Finance Committee Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Mayville · Dodge County · Finance Committee · meeting of Nov 23, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Mayville
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF MAYVILLE FINANCE COMMITTEE
MEETING AGENDA
NOVEMBER 23, 2026
6:00 PM
MAYVILLE CITY HALL
15 S. SCHOOL STREET
1. CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
2. CITIZEN COMMENTS
Citizen Comments are to be kept to a maximum of five minutes per speaker unless the chairperson
allows an extension of time. Each citizen is to make comments at the podium after stating name and
address. Each citizen may comment only one time per public hearing / meeting.
3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
3.1. Approval of Minutes of the October 26, 2026, Finance Committee Meeting
4. DISCUSS WITH POSSIBLE ACTION
4.1. Discuss, with Possible Recommendation, Financial Policies for the City of Mayville
5. ADJOURNMENT
Ald. Bob Smith, Presiding Officer
Meeting starts at 6:00PM, or immediately following the Public Works Committee meeting.
NOTE: Persons with disabilities requiring special accommodations for attendance at the meeting
should contact City Hall at least one (1) business day prior to the meeting.
Page 1 of 14
CITY OF MAYVILLE FINANCE COMMITTEE
MEETING MINUTES
OCTOBER 26, 2026
6:00 PM
MAYVILLE CITY HALL
1. CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
The meeting was called to order at 06:13 PM by Ald. Bob Smith, with the following roll call:
Present: Ald. Anthony DeBaker, Ald. Bob Smith
Excused: Ald. Molly Henkel.
Absent: None.
Staff present: Comptroller/Treasurer Darlene Smith, Police Cheif Ryan Toellner, Police Lieutenant Jeremy
Johnson, EMS Director Julie Staffin, EMS Deputy Director Devin Sellnow, Library Director Bradford Ney,
DPW/Parks Director Jacob Schellpfeffer, Fire Cheif Geoff Engel, Assistant Fire Cheif Mike Thoreson, TAG
Director Jess Loomans, and Clerk/Executive Assistant Anastasia Gonstead.
2. CITIZEN COMMENTS
None.
3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
3.1. Approval of Minutes of the September 28, 2026, Finance Committee Meeting
The motion to approve the minutes of the September 28, 2026, Finance Committee meeting was
made by Ald. DeBaker and seconded by Ald. Smith.
Ayes: Ald. DeBaker, Ald. Smith.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 2 - 0.
Motion has Passed.
4. DISCUSS WITH POSSIBLE ACTION
4.1. Review of, and Recommendations for, the Proposed 2027 City of Mayville Fee Schedule
Page 2 of 14
Background on this agenda item was provided by Clerk/Executive Assistant Gonstead. EMS
Director Staffin indicated she is not in agreement with the lift assist as proposed by the Fire
Department. Director Staffin explained she doesn't want EMS and Fire charging separately, EMS
can bill through insurance. If it affects the Fire Department's budget, EMS would be able to call a
separate ambulance instead as they are able. Fire Chief Engel disagreed. The Finance Committee
wants EMS and Fire to compromise.
The motion to table was made by Ald. DeBaker and seconded by Ald. Smith.
Ayes: Ald. DeBaker, Ald. Smith.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 2 - 0.
Motion has Passed.
4.2. Discuss, with Possible Recommendation, the 2027 Memorandum of Understanding Between the
City of Mayville and Main Street Mayville, Inc.
Background provided by Mayor Boelk.
The motion to recommend Common Council approve the 2027 memorandum of understanding
between the City of Mayville and Main Street Mayville Inc. was made by Ald. DeBaker and seconded
by Ald. Smith.
Ayes: Ald. DeBaker, Ald. Smith.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 2 - 0.
Motion has Passed.
4.3. Discussion, with Possible Recommendation, Regarding Transfer of the Youth Baseball Program
and Applicable Assets from Mayville Sports, Inc. to the Mayville Recreation Department
TAG Director Loomans provided background on this agenda item. Equipment and assets would be
transferred to the Rec Department. Director Loomans took questions from the Body. She confirmed
that the Rec. Director is in agreement.
