Agenda for Regular Common Council Meeting
City of Superior · Douglas County · meeting of Nov 17, 2026 · Agendas
Open the original document More from City of Superior
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
1
Regular Council Meeting
November 17, 2026
AGENDA FOR REGULAR COMMON COUNCIL MEETING
CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
November 17, 2026 at 6:30 p.m.
Government Center, Board Room 201, 1316 N 14th Street, Superior, WI 54880
1. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
2. ROLL CALL
3. PRESENTATIONS AND PUBLIC HEARINGS
3.1. Public hearing for comments regarding the 2027 General Fund budget and adoption of
the 2027 General Fund budget.
3.2. Superior Business Improvement District presentation and request for approval of the
Annual Operating Plan. Presented by: Kelly Peterson, Executive Director.
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
4.1. November 10, 2026 – Regular Common Council Meeting
5. CORRESPONDENCE TO BE FILED
6. MAYOR’S REPORT
6.1. Report from Mayor Paine
6.2. Committee and Commission Appointments
7. STANDING COMMITTEE REPORTS
7.1. Human Resources Committee (No meeting to report)
7.2. Public Works Committee (Meeting held November 5, 2026)
7.2.1. Renew the contract with ProPrint for printing and mailing services, including
quarterly utility bills, arrears notices, envelopes, and billing inserts, through
December 31, 2027, at an estimated annual cost of $40,633.95.
7.2.2. Renew the contract with TeamKleen for cleaning services at the Main
Treatment Plant through December 31, 2027, at an annual cost of $28,745.00.
7.3. Finance Committee (No meeting to report)
[20261117R 1]
2
Regular Council Meeting
November 17, 2026
7.4. Licenses and Fees Committee (No meeting to report)
7.5. Public Safety Committee (No meeting to report)
8. SPECIAL COMMITTEE REPORTS
8.1. REPORTS WITH RECOMMENDATIONS
8.1.1. Redevelopment Authority (Meeting held November 5, 2026)
Report from the Chair.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
8.1.1.1. R26-13897, a resolution of the City of Superior, WI, approving the
Report of the Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior in
Connection with Twin Ports Development Corporation Project.
8.1.2. Plan Commission (Meeting held November 10, 2026)
Report from the Chair.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
8.1.2.1. Award the Superior Downtown Design Best Practices guide project
to Ayres Associates, in the not to exceed amount of $35,000.00.
8.2. REPORTS SANS RECOMMENDATIONS
9. OLD BUSINESS
10. NEW BUSINESS
10.1. Miscellaneous Licenses.
10.2. R26-13898, a resolution of the City of Superior, Wisconsin Authorizing the Purchase
of Real Property from O & B Properties, L.L.P. and Authorizing Execution of a
Purchase and Sale Agreement and Related Documents in Connection Therewith.
10.3. Award the Princess Theatre Apartments construction phase project to BP Builders,
LLC, in an amount not to exceed of $497,250.00.
11. BUSINESS BY PUBLIC
Due to the requirements of the Wisconsin Open Meetings laws, only matters placed on this agenda may be approved
by the Council at this meeting.
Citizens who wish to address the council may do so during Business by Public by signing up with the city clerk and
indicating the agenda item they wish to address. All comments by members of the public shall be limited to three
minutes in length. Electioneering or personal attacks are not allowed.
[20261117R 2]
3
Regular Council Meeting
November 17, 2026
The City of Superior complies with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. If you need an accommodation to
participate in the public meeting process, please contact the City Clerk’s Office at (715) 395 -7200 (OR dial 711 for
Telecommunications Relay Se rvice) prior to the scheduled meeting. The city will attempt to accommodate any
reasonable request depending on the amount of notice received.
In compliance with Wisconsin Open Meetings Law, this agenda was posted on 11/13/2026 at the following locations:
Superior Government Center, Douglas County Courthouse, and online at https://www.superiorwi.gov/agendacenter.
It was also emailed to the Superior Telegram and the Superior Public Library.
[20261117R 3]
[20261117R 4]
[20261117R 5]
[20261117R 6]
[20261117R 7]
[20261117R 8]
[20261117R 9]
[20261117R 10]
[20261117R 11]
[20261117R 12]
[20261117R 13]
1
Regular Council Meeting
November 10, 2026
PROCEEDINGS OF THE REGULAR COMMON COUNCIL MEETING
CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
November 10, 2026 at 6:31 p.m.
Government Center, Board Room 201, 1316 N 14th Street, Superior, WI 54880
1. PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
2. ROLL CALL
Present: Nick Ledin, Sarah Anderson, Garner Moffat, Jack Sweeney, Joe Radtke, Tylor Elm,
Karly Caven, Mike Herrick, Rob Hering – 9
Virtual:
Absent: Lindsey Graskey – 1
Also Present: Mayor Paine, City Attorney Prell (Virtual), Chief of Staff Bernacki, City Clerk
Blunt, Deputy City Clerk Bacon
3. PRESENTATIONS AND PUBLIC HEARINGS
4. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
4.1. October 20, 2026 – Regular Common Council Meeting
MOTION TO APPROVE by President Herrick, was seconded by Councilor Elm,
and carried.
5. CORRESPONDENCE TO BE FILED
6. MAYOR’S REPORT
6.1. Report from Mayor Paine
6.2. 2027 Budget
7. STANDING COMMITTEE REPORTS
7.1. Human Resources Committee (Meeting held October 19, 2026)
Report from Councilor Sweeney.
RECOMMENDATIONS:
7.1.1. Approve request to adjust the wage placement of all non-union Fire Positions
and move current Battalion Chief Miner to Step 7 effective October 1, 2026.
MOTION TO APPROVE only moving current Battalion Chief Miner to
Step 7 effective October 1, 2026 by Councilor Sweeney, was seconded by
President Herrick, and carried.
[20261117R 14]
2
Regular Council Meeting
November 10, 2026
7.1.2. Approve O26-4442, an ordinance introduced by the Human Resources
Committee amending City Code Chapter 2, Article II, Section 53,
Compensation for Alderperson to update Council salary and increase pay for
elected Council President.
MOTION TO APPROVE by Councilor Sweeney, was seconded by
Councilor Caven.
MOTION TO AMEND by striking “$7,744.97” and replacing with
“$12,843.00” by Vice President Moffat. There was no second to the motion.
Motion fails.
MOTION TO AMEND to adding a sentence at the end of Section 2-53 that
reads, “Upon completion of the Council President’s term, their salary will
revert to the salary of the other alderpersons.” by President Herrick, was
seconded by Councilor Caven, and carried via voice vote.
There was no objection to Councilor Elm’s request to add Councilor
Graskey’s memo to the Council Agenda Packet.
MOTION TO AMEND by striking “$75.00 per month” and replacing with
“$500.00 per year” by President Herrick, was seconded by Councilor
Hering, and carried via voice vote.
MOTION TO APPROVE as amended carried by roll call vote:
Yes – Ledin, Anderson, Moffat, Sweeney, Radtke, Elm, Caven, Herrick (8)
No – Hering (1)
7.1.3. Approve a 3.4% cost of living increase for all non-union employees, effective
January 1, 2027.
MOTION TO APPROVE by Councilor Caven, was seconded by Councilor
Ledin, and carried. President Herrick abstained from vote.
7.2. Public Works Committee (No meeting to report)
7.3. Finance Committee (Meeting held October 27, 2026)
Report from Councilor Sweeney.
7.4. Licenses and Fees Committee (Meeting held October 19, 2026)
Report from Vice Chair Herrick.
7.5. Public Safety Committee (No meeting to report)
8. SPECIAL COMMITTEE REPORTS
[20261117R 15]
3
Regular Council Meeting
November 10, 2026
8.1. REPORTS WITH RECOMMENDATIONS
8.2. REPORTS SANS RECOMMENDATIONS
8.2.1. Urban Forestry Tree Board (Meeting held October 15, 2026)
Report from the Chair.
8.2.2. Golf Course Committee (Meeting held October 22, 2026)
Report from Councilor Hering.
There was no objection to moving report to the end of the meeting.
8.2.3. Historic Preservation Committee (Meeting held October 28, 2026)
Report from the Chair.
9. OLD BUSINESS
10. NEW BUSINESS
10.1. Approve O26-4449, an ordinance introduced by the Common Council of the City of
Superior amending City Code Chapter 112 – Traffic Code, Schedule J, Accessible
Parking Zones, to Add Accessible Parking signage at 1514 North 19th Street.
MOTION TO APPROVE by Councilor Elm, was seconded by Councilor
Anderson, and carried.
10.2. Approve O26-4450, an ordinance introduced by the Common Council of the City of
Superior amending City Code Chapter 112 – Traffic Code, Schedule J, Accessible
Parking Zones, to Add Do Not Block Sidewalk accessible parking signage at 710
Clough Avenue.
MOTION TO APPROVE by Councilor Elm, was seconded by Councilor
Anderson, and carried.
10.3. Approve O26-4451, an ordinance introduced by the Common Council of the City of
Superior amending City Code Chapter 112 – Traffic Code, Schedule J, Accessible
Parking Zones, to Add Do Not Block Sidewalk accessible parking signage at 1314
Birch Avenue.
MOTION TO APPROVE by Councilor Radtke, was seconded by Councilor Elm,
and carried.
10.4. Approve R26-13895, a resolution approving the Amendment to the Project Plan for
Tax Incremental District No. 14.
There was no objection to inviting Ehler’s representative Sean Lentz, Senior
Municipal Advisor, to present on the TID projects and amendments.
[20261117R 16]
4
Regular Council Meeting
November 10, 2026
MOTION TO APPROVE by Vice President Moffat, was seconded by Councilor
Elm, and carried.
10.5. Approve R26-13896, a resolution approving the Amendment to the Project Plan for
Tax Incremental District No. 18.
MOTION TO APPROVE by Vice President Moffat, was seconded by Councilor
Elm, and carried.
11. BUSINESS BY PUBLIC
Meeting adjourned at 8:14 p.m.
Respectfully submitted,
Heidi Blunt, City Clerk
Superior, Wisconsin
Approved this 17th day of November, 2026.
Attest:
____________________________________
Mayor
____________________________________
City Clerk
[20261117R 17]
November 13, 2026 Council: 11/17/2026
MEMORANDUM
TO: Members of the Common Council
FROM: Mayor Jim Paine
RE: Committee Appointments
Urban Forest & Tree Board
Appoint Robert-Jan Quene as Citizen Member for a term expiring 05/04/2029
Appoint Vern Northrup as Citizen Member for a term expiring 05/04/2029
Appoint Jared Ludwig as Citizen Member for a term expiring 05/04/2029
Appoint Lori Danz as Citizen Member for a term expiring 05/04/2029
Appoint Ruth Ludwig as Citizen Member for a term expiring 05/04/2029
Appoint Councilor Karly Caven as Council Member for a term expiring 05/04/2027
Parks & Recreation Commission
Appoint Richard Kaufman as Citizen Commissioner for a term expiring 05/04/2029
Library Board
Appoint Ron Leino as a Citizen At-Large Board Member for a term expiring 05/04/2029
Office of the Mayor
Jim Paine, Mayor
Justin Bernacki, Chief of Staff to the Mayor
Phone: (715) 395-7212
Fax: (715) 395-7590
TDD: (715) 395-7521
E-mail: mayor@superiorwi.gov
1316 North 14th Street, #301
Superior, WI 54880
Website: www.superiorwi.gov
[20261117R 18]
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE – 11/05/2026 Meeting (Meets monthly on 1st Thursday at 5 p.m.) Page 1 of 4
*Attended virtually
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE MINUTES
November 5, 2026 Regular Meeting
The meeting was called to order by Councilor Ledin at 5:00 p.m. on November 5, 2026, in
Government Center Room 204.
COMMITTEE MEMBERS: Nick Ledin, Garner Moffat, Tylor Elm, Joe Radtke (alt.)
1. ROLL CALL
Members Present: Nick Ledin, Garner Moffat, Tylor Elm, Joe Radtke*
City Staff Present: Chris Carlson, Kara Czapinski, Ida Sampson, Jack Sweeney,
Jim Paine, Mike Herrick
Others Present: Shelley Nelson
2. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
2.1. Public Works Committee (Meeting held October 1, 2026)
MOTION by Elm, second by Moffat and carried to approve the minutes from
October 1, 2026.
3. OLD BUSINESS
4. NEW BUSINESS
4.1. Recommendation to renew the contract with ProPrint for printing and mailing services,
including quarterly utility bills, arrears notices, envelopes, and billing inserts, through
December 31, 2027, at an estimated annual cost of $40,633.95.
Director Carlson stated that this is an annual contract with ProPrint for mailing services for
the Environmental Services Division. The committee recommended putting the contract out
for bid last year, and ProPrint submitted the lowest bid this year. Ida Sampson stated that
ProPrint has been wonderful to work with and that rates have remained relatively consistent
compared to last year, with the largest cost increases attributed to annual postage
adjustments. The committee discussed the use of electronic billing, which currently accounts
for approximately 25% to 30% of customers. The committee also discussed whether a
discount could be offered for electronic billing or a fee implemented for paper statements.
No changes were made at this time.
MOTION by Elm, second by Moffat and carried to renew the contract with ProPrint
for printing and mailing services, including quarterly utility bills, arrears notices,
envelopes, and billing inserts, through December 31, 2027, at an estimated annual cost
of $40,633.95.
[20261117R 19]
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE – 11/05/2026 Meeting (Meets monthly on 1st Thursday at 5 p.m.) Page 2 of 4
*Attended virtually
4.2. Recommendation to renew the contract with TeamKleen for cleaning services at the Main
Treatment Plant through December 31, 2027, at an annual cost of $28,745.00.
Director Carlson stated that this is an annual custodial services contract with TeamKleen,
which has held the contract for the past three years. Staff have solicited bids for the services;
however, no other bids were received. Services include cleaning twice weekly, along with
periodic specialty floor cleaning.
MOTION by Elm, second by Moffat and carried to renew the contract with
TeamKleen for cleaning services at the Main Treatment Plant through December 31,
2027, at an annual cost of $28,745.00.
4.3. Recommendation to approve a five-year extension of the FBO and Lease Agreement with
Superior Flying Services for office space at the Richard I. Bong Memorial Airport to
conduct and provide aviation services.
Director Carlson and the committee discussed the proposed five-year extension of the FBO
and Lease Agreement with Superior Flying Services. Committee members questioned
whether the current lease rate remains appropriate and discussed the possibility of adjusting
the rate to reflect market conditions or inflation. Carlson explained that the leased space is
limited and shared, making it difficult to compare with standard office rental rates. The
committee agreed to hold the recommendation until the following month to allow staff time
to gather additional information and determine whether airport representatives could attend a
future meeting to provide further clarification.
Mayor Paine joined the meeting at 5:11 p.m.
Shelley Nelson joined the meeting at 5:15 p.m.
Mike Herrick joined the meeting at 5:19 p.m.
MOTION by Elm, second by Moffat and carried to hold item 4.3 until the December 3,
2026, Public Works Committee Meeting.
4.4. Consideration of Limited Time Parking on the 5900 block of Tower Avenue.
Councilor Ledin brought this item forward to the committee, as the area is located within his
district. He stated that businesses in the 5900 block of Tower Avenue have expressed
concerns regarding parking and would like to see the two-hour parking limit established in
the city ordinance extended to three hours to better accommodate their customers. The
committee discussed parking concerns in the area, including construction vehicles and
trailers occupying available parking spaces, as well as the potential impact of extending the
time limit. It was noted that there is currently no posted time limit in the area and that an
ordinance amendment would be needed to implement three-hour parking. The committee
[20261117R 20]
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE – 11/05/2026 Meeting (Meets monthly on 1st Thursday at 5 p.m.) Page 3 of 4
*Attended virtually
agreed to research parking practices and options and bring the item back for further
discussion at the December meeting.
4.5. Discussion of Landfill status.
Director Carlson reported that the Landfill stopped accepting waste from WLSSD in May,
resulting in a significant decrease in incoming waste volumes and revenue. The committee
discussed the Landfill's remaining capacity, financial outlook, and potential closure timeline.
Based on current capacity estimates, the Landfill could continue operating for approximately
seven additional years; however, financial considerations will also play a role in determining
when closure may occur. Carlson explained that several cost-saving measures have been
implemented, including not filling the previous Landfill Manager position, eliminating an
operator position, and reducing part-time staffing and overtime hours.
The committee also discussed the possibility of partial closure, as some areas of the Landfill
are no longer actively being used but have not been formally closed. A partial closure could
help reduce future costs. The committee further discussed the financial benefits of
continuing Landfill operations versus hauling waste elsewhere, potential changes to garbage
and recycling services, and opportunities to reduce the amount of waste entering the
Landfill. Additional topics included brush disposal, spring cleanup, PFAS treatment, and
potential resource recovery opportunities. The committee requested continued updates on
Landfill operations, finances, capacity, and future closure planning.
Councilor Moffat left the meeting at 6:11 p.m.
5. RECURRING BUSINESS
5.1 ESD Director’s Update – Received and Filed
5.2 Director Update
5.1.1 Fall leaf pickup is currently underway.
5.1.2 The 2026 lead service line replacement work is nearly complete, with only restoration
work remaining. For 2027, the City of Superior was ranked fifth in the state on the
funding list and awarded $4.5 million for lead service line replacement. The funding
will cover construction costs but does not include design expenses.
5.1.3 Blatnik Bridge Project - Winter Street construction is progressing, with final paving
expected within the next few weeks, weather permitting. Once completed, Winter
Street will provide an alternate east-west route into the city during the Blatnik Bridge
closure. Public Works is also preparing for traffic changes on Belknap Street between
Banks Avenue and Tower Avenue. The center lane will be converted to a northbound
left-turn lane toward Tower Avenue, eliminating the southbound left turn onto Banks
Avenue. Temporary lane separators may be installed near Banks Avenue to maintain
left-turn access as long as conditions allow. Staff will monitor traffic safety and make
adjustments as needed.
[20261117R 21]
PUBLIC WORKS COMMITTEE – 11/05/2026 Meeting (Meets monthly on 1st Thursday at 5 p.m.) Page 4 of 4
*Attended virtually
5.3 Future Agenda Items
5.3.1 Recommendation to approve a five-year extension of the FBO and Lease Agreement
with Superior Flying Services for office space at the Richard I. Bong Memorial
Airport to conduct and provide aviation services.
5.3.2 Consideration of Limited Time Parking on the 5900 block of Tower Avenue.
5.3.3 Discussion of Landfill status.
5.3.4 2027 Lead Line Design Project.
5.4 Confirm the next meeting date as December 3, 2026, at 5:00 p.m. in Room 204 of the
Government Center.
6 ADJOURNMENT
Councilor Ledin announced the meeting adjourned at 6:31 p.m.
Respectfully submitted by Kara Czapinski
[20261117R 22]
[20261117R 23]
[20261117R 24]
Utility Billing Services 1
Request for Proposal and Qualifications - 2026
Utility Billing Services
CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
Chris Carlson, Public Works Director
Steve Roberts, Environmental Services Division Director
Ida Sampson, Stormwater and Administrative Manager
Bid #26-24-ESD
[20261117R 25]
Utility Billing Services 2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Contents
1. Advertisement for Proposals ................................ ................................ ................................ ... 3
2. Information for Prospective Service Consultant ................................ ........................... 4
3. Statement of Qualifications Requirements ................................ ................................ ...... 6
4. Scope of Services................................ ................................ ................................ ............................. 7
4.1 Purpose ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ............. 7
4.2 Provided by the City of Superior ................................ ................................ ......................... 7
4.3 Specifications for materials and printing ................................ ................................ ....... 8
4.4 Tasks and Deliverables ................................ ................................ ................................ ............ 9
4.5 Proposal................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ ......... 10
4.6 Evaluation Criteria ................................ ................................ ................................ ................... 11
5. Utility Billing Services................................ ................................ ................................ ................ 13
6. Subcontractors and Suppliers Listing ................................ ................................ .............. 16
7. Addenda Acknowledgement................................ ................................ ................................ ... 17
8. Qualification Evaluation Checklist ................................ ................................ ...................... 18
9. Statement of Qualifications Reference Form ................................ ................................ . 20
10. Agreement ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ .... 21
[20261117R 26]
Utility Billing Services 3
1. Advertisement for Proposals
Request for Statement of Proposal and Qualifications
City of Superior, Wisconsin
Utility Billing Services
Proposals will be received by the City of Superior, ATTN: Contract Analyst, at 1316
North 14th Street, 2nd floor, Superior, WI 54880. Proposals will be evaluated by City
staff.
Proposals Due:
Proposal Due Date: Tuesday, October 6, 2026, at 2:00 PM
Project: The City of Superior is requesting proposals from qualified firms to
enter into a three-year agreement and perform the following utility
billing functions: print utility bills, envelopes, billing inserts; fold
and assemble the bills and inserts into mailing envelopes, affix first
class postage, and deliver to post office.
All proposals must be prepared on the form provided and submitted in accordance
with the Instructions to Consultant/Firm. Proposal requirements may be viewed
at the City of Superior, Government Center, 2nd Floor, 1316 North 14th Street,
Superior, Wisconsin (darwinj@superiorwi.gov).
The City of Superior encourages the participation of minority, women-owned and
disadvantaged business enterprises.
The City of Superior reserves the right to reject any or all proposals, to waive
irregularities, or to accept such proposals, as in the opinion of the City, will be in its
best interests.
Environmental Services Division of Public Works
Steve Roberts, Director
Ida Sampson, Stormwater and Administrative Manager
Daily Telegram: Saturday, August 15, 2026, and Saturday, August 22, 2026
[20261117R 27]
Utility Billing Services 4
2. Information for Prospective Service Consultant
1. Proposals will be accepted until 2:00PM on Tuesday, October 6, 2026. Any
proposals received after this time may not be considered. The proposal
packet shall be placed in an envelope and shall be sealed. On the envelope
shall be plainly written: the date of the opening, the title of the project and
the name of the proposer. Respondent shall submit one (1) unbound original
(no staples, paper clips, etc.).
2. This is a qualifications-based selection. The Proposal, Statement of
Qualifications, Cost, Qualifications Reference Form, Qualification Evaluation
Checklist, reference checks, and interviews (at the option of the City) will be
used to identify the most competitive firm(s). The City reserves the right to
identify competitive firm(s), as in its opinion, will be in its best interests.
3. The City of Superior Public Works Department and its designees will review
the proposals and select the most highly qualified and cost competitive
firm(s) to contact for further screening as it deems appropriate.
4. The consultant shall submit a list of their subcontractors as a part of their
proposal, which list shall not be added to nor altered without the written
consent of the City of Superior, and as specified in 66.0901 Wisconsin
Statutes.
5. The RFP will detail costs, terms, and conditions. The City reserves the right
to amend the Request for Proposal and will provide a written amendment to
all known parties receiving the request. Respondents shall acknowledge all
addenda received.
6. Firms must submit a proposed cost in accordance with the
specifications. Proposed cost must be written out in words and also entered in
figures. In case of conflict, the written word prices will prevail. In case figures
do not match, the figure resulting in the lower price shall be deemed the price
intended and applicable.
7. Firms not returning the completed RFP within the specified time frame may
be disqualified. Irregularities in the completed RFP documents may be
considered sufficient cause for disqualification.
8. Subsequent to the RFP deadline, the Public Works Department will prepare a
recommendation as to which proposal to award, if any. The
recommendation of the Public Works Department may be subject to the
approval of the Superior Common Council.
9. The Consultant will be required to sign a standard City Service Agreement
(example attached) and provide proof of insurance for errors and omissions,
property damage, public liability, and workman’s compensation.
10. Proposals may be amended and/or withdrawn prior to the proposal opening
time. Proposals may not be withdrawn for a period of ninety (90) days after
the submission deadline.
[20261117R 28]
Utility Billing Services 5
11. Proposals are prepared and submitted at the sole cost and expense of the
respondent and shall become the property of the City of Superior; proposal
documents will not be returned.
12. Respondents will indemnify the City of Superior from any and all debts,
claims, and liabilities arising out of the proposal or the performance of the
project as a result of the consultant’s error, omissions, neglect, etc.
13. The City reserves the right to negotiate with respondents on the scope of the
project, fees, timelines, and all other components of the project, whether or
not the proposal was deemed the lowest cost to the City.
14. Firms may not subcontract any work without prior written authorization by
the City of Superior Public Works Department.
15. This shall in no way bind or prevent the Public Works Department from
performing, requesting quotes or proposals, bidding, or contracting any
services separately.
16. Trade secrets and confidential information contained in a Proposal are not
open to public inspection. Pricing is not confidential information. Proposers
who include information in a Proposal that is legally protected as a trade
secret or confidential information must clearly indicate the specific protected
information by marking that information “Trade Secret” or “Confidential” at
the appropriate place. The City will not be responsible for any public
disclosure of trade secrets or confidential information if it is not marked as
provided above. A Proposal in its entirety is not confidential. If a request is
made under the Wisconsin Public Records Law Wis Stat. §§ 19.31 -19.39 to
inspect information designated as trade secret or c onfidential in a Proposal,
the Proposer shall, upon request, immediately furnish sufficient written
reasoning as to why the information should be protected from disclosure in
order for the City Attorney to present the matter to the Attorney General of
Wisconsin for final determination. The City of Superior recommends not
submitting trade secrets or confidential information in your response.
17. During this Proposal process, Proposer shall not contact any City Staff except
those designated in the text of this RFP or subsequent addendums or
correspondence. Questions should be addressed in writing to the Contract
Analyst, via mail, e-mail: darwinj@superiorwi.gov prior to September 23,
2026, 2026, at 12:00 PM. Please reference RFP #26-24-ESD and line number
being referenced. Non-compliance with this provision may result in rejection
of the Proposal. Final Addendum will be issued by September 29, 2026.
[20261117R 29]
Utility Billing Services 6
3. Statement of Qualifications Requirements
Respondent shall submit one (1) unbound original (no staples, paper clips, etc).
3.1 State the name, address, and company profile, including size, qualifications,
technical capabilities, etc.
3.2 Attach a list of the related contracts completed by your firm.
3.3 Include a list of the key personnel and manager of the firm. Also note the
company’s ability to meet the project workload within the timelines
established.
3.4 Provide a list of all subcontractors, proposed duties and functions,
qualifications, contact information, etc.
3.5 Complete the Statement of Qualifications Reference Form. Provide at least
three (3) references of current or recent clients familiar with your project
team, not including the City of Superior. Respondents shall provide an
indemnification and hold harmless statement protecting the reference for
comments and opinions provided.
3.6 Complete the Qualification Evaluation Checklist and Reference Form.
Reporting false, inaccurate, or misleading information shall be sufficient
grounds for disqualification or contract termination. When in doubt, attach a
detailed answer or call for clarification.
3.7 The respondent shall include a statement that he/she made their own
examination, investigation and research regarding the method of doing the
work, all conditions affecting the work to be done, the labor, equipment and
materials, and the quantity of the work to be performed. The Proposer
agrees that it has satisfied itself by Proposer’s own investigation and
research regarding all of such conditions, and that Proposer’s conclusion to
enter into the Service Agreement and based upon such investigation and
research, and that Proposer shall make no claim against the City because of
any of the estimates, statements or interpretations made by any officer or
agent of the City which may prove to be erroneous in any respect.
3.8 There is no specified limit to the amount of material submitted in response to
3.1 through 3.7, however portions of submittals not clearly referencing the
respective section may not be considered in the evaluation of the firm.
[20261117R 30]
Utility Billing Services 7
4. Scope of Services
4.1 Purpose
The City of Superior generates utility bills for sewage, stormwater, recycling, and
garbage fees on a quarterly basis. Bills are mailed out in the middle of January,
April, July, and October. Included with each bill is a courtesy return envelope (for
single page bills only), a newsletter, and up to three additional inserts. Additionally,
quarterly delinquency notices are sent to tenants and landlords. In October arrears
notices are sent to owners informing them of delinquent amounts that will be placed
on the tax roll. Both the quarterly bills and delinquency notices are printed on
statement stock.
The purpose of this proposal is to select a firm to print the quarterly utility bills,
inserts, delinquency notices, arrears notices, envelopes, and billing inserts. Once
printed, they are to be folded and inserted into mailing envelopes, first class postage
applied, and delivered to the post office for mailing. This will be a three-year
agreement, with options to renew.
Delinquency notices are sent as a separate file to the firm and are sent separately
from the regular quarterly billing. Quarterly delinquency notices can range from
300-500 letters, black text only, with no logo. Annual notices sent in October are
printed in color. Approximately 2500 delinquency notices are mailed each year.
Delinquency notices are printed on the same statement stock (1/3 perf) as invoices.
The first mailing for this agreement will be January 2027 for the fourth quarter
2026.
4.2 Provided by the City of Superior
The City of Superior will provide a pdf file for each insert to be printed. On occasion,
the City of Superior will purchase inserts from a third party for simple insertion into
the envelopes. Inserts will typically be either a 1/3 page, an 8.5x11 page, an 8.5x14
page or an 11x17 page. They may be one or two sided, printed on white or colored
stock, and should be folded to fit in the envelopes. Pages that include a logo, the
logo will be printed in two colors and have black and white text.
The City will provide billing information to the preferred ftp site of the selected firm.
There will be multiple pdf files, breaking the information into groupings of similar
number of pages.
Changes in billing software and continual property purchases or sales make it
difficult to precisely indicate how many of each grouping we will have in the future.
