Zoning Board of Appeals - November 19, 2026 Agenda and Packet
City of Monona · Dane County · meeting of Nov 19, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Monona
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF MONONA
ZONING BOARD OF APPEALS
Monona City Hall – Conference Room
5211 Schluter Road, Monona, WI 53716
Thursday November 19, 2026
5:45 p.m.
N
OTICE OF ELECTRONIC MEETING
This meeting will be conducted via electronic videoconferencing/teleconferencing. As such, it is likely
that some or all members of, and a possible quorum, may be in attendance via electronic means and not
physically present. In accordance with Wisconsin law, the meeting will remain open to the public. The
public may still attend in person at the location stated in this agenda. However, due to the need to
maintain social distancing and the limited physical space available, the public is encouraged and
requested to also attend via electronic means. Directions to do so are listed at the bottom of this agenda.
Upon reasonable notice, the needs of disabled individuals will be accommodated through auxiliary aids
or services. For additional information or to request this service, contact Christina Kahl at 608-222-
2525.
1. Call to Order.
2. Roll Call.
3. Appearances.
4. Approval of September 17, 2026 Minutes.
5. Public Hearing: Bryan Pestasko , 6313 Winnequah Road is requesting a variance from
Monona Municipal Code of Ordinances Sec. 480-24(d)(4)(d) Shore Yard Setbacks for
the purpose of constructing a new 3-season porch and deck. (Case No. Z-007-2026)
6. Consideration of Action: Bryan Pestasko , 6313 Winnequah Road is requesting a
variance from Monona Municipal Code of Ordinances Sec. 480-24(d)(4)(d) Shore Yard
Setbacks for the purpose of constructing a new 3-season porch and deck. (Case No. Z-
007-2026)
7. Public Hearing: Rick and Shawdi Nesbit, 1300 Neponset Trail are requesting a variance
from Monona Municipal Code of Ordinances Sec. 480-24(d)(4)(a) Street Yard Setbacks
and Sec. 480-24(d)(4)(d) Shore Yard Setbacks for the purpose of expanding the living
space within the same footprint of the previously approved single-family home. (Case
No. Z-008-2026)
8. Consideration of Action: Rick and Shawdi Nesbit, 1300 Neponset Trail are requesting a
variance from Monona Municipal Code of Ordinances Sec. 480-24(d)(4)(a) Street Yard
Setbacks and Sec. 480-24(d)(4)(d) Shore Yard Setbacks for the purpose of expanding
the living space within the same footprint of the previously approved single-family
home. (Case No. Z-008-2026)
9. Next Meeting Date
a. Upcoming Regular Meeting Dates: December 17, 2026, January 21, 2027
b. Updates/Discussion on Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) Efforts
c. Updates/Discussion on Sustainability Efforts
10. Adjournment.
DIRECTIONS TO ATTEND MEETING ELECTRONICALLY
You may attend via videoconference by downloading the free Zoom program to your computer at
https://zoom.us/download. At the date and time of the meeting log on through the Zoom program and
enter Meeting ID: 843 1770 0478.
You may attend via telephone conference by calling the following phone number:
PHONE NUMBER: 1-301-715-8592 / MEETING ID: 843 1770 0478, FOLLOWED BY #
Please Mute Your Phone When Not Speaking To Ensure Best Possible Audio Quality.
Zoning Board of Appeals Charge (Wis. Stats 62.23(7)(e)1.): The council which enacts zoning regulations
pursuant to this section shall by ordinance provide for the appointment of a board of appeals, and shall
provide in such regulations that said board of appeals may, in appropriate cases and subject to appropriate
conditions and safeguards, make special exceptions to the terms of the ordinance in harmony with its general
purpose and intent and in accordance with general or specific rules therein contained. Nothing in this
subdivision shall preclude the granting of special exceptions by the city plan commission or the common
council in accordance with the zoning regulations adopted pursuant to this section which were in effect on
July 7, 1973 or adopted after that date.
NOTE: Upon reasonable notice, the City of Monona will accommodate the needs of disabled individuals
through auxiliary aids or services. For additional information or to request this service, contact Christina
Kahl at (608)222-2525, FAX: (608)222-9225, or through the City Police Department TDD telephone number
441-0399. The public is notified that any final action taken at a previous meeting may be reconsidered
pursuant to the City of Monona ordinances. A suspension of the rules may allow for final action to be taken
on an item of New Business.
