Board Meeting — Agenda packet
Village of Sister Bay · Door County · Board Meeting · meeting of Nov 17, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from Village of Sister Bay
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
Public Notice
Public participation at meetings and correspondence is welcome. Submit emails or letters to the Village Clerk at clerk@sisterbaywi.gov or at the
Village Administration Office at 2383 Maple Drive, Sister Bay. Letters may not be read at the meeting but referenced and/or summarized. You
may also email Board members directly. Questions regarding the nature of the agenda items or more detail on the items listed can be directed to
the Village Administrator at administrator@sisterbaywi.gov. Copies of reports and other supporting documentation are available for review online
and at the Village Administration Office during operating hours (8 a.m. to 4 p.m. Mondays – Thursdays, 8 a.m. to noon on Fridays).
Upon reasonable notice, a good faith effort will be made to accommodate the needs of disabled individuals through sign language interpreters or
other auxiliary aid or accommodation at no cost to the individual. Due to the difficulty in finding interpreters, requests should be made as far in
advance as possible, preferably a minimum of 48 hours. For additional information or to request this service, contact the Village Administration
Office at 920-854-4118; (FAX) 920-854-9637; emailing the Village Clerk at clerk@sisterbaywi.gov, or, by writing to the Village Administration Office,
2383 Maple Drive, PO Box 769, Sister Bay, WI 54234 (allow adequate mail time).
It is possible that members of and possibly a quorum of members of other governmental bodies may attend the meeting to gather information;
no action will be taken by any governmental body other than the body specifically referred to above.
The Village of Sister Bay is an Equal Opportunity Provider and Employer
Posted Date: 11/13/2026
VILLAGE BOARD MEETING
TUESDAY, NOVEMBER 17, 2026 – 6:00 PM
Sister Bay Liberty Grove Fire Station, 2258 Mill Rd., Large Meeting Rm.
To access the meeting electronically, click:
https://zoom.us/j/4439901723?pwd=yAVpi40M1OIqgNufcVUE8XWCUSkKaH.1&omn=97063638580
Meeting ID 443 990 1723, Code 304078; Connect by Phone 1-301-715-8592, Meeting ID 4439901723#
Deviations from the agenda order shown may occur
For additional meeting information visit: www.sisterbaywi.gov, click ‘Agendas and Minutes’
AGENDA
1. Call to Order & Roll Call (Zoom Participants Mute Devices)
2. Approve Agenda
3. Approve Meeting Minutes:
October 20, 2026, October 27, 2026
4. Comments, Correspondence and Concerns from the Public (Public comment limited to 3 non-transferable minutes per
person)
5. Discussion/Action Items
a) Introduction of Bob Kufrin, Zoning Consultant
b) Approval of Amendments to the Door County Tourism Zone Commission (DCTZ) Bylaws
c) Request by Chad Buntin to Purchase Village-Owned Property Parcel 0180103312843C
d) Sewer Rate Study RFP Discussion
e) Authorization of Additional $5,000 for Village Planning and Zoning Consulting Services
f) One-Time Supplemental Compensation for Village Staff Assuming Additional Responsibilities During the
Village Administrator Vacancy.
g) Re-authorization Administrative Authority and Coordination of Village Operations During the Village
Administrator Vacancy
h) Selection of a Recruitment Firm for Village Administrator Search Services
i) Monthly Financial Report & Appropriations
6. Staff Reports
7. Committee Reports (See below committee listing)
8. Closed Session
a) The Village Board may convene in closed session pursuant to Wis. Stat. § 19.85(1)(g) to confer
with legal counsel who is rendering oral or written advice concerning strategy to be adopted by
the Village Board with respect to litigation in which it is or is likely to become involved:
i. Public Service Commission Docket 9300-SI-128 – Final Decision and Order, including
potential circuit court review, further legal proceedings, and related litigation strategy.
9. Discussion and possible action regarding matters considered in closed session, if appropriate.
10. Matters to be Placed on a Future Agenda or Referred to a Committee, Official or Employee
11. Next Meeting
12. Adjourn
1. Finance Committee 10. Parks, Property & Streets Committee
2. Fire Board 11. Personnel Committee
3. Green Tier Legacy Community Committee 12. Plan Commission
4. Historical Society 13. Sewer and Water Utility Committee
5. Holiday Lighting 14. SBAA
6. Housing Committee 15. Technology & Telecomm Committee
7. Library Commission 16. Tourism Zone Commission
8. Marina Committee 17. Village Hall Planning Task Force
9. Parking Committee
1
1
VILLAGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES MEETING MINUTES 2
Tuesday, October 20, 2026 3
Unapproved 4
5
1. Call to Order & Roll Call 6
President Nate Bell called the Board of Trustees meeting to order at 6:00 PM on Tuesday, October 7
20, 2026. 8
Present: Nate Bell, Patrice Champeau, Skip Heidler, Terry Kelly, Skip Heidler, Steve Bacsi and Brigid 9
White. 10
11
Also present were Village Clerk Julie Thyssen, Finance Specialist/Treasurer Vlad Gannik, Marina 12
Manager Dave Lienau, and Utilities Director Megan Barnes, Joy Lang, Talulah, Mary Deviley, Erin 13
Peddle 14
Zoom: Debra Fitzgerald, Dr JC Hull, Parks and Streets Director Erik Linczmaier, Jenn Fuhr, Jill Wiebe 15
Megan Barns, Michael Miller, Patrick Thompson, Terry Wolf, Sarah Bertges 16
2. Approve Agenda 17
Bell asked to exclude agenda Item 6.a, on the advice of staff, because erroneous information had 18
been used in preparing that item. 19
Motion to approve the agenda, excluding Item 6.a, made by Kelly and seconded by Trustee Heidler. 20
Motion carried – all ayes. 21
3. Approve Meeting Minutes 22
a. September 15, 2026; Regular Meeting 23
The following corrections were requested: 24
• "SPAA" was to be corrected throughout the minutes. 25
• The Marina item was to be recorded as pulled from the agenda. 26
• Treasurer Gannik's appointment to the steering committee was to be added. 27
• Trustee Heidler was to be identified as vice president. 28
• Trustee White's recusal from the development agreement discussion was to be noted. 29
• The description of the mounted mechanical equipment screen was to be corrected. The 30
screen complies with stated zoning requirements but does not fully comply with the village's 31
visibility code requirements. 32
• "Door County Climate Coalition" was to be corrected. 33
Motion to approve the minutes as amended was made by President Bell and seconded by ____. 34
Motion carried – all ayes. 35
b. September 30, 2026; Special Board Meeting 36
Bell asked that the executive session items be verified against the posted agenda. 37
Motion to approve the minutes as amended was made by Trustee Kelly and seconded by ____. 38
Motion carried – all ayes. 39
40
Following the vote, Marina Manager Lienau noted that the dismissal time recorded at page 8, line 30 41
was incorrect. The record was to be corrected accordingly. 42
c. October 9, 2026; Special Board Meeting 43
Motion to approve the minutes as amended was made by Bell and seconded by Heidler. Motion 44
carried – all ayes. 45
2
Minutes of the October 20, 2026 Meeting of the Village Board of Trustees – Unapproved
2
4. Comments, Correspondence and Concerns from the Public 1
One letter was included in the meeting packet. No members of the public requested to speak in 2
person or via Zoom. 3
5. Proclamation(s) 4
a. Proclamation Honoring Joy Lang 5
The Board read and presented a proclamation honoring Joy Lang for her many years of volunteer 6
service in planting and maintaining the village's floral displays. Ms. Lang thanked the Board. 7
6. Ordinances & Resolutions 8
a. Resolution 2026-013 Creation of Zoning Administrator Position 9
This item was removed from the agenda on the advice of staff, as noted under Item 2. 10
11
b. Resolution 2026-014 Declaring Official Intent to Reimburse Expenditures from Proceeds of 12
Borrowing 13
Treasurer Gannik explained that the resolution allows the village to use reserve funds for project 14
expenditures before borrowing proceeds are received, and to reimburse those funds once the 15
borrowing closes. A separate resolution is required for each borrowing. Trustee Champeau stated 16
that the Finance Committee had met with Baird several times regarding total bonding and interest 17
costs. President Bell noted that the funds come from an enterprise fund and not from taxpayers, and 18
that the borrowing counts against the village's debt capacity, where substantial headroom remains. 19
Motion to adopt Resolution 2026-014 was made by Trustee Kelly and seconded by ____. Motion 20
carried – all ayes. 21
7. Discussion/Action Item(s) 22
a. Acceptance of Village Administrator's Resignation and Approval of Separation Agreement 23
Motion to accept the Village Administrator's resignation and approve the separation agreement was 24
made by Bell and seconded by Kelly. Motion carried – all ayes. 25
26
b. Consideration of Class "B" Fermented Malt Beverage and "Class C" Wine License applications for 27
the Sister Bay Historical Society, Corner of the Past, 10310 Fieldcrest Road 28
Thyssen explained that state law limits an organization to two temporary wine licenses, and that one 29
temporary license covers four days and not four weekends. The Historical Society's Christkindle 30
Market spans four weekends. On the Clerk's recommendation, the Society applied for a regular Class 31
"B" Fermented Malt Beverage and "Class C" Wine license. Background checks were completed and 32
the application was published. 33
Motion to grant the Class "B" Fermented Malt Beverage and "Class C" Wine licenses to the Sister Bay 34
Historical Society, Corner of the Past, 10310 Fieldcrest Road, was made by Kelly and seconded by 35
Champeau. Motion carried – all ayes. 36
c. Issuance of a Request for Proposals (RFP) for a Village of Sister Bay Sewer Rate Study 37
Barnes stated that the RFP is expected to be released the following day. Proposals will go directly to 38
the Board for selection, without a special Utilities meeting. Sewer rates are not regulated by the PSC, 39
so the study differs from the water rate study. The study does not affect any other legal matters. 40
Barnes noted that the utility code calls for annual review of rates, and that the goal is to have the 41
3
Minutes of the October 20, 2026 Meeting of the Village Board of Trustees – Unapproved
3
sewer rate in place by January 1, to coincide with the water rate change now proceeding to public 1
hearing. 2
Motion to approve issuance of the RFP for a Village of Sister Bay Sewer Rate Study was made by Bell 3
and seconded by Heidler. Motion carried – all ayes. 4
5
d. Marina Committee's recommendation to award the Marina Building demolition and 6
construction contract to Elite Builds, Inc., including conditions of award and authorization to 7
execute the contract 8
Lienau reported that bids were opened October 10 and reviewed by the Marina Committee on 9
October 14. Elite Builds, Inc. submitted the lowest bid: 10
• Base bid: $2,274,000, including $184,000 allocated to the public restrooms. 11
• Alternate for a standing seam copper roof: $112,800. 12
• Civil alternate for the sewer/water outfall pipe: $29,925. 13
• Total with alternates: $2,416,725. 14
The project architect from MDT Associates reported that reference checks with two prior clients, a 15
Wisconsin village government and a banking concern, produced positive reviews and confirmed 16
repeat business. 17
18
Discussion addressed temporary boater restroom and shower facilities during the winter and 19
summer seasons, which remain to be negotiated with the contractor. Construction was expected to 20
begin in mid-November, with heavy construction completed before the summer season and the 21
building completed by August. Elite Builds indicated it recognized the public restrooms as a priority. 22
The architect, staff, and Thyssen were thanked for the thorough bid review. 23
Motion to conditionally award the Marina Building contract to Elite Builds, Inc. in the base bid 24
amount of $2,274,000 plus Alternates 1 and 2, for a total of $2,416,725, subject to satisfactory 25
architect and attorney review confirming bid responsiveness, contract terms, scope, construction 26
schedule, marina operational continuity, insurance, and required bonding, was made by Bell and 27
seconded by Kelly. Motion carried – all ayes. 28
e. Interim Administrative Leadership and Assignment of Village Administrator Duties 29
Bell reported that he had been assisting staff since the Administrator's departure, and that Thyssen, 30
Gannik, and Bertges had absorbed substantial additional workload. He recommended retaining a 31
part-time interim administrator on an hourly basis while a thorough search is conducted for a 32
permanent administrator. He estimated the cost at $10,000 or less for the remainder of the year, 33
partially offset by reduced legal consultation. 34
Champeau also raised compensating staff for the additional duties they have assumed. The Board 35
agreed this should be addressed once the scope is clarified. 36
Motion to authorize the Village President, with oversight by the Personnel Committee chair, to 37
initiate the hiring of an interim administrator at a cost not to exceed $10,000 was made by Kelly and 38
seconded by White. Motion carried – all ayes. 39
f. Initiation of Recruitment and Hiring Process for Village Administrator Position 40
The Board agreed to conduct the recruitment as a full board and not through the Personnel 41
Committee. Discussion centered on whether to recruit one position or two, with zoning 42
administration separated from the Administrator role, and on obtaining a recruiter's input on the 43
candidate market. The Board agreed to hold a special meeting after the strategic planning session at 44
NWTC on Tuesday of the following week, at approximately 3:30 PM, to discuss the position 45
descriptions. The Zoning Administrator job description is to be returned to the Personnel 46
Committee. No action was taken. 47
4
Minutes of the October 20, 2026 Meeting of the Village Board of Trustees – Unapproved
4
g. Monthly Financial Report & Appropriations 1
Motion to pay the bills in the amount of $733,247.57 was made by Bell and seconded by Heidler. 2
Motion carried – all ayes. 3
8. Staff Reports 4
There were no questions on the staff reports. 5
9. Committee Reports 6
Champeau reported on the September Historical Society meeting. The strawberry festival was 7
successful and will again have extended hours next year. Museum tour traffic was down. The curator 8
resigned on short notice, and a new curator has since been hired and will work on village signage 9
and the marina museum projects. The Society also held an information table, membership drive, and 10
children's activities at Marina Fest; a successful open air market on October 3; a volunteer picnic; 11
and a harvest dinner fundraiser. It also sponsored a derby car and a parade entry at Fall Fest. 12
Motion to accept the committee reports was made by Bacsi and seconded by Kelly. Motion carried – 13
all ayes. 14
15
10. Matters to be Placed on a Future Agenda or Referred to a Committee, Official or Employee 16
Champeau inquired about the status of a Village Hall Task Force meeting to discuss the SBA 17
proposal. Thyssen reported that no meeting had yet been scheduled, and the Board agreed that one 18
needed to be arranged. A preliminary Village Hall fundraising concept was mentioned and was to be 19
referred to the Task Force if pursued. Bell stated that the property matter for the boathouse 20
museum remained pending with the Village Attorney and would be followed up. 21
11. Next Meeting 22
Tuesday, October 27 at 3:30 at NWTC following Strategic Planning Session 23
12. Adjourn 24
Motion to adjourn was made by Heidler and seconded by Kelly. Motion carried – all ayes. 25
26
Minutes respectfully submitted by Julie Thyssen, Village Clerk 27
5
1
VILLAGE BOARD OF TRUSTEES SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES 2
Tuesday, October 27, 2026, 3:30 p.m. 3
Unapproved 4
5
1. Call to Order & Roll Call 6
President Bell called the special meeting of the Village Board of Trustees to order 3:32 p.m. on 7
October 27, 2026. 8
9
Present: Nate Bell, Patrice Champeau, Louise Howson, Terry Kelly, Brigid White, and Steve Bacsi. 10
Skip Heidler was excused. 11
12
Also present: Village Clerk Julie Thyssen and Finance Specialist/Treasurer arrived later. Audience: 13
Susan Gulick 14
15
2. Approve Agenda 16
Motion to approve the agenda was made by Bell and seconded by Kelly. Motion carried – all ayes. 17
18
3. Comments, Correspondence And Concerns From The Public 19
None. 20
21
4. Discussion/Action Item(s) 22
a. Administration Update – Interim Operations And Organizational Updates 23
Bell had met with former Village Administrator Bob Kufrin. Kufrin is familiar with the Village zoning 24
code and agreed to provide interim planning and zoning services. Staff identified planning and 25
zoning as their greatest need. 26
27
b. Temporary Administrative Authority And Coordination Of Village Operations During The Village 28
Administrator Vacancy 29
Bell presented a drafted statement of temporary administrative authority. Village counsel and the 30
Clerk had advised that the authority already existed by statute. The President requested that it be 31
placed before the Board for clarity and public record. It would return at each Board meeting until the 32
Board allowed it to expire. Bell stated that he would sign contracts as the Village's executive, as is 33
standard practice. 34
Motion to approve the temporary administrative authority was made by Bacsi and seconded by 35
White. Motion carried – all ayes. 36
37
c. Village Administrator Recruitment Process And Professional Search Services 38
Options discussed were issuing a Request for Proposals (RFP) or directly soliciting proposals from the 39
small number of qualified firms. Concerns were raised about whether an RFP would require 40
acceptance of the lowest bidder. 41
42
The Board agreed that White would contact the firms and request proposals for the basic search 43
service. Proposals would be circulated before the November 17 meeting. The Board would then 44
narrow the field to two firms and interview them via Zoom in open session. Howson noted that the 45
existing job descriptions should be reviewed by the selected recruiter. 46
47
d. Administrative Roles For A Full-Time Planning And Zoning Administrator Vs. Village 48
Administrator 49
6
Minutes of the October 27, 2026 Meeting of the Village Board of Trustees – Unapproved
2
Howson presented the revised Village Administrator job description, a proposed Planning and 1
Zoning Administrator job description and staff report, the organizational chart, and a compensation 2
analysis. Gannik reported that, per the Department of Employee Trust Funds, positions working 3
more than 1,200 hours annually qualify for WRS and benefits. The Village currently has no policy on 4
prorated benefits, so one would need to be adopted. 5
Estimated annual costs were as follows: 6
• About $77,000 for a 1,430-hour position with benefits. 7
• About $50,000 for a position under 1,200 hours. 8
• About $117,000 for a full-time position, which is not budgeted. 9
10
The Board agreed that the Village Administrator and Planning and Zoning positions should be 11
separate roles. The decision on full-time versus part-time status was deferred until the Board 12
consults with a recruiter. No formal vote was taken. 13
14
5. Closed Session 15
a. Move To Convene In Closed Session Pursuant To Wis. Stats. 19.85(1)(e) For Deliberating Or 16
Negotiating The Purchasing Of Public Properties, The Investing Of Public Funds, Or Conducting 17
Other Specified Public Business, Whenever Competitive Or Bargaining Reasons Require A Closed 18
Session 19
Motion to convene in closed session pursuant to Wis. Stats. 19.85(1)(e) was made by Bell and 20
seconded by Kelly. Roll call vote: Champeau, Kelly, White, Bell, Howson, Bacsi. The motion carried, all 21
ayes. 22
23
6. Motion To Reconvene Into Open Session 24
Motion to reconvene into open session was made by Kelly and seconded by Champeau. Roll call vote: 25
Champeau, Kelly White, Bell, Howson, Bacsi. Motion carried – all ayes. 26
27
7. Motion For Action If Appropriate 28
Motion to authorize an expenditure of up to $10,000 for IT services was made by Kelly and seconded 29
by White. Motion carried – all ayes. 30
31
8. Matters To Be Placed On A Future Agenda Or Referred To A Committee, Official Or Employee 32
Search firm proposals are to be collected and distributed before the next regular Board meeting. 33
34
9. Next Meeting 35
The next meeting is the regularly scheduled Board meeting on November 17, 2026. 36
37
10. Adjourn 38
Motion to adjourn at 4:39 p.m. was made by Howson and seconded by White. Motion carried – all 39
ayes. 40
41
Minutes respectfully submitted by Julie Thyssen, Village Clerk 42
7
Page 1
STAFF REPORT
Date: November 13, 2026
To: Village Board
Re: Introduction of Bob Kufrin, Zoning Consultant
BACKGROUND
During the transition following the resignation of the Village Administrator, the Village has
engaged Robert (Bob) Kufrin to provide zoning consultation and support to Village staff.
DISCUSSION
Bob brings extensive municipal government experience, including many years of service as the
Village Administrator for Sister Bay. His familiarity with the Village's zoning ordinances,
procedures, and development history will be a valuable resource during this transition.
Bob will assist staff in navigating zoning -related questions, interpreting applicable ordinances,
and providing guidance on zoning matters to help ensure continuity of operations.
RECOMMENDATION
This item is informational only and serves to introduce Bob Kufrin in his role as Zoning Consultant
during the administrative transition. No Board action is requested.
8
Page 1
STAFF REPORT
Date: November 13, 2026
To: Village Board
Agenda Item: Door County Tourism Zone Commission – Proposed Bylaw Amendments
Prepared By: Julie Thyssen, Village Clerk
Action Requested: Discussion and possible action
Background
The Door County Tourism Zone Commission (DCTZ) has proposed amendments to its bylaws and
is seeking formal approval from its member municipalities as part of the adoption process.
The proposed amendments have been discussed at previous DCTZ meetings. Village Trustee
Louise Howson, who serves as Sister Bay's representative on the Commission, participated in
these discussions and voted in favor of the proposed changes.
Discussion
At its October 15, 2026 meeting, the DCTZ reported that eight member municipalities had
formally approved the proposed bylaw amendments:
• Town of Baileys Harbor
• Town of Clay Banks
• Town of Gibraltar
• Town of Egg Harbor
• Town of Jacksonport
• Town of Sevastopol
• Town of Washington
• Town of Sturgeon Bay
At that time, the Commission indicated that five additional municipal approvals were necessary
to formally adopt the amendments.
The DCTZ has requested that remaining member municipalities, including the Village of Sister
Bay, consider formal approval of the proposed amendments.
9
Page 2
Fiscal Impact
No direct fiscal impact has been identified based on the information currently available.
Recommended Board Action
Consider approval of the proposed Door County Tourism Zone Commission bylaw amendments
and authorize the Village Clerk to transmit the Board's action to the Commission.
Suggested Motion:
Motion to approve the proposed amendments to the Door County Tourism Zone Commission
bylaws as presented and direct the Village Clerk to provide written notification of approval to the
Commission.
10
DOOR COUNTY TOURISM ZONE COMMISSION
PO BOX 55, SISTER BAY WI 54234 Website: www.doorcountytourismzone.com
920.854.6200, Fax: 920-854-9019 Email: info@doorcountytourismzone.com
Date: August 9th, 2026
To: Door County Municipal Partners
From: Juliana Holly-Executive Director
Re: Request for Approval of Commission Bylaw Amendments
The Commission has completed a review of its bylaws and is recommending all Door County municipalities
approve of its changes. As with any governing document, the bylaws are reviewed and adjusted periodically to
reflect the Commission's evolving operational needs, improve clarity, and ensure they continue to support the
Commission's work effectively.
These proposed amendments are administrative in nature and are intended to keep the bylaws current with the
Commission's practices and responsibilities. Periodic updates such as these are a normal part of maintaining
effective governance. Two amendment subjects have been proposed and approved for recommendation by the
Full Commission: term-limits for Executive Committee member positions and actions to be taken in regard to
attendance.
In accordance with the Commission's bylaws, any amendments must be approved by the participating
municipalities before they can take effect. We respectfully request that you place this item on your
municipality's next meeting agenda for consideration and action.
For your convenience, the following motion language may be used:
Suggested Motion:
"I move to approve the amendments to the Commission Bylaws as recommended by the Commission and
authorize their adoption in accordance with the bylaws' amendment process."
A copy of the proposed amended bylaws is enclosed for your review. If you have any questions or would like
additional information before your meeting, please contact Juliana Holly, at info@doorcountytourismzone.com.
Thank you for your continued partnership and consideration of these proposed amendments.
