Ad Hoc Advisory Committee on Industrial Livestock Operations — Agenda Packet
Portage County · Portage County · Land and Water Conservation Committee · meeting of Nov 5, 2025 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Portage County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
PORTAGE COUNTY
MEETING AGENDA
AD HOC ADVISORY COMMITTEE ON
INDUSTRIAL LIVESTOCK
OPERATIONS
PORTAGE COUNTY ANNEX
CONFERENCE ROOMS 1 & 2
1462 STRONGS AVENUE
STEVENS POINT, WI 54481
Wednesday, November 5, 2025 7:00 PM
REMOTE ATTENDANCE & COMMENT
To attend this meeting by telephone : dial 1-872-242-7813, after dialing the number you will then be asked to enter in a
meeting number. Use the following meeting number: 846 062 856, then press #
To attend this meeting by video: Join the meeting now
Page 1 of 2
CALL TO ORDER
CORRESPONDENCE
PRESENTATIONS
1. Nathan Check, Portage County Highway Commissioner — Overview of road damage from farm equipment
REPORTS
2. Special Meeting Attendance Reports (Portage County Ordinance 3.1.47 & 3.1.48)
PUBLIC NOTICE
Members of the public who wish to address the Committee on specific agenda items must register their request at this time,
with such comments subject to the public comment ordinance and the reasonable control of the Committee Chair as set
forth in Robert’s Rules of Order.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
3. Approval of October 29th, 2025 Meeting Minutes
DISCUSSION/POSSIBLE ACTION
4. Discussion/Possible Action Re: Environmental impact recommendations as they relate to proposed industrial livestock
operations ordinance
5. Discussion/Possible Action Re: Recommendations regarding roads as they relate to proposed industrial livestock
operations ordinance
6. Discussion/Possible Action Re: Recommendations on financial assurance as they relate to proposed industrial livestock
operations ordinance
7. Discussion/Possible Action: Review of Schedule of Future Agenda and Committee Recommendations
NEXT MEETING DATE November 19th, 2025.
ADJOURNMENT
Notice: Any person who has special needs and plans on attending this meeting in-person or remotely should contact the Facilities Office
at 715-346-1598 as soon as possible to ensure that reasonable accommodations can be made.
Notice: Remote comment by the public during the meeting will be at the discretion of the Chair.
Page 1 of 19
Ad Hoc Advisory Committee on Industrial
Livestock Operations
Meeting Agenda November 5, 2025
Page 2 of 2
Notice: A quorum of the Portage County Board of Supervisors, or any committee thereof, may be present at this meeting.
Page 2 of 19
County Engineer – Lucas Meddaugh
County Patrol Manager – Kory Kukuczka State Patrol Manager – David Johnson
Parts Room / Shop Manager – Corey Giese Assistant Patrol Manager – Bob Lang
/uni0046inance /uni004F/g431ice Supervisor – Stacy Zerby /uni0046inancial Associate III – Kristen Hancock
Portage County
Highway Department
Nathan Check, PE
Commissioner
800 Plover Road
Plover, WI 54467
Phone: 715-345-5355
Fax:715 -345 -5356
Date: October 22, 2025
To: Amberle Schwartz, Chairperson for Ad Hoc Advisory Committee on Industrial
Livestock Operations
From: Nathan Check, P.E.
Subject: Portage County Ad Hoc Advisory Committee on Industrial Livestock Operations –
Road Regulations
Dear Chair Schwartz,
Thank you for reaching out to me regarding the County’s Ad Hoc Advisory Committee on
Industrial Livestock Operations and questions regarding the potential role of the Committee and
draft ordinance in regards to regulating roadway use.
I appreciate the Committee’s consideration of our important and valuable infrastructure
resources, but the Committee may want to review the information below prior to including any
additional regulations within the Operations ordinance in regard to roadway use.
1. Current Authority to Protect Local Roads
Wisconsin Statute Chapter 348 provides for the general maximum weight restrictions for
vehicles on state, county, and local roads.
https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/statutes/statutes/348.pdf
State, county, and local officials are also granted powers under Chapter 349 of the Wis Stats
which allow them to designate all or a portion of their road way systems as Class B
Highways.(
https://docs.legis.wisconsin.gov/statutes/statutes/349.pdf ).
The Class B designation reduces the permitted weight, year-round, not to exceed 60% of the
legal load limits. It takes effect when signs are posted and remains in effect until the signs are
removed. The statute does provide from some exemptions for the Class B classification which
include: local pick-up and delivery of legal loads, waste haulers at legal load, and Class B
Implements of Husbandry.(IoH). More information regarding IOH’s is below.
In addition, the statute allows county and local officials to post certain roads and bridges with
reduced load limits as an alternative to protecting the infrastructure which may be not built to
withstand heavy loads. These postings may be year-round or seasonal.
Page 3 of 19
County Engineer – Lucas Meddaugh
County Patrol Manager – Kory Kukuczka State Patrol Manager – David Johnson
Parts Room / Shop Manager – Corey Giese Assistant Patrol Manager – Bob Lang
/uni0046inance /uni004F/g431ice Supervisor – Stacy Zerby /uni0046inancial Associate III – Kristen Hancock
Portage County
Highway Department
Nathan Check, PE
Commissioner
800 Plover Road
Plover, WI 54467
Phone: 715-345-5355
Fax:715 -345 -5356
While the attached Transportation Bulletin No. 8: Using Weight Limits to Protect Local Roads is
from 2003, it includes a very good summary of the statutes and abilities for the local forms of
government to protect their local roads.
Another factor to consider is that Wis Stat 349.15 and 349.16 are very specific on who has the
authority to impose these restrictions as “the loca l authority in charge of maintenance”. The
Committee would need to check with Corporation Counsel if any town road regulation within the
ordinance is enforceable or even allowed by statute since the County is not the maintaining
authority for town roads.
2. Regulation of IoH’s
Significant changes were made to Wis Stat Chapter 348 approximately 10 years ago to provide
for additional clarification on definitions, weight and size restrictions, and regulation authority
for IoH’s and agricultural commercial motor vehicles(AgCMV). Additional information can be
found at:
https://wisconsindot.gov/Pages/dmv/agri-eq-veh/default.aspx .
