RecordWell Data

Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals — Agenda Packet

City of Green Bay · Brown County · Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals · meeting of Nov 16, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Green Bay

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Agenda of the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals November 16, 2026 Page 1 AGENDA OF THE ZONING & PLANNING BOARD OF APPEALS MONDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 2026, 4:30 PM City Hall, Room 604 - The Harry Maier Room. Virtual attendance is also available via Zoom. A. Zoom Meeting Information. 1. Join Zoom Meeting Online: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/85259382056?pwd=z6OdaYq0gNap7CSvkqqg0Ofv7lQ77t.1 Or call in by phone: +1 312 626 6799 Meeting ID: 852 5938 2056 Passcode: 915604 If you wish to leave a comment for this public meeting, please fill out the online Comment Form prior to the meeting. More detailed Zoom Instructions can be found online. B. Roll Call. 1. Members: Chair Noel Halvorsen, Vice Chair Joshua Koch, Steven Schuchart, Brian Ritter, and Dillon Maass. C. Approval of the Agenda. 1. Approval of the agenda for the Monday, November 16, 2026, meeting of the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals. D. Approval of Minutes. 1. Approval of the minutes from the October 19, 2026, meeting. E. Regular Business. 1. (Appeal 26-30) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from Tim Maertz, applicant, and 1476 University LLC, property owner, requesting approval to deviate from side yard setback standards for a commercial property adjacent to a property used for residential purposes to construct a dumpster within 20 feet of the side yard at 1476 Agenda of the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals November 16, 2026 Page 2 University Avenue (Ald. D. Orlowski, District 5). 2. (Appeal 26-31) Consideration with possible action variance request from Ronald F. Metzler, applicant, and Skyler Vanwinkle, applicant and property owner, requesting approval to deviate from accessory building bulk requirement standards for a one or two-family residence at 3805 Humboldt Road (Ald. J. Grant, District 1). 3. (Appeal 26-32) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from Kelli Lax of Creative Sign Company, applicant, and Shelia Nasgovitz of Goodwill Industries of North Central Wi Inc, property owner, requesting approval to deviate from dimensional standards for a monument sign within a Commercial district at 1660 W Mason Street (Ald. M. Eck, District 11). F. Informational. 1. Next Meeting: December 13, 2026 G. Adjournment. 1. Adjournment of the Monday, November 16, 2026, meeting of the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals. 1) THIS MEETING IS RECORDED: THE VIDEO OF THIS MEETING AND MINUTES ARE AVAILABLE ONLINE AT www.greenbaywi.gov 2) ACCESSIBILITY: Any person wishing to attend who requires special accommodation because of a disability, should contact the City Safety Manager at 920-448-3125 at least 48 hours before the scheduled meeting time so that arrangements can be made. 3) QUORUM: Please take notice that a majority or quorum of the Common Council will attend this Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals meeting and will constitute a meeting of the Common Council for purposes of discussion and information gathering relative to this agenda. 4) REPRESENTATION: The party requesting the communication, or their representative, should be present at this meeting. Report to the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals of the City of Green Bay 100 North Jefferson Street, Green Bay, Wisconsin 54301-5026 greenbaywi.gov MEETING DATE PREPARED BY November 16, 2026 AGENDA ITEM # D.1 Approval of the minutes from the October 19, 2026, meeting. BACKGROUND RECOMMENDATION FISCAL IMPACT ATTACHMENTS 1. BOA Minutes 10.19.2026 MINUTES OF THE ZONING & PLANNING BOARD OF APPEALS MONDAY, OCTOBER 19, 2026, 4:30 PM City Hall, Room 604 - The Harry Maier Room. Virtual attendance is also available via Zoom. A. ZOOM MEETING INFORMATION. 1. Join Zoom Meeting Online: https://us02web.zoom.us/j/85259382056?pwd=z6OdaYq0gNap7CSvkqqg0Ofv7lQ77t.1 Or call in by phone: +1 312 626 6799 Meeting ID: 852 5938 2056 Passcode: 915604 If you wish to leave a comment for this public meeting, please fill out the online Comment Form prior to the meeting. More detailed Zoom Instructions can be found online. B. ROLL CALL. 1. Members: Chair Noel Halvorsen, Vice Chair Joshua Koch, Steven Schuchart, Brian Ritter, and Dillon Maass. Present: Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, and Dillon Maass. C. APPROVAL OF THE AGENDA. 1. Approval of the agenda for the Monday, October 19, 2026, meeting of the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals. Moved by Joshua Koch, seconded by Brian Ritter to amend the agenda by moving Item 5 after Item 6 and to approve as amended. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No— None. Abstain—None. D. APPROVAL OF MINUTES. 1. Approval of the minutes from the September 21, 2026, meeting. Moved by Steven Schuchart, seconded by Brian Ritter to approve. