RecordWell Data

Plan Commission Agenda and Materials

Village of Shorewood · Milwaukee County · meeting of Nov 18, 2026 · Agendas

Open the original document More from Village of Shorewood

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

Plan Commission Meeting Agenda Wednesday, November 18, 2026 at 6:30 pm Village Hall Court Room 3930 N. Murray Ave. - Rear Entrance Join Zoom Meeting https://zoom.us/j/93582875867?pwd=hlIEd0VCSL7gXtA7CKPRIKoP8VRaIc.1 Or call in (audio only) +1 305-224-1968 Meeting ID: 935 8287 5867 Passcode: 038667 Community members that desire to provide public comment should plan to attend the meeting or submit their comments to bgriepentrog@shorewoodwi.gov through 3:00 pm the day prior to the meeting. Comments received prior to the deadline will be shared with the Plan Commission. Comments after that deadline will need to be shared verbally within the meeting during available public comment periods. 1) Call to order. 2) Approval of September 22, 2026 Plan Commission meeting minutes. 3) Discussion of Wisconsin Act 173 “Truth in Planning” in conjunction with five-year Comprehensive Plan review 4) Update on Accessory Dwelling Units 5) Discussion and possible consideration of 2026 Plan Commission Annual Report and Future Initiatives. 6) Future agenda items. a) Short-term rental regulations 7) A djournment. Dated at Shorewood, Wisconsin, this 13th day of November, 2026 Village of Shorewood Toya Harrell, Village Clerk Should you have any questions or comments regarding any item on this agenda, please contact Bart Griepentrog, Planning Director, Planning & Development Department, at (414) 847-2640. Upon reasonable notice, efforts will be made to accommodate the needs of all people. It is possible that members of and possibly a quorum of members of other governmental bodies of the municipality may be in attendance at the above stated meeting to gather information; no action will be taken by any governmental body at the above stated meeting other than the governmental body specifically referred to above in this notice. The Village of Shorewood is aware that phishing attempts are being sent to our constituents disguised as invoices associated with project or permit approvals. Beware of any such attempts and always verify the sender before clicking on links or downloading attachments. 1 of 29 1 Plan Commission Meeting Minutes September 22, 2026 3930 N. Murray Avenue, Village of Shorewood, WI 53211 DRAFT 1. Call to order. The meeting was called to order at 6:47 p.m. Present: Trustee Matt McGovern (Acting Chair), Commissioners Josh Pollack, Therese Klein, John Holtz, Michael Kloehn (arriving late) Absent: President Ann McKaig, Commissioner Kate Flynn Post Others present: Planning Director Bart Griepentrog 2. Approval of June 23, 2026 Plan Commission meeting minutes. Ms. Klein motioned to approve the minutes as presented, seconded by Mr. Pollack. Vote to approve, 4-0. 3. Further Discussion and possible recommendation of an ordinance amendment related to vision setbacks as defined in 535-10. a). Overview Director Griepentrog stated this item was initially discussed in June. It is before the Plan Commission because the recently updated Bike and Pedestrian Plan had a recommendation to review and update these standards with particular attention to including alleys and driveways which are not in the version of the code. This has been a longstanding staff request for enforceability because as it is currently drafted, it essentially applies nowhere because as written it currently applies to uncontrolled intersections and does not mention driveways or alleys. When people have issues with this, we cannot rely on the current code language as something to deny a fence permit or special privilege for something in the right of way. The general purpose of a vision setback area/vision triangle is to increase sight lines for all parties so there is less opportunity for conflict which would increase safety. This would be primarily enforced upon permitted improvements like fences and special privileges. It could be enforced on landscaping within the right of way if there was no special privilege on file or with the use of technology (Google Maps) to confirm when new plantings were installed after adoption of the new language. Updates to the language were based on the June discussion and conversations with the village engineer and WISDOT standards. Photo examples were provided also. b). Public Comment Trustee McGovern opened the public comment at 6:51 p.m. Barbara Kiely Miller, 4051 N. Downer Avenue, said a similar idea was brought to the Plan Commission in 2016, and she recalled the Planning Director at the time stating it was a request or idea from one of the staff members at the DPW. She said that at the time the plan commissioners were not interested in the idea and it did not advance. She said it seems that there are probably not many intersections in the village that do not have either a stop sign or a yield sign and that the restrictions 2 of 29 PC Meeting 09-22-2026 2 seem to be harsher on those who live on a corner adjacent to the end of an alley or those with a driveway. She felt this would penalize people who might want some privacy on their corner lots. She wondered if this was necessary and stated she was not in favor of it and felt it was too restrictive for those dealing with a driveway or the end of an alley. Trustee McGovern closed the public comment at 6:54 p.m. c). Plan Commission Discussion Mr. Pollack asked for clarification on the photos provided. Director Griepentrog provided examples of things such as fences up against driveways or alleys explaining that fences require permits and need village approval and during the review of the permit and survey staff would be able to enforce the clipping of the corner, making the corner more transparent or lowering the fence to make the regulation in the current draft compliant. Some photos were examples of overgrown landscaping as well and he explained that if complaints are received regarding these and there is no special privilege on file staff could require the growth to be clipped back to the private property line to comply. The purpose of the regulation is to increase sight opportunity and safety. Mr. Kloehn asked if existing uses that don’t comply with the proposed language would be legal non-conforming uses. Director Griepentrog stated that yes, anything existing with permission would have that status. Trustee McGovern stated this was something he’d probably support even not being 100% sure because in general he is in favor of things like this and felt it was worth bringing to the Village Board for discussion and to have input from the community. Ms. Klein moved to direct staff to draft an ordinance amendment to modify the village’s vision setback areas as presented and discuss for consideration at the village board. Seconded by Mr. Pollack. Vote to recommend, 5-0. Director Griepentrog stated that a public hearing will need to be scheduled for this with the village board and that that could likely be November or December. 