RecordWell Data

Packet

City of Stoughton · Dane County · meeting of Nov 17, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Stoughton

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

OFFICIAL NOTICE AND AGENDA Notice is hereby given that the Community Affairs/Council Policy Committee of the City of Stoughton, Wisconsin will hold a regular or special meeting as indicated on the date, time and location given below. Date/Time : Tuesday November 17, 2026 at 6:30pm- NOTE DIFFERENT TIME! Location: The meeting of the CA/CP will be held as a hybrid meeting (virtually and in person). In Person: Council Chambers 321 S Fourth St. Stoughton, WI. 53589 (2nd Floor Public Safety Building) Virtual: Join with Team Join: https://teams.microsoft.com/meet/2662347214190843? p=NpRmVxeWgEH2nhd2y2 Meeting ID: 266 234 721 419 084 3 Passcode: q8Me7fM3 Need help? | System reference Dial in by phone +1 929 -352-2678,,514498995# United States, New York City Find a local number Phone conference ID: 514 498 995# Members: Jonathan Schroerlucke, Adrienne Nienow, Greg Jenson, Mike Vinneau, Mark Sinnott, John Otterson, and Mayor Tim Swadley (ex officio) Call To Order Roll Call And Verification Of Quorum Certification Of Compliance With Open Meetings Law Communications Approve October 6, 2026 CACP Minutes CACP MINUTES 10.6.26.PDF Old Business Discussion And Possible Action Regarding Proposed Amendments To The Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) Expenditure Manual Relating To Automatic License Plate Reader (ALPR) System Acquisiotions CIP PURCHASING POLICY - ALPRS.PDF Discussion And Possible Action Regarding Ordinance No. [_], Creating Chapter 2, Article VIII Of The Stoughton Municipal Code Relating To Surveillance Technology And Automatic License Place Reader (ALPR) Systems ORDINANCE CHAPTER 2 - ARTICLE VIII.PDF New Business Discussion And Possible Action Regarding Ordinance No. [_], Creating Chapter 2, Article IV, Division [ ] Of The Stoughton Municipal Code Establishing A Surveillance Technology Oversight Board ORDINANCE CHAPTER 2 - ARTICLE IV.PDF Future Agenda Items Onboarding Documents- Creating An Index Open Records Review Process Adjournment 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Documents: 6. 6.a. Documents: 6.b. Documents: 7. 7.a. Documents: 8. 8.a. 8.b. 9. OFFICIAL NOTICE AND AGENDA Notice is hereby given that the Community Affairs/Council Policy Committee of the City of Stoughton, Wisconsin will hold a regular or special meeting as indicated on the date, time and location given below. Date/Time : Tuesday November 17, 2026 at 6:30pm- NOTE DIFFERENT TIME! Location: The meeting of the CA/CP will be held as a hybrid meeting (virtually and in person). In Person: Council Chambers 321 S Fourth St. Stoughton, WI. 53589 (2nd Floor Public Safety Building) Virtual: Join with Team Join: https://teams.microsoft.com/meet/2662347214190843? p=NpRmVxeWgEH2nhd2y2 Meeting ID: 266 234 721 419 084 3 Passcode: q8Me7fM3 Need help? | System reference Dial in by phone +1 929 -352-2678,,514498995# United States, New York City Find a local number Phone conference ID: 514 498 995# Members: Jonathan Schroerlucke, Adrienne Nienow, Greg Jenson, Mike Vinneau, Mark Sinnott, John Otterson, and Mayor Tim Swadley (ex officio) Call To Order Roll Call And Verification Of Quorum Certification Of Compliance With Open Meetings Law Communications Approve October 6, 2026 CACP Minutes CACP MINUTES 10.6.26.PDF Old Business Discussion And Possible Action Regarding Proposed Amendments To The Capital Improvement Plan (CIP) Expenditure Manual Relating To Automatic License Plate Reader (ALPR) System Acquisiotions CIP PURCHASING POLICY - ALPRS.PDF Discussion And Possible Action Regarding Ordinance No. [_], Creating Chapter 2, Article VIII Of The Stoughton Municipal Code Relating To Surveillance Technology And Automatic License Place Reader (ALPR) Systems ORDINANCE CHAPTER 2 - ARTICLE VIII.PDF New Business Discussion And Possible Action Regarding Ordinance No. [_], Creating Chapter 2, Article IV, Division [ ] Of The Stoughton Municipal Code Establishing A Surveillance Technology Oversight Board ORDINANCE CHAPTER 2 - ARTICLE IV.PDF Future Agenda Items Onboarding Documents- Creating An Index Open Records Review Process Adjournment 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. Documents: 6. 6.a. Documents: 6.b. Documents: 7. 7.a. Documents: 8. 8.a. 8.b. 9. MINUTES COMMUNITY AFFAIRS/COUNCIL POLICY OF THE CITY OF STOUGHTON Tuesday, October 6 , 202 6 @ 6:0 5 pm The meeting of the CA/CP was held as a hybrid meeting (in person and virtually). At 321 S Fourth St . and Microsoft Teams 1. Call to Order : The meeting of the Community Affairs/Council Policy Committee was called to order by Chair Adrienne Nienow at 6:0 0 pm 2. Roll Call Present : Adrienne Nienow, Greg Jenson, Mark Sinnott, Mike Vinneau, Jonathan Schroerlucke , John Otterson, Mayor Tim Swadley Absent : Guests : Communication- The Dane County Food Composting Program. Dane County representatives will be at Mandt Park on November 7 to assist residents with registration and provide access to the food compost bins. 3. Approval of Minutes Motion: Moved by Schroerlucke , seconded by Vinneau , to approve the minutes of the September 1 , 202 6 , meeting minutes . Vote: Motion carried unanimously ( 6 – 0). 