It is possible that members of a possible quorum of members of other governmental bodies of the
municipality may be in attendance at the above state meeting to gather information or speak about a subject,
over which they have decision-making responsibility. Any governmental body at the above state meeting
will take no action other than the governmental body specifically referred to above in this notice.
Agenda posted on the City Hall, Library, and Community Center bulletin boards and on the City of
Monona’s website, www.mymonona.com.
Zoning Board of Appeals
September 17, 2026
Draft Minutes Subject to Approval
1
Minutes
City of Monona
Zoning Board of Appeals
Thursday September 17, 2026
Chair Holmquist called the meeting of the Monona Zoning Board of Appeals to order at 5:46 pm.
Present: Alder Holmquist (Chair), Mr. Schweiger, Mr. Davies & Ms. Piliouras
Excused: Mr. Patton
Also Present: Planning Director Douglas Plowman
Minutes:
A motion by Mr. Schweiger, seconded by Mr. Davies, to approve the minutes of May 21,
2026 carried with no corrections.
Appearances:
None.
New Business:
Public Hearing: Jeff Galligan, 4414 Winnequah Road is requesting a variance from Monona
Municipal Code of Ordinances Sec. 480-24(d)(4)(c) Rear Yard Setbacks for the purpose of
constructing a new single-family home. (Case No. Z-006-2026)
Mr. Jim Lampe, the Applicant’s builder presented the variance request. Mr. Galligan seeks to tear
down the existing home and construct a new single-family home on the property. Mr. Lampe
presented the materials and shared that the proposed house fits the lot better than the existing
configuration does. The proposal is modest at 1,300 square feet and requires a 10’ rear yard
setback variance. This brings the front yard setback into compliance and adheres to the side yard
setback requirements, while the rear yard setback does not encroach further than existing
conditions. The lot is very small, and there are challenges with the condition of the existing home
that make repair (rather than replacement) very difficult. There were no other appearances and the
public hearing was declared closed.
Consideration of Action: Jeff Galligan, 4414 Winnequah Road is requesting a variance from
Monona Municipal Code of Ordinances Sec. 480-24(d)(4)(c) Rear Yard Setbacks for the
purpose of constructing a new single-family home. (Case No. Z-006-2026)
Planning Director Plowman gave an overview and explained the reason for the variance. He added
that there is a need for a Certified Survey Map (CSM) to combine the lots for the proposed home to
be built. Mr. Davies clarified that there were no water concerns for the property and discussed
abatement options (should they be needed) with Mr. Lampe. Mr. Davies asked about the rear of the
property and if there were to be any steps or structure built on the rear. Mr. Lampe clarified that
there are no steps and the proposal is zero barrier. Mr. Davies asked about the basement bedroom,
egress window requirements and setback impacts. Mr. Schweiger confirmed that the property is
currently non-conforming, and asked Director Plowman about the buildable envelope. It was shared
that the depth of the lot is challenging when complying with setbacks at around 20’. It was also
reiterated that the proposed plans address the street yard setback non-conformity. Ms. Piliouras
shared that her questions and comments had already been covered.
A motion was made by Mr. Davies, seconded by Mr. Schweiger to approve an 11.1’ variance
from Monona Municipal Code of Ordinances Sec. 480-24(d)(4)(c) Rear Yard Setbacks for
the purpose of constructing a new single-family home. The lot dimensions are unique and
Zoning Board of Appeals
September 17, 2026
Draft Minutes Subject to Approval
2
challenging. The Applicant has been conscious about the size of the house and other
setbacks as best as they can. There are no issues caused to safety or welfare of neighboring
properties. The unnecessary hardship is present based upon the unique size and square
footage of the lot presenting a challenging buildable area. Setbacks would lead to a 20’
depth, and the proposal is a minimal buildable depth. The proposal brings the request into
conformity in the street yard and reduces encroachments in the rear yard.
A condition of approval was included that the variance is conditioned on the need to record a
Certified Survey Map combining the two lots.