The definition of IoH is:
A self-propelled or towed vehicle manufactured, designed, or reconstructed to be used and that
is exclusively used in the conduct of agriculture. An implement of husbandry may also include
any of the following:
• A farm tractor (referred to as Category A);
• A self-propelled combine; a self-propelled forage harvester; self-propelled fertilizer or
pesticide application equipment but not including manure application equipment, towed
tillage, planting, and cultivation equipment and its towing power unit; or another self-
propelled vehicle that directly engages in harvesting farm products, directly applies
fertilizer, spray, or seeds but not manure, or distributes feed to livestock (referred to as
Category B);
• A farm wagon, farm trailer, manure trailer, or trailer adapted to be towed by or to tow or
pull, another implement of husbandry (referred to as Category C).
An AgCMV is also defined as:
An Ag CMV is a commercial motor vehicle to which all of the following apply:
• Substantially designed or equipped, or materially altered from its original construction,
for the purpose of agricultural use
• Designed and manufactured primarily for highway use
• Manufactured to meet federal motor vehicle safety standard certification label
requirements 49 CFR 567, after 1970
• Used exclusively in the conduct of agricultural operations
Page 4 of 19
County Engineer – Lucas Meddaugh
County Patrol Manager – Kory Kukuczka State Patrol Manager – David Johnson
Parts Room / Shop Manager – Corey Giese Assistant Patrol Manager – Bob Lang
/uni0046inance /uni004F/g431ice Supervisor – Stacy Zerby /uni0046inancial Associate III – Kristen Hancock
Portage County
Highway Department
Nathan Check, PE
Commissioner
800 Plover Road
Plover, WI 54467
Phone: 715-345-5355
Fax:715 -345 -5356
• Directly engaged in harvesting farm products, directly applies fertilizer (including
manure), spray or seeds to a farm field, or distributes feed to livestock
The statute sets the weight limit for all IoH and Ag-CMVs is 15% higher than the federal bridge
formula. This equates to a maximum single axle weight of 23,000 pounds and maximum gross
vehicle weight (GVW) of 92,000 pounds, dependent on axle number and spacing as presented in
the IoH/Ag CMV Maximum Weight Limits table (s. 348.15 3g). It also provides for exemptions
for Category B IoH’s and empty potato harvesters from the axle weight limits but they shall
adhere to the maximum gross vehicle weights.
Even with the law changes, local authorities still have ability to issue permits and post roads and
bridges as they have under prior law. Regardless of the exemptions, the statute requires all IoH’s,
including Category B’s to obey seasonal or special road and bridge postings.
Local governments also have a range of choices to implement the IoH/Ag CMV laws which also
include a uniform no-fee permit application. All other maintaining authorities are required to
participate in the permitting process but they have options in regards to regulating IoH’s by
ordinance.
The Local governments options include:
• Pass no ordinance or resolution if the local government chooses to allow the statutory
weight and length limits and exemptions to Category B IoH from axle limits on roads
under their jurisdiction. Permits may be issued to operate IoH and Ag CMVs that exceed
statutory limits on local roads.
• Pass Resolutions or ordinances if the local government chooses to:
o Opt In - Which requires all IoH (including Category B) and Ag CMVs to follow
the new IoH/Ag CMV Maximum Weight Limits for both Gross Vehicle Weight
(GVW) and Axle Weight. Permits may be issued to operate IoH and Ag CMVs
that exceed statutorial limits on local roads.
o Total Opt Out - Have no weight or length limits for IoH and Ag CMVs operating
on roads under their jurisdiction. A permit is not needed.
o Partially Opt Out I – Set weight and length limits above those set for th in statute
for IoH and Ag CMVs operating on all roads under their jurisdiction. A permit
may be necessary.
o Partially Opt Out II - Designate specific roads under their jurisdiction for over-
weight/over-length IoH and Ag- CMV travel.
Page 5 of 19
County Engineer – Lucas Meddaugh
County Patrol Manager – Kory Kukuczka State Patrol Manager – David Johnson
Parts Room / Shop Manager – Corey Giese Assistant Patrol Manager – Bob Lang
/uni0046inance /uni004F/g431ice Supervisor – Stacy Zerby /uni0046inancial Associate III – Kristen Hancock
Portage County
Highway Department
Nathan Check, PE
Commissioner
800 Plover Road
Plover, WI 54467
Phone: 715-345-5355
Fax:715 -345 -5356
• Post roads or bridges , regardless of passing an ordinance or resolution. All vehicle
operators, except those with statutory exemption, are responsible for following seasonal
and special postings and any postings on highway roads, bridges or culverts.
Ordinances or resolutions must be passed by November 30 of each calendar year and each
municipality. Additional information and be found at:
https://wisconsindot.gov/Pages/dmv/agri-
eq-veh/local-govt-info.aspx which includes links to all of the local municipal ordinances.
For Portage County roads, the County Board did not pass a resolution and as a result, county
roads follow the statutory limits and permit requirements. Portage County towns have ranged in
their decisions which are summarized below:
-Total Opt In – Towns of Dewey and Hull
-Partial Opt Out – Town of Grant
-Total Opt Out – Towns of Buena Vista, Almond, Belmont, and Amherst
-Follow Statutory Limits and Permit requirements – remaining towns
As you can see, there are major differences on how local towns within the county decided to
handle the regulation and permitting of IoH’s within their respective towns. Due to these
differences and the fact that local towns have the authority to post special weight limits, I believe
it would be difficult to draft a county-wide ordinance for every local road.
Enforcement
Since the Operations ordinance would only pertain to certain large-scale animal farming
operations, any special road ordinances may be difficult to enforce considering the large amount
of other agriculture operations within the county. It would be difficult for law enforcement to
discern if a certain IoH is operating for a large-scale animal operation that is governed by the
ordinance or if it was for another type of farm such as a grain cash crop operation that is not
covered under the ordinance.
The Committee may want to consider discussing enforcement options with the Sheriff’s Office
as their current staffing levels may be strained and weight enforcement will include additional
training and resources such as portable axle scales.
Prosecution
Enforcement may only be effective if there is follow through with prosecution. The Committee
may also want to consider discussing prosecution of the overweight fines with the District
Attorney’s Office as well.
