Historic Preservation Commission — Agenda Packet
Village of Mount Horeb · Dane County · Historic Preservation Commission · meeting of Nov 18, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Village of Mount Horeb
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Administrative Offices
Municipal Building - 138 East Main Street
Mount Horeb, Wisconsin 53572
608.437.6884 | mounthorebwi.info
Historic Preservation Commission Meeting Agenda
Wednesday, November 18, 2026 at 6:00 PM
Municipal Building Board Room
138 E. Main Street
Mount Horeb, WI
1) Call to order
2) Roll call
3) Public Participation
Participants may speak for up to three minutes. To participate, please complete a public
comment form at the Board Room entrance and submit it to staff before the meeting
begins. See below for more details.
4) Consent Agenda
All items listed below are considered to be routine by the Governing Body and will be
enacted by one motion (roll call vote). There will be no separate discussion of these
items unless a Board member so requests, in which event the item will be removed
from the Consent Agenda and considered as the first item after the Consent Agenda.
a. Meeting Minutes October 28, 2026
5) Presentations
6) Chair's Report
7) Staff Reports
8) Action Items
a. Consider approval of the CLG Design Guidelines Draft Grant Application
b. Exterior Facade Review: The Gallina Companies: consider recommendation to
Plan Commission on the proposed paint request for 101 East Main Street
c. Exterior Door Review: Troll Vape and Smoke: consider recommendation to Plan
Commission on the proposed exterior door request for 303 East Main Street
Page 1 of 46
d. Exterior Facade Review: Kyle Walser: consider recommendation to Plan
Commission on the proposed facade update for 106 East Main Street
9) Adjournment
*Public Comment Policy
Members of the public are invited to speak at meetings of all Mount Horeb Public Bodies. To comment, please complete a Public Comment
Form at the Meeting Room entrance and submit it to staff before the meeting begins. Comments are limited to three minutes, must be made
from the podium, and the speaker must return to the audience after speaking.
• Non-agenda item comments are heard at the start of the meeting. Public Body members and staff will not engage in discussion
during public comment but may consider topics for future agendas.
• Agenda item comments are heard during the relevant item, after the proposers or staff present the item and before Public Body
discussion. All public comments on the item will be heard before any discussion by the Public Body.
Members of the public will only be allowed to speak outside these public comment times if they are invited by the meeting chair to share
additional information requested by the Public Body. If so invited to speak, the member of the public must do so from the podium.
Written comments are also welcome. Written comments shall include the name and address of the submitter and should be submitted to the
Deputy Treasurer/Governance Coordinator by email at niki.erickson@mounthorebwi.info (subject line: Public Comment Request-Name of
Public Body) or delivered by to the Village at: 138 E Main Street, Mount Horeb WI, 53572, ATTN Public Comment Request-Name of Public
Body.
UPON REASONABLE NOTICE, EFFORTS WILL BE MADE TO ACCOMMODATE THE NEEDS OF DISABLED INDIVIDUALS THROUGH
APPROPRIATE AIDS AND SERVICES. FOR INFORMATION OR TO REQUEST THIS SERVICE, CONTACT ALYSSA GAFFNEY, CLERK,
AT 138 E MAIN STREET, MOUNT HOREB, WI (608) 437-9404.
Page 2 of 46
Historic Preservation Commission
Wednesday, October 28, 2026 at 6:00 PM
Draft Minutes
1) Call to order
Chair Marc Schellpfeffer called the meeting to order at 6:00 pm at the Mount Horeb
Senior Center, 107 North Grove Street, Mount Horeb, WI.
2) Roll Call
Members Present: Curtis Johnson, Ted McMillan, Jill Schuettpelz, Destinee Udelhoven
Others Present: Village Administrator Gabe Altenbernd, Village Planner Ben Rohr,
Village Attorney Bryan Kleinmaier, Village Engineer Rob Wright, Assistant Clerk Jean
Culberson
3) Public Participation
Participants may speak for up to three minutes. To participate, please complete a public
comment form at the Board Room entrance and submit it to staff before the meeting
begins. See below for more details.
No one spoke on non-agenda items.
4) Consent Agenda
All items listed below are considered to be routine by the Governing Body and will be
enacted by one motion (roll call vote). There will be no separate discussion of these
items unless a Board member so requests, in which event the item will be removed
from the Consent Agenda and considered as the first item after the Consent Agenda.
a. Consideration of August 26, 2026 Meeting Minutes
McMillian Motioned to approve the Consent Agenda and Schuettpelz seconded.
Motion carried by unanimous voice vote.
5) Chair's Report
No Report.
6) Staff Reports
No Report.
7) Action Items
a. Discuss and provide comments to the Plan Commission on the proposed Site
Plan for 208, 214, and 220 East Main Street
1. Presentation from Applicant
Developer Jeff Grundahl and Steve Shulfer from Sketchworks Architecture
gave a summary of the three-story 42-unit project with commercial
space and the proposed changes.
Page 3 of 46
2. Public Participation on Application. (Public Participation for this agenda
item will be limited to 30 minutes and all comments should be
specifically related how this project fits with the downtown design
standards or the historical nature of the area. General site plan
comments should be presented at the Plan Commission meeting which
starts at 7:00 p.m.)
The following spoke in support: Mark Mostrom and Aaron Thomas
The following spoke or registered in opposition: Kurt Nowka, Stephen
Sopcak, Lorna Brookins, Brad Brookins, Diane Hills Mochon
3. Staff Comment on Application
Planner Rohr gave a summary of his October 28, 2026 Site Plan Review
and Recommendations located in the agenda packet.
4. Commission Discussion and Potential Action
The Commission discussed the project and recommendations including
whether the State Historical Society should review it.