4. Future agenda items. a). Five-year Comprehensive Plan review b). Wisconsin Act 173 “Truth in Planning” c). Short-term rental regulations d). Update on Accessory Dwelling Units Director Griepentrog stated that per the last discussion the five-year comprehensive plan review and the Wisconsin Act 173 “Truth in Planning” happening concurrently and getting the comprehensive plan compliant with that by the end of 2027. Nothing is prepared for this yet but the planning association’s annual conference next week with a session on this for him to learn more about it and how other communities are handling it. These topics will likely be the next topic of discussion. Short-term rental regulations have become a general topic in the north shore over the past couple months with respect to the opportunity to collect room tax as an additional point of revenue. State legislation allows municipalities to collect room tax with 30% of it being kept within an operation budget and 70% need to go to an entity that promotes tourism. Staff 3 of 29 PC Meeting 09-22-2026 3 would bring the current regulations and enforcement to the Plan Commission, as this is a part of the zoning code, to see whether there is an appetite to allow more than we currently have. This is an enforcement difficulty. Once we would codify what we currently regulate the state would automatically start collecting the room tax and send the village their percentage. Other north shore communities have recently done this, and it came as an opportunity for more revenue. With respect to a six-moth update on accessory dwelling units (ADU), Director Griepentrog stated that no applications have been submitted for the construction of an ADU but that staff has received many calls about them. One individual had gotten far enough in the planning process to see the need for a variance to make the height 24 feet as opposed to 20 feet and provided justification for why he thinks that specific regulations could be reviewed to allow some wiggle room or loosening. 5. A djournment. Mr. Pollack motioned to adjourn the meeting at 7:02 p.m. Seconded by Ms. Klein. Vote to adjourn 5-0. Recorded by, Crystal Kopydlowski Planning & Development Administrative Clerk 4 of 29 Report to Plan Commission November 18, 2026 Prepared by: Bart Griepentrog, AICP, Planning & Development Director 3) Discussion of Wisconsin Act 173 “Truth in Planning” in conjunction with five-year Comprehensive Plan review Five-year Comprehensive Plan Review Overview As part of the Village’s 2027 initiative process, the Plan Commission requested to undertake a five-year Comprehensive Plan review. The Comprehensive Plan, which was adopted on April 19, 2021, contains nine required elements: • Issues and Opportunities • Housing • Transportation • Utilities and Community Facilities • Natural and Cultural Resources • Economic Development • Intergovernmental Cooperation • Land Use • Implementation The Village Board supported this initiative at their June 1, 2026 meeting. Based on the submission (see attached), the Plan Commission desired to: • R eview base line data, goals and objectives; • Write a report to update baseline data and identify the progress of implementation; • Have these updates presented to the Plan Commission • Provide a report to the Village Board Next Steps The Planning Director will begin this review, including data updates to the figures throughout the plan, for discussion and presentation to the Plan Commission in early 2027. It may work best to bring periodic updates on a chapter-by-chapter basis up to three per month. Should additional information or direction be desired, the Plan Commission is requested to offer those up for discussion and confirmation at the November 18th meeting. Wisconsin Act 173 “Truth in Planning” Overview On April 2, 2026, the State of Wisconsin enacted 2025 Wisconsin Act 173, also known as “Truth in Planning” legislation. In general, the Act requires that municipal comprehensive plans and zoning regulations be better aligned and provide more predictable opportunities for housing 5 of 29 growth. The Act does not become effective until January 1, 2028, so municipalities have time to review and update their comprehensive plans and zoning standards as necessary. Here’s a summary of the four parts of the Act as provided by the Wisconsin League of Municipalities, along with local thoughts/perspective. Part 1 The first part of Act 173 amends comprehensive planning statutes. Comprehensive plans are outward looking 20-year plans prepared by municipalities and updated every ten years since the law first took effect in 2010. For this law, the relevant section of the nine elements is land use, including the land use map. Act 173 requires that minimum and maximum densities are identified in the land use map for each area defined as future use residential for each five-year period over the 20-year planning cycle. The net densities are defined in residential units per acre, removing considerations for wetlands, floodplains, and government-owned lands. These net densities are considered a regulation, not a plan. As with current law, there is a consistency requirement, meaning that land use regulations may not be inconsistent with the comprehensive plan. This law amended this provision to state that the land use map is included in the consistency requirement, but additional land uses are allowed for designated future use areas. If the municipality enacts or amends any land use ordinance or adds land by annexation or incorporation intended for residential use, the municipality must add densities for that land to its comprehensive plan and ensure the densities are in their ordinances. If the municipality receives a request for a rezone of a parcel identified as future use residential and does not have densities defined in their comprehensive plan, the municipality has 180 days to amend their plan. Certain statutory procedures do not apply. Shorewood’s Comprehensive Plan 2040 was adopted on April 19, 2021, and was most recently amended on February 2, 2023 as part of the Commercial Zoning Update. The Land Use element includes maximum densities (up to) for our Lower, Medium and Higher Density Residential land use categories (see page 172), but it does not include minimums, which would need to be added. Densities for the Mixed Use land use category would also need to be added. All of these land use categories relate to numerous zoning classifications that exhibit different residential densities. In order to retain those densities as status quo, new land use categories will likely need to be added to the plan. Consolidation of zoning districts, which was included as a recommendation in the Comprehensive Plan (see 10. on page 182) could also be considered. In addition to defining these densities, municipalities will also need to map areas of future residential land use demand in five year increments over the 20-year planning period and the densities allowed in those areas. The Village’s current Comprehensive Plan includes a map of Areas Susceptible to Change, which could be referenced for this exercise, in conjunction with population projections. As a built-out community, large-scale changes are likely not to be anticipated. Part 2 The second part of Act 173 addresses rezoning requests of identified future use residential areas. This legislation requires that certain rezoning requests are granted within 90 days if the request aligns with the comp plan and statutory