Packet
Walworth County · Walworth County · meeting of Nov 18, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Walworth County
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
November 18, 2026 Human Resources Committee Agenda
NOVEMBER 18, 2026 HR AGENDA.PDF
November 18, 2026 Human Resources Committee Packet
NOVEMBER 18, 2026 HR PACKET.PDF
1.
Documents:
2.
Documents:
County Board Human Resources Committee
MEETING NOTICE
Wednesday, November 18, 2026
3:30 PM
County Board Room 114
Walworth County Government Center
100 W. Walworth St., Elkhorn, Wisconsin
Susan Pruessing, Chair Bud Wojcik, Vice-Chair
Supervisor Kathy Ingersoll Supervisor Ken Monroe Supervisor Tyler Schneider
(Posted in compliance with Sec. 19.84 Wis. Stats.)
A quorum of the Health & Human Services Board and Lakeland Health Care Center Board of Trustees will be in
attendance. It is possible that a quorum of the county board or any of its other committees could be in
attendance at this meeting.
Agenda enclosures are available upon request from the County Administrator’s Office or on the County’s
web page (www.co.walworth.wi.us).
A G E N D A
Note: all agenda items are subject to action.
1. Call to order
2. Roll call of committee members
3. Agenda withdrawals, if any
4. Agenda approval
5. Approval of Minutes
a) October 21, 2026, Human Resources Committee Meeting (encl. pp. 1-2)
6. Public Comment Period
7. New Business
a) Contract award recommendation for the County’s Stop Loss Insurance for the
Health Insurance Fund (encl. pp. 3-14)
b) Res. No. **-12/26 Granting a Leave of Absence for Daniel Nichols to Serve as
Undersheriff (encl. pp. 15-16)
NOTICE: THIS MEETING IS PLANNED TO PROVIDE FOR REMOTE OR OFF -SITE ATTENDANCE
BY COMMITTEE MEMBERS.
THE PUBLIC CAN WATCH THE MEETING STREAMING LIVE: https://bit.ly/2026NovHRC
Individuals wanting to provide a Public Comment can do so remotely by telephone but must contact
the County Administrator’s Office at 262-741-4357 on the day of the meeting and at least 15 minutes
prior to the start of the meeting to obtain instructions.
AGENDA – Walworth County Human Resources Committee
Wednesday, November 18, 2026, at 3:30 PM Page 2 of 2
c) Compensation Project Discussion: Pay Delivery and Implementation Impact
(encl. pp. 17-44)
8. Reports/announcements by Chairperson
9. Set/confirm next meeting date and time – Wednesday, December 16, 2026, at 3:30 p.m.
10. Adjournment
Submitted by: Susan Pruessing, Committee Chairperson
Kate Bishop, Human Resources Director
Posted: November 12, 2026
Human Resources | 100 W. Walworth St. | PO Box 1001 | Elkhorn, WI 53121
www.co.walworth.wi.us | (262) 741-7950 (o) | (262) 741-7948
Memorandum
To: Walworth County Human Resources Committee
Cc: Mark Luberda, County Administrator
From: Kate Bishop, Human Resources Director
Date: November 13, 2026
RE: November 18, 2026, Human Resources Committee Meeting
_______ _______________________
New Business:
a.) Contract award recommendation for the County’s Stop Loss Insurance for the
Health Insurance Fund . It is time to renew the Health Insurance Fund’s stop loss
insurance for fiscal year 2027. Stop loss insurance protects the insurer—in this case,
Walworth County—against large claims by providing coverage after claims exceed a
specified threshold. Our threshold is $175,000. Walworth County Human Resources,
in conjunction with its benefits consultant, Hausmann Group, recommends renewing
with the County’s current provider, QBE, as the carrier for 2027. Supporting
documents have been included for review. Jesse Oberloh, Senior Employee Benefits
Advisor with the Hausmann Group, will be present to review the materials and provide
additional details regarding the recommendation. Human Resources requests
favorable approval of the selection. The recommendation will then be forwarded to the
Finance Committee for its approval.
b.) Granting a Leave of Absence for Daniel Nichols to Serve as Undersheriff. As you
are aware, Undersheriff Tom Hauser has been elected to serve as the next Sheriff of
Walworth County and will take office on January 4, 2027. As you can see from the
enclosed memorandum from Undersheriff Hausner, he has appointed Captain Daniel
(Dan) Nichols to the position of Undersheriff. The is allowable under Section 15- 191
of the Walworth County Code of Ordinances. The draft resolution is enclosed for your
review.
2
Human Resources Cover Memo- November 2026
c.) Compensation Project Discussion: Pay Delivery and Implementation Impact .
Cottingham & Butler will present detailed cost projections showing the County’s
position at 50%, 55%, and 60% of the market, consistent with direction from the
Committee of the Whole’s September 28 session. These projections will help the
committee assess the immediate and long -term fiscal effects of each market-
positioning option.
Cottingham & Butler will also share preliminary pay plan drafts for committee review.
The presentation will address the County’s proposed transition from step progression
for hourly/non- exempt employees and performance- based increases for
salaried/exempt employees to a hybrid compensation model. Because the County
Board had limited time to consider the advantages and disadvantages of this direction,
the consultants will review them in greater detail.
Cottingham & Butler will explain the practical implications of adopting a hybrid system.
The discussion will cover:
• Challenges, including change management , manager readiness, consistent
administration of performance-based pay across job classifications, and
alignment with County operational needs.
• Benefits, including greater consistency in plan design and pay administration
across classifications, increased flexibility, and the ability to differentiate pay
based on performance.
• Implementation, including the required steps and decisions and the projected
financial impact of various implementation approaches.
By the end of the meeting, committee members should understand how each market-
positioning scenario would affect County expenditures, how the proposed pay plans
support organizational objectives, and the steps required to formally adopt a hybrid
compensation structure.
The requested health plan information follows the consultant’s materials.
DRAFT Walworth County Board of Supervisors
H
uman Resources Committee Meeting Minutes
Wednesday, October 21, 2026
Walworth County Government Center, County Board Room 114
100 West Walworth Street, Elkhorn, Wisconsin
Chair Susan Pruessing called the meeting to order at 3:30 p.m.
R
oll call was conducted, and the following members were present: Chair Susan Pruessing; Vice-Chair Bud
Wojcik; and Supervisors Kathy Ingersoll, Kenneth Monroe, and Tyler Schneider. A quorum was declared.
O
thers in Attendance
County Staff: Walworth County Administrator Mark W. Luberda; Corporation Counsel/Director of Land Use and
Resource Management Michael Cotter; Human Resources Manager Donna McIntyre; and Director-Finance
Jessica Conley.
O
n motion by Supervisor Schneider, second by Vice-Chair Wojcik, the agenda was approved with no
withdrawals.
O
n motion by Supervisor Monroe, second by Supervisor Ingersoll, the September 16, 2026, Human
Resources Committee meeting minutes were approved.
P
ublic Comment – There was none.
N
ew Business
7a) Res. No. **-11/26 Authorizing the Creation of a 1.00 FTE Special Education Aide Position at Lakeland
School
Supervisor Monroe offered a motion, second by Supervisor Ingersoll, to approve Authorizing the
Creation of a 1.00 FTE Special Education Aide Position at Lakeland School. Motion carried 5-0.
7b)
Res. No. **-11/26 Authorizing Position Changes by Department Based on the 2027 Budget
Human Resources Manager Donna McIntyre reported this is an annual item for each new budget year.
Supervisor Schneider offered a motion, second by Supervisor Monroe, to approve Authorizing Position
Changes by Department Based on the 2027 Budget. Motion carried 5-0.
7c) R
es. No. **-11/26 Adding Approved New Position Titles to the 2026 Pay Ranges for Certain Non-
Represented Hourly Employees and Salaried Exempt Employees
McIntyre stated that this is an annual item that is typically reviewed as part of the pay range adjustment
process. However, because the County is currently conducting a compensation study, this item is being
presented to the committee separately. Supervisor Ingersoll offered a motion, second by Vice-Chair
Wojcik, to approve Adding Approved New Position Titles to the 2026 Pay Ranges for Certain Non-
Represented Hourly Employees and Salaried Exempt Employees. Motion carried 5-0.