Mr. Schweiger clarified that there were no comments received from neighbors regarding the
request. He added that the proposal is in conformity with the neighborhood and a mindful
plan.
The motion passed unanimously.
Upcoming Meetings:
Director Plowman shared that the October meeting is unlikely, with a greater chance of a meeting in
November instead. Chair Holmquist highlighted that there are two vacancies on the ZBA (both
alternates) and requested members to consider if they had any recommendations from their
networks.
Updates/Discussion on Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) Efforts:
None.
Updates/Discussion on Sustainability Efforts:
None.
Adjournment:
A motion by Mr. Schweiger, seconded by Ms. Piliouras, to adjourn carried. (6:09 pm)
Respectfully submitted by:
Douglas Plowman, Director of Planning and Economic Development
97
Chapter 15 – Variances
SECTION IV
Area and Use Variance Decision Process
Step 2: Determine if all three statutory variance criteriay are met.
Step 1: Consider alternatives to the variance request.
Step 3: Grant or deny requesty qy for variance recording rationale and findings.
Area Variance – Provides an increment
of relief (normally small) from a
dimensional restriction such as building
height, area, setback, etc.
Use Variance – Permits a landowner to
put property to an otherwise prohibited
use.
1. Unnecessary Hardship exists when
compliance would unreasonably prevent
the owner from using the property for a
permitted purpose or would render
conformity with such restrictions
unnecessarily burdensome. Consider
these points:
Purpose of zoning restriction
Zoning restriction’s effect on property
Short term, long term and cumulative
effects of variance on neighborhood
and public interest.
1. Unnecessary Hardship exists when
no reasonable use can be made of the
property without a variance.
3. No harm to public interests A variance may not be granted which results in harm to
public interests. Public interests can be determined from the general purposes of an
ordinance as well as the purposes for a specific ordinance provision. Analyze short-term,
long-term and cumulative impacts of variance requests on the neighbors, community and
statewide public interest.
2. Unique physical property limitations such as steep slopes or wetlands must prevent
compliance with the ordinance. The circumstances of an applicant, such as a growing
family, elderly parents, or a desire for a larger garage, are not legitimate factors in
deciding variances.
Figure 25: Area and Use Variance Decision Process
Attn: Zoning Board of Appeals
On behalf of Bryan Petrasko and Ann Lattin, Dane Building Concepts respectfully requests a shore- yard
setback variance for a proposed screen room and deck addition at 6313 Winnequah Road.
The improvements are intended to accommodate Bryan's progressive mobility limitations while allowing
the homeowners to continue enjoying their established residence. The proposed deck and screen room
would be constructed at the same elevation as the main living level, providing direct access without stairs.
Currently, there is no stair-free access from the home to the yard facing the water.
Monona's zoning ordinance requires a 50-foot shore-yard setback measured from the historical meander
line rather than the ordinary high-water mark (OHWM). Although meander lines historically served as
surveying references rather than actual shoreline boundaries, their use as zoning setback references can
significantly restrict improvements to certain established waterfront properties.
At 6313 Winnequah Road, the location of the historical meander line, combined with the existing
residence and the property's configuration, creates an unusually restrictive building envelope.
The DNR defines it using observable shoreline characteristics, and state statutes expressly provide
mechanisms for surveyors to show an OHWM.
The hardship asserted is not simply a desire for a larger home or a more desirable design. Rather, it is
the restriction imposed on reasonable residential improvements by the interaction of the historical
meander line, the property's physical configuration, and the location of existing improvements.
Hardship 1 – Unnecessary Hardship
Strict application of the historical meander-line setback substantially restricts the homeowners' ability to
make reasonable accessibility improvements to their existing residence. The proposed screen room and
deck would provide direct, stair-free access from the main living level to an outdoor living area,
addressing Bryan's progressive mobility limitations. The location and elevation of the proposed
improvements are dictated by the existing home's configuration and the need for accessible entry, rather
than simply a desire to increase the home's size or value..
Hardship 2 – Unique Property Conditions
The location of the historical meander line, the irregular lot configuration, and the existing home's
placement create physical constraints that are unique to this property and were not created by the
homeowners.
Hardship 3 – No Harm to the Public Interest
The proposed improvements are limited to an existing residential property and are intended to preserve
its established use. The homeowners believe the improvements can be completed without materially
affecting neighboring properties, shoreline conditions, drainage, or public safety.