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No— None. Abstain—None. E. REGULAR BUSINESS. 1. (Appeal 26-25) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from Barbara Anderson, applicant and property owner, requesting approval to deviate from driveway setback standards for uncovered parking for a single-family residence within an R1 Low Density Residential District at 2264 Lakeside Place (Ald. J. Prestley, District 6). Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had any conflicts of interest. All members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had received any communication about this matter. All Board members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Jon LeRoy. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Barbara Anderson. Speakers: Jon LeRoy—Staff Barbara Anderson—2264 Lakeside Pl. Section 44-1746 Driveways shall lead from the public right of way to a garage door opening plus 24 inches on either side of said door or to a legal parking space. The applicant seeks to create a driveway which is 22 feet in width with 12.5 feet in width at the right of way of Lakeside Place. The driveway is sought to be approximately 0 feet from the side corner yard along the right of way of Florida Avenue. Moved by Steven Schuchart, seconded by Joshua Koch to open the floor. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No— None. Abstain—None. Moved by Joshua Koch, seconded by Brian Ritter to close the floor. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No— None. Abstain—None. Moved by Steven Schuchart, seconded by Dillon Maass to table this item until the November meeting. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No— None. Abstain—None. 2. (Appeal 26-26) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from Larry Peterson, applicant, and Carol Borremans of Resurrection Lutheran Church ELCA, property owner, requesting approval to deviate from side yard setback and buffer standards for an accessory building adjacent to a residential property in a (PI) Public Institutional District at 1004 Shawano Avenue (Ald. B. Delie, District 10). Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had any conflicts of interest. All members affirmed they did not, except Joshua Koch, stating a conflict of interest and recused himself from participation. Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had received any communication about this matter. All Board members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Jon LeRoy. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Larry Peterson. Speakers: Jon LeRoy—Staff Larry Peterson—1004 Shawano Ave. Section 44-856 Table 44-15 The building setback for a side yard within the PI District is a minimum distance of 10 feet. Applicant seeks 5 feet. Section 44-1964 Perimeter Landscape Buffers The development setback for nonresidential uses adjacent to residentially zoned uses is 20 feet. Applicant seeks 5 feet. Section 44-856 Table 44-15 Maximum Impervious Surface Note b Building height and impervious coverage shall not exceed that permitted in the most restrictive abutting district. The neighboring property is zoned R1 and is a small lot. The impervious surface requirement is 60 percent. The applicant seeks 92 percent impervious surface. Moved by Steven Schuchart, seconded by Brian Ritter to deny. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No—None. Abstain— None. 3. (Appeal 26-27) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from Terrance Sorenson, applicant and property owner, requesting approval to deviate from fencing standards for a parcel located in a residentially zoned district at 2257 East Shore Drive (Ald. J. Prestley, District 6). Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had any conflicts of interest. All members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had received any communication about this matter. All Board members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Jon LeRoy. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Terrance Sorenson. Speakers: Jon LeRoy—Staff Terrance Sorenson—2257 East Shore Dr. Section 44-450 (1) a. Residentially zoned districts. The maximum height of a solid fence or wall within a required front yard or corner side yard setback shall not exceed three feet. Such front yard or corner side yard fences may be increased to a maximum height of four feet if open, decorative, ornamental fencing materials that are less than 50 percent opaque are used or to a maximum height of five feet if open, decorative, ornamental fencing materials that are less than 20 percent opaque are used. The applicant seeks to create a 5-foot-tall privacy fence along the north property line which is 100 percent opaque and a 6-foot tall privacy fence within the side lot lines of the home extending into the front right of way for approximately 99 feet along Lakeside Place and 129 feet along the side lot lines (east and west sides) from Lakeside place south toward the front (along East Shore Drive) of the residence. Moved by Joshua Koch, seconded by Brian Ritter to approve. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No—Steven Schuchart. Abstain—None. 4. (Appeal 26-28) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from James Landry, applicant and property owner, requesting approval to deviate from driveway standards leading to a detached garage for a one or two-family residence at 1154 14th Avenue (Ald. B. DeBaker, District 9). Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had any conflicts of interest. All members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had received any communication about this matter. All Board members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Jon LeRoy. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Mary Jo Landry. Speakers: Jon LeRoy—Staff Mary Jo Landry—1154 14th Ave. Section 44-1746 (2) (b) Driveways shall lead from the public right-of-way to a garage door opening plus 24 inches on either side of said door or to a legal surface parking space. Detached garages. Driveways leading to detached garages shall meet the applicable side or rear setbacks for accessory structures established in the district in which it is situated or shall meet the side setback of an existing detached garage, whichever is less. The applicant is seeking to create a reconstructed driveway which is approximately 48 inches past the side of a garage door and 5 feet from the side yard of the neighboring property. Moved by Steven Schuchart, seconded by Dillon Maass to approve. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No—Joshua Koch. Abstain—None. 5. (Appeal 26-29) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from Jim Wolfe of Vierbicher, applicant, and Brian Wilson, property owner, requesting approval to deviate from floodplain standards and front yard setback standards for an infill parcel at 560 N Henry Street (Ald. D. Orlowski, Distrct 5). Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had any conflicts of interest. All members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had received any communication about this matter. All Board members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Jon LeRoy. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Jim Wolfe. Speakers: Jon LeRoy—Staff Jim Wolfe—400 Security Blvd. Section 44-1193 (1) (a) Standards for development in the floodfringe. All new construction, including placement of manufactured homes, and substantial improvement of residential structures, shall have the lowest floor elevated to or above the flood protection elevation on fill. The fill around the structure shall be one foot or more above the regional flood elevation extending at least 15 feet beyond the limits of the structure. The applicant seeks relief as to not have one foot above flood elevation at least 15 feet beyond the limits of the structure. Section 44-554 Lot dimension and building bulk requirements. Table 44-2 note E Corner properties: The side facade of a corner building adjoining a public street shall maintain the front setback of the adjacent property fronting upon the same public street. If no structure exists on the adjacent property, the setback shall be a minimum of one-half the required front yard setback of the subject property's zoning district. The applicant seeks a front yard setback of 18 feet. The adjacent property fronting the same public street has a front yard setback of 24 feet. Moved by Joshua Koch, seconded by Brian Ritter to approve. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No— None. Abstain—None. 6. (Appeal 26-30) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from Tim Maertz, applicant, and 1476 University LLC, property owner, requesting approval to deviate from side yard setback standards for a commercial property adjacent to a property used for residential purposes to construct a dumpster within 20 feet of the side yard at 1476 University Avenue (Ald. D. Orlowski, District 5). Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had any conflicts of interest. All members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen asked the Board of Appeals members to confirm whether they had received any communication about this matter. All Board members affirmed they did not. Chair Noel Halvorsen affirmed Jon LeRoy. Speakers: Jon LeRoy—Staff Moved by Steven Schuchart, seconded by Brian Ritter to table the item until the November meeting. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No— None. Abstain—None. F. INFORMATIONAL. 1. Next Meeting: November 16, 2026. G. ADJOURNMENT. 1. Adjournment of the Monday, October 19, 2026, meeting of the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals. Moved by Joshua Koch, seconded by Steven Schuchart to adjourn. Motion Passed. Yes—Noel Halvorsen, Steven Schuchart, Joshua Koch, Brian Ritter, Dillon Maass. No— None. Abstain—None. Report to the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals of the City of Green Bay 100 North Jefferson Street, Green Bay, Wisconsin 54301-5026 greenbaywi.gov MEETING DATE PREPARED BY November 16, 2026 Jon LeRoy, Zoning Administrator AGENDA ITEM # E.1 (Appeal 26-30) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from Tim Maertz, applicant, and 1476 University LLC, property owner, requesting approval to deviate from side yard setback standards for a commercial property adjacent to a property used for residential purposes to construct a dumpster within 20 feet of the side