7d
) Res. No. **-11/26 Delaying Increase in Current Active Employees’ Share of Health Insurance Premium
Equivalents for the First Four Months of 2027 and Amending the Budget to Transfer 2026 General Fund Salary
Reserves to the Health Insurance Fund and Decrease the 2027 Health Insurance Fund Revenues
Walworth County Administrator Mark W. Luberda recommended using available County funds to temporarily
offset anticipated employee health insurance premium increases. He explained that employees traditionally
receive cost-of-living adjustments in January; however, the ongoing Classification and Compensation Study will
not be completed in time for the County Board to make compensation-related decisions before the start of the
year. To provide the County Board with adequate time to review the study's findings and allow administration
sufficient time to implement any approved compensation changes, Luberda proposed in the 2027
Administrator’s Budget using available funding to maintain current employee health insurance premium
contributions for approximately four months, which is what this resolution does. This approach would defer
1 of 44
Walworth County Board of Supervisors
October 21, 2026, Human Resources Committee Meeting Minutes
Page 2 of 2
p
remium changes until after the County Board has had the opportunity to complete its review and render a
decision regarding the study. Questions were raised regarding the implications of completing the
compensation study either ahead of schedule or later than anticipated, including whether approved changes
would be implemented early and how delays beyond the projected timeline would be addressed. Luberda
indicated that implementing changes ahead of schedule would likely not be efficient. He further stated that if
the study extended beyond the anticipated timeline, administration would evaluate available options at that
time. Luberda noted that if the resolution is approved by the Committee, he would be providing a notification to
employees regarding this resolution and it’s intent. Supervisor Monroe offered a motion, second by
Supervisor Schneider, to approve Delaying Increase in Current Active Employees’ Share of Health
Insurance Premium Equivalents for the First Four Months of 2027 and Amending the Budget to Transfer
2026 General Fund Salary Reserves to the Health Insurance Fund and Decrease the 2027 Health
Insurance Fund Revenues. Motion carried 5-0.
7
e) 2027 Preliminary Budget (An additional opportunity for discussion or to Propose amendments, if any)
Director-Finance Jessica Conley reported that an amendment to the Budget is being presented to both the
Finance Committee and the Children with Disabilities Education Board regarding the inclusion of a Special
Education Aide position in the 2027 budget for the full year. Funding for the position is proposed to come
partially from tuition revenue and partially from fund balance. Conley noted that the amendment will be
presented to the County Board in November. The committee had not received the amendment and as a result
took no action on the proposed budget amendment.
R
eports
8a) Update on the Walworth County Classification and Compensation Study
McIntyre referenced the memorandum from Director-Human Resources Kate Bishop, located on pages 27-29
of the meeting packet. Cottingham and Butler will be present at the November 18, 2026, Human Resources
Committee meeting. The presentation is expected to include the information previously requested by the
County Board, as well as a report on the advantages and disadvantages of the Hybrid Plan, as requested by
Luberda. Chair Pruessing encouraged all County Board members to attend the meeting or, alternatively, view
the meeting recording.
R
eports/announcements by Chairperson – There were none.
C
onfirmation of next meeting date and time: The next meeting was confirmed for Wednesday, November
18, 2026, at 3:30 p.m.
A
djournment
O
n motion and second by Supervisor Monroe and Supervisor Schneider, Chair Susan Pruessing
adjourned the meeting at 3:46 p.m.
__________________________________________________________________________________________________
Submitted by Sarah Larsen, Administrative Assistant. Meeting minutes are not considered final until approved by the Human Resources Committee at
the next regularly scheduled meeting.
2 of 44
Walworth County
2027 Stop Loss Renewal Recommendation
Executive Summary
Walworth County transitioned its stop loss coverage from Voya to QBE effective January 1, 2024. The current
stop loss program includes:
Specific deductible of $175,000 (increased from $150,000 in 2026)
No new lasers at renewal
50% renewal rate cap
Coverage for both pre-65 and post-65 retirees
Experience Refund provision
Through September 2026, six members have exceeded the $175,000 specific deductible, with an additional
seven members currently above $125,000 in claims and approaching the stop loss threshold. Claims exceeding
the specific deductible total $1,730,169 year-to-date, compared to $4,268,747 in the prior plan year. While
large claim activity has moderated, current results remain well above the threshold required to qualify for an
Experience Refund, and no refund is anticipated for 2026.
Initial Renewal Offers
QBE's initial renewal proposals for 2027 reflected significant premium increases:
Specific Deductible Premium Increase
$175,000 40.26%
$200,000 26.90%
$225,000 17.41%
Market Review
Hausmann Group marketed the stop loss program to 17 carriers to ensure Walworth County received the
most competitive renewal terms available. Quotes were received from QBE, HCC, PartnerRe, Sun Life, Symetra,
Voya, and Wellpoint. Ten additional carriers declined to provide terms.
3 of 44
The market generated highly competitive alternatives, including proposals from Voya and Wellpoint that
significantly improved upon QBE's initial renewal pricing. These competing offers, combined with additional
information regarding ongoing high-cost claimants, enabled Hausmann Group to negotiate substantially
improved terms with the incumbent carrier. Following a final round of negotiations, both QBE and Voya
submitted materially reduced pricing.
Final Renewal Results (Appendix A)
QBE's final renewal proposal maintains two important contract protections:
No new lasers at renewal
50% renewal rate cap
As part of the negotiations, the Experience Refund provision was removed, generating approximately 5% in
premium savings. QBE's final renewal options are:
Specific Deductible Premium Change
$175,000 12.45%
$200,000 2.30%
$225,000 -4.67%
Voya's final proposal produced total premiums approximately $4,000 lower than QBE's $175,000 option.
However, the Voya proposal includes a shorter run-in period (24/12 versus QBE's 60/12) and a higher
aggregate attachment point, resulting in greater overall financial exposure for the County.
Aggregate Coverage Analysis
Aggregate stop loss coverage serves as the County's financial protection against overall claims volatility.
Through negotiations, QBE reduced aggregate premiums from $3.85 PEPM to $2.22 PEPM, generating annual
savings of approximately $14,357. Additionally, QBE's proposal increases the County's maximum liability
exposure by only 3.09% over 2026 levels, while Voya's proposal would increase maximum liability by
approximately $160,000 more than QBE.
Specific Deductible Analysis
Hausmann Group modeled multiple deductible scenarios to determine the most cost-effective stop loss
strategy for 2027. Based on projected claim activity and premium costs, the analysis indicates that maintaining
4 of 44
the $175,000 specific deductible provides the strongest balance between premium expense and expected
reimbursement value. See Appendix B for detailed modeling results.
Experience Refund Considerations
QBE's 2026 contract included an Experience Refund provision designed to return premium dollars when claims
performance met specific targets. Walworth County qualified for and received a refund of $47,969 based on
2024 results. No refund was earned for the 2025 plan year, and none is expected for 2026 given the current
loss ratio of approximately 82%, compared to the required threshold of 65% or less.
The Experience Refund feature carries an estimated premium load of approximately 5%. As part of the renewal
negotiations, QBE removed this provision, reducing fixed costs by approximately $171,000 annually. Given
both the historical performance and future refund prospects, the premium savings associated with removing
the rider outweigh the potential value of retaining it.
Final Recommendation
Hausmann Group recommends renewing stop loss coverage with QBE for the 2027 plan year with a specific
deductible of $175,000.
This option provides the most favorable overall value by:
Maintaining no individual laser liability
Preserving the no new lasers renewal protection
Retaining the 50% renewal rate cap
Limiting aggregate liability exposure relative to competing proposals
Including Gene Therapy protection to mitigate exposure to high-cost gene therapy treatments
Delivering the most cost-effective balance between premium expense and risk assumption by the
County
At the $175,000 deductible level, QBE's final renewal reflects an approximately 11.9% increase in total stop
loss premium, while continuing to provide the contractual protections and risk management features that
best align with Walworth County's long-term objectives.
5 of 44
Walworth County
Effective: 1/1/2027
Current Renewal 1 Option 1 Option 2 Option 3
Carrier QBE QBE Voya Wellpoint Symetra
Policy Wellpoint Life and Health
Individual Specific Deductible $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000
Specific Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Annual Specific Premium $ 3
,077,073 $ 3,460,098 $ 3,450,949 $ 3,689,400 $ 4,182,028
Aggregate Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Aggregate Benefits Included Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx
Annual Aggregate Premium $ 3
3,911 $ 1
9,554 $ 24,751 $ 29,948 $ 44,393
Aggregate Attachment Point $ 2
3,987,485 $ 24,727,754 $ 24,881,249 $ 24,707,112 $ 26,709,994
Lasers and Restrictions None None None None Claimant 1 @ $1M
Annual Fixed Premium (Spec & Agg Premium) $ 3
,110,984 $ 3,479,652 $ 3,475,700 $ 3,719,348 $ 4,226,421
% Difference 11.85% 11.72% 19.56% 35.85%
GTS Annual Total $ 4
1,838.00 $ 41,838.00 $ 41,838.00 $ 41,838.00 $ 41,838.00
Maximum Cost Liability (Fixed + Attachment + GTS
+ Amwins Advance) $ 2
7,140,307 $ 28,249,244 $ 28,398,787 $ 28,468,298 $ 30,978,253
% Difference 4.09% 4.64% 4.89% 14.14%
Commissions 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
SUMMARY
The above content is a high-level summary of carrier, plan, and product information. Please refer to the complete proposal for further detail.