Dane Building Concepts, LLC
603 Post Road
Madison, WI 53713
Strict enforcement of the setback would impose a substantial burden on reasonable improvements to an
established residential property.
Homeowners Statement and Request for Reasonable Accommodation
“Our property has some unique challenges because of the historic meander line. In fact, most of our
existing home would not meet today's setback requirements. This makes it difficult to make improvements
to our home, even though we're working within an area that has already been developed.
The biggest reason we're requesting this variance is accessibility. Bryan has Muscular Dystrophy, a
progressive disease that will eventually make stairs impossible for him to navigate. We love our home and
being on the water, and we want to make improvements now that will allow him to continue enjoying our
outdoor space as his mobility changes.
Given Bryan's progressive disability and the need to accommodate his changing mobility, we respectfully
request that the City consider a reasonable accommodation under applicable fair housing laws, in
addition to our request for a zoning variance. The proposed improvements are intended to allow Bryan to
continue safely accessing and enjoying his home as his physical abilities change.
We're not looking to dramatically change our property. We simply want to make it more functional and
accessible for our future.
We believe our request is reasonable given the unique location of the meander line and the limitations it
places on our property. We also don't believe the proposed improvements would negatively impact our
neighbors, the waterfront, or public safety.
Ultimately, we're just trying to make thoughtful improvements to a home we love so we can continue
enjoying it for years to come.
Thank you for taking the time to review our request. We appreciate your consideration”
Jim Lampe
Owner, Dane Building Concepts
10/5/26
Jim Lampe Date
NOTES:
-RING OUTSIDE PERIMETER IN TRIPLE LVL. 11-7/8 OR 14" ON 6X6 POSTS.
-HANGER 2 LVL INTO OUTER RING, TIGHT TO CANTILEVER. TWO POSTS ON
EITHER SIDE OF PATIO DOOR IN BASEMENT.
-SPAN 2X12 TREATED JOISTS FROM HOUSE LAKESIDE, WOULD BE HANGERED.
ELIMINATES THE NEED FOR A CENTER BEAM AND POST
-CREATE NEW BEAM POCKET AND BEARING POINT IN EXISTING WALL. AVOIDING
EXISTING WINDOW HEADER SPACE.
1’−0"
BASEMENT WALL
FIRST FLOOR WALL
DN
NEW FLOOR FRAMING PLAN
NOTES:
-EXTEND BEAM OUT TO BEAR STAIRS
-HANGAR LANDING INTO DECK RING
AC BELOW
FINAL STAIR COUNT TBD BY GRADE
NOTES:
-EXTERIOR WALL LOCATION
FROM ABOVE. DOUBLE JOIST.
14’−0"
28’−9"3’−111
2"
9’−7"9’−7"9’−7"
4’−0"9’−2"
FLOOR JOIST 16" O.C.
INSULATE AND WATERPROOF
W/ PVC PANELS AND TRIMS
NOTES:
-DECK POST FRAMING TO AVOID EXISTING RETAINING WALL. MINOR
ADJUSTMENTS MAY NEED TO BE MADE DAY OF CONSTRUCTION TO FINAL
FOOTPRINT.
POST HOLE TO BE AT LEAST 48" BELOW
GRADE. 6X6 TREATED POST
TO BEAR ON CONCRETE FOOTING PIER
(TYP.)
603 Post Road
Madison, WI 53713
www com
GENERAL NOTES
DESIGN PLANS ARE PROVIDED FOR THE FAIR
USE BY THE CLIENT OR HIS AGENT IN
COMPLETING THE PROJECT AS LISTED WITHIN
THIS CONTRACT. DESIGN PLANS REMAIN THE
PROPERTY OF THIS FIRM AND CANNOT BE
USED OR REUSED WITHOUT PERMISSION.