requirements are met. A developer may grant a 90-day extension. If a rezoning request is for an area identified in the comprehensive plan for future use residential and the densities of the rezoning proposal match the plan, a request is granted if: 6 of 29 • the area is contiguous to existing development; and • the local government does not meet existing housing demand or forecasted housing demand within the next five years, as identified in the housing element of the comprehensive plan. While granting the rezoning request is assumed under those conditions, municipalities may reject the request if they demonstrate at least one of the following: • the proposal would result in a shortage in or overburdening of public facilities; or • the proposal could create a significant threat to public health or safety. The developer requesting the rezoning may state their preference for a zoning classification in local ordinances that meet their plan (e.g., R1, R2, etc.). This request for the specific zoning classification is granted if the rezoning request is approved under the conditions above and if the zoning classification allows for the type and density of development listed in the municipality’s comprehensive plan for that area. For municipalities having trouble attracting developers, they may issue a request for proposals (RFP) for residential development for an area that has or will have water and sewer services. If no person responds to the RFP, the rezoning process laid out above is suspended for a year. A response to the RFP may include a developer submitting in writing why the RFP is economically infeasible. Shorewood’s Comprehensive Plan identifies appropriate zoning districts for each land use category (page 172). Of note, the lower density land use category includes the Village’s R-1 through R-6 districts, of which only R-6 currently allows duplexes. The confirmed or updated densities within all land use categories will need to be reviewed against the allowances of existing zoning districts to ensure that rezoning requests align with desired development patterns. For reference, the following chart identifies the zoning districts within the current lower density land use category and how those regulations pertain to the net densities identified in the plan. District Minimum Lot Size (sq. ft.) Maximum Units per Zoning* Maximum Units per Acre Maximum Units per Land Use R-1 24,000 2 10 5.5 R-2 8,000 2 10 1.8 R-3 8,000 2 10 1.8 R-4 18,000 2 10 4.1 R-5 6,000 2 10 1.3 R-6 4,500 3 10 1.0 *including ADUs Part 3 The third part of Act 173 addresses long-standing misinterpretations of TIF limitations. Under current law, newly platted residential development is restricted to only 35% of mixed-use TIFs and not allowed at all in blight, rehabilitation and conservation, or industrial TIFs. This is a significant restriction on promoting housing in TIF. Originally, this restriction was meant to limit TIF leading to urban sprawl with greenfield development. However, DOR has interpreted this provision to be any new plat, not just land that was previously unplatted. This interpretation does not just stop farm field development, it also stops infill development. Act 173 creates a statutory definition of “newly platted residential development,” with the definition reading: “residential development on a parcel that has not previously been the site of 7 of 29 permanent structures other than structures used solely for agricultural purposes.” This means that unless the property either previously had no structures (e.g., forest, farm field, vacant never developed land) or the only permanent structures on the site were solely agricultural, any TIF type can now promote housing development and mixed use TIDs can allow residential development outside the 35% restriction. Part 4 The fourth and final part of Act 173 improves municipalities’ ability to be proactive in housing. Under current law, municipalities may, by resolution of the local governing body, extend a TID that is set to close for one year and use that increment to promote housing. 75% of the funds generated must benefit affordable housing, while 25% can be utilized to improve the city or village’s existing housing stock. This legislation will increase that one-year allowable extension to two years, allowing the generation of more funding. It is worth reiterating the points above, the new definition of newly platted residential development and the TIF change, have a delayed effective date and will only go into effect on January 1, 2028. Current law and interpretations will continue to apply in the interim. In 2021 Shorewood extended TID 1 for one year for purposes of affordable housing and is nearing action to provide that funding to a developer to build a 19-unit rent-restricted apartment building. TID 3, 4 and 5 are expected to close in the upcoming years. Discussions regarding the extension of these TIDs will take place within a year of closure. Next Steps The Village will need to confirm and/or update the Land Use element of its Comprehensive Plan to include the required minimum and maximum net residential densities and identify areas of future residential land use demand in five year increments prior to 2028 to comply with this Act. This update could be discussed in conjunction with the five-year comprehensive plan review initiative or taken up as a separate matter. A public participation plan will need to be developed to gather public input on any proposed amendments, and those amendments will need to be recommended by the Plan Commission and approved by the Village Board. Direction from the Plan Commission is desired Materials Enclosed • Five-Year Comprehensive Plan Review Initiative Form • Act 173 – Plan It, Fund It (League of Wisconsin Municipalities, Wisconsin Realtors Association, Wisconsin Builders Association) • Truth in Planning Law Changes Planning and Zoning For Municipalities – von Briesen & Roper, s.c. 8 of 29 2027 VILLAGE OF SHOREWOOD INITIATIVE FORM Summary: This form is used for departments, volunteer committees and officials to propose significant initiatives such as service changes, programs, studies, capital items and other requests to be considered for the annual vision planning and prioritization process. The goal of this form is to help staff, committees and officials identify the resources, steps and time involved in executing an initiative. It allows a formalized process for the Village to recognize proposed initiatives and request the Village Board to consider an initiative before investing more resources. Name: Date: Department / Committee: Initiative: Description and Goal: Include a short summary of the initiative and the goal/desired outcome. Time Sensitivity: Identify any time constraints or deadlines associated with the initiative. Estimated Staff Time Needed to Execute: Include estimated hours and staff/persons involved. Bart Griepentrog, AICP, CNU-A February 26, 2026 Plan Commission Five-Year Comprehensive Plan Review Assess progress on Plan implementation. What has changed since 2021? What obstacles have emerged? The Planning and Development Director would be required to perform this review. Approximately 80 hours would be anticipated. The Implementation Chapter of the Comprehensive Plan notes that “A five year review will be considered to update baseline data, describe the degree of success towards achieving Plan goals and identify obstacles against Plan goals and objectives.” The Plan was adopted on April 19, 2021, so the five year review would be scheduled for 2026. 