yard at 1476 University Avenue (Ald. D. Orlowski, District 5). BACKGROUND The applicant seeks variance relief from one section of the Green Bay Municipal Code, Chapter 44: Zoning Section 44-1964 (1) For non-residential or multifamily (five or more units) uses when adjacent to residentially zoned property or property used for residential purposes, buffers shall be at least 20 feet wide. Applicant seeks a buffer of 13.5 feet. The applicant is seeking to create a dumpster enclosure near the rear of the property. The dumpster is being created to get in compliance with site plan requirements for a change of use of the property to allow for a restaurant/bakery at the former animal clinic site. The dumpster location is located near the intersection of existing legal, non-conforming parking. The structure location is proposed to be 13.5 feet away from an existing residential use along University Avenue. University Avenue is zoned C1 General Commercial, but the property has a current residential use. Thus, the addition to the parcel subjects a dumpster to the 20-foot buffer of Sec. 44-1964 (1). The dumpster is proposed to have room for one trash container and one recycling container. RECOMMENDATION FISCAL IMPACT ATTACHMENTS 1. 26-30 Redacted Application 2. 26-30 Site Plan - PS Redacted ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS VARIANCE APPLICATION Application Deadline: First Tuesday of the Month at 12:00 Noon. DATE: PROJECT #: APPEAL #: APPLICANT INFORMATION: Name: Business Name: Address: City, State, Zip Phone: Email: PROPERTY OWNER INFORMATION (if different from above): Name: Business Name: Address: City, State, Zip: Phone: Email: HAS A SITE PLAN BEEN REVIEWED BY PLANNING STAFF? YES O If you checked “NO”, do not proceed. You must contact a member of the Planning staff to review your site, identify issues with the Zoning Code, and seek potential alternatives. Upon denial of a site plan, a formal variance submission may proceed. PLEASE FILL OUT INFORMATION BELOW REGARDING THE PROPOSED DIMENSIONAL VARIANCE: Location/Address: Tax Parcel Number(s): Describe the Variance Request: List ordinance(s) (number and description) the variance will be impacting (staff will assist with this).THREE STEP TEST -To qualify for a variance, the applicant must demonstrate that their property meets the following three (3) requirements:Does unique physical characteristics of your property prevent the compliance with the ordinance? Explain Would granting the variance be contrary to the public interest? Explain. I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE READ AND FULLY UNDERSTAND THE VARIANCE PROCEDUREAND FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH CITY REQUIREMENTS WILL RESULT IN THIS APPLICATION BEING WITHHELD FROM CONSIDERATION BY THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS.Signature of the Property Owner Signature of Applicant (working as “Agent” for owner)Print Name Print NameDate Date FFICE USE ONLY:Parcel #: Residential $25 Commercial $50District: Zoning:Meeting Date:ubmittal Date:taff Signature:Commercial $Residential $5 SDN/TFM TFM G1.1 RMA ARCHITECTS, INC. 1050 SOUTH GRIDER STREET APPLETON, WISCONSIN 54914 CONTACT: TIMOTHY MAERTZ P: ( C: www.rmaarchitectsinc.com G1.1 TITLE, SHEET INDEX, SITE PLAN NORTH TFM NOTE: SCALE WILL BE HALF IF PRINTED 11X17 A1.1 BASEMENT AND FIRST FLOOR CODE PLANS NORTH SCALE: 1" = 20'-0" G1.1 1 0 30' 50'20' 10' SCALE: NONE 1476 UNIVERSITY AVENUE INTERIOR REMODEL FOR EL MANJAR BAKERY 1476 UNIVERSITY AVENUE GREEN BAY, WISCONSIN 54302 CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS 255041 2/28/26 NORTH 1 0 50' 20' PROJECT LOCATION U N I V E R S I T Y A V E N U E NORTH PLAN FIRST FLOOR - 3,410 S.F. BASEMENT - 3,300 S.F. TYPE II ALTERATION - INTERIOR REMODEL TO CONVERT OFFICE TO BAKERY, INCLUDING SALES FLOOR, PREPARATION AREA AND BAKERY INCLUDING (2) NEW UNISEX TOILET ROOMS NEW STOOP, RAMP AND SLAB AT ENTRY TO MEET ADA INCLUDING HAND RAIL AND RAILINGS. NEW STOOP AND WALK IN FREEZER (FREEZER BY OTHERS) CHANGE IN OCCUPANCY FROM B TO F-1 / M ALL MEP AND HOOD WORK UNDER SEPARATE CONTRACT AND APPROVALS A2.1 FIRST FLOOR PLAN AND DETAILS A7.1 ROOM AND DOOR SCHEDULES, ENLARGED PLAN AND DETAILS A8.1 REFLECTED CEILING PLANS x CODE / LICENSING: 2021 IBC, IEBC, IECC, IMC, IFGC WITH WI AMENDMENTS (SPS 361-366) 2017 ICC A117.1 ACCESSIBILITY CODE CITY OF GREEN BAY ZONING CODE - G2 COMMERICAL BROWN COUNTY x AREA: FIRST FLOOR - 3,410 S.F. BASEMENT FLOOR - 3.300 S.F. x OCCUPANCY: FROM B TO F-1 / M x OCCUPANCY LOAD: 39 x CONSTRUCTION CLASS: EXISTING BUILDING: TYPE VB x FIRE PROTECTION: - NOT SPRINKLED - FIRE EXTINGUISHERS. BUILDING OWNER: 1476 UNIVERSITY AVE LLC 1471 UNIVERSITY AVE. GREEN BAY WI 54302 JOSE HERNANDEZ CONTACT: AVELLA ENTERPRISE LLC 1225 E WISCONSIN AVE APPLETON WI 54911 JOSE AVELLA (9207 BY OTHERS BY OTHERS PROVIDE POLE MOUNTED HANDICAP PARKING SIGN PROVIDE STRIPING FOR HANDICAP PARKING STALL PER LOCAL CODE ADA ENTRY ACCESSIBLE ACCESSIBLE ROUTE ENTRY ENTRY G1.2 GENERAL INFORMATION 1 CB #1 RFAI 03-28-26 1 2 2 CB #2 06-22-26 2 2 SP2.1 1 3 CB #3 10-2-26 3 3 3SP2.1 DUMPSTER ENCLOSURE, DETAILS 5'-0" 13'-6" SDN TFM SP2.1 SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" SP2.1 1 SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" SP2.1 2 1 1/4" STEEL TUBE 3/4" STEEL DOWEL SCALE: 3/4" = 1'-0" SP2.1 7 SCALE: 1/2" = 1'-0" SP2.1 8 SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" SP2.1 6 4'-0" MIN.6'-0"1/2" EXPANSION JOINT 8" CONC. SLAB OVER 6" COMPACTED GRAVEL BASE 18"Ø X 4' DEEP CONC. PIER 6" DIA. STEEL BOLLARD FILLED WITH CONC. 6' ABOVE GRADE & 4' BELOW GRADE PAINTED, TYP. 1'-6" SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" SP2.1 9 6" MIN. DOME TOP OF CONCRETE (TYP.) SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" SP2.1 4 SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" SP2.1 5 SCALE: 1/4" = 1'-0" SP2.1 3 CHAIN LINK FENCE WITH PRIVACY SLATS 6"6'-0" 6'-6" 7'-0" 19'-7" 18'-10" 4" DIA SCHED. 