Schellpfeffer Motioned that the development team continue looking at
the articulation and ornate tops of the building. Johnson seconded and
the motion carried by unanimous voice vote.
Schellpfeffer Motioned that the development team continue review of the
corner at Third and Main Street for rhythm and articulation of the top two
floors. Johnson seconded and the motion carried by unanimous voice
vote.
Schellpfeffer Motioned to request an expert opinion with the State
Historical Preservation Office. Johnson seconded and the Motion passed 3
to 2. Schellpfeffer and McMillan voted no.
8) Adjournment
McMillan Motioned and Schuettpelz seconded to Meeting adjournment at 7:01 pm.
Motion carried by unanimous voice vote.
Minutes by Clerk Jean Culberson
Page 4 of 46
For assistance with CLG gr ant fun ding, contact:
Wisconsin State Historic Preservation Office
Jason Tish, CLG Coordinator
jason.tish@wisconsinhistory.org
60
8-264-6512
APPLICATION
For Federal Grant Funding to
Certified Local Governments in Wisconsin - 2027
due Dec. 18, 2026
Page 5 of 46
Application 1
1. Applicant consulted with CLG Coordinator prior to submission of Application
2. Letter of Intent was submitted by applicant before LOI deadline (Sept. 11, 2026)
3. Application was submitted on or before application deadline (Dec. 18, 2026)
4. CLG
Annual Report was submitted by applicant in January for previous year
5. Applicant complies with all state and federal requirements of the CLG program
6. Applicant has no incomplete grant-funded projects in the past five years
7. For
intensive surveys, applicant has reviewed survey boundaries with SHPO staff
8. For historic district nominations to the NRHP, applicant has consulted with SHPO
staff on the eligibility of the district and has held a public engagement meeting
within
12 months of the application deadline .
9. For individual property nominations, applicant has confirmed NRHP eligibility with
SHPO and has received written support of the nomination from property owner.
10. To host CAMP, CLG staff have consulted with SHPO on potential dates and topics
and has initiated collaboration with NAPC.
2027 Grant Cycle Timeline
Mar. 1, 2026 - CLG Grant cycle opens Sept.
11
, 2026 - Letter of Intent due Dec. 18,
2026 - Complete Application due
Minimum Requirements
Application
for Federal Historic Preservation Funding
to Certified Local Governments in Wisconsin
Federal Fiscal Year 2027 - due Dec. 18, 2026
HISTORIC PRESERVATION FUND GRANTS IN AID (CFDA 15.904)
SUBGRANT ADMINISTERED BY
WISCONSIN STATE HISTORIC PRESERVATION OFFICE
Page 6 of 46
Application 2
Grant Amount Requested
Applicant
(Must be a local government in Wisconsin certified under the CLG program)
Name of CLG community:
Year of CLG Certification:
Project Title:
Local government's EIN:
Local government’s UEI Number:
A Unique Entity ID (UEI) is a 12-character alpha-numeric code used in federal government systems as a way to identify a
unique entity for managing grant awards.
Project Manager
(The person who will manage the project and coordinate the grant with the SHPO)
Name:
Email address:
Phone number:
Mailing address:
Financial Agent
(The person who can confirm that funding is available for the project prior to reimbursement)
Name:
Email address:
Phone number:
Mailing address:
This program receives Federal financial assistance for identification and preservation of historic properties.
Under Title VI of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1973, and the Age
Discrimination Act of 1975, as amended, the U.S. Department of I nterior prohibits discrimination on the basis
of race, color, national origin, disability, or age in its federally-ass isted programs. If you believe you have been
discriminated against in any program, activity, or facility as described above, or if you desire further information,
please write to: Office of Equal Opportunity, National Park Service, 1849 C Street NW, Washington, D.C. 20240
Page 7 of 46
Application 3
Project Type (check one)
A. Initial intensive survey of the community (30 pts.)
B. Nomination of historic district to the NRHP (25 pts.)
C. Nomination of historic district under a local historic preservation ordinance (25 pts.)
D. Resurvey of a community that was surveyed more than 25 years ago (20 pts.)
E. Design guidelines or Historic Preservation plan (20 pts. plus potential Bonus*)
F. Nomination of individual, publicly-owned property or archaeological site to NRHP (15 pts.)
G. Local Landmark - nomination of individual, publicly-owned property (15 pts.)
H. Archaeology - survey (literature search) of the whole community (15 pts.)
I. Archaeology - Phase I survey (on the ground) of any area in the community (15 pts.)
J. Nomination of individual, privately-owned property or archaeological site
to the NRHP (10 pts.)
K. Nomination of individual, privately-owned property or archaeological site under a local HP
ordinance (10 pts.)
L. Public outreach and educational projects (5 pts. plus potential Bonus*)
* Bonus – Applicable to Project Types E and L only if the community has a current
survey of their entire community and has made reasonable efforts to nominate to the
NRHP all properties and districts determined eligible by the survey (20 pts.)
M. CAMP – Host a CAMP training workshop in collaboration with the National Alliance of
Preservation Commissions NAPC (100 pts). A fully developed CAMP proposal will include:
1. venue for the event
2. plan for food and/or refreshments
3. lodging availability
4. marketing plan defined in consultation with SHPO staff
5. registration protocol defined in consultation with NAPC and SHPO
6. consultation initiated with NAPC and SHPO to select sessions and presenters
7. complete list of items to be covered by grant
8. itemized budget.
Page 8 of 46
Application 4
Project Description
Describe the scope of the project you propose to undertake with requested funding.
Local historic preservation objectives
How would the project support or advance the goals in a Histor ic Preservation Plan,
Comprehensive Plan, or other plan?
How would this project support or advance the protection of historic resources or
economic development opportunities?