4. Discussion: Creating a Policy for Procurement, Evaluation, and Oversight of ALPR and/or Other Surveillance Technologies The committee discussed the development of an ordinance and accompanying policy governing Automatic License Plate Reader (ALPR) and other surveillance technologies. It was discussed that the ordinance should establish the legal framework, while the policy should serve as an administrative guide for implementation. 5. Updating the CIP Expenditure Manual - Automatic License Plate Reader System Purchases The committee reviewed the draft amendment to the CIP Purchasing Policy for Automatic License Plate Reader (ALPR) system purchases. Discussion focused on clarifying policy language, refining definitions, and establishing measurable standards within the policy. Members also discussed the scope and definition of surveillance technologies, including how the policy may apply to existing camera systems already in use by the City. Additionally, the committee considered the concept of a Surveillance Technology Oversight Committee and discussed the potential role, structure, and responsibilities of an external review body for surveillance technology proposals. The committee directed members to continue refining the document in coordination with the City Attorney to address legal considerations, improve clarity, and further develop the policy framework. 6. Future Agenda Items  Onboarding documents  Surveillance Technology Oversight board  Open records review proces s 7. Adjournment Motion: Moved by Jenson, seconded by Schroerlucke , to adjourn the meeting. Vote: Motion carried unanimously ( 6 -0) Time: The meeting adjourned at 7:20pm Updating the CIP Expenditure Manual (Policy) Amending Section II - Special Procurement Procedures Amend by adding subsection E.: E. Automatic License Plate Reader (ALPR) System Acquisitions: An ALPR system acquisition means any attempt or action to purchase, lease, borrow, accept by gift, grant, or donation, enter into a free trial, pilot program, or demonstration agreement for, upgrade, renew, substantially modify, or obtain ongoing access to an ALPR system (including any system, software, hardware, or computer algorithm used to convert images of license plates into computer- readable data) operated by the City, another governmental agency, or a private entity, regardless of cost or funding source. ALPR System Purchasing Guidelines: ALPR system purchases are strictly governed by Chapter 2, Article VIII of the Stoughton Municipal Code. Prior to encumbering funds, submitting a grant application, executing an agreement, accepting a trial or donation, or seeking budget authorization, the requesting Department Head must complete all mandatory pre-acquisition procedures set forth in Chapter 2, Article VIII, including: 1. Submitting the required Screening Report, Location and Necessity Analysis, and Proposed Use Policy at least sixty (60) days prior to council consideration; 2. Completing legal review by the City Attorney and advisory review by the Surveillance Technology Oversight Board (established under Chapter 2, Article IV); and 3. Obtaining affirmative authorization from the Common Council by resolution following a public hearing. Any contract, agreement, trial, or acquisition executed without full compliance with Chapter 2, Article VIII is voidable by the City, and no CIP or municipal funds may be expended pursuant to an unauthorized agreement. -- Archived draft (adapted for ordinances): …require Department Heads to follow the ALPR System Screening Process outlined below, and also require the Council to adopt a resolution finding (i) substantial evidence that the system’s potential benefits outweigh its potential harms; (ii) that the vendor/supplier is transparent, accountable, and reliable; (iii) that the proposed number of cameras and camera locations are the minimum necessary to achieve a demonstrated public benefit, that each location has been justified individually, and that cameras are deployed only at major ingress and egress points of the community and not for routine monitoring of activity within the community; and (iv) that the technology: 1. does not violate individual liberty, reasonable expectations of personal privacy, or freedom of speech; 2. does not act as a liability shield, preventing those from deploying or using it from being legally responsible for their actions; and 3. has been the subject of at least one public hearing. ALPR System Screening Process: 1. Requirement for the ALPR System Screening Report a. Prior to seeking authorization to purchase an ALPR system, the Department Head shall prepare an ALPR System Screening Report. b. The Report shall be published on the City’s website and submitted to the Common Council at least 60 days prior to any authorization request. c. Independent Review Prior to Authorization. Prior to Common Council consideration of an ALPR System Purchase, the completed ALPR System Screening Report, Camera Location and Necessity Analysis, and Proposed ALPR Use Policy shall undergo formal review as follows: (1) City Attorney Review. The City Attorney shall review the Report, proposed vendor contracts, and Proposed ALPR Use Policy and submit a written legal opinion to the Common Council assessing constitutional compliance, vendor liability and data ownership terms, and compliance with applicable state and federal law. (2) Citizen Oversight Board Review. The [Surveillance Technology Oversight Board / designated citizen committee] shall review the Report and supporting materials during the sixty (60) day public review period and submit a written recommendation to the Common Council regarding privacy impacts, community necessity, and proposed safeguards. 