Sincerely,
Juliana Holly, Executive Director
11
1
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
DOOR COUNTY 1
TOURISM ZONE COMMISSION 2
3
4
COMMISSION BYLAWS 5
6
7
ARTICLE I 8
9
PURPOSE AND POWER 10
11
The DOOR COUNTY TOURISM ZONE COMMISSION (the “Commission”) is created as a 12
commission under the provisions of Section 66.0615 of the Wisconsin Statutes, pursuant to which the Legislature 13
of the State of Wisconsin has determined that such commission serves a public purpose by coordinating tourism 14
promotion and development that are significantly used by transient tourists and reasonably likely to generate paid 15
overnight stays at more than one establishment owned by different persons within the tourism zone, by using 16
marketing projects, including advertising media buys, creation and distribution of printed or electronic promotional 17
tourist materials, or efforts to recruit conventions, sporting events, or motor coach groups, transient tourists 18
informational services and tangible municipal developments, including a convention center within Door County, 19
Wisconsin. The jurisdiction of the Commission shall be the area comprised of the boundaries of those 20
municipalities within Door County, Wisconsin who have, through their governmental bodies, agreed to be a 21
participating member of the Commission (the “Tourism Zone”). The Commission is a local governmental unit, 22
corporate and politic, that is separate, distinct and independent from the State of Wisconsin, Door County and all 23
local units of government with jurisdictional boundaries lying within the Tourism Zone. The Commission shall 24
have all powers, authorities; duties and responsibilities set forth in Section 66.0615 of the Wisconsin Statutes and 25
shall be subject to all provisions thereof applicable to tourism zone commissions as provided therein. As a 26
governmental body, the Commission shall comply with all applicable provisions of the Wisconsin Statutes and 27
regulations promulgated thereunder, including without limitation, the provisions of Chapter of the Wisconsin 28
Statutes, as they may relate to the Commission, its commissioners, officers and employees. 29
30
ARTICLE 2 31
32
OFFICES 33
34
Section 2.1 Offices. The principal office for the Commission shall be located at such place within the Tourism Zone 35
within Door County, Wisconsin, as shall be determined by the Commission. 36
37
ARTICLE 3 38
39
MEMBERSHIP 40
41
Section 3.1 Establishment. 42
(a) Any municipality in the County of Door is eligible to become a member of the Commission. 43
44
(b) Membership on the Commission shall be as prescribed and established under the provisions of 45
Sec.66.0615(1m), of the Wisconsin Statutes. 46
12
2
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
1
(c) To achieve membership on this Commission the applying municipality must: 2
3
1. Adopt and pass the ORDINANCE FOR THE COLLECTION OF TAX ON OVERNIGHT 4
LODGING used by the founding municipalities, including any amendments therewith (Exhibit A). 5
6
2. Adopt the Door County Tourism Zone Commission Agreement, including any amendments there 7
with, in its entirety by signature of the principal elected official in the applying municipality and shall be 8
confirmed by a majority vote of the members of the municipality’s governing body who are present when 9
the vote is taken (Exhibit B). 10
11
3. Accept the bylaws and all agreements, contracts, policies and procedures in effect at the time membership 12
is granted. 13
14
Section 3.2 Members. The Commission shall constitute the membership. 15
16
ARTICLE 4 17
18
COMMISSIONERS 19
20
Section 4.1 General Powers. The business affairs of the Commission shall be overseen by the commissioners. 21
22
Section 4.2 Number of Commissioners. 23
(a) The number of commissioners comprising the Commission shall be as prescribed under the provisions of 24
Section 66.0615(1m) (c) 2, of the Wisconsin Statutes. 25
26
(b) The municipal members of the commission shall be appointed by the principal elected official in the 27
member municipality subject to confirmation by majority vote of the members of that municipality’s 28
governing body who are present when such vote is taken. 29
30
31
(c) Two (2) additional (“At Large”) members, who represent the hotel and motel industry, shall be appointed 32
to the commission by the chairperson of the commission and shall be confirmed by a majority vote of the 33
commissioners who are present when the vote is taken. 34
35
(d) While membership on the Commission is provided for each municipality in the zone agreement, all 36
membership positions need not be filled if a municipality does not see a need. A member municipality 37
that does not appoint a representative shall not count towards the determination of a quorum. 38
39
(e) The Commission by vote of 2/3 of members present at a duly noticed meeting may establish an executive 40
committee. The membership of the executive committee shall include at least one at large member. The 41
powers of the executive committee shall include the authority to approve payments and to take such other 42
actions as is granted by the Commission. 43
44
Section 4.3 Terms of Office. 45
(a) The terms of office of the municipal commissioners shall be one (1) year commencing in June of each year. 46
Commissioners shall serve at the pleasure of the appointing official and may be reappointed for an 47
unlimited number of terms. 48
(b) The terms of office for the two (2) at large commissioners shall be one (1) year commencing in June of each 49
year. The at large commissioners shall serve at the pleasure of the chairperson of the commission and may 50
13
3
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
be reappointed for an unlimited number of terms. 1
2
Section 4.4 Vacancies. Vacancies on the Commission shall be filled by the appointing authority who appointed 3
the person whose office is vacant. A person appointed to fill a vacancy shall serve for the remainder of the 4
unexpired term to which they were appointed. 5
6
Section 4.5 Compensation. Commissioners shall receive no salaries for their services, but shall be entitled to 7
reimbursement for their actual and necessary expenses incurred in the performance of their duties. Reimbursement for 8
mileage shall be at the then current Standard Mileage Rate for Business established by the Internal Revenue Service. 9
10
Section 4.6 Confidentiality. 11
The Commission shall provide by resolution for the confidentiality of information obtained under Section 12
66.0615(2). All Room Tax returns, schedules, exhibits, writings or audit reports relating to such returns, on file 13
with the Commission and the Municipalities are deemed confidential, except the Commission or the 14
Municipalities may divulge their contents to the following, and no others: 15
16
(a) The person or his/her legal representative who filed the return; 17
18
(b) Officers, employees or agents of the municipal treasurer and the Commission; 19
20
(c) Other persons for the use in the discharge of duties imposed by law, or in the discharge of the duties of their 21
office (unless otherwise prohibited by law), or by order of a court. 22
23
The Commission may provide for the publishing of statistics classified so as not to disclose the identity of particular 24
returns. The commission shall provide that persons violating the resolution enacted under this subsection may be 25
required to forfeit not less than one hundred dollars ($100.00) or more than five hundred dollars ($500.00). 26
27
ARTICLE 5 28
29
COMMISSION MEETINGS 30
31
Section 5.1 Meeting Locations. All meetings of the Commission, annual, regular and special shall be held within 32
the municipalities which comprise the Tourism Zone. 33
34
Section 5.2 Annual Meeting. The Annual Meeting of the Commission shall be held on a date during the month 35
of May June of each year, at such place and time, as shall be determined by the Chairperson or by resolution of the 36
Commission. 37
38
Section 5.3 Regular Meetings. Regular meetings of the Commission shall be held at such dates, times and places 39
as shall be fixed by the Chairperson upon no less than forty-eight (48) hours prior notice. 40
41
Section 5.4 Special Meetings. Special meetings of the Commission may be called by the Commission Chairperson 42
or by the Vice-Chairperson, in the absence of the Chairperson. Special meetings of the Commission may also be 43
called upon a written request signed by three (3) Commissioners stating the purpose or purposes of such Special 44
Meeting request. The person or persons authorized to call special meetings of the Commission may fix the date, 45
time and place of such meeting upon no less than 48 hours prior notice. If no place of the meeting has been specified, 46
the place of the meeting shall be the Commission’s principal office in the Tourism Zone. 47
48
Section 5.5 Electronic Participation in Meetings. To the extent provided by these Bylaws, the Commission, or 49
any committee of the Commission, may, in addition to conducting meetings in which each commissioner participates 50
14
4
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
in person, and notwithstanding any place set forth in the notice of the meeting by these Bylaws, conduct any annual, 1
regular or special meeting by the use of any electronic means of communication, provided (1) all participating 2
commissioners may simultaneously hear each other during the meeting, and/or (2) all communication during the 3
meeting is immediately transmitted to each participating commissioner, and each participating commissioner is able 4
to immediately send messages to all other participating commissioners; and (3) all requirements of the Open Meetings 5
Law are met. A commissioner participating in a meeting by any means pursuant to this Section 5.5 shall be deemed 6
to be present in person at the meeting. 7
8
Section 5.6 Meeting Notice. 9
(a) Notice of any regular or special meeting shall be given by written notice, delivered personally, by mail, 10
express courier, facsimile transmission or e-mail to each commissioner at his or her business address, 11
facsimile number, e-mail address or at such other address or number as such commissioner shall have 12
designated in writing and filed at the Commission’s principal office. Such notice shall normally be given 13
at least three (3) calendar days prior to a regular meeting and, in no case, less than twenty-four (24) hours 14
prior to a meeting. In the case of an emergency, notice to commissioners shall be given at least two (2) 15
hours before a meeting. 16
17
(b) Notice of any regular or special meeting shall be given by written notice, delivered personally, by mail, 18
express courier, facsimile transmission or e-mail to each member municipality at its business address, 19
facsimile number, e-mail address or such other address or number as such municipality shall have 20
designated in writing and filed at the Commission’s principal office. It shall be the responsibility of said 21
noticed municipality to post the notice as set forth in Chapter 19 of the Wisconsin Statutes. Such notice shall 22
normally be given at least three (3) calendar days prior to a regular meeting and, in no case, less than twenty-23
four (24) hours prior to a meeting. In the case of an emergency, notice to member municipalities shall be given 24
at least two (2) hours before a meeting. 25
26
(c) Public notice of all meetings shall be given if and as required and provided in Chapter 19 of the Wisconsin 27
Statutes. If mailed, such notice shall be deemed to be delivered when deposited in the United States mail 28
so addressed, with postage thereon prepaid. If notice is given by electronic mail, such notice shall be 29
deemed to be delivered when the sender transmits the message. If notice is given by facsimile 30
transmission, such notice shall be deemed to be delivered when the sender receives in-hand a confirmation 31
sheet indicating that the transmission is complete. Whenever any notice is required to be given to any 32
commissioner under the provisions of these Bylaws, or under the provisions of any statute, a waiver thereof, 33
in writing, signed at anytime, whether before or after the time of the meeting, by the commissioner entitled to 34
such notice, shall be deemed equivalent to the given of such notice. The attendance of a commissioner at a 35
meeting shall constitute a waiver of notice of such meeting, except where a commissioner attends a meeting 36
and objects because the meeting is not lawfully called or convened. 37
38
(d) Consistent with the requirements of Section 19.84 of the Wisconsin Statutes a Commission meeting 39
shall be considered properly noticed, if the notice required above is provided to the Door County 40
Advocate, the Peninsula Pulse and the member municipalities within the required time periods. The failure 41
of any member municipality to post the meeting notice consistent with its requirements shall not invalidate 42
the Commission’s meeting notice and posting. 43
44
Section 5.7 Agenda Packet. An agenda and a copy of all materials to be presented or acted upon at a meeting of 45
the commission shall be given in written form, delivered personally, by mail or express courier to each 46
commissioner at his or her business address or at such other address as such commissioner shall have designated 47
in writing and filed at the commission’s principal office. This agenda packet shall normally be provided at least 48
three (3) calendar days prior to an annual or regular meeting; however, supporting documentation of an agenda 49
item that may not have been available at the time the packet was sent out shall be presented at the meeting as if it 50
were included in the packet. Notwithstanding, any other informational material that was not timely received to be 51
15
5
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
included in the agenda packet, which the commissioners have not had ample time to review may be presented at the 1
meeting. This information may be discussed at the meeting at the pleasure of the chairperson but under no 2
circumstance shall any action be taken except to table or have it brought forth at a future meeting at which time it shall 3
be properly noticed and timely received. 4
5
Section 5.8 Quorum. A majority of the number of commissioners then in office shall constitute a quorum for the 6
transaction of business at any meeting of the Commission. 7
8
Section 5.9 Manner of Acting. Except as otherwise specified by law or these Bylaws, the affirmative vote or 9
approval of a majority of the commissioners present at a meeting at which a quorum is present, shall be the act of the 10
Commission, [or a committee of the Commission in the case of a committee meeting]. The voting on all matters 11
presented for a vote shall be by voice vote, unless a commissioner requests a roll call, or if roll call vote is required by 12
law, in which case the Yeas and Nays shall be entered upon the minutes of the meeting. All resolutions or votes of 13
the Commission shall be entered in full in the minutes of the meeting or otherwise reduced to writing. 14
15
Section 5.10 Presumption of Assent. A commissioner, who is present at a meeting of the Commission or a committee 16
thereof at which action on any Commission matter is taken, shall be presumed to have assented the action taken 17
unless the commissioner’s dissent shall be entered in the minutes of the meeting. The right of dissent or abstention 18
is not available to a commissioner who votes in favor of the action taken. 19
20
Section 5.11 Conduct of Meetings. The Chairperson, and in his or her absence the Vice-Chairperson, and in their 21
absence, any commissioner chosen by the commissioners then present, shall call meetings of the Commission to order 22
and shall act as chairperson of the meeting. The Secretary shall act as secretary of all meetings of the Commission, but 23
in the absence of the Secretary, the presiding officer may appoint any commissioner or other person to act as secretary 24
of the meeting. Except as otherwise provided or contemplated herein, at the request of the Chairperson, or any two (2) 25
commissioners present, a meeting shall generally be conducted by Robert’s Rules of Order as revised from time to 26
time or in an orderly manner as determined by the Chairperson. 27
28
Section 5.12 Meeting Attendance. Commissioners are expected to make every effort to attend all Full 29
Commission meetings and meetings for committees to which they are appointed. Commissioners may 30
occasionally miss meetings due to factors outside their control such as illness, travel schedules, jury duty, 31
or holidays. These will generally be considered “excused” absences. In all cases, commissioners are 32
expected to notify staff or the chair of any meetings they will be unable to attend. Commissioners may be 33
removed from their committee or officer appointments by a majority vote of the Commission if more than 34
two absences without notification occur during their term. 35
36
ARTICLE 6 37
38
REPORTS AND AUDIT 39
40
Section 6.1 Reports. The Commission shall submit the following reports to all member municipalities: 41
(a) A monthly report that includes: 42
43
1. A list of all lodging properties in the municipality, the total amount of room tax paid and any properties 44
that are delinquent. 45
2. A payment to the municipality for thirty percent (30%) of the amount collected. 46
3. This report and payment should be sent by the twenty-forth (24th) of the month following the month in 47
which the tax was collected. 48
49
(b) A quarterly report that includes: 50
51
16
6
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
1. A detailed report of all administrative expenses of the commission for the past quarter. 1
2. A detailed report from the Tourism Entity itemizing all expenses incurred in the past quarter that have 2
been or should have been paid by the Commission. 3
3. This report should be delivered within sixty (60) days after the end of the quarter. 4
5
(c) The annual report that includes: 6
7
1. A summary of the activity of the past year. 8
2. A list of all room tax collected by each member municipality in the zone for each month 9
of the year. 10
3. A detailed report of all administrative expenses of the commission for the past year. 11
4. A detailed report from the Tourism Entity itemizing all expenses incurred in the past year that have been 12
or should have been paid by the Commission. 13
5. A balance sheet of the commissions finances. 14
6. An annual report from the Tourism Entity showing: 15
i. A summary of the activity of the past year. 16
ii. A report showing the return on investment, i.e., how well the established goals and objectives 17
for the year have been met. 18
iii. The mutually agreed upon goals and objectives for the new year. 19
7. These reports should be submitted to all member municipalities and all participating lodging properties no 20
less than ten (10) days before the annual meeting of the Commission but no later than the 15th day of 21
May of the year following the year being audited. 22
8. An annual meeting of the Door County Tourism Zone Commission including all member 23
municipalities, all members of the Door County Visitor Bureau which are located in the Tourism 24
Zone and all lodging properties participating in the collection of the room tax should take place each 25
year in the month of May, after the annual report has been received and before the new summer tourist 26
season begins. At this meeting, questions, concerns, future goals and objectives will be addressed. 27
28
Section 6.2 Annual Audit. An annual audit of the Door County Tourism Zone Commission’s financial records 29
shall be conducted by a licensed accounting firm chosen by a majority vote of the commissioners present at the 30
meeting when the vote is taken. This audit shall be conducted as soon as practicable after January 1 and shall be 31
completed and received by the commission no later than the 5th day of May the year after the year being audited. 32
33
34
ARTICLE 7 35
36
OFFICERS 37
Section 7.1 Designation. The principal officers of the Commission shall be a Chairperson, a Vice Chairperson, 38
a Secretary and/or a Treasurer. The Commission shall select such officers from its members. Such other officers and 39
assistant officers as may be deemed necessary by action of the Commission may be elected or appointed by the 40
Commission. 41
42
Section 7.2 Terms of Office. Except as otherwise provided in this Section, officers shall serve two-year 43
terms. Each officer shall hold office for a term of one (1) year, commencing on the day of his or her election, 44
or until his or her successor shall have been duly elected and shall have qualified, or until his or her death 45
or resignation or until he or she shall have been removed from office in the manner hereinafter provided. 46
Commissioners may serve no more than two consecutive terms as an officer, excluding any partial term 47
when a member is appointed to f ulfill an unexpired term. A year is defined as concurrent with the 48
Commission’s annual meeting schedule – i.e., June annual meeting to June annual meeting. If the election 49
of such officers shall not be held at such meeting, such election shall be held as soon thereafter as it may be convenient. 50
17
7
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
After serving two consecutive two-year terms, Commission members are eligible for reelection as an 1
officer after a one-year absence from the executive committee. Each officer shall serve until the expiration 2
of his or her term and until a successor is chosen. Officers shall be elected by and from the members of the 3
Commission. The Immediate Past Chairperson shall serve a one-year term on the executive committee after 4
serving his or her term as Chairperson, except if the Chairperson is not reappointed to the Commission the 5
year following their chairmanship. The vice-chair automatically succeeds to the office of Chairperson 6
regardless of whether they have served a previous two -year term in another position . The treasurer and 7
secretary shall be elected on odd years and the vice-chair and chair shall be elected on even years . The 8
Chairperson, Vice Chairperson, Secretary and/or Treasurer (the “Elected Officers”) shall be elected by the 9
commissioners at the June meeting of the Commission or at such other time as determined by the 10
Commission. Should an officer not be reappointed during the second year of their term, a replacement will 11
be selected by majority vote of the Full Commission. 12
13
Section 7.3 Removal. All officers who engage in the Door County lodging industry must remain in good 14
standing with the Tourism Zone for the duration of their term. Additionally, all officers must maintain good 15
attendance throughout their term in order to remain in their position. Although the Commission is unable 16
to “enforce” participation, it is essential that we ensure we are able to reach quorums in order to maintain 17
functionality. Any officer or agent elected or appointed by the Commission may be removed by the Commission 18
whenever, in its judgment, the Commission’s best interests will be served thereby. 19
20
Section 7.4 Vacancies. A vacancy in any principal office because of death, resignation, removal, disqualification 21
or otherwise, shall be filled by the Commission for the unexpired portion of the term. 22
23
Section 7.5 Chairperson. The Chairperson shall be the Commission’s principal executive officer and, subject to 24
the control of the Commission, shall, in general, supervise all of the business and affairs of the Commission. The 25
Chairperson shall, when present, preside at all meetings of the Commission. The Chairperson shall have the 26
authority, either alone, with another officer or through his designee, to sign, execute and acknowledge, on behalf 27
of the Commission, all deeds, mortgages, bonds, contracts and other documents or instruments which are necessary 28
or proper in the regular course of the Commission’s business or which may be authorized by the Commission, 29
except in cases where the signing and execution thereof shall be expressly delegated by the Commission or by the 30
Bylaws to some other officer or agent of the Commission, or shall be required by law to be otherwise signed or 31
executed. The Chairperson shall in general perform all duties incidental to the office of the Chairperson and such 32
other duties as may be prescribed by the Commission from time to time. The Chairperson shall be an ex-33
officio member of all of the Commission’s committees. In the absence of actual knowledge by third parties 34
to the contrary, the execution of an instrument of the Commission by the Chairperson shall be conclusive 35
evidence, as to such third parties, of his or her authority to execute the instrument on behalf of the Tourism 36
Zone. 37
38
Section 7.6 Vice-Chairperson. In the absence of the Chairperson, or in the event of the Chairperson’s death or 39
inability or refusal to act as directed by the Commission, the Vice-Chairperson shall perform duties of the 40
Chairperson; and when so acting, shall have all the powers of and be subject to all the restrictions upon the 41
Chairperson. The Vice-Chairperson may sign, with the Secretary, bonds or notes of the Commission and shall 42
perform all other duties as from time to time may be assigned by the Chairperson and/or the Commission. In the 43
absence of actual knowledge by third parties to the contrary, the execution of any instrument of the Commission 44
by the Vice-Chairperson shall be conclusive evidence, as to such third parties, of his or her authority to act in the 45
stead of the Chairperson. 46
47
Section 7.7 Secretary. The Secretary shall: 48
(a) Keep or appoint someone to keep the minutes of the meetings of the Commission in one or more books 49
provided for that purpose. 50
51
18
8
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
(b) See that all notices are duly given in accordance with the provisions of these Bylaws or as required by law. 1
2
3
(c) Act as the custodian or designate an individual to act as custodian of the Commission’s records and see that 4
books, reports, statements, certificates and all other documents and records required by law are properly 5
kept and filed. 6
7
(d) Keep a register of the post office address of each Commissioner and each officer, which shall be furnished to 8
the Secretary by each such person. 9
10
(e) Sign with the Chairperson and/or Vice-Chairperson, all bonds, notes, agreements, deeds, instruments, 11
certificates and other documents of the Commission which shall have been authorized by resolution of 12
the Commission. 13
14
(f) In general, perform all duties incidental to the office of the Secretary and such other duties as from time to 15
time may be assigned to him or her by the Chairperson and/or the Commission. 16
17
Section 7.8 Treasurer. The Treasurer, or his or her designee, shall: 18
(a) Have charge and custody of and be responsible for all of the Commission’s funds and securities. 19
(b) Receive and give receipts for money due and payable to the Commission from any source whatsoever, and 20
deposit all funds of the Commission in such banks, trust companies or other depositories as shall be selected 21
in accordance with the provisions of these Bylaws. 22
(c) In general perform all of the duties incidental to the office of the Treasurer and such other duties as from time 23
to time may be assigned to him or her by the Chairperson and/or the Commission. 24
25
Section 7.9 Bonds Required. As required by the Door County Tourism Zone Commission Agreement and the 26
Commission, the Officers and Administrative employees shall give a bond for the faithful discharge of their 27
duties in such sum and with such surety or sureties as the Commission shall determine. 28
29
Section 7.10 Assistant Secretaries and Assistant Treasurers. The Commission may authorize one or more 30
Assistant Secretaries and/or Assistant Treasurers from time to time. Any such Assistant Secretary may sign with 31
the Chairperson, or Vice-Chairperson, debt securities of the Tourism Zone, the issuance of which shall have 32
been authorized by a resolution of the Commission. The Assistant Secretaries and/or Treasurers, as 33
required by the Door County Tourism Zone Commission Agreement and the Commission, shall give 34
bonds for the faithful discharge of their duties in such sums and with such sureties as the Commission 35
shall determine. The Assistant Secretaries and Assistant Treasurers, in general, shall perform such 36
duties as shall be assigned to them by the Secretary or the Treasurer, respectively, or by the Chairperson 37
or the Commission. 38
39
Section 7.11 Other Personnel. The Commission may, from time to time, appoint, hire and employ such 40
other personnel as it shall deem necessary to exercise and carry out the powers, Duties and functions 41
of the Commission. The qualifications, duties and numbers of such personnel shall be consistent with 42
the policies determined by the Commission. 43
44
Section 7.12 Salaries. Officers shall receive no salaries for their services, but they shall be entitled to reimbursement 45
for their actual and necessary expenses incurred in the performance of their duties. Reimbursement for mileage 46
shall be at the then current Standard Mileage Rate for Business established by the Internal Revenue Service. 47
48
Article 8 49
50
19
9
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
Executive Committee 1
2
Section 8.1 Designation. The executive committee shall consist of all Commission officers and two 3
members from the Commission at-large. The Commission shall select such officers from its members. 4
5
Section 8.2 Terms of Office. Except as otherwise provided in this Section, members of the executive 6
committee shall serve two-year terms. Commissioners may serve no more than two consecutive terms on 7
the executive committee, excluding any partial term when a member is appointed to fulfill an unexpired 8
term. A year is defined as concurrent with the Commission’s annual meeting schedule – i.e., June annual 9
meeting to June annual meeting. If the election of such executive committee members shall not be held at 10
such meeting, such election shall be held as soon thereafter as it may be convenient. After serving two 11
consecutive two-year terms, Commission members are eligible for reelection to the executive committee 12
after a one-year absence from the committee. Each committee member shall serve until the expiration of 13
his or her term and until a successor is chosen. The members of the executive committee shall be elected 14
by and from the members of the Commission. The treasurer, secretary and two at-large positions shall be 15
elected on odd years and the vice-chair and chair positions will be elected on even years . Should an 16
executive committee member not be reappointed during the second year of their term, a replacement will 17
be selected by majority vote of the Full Commission. 18
19
Section 8.3 Removal. All executive committee members who engage in the Door County lodging industry 20
must remain in good standing with the Tourism Zone for the duration of their term. Additionally, all 21
executive committee members must maintain good attendance throughout their term in order to remain on 22
the committee. Although the Commission is unable to “enforce” participation, it is essential that we ensure 23
we are able to reach quorums in order to maintain functionality. Any committee member elected or appointed 24
by the Commission may be removed by the Commission whenever, in its judgment, the Commission’s best 25
interests will be served thereby. 26
27
Section 8.4 Vacancies. A vacancy in any principal office because of death, resignation, removal, disqualification 28
or otherwise, shall be filled by the Commission for the unexpired portion of the term. If no eligible Commission 29
member volunteers to serve on the Executive Committee for a position, a Commission member who has 30
previously served on the executive committee for two terms and has not completed the one year absence 31
can be elected to an officer or at-large executive committee position. 32
33
Section 8.5 Executive committee members shall receive no salaries for their services, but they shall be entitled to 34
reimbursement for their actual and necessary expenses incurred in the performance of their duties. 35
Reimbursement for mileage shall be at the then current Standard Mileage Rate for Business established 36
by the Internal Revenue Service. 37
38
ARTICLE 98 39
40
CONTRACTS AND FINANCIAL TRANSACTIONS 41
42
Section 98.1 Contracts. The Commission may authorize any officer or officers and/or employees, to enter into any 43
contract, or to execute and deliver any instrument in the name of and on behalf of the Commission, and such 44
authorization may be general or confined to specific instances. The Chairperson shall have the authority to enter 45
into any contract or to deliver any instrument in the name and on behalf of the Commission with respect to any 46
approved budgetary item or as may be granted by the Commission for other specific items from time to time. 47
48
Section 98.2 Deposits. All funds collected or otherwise received by the Commission not otherwise employed shall 49
be deposited from time to time to the credit and under the name of the Commission in such banks, trust companies, 50
20
10
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
or other depositories as may be selected by or under the authority of the Commission. 1
2
Section 98.3 Checks. All checks, drafts or other orders for the payment of money, notes or other evidence of 3
indebtedness issued in the name of the Commission, shall be signed by such officer or officers, agent or agents, 4
of the Commission, and in such manner as shall, from time to time, be determined by or under the authority of a 5
resolution of the Commission. 6
7
Section 98.4 Loans. No loans shall be contracted on behalf of the Commission and no evidence of indebtedness 8
shall be issued in its name unless authorized by or under the authority of a resolution of the Commission. Such 9
authorization may be general or confined to specific instances. 10
11
Section 98.5 Financial Regulations. The Commission shall have the power and authority to enact such rules and 12
regulations, consistent with the provisions of applicable Wisconsin Statutes, as it may deem necessary concerning 13
the issue, transfer, registration and verification of the Commission’s financial transactions. 14
15
ARTICLE 109 16
17
INDEMNIFICATION 18
19
Section 109.1 Mandatory Indemnification. 20
(a) Successful on the Merits. The Commission shall indemnify a commissioner, officer or employee of the 21
Commission to the extent he or she has been successful on the merits or otherwise in the defense of a 22
proceeding, for all reasonable expenses incurred in the proceeding, if the commissioner or officer was a 23
party because he or she is or was at the time of the events upon which the proceeding was based, a 24
commissioner or officer of the Commission. A commissioner or officer shall exercise his or her right to 25
indemnification under this Section 9.1 by delivering a written demand for indemnification to the 26
Commission’s Treasurer or the Chairperson if the party seeking indemnification is the Treasurer. 27
28
(b) Good Faith. In all cases not included in Section 9.1(a), the Tourism Zone shall indemnify a commissioner 29
or officer against liability incurred by the commissioner or officer in a proceeding to which the 30
commissioner or officer was a party because he or she is or was, at the time of the events upon which 31
the proceeding was based, a commissioner or officer of the Commission; provided that there is a 32
determination that the commissioner or officer acted in good faith and in a manner he or she reasonably 33
believed to be in or not opposed to the best interests of the Commission, and provided that such act or 34
omission by the commissioner does not constitute a violation of criminal law, unless a commissioner or 35
officer had reasonable cause to believe that his or her conduct was lawful or had no reasonable cause to 36
believe his or her conduct was unlawful. Whether or not a commissioner shall be entitled to 37
indemnification under this Section 9.1(b) shall be determined in accordance with the procedures 38
established in Section 9.2. 39
40
(c) No Presumption. The termination of a proceeding by judgment, order, settlement or conviction, or upon a plea 41
of no contest or an equivalent plea, does not, by itself, create a presumption that indemnification of the 42
commissioner or officer is not required under this subsection. 43
44
Section 109.2 Determination of Right to Indemnification. A commissioner or officer seeking indemnification 45
under Article 9 shall first make a written request to the Commission’s Treasurer or the Commission’s Chairperson if 46
the person seeking indemnification is the Treasurer, for such indemnification. Determination of whether 47
indemnification is required shall be made by one of the following means: 48
49
(a) By a majority vote of a quorum of the Commission consisting of commissioners who are not at the time 50
21
11
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
parties to the same or related proceedings with respect to which the indemnification claim has been made. 1
If such quorum of disinterested commissioners cannot be obtained, by a majority vote of a committee 2
duly appointed by the Commission and consisting solely of three (3) or more commissioners who are not 3
at the time parties to the same or related proceedings. Commissioners who are parties to the same or related 4
proceedings may participate in the designation of members of the committee. 5
6
(b) By independent legal counsel selected by a majority vote of a quorum of the Commission or its committee 7
consisting of commissioners who are not at the time parties to the same or related proceedings; or, if such 8
a quorum cannot be obtained, by a majority vote of the full Commission, including commissioners who 9
are parties to the same or related proceedings. 10
11
(c) By a panel of three (3) arbitrators consisting of one (1) arbitrator selected by those commissioners entitled 12
under subsection (b) above to select independent legal counsel, one (1) arbitrator selected by the commissioner 13
or officer seeking indemnification, and one (1) arbitrator selected by the other two (2) arbitrators. 14
15
(d) By a court of competent jurisdiction upon application by the commissioner or officer for an initial 16
determination of entitlement to indemnification or for review by the court of an adverse determination. 17
Indemnification shall be ordered if the court determines that the commissioner or officer is entitled to 18
indemnification under Section 9.1 or that the commissioner or officer is fairly and reasonably entitled to 19
indemnification by order of the court, in addition to indemnification against all other expenses and liability, 20
the commissioner or officer shall be reimbursed for expenses reasonably incurred in pursuing his or her 21
request for indemnification. 22
23
(e) The commissioner or officer of the Commission seeking indemnification shall designate in his or her 24
request for indemnification the method of making the indemnification determination. 25
26
Section 10.3 Advance of Expenses as Incurred. The Commission may, upon written request by the 27
commissioner or officer, pay for or reimburse the reasonable expenses incurred by a commissioner or officer who 28
is a party to the proceedings, as those expenses are incurred, if the commissioner or officer furnishes the Commission 29
with a written affirmation. 30
31
Section 10.4 Insurance. The Commission shall purchase or provide insurance on behalf of its commissioners and 32
officers, or to reimburse itself, against liability asserted or incurred and expenses incurred by the commissioner or 33
officer in connection with a proceeding brought against the commissioner or officer in his or her capacity as 34
commissioner or officer or arising from his or her status as a commissioner or officer, regardless of whether the 35
Commission is required or authorized to indemnify the individual against the same liability pursuant to the 36
provisions hereof. 37
38
Section 10.5 Severability. To the extent any court of competent jurisdiction shall determine that the indemnification 39
provided under this Article 9 shall be invalid as applied to a particular claim, issue or matter, the provisions hereof 40
shall be deemed amended to allow and require indemnification to the maximum extent permitted by law. 41
42
ARTICLE 110 43
44
RATIFICATION AND AMENDMENTS 45
46
Section 110.1 Ratification. Ratification of these Bylaws and any proposed alterations, amendments or deletions to 47
the provisions thereto shall be by two-thirds (2/3) assenting vote of all member municipalities. 48
49
Section 110.2 Action on Proposed Modifications. The Commission or any member municipality may, from 50
time to time, propose amendments, alterations or revocation of any and all provisions of these Bylaws. These 51
22
12
Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws 06/18/2026
proposed modifications to the Bylaws shall be presented to the Bylaws Committee for review and 1
recommendation. The Bylaws Committee shall review said proposed modifications and present them to the 2
commission at its next regular or special meeting, as an agenda item, with a recommendation and request for action. 3
In no case will the Bylaws Committee have less than thirty (30) days to review any proposed modifications. The 4
Commission shall debate the modifications and the recommendation and upon a two-thirds (2/3) assenting vote 5
authorize the Commission to proceed to the member municipalities for ratification. Under no circumstance shall 6
any action be taken by the Commission or the Municipalities until the Bylaws Committee has had time to review 7
the proposed modifications and make its recommendation and the Commission has cast an assenting vote to 8
proceed. 9
10
Section 110.3 Implied Amendments. Any action taken or authorized by the Commission, which would be 11
inconsistent with the Bylaws then in effect but which is taken or authorized by affirmative vote of not less than the 12
number of commissioners required to amend the Bylaws so that the Bylaws would be consistent with such action, 13
shall be given the same effect as though the Bylaws had been temporarily amended or suspended as far, but only as 14
far, as is necessary to permit the specific action so taken or authorized. 15
23
13
DOOR COUNTY TOURISM ZONE COMMISSION
COMMISSION BYLAWS
The Door County Tourism Zone Commission Bylaws dated this 28th day of May, 2008 are hereby
APPROVED
REJECTED
By the Board of the Village/Town of
By President/Chairperson
Attested by Secretary/Clerk
Date
24
Page 1
STAFF REPORT
Date: November 13, 2026
To: Village Board
Re: Consideration of Offer to Purchase Village-Owned Property – County Highway
ZZ, Town of Liberty GroveParcel Number: 0180103312843C
Action Requested: Discussion and possible action
BACKGROUND
The Village has received a written offer from Chad Buntin to purchase approximately two acres
of Village-owned property located along County Highway ZZ in the Town of Liberty Grove.