Page 6 of 19
County Engineer – Lucas Meddaugh
County Patrol Manager – Kory Kukuczka State Patrol Manager – David Johnson
Parts Room / Shop Manager – Corey Giese Assistant Patrol Manager – Bob Lang
/uni0046inance /uni004F/g431ice Supervisor – Stacy Zerby /uni0046inancial Associate III – Kristen Hancock
Portage County
Highway Department
Nathan Check, PE
Commissioner
800 Plover Road
Plover, WI 54467
Phone: 715-345-5355
Fax:715 -345 -5356
Summary
Ultimately, Wis Statutes provide the local maintaining authorities to provide for additional
restrictions to protect their road and bridge infrastructure. These local officials are required by
statute to conduct road ratings and reviews every two years and can address any issues within
their current statutory authority.
While the Committee’s consideration is appreciated, I think it may be difficult to place county-
wide regulation and oversight on the 1,300+ miles of local roads through a County-wide
ordinance specific to certain operations.
Corporation counsel should be contacted to verify if a county-wide ordinance regulating weights
on local roads is allowed and enforceable by statute.
The Sheriff’s Office would also likely be the enforcing authority and should be brought into the
discussion. Since enforcement is likely a point-in-time scenario, overweight loads would have to
be “caught in the act.” Based on current staffing and other priorities, this may be difficult.
If you have any additional questions, please do not hesitate to contact me. The purpose of the
memo was to provide additional information prior to the November Committee meeting so that
the appropriate question and answers can be presented to the Committee.
Once you have reviewed all of the information, please contact me to discuss the specific points
that you would like to focus on for the Committee discussion. We could spend hours on the IoH
discussion alone, but that statute applies to all agriculture operations, not just larger farms that
may be covered under the new ordinance.
Thank you.
Attachments: Transportation Bulletin No. 8: Using Weight Limits to Protect Local Roads
Page 7 of 19
Wisconsin’s extensive local road system is a lifeline for
our state and local economies. Farms and businesses
depend heavily on these roads to move manufactured,
forest and agricultural products. Highway and street
agencies need them to economically transport road-
building materials. The public also relies on truck trans-
portation to receive goods at reasonable prices.
However, heavy truck loads can damage local road
pavements, especially in spring when they are weakened
because they are saturated with water.
Local officials have a responsibility to preserve our
investment in roads by protecting them from excess
damage caused by trucks carrying heavy loads. They
have the authority to restrict truck weights under state
statutes. However, local officials must carefully balance
the public good in protecting roads against the legitimate
need for efficient transportation.
We can’t do anything to control the weather, but we
can regulate how much weight is carried on certain
roads, especially during spring thaw. According to a
national study by the Federal Highway Administration
(FHWA), reducing truck weights by just 20% between
late February and early May can increase the life of vul-
nerable pavements by 62%. Cutting weights in half
increases pavement life by 95%. To be most effective,
truck weight control programs should be coordinated
with the Wisconsin Department of Transportation,
adjoining local road agencies, the trucking industry, and
the public.
This bulletin describes the causes of spring weakness
in roads, how heavy loads do damage, and the charac-
teristics of vulnerable roads. Techniques are introduced
for determining which roads need protection in spring
and when roads are vulnerable, along with guidelines on
how to set weight limits. Year round restriction on roads
and bridges is also discussed briefly. Another Wisconsin
Transportation Information Bulletin, HowTVehicleTLoads
AffectTPavementTPerformance,T No.To,Tdiscusses in more
detail how heavy trucks damage pavements.
How freezing affects pavements
A road’s design is based on a reasonable estimate of the
average loads it will carry during its projected life. That
is why Interstate highways carrying thousands of trucks
a day have thick concrete pavements while rural roads,
built for local traffic and a few trucks, are often a few
inches of compacted gravel or asphalt laid on a shallow
base. Soil types and local drainage characteristics also
affect design and load capacity.
To build roads, designers use calculations based
on strength and moisture tests of the natural soil or
subgrade. The road base and surface depth are then
designed for the average condition. Roads can be
designed for the worst soil conditions but the cost is
usually not justified by the expected use.
When the weather gets cold, pavements and the
water trapped within them freeze near the surface. As
cold temperatures persist and go lower, the frost line
moves deeper into the soil. Frost depth may range from
relatively minor—one or two feet during mild winters in
southern Wisconsin—to extremes of five to eight feet
during severe winters in the northern part of the state.
Using Weight Limits to Protect Local Roads
WisconsinrTransportationrBulletinr•rNo.r8
1
Asrspringrthawrweakensrpavements,rtrucksrcarryingrheavyrloads
canrdamagerthem.
Page 8 of 19
Frostractionrandrfrostrheaves
Pavements can be severely damaged in winter by frost
heaves from water freezing in the soil. Damage can be
particularly bad when the heaving is greater in one
pavement section than another or when it occurs next
to structures that don’t move, like bridges or manholes.
There are three critical factors in frost heave: freezing
temperatures, a source of water, and susceptible soils.
Frost heave results not just from the natural expansion
of water as it freezes, but from the buildup of a series of
ice layers, called lenses, that form at the freezing front as
it penetrates downward. This can cause heaves of a few
inches to several feet.
Water comes from the normal water table. Problems
are more severe when the water table is near the pave-
ment surface, but significant frost heaving can occur
even when it is many feet below the actual frost depth.
Frost-susceptible soils are fine-grained like silt and
clay. These permit water to move from the water table to
the freezing front through capillary action. Silt is usually
the worst because it has enough capillary action to move
water and its pore spaces are big enough to transmit
large amounts of water. Granular soils like sand have
relatively large pore spaces which generally do not have
sufficient capillary action to be frost susceptible.
Springrthaw
In spring, roads begin to thaw from both the top and bot-
tom. As ice in the pavement melts, water saturates the
road’s base and subgrade. These layers lose strength, like
a handful of mud compared to dry soil. As thawing con-
tinues, melt water becomes trapped in the upper sub-
grade, unable to drain away through the frozen soils
below. Pavements weaken considerably in a very short
time under these conditions.