9 of 29 2027 Estimated Costs: Materials, contractual services, equipment, etc. Indicate annual vs. one-time. Implementation Steps for Execution: Include approvals, collaboration with other groups, etc. No costs beyond staff time are projected. 1. Review plan base line data, goals and objectives. 2. Write a report to update baseline data and identify the progress of implementation. 3. Present report to Plan Commission. 4. Provide report to Village Board. 10 of 29 ACT 173 PLAN IT, FUND IT New framework for housing planning, rezoning, and development WHAT IS ACT 173? Wisconsin communities face a housing shortage, and 2025 Wisconsin Act 173 offers a clear path forward. The law strengthens Wisconsin's comprehensive planning framework, giving city and village housing plans real weight. It also doubles the TID extension from one year to two and clarifies TIF terminology to expand housing opportunities in redevelopment. T ogether, these changes create a more efficient Wisconsin Just Made TIF Work Better For Housing This is the simplest tool in Act 173 for cities and villages. It requires no new taxes, state funding, or borrowing, and allows a successful TID to capture tax increment longer for eligible housing costs. The Affordable Housing Extension Since 2009, once a TID pays off its costs, a city or village may extend it up to 12 months by resolution to fund housing improvements. The Department of Revenue then continues allocating tax increments during the extension. Same TID, Twice the Housing Fund Act 173 expands the housing extension from 1 year to 2 years. This keeps TID funds available for housing longer. That is the entire change. Consider a TID that generates $1 million in annual increment. Under prior law, a city or village could capture approximately $1 million in housing funds. Under Act 173, the same TID can now generate approximately $2 million for housing without new taxes or debt. system. The path from plan to project is now more predictable for developers, neighbors, officials, and planning staff alike. PLAN IT, THEN BUILD IT Act 173 is built on a straightforward principle: once a community plans for housing in a specific area, that plan guides what comes next. When plans specify density and location, the rezoning process for conforming housing becomes faster and more predictable for everyone. PART 1: PLANNING FOR HOUSING A comprehensive plan is a community's long-range vision for growth and development. Act 173 makes the land use element more specific, so developers, neighbors, city councils, and village boards all share a clear picture of what the community wants and where it wants it. Cities and villages remain fully in control of that vision. Act 173 ensures the development path is specific enough to guide what follows. What must cities and villages add to their comprehensive plan? Î A 20-y ear projection, in 5-year increments, identifying areas designated for future residential development. Î F or each area and time period, a stated minimum and maximum net residential density in housing units per acre. What is "net density"? Net density is the number of housing units per acre, excluding wetlands, 100-year floodplains, and public land not intended for redevelopment. What does "consistent" mean? An ordinance is consistent with the plan if it permits a land use on the adopted land use map, even if it allows additional uses. Consistency is determined solely by the map and its category descriptions. 2025 WISCONSIN ACT 173 11 of 29 What if a plan doesn't yet include the new density information? Communities have until January 1, 2028, to update their plans. If a permit or rezoning request is submitted before then, the city or village has 180 days to add the required density information, without the full public process normally required for plan amendments. PART 2: TRUTH IN PLANNING — STREAMLINED REZONING Once a community's housing vision is in its plan, Act 173 creates a clear path to rezoning for proposals that align with it. A residential rezoning request is entitled to approval within 90 days (extendable by 90 days by the applicant) when all five criteria are met: Î The c omprehensive plan identifies the land for residential use. Î The land is adjac ent to or near existing development and can be reasonably served by existing infrastructure. Î The pr oposed density falls within the plan's specified range, or the 180-day plan update hasn't been completed. Î C urrent housing supply does not meet existing or projected demand over the next 5 years, according to the comprehensive plan. Î The requester certifies that the land is not in a farmland preservation zone or agricultural enterprise area and is not subject to a farmland preservation agreement. Community Safeguards Remain Fully Intact Even when all five criteria are met, a city or village may deny a request if necessary to prevent a shortage of, or overburdening of, public facilities, or to address public health or safety concerns. For more information, contact the Wisconsin Builders Association, the Wisconsin REALTORS® Association, or the League of Wisconsin Municipalities. This fact sheet is for educational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. QUICK FACTS Act Number: 2025 Wisconsin Act 173 Enacted: April 2, 2026 Effective: January 1, 2028 Applies to: Cities and villages (new planning & rezoning rules); all cities and villages with eligible TIDs (TID extension and TIF definition) Clarity on Newly Platted Residential Development Before Act 173, Wisconsin's TIF statute used the term 'newly platted residential development' without defining it, leaving communities and developers uncertain about which projects qualified. Act 173 defines the term as housing built on parcels with no prior permanent structures other than agricultural buildings. This draws a clear line between new residential development on undeveloped land and redevelopment of previously built sites, expanding housing development opportunities in any new TID after 2028. Use of TID Extension Funds At least 75% must benefit affordable housing, defined as housing that costs a household no more than 30% of gross monthly income. The remaining 25% must be used to improve the community's housing stock more broadly. The money does not have to be spent within the TID boundaries. It can be spent to promote positive housing initiatives anywhere in the city or village. The funds are flexible. Communities have used and can use the extension for things such as: Î Infr astructure supporting new housing development Î Housing trust funds Î R esidential blight removal Î W orkforce housing programs Î Gap financing f or affordable housing developments Î Land ac quisition for housing Î F irst-time homebuyer grants Î Do wn payment assistance programs 2025 WISCONSIN ACT 173 12 of 29 Truth in Planning Law Changes Planning and Zoning for Municipalities Jun 11 2026 Posted By: Christopher R. Smith & Samuel A. Schultz & Brian J. Seidl Practice Area: Land Use, Development and Zoning & County and Municipal