Mr. Buntin owns adjoining property and initially contacted the Village in August 2026 regarding
his interest in acquiring the parcel for additional recreational and hunting purposes.
DISCUSSION
At the request of the former Village Administrator, Mr. Buntin submitted a written offer of
$20,000 ($10,000 per acre) for the property.
The proposed terms include an as -is purchase, payment by cashier's check, and no anticipated
future development or improvements.
Comparable Sales and Market Considerations
A preliminary review of recent land sales in the area identified the following transactions:
Property Sale Date Acreage Sale Price Price/Acre
County Highway ZZ, Liberty Grove March 2026 15.19 $150,000 $9,875
Fawn Lane, Liberty Grove October 2026 1.54 $77,900 $50,584
Current Offer November 2026 Approx. 2.00 $20,000 $10,000
The County Highway ZZ sale (Parcel 0180103312843A) involved wooded recreational property
with wetlands and provides a relevant comparison to the Village -owned parcel. The Fawn Lane
sale involved a residential building lot and illustrates the potentially hi gher market value of
independently buildable property.
25
Page 2
The offered price of $10,000 per acre is generally consistent with the nearby recreational land
sale. However, the Village-owned parcel's market value may be affected by road access, zoning,
wetlands, development potential, and any existing property restrictions.
These comparisons are preliminary and do not constitute a formal appraisal.
FISCAL IMPACT
Acceptance of the offer would generate $20,000 in gross proceeds for the Village, less any
applicable transaction expenses.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the Village Board review the offer and provide direction regarding
whether to pursue the potential sale. Verification of the parcel's development potential, legal
restrictions, and market value is recommended before final consideration.
SUGGESTED MOTION
Motion to direct staff to further evaluate the $20,000 offer from Chad Buntin for Village -owned
Parcel 0180103312843C, including any necessary property valuation and legal review, and return
the matter to the Village Board for further consideration.
ATTACHMENTS
• Written Offer – Chad Buntin (Not a legally binding Offer to Purchase)
• Parcel Map – 0180103312843C
26
Page 3
27
Address
Navigable Stream
County Trunk Highway
Roads
County
Private
Town
ROW
Easements
Easement
Parcel
Gap
11/14/2026
0 870 1,740435 ft
0 260 520130 m
1:13,414
28
STAFF REPORT
Date: November 17, 2026
To: Village Board
Re: Sewer Rate Study Request for Proposals
Author(s): Megan Barnes, Utilities Director
Action(s) Requested: ☐ Ordinance ☐ Resolution ☒ Motion ☒ Receive/File
POLICY ISSUE(S)
“Should the Village Board award the Sewer Rate Study Request for Proposals (RFP)”
BACKGROUND INFORMATION
The Village’s last sewer rate study was performed in 2024, with the rates being approved by the
Village Board on December 17, 2024, and becoming effective January 1, 2025.
It is proposed to release the RFP on October 21, 2026, with a due date for submitted proposals
on November 9, 2027. With the proposed rates becoming effective January 1, 2027.
At the October 13, 2026, quarterly SWUC meeting, the committee members recommended the
Sewer Rate Study RFP be sent to the Village Board for approval. The committee agreed that
proposals should go directly to the Village Board without a separate committee meeting. The
goal of the SWUC was to coordinate the effective dates for both the water rate and sewer rates
to be implemented on January 1, 2027.
At the October 20, 2026, regular Village Board meeting, the Village Board approved the
issuance of the Sewer Rate Study RFP.
Only one response was received for the Sewer Rate Study RFP. The respondent was Trilogy
Consulting, LLC. The full response from Trilogy Consulting, LLC and an example of a recent
sewer rate study they performed for Rice Lake, Wisconsin, is included in the packet for review
and consideration.
In Trilogy’s response, it is noted that they have concerns about the feasibility of the timeline for
the study and the implementation of new rates on January 1, 2027, that is outlined in the RFP.
They are proposing an alternate timeline for preparation of a rate study for implementation of
new rates on July 1, 2027.
29
Village staff agrees that the timeline for the Sewer Rate Study and the implementation for the
new rates should be updated to allow respondents and staff adequate time to perform and
implement the rate study.
RECOMMENDED ACTION(S)
Village staff recommends that the Sewer Rate Study RFP be updated and rereleased to
proposers to change the desired effective date of the new rate implementation to July 1, 2027.
If the Village Board were in favor of this policy action, the following motion may be made:
“I move to recommend the Sewer Rate Study Request for Proposals with the updated
timeline, with the rates to become effective July 1, 2027, for approval. ”
POLICY ALTERNATIVE(S)
The Village Board could take the following actions:
• Approve with modifications.
“I move to recommend the Sewer Rate Study Request for approval with the modification of
[List Modification Sought].”
• Deny
“I move to reject the Sewer Rate Study Request for Proposals and take no further action at
this time.”
• Table
“I move to postpone action on the Sewer Rate Study Request for Proposals and direct staff to
return to the Village Board with additional information regarding [List Information Sought] at
a future meeting.”
ATTACHMENT(S)
1. Sewer Rate Study Request for Proposals - 10202026 Board Approved RFP
2. Trilogy Consulting LLC, Sewer Rate Study Proposal
3. Trilogy Consulting LLC, 2026 Rice Lake Sewer Rate Study
4. Sewer Rate Study Request for Proposals – New Proposed Timeline
30
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
SEWER RATE STUDY
SISTER BAY, WIS.
DATE ISSUED
October 21, 2026
PROPOSAL DUE DATE AND TIME
November 9, 2026, 3:45 pm CST
31
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
SEWER RATE STUDY SERVICES
SUBMISSION DEADLINE: November 9, 2026, by 3:45 PM, submitted to the Village of Sister
Bay Administrative Office located at 2383 Maple Dr., PO Box 769, Sister Bay, WI 54234, or
electronically (PDF) to administrator@sisterbaywi.gov. It shall be the responsibility of the
proposer to ensure their submission was received.
Direct all questions concerning this solicitation to Benjamin Andrews , Village
Administrator, at administrator@sisterbaywi.gov. Staff will answer all questions to the
best of their ability and post them to the Village website to ensure all proposers have
access to the same information. Visit www.sisterbaywi.gov and scroll to the bottom of the
home page.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The Village of Sister Bay (“Village”) is soliciting proposals from
qualified and licensed consultants to provide sewer rate study services in 2027. Sister Bay
is a community of roughly 1,148 people situated on the northwestern shore of the Door
Peninsula in Door Coun ty, Wisconsin. The Village lies adjacent to the Bay of Green Bay
and the Town of Liberty Grove and is located approximately 30 miles north of the City of
Sturgeon Bay and 75 miles northeast of the City of Green Bay. The Sister Bay Sewer Utility
has approximately 1,526 active service connections. The Utility serves customers located
in the Village of Sister Bay, as well as customers in the Liberty Grove Utility District No. 1,
including 214 commercial users and no industrial users. Charges for service are user fees
(or rates) for the services provided to each customer. The Village bills customers quarterly
for services rendered, including a service charge based on the size of the installed water
meter and a volumetric rate based on usage. The last sewer rate study was completed in
2024, effective January 1, 2025.
OVERVIEW/SOLICITATION: The Village of Sister Bay is seeking proposals from qualified
and licensed consultants to prepare our 2026 sewer rate study to be effective January 1,
2027. Quality and accuracy are paramount and are critical to establishing the rates.
Acknowledging publication and notification deadlines, time is of the essence.
I. Instruction to Proposers
• All respondents (proposers) must submit contact information including: Business
name, contact person, corporate ownership, address, phone number, email address,
and website.
• All costs associated with submission of this Request for Proposals are the sole
responsibility of the respondent.
• All submissions are considered public record s, and as such, may be searched for or
requested by members of the public.
• The Village of Sister Bay offers no guarantee of financial success to the respondent(s),
and respondents should use their own business acumen to determine if they are
endeavoring in a financially viable enterprise.
• This is a Request for Proposals, not an invitation to bid. Responses will be evaluated
32
on the basis of the relative merits of the proposal.
II. Submission Materials
The following should be incorporated into each submission:
Format: Electronic submissions preferred (PDF).
General Information. Business name, contact person, corporate ownership, address,
phone number, contact person's email address, website, and insurance information.
Please include a narrative introducing the company, its history of operation, relevant staff,
total number employed, and capacity to service the Village.
Project Proposal. At a minimum, provide information on approach, services, ideas, costs,
and timeline.
Prior Experience . A narrative explaining prior experience with rate studies, as well as
examples.
References. A minimum of three municipal or utility references are required.
III. Evaluation and Selection
Evaluation Process
The Village has established a proposal evaluation instrument which measures objective
criteria on a weighted basis on a scale of 0 -5 for each rating category. The Sewer and
Water Utility Committee’s average score will be evaluated against the average scores from
other submissions to determine whom to award a contract.
Selection Criteria
The following are the criteria used as rating categories:
1. Qualifications
2. Knowledge of State and Federal applicable laws
3. Experience
4. Level of Understanding of the Need Identified
5. References
6. Cost
If at any point in the review process, any proposal found to be substantially non-
responsive will be dropped from further consideration.
The Village, at its sole discretion, may require presentations by respondents clearly in
consideration for award. Other submissions, certifications, or affirmations may be
required, as appropriate.
IV. Award
Upon final selection, the Village will notify all respondents by email.
The Village reserves the right to accept or reject any or all responses, to award on the
basis of merit or cost alone, and to act in its best interests and the interests of the public.
33
The Village reserves the right to make an award or to reject any or all proposals based on
what it considers to be its best interests. A contract will be required to effectuate service.
V. Administrative Contact
Name: Benjamin Andrews
Title: Village Administrator
E-Mail: administrator@sisterbaywi.gov
Mailing Address: 2383 Maple Dr., PO Box 769, Sister Bay, WI 54234
34
169 E Wisconsin Ave, Suite R, Oconomowoc WI 53066•PHONE: (262)470-2277•FAX: (262)436-2102•www.trilogy-llc.com
November 4, 2026
SENT VIA EMAIL
Megan Barnes
Utilities Director
Village of Sister Bay
2383 Maple Dr., PO Box 769
Sister Bay, WI 54234
RE: Proposal for Sewer Rate Study
Dear Ms. Barnes:
This letter is in response to the Request for Proposals published for the Village of Sister Bay
Sewer Rate Study, dated October 21, 2026. Our two principals, Christy DeMaster and I, have
worked with many Wisconsin municipalities and utilities to adopt new rates for water and
sewer utilities. Our studies are based on a thorough and detailed analysis, provide the
community with sound estimates of how much revenue is needed for all utility needs, and
provide a sound plan for the utility’s financial future.
The RFP outlined a timeline for the study of the implementation of new rates on January 1,
2027. Considering the time it would take for Village Board approval of the undertaking of the
study, and Board adoption of the recommended rates, this would only allow for a few weeks to
actually perform the rate analysis and prepare a study report. Unfortunately, we feel that this
timeline does not allow for the quality and accuracy that the Village is looking for in its rate
study. If the Village is interested, we would propose an alternate timeline for preparation of a
rate study for implementation of new rates on July 1, 2027. This would allow for the rigorous
analysis of data and funding scenarios that the Village needs for determining fair and
reasonable sewer rates for its various customers while keeping the utility financially healthy
and able to complete its capital improvement needs.
Below is a typical approach we take to undertaking sewer rate studies. This particular scope
was prepared for the City of Rice Lake Utilities, but it would be tailored to your unique
circumstances, should you want a more detailed proposal along our alternate proposed
timeline. In recent years, we have performed similar studies for the sewer utilities in Osceola,
St. Croix Falls, Little Chute, Grafton, Mukwonago, Hudson, New Richmond, and River Falls,
among others.
35
169 E Wisconsin Ave, Suite R, Oconomowoc WI 53066•PHONE: (262)470-2277•FAX: (262)436-2102•www.trilogy-llc.com
TYPICAL SCOPE OF SERVICES
Task 1: Data Gathering and Analysis
1. Kickoff meeting —Upon commencing the project, we will conduct a project kickoff
meeting with Utility staff. We will prepare a draft agenda prior to the meeting, which will
include subjects such as the overall goals and objectives of the study, potential changes
to the current rate structure and other fees, available information and data for the study,
current billing policies and procedures, anticipated schedule and deadlines , and main
points of contact and preferred communication procedures. Prior to the meeting, we will
also provide a draft list of information requested for the study.
2. Information gathering and review
a. Prior to the kickoff meeting, we will provide Utility staff with a list of requested
information. The information requested may change based on discussions at the
kickoff meeting regarding data availability.
b. Following initial review of the information, we will confer with Utility staff as
needed to clarify any information.
3. Trend analysis and projections—We will perform an analysis of overall trends in operating
expenses and consumption by customer class for the utility. This will be used to determine
overall projections in sewer usage and O&M expenses for the future forecast, as well as
sewer use patterns and parameters to be used in the cost-of-service study and rate
design. Specifically, we will:
a. Prepare trend analysis of operating expenses by category to identify any expenses
that are increasing significantly greater than others or that fluctuate and may need
to be normalized for purposes of setting rates;
b. Prepare detailed trend analysis of historical customer data to evaluate trends in
numbers of customers, demand per customer for each customer class, and flows
and loadings from high strength industrial customers;
c. Discuss with Utility staff any known local factors, development trends or policies
that are likely to influence future patterns in the growth or decline of the customer
base or sewer use per customer;
d. Project total customers billed by customer class and meter size, and total billed
sewer consumption by customer class, including high strength loadings and
hauled waste;
36
169 E Wisconsin Ave, Suite R, Oconomowoc WI 53066•PHONE: (262)470-2277•FAX: (262)436-2102•www.trilogy-llc.com
e. Based on available data, we will perform an analysis of sewer waste strength for
domestic and non -domestic strength waste. This will be used to determine the
appropriate allocations to be used within the cost -of-service study, which
determines the proportionate amount of certain facilities’ costs that are allocated
to each customer class. This data may also be used to adjust domestic and/or
hauled waste strength assumptions, if indicated to be appropriate.
Task 2: Financial Analysis and Development of Future Projections
1. 5-Year Financial Forecast. For this task, we will develop a plan and recommendations for
funding all utility functions for 2023 through 2027, including a detailed 5 -year capital
funding plan. We will prepare alternative funding plans to evaluate the impacts of various
funding options, including varying levels of debt vs. cash-financing from current revenues
or reserves. The alternative plans will be evaluated to develop recommendations for a
capital funding plan, potential future rate increases, and criteria to use for the ongoing
analysis and monitoring of the utility’s financial status, taking into consideration the
Utility’s ability to issue debt, the avoidance of rate spikes, and any other goals regarding
rate levels and Utility policies. Specifically, the forecasts will include the following:
a. Projected customers and customer demand by class, including industrial high-
strength, hauled waste and landfill leachate;
b. Projected user charge revenues at current rates;
c. Projected other operating revenues and non-operating revenues;
d. Projected operation and maintenance expenses;
e. Evaluation of alternatives for funding and managing the Utility’s Equipment
Replacement Fund;
f. Evaluation of the feasibility and desirability of cash financing vs. debt financing
each year’s capital improvements, based on the magnitude of costs, the useful life
of the improvements, the availability of current rate revenues and/or reserve
balances to use for cash financing, Utility policies and ability to issue debt, debt
coverage requirements, debt to equity ratios and any other criteria identified for
the study;
g. Capital funding plan showing the projects, costs, and proposed financing sources
by year, and estimated debt service for anticipated debt issuances;
h. Analysis of debt coverage and the utility’s ability to meet coverage requirements;
i. Projected reserve fund balances;
37
169 E Wisconsin Ave, Suite R, Oconomowoc WI 53066•PHONE: (262)470-2277•FAX: (262)436-2102•www.trilogy-llc.com
j. Recommended minimum reserve levels, based on the value and age of assets,
annual operating expenses, any current and/or future debt obligations and the
capital improvements analysis and any formal or informal Utility policies with
respect to reserve levels;
k. Estimated timing and amount of overall user charge rate increases needed to fund
the capital improvement program, provide adequate debt coverage, and maintain
recommended reserve fund balances.
Task 3: Cost of Service Analysis and Development of User Rate Recommendations
1. We will prepare a cost -of-service model for the wastewater utility, consisting of the
following tasks:
a. Compilation and analysis of system data, such as billable usage, wastewater
influent flows and loadings to the treatment plant, estimated I/I, utility asset data,
and the adopted CIP, to determine appropriate allocation factors for O&M and
capital costs;
b. Allocation of the various categories of revenue requirements to utility functions,
including conveyance, flow, treatment categories (BOD, TSS, etc.), and customer
costs such as billing, meters and services;
c. Consideration of methods for allocating costs to additional pollutants (e.g.
Phosphorus, Nitrogen, etc.), with resultant industrial surcharge and hauled waste
rate calculations;
d. Determine each customer class’s proportionate share of functionalized costs;
e. For each utility function, the analysis will determine the share of demand for each
customer class. For the various functions, the share of cost assigned to each class
may be based on total sewer usage, estimated pounds of pollutants, number of
meters, number of equivalent meters or number of equivalent services;
f. Other operating revenues (non-user rate) will be allocated proportionately among
customer classes as an offset to revenues to be generated from user charges.
2. While performing the cost-of-service study, we will confer with Utility staff as needed to
discuss any additional information needs or clarification of any of the data used in the
cost-of-service.
3. Rate structure recommendation. As part of the kickoff meeting, we will discuss in detail
the objectives for rate structures for the utility. Based on this discussion, we will prepare
and evaluate alternatives to the current rate structure.
a. We will prepare a baseline rate structure for use as a point of comparison that will
38
169 E Wisconsin Ave, Suite R, Oconomowoc WI 53066•PHONE: (262)470-2277•FAX: (262)436-2102•www.trilogy-llc.com
mirror the current rate structure. The baseline rate structure will:
i. Recover the revenue requirements;
ii. Follow cost-of-service principles;
iii. Calculate total projected revenues from each customer class and compare
them to projected revenues under current rates;
iv. Show the impacts of the rate structures on example customers in each
customer class;
v. Show how much revenue is collected through fixed charges vs. volume
charges.
vi. A comparison with the average sewer bills for the average residential and
commercial customer for a number of peer communities in the area.
b. We will prepare alternative sewer rate structures that the Utility desires to explore
and/or are indicated by the utility cost structure. Examples of rate structures that
we may consider include adjustment to fixed charges, hauled waste rates, addition
of surcharge rates for Phosphorus or other pollutants, or any other rate structure
that may be deemed appropriate based on the results of the analysis performed
and discussions with Utility staff. For each rate structure alternative, we will
prepare the following:
i. The overall increase in revenues from each customer class;
ii. The amount of revenues collected through each type of charge;
iii. A table of the amount and percentage increase in customer bills for
various usage levels for each customer class;
iv. Show how much revenue is collected through fixed charges vs. volume
charges.
v. A comparison with the average sewer bills for the average residential and
commercial customer for several peer communities in the area.
Task 4: Written Report and Presentation
1. We will prepare a final draft report containing all analysis and findings and an electronic
copy to Utility staff for review and discussion.
2. We will attend a meeting with Utility staff to discuss any questions, comments, and
revisions regarding the study report.
3. After discussing the preliminary results and proposed rates with Utility staff, we will make
any necessary adjustments, prepare a final report, and provide an electronic PDF copy to
the Utility.
39
169 E Wisconsin Ave, Suite R, Oconomowoc WI 53066•PHONE: (262)470-2277•FAX: (262)436-2102•www.trilogy-llc.com
4. We will prepare a PowerPoint presentation of the analysis and key findings and
recommendations of the cash flow projections, cost of service studies and rate structure
analysis, to be provided to Utility staff for review in advance of the meeting.
5. We will attend a Utilit ies Commission meeting in person to present the key findings and
recommendations of the report and answer any questions.
Based on this scope of services, and hourly rates of $130 per hour, we completed the sewer
rate study for the City of Rice Lake Utilities for $13,325, which was under our projected budget
of $16,250. We would anticipate that a study for the Village of Sister Bay could be completed
within a similar range of costs, at our 2027 hourly rates of $135 per hour. I have attached the
study we completed for Rice Lake as an example of our work; this is representative of the
majority of studies that we complete. Our main contact with Rice Lake was Shanon Breed,
Finance/Office Manager. She can be reached at 715-234-7004 or
shanonb@ricelakeutilities.com as a reference.
To give you a little bit more background on our firm and experience, Trilogy was formed in
November 2011 and is jointly owned by myself and Christy DeMaster. Between the two of us,
we have a combined 48 years of experience in municipal consulting. We are a registered
Municipal Advisor firm with the Securities Exchange Commission and Municipal Securities
Rulemaking Board, and we have both taken and passed the Series 50 and Series 54 exams for
Municipal Advisor representatives and principals, respectively. Our core services include sewer,
water, and stormwater user charge rate studies and financial plans, capital improvement
funding plans, impact fees and public facilities needs assessments, and specialized policy
analysis.
If you would like to discuss our approach or experience in greater detail, please feel free to call
me at (920) 723-2169, or reach out via email at egranum@trilogy-llc.com.
Sincerely,
Erik Granum
Principal/Senior Consultant
TRILOGY CONSULTING, LLC
40
Wastewater Rate Study
Prepared for the
Rice Lake Utilities
by Trilogy Consulting, LLC
July 2026
41
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
Table of Contents
INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................................. 2
IMPETUS FOR STUDY..................................................................................................................................... 2
STUDY METHODOLOGY................................................................................................................................. 2
HISTORICAL AND FORECAST CUSTOMER DEMANDS .................................................................................... 3
Table 1 - Wastewater Treatment Plant Historical Flows & Loadings ........................................................ 4
Table 2 - Domestic Customer Projections ................................................................................................. 5
Table 3 - Industrial Surcharge Projections ................................................................................................ 5
Table 4 - Landfill Leachate Projections ..................................................................................................... 6
Table 5 - Hauled Waste Projections .......................................................................................................... 6
Table 6 - Projected 2026 Test Year Revenues at Present Rates – Domestic Strength Customers ........... 8
Table 7 - 2026 Projected Revenues at Present Rates - High Strength and Hauled Waste ....................... 9
HISTORICAL AND FORECAST EXPENSES ........................................................................................................ 9
Figure 1 - Historical Expenses and Revenues .......................................................................................... 10
CASH FLOW HISTORY AND PROJECTIONS ................................................................................................... 11
Table 8 - Projected Cash Flow under Recommended Rate Increases .................................................... 14
Figure 2 - Projected Cash Flow and Reserves under Recommended Rate Increases ............................. 15
Figure 3 – Projected Cash Flow and Reserves with Phase 1 Increase Only ............................................ 16
REVENUE REQUIREMENTS AND COST-OF-SERVICE ANALYSIS .................................................................... 16
Figure 4 - Breakdown of Revenue Requirements ................................................................................... 17
PROPOSED RATE SCHEDULE ....................................................................................................................... 18
Table 9 - Recommended Schedule of Rate Increases ............................................................................. 19
COMMUNITY RATE COMPARISON .............................................................................................................. 20
Table 10 – Peer Community Annual Bill Comparison - Average Residential Customer ......................... 21
RECOMMENDATION AND CONCLUSIONS ................................................................................................... 21
APPENDIX A: COST OF SERVICE STUDY AND RATE ANALYSIS .................................................................... 23
APPENDIX B: EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT FUND ANALYSIS DETAIL ........................................................... 35
42
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
2
INTRODUCTION
Rice Lake Utilities (RLU), the municipally -owned utilities division of the City of Rice Lake, owns
and operates a wastewater collection system and Wastewater Treatment Facility that provides
wastewater service to nearly 4,000 customers within the City, plus treatment of landfill leachate,
industrial waste, holding tank, septic tank , and grease trap waste. The industrial waste is
considered ‘high-strength’ wastewater, or wastewater with higher concentrations than normal
domestic sewage of constituents that the City is required to treat at its wastewater treatment
plant: organic pollutants (BOD), suspended solids (TSS), phosphorus and ammonia (NH-3).
RLU last conducted a full wastewater user rate study in 2010, with updates to the rates on an as
needed basis. Those increases were implemented to fund capital improvements and upgrades to
the wastewater treatment plant, and to fully fund its required equipment replacement fund.
IMPETUS FOR STUDY
The wastewater utility is experiencing a shift in customer demand, having recently lost one of its
industrial customers. With a wide range of customer types and use, and the length of time since
a formal rate study was undertaken, RLU hired Trilogy Consulting to conduct a formal
Wastewater Rate Study. The study consisted of determining recommended user rates based on
a detaile d cost of service study for 2026, and projecting future rate increases that will be
adequate to fulfill the wastewater utility’s operating and capital needs. A ten-year projection of
user rates and cash flows was then prepared to develop a plan to complete all necessary capital
improvement projects, avoid issuing debt for routine infrastructure replacement , and maintain
the financial health of the utility.
STUDY METHODOLOGY
The results of the study follow. The study is generally organized into three sections:
1. An analysis of historical conditions including historical revenues, expenses , and usage
statistics.
2. Projections for the next ten years, including wastewater usage, and future operating and
maintenance expenses. The analysis of the next ten fiscal years also takes into
consideration the City’s 5-year wastewater capital improvement needs, as well as
estimates of capital improvements for years 6-10 based on prior years’ investments.
3. Allocation of costs and detailed rate calculations.
43
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
3
The initial user rates were calculated based on a 2026 test year using a utility-based method. The
utility-based method calculates rates to recover the cost of operating and maintenance expenses,
administrative expenses, depreciation expenses and a return on net investment rate base (ROI),
which is a percentage return on utility assets. The ROI is set at a level such that it, along with the
depreciation expenses, recovers revenues sufficient to fund all annual capital outlay expenses
and adequate deposits into the utility’s equipment replacement fund.
HISTORICAL AND FORECAST CUSTOMER DEMANDS
Wastewater Treatment Plant Influent
The total volume of wastewater treated at the plant has generally been declining over the last 5
years. During that period, the peak inflow was 530 million gallons during 2023 and the lowest
was 467 million gallons during 2025. During a typical year for the wastewater utility,
approximately 65% of the volume is ‘billable’ waste, or wastewater generated by customers as
estimated by metered water use. The remaining 35% of the volume is clearwater infiltration and
inflow, water that seeps into the system via cracks in wastewater mains or customer service
laterals, or through sewer manholes. At certain times of year, such as periods of high
precipitation, infiltration and inflow (I/I) may be a higher volume of flow arriving at the treatment
plant. Levels of I/I can vary greatly for different utilities; other recent rate studies in the state
have found ranges of I/I of between 25% and 60%.
The amount of pollutant loadings has also fluctuated in the past 5 years, but appears to be rising
over time . The amount of BOD entering the treatment plant has steadily been rising , from
1,159,949 pounds in 2021 to 1,650,622 pounds in 2025. Total Suspended Solids (TSS) had been
relatively stable from 2021 to 2024, ranging between 1,383,722 and 1,451,963 pounds annually,
but spiked to 1,777,278 in 2025. Phosphorus remained relatively steady throughout the last 5
years, ranging from a low of 28,281 pounds in 2021 to a high of 32,931 pounds in 2022. Finally
ammonia has generally been in an increasing trend, from 190,789 pounds in 2021 to 232,280
pounds in 2025.
44
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
4
Table 1 - Wastewater Treatment Plant Historical Flows & Loadings
Customer Demand
The Wastewater Utility serves three general types of customers: domestic sewage customers
(residential, commercial, industrial , and public authority, i.e. government); high-strength
customers, consisting of certain industrial customers with higher concentrations of one or more
pollutant; and hauled waste. Table 1 shows the analysis of historical trends in the number of
customers, customer volume of wastewater and estimated loadings (BOD, TSS, phosphorus and
ammonia) for domestic strength customers, high -strength customers, and hauled holding tank
and septic waste.
Domestic Waste
Along with the volume of wastewater coming into the treatment plant, t he volume of domestic
strength waste has generally decli ned over the last three years. The estimates of pounds of
pollutant loadings for domestic strength waste are based on domestic strength assumptions
under the current ordinance: 290 mg/l for BOD, 250 mg/l for TSS, 8 mg/l for phosphorus, and 50
mg/l for ammonia.
2021 2022 2023 2024 2025
Wastewater Influent (gallons) 523,520,000 513,034,000 529,829,000 484,933,000 467,157,000
BOD (lbs) 1,158,949 1,361,943 1,439,271 1,351,568 1,650,622
Average Waste Strength (mg/l) 265 318 326 334 424
TSS (lbs) 1,383,722 1,451,963 1,437,999 1,420,707 1,777,278
Average Waste Strength (mg/l) 317 339 325 351 456
Phosphorus (lbs) 28,281 32,931 31,219 31,133 31,709
Average Waste Strength (mg/l) 6.5 7.7 7.1 7.7 8.1
Ammonia (lbs) 190,789 202,327 188,026 228,899 232,280
Average Waste Strength (mg/l) 44 47 43 57 60
45
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
5
Table 2 - Domestic Customer Projections
High Strength Waste
High strength waste volume has decreased recently due to the loss of one of the industrial
customers, but the amount of pollutant loadings from RLU’s remaining high -strength industrial
customer has been steady and remains a substantial proportion of the amount of BOD and TSS
entering the treatment plant. Table 3 shows the remaining industrial customer’s excess pollutant
surcharge contributions only, it does not take into account the industrial customer that has since
been discontinued.