40 PIPE W/ SLOPED MTL CAP. MAX SPACING 6'-0" O.C. SET IN CONC SLAB (TYP.) 'DOG EARED' 5/4 COMPOSITE FENCE BOARDS (TYP.) COLOR BY OWNER 4" DIA SCHED. 40 PIPE W/ SLOPED MTL CAP. MAX SPACING 6'-0" O.C. SET IN CONC SLAB (TYP.) 'DOG EARED' 5/4 COMPOSITE FENCE BOARDS (TYP.) COLOR BY OWNER 19'-7" 18'-10" GATE LATCHDOOR PINS - SEE 7/SP2.1 1'-4" 12" 4" DIA SCHED. 40 PIPE W/ SLOPED MTL CAP. MAX SPACING 6'-0" O.C. SET IN CONC SLAB (TYP.) 5/4 COMPOSITE FENCE BOARDS (TYP.) PAIR OF DOORS, 6'-0" H. 8" R/F CONC. SLAB WITH THICKENED EDGE OVER 6" GRAVEL BASE 1'-4" 12" TREATED 2 x 4 3 PLACES 6" 6'-0"6" 4" DIA SCHED. 40 PIPE W/ SLOPED MTL CAP. MAX SPACING 6'-0" O.C. SET IN CONC SLAB (TYP.) 8" R/F CONC. SLAB WITH THICKENED EDGE OVER 6" GRAVEL BASE (2) #5 CONT. 8" R/F CONC. SLAB WITH THICKENED EDGE OVER 6" GRAVEL BASE SLOPE CONC. SLAB 2" FROM BACK TO FRONT 12'-0" 4" DIA SCHED. 40 PIPE W/ SLOPED MTL CAP. MAX SPACING 6'-0" O.C. SET IN CONC SLAB (TYP.) 'DOG EARED' 5/4 COMPOSITE FENCE BOARDS (TYP.) COLOR BY OWNER TREATED 2 x 4 3 PLACES 2" TUBE STEEL DOOR FRAME, PAINTED 3'-0"4'-0"5'-0" 12'-0" 4" DIA SCHED. 40 PIPE W/ SLOPED MTL CAP. MAX SPACING 6'-0" O.C. SET IN CONC SLAB (TYP.) 'DOG EARED' 5/4 COMPOSITE FENCE BOARDS (TYP.) COLOR BY OWNER 6"6'-0" 7'-0" 6'-6" 2" TUBE STEEL DOOR FRAME, PAINTED 6"6'-0" 7'-0" 8" TREATED 2 x 4 (3 PLACES) INTERIOR REMODEL FOR EL MANJAR BAKERY 1476 UNIVERSITY AVENUE GREEN BAY, WISCONSIN 54302 CONSTRUCTION DOCUMENTS 255041 2/28/26 12'-0" 9'-0" 7 1/2" 18'-4" 7 1/2" 19'-7" 2 SP2.1 3'-0" 4'-0" EQUAL SPACING 4 SP2.1 6,8 SP2.1 5 SP2.1 SLOPE 2" 8" R/F CONC. SLAB OVER 6" GRAVEL BASE 3 SP2.1 9'-0" DOOR 6'-0" O.C. MAX 9'-0" DOOR 5'-7 1/2" 5'-7 1/2" 1'-0" BOLLARD - SEE 9/SP2.1 8 YARD DUMPSTER 6'-10" L. X 6'-10" W. X 6'-2" H. (BY VENDOR) EXISTING SHED TO BE RELOCATED. COORDINATE WITH OWNER 8" R/F CONC. SLAB OVER 6" GRAVEL BASE EXISTING ASPHALT DRIVE AND PARKING LOT. PATCH AS REQUIRED DUE TO NEW CONSTRUCTION EDGE OF EXISTING ASPHALT PROPERTY LINE NORTH NORTH PLAN 3 CB #3 10-2-26 3NEW SHEET 8 YARD DUMPSTER 6'-10" L. X 6'-10" W. X 6'-2" H. (BY VENDOR) 19'-7" 13'-6"± 5'-0" EXISTING BUILDING OVERHANG 8" R/F CONC. SLAB WITH THICKENED EDGE OVER 6" GRAVEL BASE EXISTING SIDEWALK TO REMAIN MIR24° 4'-6" Report to the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals of the City of Green Bay 100 North Jefferson Street, Green Bay, Wisconsin 54301-5026 greenbaywi.gov MEETING DATE PREPARED BY November 16, 2026 Jon LeRoy, Zoning Administrator AGENDA ITEM # E.2 (Appeal 26-31) Consideration with possible action variance request from Ronald F. Metzler, applicant, and Skyler Vanwinkle, applicant and property owner, requesting approval to deviate from accessory building bulk requirement standards for a one or two-family residence at 3805 Humboldt Road (Ald. J. Grant, District 1). BACKGROUND The applicant seeks variance relief from one section of the Green Bay Municipal Code, Chapter 44: Zoning Section 44-588 (2) and (3) (2) The accessory use or structure shall be incidental to and customarily associated with the principal use or structure served. (3) The accessory use or structure shall be subordinate in area, extent, and purpose to the principal use or structure served. The applicant seeks to create an addition on to a detached structure which is an accessory building being used as a garage. The total square footage of the proposed accessory garage is 1,904 square feet. This addition will make the principal use subordinate in area to the accessory uses/structures. Section 44-590 (b) (3) In no case shall the total floor area of an attached garage, carport, or other accessory structure exceed the ground floor area of the principal building located on the same lot. This parcel had a hearing at the September 2026 meeting of the Board of Appeals. The appeal for an accessory garage exceeding bulk requirements was denied at the time. The applicant has since been in contact with staff and has modified the request for a detached garage size at approximately 10 percent less of what was originally proposed for an addition to a detached accessory garage. Staff has maintained the notion that if an appeal is denied, an applicant can reapply for a Board of Appeals variance request for the same question if one year has passed from the original hearing or if significant changes have occurred to a site plan. This is based off Section 44-82 (2) f. which states the following: Re-application time-period. The Plan Commission will not consider any application of a