RecordWell Data

Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission — Agenda Packet

City of Stevens Point · Portage County · Historic Preservation and Design Review Commission · meeting of Jul 29, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Stevens Point

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION/ DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION Members • Chairperson Tim Siebert • Vice Chair Peter Munck • Alderperson Marc Christianson • Barry Calnan • Carol Molepske • Janet Jurgella Finn (Alternate 1) • Dan Kryst (Alternate 2) Date and Time: July 29, 2025 5:00 PM Location: Community Room 933 Michigan Avenue, Stevens Point, WI OR Zoom Teleconferencing Meeting ID: 825 8868 7464 Passcode: 962316 By Computer: https://us02web.zoo m.us/j/82588687464?pwd=HJkpK uePaVk6crtYtoNNcFLz3FaRxf.1 By Phone: +1-312-626-6799 (US Chicago) PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that any person who has special needs while attending these meetings or needs agenda materials for these meetings should contact the City Clerk as soon as possible to ensure that a reasonable accommodation can be made. The City Clerk can be reached by telephone at (715) 346-1569 or by mail at 1515 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point, WI 54481. Maps further defining the above area(s) may be obtained from the City of Stevens Point Department of Community Development, 1515 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point, WI 54481, or by calling (715) 346-1567, during normal business hours. PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that a quorum of the Common Council may be in attendance at this meeting. Opening Section: 1. Roll Call Discussion and Possible Action on: 2. Report of the June 12, 2025 meeting of the Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission. 3. A request from Ken Lewallen, representing Jason Zinser, to install a transom window and cedar shake siding on the principal structure located at 1908 Clark Street (Parcel ID 281240832103513), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). 4. A request from St. Stephen Parish to install a shed on the property located at 1335 Clark Street (Parcel ID 281240832100709), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). 5. A request from Frame Memorial Presbyterian Church of Stevens Point to install roof- mounted solar arrays on the building located at 1300 Main Street (281240832202815), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). Page 1 of 27 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that any person who has special needs while attending these meetings or needs agenda materials for these meetings should contact the City Clerk as soon as possible to ensure that a reasonable accommodation can be made. The City Clerk can be reached by telephone at (715) 346-1569 or by mail at 1515 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point, WI 54481. Maps further defining the above area(s) may be obtained from the City of Stevens Point Department of Community Development, 1515 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point, WI 54481, or by calling (715) 346-1567, during normal business hours. PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that a quorum of the Common Council may be in attendance at this meeting. 6. Discussion only: Economic Hardship Ordinance. 7. Staff Updates. Closing Section: 8. Adjourn Page 2 of 27 Page 1 of 2 REPORT OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION / DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION June 12, 2025 – 6:00 PM 933 Michigan Ave, Stevens Point, WI 54481 PRESENT: Chair Siebert, Vice Chair Munck, Commissioner Calnan, & Commissioner Kryst EXCUSED: Commissioner Finn & Commissioner Molepske ALSO PRESENT: Associate Planner/Zoning Administrator Kuhn INDEX: Opening Section: 1. Roll Call Discussion and Possible Action on the Following: 2. Report of the April 16, 2025 meeting of the Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission. 3. A request from Ryan Wanta, representing Wesley Cabral & Susy Ibrahim, for a design review to construct a building addition on the property located at 1900 Clark Street (Parcel ID 281240832103512 to remove the mural on the west elevation of the building located at 817 Clark Street (Parcel ID 281240832103512), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). 4. A request from Dave Ladick for a design review to paint a mural on the north-facing wall of the building located at 1216 Strongs Avenue (Parcel ID 281240832202932), consistent with Ch. 22.07. Closing Section: 5. Adjourn Opening Section: 1. Roll Call Present: Chair Siebert, Vice Chair Munck, Commissioner Calnan, & Commissioner Kryst Excused: Commissioner Finn Discussion and Possible Action on the Following: 2. Report of the April 16, 2025 meeting of the Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission. Motion by Vice Chair Munck to approve the April 16, 2025 minutes of the Historic Preservation/Design Review Commission; seconded by Commissioner Calnan. Motion carried 4-0. 3. A request from Ryan Wanta, representing Wesley Cabral & Susy Ibrahim, for a design review to construct a building addition on the property located at 1900 Clark Street (Parcel ID 281240832103512 to remove the mural on the west elevation of the building located at 817 Clark Street (Parcel ID 281240832103512), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). Page 3 of 27 Page 2 of 2 Associate Planner/Zoning Administrator Kuhn provided a summary of the proposed building addition, showing the site design plan and discussing the requirements necessary to meet the historic preservation requirements. Motion by Commissioner Calnan to approve the request for a design review to construct a building addition on the property located at 1900 Clark Street; seconded by Commissioner Kryst. Motion carried 4-0. 