RecordWell Data

Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission — Agenda Packet

City of Stevens Point · Portage County · Historic Preservation and Design Review Commission · meeting of Jun 12, 2025 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Stevens Point

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

AGENDA HISTORIC PRESERVATION/ DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION Members • Chairperson Tim Siebert • Vice Chair Peter Munck • Alderperson Marc Christianson • Barry Calnan • Carol Molepske • Janet Jurgella Finn (Alternate 1) • Dan Kryst (Alternate 2) Date and Time: June 12, 2025 6:00 PM Location: Community Room 933 Michigan Avenue, Stevens Point, WI OR Zoom Teleconferencing Meeting ID: 893 2919 0217 Passcode: 258101 By Computer: https://us02web.zoo m.us/j/89329190217?pwd=5cq7L hMZ7jbaEJiWLOjb By Phone: +1-312-626-6799 (US Chicago) PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that any person who has special needs while attending these meetings or needs agenda materials for these meetings should contact the City Clerk as soon as possible to ensure that a reasonable accommodation can be made. The City Clerk can be reached by telephone at (715) 346-1569 or by mail at 1515 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point, WI 54481. Maps further defining the above area(s) may be obtained from the City of Stevens Point Department of Community Development, 1515 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point, WI 54481, or by calling (715) 346-1567, during normal business hours. PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that a quorum of the Common Council may be in attendance at this meeting. Opening Section: 1. Roll Call Discussion and Possible Action on: 2. Report of the April 16, 2025 meeting of the Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission. 3. A request from Ryan Wanta, representing Wesley Cabral & Susy Ibrahim, for a design review to construct a building addition on the property located at 1900 Clark Street (Parcel ID 281240832103512), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). 4. A request from Dave Ladick for a design review to paint a mural on the north-facing wall of the building located at 1216 Strongs Avenue (Parcel ID 281240832202932), consistent with Ch. 22.07. Closing Section: 5. Adjourn Page 1 of 29 PLEASE TAKE NOTICE that any person who has special needs while attending these meetings or needs agenda materials for these meetings should contact the City Clerk as soon as possible to ensure that a reasonable accommodation can be made. The City Clerk can be reached by telephone at (715) 346-1569 or by mail at 1515 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point, WI 54481. Maps further defining the above area(s) may be obtained from the City of Stevens Point Department of Community Development, 1515 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point, WI 54481, or by calling (715) 346-1567, during normal business hours. PLEASE TAKE FURTHER NOTICE that a quorum of the Common Council may be in attendance at this meeting. Page 2 of 29 Page 1 of 3 REPORT OF THE HISTORIC PRESERVATION / DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION April 16, 2025 – 5:00 PM 933 Michigan Ave, Stevens Point, WI 54481 PRESENT: Chair Siebert, Alderperson Christianson, Commissioner Calnan, Commissioner Molepske, Commissioner Finn & Commissioner Kryst EXCUSED: Vice Chair Munck ALSO PRESENT: Associate Planner/Zoning Administrator Kuhn INDEX: Opening Section: 1. Roll Call Discussion and Possible Action on the Following: 2. Report of the March 24, 2025 meeting of the Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission. 3. A request to remove the mural on the west elevation of the building located at 817 Clark Street (Parcel ID 281240832201412), consistent with Ch. 22.07(3). 4. Public Hearing and action on a request from the City of Stevens Point to amend Section 22.04 of the Revised Municipal Code of the City of Stevens Point. Said request outlines the approval process for historic structures, properties and districts to be nominated on the State and National Register of Historic Places. 