2. Contents of the ALPR System Screening Report The Report shall include, at minimum, the following components: A. Purpose and Need The Report shall identify: a. The specific public purpose, public safety objective, or operational need the ALPR system is intended to address. b. Evidence supporting the conclusion that the proposed technology is likely to achieve the stated objective. c. An explanation of why existing practices, personnel, or less intrusive alternatives are insufficient to meet the identified need. B. Technology Description The Report shall include a description of: a. All hardware, software, algorithms, databases, and data sources used and accessed by the system. b. All information collected, generated, retained, analyzed, or shared by the system. c. Any artificial intelligence, machine learning, automated decision-making, facial recognition, behavioral analysis, or biometric capabilities associated with the system. d. Known capabilities, limitations, error rates, and failure modes of the system. C. Vendor Accountability Review The Report shall include an assessment of the vendor’s qualifications, responsible business practices, and accountability, including: a. Whether the vendor provides clear and accurate representations of system capabilities and limitations. b. Whether the vendor accepts contractual responsibility for defects, misrepresentations, misuse, negligence, inadequate safety controls, or violations of contractual obligations. c. Whether the vendor seeks contractual provisions limiting liability, accountability, transparency, or legal remedies available to the City. d. The ownership and control structure of the vendor, including: i. The legal entity providing the ALPR system; ii. Any parent company, subsidiary, affiliate, or controlling entity with ownership or operational authority over the vendor; and iii. Any ownership structure that may affect accountability, contractual obligations, access to data, or regulatory oversight. e. Whether the vendor’s products have caused documented harms and, if so, whether responsibility for those harms can be reasonably determined. D. Whether the vendor has a documented history of compliance with applicable laws, court orders, audits, regulatory actions, contractual obligations. Surveillance and Safety Assessment The report shall include an assessment of the system’s surveillance and safety characteristics, including: a. Whether the system captures, records, stores, or transmits images, video, audio, or location information. b. Whether the system tracks, logs, maps, or analyzes vehicle or individual movements. c. Whether the system creates records that can be used to reconstruct travel patterns, associations, habits, or activities. d. Whether the system enables secondary uses, commercial exploitation, or data sharing beyond the stated purpose. e. The location, storage, and management of data collected by the system, including: i. Where ALPR data, metadata, backups, audit logs, and related records are stored; ii. Whether data are maintained on City-owned infrastructure, vendor-controlled systems, third-party systems, or cloud- hosted platforms; and iii. Any legal, contractual, technical, or operational factors affecting the City's control over its data. f. Whether the vendor, its affiliates, subcontractors, service providers, or other customers may access, view, analyze, use, or otherwise interact with City data, and the circumstances under which such access may occur. g. Whether the system shares data with other governmental entities, private organizations, regional networks, vendor- operated databases, or other third parties, including: i. Whether such sharing is enabled by default; ii. Whether the City may fully disable, limit, or control such sharing; and iii. The procedures required to restrict or terminate such sharing. h. Whether the data collected by the system may be searched, queried, or accessed by external agencies, and the conditions, approvals, agreements, or permissions required before such access may occur. i. Whether the City retains sole ownership and control of all data collected, generated, maintained, or stored through operation of the system. j. Whether the vendor claims any ownership interest, license, derivative rights, analytics rights, artificial intelligence training rights, commercialization rights, or other proprietary interests in data collected through operation of the system. k. Whether the vendor may retain, use, aggregate, disclose, analyze, sell, license, or otherwise benefit from City data during or after the term of the agreement. l. Whether the vendor is contractually required to return or permanently delete all City data upon expiration or termination of the agreement, and whether the vendor will provide written certification confirming the completion of such deletion or return. m. The extent of human oversight over automated functions. n. Whether authorized personnel can promptly suspend or disable the system. o. Existing or proposed independent oversight mechanisms. p. Procedures available for individuals to correct inaccuracies and contest misuse. q. Safeguards for data security, access controls, retention schedules, and deletion practices. E. Constitutional Rights Assessment The Report shall evaluate potential impacts on constitutional