property owner or owner's designated agent for a zoning map amendment within a one-year period following a denial of the same request by the Common Council, except that the Plan Commission may permit a new application if the request is significantly altered or at the discretion of the Zoning Administrator for a different zoning district or for amended property boundaries. This language is set forth in the administration of the Plan Commission. This language is not explicit in the role of Zoning Board of Appeals administration. With this in mind, the applicant feels they have made changes which are applicable for an additional hearing. Staff has determined this item can be heard during the November 2026 meeting. page 2 of 3 The original total square footage for a detached accessory garage was requested at 2,027 square feet in September. The new proposed structure has an addition to the existing 720 square foot garage of the following update: Proposed main addition area to the existing detached garage: 23' x 48' = 1,104 square feet Proposed hallway attaching the additional area to the existing detached garage: 23' x 3.5' = 80.5 square feet Existing detached garage area: 720 square feet Total Space: 1,904.5 square feet The existing first floor principal use for the structure is 1,781.4 square feet. The existing structure for the attached three-car garage is approximately 1,107 square feet. The overall footprint of the main building (principal residence and attached garage) is about 2,888 square feet. The existing detached accessory garage is approximately 720 square feet. These two existing accessory structures/uses (the attached garage and detached garage) combined, already total at or just above the restrictions of 44-590 (3). The applicant is seeking to create an addition to the existing accessory structure which would bring the new size from 720 square feet to 1,904 square feet. The previous proposal requested approximately 2,027 square feet. The applicant submits this change to be a significant change. This proposal would create an accessory area which exceeds the principal area by about 1,230 square feet. Staff does not have an alternative to achieve extra ground floor square footage to meet code requirements within the existing footprint of the principal structure. The principal structure could be expanded. If that were to occur, the ratio of expansion of accessory structures could increase. For instance, if the ground floor principal structure were expanded by 1,230 square feet, then the proposed accessory garage addition would be in compliance with 44-590 (b) 3. and 44-588 (2) and (3) The proposed expansion will exceed standards for accessory garage height and overall accessory building size, but those variables are subject to approval from the Plan Commission and Common Council as a separate question which is not under the jurisdiction of the Board of Appeals. The applicant has submitted with this application a reference to an approved plan from earlier in the summer for driveway replacement/expansion. Inspections staff reviewed and approved a driveway replacement or expansion for residential purposes. The initial email, application, and site plan are included with this report. Inspections staff approved a request for concrete work but did not make approvals for a building expansion. The initial email included plans for the conceptual accessory building expansion, but that application is a separate process which later led to the initial appeal heard during the September 2026 meeting of the Board of Appeals. RECOMMENDATION FISCAL IMPACT ATTACHMENTS 1. 26-31 Application November 2026 Redacted 2. 26-31 Signature Page 3. 26-31 Supplemental Information Provided by Applicant 4. 26-31 Updated Site Plan page 3 of 3 5. 26-31 AI Generated Concetual Rendering 6. 26-31 Email Application [EXTERNAL] Permit for concrete - 3805 Humboldt Rd, Green Bay 7. 26-31 Building Plan Attachment submited with Concrete Permit Request 8. 26-31 Approved BuildingPermit2026061708323795 9. 26-31 Conditionally Approved Site Plan ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS VARIANCE APPLICATION Application Deadline: First Tue sday of the Month at 12:00 Noon. DATE: PROJECT #: APPEAL #: APPLICANT INFORMATION: Name: Business Name: Address: City, State, Zip: Phone: Email: PROPERTY OWNER INFORMATION (if different from above): Name: Business Name: Address: City, State, Zip: Phone: Email: HAS A SITE PLAN BEEN REVIEWED BY PLANNING STAFF? YES NO If you checked “NO”, do not proceed. You must contact a member of the Planning staff to review your site, identify issues with the Zoning Code, and seek potential alternatives. Upon denial of a site plan, a formal variance submission may proceed. PLEASE FILL OUT INFORMATION BELOW REGARDING THE PROPOSED DIMENSIONAL VARIANCE: Location/Address: Tax Parcel Number(s): Describe the Variance Request: List ordinance(s) (number and description) the variance will be impacting (staff will assist with this). THREE STEP TEST - To qualify for a variance, the applicant must demonstrate that their property meets the following three (3) requirements: Does unique physical characteristics of your property prevent the compliance with the ordinance? Explain