the Department, that by reason of facts stated in an affidavit, a stay would cause Page 36 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 9 of 13 September, 2009 imminent peril to life or property. In such case, proceedings shall not be stayed, otherwise than by a court order granted by a court of law. Sec. 5-09 Copies to Be Sent The ori ginal paperwork shall be kept within the Department. The Administrator shall promptly transmit copies of the appeal as follows: (1) All Board members, one (1) copy each; (2) Town Chair and Clerk, one (1) copy each; (3) In the case of appeals affecting property in the shoreland or floodplain districts, one (1) copy shall be sent to the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources West Central District Office. (4) In case of appeals affecting property in an exclusive agricultural district, one (1) copy shall be sent to the Wisconsin Department of Agricultural, Trade and Consumer Protection. ARTICLE VI. PUBLIC HEARINGS Sec. 6-01 Timeframe for Hearing The Board shall consider each appeal at its next regularly scheduled m eeting, provided there is sufficient time between the date of the appeal and the date of the meeting for the required hearing notices to be published. Sec. 6-02 Notice of Hearing (1) Dep artment Duties. The Department shall give, or cause to be given, notice of each hearing as required by law and these rules. This shall include at least the following: (a) Publication of a Class 2 hearing notice in a newspaper of general circulation; (b) Mailing a notice of the hearing to the appellant, where required and to the district office of the Department of Natural Resources West Central District at least 10 days before the hearing; (c) Mailing a notice of the hearing to the town chair or clerk of the town in which the property is located, not less than 10 days before the date of the hearing. (d) Mailing a notice to all property owners within 300 feet of the perimeter of the property affected. (2) Table or Postponed Hearings. A Board motion to table or postpone an appeal to a date, time and place certain, which is made at the required public hearing date for such appeal shall be adequate notice to the members and the public and shall not be subject to the requirements of (1) above. Sec. 6-03 Postponement of Hearing Appeal s may be postponed only by prior arrangement with the Department in conjunction with the Chair. Please see section 6-02(2) for publication requirements. Sec. 6-04 Order of Public Hearings Hearin gs on appeals will generally follow this order: (1) Reading of the appeal and the reason for denial by the Administrator. (2) Determination of jurisdiction when requested. Page 37 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 10 of 13 September, 2009 (3) Appellant presents evidence. (4) Others in support of appellant present evidence. (5) Objectors present evidence. (6) Questions by Board members, interested parties and Administrator. (7) Administrator recommendation. (8) Rebuttals as permitted by the Board. (9) Close hearing. (10) General discussion and further questions as allowed by the Board. (11) Decision on appeal. Sec. 6-05 Question of Jurisdiction Fol lowing the reading of the appeal, the Board may hear arguments on the question of jurisdiction and request that briefs be filed on the point. The Board may proceed with the hearing and the taking of testimony in any event and reserve its determination on a jurisdictional question until after the hearing is closed and render a decision on the merits as if it had jurisdiction. The Board may make an immediate determination and close the hearing upon a finding that it lacks jurisdiction. If the Board determines by motion that it lacks jurisdiction, the Department shall record the decision as a vote to deny the request. Sec. 6-06 Testimony (1) Oath. At the discretion of the Chair, testimony may be taken under oath. The individual addressing the Board shall state their name and current mailing address for the record. (2) Appellant. At the time of the hearing, the appellant may appear on their own behalf or be represented by their agent. (3) Witnesses. The Chair may call for the attendance of witnesses. (4) Interested Persons. Persons having an interest in the appeal may attend the hearing and may request an opportunity to testify. Sec. 6-07 Parties not to Interrupt Orderly procedure requires that each side shall proceed without interruption by the other; that all questions, argum ents and pleadings shall be addressed directly to the Board. There shall be no questioning or arguments between individuals. Sec. 6-08 Questions & Debate Duri ng the hearing, the Board and the Administrator may ask questions and make appropriate comments pertinent to the appeal; however, no member should debate or argue an issue