rights, including: a. Privacy and Fourth Amendment Considerations i. Whether the system collects information about individuals not suspected of wrongdoing. ii. Whether individuals would reasonably expect personal privacy in the information collected. iii. Whether the system enables continuous, long-term, or retrospective location tracking. iv. Whether less intrusive alternatives could achieve the same objective. v. Proposed limits on the collection, retention, sharing, access, and use of data. b. First Amendment Considerations i. Whether the system may discourage lawful speech, assembly, association, religious exercise, or political activity. ii. Whether individuals may alter lawful behavior due to awareness of monitoring. iii. Whether the system could disproportionately affect particular viewpoints, organizations, or communities. c. Due Process and Equal Protection Considerations i. System accuracy and reliability. ii. Potential consequences of errors, false positives, or incorrect matches. iii. Whether certain communities are more likely to be subjected to surveillance. iv. Procedures available to contest inaccuracies or misuse. d. Government Accountability Considerations i. The specific problem the technology seeks to address. ii. Evidence demonstrating the effectiveness of the system. iii. Oversight mechanisms governing deployment and use. iv. Methods for ensuring public transparency and accountability. v. Consequences for misuse, noncompliance, or unauthorized use. F. Fiscal Impact The Report shall include: a. Initial acquisition costs. b. Ongoing costs, including maintenance, licensing, storage, personnel, training, and upgrades. c. Identified funding sources and anticipated future financial obligations. G. Certification The Department Head shall certify that the information contained in the Report is accurate to the best of their knowledge and that all reasonably available information has been included. 3. Camera Location and Necessity Analysis a. Requirement for camera placement justification Where fixed ALPR cameras are proposed, the Department Head shall submit a Camera Location and Necessity Analysis. A separate justification shall be provided for each proposed camera location. b. Contents of the Camera Location and Necessity Analysis The Analysis shall include: ● The precise geographic location. ● The specific public benefit expected from the proposed location. ● Relevant traffic, crime, or public safety data supporting deployment at that location. ● An explanation demonstrating that the fixed location constitutes a major ingress or egress point of the community. ● An explanation of why fewer cameras or alternative placements would be insufficient to achieve the stated public safety objective. ● An assessment of less intrusive or non-surveillance-based alternatives. ● An assessment of whether the proposed location is likely to impose disproportionate impacts on particular communities and, if so, how those impacts will be mitigated. Disclosures required under this section shall comply with all exemptions under Wis. Stat. ch. 19. 4. Submission of Proposed ALPR Use Policy The Department Head shall submit a proposed ALPR Use Policy governing the department’s use of the ALPR. The Use Policy shall include: A. Authorized purposes and prohibited uses. B. Data collection practices and categories of information collected. C. Specific limits on data retention expressed in days, unless otherwise required by law. D. Data deletion procedures, including verification and auditing processes. E. Access controls identifying all categories of personnel, agencies, or contractors authorized to access ALPR data. F. Rules governing data sharing, including approved recipients, required agreements, and restrictions on secondary use. G. Training requirements for all authorized personnel. H. Audit requirements, including immutable audit logs retained for no fewer than x years. I. Public reporting requirements. J. Enforcement measures and penalties for misuse, non-compliance, or unauthorized access by personnel or contractors. K. Vendor obligations, including data breach notification standards and requirements for timely reporting of changes in system capabilities. 5. Public Review and Council Consideration A. Public Availability. The ALPR System Screening Report, Camera Location and Necessity Analysis, and Proposed ALPR Use Policy shall be publicly available no fewer than sixty (60) days before Council consideration. B. Review Period. During this period, the city’s Public Safety committee, Community Affairs/Council Policy committee, Finance committee, and members of the public shall have an opportunity to review and comment on the proposal. C. Council Findings. Following review of the report, public input, and supporting documentation, the Council may approve the purchase only if it finds the use of the ALPR system would satisfy the requirements under Section II(E). All findings shall be publicly available. D. Incomplete Information. The Council may extend the review period if required information is incomplete or if additional analysis is necessary. 