THIS RENDERING IS AN ARTIST'S
INTERPRETATION OF THE GENERAL
APPEARANCE OF THE ROOM. IT IS NOT
INTENDED TO BE A PRECISE DEPICTION
DANE BUILDING
CONCEPTS
PAGE
OF
SCALE
ALL DIMENSIONS AND SIZE DESIGNATIONS
GIVEN ARE SUBJECT TO VERIFICATION ON
JOB SITE AND ADJUSTMENT TO FIT JOB
CONDITIONS
REVISION DATES
DATE
NOTES:
DRAWN BY:
DESIGNED BY:
BRYAN AND ANN RESIDENCE
14
3/8" = 1'-0"
6313 WINNEQUA RD, MONONA WI 53716
bjf
1’−0" CANT.
BASEMENT WALL
DN
NEW 1ST FLOOR PLAN
3 SEASON PORCH
-EZE BREEZE WINDOWS
-HALF WALL AROUND FLOOR 36" TALL
-INSULATE FLOOR SYSTEM
-FINAL FLOOR COVERING TBD
-VAULTED SCISSOR TRUSSES
-ATTIC SPACE TO BE INSULATED
NEW DECK
-STANDARD ALUMINUM HANDRAIL
-COMPOSITE DECKING
PORTAL FRAME POSTS
(2) 2x10 SPF SOLID HEADER
PORTAL FRAME POSTS
14’−0"
NEW WINDOW (FINAL SIZE TBD)
72"x72" SLIDER
USE EXISTING OPENING
SCISSOR TRUSSES 24" O.C.
VAULTED CEILING 2:12 SLOPE
48"x52" EZ BREEZE
VERTICAL FOUR TRACK (TYP.)
14’−41
2"
4’−91
2"4’−91
2" 4’−91
2"
4’−89
16" 4’−613
16" 4’−89
16"
14’−41
2"3’−111
2"
14’−0"
3/0 STORM
NEW PATIO DOOR
72"x80"
USE EXISTING OPENING
NOTES:
-
603 Post Road
www.danebuildingconcepts.com
GENERAL NOTES
DESIGN PLANS ARE PROVIDED FOR THE FAIR
USE BY THE CLIENT OR HIS AGENT IN
COMPLETING THE PROJECT AS LISTED WITHIN
THIS CONTRACT. DESIGN PLANS REMAIN THE
PROPERTY OF THIS FIRM AND CANNOT BE
USED OR REUSED WITHOUT PERMISSION.
THIS RENDERING IS AN ARTIST'S
INTERPRETATION OF THE GENERAL
APPEARANCE OF THE ROOM. IT IS NOT
INTENDED TO BE A PRECISE DEPICTION
DANE BUILDING
CONCEPTS
PAGE
OF
SCALE
ALL DIMENSIONS AND SIZE DESIGNATIONS
GIVEN ARE SUBJECT TO VERIFICATION ON
JOB SITE AND ADJUSTMENT TO FIT JOB
CONDITIONS
REVISION DATES
DATE
NOTES:
DRAWN BY:
DESIGNED BY:
BRYAN AND ANN RESIDENCE
24
3/8" = 1'-0"
6313 WINNEQUA RD, MONONA WI 53716
bjf
NORTH SIDE ELEVATION
0’−111
4"
0’−71
4"
4
12
15’−81
2"
WEST SIDE ELEVATION
SOUTH SIDE ELEVATION
EXISTING HOUSE
EXISTING HOUSE
EXISTING FOUNDATION
NEW BEARING POINTS
AC
GRADE/ROCK WALL
STEP ONTO GRADE
4’−61
2"
4’−0"
2’−11" T.O.F.