Governance & Government Law Wisconsin’s recently enacted 2025 Act 173, commonly referred to as the “Truth in Planning” law, introduces important changes to the relationship between comprehensive planning and zoning for municipalities. Act 173 represents a meaningful shift in Wisconsin land use law and reflects broader policy objectives related to housing availability and affordability. By requiring municipalities to plan for residential development in a more detailed and transparent manner, the legislature intended the updated statutes to reduce uncertainty and facilitate the construction of new housing. Local governments should be mindful of how their planning decisions may affect housing supply and regional economic conditions. Municipalities that approach implementation proactively will be better positioned to comply with the statute while advancing local planning and development objectives. Prior law effectively required political subdivisions administering mapping, subdivision, and zoning ordinances to adopt comprehensive plans that included a land use element. The law required zoning decisions to be consistent with those plans. However, even when zoning decisions were consistent, the law did not force approvals. Many political subdivisions therefore denied controversial zoning applications, even though such applications were consistent with their adopted comprehensive plans. Wisconsin’s legislators recognized that these denials created uncertainty for developers, who could find themselves spending time and money preparing residential developments based on a subdivision’s comprehensive plan, only to be denied the necessary authorization at the proverbial goal‐line. Act 173 takes the current statute, Wis. Stat. Chapter 66, and places stronger emphasis on a political subdivision’s comprehensive plan by requiring a greater level of detail in the planning process for residential development. The new law directs cities and villages to identify where residential development will occur over a twenty‐year planning horizon, broken into five‐year increments, with minimum and maximum residential density ranges for those planned growth areas. The law establishes a 90‐day limit for granting a residential zoning request, and generally requires approval for residential zoning decisions that comply with the comprehensive plan. Additionally, Act 173 more clearly defines newly platted residential development as, “…residential development on a parcel that has not previously been the site of permanent structures other than structures used solely for agricultural purposes.” This term was previously undefined within the law regarding mixed‐use tax incremental districts. The law also extends the time in which a municipality may extend a tax incremental district for affordable housing to up to 2 years. 13 of 29 The practical effect of these requirements is that comprehensive plans will now function as more concrete guides for future development rather than general policy documents. Cities and villages must ensure that their zoning ordinances align with the density ranges and growth areas identified in their plans. Residential zoning decisions inconsistent with adopted plans will likely be more vulnerable to legal challenges, and the ability to rely on discretionary zoning decisions may be more limited. Implementing Act 173 will require coordination among planning staff, governing bodies, and community stakeholders. Municipalities should thoroughly review their land use element, including projecting housing demand, mapping future residential growth areas, and evaluating infrastructure capacity. Public engagement will be especially important because the comprehensive plan will carry greater legal and practical significance under the new law. From a legal perspective, municipalities that do not align their zoning ordinances with their comprehensive plans may face increased risk. Challengers to zoning decisions now have another arrow for their quiver and may focus on whether those denials are consistent with the adopted plan and the statutory requirements of Act 173. Conversely, municipalities that undertake careful planning and maintain clear alignment between plans and zoning regulations will be in a stronger position to defend their land use decisions, and are likely to become a more attractive place of development and increased economic growth. Considering these changes, local governments should begin planning efforts well in advance of the statutory deadline. Early action will allow municipalities to develop defensible, data‐driven plans and to make any necessary comprehensive plan and zoning amendments in an orderly manner. Training for planning commissions, elected officials, and staff may also be beneficial to ensure a clear understanding of the new requirements. Although the law does not take immediate effect, municipalities should be aware that compliance will be required by January 1, 2028. This transition period provides an opportunity to review and update comprehensive plans and zoning codes. Local governments should begin evaluating whether their current plans contain the level of specificity required under the statute and whether existing zoning districts permit the densities contemplated in future growth areas. von Briesen & Roper Legal Update is a periodic publication of von Briesen & Roper, s.c. It is intended for general information purposes for the community and highlights recent changes and developments in the legal area. This publication does not constitute legal advice, and the reader should consult legal counsel to determine how this information applies to any specific situation. 14 of 29 Report to Plan Commission November 18, 2026 Prepared by: Bart Griepentrog, AICP, Planning & Development Director 4) Update on Accessory Dwelling Units Overview Throughout 2025, the Plan Commission undertook discussions to increase housing opportunities within the Village of Shorewood’s Municipal Code, including the allowance of accessory dwelling units, which was ultimately adopted by the Village Board via Ord 3087 on May 4, 2026. Within discussions, it was noted that the updates, including an amendment to the definition of household and the allowance of bedrooms in basements, would likely not have dramatic impacts to the Village’s current housing supply, but were within the scope of the project. Since adoption of the ordinance, the Village has not received any permit applications to build or establish any accessory dwelling units, despite a handful of calls and expressed interests. The Village has received two communications from people who believe the adopted regulations are too restrictive. Staff informed both that they would bring their concerns to the Plan Commission as a six month update to see if the Plan Commission had any desire to seek additional public engagement on the topic or request that the Village Board consider modifications. Next Steps Should the Plan Commission desire to take a second look at the accessory dwelling unit regulations or gather additional information or feedback, they could recommend further discussion as a future item of consideration. Materials Enclosed • Ordinance 3087 • Communication from Nathan Patterson (height restriction) • Communication from BJ Westfhal (investor restriction) 15 of 29 STATE OF WISCONSIN MILWAUKEE COUNTY VILLAGE OF SHOREWOOD ORDINANCE NO. 3087 AN ORDINANCE TO PERMIT ACCESSORY DWELLING UNITS WITHIN THE R-1 THROUGH R-6 RESIDENTIAL ZONING DISTRICTS OF CHAPTER 535 ZONING OF THE VILLAGE CODE WHEREAS, throughout 2025 the Village Plan Commission undertook an initiative to identify additional housing opportunities by reviewing the Village code; WHEREAS, the Village’s current code does not permit the creation of accessory dwelling units; WHEREAS, accessory dwelling units are understood to have the potential to increase housing affordability for both homeowners and tenants, create a wider range of housing options within the community, enable seniors and adults of all abilities to stay near their family as they age, and facilitate better use of the existing housing fabric in established neighborhoods; WHEREAS, the Plan Commission discussed the benefits of permitting accessory dwelling units while recognizing that their creation was not expected to be widespread due to space limitations, cost and desire; WHEREAS, the proposed amendment, which would allow the creation of accessory dwelling units as permitted accessory uses within the R-1 through R-6 residence districts , was discussed by the Plan Commission as part of their initiative on April 22, 2025, May 27, 2025, July 22, 2025, August 26, 2025, October 28, 2025, and January 27, 2026; additional public engagement on the topic was performed in the form of an online survey in January 2026; and, the proposed amendment was subsequently recommended for approval by the Plan Commission on February 24, 2026; WHEREAS, a class two public hearing notice was published in the official newspaper on April 15, 2026 and April 22, 2026 to notify all interested parties of a public hearing at the May 4, 2026 Village Board meeting to discuss the matter. NOW THEREFORE, at a regular meeting of the Village Board of the Village of Shorewood, Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, held on the 4 th day of May 2026, by a favorable vote of the members being present and therefore, said Board does ordain as follows: SECTION 1 That Subsection A of Section 535-6 “Terms defined; word usage.” of Chapter 535 “Zoning” be amended to include: 16 of 29 ACCESSORY DWELING UNIT An accessory dwelling unit is a smaller, independent residential dwelling unit located on the same lot as a stand-alone (i.e. detached) residence. Accessory dwelling units can be created through modifications to an existing dwelling unit (internal) or accessory structure (detached), or through an addition to an existing dwelling unit (attached) or accessory structure (detached). SECTION 2 That Table 535-26-1 be amended to include the following: Accessory Use MX CX GX RX R- 1 R- 2 R- 3 R- 4 R- 5 R- 6 R- 7 R- 8 R- 9 R- 10 P- 1 P- 3 Reference Accessory Dwelling Units - - - - ● ● ● - - - - - 535-26K SECTION 3 That Subsection K of Section 535-26 “Accessory dwelling units.” of Chapter 535 “Zoning” be created to read as follows: K. Accessory dwelling units. (1) Number. No more than one per lot. (2) Type. Internal, attached or detached. (3) Size. Not to exceed gross floor area of principal dwelling unit. (4) Lot coverage. See zoning district for principal building and accessory structure maximum lot coverage. (5) Setback. See zoning district for required front, side and rear setbacks. (6) Height. Not to exceed principal building or 20 ft. if detached, as measured from grade to the peak of the roof. (7) Design. Design review required per 535-31C. (8) Parking. None required. See 535-47A(4). 17 of 29 (9) Short-term rentals. Short-term rentals of less than seven days are prohibited. (10) Owner-occupancy. Owner occupancy shall be required and verified at the time of construction or creation. SECTION 4 That Paragraph (4) “Accessory dwelling units.” of Subsection A “Dwelling and lodging uses.” of Section 535-47 “Schedule of requirements” of Chapter 535 “Zoning” be created to read as follows: (4) Accessory dwelling units. No parking shall be required for an accessory dwelling unit, nor shall parking be required for the principal dwelling unit. SECTION 5 That all Ordinances or parts of Ordinances conflicting with the provisions of this Ordinance are hereby to such extent repealed. SECTION 6 That this Ordinance shall take effect and be in force after its passage and posting. PASSED AND ADOPTED by the Village Board of the Village of Shorewood, Milwaukee County, Wisconsin, this 4 th day of May 2026. Ann McKaig, Village President Countersigned: Toya Harrell, MMC, WCPC, Village Clerk 18 of 29 From: Nathan Patterson To: Bart Griepentrog Subject: Request to revisit 20 foot ADU height limit Date: Sunday, September 13, 2026 7:53:04 PM You don't often get email from nathanjpatterson@gmail.com. Learn why this is important Dear Mr. Griepentrog, I am emailing regarding Shorewood’s ADU regulations, specifically the 20-foot maximum building height. I strongly support allowing ADUs in Shorewood, but after researching the practical implications of the height standard, I believe increasing the maximum to approximately 24 feet would be worth reconsidering. My concern is that 20 feet is unusually restrictive for one of the most logical ADU configurations in Shorewood: replacing an existing detached garage with a two-car garage and a modest apartment above it. A simple building-height calculation illustrates the problem. Even using relatively modest 8- foot ceilings on both levels consumes 16 feet before accounting for the second-floor structure, wall plates, insulation, and roof structure. This leaves only about four feet for everything else. I also reviewed architectural plan databases specifically for compact, two-story, two-car garage apartments and found that designs meeting a true 20-foot height limit were exceptionally difficult to find. In a representative search on one of the largest plan websites, none of the plans returned (0%) were 20 feet or less when measured from grade. Only about 20% were 22 feet or less, nearly 60% were 24 feet or less, and more than 90% were 28 feet or less. One of the shortest designs, which appears on several major plan sites, is described as 20'-0" from the front-door floor elevation, but the plans show an actual height of approximately 20'-8" above grade. That progression is important. At 20 feet, essentially none of the conventional plans examined comply. Moving to 22 feet begins to make some conventional designs possible, while a 24- foot limit captures a substantial portion of available designs. A relatively modest four-foot increase therefore appears to have a disproportionately large effect on the ability to use conventional residential designs and construction methods. The 20-foot limit does not simply make these buildings slightly shorter. It can require unusually low roof pitches, reduced ceiling heights, customized plans, and potentially engineered roof systems rather than common residential framing. In that sense, increasing the limit to 24 feet would not necessarily produce substantially larger ADUs; it would primarily allow otherwise modest buildings to use more conventional proportions and construction. I recognize that the height limit is intended to preserve the scale and character of Shorewood’s residential