The detail below indicates the most recent counts for each grouping. For all but
single parcel owners, there is a summary sheet that sums all of the other detail
[20261117R 31]
Utility Billing Services 8
sheets; therefore, there are no two-page bills. The number of groupings is based on
an estimated number only.
The City of Superior makes no guarantee to the number of mailings quarterly.
Below is a SAMPLE breakdown and is subject to change:
One-page bills 5,712 11-to-69-page bills 88
2-to-10-page bills 584 70-to-182-page bills 4
Bills within each pdf grouping will be sorted by zip code. Zip codes will be in a
Zip+4 format. Single page bills include the 9-digit zip, carrier route, and delivery
point with bar code. Multi-page bills only include the 9-digit zip code.
Per quarter, approximately 5,712 pages of white paper, color text will be printed.
Additionally, per quarter, approximately 4,986 pages of white paper, black and white
text will be printed. Both will have the 1/3 perforation as indicated on the bid form.
The single page invoices, and detail pages for the multipage bills have full color in the
pdf.
4.3 Specifications for materials and printing
Recycled paper must be a minimum of 30% post-consumer waste.
Invoices are printed as 1 sided with 24# 92 bright paper with full color. Invoices are
black, blue, and pink.
Newsletters and inserts are both glossy light weight papers with full color.
The 9x12 envelope is required for mailings of more than 9 pages.
The catalogue envelopes are being mailed as Standard A mail.
Invoice and Inserts
Item Paper Color Print Size (in
inches)
Special
Invoice-Single
Invoice-Multi-
page
White Color, Black &
White
8.5 x 11 1/3
perforation
Newsletters White Color 8.5 x 14 Recycled
Newsletters White Color 11 x 17 Recycled
Inserts Varied Color Varies, 1/3
page to full
page
Recycled
Inserts Varied Color Varies, 1/3
page to full
page
Regular
[20261117R 32]
Utility Billing Services 9
Envelopes per thousand
Item Color Color Printing Size Special
Envelope White City logo and
address
#10 window Left-hand
window
Envelope White None #10 2 window
for business
address and
mailing
address
Upper and
lower left-
hand window-
either 2
window or
single window
with printed
City logo may
be used for
mailing
envelope.
Large
Envelope
White City logo and
address
Catalog 9x12 Upper left-
hand window
Return mail
envelope
White None #9 return
window
envelope
Left-hand
window
4.4 Tasks and Deliverables
a. Appropriate security measures and procedures for the purpose of
providing security to the City of Superior mail during processing and
delivery to the US Postal Service.
b. Assumption of all responsibility for paperwork and reporting relationships
with the US Postal Services as they relate to presorted First-Class Mail and
Standard A Mail.
c. Suitable facilities and equipment required to perform the subject service.
Printing, Inserting, Presorting & Commingling of the City of Superior's
outgoing First Class or Standard A mail for loading onto US Postal Services
trucks or Contracted Driver vehicles for delivery to local and destination
postal facilities as the mail qualifies for postal presort discounts.
d. Provide the City confirmation for receipt of files from FTP site.
e. Provide confirmation for completion of mailing.
f. Provide approximately 100 extra of each insert to ESD.
g. Provide detailed invoice post-delivery specifying postage cost, printing fees,
and envelope pricing.
[20261117R 33]
Utility Billing Services 10
h. All artwork for the additional inserts will be submitted by the City ten (10)
business days before the files are uploaded. Turnaround time for the
Contractor to download, print, machine fold, insert items, seal, meter,
barcode, sort and deliver to the USPS is two (2) days.
In the event there are more items to insert than the Contractor can machine
fold, it will require hand folding. Up to two (2) additional production days
will be added to make the turnaround time three to four (3-4) days.
In the event of a delay, outside of the guaranteed mailing date, the Contractor
will be responsible for a penalty determined as a percentage of the entire
billing cost minus postage. Timing starts the first business day after the files
have been uploaded by the City. If greater than 98% of the invoices are not
processed by the guaranteed time of two to four (2-4) days the penalty is as
follows:
Any returned mail due to the Contractors error will be re-mailed at the Contractors
expense.
4.5 Proposal
The Proposal, at a minimum, shall include the following information:
a. Provide a brief background and description of the firm’s qualifications and
complete the Qualifications Checklist.
b. Complete and submit the reference form.
c. Complete and submit the Subcontractor form.
d. Provide a description of the method of file transfer.
e. Describe your procedure for sorting the mail.
f. Please indicate if your firm has a USPS Bulk Rate Permit. Please provide a
copy of your USPS Bulk Rate Permit.
Time Percent
Penalty
1 day late 1.0 %
2 days late 3.0 %
3 days late 10.0 %
4 days late 12.0%
5 days late 15.0%
> than 5 days
late
20.0%
[20261117R 34]
Utility Billing Services 11
g. Specify location and description of post office that will be utilized as the
primary mail drop off point for the bills.
h. Describe the timeline from when the file is received to when the bill is
delivered to the post office.
i. Provide a schedule of fees on the bid form. All fees listed should be priced
separately.
j. Provide a detailed sample invoice, listing all items, including postage. If
charges for multiple items are combined, please identify and state the
individual items that comprise the joint line item.
Below is the information from the last billing cycle with regard to the number
of bills produced. Please use the information below to create a sample billing.
For consistency, please assume that all bills receive a #10 white logo left
hand window envelope as the outer envelope, an 8.5 x 14 two sided with
bleed newsletter, a #9 white left window return envelopes included only
with the single page bills. Please also assume that all bills would receive the 1
oz postage rate.
Files sent:
5,712 Single page bills (color)
All black text only files:
211 3-page bills 182 4-page bills 56 5-page bills
45 6-page bills 24 7-page bills 21 8-page bills
20 9-page bills 17 10-page bills) 8 11-page bills
9 12-page bills 12 13-page bills 4 14-page bills
8 15-page bills 8 16-page bills 6 17-page bills
4 18-page bills 2 19-page bills 2 20-page bills
1 21-page bills 3 22-page bill 2 23-page bills
1 24-page bills 1 25-page bill 2 26-page bills
3 28-page bill 2 29-page bills 1 32-page bill
1 35-page bills 1 41-page bill 1 51-page bill
1 53-page bill 1 56-page bills 1 59-page bill
1 65-page bill 1 67-page bill 1 69-page bill
1 111-page bill 1 123-page bill 1 144-page bill
1 183-page bills
4.6 Evaluation Criteria
Proposals shall be evaluated by the ESD Administrative Staff and any others deemed
appropriate by the City. Evaluation of Proposals shall be based on the following criteria:
[20261117R 35]
Utility Billing Services 12
a. Ability to perform requested services on a consistent, high-quality basis,
maintaining scheduling timelines.
b. Cost.
c. Completeness of proposal.
d. Responses to Qualifications Evaluation Checklist.
e. Reference’s satisfaction with quality, timeliness, budget management.
f. Location where work will be done.
City reserves the right to include any other items that is deemed appropriate at the time of
evaluation.
[20261117R 36]
[20261117R 37]
[20261117R 38]
[20261117R 39]
[20261117R 40]
[20261117R 41]
[20261117R 42]
[20261117R 43]
[20261117R 44]
[20261117R 45]
[20261117R 46]
[20261117R 47]
[20261117R 48]
[20261117R 49]
[20261117R 50]
[20261117R 51]
[20261117R 52]
[20261117R 53]
Utility Billing Services 21
10. Agreement
Professional Agreement
For Utility Billing Services
Between
City of Superior
And Pro Print, Inc.
This agreement, made this ___ day of ____ 2026, by and between, Pro Print, Inc,
located at 3920 Airpark Blvd., Duluth, Minnesota (herein known as ‘Contractor’),
and the City of Superior, a municipal corporation, through its Environmental
Services Division of the Public Works Department located at 51 East 1st Street,
Superior, WI 54880 (herein known as ‘City’). The parties to this Agreement shall
be bound by the following terms and conditions.
Purpose
The purpose of this proposal is to select a firm to print the quarterly utility bills,
arrears notices, envelopes, and billing inserts. Once printed, they are to be folded
and inserted into mailing envelopes, first class postage applied, and delivered to the
post office for mailing.
Background and Objective
The City of Superior generates utility bills for sewage, stormwater, recycling, and
garbage fees on a quarterly basis. Bills are mailed out in the middle of January,
April, July, and October. Included with each bill is a courtesy return envelope, a
newsletter, and up to three additional inserts. Additionally, each October arrears
notices are sent to owners informing them of delinquent amounts that will be placed
on the tax roll.
Scope
Contractor services include, but are not limited to, all of the tasks, activities and
requirements included in Exhibit A, “Scope of Services” and other tasks and
responsibilities as identified by the Environmental Services Division of the Public
Works Department. By reference, Exhibit A is hereby incorporated into this
Agreement but shall not in any way restrict the services provided by Contractor, nor
prohibit the Stormwater and Administrative Manager from requesting other tasks
or procedures germane to the Agreement. If there are other tasks identified by the
Stormwater and Administrative Manager that are beyond the scope identified in
Exhibit A, these will be considered extra services and can be added to this
agreement by an amendment.
[20261117R 54]
Utility Billing Services 22
Term
The term of this agreement shall be from January 1, 2027, through December 31,
2029. Agreement may be extended in one-year increments if agreed upon in writing
by both parties.
Services and Fees
Contractor shall provide services not to exceed costs outlined in the accepted
schedule of fees. By reference, Exhibit B, the Contractor’s schedule of fees, is hereby
incorporated into this Agreement and such payment shall be full compensation for
services performed or services rendered and for all labor, materials, supplies,
equipment and incidentals necessary to complete the services. Any charges outside
of the scope of Exhibit B must be pre-approved in writing by the City. Any changes
to services and/or fees must be agreed upon by both parties and acknowledged in
an amendment signed by both parties.
Payments
Contractor may invoice the Environmental Services Division of the Public Works
Department on a quarterly basis for work accepted to date. Contractor may invoice
the City more frequently if additional work is completed. Contractor shall not
impose any penalties or interest for amounts invoiced. The invoice shall be itemized
and, in a form, satisfactory to the City, of expenses incurred in the previous period.
The City shall pay agreed upon amounts within thirty (30) days of receipt.
Insurance
Contractor shall maintain the appropriate insurance coverage, including but not
limited to Professional Liability coverage, Workman’s Compensation insurance and
Employer’s Liability Insurance, if required by Wisconsin Statutes. Contractor shall
maintain automobile and public liability and property damage insurance against any
claim(s) that might occur in carrying out this Agreement. Minimum coverages for
$500,000 single limit liability, or $250,000 bodily injury per person, and $500,000
per occurrence and $250,000 property damage. Such coverage shall be provided by
an insurer licensed to do business in Wisconsin and shall remain active for the
duration of the agreement. Contractor shall provide proof of coverage upon request.
General Terms and Conditions
1. No Relationship. Contractor understands and agrees that the relationship of
Contractor and the City arising out of this agreement is that of a contracted service
provider, not an employee or contracted employee of the City or any other entity
within the municipality, and therefore, is not entitled to any benefits provided to
employees of the City.
2. Taxes. Contractor will be responsible for all federal, state and local taxes arising
in accordance with this contract, as well as any other taxes, fees or licensing
expenses pertaining to these services.
[20261117R 55]
Utility Billing Services 23
3. Confidentiality. Contractor shall diligently protect the confidentiality of any
information, documentation or communication received from the City that contains
personal, financial or other information of a confidential nature, and shall not
disclose said information to any other persons, organizations or entities without the
expressed written approval of the City.
4. Qualifications. By accepting this agreement, Contractor represents that they
possess the necessary skills and qualifications to perform work under this
agreement and is familiar with the practices of the City of Superior Environmental
Services Division of Public Works Department. Contractor will comply with all
applicable local, state, and federal licensure requirements and will provide proof
upon request.
5. Legal Relations. Recommendations, policies, procedures and other
communications provided by the Contractor under this agreement will comply with
all applicable laws, ordinances, rules and regulations promulgated and enforced by
the City and any other proper authority having jurisdiction over the conduct of the
operations of the Environmental Services Division. The Contractor shall comply
with and observe federal, state and local laws that may be applicable to the project.
In carrying out provisions of this Agreement, exercising power or authority granted
to the Contractor thereby, there shall be no personal liability to the City, it being
understood that in such matters the City acts as representatives of the State. The
Contractor is not an agent of the State.
6. Assignment of Agreement. The Contractor shall not subcontract, assign or
transfer any part of this work to any other parties without the express written
agreement of the City.
7. Claims. Claims, disputes and other matters in question arising from the
performance of this contract shall be brought to the Stormwater and Administrative
Manager, whose decision shall be final.
8. Ownership of Documents. All documents prepared by the Contractor or any
party pursuant to this Agreement shall become the property of the City of Superior
on completion and acceptance of any of the Contractor’s work, or upon termination
of the Agreement, and shall be delivered to the City of Superior upon request.
9. Indemnifications. Contractor hereby agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless
the City its elected and appointed officials, officers, employees, agents, representatives
and volunteers, and each of them, from and against any and all suits, actions, legal or
administrative proceedings, claims, demands, damages, liabilities, interest, attorneys'
fees, costs, and expenses of whatsoever kind or nature in any manner directly or
indirectly caused, occasioned, or contributed to in whole or in part or claimed to be
caused, occasioned, or contributed to in whole or in part, by reason of any act, omission,
fault, or negligence, whether active or passive, of Contractor or of anyone acting under
its direction or control or on its behalf, even if liability is also sought to be imposed on
[20261117R 56]
Utility Billing Services 24
the City, its elected and appointed officials, officers, employees, agents, representatives
and volunteers.
The obligation to indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City, its elected and
appointed officials, officers, employees, agents, representatives and volunteers, and
each of them, shall be applicable unless liability results from the sole negligence of the
City, its elected and appointed officials, officers, employees, agents, representatives and
volunteers.
Contractor shall reimburse the City, its elected and appointed officials, officers,
employees, agent or authorized representatives or volunteers for any and all legal
expenses and costs incurred by each of them in connection therewith or in enforcing the
indemnity herein provided. In the event that Contractor employs other persons, firms,
corporations or entities (subcontractor) or volunteers as part of the work covered by
this Agreement, it shall be the responsibility of the Contractor to require and confirm
that each sub-contractor enters into an Indemnity Agreement in favor of the City, its
elected and appointed off icials, officers, employees, agents, representatives and
volunteers, which is identical to this Indemnity Agreement.
This indemnity provision shall survive the termination or expiration of this Agreement.
10. Deficiencies. Contractor shall not be entitled to payment for work found
deficient or failing to conform to the requirements set forth in this agreement and is
not entitled to further payments until corrected to the satisfaction of the
Stormwater and Administrative Manager. The City will inform the Contractor of any
deficiencies and/or items that do not conform to this agreement within thirty (30)
days of receipt.
11. Termination. This Agreement may be terminated by either party without cause
upon sixty (60) days written notice to the other. In the event of termination,
Contractor shall be paid for services performed to termination date. The results of
the work by Contractor shall immediately be turned over to the City of Superior and
is a condition of final payment.
12. Entire Agreement. This Agreement contains the entire understanding of the
parties with respect to the matters contained herein and supersedes all other
written and oral agreements between the parties with respect to such matters.
13. Modification. This Agreement is binding only when signed by both parties. Any
modifications or amendments must be in writing and signed by both parties.
14. Force Majeure. Each party shall be excused from any breach of this Agreement
which is causes by war, strike, and act of Nature or other similar circumstances
normally deemed outside the control of well-managed businesses.
[20261117R 57]
Utility Billing Services 25
15. Governing Law. The Agreement will be interpreted, and the rights and
liabilities of the Parties determined, in accordance with the laws of the State of
Wisconsin.
16. Headings and Captions. Headings and Captions appear solely for convenience
of reference. Such headings and captions are not part of this agreement and shall
not be used to construe it.
17. Validity. If any provision or provisions of this Agreement shall be held to be
invalid, illegal or unenforceable, the validity, legality and enforceability of the
remaining provisions shall not in any way be affected or impaired thereby.
18. Integrated Agreement. This Agreement contains the entire agreement and
understanding among the Parties regarding the matters set forth herein and
supersedes all previous negotiations, discussions, and understandings regarding
such matters. The Parties acknowledge and represent that they have not relied on
any promise, inducement, representation, or other statement made in connection
with this Agreement that is not expressly contained herein. The terms of this
Agreement are contractual and not a mere recital.
19. Guarantee of work. The Contractor shall assume responsibility for all product
defects which may develop in any part of the project caused by faulty workmanship,
material or equipment and agrees to replace work without cost to the Owner.
20. Non-Discrimination. Upon execution of this Agreement, Consultant agrees as
follows: Consultant and all Subcontractors do not discriminate against any
employee, applicant for employment, independent contractor, or any other persons
because of race, color, religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, or national
origin.
21. Authority. The Consultant represents that it has the authority to enter into this
Agreement. If the Consultant is not an individual, the person(s) signing on behalf of
the Consultant represents and warrants that they have been duly authorized to bind
the Consultant and sign this Agreement on the Consultant’s behalf.
[20261117R 58]
Utility Billing Services 26
In Witness Whereof, the parties intending to be legally bound have executed this
agreement on the day and year set forth above.
Signatures
Company Name: Pro Print, Inc.
Address: 3920 Airpark Blvd., Duluth, MN 55811
_____________________________
Creston Dorothy, Owner
ATTEST: CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
________________________________ ___________________________________
Jim Paine, Mayor Heidi Blunt, City Clerk
________________________________ ___________________________________
Nicholas Rhinehart, Finance Director Frog Prell, City Attorney
Provision has been made to
pay the liability that will
accrue under this contract.
*Approved at the City Council Meeting on
[20261117R 59]
Utility Billing Services 27
Exhibit A
Scope of Services
Provided by the City of Superior
The City of Superior will provide a pdf file for each insert to be printed. On occasion,
the City of Superior will purchase inserts from a third party for simple insertion into
the envelopes. Inserts will typically be either a 1/3 page, an 8.5x11 page, an 8.5x14
page or an 11x17 page. They may be one or two sided, printed on white or colored
stock, and should be folded to fit in the envelopes. Pages that include a logo, the
logo will be printed in two colors and have black and white text.
The City will provide billing information to the preferred ftp site of the selected firm.
There will be multiple pdf files, breaking the information into groupings of similar
number of pages.
Changes in billing software and continual property purchases or sales make it
difficult to precisely indicate how many of each grouping we will have in the future.
The detail below indicates the most recent counts for each grouping. For all but
single parcel owners, there is a summary sheet that sums all of the other detail
sheets; therefore, there are no two-page bills. The number of groupings is based on
an estimated number only.
The City of Superior makes no guarantee to the number of mailings quarterly.
Below is a SAMPLE breakdown and is subject to change:
One-page bills 5,712 11-to-69-page bills 88
2-to-10-page bills 584 70-to-182-page bills 4
Bills within each pdf grouping will be sorted by zip code. Zip codes will be in a
Zip+4 format. Single page bills include the 9-digit zip, carrier route, and delivery
point with bar code. Multi-page bills only include the 9-digit zip code.
Per quarter, approximately 5,712 pages of white paper, color text will be printed.
Additionally, per quarter, approximately 4,986 pages of white paper, black and white
text will be printed. Both will have the 1/3 perforation as indicated on the bid form.
The single page invoices, and detail pages for the multipage bills have full color in the
pdf.
Specifications for materials and printing
Recycled paper must be a minimum of 30% post-consumer waste.
Invoices are printed as 1 sided with 24# 92 bright paper with full color. Invoices are
black, blue, and pink.
Newsletters and inserts are both glossy light weight papers with full color.
[20261117R 60]
Utility Billing Services 28
The 9x12 envelope is required for mailings of more than 9 pages.
The catalogue envelopes are being mailed as Standard A mail.
Invoice and Inserts
Item Paper Color Print Size (in
inches)
Special
Invoice-Single
Invoice-Multi-
page
White Color, Black &
White
8.5 x 11 1/3
perforation
Newsletters White Color 8.5 x 14 Recycled
Newsletters White Color 11 x 17 Recycled
Inserts Varied Color Varies, 1/3
page to full
page
Recycled
Inserts Varied Color Varies, 1/3
page to full
page
Regular
Envelopes per thousand
Item Color Color Printing Size Special
Envelope White City logo and
address
#10 window Left-hand
window
Envelope White None #10 2 window
for business
address and
mailing
address
Upper and
lower left-
hand window-
either 2
window or
single window
with printed
City logo may
be used for
mailing
envelope.
Large
Envelope
White City logo and
address
Catalog 9x12 Upper left-
hand window
Return mail
envelope
White None #9 return
window
envelope
Left-hand
window
Tasks and Deliverables
e. Appropriate security measures and procedures for the purpose of
providing security to the City of Superior mail during processing and
[20261117R 61]
Utility Billing Services 29
delivery to the US Postal Service.
f. Assumption of all responsibility for paperwork and reporting relationships
with the US Postal Services as they relate to presorted First-Class Mail and
Standard A Mail.
g. Suitable facilities and equipment required to perform the subject service.
Printing, Inserting, Presorting & Commingling of the City of Superior's
outgoing First Class or Standard A mail for loading onto US Postal Services
trucks or Contracted Driver vehicles for delivery to local and destination
postal facilities as the mail qualifies for postal presort discounts.
h. Provide the City confirmation for receipt of files from FTP site.
i. Provide confirmation for completion of mailing.
j. Provide approximately 100 extra of each insert to ESD.
k. Provide detailed invoice post-delivery specifying postage cost, printing fees,
and envelope pricing.
l. All artwork for the additional inserts will be submitted by the City ten (10)
business days before the files are uploaded. Turnaround time for the
Contractor to download, print, machine fold, insert items, seal, meter,
barcode, sort and deliver to the USPS is two (2) days.
In the event there are more items to insert than the Contractor can machine
fold, it will require hand folding. Up to two (2) additional production days
will be added to make the turnaround time three to four (3-4) days.
In the event of a delay, outside of the guaranteed mailing date, the Contractor
will be responsible for a penalty determined as a percentage of the entire
billing cost minus postage. Timing starts the first business day after the files
have been uploaded by the City. If greater than 98% of the invoices are not
processed by the guaranteed time of two to four (2-4) days the penalty is as
follows:
Time Percent
Penalty
1 day late 1.0 %
2 days late 3.0 %
3 days late 10.0 %
4 days late 12.0%
5 days late 15.0%
> than 5 days
late
20.0%
[20261117R 62]
Utility Billing Services 30
Any returned mail due to the Contractors error will be re-mailed at the
Contractors expense.
[20261117R 63]
[20261117R 64]
[20261117R 65]
[20261117R 66]
[20261117R 67]
[20261117R 68]
[20261117R 69]
[20261117R 70]
[20261117R 71]
[20261117R 72]
REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF SUPERIOR - 11/5/26 Mtg Page 1 of 2
RACS Minutes
Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior
November 5, 2026 Regular Meeting
The meeting was called to order by Chair Porter at 5:00 pm on November 5, 2026, in Government Center
Room 270.
1 ROLL CALL
PRESENT: Anne Porter, Jim Paine (5:10 depart), Rob Hering, Mike Herrick, and Nick
Baker
VIRTUAL: Sakib Mahmud (5:02 pm arrival) and Debra Emery (5:07 pm arrival)
ABSENT:
CITY STAFF PRESENT: Director Serck and Tech Granlund
OTHERS PRESENT: Shelley Nelson, Mia Thibodeau, Shane Sipsas and Beau Sipsas
2 APPROVAL OF MINUTES
2.1 RACS Minutes (Meeting held April 2, 2026)
MOTION to approve RACS minutes from April 2, 2026, meeting by Herrick, seconded by
Paine, carried.
3 NEW BUSINESS
3.1 Public Hearing
a. Sale of real property to Twin Ports Development Corporation (the “Company”), in
accordance with the terms of a development agreement to be entered into among the
Authority and the Company, for the property described as follows: Lots 23 through 29,
Block 11, WEST SUPERIOR FIRST DIVISION, located in part of the Northwest Quarter of
the Northeast Quarter, Section 15, Township 49 North, Range 14 West, City of Superior,
Douglas County, Wisconsin.
Director Serck introduced the proposed land sale the history and location of the property
explaining planned project for the property. Shane and Beau Sipsas attended the meeting in
person and discussed the proposed workforce housing hotel, including the project's history,
how the development plan originated, and other project details. They also answered
questions from the committee members.
Public Hearing was opened at 5:13 pm
Chair Porter opened the public hearing reading the purpose of the public hearing for the
Sale of real property to Twin Ports Development Corporation (the “Company”), in
accordance with the terms of a development agreement to be entered into among the
Authority and the Company, for the property described as follows: Lots 23 through 29,
Block 11, WEST SUPERIOR FIRST DIVISION, located in part of the Northwest Quarter of
the Northeast Quarter, Section 15, Township 49 North, Range 14 West, City of Superior,
[20261117R 73]
REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE CITY OF SUPERIOR - 11/5/26 Mtg Page 2 of 2
Douglas County, Wisconsin. Chair Porter asked if anyone from the public wanted to discuss
or speak at the public hearing twice no public comment was offered.
b. Resolution of the Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior, Wisconsin, Approving a
Development Agreement with Genesis Attachments, LLC
• Draft Development Agreement
MOTION to close the Public Hearing at 5:14 pm and to approve the Resolution of the
Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior, Wisconsin, approving a Development
Agreement with Twin Ports Development Corporation by Baker, seconded by Herrick,
carried.
4 ADJOURNMENT 5:14 PM
Respectfully submitted by Amanda Granlund.
[20261117R 74]
RESOLUTION NO. R26-13897
Alderperson __________________ introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN ,
APPROVING THE REPORT OF THE REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY
OF THE CITY OF SUPERIOR IN CONNECTION WITH TWIN PORTS
DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION PROJECT
WHEREAS, the Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior (the “Authority”) is a
redevelopment authority duly organized by the City of Superior, Wisconsin (the “City”) pursuant
to the provisions of Wisconsin Statutes, Section 66.1333 (the “Act”); and
WHEREAS, the City and the Authority have encouraged and furthered redevelopment
and utilization of property within the City for business and other purposes, particularly property
located in the north Tower Avenue area of the City ; and
WHEREAS, representatives of the Authority have been negotiating with Twin Ports
Development Corporation (the “Company”) regarding the purchase of real property by the
Company and has requested that the Authority sell the real p roperty described on Exhibit A
hereto (the “Development Property”) to the Company in connection with the construction of a
30-unit extended-stay workforce hotel and related parking on Tower Avenue and N. 4th Street for
use as workforce housing for the upcoming Blatnik Bridge replacement project, to be constructed
by the Company on the Development Property; and
WHEREAS, the City and the Authority have determined to provide assistance to the
Company through a development grant and other actions to encourage such developments; and
WHEREAS, the City and the Authority agree that the redevelopment of the Development
Property will be crucial to the achievement of a sound and coordinated development and
redevelopment of such area in general and to the inducement of private development in
particular; and
WHEREAS, the Authority and the Company have proposed to enter into a development
agreement regarding the purchase of the Development Property by the Company and the
construction of the Project; and
WHEREAS, the terms and conditions of the development are set forth in the
Development Agreement to be entered into between the Authority and the Company (the
“Development Agreement”), the form of which has been provided to the Alderpersons and is on
file in the office of the City Clerk; and
WHEREAS, following the Authority’s approval of the Development Agreement on
November 5 , 20 26, the Authority reported to the Council on the terms, conditions and other
material provisions of such transaction as required by Wis. Sta t. § 66.1333(9) (a)1.d., which
included a transmittal from the Authority’s Executive Director and the form of the Development
Agreement (the “Report”); and
[20261117R 75]
WHEREAS, the City and the Authority agree that the development of the Development
Property by the Project will promote and carry out the development objectives of the City and
the Authority and will provide renewal and redevelopment within the City.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED, as follows:
1. The Council hereby approves the Report.
Adopted: November 17, 2026.
________________________________
Attest: Mayor
___________________________________
City Clerk
The motion for the adoption of the foregoing resolution was duly seconded by Alderperson
_________________ and, upon vote being taken thereon, the following voted in favor thereof:
and the following voted against the same:
and the following were absent:
whereupon, the resolution was declared duly passed and adopted and was approved and signed
by the Mayor, whose signature was attested by the City Clerk.
08493\000373\1F68836.DOC
[20261117R 76]
EXHIBIT A
Legal Description of Development Property
Lots 23 through 29, Block 11, WEST SUPERIOR FIRST DIVISION, located in part of the
Northwest Quarter of the Northeast Quarter, Section 15, Township 49 North, Range 14 West,
City of Superior, Douglas County, Wisconsin.
[20261117R 77]
[20261117R 78]
Draft: November 13, 2026
______________________________________________________________________________
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
BETWEEN
REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE
CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
AND
TWIN PORTS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
DATED AS OF NOVEMBER ___, 2026
______________________________________________________________________________
Drafted by:
Fryberger, Buchanan, Smith & Frederick, P.A.