NOTES:
-LP SMART TRIM
CUT TO FIT AROUND WINDOWS
-GABLE EXTERIOR SIDING TBD
(SHAKES OR B&B)
NOTES:
-LP SMART TRIM
EXTEND DECK FASCIA BOARD
AROUND 3 SEASON ROOM
HOT TUB
6’−117
8"
NOTES:
-ROOF CONSTRUCTION:
TRUSSES
-DRAWN WITH 2X6 FASCIA
-4/12 ROOF SLOPE/VAULTED
-ALUMINUM SOFFIT AND FASCIA
-ARCHITECTURAL SHINGLES TO MATCH EXISTING
-STORM DOOR ENTRY DOOR
-COMPOSITE DECKING
-ALUMINUM POST AND RAIL SYSTEM
-EZE BREEZE WINDOWS
-LP SMARTSIDE
-LP SMART TRIM
0’−111
2"
SET WINDOW
INTO TRIM
SURROUND
5/4 SILL
3’−0" HALF WALL
3/4" SUBFLOOR
NOTES:
5/4 x 4 LP TRIM
5/4 x 6 LP TRIM
PITCHED
5/4 x 12 LP TRIM
4/4 x 12 LP TRIM
LP TRIM POST
WRAP TBD
WALL COVERING TBD
WINDOW AND DOOR CASING TBD
PARTIAL TRIM DETAIL
TYPICAL FOOTING
6X6 TREATED POST
48" DOWN ON CONC. PAD
603 Post Road
Madison, WI 53713
www.danebuildingconcepts.com
GENERAL NOTES
DESIGN PLANS ARE PROVIDED FOR THE FAIR
USE BY THE CLIENT OR HIS AGENT IN
COMPLETING THE PROJECT AS LISTED WITHIN
THIS CONTRACT. DESIGN PLANS REMAIN THE
PROPERTY OF THIS FIRM AND CANNOT BE
USED OR REUSED WITHOUT PERMISSION.
THIS RENDERING IS AN ARTIST'S
INTERPRETATION OF THE GENERAL
APPEARANCE OF THE ROOM. IT IS NOT
INTENDED TO BE A PRECISE DEPICTION
DANE BUILDING
CONCEPTS
PAGE
OF
SCALE
ALL DIMENSIONS AND SIZE DESIGNATIONS
GIVEN ARE SUBJECT TO VERIFICATION ON
JOB SITE AND ADJUSTMENT TO FIT JOB
CONDITIONS
REVISION DATES
DATE
NOTES:
DRAWN BY:
DESIGNED BY:
BRYAN AND ANN RESIDENCE
34
3/16" = 1'-0"
6313 WINNEQUA RD, MONONA WI 53716
bjf
Plat of Survey
C:\PROJECTS\2026\260710-PETRASKO_6313WINNEQUA\260710-PETRASKO_6
IRON PIPE FOUND (1.5" Outside Diameter)
INDICATES RECORDED AS
DISTANCES ARE MEASURED TO THE
LEGEND
( )
NEAREST HUNDREDTH OF A FOOT.
PREPARED BY:
ISTHMUS SURVEYING, LLC
450 NORTH BALDWIN STREET
MADISON, WI 53703
(608) 244.1090
www.isthmussurveying.com
PREPARED FOR:
BRYAN PETRASKO
MONONA, WI 53716
6313 WINNEQUAH ROAD
ASSUMED TO BEAR S 13°05'48" E
PLATTED BOUNDARY LINE OF LOT 6
BEARINGS ARE ASSUMED, THE EASTERLY
SURVEYOR'S CERTIFICATE
I, Paul A. Spetz, professional land surveyor for Isthmus Surveying LLC,
hereby certify that we surveyed the property described above and that the
map is a true representation thereof and shows the size and location of
the property, visible improvements, potential encroachments and it's
exterior boundaries. Said survey meets the minimum standards for
property surveys of the Wisconsin Administrative Code (A-E7) and the
map hereon is correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. This
Survey is solely for the use of the present owners of the property at the
date below.
Dated this 3rd Day of June, 2026: Paul A. Spetz, S 2525
Notes:
1. Building dimensions and associated offset distances were measured
along the outside of the siding.
2. This parcel may be subject to, or benefit from, Easements or
agreements, written or otherwise, not shown hereon.
20' 0' 20'
Parcel Contains
63.8'±
80.97'
83.50'
60.5'±
N 79°28'23" E 144.8'±
S 13°05'48" E 50.10'
S 79°22'37" W
144.0'±
50.4'±
8.91'
51.6'±
concrete seawall
Ordinary high water mark line (O.H.W.M)
(high water stain on seawall face)
N 13°05'48" W 25.72'
concrete pad
concrete
Yahara River
W I N N E Q U A H
B L O C K 4
R E P L A T O F I N T E R L A K E
R O A D
6
50'
50'
1 00'
5
7
7,245 S. F.
0.17 Acres
Area above meander line
3,123 S. F.
0.07 Acres
Area b/n O.H.W.M. & Meander line
4,122 S. F.