5. A request from James Lucas, representing Amethyst Main LLC, for a design review to perform exterior improvements on the building located at 968 Main Street (Parcel ID281240832201526), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). 6. A request from Jason Bacher, representing Leon Ayers, for a design review to perform storefront improvements on the building located at 1044 Main Street (Parcel ID 281240832202924), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). 7. A request from David Ladick to paint the north-facing wall of the building located at 1216 Strongs Avenue (Parcel ID 281240832202932), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). Closing Section: 8. Adjourn Opening Section: 1. Roll Call Present: Siebert, Christianson, Calnan, Molepske, Finn & Kryst Excused: Munck Discussion and Possible Action on the Following: 2. Report of the March 24, 2025 meeting of the Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission. Page 3 of 29 Page 2 of 3 Motion by Commissioner Calnan to approve the March 24, 2025 minutes of the Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission; seconded by Commissioner Kryst. Motion carried 5-0. 3. A request to remove the mural on the west elevation of the building located at 817 Clark Street (Parcel ID 281240832201412), consistent with Ch. 22.07(3). Mayor Wiza provided a summary of the mural removal request. Motion by Commissioner Molepske to remove the mural on the west elevation of the building located at 817 Clark Street; seconded by Alderperson Christianson. Motion carried 4-1. 4. Public Hearing and action on a request from the City of Stevens Point to amend Section 22.04 of the Revised Municipal Code of the City of Stevens Point. Said request outlines the approval process for historic structures, properties and districts to be nominated on the State and National Register of Historic Places. Associate Planner / Zoning Administrator Kuhn provided a summary of the ordinance amendment request, outlining that this is a required amendment to be compliant with the State Historical Society’s Certified Local Government Program. Chair Siebert declared the public hearing open. With no testimony being received, Chair Siebert declared the public hearing closed. Motion by Alderperson Christianson to approve the ordinance amendment as presented; seconded by Commissioner Calnan. Motion carried 5-0. 4. A request from James Lucas, representing Amethyst Main LLC, for a design review to perform exterior improvements on the building located at 968 Main Street (Parcel ID281240832201526), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). Associate Planner / Zoning Administrator Kuhn provided a summary of the proposed changes to the building storefront, and the intention of creating a new housing unit on the second floor of the building. Motion by Commissioner Molepske to approve the request for a design review to perform exterior improvements on the building located at 968 Main Street; seconded by Commissioner Finn. Motion carried 5-0. 5. A request from Jason Bacher, representing Leon Ayers, for a design review to perform storefront improvements on the building located at 1044 Main Street (Parcel ID 281240832202924), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). Associate Planner / Zoning Administrator Kuhn provided a summary of the proposed improvements to the storefront windows and trim. Motion by Commissioner Molepske to approve the request for a design review Page 4 of 29 Page 3 of 3 to perform storefront improvements on the building located at 1044 Main Street; seconded by Commissioner Calnan. Motion carried 5-0. 