4. A request from Dave Ladick for a design review to paint a mural on the north-facing wall of the building located at 1216 Strongs Avenue (Parcel ID 281240832202932), consistent with Ch. 22.07. Associate Planner/Zoning Administrator Kuhn provided a summary of the mural request, addressing the necessary items needed to approve of the installation of the mural. Motion by Commissioner Kryst to approve the request for a design review to paint a mural on the north-facing wall of the building located at 1216 Strongs Avenue, with the exception to exceed the seventy percent mural coverage rule due to age of the brick wall; seconded by Vice Chair Munck. Motion carried 4-0. Closing Section: 5. Adjourn Meeting adjourned at 6:28 PM. A recording of this meeting can be viewed/heard at: https://stevenspoint.com/365/AgendasMinutesVideos Page 4 of 27 City of Stevens Point 1515 Strongs Avenue Stevens Point, WI 54481-3594 Department of Community Development Adam Kuhn Associate Planner Zoning Administrator Ph: (715) 346-1567 Fax: (715) 346-1498 www.stevenspoint.com Open Records Rider: The City of Stevens Point is subject to Wisconsin Statutes relating to public records. Communication, such as this document, sent or received by City employees are subject to these laws. Unless otherwise exempted from the public records law, senders and receivers of City communication should presume that the communications are subject to rel ease upon request, and to state record retention requirements. Page 1 of 1 MEMORANDUM To: Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission From: Adam Kuhn, AICP Associate Planner / Zoning Administrator Date: July 29, 2025 RE: Design Review – 1908 Clark Street – Windows & Siding ------------------- Background: The property owner of 1908 Clark Street is requesting a design review to install a new bathroom window on the second floor of the house. As shown in the image attached, the existing bathroom window is proposed to be replaced with a 3’ x 12’’ vinyl transom window. The proposed transom window will have the same yellow window trim that exists on the other first- and second-floor windows. The Commission’s Design Guidelines permits the replacement of windows so long as it is a like-for-like replacement in size. The proposed transom window will be located slightly above the existing bathroom window. As the dimensions of the existing window opening will be slightly altered with the proposed transom window, the Commission is required to consider the request. For portions of the existing window opening that will not be used for the proposed transom window, the applicant is proposing to reintroduce the same cedar shake siding that exists on the second floor of the house. Overall, my recommendation is to approve this design review request with the following conditions: 1. The applicant shall submit the proposed trim color, subject to the review and approval of the Designated Agent. 2. Caulking and weather stripping shall be provided to ensure that the window unit is weather tight. Page 5 of 27 Page 6 of 27 Page 7 of 27 Page 8 of 27 City of Stevens Point 1515 Strongs Avenue Stevens Point, WI 54481-3594 Department of Community Development Adam Kuhn Associate Planner Zoning Administrator Ph: (715) 346-1567 Fax: (715) 346-1498 www.stevenspoint.com Open Records Rider: The City of Stevens Point is subject to Wisconsin Statutes relating to public records. Communication, such as this document, sent or received by City employees are subject to these laws. Unless otherwise exempted from the public records law, senders and receivers of City communication should presume that the communications are subject to rel ease upon request, and to state record retention requirements. Page 1 of 1 MEMORANDUM To: Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission From: Adam Kuhn, AICP Associate Planner / Zoning Administrator Date: July 29, 2025 RE: Design Review – Shed at St Stephens ------------------- Background: St. Stephens Parish is requesting a design review to install an 8’ x 10’ prefabricated shed in the southwest parking lot near Ellis Street. The intention of this shed is to store miscellaneous equipment. The construction of any accessory structure greater than 25 sq ft in size requires consideration by the Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission. When reviewing this request relative to the Commission’s Design Guidelines, there are a few guidelines that stand out. First, Section 3.12(6) requires that new outbuildings be located in rear yards if possible. As the subject property abuts three streets, the location of the shed would be in the corner rear yard – still visible from a street. Second, Section 3.12(5) states that designs for new outbuildings and accessory structures should complement the architectural style and period of the primary structures as well as examples of similar structures within the district. There are few examples of prefabricated structures in the Downtown Design Review District, however that is primarily due to the fact that most lots are improved with zero-lot-line buildings. Ultimately, it is the Commissions discretion as to if a prefabricated structure is historically appropriate for the subject property or if more architectural detail shall be provided on a stick-built structure. Lastly, Section 3.12(7) states that new outbuildings should be proportionally the same in size and height to the primary structure. As the proposed shed pales in comparison to the size