6. Ongoing Review Following approval, the department shall submit a quarterly ALPR System Report to the Council describing: A. System uses. B. Number of searches conducted. C. Data sharing activities. D. Compliance audits. E. Complaints, misuse incidents, or breaches. F. Effectiveness in achieving stated objectives. G. Any changes in vendor capabilities, contract terms, ownership, or legal requirements. The Council may reconsider authorization at any time upon a material change in technology capabilities, legal standards, vendor conduct, constitutional concerns, or evidence of misuse. Resources/fodder used for the creation of this draft: https://www.aclu.org/documents/local-automatic-license-plate-reader-privacy-model-bill https://www.eff.org/pages/what-alpr https://www.brennancenter.org/our-work/research-reports/automatic-license-plate-readers-legal- status-and-policy-recommendations https://humanstatement.org/ https://www.vatican.va/content/leo-xiv/en/encyclicals/documents/20260515-magnifica- humanitas.html#CHAPTER_THREE City of Urbana Surveillance Tech Ordinance - Aug 3, 2026 Ordinance Regulating Surveillance Technology & ALPR Systems (Chapter 2, Article VIII) ORDINANCE NO. [______] AN ORDINANCE CREATING ARTICLE VIII OF CHAPTER 2 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE CITY OF STOUGHTON, WISCONSIN, RELATING TO SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY AND AUTOMATIC LICENSE PLATE READER (ALPR) SYSTEMS ARTICLE VIII. – SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY DIVISION 1. – GENERALLY Sec. 2-700. – Purpose and Intent. The purpose of this Article is to establish transparent, accountable, and democratic oversight over the acquisition, deployment, and operation of Surveillance Technology by the City of Stoughton, ensuring that public safety initiatives are balanced with constitutional rights, personal privacy, and fiscal responsibility. Secs. 2-701 – 2-709. – Reserved. DIVISION 2. – AUTOMATIC LICENSE PLATE READER (ALPR) SYSTEMS Sec. 2-710. – Definitions. The following words, terms and phrases, when used in this article, shall have the meanings ascribed to them in this section, except where the context clearly indicates a different meaning: a) Automatic License Plate Reader (ALPR) System means any system, software, hardware, or computer algorithm, whether used independently or in combination with one or more mobile or fixed automated cameras, that is used to convert images of license plates into computer- readable data. b) ALPR System Acquisition means any attempt or action by a City department, officer, or agent to purchase, lease, borrow, accept by gift, grant, or donation, enter into a free trial, pilot program, or demonstration agreement for, upgrade, renew, substantially modify, or obtain ongoing access to an ALPR System or ALPR data operated by another governmental agency or private entity, regardless of cost or whether any City funds are expended. Sec. 2-711. – Common Council Authorization, Public Hearing, and Findings Required. a) Prior Authorization. No City department, officer, or agent shall complete an ALPR System Acquisition, submit a grant application for an ALPR System, accept a free trial, pilot, loan, or donation of an ALPR System, access an external ALPR System on an ongoing basis, or deploy or operate an ALPR System without first completing the screening, analysis, policy submission, independent review, and public review procedures set forth in Sections 2-712 through 2-715 and obtaining authorization from the Common Council by resolution. b) Mandatory Public Hearing. Prior to adopting a resolution authorizing an ALPR System Acquisition, the Common Council shall hold at least one public hearing on the proposed acquisition and all accompanying reports, reviews, and policies. c) Required Findings. Following review of the submitted reports, independent reviews, public input, and supporting documentation, the Common Council may approve an ALPR System Ordinance Regulating Surveillance Technology & ALPR Systems (Chapter 2, Article VIII) Acquisition by resolution only if it finds the use of the ALPR system would satisfy the following requirements: 1. There is substantial evidence that the ALPR System’s potential benefits outweigh its potential harms; 2. The vendor or supplier is transparent, accountable, and reliable; 3. The proposed number of cameras and camera locations are the minimum necessary to achieve a demonstrated public benefit, each location has been individually justified, and fixed cameras are deployed only at major ingress and egress points of the City and not for routine monitoring of activity within the community; 4. The technology does not violate individual liberty, reasonable expectations of personal privacy, or freedom of speech; 5. The technology and its governing agreements do not act as a liability shield preventing those deploying or using the system from being held legally responsible for their actions; and 6. The proposed ALPR System Acquisition has been the subject of at least one public hearing before the Common Council. d) Public Availability of Findings. All findings adopted by the Common Council pursuant to this section shall be made publicly available. Sec. 2-712. – ALPR System Screening Report. a) Preparation. Prior to seeking authorization for an ALPR System Acquisition, the requesting Department Head shall prepare a written ALPR System Screening Report. b) Required Report Contents. The ALPR System Screening Report shall include, at minimum, the following components: 1. Purpose and Need. a. The specific public purpose, public safety objective, or operational need the ALPR System is intended to address; b. Evidence supporting the conclusion that the proposed technology is likely to achieve the stated objective; and c. An explanation of why existing practices, personnel, or less intrusive alternatives are insufficient to meet the identified need. 2. Technology Description. a. All hardware, software, algorithms, databases, and data sources used and accessed by the system; b. All information collected, generated, retained, analyzed, or shared by the system; c. Any artificial intelligence, machine learning, automated decision-making, facial recognition, behavioral analysis, or biometric capabilities associated with the system; and Ordinance Regulating Surveillance Technology & ALPR Systems (Chapter 2, Article VIII) d. Known capabilities, limitations, error rates, and failure modes of the system. 