6. A request from David Ladick to paint the north-facing wall of the building located at 1216 Strongs Avenue (Parcel ID 281240832202932), consistent with Ch. 22.05(2). Associate Planner / Zoning Administrator Kuhn provided a summary of the proposed paint color and the need for the Commission to consider the request. Motion by Commissioner Calnan to paint the north-facing wall of the building located at 1216 Strongs Avenue; seconded by Alderperson Christianson. Motion carried 5-0. Closing Section: 5. Adjourn Meeting adjourned at 5:38 PM. A recording of this meeting can be viewed/heard at: https://stevenspoint.com/365/AgendasMinutesVideos Page 5 of 29 HISTORIC PRESERVATION/ DESIGN REVIEW COMMISSION City of Stevens Point Community Development Department 1515 Strongs Avenue, Stevens Point, WI 54481 (715) 346-1567 (715) 346-1498 communitydevelopment@stevenspoint.com hƩp://stevenspoint.com Application for Design Review Page 1 of 2 APPLICATION FOR DESIGN REVIEW  ADMINISTRATIVE SUMMARY (Staff Use Only)  ApplicaƟon # Date SubmiƩed Assigned Case  Manager  Associated Permits or  ApplicaƟons (if any)  Pre­ApplicaƟon  Conference Date  Decision   Date Reviewed  Staff Signature  Notes:  APPLICANT/CONTACT INFORMATION  APPLICANT INFORMATION  CONTACT INFORMATION (Same as Applicant?  )  Applicant Name  Contact Name  Address  Address  City, State, Zip  City, State, Zip  Telephone Telephone   Fax  Fax  Email Email  OWNERSHIP INFORMATION  PROPERTY OWNER OF RECORD 1 INFORMATION (Same as Applicant?  )  PROPERTY OWNER OF RECORD 2 INFORMATION (If Needed)   Name   Name  Address  Address  City, State, Zip  City, State, Zip  Telephone Telephone   Fax  Fax  Email Email  PROJECT SUMMARY  Subject Property LocaƟon [Please Include   Number(s)]  Parcel 1  Parcel 2  Parcel 3  Legal DescripƟon of Subject Property Area of Subject Property (Acres/Sq Ft)  Area of Building or Structure (Sq Ft)  6=%2;%28% )/-2+6( ;%94%'%;-  6=%2$;%28%'31 ()213-&6%,-1 '0%6/78 78):)2743-28;-   ()213$1)'31  4%68038 038&0/ 4%686)7)6:)&0/&3=-2+832 %8;)00 7%((()7 7)2)786 %'6) 75*8 Page 6 of 29 Application for Design Review Page 2 of 2 Current Zoning District(s) Current Historic District(s) ­ Local, State, NaƟonal Designated Future Land Use Category Current Use of Property Proposed Use of Property Briefly describe the proposed building, structure construcƟon, reconstrucƟon or exterior alteraƟon. Please also provide raƟonale for the design review request, along with the Ɵme schedule (if any) for the project. (Use addiƟonal pages if necessary) Will the proposed work detrimentally change, destroy or adversely affect any exterior architectural features of the improvement upon which said work is to be done? Explain you answer. Does the proposed work match and harmonize with the external appearance of adjacent neighboring improvements. Explain your answer. Does the proposed work conform to the objecƟves of the historic preservaƟon plan for said district (if any)? Explain you answer. Does the proposed work conform with the architectural design guidelines with emphasis on contextual issues including compaƟbility of size, volume proporƟons, rhythm, materials, detailing, colors, and expressiveness? (Historic Design Guidelines can be found at www.stevenspoint.com) Explain you answer. EXHIBITS LeƩer to District Alderperson (www.stevenspoint.com/Directory) AddiƟonal Exhibits If Any (List): Photographs of Building or Structure Renderings or ElevaƟons Site Plan (for addiƟons, and new construcƟon) CERTIFICATION AND SIGNATURE By my signature below, I cerƟfy that the informaƟon contained in this applicaƟon is true and correct to the best of my knowledge at the Ɵme of the applicaƟon. I acknowledge that I understand and have complied with all of the submiƩal requirements and procedures and that this applicaƟon is a complete applicaƟon submiƩal. I further understand that an incomplete applicaƟon submiƩal may cause my applicaƟon to be deferred to the next posted deadline date. Signature of Applicant Date Signature of Property Owner(s) Date 67MRKPIERH8[S*EQMP]6IWMHIRXMEP 'PEVO7XVIIX,MWXSVMG(MWXVMGX 6)7-()28-%0 6)7-()28-%0 6)7-()28-%0 92',%2+)( ;)%6)033/-2+83()130-7,%2)<-78-2+)2'037)(436',%2(&9-0( %2)<4%27-32%003;-2+*36%97)(*90/-8',)28,)'966)28/-8',)2-7 '6%14)(%2(,%7&))2'3&&0)(83+)8,)63:)68,)=)%67'6)%8-2+ %:)6=927-+,80=%2(9297%&0)74%');)%6)%073033/-2+83%((  %238,)6&%8,6331%78,)6)-723&%8,6331328,)1%-2*0336320 =7)'32(%2(&%7)1)28-236()68346)7)6:)38,)6%6',-8)'896%0  74%')78,)320=%27;)6-783)<4%2(;)%6)%073033/-2+836) 4%-288,))28-6),397)831%8',)<-78-2+'30367-2%((-8-32 ;)%6) 033/-2+836)40%')6388)('309127328,);)784368-'3;-8,7869 '896%0*-&)6+0%77'309127 23-8,-2/-8,%6132->)72-')0=98-0-8->2+8,)7%1)%6',-8)'896%0()8%-0-2+,)04783-2'36436%8)8,)2);)<4%27-32;) %07398-0->)7%1)78=0)3*;-2(3;786-17-(-2+633*-2+8,)%((-8-32-7%073328,)&%'/3*8,),397)238',%2+-2+ %2=%44)%6%2')%77))2*631'0%6/786))8-2%((-8-32&=6)4%-28-2+8,),397)%2(6)40%'-2+8,)'3091273*8,);)78 4368-'3;))2796)8,%88,)7869'896)-71%-28%-2)(*36=)%6783'31) =)78,-7-7%,-7836-'(-786-'87966392()(&=,-7836-',31)78,)%((-8-32-783 8,)&%'/3*8,),397)238%**)'8-2+8,):-);%77))2*631'0%6/78 =)7;)1%-28%-28,)033/3*8,))<-78-2+4634)68=%2(1%-28%-28,)7869'896)%2(%44)%6%2') *36=)%6783'31);)%07386=23883-1-8%8)8,)033/3*8,)7 832)1%7326=*392(%8-32%7 *%/)(,-7836-'-7&)7883&)%:3-()(-278)%(;)8%/)8,)36 -+-2%07-(-2+(3;2838,)+6392( =)7-&)0-):)73;)98-0->)8,)7%1)%6',-8)'896%0()8%-077 9',%786-1)<%'81%8',-2+;33( 7-(-2+ *631*)08>091&)6 70-&6%6= 6)40-'%8-2+8,)*6-)>)138-*%7)<-78-2+%2(98-0->-2+% 03;4-8',)(,-44)(633*;)%07398-0->)%1900)((39&0),92+; -2(3; %7)<-78-2+ %2(71%00)6 (39&0),92+7328,)2368,%78,))<-78-2+7869'896),%71%2=(- **)6)28;-2(3;7%2(7->)7     6/42025 Page 7 of 29 R.J.Wanta Design Ryan Wanta E1750 King Rd Waupaca, WI 54981 ryan@wanta.com 6/4/2025 District 3 Alderperson Ginger Keymer, City of Stevens Point 1515 Strongs Avenue Stevens Point, WI 54481 Dear District 3 Alderperson Ginger Keymer, I hope this letter finds you well. This is Ryan Wanta, and I am writing to you, representing my clients, Denmo Ibrahim and Wesley Cabral, regarding and addition and repairs of their property, located at 1900 Clark St (SE corner at Phillips) St. As you well know, the property is in the Clark Street Historic District and is subject to design review by the Historic Preservation/Design Review Commission. We are excited to begin our project. To be specific, we are applying to the City of Stevens Point Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission for several items. 1. To allow us to construct an approx. 174 sq ft addition. I will also be attaching some renderings and plans for you to have. Why are we adding on? Well, originally, this house was seemed to be constructed without a kitchen. Supposedly, there was another structure adjacent, which housed the kitchen. Pretty fancy. Well, over the years, one was added and it’s rough and cobbled-together, not allowing for proper use and function. There is also no bathroom on the main floor. So, to squeeze in those needs and avoid ruining the interior architectural detail, we are looking to demolish the existing covered porch (which is in pretty rough shape) on the North side and construct, in its place, an addition to allow for the new kitchen. A new bathroom will go where the former kitchen now stands. There will also be a butler’s pantry. 2. To allow us to repaint, matching existing colors. Now, these colors are not in any committee pre-approved Historical Paint color collections, but we are very happy with the current, subtle palette and would like to continue with its use. It does seem very appropriate. We would like to use paint color, Sherwin Williams SW6049 “Gorgeous White” for the siding. SW7566 “Westhighland White” for the trim, and SW7757 “High Reflective White” for the windows, doors, columns, and balustrade. 3. We are looking to replace the rotting columns on the West Portico. Wood in direct contact with cement has allowed moisture to wick up and degrade the existing columns. We are looking to replace with similar Structural Fiberglass Columns, painted to match. Page 8 of 29 Page 2 of 2 We are asking for your support in the matter and are looking forward to swinging the hammers and paintbrushes soon! If there are any questions, thoughts, or concerns, please do not hesitate to reach out. Thank you for your time. Sincerely, Ryan J. Wanta Designer / Sales Wanta & Son, Inc. Page 9 of 29 13'-1/2" EXISITING ENCLOSED PORCH TO BE DEMOLISHED GARAGE HOUSE GAS POSS. SANITARY POSS. SANITARY POSS. WATER FIBER OPTIC FIBER OPTIC ELECTRICAL UNDERGROUND STORM SEWER STORM SEWER WATER ELECTRICAL OVERHEAD ELECTRICAL OVERHEAD 32'-1 47/64" 35'-5/16" 13'-7" CLARK ST PHILLIPS ST SHOWN TO