Board of Review — Minutes
Town of Phelps · Vilas County · Board of Review · meeting of Oct 29, 2026 · Minutes
Open the original document More from Town of Phelps
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
BOARD OF REVIEW MINUTES
Town of Phelps, Vilas County, WI
Thursday, October 29, 2026 - 6:00 P.M.
Page 1 | 4
1. Call to Order – The 2026 Board of Review Two -Hour Meeting was called to order at 6 pm by Town Chair Steve
Doyen.
2. Roll Call – Present: Town Assessor Terry Vosburgh of Hoffman Appraisals; Town Chair Steve Doyen; Town Board
Supervisors Jeremy Ryan, Mary Ann Holcomb, Steve Waier; Clerk/Treasurer Sheryl J Ward. Excused – Maureen
L Robinson.
3. Pledge of Allegiance – Recited.
4. Confirmation of Appropriate Board of Review and Open Meeting Notices – Chair Doyen confirmed proper
posting and publication of the meeting notices. On September 9, 2026, the combined notice of Open Book (held
October 14, 2026) and the Board of Review Two -Hour Meeting was published in the Vilas County News Review
and on the Town website, and posted at the Phelps Post Office, the Phelps Convenience Cent er, and the
Community Center bulletin board. Publication and posting occurred at least 30 days before Open Book, as
required in a revaluation year pursuant to Wis. Stat. 70.47(2). The agenda for the Board of Review Two -Hour
Meeting was published on the Town website and posted at the Phelps Post Office, the Phelps Convenience
Center, and the Community Center bulletin board on October 26, 2026.
5. Select a Chairperson for The Board of Review – Motion by Steve Waier to select Steve Doyen to be the
Chairperson for the Board of Review. Second by Jeremy Ryan. All voting aye. Motion carried.
6. Select a Vice-Chairperson for The Board of Review – Motion by Steve Doyen to select Steve Waier to be the
Vice-Chairperson for the Board of Review. Second by Mary Ann Holcomb. All voting aye. Motion carried.
7. Verify That a Member Has Met the Mandatory Training Requirements for The Board of Review Pursuant to
Sec. 70.46(4) – Board of Review members who have completed the training pursuant to Sec. 70.46(4) are: Sheryl
J Ward, Jeremy Ryan, and Steve Waier on February 13, 2026. Affidavit filed by Clerk Ward March 18, 2026.
8. Verify That the Town Has an Ordinance for the Confidentiality of Income and Expense
Information Under State Law Sec. 70.47(7) (af). – Verified by Clerk Ward. Ordinance on file and available at
meeting.
9. Receipt of the Assessment Roll and Sworn Statements from the Clerk – Clerk received and signed the
assessment roll.
10. Review The Assessment Roll and Perform Statutory Duties – Roll examined. Correct Description or
Calculation Errors – None. No omitted properties or elimination of double assessed properties.
11. Discussion/Action – Certify All Corrections of Error Under State Law (Wis. Stat. 70.43) – None.
12. Verify With the Assessor that Open Book Changes are Included in the Assessment Roll – Verified with
Assessor. Open book for inspection of the assessment roll was held October 14, 2026, from 9 am to 5 pm.
Assessor Terry Vosburgh was present. Per Terry Vosburgh, several property owners attended the Open Book.
13. Allow Taxpayers to Examine Assessment Data – One taxpayer, Craig Gourley (Craig & Carla Gourley Living
Trust), was present, but did not examine the rolls.
14. During the First 2 Hours, Consideration of:
• Waivers of the Required 48-Hour Notice of Intent to File an Objection, When There is Good Cause –None.
• Requests for Waiver of the BOR Hearing Allowing the Property Owner an Appeal Directly to the Circuit
Court – None.
• Act On Any Other Legally Allowed/Required Board of Review Matters – None.
BOARD OF REVIEW MINUTES
Town of Phelps, Vilas County, WI
Thursday, October 29, 2026 - 6:00 P.M.
Page 2 | 4
15. Review Any Notices of Intent to File Objection and Proceed to Hear Objections Under Oath from All
Persons Who Appear Before It:
Clerk Ward is called upon by Chair Doyen to introduce the first case. Clerk Ward speaks:
This case is of The Craig & Carla Gourley Living Trust. The property owner/objector resides at 10707
Sagamore Ln., Bentonville AR, 72712.
The address for the property in questions is 867 Eagles Nest, Phelps, WI, 54554. The tax key for this
property is 18-2004-03.
This property has been classified for assessment purposes as Residential.
