RecordWell Data

County Board -Mid Month - Administration Building — Agenda Packet

Ozaukee County · Ozaukee County · County Board · meeting of Nov 18, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from Ozaukee County

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

1 County Board Regular Meeting Wednesday, November 18, 2026, 9:00 AM Ozaukee County Fairgrounds - South Pavilion W67N866 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012 The following business will be before the County Board for initiation, discussion, consideration, deliberation and possible formal action: The public can access the meeting by viewing the live stream on the County website, Agendas & Minutes page and select the meeting agenda date. The public can submit comments here: Public Comment Form Public Comment Policy & Instructions For Submitting Public Comments Online AGENDA Meeting Place: Ozaukee County Fairgrounds - South Pavilion W67N866 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012 1. Call to Order 2. Pledge of Allegiance to The Flag 3. Public Comments Legislative Updates Chairperson Proclamation 4. Communications 5. Claims 6. Presentation a. Cedarburg Fireman's Park Acquisition Review — Fairgrounds history, Policy and Funding Considerations Jason Dzwinel, County Administrator 7. Tour of Cedarburg Firemen's Park Parcel 8. Adjournment People with disabilities requiring accommodation for attendance at this meeting should contact the County Clerk’s Office at 262-284- 8110, twenty-four (24) hours in advance of the meeting. Page 1 of 7 DEPARTMENT OF ADMINISTRATION COUNTY ADMINISTRATOR’S OFFICE Jason Dzwinel, County Administrator www.ozaukeecounty.gov TO: Ozaukee County Board FROM: Jason Dzwinel, County Administrator DATE: November 18, 2026 SUBJECT: Cedarburg Fireman ’s Park Acquisition Revie w - Fairgrounds history, P urchase Considerations and Further Evaluation . Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. approached county leadership regarding the purchase of the 16.18-acre Cedarburg Fireman’s Park parcel immediately south of the County Fairgrounds. Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. is seeking to sell the parcel and in 2024-2025 engaged in a strategic planning session to determine how to best sell this asset to create revenue for their organization. After reviewing the proposals Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. representatives met with county leadership met to discuss county acquisition of the parcel. Both county leadership and Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. recognize the importance of the investments that Ozaukee County has made on the 22.10-acre parcel north of the Fireman’s parcel and a shared desire to ensure that the County Fair can remain at its location in the City of Cedarburg. If the Fireman’s parcel were sold for another use the impact to the County Fair would be significant. Moreover, Ozaukee County and Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. negotiated a Right of First Refusal (ROFR) recognizing that it is in the best interest of both parties that acquisition of the parcel is of importance. The City of Cedarburg holds a Right of Second Refusal on the Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. parcel. The purchase of the 16.18-acre Cedarburg Fireman’s Park parcel raises a broader policy decision about the future of the County Fair and the County’s responsibility for the combined Fairgrounds. Purchase of the parcel is assumed at $1.7 - $2.0 million. Preliminary staff estimates place the cost of demolishing the grandstand and other structures and constructing a replacement grandstand at $3.0 million. The Committee should evaluate this commitment against continued separate ownership, rehabilitation and relocation alternatives. This memorandum considers the following: 1. The 2002 study commissioned by Ozaukee County to examine the future of the county owned parcel to the north of the 16.18-acre Cedarburg Fireman’s Park parcel. 2. The subsequent County investment in the county owned parcel primarily the Ozaukee Pavilion and the Ascension St. Mary’s County/Curling Building. 3. A 2025 appraisal of the 16.18-acre Cedarburg Fireman’s Park parcel. 4. Historical price comparisons based on a purchase of 4.4 acres from Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. in July of 2009. 5. Finally policy questions requiring resolution including: a. The $1.7–$2.0 million purchase range. Page 2 of 7 b. The $3.0 million redevelopment estimate is a working assumption supplied for this discussion. Findings of the 2002 study The November 2002 study examined approximately 39 acres under divided ownership of Ozaukee County and Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. It identified deteriorating facilities, infrastructure needs, fragmented management and volunteer limitations. Consultants favored retaining the Cedarburg location, improving coordination and pursuing County acquisition of Fireman’s Park to secure land needed for the Fair. Their preferred long-term option added a multipurpose building. 