Appendix A
6 of 44
Walworth County
Effective: 1/1/2027
Current Renewal 1 Option 1 Option 2 Option 3
Carrier QBE QBE Voya Wellpoint Symetra
Policy Wellpoint Life and Health
Carrier Rating A A A A A
TPA Auxiant Auxiant Auxiant Auxiant Auxiant
PPO Network HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS
UR Vendor American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc.
PBM Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics
Specific Benefits Included Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx
Plan Lifetime Maximum Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited
Individual Specific Deductible: $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000
Specific Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Spec TLO No No Yes 3 Months No No
275 EE Only 147.79$ 166.60$ 179.20$ 177.20$ 208.51$
459 Family 470.11$ 528.38$ 519.17$ 563.66$ 634.34$
734 Composite 349.35$ 392.84$ 391.80$ 418.87$ 474.80$
Annual Specific Premium $ 3,077,073 $ 3,460,098 $ 3,450,949 $ 3,689,400 $ 4,182,028
% Difference 12.45% 12.15% 19.90% 35.91%
Disclosure Status Firm Through 10/16/2026 Firm Through 10/16/2027 Firm Through 10/9/2026 Firm Through 10/5/2026
Lasers and Restrictions None None None Claimant 1 @ $1M
No New Laser + Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap
Experience Refund Yes Not Included Not Included Yes Yes
GTS (PEPM) $ 4.75 $ 4.75 $ 4.75 $ 4.75 $ 4.75
Am
wins Advance (PEPM) Not Included Not Included Not Included Not Included Not Included
Commissions 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
SPECIFIC STOP LOSS
All applicable legal terms and conditions governing this proposal are outlined on the Contingency page; please review that section for complete details.
7 of 44
Walworth County
Effective: 1/1/2027
Current Renewal 1 Option 1 Option 2 Option 3
Carrier QBE QBE Voya Wellpoint Symetra
PPO Network HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS
Individual Specific Deductible: $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000 $175,000
Specific Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Aggregate Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Aggregate Benefits Included Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx
Aggregate Corridor 125% 120% 125% 125% 125%
Annual Max Reimbursement $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000
Aggregate TLO Included ($1.04) Included ($1.04) Included Not Included Not Included
734 Composite 3.85$ 2.22$ 2.81$ 3.40$ 5.04$
Annual Aggregate Premium 33,911$ 19,554$ 24,751$ 29,948$ 44,393$
Aggregate Attachment
275 EE Only 1,328.54$ 1,387.24$ 1,353.17$ 1,368.40$ 1,688.00$
459 Family 3,559.06$ 3,658.29$ 3,706.57$ 3,665.83$ 3,837.98$
734 Composite 2,723.37$ 2,807.42$ 2,824.85$ 2,805.08$ 3,032.47$
Aggregate Attachment Point 23,987,485$ 24,727,754$ 24,881,249$ 24,707,112$ 26,709,994$
% Difference 3.09% 3.73% 3.00% 11.35%
Commissions 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
All applicable legal terms and conditions governing this proposal are outlined on the Contingency page; please review that section for complete details.
AGGREGATE STOP LOSS
8 of 44
Walworth County
Effective: 1/1/2027
Current Renewal 2 Option 4 Option 5 Option 6
Carrier QBE QBE Voya Wellpoint Symetra
Policy Wellpoint Life and Health
Carrier Rating A A A A A
TPA Auxiant Auxiant Auxiant Auxiant Auxiant
PPO Network HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS
UR Vendor American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc.
PBM Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics
Specific Benefits Included Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx
Plan Lifetime Maximum Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited
Individual Specific Deductible: $175,000 $200,000 $200,000 $200,000 $200,000
Specific Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Spec TLO No No Yes 3 Months No No
275 EE Only 147.79$ 150.51$ 163.68$ 163.02$ 188.30$
459 Family 470.11$ 483.75$ 475.63$ 518.57$ 579.12$
734 Composite 349.35$ 358.90$ 358.76$ 385.36$ 432.70$
Annual Specific Premium $ 3,077,073 $ 3,161,178 $ 3,159,915 $ 3,394,250 $ 3,811,183
% Differ
ence 2.73% 2.69% 10.31% 23.86%
Disclosure Status Firm Through 10/16/2026 Firm Through 10/16/2027 Firm Through 10/9/2026 Firm Through 10/5/2026
Lasers and Restrictions None None None Claimant 1 @ $1M
No New Laser + Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap
Experience Refund Yes Not Included Not Included Yes Yes
GTS (PEPM) $ 4.75 $ 4.75 $ 4.75 $ 4.75 $ 4.75
Am
wins Advance (PEPM) Not Included Not Included Not Included Not Included Not Included
Commissions 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
SPECIFIC STOP LOSS
All applicable legal terms and conditions governing this proposal are outlined on the Contingency page; please review that section for complete details.
9 of 44
Walworth County
Effective: 1/1/2027
Current Renewal 2 Option 4 Option 5 Option 6
Carrier QBE QBE Voya Wellpoint Symetra
PPO Network HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS
Individual Specific Deductible: $175,000 $200,000 $200,000 $200,000 $200,000
Specific Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Aggregate Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Aggregate Benefits Included Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx
Aggregate Corridor 125% 120% 125% 125% 125%
Annual Max Reimbursement $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000
Aggregate TLO Included ($1.04) Included ($1.04) Included Not Included Not Included
734 Composite 3.85$ 2.29$ 3.62$ 3.45$ 5.16$
Annual Aggregate Premium 33,911$ 20,171$ 31,885$ 30,388$ 45,450$
Aggregate Attachment
275 EE Only 1,328.54$ 1,409.09$ 1,381.88$ 1,421.54$ 1,711.43$
459 Family 3,559.06$ 3,715.90$ 3,785.23$ 3,808.19$ 3,891.27$
734 Composite 2,723.37$ 2,851.63$ 2,884.79$ 2,914.01$ 3,074.57$
Aggregate Attachment Point 23,987,485$ 25,117,175$ 25,409,251$ 25,666,593$ 27,080,835$
% Difference 4.71% 5.93% 7.00% 12.90%
Commissions 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
All applicable legal terms and conditions governing this proposal are outlined on the Contingency page; please review that section for complete details.
AGGREGATE STOP LOSS
10 of 44
Walworth County
Effective: 1/1/2027
Current Renewal 3 Option 7 Option 8 Option 9
Carrier QBE QBE Voya Wellpoint Symetra
Policy Wellpoint Life and Health
Carrier Rating A A A A A
TPA Auxiant Auxiant Auxiant Auxiant Auxiant
PPO Network HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS
UR Vendor American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc. American Health Holding, Inc.
PBM Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics Prime Therapeutics
Specific Benefits Included Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx
Plan Lifetime Maximum Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited Unlimited
Individual Specific Deductible: $175,000 $225,000 $225,000 $225,000 $225,000
Specific Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Spec TLO No No Yes 3 Months No No
275 EE Only 147.79$ 138.22$ 150.85$ 148.85$ 171.96$
459 Family 470.11$ 449.74$ 439.14$ 473.48$ 534.47$
734 Composite 349.35$ 333.03$ 331.13$ 351.85$ 398.65$
Annual Specific Premium $ 3,077,073 $ 2,933,294 $ 2,916,589 $ 3,099,133 $ 3,511,329
% Differ
ence -4.67% -5.22% 0.72% 14.11%
Disclosure Status Firm Through 10/16/2026 Firm Through 10/16/2027 Firm Through 10/9/2026 Firm Through 10/5/2026
Lasers and Restrictions None None None Claimant 1 @ $1M
No New Laser + Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap Included + 50% Rate Cap
Experience Refund Yes Not Included Not Included Yes Yes
GTS (PEPM) $ 4.75 $ 4.75 $ 4.75 $ 4.75 $ 4.75
Am
wins Advance (PEPM) Not Included Not Included Not Included Not Included Not Included
Commissions 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
SPECIFIC STOP LOSS
All applicable legal terms and conditions governing this proposal are outlined on the Contingency page; please review that section for complete details.
11 of 44
Walworth County
Effective: 1/1/2027
Current Renewal 3 Option 7 Option 8 Option 9
Carrier QBE QBE Voya Wellpoint Symetra
PPO Network HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS HPS,PHCS
Individual Specific Deductible: $175,000 $225,000 $225,000 $225,000 $225,000
Specific Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Aggregate Contract 48/12 60/12 24/12 24/12 36/12
Aggregate Benefits Included Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx Med + Rx
Aggregate Corridor 125% 120% 125% 125% 125%
Annual Max Reimbursement $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000 $1,000,000
Aggregate TLO Included ($1.04) Included ($1.04) Included Not Included Not Included
734 Composite 3.85$ 2.34$ 3.85$ 3.65$ 5.29$
Annual Aggregate Premium 33,911$ 20,611$ 33,911$ 32,150$ 46,595$
Aggregate Attachment
275 EE Only 1,328.54$ 1,427.25$ 1,401.04$ 1,474.68$ 1,730.38$
459 Family 3,559.06$ 3,763.80$ 3,837.69$ 3,950.56$ 3,934.36$
734 Composite 2,723.37$ 2,888.39$ 2,924.78$ 3,022.95$ 3,108.62$
Aggregate Attachment Point 23,987,485$ 25,440,936$ 25,761,429$ 26,626,129$ 27,380,709$
% Difference 6.06% 7.40% 11.00% 14.15%
Commissions 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
All applicable legal terms and conditions governing this proposal are outlined on the Contingency page; please review that section for complete details.