with the appellant. The Chair or Board may direct any question to the appellant or to any person speaking in order to bring out all relevant facts, circumstances and conditions affecting the case and may call for questions from the Administrator. Sec. 6-09 Evidence (1) Rules. The B oard shall not be bound by court rules of evidence, but it may exclude irrelevant, immaterial, incompetent, unduly argumentative or repetitious testimony or evidence. The Chair shall rule on all questions relating to the admissibility of evidence, which may be overruled by a majority of the Board present. Page 38 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 11 of 13 September, 2009 (2) Presentation. All supporting evidence for and against each appeal shall be presented to the assembled Board. The appellant shall be responsible for the presentation of all information supporting their case. The Board may take administrative notice of the ordinances of the County and laws of the State of Wisconsin and of other relevant facts not reasonably subject to dispute on its own motion or motion of a party. (3) Additional Evidence. The Board may take an appeal under advisement for later consideration and determination, or may defer action whenever it concludes that additional evidence is needed or further study is required. Sec. 6-10 Withdrawal of an Appeal An appel lant may withdraw an appeal at any time prior to the decision, but a pending motion to grant or dismiss the appeal shall have precedence over a withdrawal. The withdrawal of the appeal shall not entitle the appellant to a refund of the required filing fee and shall be subject to new filing fees if the appellant submits a new appeal. Sec. 6-11 Record of Hearing All proceedings at a public hearing shall be recorded in an electronic or digital form at. The Department shall prepare a summary of motions, witnesses, appearances, roll call, votes and all other matters constituting the substance of the proceedings which shall become part of the record filed in the office of the Board and open to the public. Transcripts of recorded proceedings shall not be prepared unless ordered by the circuit court by a writ of certiorari. Any party or member of the public may request a copy of the record of the proceedings. ARTICLE VII. DECISIONS OF THE BOARD Sec. 7-01 Majority Vote Required The concurri ng vote of a majority of all voting members, i.e. 3 members present and voting, shall be necessary to reverse any order, requirement, decision, or determination of any administrative official, to decide in favor of the appellant on any matter upon which it is required to pass under any ordinance or to grant any variance. Sec. 7-02 Findings of Facts (1) Variance. The B oard shall make findings of facts supporting its actions and/or decisions when granting or denying a variance. In every case where a variance from the ordinance is granted by the Board, the minutes of the Board shall affirmatively explain why, in the Board’s belief, an unnecessary hardship exists, why it is unnecessarily burdensome for the appellant to follow the ordinance provisions, what type of physical limitations the property has and that no harm to the public interest will occur as a result of the granting of the variance. The record of the Board shall clearly show in what particular and specific respects an unnecessary hardship exists. (2) Administrative Appeals. The Board shall make findings of facts supporting it actions and/or decisions when making a decision on an administrative appeal. In each appeal the minutes of the Board shall affirmatively show why, in their belief, what the interpretation of the ordinance provision is and that the appellant, staff or committee has misinterpreted the provision. (3) Conditional Use Permits. In each appeal, in which a conditional use permit for the zoning regulations is granted and/or denied by the Board, the record shall explain the reasoning behind such decision as well as provide for any type of conditions to be placed on the permit itself. Sec. 7-03 Decisions to be Written Al l decisions shall be in writing and contain the facts upon which the decision is based. The final decision shall be presented at the next Board meeting for approval. Sec. 7-04 Decisions to be Mailed (1) Appel lants. Within 45 days of the close of the hearing to which the decision relates, written copies of such decision shall be mailed to the appellant and all interested parties by the Department. The approval or granting of appeals by the Page 39 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 12 of 13 September, 2009 Board is deemed to constitute an order to the Administrator to issue the required permits. A denial of the appeal by the Board is deemed to be an order to deny the permit. (2) State Agencies. (a) Wisconsin