2002 alternatives Estimated capital cost Existing facility improvements with separate ownership $3,070,128 Improvements to county owned parcel with a multipurpose building $7,596,960 Relocation before sale of the existing grounds $19,464,200 Acquisition of Fireman’s parcel with existing facility improvements $4,305,128 Acquisition of Fireman’s parcel with a multipurpose building $8,831,960 Acquisition of the Fireman’s parcel in the 2002 report assumed 19 acres at $65,000 per acre, or $1,235,000. County investment following the study The County subsequently improved its portion of the Fairgrounds and expanded shared community use. Infrastructure work included sewer and water improvements, animal wash facilities, electrical upgrades and handwashing stations. Later redevelopment addressed grading, parking, lighting and stormwater management. On July 15, 2009, the Ozaukee County Board approved a purchase of 4.4 acres from Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. for $275,000 to accommodate multipurpose facilities supporting existing County Fair uses, the partnership with Milwaukee Curling Association, and rental uses. On August 3, 2011, the County Board approved the final Lease and Development Agreement with the Milwaukee Curling Association following consideration of a 50-year partnership. The club began curling at the site in October 2012. This arrangement established an anchor tenant with seasonal use complementary to the Fair and other events. Page 3 of 7 The Board also awarded $4.6 million in general obligation County building bonds on August 3, 2011, dated August 24, 2011. The authorized scope included a multipurpose curling facility, a pole barn and multipurpose building, parking, lighting and a drainage-retention pond. The borrowing amount is not presented here as the final total cost of all Fairgrounds improvements. The redevelopment produced facilities now known as the Ozaukee Pavilion and Ascension Columbia St. Mary’s Expo Center. County rental information identifies approximately 7,000 square feet in the Pavilion, available year-round, and 27,000 square feet in the Expo Center, available April through September around winter curling use. The gazebo and additional exhibition buildings followed in 2015 at a cost of $450,000. Historical context for the purchase price The 2002 Fairgrounds Study assumed a land acquisition price of $65,000 per acre. Applied to the approximately 16.18 acres now under consideration, that assumption produces a historical baseline of $1,051,700. A purchase price of $1.7 - $2.0 million represents approximately 2.0% - 2.7% annual compounded growth over 24 years. This provides historical context, although it does not independently establish current market value. More directly relevant is the appraisal prepared for Ozaukee County by L. A. Duesterbeck & Associates, Inc., dated August 29, 2025, with an effective valuation date of August 11, 2025. The appraisal identifies 16.183 acres and concludes an as-is market value of $1,495,000 for the fee simple interest in real estate. Its final reconciliation allocates $1,330,000 to land and $165,000 to existing improvements. Comparison Amount Relationship to 2025 appraisal Appraised as-is value $1,495,000 Baseline Potential purchase price $1,700,000 $205,000 above appraisal; 13.7% Potential purchase price $2,000,000 $505,000 above appraisal; 33.8% The appraised land component equates to approximately $82,185 per acre, compared with the study’s $65,000-per-acre assumption. This represents approximately 26.4% growth, or 1.03% annually over 23 years. The appraisers concluded that the highest and best use of the property as improved was continued operation as an outdoor event venue, while the land as though vacant was suited to residential development within the applicable zoning and land-use context. The 2025 appraisal serves as the principal valuation reference. Assessing the parcel’s value to the County for continued public fairgrounds use is challenging because comparable sales are limited and market value does not fully capture its educational, recreational and community benefits. Its connection to the County’s existing fairgrounds also provides benefits specific to the County, including coordinated operations and greater certainty for the County Fair’s future. Page 4 of 7 The County must weigh these public benefits against acquisition costs, future maintenance obligations, and available alternatives to determine an appropriate purchase price. Any purchase premium should be supported by separately documented public benefits, such as securing the Fair’s continued operation, consolidating ownership and avoiding the cost of alternative arrangements. Property trends and limits of the comparison Although comparing valuation growth in the City of Cedarburg by property class totals is not a like-for-like comparison, it provides additional context. The verified comparison available for this review is 2005–2025. These totals include land and buildings, new construction, redevelopment and classification changes. Property class 2005 value 2025 value Growth Annual Residential $860.8M $2,050.4M 138.2% 4.44% Commercial $172.6M $462.4M 167.9% 5.05% Manufacturing real estate $23.2M $45.0M 93.8% 3.36% Policy Analysis Considerations for the Continued use of the Cedarburg site Does the County intend to preserve the Fair at this location for the next 25–30 years, and what public purposes beyond the annual Fair should the property serve? Staff recommendation is that the County is committed