AGGREGATE STOP LOSS
12 of 44
Walworth County
Effective: 1/1/2027
Amwins Gene Therapy Solutions
734 Composite 4.75$
Monthly Specific Premium 3,486.50$
Annual Specific Premium 41,838.00$
GTS Covers
Zolgensma Elevidys Tecelra
Luxturna Casgevy Encelto
Spinraza Lyfgenia Kebilidi
Zynteglo Lenmeldy Zevaskyn
Skysona Abecma Itvisma
Roctavian Carvykti
Hemgenix Rethymic
13 of 44
Walworth County - Deductible Selection Worksheet (2027)
Enrolled Employees 10/1/2026
Single 275
Family 459
Total 734
Stop Loss Options Current Option 1 Option 2 Option 3
QBE QBE QBE QBE
ISL Deductible $175,000 $175,000 $200,000 $225,000
Contract Basis 48/12 60/12 60/12 60/12
Aggregate Rate $3.85 $2.22 $2.29 $2.34
Aggregate Premium $33,911 $19,554 $20,170 $20,611
Change from Current -42.3% -40.5% -39.2%
QBE Composite $349.35 $392.84 $358.90 $333.03
QBE Premium $3,077,075 $3,460,135 $3,161,191 $2,933,328
Change from Current 12.4% 2.7% -4.7%
Total Stop Loss Premium $3,110,986 $3,479,688 $3,181,362 $2,953,939
Change from Current 11.9% 2.3% -5.0%
Premium + No Claims $3,479,688 $3,181,362 $2,953,939
Premium + 1 Claim $3,654,688 $3,381,362 $3,178,939
Premium + 2 Claims $3,829,688 $3,581,362 $3,403,939
Premium + 3 Claims $4,004,688 $3,781,362 $3,628,939
Premium + 4 Claims $4,179,688 $3,981,362 $3,853,939
Premium + 5 Claims $4,354,688 $4,181,362 $4,078,939
Premium + 6 Claims $4,529,688 $4,381,362 $4,303,939
Premium + 7 Claims $4,704,688 $4,581,362 $4,528,939
Premium + 8 Claims $4,879,688 $4,781,362 $4,753,939
Premium + 9 Claims $5,054,688 $4,981,362 $4,978,939
Premium + 10 Claims $5,229,688 $5,181,362 $5,203,939
Premium + 11 Claims $5,404,688 $5,381,362 $5,428,939
Premium + 12 Claims $5,579,688 $5,581,362 $5,653,939
Premium + 13 Claims $5,754,688 $5,781,362 $5,878,939
Premium + 14 Claims $5,929,688 $5,981,362 $6,103,939
Premium + 15 Claims $6,104,688 $6,181,362 $6,328,939
Premium + 16 Claims $6,279,688 $6,381,362 $6,553,939
Premium + 17 Claims $6,454,688 $6,581,362 $6,778,939
Premium + 18 Claims $6,629,688 $6,781,362 $7,003,939
Premium + 19 Claims $6,804,688 $6,981,362 $7,228,939
Premium + 20 Claims $6,979,688 $7,181,362 $7,453,939
Represents being within 5% of the minimum value, which is indicated with bolded text, in that row.
14 of 44
1
Resolution No. **-12/26
Granting a Leave of Absence for Daniel Nichols to Serve as Undersheriff
M
oved/Sponsored by: Human Resources Committee 1
2
WHEREAS, Pursuant to Section 59.26 of the Wisconsin State statutes, the Sheriff shall appoint 3
an Undersheriff; and, 4
5
WHEREAS, Thomas Hausner, who will assume the Office of Sheriff on January 4, 2027, has 6
announced the appointment of Captain Daniel Nichols as Undersheriff of the Walworth County 7
Sheriff’s Office effective that same date; and, 8
9
WHEREAS, Section 15-191 of the Walworth County Code of Ordinances authorizes a deputy to 10
take a leave of absence to serve as Undersheriff and upon completion of his duties as 11
Undersheriff, he shall immediately be returned to his former Deputy Sheriff position of Captain 12
without loss of any rights. 13
14
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED by the Walworth County Board of Supervisors that 15
Captain Daniel Nichols is hereby granted a leave of absence from his duties as Captain to assume 16
the position of Undersheriff for the Walworth County Sheriff’s Office. Upon completion of his 17
duties as Undersheriff, Daniel Nichols shall immediately be returned to his former Deputy 18
Sheriff position of Captain pursuant to the above-stated ordinance. 19
20
BE IT FURTHER RESOLVED that salary and benefits for the position shall be provided in 21
accordance with the Walworth County Code of Ordinances. 22
23
24
25
26
27
Rick Stacey Susi Pike 28
County Board Chair County Clerk 29
30
County Board Meeting Date: December 8, 2026 31
32
Action Required: Majority Vote X Two-thirds Vote Other ______ 33
Policy and Fiscal Note is attached.
Reviewed and approved pursuant to Section 2-91 of the Walworth County Code of Ordinances:
____
________________________ _____________________________
Michael P. Cotter Date Jessica Conley Date
Corporation Counsel Finance Director
Mark W. Luberda Date
County Administrator
I
f unsigned, exceptions shall be so noted by the County Administrator.
15 of 44
2
Policy and Fiscal Note
Resolution No. **-12/26
I. T
itle: Granting a Leave of Absence for Daniel Nichols to Serve as Undersheriff
II. P
urpose and Policy Impact Statement: The purpose of this resolution is to authorize a
leave of absence for Daniel Nichols to serve as the Undersheriff, pursuant to Walworth
County Ordinance 15-191.
III. B
udget and Fiscal Impact: Passage of this resolution will have minimal impact on the
2027 budget.
I
V. Referred to the following standing committees for consideration and date of
referral:
C
ommittee: Human Resources Committee Date: November 18, 2026
V
ote:
C
ounty Board Meeting Date: December 8, 2026
Policy and fiscal note has been reviewed and approved as an accurate statement of the probable policy and fiscal
impacts associated with passage of the attached resolution.
____
_______________________________ ____________________________________
Michael P. Cotter Date Jessica Conley Date
Corporation Counsel Finance Director
Mark W. Luberda Date
County Administrator
16 of 44
P R E S E N T E D B Y
Compensation Project Discussion: Pay
Delivery and Implementation Impact
Walworth County, WI N o v e m b e r 1 8 , 2 0 2 6
Total Rewards Consulting, A Division of Cottingham and Butler
Jenna Bidwell| Director, Total Rewards Consulting
Shanon Swaney | Consultant, Total Rewards Consulting
Alyssa Woltring| Analyst, Total Rewards Consulting
17 of 44
RECAP OF PRIOR DISCUSSION
• Reviewed market results
• Overall, County sitting competitively with current pay at 101.3% of the median
market
• Education results: Teacher structure & current pay more competitive later in
schedule, lags at beginning of structure. Current merit practices help achieve more
competitive pay. Therapist rates lag more than teachers with SLP representing the
greatest gap and will benefit from re-aligning with market practices.
• Discussed target market placement
• Current target is median market, County is meeting with this current pay
• Reviewed potential for a more aggressive target market placement and TRC will
provide costing for median (50th percentile), as well as 55th and 60th percentile
placements
• Discussed pay design
• Reviewed observations in current pay delivery; number of pay structures combined
with varying philosophies within
• Consideration for more consolidated groupings
• Consideration for consistent pay delivery: hybrid model
2
18 of 44
AGENDA FOR TODAY
Review of Hybrid Pay System
3
Pay Philosophy & Design Impact Considerations
Target Market Placement Review
Estimated Cost Impact
19 of 44
THREE BASIC PAY MODELS
TENURE (STEPS) PERFORMANCE (OPEN
RANGE)
HYBRID
• Based on the idea of long-term
employment
• Almost all pay raises are step
progression, promotion or across-
the-board
• Step advancement should still be
based on an annual performance
review that “meets expectations”
• More predictable, compact
structure
• Rewards for tenure and assumes
increasing competency and
mastery in role with time
• Employees compete for pay, and
the best are rewarded
• Less predictability
• Lower hiring rates with the
tradeoff of potentially higher
maximum with continued
outstanding performance
• Can be difficult to move
employees past C/P
• Can come with additional risk
based on how well performance
system is administered
• Less differentiation based on
performance (step based until
control point)
• Clear path to the control point (i.e.
midpoint of range), but no
promise beyond that unless
performance meets organization’s
standards
• Can be difficult to move
employees past C/P
• Can come with additional risk
based on how well performance
system is administered
4
20 of 44
WHAT IS A HYBRID PAY SYSTEM?