The weakness can continue for weeks or months after
the pavement is completely thawed. It takes a long time
for water to leave the pavement because frost-susceptible
silt and clay soils are relatively slow to drain.
How heavy vehicles damage roads
Without adequate support, a pavement or gravel surface
deflects too much under trucks carrying heavy loads,
developing cracks or ruts. These then let more moisture
penetrate, worsening the cycle until the road fails
completely. The amount of damage a road sustains is
directly related to the weight of the load and how
often it is applied, according to tests by AASHTO (the
American Association of State Highway and Transporta-
tion Officials). Passenger autos and light duty vehicles
are not a problem. It is trucks carrying legal weight loads
of up to 80,000 GVW over weakened surfaces which do
the damage. When trucks carry loads that are heavier
than the statutory weight limit, the potential for damage
is much higher.
Another factor is the amount of weight and number
of tires on each axle. Damage increases rapidly with
higher axle loads and actually worsens at a faster rate
than the load increases. A nine-ton axle load, for
example, causes about ten times more damage than a
five-ton axle load. Distributing a vehicle’s weight and its
payload over more axles and tires makes the load lighter
at each point of contact, reducing damage to the road.
However, low-inflation tires do not protect roads
from damage. It has been commonly assumed that large
loads carried by off road equipment would have little
adverse affect because they have flotation tires or treads
that allow them to work in soft soils. In actual field tests,
the South Dakota DOT showed that off road equipment
with axle loads that exceeded legal limits caused
damage to asphalt, sealcoat, and gravel roads and
shortened pavement life.
Imposing restrictions on truck weight limits is a
reasonable and practical way to protect vulnerable local
roads when they are at their weakest. Spring weight
limits should begin with the first thawing and continue
until the pavement is again strong enough to carry
normal loads.
2
WINTER SPRING SUMMER FALL
STRENGTH
Restrict
Load
Variationrinrpavementrstrengthrthroughoutrtheryear.
Page 9 of 19
Choosing roads for spring
weight restrictions
Consider the following factors in deciding which roads
or segments should have restrictions.
•PavementTthicknessTAsphalt surfaces of two inches
or less, or total pavement less than 12 inches thick.
•TypeTofTsubgradeFine-grained subgrade soils, like
silts and clays, and areas with a high water table
and poor drainage.
•PastTexperienceAreas with alligator cracking or
rutting that break up every year and need frequent
patching and repair.
•AmountTandTtypeTofTtruckTtrafficConsider all truck
traffic and especially seasonally higher volumes of
trucks carrying heavy loads.
•SurfaceTdeflectionTPavement sections where the
surface deflects or bends 50% more during spring
thaw than in summer. Also, increased deflection
lower than 50% on weaker pavements where
summer deflections are relatively high.
•PavementTage/conditionWeight restrictions can
protect your investment in new pavements and
prolong the life of weak or aging pavements.
Year round restrictions —
Class II and Class B roads
All public roads are considered to be Class A unless des-
ignated otherwise. Vehicle weight restrictions established
in Chapter 348 are intended for travel on Class A high-
ways. Some roads, designated Class II or Class B, have
permanent weight restrictions, with some exceptions.
The state may designate certain highways as Class II.
These are limited to legal loads. No overloads are
allowed, even when the hauler has an overload permit.
About 1600 miles of state highway, mostly in the north
and west, are Class II.
State, county and local authorities may designate all
or a portion of their systems as Class B highways under
Sections 349.15 and 349.16, Wisconsin Statutes. This
designation reduces the permitted weight, year round,
not to exceed 60% of the legal load limits. It takes effect
when signs are posted and remains in effect until the
signs are removed.
Two types of loads are exempted under Class B desig-
nation. The rules now allow local pick-up and delivery
of full legal loads. Also, waste haulers can haul their full
legal load if, because of health concerns, the material
must be removed from a septic or holding tank within 24
hours and if they minimize their travel on the weight-
restricted roads.
Class B highway designation, which in general is
permanent, not seasonal, is intended for situations where
the pavement cannot withstand normal, legal truck
weights. Such roads may not have been constructed to
adequately handle these loads, or they may be roads
through low areas with poor supporting soils. The Class
B designation is well understood by industry. It is a
reasonable option for local authorities when they believe
it is necessary to protect pavement. WisDOT recognizes
this local authority through administrative code. For
example TRANS 255.12(6) requires explicit written
permission for movement on Class B local roads even
if a state permit has been issued.
Posting reduced load limits, such as a 24-ton limit,
is an alternative for protecting roads in weak condition.
Local officials may choose this option if the exemptions
which were added in 2002 to Class B for local pickup
and delivery are unacceptable.
Some bridges may also need protection. Although
their strength is not affected by freezing, bridges may be
weakened by age. Load limits should be determined by
a competent bridge inspector or consulting engineer. As
with roads, local agencies have authority to post weight
limits for bridges under Chapter 349 of the Wisconsin
Statutes. In addition to a sign at the bridge, there must
be an advance warning sign at the nearest intersection.
Determining weight limit
reductions
Aweight reduction of just 20% during critical weeks in
March and April can make a major difference in pave-
ment life according to a study by the Federal Highway
Administration. As weights are reduced further, potential
pavement life increases even more.
Local agencies have the authority to determine
seasonal weight limits on their road systems. About
50% of the normal limit is typical, but establishing limits
that are consistent with those set by the state DOT and
adjoining agencies on nearby roads is strongly recom-
mended. For state highways WisDOT normally uses a
3
Page 10 of 19
spring weight limit of six
tons per single axle and
10 tons per tandem axle.
To be effective, loads
should be reduced at least
20%, while reduction over
60% may have little added
benefit. Nationally, the
average reduction is 44%
which would lengthen
pavement life by about 88%, according to study results.
Consider other factors also, however. Thin or weak
pavements may need significant reductions during spring
thaw; small or even modest load reductions will not
prevent damage.
Since limits will be ineffective if local haulers do not
cooperate with them, the most effective restrictions are
reasonable and directly related to pavement damage.