3. Vendor Accountability Review. An assessment of the vendor’s qualifications, responsible business practices, and accountability, including: a. Whether the vendor provides clear and accurate representations of system capabilities and limitations; b. Whether the vendor accepts contractual responsibility for defects, misrepresentations, misuse, negligence, inadequate safety controls, or violations of contractual obligations; c. Whether the vendor seeks contractual provisions limiting liability, accountability, transparency, or legal remedies available to the City; d. The ownership and control structure of the vendor, including: (i) the legal entity providing the ALPR System; (ii) any parent company, subsidiary, affiliate, or controlling entity with ownership or operational authority over the vendor; and (iii) any ownership structure that may affect accountability, contractual obligations, access to data, or regulatory oversight; e. Whether the vendor’s products have caused documented harms and, if so, whether responsibility for those harms can be reasonably determined; and f. Whether the vendor has a documented history of compliance with applicable laws, court orders, audits, regulatory actions, and contractual obligations. 4. Surveillance and Safety Assessment. An assessment of the system’s surveillance and safety characteristics, including: a. Whether the system captures, records, stores, or transmits images, video, audio, or location information; b. Whether the system tracks, logs, maps, or analyzes vehicle or individual movements; c. Whether the system creates records that can be used to reconstruct travel patterns, associations, habits, or activities; d. Whether the system enables secondary uses, commercial exploitation, or data sharing beyond the stated purpose; e. The location, storage, and management of data collected by the system, including: (i) where ALPR data, metadata, backups, audit logs, and related records are stored; (ii) whether data are maintained on City- owned infrastructure, vendor-controlled systems, third-party systems, or cloud-hosted platforms; and (iii) any legal, contractual, technical, or operational factors affecting the City's control over its data; Ordinance Regulating Surveillance Technology & ALPR Systems (Chapter 2, Article VIII) f. Whether the vendor, its affiliates, subcontractors, service providers, or other customers may access, view, analyze, use, or otherwise interact with City data, and the circumstances under which such access may occur; g. Whether the system shares data with other governmental entities, private organizations, regional networks, vendor-operated databases, or other third parties, including: (i) whether such sharing is enabled by default; (ii) whether the City may fully disable, limit, or control such sharing; and (iii) the procedures required to restrict or terminate such sharing; h. Whether the data collected by the system may be searched, queried, or accessed by external agencies, and the conditions, approvals, agreements, or permissions required before such access may occur; i. Whether the City retains sole ownership and control of all data collected, generated, maintained, or stored through operation of the system; j. Whether the vendor claims any ownership interest, license, derivative rights, analytics rights, artificial intelligence training rights, commercialization rights, or other proprietary interests in data collected through operation of the system; k. Whether the vendor may retain, use, aggregate, disclose, analyze, sell, license, or otherwise benefit from City data during or after the term of the agreement; l. Whether the vendor is contractually required to return or permanently delete all City data upon expiration or termination of the agreement, and whether the vendor will provide written certification confirming the completion of such deletion or return; m. The extent of human oversight over automated functions; n. Whether authorized personnel can promptly suspend or disable the system; o. Existing or proposed independent oversight mechanisms; p. Procedures available for individuals to correct inaccuracies and contest misuse; and q. Safeguards for data security, access controls, retention schedules, and deletion practices. 