The motion to recommend Common Council approve the transfer of the Youth Baseball Program
and applicable assets from Mayville Sports Inc. to the Mayville Recreational Department was made
by Ald. DeBaker and seconded by Ald. Smith.
Ayes: Ald. DeBaker, Ald. Smith.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 2 - 0.
Motion has Passed.
4.4. Review, with Possible Recommendation, Annual TAG Membership Rates Including 24/7 Access
Pricing, Punch Cards, and Day Passes
TAG Director Jess Loomans provided background on this agenda item. She provided an overview
of the supplemental handout; 5% membership increase, $1 increase on day passes, $5 increase on
aquatic classes, $30 annual key fob fee. The fee increases were included in the TAG Center's 2027
proposed budget. Director Loomans also provided an overview of the potential longer pool
shutdown in the early summer months.
Page 3 of 14
4.5. Discuss, with Possible Recommendation, the Issuance of Complimentary TAG Center Passes to
City of Mayville Taxpayers
Background was provided by Ald. Smith. TAG Director Loomans confirmed it would be the same as
last year, 4 complimentary TAG Center passes per tax bill.
The motion to recommend Common Council approve the issuance of complimentary TAG Center
passes to City of Mayville taxpayers was made by Ald. DeBaker and seconded by Ald. Smith.
Ayes: Ald. DeBaker, Ald. Smith.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 2 - 0.
Motion has Passed.
4.6. Discuss, with Possible Recommendation, Ordinance 1158-2026, "An Ordinance Amending the
Annual Compensation of the Mayor and Alderpersons for the City of Mayville"
The motion to recommend Common Council approve Ordinance 1158-2026, "An Ordinance
amending the annual compensation of they Mayor and Alderpersons for the City of Mayville" was
made by Ald. DeBaker and seconded by Ald. Smith.
Ayes: Ald. DeBaker, Ald. Smith.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 2 - 0.
Motion has passed.
5. ADJOURNMENT
The motion to adjourn the meeting was made by Ald. DeBaker and seconded by Ald. Smith.
Ayes: Ald. DeBaker, Ald. Smith.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 2 - 0
Motion has Passed. The Finance Committee meeting was adjourned at 6:42 PM.
Respectfully submitted by Lexi Volbright - Deputy Clerk.
Page 4 of 14
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
STAFF MEMO
Meeting Date: November 23, 2026
To: Finance Committee
From: Anastasia Gonstead – City Clerk/Executive Assistant
Subject: Review of Proposed Financial Policies
Background
Comptroller/Treasurer Darlene Smith has developed three proposed financial policies for
consideration: the Fund Balance and General Obligation Debt Limit Policy, the Investment
Policy and Designation of Public Depositories, and the Purchasing Authority Policy and
Procedures. These policies are intended to establish consistent financial practices, clarify
authority and responsibility, strengthen internal controls, and provide greater transparency and
accountability in the management of public funds.
The City's auditors have noted the need for formal policies in these areas. The development of
these policies is intended to address those recommendations while providing staff, elected
officials, and department heads with clear guidelines for financial decision-making and day-to-
day operations.
1. Fund Balance and General Obligation Debt Limit Policy
This policy establishes guidelines for maintaining adequate financial reserves, managing fund
balance classifications, and monitoring the City's general obligation debt. It establishes a
target General Fund unassigned fund balance of 20% to 30% of annual operating expenditures,
outlines procedures for replenishment if reserves fall below the minimum target, and
establishes priorities for the use of year-end surplus funds. It also addresses the City's
statutory general obligation debt limit.
The purpose of this policy is to promote long-term financial stability, protect the City's ability to
maintain essential services during emergencies or revenue shortfalls, stabilize tax rates, and
reduce reliance on borrowing for capital projects. It also provides clear guidelines for how
reserves are classified, maintained, and utilized.