DNR. Copies of written decisions authorizing conditional uses or variances in floodplain or shoreland districts shall be mailed to the Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources West Central District. (b) Wisconsin DATCP. Copies of written decisions authorizing conditional uses or variances in exclusive agricultural districts shall be mailed to the Wisconsin Department of Agricultural, Trade and Consumer Protection. Sec. 7-05 Order for Permit Valid for One (1) Year An order i ssued by the Board requiring the Administrator to issue a permit shall become void after one (1) year unless the appellant has filed an application for such permit with the Department within such time and the permit has been issued. The time limit may be extended when so specified by the Board in the original motion. Sec. 7-06 Writ of Certiorari Any person or persons jointly or severally aggrieved by any decision of the Board, or any taxpayer, or any officer, department, board or bureau of the County may commence an action in the circuit court for writ of certiorari to review the legality of such decision in whole or in part, within thirty (30) days after the filing of the decision in the office of the Department. ARTICLE VIII. REFILING & REHEARING OF APPEALS Sec. 8-01 One Year Refiling Rule An appeal , that the Board has acted upon, shall not be considered again within one (1) year from the date of action concerning the same property, except as hereinafter provided: (1) The appeal does not involve a request for an identical permit or does not allege the same misinterpretation or error, point of non-coverage or hardship as the previous appeal, or when (2) The appeal does not contain the original request for the same variance, or (3) When substantial change in the use of adjacent property has occurred since the previous appeal was heard, or (4) If the previous appeal was closed without a hearing because the appellant was not present at the time the appeal was scheduled for a public hearing. Sec. 8-02 Reopening & Rehearing is Limited The Board m ay not: (1) Reopen any appeal upon which a previous hearing has been held, except to correct a material error; but it may reconsider an appeal as provided by these rules; (2) Hear or rehear any appeal to determine the location of any district boundary line where the Board has previously determined the location of such boundary line, unless new evidence is submitted. Sec. 8-03 Closure of Appeals An appeal will be considered as heard and closed at such time as the Board approves or rejects an appeal by motion or when it is considered closed by operation of these rules. Page 40 of 41 Chippewa County Board of Adjustment – Rules & By-Laws Page 13 of 13 September, 2009 ARTICLE IX. RECONSIDERATION OF APPEALS Sec. 9-01 Board Motion A deci sion of the Board may be reconsidered: (1) By a “Motion to Reconsider” made at the same meeting which may be immediately disposed of without further notice, or (2) By a “Motion to Reconsider” made no later than the following regular meeting, in which event, the matter shall be placed on the calendar for a subsequent hearing and a new notice given without additional fee. Sec. 9-02 Party in Interest The Board m ay entertain a request for reconsideration by a party in interest provided the request is in writing and new written evidence is submitted with the request. A request for reconsideration must be filed with the Department within 15 days after the Board has made a decision on the request. On receipt of a properly filed request to reconsider, the Department shall place the matter on the Board agenda under "Other Business" for consideration at the next regular meeting. A new notice shall be provided by the Department, which is paid for by requestor. Sec. 9-03 Delay in the Appeal Period The fi ling of a request or adoption of a motion for reconsideration shall stop the running of the 30-day period in which a petition to the circuit court must be made. The 30-day period will run in such event from the date a decision not to reconsider is made by the Board, or if the matter is reconsidered, from the date the decision on the reconsidered matter is filed in the Department. Sec. 9-04 Majority Vote Required. A sim ple majority vote shall be sufficient to reconsider a previous decision. If reconsideration is refused to an interested party who has requested reconsideration, the Board shall enter on the minutes the basis of the request, the reason why it was refused and the vote of the Board members thereon. If reconsideration is approved, the case will be placed on the agenda for the next regular meeting and notice given of the re-hearing as required for an original hearing upon payment of the re- hearing fee. Page 41 of 41

Source: Chippewa County website. First collected Nov 12, 2026.