0.09 Acres
N 10°12'28" W 50.19'meander line
Residence-6313 W
innequah Road
Note: Corner falls in a large Tree; A found
bent iron rod is pushed to the SE
chain link fence steel fence
Legal Description of Record: Document No. 5087241
Lot Six (6), Block Four (4), Replat of Interlake, in the City of Monona,
Dane County, Wisconsin
WI
MADISON,
S2525
PAUL A. SPETZ
7’−31
8"
11’−211
16"
28’−9"
10’−15
16"
14’−0" NEW 3 SEASON/DECK
56’−89 16"
54’−101 8"
603 Post Road
Madison, WI 53713
www. .com
GENERAL NOTES
DESIGN PLANS ARE PROVIDED FOR THE FAIR
USE BY THE CLIENT OR HIS AGENT IN
COMPLETING THE PROJECT AS LISTED WITHIN
THIS CONTRACT. DESIGN PLANS REMAIN THE
PROPERTY OF THIS FIRM AND CANNOT BE
USED OR REUSED WITHOUT PERMISSION.
THIS RENDERING IS AN ARTIST'S
INTERPRETATION OF THE GENERAL
APPEARANCE OF THE ROOM. IT IS NOT
INTENDED TO BE A PRECISE DEPICTION
DANE BUILDING
CONCEPTS
PAGE
OF
SCALE
ALL DIMENSIONS AND SIZE DESIGNATIONS
GIVEN ARE SUBJECT TO VERIFICATION ON
JOB SITE AND ADJUSTMENT TO FIT JOB
CONDITIONS
REVISION DATES
DATE
NOTES:
DRAWN BY:
DESIGNED BY:
BRYAN AND ANN RESIDENCE
44
1/16" = 1'-0"
6313 WINNEQUA RD, MONONA WI 53716
bjf
Last Revised 10/2019
CITY OF MONONA: ZONING VARIANCE APPLICATION FORM
This application must be submitted to the Zoning Board of Appeals (ZBA) for approval. Applications must be
complete before they are reviewed, and must be submitted to the City Planner at least four weeks before
the ZBA meeting, due to noticing requirements. It is the responsibility of the applicant to contact the City
Planner at (608) 222-2525 or dplowman@ci.monona.wi.us, with any questions.
APPLICANT INFORMATION:
Name: Home:
Company: Work:
Email: Cell:
Mailing Address:
PROPERTY INFORMATION:
Address of Property:
Lot: Block: Plat:
Present Use of Property:
Proposed Use of Property:
Zoning Classification:
OWNER’S INFORMATION (if other than shown above): ☐ N/A
Name: Company:
Phone Number: Email:
Mailing Address:
PREVIOUS APPEALS
Has a previous appeal or application been made with respect to this property? ☐ Yes ☐ No
If ‘yes’, state nature of previous appeal or application:
Rick and Shawdi Nesbit
N/A
N/A
133 W Kohler St, Sun Prairie, WI 53590
1300 Neponset Trail, Monona, WI 53716
Bell Isle
10
11
Family Residence
Primary Residence
Residential
✔
✔
1300 Neponset Trail | 1
Proposed Amendment to Approved Variance
1300 Neponset Trail
Rick and Shawdi Nesbit
City of Monona Zoning Board of Appeals
Prior approval Case No. Z-004-2026
Dear Members of the Zoning Board of Appeals,
We respectfully request approval of an amendment to the plans associated with the shore-yard and street-
yard setback variances granted for our home at 1300 Neponset Trail. Our proposal extends the upper-level
rec room four feet into a portion of the covered deck shown in the approved plans. The covered deck
would be reduced by the same amount. This change remains within the existing footprint and the overall
footprint approved by the Board, without moving the home closer to the shore or either street.
Background and purpose
The Board granted our setback variances at its May 21, 2026 hearing, as documented in the written
decision dated August 26, 2026. We appreciate the Board’s consideration of the property’s unique
configuration and the opportunity to rebuild our family home in a location consistent with the surrounding
neighborhood.
As we refined the design with Marten Building & Design, we identified a modest adjustment that would
improve the entrance and circulation into the upstairs rec room and provide additional usable space for
family gatherings. Following our discussion with City staff, we are returning to the Board to request
approval of this revision to the previously approved plans.