2. Investment Policy and Designation of Public Depositories
This policy establishes parameters for investing City funds not immediately needed for
operating expenses, including investment objectives, authorized investments, investment
authority, diversification, collateralization, internal controls, reporting requirements, and
approved financial institutions and investment providers.
Page 5 of 14
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
The primary objectives are safety of principal, liquidity to meet anticipated cash-flow needs,
and yield, in that order. The policy provides a framework for protecting public funds while
allowing the City to prudently manage available cash and earn investment income. It also
establishes accountability and safeguards through authorized investment personnel, reporting
to the Common Council, and periodic review.
3. Purchasing Authority Policy and Procedures
This policy establishes purchasing thresholds, competitive quote and bid requirements,
approval authority, purchasing procedures, and requirements for purchase orders, credit cards,
petty cash, professional services, sole-source purchases, emergency purchases, and formal
bidding. It also addresses conflicts of interest, gifts, ethics, and vendor-related campaign
contributions.
The purpose of this policy is to ensure City purchases are made consistently, transparently,
and in the City's best financial interest. It establishes clear expectations for employees and
department heads, ensures appropriate oversight based on the dollar value of purchases,
encourages competition, and helps prevent unauthorized expenditures, conflicts of interest,
and the splitting of purchases to avoid approval requirements.
Why These Policies Are Necessary
Formal financial policies are an important component of responsible municipal financial
management. They establish expectations before financial decisions are made, rather than
relying solely on past practice or individual judgment. They provide a framework for staff to
follow, help ensure consistency between departments, strengthen internal controls, and
protect both the City and those entrusted with managing public funds.
Additionally, having these policies formally adopted by the Common Council demonstrates the
City's commitment to sound financial management, accountability, transparency, and
responsible stewardship of taxpayer dollars. As noted by the City's auditors, formal policies in
these areas are needed and should be established.
Recommendation
Staff recommends that the Finance Committee review the three proposed policies developed
by Comptroller/Treasurer Darlene Smith, provide any suggested revisions, and recommend
forwarding the policies to the Common Council for consideration and formal adoption. Once
adopted, the policies will provide a foundation for consistent financial practices and will be
reviewed periodically and updated as necessary to reflect changes in municipal operations,
statutory requirements, and financial management practices.
Page 6 of 14
City of Mayville
Fund Balance and General Obligation Debt Limit Policy
1. Purpose
This policy establishes guidelines for maintaining adequate financial reserves and
managing debt for the City of Mayville. Its goal is to stabilize tax rates, protect essential
services during emergencies or revenue shortfalls, maintain sufficient working capital,
and reduce reliance on borrowing for capital projects while complying with GASB
Statement No. 54.
2. Fund Balance Classifications & Authority
The City reports governmental fund balances in five GASB 54 categories:
• Nonspendable: Amounts that cannot be spent because they are not in spendable
form (such as inventory, prepaid items, or long-term receivables/advances to
other funds) or are legally required to remain intact.
• Restricted: Amounts constrained by external parties, grantors, creditors, or
enabling legislation (such as debt service funds, grant funds, and impact fees).
• Committed: Amounts constrained for a specific purpose by the Common Council
through an ordinance adopted by simple majority prior to December 31 of the
fiscal year. If the exact dollar amount is unknown by year-end, the ordinance
must specify the formula or method to calculate it. Modifying or removing a
commitment requires a subsequent ordinance.
• Assigned: Amounts intended for a specific purpose (such as Capital
Improvement Plan projects) that are neither restricted nor committed. Both the
Common Council (by simple majority vote recorded in the minutes) and the
Comptroller/Treasurer (with prompt reporting to the Council) have the authority
to assign, modify, or remove assignments.
• Unassigned: The residual spendable balance in the General Fund available for
any lawful purpose.
Order of Spending: When multiple fund balance categories are available for an
expenditure, the City will spend Restricted funds first, followed by Committed, Assigned,
and finally Unassigned funds, unless the Common Council specifies otherwise.
3. General Fund Reserve Target & Replenishment
Page 7 of 14
• Target Range: The City will maintain an Unassigned General Fund balance of 20%
to 30% of annual General Fund operating expenditures.