of the primary buildings on the lot, the shed dimensions would maintain some proportionality. Overall, please be prepared to discuss the appropriateness of allowing prefabricated accessory structures. While the Design Guidelines do not explicitly prohibit it, the above guidelines are important to consider for case-by-case requests. Page 9 of 27 Page 10 of 27 Page 11 of 27 Page 12 of 27 Page 13 of 27 Page 14 of 27 Adopted - 03/17/2014, Last Amended 09/19/202224 | Stevens Point - Design Guidelines Sec. 3.12 Outbuildings and Accessory Structures Original outbuildings such as barns, sheds, and garages, have often gained historic significance in their own right due to their construction method, architectural style, and period. In fact, many of these structures still survive in the districts and are still being used as they were originally intended. Many of these historic outbuildings have architectural characteristics and style similar to the primary structure with which they are associated. They are more utilitarian in nature, and are usually situated in rear yards adjacent to alleyways. Outbuildings and Accessory Structures Guidelines 1. The same criteria related to the use of materials for new construction apply to outbuildings and accessory structures. 2. Retain and preserve origi- nal outbuildings which have gained historic significance on their own. 3. Architectural elements of historic outbuildings such as roofs, siding, material, windows and doors, foundations, and character-defining detailing should be retained and preserved. 4. If replacement of an element on a historic outbuild- ing is necessary, replace only the deteriorated por- tion to match the original in mate- rial, size, propor- tion, texture, and detailing. 5. Designs for new outbuildings and accessory structures should com- plement the architectural style and period of the primary structures as well as examples of similar structures within the district. 6. New outbuildings should be located in rear yards if possible. 7. New outbuildings should be proportionally the same in size and height to the primary structure as is seen in the relationship be- tween other primary and secondary structures in the district. 8. Prefabricated wooden accessory structures that are not architec- turally similar to the primary structure are allowed only if screened from view from any existing right-of-way. Prefabricated metal stor- age buildings are not recommended. Sec. 3.13 Safety and Accessibility Due to the fact that historic structures were constructed before life safety and accessibility codes were developed, they normally don’t meet modern safety and accessibility standards as required by local building and fire codes. Some renovations to historic structures can trigger these codes and therefore, facilities for safety and accessibility should be incorporated into the project. Wisconsin State Building Code and federal requirements related to the Americans with Disabilities Act provide certain flexibility concerning historic structures. Contact the building inspection office for complete details regarding these matters. While these building codes often result in substantial changes to a historic property, the installation of accessibility and life safety features can usually be done in a manner that does not compromise the historic character of the structure. Safety and Accessibility Guidelines Accessibility ramp added complying with ADA 1. When projects must include the addition of health and safety fea- tures, whatever means possible should be used to minimize visual impact, and protect the historic character of the structure, and its character-defining details. Page 15 of 27 City of Stevens Point 1515 Strongs Avenue Stevens Point, WI 54481-3594 Department of Community Development Adam Kuhn Associate Planner Zoning Administrator Ph: (715) 346-1567 Fax: (715) 346-1498 www.stevenspoint.com Open Records Rider: The City of Stevens Point is subject to Wisconsin Statutes relating to public records. Communication, such as this document, sent or received by City employees are subject to these laws. Unless otherwise exempted from the public records law, senders and receivers of City communication should presume that the communications are subject to rel ease upon request, and to state record retention requirements. Page 1 of 1 MEMORANDUM To: Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission From: Adam Kuhn, AICP Associate Planner / Zoning Administrator Date: July 29, 2025 RE: Design Review – Solar Array at Frame Memorial Presbyterian Church ------------------- Background: Frame Memorial Presbyterian Church is requesting a design review to install roof-mounted solar arrays on the east elevation of the church. As Commissioners recall during the development of the City’s Historic Preservation Plan, ample discussion ensued about the allowance of solar energy collection systems on historic buildings and sites. For roof-mounted solar arrays, such arrays are preferred to be located on the south elevation of a building to maximize sunlight exposure. Frame Memorial Presbyterian Church abuts three streets – Main Street to the south, Church Street to the west and College Court to the north. Per Section 3.14(9) of the Commission’s Design Guidelines, solar arrays are not to be visible from a street. As a compromise to the aforementioned design guideline, the applicant relocated the proposed location of the solar arrays to the east elevation of the building. The proposed location still generates sufficient sunlight exposure for solar energy collection, however it would still be visible from Main Street. As such, the Commission will be required to consider the