If applicable, how
would this project support or advance the history of racial, ethnic,
sexual, or gender minority communities who have been underrepresented in past
surveys or plans?
Page 9 of 46
Prior CLG Grant-funded projects completed
List projects funded by CLG grant in the past five years. Include the year of the grant
award, and discuss whether the projects were completed successfully and how they
benefited the community.Training
Describe recent technical or policy training in which your Historic Preservation staff or
Commissioners have participated including, but not limited to, webinars, conferences, online
modules, technical workshops, CAMP, or any other formats that include training on historic
preservation policies, best practices, or technical methods.
Experience
Describe the experience of key staff , officials, and volunteers who will be involved in this
project. Outline their expected roles in this project and their experience with similar projects
Application 5
Page 10 of 46
A pplication 6
Item Estimated Costs
CLG Personnel - salaries/wages $
fringe benefits $
supplies/materials $
travel/per diem $
equipment $
Consultant fees $
Other (specify) $
Total $
Quotes
List all consultants from whom quotes were solicited (not just received) for this project.
Also, attach a copy of any written requests sent to consultants, and their responses.
Budget
Maximum award amount is $50,000 with no local match required. Provide an estimate of
project costs in whole dollars. The applicant is reimbursed upon project completion up to the
award amount; if project costs exceed the award, the applicant will be expected to pay for
additional costs. Two rough estimates prepared by professional consultants must be submitted
with this application.
Page 11 of 46
I affirm that all information on the application is true to the best of my knowledge.
The agents acting on behalf of the Applicant agree to comply with Title IV of the Civil
Rights Act of 1964 and all requirements imposed by or pursuant to the Department of
the Interior regulations issued pursuant to that title. No person in the United States shall,
on the ground of race, color, national origin, disability, or age be excluded from
participation in, be denied benefits of, or be otherwise subjected to discrimination under
any program or activity for which financial assistance is received from the National Park
Service and hereby give assurance that we will immediately take any measures to
effectuate this agreement.
Applicant’s Project Manager Date
I affirm that municipal funding is available to complete the proposed project prior to the
disbursal of grant funding.
Applicant’s Financial Agent Date
Printed Name Email phone
Printed Name Email phone
Mailing Address
A pplicat io n 7
Title
Title
Page 12 of 46
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Mount Horeb Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
3 messages
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org> Thu, Nov 5, 2026 at 10:44 AM
To: jlehrke@legacy-architecture.com
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>, Gabe Altenbernd <gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>
To Whom It May Concern:
I am a citizen member of the Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission.
We are putting together a CLG grant application, with a rapidly approaching mid-December due date. We are pursuing
funding for the consultant-led preparation of residential design guidelines to assist both property owners and HPC members
in best-practices execution of renovations or additions.
(CLG Grant awards will be announced in March 2027, with RFB's to go out soon after.)
As part of this application process, we are seeking professional project estimates in order to establish both a
realistic cost quote, as required within the application, and to get a head start on a roster of qualified and interested
consultants.
If you are interested in this project, I am hoping you can provide a single-number, ballpark quote (no itemization
necessary) on or before Friday, November 20, 2026.
The general parameters of the term "residential," as applies to this project, is based on the historic residential core of our
small Village.
["Historic residential core" is hereby geographically defined as Ninth Street as its eastern edge (extending north and south
beyond the short extent of Ninth Street); a line extending east and west along the line of Spellman Street as the southern
edge; a line extending from Hickory Street to Orchard Lane to South Blue Mounds Street as the western edge; and an east-
west line from the northern extent of Lake Street (before the right-hand curve of County Highway JG) as the northern edge.]
This boundary encompasses 115 properties identified as potentially eligible for the Municipal Register by a recent, still-in-
progress Historic Resource Survey, and one potential National Register neighborhood district that includes 54 contributing
structures. (This Survey was funded by a CLG grant. The numbers listed are drawn from an early Survey draft that is
scheduled to be finalized in 2027.) A general range of construction dates is 1880s to 1960s, though a few earlier and later
structures are present.
An example of a fairly current (2002) document that we found aspirational is the City of Racine Historic Residential
Properties Design Guidelines. That said, our final project parameters would, of course, be shaped and impacted by available
funds.
The Racine document can be found here: https://www.buildupracine.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/final-design-
guidelines.pdf
If you are not interested or do not have the resources or time for this potential project, I would appreciate knowing
that, too.
Questions? Feel free to respond to this email, or call me directly via my cell at 605-840-0037.
Thank you for your time!
Sincerely,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
Jennifer L. Lehrke, AIA <jlehrke@legacy-architecture.com> Fri, Nov 6, 2026 at 2:52 PM
To: Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Page 13 of 46
Caution: This email originated from outside of Legacy Architecture. Please take care when clicking links or opening
attachments. When in doubt, don't click on the attachments.
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>, Gabe Altenbernd <gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>, Lisa
Hartman <lhartman@legacy-architecture.com>, Rowan Davidson <rdavidson@legacy-architecture.com>
Destinee,
Please see attached proposal.
Good luck with your grant application!
Jennifer L. Lehrke, AIA, LEED AP, NCARB
President, Principal Architect, Interior Designer & Historic Preservation Consultant
Legacy Architecture, Inc. | 605 Erie Avenue, Suite 101 | Sheboygan, WI 53081
P: (920) 783-6303 | M: (920) 980-9420
jlehrke@legacy-architecture.com | www.legacy-architecture.com
From: Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Sent: Thursday, November 5, 2026 10:44 AM
To: Jennifer L. Lehrke, AIA <jlehrke@legacy-architecture.com>
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>; Gabe Altenbernd
<gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>
Subject: Mount Horeb Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
[Quoted text hidden]
26.049 Mt. Horeb Design Guidelines - CLG Grant Application Quote.pdf
137K
Page 14 of 46
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org> Fri, Nov 6, 2026 at 4:43 PM
To: "Jennifer L. Lehrke, AIA" <jlehrke@legacy-architecture.com>
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>, Gabe Altenbernd <gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>, Lisa
Hartman <lhartman@legacy-architecture.com>, Rowan Davidson <rdavidson@legacy-architecture.com>
Jennifer,
This is swift, thorough and oh-so-helpful!