Otherrremedialractions
Along with restricting load limits, consider other ways of
protecting pavements. When haulers seek exemptions,
consider including special requirements. For example,
a load could be made in two smaller loads. The route
could be modified so that pick-up or delivery is made
at the start or end, or so that the route is traveled in a
different direction. The goal is to minimize the length of
travel and number of truck loads on weak road sections.
Another common approach to exceptions is to
require that deliveries be made at night or in the early
morning when roads may be stronger due to overnight
freezing. Be careful not to overuse this approach. If
substantial subgrade thawing has started, a light frost
in the pavement surface offers limited value.
Physical changes can also help. For
example, where pavements are shaded,
you can increase exposure to sunlight
by removing trees, billboards or other
obstacles. Eliminate standing water in
roadside ditches and fill pavement
surface cracks to reduce the amount
of water getting to the freezing zone.
Improve drainage in the roadbed by
removing frost susceptible soils. A three
foot combined depth of pavement and
replacement base will prevent substantial
subgrade freezing in the coldest winter in
10, according to the 1993 AASHTO
DesignTGuide.
Install geosynthetics between the
free water layer and the freezing zone.
Optimal placement depth and whether
multiple layers are needed remains to
be determined, however. Geosynthetic
reinforcements may also limit damage during spring
thaw by helping bridge weak areas and limiting pave-
ment spread.
When to begin restrictions
It can be difficult to determine when the thaw begins.
In Wisconsin, it generally starts in early March and is
complete by early May. According to 38 years of data
from the Wisconsin Department of Transportation
(WisDOT), the average date for legal load restrictions
on some state highways is March 10. Posting usually
begins between March 1–8 in the southern half of the
state and March 12–18 in the north. The posted road
period generally ends between April 25–May 1 in the
south and May 1–14 in the north. However conditions in
the state can vary considerably from north to south, and
even from road to road in the same county. Unusually
warm winters also affect road posting dates. Local
knowledge of typical thaw periods is extremely helpful.
Since a uniform system of spring weight restrictions
is more understandable and enforceable, it is vital to
coordinate with the Wisconsin DOT, the county, and
adjoining road agencies. Also, when weight limits are
not uniform or when some communities post limits
and others don’t, vulnerable unposted roads may be
damaged by truck traffic taking alternate routes.
Local officials should time their road postings to
coincide with the spring weight restrictions that WisDOT
posts on the state highway system. The county highway
department, WisDOT district maintenance office, and
the WisDOT central maintenance office can tell you
when they will begin.
4
Feb 15
Mar 1
Mar 15
Apr 1
Apr 15
May 15
Jun 1
May 1
1966
1970
1974
1978
1982
1986
1990
1994
1998
2002
Ending dates of
weight restriction
Starting dates of
weight restriction
Wisconsin Spring Weight Limits Season on Class II Road Sections
Load Increase in
reduction pavement life
20% 62%
30% 78%
40% 88%
50% 90%
Page 11 of 19
To decide on a posting date, WisDOT uses informa-
tion from frost tubes buried in pavements around the
state. A liquid in the tubes changes color when it freezes.
District maintenance staff check the tubes periodically to
determine frost depth and location.
There are also about 60 automatic pavement and
weather monitoring stations in place around the state.
By watching reports from these stations on pavement
surface temperatures and at 18 inches below the surface,
county and state highway staffs can better predict when
spring thawing is underway.
For local roads, you generally must use judgment and
experience. However, a Thawing Index (TI)—calculated
like heating degree days used by winter fuel suppliers—
can help you predict when to begin restrictions. Figuring
thawing degree days involves recording daily high and
low air temperatures in your community and making a
simple calculation. For weaker or problem pavements
you may want to record daily highs and lows at the site.
Studies also show that the Thawing Index is more reli-
able for fine-grained soils than coarse-grained ones.
Begin using the Thawing Index when the average
daily temperature rises above 29° F—chosen as a
reference temperature because tests show that an asphalt
pavement surface is 32° F when air temperature is about
29° F. For midwinter thaws, use 31° F as the reference
temperature for the Thawing Index because of lower sun
angle and increased cloud cover in midwinter.
You can use high and low temperature predictions
from a five-day advance weather forecast to project
when load restrictions must take effect. This will allow
you to prepare the public and alert local heavy haulers.
Pavement thickness determines how many thawing
degree days are needed for applying spring load restric-
tions. The FHWA study GuidelinesTforTSpringTHighway
UseTRestrictionshas established “should” and “must”
Thawing Index levels for thick and thin pavements (see
below). The “should” level estimates thaw to the bottom
of the base course. The “must” level estimates thaw to
about four inches below the bottom of the base course.
When to remove restrictions
In general, keep weight restrictions in place until soils
are completely thawed and drained to normal moisture
levels. The most accurate way to tell is by testing for
5
Usual southern
thawing season:
from March 1–8
to April 25–May 1
Usual northern thawing season:
from March 12–18 to May 1–14
90
90
94
94
94
43
43
94
53
53
51
51
45
45
141
8
8
29
18
151
151
10
Prairie
du Chien Madison
Beloit Kenosha
Milwaukee
Portage
Oshkosh
La Crosse
Manitowoc
Appleton
Green Bay
Eagle River
Wausau
Marshfield Stevens
Point
Wisconsin
Rapids
Ashland
Superior
Rice Lake
Hudson
Eau ClaireOsseo
Thawingrconditionsrcanrvaryrconsiderablyrfromrnorthrtorsouth.
Thawing Index levels for posting load restrictions on asphalt
Pavement structure Thawing Index
“Should”rLevel “Must”rLevelr
THINAsphalt 2” or less 10° F-days 40° F-days
Base course 6” or less
THICKAsphalt more than 2” 25° F-days 50° F-days
Base course more than 6”
Thawing
Index
Average Daily
Temperature
Reference
Temperature
= 4° F–days TI 33° F – 29° F
MINUS EQUALS
Compute Thawing Index (TI)
100
0
100
0
High Low Average Daily
TemperaturePLUS DIVIDED
BY TWO
Compute average daily temperature
28° F ÷ 2 38° F + = 33° F
100
0
100
0
EQUALS
Day 1: 33° F - 29° F = 4° F-days
Day 2: 35° F - 29° F = 6° F-days
2-day TI total: 4 + 6 = 10° F-days
1) Determine the average
daily temperature by
adding the day’s high
and low temperatures
and dividing by 2.