302 West Superior Street, Suite 700
Duluth, Minnesota 55802
08493\000373\1EY0061.DOCX
[20261117R 79]
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Section 1. Definitions, Exhibits, Rules of Interpretation ......................................................... 1
1.01 Definitions....................................................................................................................... 1
1.02 Exhibits ........................................................................................................................... 2
1.03 Rules of Interpretation .................................................................................................... 2
Section 2. Representations and Warranties. ............................................................................. 3
2.01 Representations and Warranties by the Authority .......................................................... 3
2.02 Representations and Warranties by the Company .......................................................... 3
Section 3. Real Estate Transaction........................................................................................... 4
3.01 Conveyance ..................................................................................................................... 4
3.02 Conditions Precedent ...................................................................................................... 4
3.03 Purchase Price ................................................................................................................. 4
3.04 Title ................................................................................................................................. 5
Section 4. Construction of Improvements ............................................................................... 5
4.01 Construction Plans .......................................................................................................... 5
4.02 Commencement and Completion of Construction .......................................................... 5
4.03 Certificate of Completion ............................................................................................... 5
4.04 Development Grant ......................................................................................................... 6
Section 5. Insurance; Transfer; Indemnification ...................................................................... 6
5.01 Insurance ......................................................................................................................... 6
5.02 Representation as to Development.................................................................................. 7
5.03 Prohibitions Against Transfer of Property and Assignment of Agreement .................... 7
5.04 Release and Indemnification Covenants ......................................................................... 9
Section 6. [Intentionally Omitted] ........................................................................................... 9
Section 7. Events of Default .................................................................................................... 9
7.01 Events of Default Defined .............................................................................................. 9
7.02 Remedies on Default ..................................................................................................... 10
7.03 No Remedy Exclusive................................................................................................... 10
7.04 No Additional Waiver Implied by One Waiver ............................................................ 10
7.05 Agreement to Pay Attorneys’ Fees and Expenses ........................................................ 10
7.06 Revesting Title in Authority Upon Happening of Event Subsequent to Conveyance to
Company ................................................................................................................................... 11
Section 8. Additional Provisions............................................................................................ 11
8.01 Notices and Demands ................................................................................................... 11
[20261117R 80]
8.02 Counterparts .................................................................................................................. 12
8.03 Amendments ................................................................................................................. 12
8.04 Termination of Agreement ............................................................................................ 12
[20261117R 81]
DEVELOPMENT AGREEMENT
This Agreement is made and entered into as of this ________ day of November, 2026, by
and between the Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior, Wisconsin (the “Authority”)
and Twin Ports Development Corporation, a Wisconsin corporation (the “Company”).
R E C I T A L S:
WHEREAS, the Authority is a redevelopment authority duly organized by the City of
Superior, Wisconsin (the “City”) pursuant to the provisions of Wisconsin Statutes, Section 66.1333
(the “Act”); and
WHEREAS, the City and the Authority have encouraged and furthered redevelopment and
utilization of property within the City for business and other purposes, particularly property located
in the north Tower Avenue area of the City; and
WHEREAS, the Company has proposed to the Authority to acquire property from the
Authority for the construction of a 30-unit extended-stay workforce hotel and related parking on
Tower Avenue and N. 4 th Street for use as workforce housing for the upcoming Blatnik Bridge
replacement project; and
WHEREAS, the City and the Authority have determined to provide assistance through the
sale of land and other actions, to encourage industrial and related development; and
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the promises and mutual obligations of the
parties contained herein, the receipt and sufficiency of which are hereby acknowledged, each of
them does hereby represent, covenant, and agree with the other as follows:
Section 1. Definitions, Exhibits, Rules of Interpretation.
1.01 Definitions. In this Agreement, the following terms have the following respective
meanings unless the context hereof clearly requires otherwise:
“Agreement” means this Development Agreement by and between the Authority and the
Company, as the same may be from time to time amended.
“Authority” means the Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior, Wisconsin.
“Certificate of Completion” means the certification, in the form of the Certificate attached
as Exhibit B hereto, provided to the Company pursuant to Section 4.03 of this Agreement and to
be recorded by the Company, upon satisfactory completion of the Improvements.
“City” means the City of Superior, Wisconsin.
“Closing Date” means the date upon which the Authority and the Company close on the
sale of the Property as provided in Section 3.01 which shall be a date mutually agreed to by the
parties hereto and is anticipated to be on or before December 18, 2026.
[20261117R 82]
2
“Company” means Twin Ports Development Corporation, a Wisconsin corporation.
“Construction Plans” means the construction plans for the Improvements to be performed
by the Company on the Property pursuant to this Agreement.
“Improvements” means each and all of the improvements specified and provided in the
Construction Plans, but generally described as an approximately 30-unit extended-stay workforce
hotel and related parking on Tower Avenue and N. 4th Street for use as workforce housing for the
upcoming Blatnik Bridge replacement project to be constructed by the Company on the Property.
The Improvements are expected to cost approximately $2,500,000.
“Project” means the Property, as improved by the Improvements.
“Property” means the real property described in Exhibit A to this Agreement.
“Schedule” means the schedule for the elements of the development contemplated by this
Agreement, as set forth on Exhibit C.
“Termination Date” means the earlier of the following: the date of the issuance of the
Certificate of Completion of the Improvements; or the date this Agreement is terminated pursuant
to Section 7.02C.
“Transfer” has the meaning given in Section 5.03A. of this Agreement.
“Unavoidable Delays” means delays, outside the control of the party claiming its
occurrence, which are the direct result of strikes, other labor troubles, unusually severe or
prolonged bad weather, acts of God, supply chain delays, fire or other casualty to the improvements
being constructed, pandemic or epidemic, governmental order, litigation commenced by third
parties which, by injunction or other similar judicial action, directly results in delays, or acts of
any federal, state or local government (other than the City) which directly results in delays.
1.02 Exhibits. The following exhibits are attached to and by reference made a part of
this Agreement:
Exhibit A Legal Description of the Property
Exhibit B Form of Certificate of Completion
Exhibit C Schedule
Exhibit D Sources and Uses of Funds
1.03 Rules of Interpretation.
A. This Agreement and the other agreements executed by the parties in connection
with the Property, shall be interpreted in accordance with and governed by the laws of the State of
Wisconsin.
[20261117R 83]
3
B. The words herein and hereof and words of similar import, without reference to any
particular section or subdivision, refer to this Agreement as a whole rather than any particular
section or subdivision hereof.
C. References herein to a particular section or subdivision hereof are to the section or
subdivision of this instrument as originally executed.
D. Any titles of the several parts, articles and sections of this Agreement are inserted
for convenience and reference only and shall be disregarded in construing or interpreting any of
its provisions.
E. In the event that any provision or clause of this Agreement conflicts with applicable
law, such conflict shall not affect other provisions of this Agreement which can be given effect
without the conflicting provisions, and to this end the provision of this Agreement are declared to
be severable.
Section 2. Representations and Warranties.
2.01 Representations and Warranties by the Authority . The Authority represents and
warrants that:
A. The Authority is a public body, corporate and politic, organized under the laws of
Wisconsin.
B. The Authority has the power to enter into this Agreement and carry out its
obligations hereunder pursuant to the powers granted to it by the Wisconsin Constitution and State
law.
2.02 Representations and Warranties by the Company . The Company represents and
warrants that:
A. The Company is a corporation duly organized and in good standing under the laws
of the State of Wisconsin, is not in violation of any provisions of its organizational documents or
the laws of the State of Wisconsin, is duly qualified to do business in the State of Wisconsin, has
power to enter into this Agreement and to perform its obligations hereunder, and has duly
authorized the execution, delivery, and performance of this Agreement by proper corporate action.
B. The Company will construct or cause the Improvement s to be constructed in
accordance with the terms of this Agreement.
C. The Company will use commercially reasonable efforts to obtain, in a timely
manner, all required permits, licenses and approvals, and to meet, in a timely manner, all
requirements of applicable local, state and federal laws and regulations which must be obtained or
met before the Improvements may be lawfully constructed.
D. To the Company’s knowledge, n either the execution and delivery of this
Agreement, the consummation of the transactions contemplated hereby, nor the fulfillment of or
[20261117R 84]
4
compliance with the terms and conditions of this Agreement is prevented or limited by, or in
conflict with or will result in a breach of, the terms, conditions or provisions of any restriction of
the Company, or any indebtedness, agreement or instrument of whatever nature to which the
Company is now a party or by which it is bound, or will constitute a default under any of the
foregoing.
Section 3. Real Estate Transaction.
3.01 Conveyance. On the Closing Date, which is scheduled to be on or before December
18, 2026, unless otherwise agreed by the Parties, the Authority shall convey title and possession
of the Property to the Company under a quit claim deed (the “Deed”). The Authority shall convey
the Property “as is” as of the Closing Date and the Authority and the City make no warranty as to
the condition of the Property or its suitability for the purposes of the Company. The Company’s
use of the Property for the Improvements shall be subject to all building and zoning laws and
ordinances and all other local, state and federal laws and regulations.
3.02 Conditions Precedent. A. The Authority’s obligation to convey the Property to
the Company shall be subject to satisfaction of the following conditions precedent:
(i) The Company shall be in material compliance with all the terms and
provisions of this Agreement;
(ii) The Authority shall have approved the Construction Plans pursuant to
Section 4.01 hereof; and
(iii) The Company shall have obtained financing for construction and equipping
of the Improvements satisfactory to the Authority;
The Company agrees that if, upon the Closing Date, the conditions precedent provided hereinabove
are not satisfied, the Authority shall have no obligation under this Agreement to convey the
Property to the Company.
B. The Company’s obligation to acquire the Property and to construct the
Improvements shall be subject to satisfaction of the following conditions precedent:
(i) The Authority shall have approved the Construction Plans pursuant to
Section 4.01 hereof; and
(ii) The Company shall have obtained a title insurance commitment for the
Property in form and substance satisfactory to the Company.
The Authority agrees that if, upon the Closing Date, the conditions precedent provided in this
Section 3.02B. are not satisfied, the Company shall have no obligation under this Agreement to
acquire the Property from the Authority.
3.03 Purchase Price . On the Closing Date, the Company shall pay the Authority
$95,000, as the purchase price for the Property ; such amount being the fair market value of such
[20261117R 85]
5
property. Unless otherwise mutually agreed by the Authority and the Company, the closing shall
be made at the Government Center. The Company shall pay all costs in connection with the
recording of the deed, including transfer tax and recording fee.
3.04 Title. The Authority shall not further encumber title, or fail to take any necessary
actions to prevent encumbrance of title, to the Property before the time at which the Deed is
delivered to the Company. The Authority shall assist the Company in obtaining a title insurance
policy on the Property at Company’s expense and shall execute the Seller’s Affidavit and FIRPTA
certificate required by the Title Company. Upon delivery of the Deed to the Company pursuant to
this Section, all responsibilities and liabilities whatsoever with respect to title to the Property shall
from and after such date be the sole responsibility of the Company.
Section 4. Construction of Improvements.
4.01 Construction Plans. Prior to the Closing Date, the Company shall submit to the
Authority the plans for the construction of the Improvements. Such plans include the following:
(a) site plans; (b) floor plans; and (c) elevations (the “Construction Plans”), and shall provide for
the construction of a n approximately 30-unit extended-stay workforce hotel and related parking .
The Company agrees that it will construct the Improvements on the Property in substantial
conformance with the Construction Plans. The Company agrees that the scope and scale of the
Improvements to be constructed shall not be significantly less than the scope and scale of the
Improvements as detailed and outlined in the Construction Plans.
4.02 Commencement and Completion of Construction. Subject to Unavoidable Delays
and subject to obtaining financing satisfactory to the Company, the Company shall commence
construction on the Improvements by May 1, 2027, or such other date as the parties hereto shall
agree in writing. Subject to Unavoidable Delays, the Company shall have completed the
Improvements no later than June 1, 2028 . All work with respect to the Improvements to be
constructed or provided by the Company on the Property shall be in conformity with the
Construction Plans.
The Company agrees that the Company shall promptly begin and diligently prosecute to
completion construction of the Improvements, and that such construction shall in any event be
commenced and completed within the period specified in this Section of the Agreement.
4.03 Certificate of Completion . Promptly after completion of the Improvements in
accordance with the provisions of this Agreement, the Authority will furnish the Company with a
recordable Certificate of Completion, in substantially the form set forth in Exhibit B attached
hereto. Such Certificate of Completion shall be a conclusive determination of satisfaction and
termination of the agreements and covenants in this Agreement with respect to the obligations of
the Company, and its successors and assigns, to construct the Improvements and shall be recorded
by the Company . The Authority reserves the right to issue the Certificate of Completion if the
Improvements are completed, except for items which cannot be completed due to weather or other
causes beyond the control of the Company , and the Authority and the Company enter into an
escrow agreement to assure full completion of the Improvements.
[20261117R 86]
6
4.04 Development Grant. Upon the Authority’s issuing the Certificate of Completion
for the Improvements, the Authority shall pay the Company a development grant in the amount of
$50,000.
Section 5. Insurance; Transfer; Indemnification.
5.01 Insurance.
A. The Company will provide and maintain (or cause to be maintained) at all times
during the process of construction of the Improvements an “All Risk Broad Form Basis” insurance
policy and from time to time during that period at the request of the Authority, furnish the
Authority with proof of payment of premiums on policies covering the following:
(i) Builder’s risk insurance, written on the so -called “Builder’s Risk --
Completed Value Basis,” in an amount equal to 100% of the insurable value of the
Improvements at the date of completion, and with coverage available in nonreporting form
on the so-called “all risk” form of policy; and
(ii) Comprehensive general liability insurance (including operations,
contingent liability, operations of subcontractors, completed operations and contractual
liability insurance) together with an Owner’s Protective Liability Policy with limits against
injury and property damage of not less than $1,000,000 for each occurrence (to accomplish
the above-required limits an umbrella excess liability policy may be used). The Authority
shall be listed as an additional insured on the policy.
B. All insurance required by this Section shall be taken out and maintained in
responsible insurance companies selected by the Company which are authorized under the laws of
the State of Wisconsin to assume the risks covered thereby. Upon request, the Compan y will
deposit annually with the Authority copies of policies evidencing all such insurance, or a certificate
or certificates or binders of the respective insurers stating that such insurance is in force and effect.
In lieu of separate policies, the Company may maintain a single policy, blanket or umbrella policy,
or a combination thereof, having the coverage required herein, in which event the Company shall
deposit with the Authority a certificate or certificates of the respective insurers as to the amount of
coverage in force upon the Improvements.
C. No policy of insurance shall be so written that the proceeds thereof will produce
less than the minimum coverage required hereby, by reason of co -insurance provisions or
otherwise, without the prior consent thereto in writing by the Authority. All polici es evidencing
insurance required by this subparagraph with respect to the Improvements shall be carried in the
names of the Company, the Authority and the holder of any Mortgage, as their respective interests
may appear.
D. The Company and the Authority agree that all of the insurance provisions set forth
in this Section shall terminate as of the Termination Date.
[20261117R 87]
7
5.02 Representation as to Development . The Company represents and agrees that its
undertakings with respect to the Property pursuant to the Agreement are and will be used for the
purpose of construction and use of the Improvements and not for speculation in land holding.
5.03 Prohibitions Against Transfer of Property and Assignment of Agreement . The
Company represents and agrees as follows:
A. Except only by way of security for the purposes of obtaining financing necessary
to enable the Company or any successor in interest to the Property, or any part thereof, to perform
its obligations with respect to making the Improvements under this Agreement, and any other
purpose authorized by th is Agreement, the Company (except as so authorized) has not made or
created and will not make or create or suffer to be made or created any total or partial sale,
assignment or conveyance, or any trust or power, or transfer in any other mode or form of or with
respect to this Agreement or the Property or any part thereof or any interest therein, or any contract
or agreement to do any of the same (collectively, a “Transfer”), to any person or entity, without
the prior written approval of the Authority. Any such Transfer shall be subject to the provisio ns
of this Agreement; provided, however, the Authority will, at the request of a first mortgage lender,
subordinate the Company’s obligation to obtain such consent under this Section 5.03A pursuant
to a subordination agreement reasonably acceptable to the Authority and such lender. This
restriction on Transfer shall terminate upon the Authority’s issuance of the Certificate of
Completion.
B. In the event the Company upon a Transfer seeks to assign its rights and obligations
under this Agreement as to the portions of the Property that are transferred or assigned, the
Authority shall be entitled to require, except as otherwise provided in the Agreement, as conditions
to any such approval or release that:
(i) Any proposed transferee shall have the qualifications, in the reasonable
judgment of the Authority, necessary and adequate to fulfill the obligations undertaken in
this Agreement by the Company. The criteria to be considered by the Authority in
determining the qualifications for any proposed transferee shall be such transferee’s ability
to complete construction of the Improvements.
(ii) Any proposed transferee, by instrument in writing satisfactory to the
Authority in form recordable among the land records, shall, for itself and its successors
and assigns, expressly assume all of the obligations of the Company under this Agreement
as to the portion of the Property subject to the Transfer and agree to be subject to all the
conditions and restrictions to which the Company is subject as to such portion; unless the
Company agrees to continue to fulfill those obligations, in which case the provisions of
Section 5.03A. shall not apply.
(iii) There shall be submitted to the Authority for review and prior written
approval all instruments and other legal documents involved in effecting the Transfer of
any interest in this Agreement or the Property.
(iv) In the absence of a specific written agreement by the Authority to the
contrary, no such Transfer or approval by the Authority thereof shall be deemed to relieve
[20261117R 88]
8
the Company or any other party bound in any way by this Agreement or otherwise with
respect to the construction of the Improvements or from any of its obligations with respect
thereto.
C. In the event the foregoing conditions are satisfied, then the Company shall be
released from its obligations under this Agreement as to the portion of the Property subject to the
Transfer.
D. Notwithstanding anything above to the contrary, the Authority shall have the first
right of refusal (“ROFR”) to purchase Company’s interest in the Property in response to any bona
fide offer or offers to purchase the Property received by Company that Company is ready and
willing to accept (a “Bona Fide Offer”), all as further described below.
1. If Company receives a Bona Fide Offer, Company shall communicate the Bona
Fide Offer to Authority and the terms thereof to the Authority in writing by
delivering copy of the Bona Fide Offer to City of Superior at the address set forth
below. This communication by Company to Authority will be deemed an offer by
Company to sell the Property to the Authority (the “ROFR Offer”).
2. The Authority will have the right, for a period of 60 days after the date of receipt
by the Authority from the Company of the Bona Fide Offer (the “ROFR Option
Period”) to execute and deliver to Company a purchase agreement for the purchase
of the Property at the Bona Fide Offer price and including such other terms and
conditions for similar transactions as determined by the Authority. Delivery of the
signed purchase agreement by the Authority to Company shall be deemed
acceptance of the ROFR Offer. Delivery of the signed purchase agreement to
Company must occur within the ROFR Option Period.
3. If Authority does not accept the ROFR Offer, Company may sell the Property
pursuant to the Bona Fide Offer.
4. If Authority does not accept the Company Offer, but Company does not (for any
reason) close on the sale of the Bona Fide Offer within 90 days of the expiration of
the Bona Fide Offer, the ROFR restrictions on the Property shall be revived in favor
of the Authority and shall continue and shall apply to subsequent Bona Fide Offers
for the Property.
5. If Authority accepts the Company Offer, the closing date shall be within 60 days of
the date Authority executes and delivers the purchase agreement, at a title company
selected by Authority and on a date mutually agreed to by the parties in writing.
6. This ROFR restriction will be binding upon Company and Authority and the
parties’ successors and assigns and shall burden the Property and run with the land.
7. Except as provided herein, Company has no obligation to seek or accept any offer
for the purchase of the Property.
[20261117R 89]
9
5.04 Release and Indemnification Covenants.
A. The Company releases from and covenants and agrees that the Authority and the
City and their governing body members, officers, agents, including their independent contractors,
consultants and legal counsel, servants and employees (hereinafter, for purposes of this Section,
collectively the “Indemnified Parties”) shall not be liable for and agrees to indemnify and hold
harmless the Indemnified Parties against any loss or damage to the Property and the Improvement
or any injury to or death of any person resulting from any defect in the Project.
B. Except for any willful misrepresentation , or any willful or wanton misconduct of
the Indemnified Parties, the Company agrees to protect and defend the Indemnified Parties now
and forever and further agrees to hold the aforesaid harmless from any claim, demand, suit, action
or other proceeding whatsoever by any person or entity whatsoever arising or purportedly arising
from this Agreement, or the transactions contemplated hereby or the acquisition, construction,
installation, ownership, and operation of the Project, provided that this indemnificati on shall not
apply to the warranties made or obligations undertaken by the Authority in this Agreement.
C. The Authority and the Indemnified Parties shall not be liable for any damage or
injury to the persons or property of the Company or its officers, agents, servants, or employees or
any other person who may be about the Property or the Improvements due to any act of negligence
of any person; provided, that nothing contained herein shall be interpreted to alter the liability of
the Authority or Indemnified Parties for any damage or injury to the persons or property of the
Company or its officers, agents, contractors, or employees or any other person who may be about
the Property or the Improvements caused by any act of negligence of the Authority or the
Indemnified Parties.
Section 6. [Intentionally Omitted]
Section 7. Events of Default.
7.01 Events of Default Defined. The following shall be “Events of Default” under this
Agreement and the term “Event of Default” shall mean, whenever it is used in this Agreement,
any one or more of the following events:
A. Failure of the Authority or the Company to proceed to close on the Property after
compliance with or the occurrence of all conditions precedent to closing.
B. Failure by the Company to commence and complete construction of the
Improvements pursuant to the terms, conditions, and limitations of Section 4.
C. Failure by the Company to timely pay the real estate taxes on the Project.
D. Failure by either party to observe or perform any covenant, condition, obligation or
agreement on their part to be observed or performed under this Agreement.
[20261117R 90]
10
7.02 Remedies on Default. Whenever any Event of Default referred to in Section 7.01
of this Agreement occurs, the non -defaulting party may take any one or more of the following
actions after provision of thirty (30) days’ written notice by the non -defaulting party to the
defaulting party of the Event of Default, but only if the Event of Default has not been cured within
said thirty (30) days or if the Event of Default cannot be cured within thirty (30) days, the
defaulting party does not provide assurances to the non-defaulting party reasonably satisfactory to
the non-defaulting party that the Event of Default will be cured as soon as reasonably possible:
A. Suspend its performance under the Agreement, including refusing to close on the
Property until the non -defaulting party receives assurances from the defaulting party, deemed
adequate by the non-defaulting party, that the defaulting party will cure its default and continue its
performance under the Agreement.
B. The Authority may withhold the Certificate of Completion, but only so long as an
Event of Default has not been cured.
C. Terminate or rescind this Agreement.
D. Take whatever action, including legal or administrative action, which may appear
necessary or desirable to the non -defaulting party to enforce performance and observance of any
obligations or covenant of the defaulting party under this Agreement ; p rovided that nothing
contained herein shall give the Authority the right to rescind this Agreement or reacquire the
Property once the Certificate of Completion for the Improvements is issued.
7.03 No Remedy Exclusive . No remedy herein conferred upon or reserved herein is
intended to be exclusive of any other available remedy or remedies, but each and every such
remedy shall be cumulative and shall be in addition to every other remedy given under this
Agreement or now or hereafter existing at law or in equity or by statute. No delay or omission to
exercise any right or power accruing upon any default shall impair any such right or power or shall
be construed to be a waiver thereof, but any such right and power may be exercised from time to
time and as often as may be deemed expedient.
7.04 No Additional Waiver Implied by One Waiver . In the event any agreement
contained in this Agreement should be breached by any party and thereafter waived by any other
party, such waiver shall be limited to the particular breach so waived and shall not be deemed to
waive any other concurrent, previous or subsequent breach hereunder.
7.05 Agreement to Pay Attorneys’ Fees and Expenses. Whenever any Event of Default
occurs and the Authority shall employ attorneys or incur other expenses for the collection of
payments due or to become due or for the enforcement or performance or observance of any
obligation or agreement on the part of the Company herein contained, the Company agrees that it
shall, on demand therefore, pay to the Authority the reasonable fees of such attorneys and such
other expenses so incurred by the Authority; provided that if a lawsuit or other civil actions is
instituted between the Parties, the Party which does not prevail shall pay to the prevailing Party
the reasonable fees of attorneys and other expenses so incurred by the prevailing Party and if the
Authority is not the prevailing Party in such a lawsuit or actio n the Authority shall have no claim
under this Section.
[20261117R 91]
11
7.06 Revesting Title in Authority Upon Happening of Event Subsequent to
Conveyance to Company . In the event that subsequent to conveyance of the Property to the
Company and prior to receipt by the Company of the Certificate of Completion, the Company,
subject to Unavoidable Delays, shall fail to begin construction of the (i ) Improvements in
conformity with this Agreement and such failure to begin construction is not cured within ninety
(90) days after written notice from the Authority to the Company to do so; or (ii) the Company
shall fail to commence construction by September 1, 2027 for any reason, then the Authority shall
have the right to re -enter and take possession of the Property and to terminate and revest in the
Authority the estate conveyed by the Deed to the Company, it being the intent of this provision,
together with other provi sions of the Agreement, that the conveyance of the Property to the
Company shall be made upon a condition subsequent to the effect that upon the occurrence and
during the continuance of any Event of Default on the part of the Company and failure on the part
of the Company to remedy, end, or abrogate such Event of Default within the period and in the
manner stated herein, or as otherwise agreed in writing by the parties, the Authority at its option
may declare a termination in favor of the Authority of the t itle, and of all the rights and interests
in and to the Property conveyed to the Company, and that such title and all rights and interests of
the Company, and any assigns or successors in interest to and in the Property, shall revert to the
Authority, but only if an event stated in this Section 7.06 has not been cured within the time period
provided above, or if the event cannot be cured within such time period, the Company does not
provide reasonable assurances satisfactory to the Authority that the event will be cured as soon as
reasonably possible. Upon such revesting, at the request of the Authority, the Company shall
execute and deliver a quit claim deed to the Authority for the Property.
Upon revesting of the Property and upon all liens and encumbrances being removed and
upon the Company providing a quit claim deed to the Authority for the Property, the Authority
will return the purchase price of the Property less the costs incurred by the Authority for the sale
of the Property to the Company and the costs in connection of such revesting of title and other fees
and expenses described in Section 7.05 hereof.
Section 8. Additional Provisions.
8.01 Notices and Demands. Except as otherwise expressly provided in this Agreement,
a notice, demand or other communication under this Agreement by any party to the others shall be
sufficiently given or delivered if it is dispatched by registered or certified mail, postage prepa id,
return receipt requested, or delivered personally; and
A. In the case of the Company, is addressed or delivered personally to:
Twin Ports Development Corporation
Attn: Miles Eberhard
9395 Wallace Road
Iron River, WI 54847
With a copy to:
[20261117R 92]
12
Steve Olson
Ledin Olson & Cockerham
1109 Tower Avenue
Superior, WI 54880
B. In the case of the Authority, is addressed to or delivered personally to the following:
Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior
1316 North 14th Street
Superior, WI 54880
Attention: Executive Director
With a copy to:
Mia Thibodeau
Fryberger, Buchanan, Smith & Frederick, P.A.
302 West Superior Street, Suite 700
Duluth, MN 55802
at such other addresses as either party may, from time to time, designate in writing and forward to
the other as provided in this Section.
8.02 Counterparts. This Agreement is executed in any number of counterparts, each of
which shall constitute one and the same instrument.
8.03 Amendments. Neither this Agreement, nor any other document to which the
Company and the Authority are a party, relating to the development contemplated by this
Agreement, may be effectively amended, changed, modified, altered or terminated, except upon
the written agreement of the Authority and the Company.
8.04 Termination of Agreement. This Development Agreement shall terminate on the
Termination Date. Except for the provisions of Section 5.04, the Company shall have no obligation
under this Agreement after the Termination Date. Notwithstanding such termination, the
Authority shall still be obligated to issue the Certificate of Completion as provided in Section 4.03
above, within ten (10) days of the Company’s written request.
[20261117R 93]
13
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Authority has caused this Agreement to be duly executed
in its name and behalf and its seal to be hereunto duly affixed and the Company has caused this
Agreement to be executed in its name and behalf, on or as of the date first above written.
REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE
CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
By
Chairman
By
Executive Director
[20261117R 94]
14
TWIN PORTS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
By
Its
[20261117R 95]
EXHIBIT A
Property
Lots 23 through 29, Block 11, WEST SUPERIOR FIRST DIVISION, located in part of the
Northwest Quarter of the Northeast Quarter, Section 15, Township 49 North, Range 14 West, City
of Superior, Douglas County, Wisconsin.
Parcel ID #04-804-00060-00
[20261117R 96]
EXHIBIT B
CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION AND TERMINATION
WHEREAS, by a Development Agreement (the “Agreement”) dated as of ____________,
2026, entered into by and between the Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior,
Wisconsin (the “Authority”) and Twin Ports Development Corporation (the “Company”), the
Company has developed the real property (the “Site”) described on the attached Exhibit A, by
constructing or causing to be constructed, the improvements thereon according to the terms and
conditions of the Agreement;
WHEREAS, pursuant to the Agreement, promptly after completion of all work of
construction to be completed by the Company upon the Site, the Authority shall furnish the
Company with a Certificate of Completion upon written request therefore by the Company;
WHEREAS, the issuance by the Authority of the Certificate of Completion shall be
conclusive evidence that the Company has complied with the terms of the Agreement pertaining
to construction of the Improvements on the Site and that the Agreement has terminated;
WHEREAS, the Company has requested that the Authority furnish the Company with this
Certificate of Completion; and
WHEREAS, the Authority has conclusively determined that the work of construction of
the Improvements on the Site as required by the Agreement has been satisfactorily completed.
NOW, THEREFORE, be it resolved:
1. As provided in the Agreement, the Authority does hereby certify that construction
of the Improvements on the Site has been fully and satisfactorily performed and completed, and
that such construction work is in full compliance with the terms, provisions, and conditions
established in the Agreement.