5
In a hybrid pay system
employees progress
through defined steps to a
designated control point
(C/P), providing
predictable and equitable
early-career advancement.
Once employees reach the
control point, future
movement within the open
range is determined by
performance.
21 of 44
CONSIDERATIONS IN ADOPTING A HYBRID PAY SYSTEM
6
Potential Benefits Potential Challenges
• Allows opportunity to have some differentiation based on
performance. Strengthens the connection between
performance management and compensation decisions.
• Supports career growth; provides clear progression for newer
employees learning their role and continued incentives beyond
C/P for skill mastery & contribution.
• Consistency in philosophy and administration across the
County.
• When managed well, can help create meaningful incentive for
retention and sustained effort.
• Shift in employee expectations, particularly hourly employees.
Hourly staff are accustomed to predictable step-based
movement.
• Performance evaluations must be administered consistently
across departments; managers must be trained and supported
to equitable and efficiently differentiate performance without
bias.
• Perception of inconsistency or favoritism can arise if standards
are not clearly communicated and applied; employees may
question why colleagues receive different increase amounts
than they did.
Key Considerations for Successful Implementation
• Not all employees can be or
should be rated “exceeding
expectations”. Performance
standards must be clearly
communicated and applied
equitably across departments.
• Employees must have clear and
reasonable expectations around
performance standards and annual
compensation growth. The hybrid pay
system does not mean larger
individual employee increases year
over year for the majority of
employees.
• Additional manager training
will be needed to ensure
performance management
process is consistent and
support their ability to have
meaningful performance
conversations.
22 of 44
A THREE-LEVEL SCALE CLARIFIES PERFORMANCE EXPECTATIONS
7
Recommendation: consolidate five ratings into three distinct performance categories.
CURRENT | 5 RATINGS RECOMMENDED | 3 RATINGS
High Level
Contributor
Solid Contributor
Average
Needs Improvement
Not Meeting
Expectations
WHY SIMPLIFY?
More consistent
evaluations; the more
levels the harder it can
be to meaningfully
differentiate and
communicate
Exceeds
Expectations
Consistently surpasses normal role
requirements through exceptional
initiative, results beyond expectations,
and significant value.
AWARD
SELECTIVELY
Meets
Expectations
Strong, successful performance: fulfills key
responsibilities, meets standards,
demonstrates required competencies,
and contributes meaningfully.
EXPECTED
MAJORITY
Not Meeting
Expectations
Performance does not consistently meet
role standards; identify gaps, set clear
expectations, and provide coaching and
support.
COACH TO
IMPROVE
Meets Expectations represents strong, successful performance, not a lesser
rating.
23 of 44
MOVEMENT WITHIN THE HYBRID STRUCTURE
Step 1 Step 2 Step 3 Step 4 Step 5 Step 6 Performance Range Max
90.00% 92.00% 94.00% 96.00% 98.00% 100.00% 118.00%
Hybrid Structure Option
Recommended Merit Matrix
Rating Levels Performance Range Increase
Exceeds Expectations 2.75% - 3.75%
Meets Expectations 1.5% - 2.5%
Not Meeting Expectations 0%
Merit Matrices can be static
or fluctuate annually based
on budget affordability and
organizational desire
Movement annually based upon meeting expectations
performance eval rating
Movement variable and based upon
performance evaluation score and
merit matrix
8
24 of 44
PAY DELIVERY /PHILOSOPHY IMPACT
9
Current
Structure Name Min % of
Market
Max % of
Market
Non-Premium
Hourly
86%-88% 115%-117%
HHS Professional
Employees
87% 114%-115%
PW Premium Hourly 81%-84% 106%-110%
LHCC Premium
Hourly
86%-88% 113%-117%
IT Premium
Management
87% 113%
Non-Premium
Management
87% 113%
SO Premium
Management
87% 113%
WCHC Premium
Management
87%-88% 111%-113%
Proposed
Structure Name
Non-exempt (hourly)
Exempt (salaried)
Sheriff’s Office Management
Proposed structure options
Option Min % of
Market
Max % of
Market
Option 1 87.5% 115%
Option 2 90% 118%
Option 3 90% 120%
Proposed options lead to more
consistent groupings and structure
designs. This enhances internal
equity and simplifies administration.
25 of 44
TARGET MARKET PLACEMENT OPTIONS
10
Control Point (C/P): The market-based target pay rate used as the anchor for each pay grade. Based on benchmark market
data and the County's target market position, it serves as the foundation for the pay range and reflects the general market
value of jobs within the grade.
Target Market Placement refers to the intended competitive placement that we will anchor the structure’s control points to.
For example, if median is chosen, each grade’s control points would be anchored to the median market measurement. If the
55th percentile was chosen, each grade’s control points would be anchored slightly above the median.
25th 50th 75th
50th
Percentile
Current
Target
55th
Percentile
60th
Percentile
LAG MARKET AT MARKET LEAD MARKET
25th percentile Median / 50th percentile 75th percentile
PLACEMENT OPTIONS UNDER CONSIDERATION
Maintain median market position (50th) or move modestly above market to the 55th or
60th percentile.
26 of 44
ESTIMATED COST IMPACT BY IMPLEMENTATION OPTION
11
Target Market
Placement
Estimated
cost
Average
Employee
Increase
Overall Budget
Impact
Estimated cost Average
Employee
Increase
Overall Budget
Impact
Meets Market
(50th Percentile ) $811,321 2.6% 1.7% $1,550,209 4.0% 3.2%
Above Market
(55th Percentile) $1,141,947 3.4% 2.4% $1,817,239 4.7% 3.8%
Above Market
(60th Percentile) $1,483,030 4.3% 3.1% $2,131,729 5.5% 4.4%
Costing assumptions:
• Costing includes aligning structure with target market, then placing employees into the new structure based
upon implementation option
• Based on the option 2 sample hybrid structure design of 90% - 118%
Option 1: Step placement
• Gets all employees into structure
• Places employees into the step that provides an increase; if
employees current rate places them within the performance
range, it maintains current rate. Goal is to get all staff within the
new structure
• No employees receive decrease in base pay
Option 2: Minimum 2% increase
• Places all employees within the new structure to ensure
increase of at least 2%.
• Places employees on step that provides at least 2%, employees
that fall within open range receive 2%.
• No employees receive decrease in base pay
Option 1: Step placement Option 2: Minimum 2% increase
27 of 44
ESTIMATED COST IMPACT CONTINUED
12
Prior calculations do not
include base pay
adjustments for
employees above the new
range maximum
The final number of employees
outside the max depends on:
1.) Target market approach: the
more aggressive the target, the
fewer employees over max
2.) Final structure design
Approaches for employees outside the max at
implementation
No base pay reductions are recommended.
Option A: Freeze base pay
Hold base pay and make no other adjustments.
Option B: One-time, non-base-building payment
Aligns with the overall implementation strategy. For example,
if others receive a 2% increase through placement in the
structure, employees over max could receive a 2% payment.Final cost impact can be determined
once target market and
implementation strategy are finalized.
28 of 44
EDUCATION JOBS: TARGETED APPROACH
13
This market and its
practices vary, so a
targeted approach is
recommended
Recommendations differ by job
group:
Teachers and counselors
SLP, OT, and PT
Teachers and counselors
• Align structure design for counselors and teachers
• Maintain the 29-step design and continue to allow 2 steps per
year based on performance
• Updated structure realigns these groups to their respective
markets and fixes the competitiveness issues identified
SLP, OT, and PT
• Align into a more market-aligned structure and provide one
step per year
• Recommend increasing SLP annual hours from 1,520 to 1,600,
based on need and internal therapist alignment
29 of 44
RECOMMENDED EDUCATION STRUCTURE DESIGNS: TEACHERS & COUNSELORS
Step 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29
SPED Teachers
1,520 hours per year
Counselors
1,600 hours per year
Step progression: 1 step per year, or up to 2 steps per year based on performance → Step 1 to Step 29
One design, two ranges
Both groups share the same 29-step
structure. SPED Teachers and
Counselors each have their own pay
range.
Up to 2 steps per year
Employees can advance up to 2
steps per year, based on
performance consistent with current
practice.
