Personnel Committee Meeting — Agenda Packet
City of Mayville · Dodge County · Personnel Committee · meeting of Nov 23, 2026 · Agenda packets
Open the original document More from City of Mayville
Text
Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.
CITY OF MAYVILLE PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
MEETING AGENDA
NOVEMBER 23, 2026
6:00 PM
MAYVILLE CITY HALL
15 S. SCHOOL STREET
1. CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
2. CITIZEN COMMENTS
Citizen Comments are to be kept to a maximum of five minutes per speaker unless the chairperson
allows an extension of time. Each citizen is to make comments at the podium after stating name and
address. Each citizen may comment only one time per public hearing / meeting.
3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
3.1. Approval of Minutes of the October 26, 2026, Personnel Committee Meeting
4. DISCUSS WITH POSSIBLE ACTION
4.1. Discuss, with Possible Recommendation, Clarification to Section 3.03 - Separeation from
Employment: Good Standing and Separation Payouts, of the City of Mayville Employee Handbook
5. ADJOURNMENT
Ald. Kim Olson, Presiding Officer
Meeting starts at 6:00 PM, or immediately following the Finance Committee meeting.
NOTE: Persons with disabilities requiring special accommodations for attendance at the meeting
should contact City Hall at least one (1) business day prior to the meeting.
Page 1 of 11
CITY OF MAYVILLE PERSONNEL COMMITTEE
MEETING MINUTES
OCTOBER 26, 2026
6:00 PM
MAYVILLE CITY HALL
1. CALL TO ORDER AND ROLL CALL
The meeting was called to order at 06:42 PM by Ald. Kim Olson, with the following roll call:
Present: Ald. Mary Winter, Ald. Jason Buske, Ald. Kim Olson.
Excused: None.
Absent: None.
Staff present: Clerk/Executive Assistant Anastasia Gonstead.
2. CITIZEN COMMENTS
None.
3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES
3.1. Approval of Minutes of the September 28, 2026, Personnel Committee Meeting
The motion to approve the minutes of the September 28, 2026, Personnel Committee meeting was
made by Ald. Buske and seconded by Ald. Winter.
Ayes: Ald. Winter, Ald. Buske, Ald. Olson.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 3 - 0.
Motion has Passed.
4. DISCUSS WITH POSSIBLE ACTION
4.1. Discuss, with Possible Recommendation, Full-Time Employee Wage Scale to Accompany the Full-
Time Employee Position Scale
Background on this agenda item was provided by Clerk/Executive Assistant Gonstead. She
provided an overview of information in the packet.
The motion to recommend Common Council approve wage scale option 1 with sets of years for
full-time employees to accompany the full-time employee position scale was made by Ald. Buske
and seconded by Ald. Winter.
Ayes: Ald. Winter, Ald. Buske, Ald. Olson.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 3 - 0.
Motion has Passed.
4.2. Discuss, with Possible Recommendation, Providing Annual TAG Center Memberships for Full-Time
City Employees
Page 2 of 11
Background on this agenda item was provided by TAG Director Loomans, recommended by Park
Commission.
The motion to recommend Common Council approve annual single memberships for full-time City
employees and elected officials was made by Ald. Winter and seconded by Ald. Buske.
Ayes: Ald. Winter, Ald. Buske, Ald. Olson.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 3 - 0.
Motion has Passed.
5. ADJOURNMENT
The motion to adjourn the meeting was made by Ald. Buske and seconded by Ald. Winter.
Ayes: Ald. Winter, Ald. Buske, Ald. Olson.
Nays: None.
Vote Count: 3 - 0.
Motion has Passed. The Personnel Committee meeting was adjourned at 6:53 PM.
Respectfully submitted by Lexi Volbright - Deputy Clerk.
Page 3 of 11
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
STAFF MEMO
Meeting Date: November 23, 2026
To: Personnel Committee
From: Anastasia Gonstead – City Clerk/Executive Assistant and Darlene Smith – Comptroller
Treasurer
Subject: Proposed Employee Handbook Revisions – Separation Payouts and Retirement
Benefits
Background:
As part of the onboarding process for the City's new Comptroller/Treasurer, a review of the
City's existing employee separation payout procedures and benefit provisions was conducted.
During this review, it became apparent that the current Employee Handbook does not clearly
define all aspects of separation payouts, particularly regarding vacation calculations, sick
leave payout eligibility, and the administration of retirement-related benefits.