SCALE: 3/32" = 1'-0" ADDITION FIRE HYDRANT INGROUND BOX DRIVEWAY 5/20/25 Page 10 of 29 ADDTION / REPAIRS AT 1900 CLARK ST R.J.WANTA DESIGN 6/4/25 Page 11 of 29 1900 CLARK ST - EXISTING ELEVATIONS NORTH ELEVATION WEST ELEVATION EAST ELEVATION SOUTH ELEVATION SHOWN TO SCALE: 1/8" = 1-'=0" Page 12 of 29 1900 CLARK ST - ADDITION ELEVATIONS NORTH ELEVATION WEST ELEVATION EAST ELEVATION SOUTH ELEVATION SHOWN TO SCALE: 1/8" = 1-'=0" 13'-1 1/4" 13'-6" 1'-4" 5'-3" 3'-9" 14'-5" 13'-8 1/2" 1'-0" 1'-4" 2-1/4" / 12" RISE 2" / 12" RISE 6'-0" 2'-6" 2'-7" CRAWL SPACE ACCES HATCH FRIEZE ORIG. HOUSE REPLICATED CORNER TRIM AS HOUSE ORIGINAL WOOD SIDING BLADE ON FILE AT FELTZ LUMBER 6 3/4" 6'-7" 7'-8 1/2" 2'-0" 2'-6" 8'-11 1/2" 4'-5" 1'-7 3/4" NEW DBL HUNG WINDOWS TO BE ANDERSON 400 SERIES "WOODWRIGHT" OR SIMILAR REPLACE (5) EXISITING COLUMNS WITH STRUCTURAL FIBERGLASS REPLICAS Page 13 of 29 AS-IS ADDITION AS-IS ADDITION Page 14 of 29 AS-IS ADDITION ENTIRE HOUSE TO BE REPAINTED TO MATCH *colors are not in the committee-approved historic color collections* ALL SIDING ALL TRIM COLUMNS / BALUSTRADE / WINDOWS / DOORS Page 15 of 29 (5) ROTTED COLUMNS TO BE REPLACE WITH NEW, STRUCTURAL FIBERGLASS REINFORCED PLOYMER (FRP) REPLICA COLUMNS STYLE: ROUND TAPERED, PLAIN/SMOOTH (NO FLUTING), ATTIC BASE WITH SQUARE PLINTH, TUSCAN CAPITAL Page 16 of 29 Page 17 of 29 Page 18 of 29 Page 19 of 29 Page 20 of 29 Adopted - 03/17/2014, Last Amended 09/19/202238 | Stevens Point - Design Guidelines 5. If vinyl-clad windows are used, they should have permanent exterior muntins to match the existing windows. 6. Aluminum and vinyl siding are not recommended on new construc- tion. 7. There are a variety of roof forms in the districts including gable, hip, and gambrel. The roof forms used on new construction should relate to neighboring buildings in form and material. 8. The historic landscape of the district including green space and ma- ture trees is one of the character-defining elements of the districts. When undertaking new construction, significant trees or vegetation should be preserved. Sec. 5.3 Additions Historic districts change over time with new construction, demolition, and sometimes redevelopment. A quick look at Stevens Point's historic districts shows historic buildings from different eras that were built as the districts evolved, each with different qualities and character. This is also the case with additions to historic structures. Historic buildings may have additions from different eras that often are historic themselves. Therefore, it is important that new additions be compatible in size and scale, setback, materials, and design as the main structure. Poorly designed additions can dramatically change, and often destroy, the historic qualities of a structure. Additions, whether on commercial or residential structures, should be done in a manner that does not diminish the historic character of the building and district. Like new construction, additions can be contemporary, but also should be compatible with there surroundings. Additions shall conform to local zoning and building codes. Addition Guidelines 1. Additions should be located to the rear or non-character defining elevation. With historic residential structures, additions should be placed in a manner that they are not clearly seen from the public right-of-way. Landscaping can often be used to minimize the visual impact that additions may have to the historic structure. 2. New additions should not remove, damage, or obscure character- defining architectural features. 3. Additions should be compatible in materials, design, roof form, and proportion to the main structure. However, new additions should be constructed at a scale smaller than the historic structure so as not to overpower the existing historic building. 4. Additions, like new construc- tion, are representative of the time in which they are built. Therefore, contemporary designs are permitted, but should always be compat- ible with the existing historic structure. Inappropriat e Addition 5. An addition should never mimic or recreate the architecture of the primary historic structure. 