Thank you!
If we are lucky enough to receive grant funding and proceed to the RFB phase, we'll be back in touch next spring.
Best Wishes,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
[Quoted text hidden]
Page 15 of 46
605 Erie Avenue, Suite 101
Sheboygan, Wisconsin 53081
(920) 783-6303
www.legacy-architecture.com
November 6, 2026
Destinee K. Udelhoven
Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission
The Mount Horeb Village Hall
138 E. Main Street
Mount Horeb, WI 53572
Re: CLG Grant Application Quote
Mt. Horeb Residential Design Guidelines
Dear Members of the Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission:
As we understand it, the Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission intends to apply to the State
Historic Preservation Office (SHPO) for a 2027 Certified Local Government Subgrant to develop design
guidelines for the residential core of the Village, including 115 properties identified through a recent Historic
Resource Survey. As part of the application process, you are required to obtain two competitive quotes for the
work. Legacy Architecture is pleased to provide this proposal for your consideration.
HISTORIC PRESERVATION CONSULTING SERVICES
Residential Design Guidelines
Based on our past experience, we propose the following scope of work:
1. Coordinate with Village staff to develop a project plan and strategy to ensure that all work is completed
within the required deadlines. Participate in monthly meetings with Village staff, as needed, to discuss
progress.
2. Review the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards, National Park Service Preservation Briefs, and other
professional resources to identify current industry best practices and inform the design guidelines. Review
the Wisconsin Historical Society’s online Architecture & History Inventory (AHI) / Wisconsin Historic
Preservation Database (WHPD), National Register of Historic Places nominations, local landmark
designations, and the recent Historic Resource Survey to further inform the design guidelines.
3. Develop a strategy for effectively inventorying the residential property types present in the Village. Draft
an introduction, including a summary of the Village’s Historic Preservation Ordinance and an explanation
of the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards. Develop and draft the Residential Property Types &
Architectural Styles chapter, including background on Mount Horeb’s historic architecture and the
characteristic features of the historic residential architectural styles found in Mount Horeb.
4. Develop and draft recommended treatments for siding; windows; roofs and chimneys; decks; fire escapes
and exit platforms; porches and exterior stairs; building additions and exterior alterations; accessory
structures; front-yard fencing and other site or landscape features; energy-efficiency and other
sustainability features; and new construction on vacant or cleared lots or parcels.
5. Photograph existing local landmark and National Register of Historic Places (NRHP)-listed properties to
illustrate the design guidelines. Develop and draft recommended treatments for demolition and
maintenance. Develop and draft a glossary of historic preservation, architectural, and construction
Page 16 of 46
2
terminology. Compile resources for inclusion in an appendix, including lists of local landmark
designations, NRHP-listed properties and districts, and NPS Preservation Briefs.
6. Format the draft Design Guidelines. Submit the draft Design Guidelines to SHPO and Village staff for
review and comment and incorporate their comments. Present the final draft of the Design Guidelines to
the Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission and incorporate the Commission’s
comments. Submit the final Design Guidelines to SHPO and the Village upon completion and acceptance
by the Historic Preservation Commission.
FEES
Professional Service Fees
The fee for the services described above is $37,000.
Reimbursable Expenses
Reimbursable expenses, such as printing, mileage, shipping, and postage, are included in the professional service
fee stated above.
We appreciate the opportunity to provide this proposal and would welcome the opportunity to work with the
Village of Mount Horeb on this project. Please contact us with any questions or if you require additional
information.
Sincerely,
Legacy Architecture, Inc.
Jennifer L. Lehrke
Jennifer L. Lehrke, AIA, LEED AP, NCARB
Principal Architect, Interior Designer & Historic Preservation Consultant
Page 17 of 46
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
Erica Ruggiero <erica@miarchitects.com> Thu, Nov 12, 2026 at 11:23 AM
To: Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>, Gabe Altenbernd <gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>
Thank you, Destinee! It was a rainy and dreary Sunday in June, so I will definitely be back.
I had a chance to look at two of our most recent CLG design guidelines projects - Stoughton, WI and Rock Island, IL - and
our ballpark fee is $16,740. This is calculated by multiplying our hourly rate ($124/hr.) by the anticipated number of hours
(level of effort).
Please let me know if you need anything else for the grant application. We are happy to assist.
Thank you again!
erica
ERICA RUGGIERO, ASSOCIATE AIA
erica@miarchitects.com
(847) 328 5679 x4
From: Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Sent: Thursday, November 5, 2026 12:41 PM
To: Erica Ruggiero <erica@miarchitects.com>
Cc: Amy Gauen <amy@miarchitects.com>; Sarah Haas <sarah@miarchitects.com>; Marc Schellpfeffer
<Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>; Gabe Altenbernd <gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>
Subject: Re: Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
Thanks for your quick response, Erica!
I hope you received some warm Mount Horeb hospitality when you visited.
If you are ever in the area again, drop into my downtown workplace at the Driftless Historium museum and research
center. 🙂
I look forward to your quote.
Regards,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
On Thu, Nov 5, 2026 at 11:32 AM Erica Ruggiero <erica@miarchitects.com> wrote:
Hi Destinee,
Thank you for reaching out! I actually just visited Mt. Horeb over the summer to explore the architecture and am familiar
with the historic residential areas.