2. The Agreement is therefore terminated and of no further force and effect, and all
rights duties, obligations, and liabilities of the Authority and the Company thereunder regarding
initial construction of the Improvements shall cease to exist. Any continuing and existing rights,
duties, obligations, and liabilities which expressly survive the termination of the Agreement shall
continue to remain in force and effect.
3. This Certificate of Completion shall not constitute evidence of compliance with or
satisfaction of any obligation of the Company to any holder of a mortgage, or any insurer of a
mortgage, securing money loaned to finance the work of construction and develo pment of the
improvements on the Site, or any part thereof. This Certificate of Completion is not a notice of
completion as referenced in Wisconsin Statutes.
[20261117R 97]
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, the Authority has executed this Certificate of Completion as of
this ______ day of ______________, 202___.
REDEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY OF THE
CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
By
Its Chair
By
Its Executive Director
[20261117R 98]
ACCEPTED BY:
TWIN PORTS DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION
By
Its________________________________
[20261117R 99]
EXHIBIT A TO CERTIFICATE OF COMPLETION
Legal Description
Lots 23 through 29, Block 11, WEST SUPERIOR FIRST DIVISION, located in part of the
Northwest Quarter of the Northeast Quarter, Section 15, Township 49 North, Range 14 West, City
of Superior, Douglas County, Wisconsin.
04-804-00060-00
[20261117R 100]
EXHIBIT C
SCHEDULE
Agreement
Reference Activity Required Date
Section 3.01 Authority delivers Deed December 18, 2026
Section 4.01 Construction Plans Approved By December 11, 2026
Section 4.02 Company commences construction of Improvements By May 1, 2027
Section 4.02 Completion of Improvements June 1, 2028
Section 4.03 Authority signs Certificate of Completion June 2028
[20261117R 101]
EXHIBIT D
SOURCES AND USES OF FUNDS FOR PROJECT
Sources
Bank Loan $1,875,000.00
Equity 625,000.00
TOTAL $2,500,000.00
Uses
Construction of Improvements $2,275,000.00
Purchase Price of Property 95,000.00
Site Plan & Design 60,000.00
Contingency/Overages 50,000.00
Laundry Equipment 20,000.00
TOTAL $2,500,000.00
[20261117R 102]
PLAN COMMISSION MINUTES - 11/10/26 Mtg (Meets monthly on 2nd Tuesday of each month) Page 1 of 2
PLAN COMMISSION Minutes
November 10, 2026 Regular Meeting
The meeting was called to order by Chair Paine at 5:00 pm on November 10, 2026, in Government
Center Room 270.
1 ROLL CALL
PRESENT: Jim Paine, Lynn Wohlwend, Garner Moffat, Tylor Elm, and Anne Porter
VIRTUAL:
ABSENT: Lindsey Graskey
CITY STAFF PRESENT: Director Serck, Jeff Skrenes, Justin Bernacki (5:03 pm), Tech
Granlund, and Mary Osborne (virtual)
OTHERS PRESENT: Shelley Nelson
2 APPROVAL OF MINUTES
2.1 Plan Commission Minutes (November 10, 2026)
MOTION to approve the November 10, 2026, minutes by Commissioner Moffat, seconded by
Commissioner Elm. Carried.
3 REPORTS
3.1 Revitalize, or Die Assessment Report
MOTION by Commissioner Elm to hold in committee until next meeting.
4 OLD BUSINESS
4.1 Review and Approve Designated Outdoor Refreshment Area Ordinance and Resolution
No new updates
MOTION by Commissioner Paine hold in until the ordinance is ready to bring to the
commission.
4.2 Review for Approval – Downtown Superior Design Guidelines
Commissioner Paine introduced the discussion regarding the five requests for proposal (RFP)
reviews. Commissioners shared with the committee the preferences and recommendations for
the firm to be recommended to the City Council for approval.
Commissioners voted 4-1 to recommend Ayres as the selected firm and forward the
recommendation to the City Council for consideration and approval.
5 NEW BUSINESS
6 RECURRING BUSINESS
6.1 Planning & Development Director Report
[20261117R 103]
PLAN COMMISSION MINUTES - 11/10/26 Mtg (Meets monthly on 2nd Tuesday of each month) Page 2 of 2
Director Serck let commissioners know that the zoning code updates will continue at the
December Plan Commission meeting. He also shared with commissioners the contents of the
meetings of the Joint Review Board and Redevelopment Authority of the City of Superior.
6.2 Housing Coordinator Update
Jeff Skrenes shared with commissioners the takeaway from recent conferences that he was in
attendance. Also sharing with commissioners, the work being done with the creation of the City
of Superior’s Land Trust program. For the December meeting a memo lining out the Land Trust
Policy will be provided.
7 ADJOURNMENT
Meeting adjourned at 5:48 pm
Respectfully submitted by Amanda Granlund.
[20261117R 104]
Date: November 12, 2026 City Council Date: November 17, 2026
M E M O R A N D U M
TO: Mayor Jim Paine and Members of the Common Council
FROM: Jason Serck, Planning, Economic Development & Port Director
RE: Princess Theatre Apartments
INTRODUCTION – It is my recommendation to award the Superior Downtown Design Best
Practices guide project to Ayres Associates, in the not to exceed amount of thirty-five thousand
dollars ($35,000.00) for the base services of thirty-one thousand dollars ($31,000.00) and the
optional downtown walking workshop services in the amount of four thousand dollars
($4,000.00).
BACKGROUND - The City of Superior advertised a request for proposals from qualified firms
for a firm to create a clear and concise design façade and streetscape best practices guide
document for downtown buildings and streetscapes, as well as a series of façade
recommendations for up to 15 buildings in the downtown area on September 19, 2026.
The best practices guide document intent is to help the City accomplish important goals related
to planning and project design review for the public and private sectors by clarifying
expectations and communicating requirements and options to all stakeholders, property owners,
developers and the public. This document will shape redevelopment, new construction, building
additions, historic preservation, future grant and incentive programs, and communication of
expectations to property owners, developers and the public the City’s best practices for
downtown façades to create a cohesive downtown area.
This document should be adaptable for future potential updates to the City’s zoning ordinances.
The document shall be developed in conjunction with several stakeholders, in addition to the
City, such as the Superior Business Improvement District, Chamber of Commerce and others as
deemed appropriate, residents, business owners and local leaders.
On October 20, 2026, the City received five proposals.
Cardo $34,100.00
Ayres $31,000.00
BKV Group $35,000.00
Meyer Group $49,000.00
Damon Farber $35,000.00
[20261117R 105]
The Plan Commission met on November 10, 2026. The Plan Commission reviewed the proposals
and are recommending the project be awarded to Ayres Associates. Ayres offered an optional
“Walking Workshop” in the amount of four thousand dollars ($4,000.00), which the Plan
Commission also recommends being awarded.
BUDGET SOURCE – This project is funded through the Economic Development Fund.
CONCLUSION – It is recommended to award the Superior Downtown Design Best Practices
guide project to Ayres Associates, in the not to exceed amount of thirty-one thousand dollars
($35,000.00).
Recommend:
Jim Paine, Mayor
[20261117R 106]
Contract- 2026
Superior Downtown Design Best
Practices
CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
Jason Serck
Planning Director
Bid #26-25-PL
[20261117R 107]
2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1. Advertisement ................................ ................................ ................................ .............................. 3
2. Schedule of Activities ................................ ................................ ................................ ................ 4
3. Information for Prospective Service Consultant ................................ ....................... 5
4. Statement of Qualifications Requirements ................................ ................................ ... 7
5. Scope of Services ................................ ................................ ................................ ......................... 9
6. Fee Proposal ................................ ................................ ................................ ............................... 11
7. Evaluation Criteria ................................ ................................ ................................ .................. 11
8. Professional Services ................................ ................................ ................................ ............. 12
9. Subcontractors Listing ................................ ................................ ................................ .......... 13
10. Addenda Acknowledgement................................ ................................ ............................... 14
11. Qualification Evaluation Checklist ................................ ................................ .................. 15
12. Statement of Qualifications Reference Form ................................ ............................ 17
13. Agreement ................................ ................................ ................................ ................................ .... 18
[20261117R 108]
3
1. Advertisement
Request for Proposal (RFP)
City of Superior, Wisconsin
Professional Services for
Superior Downtown Design Best Practices
Responses will be received by the City of Superior, Attn: Contract Analyst, at 1316 North
14th Street, 2nd floor, Superior, WI 54880. Responses will be evaluated by City staff.
Proposals Due: Tuesday, October 20, 2026, at 2:30 PM CST
Project: The City of Superior, Wisconsin (City), is requesting proposals from
qualified firms to provide the City with a design façade and streetscape
best practices guide for the downtown area of Superior. This project is part
of the City’s downtown revitalization and preservation efforts. This
project is to be completed by April 30, 2027.
All proposals must be prepared with the forms provided and submitted in accordance
with the Instructions to Consultant/Firm. Specifications may be obtained through
DemandStar.com. Proposal requirements may be viewed at the City of Superior,
Government Center, 2nd Floor, 1316 North 14th Street, Superior, Wisconsin
(darwinj@superiorwi.gov).
The City of Superior encourages the participation of minority, women-owned and
disadvantaged business enterprises.
The City of Superior reserves the right to reject any or all proposals, to waive
irregularities, or to accept such proposals, as in the opinion of the City, will be in its best
interests.
Jason Serck, Planning Director
Planning Department
Superior Telegram: Saturday, September 19, 2026, and Saturday, September 26,
2026
[20261117R 109]
4
2. Schedule of Activities
Subject: Superior Downtown Design Best Practices
RFP#: 26-25-PL
Due Date: Tuesday, October 20, 2026
Time Due: 2:30 PM
DATE EVENT
September 19, 2026 RFP Released
September 19 and 26, 2026 Publication Dates
None Scheduled
Pre-Proposal Conference
October 8, 2026 Deadline for Questions
October 12, 2026 Final Addendum Issued
October 20, 2026 Sealed Proposals Due
November 1 - 20 Potential Interview(s)
December 15, 2026 City Council vote on recommendation
Week of December 21, 2026 Sign Agreement
March 30, 2027 Draft document
April 30, 2027 Final document
[20261117R 110]
5
3. Information for Prospective Service Consultant
3.1 Proposals will be accepted until the date and time stated in this document. Any
proposals received after this time may not be considered. The proposal packet
shall be placed in an envelope and shall be sealed. On the envelope shall be
plainly written: the date of the opening, the title of the project, Attn: Contract
Analyst, and the name of the proposer. Respondent shall submit one (1) unbound
original and one (1) electronic version on a flash drive of the proposal documents.
3.2 This is a qualifications and cost-based selection. The Proposal, Cost Proposal,
Addenda Acknowledgement, Sub-Consultants, Statement of Qualifications,
Qualifications Reference Form, Qualification Evaluation Checklist, reference
checks, and interviews (at the option of the City) will be used to identify the most
competitive firm(s). The City reserves the right to identify competitive firm(s), as
in its opinion, will be in its best interests. Proposals shall be valid for 90 days.
3.3 The City of Superior Planning Department and its designees will review the
proposals and select the most highly qualified and cost competitive firm(s) to
contact for further screening as it deems appropriate.
3.4 The consultant shall submit a list of their subcontractors as a part of their
proposal, which list shall not be added to nor altered without the written consent
of the City of Superior, and as specified in 66.0901 Wisconsin Statutes.
3.5 The RFP will detail terms and conditions. The City reserves the right to amend
the Request for Proposal and will provide a written amendment to all known
parties receiving the request. Respondents shall acknowledge all addenda
received.
3.6 Firms must submit a proposed cost in accordance with the specifications. Proposed
cost must be written out in words and also entered in figures. In case of conflict,
the written word prices will prevail. In case figures do not match, the figure
resulting in the lower price shall be deemed the price intended and applicable.
3.7 Firms not returning the completed RFP within the specified time frame may be
disqualified. Irregularities in the completed RFP documents may be considered
sufficient cause for disqualification.
3.8 Subsequent to the RFP deadline, the Planning Department will prepare a
recommendation as to which proposal to award, if any. The recommendation of
the Planning Department may be subject to the approval of the Superior Common
Council.
3.9 The Consultant will be required to sign a standard City Service Agreement
(example attached) and provide proof of insurance for errors and omissions,
property damage, public liability and workman’s compensation.
3.10 Proposals may be amended and/or withdrawn prior to the proposal opening time.
Proposals may not be withdrawn for a period of ninety (90) days after the
submission deadline.
[20261117R 111]
6
3.11 Proposals are prepared and submitted at the sole cost and expense of the
respondent and shall become the property of the City of Superior; proposal
documents will not be returned.
3.12 Respondents will indemnify the City of Superior from any and all debts, claims,
and liabilities arising out of the proposal or the performance of the project as a
result of the consultant’s error, omissions, neglect, etc.
3.13 The City reserves the right to negotiate with respondents on the scope of the
project, fees, timelines, and all other components of the project, whether or not
the proposal was deemed the lowest cost to the City.
3.14 Firms may not subcontract any work without prior written authorization by the
City of Superior Planning Department.
3.15 This shall in no way bind or prevent the City of Superior from performing,
requesting quotes or proposals, bidding, or contracting any services separately.
3.16 Trade secrets and confidential information contained in a Proposal are not open to
public inspection. Pricing is not confidential information. Proposers who include
information in a Proposal that is legally protected as a trade secret or confidential
information must clearly indicate the specific protected information by marking
that information “Trade Secret” or “Confidential” at the appropriate place. The City
will not be responsible for any public disclosure of the trade secret or confidential
information if it is not marked as provided above. A Proposal in its entirety is not
confidential. If a request is made under the Wisconsin Public Records Law Wis
Stat. §§ 19.31 -19.39 to inspect information designated as trade secret or
confidential in a Proposal, the Proposer shall, upon request, immediately furnish
sufficient written reasoning as to why the information should be protected from
disclosure in order for the City Attorney to present the matter to the Attorney
General of Wisconsin for final determinat ion. The City of Superior recommends
not including any confidential information in the proposal.
3.17 During this Proposal process, Proposer shall not contact any City Staff except
those designated in the text of this RFP or subsequent addendums or
correspondence. Questions should be addressed in writing to the Contract
Analyst, via e-mail: darwinj@superiorwi.gov, prior to the deadline as stated
in Section 2. Please reference RFP #26-25-PL and line number being referenced.
Non-compliance with this provision may result in rejection of the Proposal.
[20261117R 112]
7
4. Statement of Qualifications Requirements
Respondent shall submit one (1) unbound original and one (1) electronic version on a
flash drive of qualifications documents.
4.1 State the name, address, and company profile, including size, qualifications,
technical capabilities, etc.
4.2 Include a list of the key personnel and managers of the firm. Provide a summary
of the project team, field staff, and their capabilities and detailed experience with
downtown design best practices guides, historic preservation, downtown
revitalization, municipal zoning review, public engagement, architectural
visualization/rendering, Wisconsin municipalities. Also note their ability to meet
the project workload within the timelines established.
4.3 Provide examples of related experience performed by the firm during the previous
five (5) years (projects with services similar to those outlined in Section 5,
General Scope of Services). The firm and key personnel must have no less than
five (5) years’ actual business experience in the services to be provided. Provide
two samples of actual completed design best practices guides.
4.4 Provide a statement describing your approach to the project and overall project
management including: cost control, quality assurance, and other factors that
impact the project. Note experience with applicable federal and state regulations,
budget management, as well as public participation and communication strategy,
etc.
4.5 Fee proposal. Provide a firm, fixed total price for completion of the services.
This price shall include any and all costs to perform the services to the City’s
satisfaction, including but not limited to all costs for materials, labor, travel,
supplies, permits, licenses, other typical reimbursable expenses, and indirect
costs.
Provide a detailed breakdown of the total price for the services for the entire term.
Please provide a specific line-item accounting for the cost of each and every task
and/or deliverable outlined in the Scope of Services.
Provide a schedule of billing rates by category of employee and job title to be
used during the term of the agreement. This fee schedule will be firm for at least
one (1) year from the date of the agreement. The fee schedule will be used as a
basis for determining fees should additional services be necessary. A fee
schedule for sub-consultants, if used, shall be included.
4.6 Provide a list of all subcontractors, proposed duties and functions, qualifications,
contact information, etc.
4.7 Complete the Statement of Qualifications Reference Form. Provide at least three
(3) references from current or recent clients familiar with your project team on
similar scoped projects.
[20261117R 113]
8
4.8 Complete the Qualification Evaluation Checklist. Reporting false, inaccurate, or
misleading information shall be sufficient grounds for disqualification or contract
termination. When in doubt, attach a detailed answer or call for clarification.
4.9 The respondent shall include a statement that they made their own examination,
investigation and research regarding the method of doing the work, all conditions
affecting the work to be done, the labor, equipment and materials, and the
quantity of the work to be performed. The Proposer agrees that it has satisfied
itself by Proposer’s own investigation and research regarding all of such
conditions, and that Proposer’s conclusion to enter into the Service Agreement
and based upon such investigation and research, and that Proposer shall make no
claim against the City because of any of the estimates, statements or
interpretations made by any officer or agent of the City which may prove to be
erroneous in any respect.
4.10 There is no specified limit to the amount of material submitted in response to 4.1
through 4.9, however portions of submittals not clearly referencing the respective
section may not be considered in the evaluation of the firm.
[20261117R 114]
9
5. Scope of Services
5.1 Purpose and Background
The City of Superior, Wisconsin is requesting proposals for professional services to
create a clear and concise design façade and streetscape best practices guide document
for downtown buildings and streetscapes, as well as a series of façade recommendations
for up to 15 buildings in the downtown area.
The best practices guide document intent is to help the City accomplish important goals
related to planning and project design review for the public and private sectors by
clarifying expectations and communicating requirements and options to all stakeholders,
property owners, developers and the public. This document will shape redevelopment,
new construction, building additions, historic preservation, future grant and incentive
programs, and communication of expectations to property owners, developers and the
public the City’s best practices for downtown façades to create a cohesive downtown
area.
This document should be adaptable for future potential updates to the City’s zoning
ordinances. The document shall be developed in conjunction with several stakeholders, in
addition to the City, such as the Superior Business Improvement District, Chamber of
Commerce and others as deemed appropriate, residents, business owners and local
leaders. The best practices guide should also include consideration of Wisconsin
Department of Transportation regulations.
The downtown implementation area will be centered on the areas in and around Tower
Avenue but will not be limited to it.
This area is generally historic in character. Buildings in this area are typically multi-story
buildings with the occasional single-story building. This area contains a mix of
commercial and residential use buildings, varying in architectural character. The firm
shall address historically significant architectural features, character-defining elements,
appropriate rehabilitation approaches, appropriate and inappropriate alterations,
compatible infill, treatment of historic storefronts, preservation versus reconstruction.
The final document shall include design Best Practices for private and public properties.
5.2 Tasks
Please describe in your proposal your approach to the following tasks. Alternative
approaches to the scope, so long as the end result is achieved, may be included.
1. Review the existing City comprehensive plan and zoning codes and any other
documents that may assist the firm with developing a more in-depth
understanding of the past and present character, culture, and values of the
community.
[20261117R 115]
10
https://www.superiorwi.gov/DocumentCenter/View/13869/Superior-2040-Comp-
Plan
Code of Ordinances | Superior, WI | Municode Library
2. On-site visit and review of the project area, and host in-person/virtual
stakeholders’ meetings. The firm will prepare meeting agendas, presentation
materials, sign-in/attendance information, meeting summaries, public comments
received, and a written summary explaining how public/stakeholder feedback was
incorporated. This task should accomplish the following:
a. Kick-off meeting
b. Tours
c. One meeting with the Common Council, Plan Commission, or other City
bodies, as determined by the City, in accordance with applicable open
meetings requirements, to establish goals and outcomes
d. Two stakeholder and two public sessions
e. Record existing conditions as it relates to buildings, streetscapes and other
pertinent development patterns that may influence the design solution
3. With the direction of the City staff and input from stakeholders and the
community, draft a best practices guide for downtown building design as well as a
series of façade recommendations for up to 15 buildings in the downtown area.
The City determines the final policy direction. These best practices guide should
include the following elements:
a. block face design
b. site design
c. building design, massing, façade composition, and articulation
d. lighting
e. streetscape
f. signs
g. materials
4. Identify 15 buildings and provide façade recommendations for each of them.
Permission from the owners must be obtained by the firm before commencing this
task. Provide before and after images, as well as a description of the graphics and
future steps to accomplish each recommendation. Please provide in your proposal
with a per each façade cost for beyond the first 15, should the City elect to
complete more than 15 façade recommendations. Include consideration of in-
person owner meetings for any additional façade recommendations requested by
the City.
5. In-person review of the draft guide and façade recommendations with the City
and stakeholders to present and review the documents in order to prepare for a
final draft. The base fee should include at least two rounds of consolidated city
comments and revisions to the draft document. In-person meetings with each
[20261117R 116]
11
owner included in the 15 building façade recommendations to review the
recommendations.
6. Develop a final document based on the outcomes in Task 5, which includes
detailed recommendations and visuals.
7. Virtually attend a City Council meeting to present the final document. The final
document will be delivered in a single pdf, with clear graphics, and shall not be
longer than 25 pages, on 11x17 paper
6. Fee Proposal
The Consultant shall submit a total fee for the above-referenced services. The total shall
include a lump sum fee for all direct and indirect costs, including travel, meetings,
printing, photography, graphics, rendering public engagement, presentations, revisions,
and other services necessary to complete the scope of services.
Include a per each façade recommendation cost for beyond the first 15, should the City
elect to complete more than 15 façade recommendations. Include consideration of in-
person owner meetings, images, written description, and any other expenses to provide
additional façade recommendations requested by the City.
7. Evaluation Criteria
Proposals shall be evaluated by the Director of Planning, Contract Analyst, Planning
Department, and any others deemed appropriate by the City.
Evaluation of Proposals shall be based on the following criteria:
1. Relevant firm/team experience
2. Understanding and approach
o Quality/appropriateness of proposed methodology
o Public engagement approach
o Qualifications of project manager/key personnel
3. Reference’s satisfaction and quality of sample work
4. Schedule
5. Total Proposed Price
City reserves the right to include any other items that is deemed appropriate at the time of
evaluation.
[20261117R 117]
715.834.3161 | 3433 Oakwood Hills Parkway | Eau Claire, WI 54701-7698
www.AyresAssociates.com
October 20, 2026
City of Superior
Contract Analyst
1316 North 14th Street, 2nd floor
Superior, WI 54880
Re: Do wntown Design Best Practices Request for Proposal
Dear Selection Committee:
Downtown Superior already has what many communities are trying to create: authentic character, a recognizable urban
structure, and buildings that tell the story of the City. The opportunity is not to reinvent that identity, but to give property
owners, developers, and the City a clearer path for strengthening it.
That is how we see the Superior Downtown Design Best Practices project. The guide should be more than a document
on a shelf. It should become a practical design tool that helps people make better decisions, from the rehabilitation
of a storefront to the design of a block, streetscape, or new investment. The City’s scope reinforces that ambition by
connecting historic preservation, façade improvements, streetscape design, public engagement, and recommendations
for 15 downtown buildings.
» Historic character as a starting point. We will approach downtown’s existing buildings and storefronts as assets,
pairing preservation expertise with design thinking that helps historic properties remain relevant, useful, and
distinctly Superior.
» From façade to street. Building design cannot be separated from the public realm around it. Our team brings
façade, urban design, and streetscape thinking together so improvements to individual properties contribute to a
stronger and more cohesive downtown.
» Recommendations people can see. Clear before-and-after imagery, diagrams, and graphics will help turn design
principles into ideas that property owners and decision-makers can understand and act upon, an important part of
the City’s requested façade recommendations and final guide.
» A process grounded in Superior. The best ideas will come from combining professional judgment with the
knowledge of the people who use, own, operate, and invest in downtown every day. We will use that input to shape a
guide that is practical for Superior rather than simply importing best practices from somewhere else.
We see this project as an opportunity to help Superior establish a shared design language for downtown, one that
respects what is already there while giving the community confidence about what comes next.
Sincerely,
Ayres Associates Inc.
Alissa M. Santurri, PLA Matthew J . Ashby, AICP CUD
Project Manager V ice President – Development Services
715.202.8403 | SanturriA@AyresAssociates.com 97 0.797.3595 | AshbyM@AyresAssociates.com
[20261117R 118]
4
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
Project Team & Integrated Delivery Approach
Our team is intentionally structured around the core challenges of the Superior Downtown Design Best Practices project:
understanding and celebrating downtown Superior’s historic character, translating that character into practical building façade
and streetscape recommendations, and creating a clear, highly visual guide that can support future investment and
decision-making. Alissa Santurri will serve as Project Manager, coordinating an integrated team that includes Jay
Molokwu as Historic Preservation Lead, Craig Stoffel as Façade Design Lead, Josh Olhava as Community Engagement +
Planning Lead, Tiara Wuethrich as Visualization + Graphic Design Lead, and Chris Silewski as Technical Advisor for Streetscape
+ Urban Design. Matt Ashby will serve as Walking Workshop Facilitator for the optional in-person Downtown Walking
Workshop, guiding an on-the-ground conversation about the buildings, streets, and public spaces that define downtown.
This structure allows the team to work across the full scale of downtown, from the preservation and rehabilitation of individual
buildings to the relationship between storefronts, blocks, streetscapes, and the larger public realm. Historic preservation
and façade design will inform site and streetscape recommendations; community engagement and planning will connect
those ideas to local priorities; and visualization will make the recommendations clear and accessible to property owners, City
leaders, and the community. The optional walking workshop adds another layer to this process by bringing the conversation
directly into downtown, allowing participants to explore opportunities and challenges in context. Together, the team brings the
right perspectives to create a cohesive, practical, and implementable framework for downtown Superior.
Craig Stoffel, PLA
Façade Design Lead
Josh Olhava, AICP, PCCP
Community Engagement +
Planning Lead
Chris Silewski, PLA
Technical Advisor
for Streetscape +
Urban Design
Matt Ashby, AICP CUD
Urban Design Best
Practices Facilitator
Tiara Wuethrich, PLA
Visualization +
Graphic Design Lead
Jay Molokwu
Historic Preservation
Lead
City of
Superior
Alissa Santurri, PLA
Project Manager
[20261117R 119]
5
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Total Experience
15 Years
Registration
Professional Landscape
Architect, WI
Education
BS, Landscape Architecture,
University of Wisconsin-
Madison
Memberships
American Society of Landscape
Architects
Alissa Santurri, PLA
Project Manager I Senior Landscape Architect
Alissa will serve as the City’s primary point of contact and lead the overall
coordination of the project. She will be responsible for keeping the
multidisciplinary team aligned, managing the work plan and schedule,
coordinating meetings and deliverables, and bringing the various components
together into a concise and implementable Downtown Design Best Practices
document.
Alissa is an award-winning landscape architect with 15 years of experience leading
parks, recreation, public-space, healthcare, academic, and campus projects. Her
approach combines clear communication, practical decision-making, and strong
field knowledge to move complex projects forward while keeping community
priorities, project goals, and implementation needs aligned. Alissa leads
engagement activities that invite meaningful input at key decision points and
translate feedback into clear, buildable outcomes. She develops communication
approaches that help agencies, stakeholders, and community members
understand options, participate in the process, and see how priorities inform final
recommendations.
Alissa brings a wide-ranging portfolio that includes natural playscapes, park
and recreation systems, waterfront and trail environments, athletic facilities,
healthcare settings, academic institutions, and science and technology
campuses. Her work reflects a thoughtful balance of site design, public
engagement, technical coordination, schedule management, and practical
construction considerations.
Select Experience
• ECWRPC Small Business and Community Technical Assistance (SPARC)
Program, Various Locations, WI: Alissa worked closely with the community
of Omro to develop a plan for abandoned industrial parcels in the heart of
the downtown. The final illustrative plan brought multi-family housing and
economic development to the community.
• State Fair Park West Grounds Infrastructure Improvements,
West Allis, WI: Alissa provided landscape architecture services for
improvements around the Dairy Building, formerly the Cream Puff Pavilion.
The work included landscape and pedestrian-flow concepts, water main,
sanitary sewer, storm sewer, pavement, grading, accessibility improvements,
and colored concrete to improve aesthetics and visitor circulation
• Shipyard Plaza Phase II Development, Green Bay, WI
• Downtown Hortonville Master Plan, Hortonville, WI
• Cannery Trail Residences Roof Deck and Courtyard Renovation, Madison, WI
• Madlen Avenue Concept Refinement, Madison, WI
• Water Street Trail and Wall Design Services, Eau Claire, WI
Alissa keeps projects
moving forward with
clarity, coordination,
and a strong focus
on deliverability.
[20261117R 120]
6
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Jay Molokwu
Historic Preservation Lead I Planner
Jay will lead the historic preservation component of the project, providing
guidance related to Superior’s historic downtown character, character-defining
architectural elements, historic storefronts, appropriate rehabilitation,
compatible infill, and the relationship between preservation and reconstruction.
This role will emphasize protecting and reinforcing the historic character of
downtown Superior.
An urban designer and planner, Jay brings experience in historic preservation,
downtown planning, public engagement, and visual communication. She
combines architectural and urban design training with a practical ability to
analyze complex information and translate it into clear graphics, planning
materials, and recommendations. Her work supports communities as they
connect historic character with contemporary needs, helping stakeholders
understand preservation priorities, development options, and the role of
historic resources in long-term downtown vitality.