Table 3 - Industrial Surcharge Projections
Landfill Leachate
The volume of leachate has been decreasing over the last several years, although the amount of
pollutant loadings has not necessarily decreased proportionately over the same time. BOD
2026
2023 2024 2025 Average Projections
Customer Demand
McCain Foods
Excess BOD (lbs.) 416,464 418,490 422,207 419,054 422,207
Excess TSS (lbs.) 194,368 180,555 195,147 190,023 195,147
Batter (gallons) 51,200 36,800 68,900 52,300 68,900
46
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
6
loadings have declined significantly more than volume , whereas ammonia has stayed relatively
proportional to volume and TSS has fluctuated.
Table 4 - Landfill Leachate Projections
Hauled Waste
RLU has experienced an increase in total volume from waste haulers in the past three years.
Table 5 - Hauled Waste Projections
2026
2023 2024 2025 Average Projections
Customer Demand
Landfill Leachate
Flow (gallons) 16,331,580 13,749,029 12,314,803 14,131,804 12,314,803
Excess BOD (lbs.) 101,888 23,422 15,175 46,828 15,175
Excess TSS (lbs.) 2,274 2,727 7,889 4,297 7,889
Excess Ammonia (lbs.) 122,593 116,031 103,899 114,174 103,899
47
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
7
Forecast Revenues at Present Rates
Table 6 shows the forecast revenues at present rates for 2026, based on the forecast number of
customers, volume of sewer usage , hauled waste, and excess pollutant loadings from high
strength customers. RLU currently charges the following user charges:
• Sewer Usage Charge of $ 3.08 per 1,000 gallons of domestic strength wastewater
(estimated based on metered water use) for all users located within the City, and $4.32
per 1,000 gallons for users located outside of the City;
• Flat Charge of $4.40 per month for customers located in the City and $6.16 per month for
customers located outside of the City;
• Surcharges for pollutant loadings more than domestic strength waste for certain
industrial customers located within the City , charged as a rate per pound (there is
currently one customer classified as industrial high-strength);
• Leachate waste based on the amount of flows and total loadings hauled into the
wastewater treatment plant;
• Hauled in waste which is measured and sampled daily and charged based on the amount
of flows and total loadings hauled into the wastewater treatment plant;
• Hauler Charges, which include variable charges per 1,000 gallons for holding tank waste,
septage, grease trap waste, and portable toilets.
Forecast user charge revenues of $1,919,676 are similar, but slightly lower than 2025 user charge
revenues of $2,048,721. Much of this is due to the loss of an additional high-strength industrial
customers beginning in 2026.
48
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
8
Table 6 - Projected 2026 Test Year Revenues at Present Rates – Domestic Strength Customers
49
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
9
Table 7 - 2026 Projected Revenues at Present Rates - High Strength and Hauled Waste
HISTORICAL AND FORECAST EXPENSES
Operation & Maintenance Expenses
During the period 2021 through 2025, operation and maintenance (O&M) expenses fluctuated
year by year, but generally stayed relatively steady, with a total increase of 1.4% over the 5-year
period. The 2026 budgeted expenses are at a similar level to the previous 5 years. O&M expenses
are assumed to increase in the future at a rate of 2 percent annually from inflation, a slightly
higher rate than the utility has experienced in recent years, but a conservative rate compared to
average rates of inflation.
McCain Units Rates Revenues
BOD 422,207 $0.2630 $111,040 $111,040
TSS 195,147 $0.3064 $59,793 $59,793
Phophorus - $3.8786 $0 $0
NH-3 - $1.2097 $0 $0
Batter 68,900 $157.60 $10,859 $10,859
Subtotal $181,692 $181,692
Landfill Leachate Units Rates Revenues
Flow 12,314,803 $4.3120 $53,101 $53,101
BOD 15,175 $0.3682 $5,587 $5,587
TSS 7,889 $0.4290 $3,384 $3,384
Phophorus $5.4300 $0 $0
Ammonia 103,899 $1.6937 $175,974 $175,974
Lab Testing $12,091 $12,091
Subtotal $250,138 $250,138
Foremost Farms Units Rates Revenues
Flow 1,151,497 $4.3120 $4,965 $4,965
BOD 227,245 $0.3682 $83,672 $83,672
TSS 82,788 $0.4290 $35,516 $35,516
Phophorus 3,986 $5.4300 $21,645 $21,645
Ammonia - $1.6937 $0 $0
Lab Testing $5,166 $5,166
Subtotal $150,964 $150,964
Hauled Waste Units Rates Revenues
Septic Tank (1,000 gallons) 3,794 $38.10 $144,559 $144,559
Holding Tank (1,000 gallons) 15,907 $6.41 $101,966 $101,966
Grease Trap (1,000 gallons)
In-City 80 $157.60 $12,537 $12,537
Portable Toilets (1,000 gallons) 158 $91.44 $14,413 $14,413
Subtotal $273,476 $273,476
Total $1,919,676
50
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
10
Capital Improvements
During the period 2021 through 2025, the amount invested in capital improvements averaged
about $879,000 per year. Most of this investment was able to financed through annual revenues
or was contributed by developers, with the remaining funded from utility reserves. Utility-funded
capital spending averaged $711,000 annually during this period. The 2026 through 2030 capital
improvement plan includes slightly more annual utility investment, averaging about $ 907,000
per year. Assuming no debt will be issued for this routine capital outlay, it will also need to be
funded through a combination of annual revenues and utility reserves.
Figure 1 below shows the combined O&M expenses and capital outlay compared to annual
revenues. As the chart shows, the utility has generally been bringing in enough revenue to fully
fund its annual O&M and capital needs through cash received, although with the drop in
revenues in 2025, the utility did need to rely on its cash reserves to fund its capital investment.
As discussed in the previous section, this lower level of revenues is expected to continue without
an increase in user rates.
Figure 1 - Historical Expenses and Revenues
0
00,000
1,000,000
1, 00,000
,000,000
, 00,000
,000,000
0 1 0 0 0 0
xpenses U lity unded Capital mprovements Revenues
51
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
11
CASH FLOW HISTORY AND PROJECTIONS
To estimate the overall level of immediate and future rate increases, a ten-year cash flow forecast
was prepared. Several cash flow forecasts were tested for various scenarios of financing for the
utility’s capital improvement program and level and timing of immediate and future rate
increases. Each forecast was evaluated relative to the following criteria:
• Monitoring cash flow – cash flow may fluctuate from year to year, and it is not necessary
to generate positive cash flow every year, but the rates should be sufficient to generate
positive cash flow if the utility reserves need to be increased or mini mize negative cash
flows if the utility has sufficient reserves.
• Providing sufficient debt covera ge for any outstanding revenue debt – revenue debt is
backed by a pledge of utility revenues. Revenue bonds usually require that the utility
maintain net revenues (revenues minus operation and maintenance expenses) that are
equal to the total annual payments on revenue debt plus a coverage factor of 10 to 25
percent. Currently, the sewer does not have any debt, but if any debt is projected in future
years, debt coverage would be evaluated.
• Avoiding or mitigating the need for issuance of new debt for routine wastewater main
and equipment replacement – most utilities issue debt from time to time to fund major
capital projects, and sometimes to fund more routine ongoing replacement and renewal
projects if current revenues or reserves funds are insufficient. Issuing debt for major,
infrequent projects provides a means of spreading the costs of the project over a longer
period rather than requiring current customers to pay the entire cost. At this time, no
major project that would require debt financing is included in the cash flow forecast.
• Maintaining the utility’s reserves at recommended levels – it is important for utilities to
maintain sufficient cash reserves to manage cash flow fluctuations throughout the year,
to absorb unexpected fluctuations in operating revenues or expenses, to fund unexpected
capital costs to rehabilitate or replace infrastructure that wears out faster than expected,
or to cash finance planned capital improvements. RLU currently maintains an equipment
replacement fund for routine capital equipment replacement.
• Rate of return on utility assets – the rate of return is the net operating income of the
utility as a percentage of the utility’s investment in infrastructure, net of accumulated
depreciation. For most utilities a very low rate of return may indicate that either the utility
is not generating sufficient revenues to fund reinvestment in its infrastructure or that the
utility has very low debt service payments and does not need to generate much of a return
on investment. A high rate of return may indicate that the utility is generating excess
revenues or that it is highly leveraged with debt financing and requires a high rate of
return.
52
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
12
• Percentage of debt vs. equity – As with the rate of return, the appropriate percentage of
debt financing depends on the specific conditions of the utility system. A very new system
or one that has recently invested significantly in its infrastructure may have a relatively
higher percentage of debt financing. On the other hand, an older utility system that has
deferred infrastructure replacements or has undertaken replacements on an incremental
basis with cash financing will probably have a very low percentage of debt. If a utility has
a percentage of debt financing that is more than 50 percent and the level of debt financing
is increasing, steps should be taken to reduce the reliance on debt financing over time. If
a utility has a lower percentage of debt financing and has the resources to cash finance a
sufficient program of infrastructure renewal and replacement, there is no need to
increase its reliance on debt financing, as this will only add to its capital costs.
Utility Financial Status / Historical Cash Flow
Key findings and recommendations regarding the utility’s financial condition are as follows:
• The utility has usually had positive cash flow in recent years, with all capital improvements
funded through annual revenues and utility cash reserves.
• Currently, the utility is carrying no debt and has not in the last five years.
• While the utility has been carrying healthy reserves, most reserves have been held in a
restricted Equipment Replacement Fund (ERF) that is restricted to use for equipment
replacement only. A detailed analysis of the equipment replacement fund was performed
and it was determined that a large share of these reserves could transferred out of the
ERF and into unrestricted funds and made available for other utility purposes.
• Unrestricted reserves have fluctuated but have been positive overall.
• In 2025, the utility’s rate of return (net operating income divided by net utility plant) was
approximately negative-3 %. This may indicate that the utility is not generating enough
revenues to fully fund its annual capital needs, although since the utility is not carr ying
any debt, a negative operating income is not necessarily surprising.
The biggest finding related to the utility’s current financial status is the recent drop in revenues
due to the loss of a large customer. This drop in revenues is the largest factor in projecting future
cash flows and determining the appropriate increase in rates needed to fully fund the utility’s
annual needs and maintain financially health into the future.
Projected Cash Flow
Cash flow projections were based on the following common assumptions:
53
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
13
• No change in future customer demand after 2026 (number of customers, sewage volume,
high strength ‘excess’ loadings, etc.);
• Inflation of two percent per year in operation and maintenance expenses;
• Continuation of a similar level of other operating revenues at historical levels;
• Completion of all the projects listed in the utility’s capital improvement plan for 2026-
2030;
• No future issuances of debt, as there are no major projects contained in the capital
improvement plan;
• Recommended reserve levels include the following:
o Operating reserve equal to 4 months of annual operating expenses;
o Equipment replacement fund (ERF) re-set to a lower level based on an itemized list
of assets and a re-calculated annual amount to be transferred from utility revenues
to the ERF, as shown in Appendix A and per Wisconsin DNR rules; it is recommended
that the excess cash in the ERF be transferred to unrestricted reserves;
o Depreciation/Capital reserve equal to one year’s planned capital outlay for utility
assets not covered by the equipment replacement fund (mains, structures, etc.).
The utility has planned capital improvements totaling about $4.5 million, or an average of about
$907,000 per year, planned for the period 2026-2030, consisting of the following projects:
• Annual collection main renewal and replacements: $2.0 million;
• Lift station upgrades and replacements, as needed: $755,000;
• Treatment plant equipment upgrades and replacements: $1.23 million;
• Vehicles and other equipment: $560,000.
Following evaluation of various alternative rate scenarios, one alternative was selected for
recommendation. This scenario, shown in Table 8, would increase rates in two phases at the
beginning of 2027 and 2029, with annual inflationary increases as needed beyond that.
Increases in user charge revenues of approximately 17.6% in 2027, 15.3% in 202 9, and
inflationary increases as needed thereafter are recommended to generate sufficient revenues to
fund the capital improvement program and maintain cash reserves at the recommended level.
As investment in utility plant increases, so will the recommended level of reserves.
The recommended plan, shown in Table 8, would not require any new debt . Figure 2 shows
graphically the projected cash flows and reserve levels. As shown, with the recommended rate
increases, the utility is still projected to draw down the current reserve levels to the
recommended minimum levels and then maintain reserves at or slightly above the recommended
levels.
54
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
14
Table 8 - Projected Cash Flow under Recommended Rate Increases
55
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
15
Figure 2 - Projected Cash Flow and Reserves under Recommended Rate Increases
Figure 3 shows the projected cash flows and reserve levels if only the first phase of the rate
increase is approved, with no future increases. As the graph shows, regardless of whether or not
both phases of the recommended rate increase are approved at this time, sewer rates will need
to be re-assessed and increased to some degree for 2029 and beyond, as reserves are projected
to continue to be depleted at a rapid pace.
( ,000,000)
( 1,000,000)
0
1,000,000
,000,000
,000,000
,000,000
,000,000
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
rojected Cash low and Reserve Levels Recommended Rates
otal Cash n otal Cash ut et Cash low
otal Reserves Recommended Reserve Unrestricted Reserves
56
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
16
Figure 3 – Projected Cash Flow and Reserves with Phase 1 Increase Only
It should be noted that these future projections of cash flow are for planning purposes only. RLU
should continue to assess the financial, physical, and operational conditions of the utility on an
annual basis to respond to changing conditions and make decisions regarding which capital
improvement projects to undertake, how those projects should be financed and the appropriate
rate increase that may be needed to meet the revenue requirements of the utility.
REVENUE REQUIREMENTS AND COST-OF-SERVICE ANALYSIS
The tables attached to this report as an appendix summarize the cost-of-service analysis, which
allocates the utility’s revenue requirements first to utility functions and then to each customer
class, the rate calculations, and the estimated revenues at the proposed rates . Utility revenue
requirements include operation and maintenance expenses, depreciation expense, and a return
on investment. Figure 4 shows the breakdown of the revenue requirements by type of expense.
Operation and maintenance expenses comprise the biggest portion, about 67 percent of total
( ,000,000)
( 1,000,000)
0
1,000,000
,000,000
,000,000
,000,000
,000,000
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0
rojected Cash low and Reserve Levels hase 1 nly
otal Cash n otal Cash ut et Cash low
otal Reserves Recommended Reserve Unrestricted Reserves
57
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
17
expenses. With the recommended increases, the utility’s current negative operating income
would reverse to a positive income over time, as the rate increases are implemented.
Figure 4 - Breakdown of Revenue Requirements
Costs were first allocated to the functions served by the utility. Under this method, each of the
utility’s costs is split between costs to provide collection sewer, wastewater treatment for
average daily volume, costs to treat pollutant loadings (BOD, TSS, phosphorus and ammonia),
and customer costs that are relatively fixed per customer or meter.
Costs were then allocated to each customer class (residential, multi -family, commercial,
industrial, public authority, high strength industrial, landfill leachate, and all other hauled waste)
based on the demand characteristics of each customer class. A portion of the conveyance system
and average day flow costs were allocated to infiltration and inflow (I/I) based on forecast
percentage of I/I on an average day basis. Costs allocated to I/I are proposed to be largely
recovered through the flat charge, as the amount of I/I in the system is related more closely to
the number of customers, size of sewer laterals and feet of sewer main rather than the volume
of wastewater generated by each customer.
pera on and aintenance Deprecia on xpense Return on nvestment
58
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
18
PROPOSED RATE SCHEDULE
The projected overall increase in user charge re venues over the 10-year period from 2027 to
2034 is approximately 51.7 percent, recommended to be implemented in two main increases in
2027 and 2029 , followed by small inflationary increases as needed . Rate increases for specific
types of charges vary from the overall rate increase, as shown in the following detailed schedule
of proposed rate increases for 2027-2029.
59
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
19
Table 9 - Recommended Schedule of Rate Increases
Flat Charge
Connection Size
Current
Charge
Proposed
Charge - 2027
Percent
Change
Proposed
Charge - 2028
Percent
Change
Proposed
Charge - 2029
Percent
Change
5/8 $4.40 $5.41 23% $5.41 0% $6.50 20%
3/4 $4.40 $5.41 23% $5.41 0% $6.50 20%
1 $4.40 $5.41 23% $5.41 0% $6.50 20%
1 1/4 $4.40 $8.06 83% $8.06 0% $12.00 49%
1 1/2 $4.40 $8.06 83% $8.06 0% $12.00 49%
2 $4.40 $8.06 83% $8.06 0% $12.00 49%
3 $4.40 $8.06 83% $8.06 0% $12.00 49%
4 $4.40 $8.06 83% $8.06 0% $12.00 49%
6 $4.40 $8.06 83% $8.06 0% $12.00 49%
8 $4.40 $8.06 83% $8.06 0% $12.00 49%
Special $4.40 $5.41 23% $5.41 0% $6.50 20%
Pit $4.40 $5.41 23% $5.41 0% $6.50 20%
Unmetered $4.40 $5.41 23% $5.41 0% $6.50 20%
Unmetered CR $4.40 $5.41 23% $5.41 0% $6.50 20%
Meter Only $4.40 $5.41 23% $5.41 0% $6.50 20%
Flat $13.64 $15.74 15% $15.74 0% $17.99 14%
Outside-City $6.16 $7.57 23% $7.57 0% $9.10 20%
Units
Proposed
Rate - 2027
Percent
Chage
Proposed
Rate - 2028
Percent
Change
Proposed
Rate - 2029
Percent
Change
Usage Charge $/1,000 gallons $3.08 $3.46 12% $3.46 0% $3.83 11%
Holding Tank Waste $/1,000 gallons $6.41 $7.51 17% $7.51 0% $8.61 15%
Septic Tank Waste $/1,000 gallons $38.10 $51.99 36% $51.99 0% $67.86 31%
Grease Trap Waste $/1,000 gallons $157.60 $236.00 50% $236.00 0% $325.59 38%
Portable Toilets $/1,000 gallons $91.44 $113.72 24% $113.72 0% $136.00 20%
High-Strength Surcharges - In-City
Pollutant Units
Current
Charge
Proposed
Rate - 2027
Percent
Change
Proposed
Rate - 2028
Percent
Change
Proposed
Rate - 2029
Percent
Change
BOD $/lb. $0.263 $0.293 11% $0.293 0% $0.322 10%
TSS $/lb. $0.306 $0.380 24% $0.380 0% $0.454 19%
P $/lb. $3.879 $7.212 86% $7.212 0% $9.940 38%
Ammonia $/lb. $1.210 $1.356 12% $1.356 0% $1.525 12%
High-Strength Surcharges - Outside-City
Pollutant Units
Current
Charge
Proposed
Rate - 2027
Percent
Change
Proposed
Rate - 2028
Percent
Change
Proposed
Rate - 2029
Percent
Change
BOD $/lb. $0.368 $0.410 11% $0.410 0% $0.451 10%
TSS $/lb. $0.429 $0.532 24% $0.532 0% $0.636 20%
P $/lb. $5.430 $10.097 86% $10.097 0% $13.916 38%
Ammonia $/lb. $1.694 $1.898 12% $1.898 0% $2.135 12%
Lab Testing
Units
Current
Charge
Proposed
Rate - 2027
Percent
Change
Proposed
Rate - 2028
Percent
Change
Proposed
Rate - 2029
Percent
Change
BOD/COD $/Sample $10.60 $11.80 11% $11.80 0% $13.00 10%
TSS $/Sample $4.65 $5.80 25% $5.80 0% $6.90 19%
Phosphorus $/Sample $13.00 $23.20 78% $23.20 0% $33.30 44%
Ammonia $/Sample $13.50 $15.30 13% $15.30 0% $17.00 11%
pH $/Sample $2.25 $2.60 16% $2.60 0% $3.00 15%
Chlorides $/Sample $12.00 $14.10 18% $14.10 0% $16.30 16%
60
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
20
COMMUNITY RATE COMPARISON
To provide context for the proposed rates within Rice Lake, a comparison with the sewer user
rates charged by peer Wisconsin communities was prepared. The basis of the charges, and the
estimated total annual bill for a residential customer for each community are shown in the
following tables. As shown, for a customer using 36,000 gallons or 4,813 cubic feet of water per
year, the estimated annual bill under current RLU rates would be $ 163.68 per year. Under the
proposed rate increase for 2027, this would increase to $189.48, and to $215.88 for 2029. Several
other communities have also approved rate increases beyond 2026 as noted in the table.
61
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
21
Table 10 – Peer Community Annual Bill Comparison - Average Residential Customer
RECOMMENDATION AND CONCLUSIONS
It is recommended that RLU adopt the schedule of rate increases as shown in Table 9. This will
allow the Wastewater Utility to phase in the rate increase needed to provide adequate funding
for the utility’s capital improvement program while mitigating the increase and maintaining the
62
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
22
utility’s reserve funds at or above recommended levels. Rates should be re-evaluated in 2030 to
be sure that the projections used in this study are on track, and that rates continue to reflect the
cost-of-service analysis. Alternatively, RLU could adopt the rate schedule for 202 7 only and
perform an additional review each year to assess the wastewater utility’s trajectory remains on
a healthy financial trajectory.