• Drawing Below Minimum: Any budget amendment or action that reduces the
Unassigned Fund Balance below the 20% minimum requires a two-thirds (2/3)
vote of the Common Council.
• Replenishment: If the Unassigned Fund Balance falls below 20%, the
Comptroller/Treasurer will present a replenishment plan to the Common Council
during the next budget cycle to restore the balance within 1 to 3 fiscal years.
4. Use of Year-End Surplus (Above 30%)
At the close of each fiscal year, any General Fund surplus will first be applied to bring
the Unassigned Fund Balance within the 20%–30% target range. Once the reserve is
fully funded, the Common Council may allocate excess funds by simple majority
resolution in the following priority order:
1. Debt Reduction: Paying down callable principal, refinancing high-interest debt, or
funding an irrevocable debt service escrow account.
2. Capital Improvements: Transferring funds to the Capital Improvement Fund to
support pay-as-you-go capital projects.
3. Alternative One-Time Uses: Authorizing other one-time operational or financial
priorities if debt and capital needs are met.
5. General Obligation (G.O.) Debt Limit
In accordance with Wisconsin statutory limits, the City’s total outstanding general
obligation debt principal may not exceed 5% of the City’s equalized value (including tax
increments) as determined by the Wisconsin Department of Revenue.
6. Annual Review
Staff will review this policy annually following the completion of the fiscal year audit and
recommend updates to the Common Council as needed.
Page 8 of 14
City of Mayville
Investment Policy and Designation of Public Depositories
1. Purpose & Scope
This policy governs the investment of all City of Mayville funds not immediately needed
to meet operating expenses. Unless specifically exempted by the Common Council, this
policy applies to all current and future City funds—including the General, Debt Service,
Capital Projects, Water Utility, Sewer Utility, and TAG Center funds. Where legally
permissible and financially prudent, the Comptroller/Treasurer is authorized to pool
cash across these funds to maximize investment returns. Investment earnings will be
allocated back to each participating fund on a pro-rata basis.
2. Core Objectives (In Priority Order)
All City investments must be managed according to the following three priorities,
ranked from highest to lowest:
1. Safety: Preservation of principal is the foremost objective. Investments must
minimize credit risk, concentration risk, interest rate risk, and foreign currency
risk.
2. Liquidity: The portfolio must remain sufficiently liquid to meet all reasonably
anticipated operating cash needs through matched maturities, money market
accounts, or the Wisconsin Local Government Investment Pool (LGIP).
3. Yield: The portfolio will be designed to earn a market rate of return across
economic cycles, secondary to safety and liquidity. Securities will generally be
held to maturity, except when sold early to prevent principal loss from declining
credit quality, to meet unexpected liquidity needs, or to execute a swap that
improves overall portfolio safety and yield.
3. Authority, Prudence & Ethics
• Delegation of Authority: Management of the investment program is entrusted to
the Comptroller/Treasurer under the direction of the Common Council. Only
personnel listed in Appendix A may execute investment transactions.
• Standard of Prudence: Investments must be made with judgment and care—
never for speculation or with aggressive leverage. In accordance with Wis. Stat. §
34.06, the Comptroller/Treasurer is relieved of personal liability for losses
resulting from the failure of a public depository when deposits are made in
compliance with Wis. Stat. § 34.05.
• Ethics & Conflicts of Interest: Officers and employees involved in the investment
process must avoid personal business activities that could impair impartial
decision-making and may not conduct personal investment transactions with the
same individuals who handle City business.
Page 9 of 14
4. Permissible Investments & Diversification
• Authorized Investments: City funds may only be invested in instruments
permitted under Wis. Stat. § 66.0603(1m) (summarized in Appendix B). Debt
service reserve funds for General Obligation debt are further restricted to
instruments permitted under Wis. Stat. § 67.11.
• Diversification: To protect against loss, the portfolio will be diversified across
issuers, sectors (excluding U.S. Treasury obligations), and staggered maturities,
while keeping an appropriate share in liquid, same-day accounts.