Jay has prepared educational materials for historic preservation, including
resource catalogs, oral histories, images, historically significant artifacts,
outreach materials, and a heritage trail map. She will help identify and
communicate the downtown’s historic assets, support preservation-focused
engagement and documentation, and contribute clear, context-sensitive
strategies that respect local character while informing future investment and
redevelopment decisions.
Select Experience
• Historic Preservation Plan and Downtown Historic Preservation
Design Guidelines, St. Cloud, FL: Jay supported planning efforts to
protect historic resources and architectural character while establishing
clear direction for alterations, additions, and new construction within a
historic preservation overlay district.
• Vision/Master Planning and Redevelopment Plan Update,
Crescent City, FL: Jay helped develop a vision and master plan that
builds on the community’s lakeside setting in the St. Johns watershed
while preserving its old-town character. The process brought together
stakeholders, residents and decision-makers to shape redevelopment
strategies, policy updates and implementation support for key sites, events
and recreation along the lakes.
• Williams Street Branding & Placemaking, Waukesha, WI
• Parks and Open Space Plan, Wauwatosa, WI
• Facility Location Plan, Sister Bay, WI
• Rural Plains Communities Regional Affordable Housing Needs Assessments
and Strategies, Limon, CO
Total Experience
5 Years
Education
MA, Urban Design, Florida
International University
MArch, Architecture, Florida
International University
AA, Architecture, Hillsborough
Community College
Memberships
American Institute of Architects
American Planning Association,
Florida Chapter
Jay blends historical
architecture, urban
design, and data
visualization to
support sustainable,
welcoming
communities.
[20261117R 121]
7
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Craig Stoffel, PLA
Façade Design Lead I Landscape Architect
Craig will lead the building façade design effort, translating the broader
downtown best practices into practical recommendations for individual
properties. Craig will focus on façade composition and articulation, storefront
design, materials, signs, building improvements, and development of
recommendations for the 15 buildings identified through the project. He will
coordinate before-and-after images and descriptions of the recommendations
and future steps for each building.
With more than 20 years of landscape architecture, urban revitalization, and
visualization experience, Craig brings a practical, place-based approach to
shaping memorable downtown environments. His work spans streetscape
revitalization, downtown development, plazas, pocket parks, corridor
improvements, trail systems, and community planning. Craig guides concepts
from early visioning through design development, coordinating with clients
and stakeholders to create solutions that respond to local character,
community goals, and implementation realities.
Craig is especially valued for his hand sketching, illustration, and visualization
skills, which bring building, streetscape, and public-realm ideas into focus
early in the planning process. Through design charrettes, workshops, and
stakeholder meetings, he uses real-time sketches and visual studies to
help participants compare alternatives, communicate priorities, and build a
shared understanding of possible outcomes. His work will support building
improvements that strengthen street presence, reinforce pedestrian-scale
detail, and connect individual projects to a cohesive downtown experience.
Select Experience
• ECWRPC Small Business and Community Technical Assistance
(SPARC) Program, Various Locations, WI: Craig supported community
planning and engagement through hand sketching and real-time visual
analysis. His illustrations helped participants discuss alternatives and
translate local priorities into clear planning concepts.
• Shipyard Plaza Phase II Development, Green Bay, WI: Craig
contributed landscape architecture, urban design, illustration, and
visualization support for this public-realm development project. His role
helped communicate design ideas and future possibilities for a prominent
waterfront and downtown setting.
• Wick Park Public Engagement, Milwaukee, WI: Craig used sketching
and illustration to support public engagement, helping community
members react to concepts and share input during the planning process.
• Historic Tram Park, Twin Buttes, Durango, CO: Craig contributed
to park planning and design for a historic tram site, providing relevant
experience in projects where public-realm improvements respond to
historic context.
• Sonnentag Event/Recreation Complex, Eau Claire, WI
Total Experience
20 Years
Registration
Professional Landscape
Architect, CO, AZ
Education
BS, Landscape Architecture,
Colorado State University
Craig is motivated
by helping people
see the possibility
before a place is
ever built.
[20261117R 122]
8
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Josh Olhava, AICP, PCCP
Community Engagement + Planning Lead I Planner
Josh will lead the planning and community engagement effort, translating the
downtown design and streetscape best practices into practical zoning review and
public outreach recommendations. He will focus on land use policies, procedures
and regulations; review how existing standards affect the built environment; and
help gather, organize and communicate community input to support the final
guide.
Josh brings 16 years of experience in community and strategic planning, urban
redevelopment, land use policy, and public facilitation. A recognized industry
expert in local government processes and process improvement, he combines
the skills of a certified planner, certified change practitioner, and trained process
improvement specialist to develop practical strategies for community and
organizational challenges. Josh leads multidisciplinary teams through complex
planning initiatives, guiding stakeholder conversations, building consensus,
and translating community priorities into clear, actionable recommendations.
His background in community and regional planning and historic preservation
supports an approach that respects local character while advancing
implementation. His experience spans downtown, corridor, master planning,
and land use initiatives throughout the Midwest, Mountain West, and Southeast,
reflecting an understanding of downtowns as civic, economic, and social centers.
Select Experience
• Comprehensive Plan Update 2026, Kimberly, WI: Contributed to
comprehensive and master planning, addressing community-wide direction
that can inform land use, redevelopment, transportation, housing, public
spaces, and implementation priorities.
• Downtown/Main Street Planning: Multiple Communities, CO; Douglas,
Hudson, WY: Led downtown and Main Street planning initiatives that
address community vision, land use, redevelopment, public engagement,
and implementation for traditional downtown areas.
• Design Guideline and Entitlement Support: McWhinney Development -
Broomfield, Johnstown, Loveland, CO
• Colorado Main Street Technical Support: Multiple Communities, CO Fee
Study Analysis: Broomfield*, Estes Park, Greeley, Larimer County, Windsor*,
CO
• Rural Plains Communities Regional Affordable Housing Needs Assessments
and Strategies, Limon, CO
• Comprehensive / Master Planning: Kimberly, WI; Evans, Lamar, Windsor*,
Wray, Yuma, CO; Douglas, Lander, Wright, WY; Chadron, NE
• Process Evaluations and Improvements: Broomfield*, Estes Park,
Greeley, Larimer County, Montezuma County, Severance, Windsor*, CO
• Land Use Regulation Analysis and Updates: Berthoud, Mead, NE Region
(Akron, Brush, Haxtun, Holyoke, Julesburg, Peetz, Wiggins, Wray), Pueblo,
Severance, Windsor*, CO; Douglas, Sheridan, WY
* Work done under prior employment
Total Experience
16 Years
Certifications
American Institute of Certified
Planners, Prosci
Certified Change Practitioner,
Prosci
Certificate in Historic
Preservation, University of
Cincinnati
Education
MS, Community Planning,
University of Cincinnati
BS, Community and Regional
Planning, Iowa State University
Memberhips
American Planning Association
(APA)
Colorado Chapter of the APA
Colorado President (2025-
present)
APA Colorado Executive Board
APA Colorado Professional
Development Committee
Josh turns
community voices
into actionable plans
to help communities
build momentum
around their future.
[20261117R 123]
9
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Total Experience
5 Years
Registration
Professional Landscape
Architect, WI
Education
BS, Landscape Architecture,
University of Wisconsin-
Madison
Memberships
American Society of Landscape
Architects, Member-at-Large
(WI ASLA)
Tiara Wuethrich, PLA
Visualization + Graphic Design Lead I Landscape
Architect
Tiara will serve as Visualization + Graphic Design lead helping to translate
the team’s broader downtown recommendations into clear visuals that City
staff, property owners, and the public can easily understand. She will focus
on concept graphics, plan illustrations, 3D renderings, and before-and-after
images that show façade improvements, streetscape recommendations,
and future steps for individual buildings identified through the project. Her
ability to translate planning ideas into compelling visual narratives using 3D
modeling, rendering, and CADD-integrated workflows will help make the final
guide practical, approachable, and ready to use.
Tiara brings experience supporting master planning, public-space design,
waterfronts, plazas, streetscapes, and urban redevelopment efforts. Her
portfolio includes visual and design support for park and urban design projects
in Wisconsin, including work through the East Central Wisconsin Regional
Planning Commission Small Business and Community Technical Assistance
Program, as well as planning and streetscape work that draws on local history,
ecology, community input, and district identity. She works closely with
planners, engineers, and project managers so that visual materials reflect
constructability, maintenance considerations, and program needs. Her visual
communication approach will help connect the community’s ideas with a clear
and compelling future for downtown.
Select Experience
• ECWRPC Small Business and Community Technical Assistance
(SPARC) Program, Various Locations, WI: Tiara provided visual-design
and technical-assistance support for community planning initiatives.
The program delivered tools through one-day workshops and helped
communities address needs ranging from zoning recommendations to
master planning.
• City of Marinette, WI: Led a citywide CORP process to evaluate
park conditions, access, and natural resource constraints along the
Menominee River and Green Bay shoreline, resulting in a prioritized,
grant-ready framework to guide reinvestment and long-term park system
improvements.
• City of Wauwatosa, WI: Supported the City’s CORP and recreation
planning efforts by evaluating parks, trails, and open spaces through a
system-level lens, helping establish priorities that align participation goals
with implementable improvements.
• State Fair Park West Grounds Infrastructure Improvements,
West Allis, WI
• Shipyard Plaza Phase II Development, Green Bay, WI
Tiara brings
environments to life
through engaging
design and visual
storytelling that
connects community
character, public
spaces, and future-
focused planning.
[20261117R 124]
10
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Total Experience
19 Years
Registration
Professional Landscape
Architect, WI, MN, FL
Education
BS, Environmental Design,
North Dakota State University
BLA, Landscape Architecture,
North Dakota State University
Memberships
American Society of Landscape
Architects, Treasurer
Chris Silewski, PLA
Technical Advisor for Streetscape + Urban Design I
Principal Landscape Architect
Chris will serve as Technical Advisor for Streetscape + Urban Design and
will guide the effort to translate the broader downtown best practices into
practical recommendations for the public realm. He will focus on streetscape
character, pedestrian amenities, wayfinding, signage, and downtown gateway
improvements, and will develop recommendations for the priority areas
identified through the project. His work with multiple smaller Wisconsin
communities on streetscape and wayfinding issues tied to signage is a strong
match for Superior’s downtown design and streetscape guidance.
Chris brings nearly two decades of experience in urban design, streetscape
planning, complete streets, multimodal corridors, and placemaking. He
provides strategic guidance for municipal streetscapes, urban infill, downtown
revitalization, and public-realm improvements. His approach combines
site analysis, community priorities, regulatory context, and practical
implementation considerations to shape streets and public spaces that
support local character, walkability, and long-term vitality.
Select Experience
• ECWRPC Small Business and Community Technical Assistance
(SPARC) Program, Various Locations, WI: Chris has participated in
these rapid design response exercises for rural communities for multiple
years, providing plans to assist communities in visioning, economic
development and grant funding.
• Harborview Plaza, Milwaukee, WI: Urban waterfront plaza with a
distinctive play structure, water features, canoe/kayak launch, and seating
that reconnects the city to its inner harbor and supports inclusive family
recreation.
• River Prairie Park, Altoona, WI: Vibrant riverside park adjacent to a
mixed-use district that features walking and bike trails, splash pad, play
areas, open green space, and places for community events and casual
gathering.
• St. Johns Avenue Reimagining, Palatka, FL: Chris supported
streetscape design, utility coordination, public engagement, community
outreach, and visualization for a downtown corridor inspired by Palatka’s
history, local ecology, and community social structures. The design
organized a pedestrian experience around individual district identities.
• Downtown Streetscape and Urban Design, Marinette, WI
• Eau Claire Parks and Recreation Plan and Eau Claire County Parks Master
Plan, WI
• Saratoga Lake & Riverwalk Plan, Waukesha, WI
• Shipyard Plaza Phase II Development, Green Bay, WI
• Sonnentag Event/Recreation Complex, Eau Claire, WI
Chris is driven
by the belief that
great public spaces
emerge when
vision, ecology, and
implementation are
aligned from the
beginning.
[20261117R 125]
11
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Total Experience
25 Years
Certification
American Institute of Certified
Planners
Education
MS, Urban Design, University of
Colorado
MS, Urban and Regional Planning
BS, Environmental Design,
University of Colorado
Presentations
• 2025 National Brownfield
Conference, This Ain’t A One
and Done: Creating a Brownfield
Program that Lasts
•2025 Radically Rural,
Innovations in Brownfield
Revitalization
•2025 American Planning
Association, Navigating Political
Challenges to Create a Housing
Code that Works
•2024 West Virginia Brownfield
Conference, How to Think Like A
Developer
•2023 National Main Street
Conference, A Practitioner’s
Guide to Redevelopment
•2023 Colorado Municipal
League, Small Lot Development
is No Small Thing
•2022 National Main Street
Conference, Demystifying
Brownfields in 4 Easy Points
(Brownfields as a vehicle for Main
Street Revitalization
Matt Ashby, AICP CUD
Urban Design Best Practices Facilitator I Principal
Urban Planner
Matt will serve as Urban Design Best Practices Facilitator for the Superior
Downtown Planning and Design project and as Walking Workshop Facilitator
for the optional in-person Downtown Walking Workshop. Drawing on his
background in downtown development, planning, design review, and zoning,
Matt will guide an on-the-ground discussion of the buildings, streets, and public
spaces that shape downtown Superior’s character and function. He will help
participants observe how the physical environment supports walkability, activity,
placemaking, redevelopment, and connections among public and private spaces.
His facilitation will translate workshop observations into practical considerations
for the project’s downtown vision and implementation priorities.
Matt is an urban planning professional with over two decades of industry
experience, including 15 years in public-sector service. His work spans
community development, downtown development, comprehensive and strategic
planning, code writing, design review, zoning entitlements, brownfield practices,
transportation planning, urban parks, and recreation planning. He served seven
years as the City of Cheyenne’s planning director and has led planning services
for communities across the country.
His relevant experience includes Colorado Main Street strategic planning for
more than 10 communities, Colorado Pickaxe Workshops for more than 25
Main Street communities, land development and housing code updates, unified
development code work, and EPA brownfield grant and area-wide planning. Matt
has helped communities turn EPA brownfield grants into millions of dollars in
public and private investment. His work on PlanCheyenne received the American
Planning Association’s Daniel Burnham Award, recognizing his ability to connect
big-picture community goals with practical planning and implementation.
Select Experience
• Colorado Main Street Strategic Planning, 10+ Main Street
communities: Led strategic planning support for more than 10 Main Street
communities, addressing downtown development priorities, community
visioning, and implementation direction.
• Colorado Pickaxe Workshops, 25+ Main Street communities: Facilitated
workshops for more than 25 Main Street communities, supporting on-the-
ground discussion of downtown conditions, development opportunities, and
community-focused strategies.
• Vision/Master Planning and Redevelopment Plan Update, City of
Crescent City FL: Contributed urban planning and redevelopment expertise
to a community vision and master planning update focused on future growth
and redevelopment direction.
• EPA Brownfield Grant and Area-Wide Planning, Craig, CO: Supported
planning to guide brownfield reuse and redevelopment, helping connect
environmental remediation with investment, public spaces, and broader
economic development objectives.
[20261117R 126]
22
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
Canal Park Restoration, Duluth, MN
Phoenix Park Redevelopment, Eau Claire, WI
Listen. Align. Design. Deliver.
4.4 APPROACH &
METHODOLOGY
[20261117R 127]
23
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
Methodology
Understanding
Downtown Superior is at an important intersection of preservation and reinvestment. Its historic buildings, storefronts,
streets, and public spaces establish a character worth protecting, while continued redevelopment requires clear guidance
for how new investment can contribute to that character. The City is seeking a best practices guide that can bridge those
needs, providing practical direction for building façades, compatible infill, site design, streetscapes, lighting, signage, and
materials while remaining adaptable to future zoning updates.
We understand that success will depend on making these ideas tangible and usable. The 15 façade recommendations
create an opportunity to demonstrate how broader design principles can translate to real properties, while engagement
with property owners, businesses, residents, stakeholders, and City leadership will help ground the recommendations in
downtown Superior itself. Our goal is to connect these scales, from storefront to block to street, into a concise and highly
visual guide that gives the City and community a practical framework for shaping downtown investment over time.
Approach
A successful downtown design guide must do more than describe good design. It must help the City, property owners,
developers, and community members make confident decisions about real buildings and public spaces. Our Collect,
Connect, Consider, Commit framework begins with downtown Superior as it exists today, brings local knowledge into
the design process, tests recommendations against actual properties, and concludes with a concise guide that can
support both near-term improvements and long-term reinvestment.
The process is intentionally iterative.
Engagement does not occur as a single
isolated task, and design does not
begin after engagement ends. Instead,
information is gathered, shared, tested,
refined, and documented throughout
the project. This structure allows the
City to establish policy direction at key
milestones while keeping the work focused
on the required schedule, budget, and final
deliverables.
COLLECT CONNECT CONSIDER COMMIT
We begin with a data farm. Collecting as
much information about the site as is
publicly available, in addition to
identifying opportunities in the context
that may bene/f_it the project.
Once an understanding of the site has
been acquired, it is time to engage the
users. Analyzing the integration of
users and space and realizing the goals
and desires, lead to the success of
the project.
With the site and project goals
in-hand, concept development
begins. Through and iterative process,
spaces become de/f_ined and the
design begins to take shape.
Finally, following the approved
design, we focus in on the /f_inal
design. Verifying constructibility and
clarity, leading to an effortless
construction phase.
COLLECT CONNECT CONSIDER COMMIT
We begin with a data farm. Collecting as
much information about the site as is
publicly available, in addition to
identifying opportunities in the context
that may bene/f_it the project.
Once an understanding of the site has
been acquired, it is time to engage the
users. Analyzing the integration of
users and space and realizing the goals
and desires, lead to the success of
the project.
With the site and project goals
in-hand, concept development
begins. Through and iterative process,
spaces become de/f_ined and the
design begins to take shape.
Finally, following the approved
design, we focus in on the /f_inal
design. Verifying constructibility and
clarity, leading to an effortless
construction phase.
[20261117R 128]
24
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
01 | COLLECT
Understand Downtown Superior Before Recommending Its Future
Objective
Establish a shared understanding of downtown Superior’s
physical character, historic resources, regulatory framework,
community values, and current development patterns. This
initial phase will create the factual and visual foundation for
the best practices guide and façade recommendations.
TASKS
1. Project initiation and management framework
We will begin with a virtual kickoff meeting with City staff
to confirm project goals, roles, communication protocols,
schedule, stakeholder groups, available background
information, and decision-making responsibilities. The
team will also confirm expectations for consolidated City
review, property-owner coordination, public meetings,
and final document production.
Following the kickoff, we will prepare a detailed work
plan organized around the City’s required milestones,
including the March 30, 2027, draft and April 30, 2027,
final document deadlines.
2. Plans, policies, and regulatory review
The team will review the Superior 2040 Comprehensive
Plan, zoning and development regulations, applicable
downtown plans and studies, historic-resource
information, relevant grant or incentive programs, and
other materials provided by the City. This review will
focus on identifying:
Existing goals for downtown revitalization,
preservation, growth, and public investment
Zoning provisions that affect building placement,
height, massing, façades, signs, lighting, site design,
and parking
Areas where the best practices guide could clarify,
support, or inform future City policy
Applicable state and federal considerations,
including accessibility requirements and relevant
Wisconsin Department of Transportation
requirements
Existing recommendations that should be carried
forward, clarified, or updated
The intent is not to repeat existing plans or ordinances.
It is to understand where the new guide can make
design expectations clearer and more useful.
3. Downtown field review and documentation
The multidisciplinary team will conduct an on-site
tour of the downtown implementation area, centered
on Tower Avenue while also considering surrounding
blocks and connections. The field review will record
existing conditions affecting both private property and
the public realm, including:
Downtown blocks and development patterns
Building types, scale, massing, and architectural
character
Historic storefronts and character-defining features
Building façades, entrances, signs, lighting, and
materials
Vacant, underused, altered, and infill properties
Sidewalks, streetscape elements, crossings,
furnishings, and pedestrian conditions
The relationship between buildings, sites, parking,
and streets
Opportunities for coordinated public and private
investment
Field observations will be documented through
photography, annotated maps, written observations,
and initial building-character classifications.
4. Preliminary façade candidate identification
Working with City staff, the team will establish criteria
for selecting the 15 façade recommendation properties.
Criteria may include visibility, architectural significance,
geographic distribution, building type, degree of need,
potential community impact, owner interest, and
the ability to demonstrate broadly applicable design
principles. The City and consultant team will develop a
preliminary candidate list. Final participation will depend
on property-owner interest and permission.
Deliverables
• Kickoff meeting agenda, presentation, and summary
• Detailed project work plan and milestone schedule
• Background document and regulatory review
summary
• Existing-conditions photo inventory
• Annotated downtown analysis maps
• Initial building and storefront character observations
• Preliminary façade candidate criteria and property list
• Initial project opportunities, constraints, and
decision log
[20261117R 129]
25
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
02 | CONNECT
Build the Guide Around Local Knowledge and Shared Priorities
Objective
Engage City leadership, property owners, businesses,
residents, and downtown stakeholders in a focused
conversation about what should be protected, what should
change, and how the guide can become a practical tool for
reinvestment.
TASKS
1. Public participation and communication strategy
At the beginning of this phase, the team will prepare
a concise engagement plan identifying audiences,
meeting objectives, formats, communication
responsibilities, input methods, documentation
procedures, and decision points.
Each engagement activity will be designed to answer
a specific project question. Rather than asking
participants broad questions about what they like
or dislike, we will use maps, photographs, building
examples, and visual preference exercises to discuss:
What makes downtown Superior recognizable
Which architectural and streetscape characteristics
should be reinforced
Where existing conditions create barriers to
investment
What guidance property owners need to make
improvements
How preservation, rehabilitation, and new
construction can work together
What would make the guide easier for the City and
property owners to use.
2. Downtown tour and working sessions
The project team will conduct the required downtown
tour in coordination with City staff and selected
stakeholders. The tour will allow participants to discuss
existing conditions in place and identify recurring issues
that should be addressed in the guide.
Observations from the tour will be recorded and
incorporated into the existing-conditions analysis.
3. City body goal-setting meeting
The team will participate in one meeting with the
Common Council, Plan Commission, or another City
body selected by the City. This session will establish
desired outcomes, confirm major project priorities, and
clarify the City’s role in setting final policy direction.
Stakeholder and public sessions
We will plan and facilitate:
Two (2) stakeholder sessions
Two (2) public sessions
One (1) meeting with the Common Council, Plan
Commission, or other designated City body
Early sessions will focus on downtown character,
opportunities, concerns, and desired outcomes. Later
sessions will test draft design concepts, priorities, and
the clarity of the proposed guidance.
The team will prepare agendas, presentation materials,
sign-in and attendance information, comment records,
meeting summaries, and a written explanation of how
public and stakeholder feedback influenced the work.
4. Property-owner outreach and permissions
The team will coordinate with the City to contact owners
of the proposed façade properties, explain the purpose
and expectations of the program, request permission to
proceed, and schedule owner discussions.
If a selected owner declines to participate, the team will
move to an agreed-upon alternate property. Written
permission will be obtained before façade design work
begins.
5. Synthesis of community input
Following the initial engagement activities, the team
will organize feedback into clear project themes. Input
will be compared against field observations, regulatory
requirements, City policy, and professional design
judgment.
The result will be a concise set of guiding principles for
City review. These principles will provide direction for the
guide without treating every individual comment as a
design requirement.
Deliverables
• Public participation and communication plan
• Downtown tour materials and summary
• City body meeting agenda, presentation, attendance
record, and summary
• Agendas and presentation materials for two
stakeholder sessions
• Agendas and presentation materials for two public
sessions
[20261117R 130]
26
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
• Sign-in and attendance documentation
• Public and stakeholder comment record
• Property-owner outreach materials
• Written owner permissions for participating properties
• Engagement findings and incorporation matrix
• City-confirmed guiding principles for the draft guide
03 | CONSIDER
Translate What We Learn into Practical Design Guidance
Objective
Develop and test a coordinated set of best practices
addressing buildings, façades, sites, blocks, and
streetscapes, then demonstrate those principles through
recommendations for 15 actual downtown properties
TASKS
1. Best practices guide framework
Before producing the full draft, the team will prepare
an annotated outline and graphic framework for City
review. This early checkpoint will confirm the guide’s
organization, level of detail, visual language, and
relationship to existing City regulations.
The outline will be structured around the topics
required by the City:
Block-face design
Site design
Building design and massing
Façade composition and articulation
Lighting
Streetscape
Signs
Materials
The framework will also address historic architectural
features, character-defining elements, appropriate
rehabilitation, inappropriate alterations, compatible
infill, historic storefronts, and preservation versus
reconstruction.
2. Develop design principles and recommendations
For each topic, the team will identify:
The intended design outcome
Conditions commonly found in downtown Superior
Recommended practices
Practices to avoid
Considerations for historic buildings and
compatible infill
Relationships to City codes or future policy
Implementation considerations
Visual examples or diagrams needed to explain the
guidance
Recommendations will be specific enough to support
project conversations while remaining flexible enough
to respond to different building types, ownership
conditions, and investment levels
3. Prepare 15 façade recommendations
For each participating property, the team will:
Review existing building conditions and available
information
Meet with the property owner
Identify historic and character-defining building
features
Discuss owner objectives and likely improvement
priorities
Develop a recommended façade concept
Prepare before-and-after imagery
Describe the intent of the proposed improvements
Identify potential next steps for implementation
The façade concepts will illustrate a practical
design direction rather than constitute construction
documents. Each recommendation will connect to
the broader principles in the guide, allowing the 15
properties to function as applied examples rather than
unrelated design exercises.
4. Coordinate building and public-realm
recommendation
The historic preservation, façade design, streetscape,
planning, and visualization disciplines will review the
work together. This coordination will ensure that façade
recommendations support the larger block face and
that streetscape recommendations account for building
entrances, storefront activity, visibility, signs, pedestrian
movement, and surrounding context.
5. Internal quality review
Before the draft is issued to the City, the team will
complete a multidisciplinary quality review. The review
will evaluate:
[20261117R 131]
27
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
Responsiveness to the approved guiding principles
Consistency between written and graphic
recommendations
Historic-preservation appropriateness
Planning and regulatory considerations
Technical accuracy
Accessibility and readability
Graphic consistency
Completeness against the RFP scope
Compliance with the 25-page, 11x17 final-document
requirement
Deliverables
• Annotated guide outline and graphic framework
• Draft design principles
• Draft recommendations for block face, site design,
buildings, façades, lighting, streetscape, signs, and
materials
• Draft historic-preservation and compatible-infill
guidance
• Existing-condition documentation for 15 properties
• Draft before-and-after images for 15 façade
recommendations
• Written description and suggested next steps for
each façade
• Internal quality-control checklist
• Draft Downtown Design Best Practices guide
04 | COMMIT
Refine, Document, and Position the Guide for Use
Objective
Confirm the guide with City staff, stakeholders, and
participating property owners; document how comments
were addressed; and deliver a concise, accessible tool
that the City can use to guide future public and private
investment.
TASKS
1. In-person draft review
The team will present the draft guide and façade
recommendations during an in-person review with the
City and stakeholders. The presentation will focus on
key recommendations, how community input shaped
the draft, and decisions requiring City direction.
Visual materials will be used to make the
recommendations understandable to technical and
nontechnical audiences.
2. Individual property-owner meetings
The team will meet in person during one trip with each
owner participating in the 15 façade recommendations.
During these meetings, the team will explain the
recommendation, discuss owner feedback, clarify
that the concept is advisory, and identify appropriate
revisions.
Owner feedback will be considered alongside the
historic, design, regulatory, and project-wide goals of
the guide.
3. Consolidated City review and revisions
The base scope will include two (2) rounds of
consolidated City comments and revisions.
To maintain schedule and budget, the project manager
will provide the City with a comment matrix for each
review. The City will be asked to reconcile internal
comments and return one consolidated set of direction
at each milestone. The team will document how
comments were addressed and identify decisions that
require further City direction.
4. Final guide production
The team will refine the written recommendations,
façade concepts, diagrams, and document layout into
one coordinated final guide. The document will be
designed for use on screen and in print, with a clear
hierarchy, legible graphics, accessible navigation, and
appropriately described visual content.
The final guide will be delivered as a single PDF, not
more than 25 pages, formatted at 11x17, as required by
the City.
5. City Council presentation
The team will prepare for and virtually attend a City
Council meeting to present the final document. The
presentation will explain:
[20261117R 132]
28
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
What the team learned about downtown Superior
How the public and stakeholders informed the
work
The major design principles
How the façade recommendations demonstrate
those principles
How the guide can support future review,
investment, and implementation
Deliverables
• In-person draft review presentation
• Draft review meeting summary
• Fifteen (15) in-person property-owner meetings
• Property-owner comment record
• Two (2) City review comment matrices
• Two (2) rounds of consolidated revisions
• Public and stakeholder feedback incorporation
summary
• Final Downtown Design Best Practices guide
• One (1) accessible, graphically clear PDF
• Final City Council presentation
• Virtual City Council attendance and presentation
Optional Task | DOWNTOWN W ALKING WORKSHOP
Objective
Bring the design conversation directly into downtown
Superior through an interactive, in-person walking workshop.