We have several recent projects preparing design guidelines as part of CLG grants and are happy to provide a quote to
support the grant application.
I'll review the information you provided and send our quote next week.
Please feel free to reach out with any questions for us in the meantime.
Thank you!
erica
Page 18 of 46
ERICA RUGGIERO, ASSOCIATE AIA
erica@miarchitects.com
(847) 328 5679 x4
From: Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Sent: Thursday, November 5, 2026 10:54 AM
To: Erica Ruggiero <erica@miarchitects.com>; Amy Gauen <amy@miarchitects.com>; Sarah Haas
<sarah@miarchitects.com>
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>; Gabe Altenbernd
<gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>
Subject: Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
To Whom It May Concern:
I am a citizen member of the Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission.
We are putting together a CLG grant application, with a rapidly approaching mid-December due date. We are pursuing
funding for the consultant-led preparation of residential design guidelines to assist both property owners and HPC members
in best-practices execution of renovations or additions.
(CLG Grant awards will be announced in March 2027, with RFB's to go out soon after.)
As part of this application process, we are seeking professional project estimates in order to establish both a
realistic cost quote, as required within the application, and to get a head start on a roster of qualified and
interested consultants.
If you are interested in this project, I am hoping you can provide a single-number, ballpark quote (no itemization
necessary) on or before Friday, November 20, 2026.
The general parameters of the term "residential," as applies to this project, is based on the historic residential core of our
small Village.
["Historic residential core" is hereby geographically defined as Ninth Street as its eastern edge (extending north and south
beyond the short extent of Ninth Street); a line extending east and west along the line of Spellman Street as the southern
edge; a line extending from Hickory Street to Orchard Lane to South Blue Mounds Street as the western edge; and an east-
west line from the northern extent of Lake Street (before the right-hand curve of County Highway JG) as the northern edge.]
This boundary encompasses 115 properties identified as potentially eligible for the Municipal Register by a recent, still-in-
progress Historic Resource Survey, and one potential National Register neighborhood district that includes 54 contributing
structures. (This Survey was funded by a CLG grant. The numbers listed are drawn from an early Survey draft that is
scheduled to be finalized in 2027.) A general range of construction dates is 1880s to 1960s, though a few earlier and later
structures are present.
An example of a fairly current (2002) document that we found aspirational is the City of Racine Historic Residential
Properties Design Guidelines. That said, our final project parameters would, of course, be shaped and impacted by
available funds.
The Racine document can be found here: https://www.buildupracine.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/final-design-
guidelines.pdf
If you are not interested or do not have the resources or time for this potential project, I would appreciate knowing
that, too.
Questions? Feel free to respond to this email, or call me directly via my cell at 605-840-0037.
Thank you for your time!
Sincerely,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
Page 19 of 46
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org> Mon, Nov 9, 2026 at 3:15 PM
To: Gail Rae Klein <grklein@uwm.edu>
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>, Gabe Altenbernd <gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>, "Tish,
Jason L - WHS" <jason.tish@wisconsinhistory.org>
The $36K (which actually is $37K--my error) is from a Wisconsin firm.
They did include a simple scope of work, that included using local properties as illustrations/examples, as well as an appendix that
would provide an overview of our municipal register, its provisions, and how to nominate a property.
Perhaps the higher estimate is because we are asking for a wider-reaching document, that will generally assist a variety of
property owners?
Were Racine and Stoughton's district-based?....so maybe the guidelines were more limited in scope?
We are expecting at least one more estimate, so that should help us come up with a tenable grant number among the three.
Thank you again, Gail!
Destinee K. Udelhoven
On Mon, Nov 9, 2026 at 12:59 PM Gail Rae Klein <grklein@uwm.edu> wrote:
Hi Destinee,
I'm surprised at the cost of the other bid. Was it from an out-of-state firm? Recent CLG grants that SHPO approved for
design guidelines were $10,000 to the City of Racine for residential design guidelines and $17,000 to the City of Stoughton
for commercial design guidelines. That was back in 2021, but even accounting for inflation over the last five years, $36,000
seems quite high.
Please let me know if you receive additional quotes in that range as I may want to check in with Jason Tish at SHPO to be
sure that the typical requirements for design guideline projects haven't changed recently.
Thanks!
Gail Klein, M.S.
Architectural Historian, Cultural Resource Management
Archaeological Research Laboratory Center
University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
PO Box 413
Milwaukee, WI 53201
Office (414) 229-3078 | Direct (414) 251-6772
From: Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Sent: Monday, November 9, 2026 12:46 PM
To: Gail Rae Klein <grklein@uwm.edu>
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>; Gabe Altenbernd
<gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>
Subject: Re: Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
This simple estimate is just what we need!
Though I will state that the one other estimate that we've received so far came in at $36K.
This discrepancy sort of concerns me.
Do you feel like I've given you enough info?
Or do you think the other bid is perhaps the "Cadillac" version of this project?
Page 20 of 46
I know I haven't given you much lead time, and I don't expect you to guess at or attempt to explain other quotes, of course.
I am just thinking ahead about what number to use in the grant...
Regards,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
On Mon, Nov 9, 2026 at 9:24 AM Gail Rae Klein <grklein@uwm.edu> wrote:
Hi Destinee,
After reviewing the information you provided, UWM-Cultural Resource Management's estimate for the proposed work is
between $15,500 and $16,500.
I know that you've requested a single-number estimate; however, per UWM policy, we're unable to provide an exact
figure without preparing a full proposal. Please let me know if you are able to work with the above figures. We've
provided similar estimates for other municipalities' CLG grant applications with no push-back from SHPO, but I
understand that every community has their own process in place.
Thanks!
Gail Klein, M.S.