neighborhoods and to limit impacts on adjacent properties. My concern is simply that 20 feet may be lower than necessary to accomplish those goals, while creating significant practical constraints for otherwise modest garage-apartment designs. This seems particularly important because Shorewood already limits an ADU's footprint relative to lot area. The footprint restriction controls the amount of the property occupied by the building, while the 20-foot height restriction can make it unnecessarily difficult to place 19 of 29 usable living space above a replacement garage. Allowing somewhat more height would therefore improve design flexibility without increasing the building footprint. I would encourage the Village to consider a 24-foot maximum for two-story detached ADUs, or at least evaluate a separate height allowance for garage apartments. Based on the plan survey and dimensional analysis, the difference between 20 and 24 feet appears to be less about creating a noticeably larger building and more about moving from a highly constrained custom design into the range of conventional residential construction. Thank you for considering the request and for the work that went into establishing the ADU ordinance. Sincerely, Nathan Patterson 4223 N. Stowell Ave CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the North Shore Consolidated O365 Email System (Bayside, Glendale, Shorewood, Brown Deer, Whitefish Bay, and North Shore Fire & Rescue). Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. 20 of 29 From: BJ Westfahl To: Bart Griepentrog Subject: Shorewood ADU Date: Monday, October 12, 2026 12:14:42 PM You don't often get email from bjwestfahl@yahoo.com. Learn why this is important Bart, I spoke with the zoning department within the last couple weeks in regard to the opportunity for an ADU on a home I own in Shorewood and a home is was looking to purchase. I live in the area, as well as own and self-manage a couple properties in the area. I understand that the current code requires the owner to reside on the property at the time the ADU is constructed. At the time of my conversation with staff I shared that I believe this restriction significantly impacts the goals of the ADU initiative of providing additional housing stock and tax revenue for the village. Investor owners have greater access to cash/financing, greater market and construction experience and skills to complete these projects that are complex in nature but are now prevented from does so thus thwarting the goals of the initiative. Thank you for the time. BJ Westfahl CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the North Shore Consolidated O365 Email System (Bayside, Glendale, Shorewood, Brown Deer, Whitefish Bay, and North Shore Fire & Rescue). Do not click links or open attachments unless you recognize the sender and know the content is safe. 21 of 29 Re port to Plan Commission November 18, 2026 Prepared by: Bart Griepentrog, AICP, Planning & Development Director 6) D iscussion and possible consideration of 2026 Plan Commission Annual Report and Future Initiatives. Overview All Village Boards, Committees and Commissions are asked to provide annual reports summarizing their year’s activities and accomplishments. The combined annual report is typically provided to the Village Board in late Spring. Deadlines for the submission of reports have been pushed up to be received by the end of the year. A ll Village Boards, Committees and Commissions are also asked to provide a list of future initiatives that they’d like the Village to pursue. The combined listing of proposed initiatives is provided to the Village Manager on March 1st of each year. The Village Manager distributes proposed initiatives to Lead Departments for review and refinement prior to resubmission to the Village Board by the end of April for consideration in June. At that time, the Village Board is asked to select proposed initiatives in order to allocate staff and budgetary resources to projects in the next year, as available. I n 2026, the Plan Commission identified three future initiatives for consideration: 1. Five-year comprehensive plan review 2. Review/Update Home Occupation Regulations 3. Review/Update Notice Requirements (include tenants?) 4. Review/Update Decision Criteria for Zoning Petitions A ll of the Plan Commission’s initiatives were supported to move forward, with the five-year comprehensive plan review added to the Planning Director’s work plan for completion in 2027. R egarding future initiatives, should the Plan Commission wish to add, remove, reprioritize or amend anything on the list, discussion and consideration may take place at the November 18th and December 16th meetings prior to submitting to the Village Manager and Village Board. A review of the Village’s 2040 Comprehensive Plan could be useful in understanding or identifying future initiatives related to the Plan Commission’s scope of work. The implementation table begins on page 189 and includes reference to responsible parties, including the Plan Commission (PC). P ossible Motion: I move to approve the Plan Commission’s 2026 Annual Report and Future Initiatives, (as drafted, discussed or amended). M aterials Enclosed • DRAFT 2026 Annual Report– Plan Commission • I nitiative Form - Review/Update Home Occupation Regulations • Initiative Form Review/Update Notice Requirements (include tenants?) • Initiative Form - Review/Update Decision Criteria for Zoning Petitions 22 of 29 Village of Shorewood 2026 Annual Report VILLAGE OF SHOREWOOD DEPARTMENT / COMMITTEE ANNUAL REPORT Instructions: To help inform the Village Board on the annual operations, services and activities being performed by all areas of the Village, the Village Manager is asking each department and citizen committee to complete the following report. Please contact the Village Manager’s Office if you have any questions about the report. Name of Department / Committee: Name of Department Head / Committee Chair: Other Department Managers / Committee Members: Identify your most significant department / committee services and activities performed in the past year. Tr. Matt McGovern, Kate Flynn Post, Therese Klein, Michael Kloehn, Josh Pollack, Dan Wycklendt (through May) and John Holtz (starting in June) Plan Commission Bart Griepentrog (staff liaison) / President Ann McKaig 1. Convened 6 meetings (through November). 2. Discussed and recommended options to increase housing opportunities in the village, namely by updating the definition of household, allowing bedrooms in basements, and permitting accessory dwelling units (8 meetings, starting in 2025). 3. Discussed and recommended an amendment to the zoning code to clarify the permitted location of office uses within the MX districts. (Adopted by the Village Board via Ord 3080 on March 16, 2026) 4. Discussed and recommended an amendment to the zoning code to update vision setback requirements. (To be considered by the Village Board via Ord 3094 on November 16, 2026.) 