The existing language has left room for interpretation and has made it difficult for staff to
consistently navigate and administer these benefits. In some instances, understanding the
intended application of the policy has relied on historical knowledge and familiarity with past
practices rather than clear, written procedures.
Staff believes it is important to address these deficiencies by establishing clear,
comprehensive language that can be consistently applied regardless of changes in
administrative personnel. The intent is to create a policy that serves as a reliable reference for
employees, supervisors, payroll, and administration, eliminating reliance on institutional
knowledge held by individual staff members.
The proposed revisions are intended to accomplish three primary objectives:
1. Clarify existing employee benefit provisions and establish consistent eligibility and
calculation requirements.
2. Streamline the administration of separation payouts so procedures remain consistent
despite staff turnover or changes in administrative responsibilities.
3. Establish a more predictable and financially responsible approach to retirement-related
sick leave benefits.
Page 4 of 11
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
1. Vacation Payout Clarification
The current handbook states that unused vacation is paid out upon separation, prorated to the
date of separation. However, it does not clearly distinguish between the annual vacation
allotment awarded on January 1 and the additional prorated entitlement associated with the
year of separation.
The proposed revision clarifies that:
• Eligible employees receive their annual vacation allotment on January 1.
• Employees who voluntarily resign or retire while in good standing are eligible for
payment of their unused vacation balance.
• An additional prorated current-year vacation entitlement is calculated through the
employee's final date of employment.
• A standardized calendar-day calculation will be used, based on the employee's annual
vacation allotment and the number of days employed during the calendar year.
This clarification provides a consistent method for calculating final vacation payouts and
eliminates uncertainty regarding the City's intent when awarding vacation annually and
calculating benefits upon separation.
2. Sick Leave Payout – Employees Hired Prior to January 1, 2011
The existing sick leave payout schedule for employees hired prior to January 1, 2011, will
remain unchanged in terms of payout percentages.
The proposed revision clarifies that unused sick leave is only eligible for payout upon
retirement from City employment, provided the employee leaves in good standing and meets
the applicable years-of-service requirements.
The existing vesting schedule will remain:
Years of Service Payout
5 years 60%
10 years 68%
15 years 74%
20 years 80%
This change provides clarity that resignation or other voluntary separation, without retirement,
does not qualify an employee for a sick leave payout.
Page 5 of 11
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
3. Retirement Sick Leave Benefit – Employees Hired On or After January 1, 2011
For employees hired on or after January 1, 2011, staff is proposing a different approach to the
retirement sick leave benefit.
Under the proposed revision, eligible full-time employees would receive a retirement health
insurance benefit equal to 50% of their accumulated unused sick leave balance, calculated at
their final base hourly rate of pay, subject to a maximum of 360 converted hours.
To qualify, employees must:
• Retire from City employment and have their Wisconsin Department of Employee Trust
Funds (ETF) retirement paperwork on file with the City.
• Have completed at least 10 years of full-time service with the City.
• Leave employment in good standing, as defined in the Employee Handbook.
• Meet the applicable Wisconsin Retirement System retirement eligibility provisions.
The benefit would be credited to a designated account for the retiree's use toward health
insurance premiums. The benefit may also be used by an eligible spouse, subject to applicable
plan requirements and administrative procedures. It would not be issued as a direct cash
payment to the employee.
The proposed benefit recognizes and rewards long-term City service while providing a more
controlled and sustainable approach to administering retirement sick leave benefits.
4. Administrative and Financial Benefits to the City
In addition to clarifying employee benefits, these proposed revisions provide several
administrative and financial advantages for the City.
Consistency and Continuity of Administration
One of the primary goals of this revision is to establish written procedures that are clear
enough to be administered consistently by any designated City employee.
The previous handbook language left room for interpretation and required staff to rely, in part,
on historical practices and the knowledge of employees familiar with prior separation payouts.
This creates unnecessary administrative challenges when responsibilities change or
employees leave their positions.
Page 6 of 11
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
The proposed revisions establish defined eligibility requirements, standardized calculations,
and clear procedures for processing separation payouts. This will allow future administrative
personnel to reference the handbook and follow established requirements without having to
reconstruct past practices or rely on information passed between employees.
Ultimately, the goal is to create a process that is institutionalized within City policy rather than
dependent on the individual administering it.
Improved Administrative Efficiency
Establishing specific eligibility requirements for retirement sick leave benefits, including ETF
retirement documentation and minimum years of full-time service, provides a more
straightforward process for determining eligibility.