Structure Lift Adjustments
Starting pay is being recommended to
move from $31.50 to $35 for Teachers at
median market. This adjustment will
address the competitiveness gap
identified at the beginning of the structure
Design recommended to maintain alignment with market practices and Lakeland operational practices
14
30 of 44
RECOMMENDED THERAPIST STRUCTURE DESIGN: THERAPISTS
Step 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
Speech Language Pathologist
Occupational Therapist
Physical Therapist
Step progression: one step per year → Step 1 to Step 13
One structure, three jobs
A 13-step structure with a grade for
Speech Language Pathologist, OT,
and PT.
One step per year
This grouping is eligible for one step
per year.
Structure Lift Adjustments
Therapist pay will be realigned with
the market to address
competitiveness concerns.
Market-aligned structure, recommended to maintain alignment with market practices and Lakeland operational practices
15
31 of 44
ESTIMATED COST IMPACT BY IMPLEMENTATION OPTION: EDUCATION
16
Target Market
Placement
Estimated
cost
Average
Employee
Increase
Overall Budget
Impact
Estimated cost Average
Employee
Increase
Overall Budget
Impact
Meets Market
(50th Percentile ) $94,960 3.0% 2.8% $151,118 4.6% 4.5%
Above Market
(55th Percentile) $107,899 3.6% 3.2% $160,134 5.1% 4.8%
Above Market
(60th Percentile) $124,699 4.2% 3.7% $176,368 5.7% 5.2%
Option 1: Step placement
• Gets all employees into structure
• Places employees into the step that provides an increase
• No employees receive decrease in base pay
Option 2: Minimum 2% increase
• Gets all employees into structure
• Places all employees within the updated structure to ensure
increase of at least 2%.
• No employees receive decrease in base pay
Option 1: Step placement Option 2: Minimum 2% increase
32 of 44
ONE-TIME PERFORMANCE BONUSES
17
Annual structure
adjustments and
employee progression
take priority over
bonuses
TRC views bonuses as an
optional supplement when
funding allows.
If the County wishes to continue to reward
performance at top of scale
• Limit eligibility to employees at or above the range
maximum.
• Set bonus rates annually based upon budget feasibility,
consistent across employee groups.
• Apply approved COLA at the maximum without
exceeding the adjusted range.
Illustrative bonus rates
Performance Bonus
Exceeds Expectations 2.75%
Meets Expectations 1.5%
Needs Improvement 0%
Percent of grade maximum (top step),
rather than individual base pay.
Adjustment and re-alignment
of structure designs provides
an opportunity review bonus
practice
33 of 44
Next Steps
18
34 of 44
NEXT STEPS
FINALIZE TARGET
MARKET PLACEMENT
FINALIZE
STRUCTURE(S)
DETERMINE
IMPLEMENTATION
STRATEGY
19
35 of 44
Questions
20
36 of 44
Page 1 of 4
HEALTH INSURANCE DEFINITIONS
Premium The monthly cost of health insurance coverage.
• Premiums are typically shared between the employer
and employee.
• The premium is paid regardless of whether healthcare
services are used.
• Premium amounts do not count toward the deductible
or out-of-pocket maximum.
Deductible The amount a member must pay for covered healthcare
services before the health plan begins sharing costs.
Example:
• Annual deductible: $2,000
• The member pays the first $2,000 of covered
expenses.
• After the deductible is met, the plan begins paying a
portion of covered costs according to the plan's cost-
sharing provisions.
Important: Certain services, such as preventive care, may be
covered before the deductible is met.
Coinsurance The percentage of covered healthcare expenses paid by the
member after the deductible has been met.
Example:
• A member has met their deductible.
• The plan provides 80% coverage. The member is
responsible for 20% coinsurance. (80/20)
If a covered medical service costs $1,000:
• Plan pays $800 (80%)
• Member pays $200 (20%)
Copayment (Copay) A fixed dollar amount a member pays for certain healthcare
services.
Common examples:
• Primary care visit: $35 copay
• Specialist visit: $50 copay
• Urgent care visit: $75 copay
Copays do not count toward the deductible, but they do
typically count toward the out-of-pocket maximum.
37 of 44
Page 2 of 4
Out-of-Pocket Maximum (OOPM) The maximum amount a member pays during a plan year for
covered healthcare expenses.
Once the out-of-pocket maximum is reached:
• The plan pays 100% of covered in-network expenses
for the remainder of the plan year.
• Expenses that typically count toward the maximum
include deductibles, copays, and coinsurance.
Important: Premiums, non-covered services, and certain out-
of-network expenses generally do not count toward the out-
of-pocket maximum.
Network The group of doctors, hospitals, clinics, and other healthcare
providers that contract with a health plan to provide services
at negotiated rates.
In-N
etwork
Providers who have contracted with the health plan and
agreed to discounted reimbursement rates.
Out-of-Network
Providers who do not participate in the plan's network and
may result in higher member costs or reduced coverage.
Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) A type of health plan that provides access to a broad network
of providers and allows members to receive care without
selecting a primary care physician or obtaining specialist
referrals.
Key characteristics:
• Greater provider flexibility
• Coverage for both in-network and out-of-network
services (subject to plan provisions)
• Typically, higher premiums than more restrictive
network models
High-Deductible Health Plan (HDHP) A health plan designed with a higher deductible and lower
monthly premiums than traditional health plans. HDHPs must
meet IRS requirements in order to qualify members for Health
Savings Account (HSA) eligibility.
Key characteristics:
• Lower monthly premiums
• Higher deductibles
• Members generally pay a larger share of costs upfront
before the plan begins sharing expenses
38 of 44
Page 3 of 4
Health Savings Account (HSA) A tax-advantaged account available to individuals enrolled in
a qualified HDHP.
Funds can be used to pay for eligible healthcare expenses,
including:
• Deductibles
• Coinsurance
• Copays
• Prescription drug expenses
• Many other qualified medical expenses
Advantages of an HSA
• Contributions are tax-free.
• Investment earnings grow tax-free.
• Withdrawals for qualified healthcare expenses are tax-
free.
• Funds roll over from year to year and are never
forfeited.
• The account belongs to the employee and remains
with them even if they leave employment or retire.
Many employers contribute funds to employees' HSAs to help
offset the higher deductible associated with HDHPs.
Health Reimbursement Arrangement
(HRA)
An employer-funded account that reimburses eligible
healthcare expenses.
Key features:
• Funded solely by the employer
• Employees cannot contribute
• Funds may be used for qualified medical expenses as
defined by the plan
• Unused balances may or may not roll over depending
on employer rules
Health Risk Assessment (HRA) A confidential wellness screening used to evaluate an
individual's health risks and identify opportunities for
preventive care and wellness improvement.
Health Risk Assessments are frequently used as part of
employer wellness programs.
Self-Insured Plan A funding arrangement in which the employer assumes
responsibility for paying healthcare claims.
Characteristics:
• Employer bears the financial risk for claims.
39 of 44
Page 4 of 4
• Claims administration is often handled by a third-party
administrator (TPA).
• Costs may fluctuate based on actual claims
experience.
• Provides employers with greater flexibility in plan
d
esign and access to claims data that can support
benefit and cost-management decisions.
Fully-Insured Plan A funding arrangement in which the employer pays fixed
premiums to an insurance carrier.
Characteristics:
• Insurance carrier assumes the financial risk for claims.
• Premium rates are established by the insurance
carrier.
• Plan design and financial decisions are typically more
dependent on the insurance carrier's offerings and
pricing structure.
40 of 44
Tier 1 Tier 2 - HDHP Tier 1 Tier 2 HDHP Choice Plus HDHP Traditional Plan HDHP
Deductible
Individual 1,250$ 1,700$ 750$ 750$ 3,000$ 800$ 2,100$ 1,000$ 5,000$
Family 3,750$ 3,400$ 1,500$ 1,500$ 6,000$ 2,400$ 4,200$ 2,000$ 10,000$
Coinsurance (%)
80/20 90/10 90/10 70/30 100/0 80/20 80/20 80/20 100/0
Out-of-Pocket Maximum
Individual 6,250$ 3,200$ 3,500$ 3,500$ 4,000$ 2,600$ 3,250$ 1,500$ 2,500$ 5,000$
Family 12,500$ 6,400$ 7,000$ 7,000$ 8,000$ 6,600$ 6,500$ 4,500$ 5,000$ 10,000$
Employer HSA Contribution
Single N/A 875$ N/A N/A N/A 1,125$ N/A 700$
Family N/A 1,750$ N/A N/A N/A 2,250$ N/A 1,200$
Network
HPS HPS UHC Nexus ACO UHC Nexus ACO UHC Choice Plus UHC UHC UHC Choice Plus UHC Choice Plus
Employer Clinic
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Self or Fully Insured
Self-Insured Self-Insured Self-Insured Self-Insured Self-Insured Se lf-Insured
Total Monthly Premiums Mercy Network Dean Network
Single 1,183.60$ 1,045.98$ 1,090.46$ 747.23$ 940.80$ 973.68$ 886.00$ 596.00$
EE + Child 2,418.78$ 2,111.40$ - - - - - 1,693.20$ 1,752.62$ - -
EE + Spouse 2,658.00$ 2,346.00$ - - - - - 2,069.