proposed array location. Overall, I am in support of the request and would recommend approval. Given the roof pitch that exists on Frame Memorial Presbyterian Church, the availability of sufficient roof lines for solar arrays are limited. The proposed location is arguably the best location for an array that is somewhat shielded from visibility, in part due to the mature trees that are situated to the east of the building. Page 16 of 27 Page 17 of 27 Page 18 of 27 Page 19 of 27 Page 20 of 27 Photos of Frame Memorial Presbyterian Church from along Main Street Taken July 2, 2025 Three photos taken from the sidewalk on the south side of Main Street across the street from the church Page 21 of 27 Three photos taken from the sidewalk on the north side of Main Street adjacent to the church Page 22 of 27 Page 23 of 27 Page 24 of 27 City of Stevens Point 1515 Strongs Avenue Stevens Point, WI 54481-3594 Department of Community Development Adam Kuhn Associate Planner Zoning Administrator Ph: (715) 346-1567 Fax: (715) 346-1498 www.stevenspoint.com Open Records Rider: The City of Stevens Point is subject to Wisconsin Statutes relating to public records. Communication, such as this document, sent or received by City employees are subject to these laws. Unless otherwise exempted from the public records law, senders and receivers of City communication should presume that the communications are subject to rel ease upon request, and to state record retention requirements. Page 1 of 1 MEMORANDUM To: Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission From: Adam Kuhn, AICP Associate Planner / Zoning Administrator Date: July 29, 2025 RE: Ordinance Amendment – Economic Hardship Provisions ------------------- Background: Last year during the development of the City’s Historic Preservation Plan, an interest was observed by the Commission to incorporate economic hardship provisions when considering variances to architectural requirements. As the Commission knows, a balancing act needs to occur that 1.) encourages property owners to maintain their historic buildings in a historically appropriate manner and 2.) ensures that the City’s architectural standards for building improvements does not make such work cost prohibitive. The desire to establish economic hardship provisions in the City’s Historic Preservation Ordinance was identified as a policy recommendation in the Historic Preservation Plan. Included in the agenda packet is a draft economic hardship ordinance. This draft ordinance includes recommended ordinance language from the Wisconsin Historical Society, as well as common language derived from other Wisconsin communities who have a similar ordinance. Please review the draft ordinance and be prepared to provide feedback. If you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. Page 25 of 27 ORDINANCE AMENDING THE REVISED MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE CITY OF STEVENS POINT, WISCONSIN [Chapter 22 of the Revised Municipal Code – Historic Preservation / Design Review – Economic Hardship Ordinance] The Common Council of the City of Stevens Point, Portage County, Wisconsin, do ordain as follows: SECTION I: That Section 22.05(2), Historic Preservation Ordinance of the Revised Municipal Code of the City of Stevens Point, shall be amended to create Section 22.05(2)(3) as follows: 3) Economic Hardship The Commission may grant a variance from Design Guidelines standards, by majority vote, if all of the following apply: a) Strict literal application of the standard(s) would deny the property owner a reasonable rate of return on investment, or would impose upon the property owner an unreasonable and unnecessary financial hardship. b) The circumstances justifying the variance are unique to the property in question, and, 1) Were not caused by the owner's failure to maintain the property as required by this Chapter; and 2) Does not apply to a substantial portion of the historic district or historic resources within two hundred (200) feet of the subject property; and 3) Will not alter the historic character of the historic district or historic resources within two hundred (200) feet of the subject property. c) The property owner documents the circumstances justifying the variance. The minimum evidence shall include for all property: 1) Nature of ownership (individual, business, or nonprofit) or legal possession, custody, and control; Page 26 of 27 2) Financial resources of the owner and/or parties in interest; 3) Cost of repairs; 4) Assessed value of the land and improvements; 5) Real estate taxes for the previous two (2) years; 6) Amount paid for the property, date of purchase, and party from whom purchased, including a description of the relationship between the owner and the person from whom the property was purchased, or other means of acquisition of title, such as by gift or inheritance; 7) Annual debt service, if any, for previous two (2) years received; 8) Any listing of the property for sale or rent, price asked, and offers received, if any. In addition, for income-producing property, the minimum evidence shall include: 1) Annual gross income from the property for the previous two (2) years; 2) Itemized operating and maintenance expenses for the previous two (2) years; 3) Annual cash flow, if any, for the previous two (2) years. SECTION II: That this ordinance shall take effect upon passage and publication. Approved: ________________________________ Mike Wiza, Mayor Attest: ________________________________ Susan Pagel, City Clerk Dated: Adopted: Drafted by: Adam Kuhn Return to: City Clerk Page 27 of 27

Source: City of Stevens Point website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.