The session will allow participants to observe buildings,
storefronts, blocks, streetscapes, and public spaces together,
creating a shared understanding of what is working, what is
getting in the way, and where the Downtown Design Best
Practices can have the greatest impact.
Rather than discussing design principles in the abstract,
the workshop will use downtown itself as the working
canvas. At a series of planned stops, our team will lead
focused conversations around historic character, façades,
storefronts, signs, site design, streetscape, materials, and
the relationship between buildings and the public realm.
Observations and ideas gathered during the walk will be
documented and carried directly into the development of
the guide and façade recommendations.
TASKS
Develop a focused walking-workshop agenda and field
guide.
Facilitate an approximately 90-minute to two-hour
walking workshop through the downtown study area.
Use specific buildings, storefronts, blocks, and
streetscapes to discuss preservation, design
opportunities, and recurring challenges.
Lead participants through targeted questions at key
stops to establish preferences and priorities.
Document observations, photographs, comments, and
recurring themes.
Synthesize workshop findings and incorporate relevant
direction into the Downtown Design Best Practices and
façade recommendations.
Deliverables
• Workshop route, agenda, and field materials
• Facilitated in-person Downtown Walking Workshop
• Photographic and written documentation of key
observations
• Concise workshop findings summary
• Integration of applicable findings into the draft guide
and façade recommendations
[20261117R 133]
29
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
Project Management
One Point of Accountability
Alissa Santurri, Project Manager, will serve as the City’s primary point of contact and be responsible for coordinating the team,
schedule, budget, meetings, reviews, and deliverables. The project manager will maintain continuity among the preservation, façade
design, planning, engagement, visualization, streetscape, and urban-design workstreams.
At kickoff, the team and City will agree on communication protocols, milestone dates, review responsibilities, and decision authority.
Regular coordination meetings will be concise and decision-focused, supported by agendas, action items, and a current decision log.
SCHEDULE
MANAGEMENT
COST
CONTROL
QUALITY
OF WORK
Quality will be built into the process
rather than reserved for a final
proofreading exercise. Reviews will
occur at the end of each phase and
before major submissions.
The quality-assurance process will
include:
• Scope review: Confirm that the
proposed content addresses
each required RFP task and
deliverable.
• Technical review: Check
preservation, planning, urban
design, streetscape, façade,
accessibility, and regulatory
considerations.
• Interdisciplinary review:
Confirm that building, site,
block, and public-realm
recommendations work together.
• Graphic review: Verify that
diagrams and before-and-after
images accurately support the
written recommendations.
• Editorial review: Check clarity,
consistency, terminology,
grammar, and document
navigation.
• Final compliance review:
Confirm file format, page size,
page limit, accessibility, and
delivery requirements.
The project manager will be
responsible for closing review
comments before each submission.
Cost control begins with a clearly
defined work plan, disciplined review
process, and early agreement on what
each deliverable must accomplish. The
project manager will monitor effort by
phase and task against the approved
fee and will review progress at regular
intervals.
Our cost-management practices will
include:
• Aligning labor and budget with the
work breakdown structure
• Using senior specialists at key
decision points while assigning
production efficiently
• Confirming meeting purposes and
desired decisions before materials
are prepared
• Developing the guide outline
before full writing and graphic
production
• Securing owner permission before
beginning property-specific façade
concepts
• Using one consolidated City
comment set for each review round
• Maintaining a decision and change
log
• Identifying potential scope changes
before additional work proceeds
• Providing a separate unit cost
for each additional façade
recommendation beyond the first 15
No additional service will be
undertaken without first documenting
the proposed scope, schedule effect,
and fee for City authorization.
The project schedule will be
organized backward from the City’s
required draft and final delivery
dates. Each phase will include a
clear City decision point before the
team advances to the next level of
detail.
The working schedule will track:
• Required meetings and
engagement activities
• Property-owner permissions and
coordination
• Existing-conditions
documentation
• Guide outline approval
• Façade concept development
• Internal quality reviews
• Draft delivery
• Two consolidated City review
periods
• Final production
• City Council presentation
Potential schedule risks, particularly
owner permissions, meeting
availability, and delayed or
conflicting review comments, will
be identified early and discussed
with the City before they affect
subsequent work.
[20261117R 134]
30
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
Public Participation + Communication Framework
Our approach to public participation is built around a simple principle: engagement should influence the work, not
simply document that engagement occurred. The strategy will be transparent and visual, with each meeting tied to a
defined decision. Participants will be shown how previous input affected the work.
The team will maintain:
• Consistent project messaging
• Clear meeting agendas
• Accessible presentation materials
• Attendance and comment records
• Summaries written for public understanding
• A feedback incorporation matrix
• A record of City direction and major decisions
For the Superior Downtown Design Best Practices project, each interaction will be tied to a specific decision in the design
process. Early conversations will help us understand what the community values about downtown and where change is
needed. As ideas develop, engagement will shift toward testing priorities, reviewing recommendations, and building a shared
understanding of how the guide can support reinvestment. Property owners will have a particularly important role, providing
direct input on the 15 façade recommendations before those concepts are finalized.
The engagement process will follow the same Collect, Connect, Consider, Commit framework as the overall project approach.
Communication will be visual and place-based, using photographs, maps, precedent imagery, façade concepts, and diagrams
to make design conversations accessible. The optional Downtown Walking Workshop, facilitated by Matt Ashby, strengthens
this approach by moving the conversation onto the street, where participants can discuss buildings, storefronts, blocks, and
public spaces in context. Throughout the process, we will maintain a clear record of what we heard, what we learned, and how
that input shaped the recommendations.
Regulatory and Technical Coordination
The team will review relevant local plans and ordinances and consider applicable state and federal requirements within the
scope of the guide. Particular attention will be given to Wisconsin Department of Transportation (WisDOT) considerations,
open meetings requirements, accessibility, historic-resource considerations, and the relationship between best practices and
potential future zoning updates, all of which are identified or anticipated in the City’s requested work.
Where the guide provides design recommendations rather than regulatory requirements, that distinction will be clearly
communicated. This will help the City use the document appropriately and reduce confusion for property owners and
applicants.
Listen to
Superior
Experience
Downtown
Together
Test the Ideas Show How Input
Shaped the
Outcome
[20261117R 135]
31
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
Brownfield Reimagining I Racine, WI
Value-driven. Clear and accountable.
4.5 FEE
PROPOSAL
[20261117R 136]
FEE
PROPOSAL
BASIS OF FEE
Our proposed fee is structured to align with the services
requested in the RFP and the phased progression of the
project from planning refinement through implementation.
The base fee reflects the professional services required to
complete the project.
Alissa Santurri
715.202.8403
SanturriA@AyresAssociates.com
Matt Ashby
970.797.3595
AshbyM@AyresAssociates.com
Ayres Associates Inc.
3433 Oakwood Hills Parkway
Eau Claire, WI
AyresAssociates.com
Should you have any questions about the proposed fee or scope,
please feel free to contact us.
EXCLUSIONS
Unless specifically identified as an optional or additional
service, the following items are excluded from the base fee:
• Survey
• Environmental testing, hazardous materials assess-
ment, or remediation
• Wetland delineation
• Geotechnical investigation
• Construction level documentation
• Permit and application fees
• Architectural drawings and specifications
A breakdown by phase is shown below.
Task Cost
01: Collect $8,000
02: Connect $6,000
03: Consider $10,000
04: Commit $7,000
TOTAL $31,000
Optional: Walking Workshop $4,000
Additional Tasks Cost
Cost per façade
recommendation beyond 15
$1,350(ea)
[20261117R 137]
33
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
AYRES DEVELOPMENT SERVICES
Billing Category 2026 Per Hour
Rate
Principal $ 300.00
Service Group Manager $ 250.00
Service Group Supervisor $ 235.00
Senior Project Manager 5/Business Development Strategist $ 225.00
Senior Project Manager 4 $ 215.00
Senior Project Manager 3 $ 205.00
Senior Project Manager 2 $ 200.00
Senior Project Manager 1 $ 195.00
Project Manager 5 $ 190.00
Project Manager 4 $ 185.00
Project Manager 3 $ 180.00
Project Manager 2 $ 175.00
Project Manager 1 $ 165.00
Professional 5 $ 155.00
Professional 4 $ 145.00
Professional 3/Project Controller $ 140.00
Professional 2 $ 135.00
Professional 1 $ 130.00
Junior Professional 3/Technician 4 $ 125.00
Administrative/Accounting $ 110.00
Junior Professional 2/Technician 3 $ 105.00
Junior Professional I/Graphic Designer/ Tech 2 $ 100.00
Intern $ 80.00
This schedule of charges shall be in effect from January 1 through December 31, 2026. These rates are
subject to an annual adjustment to be determined by Ayres Associates and shall become its prevailing
rates for the ensuing year.
[20261117R 138]
34
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
4.6 - 4.9
FORMS
[20261117R 139]
35
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
12
8. Professional Services
Date: _____________
City of Superior, Wisconsin
I/we, the undersigned, being familiar with your local conditions, having made a field
inspection and investigation that I/we deemed necessary, having studied the scope of
work and being familiar with all the factors and other conditions affecting the work, are
hereto attaching the following documents:
1) Subcontractors List
2) Addenda Acknowledgment
3) Qualification & Evaluation Checklist
4) References
I/we, the undersigned, hereby propose to furnish all labor, tools, materials, skills,
equipment and all else necessary to complete the work, in accordance with the
specifications, and are hereby submitting the following proposal:
Total Cost (Not-to-Exceed): $______________________________________________
Amount in written figures: ______
Completion Date: __________________(date)
Interested firms may, at their discretion, suggest additional services not explicitly requested by
this RFP. Proposals should include line-item costs for additional services. Please note that
additional services may or may not be awarded by the City and that costs for additional services
are excluded from the base proposal.
SIGNATURE____________________________________ Date___________________
Print Name______________________________________________________________
Name of Company________________________________________________________
Address_________________________________________________________________
Phone_______________________________Fax_________________________________
E-mail Addrees___________________________________________________________
10/20/2026
10/20/2026
10/20/2026
31,000
Thirty-one thousand dollars
Matthew J. Ashby, AICP CUD
Ayres Associates Inc.
3433 Oakwood Hills Parkway, Eau Claire, WI 54701-7698
970.797.3595 715.831.7500
AshbyM@AyresAssociates.com
[20261117R 140]
36
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
13
9. Subcontractors Listing (Must be submitted with proposal.)
Superior Downtown Design Best Practices
The undersigned agrees to employ the following listed subcontractors for the following
enumerated classes of work and not to alter or add to such list without the written consent
of the City of Superior, WI. Use separate sheet as necessary.
SUBCONTRACTOR CLASS OF WORK
1)
2)
3)
4)
5)
Submitted by: COMPANY
ADDRESS
COMPANY REPRESENTATIVE
NONE
Matthew J. Ashby, AICP CUD
Ayres Associates Inc.
3433 Oakwood Hills Parkway, Eau Claire, WI 54701-7698
[20261117R 141]
37
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
14
10. Addenda Acknowledgement (Must be submitted with Proposal)
Superior Downtown Design Best Practices
I/we hereby acknowledge receipt of the following addenda(s):
Addendum No. Dated
Addendum No. Dated
Addendum No. Dated
Addendum No. Dated
I/we further certify that no agreement has been entered into to prevent competition for
said work and that I/we carefully examined the site where the work is to take place, and
the plans, specifications, form of contract and all other contract documents.
I/we further agree to enter into the contract, as provided in the contract documents, under
all the terms, conditions and requirements of those documents.
* If no addenda were issued, the consultant/firm shall so indicate and sign this document.
________________________________________
Company
Representative Signature
09/29/20261
Ayres Associates Inc.
[20261117R 142]
38
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
15
11. Qualification Evaluation Checklist
Owner: _______________________________________________________________
Contact Person: _________________________________________________________
Address: _______________________________________________________________
City: ________________________________________________ State: ____________
Zip: _____________________
Telephone: _______________________________
Yes Sub No # Question
1.
How many years has your firm been engaged in the consulting business
under the present firm name? ________________________
□ □ 2. Has your firm ever failed to complete any work awarded to you?
Comment/Explanation:
Instructions:
1. When filling out the checklist check “YES” only to those services provided “in-house” by
your firm (or prior experience of key personnel anticipated to perform a substantial
amount of the project work) and check “SUB” for services you intend to subcontract out.
List the subcontracting firm in the “Comments/Explanation” area.
2. Respondents are encouraged to add comments and to attach more detailed information
where appropriate in response to checklist items. Such clarification can greatly assist the
evaluation process. Firms may include other information as they deem appropriate.
3. Attach to this checklist any appropriate licenses, certification, degrees, or appropriate
training that will assist in qualifying your firm for these services.
4. Consultant qualifications will be determined using this checklist along with the
information provided as outlined in the “Requirements for Statement of Qualifications”.
5. Firms are expected to answer “YES” to some of the checklist items, but not all of them.
6. False, inaccurate or misleading information shall be grounds for disqualification at any
time during and after the selection process. When in doubt attach a detailed answer or
call for clarification.
15
11. Qualification Evaluation Checklist
Owner: _______________________________________________________________
Contact Person: _________________________________________________________
Address: _______________________________________________________________
City: ________________________________________________ State: ____________
Zip: _____________________
Telephone: _______________________________
Yes Sub No # Question
1.
How many years has your firm been engaged in the consulting business
under the present firm name? ________________________
□ □ 2. Has your firm ever failed to complete any work awarded to you?
Comment/Explanation:
Instructions:
1. When filling out the checklist check “YES” only to those services provided “in-house” by
your firm (or prior experience of key personnel anticipated to perform a substantial
amount of the project work) and check “SUB” for services you intend to subcontract out.
List the subcontracting firm in the “Comments/Explanation” area.
2. Respondents are encouraged to add comments and to attach more detailed information
where appropriate in response to checklist items. Such clarification can greatly assist the
evaluation process. Firms may include other information as they deem appropriate.
3. Attach to this checklist any appropriate licenses, certification, degrees, or appropriate
training that will assist in qualifying your firm for these services.
4. Consultant qualifications will be determined using this checklist along with the
information provided as outlined in the “Requirements for Statement of Qualifications”.
5. Firms are expected to answer “YES” to some of the checklist items, but not all of them.
6. False, inaccurate or misleading information shall be grounds for disqualification at any
time during and after the selection process. When in doubt attach a detailed answer or
call for clarification.
15
11. Qualification Evaluation Checklist
Owner: _______________________________________________________________
Contact Person: _________________________________________________________
Address: _______________________________________________________________
City: ________________________________________________ State: ____________
Zip: _____________________
Telephone: _______________________________
Yes Sub No # Question
1.
How many years has your firm been engaged in the consulting business
under the present firm name? ________________________
□ □ 2. Has your firm ever failed to complete any work awarded to you?
Comment/Explanation:
Instructions:
1. When filling out the checklist check “YES” only to those services provided “in-house” by
your firm (or prior experience of key personnel anticipated to perform a substantial
amount of the project work) and check “SUB” for services you intend to subcontract out.
List the subcontracting firm in the “Comments/Explanation” area.
2. Respondents are encouraged to add comments and to attach more detailed information
where appropriate in response to checklist items. Such clarification can greatly assist the
evaluation process. Firms may include other information as they deem appropriate.
3. Attach to this checklist any appropriate licenses, certification, degrees, or appropriate
training that will assist in qualifying your firm for these services.
4. Consultant qualifications will be determined using this checklist along with the
information provided as outlined in the “Requirements for Statement of Qualifications”.
5. Firms are expected to answer “YES” to some of the checklist items, but not all of them.
6. False, inaccurate or misleading information shall be grounds for disqualification at any
time during and after the selection process. When in doubt attach a detailed answer or
call for clarification.
Matthew J. Ashby, Vice President - Development Services
Ayres Associates Inc.
3433 Oakwood Hills Parkway
Ayres was established April 28, 1959, as Garnock, Ayres and Loken Engineering and
Surveying. The company was renamed Owen Ayres & Associates, Inc. in 1962. It adopted
the trade name Ayres Associates in 1984 and changed its legal name to Ayres Associates
Inc. on Dec. 3, 2004.
Clients may stop projects for a range of reasons. Ayres does not record or track instances
in which a project is stopped, the circumstances surrounding the decision, or comparable
details related to work employees performed before joining Ayres. Therefore, Ayres cannot
provide a definitive statement that it has or has not failed to complete work.
Eau Claire WI
54701-7698
970.797.3595
Please see
comment
[20261117R 143]
39
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
16
Yes Sub No # Question
□ □ 3. Has your firm ever defaulted on a contract?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ 4.
Has your firm ever had claims filed for errors and omissions or been sued
for services you provided?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ 5.
Is your firm willing to provide (at no cost to the City) an on-site or virtual
presentation to the City regarding your firm’s qualifications?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ □ 6.
Have you reviewed the example of the service contract attached and are
willing to sign a similar agreement?
Comment/Explanation:
16
Yes Sub No # Question
□ □ 3. Has your firm ever defaulted on a contract?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ 4.
Has your firm ever had claims filed for errors and omissions or been sued
for services you provided?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ 5.
Is your firm willing to provide (at no cost to the City) an on-site or virtual
presentation to the City regarding your firm’s qualifications?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ □ 6.
Have you reviewed the example of the service contract attached and are
willing to sign a similar agreement?
Comment/Explanation:
16
Yes Sub No # Question
□ □ 3. Has your firm ever defaulted on a contract?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ 4.
Has your firm ever had claims filed for errors and omissions or been sued
for services you provided?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ 5.
Is your firm willing to provide (at no cost to the City) an on-site or virtual
presentation to the City regarding your firm’s qualifications?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ □ 6.
Have you reviewed the example of the service contract attached and are
willing to sign a similar agreement?
Comment/Explanation:
To the best of Ayres’ knowledge, no owner has directly notified Ayres that it was
terminated for default as defined within the past five years. Ayres does not track the
reasons clients may terminate projects.
Please refer to the list on the following page for full details.
Ayres will want to review the final language and limitations of the contract to ensure that
it does not unduly obligate Ayres to indemnify actions not associated with negligence
caused by our performance.
X
X
X
16
Yes Sub No # Question
□ □ 3. Has your firm ever defaulted on a contract?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ 4.
Has your firm ever had claims filed for errors and omissions or been sued
for services you provided?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ 5.
Is your firm willing to provide (at no cost to the City) an on-site or virtual
presentation to the City regarding your firm’s qualifications?
Comment/Explanation:
□ □ □ 6.
Have you reviewed the example of the service contract attached and are
willing to sign a similar agreement?
Comment/Explanation:
X
[20261117R 144]
44
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
17
12. Statement of Qualifications Reference Form
Applicant Firm Name:
Contact Person:
Address:
City, State, and Zip Code:
Telephone:
Reference #1
Owner or Company Name:
Contact Person:
Type of Service(s) Provided:
Calendar Year(s) of Service(s) Provided:
City, State, and Zip Code:
Telephone:
Reference #2
Owner or Company Name:
Contact Person:
Type of Service(s) Provided:
Calendar Year(s) of Service(s) Provided:
City, State, and Zip Code:
Telephone:
Reference #3
Owner or Company Name:
Contact Person:
Type of Service(s) Provided:
Calendar Year(s) of Service(s) Provided:
City, State, and Zip Code:
Telephone:
Alissa Santurri
Ayres Associates Inc.
East Central Wisconsin Regional Planning Commission
National Association of Development Organizations (NADO)
Colorado Department of Local Affairs, Colorado Main Street Program
Downtown and waterfront plans, streetscape and park improvements,
trail planning, alley designs, and organizational strategies.
Joe Stephenson, Economic Development Planner
Carrie Kissel, Associate Director
Gayle Langley, Program Coordinator
2021 - Present
SPARC started in 2021 and started partnering with NADO in 2025 to present
2020 - present
400 Ahnaip Street, Suite 100, Menasha, Wisconsin 54952
122 C Street, NW, Suite 830, Washington, DC 20001
1313 Sherman Street, Room 521, Denver, Colorado 80203
920.886.6832 I jstephenson@ecwrpc.org
202.921.4449 I ckissel@nado.org
303.864.7720 I gayle.langley@state.co.us
3433 Oakwood Hills Parkway
Eau Claire, WI 54701-7698
715.202.8403
Rapid site planning & technical assistance to support community & economic
development, transportation access, and small-business resilience for the Menominee
Indian Tribe of Wisconsin and Menominee County.
Colorado Main Street planning and $2 million CDOT grant-support services for
downtown revitalization and multimodal improvements.
[20261117R 145]
45
AYRES | DOWNTOWN DESIGN BEST PRACTICES: RFP #26-25-PL | CITY OF SUPERIOR
Ingenuity, Integrity, and Intelligence.
4.9 Proposer Statement
Ayres has made its own examination, investigation, and research regarding the method of doing the work, all conditions
affecting the work to be done, the labor, equipment and materials, and the quantity of the work to be performed. Ayres
agrees that it has satisfied itself by its own investigation and research regarding all of such conditions, and that Ayres’
conclusion to enter into the Service Agreement is based upon such investigation and research, and that Ayres shall make
no claim against the City because of any of the estimates, statements, or interpretations made by any officer or agent of
the City which may prove to be erroneous in any respect.
[20261117R 146]
18
13. Agreement
Professional
Services Agreement
for the Superior Downtown Design Best Practices
This agreement made this _____ day of_________________ 2026, by and between,
Ayres Associates, Inc., an incorporated business (herein known as ‘Consultant’), and the
City of Superior, a municipal corporation, through its Planning Department (herein
known as ‘City’). The parties to this Agreement shall be bound by the following terms
and conditions.
Scope
Consultant services include, but are not limited to, all of the tasks, activities and
requirements included in Exhibit A, “Scope of Services” and other tasks and
responsibilities as identified by the Planning Department. By reference, Exhibit A is
hereby incorporated into this Agreement but shall not in any way restrict the services
provided by consultant, nor prohibit the Planning Director from requesting other tasks or
procedures germane to the Agreement. If there are other tasks identified by the Planning
Director that are beyond the scope identified in Exhibit A, these will be considered extra
services and can be added to this agreement by an amendment.
Term
The term of this agreement shall be from the date of the agreement through April 30,
2027, or completion of the scope of work.
Services and Fees
Costs shall be full compensation for services performed or services rendered and for all
labor, materials, supplies, equipment, incidentals, applicable taxes, fees and applicable
expenses, necessary to complete the base services and include the optional walking
workshop for a not to exceed amount of thirty-five thousand dollars ($35,000.00),
attached proposal and incorporated herein by reference. All other expenditures shall be
the sole responsibility of the Consultant.
Changes to services and/or fees that are agreed to by both parties shall be acknowledged
in an amendment signed by both parties.
Payments
Consultant may invoice the Planning Department on a monthly basis during the progress
of the work for partial payment on account of work completed and accepted to date and
shall not impose any penalties or interest for amounts invoiced. The invoice shall be
itemized and, in a form, satisfactory to the City, of expenses incurred in the previous
period. The City shall pay agreed upon amounts within thirty (30) days of receipt.
Insurance
Consultant shall provide up-to-date, accurate professional liability information on
[20261117R 147]
19
Consultant’s Data Record, including amount of insurance, deductible, carrier and
expiration date of coverage. Consultant shall furnish the City with an endorsement for
earlier notice of cancellation and/or non-renewal and the Certificate of Insurance showing
the type, amount, deductible, effective date and date of expiration of such policy.
Consultant shall not cancel or materially alter this coverage without prior written approval
by the City. Consultant shall be responsible for consultants maintaining professional
liability insurance during the life of their Agreement and for 2 years after final acceptance
for the service.
Consultant and its subconsultants retained under the terms of this Agreement shall procure
and maintain professional liability insurance providing for payment of the insured's
liability for errors, omissions or negligent acts arising out of the performance of the
professional services required under this Contract.
It is hereby agreed and understood that the insurance required by the City is primary
coverage and that any insurance or self-insurance maintained by the City, its officers,
council members, agents, employees or authorized volunteers will not contribute to a
loss. All insurance shall be in full force prior to commencing work and remain in force
until the entire job is completed and the length of time that is specified, if any, in the
agreement or listed below whichever is longer.
1. PROFESSIONAL LIABILITY
A. Limits
(1) $1,000,000 each claim
(2) $1,000,000 annual aggregate
B. Must continue coverage for 2 years after final acceptance for service/job
2. GENERAL LIABILITY COVERAGE
A. Commercial General Liability
(1) $1,000,000 each occurrence limit
(2) $1,000,000 personal liability and advertising injury
(3) $2,000,000 general aggregate
B. Claims made form of coverage is not acceptable.
C. Insurance must include:
(1) Premises and Operations Liability
(2) Contractual Liability
(3) Personal Injury
(4) The general aggregate must apply separately to this project/location
3. BUSINESS AUTOMOBILE COVERAGE
A. $1,000,000 combined single limit for Bodily Injury and Property Damage
each accident
B. Must cover liability for Symbol #1 - "Any Auto" - including Owned,
Non-Owned and Hired Automobile Liability.
4. WORKERS COMPENSATION AND EMPLOYERS LIABILITY
A. Must carry coverage for Statutory Workers Compensation and an
Employers Liability limit of:
[20261117R 148]
20
(1) $100,000 Each Accident
(2) $500,000 Disease Policy Limit
(3) $100,000 Disease - Each Employee
5. UMBRELLA LIABILITY - Provide coverage at least as broad as the underlying
Commercial General Liability, Automobile Liability and Employers Liability, with a
minimum limit of $2,000,000 each occurrence and $2,000,000 aggregate, and a
maximum self-insured retention of $10,000.
6. ADDITIONAL INSURANCE PROVISIONS
A. Primary and Non-contributory requirement - all insurance must be primary and non-
contributory to any insurance or self-insurance carried by City
B. Acceptability of Insurers - Insurance is to be placed with insurers who have an A.M.
Best rating of no less than A- and a Financial Size Category of no less than Class
VII, and who are authorized as an admitted insurance company in the state of
Wisconsin.
C. Additional Insured Requirements - The following must be named as additional
insureds on the General Liability and Business Automobile liability coverage
arising out of project work - City, and its officers, council members, agents,
employees and authorized volunteers. This does not apply to Workers Compensation
Policies.
D. Deductibles and Self-Insured Retentions - Any deductible or self-insured retention
must be declared to and approved by the City.
E. Evidences of Insurance - Prior to execution of the agreement, the Consultant shall
file with the City a certificate of insurance (Accord Form 25-S or equivalent) signed
by the insurer's representative evidencing the coverage required by this agreement.
F. Provide a waiver of subrogation in favor of the City for the workers’ compensation.
Agreement General Terms and Conditions
1. No Relationship. Consultant understands and agrees that the relationship of
Consultant and the City arising out of this agreement is that of a contracted service
provider, not an employee or contracted employee of the City or any other entity within
the municipality, and therefore, is not entitled to any benefits provided to employees of
the City.
2. Taxes. Consultant will act as an independent contractor and will be responsible for all
federal, state and local taxes arising in accordance with this contract, as well as any other
taxes, fees or licensing expenses pertaining to these services.
3. Confidentiality. Consultant shall diligently protect the confidentiality of any
information, documentation or communication received from the City that contains
personal, financial or other information of a confidential nature, and shall not
disclose said information to any other persons, organizations or entities without the
expressed written approval of the City, except that Consultant may disclose
confidential information that is reasonably necessary to defend itself in the event of
[20261117R 149]
21
a dispute. Nothing herein shall be construed to conflict with the obligations under
Wisconsin Public Records Law, Wis. Stat. §19.31, et. Seq.
4. Qualifications. By accepting this agreement, Consultant represents that they possess
the necessary skills and qualifications to perform work under this agreement and is
familiar with the scope of work included in this Agreement. Consultant will comply with
all applicable local, state, and federal licensure requirements and will provide proof upon
request.
5. Legal Relations. Recommendations, policies, procedures and other communications
provided by the Consultant under this agreement will comply with all applicable laws,
ordinances, rules and regulations promulgated and enforced by the City and any other
proper authority having jurisdiction over the conduct of the operations of the City. The
Consultant shall comply with and observe federal, state and local laws that may be
applicable to the project. In carrying out provisions of this Agreement or exercising
power or authority granted to the Consultant thereby, there shall be no personal liability
to the City, it being understood that in such matters the City acts as representatives of the
State. The Consultant is not an agent of the State.
6. Assignment of Agreement. The Consultant shall not subcontract, assign or transfer
any part of this work to any other parties without the express written agreement of the
City.
7. Claims. Claims, disputes and other matters in question arising from the
performance of this contract shall be brought to the Director of Planning for review
and mutual resolution. If the parties cannot mutually resolve the matters in question,
the parties shall endeavor to settle disputes by mediation. A demand for mediation
shall be filed, in writing, within a reasonable period of time after a claim, dispute, or
other matter in question has arisen. In no event shall a demand for mediation be made
after the date when the institution of legal or equitable proceedings, based upon such
a claim, dispute, or other matter in question would have been barred by an applicable
statute of limitations.
8. Ownership of Documents. All documents, specifications, renderings, models,
approved copies, manuals and other such documents prepared by the Consultant or any
party pursuant to this Agreement shall become the property of the City of Superior on
completion and acceptance of any of the Consultant’s work, or upon termination of the
Agreement and upon payment with the terms of this Agreement and shall be delivered to
the City of Superior upon request. The City shall have unrestricted use of the final work
product. The Consultant must disclose any third-party licensed material that the City will
not have the right to reuse. Final electronic documents shall be provided in an accessible
format consistent with applicable federal and state accessibility requirements, including
appropriate tagging, headings, alternative text for images, readable contrast, and
accessible navigation to the extent applicable.