63
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
23
APPENDIX A: COST OF SERVICE STUDY AND RATE ANALYSIS
64
System Demand and Allocation Methods
Allocation Allocation Allocation Allocation Allocation Allocation Allocation Allocation Allocation
Method 1 Method 2 Method 3 Method 4 Method 5 Method 6 Method 7 Method 8 Method 9
Flow Share 100.00% 20.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 0.00% 50.00%
Treatment Share 0.00% 80.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 50.00%
BOD 0.00% 20.00% 0.00% 25.00% 30.00% 50.00% 0.00% 40.00% 0.00%
TSS 0.00% 20.00% 100.00% 25.00% 30.00% 40.00% 0.00% 40.00% 50.00%
P 0.00% 20.00% 0.00% 10.00% 15.00% 5.00% 100.00% 5.00% 0.00%
Ammonia 0.00% 20.00% 0.00% 40.00% 25.00% 5.00% 0.00% 15.00% 0.00%
Total 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00% 100.00%
65
Allocation of Operation and Maintenance Expenses to Service Cost Functions
CONVEYANCE
Alloc
No. Account Description 2026 Budget
Customer
Flow
Inflow /
Infiltration Average Peak BOD TSS P Ammonia Billing
Equivalent
Meter
($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
WWTP OPERATION EXPENSES
WORK ORDERS - NEW CONSTRUCTION 0
4 OPERATING POWER & PUMP EQUIPME 110,000 0 0 27,500 27,500 11,000 44,000
1 OBSERVING & RECORDING FLOW 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Propor. OPERATING PURIFICATION EQUIPME 50,000 2,723 0 11,991 13,297 9,881 12,108
3 CLEANING TANKS, F BEDS ETC 13,125 0 0 0 13,125 0 0
5 LABORATORY & ANALYSIS WORK 128,913 0 0 38,674 38,674 19,337 32,228
8 SLUDGE DISPOSAL 30,986 0 0 12,394 12,394 1,549 4,648
2 POWER & FUEL FOR PUMPING 35,547 7,109 0 7,109 7,109 7,109 7,109
4 POWER & FUEL FOR AERATION EQUI 67,295 0 0 16,824 16,824 6,730 26,918
1 CHLORINE 20,248 20,248 0 0 0 0 0
7 PHOSPHORUS REMOVAL CHEMICALS 51,300 0 0 0 0 51,300 0
8 SLUDGE CONDITIONING CHEMICALS 44,906 0 0 17,962 17,962 2,245 6,736
8 OTHER CHEM FOR SLUDGE TREATMEN 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Propor. OTHER OPERATING SUPPLIES, EXP 44,759 2,438 0 10,734 11,903 8,845 10,839
Propor. TRANPORTATION EXPENSE 22,050 1,201 0 5,288 5,864 4,358 5,340
Propor. RENTS 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
WWTP MAINTENANCE EXPENSES
Conv MTSE SEWER COLL SYSTEM 104,325 67,882 36,443
Conv MTSE COLL SYSTEM PUMP EQUIPMEN 11,768 7,657 4,111
Propor. MTSE TREATMENT & DISP PLANT EQ 83,761 4,562 0 20,087 22,276 16,553 20,283
Propor. MTSE GEN PLANT STRUC & EQUIP 54,953 2,993 0 13,179 14,614 10,860 13,307
CUSTOMER ACCOUNTING EXPENSES
Cust SUPERVISION 34,045 34,045
Cust METER READING EXPENSES 63,000 63,000
Propor. CUSTOMER RECORDS & COLL EXP 194,139 34,467 38,223 28,403 34,804 58,242
Cust UNCOLLECTIBLE ACCOUNTS 3,000 3,000
1,168,120 75,539 40,554 41,274 0 216,209 239,766 178,171 218,319 100,045 58,242
Subtotal for allocation of G & A expenses 873,936 75,539 40,554 41,274 0 181,742 201,544 149,768 183,516 0 0
PERCENTAGE 8.64% 4.64% 4.72% 0.00% 20.80% 23.06% 17.14% 21.00% 0.00% 0.00%
GENERAL AND ADMINISTRATIVE EXPENSES
Gen ADMIN & GENERAL SALARIES 168,032 14,524 7,797 7,936 0 34,944 38,751 28,796 35,285 0 0
Gen OFFICE SUPPLIES & EXPENSE 32,411 2,801 1,504 1,531 0 6,740 7,474 5,554 6,806 0 0
Gen OUTSIDE SERVICES EMPLOYED 9,029 780 419 426 0 1,878 2,082 1,547 1,896 0 0
T. Plant PROPERTY INSURANCE 37,692 3,258 1,749 1,780 0 7,838 8,692 6,459 7,915 0 0
Gen INJURIES & DAMAGES 24,946 2,156 1,158 1,178 0 5,188 5,753 4,275 5,238 0 0
Gen EMPLOYEE PENSION & BENEFITS 261,326 22,588 12,127 12,342 0 54,345 60,266 44,784 54,875 0 0
1 WRS PENSION EXPENSE 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Gen 1 LRLIF 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Gen REGULATORY COMMISSION EXP 15,572 1,346 723 735 0 3,238 3,591 2,669 3,270 0 0
Gen MISC. GENERAL EXPENSES 36,260 3,134 1,683 1,712 0 7,541 8,362 6,214 7,614 0 0
Gen RENTS 37,044 3,202 1,719 1,749 0 7,704 8,543 6,348 7,779 0 0
622,312 53,790 28,878 29,390 0 129,415 143,515 106,647 130,678 0 0
1,790,432 129,328 69,432 70,664 0 345,624 383,281 284,818 348,997 100,045 58,242
CUSTOMER COSTS
TOTAL
TREATMENT PLANT
FLOW WASTE TREATMENT
66
Allocation of Plant to Service Cost Functions
CONVEYANCE
Alloc
No. Account Description EOY 2024
Customer
Flow
Inflow /
Infiltration Average Peak BOD TSS P NH3 Billing
Equivalent
Meter
($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
COLLECTION SYSTEM
C/I Collct Sys Lnd Right 6,020 3,917 2,103
C/I Coll Sys Struc & Imprv 396,281 257,850 138,431
Meter Serv Conn &Traps 1,094,783 1,094,783
C/I Coll Mains & Access 6,705,529 4,363,113 2,342,416
C/I Force mains 297,071 193,296 103,775
SYSTEM PUMPING
C/I Receiving Wells 133,187 86,661 46,526
C/I Elec Pumping Equip 689,622 448,719 240,903
TREATMENT AND DISPOSAL PLANT
Prop. Disposal Land & Land Rights 164,988 17,469 0 46,614 54,185 13,286 33,434
Prop. T Disp Struct & Improv 4,211,132 445,884 0 1,189,764 1,383,016 339,107 853,360
9 Prelim Treat Equip 752,785 376,392 0 0 376,392 0 0
2 Primary Treat Equip 599,273 119,855 0 119,855 119,855 119,855 119,855
4 Secondary Treat Equip 2,054,209 0 0 513,552 513,552 205,421 821,683
1 Chlorination Equip 58,927 58,927 0 0 0 0 0
8 Sludge Disp Equip 3,292,992 0 0 1,317,197 1,317,197 164,650 493,949
8 Plant Site Pumping 560,353 0 0 224,141 224,141 28,018 84,053
1 Flow Monitor Equip 101,353 101,353 0 0 0 0 0
1 Outfall Sewer Pipes 69,382 69,382 0 0 0 0 0
2 Other Treat/Disp Eq 712,641 142,528 0 142,528 142,528 142,528 142,528
Prop. Other Plant Equip 21,307 2,256 0 6,020 6,997 1,716 4,318
SUBTOTAL 21,921,834 5,353,557 2,874,154 1,334,046 0 3,559,670 4,137,864 1,014,580 2,553,180 0 1,094,783
PERCENTAGE 24.42% 13.11% 6.09% 0.00% 16.24% 18.88% 4.63% 11.65% 0.00% 4.99%
GENERAL PLANT
Gen Utility Plant Structures in service 290,239 70,879 38,053 17,662 0 47,129 54,784 13,433 33,803 0 14,495
Gen Office Furn & Equip 21,413 5,229 2,807 1,303 0 3,477 4,042 991 2,494 0 1,069
Gen Transportation Equip 895,888 218,786 117,459 54,519 0 145,474 169,104 41,463 104,342 0 44,741
Gen Power Oper Equip 63,621 15,537 8,341 3,872 0 10,331 12,009 2,944 7,410 0 3,177
Gen Computers/Software 11,385 2,780 1,493 693 0 1,849 2,149 527 1,326 0 569
Gen Communication Equip 154,156 37,647 20,211 9,381 0 25,032 29,098 7,135 17,954 0 7,699
Gen Other General Plant 93,531 22,841 12,263 5,692 0 15,188 17,655 4,329 10,893 0 4,671
1,530,233 373,700 200,628 93,122 0 248,479 288,840 70,822 178,222 0 76,420
23,452,067 5,727,257 3,074,781 1,427,168 0 3,808,150 4,426,704 1,085,402 2,731,402 0 1,171,203
TREATMENT PLANT
FLOW WASTE TREATMENT CUSTOMER COSTS
67
Allocation of Depreciation Expense to Service Cost Functions
CONVEYANCE
Alloc
No. Account Description
2026 Test
Year
Customer
Flow
Inflow /
Infiltration Average Peak BOD TSS P NH3 Billing
Equivalent
Meter
($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
COLLECTION SYSTEM
C/I Collct Sys Lnd Right 0 0 0
C/I Coll Sys Struc & Imprv 9,907 6,446 3,461
Meter Serv Conn &Traps 19,899 19,899
C/I Coll Mains & Access 65,608 42,690 22,919
C/I Force mains 2,971 1,933 1,038
SYSTEM PUMPING
C/I Receiving Wells 5,327 3,466 1,861
C/I Elec Pumping Equip 26,648 17,339 9,309
TREATMENT AND DISPOSAL PLANT
Prop. Disposal Land & Land Rights 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Prop. T Disp Struct & Improv 105,278 9,590 0 30,336 34,652 8,607 22,092
9 Prelim Treat Equip 25,068 12,534 0 0 12,534 0 0
2 Primary Treat Equip 23,971 4,794 0 4,794 4,794 4,794 4,794
4 Secondary Treat Equip 82,168 0 0 20,542 20,542 8,217 32,867
1 Chlorination Equip 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
8 Sludge Disp Equip 131,034 0 0 52,414 52,414 6,552 19,655
8 Plant Site Pumping 14,009 0 0 5,604 5,604 700 2,101
1 Flow Monitor Equip 4,054 4,054 0 0 0 0 0
1 Outfall Sewer Pipes 1,735 1,735 0 0 0 0 0
2 Other Treat/Disp Eq 23,648 4,730 0 4,730 4,730 4,730 4,730
Prop. Other Plant Equip 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
SUBTOTAL 541,325 71,875 38,587 37,437 0 118,419 135,269 33,600 86,240 0 19,899
PERCENTAGE 13.28% 7.13% 6.92% 0.00% 21.88% 24.99% 6.21% 15.93% 0.00% 3.68%
GENERAL PLANT
Gen Utility Plant Structures in service 8,417 1,118 600 582 0 1,841 2,103 522 1,341 0 309
Gen Office Furn & Equip 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Gen Transportation Equip 82,013 10,889 5,846 5,672 0 17,941 20,494 5,091 13,066 0 3,015
Gen Power Oper Equip 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Gen Computers/Software 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Gen Communication Equip 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Gen Other General Plant 1,708 227 122 118 0 374 427 106 272 0 63
SUBTOTAL 92,138 12,234 6,568 6,372 0 20,156 23,024 5,719 14,679 0 3,387
TOTAL 633,463 84,108 45,155 43,809 0 138,575 158,293 39,319 100,919 0 23,285
TREATMENT PLANT
FLOW WASTE TREATMENT CUSTOMER COSTS
68
Summary of Allocation of Operating Costs to Service Cost Functions
Overall Rate of Return 1.83%
Net Investment Rate Base 13,105,668
CONVEYANCE
Operating Cost Total
Collection
System
Interceptor
System Average Peak BOD TSS P NH3 Billing
Equivalent
Meter
($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
Operation and Maintenance 1,790,432 129,328 69,432 70,664 0 345,624 383,281 284,818 348,997 100,045 58,242
Depreciation Expense 633,463 84,108 45,155 43,809 0 138,575 158,293 39,319 100,919 0 23,285
Return on Investment 239,347 58,451 31,381 14,565 0 38,865 45,178 11,077 27,876 0 11,953
Total 2,663,242 271,888 145,968 129,038 0 523,064 586,753 335,215 477,792 100,045 93,480
CUSTOMER COSTS
TREATMENT PLANT
FLOW WASTE TREATMENT
69
Customer Class Demand Ratios
Billing Units - 1,000 Gallons
Customer Class
Annual
Volume
Average Day
Volume
System
Percent
(%)
Collection
Percent
(%)
Waste
Strength
(mg/l)
Loadings
(lbs)
Percent
(%)
Waste
Strength
(mg/l)
Loadings
(lbs)
Percent
(%)
Waste
Strength
(mg/l)
Loadings
(lbs)
Percent
(%)
Waste
Strength
(mg/l)
Loadings
(lbs)
Percent
(%)
Residential 116,420 318,958 24.82% 26.73% 290 281,573 18.99% 250 242,735 20.14% 8.0 7,768 26.29% 50.0 48,547 20.58%
Commercial 101,837 279,005 21.71% 23.38% 290 246,302 16.61% 250 212,330 17.62% 8.0 6,795 23.00% 50.0 42,466 18.00%
Industrial 44,064 120,723 9.40% 10.12% 290 106,573 7.19% 250 91,873 7.62% 8.0 2,940 9.95% 50.0 18,375 7.79%
Public Authority 9,771 26,770 2.08% 2.24% 290 23,632 1.59% 250 20,373 1.69% 8.0 652 2.21% 50.0 4,075 1.73%
Interdepartmental 81 222 0.02% 0.02% 290 196 0.01% 250 169 0.01% 8 5 0.02% 50.0 34 0.01%
High-Strength Surcharges - - 0.00% 0.00% 422,207 28.47% 195,147 16.19% - 0.00% - 0.00%
Septic Tank Haulers 3,794 10,395 0.81% 0.00% 2,089 66,104 4.46% 7,651 242,106 20.09% 100.0 3,164 10.71% 90.0 2,848 1.21%
Holding Tank Haulers 15,907 43,582 3.39% 0.00% 263 34,892 2.35% 361 47,893 3.97% 25.0 3,317 11.23% 75.0 9,950 4.22%
Grease Traps 80 219 0.02% 0.00% 29,660 19,789 1.33% 35,008 23,357 1.94% 8.0 5 0.02% 50.0 33 0.01%
Portable Toilets 158 433 0.03% 0.00% 7,066 9,311 0.63% 18,288 24,098 2.00% 8.0 11 0.04% 50.0 66 0.03%
Landfill Leachate 12,315 33,740 2.63% 0.00% 400 41,156 2.78% 193 19,793 1.64% 8.0 822 2.78% 1,061.0 109,034 46.22%
Foremost Farms 1,151 3,153 0.25% 0.00% 24,072 231,214 15.59% 8,901 85,496 7.09% 423.0 4,063 13.75% 50.0 480 0.20%
Inflow / Infiltration 163,437 447,772 34.85% 37.52% - - 0.00% - - 0.00% - - 0.00% - - 0.00%
Total 469,015 1,284,972 100.0% 100.0% 1,482,948 100.0% 1,205,371 100.0% 29,541 100.0% 235,908 100.0%
BASE DEMAND TREATMENT CATEGORIES
BOD TSS Phosphorus Ammonia
70
Consumer Costs Allocation Factors
Number of Meters
Customer Class 5/8 3/4 1 1 1/2 2 3 4 Special Unmetered
Unmetered
CR
Meter
Only Flat
Outside-
City
Total
Meters
Percent
Total
Residential 3,314 64 4 - - - - - - - 3 2 40 3,427 83.09%
Commercial 330 42 114 54 61 11 4 3 1 1 - 1 1 622 15.09%
Industrial 5 2 7 3 7 2 - 1 - - - - - 27 0.65%
Public Authority 5 6 9 - 15 7 3 - - - - - - 45 1.10%
Interdepartmental 1 - - - 2 - - - - - - - - 3 0.07%
Total 3,654 114 134 57 85 20 7 4 1 1 3 3 41 4,124
Equivalent Meters
Allocation factor: Total
Meter Size (Inches): 5/8 3/4 1 1 1/2 2 3 4 Special Unmetered
Unmetered
CR
Meter
Only Flat
Outside-
City Equiv. Percent
Equiv. Meters Ratio: 1 1.0 2.5 5 8 15 25 1 1 1 1 1 1 Meters Total
Customer Class
Residential 3,314 64 11 - - - - - - - 3 2 40 3,433 61.29%
Commercial 330 42 285 272 485 166 100 3 1 1 - 1 1 1,686 30.09%
Industrial 5 2 18 15 56 30 - 1 - - - - - 126 2.26%
Public Authority 5 6 23 - 121 110 75 - - - - - - 339 6.06%
Interdepartmental 1 - - - 16 - - - - - - - - 17 0.30%
Total 3,654 114 335 287 677 306 175 4 1 1 3 3 41 5,601 100.00%
71
Allocation of Service Cost Functions to Customer Classes
Total Residential Commercial Industrial
Public
Authority
Interdepart
mental
High-
Strength
Surcharges
Septic Tank
Haulers
Holding
Tank
Haulers Grease Traps
Portable
Toilets
Landfill
Leachate
Foremost
Farms
Infiltration
/ Inflow
($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($) ($)
CONVEYANCE COSTS:
Collection 271,888 72,664 63,562 27,503 6,099 51 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 102,010
Interceptor 145,968 39,011 34,124 14,765 3,274 27 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 54,766
FLOW COSTS:
Average Flow 129,038 32,030 28,018 12,123 2,688 22 0 1,044 4,377 22 43 3,388 317 44,966
Peak Flow 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
TREATMENT COSTS:
BOD 523,064 99,316 86,876 37,590 8,336 69 148,920 23,316 12,307 6,980 3,284 14,517 81,553 0
TSS 586,753 118,159 103,358 44,722 9,917 82 94,994 117,853 23,313 11,370 11,731 9,635 41,618 0
P 335,215 88,140 77,100 33,360 7,398 61 0 35,907 37,635 61 120 9,329 46,104 0
NH3 477,792 98,324 86,008 37,215 8,252 68 0 5,768 20,152 68 133 220,831 973 0
Billing 100,045 83,128 15,096 651 1,102 69 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
Equivalent Meters 93,480 57,298 28,132 2,108 5,661 281 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
SUBTOTAL COST before I/I 2,663,242 688,070 522,273 210,039 52,726 731 243,914 183,888 97,785 18,500 15,311 257,700 170,564 201,741
2 I/I Allocation % 73% 22% 1% 3% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
TOTAL COST after I/I 2,663,242 834,457 567,337 212,915 59,775 1,095 243,914 183,888 97,785 18,500 15,311 257,700 170,564
LESS OTHER REVENUE 52,483 26,137 17,770 6,669 1,872 34 0 0 0
50% 34% 13% 4% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%
COST OF SERVICES 2,610,759 808,320 549,567 206,246 57,903 1,061 243,914 183,888 97,785 18,500 15,311 257,700 170,564
REVENUE AT PRESENT RATES 1,919,676 541,774 351,606 137,134 32,493 399 181,692 144,559 101,966 12,537 14,413 250,138 150,964
DIFFERENCE 691,083 266,545 197,961 69,112 25,410 662 62,222 39,328 (4,182) 5,963 898 7,562 19,601
PERCENT INCREASE/DECREASE 36.00% 49.20% 56.30% 50.40% 78.20% 165.84% 34.25% 27.21% -4.10% 47.56% 6.23% 3.02% 12.98%
CUSTOMER COSTS:
72
Flat Charge Calculation
Cost of
Service Allocated I/I Units
Annual Billing
Periods
Cost per
Billing Cycle
($/Unit) Billing Cycle - Monthly
Billing Cost $100,045 $201,741 4,124 12 $6.10
Equivalent Meters $93,480 $0 5,601 12 $1.39
$193,525 $201,741
Size of Connection
Billing Cost
($/unit)
Equivalent
Meter Ratio
Meter Cost
($/unit)
Calculated
Charge
($/unit)
Present
Charge
($/unit)
Proposed
Flat Charge
($/unit)
No.
Connections
Revenues at
Present Rates
Revenues at
Proposed Rates
5/8-inch $6.10 1.26 $1.75 $7.85 $4.40 $6.50 3,654 $192,951 $285,041
3/4-inch $6.10 1.26 $1.75 $7.85 $4.40 $6.50 114 $5,997 $8,860
1-inch $6.10 1.26 $1.75 $7.85 $4.40 $6.50 134 $7,080 $10,459
1 1/2-inch $6.10 5.97 $8.31 $14.40 $4.40 $12.00 57 $3,027 $8,256
2-inch $6.10 5.97 $8.31 $14.40 $4.40 $12.00 85 $4,470 $12,192
3-inch $6.10 5.97 $8.31 $14.40 $4.40 $12.00 20 $1,078 $2,940
4-inch $6.10 5.97 $8.31 $14.40 $4.40 $12.00 7 $370 $1,008
Special $6.10 1.26 $1.75 $7.85 $4.40 $6.50 4 $202 $299
Unmetered $6.10 1.26 $1.75 $7.85 $4.40 $6.50 1 $44 $65
Unmetered CR $6.10 1.26 $1.75 $7.85 $4.40 $6.50 1 $53 $78
Meter Only $6.10 1.26 $1.75 $7.85 $4.40 $6.50 3 $158 $234
Flat $6.10 1.26 $1.75 $19.34 $13.64 $17.99 3 $423 $558
Outside-City $6.10 1.26 $1.75 $7.85 $6.16 $9.10 41 $3,062 $4,523
Total 4,124 $218,915 $334,512
Cost of Service $395,266
Percent of Cost 84.6%
73
Usage, Surcharge, and Hauled Waste Rate Calculations
Total Residential Commercial Industrial
Public
Authority
Interdepart
mental
High-
Strength
Surcharges
Residential -
Outside
Commercial -
Outside
Septic Tank
Haulers
Holding
Tank
Haulers
Grease
Traps
Portable
Toilets
Landfill
Leachate
Foremost
Farms
Allocated Cost - Flow $2,215,493 $521,507 $461,275 $200,610 $44,091 $347 $0 $0 $183,888 $97,785 $18,500 $15,311 $3,388 $317
Billable Units 1,000 Gallons 305,577 115,420 97,837 44,064 9,771 81 1,000 4,000 3,794 15,907 80 158 12,315 1,151
Calculated Rate $ / 1,000 Gallons $4.52 $4.71 $4.55 $4.51 $4.28 $0.00 $0.00 $48.47 $6.15 $232.56 $97.14 $0.28 $0.28
Proposed Rate $ / 1,000 Gallons $3.83 $3.83 $3.83 $3.83 $3.83 $5.36 $5.36 $67.86 $8.61 $325.59 $136.00 $5.36 $5.36
Allocated Cost - BOD $244,990 $148,920 $14,517 $81,553
Billable Units Pounds 664,627 422,207 15,175 227,245
Calculated Rate $ / lb. $0.369
Proposed Rate $0.322 $0.322 $0.451 $0.451
Allocated Cost - TSS $146,247 $94,994 $9,635 $41,618
Billable Units Pounds 285,824 195,147 7,889 82,788
Calculated Rate $ / lb. $0.512
Proposed Rate $0.454 $0.454 $0.636 $0.636
Allocated Cost - Phosphorus $55,433 $0 $9,329 $46,104
Billable Units Pounds 3,986 0 0 3,986
Calculated Rate $ / lb. $13.906
Proposed Rate $9.940 $9.940 $13.916 $13.916
Allocated Cost - NH-3 $221,804 $0 $220,831 $973
Billable Units Pounds 103,899 0 103,899 0
Calculated Rate $ / lb. $2.135
Proposed Rate $1.525 $1.525 $2.135 $2.135
Batter (Grease Trap)
Billable Units 68,900
Proposed Rate $325.59
Lab Testing Current Fees / Sample Proposed Fees / Sample
BOD/COD $10.60 $13.00 $8,060 $2,925
TSS $4.65 $6.90 $4,278 $1,553
Phosphorus $13.00 $33.30 $0 $1,665
NH-3 $13.50 $17.00 $1,700 $0
pH $2.25 $3.10 $1,922 $698
Chlorides $12.00 $16.30 $0 $326
Estimated Revenues $2,278,427 $442,058 $374,715 $168,765 $37,423 $310 $246,981 $5,360 $21,440 $257,475 $136,963 $25,900 $21,437 $315,654 $223,947
74
Comparison of Revenue at Present Rates, Cost-of-Service and Proposed Rates
Cost of Service
Customer
Class
Revenue at
Current Rates
Revenue
Required
Increase
Over Present
Rates
Revenue at
Proposed 2030
Rates
Increase
Over Present
Rates
Percent
of Cost of
Service
Inside City
Residential $541,774 $808,320 49.2% $710,823 31.2% 87.9%
Commercial $351,606 $549,567 56.3% $432,002 22.9% 78.6%
Industrial $137,134 $206,246 50.4% $171,650 25.2% 83.2%
Public Authority $32,493 $57,903 78.2% $42,643 31.2% 73.6%
Interdepartmental $399 $1,061 165.8% $663 66.2% 62.5%
High-Strength Surcharges $181,692 $243,914 34.2% $246,981 35.9% 101.3%
Subtotal Urban Retail $1,245,098 $1,867,011 49.9% $1,604,763 28.9% 86.0%
Outside City - Volume Only
Residential - Outside $5,360
Commercial - Outside $21,440
Subtotal Suburban Retail $26,800
Hauled Waste
Septic Tank Haulers $144,559 $183,888 27.2% $257,475 78.1% 140.0%
Holding Tank Haulers $101,966 $97,785 -4.1% $136,963 34.3% 140.1%
Grease Traps $12,537 $18,500 47.6% $25,900 106.6% 140.0%
Portable Toilets $14,413 $15,311 6.2% $21,437 48.7% 140.0%
Landfill Leachate $250,138 $257,700 3.0% $315,654 26.2% 122.5%
Foremost Farms $150,964 $170,564 13.0% $223,947 48.3% 131.3%
Subtotal Wholesale $674,577 $743,748 10.3% $981,376 45.5% 132.0%
Total $1,919,676 $2,610,759 36.0% $2,612,939 36.1% 100.1%
Proposed Rates for 2030
75
Rice Lake Utilities
2026 Wastewater Rate Study
35
APPENDIX B: EQUIPMENT REPLACEMENT FUND ANALYSIS DETAIL
76
Itemized Method 2026
Asset Book Cost
Service
Life
Year
Installed
Remaining
Life
Annual
Deposit
Minimum
Required
Balance
3.101.1323 Electric Pumping Equipment Lift Station Pump $25,936 20 2013 7 $1,297 $16,858
Lift Station Pump (2 pumps) $16,272 20 2014 8 $814 $9,763
Lift Station Pump $19,575 20 2015 9 $979 $10,766
Septage pump $3,756 20 2015 9 $188 $2,066
Liftstation Pumps (2 pumps) $25,372 20 2016 10 $1,269 $12,686
Hammond Lift Station pumps $21,545 20 2017 11 $1,077 $9,695
Control for Pumps $16,680 20 2019 13 $834 $5,838
Control for Pumps $16,860 20 2019 13 $843 $5,901
Orchard Beach Lift Station (pumps) $15,920 20 2021 15 $796 $3,980
Orchard Beach Lift Station (controls) $19,260 10 2021 5 $1,926 $9,630
Lift Station Pump (Quality Flow) $11,380 20 2022 16 $569 $2,276
Control Panel $31,490 10 2022 6 $3,149 $12,596
Lift Station Pump $18,460 20 2023 17 $923 $2,769
3.101.1332 Prelim. Treatment Equipment Plant upgrade $164,172 20 2013 7 $8,209 $106,712
Grit Pump $20,000 20 2013 7 $1,000 $13,000
Grit Classifier/Washer $129,000 10 2013 - $0 $129,000
Primary Influent Pump #1 $20,950 20 2013 7 $1,048 $13,618
Primary Influent Pump #2 $20,950 20 2013 7 $1,048 $13,618
Primary Influent Pump #3 $20,950 20 2013 7 $1,048 $13,618
Primary Influent Pump #4 $20,950 20 2013 7 $1,048 $13,618
Primary Sludge Pump #1 $26,900 20 2013 7 $1,345 $17,485
Primary Sludge Pump #2 $26,900 20 2013 7 $1,345 $17,485
Primary Scum Pump $18,300 20 2013 7 $915 $11,895
Mixer sepatage receiving $4,577 15 2017 6 $305 $2,746
New Step Screen $179,975 15 2020 9 $11,998 $71,990
Grease Station at plant $19,686 20 2022 16 $984 $3,937
Septage Receiving Station $36,060 20 2022 16 $1,803 $7,212
Pump Mixer Grease Station $25,285 20 2023 17 $1,264 $3,793
Septage Pump #1 $9,065 20 2023 17 $453 $1,360
Septage Pump #2 $9,065 20 2023 17 $453 $1,360
3.101.1334 Secondary Treatment Equipment Surface Mixer $9,818 15 2008 - $0 $9,818
Surface Mixer $9,818 15 2008 - $0 $9,818
RAS Pumps (3) Replacement $17,046 20 2010 4 $852 $13,637
RAS Pumps (3) Replacement $17,046 20 2010 4 $852 $13,637
RAS Pumps (3) Replacement $17,046 20 2010 4 $852 $13,637
Recirculation pump $23,611 20 2013 7 $1,181 $15,347
Aeration Blower # 1/VFD $43,033 20 2013 7 $2,152 $27,972
Aeration Blower # 2/VFD $43,033 20 2013 7 $2,152 $27,972
Aeration # 3/VFD $23,033 20 2013 7 $1,152 $14,972
Chemical Feed Equip. #1 $16,400 20 2013 7 $820 $10,660
Chemical Feed Equip. #2 $16,400 20 2013 7 $820 $10,660
Digester Draft Tube #1 $47,500 20 2013 7 $2,375 $30,875
Digester Draft Tube #2 $47,500 20 2013 7 $2,375 $30,875
Fine Bubble Aeration Equip. $158,100 20 2013 7 $7,905 $102,765
Sludge Recirculation Pump #2 $23,000 20 2013 7 $1,150 $14,950
Combination Boiler/Heat Exchanger $141,264 20 2013 7 $7,063 $91,822
Phosphorus analyser $26,355 12 2015 1 $2,196 $24,159
Polymer Equipment $35,500 15 2016 5 $2,367 $23,667
Digested Sludge Transfer Pipe $21,725 20 2018 12 $1,086 $8,690
Aeration Blower # 3 $18,983 20 2019 13 $949 $6,644
Category of Assets
77
Asset Book Cost
Service
Life
Year
Installed
Remaining
Life
Annual
Deposit
Minimum
Required
BalanceCategory of Assets
Gravity Belt Thickener $43,500 20 2020 14 $2,175 $13,050
Aeration process equip upgradge $62,971 20 2021 15 $3,149 $15,743
Recycle Pump (Quality Flow) $15,560 20 2021 15 $778 $3,890
Pump for Secondary Treatment $26,526 20 2022 16 $1,326 $5,305
Recirculation pump VFD $3,986 20 2022 16 $199 $797
DO Sensors Transmitters $6,525 10 2022 6 $652 $2,610
WAS Pump $24,250 20 2022 16 $1,213 $4,850
Digester Entry Hatches & Manway $42,490 20 2023 17 $2,125 $6,374
3.101.1336 Chlorination Equipment Plant upgrade $3,213 20 2013 7 $161 $2,088
Chlorination Omni valve $2,790 20 2015 9 $140 $1,535
ORP Meter $3,104 20 2017 11 $155 $1,397
Chlorination pump $3,080 20 2017 11 $154 $1,386
Chlorination scale $5,489 20 2018 12 $274 $2,196
Sulfur Dioxide Onmi Valve $2,998 20 2023 17 $150 $450
3.101.1339 Flow Metering Monitoring Equipment Isco Collection Meters for receiving flow $14,905 10 2019 3 $1,491 $10,434
Flow Meter WAS Sludge $4,189 10 2022 6 $419 $1,676
Flow Meter Coleman Lift Station $3,608 10 2022 6 $361 $1,443
Flow Meter Digested Sludge $3,487 10 2023 7 $349 $1,046
Flow Meter Thick WAS Sludge $2,977 10 2023 7 $298 $893
Flow Meter Thick Digestor Sludge $2,977 10 2023 7 $298 $893
Influent Flow Meter $2,501 20 2023 17 $125 $375
Effluent Flow Meter $2,501 20 2023 17 $125 $375
3.101.1341 Other Treatment Plant & Disposal Equipment Auto Clave Lab Equip (napoc800dse) $4,401 12 2008 - $0 $4,401
Lab Sampler $8,157 12 2008 - $0 $8,157
SPECTROPHOTOMETER $3,294 12 2014 - $0 $3,294
REACTOR 110V $1,194 12 2014 - $0 $1,194
Combustable Gas Detectors $3,131 12 2017 3 $261 $2,348
Combustable Gas Detectors $3,131 12 2017 3 $261 $2,348
Sulfide Gas Detectors $3,131 12 2017 3 $261 $2,348
Chlorine Gas Detectors $3,131 12 2017 3 $261 $2,348
Non-Potable water pump $3,080 20 2017 11 $154 $1,386
BOD Incubator $4,098 20 2019 13 $205 $1,434
Water Distiller & Collection $7,904 20 2019 13 $395 $2,766
Ohaus PX124/E AM (T Equipment 4/27/21) $1,385 20 2021 15 $69 $346
Orion ph/Chlorine Meter $1,606 10 2021 5 $161 $803
Orion Ammonia/Fluoride Meter $1,606 10 2021 5 $161 $803
Muffle Furnace $1,761 20 2022 16 $88 $352
Portable Gas Detector $3,370 12 2023 9 $281 $843
Lab Equipment Ecoli Tester $4,997 12 2024 10 $416 $833
3.101.1352 Other Plant Equipment Manhole monitor (quantity 2) $3,495 20 2017 11 $175 $1,573
Davit System Confiined space safety system $7,667 20 2018 12 $383 $3,067
Welder $2,054 20 2019 13 $103 $719
Welding Exhaust unit $3,214 20 2023 17 $161 $482
3.101.1392 Wastewater Transportation Equipment 2017 Western star 4900SB 5KKMALBG2HPJB9899 $181,717 10 2016 - $0 $181,717
2018 CHEV SILVERADO CAB PICKUP 1G0KUEG5JZ213465 $36,542 10 2018 2 $3,654 $29,234
2018 FORD Transit 1FTRS4XVIJKA86662 $141,262 10 2018 2 $14,126 $113,010
2022 Chevrolet Silverado 3500 $50,646 10 2022 6 $5,065 $20,258
2022 Freightlinger combo/jet vac truck 3ALHB3FM8NDNM4677 $409,963 20 2023 17 $20,498 $61,494
3.101.1396 Power Operated Equipment Crane for truck #31 $4,909 10 2013 - $0 $4,909
Case Skidsteer SR210 (JAFSR210TRM455067) $42,100 10 2024 8 $4,210 $8,420
78
Asset Book Cost
Service
Life
Year
Installed
Remaining
Life
Annual
Deposit
Minimum
Required
BalanceCategory of Assets
3.101.1400 Computer Equipment Copymachine/printer Lenmark $1,249 8 2016 - $0 $1,249
Image runner Copy Machine $3,383 8 2019 1 $423 $2,960
ThinkCentre M90q $1,038 5 2021 - $0 $1,038
Lenovo computer $1,161 5 2023 2 $232 $697
Lenovo computer $1,161 5 2023 2 $232 $697
Lenovo computer $1,161 5 2023 2 $232 $697
Lenovo computer $1,161 5 2023 2 $232 $697
Server upgrade $1,069 8 2023 5 $134 $401
3.101.1397 Communication Equipment SCADA $134,167 5 2013 - $0 $134,167
SCADA Upgrade wonderware/Installation $14,535 5 2018 - $0 $14,535
SCADA Computer Updgrade $3,989 5 2024 3 $798 $1,596
3.101.1399 Miscellaneous Equipment AED Defibulator $1,833 15 2009 - $0 $1,833
Surveillance Cameras $1,697 10 2010 - $0 $1,697
Water bubbler $608 20 2011 5 $30 $456
Wash Machine $540 20 2011 5 $27 $405
snowblower $1,199 15 2014 3 $80 $959
Dishwasher $629 20 2019 13 $31 $220
Refrigerator $1,079 20 2019 13 $54 $378
Rotary Cutter $3,699 20 2019 13 $185 $1,295
Wall mount pressure washer $3,895 20 2020 14 $195 $1,169
Tool Chest $1,300 20 2023 17 $65 $195
Northstar gas pressure washer $1,076 20 2024 18 $54 $108
Honda Self-priming Construction Fall Trash Pump $1,675 20 2024 18 $84 $167
Metal cutting chop saw $479 20 2024 18 $24 $48
Total $3,161,859 $157,802 $1,757,198
79
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
SEWER RATE STUDY
SISTER BAY, WIS.