5. Constitutional Rights Assessment. An evaluation of potential impacts on constitutional rights, including: a. Privacy and Fourth Amendment Considerations: (i) whether the system collects information about individuals not suspected of wrongdoing; (ii) whether individuals would reasonably expect personal privacy in the information collected; (iii) whether the system enables continuous, long- term, or retrospective location tracking; (iv) whether less intrusive Ordinance Regulating Surveillance Technology & ALPR Systems (Chapter 2, Article VIII) alternatives could achieve the same objective; and (v) proposed limits on the collection, retention, sharing, access, and use of data. b. First Amendment Considerations: (i) whether the system may discourage lawful speech, assembly, association, religious exercise, or political activity; (ii) whether individuals may alter lawful behavior due to awareness of monitoring; and (iii) whether the system could disproportionately affect particular viewpoints, organizations, or communities. c. Due Process and Equal Protection Considerations: (i) system accuracy and reliability; (ii) potential consequences of errors, false positives, or incorrect matches; (iii) whether certain communities are more likely to be subjected to surveillance; and (iv) procedures available to contest inaccuracies or misuse. d. Government Accountability Considerations: (i) the specific problem the technology seeks to address; (ii) evidence demonstrating the effectiveness of the system; (iii) oversight mechanisms governing deployment and use; (iv) methods for ensuring public transparency and accountability; and (v) consequences for misuse, noncompliance, or unauthorized use. 6. Fiscal Impact. i. Initial acquisition costs; ii. Ongoing costs, including maintenance, licensing, storage, personnel, training, and upgrades; iii. The total cumulative cost over the full term of the proposed contract, including all optional or automatic renewal years, rather than single-year or introductory pricing; iv. All costs, penalties, or fees associated with early termination of the contract and the physical removal or decommissioning of cameras and related hardware; v. Identified funding sources and anticipated future financial obligations; and vi. Any grant conditions, matching requirements, data-sharing mandates, or other legal or operational obligations attached to outside funding. c) Independent Review Prior to Authorization. Prior to Common Council consideration of an ALPR System Acquisition, the completed ALPR System Screening Report, Camera Location and Necessity Analysis, and Proposed ALPR Use Policy shall undergo formal review as follows: 1. City Attorney Review. The City Attorney shall review the Report, proposed vendor contracts, and Proposed ALPR Use Policy and submit a written legal opinion to the Common Council assessing constitutional compliance, vendor liability and data ownership terms, and compliance with applicable state and federal law. Ordinance Regulating Surveillance Technology & ALPR Systems (Chapter 2, Article VIII) 2. Citizen Oversight Board Review. The Surveillance Technology Oversight Board established under Chapter 2, Article IV shall review the Report and supporting materials during the sixty (60) day public review period and submit a written recommendation to the Common Council regarding privacy impacts, community necessity, and proposed safeguards. d) Certification. The Department Head shall certify in writing that the information contained in the ALPR System Screening Report is accurate to the best of their knowledge and that all reasonably available information has been included. Sec. 2-713. – Camera Location and Necessity Analysis. a) Requirement for Justification. Where fixed ALPR cameras are proposed, the Department Head shall submit a Camera Location and Necessity Analysis providing a separate, individualized justification for each proposed camera location. b) Required Analysis Contents. For each proposed location, the Analysis shall include: 1. The precise geographic location; 2. The specific public benefit expected from the proposed location; 3. Relevant traffic, crime, or public safety data supporting deployment at that location; 4. An explanation demonstrating that the fixed location constitutes a major ingress or egress point of the community; 5. An explanation of why fewer cameras or alternative placements would be insufficient to achieve the stated public safety objective; 6. An assessment of less intrusive or non-surveillance-based alternatives; and 7. An assessment of whether the proposed location is likely to impose disproportionate impacts on particular communities and, if so, how those impacts will be mitigated. c) Public Records Compliance. Disclosures required under this section shall comply with all applicable exemptions under Wis. Stat. ch. 19. Sec. 2-714. – Proposed ALPR Use Policy. Prior to seeking authorization for an ALPR System Acquisition, the Department Head shall submit a proposed ALPR Use Policy governing the department’s use of the ALPR System, which shall include: a. Authorized purposes and prohibited uses; b. Data collection practices and categories of information collected; c. Specific limits on data retention expressed in days, unless otherwise required by law; d. Data deletion procedures, including verification and auditing processes; e. Access controls identifying all categories of personnel, agencies, or contractors authorized to access ALPR data; f. Rules governing data sharing, including approved recipients, required agreements, and restrictions on secondary use; Ordinance Regulating Surveillance Technology & ALPR Systems (Chapter 2, Article VIII) g. Training requirements for all authorized personnel; h. Audit requirements, including immutable audit logs retained for no fewer than 7 years; i. Public reporting requirements; j. Enforcement measures and penalties for misuse, non-compliance, or unauthorized access by