• Safekeeping: All investment securities must be held in the City’s name by a third-
party custodian under a written custodial agreement compliant with Wisconsin
law.
5. Collateralization
• Required Collateral: Any Certificate of Deposit (CD) exceeding federal (FDIC) and
Wisconsin State Deposit Guarantee Fund (Wis. Stat. § 34.08) coverage limits
must be collateralized at 102% of principal and accrued interest. The City may
also require 102% collateralization for any other deposits exceeding FDIC limits.
• Custody & Substitutions: Pledged collateral must be held in the City’s name by an
independent third-party custodian under a Tri-Party Security Agreement,
evidenced by safekeeping receipts provided to the Comptroller/Treasurer. Any
collateral substitution requires prior City authorization.
6. Internal Controls & Reporting
• Internal Controls: The Comptroller/Treasurer and external Auditor will maintain
controls that separate transaction authority from accounting and recordkeeping,
require written confirmation of all trades and wire transfers, record earnings per
GAAP, and verify policy compliance during the annual external audit.
• Council Reporting: The Comptroller/Treasurer will provide periodic investment
summaries to the Common Council detailing portfolio holdings, transactions, and
compliance with this policy.
7. Policy Adoption & Review
This policy—including its designated depositories and authorized personnel in the
appendices—must be adopted by Common Council resolution and reviewed at least
every two years.
Page 10 of 14
Appendix A: Authorized Investment Personnel
• Comptroller/Treasurer (Currently: Darlene Smith)
Appendix B: Summary of Permissible Investments (Wis. Stat. §
66.0603(1m))
Under Wisconsin law, the City may invest idle funds in:
1. Time Deposits: Certificates of deposit and time deposits in any credit union,
bank, savings bank, trust company, or savings and loan association authorized to
transact business in Wisconsin.
2. U.S. Government Securities: Bonds or securities issued or guaranteed as to
principal and interest by the federal government or its
agencies/instrumentalities.
3. Wisconsin Municipal Bonds: Bonds or securities of any Wisconsin county, city,
village, town, school district, technical college district, drainage district, or
designated state authority (such as UW Hospitals and Clinics Authority).
4. High-Grade Corporate/Other Securities: Any security maturing (or tenderable at
the holder's option) within 7 years of acquisition that carries the highest or
second-highest rating from a nationally recognized rating agency (e.g., S&P or
Moody's).
5. Government Money Market Funds: Open-end management investment
companies/trusts (no-load, registered under the Investment Company Act of
1940) whose portfolios are restricted strictly to U.S. government/agency
securities and fully collateralized repurchase agreements.
Appendix C: Approved Depositories, Financial Institutions &
Broker/Dealers
• Horicon Bank
• State of Wisconsin Local Government Investment Pool (LGIP)
• Ehlers Investment Partners LLC
Page 11 of 14
City of Mayville
Purchasing Authority Policy and Procedures
1. Purpose & Enforcement
This policy establishes rules for acquiring goods and services efficiently, economically,
and transparently for the City of Mayville. The Comptroller/Treasurer (or designee)
oversees enforcement of this policy. Violations may result in disciplinary action under
the City Employee Handbook.
2. Purchasing Authority & Competitive Quote/Bid Thresholds
All purchases require competitive pricing and sign-off based on total transaction value.
Purchases must never be split to bypass approval or quote thresholds.
Purchase Amount Competitive Quote / Bid
Requirement Required Approvals
Under $500 None required (best
judgment) Department Head
$500 – $3,000 At least 2 written or verbal
quotes
Department Head, Mayor, and
Comptroller/Treasurer
$3,000.01 –
$24,999.99
At least 3 documented
written quotes
Department Head, Mayor, Comptroller/Treasurer,
and Common Council
$25,000 and over Formal sealed bidding (after
public notice)
Department Head, Mayor, Comptroller/Treasurer,
and Common Council
• Delegation: Any approver may formally delegate authority to a designee when
unavailable.