The value in the Assessment Roll for the current year is:
Land - $373,500.00
Improvements - $1,448,800.00
Total Assessment - $1,822,300.00
Clerk Ward swears in the Assessor and the Objector. Clerk Ward asks those persons sworn in to state
their name and address:
Assessor States – Terry Vosburgh, N3737 County Line Rd., Gleason WI, 54435
Objector States – Craig Gourley, 10707 Sagamore Ln., Bentonville AR, 72712, and 867 Eagles
Nest, Phelps WI, 54554
Findings of Fact:
• The property is identified as parcel 18-2004-03.
• It is owned by the Craig & Carla Golurley Living Trust.
• The assessment year in question is 2026.
• The total assessment of land and improvements is $1,822,300.00.
• The hearing date is the date of Board of Review, October 29, 2026.
• The taxpayer filed a timely notice of “Intent to File an Objection” with the Clerk on October 27, 2026,
before 6 pm. Also filed was the “Objection to Real Property Assessment” on the same day.
• Board of Review Members present for the Hearing: Chair Steve Doyen; Supervisors Mary Ann Holcomb,
Jeremy Ryan, and Steve Waier; Clerk Sheryl Ward. Supervisor Maureen Robinson was excused.
• Board Members Ryan, Ward, and Waier were trained as required, and an affidavit was filed March 18,
2026.
Sworn Testimony:
• Gourley questioned why neighboring properties were seemingly assessed differently and emphasized
wanting to pay his fair share but not wanting to overpay. Gourley presents a list of the assessment of
properties he believes are like his.
• Vosburgh said four properties on Gourley’s list (which were not recent sales, but assessments)
increased 97%–104%, compared with 99.8% for Gourley’s property. He explained that improvements,
amenities, construction, and the location of square footage affect assessed values, and that he was
required to use the recent arm’s-length transaction – with the purchase by the Gourley’s in June of
2026, for $1,975,000.00, being the arm’s-length transaction used for assessment purposes.
BOARD OF REVIEW MINUTES
Town of Phelps, Vilas County, WI
Thursday, October 29, 2026 - 6:00 P.M.
Page 3 | 4
• Discussion addressed upgrades and improvements since 2020 and differences between full-log and
half-log homes. Doyen explained the greater construction costs of full-log homes and supported the
assessor’s value.
• Gourley acknowledged the upgrades and construction differences and said he had learned a lot.
Vosburgh explained that assessment increases would not produce equivalent tax-rate increases,
though he could not determine the final mill rate for the Town of Phelps.
Doyen – My last question to you (Gourley) is are you alright with our findings?
Gourley – Yes, I am.
Doyen – I am now closing the testimony in this case.
16. Act on Finding of Fact, Determinations and Decision –
Findings of Fact:
• The assessor’s valuation is correct;
• The assessor presented evidence of the fair market value of the subject property using assessment
methods which conform to the statutory requirements, and which are outlined in the Wisconsin
Property Assessment Manual;
• That the assessor presented evidence of the proper classification of the subject property using
assessment methods which control to the statutory requirements, and which are outlined in the
Wisconsin Property Assessment Manual;
• That the property owner did not present sufficient evidence to rebut the presumption of correctness
granted by law to the assessor;
• That the assessor’s valuation is reasonable considering all the relevant evidence;
Chair Doyen asks the Board whether the assessor’s valuation ($1,822,300.00) is correct or incorrect.
Waier motions that the assessor’s valuation is correct.
Doyen seconds the motion.
Roll Call Vote: Sheryl Ward, Clerk of the Board of Review, certifies that the members of the Board of Review
voted as follows:
Steve Doyen – Yes
Mary Ann Holcomb – Yes
Steve Waier – Yes
Shery Ward – yes
Jeremy Ryan – Abstains, as he sold the property to Craig & Carla Gourley.
Therefore, the Findings of Fact, Determination, and Decision were adopted October 29, 2026.
Signed _______________________________ Sheryl J Ward, Clerk of the Board of Review
Clerk Ward personally gives completed Form PR-302, “Notice of Board of Review Determination” to Craig
Gourley before meeting is adjourned.
BOARD OF REVIEW MINUTES
Town of Phelps, Vilas County, WI
Thursday, October 29, 2026 - 6:00 P.M.
Page 4 | 4
17. Consider/Act on Scheduling Additional Board of Review Date(S) if Necessary – Additional meetings of the
Board of Review are not necessary.
18. Meeting Adjournment – Chair Doyen adjourned meeting at 8:00 pm.
________________________
Sheryl J Ward
Clerk-Treasurer, Town of Phelps
Source: Town of Phelps website. First collected Nov 12, 2026.