Architectural Historian, Cultural Resource Management
Archaeological Research Laboratory Center
University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
PO Box 413
Milwaukee, WI 53201
Office (414) 229-3078 | Direct (414) 251-6772
From: Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Sent: Thursday, November 5, 2026 12:42 PM
To: Gail Rae Klein <grklein@uwm.edu>
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>; Gabe Altenbernd
<gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>
Subject: Re: Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
Thanks for your speedy response, Gail!
I look forward to your estimate--and please do reach out with any questions in the meantime.
Sincerely,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
On Thu, Nov 5, 2026 at 12:14 PM Gail Rae Klein <grklein@uwm.edu> wrote:
Hi Destinee,
Thanks for reaching out! Yes, we would be happy to provide an estimate for preparing residential design guidelines.
We'll take a look at the information you've provided and we'll reach out with any questions.
Thank you!
Gail Klein, M.S.
Architectural Historian, Cultural Resource Management
Archaeological Research Laboratory Center
University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee
PO Box 413
Milwaukee, WI 53201
Office (414) 229-3078 | Direct (414) 251-6772
Page 21 of 46
From: Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Sent: Thursday, November 5, 2026 11:06 AM
To: Gail Rae Klein <grklein@uwm.edu>
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>; Gabe Altenbernd
<gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>
Subject: Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
Hi, Gail!
I hope this finds you well.
We are applying for another CLG grant here in Mt Horeb, and I was wondering if this type of project is something your
team does?
See below.
Regards,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
_______________________________
To Whom It May Concern:
I am a citizen member of the Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission.
We are putting together a CLG grant application, with a rapidly approaching mid-December due date. We are pursuing
funding for the consultant-led preparation of residential design guidelines to assist both property owners and HPC
members in best-practices execution of renovations or additions.
(CLG Grant awards will be announced in March 2027, with RFB's to go out soon after.)
As part of this application process, we are seeking professional project estimates in order to establish both a
realistic cost quote, as required within the application, and to get a head start on a roster of qualified and
interested consultants.
If you are interested in this project, I am hoping you can provide a single-number, ballpark quote (no itemization
necessary) on or before Friday, November 20, 2026.
The general parameters of the term "residential," as applies to this project, is based on the historic residential core of our
small Village.
["Historic residential core" is hereby geographically defined as Ninth Street as its eastern edge (extending north and south
beyond the short extent of Ninth Street); a line extending east and west along the line of Spellman Street as the southern
edge; a line extending from Hickory Street to Orchard Lane to South Blue Mounds Street as the western edge; and an
east-west line from the northern extent of Lake Street (before the right-hand curve of County Highway JG) as the northern
edge.]
This boundary encompasses 115 properties identified as potentially eligible for the Municipal Register by a recent, still-in-
progress Historic Resource Survey, and one potential National Register neighborhood district that includes 54 contributing
structures. (This Survey was funded by a CLG grant. The numbers listed are drawn from an early Survey draft that is
scheduled to be finalized in 2027.) A general range of construction dates is 1880s to 1960s, though a few earlier and later
structures are present.
An example of a fairly current (2002) document that we found aspirational is the City of Racine Historic Residential
Properties Design Guidelines. That said, our final project parameters would, of course, be shaped and impacted by
available funds.
The Racine document can be found here: https://www.buildupracine.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/final-design-
guidelines.pdf
If you are not interested or do not have the resources or time for this potential project, I would appreciate knowing
that, too.
Questions? Feel free to respond to this email, or call me directly via my cell at 605-840-0037.
Thank you for your time!
Sincerely,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
Page 22 of 46
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org> Thu, Nov 5, 2026 at 11:00 AM
To: info@newhistory.com, collette@newhistory.com, elliott@newhistory.com
Cc: Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>, Gabe Altenbernd <gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>
To Whom It May Concern:
I am a citizen member of the Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission.
We are putting together a CLG grant application, with a rapidly approaching mid-December due date. We are pursuing funding for
the consultant-led preparation of residential design guidelines to assist both property owners and HPC members in best-practices
execution of renovations or additions.
(CLG Grant awards will be announced in March 2027, with RFB's to go out soon after.)
As part of this application process, we are seeking professional project estimates in order to establish both a realistic
cost quote, as required within the application, and to get a head start on a roster of qualified and interested consultants.
If you are interested in this project, I am hoping you can provide a single-number, ballpark quote (no itemization
necessary) on or before Friday, November 20, 2026.
The general parameters of the term "residential," as applies to this project, is based on the historic residential core of our small
Village.
["Historic residential core" is hereby geographically defined as Ninth Street as its eastern edge (extending north and south beyond
the short extent of Ninth Street); a line extending east and west along the line of Spellman Street as the southern edge; a line
extending from Hickory Street to Orchard Lane to South Blue Mounds Street as the western edge; and an east-west line from the
northern extent of Lake Street (before the right-hand curve of County Highway JG) as the northern edge.]
This boundary encompasses 115 properties identified as potentially eligible for the Municipal Register by a recent, still-in-progress
Historic Resource Survey, and one potential National Register neighborhood district that includes 54 contributing structures. (This
Survey was funded by a CLG grant. The numbers listed are drawn from an early Survey draft that is scheduled to be finalized in
2027.) A general range of construction dates is 1880s to 1960s, though a few earlier and later structures are present.
An example of a fairly current (2002) document that we found aspirational is the City of Racine Historic Residential Properties
Design Guidelines. That said, our final project parameters would, of course, be shaped and impacted by available funds.
The Racine document can be found here: https://www.buildupracine.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/final-design-guidelines.pdf
If you are not interested or do not have the resources or time for this potential project, I would appreciate knowing that,
too.
Questions? Feel free to respond to this email, or call me directly via my cell at 605-840-0037.
Thank you for your time!