Standardized vacation calculations and clearly defined sick leave provisions will also reduce
the potential for inconsistent interpretations between employees, administration, and payroll.
Reduced Immediate Financial Exposure
One of the more significant financial considerations is the proposed change to the retirement
sick leave benefit for employees hired on or after January 1, 2011.
Under the current structure, eligible employees may accumulate substantial sick leave
balances that could result in significant lump-sum payouts upon separation or retirement.
The proposed approach changes this structure by:
• Limiting eligibility to employees who formally retire and meet the established service
requirements.
• Providing a 50% benefit rather than a full-value cash payout.
• Establishing a maximum of 360 converted sick leave hours.
• Directing the benefit toward retiree health insurance premiums rather than issuing a
lump-sum cash payment.
This approach reduces the City's immediate cash outlay associated with retirement sick leave
payouts and provides greater predictability when planning for employee retirements.
While the City would still have a financial obligation associated with the retirement health
insurance benefit, the expense would be administered through a designated benefit
arrangement rather than as a potentially substantial lump-sum payment at the time of
retirement.
Page 7 of 11
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
Long-Term Financial Planning
Establishing a defined maximum benefit and clear eligibility requirements allows the City to
better anticipate and manage future retirement-related expenses. It also provides a more
consistent framework for evaluating the financial implications of employee retirements.
Consideration of the Ten-Year Service Requirement
The proposed ten (10) year minimum service requirement was selected with consideration of
current employment trends and the City's existing benefit structure. It has become increasingly
uncommon for employees to spend 20 or more years with a single employer. Requiring 20
years of service before an employee becomes eligible for any retirement sick leave benefit
may make the benefit less meaningful or attainable for a significant portion of the workforce.
Additionally, employees hired prior to January 1, 2011, begin vesting in their sick leave payout
benefit after five (5) years of service. Establishing a ten (10) year minimum for employees
hired on or after January 1, 2011, provides a distinction between the two employee groups
while still recognizing and rewarding a meaningful period of service to the City.
The ten-year threshold is a proposed starting point and may be adjusted at the discretion of
the elected body based on the City's intended purpose for offering this benefit. Specifically, the
Common Council may wish to consider whether the primary objective is to:
• Encourage employee longevity: Establish a higher service threshold that incentivizes
employees to remain with the City for a longer period of time.
• Recognize retiring employees: Establish a more attainable service threshold that
provides a retirement benefit to employees who have dedicated a meaningful portion of
their careers to the City, even if they have not reached 20 years of service.
The proposed ten (10) year requirement attempts to balance these objectives by recognizing
meaningful service while providing a retirement benefit that employees have a reasonable
opportunity to attain.
Next Steps
Once the Personnel Committee has reviewed the proposed changes and made a
recommendation, the revisions will be incorporated into the current draft of the Employee
Handbook. The updated handbook will then be brought before the Common Council in
December for consideration and, hopefully, formal adoption.
Attachment: Proposed Separation Payouts Verbiage
Page 8 of 11
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
Separation Payouts
Separation payouts shall include the following, provided the employee meets the eligibility
requirements outlined in this section and applicable provisions of this Employee Handbook.
1. Vacation Payout
Vacation is awarded to eligible employees annually on January 1 of each calendar year.
Employees who voluntarily separate from employment with the City, including through
resignation or retirement, while in good standing, as defined elsewhere in this Employee
Handbook, shall be eligible for payment of their unused vacation balance upon separation. The
vacation payout shall include:
a. Payment of all unused vacation hours remaining in the employee's vacation bank as
of the date of separation.
b. An additional prorated amount of vacation earned during the calendar year in which
the employee separates from employment. This amount shall be calculated by
multiplying the employee's annual vacation allotment by the number of calendar days
employed during the year, through and including the employee's final date of
employment, divided by the total number of calendar days in that year (365 days, or 366
days in a leap year).
Any vacation already used during the calendar year shall be deducted from the prorated
vacation entitlement when determining the final vacation payout. The total vacation payout
shall include the employee's remaining unused vacation balance and any additional prorated
vacation entitlement earned through the date of separation.
Vacation payouts are subject to standard payroll withholdings.