2) Subtract the reference
temperature (29° F for spring
thawing or 31° F for midwinter
thaws) from the Daily Average
Temperature. The remainder is
the TI for that day.
CalculatingrtherThawingrIndex
Sample calculation of
Thawing Index for two days:
Page 12 of 19
deflection. However, combining judgement and experi-
ence with an estimate based on the Thawing Index is
very economical and will suffice in many cases.
To make this estimate you must know the Winter
Freezing Index. The Freezing Index is calculated the
same way as the Thawing Index, using 32° F as the
reference temperature. Beginning when the average
daily temperature has been below 32° F for several
days, calculate daily average temperatures. (Add the
high and the low for the day and divide by 2.) Subtract
the average daily temperature from 32° F and record the
result. Keep a running total until spring thawing begins.
This total is the winter’s freezing index in your area.
High and low temperatures reported in the local media
may also work well enough for this purpose.
To calculate the total number of thawing degree
days until the thaw is complete, multiply the Winter
Freezing Index by 0.3. For example, for a Winter
Freezing Index of 1375° F-days, the Thawing Index
would be 412° F-days: 0.3rxr1375r=r412
Implementing local weight limits
Authority
To institute a permanent weight limit on a road, the local
elected board or council should pass an appropriate
ordinance and post the necessary signs. For a temporary
restriction like spring load limits, the “authority in charge
of maintenance” can impose the limits under Section
349.16 of theWisconsinTStatutes.T
It may not be clear who is the “authority in charge of
maintenance.” It is best for the local board or council, at
a regularly scheduled meeting, to specifically identify a
person or position to have that authority. For county
trunk highways, the highway commissioner is commonly
chosen. Towns, villages or cities should designate their
highway superintendent, road foreman, street superin-
tendent, or similarly titled officer. The board or council
should also give this person or position authority to issue
special weight permits.
The local authority can impose weight limits on a
highway or bridge that they believe will be damaged
because of roadbed weakness or other special
conditions. Signs must be posted to give notice of
the restrictions, and these signs must conform to the
current ManualTonTUniformTTrafficTControlTDevicesand
the WisconsinTSupplementto that manual. For bridges
there must be an advance warning sign at the nearest
intersection. Limits become enforceable as soon as
signs are in place.
It can be complicated to analyze the capacities of
individual pavements and bridges. Local authorities may
use their judgement and knowledge of existing pavement
conditions or may hire a consultant to conduct engineer-
ing analyses. Limits based on actual testing will stand
up to potential litigation better than those based on
experience alone.
Legal authority for establishing weight limits is found
in Chapters 348 and 349 of the Wisconsin State Statutes.
Chapter 348 establishes restrictions on the size, weight
and loading of vehicles. Section 348.15 establishes
specific truck weight limitations and exemptions.
Sections 348.25, 348.26 and 348.27 outline the
provisions for permits for vehicles of excessive size and
weight. Such permits are generally issued by the state
Department of Transportation for state highways. Local
officials also have authority to issue credentials for their
road systems under Section 348.26(2).
Chapter 349 gives state and local agencies authority
to regulate movement of heavy vehicles. Section 349.15
provides the authority to establish Class B highways on
local roads. Section 349.16 gives the authority for local
officials to impose special or seasonal weight limitations.
Section 349.17 is the authority for cities, villages, and
towns to establish designated truck routes.
Exemptionsrandrenforcementr
State statutes have many provisions permitting overloads
for specific commodities such as milk and logs. As a
result, some people believe that this special treatment
applies to local roads with load restrictions. This is
not the case. In fact, local weight limits override all
special permits in the statutes. Local officials maymake
exceptions, but are not required to.
Once load limits are posted, numerous requests for
exceptions are likely. Local agencies may make excep-
tions, but it is important to be consistent and reasonable.
Overusing exceptions weakens the effectiveness of load
limit programs.
6
Page 13 of 19
PublicTagencyTvehiclesTareTnotTexemptTfromTweight
andTsizeTrestrictions.All statutory restrictions and locally
adopted weight restrictions apply uniformly to public
vehicles as well as private trucks.
To implement your authority to issue exemptions
under Section 349.16(3) it is best to put the exemptions
in writing. For commodities that will be exempted either
seasonally or permanently, make a good faith effort to
publish these rules. If, as a local official, you intend to
exempt some commodities, you can still restrict their
movement by specifying how often each day they may
travel on a road. You may also require that they travel
at specific times during the day, such as before 7:30 am
when overnight temperatures may have temporarily
strengthened the road. Like the basic exemptions, these
restrictions should be in writing and publicized.
Before posting roads, local agencies should plan how
to enforce the limits. Law enforcement officers can order
an apparent violator off the highway and issue citations.
Repeat violators must pay higher amounts, and the
amount to be paid increases with the amount of weight
over the limit.
State Patrol officers and county deputies are author-
ized to enforce weight limits. The State Patrol offers
annual training sessions on enforcing truck sizes and
weights for local law enforcement officials. Scales used
to enforce weight laws must be certified accurate.
Haulers have another considerable incentive to
comply. Under Section 86.02 of the Statutes, a party
which has caused damage to the highway is liable for
triple the cost to repair the damages. These are collected
through civil court.
Speed enforcement is also important because damage
is increased at high speed.
Permitsr
Haulers with loads over the weight and size limitations
can request permits for travel on state trunk highways
from the Wisconsin DOT. Permits can be for a single trip
or multiple trips and are issued at the WisDOT central
office in Madison.
Except for vehicles authorized in the Statutes to have
excess axle weights (Sections 348.15(3) (bg, br, & bv),
trucks which intend to also use local road systems must
obtain permission from the local maintenance authority.
Local agencies should establish permit procedures
and designate a person with authority to issue them.
Assigning this to the same person who establishes weight
limits is reasonable and convenient. However, if a
different person is issuing permits—the town clerk, for
example—it is a good idea to coordinate with the local
authority which establishes the limits. Local permit forms
may be individualized, but many local officials have
found it useful to copy WisDOT forms.
Single trip permits authorize an overweight or over-
sized vehicle to make one trip over a designated route.