Sincerely,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
Page 23 of 46
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org> Thu, Nov 5, 2026 at 10:48 AM
To: info@thelakotagroup.com, astein@thelakotagroup.com
Cc: Gabe Altenbernd <gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>, Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>
To Whom It May Concern:
I am a citizen member of the Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission.
We are putting together a CLG grant application, with a rapidly approaching mid-December due date. We are pursuing
funding for the consultant-led preparation of residential design guidelines to assist both property owners and HPC members
in best-practices execution of renovations or additions.
(CLG Grant awards will be announced in March 2027, with RFB's to go out soon after.)
As part of this application process, we are seeking professional project estimates in order to establish both a
realistic cost quote, as required within the application, and to get a head start on a roster of qualified and interested
consultants.
If you are interested in this project, I am hoping you can provide a single-number, ballpark quote (no itemization
necessary) on or before Friday, November 20, 2026.
The general parameters of the term "residential," as applies to this project, is based on the historic residential core of our
small Village.
["Historic residential core" is hereby geographically defined as Ninth Street as its eastern edge (extending north and south
beyond the short extent of Ninth Street); a line extending east and west along the line of Spellman Street as the southern
edge; a line extending from Hickory Street to Orchard Lane to South Blue Mounds Street as the western edge; and an east-
west line from the northern extent of Lake Street (before the right-hand curve of County Highway JG) as the northern edge.]
This boundary encompasses 115 properties identified as potentially eligible for the Municipal Register by a recent, still-in-
progress Historic Resource Survey, and one potential National Register neighborhood district that includes 54 contributing
structures. (This Survey was funded by a CLG grant. The numbers listed are drawn from an early Survey draft that is
scheduled to be finalized in 2027.) A general range of construction dates is 1880s to 1960s, though a few earlier and later
structures are present.
An example of a fairly current (2002) document that we found aspirational is the City of Racine Historic Residential
Properties Design Guidelines. That said, our final project parameters would, of course, be shaped and impacted by available
funds.
The Racine document can be found here: https://www.buildupracine.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/final-design-
guidelines.pdf
If you are not interested or do not have the resources or time for this potential project, I would appreciate knowing
that, too.
Questions? Feel free to respond to this email, or call me directly via my cell at 605-840-0037.
Thank you for your time!
Sincerely,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
Page 24 of 46
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org>
Mount Horeb, WI Residential Design Guidelines PROJECT INQUIRY
Destinee Udelhoven <dudelhoven@mthorebhistory.org> Thu, Nov 5, 2026 at 10:56 AM
To: info@cornerstonepreservation.com
Cc: Gabe Altenbernd <gabe.altenbernd@mounthorebwi.info>, Marc Schellpfeffer <Marc.Schellpfeffer@mounthorebwi.info>
To Whom It May Concern:
I am a citizen member of the Village of Mount Horeb Historic Preservation Commission.
We are putting together a CLG grant application, with a rapidly approaching mid-December due date. We are pursuing funding for
the consultant-led preparation of residential design guidelines to assist both property owners and HPC members in best-practices
execution of renovations or additions.
(CLG Grant awards will be announced in March 2027, with RFB's to go out soon after.)
As part of this application process, we are seeking professional project estimates in order to establish both a realistic
cost quote, as required within the application, and to get a head start on a roster of qualified and interested consultants.
If you are interested in this project, I am hoping you can provide a single-number, ballpark quote (no itemization
necessary) on or before Friday, November 20, 2026.
The general parameters of the term "residential," as applies to this project, is based on the historic residential core of our small
Village.
["Historic residential core" is hereby geographically defined as Ninth Street as its eastern edge (extending north and south beyond
the short extent of Ninth Street); a line extending east and west along the line of Spellman Street as the southern edge; a line
extending from Hickory Street to Orchard Lane to South Blue Mounds Street as the western edge; and an east-west line from the
northern extent of Lake Street (before the right-hand curve of County Highway JG) as the northern edge.]
This boundary encompasses 115 properties identified as potentially eligible for the Municipal Register by a recent, still-in-progress
Historic Resource Survey, and one potential National Register neighborhood district that includes 54 contributing structures. (This
Survey was funded by a CLG grant. The numbers listed are drawn from an early Survey draft that is scheduled to be finalized in
2027.) A general range of construction dates is 1880s to 1960s, though a few earlier and later structures are present.
An example of a fairly current (2002) document that we found aspirational is the City of Racine Historic Residential Properties
Design Guidelines. That said, our final project parameters would, of course, be shaped and impacted by available funds.
The Racine document can be found here: https://www.buildupracine.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/09/final-design-guidelines.pdf
If you are not interested or do not have the resources or time for this potential project, I would appreciate knowing that,
too.
Questions? Feel free to respond to this email, or call me directly via my cell at 605-840-0037.
Thank you for your time!
Sincerely,
Destinee K. Udelhoven
Page 25 of 46
Page 1 of 2
2027 CLG Grant Application DRAFT
PROJECT TITLE: Village of Mount Horeb Residential Design Guidelines
QUESTION NARRATIVES THAT EXCEEDED GRANT FORM’S VISIBLE SPACE LIMITATIONS
(PG 4)
Project Description
This project would help protect and preserve Mount Horeb's historic built environment by providing
clear and specific residential design guidelines for both property owners looking to maintain or alter
their historic residence and for HPC and Village Trustees entrusted with oversight of Municipal
Register-listed structures.