Would granting the variance be contrary to the public interest? Explain. Why would not getting the variance unreasonably prevent you from using the property for a permitted purpose (leaving the property owner without any use that is permitted for the property) or would render conformity with such restrictions unnecessarily burdensome? I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE READ AND FULLY UNDERSTAND THE VARIANCE PROCEDURE AND FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH CITY REQUIREMENTS WILL RESULT IN THIS APPLICATION BEING WITHHELD FROM CONSIDERATION BY THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS. Signature of the Property Owner Signature of Applicant (working as “Agent” for owner) Print Name Print Name Date Date OFFICE USE ONLY: Parcel #: Residential $225 Commercial $350District: Zoning: Meeting Date: Submittal Date: Staff Signature: Receipt #: Commercial $700Residential $450 Work started or completed: Caution: This email originated from a sender outside of your organization. Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. From: Skyler Van Winkle To: Inspection Website Mail Subject: [EXTERNAL] Permit for concrete - 3805 Humboldt Rd, Green Bay Date: Monday, June 15, 2026 8:24:16 AM Attachments: image.png (Bid Plan).pdf Good Morning, We are planning an addition to our back detached garage later this summer. Our concrete contractor is looking to start int he next 7-10 days with his work. Hoping you can assist with the permit for the flatwork. I have attached the build plans I have. The 24x30 garage on the left is the current building. The addition will be to the left as seen in the plans. I have also included an aerial photo to give a general idea where the new concrete will be. There will be a small driveway addition just in front of the new garage pad: Concrete garage pad/driveway extension DEPARTMENT OF COMMUNITY AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT It shall be unlawful to conceal or proceed with any part of the work on this building until official approval has been given. THE FOLLOWING INSPECTIONS ARE REQUIRED: Bldg:  Footing ❑ Rough In/Framing ❑ Foundation/Wall ❑ Insulation ❑ Tar/Tile/Stone  Final Hvac: ❑ Rough In ❑ Final Elec: ❑ Service ❑ Rough In ❑ Final Plbg: ❑ Sewer ❑ Groundwork ❑ Rough In ❑ Final THIS BUILDING PERMIT COVERS: PERMIT EXPIRES: 06/17/2027 Please be advised that any work within or around the right-of-way that would affect a public tree may be subject to fees as outlined by the City of Green Bay Tree and Stump Removal Policy. IT IS UNLAWFUL TO COMMENCE WORK BEFORE THIS CERTIFICATE IS PLACED IN A CONSPICUOUS PLACE ON THE PREMISES THIS CERTIFIES THAT A BUILDING PERMIT HAS BEEN ISSUED TO SKYLER & CARRIE VANWINKLE Authorizing such building, repairing, or remodeling as shown in the application, plans, and specifications on file in the office of the Building Inspector, City Hall, Green Bay, Wisconsin Address: 3805 HUMBOLDT RD Parcel # 21-391 Project # 124490 Dated: 6/17/2026 LoganKr BUILDING INSPECTOR NOTICE: No wiring shall start until an electrical permit is obtained. An electrical permit signed by the owner or licensed electrical contractor is required before wiring can begin. NOTICE: It is the general contractor’s responsibility to schedule all applicable inspections. Please post this permit in a window visible from the street when work commences and remove after final inspection has been approved. Scan QR code to schedule inspections or call (920) 448-3300 between 8 am - 4 pm at least one business day prior to inspection date needed. Report to the Zoning & Planning Board of Appeals of the City of Green Bay 100 North Jefferson Street, Green Bay, Wisconsin 54301-5026 greenbaywi.gov MEETING DATE PREPARED BY November 16, 2026 Jon LeRoy, Zoning Administrator AGENDA ITEM # E.3 (Appeal 26-32) Consideration with possible action on a variance request from Kelli Lax of Creative Sign Company, applicant, and Shelia Nasgovitz of Goodwill Industries of North Central Wi Inc, property owner, requesting approval to deviate from dimensional standards for a monument sign within a Commercial district at 1660 W Mason Street (Ald. M. Eck, District 11). BACKGROUND The applicant seeks variance relief from one section of the Green Bay Municipal Code, Chapter 30: Signs Table 30-2 The maximum height of a monument sign is limited to 6 feet. The applicant requests a 21-foot-tall monument sign. The applicant is seeking to replace an existing sign which has been damaged at Goodwill on West Mason Street. They are seeking to create a freestanding monument sign which is 21 feet in height and 11 feet in width. A monument sign is defined as follows: A type of freestanding sign where at least three-fourths of the horizontal length of the sign is permanently fixed to a decorative base, the full horizontal length of which is anchored to the ground. The proposed signage has a ratio of 1:1 for the affixed ground base to sign ratio. The applicant believes the sign to be more in alignment with a pylon sign. A pylon sign is defined as follows: A type of freestanding sign erected on shafts, posts, walls, or piers that are solidly affixed to the ground and not attached to a building. A pylon sign shall be considered as one sign, though it may have two or more faces. Pylon signs can be up to 30 feet tall in this district, but must be erected by shafts/posts/walls/or piers and must maintain a minimum clearance of 10 feet. If the proposed sign were to be considered a pylon sign, its affixed base inherently creates a clearance of 0 feet. The applicant can create a sign which is similar in nature to the existing signage and utilize pylons which do not exceed more than 3/4 of the horizontal length of the sign or shrink the height of a monument sign down to six feet to meet the code. RECOMMENDATION page 2 of 2 FISCAL IMPACT ATTACHMENTS 1. 