50$ 2,142.10$ - -
Family 3,163.02$ 2,791.74$ 2,942.00$ 2,019.34$ 3,104.30$ 3,213.14$ 2,558.00$ 1,721.00$
County Portion*
Single 1,065.24$ 941.38$ 872.37$ 635.15$ 884.35$ 915.26$ 753.10$ 506.60$
EE + Child 2,176.90$ 1,900.26$ - - - - - 1,591.61$ 1,647.46$ - -
EE + Spouse 2,392.20$ 2,111.40$ - - - - - 1,945.33$ 2,013.57$ - -
Family 2,846.72$ 2,512.58$ 2,353.60$ 1,716.44$ 2,918.10$ 3,020.35$ 2,174.30$ 1,462.85$
Employee Portion*
Single 118.36$ 104.60$ 218.09$ 112.08$ 56.45$ 58.42$ 132.90$ 89. 40$
EE + Child 241.88$ 211.14$ - - - - - 101.59$ 105.16$ - -
EE + Spouse 265.80$ 234.60$ - - - - - 124.17$ 128.53$ - -
Family 316.30$ 279.16$ 588.40$ 302.90$ 186.20$ 192.79$ 383.70$ 258.15$
Restrictions by Employee
Groups
Notes
2026 Health Insurance Comparison
Racine County Jefferson County
Deputies hired before Act 10 -
grandfathered into the County
paying for the employee share
of WRS. These empoyees can
only enroll in the Tier 2 -
HDHP.
Tier 1 and 2 are for general employees. HDHP is for
sworn employees.
For Sheriffs Dept - PPO
(Choice Plus) plan is only
available to those who were
hired before 2017. The HDHP
is available to everyone.
None- all employees have the
choice of any plan option
None- all employees have the choice of
any plan option
Local HDHP
1,700$
3,400$
90/10
2,250$
2,500$
Waukesha County
*Premium share differs if EE
does not complete HRA. EE's
on HDHP must complete
HRA in order to receive HSA
employer contribution.
Clarify difference between bronze/silver/gold
premiums? TPA = UMR - assuming self-insured? EE
Clinic?
Rock County
*EE pays 6% of premium if they
complete wellness program. If not,
10%.
HMO, dual choice Mercy/Dean
No
Fully Insured
Walworth County Kenosha County
*Premium share is 90/10% if
EE completes annual HRA. If
not, it would be 85/15.
75/25
750$
5,000$
Fully Insured (State Plan)
$796.87
$1,958.04
-
-
$820.96 - $1,336.40
-
-
$2,009.02 - $3,297.62
*Several different network options -
please see attached
No
County contributes to a Health
Reimbursement Account. The
amount over the deductible is
reimbursed up to the out-of-pocket
max. In 2026, for Single, the
deductible is $1700 and OOPM is
$2500 so $800 would be
reimbursed. For Family, the
deductible is $3400 and OOPM is
$5000 so $1600 would be
reimbursed.
N/A
N/A
N/A
N/A
$24.09 - $539.53
-
-
$50.98 - $1,339.58
None- all employees have the
choice of any plan option
41 of 44
Tier 1 Tier 2 - HDHP Tier 1 Tier 2 Choice Plus HDHP Traditional Plan Copay Plan (Surest) HDHP
Deductible
Individual 1,250$ 1,750$ 800$ 2,100$ 1,500$ 1,000$
-$
5,000$
Family 3,750$ 3,500$ 2,400$ 4,200$ 3,750$ 2,000$
-$
10,000$
Coinsurance (%)
80/20 90/10 80/20 80/20 80/20 100/0 100/0
Out-of-Pocket Maximum
Individual 6,250$ 3,200$ 2,600$ 3,250$ 2,500$ 2,500$
4,000$
5,000$
Family 12,500$ 6,400$ 6,600$ 6,500$ 7,500$ 5,000$
8,000$
10,000$
Employer HSA Contribution
Single N/A 875$ N/A N/A N/A 1,125$ N/A N/A 700$
Family N/A 1,750$ N/A N/A N/A 2,250$ N/A N/A 1,200$
Network
HPS HPS UHC Nexus ACO UHC Nexus ACO UHC Choice Plus UHC UHC UHC Choice Plus UHC Choice Plus UHC Choice Plus
Employer Clinic
Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
Self or Fully Insured
Self-Insured Self-Insured Self-Insured Self-Insured Self-Insured Self-Insured Self-Insured
Total Monthly Premiums Mercy Network Dean Network
Single 1,271.20$ 1,073.18$ 1, 195.73$ 804.86$ 1,020.80$ 1,031.11$ 921.00$ 857.00$ 596.00$
EE + Child 2,288.16$ 1,931.72$ - - - - 1,837.10$ 1,856.00$ - - -
EE + Spouse 2,796.64$ 2,361.00$ - - - - 2,245.
40$ 2,268.44$ - - -
Family 3,813.60$ 3,219.54$ 3,227.33$ 2,174.84$ 3,368.20$ 3,402.66$ 2,660.00$ 2,474.00$
1,721.00$
County Portion*
Single 1,144.08$ 965.86$ 956.58$ 684.13$ 949.34$ 958.93$ 782.85$ 728.45$
506.60$
EE + Child 2,059.34$ 1,738.54$ - - - - 1,708.50$ 1,726.08$ - - -
EE + Spouse 2,516.98$ 2,124.90$ - - - - 2,088.22$ 2,109.65$ - - -
Family 3,432.24$ 2,897.60$ 2,581.86$ 1,848.61$ 3,132.43$ 3,164.47$ 2,261.00$ 2,102.90$
1,462.85$
Employee Portion*
Single 127.12$ 107.32$ 239.15$ 120.73$ 71.46$ 72.18$ 138.15$ 128.55$ 89. 40$
EE + Child 228.82$ 193.18$ - - - - 128.60$ 129.92$ - - -
EE + Spouse 279.66$ 236.10$ - - - - 157.18$ 158.79$ - - -
Family 381.36$ 321.94$ 645.47$ 326.23$ 235.77$ 238.19$ 399.00$ 371.10$
258.15$
Restrictions by Employee
Groups
Notes
3,500$
*Several different network
options - please see
attached
No
Fully Insured (State Plan)
$935.58
N/A
N/A
$875.96 - $1,574.28
-
-
$2,142.50 - $3,888.30
7,000$
-
$0.00 - $1,586.63
None- all employees have
the choice of any plan option
County contributes to a
Health Reimbursement
Account. The amount over
the deductible is reimbursed
up to the out-of-pocket max.
In 2027, for Single, the
deductible is $2000 and
OOPM is $3500 so $1500
would be reimbursed. For
Family, the deductible is
$4000 and OOPM is $7000
so $3000 would be
reimbursed.
-
-
$2,301.67
-
$0.00 - $638.70
Local HDHP
4,000$
2,000$
90/10
2027 Health Insurance Comparison
Walworth County Kenosha County Waukesha County Rock County Racine County Jefferson County
75/25
HMO, dual choice Mercy/Dean
No
Fully Insured
*Premium share is 90/10% if
EE completes annual HRA. If
not, it would be 85/15.
*Premium share differs if EE
does not complete HRA. EE's
on HDHP must complete
HRA in order to receive HSA
employer contribution.
*EE pays 7% of premium if they
complete wellness program. If not,
10%.
None- all employees have the
choice of any plan option
Deputies hired before Act 10 -
grandfathered into the County
paying for the employee share
of WRS. These empoyees can
only enroll in the Tier 2 - HDHP.
For Sheriffs Dept - PPO
(Choice Plus) plan is only
available to those who were
hired before 2017. The
HDHP is available to
everyone.
N/A
N/A
None- all employees have the choice of any plan option Tier 1 and 2 are for general employees. HDHP is for
sworn employees.