DATE ISSUED
November 18, 2026
PROPOSAL DUE DATE AND TIME
January 7, 2027, 3:45 pm CST
80
REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS
SEWER RATE STUDY SERVICES
SUBMISSION DEADLINE: January 7, 2027, by 3:45 PM, submitted to the Village of Sister
Bay Administrative Office located at 2383 Maple Dr., PO Box 769, Sister Bay, WI 54234, or
electronically (PDF) to megan.barnes@sisterbaywi.gov. It shall be the responsibility of the
proposer to ensure their submission was received.
All questions concerning this solicitation should be directed to Megan Barnes, Utilities
Director at megan.barnes@sisterbaywi.gov. All questions will be answered to the best of
staff’s ability, and posted to the Village website to ensure all proposers have access to the
same information. Visit www.sisterbaywi.gov and scroll to the bottom of the home page.
PROJECT DESCRIPTION: The Village of Sister Bay (“Village”) is soliciting proposals from
qualified and licensed consultants to provide sewer rate study services in 2027. Sister Bay
is a community of roughly 1,148 people situated on the northwestern shore of the Door
Peninsula in Door Coun ty, Wisconsin. The Village lie s adjacent to the Bay of Green Bay
and the Town of Liberty Grove and is located approximately 30 miles north of the City of
Sturgeon Bay and 75 miles northeast of the City of Green Bay. The Sister Bay Sewer Utility
has approximately 1,526 active service connections. The Utility serves customers located
in the Village of Sister Bay, as well as customers in the Liberty Grove Utility District No. 1,
including 214 commercial users and no industrial users. Charges for service are user fees
(or rates) for the services provided to each customer. The Village bills rates quarterly to
customers for services rendered, which includes a service charge based on the size of the
installed water meter and volumetric rate based on usage. The last sewer rate study was
completed in 2024, effective January 1, 2025.
OVERVIEW/SOLICITATION: The Village of Sister Bay is seeking proposals from qualified
and licensed consultants to prepare our 2027 sewer rate study to be effective July 1, 2027.
Quality and accuracy are paramount and are critical to establishing the rates.
Acknowledging publication and notification deadlines, time is of the essence.
I. Instruction to Proposers
• All respondents (proposers) must submit contact information including: Business
name, contact person, corporate ownership, address, phone number, email address,
and website.
• All costs associated with submission of this Request for Proposals are the sole
responsibility of the respondent.
• All submissions are considered public record s, and as such, may be searched or
requested by members of the public.
• The Village of Sister Bay offers no guarantee of financial success to the respondent(s),
and respondents should use their own business acumen to determine if they are
endeavoring in a financially viable enterprise.
• This is a Request for Proposals, not an invitation to bid. Responses will be evaluated
on the basis of the relative merits of the proposal.
81
II. Submission Materials
The following should be incorporated into each submission:
Format: Electronic submissions preferred (PDF).
General Information. Business name, contact person, corporate ownership, address,
phone number, email address of contact person, website, and insurance information.
Please include a narrative introducing the company, its history of operation, relevant staff,
total number employed, and capacity to service the Village.
Project Proposal. At a minimum, provide information on approach, services, ideas, costs,
timeline.
Prior Experience . A narrative explaining prior experience with rate studies, as well as
examples.
References. A minimum of three municipal or utility references are required.
III. Evaluation and Selection
Evaluation Process
The Village has established a proposal evaluation instrument which measures objective
criteria on a weighted basis on a scale of 0 -5 for each rating category. The Sewer and
Water Utility Committee’s average score will be evaluated against the average scores from
other submissions to determine whom to award a contract.
Selection Criteria
The following are the criteria used as rating categories:
1. Qualifications
2. Knowledge of State and Federal applicable laws
3. Experience
4. Level of Understanding of the Need Identified
5. References
6. Cost
If at any point in the review process, any proposal found to be substantially non-
responsive will be dropped from further consideration.
The Village, at its sole discretion, may require presentations by respondents clearly in
consideration for award. Other submissions, certifications, or affirmations may be
required, as appropriate.
IV. Award
Upon final selection, all respondents will be notified by the Village, via email.
The Village reserves the right to accept or reject any or all responses, to award on the
basis of merit or cost alone, and to act in its best interests and the interests of the public.
82
The Village reserves the right to make an award or to reject any or all proposals based on
what it considers to be its best interests. A contract will be required to effectuate service.
V. Administrative Contact
Name: Megan Barnes
Title: Utilities Director
E-Mail: megan.barnes@sisterbaywi.gov
Mailing Address: 2383 Maple Dr., PO Box 769, Sister Bay, WI 54234
83
Page 1
STAFF REPORT
Date: November 14, 2026
To: Village Board
Re: Authorization of Additional $5,000 for Village Planning and Zoning Consulting Services
BACKGROUND
At its October 2026 meeting, the Village Board authorized $10,000 for planning and zoning
consulting services provided by Robert (Bob) Kufrin to assist Village staff during the
administrative transition.
DISCUSSION
Mr. Kufrin continues to provide planning and zoning guidance to staff to ensure continuity of
Village operations. An itemized invoice for services rendered has not yet been received, so the
remaining balance of the initial authorization has not been confirmed.
An additional $5,000 authorization is requested to ensure consulting services can continue
without interruption until the next regular Village Board meeting.
FISCAL IMPACT
Additional authorization of $5,000, bringing the total authorized amount to $15,000.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends approval of an additional $5,000 for planning and zoning consulting services
to maintain continuity during the administrative transition.
SUGGESTED MOTION
Motion to authorize an additional $5,000 for planning and zoning consulting services provided
by Robert Kufrin, increasing the total authorization to $15,000, subject to review of itemized
invoices and applicable Village purchasing procedures.
84
Page 1
STAFF REPORT
Date: November 14, 2026
To: Village Board
Re: One-Time Supplemental Compensation for Village Staff Assuming Additional Responsibilities
During the Village Administrator Vacancy
BACKGROUND
Following the resignation of the Village Administrator, effective October 12, 2026, several Village
employees have assumed additional duties and responsibilities to maintain continuity of Village
operations.
DISCUSSION
The Village Board should consider providing additional compensation to employees who have
taken on responsibilities beyond their normal duties during the Administrator vacancy.
Any compensation should be reasonable, equitable, and reflective of the additional
responsibilities, workload, and duration of service.
The Finance Committee Chair, working with the Village Finance Specialist, would be tasked with
evaluating the financial impact, identifying an appropriate total compensation amount, and
recommending an equitable distribution among affected employees.
FISCAL IMPACT
Up to $__________ in one -time supplemental compensation, subject to final Village Board
approval of the proposed distribution.
RECOMMENDATION
Authorize up to $__________ in one -time supplemental compensation for Village employees
who have assumed additional responsibilities during the Village Administrator vacancy.
85
Page 2
Direct the Finance Committee Chair to work with the Village Finance Specialist to determine an
equitable distribution of these funds among affected employees, considering additional
workload, responsibilities, and duration of service.
The proposed distribution shall be brought back to the Village Board for final approval.
SUGGESTED MOTION
Motion to authorize up to $__________ for one -time supplemental staff compensation related
to the Village Administrator vacancy and direct the Finance Committee Chair, working with the
Village Finance Specialist, to develop an equitable distribution plan for subsequent Village Board
approval.
86
Page 1
STAFF REPORT
Date: November 14, 2026
To: Village Board
Re: Re-authorization of Administrative Authority and Coordination of Village Operations During
the Village Administrator Vacancy
BACKGROUND
At its October 2026 meeting, the Village Board authorized the Village President to provide interim
administrative coordination and oversight during the Village Administrator vacancy. The Board
agreed that this authorization would be reconsidered at each re gular Board meeting until a
permanent Village Administrator is hired.
DISCUSSION
With the Village Administrator position remaining vacant, continued interim administrative
authority is necessary to ensure continuity of Village operations and provide staff with
appropriate direction and support.
RECOMMENDATION
Staff recommends that the Village Board reauthorize the previously approved interim
administrative arrangements until the next regular Board meeting.
SUGGESTED MOTION
Motion to reauthorize the Village President's interim administrative authority and coordination
of Village operations, consistent with the limitations and conditions previously established by the
Village Board, until the next regular Board meeting.
87
Page 1
STAFF REPORT
Date: November 13, 2026
To: Village Board
Agenda Item: Village Administrator Recruitment – Review of Executive Search Firm Proposals
Prepared By: Village Clerk
Action Requested: Discussion and Possible Action
Background
Following the resignation of the Village Administrator in October 2026, the Village initiated
the process of identifying a recruitment firm to assist with the selection of a new Village
Administrator.
Proposals were received from five executive recruitment firms offering services related to
municipal administrator recruitment, candidate screening, interview coordination, and
selection assistance.
The proposals have been provided to Village Board members for review prior to the
meeting.
Proposals Received
Recruitment Firm Proposed Fee Anticipated Timeline
Innovative Public
Advisors (IPA) $5,000 flat fee Approximately 8 weeks
Public Administration
Associates (PAA)
$14,500 plus certain
additional expenses
Approximately 10 weeks, with
recruitment recommended to
begin after January 1
McMahon Associates,
Inc. Not to exceed $13,500 Approximately 3–4 months
MGT Impact
Solutions
Approximately $21,500,
plus applicable additional
expenses
Approximately 90–120 days
The Harding Group,
LLC Estimated $13,000–$16,000 Anticipated appointment by April
2027
Fees and timelines are based on the proposals submitted. Certain costs, exclusions, and
scheduling conditions may apply. Refer to the individual proposals for complete terms.
88
Page 2
Discussion
Each firm has proposed an approach to recruiting and evaluating candidates for the Village
Administrator position. The proposals vary in recruitment methodology, candidate
assessment procedures, anticipated timelines, fee structures, and replacement guarantees.
The Village Board may wish to consider the following factors during its review:
• Experience conducting municipal executive searches, particularly in Wisconsin and
communities comparable to Sister Bay.
• Recruitment strategies and methods for identifying qualified candidates.
• Candidate screening, reference checks, background investigations, and leadership
assessments.
• Opportunities for Village Board, staff, and stakeholder participation in the selection
process.
• Anticipated recruitment timeline and availability to begin services.
• Proposed fees, additional expenses, and contractual provisions.
• Replacement-search guarantees and other post-placement services.
Certain firms have also indicated the ability to assist with recruitment for a separate Zoning
Administrator position, and/or Village Analysis for efficiencies should the Village elect to
pursue those services.
Financial Considerations
The proposed Village Administrator recruitment fees range from $5,000 to approximately
$21,500, excluding applicable additional expenses.
Funding for recruitment services would be subject to the Village's available budget and
applicable approval procedures.
Board Consideration
The Village Board is asked to review and discuss the proposals received and determine the
appropriate next steps in the recruitment process.
Potential actions may include identifying firms for further consideration, requesting
additional information or interviews, or selecting a recruitment firm, subject to review and
approval of the applicable agreement.
89
/0/1/2 /3 /4 /4 /5
/6 /7 /8 /8 /9 /10 /11 /i255 /13 /14/15/7/16 /7 /17 /18 /19 /9 /18 /20 /19 /i255 /21 /11 /9 /19 /22 /23
/24 /19 /20/15/25/3 /26 /27/2 /i255 /29 /30 /26 /31 /3 /32 /33 /i255 /34 /35 /3 /26 /27 /2 /36 /30 /26 /31 /3 /32 /33/37/4/1 /2 /3 /4 /4 /5 /38 /35 /4/39/40
/41 /9 /18/11/42/43 /1/i255 /44 /45 /46 /47 /48 /46 /47 /45 /47 /49 /i255 /50 /51 /52 /50 /i255 /53 /54
/55/20/56/57 /2/32 /i255 /58 /32 /3 /3 /i255 /34 /27 /57 /2 /32 /38 /59 /32 /3 /3/37/60/26 /60 /2 /32 /30 /59 /57 /33 /61 /26 /38 /36 /4 /62 /40
/63/22/64/1 /3 /26 /32/i255 /42 /43 /33 /60 /60 /32 /27 /i255 /34 /35 /3 /32 /30 /5/37/60/26 /60 /2 /32 /30 /59 /57 /33 /61 /26 /38 /36 /4 /62 /40 /65 /i255 /66 /57 /30 /57 /43 /i255 /58 /32 /30 /2 /36 /32 /60 /i255 /34 /57 /31/39/26/27 /57 /60 /60 /26 /60 /2/37/60/26 /60 /2 /32 /30 /59 /57 /33 /61 /26 /38 /36 /4 /62 /40
/67 /68 /69 /70 /i255 /72 /73 /74 /74 /69 /75 /68 /i255/76 /70 /68 /77 /73 /78 /68 /79 /80 /i255 /81 /68 /74 /74 /82
/i255
/83 /i255 /68 /79 /84 /85 /86 /68 /78 /i255 /85 /87 /70/i255 /88 /89 /85 /69 /70 /78 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255/90/86/77 /68 /74 /91 /92 /i255 /80 /73/90/68/i255 /80 /85 /75 /68 /80 /93 /68 /70 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255 /85 /94 /68 /70 /69 /74 /74 /95 /i255 /83 /i255 /89 /68 /74 /73 /68 /94 /68 /i255 /73 /80 /i255 /96 /69 /77 /i255 /69 /i255 /77 /87 /97 /97 /68 /77/77 /91 /87 /74 /i255 /69 /79 /78
/98 /70 /85 /78 /87 /97 /80 /73 /94 /68 /i255 /68 /94/68 /79 /80 /99 /i255 /i255 /100 /80 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /68 /79 /78 /i255 /85 /91 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /68 /75 /73 /97 /i255 /98 /74 /69 /79 /79 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /98 /70 /85 /97 /68 /77 /77 /95 /i255 /83 /i255 /80 /93 /85 /87 /75 /93 /80 /i255 /93 /69 /94 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /69 /i255 /78/73 /77 /97 /87 /77 /77 /73 /85 /79 /i255 /85 /79
/91 /73 /74 /74 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /72 /73 /74 /74/69 /75 /68 /i255 /100 /78/90/73/79 /73 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /85 /70 /i255 /98 /85 /77 /73 /80 /73 /85 /79 /i255 /96 /69 /77 /i255 /69 /74 /77 /85 /i255 /69 /i255 /91 /70 /87 /73 /80 /91 /87 /74 /i255 /97 /85 /79 /94 /68 /70 /77 /69 /80 /73 /85 /79 /99 /i255 /i255 /101 /98 /85 /79 /i255 /70 /68 /91 /74 /68 /97/80 /73 /85 /79 /95 /i255 /83 /i255 /96 /85 /87 /74 /78
/74 /73 /102 /68 /i255 /80 /85 /i255 /70 /68 /77 /98 /68 /97/80 /91 /87 /74 /74 /86 /i255 /85 /91 /91 /68 /70 /i255 /77 /85/90/68/i255 /91 /87 /70 /80 /93 /68 /70 /i255 /103 /87 /68 /77 /80 /73 /85 /79 /77 /i255 /91 /85 /70 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /72 /73 /74 /74 /69 /75 /68 /i255 /81 /85 /69 /70 /78 /i255 /80 /85 /i255 /98 /85 /79 /78 /68 /70 /i255 /69 /77 /i255 /86/85 /87
/97 /85 /79 /80 /68/90/98/74 /69 /80 /68 /i255/80 /93 /68 /i255 /79 /68 /104 /80 /i255 /77 /80 /68 /98 /77 /i255 /91 /85 /70 /i255 /91 /73 /74 /74 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /98 /85 /77 /73 /80 /73 /85 /79 /82
/i255
/105 /99 /i255/106 /107 /108 /109 /110 /111 /106/112 /108 /113 /114 /115 /i255 /117 /109 /118 /113 /109/119/i255/111 /i255/120 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /73 /77 /i255 /79 /85 /80 /i255 /69 /79 /i255 /68 /69 /77 /86 /i255 /80 /69 /77 /102 /95 /i255 /89 /87 /80 /i255 /73 /80 /i255 /97 /69 /79 /i255 /93 /68 /74 /98 /i255 /77 /68 /80 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /77 /80 /69 /75 /68 /i255 /91/85 /70 /i255 /80 /93 /68
/77 /87 /97 /97 /68 /77/77 /i255 /85 /91 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /79 /68 /104 /80 /i255 /69 /78/90/73/79 /73 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /85 /70 /99 /i255 /i255 /120 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /98 /70 /85 /97 /68 /77 /77 /i255 /97 /85 /87 /74 /78 /i255 /73 /79 /97 /74 /87 /78 /68 /i255 /69 /79 /77 /96 /68 /70 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /77 /87 /97 /93/i255 /103 /87 /68 /77 /80 /73 /85 /79 /77
/74 /73 /102 /68 /82
/69 /99 /i255 /121/93 /69 /80 /i255 /96 /68 /79 /80 /i255 /96 /68 /74 /74 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255 /96 /93 /69 /80 /i255 /78 /73 /78 /i255 /79 /85 /80 /i255 /75 /85 /i255 /96 /68 /74 /74 /i255 /96 /73 /80 /93 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /98 /70 /68 /94 /73 /85 /87 /77 /i255 /88 /122 /123 /122 /124 /92 /i255 /77 /68 /69 /70 /97 /93/i255 /98 /70 /85 /97 /68 /77 /77 /125 /i255
/100/79 /86 /80 /93 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /86 /85 /87 /126 /78 /i255 /78 /85 /i255 /78 /73 /91 /91 /68 /70 /68 /79 /80 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /80 /73/90/68/i255 /69 /70 /85 /87 /79 /78 /125
/89 /99 /i255 /121/93 /69 /80 /i255 /96 /68 /79 /80 /i255 /96 /68 /74 /74 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255 /96 /93 /69 /80 /i255 /78 /73 /78 /i255 /79 /85 /80 /i255 /75 /85 /i255 /96 /68 /74 /74 /i255 /96 /73 /80 /93 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /81 /68 /79 /126 /77 /i255 /85 /70 /73 /68 /79 /80 /69 /80 /73 /85 /79 /i255 /89 /86 /i255 /80 /93/68 /i255 /94 /73 /74 /74 /69 /75 /68 /125
/i255 /121/73 /80 /93 /i255 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /98 /68 /70 /91 /85 /70/90/69/79 /97 /68 /125 /i255 /i255/121/73/74 /74 /i255 /86 /85 /87 /i255 /93 /69 /94 /68 /i255 /69 /i255 /77 /87 /98 /98 /85 /70 /80 /i255 /77 /86 /77 /80 /68/90/i255/69 /70 /70 /69 /79 /75 /68/90/68/79 /80 /i255 /91 /85/70 /i255 /80 /93 /68
/85/79 /75 /85 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /97 /85 /69 /97 /93 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255/90/68/79 /80 /85 /70 /77 /93 /73 /98 /i255 /85 /91 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /79 /68 /104 /80 /i255 /69 /78/90/73/79 /73 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /85 /70 /125 /i255 /i255 /120 /93 /68 /i255 /83 /127/128/100/i255 /93 /69 /77 /i255 /69 /i255 /77 /80 /69 /80 /68 /129
/89/86 /129 /77 /80 /69 /80 /68 /i255/77 /68 /79 /73 /85 /70 /i255 /69 /78 /94 /73 /77 /85 /70 /i255 /98 /70 /85 /75 /70 /69 /90/i255 /80 /93 /69 /80 /i255 /73 /77 /i255 /96 /68 /74 /74 /i255 /70 /68 /77 /98 /68 /97 /80 /68 /78 /99 /i255 /i255 /120 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /97 /69 /79 /i255 /69 /74 /77 /85 /i255 /89 /68/i255 /85 /91 /91 /68 /70 /68 /78 /i255 /89 /86
/80 /93/68 /i255 /77 /68 /74 /68 /97 /80 /68 /78 /i255 /70 /68 /97 /70 /87 /73 /80 /68 /70 /i255 /69 /77 /i255 /98 /69 /70 /80 /i255 /85 /91 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /73 /70 /i255 /97 /85 /79 /80 /73 /79 /87 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /77 /68 /70 /94 /73 /97 /68 /77 /99
/97 /99 /i255 /121/93 /69 /80 /i255 /69 /77 /98 /68 /97 /80 /77 /i255 /85 /91 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /94 /73 /74 /74 /69 /75 /68 /i255 /69 /78/90/73/79 /73 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /85 /70 /i255 /98 /68 /70 /91 /85 /70/90/69/79 /97 /68 /i255 /80 /93 /69 /80 /i255 /78 /73 /78 /i255 /79 /85 /80 /i255/90/68/68 /80
/68/104 /98 /68 /97 /80 /69 /80 /73 /85 /79 /77 /i255 /96 /68 /70 /68 /i255 /72 /73 /74 /74 /69 /75 /68 /i255 /88 /68/90/98/74 /85 /86 /68 /70 /92 /i255 /73 /77 /77 /87 /68 /77 /i255 /80 /93 /69 /80 /i255 /97 /69 /79 /i255 /89 /68 /i255 /97 /85 /70 /70 /68 /97 /80 /68 /78 /125 /i255 /i255/121/93/69 /80 /i255 /69 /77 /98 /68 /97 /80 /77
/96/68 /70 /68 /i255 /77 /80 /70 /73 /97 /80 /74 /86 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /69 /78/90/73/79 /73 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /85 /70 /126 /77 /i255 /98 /68 /70 /91 /85 /70/90/69/79 /97 /68 /i255 /73 /77 /77 /87 /68 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255 /79 /85 /80 /i255 /85 /91 /i255 /69 /79 /86 /i255 /68/90/98/74 /85/86 /68 /70
/70 /68/77 /98 /85 /79 /77 /73 /89 /73 /74 /73 /80 /86 /125 /i255
/78 /99 /i255 /130/69 /94 /68 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /70 /68 /i255 /89 /68 /68 /79 /i255 /69 /79 /86 /i255 /97 /85/90/90/85/79 /i255 /94 /73 /74 /74 /69 /75 /68 /i255 /89 /85 /69 /70 /78 /95 /i255 /85 /70 /i255 /97 /85/90/90/87/79 /73 /80 /86 /95 /i255 /85 /70 /i255 /73 /79 /80 /68 /70 /79 /69 /74 /i255 /68/90/98/74 /85 /86 /68 /68
/73 /77/77 /87 /68 /77 /i255 /68 /91 /91 /68 /97 /80 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /74 /69 /77 /80 /i255 /91 /73 /94 /68 /i255 /69 /78/90/73/79 /73 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /85 /70 /77 /i255 /73 /79 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /74 /69 /77 /80 /i255 /80 /68 /79 /i255 /86 /68 /69 /70 /77 /i255 /80 /93 /69 /80 /i255 /97 /69 /79/i255 /89 /68
/97/85 /70 /70 /68 /97 /80 /68 /78 /125 /i255 /67 /85 /i255 /86 /85 /87 /i255 /93 /69 /94 /68 /i255 /69 /79 /i255 /69 /87 /80 /93 /68 /79 /80 /73 /97 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255 /69 /97 /97 /87 /70 /69 /80 /68 /i255 /70 /68 /77 /98 /85 /79 /77 /68 /i255 /80 /85 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /74 /68 /94 /68/74 /i255 /85 /91 /i255 /80 /87 /70 /79 /85 /94 /68 /70
/88 /75/85 /85 /78 /i255 /97 /69 /79 /78 /73 /78 /69 /80 /68 /77 /i255 /96 /73 /74 /74 /i255 /69 /77 /102 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /103 /87 /68 /77 /80 /73 /85 /79 /92 /125
/68 /99 /i255 /121/93 /69 /80 /i255 /97 /69 /79 /i255 /89 /68 /i255 /74 /68 /69 /70 /79 /68 /78 /i255 /91 /70 /85/90/i255/80 /93 /68 /i255 /69 /89 /85 /94 /68 /i255 /80 /93 /69 /80 /i255 /96 /73 /74 /74 /i255 /93 /68 /74 /98 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /94 /73 /74 /74 /69 /75 /68 /i255 /73 /79 /i255 /70 /68 /97 /70 /87 /73 /80 /73 /79/75 /95 /i255 /70 /68 /80 /69 /73 /79 /73 /79 /75 /95
/69/79 /78 /i255 /73/90/98/70 /85 /94 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /91 /73 /80 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255 /68 /91 /91 /68 /97 /80 /73 /94 /68 /79 /68 /77 /77 /i255 /85 /91 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /79 /68 /104 /80 /i255 /94 /73 /74 /74 /69 /75 /68 /i255 /69 /78/90/73/79 /73 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /85 /70 /125
/91 /99 /i255 /127/85 /79 /77 /73 /78 /68 /70 /i255 /73 /91 /95 /i255 /96 /73 /80 /93 /i255 /85 /98 /68 /79 /i255/90/68/68 /80 /73 /79 /75 /i255 /74 /69 /96 /95 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /89 /85 /69 /70 /78 /i255 /97 /69 /79 /i255 /68 /91 /91 /68 /97 /80 /73 /94 /68 /74 /86 /i255 /98 /68 /70 /91 /85 /70/90/i255/80 /93 /73/77 /i255 /69 /91 /80 /68 /70 /129 /69 /97 /80 /73 /85 /79
/70 /68/94 /73 /68 /96 /95 /i255 /85 /70 /i255 /78 /85 /i255 /86 /85 /87 /i255 /96 /69 /79 /80 /i255 /80 /85 /i255 /77 /68 /74 /68 /97 /80 /i255 /69 /i255 /80 /70 /87 /77 /80 /68 /78 /i255 /77 /80 /69 /91 /91 /i255/90/68 /90/89/68 /70 /i255 /85 /70 /i255 /69 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /70 /78 /i255 /98 /69 /70 /80 /86 /i255 /80 /85/i255 /78 /85 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /77
/96/85 /70 /102 /i255 /80 /93 /70 /85 /87 /75 /93 /i255 /69 /79 /i255 /73 /79 /80 /68 /70 /94 /73 /68 /96 /129 /89 /69 /77 /68 /78 /i255 /98 /70 /85 /97 /68 /77 /77 /99 /i255 /i255 /83 /91 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /73 /77 /i255 /78 /85 /79 /68 /i255 /89 /86 /i255 /69 /79 /i255 /69 /80 /80 /85 /70 /79 /68 /86/i255 /85 /70 /i255 /69 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /70 /78
/98/69 /70 /80 /86 /95 /i255 /78 /85 /97 /87/90/68/79 /80 /69 /80 /73 /85 /79 /i255 /73 /79 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /77 /i255 /70 /68 /75 /69 /70 /78 /i255/90/69/86 /i255 /93 /69 /94 /68 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /89 /68 /79 /68 /91 /73 /80 /i255 /85 /91 /i255 /98 /70 /73 /94 /73 /74 /68 /75 /68 /78 /i255 /73 /79/91 /85 /70/90/69/80 /73 /85 /79 /99
/i255
/122 /99 /i255/131 /110 /109 /111 /117 /109/112 /110 /132 /113 /108/133/109/115 /108 /i255 /111 /i255/134 /94 /69 /74 /87 /69 /80 /68 /i255 /73 /91 /i255 /86 /85 /87 /i255 /96 /69 /79 /80 /i255 /77 /80 /69 /91 /91 /i255 /85 /70 /i255 /69 /i255 /80 /93 /73 /70 /78 /129 /98 /69 /70 /80 /86 /i255 /80 /85 /i255 /98 /68 /70 /91 /85 /70/90/i255/80 /93 /68 /i255 /91 /85/74 /74 /85 /96 /73 /79 /75 /82
/69 /99 /i255/135/70/75 /69 /79 /73 /136 /69 /80 /73 /85 /79 /i255 /70 /68 /94 /73 /68 /96 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255 /70 /68 /97 /85/90/90/68/79 /78 /69 /80 /73 /85 /79 /i255 /85 /79 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /i255 /94 /73 /74 /74 /69 /75 /68 /i255 /69 /78/90/73/79 /73 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /85 /70 /i255 /84 /85 /89 /i255 /78 /87 /80 /73 /68 /77 /i255 /69 /79 /78
/85 /70 /75 /69 /79 /73 /136 /69 /80 /73 /85 /79 /69 /74 /i255 /77 /80 /70 /87 /97 /80 /87 /70 /68 /i255 /85 /98 /80 /73 /85 /79 /77
/89 /99 /i255/128/69/70 /102 /68 /80 /i255 /70 /68 /77 /68 /69 /70 /97 /93 /i255 /85 /79 /i255 /97 /87 /70 /70 /68 /79 /80 /i255 /97 /85/90/98/69 /70 /69 /89 /74 /68 /i255 /98 /69 /86 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255 /89 /68 /79 /68 /91 /73 /80 /77
/97 /99 /i255 /134 /94 /69 /74 /87 /69 /80 /68 /i255 /73 /91 /i255 /80 /93 /68 /70 /68 /i255 /69 /70 /68 /i255 /73 /79 /80 /68 /70 /79 /69 /74 /i255 /77 /80 /69 /91 /91 /i255 /98 /70 /85/90/85/80 /73 /85 /79 /69 /74 /i255 /85 /98 /98 /85 /70 /80 /87 /79 /73 /80 /73 /68 /77 /95 /i255 /85 /70 /i255 /74 /85 /97 /69 /74 /i255 /69 /79 /78 /i255 /70 /68 /75 /73 /85 /79 /69 /74