personnel or contractors; and k. Vendor obligations, including data breach notification standards and requirements for timely reporting of changes in system capabilities. Sec. 2-715. – Public Review and Common Council Consideration. a) Public Availability. The ALPR System Screening Report, Camera Location and Necessity Analysis, and Proposed ALPR Use Policy shall be published on the City’s official website, submitted to the Common Council, and made publicly available no fewer than sixty (60) days before Common Council consideration. b) Committee and Public Review Period. During the sixty (60) day review period, the Surveillance Technology Oversight Board shall review the proposal pursuant to Section 2- 712(c)(2), and the Public Safety Committee, Community Affairs and Council Policy Committee, and Finance Committee shall each have an opportunity to review and submit recommendations to the Common Council. Members of the public shall have an opportunity to submit written comments during the review period and to provide oral comments at a public hearing prior to Common Council action. c) Incomplete Information. The Common Council may extend the review period if required information is incomplete or if additional analysis is necessary. Sec. 2-716. – Ongoing Review and Reconsideration. a) Periodic ALPR System Report. Following approval of an ALPR System Acquisition, the operating department shall submit a written ALPR System Report to the Common Council and the Surveillance Technology Oversight Board quarterly during the first year following initial authorization and annually thereafter. Each report shall describe: i. System uses; ii. Number of searches conducted; iii. Data sharing activities; iv. Compliance audits; v. Complaints, misuse incidents, or breaches; vi. Effectiveness in achieving stated objectives; and vii. Any changes in vendor capabilities, contract terms, ownership, or legal requirements. b) Reconsideration of Authorization. The Common Council may reconsider, suspend, or revoke authorization at any time upon a material change in technology capabilities, legal standards, vendor conduct, constitutional concerns, or evidence of misuse. Secs. 2-717 – 2-729. – Reserved. Ordinance Regulating Surveillance Technology & ALPR Systems (Chapter 2, Article VIII) DIVISION 3. – RESERVED (Reserved for future regulations governing Unmanned Aircraft Systems, Biometric/Facial Recognition Technology, or other Surveillance Technologies.) Ordinance Creating the Surveillance Technology Oversight Board (Chapter 2, Article IV) ORDINANCE NO. [______] AN ORDINANCE CREATING DIVISION [__] OF ARTICLE IV OF CHAPTER 2 OF THE MUNICIPAL CODE OF THE CITY OF STOUGHTON, WISCONSIN, ESTABLISHING A SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY OVERSIGHT BOARD DIVISION [__]. – SURVEILLANCE TECHNOLOGY OVERSIGHT BOARD Sec. 2-[___]. – Creation of a surveillance technology oversight board. Pursuant to the home rule authority of the City of Stoughton, there is hereby created an independent civilian oversight board which shall be known as the Surveillance Technology Oversight Board (Board) of the City of Stoughton. Sec. 2-[___]. – Appointment, confirmation, and term of members. The Board shall consist of five (5) Stoughton residents appointed by the mayor and confirmed by the city council 1-year terms without compensation. No member may be a current sworn law enforcement officer, a current city officer or employee, or have a financial interest in any surveillance technology vendor. Sec. 2-[___]. – Organization and rules. At its May meeting each year, the Board shall elect a chairperson and vice-chairperson from among its members. Three (3) members constitute a quorum to conduct official business. The Board may adopt its own rules of procedure to govern its meetings and internal operations, provided those rules do not conflict with state law or this Code. Sec. 2-[___]. – Powers and duties. a) Pre-acquisition review. The Board shall review every Screening Report, Location and Necessity Analysis, and proposed Use Policy submitted pursuant to Chapter 2, Article VIII during the sixty (60) day public review period, and shall submit a written recommendation to the city council prior to any council vote on authorization. b) Ongoing audit and periodic report review. The Board shall be responsible for regularly reviewing all quarterly and annual reports, compliance audits, and misuse or breach notifications submitted by operating departments pursuant to Chapter 2, Article VIII, and shall report any compliance concerns or recommended policy revisions to the city council. c) The Board shall also perform such other advisory duties related to surveillance technology as the city council may direct. Sec. 2-[___]. – Severability. If any section, subsection, sentence, clause, phrase, or portion of this division is for any reason held invalid or unconstitutional by any court of competent jurisdiction, such portion shall be Ordinance Creating the Surveillance Technology Oversight Board (Chapter 2, Article IV) deemed a separate, distinct, and independent provision and such holding shall not affect the validity of the remaining portion of the division. Sec. 2-[___]. – Construction. The powers and duties granted to the Board under this division and Chapter 2, Article VIII shall be construed liberally to promote independent civilian oversight and transparency.

Source: City of Stoughton website. First collected Nov 14, 2026.