2. Sick Leave Payout
Unused sick leave shall only be eligible for payout or retirement benefit upon retirement from
City employment, subject to the eligibility requirements outlined below. Employees who resign
or otherwise voluntarily separate from employment without retiring shall not be eligible for a
sick leave payout or retirement sick leave benefit.
a. Employees Hired Prior to January 1, 2011
Employees hired prior to January 1, 2011, who retire from the City in good standing, as
defined elsewhere in this Employee Handbook, shall be eligible for a payout of their
unused sick leave, at their existing rate of pay, as follows:
Years of Service Payout Percentage
Five (5) years of service 60%
Ten (10) years of service 68%
Fifteen (15) years of service 74%
Twenty (20) years of service 80%
Page 9 of 11
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
Employees must meet the applicable years-of-service requirement as of their retirement
date to qualify for the corresponding payout percentage. The applicable payout
percentage shall be applied to the employee's accumulated unused sick leave balance
at their existing rate of pay.
An eligible retiring employee may elect to receive the sick leave payout or apply the
value of the payout toward health insurance premiums, subject to applicable City
policies and administrative procedures.
b. Employees Hired On or After January 1, 2011
Full-time employees hired on or after January 1, 2011, may accumulate unused sick
leave in accordance with Section 3.03 of this Employee Handbook. Upon retirement
from City employment, eligible employees may receive a retirement sick leave benefit,
subject to the following conditions:
i. The employee must retire from City employment and have their retirement
paperwork through the Wisconsin Department of Employee Trust Funds (ETF) on
file with the City.
ii. The employee must have completed a minimum of ten (10) years of full-time
service with the City as of their retirement date.
iii. The employee must leave employment in good standing, as defined elsewhere
in this Employee Handbook.
iv. The employee must be eligible for retirement under the applicable Wisconsin
Retirement System (WRS) provisions.
Upon meeting the eligibility requirements, fifty (50) percent of the employee's accrued unused
sick leave balance, calculated at the employee's final base hourly rate of pay, shall be credited
to a designated account for the retiree's use toward health insurance premiums. The benefit
shall be limited to a maximum of three hundred sixty (360) hours of sick leave converted to the
account.
The designated account may be used by the retiree or their eligible spouse toward health
insurance premiums, subject to applicable plan requirements and administrative procedures
established by the City. This benefit shall not be paid directly to the employee as cash.
Employees who resign, are terminated, or otherwise separate from City employment without
meeting the retirement eligibility requirements outlined above shall not be eligible for this
retirement sick leave benefit.
The retirement sick leave benefit shall be administered in accordance with applicable law, City
policy, and the provisions of this Employee Handbook.
Page 10 of 11
15 South School Street, PO Box 273, Mayville WI 53050
Phone: 920.387.7900 Fax: 920.387.7919
www.mayvillecity.com
3. Application of Payouts Toward Health Insurance Premiums
An employee who is eligible for a sick leave payout or retirement sick leave benefit in
accordance with this section may have the option of receiving the eligible sick leave payout or
applying the unused sick leave toward health insurance premiums, subject to applicable
provisions of this section and City policies.
Employees eligible for a vacation payout may also elect to use the monies paid to them for
unused vacation toward health insurance premiums. Vacation payout is subject to standard
payroll withholdings. After receiving the separation payout, an employee may return the funds
to the City for use in paying health insurance premiums for that employee, subject to
applicable administrative procedures.
4. Calculation of Separation Payouts and Deductions
Any separation payout or retirement benefit due to an eligible employee shall be calculated in
accordance with the provisions of this Handbook and applicable City policies.
Deductions may be made from the employee's final separation payout, as permitted by
applicable law and City policy. Such deductions may include, but are not limited to, the cost of
City-owned property not returned, costs associated with employment-related commitments
that cannot be cancelled or recovered by the City, education or training costs subject to
repayment or deduction as established in Section 4.02 of the Employee Handbook, and any
other amounts that the employee has authorized or that the City is otherwise permitted by
applicable law or City policy to deduct from the employee's final payout.
5. Approval and Administration of Separation Payouts
Separation payouts will be made after approval from the Personnel Committee. The City will
provide the employee with a written calculation of the final separation payout. A copy of the
payout calculation form will be mailed to the employee's last known address following
separation from employment.
The City may require the employee to satisfy outstanding obligations to the City that cannot
lawfully be deducted from the final separation payout through other appropriate means.
6. Involuntary Separation
Employees terminated for a violation of policy or for unacceptable performance are not eligible
for separation payout, except as otherwise required by applicable law.
Page 11 of 11
Source: City of Mayville website. First collected Nov 20, 2026.