The local authority should carefully select roads and
bridges that can adequately handle the excess load.
Determining these permitted routes can be complex
and may require help from an engineering consultant.
When the state puts roads into “thaw status,” it
reduces maximum weights for single trip permits. It also
suspends the authority for moving overweight loads that
are divisible (like garbage, logs, agricultural products),
and declares certain vulnerable state highways as Class II
roadways which limits the maximum weight during
spring thaw to a GVW of 80,000. Class II roadways may
also be temporarily posted for even lower weight limits.
Signingrforrweightrrestrictionsr
Weight restriction signs are regulatory and should be
white with black lettering to conform with the federal
ManualTonTUniformTTrafficTControlTDevicesTdMUTCDe
and the WisconsinTSupplement. Uniform signing
improves coopera-
tion and makes
enforcement easier.
All weight limit
signs must say:
“by order of” the
local agency.
Class B high-
way signs should
be installed at
intersections with
other highways.
Bridge weight restriction signs must follow instructions
from WisDOT. These signs must include the gross
weight and maximum limits for axle loads. Signs should
be posted at the bridge and also far enough in advance
that trucks can detour around the limited structure.
Permanent special weight signs must be permanently
installed and designate the maximum gross weight.
Temporary weight limits such as spring load restrictions
should also be on standard signs that are reflectorized
and that meet the standards of the MUTCD. Hand
painted and faded signs are not appropriate.
7
BY ORDER OF
TOWN OF FAVREVILLE
BY ORDER OF
TOWN OF FAVREVILLE
BY ORDER OF PACKER COUNTY
BY ORDER OF
PACKER COUNTY
Page 14 of 19
BulletinTNo.TwTrevisedTNovemberTommpT©TCopyrightTWisconsinTTransportationTInformationTCenter.T
WisconsinrTransportationrBulletinrisTaTseriesTofTfactTsheetsTprovidingTinformationTtoTlocalTtown,TmunicipalTandTcountyTofficialsTonTstreetTandThighwayTdesign,Tconstruction,T
maintenance,TandTmanagement.TTheseTfactTsheetsTareTproducedTandTdistributedTbyTtheTWisconsinTTransportationTInformationTCenter,TaTprojectTofTtheTUniversityTofTWisconsinj
Madison,TDepartmentTofTEngineeringTProfessionalTDevelopment,TfundedTasTaTLocalTTechnicalTAssistanceTCenterTbyTtheTFederalTHighwayTAdministration,TWisconsinTDepartmentT
ofTTransportation,TandTUWjExtension.TUWjMadisonTprovidesTequalTopportunitiesTinTemploymentTandTprogramming,TincludingTTitleTIXTrequirements.
CopiesTareTavailableTfreeTwhileTsuppliesTlastTfromTtheTTransportationTInformationTCenter,TqpoTNorthTLakeTStreet,TMadison,TWITrpvmu.T
PhoneyTwmm/qqojqunrzTejmailyTtic@epd.engr.wisc.eduzTURLyThttpy//tic.engr.wisc.edu
8
Communication
Effective communication with the public, your own
agency, and affected haulers is essential. Alert the local
media when weight restrictions are imminent. Remind
drivers of public works trucks that weight restrictions
apply to them too. Contact industries which make local
deliveries or supply local services and tell them what the
limits are and when limits will begin.
Consult with local haulers about ways to protect par-
ticularly vulnerable roads. For example, milk haulers
could alter the order of pick up to lessen the weight at a
bad site, or septic pumpers may limit how full their tanks
are when traveling problem roads to service customers.
Large construction projects that require hauling
heavy construction materials need special coordination
in advance. Local officials and contractors should plan
together well before the limits are imposed. They can
agree on specific hauling routes using roads that are
both strong enough and reasonably efficient.
Advance agreements with contractors and other
heavy haulers can be very effective. Informal agreements
or formal contracts assign responsibility to these haulers
for repairing damage along their routes. Some agencies
require bonds or escrow accounts in advance to ensure
compliance. Inspecting haul routes ahead of time is
important in enforcing these agreements. Photographing
or video taping is also helpful in documenting existing
condition. These techniques establish pavement condi-
tions before spring thaw begins.
The alternative to advance agreements—establishing
very restrictive weight limits after bids are in or construc-
tion is underway—can be very disruptive and costly, and
may result in litigation. Both contractors and local agen-
cies are responsible for this advance coordination.
Summary
Protecting local roads from damage by heavy vehicles is
the responsibility of local authorities. WisconsinTStatutes
provide adequate authority to exercise this control. In
establishing weight restrictions, local authorities must
use judgment and common sense to balance the need
for protecting roads with maintaining commerce and an
efficient transportation system. Close coordination with
Wisconsin DOT and adjoining local agencies is essential
to an effective program. Also, set a good example with
your own agency. Be sure that all publicly-owned
equipment observes the weight restrictions.
Resources
GuidelinesrforrSpringrHighwayrUserRestrictions,
Federal Highway Administration, Report No. FHWA-
TS-87-209, Turner-Fairbank Highway Research Center,
6300 Georgetown Pike, McLean, VA 22101-2296. And
related videotapes.
StaterHighwayrMaintenancerManual,rGuideline 30.06,
January 1, 1993, Wisconsin Department of Transpor-
tation, State Maintenance Engineer for Highways,
PO Box 7916, Madison, WI 53707-7916.
HowrVehiclerLoadsrAffectrPavementrPerformance,
Wisconsin Transportation Information Bulletin, No. 2,
Wisconsin Transportation Information Center–LTAP,
432 N. Lake St., Madison, WI 53706.
Other references
StudyrEffectsrofrOff-RoadrEquipmentrTiresronrFlexible
andrGranularrPavements.An Executive Summary of the
South Dakota Department of Transportation describes
damage to test pavements. The report is available for
download at: http://www.state.sd.us/Applications/HR19
ResearchProjects/oneproject_search.asp?projectnbr=
SD1999-15 (The 131 page report is a 4.4 MB pdf file.)
FrostrHeave:rWhatrcausesritrandrhowrwercanrinterfere
withrit,Special Bulletin #19, November 1995. Written
by Dr. Rich Reid, Asst. Prof. of Civil Engineering, South
Dakota State University, for South Dakota Transportation
Technology Transfer Service.