Description of the proposed change
The wall separating the upper-level rec room from the covered deck would move four feet toward the deck.
A four-foot portion of the previously approved covered outdoor space would become enclosed rec-room
space, with the remainder retained as a covered deck. Both areas are beneath a roof in the approved and
proposed designs. The preferred plans and elevations submitted with this request illustrate the revised wall
location and exterior appearance.
This is the building plan for the upper level that was submitted with the variance request. The area in
question is within the red box.
1300 Neponset Trail | 2
This is the updated plan which shows a 4ft expansion of the rec room. In both plans, the rec room
and deck are covered by a roof.
Relationship to the approved variance
Our request is limited to approval of this four-foot conversion from covered deck to enclosed rec-room
space. We are not requesting a further reduction in the approved street-yard or shore-yard setbacks. The
proposed home would retain the site placement shown in the approved submittal, including the 37.5-foot
setback from the meander line and the 12.5-foot setback along Tecumseh Avenue.
The change increases enclosed upper-level living space, but does so within an area already included in the
approved building footprint and covered by a roof. It does not extend the foundation or the overall
footprint farther toward the water, the streets, or neighboring properties. The property would continue to
be used as our single-family residence.
Basis for approval
The physical conditions that supported the original variance remain the same. Our lot is constrained by its
location along the channel and the surrounding streets. As described in our original application, applying
the standard setbacks would leave a building envelope only approximately 14.5 feet wide by 72.5 feet
deep. This amendment retains the approved approach to those constraints and the established placement
of the home within the neighborhood.
We believe the limited conversion is consistent with the purpose of the approved setback relief. It improves
the function of the upstairs layout while keeping the same overall relationship between the home, the
shoreline, the streets, and adjoining properties. Because it uses space already allocated to the covered
deck, it does not require an expansion of the building footprint or additional ground coverage for this
change.
Requested action
We respectfully ask the Board to approve the four-foot rec-room extension and corresponding reduction in
the covered deck as an amendment to Case No. Z-004-2026, as illustrated in the accompanying preferred
plans and elevations. We propose that the previously approved setback locations and the conditions of the
1300 Neponset Trail | 3
original decision, including the requirement that the property remain outside the regulatory floodplain,
continue to apply.
Thank you for your time and consideration of this proposed amendment. We look forward to completing a
home that serves our family and fits within the Belle Isle neighborhood.
Sincerely,
Rick and Shawdi Nesbit
Property owners
1300 Neponset Trail
REVISIONS:
A3 CUSTOM HOME DESIGN FOR:
SHEET:
SCALE:
DATE:
JOB NAME:
NESBIT
3-12-26
1/4" = 1'-0" DRAWINGS BY:
THIS DOCUMENT CONTAINS CONFIDENTIAL OR PROPRIETARY INFORMATION OF MARTEN BUILDING & DESIGN INC. (MBD).
NEITHER THIS DOCUMENT NOR THE INFORMATION HERE IN IS TO BE REPRODUCED, DISTRIBUTED,
USED, OR DISCLOSED EITHER IN WHOLE OR IN PART EXCEPT AS AUTHORIZED BY MBD. MBD
ASSUMES NO LIABILITY FOR HOME CONSTRUCTION FROM THIS PLAN. IT IS THE RESPONSIBILITY
OF THE PURCHASER OF THIS PLAN TO HAVE BUILDER OR CONTRACTOR VERIFY ALL DIMENSIONS PRIOR
TO PROCEEDING WITH CONSTRUCTION. BUILDER OR CONTRACTOR MUST ALSO VERIFY COMPLIANCE
WITH ALL LOCAL CODES AND CONDITIONS. ALL CARE HAS BEEN TAKEN BY MSM TO MAKE PLANS
ACCURATE. PLANS ARE FOR LOCATIONS AND REFERENCE ONLY. BUILDER OR CONTRACTOR RESPONSIBLE
FOR ANY ENGINEERING AND REVISIONS TO PLAN. ALL ENGINEERING TO INCORPORATE ACTUAL SITE CONDITIONS.
12-15-25
1-16-26
2-27-26
PDF created with pdfFactory Pro trial version www.pdffactory.com
Source: City of Monona website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.