9. Indemnifications. Consultant hereby agrees to indemnify, defend and hold harmless the
[20261117R 150]
22
City its elected and appointed officials, officers, employees, agents, representatives and
volunteers, and each of them, from and against any and all suits, actions, legal or
administrative proceedings, claims, demands, damages, liabilities, interest, attorneys' fees,
costs, and expenses of whatsoever kind or nature in any manner directly or indirectly caused,
occasioned, or contributed to in whole or in part or claimed to be caused, occasioned, or
contributed to in whole or in part, by reason of any act, omission, fault, or negligence, whether
active or passive, of Consultant or of anyone acting under its direction or control or on its
behalf, even if liability is also sought to be imposed on the City, its elected and appointed
officials, officers, employees, agents, representatives and volunteers.
The obligation to indemnify, defend and hold harmless the City, its elected and appointed
officials, officers, employees, agents, representatives and volunteers, and each of them, shall
be applicable unless liability results from the sole negligence of the City, its elected and
appointed officials, officers, employees, agents, representatives and volunteers.
Consultant shall reimburse the City, its elected and appointed officials, officers, employees,
agent or authorized representatives or volunteers for any and all legal expenses and costs
incurred by each of them in connection therewith or in enforcing the i ndemnity herein
provided. In the event that Consultant employs other persons, firms, corporations or entities
(subcontractor) or volunteers as part of the work covered by this Agreement, it shall be the
consultant’s responsibility to require and confirm that each sub -contractor enters into an
Indemnity Agreement in favor of the City, its elected and appointed officials, officers,
employees, agents, representatives and volunteers, which is identical to this Indemnity
Agreement.
This indemnity provision shall survive the termination or expiration of this Agreement.
10. Final Payment. Prior to final payment, the Planning Department shall review project
documents, recommendations, tasks and procedures, etc., and all other recommendations
submitted by Consultant to determine the satisfaction thereof; it will be at the Planning
Department’s sole discretion when the final payment is made. Final payment will be
made to Consultant within thirty (30) days of the City’s acceptance of services as
complete.
11. Deficiencies. Consultant shall not be entitled to payment for work found deficient or
failing to conform to the requirements set forth in this agreement and is not entitled to
further payments until corrected to the satisfaction of the Director of Planning. The City
will inform the Consultant of any deficiencies and/or items that do not conform to this
agreement within thirty (30) days of receipt.
12. Termination. This Agreement may be terminated by either party without cause upon
ten (10) days written notice to the other. In the event of termination, Consultant shall be
paid for services performed to termination date. The results of the work by Consultant
shall immediately be turned over to the City of Superior and is a condition of final
payment.
[20261117R 151]
23
13. Warranty of Documents. The City, its representatives, employees, and agents make
no representations of the accuracy of documents, drawings, procedures, etc., provided to
Consultant under this Agreement, and shall not be held liable for the inadequacy thereof.
To the greatest extent possible, any document, drawing, procedure, etc., provided by the
City for the purposes of the project that cannot be utilized as reliable information by the
Consultant shall be noted as such by the City in the transmittal of the material.
14. Entire Agreement. This Agreement contains the entire understanding of the parties
with respect to the maters contained herein and supersedes all other written and oral
agreements between the parties with respect to such matters.
15. Modification. This Agreement is binding only when signed by both parties. Any
modifications or amendments must be in writing and signed by both parties.
16. Force Majeure. Each party shall be excused from any breach of this Agreement
which is caused by war, strike, act of Nature or other similar circumstances normally
deemed outside the control of well-managed businesses.
17. Governing Law. The Agreement will be interpreted, and the rights and liabilities of
the Parties determined, in accordance with the laws of the State of Wisconsin.
18. Headings and Captions. Headings and Captions appear solely for convenience of
reference. Such headings and captions are not part of this agreement and shall not be
used to construe it.
19. Validity. If any provision or provisions of this Agreement shall be held to be invalid,
illegal or unenforceable, the validity, legality and enforceability of the remaining
provisions shall not in any way be affected or impaired thereby.
20. Integrated Agreement. This Agreement contains the entire agreement and
understanding among the Parties regarding the matters set forth herein and supersedes all
previous negotiations, discussions, and understandings regarding such matters. The
Parties acknowledge and represent that they have not relied on any promise, inducement,
representation, or other statement made in connection with this Agreement that is not
expressly contained herein. The terms of this Agreement are contractual and not a mere
recital.
21. Safety And Security. The Consultant shall at all times perform in a safe and
workmanlike manner to avoid injury or damage to any person or property. The
Consultant shall comply with applicable requirements and specifications relating to the
safety, health and sanitation measures applicable to the project. The Consultant shall
exercise the applicable necessary precautions for the safety of its employees, and be in
compliance with applicable federal, state and local laws, statutes, ordinances, rules and
regulations. Including, but not limited to, the Wisconsin Labor Code, The U.S.
Department of Transportation Omnibus Transportation Employee Testing Act, and
OSHA standards.
[20261117R 152]
24
The Consultant shall provide its employees all necessary safeguards, devices and
protective equipment, including but not limited to adequate life protection and lifesaving
equipment, and shall ensure the proper inspection and maintenance of safety measures
are current and in compliance.
The City may halt progress on any project where appropriate safety measures and
equipment are not being used, or any safety regulations are not being followed. Services
will not be permitted to resume until required safety provisions have been made and
delays as a result of this provision will not be considered a basis for an increase in the
Agreement price or an extension of the completion deadline.
22. Standard of Care. Consultant represents that it will perform the Services in a
manner consistent with that degree of care and skill ordinarily exercised by members of
the same profession currently practicing under similar circumstances at the same time and
in the same locality. To the extent Consultant’s services do not meet this standard of
care; Consultant shall re-perform its work at no cost to the City.
23. Appropriation. State and/or Federal funds may be used to fund all or part of this
Agreement. Allowances detailed in the Project scope shall be awarded at the City’s
discretion, and is subject to available funding, project progress and other terms and
conditions as identified by the City. The City will not be held liable for any damages
incurred due to changes in State or Federal funding, including (but not limited to) a
reduction, delay, or cancellation of the project.
24. Non-Discrimination. Upon execution of this Agreement, Consultant agrees as
follows:
Consultant and all Subcontractors do not discriminate against any employee, applicant for
employment, independent contractor, or any other persons because of race, color,
religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, or national origin.
25. Authority. The Consultant represents that it has the authority to enter into this
Agreement. If the Consultant is not an individual, the person(s) signing on behalf of the
Consultant represents and warrants that they have been duly authorized to bind the
Consultant and sign this Agreement on the Consultant’s behalf.
[20261117R 153]
25
The parties intending to be legally bound have executed this agreement on the day and
year set forth above.
Signatures
Company: Ayres Associates, Inc.
Address: 3433 Oakwood Hills Parkway, Eau Claire, WI 54701-7698
_____________________________ __________________________________
Name/title Name/title
ATTEST: CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
___________________________________
Jim Paine, Mayor Heidi Blunt, City Clerk
___________________________________
Nicholas Rhinehart, Finance Director Frog Prell, City Attorney
Provision has been made to
pay the liability that will
accrue under this contract.
*Approved by Superior Common Council on
[20261117R 154]
26
Exhibit A
Purpose and Background
The City of Superior, Wisconsin is requesting proposals for professional services to
create a clear and concise design façade and streetscape best practices guide document
for downtown buildings and streetscapes, as well as a series of façade recommendations
for up to 15 buildings in the downtown area.
The best practices guide document intent is to help the City accomplish important goals
related to planning and project design review for the public and private sectors by
clarifying expectations and communicating requirements and options to all stakeholders,
property owners, developers and the public. This document will shape redevelopment,
new construction, building additions, historic preservation, future grant and incentive
programs, and communication of expectations to property owners, developers and the
public the City’s best practices for downtown façades to create a cohesive downtown
area.
This document should be adaptable for future potential updates to the City’s zoning
ordinances. The document shall be developed in conjunction with several stakeholders, in
addition to the City, such as the Superior Business Improvement District, Chamber of
Commerce and others as deemed appropriate, residents, business owners and local
leaders. The best practices guide should also include consideration of Wisconsin
Department of Transportation regulations.
The downtown implementation area will be centered on the areas in and around Tower
Avenue but will not be limited to it.
This area is generally historic in character. Buildings in this area are typically multi-story
buildings with the occasional single-story building. This area contains a mix of
commercial and residential use buildings, varying in architectural character. The firm
shall address historically significant architectural features, character-defining elements,
appropriate rehabilitation approaches, appropriate and inappropriate alterations,
compatible infill, treatment of historic storefronts, preservation versus reconstruction.
The final document shall include design Best Practices for private and public properties.
Tasks
Please describe in your proposal your approach to the following tasks. Alternative
approaches to the scope, so long as the end result is achieved, may be included.
(1) Review the existing City comprehensive plan and zoning codes and any
other documents that may assist the firm with developing a more in-depth
understanding of the past and present character, culture, and values of the
community.
[20261117R 155]
27
https://www.superiorwi.gov/DocumentCenter/View/13869/Superior-2040-Comp-
Plan
Code of Ordinances | Superior, WI | Municode Library
(2) On-site visit and review of the project area, and host in-person/virtual
stakeholders’ meetings. The firm will prepare meeting agendas, presentation
materials, sign-in/attendance information, meeting summaries, public comments
received, and a written summary explaining how public/stakeholder feedback was
incorporated. This task should accomplish the following:
A. Kick-off meeting
B. Tours
C. One meeting with the Common Council, Plan Commission, or other City
bodies, as determined by the City, in accordance with applicable open meetings
requirements, to establish goals and outcomes
D. Two stakeholder and two public sessions
E. Record existing conditions as it relates to buildings, streetscapes and other
pertinent development patterns that may influence the design solution
(3) With the direction of the City staff and input from stakeholders and the
community, draft a best practices guide for downtown building design as well as a
series of façade recommendations for up to 15 buildings in the downtown area.
The City determines the final policy direction. These best practices guide should
include the following elements:
a. block face design
b. site design
c. building design, massing, façade composition, and articulation
d. lighting
e. streetscape
f. signs
g. materials
(4) Identify 15 buildings and provide façade recommendations for each of
them. Permission from the owners must be obtained by the firm before
commencing this task. Provide before and after images, as well as a description of
the graphics and future steps to accomplish each recommendation. Please provide
in your proposal with a per each façade cost for beyond the first 15, should the
City elect to complete more than 15 façade recommendations. Include
consideration of in-person owner meetings for any additional façade
recommendations requested by the City.
(5) In-person review of the draft guide and façade recommendations with the
City and stakeholders to present and review the documents in order to prepare for
a final draft. The base fee should include at least two rounds of consolidated city
comments and revisions to the draft document. In-person meetings with each
[20261117R 156]
28
owner included in the 15 building façade recommendations to review the
recommendations.
(6) Develop a final document based on the outcomes in Task 5, which
includes detailed recommendations and visuals.
(7) Virtually attend a City Council meeting to present the final document. The
final document will be delivered in a single pdf, with clear graphics, and shall not
be longer than 25 pages, on 11x17 paper
[20261117R 157]
SIMKO 1901 N 6th Street, Superior, WI 54880 Pending Payment
Christina Greene/Sellers Auction 102 Belknap Street, Superior, WI 54880 Pending Payment
Hunter Bjorkman/ecoATM 3705 Tower Avenue, Superior, WI 54880 Pending Payment
Maria Lockwood/Foxes & Fireflies 1401 Tower Avenue, Superior, WI 54880
Jacob Regner/Superior Pickers 1211 Tower Avenue, Superior, WI 54880
Cara James/Earth Exchange 1713 Belknap Street, Superior, WI 54880 Pending Payment
Dennis McCaffrey/National Rarities 1120 Belknap Street, Superior, WI 54880 Pending Payment
Janet Sobolik/Antiques on Belknap 1709 Belknap Street, Superior, WI 54880 Pending Payment
Darin Lind/Duke's Towing 6110 Grand Avenue, Duluth, MN 55807 Pending Building Inspection
Jeremy Winans/Lakeside Towing 8492 E State Road 13, South Range, WI 54874
Maurice Bourdage/NASCAR Towing 4918 Lightning Drive, Hermantown, MN 55811 Pending PD Inspection
Darin Lind/Duke's Towing 6110 Grand Avenue, Duluth, MN 55807 Pending Building and PD Inspections
10.1 City Clerk's Office - Miscellaneous License Applications 11/17/2026
2027-2028 Salvage/Junk Dealer/Yard
2027-2028 Secondhand Dealer/Jewelry
2027-2028 Storage of Non-Operating Vehicles
2027-2028 Towing/Wrecker License
[20261117R 158]
1
PURCHASE AND SALE AGREEMENT
This Purchase and Sale Agreement ( this “Agreement”) is made by and between O & B
Properties, L.L.P. , a Wisconsin limited liability partnership (“Seller”), and the City of Superior,
Wisconsin (“Buyer”).
In consideration of this Agreement, Seller and Buyer agree as follows:
1. Sale of Property. Seller agrees to sell to Buyer, and Buyer agrees to buy from Seller, the
following property (collectively, the “Property”):
(a) Real Property. The land, buildings and improvements located in Douglas
County, Wisconsin, described on the attached Exhibit 1.(a) , together with all easements and
rights benefitting or appurtenant to the land (collectively, the “Real Property”). The legal
description for the Real Property shall be prepared by Title (defined below) is subject to approval
by Buyer and Seller.
(b) Personal Property . All of Seller’s assignable interest, if any, in the tangible
personal property (collectively, the “Personal Property”) situated in or about the Real Property.
Seller does not claim to have any interest in the property described in this section and is included
as an accommodation to Buyer only.
2. Effective Date. The date this Agreement is fully executed by both Buyer and Seller shall
be the “Effective Date.”
3. Purchase Price and Manner of Payment . The total purchase price (“Purchase Price”)
to be paid by Buyer to Seller for the Property shall be $720,000.00 (or such greater amount as is
necessary to pay Buyer’s net obligation to pay prorations) to be paid to Seller by check or by wire transfer
during or prior to the Closing (defined below).
4. Buyer’s Contingencies . The obligations of Buyer under this Agreement and Buyer’s
obligation to close this transaction are contingent upon the following:
(a) Title to the Real Property shall have been found acceptable , been made
acceptable or been accepted, in accordance with the requirements and terms of Section 4.2 below.
(b) Delivery by Seller to Buyer of each of the Seller’s Closing Documents (defined
below).
(c) The environmental condition of the Property shall have been determined by
Buyer to be acceptable, based on the results of an Environmental Survey Phase I of the Property,
which shall be obtained by Buyer at Buyer’s expense.
(d) Approval of this Agreement by the Common Council of the City of Superior.
(e) Approval of an amendment of Tax Incremental District No. 14 by the Common
Council of the City of Superior to include the Property.
[20261117R 159]
2
(f) All representations made by Seller pursuant to this Agreement shall be true in all
material respects as of the Closing Date (defined below).
(g) Seller shall have materially performed all of Seller’s obligations and covenants
pursuant to this Agreement.
The conditions set forth in this Section 4 are for Buyer’s benefit and may be waived by Buyer.
4.1 Seller’s Conditions Precedent to Closing . The following are conditions precedent to
Seller’s obligation to close this transaction:
(a) Payment of the Purchase Price.
(b) Delivery by Buyer to Seller of each of the Buyer’s Closing Documents (defined
below).
(c) All representations made by Buyer pursuant to this Agreement shall be true in all
material respects as of the Closing Date.
(d) Buyer shall have materially performed all of Buyer’s obligations and covenants
pursuant to this Agreement.
The conditions set forth in this Section 4.1 are for Seller’s benefit and may be waived by Seller.
4.2 Title Matters. The obligations of Buyer under this Agreement are contingent upon title
to the Real Property having been accepted as provided herein.
(a) Buyer shall, at Buyer’s expense and within a reasonable time after the Effective
Date, obtain from a title insurance company of Buyer’s choice (“ Title”) a title insurance
commitment (the “Title Commitment”) using the most current form of ALTA Owner’s Policy of
Title Insurance ( the “Title Policy”), insuring title to the Real Property in the amount of the
Purchase Price. At the time the Title Commitment is issued, Title shall furnish to Buyer legible
copies of all instruments referred to in the Title Commitment.
(b) Within fifteen business days after receiving the Title Commitment, Buyer shall
make any written objections (“Objections”) to the title as reflected in the Title Commitment.
Buyer’s failure to make Objections within such time period shall constitute waiver of Objections
and acceptance of title . Any matter shown on the Title Commitment and not objected to by
Buyer shall be a “Permitted Encumbrance” hereunder. Seller shall , within five days after
receipt of any Objections, cure the Objections or make arrangements satisfactory to Buyer to cure
the Object ions, during which period the Closing shall be postponed as necessary. If the
Objections are not cured within such 5-day period or if Seller’s arrangements to cure the
Objections are not deemed satisfactory to Buyer during the 5 -day period, Buyer shall have the
option of doing any of the following:
(i) terminate this Agreement; or
[20261117R 160]
3
(ii) accept title, waive any Objections and proceed to the Closing.
(c) Notwithstanding the foregoing provisions of this Section or any other provision
contained in this Agr eement, and regardless of whether or not Buyer delivers any Objections,
Seller shall be obligated to cure, discharge, remove, and satisfy on or before the Closing: (i) the
liens of any mortgage and other security instruments created by or otherwise arising through
Seller, (ii) tax liens for delinquent real estate taxes and assessments, and (iii) judgment liens,
mechanics’ and materialmen’s liens, and all other monetary liens created by or otherwise arising
through Seller.
5. Closing. The closing on the purcha se and sale contemplated by this Agreement (the
“Closing”) shall occur on or before December 31 , 2026, or as of an alternative date agreed to by Buyer
and Seller (the “Closing Date”), at the offices of Title which shall act as closing agent, at such time as the
parties shall mutually agree. The parties shall deliver to Title an executed copy of this Agreement, which
shall constitute instructions. Seller agrees to deliver possession of the Property immediately after the
Closing.
(a) Seller’s Closing Documents . On the Closing Date, Seller shall execute and/or
deliver to Buyer the following (collectively, “Seller’s Closing Documents”):
(i) Seller’s Affidavit. An owner’s affidavit reasonably required by Title as
to liens, debts and possession.
(ii) FIRPTA Affidavit. A non-foreign affidavit.
(iii) Special Warranty Deed. A Special Warranty Deed in substantially the
form of the Wisconsin State Bar Form 6, subject also, however, to the Permitted
Encumbrances.
(iv) Bill of Sale . A bill of sale in substantially the form attached hereto as
Exhibit 5.(a)(iv) conveying the Personal Property.
(v) Other Documents. All other documents reasonably determined by Title
on or before the Closing Date to be necessary to transfer the Property to Buyer on the
terms stated herein.
(b) Buyer’s Closing Documents . On the Closing Date, Buyer shall execute and/or
deliver to Seller the following (collectively, “Buyer’s Closing Documents”):
(i) Purchase Price. The balance of the Purchase Price.
(ii) Title Documents . Such affidavits of purchaser or other documents as
may be reasonably required by Title in order to record the Seller’s Closing Documents
and issue the Title Policy.
6. Prorations. Seller and Buyer agree to the following prorations and allocations of costs
regarding this Agreement:
(a) Title and Closing Fees . Buyer shall pay all costs of the Title Commitment and
all premiums required for the issuance of the Title Policy. Seller and Buyer shall each pay one -
[20261117R 161]
4
half of any reasonable and customary closing fee or charge imposed by Title as the closing agent,
if any.
(b) Taxes. General real estate taxes and installments of special assessments due and
payable in all years prior to the year of the Closing shall be paid by Seller. General real estate
taxes due and payable in all years subsequent to the year of the Closing shall be paid by Buyer.
General real estate taxes and installments of special assessments due and payable in the year of
the Closing shall be prorated as of the Closing Date, with Seller to pay that portion attributable to
those days in the year having elapsed prior to the Closin g Date. All real estate transfer fees , and
all ad valorem taxes due on the sale of the Property, or sales taxes, or similar taxes (including
interest and penalties) owing with respect to activities occurring before the Closing in connection
with the Property or becoming due and payable prior to, simultaneously with, or as a result of
execution, delivery, or recordation of the Special Warranty Deed, shall be paid by Seller. Buyer
will pay all mortgage registry and similar taxes.
(c) Recording Costs. Buyer shall pay the cost of recording all documents necessary
to place record title in Buyer. Seller shall pay the transfer tax on the sale.
(d) Attorneys’ Fees. Each of the parties shall pay its own attorneys’ fees relating to
this Agreement and the purchase and sale of the Property, except that a party defaulting under this
Agreement shall pay the reasonable attorneys’ fees and court costs incurred by the non-defaulting
party, including such fees and costs incurred to enforce its rights regarding such default.
7. Seller’s R epresentations. Seller represents to Buyer, as of the Effective Date , the
following:
7.1 Transaction Authorized . The execution of this Agreement by Seller , and the
transactions contemplated hereby have been duly authorized by all requisite action on the part of Seller.
7.2 Power and Authority . Seller is a limited liability partnership, duly organized, validly
existing and in good standing under the laws of Wisconsin. Seller has the capacity and authority to enter
into this Agreement and consummate the t ransactions herein provided and nothing prohibits or restricts
the right or ability of Seller to close the transactions contemplated hereunder and carry out the terms
hereof.
7.3 No Violation of Instruments . The execution, delivery and performance of this
Agreement by Seller and the consummation of the transaction contemplated herein will not result in a
breach or violation of the terms and provisions of the organizational documents of Seller in effect on the
date hereof and will not constitute a material default under any indenture, mortgage, deed of trust or other
material agreement or instrument to which Seller is a party or by which Seller is bound.
7.4 Non-Foreign Person . Seller is not a “foreign person” within the meaning of section
1445(e)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code of 1986, as amended, and Seller shall deliver to Buyer at the
Closing a Non-Foreign Affidavit pursuant to Section 1445 of the Internal Revenue Code.
7.5 Bankruptcy. There are no actions or proceedings pending or, to Seller’s k nowledge,
threatened to liquidate, reorganize, place in bankruptcy or dissolve Seller. Seller has not made a general
assignment for the benefit of creditors, filed any voluntary petition in bankruptcy or suffered the filing of
an involuntary petition by its creditors, suffered the appointment of a receiver to take possession of
substantially all of its assets, suffered the attachment or other judicial seizure of substantially all of its
[20261117R 162]
5
assets, admitted its inability to pay its debts as they come due, or made an offer of settlement, extension or
composition to its creditors generally.
7.6 No Broker. Seller has not engaged or dealt with any broker or finder in connection with
the sale contemplated by this Agreement . Seller shall indemnify and hold harmless Buyer from any
claims, costs, damages or liabilities (including reasonable attorneys' fees) arising from any breach of this
representation.
7.7 Leases. Seller represents that there are no outstanding leases of the Real Property.
7.8 Third Party Ri ghts. No person, firm or entity has any rights in or to acquire the
Property or any part thereof and there is no agreement of any kind or nature affecting the Property or the
operation thereof which will survive the Closing.
7.9 Environmental. Seller has not, and prior to the Closing Date Seller will not, discharge,
release, generate, treat, store, dispose of or deposit in, on or under the Property, any "toxic or hazardous
substance", asbestos, urea formaldehyde insulation, PCBs, radioactive material, fl ammable explosives, or
any other hazardous or contaminated substance (collectively, “Contaminants”) prohibited, limited or
regulated under the Comprehensive Environmental Response Compensation and Liability Act, the
Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, the Hazardous Materials Transportation Act, the Toxic
Substance Control Act, the Federal Insecticide, Fungicide and Rodenticide Act, or under any other
applicable federal, state or local statutes, regulations or ordinances (collectively the "Environmental
Laws"). Seller has no actual knowledge of any suit, action or other legal proceeding arising out of or
related to any Environmental Laws with respect to the Property which is pending or threatened before any
court, agency or government authority, and Seller has not received any notice that the Property is in
violation of the Environmental Laws.
7A. SURVIVAL OF SELLER’S REPRESENTATIONS AND AS IS PROVISIONS
7A.1 Survival of Seller’s Representations . The representations made by Seller in this
Agreement shall survive the recording of the Special Warranty Deed for a period expiring on the date that
is 24 months following the Closing (the “Survival Date”) and any action for a breach of Seller’s
representations must be made and filed by the Survival Date. Any Buyer claim for a breach of Seller’s
representations which is not made and filed by Buyer prior to the Survival Date shall, from and after the
Survival Date, be deemed to have been waived by Buyer and rendered null and void and of no further
force and effect.
7A.2 As Is Provisions. Buyer is purchasing the Property “AS IS” and “WHERE IS”, and with
all faults, and except as expressly set forth in Section 7, Seller makes no representations or warranties,
whether express or implied, by operation of law or otherwise, with respect to the quality, physical
condition or value of the Property, the compliance of the Property with applicable building or fire codes
or other laws or regulations. Buyer agrees that Seller is not liable or bound by any guarantees, p romises,
statements, representations or information pertaining to the Property made or furnished by any agent,
officer, director, employee or other person representing or purporting to represent Seller, except as and to
the extent expressly set forth in Section 7. To the fullest extent allowed by Wisconsin and Federal law,
Buyer and Seller agrees as follows: Buyer expressly waives the requirement of any disclosure not
expressly contained in this Agreement (including, without limitation, any disclosure requ ired pursuant to
Wis. Stat. § 709), and Buyer agrees to take the Property “As Is” notwithstanding any matter set forth in
any disclosure statement required by Wisconsin law.
[20261117R 163]
6
8. REPRESENTATIONS OF BUYER.
8.1 No Broker . Buyer has not engaged any broker or finder in connection with the sale
contemplated by this Agreement.
8.2. Buyer Acknowledgements . The consummation of this transaction shall constitute
Buyer's acknowledgment that it has independently inspected and investigated the Property and has mad e
and entered into this Agreement based upon such inspection and investigation and its own examination of
the condition of the Property.
8. Damage. In the event the Property is damaged by fire, contamination, or other
casualty, Buyer may elect, prior to the Closing Date, to give notice of termination of this
Agreement, in which event the parties shall have no further obligations hereunder. In the event
Buyer does not elect to terminate this Agreement, Seller shall be entitled to receive all insurance
proceeds, but Buyer shall be credited with such amounts at the C losing, and shall further be
credited with any applicable deductibles.
10. Condemnation. If, prior to the Closing Date, eminent domain proceedings are
commenced against all or any part of the Property, Seller shall immediately give notice to Buyer of such
act and at Buyer’s option (to be exercised within 10 business days after Seller’s notice), this Agreement
shall terminate, in which event neither party shall have any further obligations under th is Agreement. If
Buyer shall fail to give notice of its choice of options, then there shall be no reduction in the Purchase
Price, and Seller shall assign to Buyer at the Closing all of Seller’s right, title, and interest in and to any
award made or to be made in the condemnation proceedings. Prior to the Closing Date, Seller shall not
designate counsel, appear in, or otherwise act with respect to the condemnation proceedings without
Buyer’s prior written consent.
11. Assignment. Buyer shall not assign its rights under this Agreement without the consent
of Seller.
12. Notices. Any notice required or permitted to be given by any party upon the other is
deemed delivered in accordance with this Agreement (i) twenty-four (24) hours after it is deposited with a
nationally-recognized over-night courier; or (ii) when it is personally delivered.
If to Seller:
O & B Properties, L.L.P.
Attn: James Kari, Owner
2440 New York Avenue
Superior, WI 54880
If to Buyer:
City of Superior
Attn: City Clerk
1316 N. 14th Street
Superior, WI 54880
[20261117R 164]
7
Notices shall be deemed effective on the date they are deemed to be delivered. Any party may change its
address for the service of notice by giving written notice of such change to the other party, in any manner
above specified, 10 days prior to the effective date of such change.
13. Captions. The paragraph headings or captions appearing in this Agreement are for
convenience only, are not a part of this Agreement, and are not to be considered in interpreting this
Agreement.
14. Entire Agreement Modification . This Agreement constitutes the complete agreement
between the parties and supersedes any prior oral or written agreements between the parties regarding the
Property. There are no verbal agreements that change this Agreement and no waiver or amendment of any
of its terms shall be effective unless in writing executed by the parties. This Agreement or any
amendments may be executed in counterparts, which, taken together, shall constitute one original. The
parties agree that this Agr eement may be transmitted between themselves electronically. The parties
intend that electronically transmitted signatures constitute original signatures and that an electronically
transmitted agreement or counterparts containing the signatures (original or faxed) of all the parties is
binding upon the parties.
15. Binding Effect. This Agreement binds and benefits the parties and their successors and
assigns.
16. Choice of Law . This Agreement shall be subject to and governed by the laws of the
State of Wisconsin and all questions concerning the meaning or intention of the terms of this Agreement
or concerning the validity thereof, and questions relating to the performance hereunder shall be adjudged
and resolved in accordance with the laws of the State of Wisconsin. All actions to enforce the terms and
provisions of this Agreement shall be brought and maintained only within the State of Wisconsin, and
Buyer and Seller each hereby consent to the exclusive jurisdiction of the State Courts, sited in Douglas
County, Wisconsin. Buyer and Seller each hereby expressly waive any and all rights which it may have to
make any objection based on (a) jurisdiction, to any suit brought to enforce this Agreement in the State of
Wisconsin, or (b) venue, to any action brought to enforce this Agreement in Douglas County, Wisconsin,
in each case in accordance with the above provisions. Whenever possible, each provision of this
Agreement shall be interpreted in such a manner as to be effective and valid pursuant to applicable laws;
however, if any part hereof shall be prohibited by applicable law or invalid thereunder, such provision
shall be ineffec tive to the extent of such prohibition or invalidity only and without invalidating the
remainder thereof. Nothing in this Section 1 6 will prevent the docketing, registration or enforcement of
any judgment or order obtained in compliance with this Section 1 6 in a State or jurisdiction other than
Wisconsin.