/74 /68 /69 /78 /68 /70 /77 /i255 /80 /93 /69 /80 /i255 /96 /73 /80 /93 /i255 /69 /i255 /98 /70 /85 /91 /68 /77 /77 /73 /85 /79 /69 /74 /i255 /78 /68 /94 /68 /74 /85 /98/90/68/79 /80 /i255 /98 /74 /69 /79 /95 /i255 /97 /85 /87 /74 /78 /i255 /68 /91 /91 /68 /97 /80 /73 /94 /68 /74 /86 /i255 /91 /87 /74 /91 /73 /74 /74 /i255 /80 /93 /68
/69 /78/90/73/79 /73 /77 /80 /70 /69 /80 /85 /70 /i255 /78 /87 /80 /73 /68 /77 /99
90
/0 /1 /i255 /3 /4 /5 /i255 /6 /7 /5 /4 /5 /i255 /8 /9 /6 /5 /4 /10 /11 /12 /5 /4 /9/13/5/9 /6 /14 /15 /i255 /16 /14 /4 /6 /9 /5 /4 /17 /7 /8 /16 /i255 /11 /16 /16 /11 /4 /6 /18 /9 /8 /6 /8 /5 /17 /i255 /6 /7 /14 /6 /i255 /19 /11 /18 /15 /0 /i255/13/14/20 /5 /i255 /17 /5 /9 /17 /5 /i255 /6 /11
/5 /21 /16 /15 /11 /4 /5 /i255 /22 /5 /23 /11 /4 /5 /i255 /17 /5 /6 /6 /8 /9 /10 /i255 /6 /7 /5 /i255 /18 /16 /0 /14 /6 /5 /0 /i255 /14 /0/13/8/9 /8 /17 /6 /4 /14 /6 /11 /4 /i255 /24 /11 /22 /i255 /0 /5 /17 /25 /4 /8 /16 /6 /8 /11 /9 /26
/i255
/27 /1 /i255/28 /29 /30 /30 /31 /32 /33 /i255 /35 /36/37/29/38 /29 /39 /40 /41 /31 /40 /42 /41 /i255 /43 /41 /42 /44 /33 /39 /39 /i255 /45
/14 /1 /i255/46/8/15 /15 /i255 /47 /11 /18 /i255 /7 /14 /12 /5 /i255 /6 /7 /5 /i255 /12 /8 /15 /15 /14 /10 /5 /i255 /48 /49 /i255 /17 /6 /14 /23 /23 /i255/13/5 /13/22/5 /4 /i255 /15 /5 /14 /0 /i255 /14 /9 /0 /i255 /16 /5 /4 /23 /11 /4/13/i255/6 /7 /5 /i255 /4 /5 /25 /4 /18 /8 /6/13/5/9 /6 /i255 /16 /4 /11 /25 /5 /17 /17 /50
/11 /4 /i255 /0 /11 /i255 /47 /11 /18 /i255 /19 /14 /9 /6 /i255 /6 /11 /i255 /18 /17 /5 /i255 /14 /i255 /6 /7 /8 /4 /0 /i255 /16 /14 /4 /6 /47 /i255 /4 /5 /25 /4 /18 /8 /6 /5 /4 /26
/22 /1 /i255 /51 /23/i255 /47 /11 /18 /i255 /18 /17 /5 /i255 /14 /i255 /4 /5 /25 /4 /18 /8 /6 /5 /4 /50 /i255 /19 /8 /15 /15 /i255 /47 /11 /18 /i255 /0 /8 /4 /5 /25 /6 /52 /25 /11 /9 /6 /4 /14 /25 /6 /i255 /53 /14 /15 /15 /11 /19 /5 /0 /i255 /23 /11 /4 /i255 /16 /4 /11 /23 /5 /17 /17 /8 /11 /9 /14 /15 /i255 /17 /5/4 /12 /5 /17 /54 /i255 /11 /4
/25/4 /5 /14 /6 /5 /i255 /14 /i255 /4 /5 /55 /18 /5 /17 /6 /i255 /23 /11 /4 /i255 /16 /4 /11 /16 /11 /17 /14 /15 /i255 /53 /49 /56 /57 /54 /i255 /6 /11 /i255 /4 /5 /25 /5 /8 /12 /5 /i255/13/18/15 /6 /8 /16 /15 /5 /i255 /16 /4 /11 /16 /11 /17 /14 /15 /17
/25 /1 /i255 /51 /23/i255 /14 /9 /i255 /49 /56 /57 /50 /i255 /19 /7 /14 /6 /i255 /8 /17 /i255 /47 /11 /18 /4 /i255 /16 /4 /11 /25 /5 /17 /17 /i255 /23 /11 /4 /i255 /6 /7 /5 /i255 /25 /11 /9 /17 /18 /15 /6 /14 /9 /6 /i255 /17 /5 /15 /5 /25 /6 /8 /11 /9 /26
/0 /1 /i255 /58/8/13/8/9 /10 /i255 /23 /11 /4 /i255 /22 /5 /10 /8 /9 /9 /8 /9 /10 /i255 /6 /7 /8 /17 /i255 /16 /4 /11 /25 /5 /17 /17 /i255 /53 /17 /5 /5 /i255 /25 /11/13/13/5/9 /6 /17 /i255 /8 /9 /i255 /59 /60 /i255 /14 /9 /0 /i255 /59 /61 /54
/5 /1 /i255 /46/8 /15 /15 /i255 /47 /11 /18 /i255 /16 /5 /4 /23 /11 /4/13/i255/14 /i255 /62 /15 /5 /14 /0 /5 /4 /17 /7 /8 /16 /i255 /14 /17 /17 /5 /17 /17/13/5/9 /6 /63 /i255 /53 /16 /7 /47 /17 /8 /11 /15 /11 /10 /8 /25 /14 /15 /i255 /16 /4 /11 /23 /8 /15 /5 /54 /i255 /11 /23 /i255 /6 /7 /5/i255 /23 /8 /9 /14 /15 /8 /17 /6 /i255 /16 /4 /8 /11 /4
/6 /11/i255 /11 /23 /23 /5 /4 /26
/23 /1 /i255 /46/7 /14 /6 /i255 /15 /5 /12 /5 /15 /i255 /11 /23 /i255 /22 /14 /25 /20 /10 /4 /11 /18 /9 /0 /i255 /14 /17 /17 /5 /17 /17/13/5/9 /6 /i255 /19 /8 /15 /15 /i255 /22 /5 /i255 /16 /5 /4 /23 /11 /4/13/5/0 /26 /i255
/i255
/51 /i255 /4 /5 /25 /11 /10 /9 /8 /64 /5 /i255 /6 /7/8 /17 /i255 /8 /17 /i255 /14 /i255 /15 /11 /6 /i255 /11 /23 /i255 /6 /7 /11 /18 /10 /7 /6 /17 /i255 /14 /9 /0 /i255 /55 /18 /5 /17 /6 /8 /11 /9 /17 /i255 /6 /11 /i255 /16 /4 /11 /25 /5 /17 /17 /i255
/1 /i255 /i255 /65 /5 /17 /6 /i255 /19 /8 /17 /7 /5 /17 /i255 /19 /8 /6 /7 /i255/47 /11 /18 /4 /i255 /9 /5 /21 /6
/17 /6 /5 /16 /17 /i255 /6 /11 /i255 /17 /18 /25 /25/5 /17 /17 /23 /18 /15 /15 /47 /i255 /23 /8 /15 /15 /i255 /6 /7 /8 /17 /i255 /25 /4 /8 /6 /8 /25 /14 /15 /i255 /16 /11 /17 /8 /6 /8 /11 /9 /66
/i255
/67 /15 /8 /9 /6
/i255
91
Village of Sister Bay
Board Report
Meeting Date: November 17, 2026
Amount Total
177,343.52$
31,107.76
Village Total 208,451.28$
244.78$
-
-
Minor Funds Total 244.78$
Debt Service Village -$
Special Revenue -
Marina -
Utilities -
Debt Service Total -$
-$
-
CIP/TIF total -$
10,272.62$
45,813.84
1,188.17
-
Utility total 57,274.63$
16,533.57$
1,373.26$
934.04$
Marina Total 18,840.87$
Net payroll:
10/02, 10/16, 10/30
and Admin's last
paycheck 131,956.54$
8,459.54
19,130.54
Payroll/taxes total 159,546.62$
444,358.18$
Respectfully submitted,
Volodymyr Gannik
Bank fees & bills paid electronically
Staff members have carefully reviewed the following bills and are recommending
that they all be approved.
Bills By Type
Village bills prepaid
Bank fees & bills paid electronically
Special Revenue Funds bills
Special Revenue Sales Tax
Financial Specialist/Village Treasurer
Retirement paid online
TOTAL ALL BILLS
CIP/TIF bills prepaid
CIP/TIF Bank fees paid electronically
Water fund bills prepaid
Collection fund bills prepaid
Bank fees & bills paid electronically
State taxes paid online
Wastewater fund bills prepaid
Marina bills prepaid
Marina sales tax
Marina credit card fees & bills paid by EFT
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
VILLAGE OF SISTER BAY
Vendor Vendor Name Invoice Number
1001364
10013 MetLife Cust#268973 S
1001365
10013 Sarah Bertges NOV 2026
1001375
10013 Caliber Collision 3804001400
1001378
10013 Dan's Door Co Blooms 191
10013 Dan's Door Co Blooms 191
10013 Dan's Door Co Blooms 191
1001387
10013 Public Administration Associat C-26-114
1001393
10013 Ashley's Property Maintenanc 8521
Grand Totals:
Dated:
Staff:
Report Criteria:
Detail report.
Invoice detail records above $0 included.
Only paid invoices included.
Invoice Detail.Input date= 10/17/2026-11/13/2026
Payment Approval Report - Village Board Format
Report dates: 1/1/2026-12/31/2026
Description Invoice Date
VISION 11/2026 11/10/2026
VILLAGE BOARD OFFICE SUPP 11/10/2026
INSURRANCE DEDUCTIBLE 10/30/2026
POST OFFICE HOURS 11/01/2026
VILLAGE HALL HOURS 11/01/2026
MARINA HOURS 11/01/2026
STRATEGIC PLANING SERVICE 11/06/2026
PRESSURE WASH PIERS 10/29/2026
Page: 7
Nov 13, 2026 11:47AM
Net Amount Paid Date Paid Voided GL
Invoice Amount
-----
160.06 160.06 11/12/2026 100
59.07 59.07 11/12/2026 100
500.00 500.00 11/06/2026 100
600.00 600.00 11/06/2026 100
300.00 300.00 11/06/2026 100
200.00 200.00 11/06/2026 100
4,916.66 4,916.66 11/06/2026 100
6,825.00 6,825.00 10/30/2026 690
251,395.50 251,395.50
Follow link below for more reports:
https://acrobat.adobe.com/id/
urn:aaid:sc:VA6C2:542f3c96-8ed3-479a-905c-509cf3d179f2
99
Page 1
STAFF REPORT
Date: November 14, 2026
To: Village Board
From: Julie Thyssen, Village Clerk
Re: Availability of Additional Reserve “Class B” Liquor License SECOND NOTICE
Background
The Wisconsin Department of Administration (DOA) has confirmed the Village of Sister Bay's
2026 population at 1,229 residents, exceeding the Village's next population threshold of 1,225
for an additional Reserve “Class B” liquor license.
As a result, the Village qualifies for one additional Reserve “Class B” liquor license under
Wisconsin's population-based quota system.
Village Ordinance Requirements
The Village's existing alcohol licensing ordinance establishes the following requirements:
(a) Application for Reserve “Class B” Liquor License: Reserve “Class B” liquor licenses were
created by the State of Wisconsin through special legislation in the late 1990’s and are available
through population increases of 500 people based on estimates provided by the State
Department of Administration (DOA) since the inception of the quota system.
The availability of a Reserve “Class B” liquor license will be published on the Village website and
announced at a minimum of two (2) board meetings following the receipt of the DOA population
estimate qualifying the Village for such license.
Application will be made on state prescribed forms (AT-106, AT-103, and AT-104) and an auxiliary
questionnaire prepared by the Municipality and provided by the Clerk. The filing deadline will be
April 1 of each year. Candidates will be provided with the da te of the board meeting at which
those applications will then be reviewed.
The availability of a Reserve “Class B” liquor license does not require the Village Board to grant
it.
100
Page 2
License Availability and Next Steps
Pursuant to the ordinance, the Village will:
1. Publish notice of the additional Reserve “Class B” liquor license availability on the Village
website.
2. Announce the availability at October 20 , 2026 and November 17, 2026, Village Board
meetings to satisfy the two-meeting requirement.
3. Make application materials available through the Village Clerk's office, with an application
filing deadline of April 1, 2027.
4. Present any applications received to the Village Board for consideration in accordance
with the ordinance.
Board Action
No Board action is required at this time. This report serves as the second of the two required
Village Board announcements regarding the availability of the additional Reserve “Class B” liquor
license.
101
Page 3
AWARDING AVAILABLE “CLASS B” LIQUOR LICENCES
Authority: Authority to grant liquor license in the Village of Sister Bay lies with the
Village Board per Wis. Stats. Chapter 125 and Chapter 6 of the Sister Bay Municipal
Code. Seated board members who own, operate, or are associated by employment by
any establishment requesting licensure from the full board shall recuse them
themselves from discussion and voting on license requests. If the number of individuals
required to recuse themselves from discussion results in the lack of a quorum, a
majority vote of the remaining trustees will be sufficient to grant a license.
Process: When a Reserve “Class B” license becomes available, the municipality shall
publish notice on its website and include an announcement at a minimum of two (2)
board meetings following the receipt of the DOA population estimate. Interested
candidates will submit an application on state prescribed forms (AB-200, AB-100, and
AB-101), and an auxiliary questionnaire prepared by the municipality and provided by
the Clerk. The deadline for filing of applications will be April 1 of each year. Candidates
will be provided with the date of the board meeting at which those applications will be
reviewed. The availability of a Reserve “Class B” liquor license does not require the
Village Board to grant it.
General Qualifications: Applicants shall be familiar with the requirements in Wis. Stats.
Chapters 125 and 139, and Chapter 6 of the Sister Bay Municipal Code prior to licensure.
Additional information can be found at the WI Department of Revenue website:
https://www.revenue.wi.gov/Pages/AlcoholBeverage/home.aspx
Required Documentation:
• AB-200 Alcohol Beverage License Application
• AB-100 Alcohol Beverage Individual Questionnaire (Required for all members of the
business. If their name is on the application, they need to complete this form.)
• AB-101 Alcohol Beverage Appointment of Agent (if required)
• Village of Sister Bay Reserve License Questionnaire (attached)
• Copy of Wisconsin Seller’s Permit Identification Number
• Copy of Federal Identification Number (FEIN)
• If leasing a space, provide a copy of the current lease to include the property address,
parties involved and the dates of the lease
• Proof of completion of a responsible beverage server training course
• Site Plan with on-site parking
• Floor plan with available seating and labeled areas where alcohol is served and stored
• Reserve License initial issuance fee of $20,000
102
VILLAGE HALL PLANNING TASK FORCE MEETING MINUTES 1
Wednesday, October 28, 2026 2
(Approval Pending) 3
4
5
1. Call to Order 6
Chairperson Champeau called the Village Hall Planning Task Force to order. Present: 7
Chairperson/Trustee Champeau, Trustee White, Van Gemert. Administrative Assistant Bertges was 8
also present. Absent: Hanson (excused). A quorum was established. 9
The October 28, 2026, meeting of the Village Hall Planning Task Force was called to order by 10
Committee Chairperson Patrice Champeau at 4:01 P.M. 11
12
Present: Patrice Champeau, Brigid White, Kathleen Van Gemert. Doug Hanson was excused. 13
14
Staff: Administrative Assistant Sarah Bertges, Parks and Streets Director Erik Linczmaier 15
16
Others: Abby Doobie, Erin Peddle, John Lijewski, Steve Bacsi, Paula Anschutz. Via Zoom: Paige 17
Funkhouser 18
19
2. Approval of Agenda 20
Motion to approve the agenda as presented was made by White and second by Van Gemert. The 21
motion carried - all ayes. 22
23
3. Approval of Minutes – April 15, 2025 24
Motion to approve the minutes of April 15, 2025 as presented, was made by Champeau and second 25
by Van Gemert. The motion carried - all ayes. 26
27
4. Comments, Correspondence and Concerns from the Public 28
Bertges reported that correspondence from the Sister Bay Advancement Association (SBAA) was 29
included in the meeting packet. Public comment on the Village Hall's future was held for discussion 30
under Item 5. 31
32
5. Discussion/Action Items: 33
a) Sister Bay Advancement Association (SBAA) Request to Explore Use of Village Hall for Office 34
Space 35
Abby Doobie of the SBAA read the Association's letter into the record. The letter outlined two 36
options for the task force to consider: 37
● Option 1: Incorporate the SBAA into the previously drawn renovation plans (Isaacson plans). The 38
SBAA would occupy space for a visitor center and administrative office. It would contribute 39
toward its share of construction costs in exchange for a reduced rental rate and a long-term 40
lease. 41
● Option 2: If no renovation proceeds, the SBAA would lease the entire building long term. 42
43
The SBAA also requested information on the findings of the North Star environmental testing, any 44
remediation completed, cost estimates for remediation and ADA compliance, and a potential 45
timeline. Ms. Doobie stated that the SBAA's current office lease had been extended one year. The 46
SBAA nonetheless needed a stable, long-term home and was pursuing other opportunities that 47
required a timely decision. The SBAA's preferred approach was shared space that remained available 48
to the community. Ms. Doobie and SBAA representatives estimated the current visitor center at 49
roughly 10' x 20' and the office and work area at roughly 20' x 30', plus event storage. Full-time staff 50
numbered two, with a third seasonal employee. Visitor counts ranged from about 10 to 40 per day in 51
103
peak season, and the visitor center was closed in person during the off season. Paula Anschutz, SBAA 1
Vice President, urged the village to treat the visitor center as a village priority, and noted that other 2
area tourism bodies typically receive space or other in-kind support from their municipalities. 3
White explained that the draft capital budget included funds for planning and engineering in 2028, 4
with renovation beginning in 2029. The funds had previously been scheduled for 2027. They were 5
moved because of the administration building, marina, trail and downtown triangle projects. White 6
advised that members of the public could write letters to the Village Board and Finance Committee 7
to request that the funds be moved up. White said she supported a one-year interim lease for the 8
SBAA, and would support a small addition or "bump out" to the building as a permanent home for 9
the SBAA and visitor center. She did not support dedicating the existing hall to the SBAA in a way 10
that removed it from public use, and asked the SBAA to provide a visual layout of its space needs. 11
12
Champeau stated that the ceiling, restrooms, ADA access and entrance were priorities, and that she 13
hoped to proceed in phases. She expressed concern about losing community use of the hall 14
(including Scouts, Pride events, art fairs and holiday events). She said she would support the SBAA 15
only if it shared the space with a proposed heritage exhibit honoring prominent citizens. She added 16
that the Historical Society's barn project could accommodate some community events. 17
18
John Lijewski spoke in support of preserving the building's historic character, a more conservative 19
design than the earlier plans, an improved accessible entrance and restrooms, and the SBAA's 20
location in the village center. He recommended that an architect prepare a concept plan and cost 21
estimate incorporating the SBAA's needs. Van Gemert asked about the lease term sought and 22
expressed doubt that the barn project would be ready to absorb displaced events. Van Gemert said 23
she was open to an addition connected to the building. Linczmaier reported that the basement was 24
dry and secured and that asbestos and mold had been remediated. 25
26
The task force requested the following from the SBAA, to be submitted through Bertges: 27
● measurements of current and projected space needs 28
● historical visitor traffic numbers 29
● parking and restroom needs 30
31
Champeau stated that the item would be postponed so the task force could gather more 32
information and review the plans. No formal action was taken. The consensus favored exploring a 33
possible addition for the SBAA while preserving the hall for public use. The task force would consider 34
an interim lease request and a recommendation to the Village Board at a later meeting. 35
36
6. Matters to be placed on a future agenda or referred to a committee, official or employee 37
The SBAA's potential use of the Village Hall and future plans for the Village Hall will be placed on a 38
future agenda. The next meeting is anticipated after Thanksgiving, with the date to be set and a 39
Zoom option under consideration. Members of the public were encouraged to submit letters to the 40
Village Board and Finance Committee supporting planning funds in 2027. 41
42
7. Adjournment 43
A motion was made by White, second by Champeau to adjourn the October 28, 2026, meeting of the 44
Village Hall Planning Task Force at 5:14 P.M. Motion carried – all ayes. 45
46
Respectfully submitted, Sarah Bertges Administrative Assistant 47
48
104
Room Tax 2026
+9.7% to LYMay
Sister Bay
Year to Date +5.1% to LY
Door County
5.1% to LYMay
Year to Date +1.3% to LY
Occupancy 2026
+.005%Available Units .......LY 17,406 vs TY 17,407
Sister Bay - May
Occupancy .........................TY 41% vs LY 40%
+6.9%Avg. Room Rate .......... TY $230 vs LY $215
-2.5%Available Units ..LY 132,938 vs TY 129,587
Door County - May
+5.7%Occupancy ......................... TY 37% vs LY 35%
+5.5%Avg. Room Rate .......... TY $210 vs LY $199
Website Traffic | sisterbay.com
June 1 - June 30, 2026
Total Sessions
2.18% YoY
21,278
Chicago
MinneapolisMilwaukee
Sturgeon Bay
Dallas
Sister Bay
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
Top Cities (Active Users)
0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000
Sunset Camera
Homepage
Goat Parade
Concerts in the Park
Fall Fest
Goat Parade (Calendar)
Top Performing Pages (Sessions)
Active Users
3.5% YoY
12,615
Average Session Duration
2m 26s
SBAA Staff Report
Period : May 2026
Presented: July 2026
0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000
Organic Search
Direct
Referral
Organic Social
AI Assistant
Other
Marketing Report
Traffic Acquisition (by Sessions)
+2.5%
105
Reach
72,247
Views (Organic)
419,169
Views
235,320
Content Interactions
13,106
Total Followers
16,903
Views (Total)
26.9% YoY
457,604
Content Interactions
19.7% YoY
9,144
Total Followers
35,061
490 New Followers (Net)
Marketing Report Cont.
Period : June 2026
Presented: July 2026
Social Media Performance
Facebook | June 1 - June 30, 2026
Top Content by Views
Instagram | June 1 - June 30, 2026
Top Content by Views
78.9% YoY
709 New Followers (Net)
195.2% YoY
Some YoY comparisons are not available due to changes in Meta’s reporting.
106
Staff Updates
Membership
We are initiating the membership process earlier this year to improve
communication and invoicing. Members with two businesses will need to
complete a renewal for each. Thank you to everyone who filled out the renewal
form, allowing us to make necessary edits before reaching out to the general
membership. We would like to implement a late fee for membership. A member
paid their 2026 dues on 6/15/26 and though I would handle it more aggressively
(professionally) than historically this would be a good system to put in place.
Village Agreement
The agenda for the July Village board meeting will be quite extensive, so our
agreement has been rescheduled for the August meeting.
Utilites Club Car
Megan Barnes responded on June 29 regarding the use of the Utilities cart. They
utilize it daily and wish to retain possession of it. We are permitted to use it for
events when needed. We have started documenting any instances we use the
cart.
Event Updates
Concerts and Movies (6/17-8/12)
After two rainouts, we finally held our first concert featuring Bacchus Lotus,
followed by a rainy concert with Kyle Megna & the Monsoons. We had no rain for
The Deep End but we did have to consider public health with the very unhealthy
air quality. Thank you to the board members that have checked in with us during
the concerts. You have all been helpful. We encourage everyone to come and
enjoy a concert soon, they’re a lot of fun!
Kite Day (6/27)
Weather was great. Turnout was slighty lower than last year. We wonder if we are
competeing with Strawberry Fest for timing. They had new earlier hours this year
and the event went from 9am-3pm.
Festival of Fine Arts (8/10)
We have 20 artists lined up and are seeking a volunteer for the kids' craft tent, to
allow our staff to assist with other festival activities. PLEASE consider spending a
few hours with us! The full-time commitment is from 9 AM to 4 PM, but we are
open to shorter shifts if that works for you.
Marina Fest (9/5-6)
On June 25, we met with Dave Lineau from the Marina, who informed us about
options for fireworks. Unfortunately, the cost of the barge he rents has more than
doubled, and several vital resources have been cut, making that option
unavailable. The Freedomfest fireworks were a great success, and we are
optimistic that the Marina Fest fireworks will also impress.
We are actively working on securing more festival sponsors and have a meeting
scheduled with the Fire Department to go over their involvement. John Blossom
has taken the lead on the Wooden & Classic Boat Show, and we are developing
his agreement. He wishes to sponsor Culinaria which would be located by
Sputnik at the Marina Entrance. Blossom is enthusiastic, and we are thrilled to
have him on our team.
Fall Fest (10/16-18)
We met via phone with the State Patrol to obtain guidance on our proposed road
closure. We have submitted the closure request to the DOT and are currently
awaiting new maps from Warning Lites for the final submission of the detour
plan.
107
Room Tax 2026
+11.3% to LYJune
Sister Bay
Year to Date +8.8% to LY
Door County
5.1% to LYMay
Year to Date +1.3% to LY
Occupancy 2026
-2.5%Available Units .......LY 17,759 vs TY 17,324
Sister Bay - June
Occupancy .........................TY 62% vs LY 65%
+7.5%Avg. Room Rate .......... TY $305 vs LY $328
-2.5%Available Units ..LY 132,938 vs TY 129,587
Door County - May
+5.7%Occupancy ......................... TY 37% vs LY 35%
+5.5%Avg. Room Rate .......... TY $210 vs LY $199
Website Traffic | sisterbay.com
July 1 - July 31, 2026
Total Sessions
9.8% YoY
27,303
Chicago
MinneapolisMilwaukee
Sturgeon Bay
Sister BayWaukesha
Dallas
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
Top Cities (Active Users)
0 2000 4000 6000 8000 10000
Sunset Camera
Homepage
Concerts in the Park
Fall Fest
Freedom Fest
Getting Around (Shuttle)
Stay
Top Performing Pages (Sessions)
Active Users
1.03% YoY
15,503
Average Session Duration
2m 51s
SBAA Staff Report
Period : June 2026
Presented: August 2026
0 5,000 10,000 15,000 20,000
Organic Search
Direct
Referral
Organic Social
AI Assistant
Other
Marketing Report
Traffic Acquisition (by Sessions)
-3%
108
Reach
21,154
Views (Organic)
153,235
Views
120,856
Content Interactions
4,019
Total Followers
17,171
Views (Total)
26.3% YoY
203,408
Content Interactions
10.4% YoY
3,522
Total Followers
35,397
336 New Followers (Net)
Marketing Report Cont.
Period : July 2026
Presented: August 2026
Social Media Performance
Facebook | July 1 - July 31, 2026
Top Content by Views
Instagram | July 1 - July 31, 2026
Top Content by Views
29.2% YoY
268 New Followers (Net)
25.3% YoY
Some YoY comparisons are not available due to changes in Meta’s reporting.
109
Staff Updates
Village Agreement
The Parks committee motioned to pay us a flat fee of $72,000 for 2027 instead of
12%. This process is projected to be finalized for September village meeting.
Howson proposed the change with the potential idea that we might be able to
partner with the village to find a new long-term home fo us. Village admin is
going back to their attorney for updates before presenting the new document to
us.
Conflict of Interest Policy
BOD, please read and sign this document. We have a recently signed copy from
Ornelas & White on file.
Membership
Early bird discount has ended. Invoicing will go out early fall. Those renewing for
more than one business needs to fill out the form for each business.
Fall Social
Our Fall Social will be held at Twelve Eleven on Monday October 26.
Budget
We have started putting together our 2027 budget. After we work through some
events we’d like to meet with Bacon and Cora before presenting to full board. We
recommend that the full time staff payroll be decided by the board following
annual reviews. Reviews should happen before our November board meeting.
We have been refunded $1500 by our insurance company for taking the truck off
the account and plan to include a utillty cart in our 2027 budget.
Event Updates
Concerts and Movies (6/17-8/12)
Concerts & movies ended with Modern Day Drifters. Thank you to the board
members that consistently checked in with staff throughout the weeks. We are
already booking for next year and might need to find a few new bands. We met
with Staci Griesbach of Jazz Fest and she would like to make our Sister Bay venue
her Jazz Fest closer on Saturday 8/7/27.
Festival of Fine Arts (8/10)
Weather was delightful for the event. Thank you Sarah & Nora for volunteering
your time. We submitted an anonymous feedback form to artists and we have
received a lot of priase and constructive feedback with intentions to keep
improving the event. The S-240 Temporary Event Report has been submitted.