26-32 Application Redacted 2. 6856_Goodwill_101926 3. 26-32 Pylon Sign Graphic 4. 26-32 Monument Sign Graphic 5. 26-32 Street View of Existing Sign Sept 2026 List ordinance(s) (number and description) the variance will be impacting (staff will assist with this). THREE STEP TEST - To qualify for a variance, the applicant must demonstrate that their property meets the following three (3) requirements: Does unique physical characteristics of your property prevent the compliance with the ordinance? Explain Would granting the variance be contrary to the public interest? Explain. Why would not getting the variance unreasonably prevent you from using the property for a permitted purpose (leaving the property owner without any use that is permitted for the property) or would render conformity with such restrictions unnecessarily burdensome? I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE READ AND FULLY UNDERSTAND THE VARIANCE PROCEDURE AND FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH CITY REQUIREMENTS WILL RESULT IN THIS APPLICATION BEING WITHHELD FROM CONSIDERATION BY THE ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS. Signature of the Property Owner Signature of Applicant (working as “Agent” for owner) Print Name Print Name Date Date OFFICE USE ONLY: Parcel #: Residential $225 Commercial $350District: Zoning: Meeting Date: Submittal Date: Staff Signature: Receipt #: Commercial $700Residential $450 Work started or completed: Sheila Nasgovitz, Director of Marketing 10/20/26 DETAIL VIEW SCALE: 1/4” = 1’ SIDE A & B ARE IDENTICAL 30" 20" CS DECAL: CS-BL-9.5 30" (2'-6") 24" (2'-0") VO 18" LOGO 78.375" (6'-6 3/8") OAH 252" (21'-0") CAP 132" (11'-0") BASE 128" (10'-8") POLE COVER 120" (10'-0") 124" (10'-4") 6” ALUM CAP , P-2 GOODWILL LOGO & TENANT SPACE TO BE ROUTED INTO POLE COVER & BACKED W/ LEXAN CWC DIG PRINT ON CLEAR VINYL W/ GLOSS LAM, 1ST SURFACE (® TO BE V-3) 3” P-2 FABRICATED ALUM BASE, P-2 3” ALUM CAP , P-5 NON-LIT FABRICATED ALUM POLE COVER, P-1 36" 24" 96" (8'-0") CUSTOMER SIGNATURE FOR DESIGN APPROVAL: COLORS: 505 LAWRENCE DR, DE PERE, WI 54115 920.336.8900 CREATIVESIGNCOMPANY .COM REVISION LOG: INTL DATE DESCRIPTION CONCEPTUAL DRAWING ONLY CUSTOMER RESPONSIBILITIES All sizes and dimensions are illustrated for client conception of the project and are not to be understood as being exact size or exact scale. Renderings, including lighting effects, opacities, and coloration, are an approximation. Please review all drawing details closely, as Creative Sign will produce signs as approved drawing indicates. Some changes may occur based on production needs. While Creative Sign will make all efforts to correct any obvious spelling or grammatical errors, the customer is responsible for confirming that the above copy, including names and titles, appear as desired. Creative Sign will make every effort to closely match colors, including PMS, where specified. We cannot guarantee exact matches due to varying compatibility of surface materials and paints used. THIS DRAWING IS THE PROPERTY OF CREATIVE SIGN CO, INC. This is an original, unpublished drawing by Creative Sign Co, Inc. It is for your personal use, in conjunction with a project being planned for you by Creative Sign Co, Inc. It is not to be shown to anyone outside of your organization nor is it to be used, reproduced, copied or exhibited in any fashion. Use of this design or the salient elements of this design in any sign done by any other company, without the expressed written permission of Creative Sign Co, Inc., is forbidden by law and carries a civil forfeiture of up to 25% of the purchase price of the sign. CONTACT YOUR SIGN CONSULTANT TO PURCHASE THE RIGHTS TO THIS DESIGN. SIGNATURE DATE BV NM NM NM 10/05/2026 10/12/2026 10/14/2026 10/19/2026 NEW PAGE ONLY 1 TENANT CAP SIZE DESIGN/TENANT CLIENT: LOCATION: DRAWN BY: SALESPERSON: DATE: LEAD: PAGE: GOODWILL INDUSTRIES 1660 W MASON, GREEN BAY WI NICOLE M KELLI L 08/25/2026 6856 3 EXISTING VIEW N.T .S. LOCATION VIEW (AFTER) SCALE: 1/8” = 1’ REMOVE & DISPOSE OF EXISTING PYLON OPTION C C-1/P-1 WHITE C-3/V-3 ORACAL 751-070 BLACK VINYL C-4 PMS REFLEX BLUE CVC P-2 PMS 541 C QUANTITY: PHOTO EYE/TIMER: MOUNTING: INSTRUCTION: SQ FT: 1 D/F ILLUMINATED SIGN BY ELECTRICIAN DIRECT EMBEDMENT PRODUCE & INSTALL 74.7 SQ FT BEFORE PRODUCTION SURVEYREQUIRED SURVEY SITE, SLOPE FOUNDATION BEFORE PRODUCTION INFOREQUIRED INFO ORDINANCE NIGHT VIEW N.T .S. FILL POSSIBLY NEEDED BY OTHERS 132" 11'-0" 32" 2'-8" 213" 17'-9" 6" 183" 15'-3"

Source: City of Green Bay website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.