• Cooperative Purchasing Exception: Goods or services bought at negotiated
government rates through Sourcewell or VendorNet are exempt from quote and
formal bid requirements, though standard dollar-limit approvals still apply.
• Budget Adjustments: The Comptroller/Treasurer may make budget transfers for
non-budgeted items up to $50,000 provided the bottom-line budget does not
increase (any adjustment of $25,000 or more must be reported to the Common
Council in advance). Any amendment increasing the total budget requires prior
Common Council approval.
3. Procurement Methods & Sales Tax
• Purchase Orders (POs): Required before ordering any goods or services of
$2,500 or more, except for routine recurring obligations (utilities, approved
contracts, and intergovernmental agreements).
• Invoices & City Credit Cards: Purchases under $2,500 and routine contract/utility
bills may be processed via invoice approval in the financial system or paid with a
City credit card.
• Online Purchasing & Personal Cards: Online orders follow all standard approval
and quote rules and should use a City credit card. Personal credit cards may only
Page 12 of 14
be used with prior Department Head approval and are reimbursed through payroll
with an itemized receipt.
• Petty Cash: Limited to $100 or less per purchase. Requires a Department Head-
approved voucher, itemized receipt, and (for advances) a signed GL-coded
request form.
• Sales Tax Exemption: City purchases are exempt from sales tax. Employees
must provide the City’s exemption certificate (available from the
Comptroller/Treasurer) to vendors and may never use it for personal purchases.
4. Special Procurements
• Sole Source Purchases: Exempt from competitive quotes/bids when only one
vendor can supply the item (e.g., proprietary software, OEM replacement parts,
regulated utilities, or time-sensitive used equipment). The requisition must
document the sole-source justification. Sole-source purchases over $50,000
require prior Common Council approval to waive bids.
• Professional Services: Procured via RFP, RFQ, or direct negotiation based on
qualifications and prior City experience. All professional service providers must
submit proof of professional liability (errors and omissions) insurance with their
proposal. Contracts exceeding $10,000 require review by the
Comptroller/Treasurer (and City Attorney, if needed) plus standard dollar
approvals.
• Emergencies: When an unforeseen event threatens public health or safety, the
Comptroller/Treasurer or a Department Head may authorize immediate work
without formal quotes or bids. Staff must document the emergency and notify
the Common Council promptly; emergency purchases of $50,000 or more require
retroactive Common Council approval.
5. Formal Bidding Process ($25,000+)
For purchases of $25,000 or more (unless waived by a two-thirds vote of the Common
Council):
1. Bid Notice & Review: Staff prepares specifications, cost estimates, and
schedules, which are reviewed by the Clerk/Executive Assistant before release. A
Bid Notice must be published on the City website and in at least one newspaper
at least two weeks prior to bid opening.
2. Fair Evaluation & Award: All bidders must receive identical information. Bids are
evaluated strictly on the criteria stated in the invitation to bid and awarded to the
lowest responsible bidder (or another bidder deemed in the City's best interest by
the Common Council).
6. Ethics, Conflicts of Interest & Gifts
City elected officials, appointed officials, and employees must maintain the highest
ethical standards and protect confidential vendor information:
• Conflicts of Interest: No City representative may participate in a purchase if they,
their partner, or an immediate family/household member (spouse, children,
siblings, or household residents) holds a financial interest, leadership role, or
Page 13 of 14
prospective employment arrangement with a vendor, unless disclosed to and
permitted by the Common Council.
• Gifts & Gratuities: Representatives may not accept personal loans, favors, or gifts
beyond nominal promotional items (e.g., pens, calendars, or shareable office
treats). Unacceptable gifts must be returned via the Comptroller/Treasurer.
Corporate discounts are permitted only if offered equally to all City staff and
other corporate clients.
• Campaign Contribution Ban: Any vendor or owner who donates $200 or more to a
City representative, their campaign, or a supporting organization is barred from
supplying goods or services to the City unless selected as the lowest responsible
bidder through formal competitive bidding.
Page 14 of 14
Source: City of Mayville website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.