17. Time of Essence. Time is of the essence in all terms herein.
18. DEFAULT AND REMEDIES.
18.1 Buyer’s Default. If Buyer defaults under this Agreement, Seller shall have the right to
terminate this Agreement , after written notice of cancellation is provided under Wisconsin law. Upon
such termination, Seller shall be entitled to payment of $500.00 as liquidated damages, time being of the
essence of this Agreement. Seller and Buyer agree that Seller’s economic detriment resulting from the
removal of the Property from the market and the carrying and other costs incurred thereaf ter and
associated therewith, including any costs to be incurred by Seller in order to satisfy the conditions set
[20261117R 165]
8
forth in this Agreement, are impracticable or extremely difficult to ascertain. Seller and Buyer agree that
$500.00 is a reasonable estimate of such damages in the event of Buyer’s failure to perform according to
the provisions of this Agreement. Such payment is intended to be liquidated damages and not intended to
be a forfeiture or penalty. The termination of this Agreement and payment of $500.00 will be the sole
and exclusive remedy available to Seller for default by Buyer, and Buyer will not be liable for damages or
specific performance for such default. Seller and Buyer acknowledge and agree that any liability of Buyer
to Seller under any provision of this Agreement which provides that Buyer will indemnify, defend, or
hold Seller harmless will not be limited by this liquidated damage provision.
18.2 Seller’s Default. If Seller defaults under this Agreement, Buyer shall have the right t o
terminate this Agreement by giving 15 days written notice of termination to Seller, whereupon this
Agreement will terminate. In lieu of terminating this Agreement, Buyer may maintain a suit for specific
performance of this Agreement provided, however, that any such suit must be commenced within 180
days of the date of this Agreement. Termination and specific performance pursuant to this Section 18.2
are the sole and exclusive remedies afforded to Buyer and in no event shall Seller be liable for any actu al,
general, specific, punitive, incidental, speculative, consequential or other damages of any kind or nature.
[20261117R 166]
9
Seller and Buyer have executed this Agreement as of the respective dates stated below.
SELLER:
O & B PROPERTIES, L.L.P., a Wisconsin limited
liability partnership
Dated: _____________, 2026
By:
James Kari
Its Owner
By:
Wayne Kari
Its Owner
BUYER:
CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
Dated: _____________, 2026 _____________________________________________
By Jim Paine, Mayor
_____________________________________________
By Heidi Blunt, City Clerk
08493\000371\1F3755902.DOC
[20261117R 167]
10
EXHIBIT 1(a)
Legal Description
Lots 1 through 17 and 24 through 28 inclusive, Block 102, WEST SUPERIOR, FIRST
DIVISION, including the adjacent vacated North -South alley and the adjacent vacated
East-West alley abutting said lots, in the City of Superior, Douglas County, Wisconsin.
Property Address: 1002 Tower Avenue, Superior, WI 54880
PID: 06-806-00194-00
06-806-00192-00
06-806-00197-00
06-806-00198-00
06-806-00199-00
06-806-00201-00
08493\000371\1F3755902.DOC
[20261117R 168]
EXHIBIT 5.(a)(iv)
BILL OF SALE
FOR VALUABLE CONSIDERATION, the receipt and sufficiency of which is hereby
acknowledged, O & B Properties , L .L.P., a Wisconsin limited liability partnership (“Seller”) hereby
conveys and quitclaims to the CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN (“Buyer”), Seller’s assignable
interest, if any, in the property designated as “Personal Property” in the Purchase and Sale Agreement
(“Agreement”) between Seller and Buyer dated ______________, 2026. The “Personal Property” is a
part of the “Property” as that term is defined in the Agreement and, as more fully set forth in the
Agreement, the Property is conveyed AS IS without representations or warranties of any kind.
IN WITNESS WHEREOF, Seller has executed this Bill of Sale as of ____________, 2026.
SELLER:
By:
James Kari
Its Owner
By:
Wayne Kari
Its Owner
[20261117R 169]
RESOLUTION NO. R26-13898
Alderperson ____________________ introduced the following resolution and moved its adoption:
RESOLUTION OF THE CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
AUTHORIZING THE PURCHASE OF REAL PROPERTY FROM O & B
PROPERTIES, L.L.P. AND AUTHORIZING EXECUTION OF A
PURCHASE AND SALE AGREEMENT AND RELATED DOCUMENTS IN
CONNECTION THEREWITH
WHEREAS, representatives of the City of Superior, Wisconsin (the “City”) have been
negotiating with O & B Properties, L.L.P. (the “Company”) regarding the purchase of property
located at 1002 Tower Avenue in the City and legally described on Exhibit A attached hereto (the
“Property”); and
WHEREAS, the purchase of the Property and the approval of an amendment to Tax
Incremental District No. 14 to include the Property will provide an opportunity for the City to
market the Property for future developments within the City; and
WHEREAS, the terms and conditions of the purchase are as set forth in the Purchase and
Sale Agreement between the Company, as seller, and the City, as buyer (the “Purchase
Agreement”), the form of which is on file in the office of the City Clerk.
NOW, THEREFORE, BE IT RESOLVED:
1. The form of Purchase Agreement, as presented to the Common Council, is hereby
approved with such insubstantial changes as are necessary in the opinion of the Mayor and the
City Clerk, without further act or authorization. The Mayor and the City Clerk are authorized and
directed in the name and on behalf of the City to execute the Purchase Agreement and such other
documents, instruments or certificates as are deemed necessary or desirable by counsel for the City
to complete the transaction.
2. The Common Council hereby authorizes and directs the Mayor and the City Clerk
to carry out the obligations of the City contained in the Purchase Agreement.
3. The purchase price for the Property shall consist of cash in the amount of $720,000
which shall be paid from the proceeds of an interfund loan from the City’s Economic Development
Fund to the City’s TID #14 Fund. Upon sale of the Property, the City shall use the sale proceeds
to repay such interfund loan.
[20261117R 170]
Adopted: November 17, 2026.
Mayor
Attest:
City Clerk
[20261117R 171]
The motion of the adoption of the foregoing Resolution was duly seconded by Alderperson
___________________________ and, upon vote being taken, the following voted in favor thereof:
the following voted against the same:
the following were absent:
whereupon, said Resolution was declared duly passed and adopted, and approved and signed by the Mayor
and attested by the City Clerk.
08493\000371\1F68840.DOCX
[20261117R 172]
EXHIBIT A
Legal Description
Lots 1 through 17 and 24 through 28 inclusive, Block 102, WEST SUPERIOR, FIRST
DIVISION, including the adjacent vacated North -South alley and the adjacent vacated
East-West alley abutting said lots, in the City of Superior, Douglas County, Wisconsin.
Property Address: 1002 Tower Avenue, Superior, WI 54880
PID: 06-806-00194-00
06-806-00192-00
06-806-00197-00
06-806-00198-00
06-806-00199-00
06-806-00201-00
[20261117R 173]
[20261117R 174]
CONTRACT VOLUME &
BIDDING DOCUMENT- 2026
Princess Theatre
Apartments
CITY OF SUPERIOR, WISCONSIN
Jason Serck
Planning Director
Bid #26-27-PL
[20261117R 175]
Princess Theatre 2
Table of Contents
1. ADVERTISEMENT TO BID ............................................................................................ 3
2. INSTRUCTIONS TO BIDDERS ...................................................................................... 4
3. BID PROPOSAL ............................................................................................................... 8
4. SUBCONTRACTORS AND SUPPLIERS LISTING .................................................... 10
5. ADDENDA ACKNOWLEDGMENT ............................................................................. 11
6. BID BOND ...................................................................................................................... 12
7. BIDDER'S PROOF OF RESPONSIBILITY ................................................................... 13
8. AFFIDAVIT OF ORGANIZATION AND AUTHORITY ............................................. 15
9. AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE ................................................................................... 16
10. CONTRACT .................................................................................................................... 20
11. PERFORMANCE AND PAYMENT BOND .................................................................. 24
12. GENERAL SPECIFICATIONS ...................................................................................... 25
13. ENGINEER CERTIFICATION ....................................................................................... 33
14. SPECIAL PROVISIONS .................................................................................................. 34
15. CONTRACT CHANGE ORDER ..................................................................................... 35
Project Plan Set dated September 11, 2026 (39 pages)
Specifications (200 pages)
[20261117R 176]
Princess Theatre 3
1. ADVERTISEMENT TO BID
Princess Theatre Apartments
Sealed bids will be received by the City of Superior, Attn: Contract Analyst, at 1316
North 14th Street - 2nd Floor, Suite 200, Superior, WI 54880. Bids will be publicly
opened and read aloud in the City offices as follows:
Bid Opening: Tuesday, October 20, 2026, at 3:00 PM CST
Bid Project: The City of Superior is seeking bids from qualified contractors for the
renovation of approximately 1,608 sf of second-floor space within the Princess Theatre
building at 1310 Tower Avenue, Superior, WI. This renovation will create two one-
bedroom apartments, as per plans and specifications. The work generally consists of new
partitions, windows, finishes, plumbing, and electrical. This project shall be completed by
May 30, 2027.
All bids must be prepared with the forms provided and submitted in accordance with the
Instructions to Bidder.
Specifications may be obtained through the internet at www.DemandStar.com. Bidding
documents may be viewed at the City of Superior, Government Center, 1316 North 14th Street -
2nd Floor, Superior, Wisconsin (darwinj@superiorwi.gov), at the Minnesota Builders Exchange
(mbex.org), Builders Exchange of Wisconsin (bxwi.com), Northwest Regional Builders
Exchange (nwrbx.com), and LaCrosse Builders Exchange (laxbx.com).
The contractor shall submit a list of its subcontractors as a part of its proposal, which list
shall not be added to or altered without the written consent of the City of Superior, and as
specified in 66.0901 Wisconsin Statutes.
The City of Superior encourages the participation of women and minority owned
businesses.
The City of Superior reserves the right to reject any or all bids, to waive irregularities, or
to accept such bids, as in the opinion of the City, will be in its best interests.
Jason Serck
Planning Director
Daily Telegram: Saturday, September 19, 2026, and Saturday, September 26, 2026
[20261117R 177]
Princess Theatre 4
2. INSTRUCTIONS TO BIDDERS
2.1 Questions regarding this bid may be directed to the City of Superior as follows:
Project specifications: Thomas Westlund, Westlund Architecture,
Thomas.westlund@westlundae.com.
Bidding documents: Jane Darwin, Contract Analyst, darwinj@superiorwi.gov.
2.2 Method of Bidding: The only acceptable method of bidding a contract with the City of
Superior, Wisconsin, is described as follows and must be strictly complied with. The
City of Superior reserves the right to determine the low Bidder on the basis of the Base
Bid alone or the Base Bid plus any alternates or combinations of alternates, at the City’s
discretion. The City of Superior is tax exempt. Bids shall be valid for 90 days.
2.3 Bid Packet Components: Each item listed must be included with the bid submission:
a) Bidders must file a PROPOSAL OR BID on the form the City has prepared. (See BID
PROPOSAL Section 3.)
b) Bidders shall be required to submit a list of SUBCONTRACTORS AND SUPPLIERS
with their proposal in accordance with Section 66.0901(7), Wisconsin Statutes, and
subsequent amendments. Such list shall not be added to or altered without the written
consent of the City of Superior. (See SUBCONTRACTORS AND SUPPLIERS
LISTING Section 4.)
c) Bidders shall be required to submit an ADDENDA ACKNOWLEDGMENT with their
proposal. Such acknowledgment shall note acknowledgment of receipt of any and all
addenda. If no addenda were issued, the bidder shall so indicate and sign document.
(See ADDENDA ACKNOWLEDGMENT Section 5.)
d) The bidder must file, at the time of the opening of the bids, either a BID BOND or a
certified check in the amount of at least five percent (5%) of the total bid, conditioned
that if the bidder is successful bidder will, within the time allotted by the City, file a
properly executed contract and performance bond as per Wisconsin Statutes 62.15(3).
(See BID BOND Section 6.)
e) The bid proposal must have attached to it the BIDDER’S PROOF OF
RESPONSIBILITY identifying the bidder’s qualifications. (See BIDDER’S PROOF OF
RESPONSIBILITY Section 7.). Prospective bidders are required to furnish a statement
of financial ability, equipment and experience in the work prescribed in said public
contract in accordance with the provisions of Section 66.0901(2) of the Wisconsin
Statutes at the time of the opening of the bids. The object of the questionnaire and the
pre-qualification of bidders are to enable the City to have sufficient information regarding
financial ability, equipment and experience in order to reduce the hazards involved in
awarding contracts to parties not qualified to perform them and to select those contractors
qualified to properly complete the work proposed.
f) The bid proposal must have attached to it the AFFIDAVIT OF ORGANIZATION
[20261117R 178]
Princess Theatre 5
AND AUTHORITY identifying a corporation, partnership or sole trader. The affidavit
must contain a sworn statement that the bidder has examined and carefully prepared the
proposal from the plans and specifications and has checked the same in detail per Section
66.0901 (7), Wisconsin Statutes. (See AFFIDAVIT OF ORGANIZATION &
AUTHORITY Section 8.)
g) The bid proposal must have attached to it the AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE
swearing compliance with the criteria set forth in the Responsible Contractor Criteria in
the City Code of Ordinances, Chapter 2, Article XII from the Contractor and all sub-
contractors. (See AFFIDAVIT OF COMPLIANCE Section 8).
h) The bid proposal packet shall be placed in an envelope and shall be sealed. ON THE
ENVELOPE SHALL BE, plainly written: the date of the bid opening, the title of the
project and the name of the bidder. Such envelope shall be addressed and delivered to:
The City of Superior, Attn: Contract Analyst, 1316 North 14th Street - 2nd Floor, Suite
200, Superior, Wisconsin, before the time and date specified for opening bids as listed on
the Advertisement to Bid.
i) Wisconsin’s Public Records Law creates a statutory presumption in favor of complete
access to public records and the City of Superior endeavors always to conduct its
municipal affairs in strict compliance with Wisconsin Statutes §§ 19.31-19.39. Any
entities or individuals who submit materials to the City of Superior in response to this
request should avoid submitting any proprietary information.
2.4 Work Site and Contract Document Examination: Bidders must satisfy themselves, by
examination of the contract documents, the work site and the conditions and obstacles to
be encountered in the field, and by such other means as may be necessary, as to the
accuracy of the schedule of quantities of the work to be done and the intent of said
contract documents. After the submission of the proposal, no complaint or claim that
there was any misunderstanding as to the quantities, conditions or nature of the work will
be entertained and no extra compensation shall be allowed by reason of any matter or
thing concerning which such bidder might have informed himself prior to the bidding.
Upon award of bid, the Contractor must execute the required Performance and Payment
Bond in the total amount of the bid. (see PERFORMANCE AND PAYMENT BOND
Section 11.)
2.5 Time of Performance: When not otherwise specified, the bidder must state in the
proposal, the least number of calendar days (counting weekends and holidays), after date
to commence work given in the Notice to Proceed, in which bidder will start construction
and the number of calendar days (counting weekends and holidays), after date to
commence work given in the Notice to Proceed, in which bidder will fully complete the
work as specified. The bidder should make allowance for all probable difficulties which
may be encountered. In the event of failure completing the work within the time stated or
[20261117R 179]
Princess Theatre 6
otherwise specified, liquidated damages will be assessed as provided in the
specifications.
2.6 Quantities: The estimated quantities of the work are the result of careful calculations but
are not to be considered as final. Such estimates will be used as a basis for determining
the lowest bidder. After the contract is awarded, the quantity of work listed under any
item, or all items, may be increased or decreased according to the specifications at the
discretion of the City of Superior without in any way invalidating the bid price (see
CONTRACT CHANGE ORDER Section 15).
2.7 Bid Prices: Bidders must submit a bid price, in accordance with the specifications, for
each item of the job or branch, in compliance with the bidding units specified for the
quantities listed in the proposal. Bid prices must be written out in words and also entered
in figures. In case of conflict, the written word prices will prevail. Totals must be shown
based on unit cost and quantity. In case figures do not match, the figure resulting in the
lower price shall be deemed the price intended and applicable.
2.8 Inadequacies and Omissions: The City of Superior will not be responsible for verbal
information or statements made by representatives of the Engineering Department, or any
other department for which work will be performed. Bidders shall bring any
inadequacies, omissions or conflicts to the attention of the City of Superior before the due
date for bids. Prompt written clarification will be immediately supplied to all bidders by
Addenda before the due date for bids and each Addendum shall be acknowledged on the
Addenda Acknowledgment form. Failure to so request clarification of any inadequacy,
omission or conflict will not relieve the Contractor of responsibility.
2.9 No Double Bidding: Two (2) or more proposals under different names will not be
accepted from one firm or association.
2.10 Partial Bidding: Bidders must quote on all items appearing on the bid forms unless
specific directions in the advertisement, on the bid form, or in the special specifications
allow for partial bids. Failure to quote on all items, unless specifically exempted as set
forth above, shall disqualify the bid. When quotations on all items are not required,
bidders shall insert the words "no bid" where appropriate.
2.11 Right of Waiver or Rejection: The City reserves the right to reject any or all bids or
waive any defects found in bids or proposals submitted.
2.12 Wage Rates: This Project is not subject to Prevailing Wage Rates.
2.13 Pre-Bid Conference: Tuesday, October 6, 2026, at 3:00 PM. Virtual or in-person.
In-person: 1316 N 14th Street, Superior, WI, Room 217.
Virtual:
Microsoft Teams meeting
[20261117R 180]
Princess Theatre 7
Join: https://teams.microsoft.com/meet/239744001399260?p=2EwJShk9dmRBAatEwG
Meeting ID: 239 744 001 399 260
Passcode: xQ6xe2Uo
Need help? | System reference
Dial in by phone
+1 872-242-8028,,123195510# United States, Chicago
Find a local number
Phone conference ID: 123 195 510#
Deadline for questions is 12:00 PM, October 9, 2026. All questions should be emailed to
the contacts listed in Section 2.1. The final addendum(s) will be issued by October 13,
2026.
2.14 Contract Documents: Upon award of the bid the contract documents will consist of the
Advertisement to Bid, Instructions to Bidders, Bid Proposal, Subcontractors & Suppliers
Listing, Addenda Acknowledgment, Bid Bond, Bidder's Proof of Responsibility,
Affidavit of Organization & Authority, Contract, Affidavit of Compliance(s),
Performance and Payment Bond, Certificate of Insurance as required, General
Specifications, Special Provisions, Plan Set, and include all other herein bound
attachments and modifications thereof incorporated in the documents as prepared by the
City of Superior.
[20261117R 181]
[20261117R 182]
[20261117R 183]
[20261117R 184]
[20261117R 185]
[20261117R 186]
[20261117R 187]
[20261117R 188]
[20261117R 189]
[20261117R 190]
[20261117R 191]
[20261117R 192]
[20261117R 193]
[20261117R 194]
[20261117R 195]
Princess Theatre 17
ORDINANCE #O20-4178
ORDINANCE INTRODUCED BY MAYOR JIM PAINE REPEALING SECTION 2,
ARTICLE XII PUBLIC WORKS PROJECTS AND RECREATING SECTION 2,
ARTICLE XII RESPONSIBLE CONTRACTOR CRITERIA
The Common Council of the City of Superior, Wisconsin, does ordain as follows:
SECTION 1. Chapter 2, Article XII, Public Works Projects of the City Code of Ordinances is
hereby repealed and recreated as follows:
ARTICLE XII. RESPONSIBLE CONTRACTOR CRITERIA
Section 2-468. Purpose. Pursuant to Wis. Stats. § 66.0901, whenever the city lets public work by
contract, the contract must be awarded to the lowest qualifi ed responsible contractor . What
constitutes a qu alified responsible contractor is a determination that requires the exercise of
discretion by the city and its departments, officials or employees under reasonably con sistent
responsible contractor criteria when exercising its discretion.
Section 2 -469. Definitions. In this section, the following definitions shall apply.
“Contractor” means a person, corporation, partnership or any other business ent ity that performs
work on a public works contract as a general contractor, prime contractor or subcontractor at any
tier.
“Apprenticeship program” means an apprenticeship program that is currently approved by the U.S.
Department of Labor or a state apprenticeship agency and has graduated apprentices to
journeyperson status for three years.
“Public works contract” means a contract for the construction, alteration, execution, repair,
remodeling or improvement of a public work or building, where the contract i s in excess of
$25,000 and is require d to be bid pursuant to Wis. Stats. § 59.52(29).
“Qualified contractor (Bidder)” means a person, corporation, partnership or any other business
entity that meets the requirements specified in this ordinance as well as the criteria specified in
Wis. Stats. 16.855 (9m) (b) (1) (a & b)
Section 2-470 Responsible Contractor Criteria. In order to be a qualified responsible
contractor for purposes of being awarded a public works contract, the contractor must meet the
following criteria.
a) The contractor maintains a permanent place of business.
b) The contractor is authorized to do business in the State of Wisconsin.
[20261117R 196]
Princess Theatre 18
c) The contractor, or agent, partner, employee or officer of the contractor, is not
debarred, suspended, proposed for debarment or declared ineligible from contracting
with any unit of federal, state or local government.
d) The contractor is in compliance with provisions of Section 2000e of Chapter 21,
Title 42 of the United States Code and Federal Executive Order No. 11246 as
amended by Executive Order No. 11375 (known as the Equal Opportunity Employer
provisions).
e) The contractor has general liability, workers’ compensation, automobile insurance
and unemployment insurance.
f) The contractor has complied with all provisions of any prevailing wage laws and
federal Davis-Bacon related Acts, and the rules and regulations therein, for projects
undertaken by the contractor that are covered by these laws, for the past five (5)
years.
g) The contractor participates in an apprenticeship program as referred in section 2-
46 9, if the contractor employs more than two (2) employees.
h) The contractor has a written substance abuse prevention program meeting the
requirements of Wis. Stat. §103.503.
i) The employees who will perform work on the project are properly classified as
employees or independent contractors under all applicable state and federal laws.
j) The contractor has not been the subject to any investigation, order or judgement
regarding the construction industry from a state or federal agency or court concerning
an employment practice, including but not limited to, classification of employees,
unemployment insurance, discrimination or payroll fraud. If the contractor has been
the subject of any of the aforementioned, the contractor must provide copies of the
investigation, order or judgement and may be disqualified.
k) The contractor’s employees who will perform work on the project are:
1) Covered under a current workers’ compensation policy; and properly
classified under such policy.
2) Covered under a current health insurance policy as required by federal or
state law.
l) The contractor possesses all applicable professional and trade licenses required
for performing the public works.
m) The contractor has adequate financial resources to complete the public works
contract, as well as all other work the bidder is presently under contract to complete.
n) The contractor is bondable for the terms of the proposed public works contract.
[20261117R 197]
Princess Theatre 19
o) The contractor has a record of meeting the criteria which will be considered in
determining satisfactory completion of projects and may include, but are not limited
to:
1) Completion of contracts in accordance with drawings and specifications;
2) Diligent execution of the work and completed contracts according to the
established time schedules unless extensions are granted by the owner; and
3) Fulfilled guarantee requirements of the contract documents.
p) The contractor has, and diligently maintains, a written safety program.
Section 2-471. No Restriction on Discretion. If information other than what was disclosed by
the contractor in section 2-470 is discovered by the city or the department, official or employee
responsible for awarding the public works contract, and such information calls into question the
contractor’s abilities or competence to faithfully and responsibly comply with the terms of a
public works contract, that information shall be considered in determining whether the contractor
is a qualified responsible contractor.
Section 2-472. Affidavit of Compliance.
In the event a construction management company is to administer the said contract with
general contractors, prime contractors or subcontractors of any tier, the construction
management firm shall ensure all the rules and regulations contained in this Responsible
Contractors Ordinance are followed by all contractors of any tier.
The general, prime contractor, or sub-contractor of any tier bidding on a public works
project must include in its sealed bid:
a) Its own affidavit swearing compliance with the criteria set forth in section 2-
470 on the form required by city; and
b) An affidavit swearing compliance with the criteria set forth in section 2-470 on
the form required by the city from every subcontractor at any tier who will perform
work on the project.
Failure to submit the required affidavit, or providing incorrect, false, or misleading information
may disqualify the contractor’s bid.
SECTION 2. All ordinances and parts of ordinances conflicting with this ordinance are hereby
repealed.
SECTION 3. This ordinance shall be in full force and effect from and after its passage and
publication.
[20261117R 198]
Princess Theatre 20
10. CONTRACT
Princess Theatre Apartments
10.1 Preamble
This contract made this ___ day of ____ 2026, by and between BP Builders, LLC,
located at 5 Jay Cooke Rd, Esko, Minnesota, herein called "Contractor", and the City of
Superior, a municipal corporation, located in Douglas County, Wisconsin, herein called
"Owner".
WITNESSETH, that the Contractor and Owner for the consideration stated herein, agree
as follows:
10.2 Article I - Scope of Work
The Contractor shall perform everything required to be performed and shall provide and
furnish all the applicable labor, materials, equipment, necessary tools, expendable equipment,
insurance provided by the specifications, contributions to social security and all utility and
transportation services required to perform and complete in a workmanlike manner the following
work:
Bid Project: Princess Theatre Apartments
All work shall be in strict compliance with the Contractor's proposal and other contract
documents, herein mentioned as component parts of this contract.
10.3 Article II - Contract Price
The Owner shall pay the Contractor for the performance of this contract an amount based
upon the unit prices contained in the proposal for the actual measured quantities of work done or
lump sum as proposed.
Contractor shall not be entitled to payment for work found deficient or failing to conform
to the requirements set forth in this agreement and is not entitled to further payments until
corrected to the satisfaction of the Director of Planning at the cost of the Contractor. The City
will inform the Contractor of any deficiencies and/or items that do not conform to this contract
within thirty (30) days of receipt.
Unless otherwise provided in the special provisions, payments are to be made to the
Contractor within 30 days of receipt of an approved payment application/invoice on the basis of
[20261117R 199]
Princess Theatre 21
written approval of estimates by the Owner of the value of the work performed during the
preceding billing period. However, in accordance with 66.0901(9) Wisconsin Statutes, owner
will retain five percent (5%) of the amount of each such estimate, until the work has been
completed. This retainage will be held until completion and acceptance of all work included in
this contract.
Submission of a final payment application/invoice shall be accompanied by applicable
payroll reports and final unconditional lien waivers (from all sub-contractors and suppliers) to
the Owner. Prior to release of final payment, the Planning Department shall review project
documents, submitted by Contractor to determine the satisfaction thereof; it will be at the
Planning Department’s sole discretion when the final payment is made. Final payment will be
made to Contractor within thirty (30) days of the City’s acceptance of services as complete.
The Owner, in case the work under this contract is not completed within the time required
or within an extended time approved in writing by the Owner, is authorized to take charge of the
work and finish it at the expense of the Contractor and his sureties, and to apply the amount
retained from estimates to the completion of the work.
10.4 Article III - Component Parts of this Contract
This contract consists of the following component parts, all of which are as fully a part of
it as if set out verbatim herein, or if not attached, as if the same were hereto attached:
1. Advertisement to Bid
2. Instructions to Bidders
3. Bid Proposal
4. Subcontractors & Suppliers Listing
5 Addenda Acknowledgment and all addenda
6. Bid Bond
7. Bidder's Proof of Responsibility
8. Affidavit of Organization and Authority
9. Affidavit of Compliance from Contractor and all Sub-Contractors
10. Contract
11. Certificate of Insurance
12. Performance and Payment Bond
13. General Specifications
14. Engineer’s Certificate (as applicable)
15. Special Provisions (as applicable)
16. Contract Change Order
17. Additional Attachments per Index (as applicable)
The contract documents form a complete unit and requirements called for by one are as
binding as if called for by all. In cases of conflict between plans and specifications, the
specifications shall govern. Special Provisions shall control over General Specifications.
[20261117R 200]
Princess Theatre 22
10.5 Article IV - Payment for Labor & Materials
The Contractor specifically agrees to pay for all claims for labor performed for this
project and materials furnished, used and consumed in completing the foregoing contract,
together with all items enumerated in Section 779.035, of the Wisconsin Statutes, as the
obligation of the Contractor. No assignment, modification or change in the contract, or change in
the work covered thereby, or any extension of time for completion of the contract shall release
the sureties on the bond.
10.6 Article V – Insurance
Within ten (10) days after the execution of the contract, and prior to commencement of
any work, the Contractor shall file with the Owner, satisfactory evidence of having adequate
worker’s compensation insurance and public liability insurance, both personal and property, as
outlined in the General Specifications, section 12.3.
10.7 Non-Discrimination
Upon execution of this Agreement, Contractor/Consultant agrees as follows:
Contractor/Consultant and all Subcontractors do not discriminate against any employee,
applicant for employment, independent contractor, or any other persons because of race, color,
religion, sex, sexual orientation, gender identity, or national origin.
10.8 Authority
The Contractor represen
Text truncated. Open the original for the full document.
Source: City of Superior website. First collected Nov 18, 2026.