6. Additions to historic structures should be clearly identifiable as such. Additions should be set back and constructed at a smaller scale than the original building. Architectural details should complement the main structure but should be clearly differentiated. 7. Large additions to commercial structures can be designed to appear as a separate building, but with a connection joint setback from the two structures. 8. Service additions to commercial buildings should always be to the rear of the main structure. 9. Significant trees or other landscape should not be removed or dam- aged when constructing an addition. Sec. 5.4 Decks The outdoor deck is a contemporary exterior feature frequently introduced in the residential historic districts. A deck is an uncovered wooden structure, similar to a back porch that is located above grade at the rear of the structure. Decks shall conform to local building codes. Page 21 of 29 City of Stevens Point 1515 Strongs Avenue Stevens Point, WI 54481-3594 Department of Community Development Adam Kuhn Associate Planner Zoning Administrator Ph: (715) 346-1567 Fax: (715) 346-1498 www.stevenspoint.com Open Records Rider: The City of Stevens Point is subject to Wisconsin Statutes relating to public records. Communication, such as this document, sent or received by City employees are subject to these laws. Unless otherwise exempted from the public records law, senders and receivers of City communication should presume that the communications are subject to rel ease upon request, and to state record retention requirements. Page 1 of 2 MEMORANDUM To: Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission From: Adam Kuhn, AICP Associate Planner / Zoning Administrator Date: June 12, 2025 RE: Mural Request – 1216 Strongs Avenue ------------------- Background: In 2023, the Common Council approved an amendment to the City’s Historic Preservation Ordinance to create guidelines for the painting of new murals. While mural are a great opportunity to promote local history through artistic means, previously painted mural have had an adverse impact on the buildings that they are painted on – resulting in the chipping and bubbling of paint that is prevalent on our older murals. In April, the applicant submitted a design review request to the Commission to paint the north wall of the building at 1216 Strongs Avenue a solid color. As this wall was historically unpainted, Commission review was required and ultimately granted. Following April approvals, the applicant submitted paperwork to me to paint a mural on this north wall. The proposed mural has an aviation theme, with historic justification included within this agenda packet. When reviewing the mural guidelines, one standard that stands out is that “no mural may be located on elevations that directly face or are parallel to sidewalks and public right-of-way.” Given the configuration of the road network adjacent to this property, all sides of the building are parallel with a street. While the proposed mural would be adjacent to Strongs Avenue, the planned future extension of Strongs Avenue to Union Street would make this mural not be directly parallel with the street. Knowing this, I believe that the review standards for mural exceptions (Sec. 22.07(4)) would be met. Overall, I am in support of this request and would recommend approval subject to the following conditions: Page 22 of 29 stevenspoint.com 1. The applicant shall provide a maintenance plan specifying care and the parties responsible for the maintenance of the mural. 2. An agreement between the artist and the property owner shall be executed that identifies who is responsible for removal of a mural. 3. Photographic documentation of the completed mural shall be supplied to the Historic Preservation / Design Review Commission to provide a base line for future maintenance, conservation and restoration. If you have any questions, please let me know. Page 23 of 29 Page 24 of 29 Page 25 of 29 Page 26 of 29 Page 27 of 29 Page 28 of 29 Page 29 of 29

Source: City of Stevens Point website. First collected Nov 18, 2026.