Marina Fest (9/5-6)
Met with Chief Goldstone and Billy Appel on 7/23. The Fire Department
understands why non-profits pay 15% to contribute to the rest of Marina Fest.
Everything is on track for this year’s event. John Blossom is taking ownership of
the Vintage & Classic Boat Show and is bringing a food vendor to the north end
of the festival at the Marina.
Fall Fest (10/16-18)
We have updated our Fall Fest permit structure. Sent out forms for ping pong
drop, parade registration, permits, and Volunteer of the Year submissions.
Marketing designs are almost done and we’ve started to order merch. A&C is full
and we’re continuing to collect payments. We are still in the process of working
with the DOT, State Patrol, and the Village to get the new road closure approved.
We have our second safety meeting scheduled for 9/16 at 1pm at the Fire Station.
We’re working on filling our volunteer schedule, so if anyone would like to
volunteer or knows someone who would like to, please sign up!
110
SBAA BOARD OF DIRECTOR’S MEETING MINUTES
Thursday, October 22, 2026
NWTC Northern Door Campus- 2438 S. Bay Shore Drive
(Unapproved)
The October 22, 2026 meeting of the Sister Bay Advancement Association (SBAA) Board of
Directors was called to order by Kit Butz, at 8:01 A.M.
1.Call to order/roll call
Present: Steve Bacsi, Kit Butz, Cora Doumouras, Tina Torcivia, Sarah White, Juan Ornelas,
Nora Zacek, Drew Bickford
Absent, Excused: Ben Ehlert
Absent, Unexcused: Paula Anschutz
Staff Members: Executive Director Abby Doobie, Marketing & Events Erin Peddle.
2.Approval of Agenda:
A motion was made by Zacek, seconded by Bickford to approve the agenda as presented for
the October 22, 2026 meeting of the SBAA Board of Directors be approved. Motion carried- all
ayes.
3.Approval of Minutes:
A motion was made by Bickford seconded by Zacek that the minutes for the September 24,
2026 regular monthly meeting of the SBAA Board of Directors be approved as presented.
Motion carried- All ayes.
4. Financials:
White inquired about the amount of cash we have on hand. Doumouras noted some to hopefully
be used for down-payment of future office space. Peddle stated Bacon wants enough cash on
hand for 6-12 months operating expenses. Fall Fest expenses are still processing and not
reflected yet. A motion was made by Doumouras, seconded by White that the financials for
September 2026 be approved as presented. Motion carried- All ayes.
5. Village Board Report:
Bacsi informed board that Ben Andrews has resigned and the Village Board has finalized a
separation agreement for his resignation. Looking to hire interim administrator while searching
for a replacement. Strategic planning meetings with the board are scheduled for next week. The
village clerk is temporarily monitoring incoming administrative emails and correspondence, while
Bell will temporarily handle matters requiring executive approval. Joy Lang of Jerry’s Flowers
has been recognized for her years of beautifying the village with her flowers. The village board
has approved the lowest bidder for the Marina project and might begin demolition as soon as
mid-November.
111
6. Discussion/Action Item:
A. Committee updates:
1. HR Committee: Butz said no current update. They haven’t met recently, but do have
Google Doc going around with committee members. Hoping to have updated for the new
year.
2. Policy Committee: Bickford stated that Doobie sent out proposed new bylaws to
membership, which will be voted on at Fall Social gathering. Doobie said we have
received one proxy so far.
B. Village Agreement: Terms related to waste removal and traffic control expenses
remain subject to differing interpretations between staff and Village financial officer. A
motion was made by White, seconded by Zacek to sign Agreement with village. Motion
carried- All ayes.
7. Staff Reports:
A. Updates:
1. Room Tax & Occupancy: Doobie compared August numbers compared to YTD.
Occupancy available room tax continues to go up. Occupancy availability for county has
been down all year.
2. Marketing Report: Peddle stated overall traffic is up year after year. Facebook stats,
especially views, are up. Content interactions are down a bit. Instagram is up across the
board.
3. Office Space: Doobie reported that Al Johnson’s has granted an additional year
in the current location while the search for a permanent space continues. Butz,
Doumouras, Peddle, and Doobie met with Nicolet to explore potential property
purchases. Village Hall remains an option, pending feedback from the Task Force
Committee. Doobie contacted Patrice Champeau, Brigid White, and Ben Andrews
in July to express interest but has not received a response. Peddle hopes to meet
with the Task Force Committee, and Doobie confirmed that both the Village Hall
option and potential property purchases will continue to be pursued.
6. Fall Social
Fall Social will be held at Twelve Eleven on Monday, October 26, 2026. Emails went
out to members about the bylaws to be voted on at meeting. Doors open at 5:30pm,
voting at 6:00pm.
112
B. Festivals & Events:
1. Fall Fest: SBAA secured two Fall Fest trademarks for Door County Fall Fest and
Sister Bay Fall Fest to prevent unauthorized merchandise sales. Looking for more
insight into how to use them and how association members can also use them.
Friday canceled arts and crafts and Ferris Wheel due to weather. Vendors noted
they had record sales on Saturday.
Ferris Wheel was cancelled on Saturday due to generator issues. Dorr and SBAA will
be getting refunded. Parade was about an hour in length. Next year they don’t want
to accept day of registrants. Winning float was Peninsula Aquatics Center.
Two safety incidents occurred, including a spectator struck by football during
parade and a woman who suffered a broken wrist at the soap box derby. Derby
incident was reported to insurance, and additional safety measures were discussed
for next year, particularly with the hay bales.
Ping ball drops were conducted from fire truck ladder. Hoping to come up with
improved ideas for next year.
Zacek mentioned that the shuttle app wasn’t working correctly during Saturday
daytime, but outside of that it seemed to work well.
Bickford made note of how great this year’s barricades worked.
2. Capture the Spirit – Doobie confirmed that Santa and reindeer are coming again
and Santas fee will be donated to Door Cancer.
3. Al’s Goat Drop –Butz explained this is a new event to take place of cherry drop.
Will be held outside Stabbur. Will have heated tent that weekend. Peddle plans to
continue marketing similar to previous years, centering around Sister Bay dining
and shopping before the fireworks and goat drop.
4. Winter Wellness – Doobie and Peddle to sent out communication to local
businesses if they are interested in signing up to participate in the event.
8. Green Tier Update: Anschutz not present. No update.
9.Items to be placed on a future agenda: Moving next two meetings due to holidays. They will
be changed to November 19, 2026 to avoid Thanksgiving and December 17, 2026 to avoid
Christmas Eve.
10.Next Meeting Thursday, November 19, 2026 at 8am at Sister Bay Historical Society
(SBHS)
113
11.Adjourn
At 9:30 A.M. A motion was made by Butz and seconded by Bickford that the October 22, 2026
meeting of the SBAA Board of Directors be adjourned. Motion carried- All ayes.
114
SBAA MEMBERS MEETING MINUTES
Monday, October 26, 2026
Twelve Eleven Wine Bar + Provisions – 10339 Hwy 57
(Unapproved)
The October 26, 2026 meeting of the Sister Bay Advancement Association Members was called
to order by Kit Butz, at 6:02 P.M.
1.Call to order/roll call
Present: Paula Anschutz, John Bacon, Drew Bickford, Tammy Bunette, Kit Butz, Mary Pat
Carlson, Cora Doumouras, Ben Ehlert, John Frawley, Kelly Khemchandani, Scott McEvoy, Joan
Mero, Kalli Mikkonen, Britta Nelson, Claudia Rudzinski, Steve Sohns, Tina Torcivia, Sophie
Widman, Nora Zacek
Absent, Excused: Juan Ornelas, Sam Perlman, Paul Rhistau, Sarah White
Staff Members: Executive Director Abby Doobie, Marketing & Events Erin Peddle.
1.Approval of Agenda:
A motion was made by Butz, seconded by Torcivia, to approve the agenda as presented for the
October 26, 2026 meeting of the SBAA Members be approved. Motion carried- all ayes.
2. Discussion/Action Item:
1. Amended Bylaws: Butz noted the proposed amended bylaws had been
distributed to all members via email prior to meeting, with the expectation that
members had reviewed them in advance. A motion was made to approve the
amended bylaws as presented. The motion carried – all ayes.
11.Adjourn
At 6:03 P.M. A motion was made by Butz and seconded by Ehlert that the October 26, 2026
meeting of the SBAA Members be adjourned. Motion carried- All ayes.
115
2026 Q3 Profit & Loss Report
Sister Bay Advancement Association (SBAA)
Q3 2026
Published on 18 Oct 2026
116
Basis of Preparation
This software-generated report was not prepared, compiled, reviewed or audited by an accounting firm. This report was generated from the financial and non-financial
information contained in Sister Bay Advancement Association (SBAA)'s accounting software. It is intended solely for the confidential use of Sister Bay Advancement
Association (SBAA) and as such the information is not presented in a manner that conforms with financial statements that are prepared in accordance with U.S. Generally
Accepted Accounting Principles (US GAAP), or any other formal reporting framework, which, among other things, may require various financial notes and disclosures to be
included per the American Institute of CPAs' Statement on Standards for Accounting and Review Services (SSARS) or Statements on Auditing Standards (SASs). As such, no
opinion, conclusion or assurance is expressed on this report.
117
Quarterly Profit & Loss Report
INCOME STATEMENT ($) Q3 2026 Budget (Q3 2026) This quarter vs budget ($) Q3 2025 This quarter vs same
quarter LY ($)
Revenue
Membership Income
4110 - Membership Dues (325) 0 (325) (300) (25)
Member Advertising Income
4123 - Map Income 0 0 0 300 (300)
4124 - Social Media Income 0 0 0 3,800 (3,800)
Total Member Advertising Income 0 0 0 4,100 (4,100)
4130 - Spring/Fall Dinner Income 650 0 650 (25) 675
Total Membership Income 325 0 325 3,775 (3,450)
Event Revenue
4205 - Event Activity Income 1,770 1,550 220 564 1,207
4210 - Event Sponsorship Income 15,200 5,000 10,200 8,000 7,200
4220 - Event Donation 794 750 44 875 (82)
4230 - Event Vendor Fees 12,944 7,500 5,444 18,030 (5,086)
4235 - Event Arts & Crafts Booth Fees 4,150 2,200 1,950 3,525 625
4260 - Food & Beverage Sales 4,010 3,900 110 3,489 521
4270 - Merchandise Sales 359 790 (431) 322 37
Total Event Revenue 39,226 21,690 17,536 34,805 4,421
Direct Public Support
4420 - SCP-Strategic Comm. Partnership 141,438 141,438 0 133,314 8,124
4430 - Village Contributions 17,921 17,579 341 17,067 853
4450 - General Donations 600 0 600 500 100
Total Direct Public Support 159,959 159,018 941 150,882 9,078
Total Revenue 199,510 180,708 18,803 189,461 10,049
Cost of Goods Sold
5100 - COGS - Merchandise 12,952 0 12,952 9,785 3,167
5200 - COGS - Food & Beverage 485 700 (215) 615 (130)
Total Cost of Goods Sold 13,438 700 12,738 10,400 3,038
Gross Profit 186,073 180,008 6,065 179,061 7,011
Page 1
118
Q3 2026 Budget (Q3 2026) This quarter vs budget ($) Q3 2025 This quarter vs same
quarter LY ($)
Expenses
Advertising & Marketing
6005 - Website Expense 740 600 140 540 200
6010 - Banner Expense 1,184 1,800 (616) 1,304 (120)
6011 - Brochure Expense 150 0 150 0 150
6012 - Poster Expense 1,408 1,600 (192) 1,327 81
6020 - Print Advertising Expense 2,173 1,395 778 2,821 (648)
6025 - Digital Advertising Expense 2,464 1,800 664 1,046 1,418
6030 - Radio Advertising Expense 336 400 (64) 550 (214)
6040 - Photography 613 3,700 (3,088) 275 338
6041 - Videography 0 2,000 (2,000) 0 0
6042 - Graphic Design Services 625 5,900 (5,275) 4,000 (3,375)
6045 - Sponsorship Expense 3,500 3,500 0 3,000 500
6049 - Other Advertising & Marketing Expense 76 0 76 0 76
Total Advertising & Marketing 13,268 22,695 (9,427) 14,864 (1,596)
6200 - Bank & Credit Card Fees 1 0 1 0 1
6210 - Payment Processing Fees 624 718 (94) 717 (94)
6260 - Charitable Contributions 0 0 0 300 (300)
6320 - Depreciation Expense 0 50 (50) 15 (15)
6360 - Fixed Assets Under $2500 1,273 2,200 (927) 1,226 46
6330 - Decorations 1,479 1,200 279 1,380 99
6335 - Gnomes Expense 793 1,000 (207) 641 152
6550 - Postage, Shipping & Freight 110 0 110 0 110
Gifts Expense
6603 - Employee Gifts (Excludable from Taxable … 30 0 30 0 30
Insurance
6651 - Directors & Officers Insurance 113 129 (17) 107 5
6652 - Liability Insurance 2,018 2,053 (35) 1,786 232
6653 - Automobile Insurance 150 621 (471) 540 (390)
6654 - Umbrella Insurance 359 373 (14) 324 34
6655 - Workers Comp. Insurance (115) 246 (361) 214 (329)
6656 - Commerical Property Insurance 163 151 11 137 25
6657 - Liquor Liability Insurance 100 110 (10) 95 5
6659 - Data Processing Insurance 38 41 (4) 36 2
6660 - Other Insurance Expense (2) 0 (2) 0 (2)
Page 2
119
Q3 2026 Budget (Q3 2026) This quarter vs budget ($) Q3 2025 This quarter vs same
quarter LY ($)
Total Insurance 2,823 3,725 (901) 3,240 (416)
Legal & Professional Fees
6751 - Accounting Services 4,605 5,085 (480) 4,335 270
6850 - Licenses & Permits (25) 50 (75) 76 (101)
Meals
6901 - Member/Vendor Meals 20 500 (480) 361 (341)
6902 - Volunteer Meals 119 0 119 17 102
6903 - Board Meeting Meals 0 150 (150) 18 (18)
6904 - Employee Meals 1,212 970 242 432 780
Total Meals 1,351 1,620 (269) 829 522
6960 - Operating Supplies 181 200 (19) 92 89
Event Expense
7105 - Event Supplies 482 50 432 315 167
7110 - Activity Expenses 2,287 1,950 337 11,430 (9,143)
7115 - Movie Fees 0 2,100 (2,100) 1,980 (1,980)
7120 - Performance Expense 27,940 17,738 10,202 23,325 4,615
7125 - Fireworks Expense 7,000 0 7,000 2,350 4,650
7145 - Prize Expense 469 750 (281) 502 (34)
7150 - Other Event Expenses 2,986 3,500 (514) 3,130 (144)
Total Event Expense 41,163 26,088 15,076 43,032 (1,869)
7200 - Rent Expense 3,246 3,246 0 3,262 (16)
7250 - Repairs & Maintenance (Non-Auto) 0 75 (75) 34 (34)
Salaries & Wages Expense
7302 - Coordinator Payroll 20,191 16,740 3,451 14,308 5,883
7303 - Event Assistant Payroll 462 400 62 357 105
7304 - Info Center Payroll 13,473 15,950 (2,478) 12,024 1,449
7305 - Marketing Director Payroll 16,934 14,040 2,894 12,000 4,934
Total Salaries & Wages Expense 51,060 47,130 3,930 38,689 12,371
Payroll Taxes
7310 - Payroll Taxes 1,169 0 1,169 0 1,169
7312 - Coordinator Payroll Taxes 1,103 1,304 (201) 1,095 9
7313 - Event Assistant Payroll Taxes 0 34 (34) 32 (32)
7314 - Info Center Payroll Taxes 829 1,339 (511) 1,088 (259)
7315 - Marketing Director Payroll Tax 925 1,098 (172) 918 7
Total Payroll Taxes 4,026 3,775 251 3,133 893
Page 3
120
Q3 2026 Budget (Q3 2026) This quarter vs budget ($) Q3 2025 This quarter vs same
quarter LY ($)
7320 - Work Clothing/Uniforms 0 0 0 36 (36)
7340 - Software & Applications 1,436 2,353 (918) 1,114 322
Travel
7501 - Transportation & Mileage Reimbursements 161 0 161 0 161
7510 - Conference & Convention Fees 0 1,700 (1,700) 0 0
Total Travel 161 1,700 (1,539) 0 161
Utilities
7601 - Telephone/Internet 181 510 (329) 497 (316)
7602 - Cell Phone 625 1,020 (395) 616 10
Total Utilities 807 1,530 (723) 1,113 (306)
7900 - Shuttle Bus Expense 0 0 0 41 (41)
Total Expenses 128,412 124,440 3,972 118,169 10,243
Operating Profit 57,660 55,568 2,092 60,892 (3,232)
Other Income
8900 - Gain/Loss on Sale of Assets 150 0 150 0 150
Other Expenses
9500 - Cash Over & Short 2 0 2 0 2
Earnings Before Interest & Tax 57,808 55,568 2,240 60,892 (3,084)
Interest Income
8100 - Interest Income 1,016 538 478 538 478
Earnings Before Tax 58,825 56,106 2,719 61,431 (2,606)
Net Income 58,825 56,106 2,719 61,431 (2,606)
Page 4
121
Sister Bay/Liberty Grove Librarian’s Report Recapping October 2026 Highlights
– Submitted by Christina Johnson
In October, we shared three Baby & Me storytimes with families. Each week our numbers
grew with participation. It’s been wonderful seeing in addition to regulars attending (who
have new little ones), also new families (who are parents for the first time) discovering and
joining us as we continue this series. For October, the first session had 11 people, the
second had 14, and the third session grew to 17! It’s become a wonderful community of
families that are getting to know each other through our Baby & Me Storytime series;
gathering around good vibes and lots of learning going on.
Winnie-Pooh-Looza was fun to host in October:
• We incorporated it into our third storytime of the month in several ways, including
learning about bees and beehives.
• We also had displays for check-out of Winnie-The-Pooh books for all reading levels
from board books to adult books, as well as kids nonfiction books about bears,
hibernation, trees, tigers, owls, rabbits, bees, honey, rain, and more. As things
checked out, we’d replace it with additional related in theme books.
• As for the activity kits, there were many that still needed homes. So in addition to
promoting them within our location, I also partnered in outreach with the local
daycare in Sister Bay and two senior living facilities in Door County as they were
great matches for both our youth and elders in the community to do as activities for
Pooh’s 100 year anniversary season. I also shared a batch with Crossroads at Big
Creek (who was one of the listed partners for the celebration) for their Trick-or-Treat
event night.
o In total, I had 320 to work with and was able to match 290 of the activity
booklets out in October, with 30 remaining at our branch for those that come
by in November yet if they missed it.
• For the countywide Raffle to Win a Stuffy Bear, our location had 17 entries.
122
• For the Friends of DCL “Write a Letter to Pooh” campaign, 44 kits went out to
families from our branch, 19 filled out letters in envelopes to various Winnie-The
Pooh characters were turned back in to our location for the countywide mailing
initiative. 16 of them that returned to us were in partnership with the 3K classes at
the Northern Door Children’s Center.
We held our reoccurring events with Book Club, Wooly Stitches, and our Northern Door
Genealogy Society monthly gatherings, plus Trick-or-Treating at the library on the 31st.
We brought back the Alpaca Tour by popular demand in partnership with the Door County
Alpaca Ranch for our Fall season off-site outdoor learning program feature. The
changing colors of leaves on the trees were gorgeous as a backdrop on the ranch and the
weather was perfect! So many happy folks with lots of great learning locally together.
123
For adults specifically, we had an educational partnership with Laura Kayacan from
Sturgeon Bay Library who arranged a Zoom presentation from Caron Primas Brennan
about how to use DNA in genealogy research. Ours together was featured as an October
event for the Wisconsin Science Festival week held as watch parties at both of our library
locations. We had some members from our two genealogy groups, as well as new-to-
genealogy attendees for a total of 17 participants (6 at Sister Bay, 5 at Sturgeon Bay, and 6
online). In the following days we had several people asking about it and interested in the
handout notes from Caron. A week later a regular patron of ours came in to ask about the
presentation. She then met with some of our club members and may be joining in the
future inspired by this event and the potential of DNA to help solve her family mysteries.
She is hoping to be able to connect a trip to the rights spots in her homelands of Ireland.
Caron’s presentation was very helpful to all, great takeaways, and we’d love to host her
again for other presentations in the future.
124
Sister Bay–Liberty Grove Library Commission
Meeting Minutes
Date: Monday, October 12, 2026
Time: 1:00 p.m.
Location: Sister Bay–Liberty Grove Library
1. Call to Order and Roll Call The meeting was called to order at 1:00 p.m. Members in attendance
were Chairwoman Kingsbury, Peters, Herman, Watkins, Kelly, and Wilker. R. Kingsbury, Johnson,
and Ash were absent.
2. Approval of the Agenda A motion was made and seconded to approve the agenda. The motion
carried.
3. Public Input No public input was offered.
4. Approval of Previous Meeting Minutes The Commission reviewed the minutes of the
September 21, 2026, meeting. A motion was made and seconded to approve the minutes. The
motion carried.
5. Maintenance Report The Commission reviewed the maintenance report on behalf of R.
Kingsbury.
Pest control: Wasp pesticide was applied on September 7. Wasps continued to return following
treatment, although the treatment appeared to be having some effect.
Building and grounds inspection: An inspection of the property, both inside and outside, was
completed on September 23. The restroom heat was set to 68 degrees; however, the rooms
remained warmer than expected because of the thermostat's location outside the restrooms. Three
dead ash trees on the southwest portion of the property are scheduled for removal when time
permits.
Restroom soap dispensers and cleaning supplies: Members discussed problems with the
existing soap dispensers, which can dispense soap unpredictably. The dispensers were purchased
through Warner Wexel, the supplier currently used by the cleaning service for paper and cleaning
products.
The Commission discussed obtaining cleaning supplies directly from online vendors to reduce
costs and improve product selection. A motion was made to discontinue purchasing supplies
through Warner Wexel and instead source comparable, less expensive products online. The motion
was approved.
Kingsbury and Wilker will work with Ahnapee Cleaning to identify the supplies currently in use,
prepare a purchasing spreadsheet, and identify lower-cost alternatives. The cleaning service will be
notified to stop ordering supplies through Warner Wexel.
125
Winter preparations: On September 23, the sail was removed from the building and stored away
from the structure for winter. Winter ice melt, sand, and the spreader are scheduled to be returned
to the shed at the end of October.
Exterior painting: Peninsula Painting submitted a proposal of $32,700 for exterior painting planned
for next summer. This exceeds the $20,000 budgeted in the Capital Improvement Plan (CIP). The
Commission discussed the importance of obtaining additional estimates before proceeding. A
second estimate is being pursued from another painting contractor.
Building locks: The planned lock change to establish a single-key system had not yet been
completed. Jonathan Parsons is scheduled to meet Kingsbury on Wednesday to complete the work.
Landscaping: Members discussed responsibility for maintaining the planting area near the front
entrance, including trimming back the existing vegetation. Kingsbury and Peters will be meeting
with Springhill Landscaping and will address the area.
6. Bills and Financial Report The Commission reviewed the bills and financial report. Quarter-
three payroll expenses resulted in a higher-than-usual monthly total. Other expenses were reported
to be routine.
Ahnapee Hill Cleaning September Service $ 1,392.00
WPS September Service $ 402.09
Frontier September Service $ 399.52
Christina Johnson Quarter 3 payroll $ 120.00
David Watkins Quarter 3 payroll $ 120.00
Glenna Peters Quarter 3 payroll $ 120.00
Julie Kingsbury Quarter 3 payroll $ 120.00
Laura Wilker Quarter 3 payroll $ 1,620.00
Lynn Herman Quarter 3 payroll $ 120.00
Maurice Ash Quarter 3 payroll $ 120.00
Rick Kingsbury Quarter 3 payroll $ 1,020.00
Sister Bay Water & Sewer Quarter 3 + Q2 correction $ 966.21
Sister Bay Water & Sewer Quarter 3 Sprinkler $ 110.25
Total $ 4,161.61
The Commission also reviewed the second-quarter water and sewer billing issue arising from a
previously malfunctioning meter. The Village of Sister Bay calculated an additional charge of $87.91
for the second quarter, based on average usage in accordance with the applicable state statute.
The adjustment appeared on the third-quarter bill.
The total water and sewer payment discussed was $966.21. The Village provided a spreadsheet
explaining its calculation, which will be available for review.
126
A motion was made and seconded to approve the bills. The motion carried.
7. Librarian's Report The librarian's report had been distributed electronically with the meeting
materials. Members indicated that the electronic format was satisfactory. The report was received
without a verbal review of its contents.
8. Quarterly State Unemployment Filing The Commission discussed the upcoming change to the
state's quarterly unemployment reporting process. Although the library does not pay into the
unemployment system, it is still required to submit quarterly filings. Beginning in 2027, paper
reports will no longer be mailed, and filing will need to be completed online.
Wilker encountered difficulty identifying the appropriate government agency classification when
attempting to establish an online account. Because the library commission is jointly supported by
the Village and Town, the correct classification was unclear.
Members discussed whether the library should be classified as a village or another type of
government entity. Wilker will review the available options and attempt to contact the state for
clarification. If necessary, the library will use the village classification based on its location, while
recognizing that confirmation is preferred.
9. Next Meeting The next meeting is scheduled for Monday, November 9, 2026, at 1:00 p.m.
10. Adjournment The meeting was adjourned at 1:13PM.
127
*Library Facility Manager Report
October 2026
10-2--Power outage scheduled for updates, alarm company notified
10-6—Power outage complete, no issues.
10-14—Winterized garden hose. Met with locksmith to schedule replacing lock
on inside lobby door. Estimate received, approved. Inspected entire property.
Met with Steve from Springhill Landscape about landscaping contract. Genna
met and went along. Discovered the upper pond is not under the current
contract. Discussed issues with some plants, walkways. Also discovered the
irrigation system was never turned on. New contract forth coming.
10-27—Fireline inspected and completed annual testing of the sprinkler system.
No issues. Emergency lights and hallway lights out. Breaker #25 was turned
off. Ordered lock outs for the breaker to comply with state code. Install as soon
as parts arrive. Took out lamp for repair. Socket bad, ordered the part. Will
bring back when done.
10-27--Update from Springhill Landscape: Steve is no longer with them. New
contact is Alissa Berken. New contract supposedly coming soon.
10-28—Locksmith has been sick. New lock will be installed on November 4th.
Respectfully,
Rick Kingsbury
Library Facilities Mgr.
414-550-3563
128
Oct 26 Jan - Oct 26
Income
4000 · Contributions
4010 · Donations
4130 · Used Book Sales 0.00 4,744.29
Total 4010 · Donations 0.00 4,744.29
4120 · Interest Earned 0.00 103.32
Total 4000 · Contributions 0.00 4,847.61
4200 · Operating Income
4206 · Town of Liberty Grove 10,472.00 41,888.00
4207 · Village of Sister Bay 0.00 31,416.00
Total 4200 · Operating Income 10,472.00 73,304.00
Total Income 10,472.00 78,151.61
Gross Profit 10,472.00 78,151.61
Expense
5100 · Bank Deposit Box 0.00 45.00
5111 · Insurance
5110 · Building / Liability 0.00 573.52
5120 · Property 0.00 1,840.10
5130 · Workers Compensation Ins. 0.00 253.00
Total 5111 · Insurance 0.00 2,666.62
5150 · Reconciliation Discrepancies 0.00 200.00
5200 · Operations
5210 · Audit 0.00 3,671.66
5215 · Services Purchased 0.00 0.00
5219 · Snow Plowing 0.00 623.95
5222 · Building Repairs 0.00 218.56
5229 · Cleaning
5231 · General 1,392.00 16,564.00
5232 · Supplies 32.57 436.94
5235 · Equipment 0.00 15.18
Total 5229 · Cleaning 1,424.57 17,016.12
5240 · Landscpe & Lawn Maintenance 311.24 10,794.45
5250 · Office Supplies 0.00 2,441.60
5260 · Postage 0.00 204.00
Total 5200 · Operations 1,735.81 34,970.34
5310 · Payroll Expenses
5320 · Clerk/Treasurer 0.00 7,200.00
5330 · Commissioners 0.00 2,680.00
5340 · Tax - State 0.00 0.00
5310 · Payroll Expenses - Other 0.00 784.74
Total 5310 · Payroll Expenses 0.00 10,664.74
5600 · Utilities
5610 · Electric 402.09 4,988.32
5620 · Fire Protection Services 0.00 4,781.34
5630 · Propane 0.00 4,645.63
5640 · Telephone 414.13 3,845.43
5660 · Fire Sprinkler Water 1,076.46 2,349.04
5680 · Water & Water Softner Service 0.00 81.50
Total 5600 · Utilities 1,892.68 20,691.26
Total Expense 3,628.49 69,237.96
Net Income 6,843.51 8,913.65
10:04 AM Sister Bay / Liberty Grove Library Commission
11/07/26 Profit & Loss YTD Comparison
Cash Basis October 2026
Page 1
129
Source: Village of Sister Bay website. First collected Nov 18, 2026.