to continuing the County Fair on the existing site considering the public funds expended to improve the currently county owned portion of the grounds. What is the cost to acquire the Fireman’s parcel? County leadership and Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. have held informal discussions on the ROFR and a potential purchase price. The potential purchase price ranges from $1.7 million to $2.0 million. The 2025 appraisal serves as the principal valuation reference. Assessing the parcel’s value to the County for continued public fairgrounds use is challenging because comparable sales are limited and market value does not fully capture its educational, recreational and community benefits. Its connection to the County’s existing fairgrounds also provides benefits specific to the County, including coordinated operations and greater certainty for the County Fair’s future. What are high-level estimates for the redevelopment of the Fireman’s parcel? Based on staff estimates and anecdotal discussions, demolition and a replacement grandstand would represent a preliminary commitment of $2.4 - $3.0 million before additional costs not included in those estimates. Page 5 of 7 Preliminary acquisition and redevelopment costs Component Working estimate Purchase of 16.18 acres $1,700,000–$2,000,000 Demolition of existing structures $400,000 Replacement grandstand $2,600,000 Combined initial commitment $4,600,000–$5,000,000 Which Fair activities require the Fireman’s parcel? Currently the Fireman’s parcel primarily hosts the midway for the County Fair and the area for the demolition derby and parking. Acquisition resolves long-term needs for these activities, absent this parcel the County Fair would be significantly impacted. What would it cost to relocate the County Fair Grounds? Staff does not view relocation as a viable alternative, given the County’s investment in the existing Fairgrounds and the substantially greater anticipated cost of relocation compared with acquisition and redevelopment. The historical information below provides context. The information is provided below. The 2002 Fairgrounds Study estimated that relocating the Fairgrounds and Fireman’s Park operations to the approximately 60-acre Kohlwey site would cost $19,464,200, including land acquisition, construction, utility extensions, contingency and related project costs. The study assumed that the existing grounds could be sold for approximately $2,535,000, reducing the net relocation cost to $16,929,200. These estimates predate the County’s subsequent investment in the Pavilion, Expo Center and other Fairgrounds improvements. A current relocation analysis would need to update construction and land costs, identify which facilities would require replacement, evaluate existing contractual commitments and determine realistic proceeds from disposition of the current property. Washington County moved its Fair in 1999 from 13 acres to a 133-acre site. The initial development included a 24,000-square-foot pavilion, four livestock barns, show arena, milking facilities, restrooms and animal wash facilities. This is a useful scope benchmark, but its size and program differ from Ozaukee’s. In 1997 Washington County issued $6.5 million in debt for acquisition and development of the parcel. What is the economic impact of the County Fair? Johnson Consulting prepared an economic impact study for the Ozaukee County Fair Board of Directors estimating that the 2024 Ozaukee County Fair generated $16.1 million in total economic activity, supported approximately $5.5 million in wages and 120 ongoing jobs, and attracted attendance of approximately 68,900. Page 6 of 7 Estimated direct spending totaled $7.3 million, including spending at the fair, purchases at surrounding businesses, and fair operations. The study estimates 8,100 visitors traveled from more than 50 miles away, with approximately 300 hotel room nights generated. Estimated tax revenues totaled $402,700, including $363,900 in state sales taxes, $36,400 in county sales taxes, and $2,400 in municipal hotel taxes. The fair’s estimated total economic impact was approximately 46% above the benchmark for Upper Midwest fairs with attendance between 25,000 and 100,000. Statement from Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. is seeking a $2,000,000 sales price on the property because it is the smallest amount for which they can sell the property and still fulfill their mission as a volunteer fire department commensurate with the income they have been receiving as owner of the parcel. Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. believes the property located within the city limits on Cedarburg’s main street would be far more valuable on the open market to a developer or real estate investor, but it is their preference to serve the County and the greater community by preserving our very special County Fair at its traditional and long-time location. So, while Cedarburg Fireman’s Park, Inc. may be in position to otherwise utilize the property to receive greater profit, they are simply looking to retain status quo for themselves financially and at the same time create a win-win-win for themselves, the City of Cedarburg and the County. Page 7 of 7

Source: Ozaukee County website. First collected Nov 17, 2026.