AGuidertorSpringrHighwayrUserRestrictions:rWhenr
torApply,rHowrLongrtorApply,randrWhenrtorRemove.
TheTBridgeTFactTSheet,Spring 1994, Michigan Local
Technical Assistance Program, Houghton, Michigan.
PostingrandrBondingrLocalrRoads:rASolutionrto
DamagesrCausedrbyrHeavyrHaulers,LTAP Technical
Information Sheet #57, January 1994, by Alan L.
Gesford, LTAP Engineer, Pennsylvania Local Roads
Program, Penn State Harrisburg, 777 West Harrisburg
Pike, Middletown, PA 17057-4898.
WalshrCounty’srLoadrLimitrEnforcementrProgram,by
Harvey Melstad, in TheTCenterTLine,TFall 1990, North
Dakota State University.
LegalrOpinionsby Attorney J.R. Habeck, in the news-
letter of the Wisconsin Towns Association.
Page 15 of 19
PORTAGE COUNTY
MEETING MINUTES
AD HOC ADVISORY
COMMITTEE ON INDUSTRIAL
LIVESTOCK OPERATIONS
PORTAGE COUNTY ANNEX
CONFERENCE ROOMS 1 & 2
1462 STRONGS AVENUE
STEVENS POINT, WI 54481
Wednesday, October 29, 2025 7:00 PM
REMOTE ATTENDANCE & COMMENT
To attend this meeting by telephone : dial 1-872-242-7813, after dialing the number you will then be asked to enter in a
meeting number. Use the following meeting number: 337 011 568, then press #
To attend this meeting by video: Join the meeting now
Page 1 of 2
CALL TO ORDER
The Ad Hoc Advisory Committee on Industrial Livestock Operations meeting was called to order at 7:00pm.
Members Present: Amberle Schwartz, Janell Wehr, Ken Feltz, Tyler Bulgrin, Mike Pagel, Lynn Markham, Christine Mechenich
Staff Attending: Tracy Arnold, Shawn O'Connell, Andrew Senderhauf, Tim Reed, Camryn Brewbaker, Tyler Kunze
CORRESPONDENCE
No Report.
PRESENTATIONS
1. Victoria Ziegler, Department of Natural Resources, Program Coordinator on Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations
(CAFO) — CAFO Overview
Victoria Ziegler presented on how the Department of Natural Resources regulates CAFOs.
2. Tim Jackson, Agricultural Land Use, Planning and Ordinance Specialist and Jenn Chakravorty, Ordinance Specialist
with the Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection — Operational Ordinance Standards under Wis.
Stats. Chapters 92 and 93.
Tim Jackson presented on the Department of Agriculture, Trade, and Consumer Protection Operational Ordinance Standards under
Wis. Stats. Chapter 92 and 93.
REPORTS
3. Special Meeting Attendance Reports (Portage County Ordinance 3.1.47 & 3.1.48)
No Report.
PUBLIC NOTICE
Members of the public who wish to address the Committee on specific agenda items must register their request at this time,
with such comments subject to the public comment ordinance and the reasonable control of the Committee Chair as set
forth in Robert’s Rules of Order.
APPROVAL OF MINUTES
4. Approval of October 15th, 2025 Meeting Minutes
A motion was made by Mike Pagel, seconded by Tyler Bulgrin, to Approve minutes. Motion to Approve minutes carried by voice vote,
with no negative votes.
DISCUSSION/POSSIBLE ACTION
5. Discussion/Possible Action Re: Waste management recommendations as they relate to proposed industrial livestock
operations ordinance
Page 16 of 19
Ad Hoc Advisory Committee on Industrial
Livestock Operations
Meeting Minutes October 29, 2025
Page 2 of 2
The committee discussed waste management recommendations.
6. Discussion/Possible Action Re: Environmental impact recommendations as they relate to proposed industrial livestock
operations ordinance
Line item moved to next meeting date of November 5th, 2025.
7. Discussion/Possible Action: Review of Schedule of Future Agenda and Committee Recommendations
The committee reviewed schedule of future agenda and committee recommendations.
NEXT MEETING DATE November 5th, 2025
There will be a quorum of committee members on Monday, November 3rd for a Farm Tour. Members will meet in the parking lot of the
Portage County Annex Building and carpool to Miltrium Farm in Marathon County. The meeting will be called to order at the Annex
Building and adjourned at the farm. Separate cars will be driven as no quorum is allowed in one vehicle at a time. The next committee
meeting will take place in the Portage County Annex Building, Conference Rooms 1 & 2, on November 5th, 2025 at 7:00pm.
ADJOURNMENT
Meeting adjourned at 10:08pm.
Page 17 of 19
Schedule of Future Agenda and Committee Recommendations
LAST UPDATED 10/29/25
Meeting
Date
Topics Other Info
Fire/Emergency Management
• Documentation and map of facilities on site
• Determine firefighting water needs
• Fire readiness/training
• Pre incident fire safety plan required – once a year
walkthrough, onsite and employee housing, 360
access to facilities & 60-foot clearance for fire
lanes, fire dept has access to all gates/buildings
(Knox box)
• Fire exits every 15,000 sq ft
• Map of site showing housing, water sources and
pumping capacity, and where fuel and other
chemicals are stored
Added October
29th meeting
date
Waste Management/Nutrient Management
Triggers – total animal units
• If existing farm is over 1,000 animal units, ordinance
is triggered once 500+ animal units are added
(proposed but not approved at 10.15.25 meeting)
• Calculate mass balance nitrogen as an educational
tool, make sure it is simple & possibility in a
spreadsheet
• County staff has the discretion to request, review &
verify landowner lease agreements/manure land
application agreements
LWCD & UW
Extension
Presentations
Farm Tour-
Monday, Nov
3rd @8am
Environmental impacts DATCP & DNR
Presentations
Nov 5th Roads, financial security Nathan Check
Nov 19th Public health, population & depopulation, biosecurity State vet & Po
Co Health Dept
Dec 3rd
Page 18 of 19
Page 19 of 19
Source: Portage County website. First collected Nov 13, 2026.