Do not have 2027 yet
42 of 44
2026 Rates
ALL INSURANCE CARRIERS
Monthly
Employer
Share
Monthly
Employee
Share
Total
Monthly
Premium
Monthly
Employer
Share
Monthly
Employee
Share
Total
Monthly
Premium
Aspirus Health Plan 796.87$ 404.41$ 1,201.28$ 1,958.04$ 1,001.78$ 2,959.82$ https://p1.aspirushealthplan.com/etf/ 1-866-631-8583
CareSource Wisconsin 796.87$ 395.23$ 1,192.10$ 1,958.04$ 978.82$ 2,936.86$
https://group-health.com/getdoc/51036cd4-5f99-4e76-8de1-
d84a09422a86/state-of-wi-ghcec-cghc 1-888-203-7770
Dean Health Plan by Medica 796.87$ 311.27$ 1,108.14$ 1,958.04$ 768.92$ 2,726.96$
GHC of Eau Claire Greater Wisconsin 796.87$ 539.53$ 1,336.40$ 1,958.04$ 1,339.58$ 3,297.62$
https://group-health.com/getdoc/35cd49b0-1b9b-478e-903d-
bfc7245ca03c/state-of-wi-group-health-insurance-etf
1-888-203-7770
1-715-552-4300
GHC of Eau Claire River Region 796.87$ 530.57$ 1,327.44$ 1,958.04$ 1,317.18$ 3,275.22$
https://group-health.com/getdoc/35cd49b0-1b9b-478e-903d-
bfc7245ca03c/state-of-wi-group-health-insurance-etf
1-888-203-7770
1-715-552-3500
GHC- SCW Dane Choice 796.87$ 24.09$ 820.96$ 1,958.04$ 50.98$ 2,009.02$ https://ghcscw.com/health-insurance/government-employees
1-888-203-7770
1-715-552-3500
GHC -SCW Neighbors 796.87$ 260.21$ 1,057.08$ 1,958.04$ 641.28$ 2,599.32$ https://ghcscw.com/health-insurance/government-employees
1-800-605-4327
608-828-4853
HealthPartners Health Plan Southeast 796.87$ 422.05$ 1,218.92$ 1,958.04$ 1,045.88$ 3,003.92$ https://www.healthpartners.com/stateofwis/ 1-855-542-6922
HealthPartner Health Plan West 796.87$ 500.41$ 1,297.28$ 1,958.04$ 1,241.78$ 3,199.82$ https://www.healthpartners.com/stateofwis/ 1-855-542-6922
Medica West and Mayo Clinic Health System 796.87$ 490.37$ 1,287.24$ 1,958.04$ 1,216.68$ 3,174.72$
Medical Associates Health Plans 796.87$ 85.69$ 882.56$ 1,958.04$ 204.98$ 2,163.02$
https://www.mahealthcare.com/insurance/products-and-
services/state-of-wi-plan/ 1-866-421-3992
MercyCare Health Plans 796.87$ 80.91$ 877.78$ 1,958.04$ 193.02$ 2,151.06$
https://mercycare.healthsparq.com/healthsparq/public/#/one/city=&
state=&postalCode=&country=&insurerCode=MERCYCARE_I&brandC
ode=MERCYCARE?
1-800-895-2421
option 5
Network Health 796.87$ 131.71$ 928.58$ 1,958.04$ 320.02$ 2,278.06$ https://networkhealth.com/employer/state
1-844-625-2208
920-720-1811
Prevea360 East 796.87$ 92.43$ 889.30$ 1,958.04$ 221.82$ 2,179.86$
Quartz Central 796.87$ 457.65$ 1,254.52$ 1,958.04$ 1,134.88$ 3,092.92$
https://quartzbenefits.com/members/state-local-members/local-
employee-plans/ 1-844-644-3455
Quartz - UW Health 796.87$ 54.99$ 851.86$ 1,958.04$ 128.22$ 2,086.26$
https://quartzbenefits.com/members/state-local-members/local-
employee-plans/ 1-844-644-3455
Quartz West 796.87$ 121.33$ 918.20$ 1,958.04$ 294.08$ 2,252.12$
https://quartzbenefits.com/members/state-local-members/local-
employee-plans/ 1-844-644-3455
Robin with HealthPartners Health Plan 796.87$ 468.31$ 1,265.18$ 1,958.04$ 1,161.52$ 3,119.56$ https://www.healthpartners.com/etfrobin 1-855-542-6922
Security Health Plan 796.87$ 342.67$ 1,139.54$ 1,958.04$ 847.42$ 2,805.46$ http://securityhealth.org/state 1-544-813-7286
State Mainenance Plan (SMP) 796.87$ 215.03$ 1,011.90$ 1,958.04$ 528.36$ 2,486.40$ http://www.deancare.com/wi-employees 1-800-279-1301
Access Plan 796.87$ 469.23$ 1,266.10$ 1,958.04$ 1,163.86$ 3,121.90$ http://www.deancare.com/wi-employees 1-800-279-1301
Single Family
PhoneInsurance Websites
43 of 44
2027 Rates
ALL INSURANCE CARRIERS
Monthly
Employer
Share
Monthly
Employee
Share
Total
Monthly
Premium
Monthly
Employer
Share
Monthly
Employee
Share
Total
Monthly
Premium
Aspirus Health Plan 935.58 $ 345.60$ 1,281.18 $ 2,301.67 $ 853.89$ 3,155.56 $ https://p1.aspirushealthplan.com/etf/
1-866-631-8583
CareSource Wisconsin 935.58$ 217.02$ 1,152.60$ 2,301.67$ 532.43$ 2,834.10$ https://group-health.com/ 1-833-742-0952
Dean Health Plan by Medica 935.58 $ 230.54$ 1,166.12 $ 2,301.67 $ 566.23$ 2,867.90 $ https://www.deancare.com/members/state-of-wisconsin-employees 1-877-371-6762
GHC of Eau Claire Greater Wisconsin 935.58$ 484.80$ 1,420.38$ 2,301.67$ 1,201.89$ 3,503.56$ https://group-health.com/ 1-833-742-0952
GHC of Eau Claire River Region 935.58$ 638.70$ 1,574.28$ 2,301.67$ 1,586.63$ 3,888.30$ https://group-health.com/ 1-833-742-0952
GHC- SCW Dane Choice 935.58$ $0.00 875.96$ 2,301.67$ $0.00 2,142.50$ https://ghcscw.com/health-insurance/government-employees 1-800-605-4327
GHC -SCW Neighbors 935.58$ 240.58$ 1,176.16$ 2,301.67$ 591.33$ 2,893.00$ https://ghcscw.com/health-insurance/government-employees 1-800-605-4327
HealthPartners Health Plan Northeast 935.58 $ 331.42$ 1,267.00 $ 2,301.67 $ 818.43$ 3,120.10 $ https://www.healthpartners.com/stateofwis/ 1-855-542-6922
HealthPartners Health Plan Southeast 935.58 $ 383.46$ 1,319.04 $ 2,301.67 $ 948.53$ 3,250.20 $ https://www.healthpartners.com/stateofwis/ 1-855-542-6922
HealthPartner Health Plan West 935.58 $ 381.62$ 1,317.20 $ 2,301.67 $ 943.93$ 3,245.60 $ https://www.healthpartners.com/stateofwis/ 1-855-542-6922
Medica West and Mayo Clinic Health System 935.58 $ 557.68$ 1,493.26 $ 2,301.67 $ 1,384.09$ 3,685.76 $ https://www.deancare.com/members/state-of-wisconsin-employees 1-877-371-6762
Medical Associates Health Plans 935.58 $ 32.94$ 968.52 $ 2,301.67 $ 72.23$ 2,373.90 $ https://www.mahealthplans.com/hp/members/state-of-wi-group/ 1-866-421-3992
MercyCare Health Plans 935.58 $ 35.36$ 970.94 $ 2,301.67 $ 78.29$ 2,379.96 $ https://www.mercycarehealthplans.com/
1-800-895-2421
option 5
Network Health 935.58 $ 31.32$ 966.90 $ 2,301.67 $ 68.19$ 2,369.86 $ https://networkhealth.com/employer/state 1-844-625-2208
Prevea360 East 935.58 $ $0.00 931.02 $ 2,301.67 $ $0.00 2,280.16 $ https://www.prevea360.com/Members/State-of-Wisconsin-Members 1-877-371-6772
Quartz Central 935.58$ 394.94$ 1,330.52$ 2,301.67$ 977.23$ 3,278.90$ https://quartzbenefits.com/members/state-local-members/ 1-844-644-3455
Quartz - UW Health 935.58$ $0.00 911.48$ 2,301.67$ $0.00 2,231.30$ https://quartzbenefits.com/members/state-local-members/ 1-844-644-3455
Quartz West 935.58 $ 199.44$ 1,135.02 $ 2,301.67 $ 488.49$ 2,790.16 $ https://quartzbenefits.com/members/state-local-members/ 1-844-644-3455
Security Health Plan 935.58 $ 242.02$ 1,177.60 $ 2,301.67 $ 594.93$ 2,896.60 $
https://www.securityhealth.org/provider-
directory?planId=33#/findcare/location 1-844-813-7286
State Mainenance Plan (SMP) 935.58 $ 252.46$ 1,188.04 $ 2,301.67 $ 621.09$ 2,922.76 $ http://www.deancare.com/wi-employees 1-877-371-6762
Access Plan 935.58 $ 470.28$ 1,405.86 $ 2,301.67 $ 1,165.63$ 3,467.30 $ http://www.deancare.com/wi-employees 1-877-371-6762
Single Family
PhoneInsurance Websites
44 of 44
Source: Walworth County website. First collected Nov 17, 2026.