A qualified consultant will:
*inventory residential property types present in the Village (as found within a diverse stock of
properties circa 1880s to 1960s with high historical integrity, and one potentially eligible NRHP
neighborhood district containing over 50 contributing structures);
*draft "Residential Design Guidelines" document /manual that includes: contextual information
about the Village's HP Ordinance and the Secretary of the Interior's Standards; background on
Mount Horeb's residential architecture styles; detailed HP best-practices guidance related to
typical building maintenance and alterations (including, but not limited to, windows, roofs,
chimneys, additions, accessory structures, mechanical upgrades, etc) --using local landmarks and
NRHP-listed properties as photographic examples when possible; and include a comprehensive
glossary and/or appendix of explanatory articles/NPS Preservation Briefs.
*submit draft to SHPO and Project Team (including HPC) for review
*incorporate feedback and submit final draft to SHPO and Project Team
In addition, the HPC and Mount Horeb Area Historical Society will partner with SHPO to host a
public information session, explaining the project process and objectives, prior to or in the beginning
stages of the project.
This project will benefit from field work associated with and information contained within the Village
of Mount Horeb Intensive Survey of Historic Resources, now underway with a March 2027
completion deadline.
(PG 4)
Local historic preservation objectives
The development of community-specific Historic Residential Design Guidelines is in direct support
of the Village of Mount Horeb Comprehensive Plan. This 2022 document espouses a strong and
Page 26 of 46
Page 2 of 2
repeated commitment to preserving and protecting our community's cultural resources as both an
economic and quality of life asset.
In fact, one of just three "Overarching Plan Goals" is to "Improve, protect and leverage natural,
cultural and historic resources."
Furthermore, the creation and utilization of Residential Design Guidelines implements policy
strategies listed in "Chapter 5: Cultural Resources." Namely: (2) Encourage the preservation of
historically and architecturally significant structures/districts... especially the historic residences,
and (3) Work with local organizations like the Mount Horeb Area Historical Society and property
owners to protect resources that contribute to the Village's character.
Besides enhancing Mount Horeb's established reputation as a heritage destination, historic
preservation efforts (aided by our personalized Residential Design Guidelines) are sure to benefit
property owners through increased resale value and improve the overall appearance of
neighborhoods.
(PG 5)
Experience
Village Administrator Gabe Alterbernd will serve as Project Manager. He will monitor the project
timeline and provide required progress reports to SHPO staff. This role is a natural extension of his
daily workload as Mount Horeb's chief administrative officer, in which he regularly oversees a variety
of project schedules and related liaisons between participating and impacted parties.
The selected professional consultant will collaborate with the project team and community
stakeholders to produce illustrated and detailed design guidelines that encourage, via best
practices, the preservation and retention of architectural features that contribute to the historic
character of individual buildings and our Village.
Village Finance Director Denise Schwenn will serve as Financial Agent. Schwenn will review and
pay all invoices and maintain related financial records.
HPC Citizen Member and Mount Horeb Area Historical Society Executive Director Destinee
Udelhoven will serve as the Commission point person. She can directly facilitate access to relevant
historical materials (archives, photos, etc) and local history information, and help organize any
public engagement and education sessions within the community.
Page 27 of 46
From: Karen Johnson
To: Jean Culberson; Building Inspector
Cc: Joseph R. Gallina
Subject: November Meeting
Date: Friday, October 2, 2026 10:50:01 AM
Attachments: image.png
Good morning Jean.
Joe Gallina and I met with Gabe this morning and he felt we should get on the agenda for
the November meeting. Therefore, could you please add Joe Gallina to the agenda for
both the Preservation Committee Meeting and the Plan Commission meeting on November
18th.
The purpose will be to request a waiver to paint the upper windows of the Hoff Mall building
anodized bronze to match the 1
st floor store front windows, vs. replacing the upper windows
in an anodized bronze color, which is allowed under the Ordinance Section 17.07.50 (d)
1.b.
Thank you.
Karen Johnson
Executive Relations Officer
101 East Main Street, Suite 500
Mount Horeb WI 53572
P: 608.237.1300 | www.gallinacompanies.com
Confidentiality notice: The information included in this e-mail, including any attachments, is
for the sole use of the intended recipient and may contain information that is confidential and
protected. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure, distribution or similar action is
prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender and delete all copies
of the original message immediately.
Disclaimer
The information contained in this communication from the sender is confidential. It is intended solely for use
by the recipient and others authorized to receive it. If you are not the recipient, you are hereby notified that
any disclosure, copying, distribution or taking action in relation of the contents of this information is strictly
prohibited and may be unlawful.
This email has been scanned for viruses and malware, and may have been automatically archived by
Mimecast, a leader in email security and cyber resilience. Mimecast integrates email defenses with brand
protection, security awareness training, web security, compliance and other essential capabilities. Mimecast
Page 28 of 46
helps protect large and small organizations from malicious activity, human error and technology failure; and
to lead the movement toward building a more resilient world. To find out more, visit our website.
Confidentiality notice: The information included in this e-mail, including any attachments, is
for the sole use of the intended recipient and may contain information that is confidential and
protected. Any unauthorized review, use, disclosure, distribution or similar action is
prohibited. If you are not the intended recipient, please contact the sender and delete all copies
of the original message immediately.
Page 29 of 46
Page 30 of 46
Page 31 of 46
Page 32 of 46
Page 33 of 46
Page 34 of 46
Page 35 of 46
Page 36 of 46
Page 37 of 46
Page 38 of 46
Page 39 of 46
Page 40 of 46
Page 41 of 46
Page 42 of 46
• Here is the rendering.
•
• SW 2802 Rookwood Red siding
• SW 0046 White Hyacinth trim and storefront framing
• SW 2808 Rookwood Dark Brown doors
•
• Do you need anything else from me for you to compile information for the meeting?
Thanks,
Kyle Walser
TruNorth Electric LLC
Ph: 715-543-1027
Page 43 of 46
Page 44 of 46
Page 45 of 46
108 E Main
Page 46 of 46
Source: Village of Mount Horeb website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.