5. Began discussion of Wisconsin Act 173 “Truth in Planning” in conjunction with five-year Comprehensive Plan Review 23 of 29 2027 VILLAGE OF SHOREWOOD INITIATIVE FORM Summary: This form is used for departments, volunteer committees and officials to propose significant initiatives such as service changes, programs, studies, capital items and other requests to be considered for the annual vision planning and prioritization process. The goal of this form is to help staff, committees and officials identify the resources, steps and time involved in executing an initiative. It allows a formalized process for the Village to recognize proposed initiatives and request the Village Board to consider an initiative before investing more resources. Name: Date: Department / Committee: Initiative: Description and Goal: Include a short summary of the initiative and the goal/desired outcome. Time Sensitivity: Identify any time constraints or deadlines associated with the initiative. Estimated Staff Time Needed to Execute: Include estimated hours and staff/persons involved. Bart Griepentrog, AICP, CNU-A February 26, 2026 Plan Commission Home Occupation Regulations Home Occupations are regulated by 535-26 within the Village's Zoning Chapter. Those regulations were last amended in 1991. Since that time, the economy has shifted, and technology has changed making home-based businesses more feasible for many residents. The recent COVID-19 health pandemic made this conversation more relevant. The goal of this review would be to update regulations as necessary to provide a balance of needs while maintaining neighborhood character. The Planning & Development Director would lead this initiative with the input of the Plan Commission. Approximately 80 hours would be estimated to complete the initiative. There is no time sensitivity with this initiative. 24 of 29 2027 Estimated Costs: Materials, contractual services, equipment, etc. Indicate annual vs. one-time. Implementation Steps for Execution: Include approvals, collaboration with other groups, etc. Beyond staff time and publication, no additional costs are expected with this initiative. 1. Staff would present the current home occupation regulations to the Plan Commission for discussion, along with a report of any known permitted home occupations. 2. The Plan Commission would provide direction for moving forward, possibly with alternative scenarios. 3. Some level of public outreach between the Plan Commission, residents and existing home occupation businesses would be convened to discuss the impacts of potential changes to the code 4. The Plan Commission would make a recommendation to the Village Board. 5. The Village Board would review and consider the proposed changes upon the holding of a public hearing. 25 of 29 2027 VILLAGE OF SHOREWOOD INITIATIVE FORM Summary: This form is used for departments, volunteer committees and officials to propose significant initiatives such as service changes, programs, studies, capital items and other requests to be considered for the annual vision planning and prioritization process. The goal of this form is to help staff, committees and officials identify the resources, steps and time involved in executing an initiative. It allows a formalized process for the Village to recognize proposed initiatives and request the Village Board to consider an initiative before investing more resources. Name: Date: Department / Committee: Initiative: Description and Goal: Include a short summary of the initiative and the goal/desired outcome. Time Sensitivity: Identify any time constraints or deadlines associated with the initiative. Estimated Staff Time Needed to Execute: Include estimated hours and staff/persons involved. Bart Griepentrog, AICP, CNU-A February 26, 2026 Plan Commission Review/Update Notice Requirements Current notice requirements for zoning amendments state that all property owners within 250 feet of the subject property shall be noticed at least 10 days prior to the hearing if sought by petition. This requirement does not include residential and/or commercial tenants within that same area. This initiative would research the desirability and feasibility of adding those occupants to such notices. The Planning and Development Director would be required to perform this review. Approximately 80 hours would be anticipated. If implemented, additional staff time would likely be needed to update and maintain tenant addresses within the building department database. None. 26 of 29 2027 Estimated Costs: Materials, contractual services, equipment, etc. Indicate annual vs. one-time. Implementation Steps for Execution: Include approvals, collaboration with other groups, etc. No costs beyond staff time and publication costs would be anticipated. If implemented, additional postage costs would be likely. 1. Review existing ordinance to confirm current regulations and practice. 2. Research other municipal ordinances for examples. 3. Confirm ability to maintain data related to tenant addresses. 4. Discuss options with Village Attorney. 5. Present findings of research and legal opinion to Plan Commission. 6. Seek recommendation of possible changes from Plan Commission. 7. Conduct Public Hearing and seek consideration from the Village Board. 27 of 29 2027 VILLAGE OF SHOREWOOD INITIATIVE FORM Summary: This form is used for departments, volunteer committees and officials to propose significant initiatives such as service changes, programs, studies, capital items and other requests to be considered for the annual vision planning and prioritization process. The goal of this form is to help staff, committees and officials identify the resources, steps and time involved in executing an initiative. It allows a formalized process for the Village to recognize proposed initiatives and request the Village Board to consider an initiative before investing more resources. Name: Date: Department / Committee: Initiative: Description and Goal: Include a short summary of the initiative and the goal/desired outcome. Time Sensitivity: Identify any time constraints or deadlines associated with the initiative. Estimated Staff Time Needed to Execute: Include estimated hours and staff/persons involved. Bart Griepentrog, AICP, CNU-A February 26, 2026 Plan Commission Decision Criteria for Zoning Petitions State statute governs conditional use permits, but other zoning petitions lack an established standard, which leaves decisions to each commissioner and Trustee’s judgement based on the totality of the circumstances. This places a high burden on petitioners who risk inconsistent outcomes of their applications. Establishing clear criteria could provide predictability for both petitioners and Village officials. The Planning and Development Director would be required to perform this review. Approximately 80 hours would be anticipated. None. 28 of 29 2027 Estimated Costs: Materials, contractual services, equipment, etc. Indicate annual vs. one-time. Implementation Steps for Execution: Include approvals, collaboration with other groups, etc. No costs beyond staff time and publication costs would be anticipated. 1. Review existing ordinance to confirm current regulations and practice. 2. Research other municipal ordinances for examples. 3. Discuss options with Village Attorney. 4. Present findings of research and legal opinion to Plan Commission. 5. Seek recommendation of possible changes from Plan Commission. 6. Conduct Public Hearing and seek consideration from the Village Board. 29 of 29

Source: Village of Shorewood website. First collected Nov 15, 2026.