RecordWell Data

Rescheduled - Landmarks Commission Meeting — Agenda Packet

City of Menasha · Winnebago County · Landmarks Commission · meeting of Nov 18, 2026 · Agenda packets

Open the original document More from City of Menasha

Text

Extracted automatically from the original. Tables and formatting may not survive; the original document is authoritative.

A Quorum of the Administration Committee, Board of Public Works, Common Council, Personnel Committee, Plan Commission, Redevelopment Authority, and other City bodies may attend this meeting, though no official action of these bodies will be taken. LANDMARKS COMMISSION Wednesday, November 18, 2026 at 4:00 PM Elisha D. Smith Public Library Elisha D. Smith Conference Room 440 First Street, Menasha, WI AGENDA A. Call to Order B. Roll Call/Excused Absences C. Minutes to Approve 1. Landmarks Commission, 09/30/26 D. Public Comment on Any Matter Listed on the Agenda or Any Item Related to the Responsibilities of the Landmarks Commission E. Communication 1. Draft 2027 Meeting Schedule F. Discussion / Action Items 1. 200 Main Street Historic District Renovation Application 2. Set Next Meeting Date G. Public Comments on Any Matter Listed on the Agenda (5 minute time limit for each person) H. Adjournment If you have questions, please call the Community Development Department at (920) 967-3650 between 8:00 AM – 4:00 PM, Monday through Friday. "Menasha is committed to its diverse population. Our Non-English speaking population and those with disabilities are invited to contact the Community Development Department at (920) 967-3650 24-hours in advance of the meeting for the City to arrange special accommodations." Page 1 of 11 CITY OF MENASHA Landmarks Commission Elisha D. Smith Public Library 440 First Street, Menasha Elisha D. Smith Conference Room September 30, 2026 DRAFT MINUTES A. CALL TO ORDER The meeting was called to order by Chair Davis at 5:33pm. B. ROLL CALL/EXCUSED ABSENCES LANDMARKS MEMBERS PRESENT: Chair George Davis, Alderman Tim Hale, Commissioners Carol Sturm, Kari Mulder, and Danielle Rand. LANDMARKS MEMBERS EXCUSED: Vice-Chair Anastasia Horan OTHERS PRESENT: PP Larsen, Aaron Lavoy, Jennifer Lavoy C. MINUTES TO APPROVE 1. Minutes of the July 8, 2026 Landmarks Commission Meeting A motion was made by Comm. Rand to approve the minutes of the July 8, 2026 Landmarks Commission meeting. The motion was seconded by Comm. Mulder. The motion carried. 2. Minutes of the September 10, 2026 Landmarks Commission Meeting A motion was made by Comm. Rand to approve the minutes of the September 10, 2026 Landmarks Commission meeting. The motion was seconded by Comm. Mulder. The motion carried. D. PUBLIC COMMENT ON ANY ITEM OF CONCERN ON THIS AGENDAS OR ANY ITEM RELATE4ED TO THE LANDMARKS RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE LANDMARKS COMMIISSION No public comment. E. ACTION / DISCUSSION ITEMS 1. Historic Building Renovation Application – 210 Main Street Aaron and Jennifer Lavoy presented a proposal to paint the trim and door around the front entrance of 210 Main Street, changing the existing burgundy color to a dark chocolate brown selected from the historic color collection. They also described their operations and future plans for the business (Lumiere de Bougie). Commissioners discussed the proposal and confirmed the use of approved color selections. A motion was made by Comm. Rand and seconded by Ald. Hale to approve the Historic District Renovation Application and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness for the proposed façade renovations at 210 Main Street. The motion carried. 2. Historic Building Renovation Application – 14 Tayco Street PP Larsen presented the historic district renovation application and the images to replace the existing Hungry Donkey exterior signs with new vinyl signs for a new restaurant, Mrs. Potatoes. Commissioners discussed compliance with sign code requirements and noted no objection since the signage meets size and placement standards. A motion was made by Comm. Sturm and seconded Comm. Mulder to approve the Historic District Renovation Application and issue a Certificate of Appropriateness for the sign installation at 14 Tayco Street. The motion carried. Page 2 of 11 F. COMMUNICATIONS 1. Set Next Meeting The next meeting was set for November 11, 2026. Members discussed possible conflicts and alternatives for scheduling. G. PUBLIC COMMENT ON ANY ITEM OF CONCERN ON THIS AGENDA No public comment. H. ADJOURNMENT. A motion was made by Ald. Hale to adjourn the meeting at 5:54pm. The motion was seconded by Comm. Sturm. The motion carried. Minutes prepared by PP Larsen Page 3 of 11 100 Main Street, Suite 200 | Menasha, Wisconsin 54952-3151 Phone (920) 967-3650 | Fax (920) 967-5272 | menashawi.gov City of Menasha | Department of Community Development 2027 Meeting Schedule and Schedule Landmarks Commission Wednesday Deadline 4:00 PM (3rd Wed before) Façade Grant/Alteration Application Wednesday 5:30 PM Landmarks Commission December 23 January 13 January 20 February 10 February 17 March 10 March 24 April 14 April 21 May 12 May 19 June 9 June 23 July 14 July 21 August 11 August 18 September 9 September 22 October 13 October 20 November 10 November 17 December 8 RED dates are “as needed” meetings Bold = Irregular Meeting Dates Page 4 of 11 Page 5 of 11 HISTORIC DISTRICT RENOVATION APPLICATION - DESIGN NARRATIVE 200 Main Street, Menasha, Wisconsin | Emprize Brewing LLC | Supplemental Landmarks Details Purpose This supplemental submission provides additional detail for the proposed exterior work at 200 Main Street. The project is organized into four phases: Phase 1 - storefront windows and two entry doors; Phase 2 - exterior lighting and decorative tin/metal work; Phase 3 - Emprize Brew Mill signage; and Phase 4 - step repair. Phase 1 - Storefront Windows and Doors Phase 1 includes replacement of the damaged storefront window system and two entry doors at 200 Main Street. Pricing from Packerland and Tri-City is approximately $25,000 for this work. The new 200 Main storefront will follow the same general style, proportions, dark metal framing, door character, and historic-modern appearance as the existing 198 Main storefront. The 198 Main storefront was previously approved by the Landmarks Committee and is already installed. Storefront element Proposed treatment at 200 Main Windows New storefront windows styled to match the existing 198 Main storefront framing and proportions. Glass Clear, transparent, see-through glass. The glazing is not intended to be mirrored, reflective, tinted, or opaque. Visibility into the storefront and brewery will be maintained. Doors Two new entry doors coordinated with the 198 Main storefront style, including compatible dark framing and transom treatment above the doors. Finish Frame color and finish to coordinate with the existing 198 Main storefront and the broader historic facade. Phase 2 - Exterior Lighting and Decorative Tin / Metal Phase 2 includes repair or replacement of exterior lighting and repair of the existing decorative tin, or replacement with a compatible metal treatment if the existing material cannot reasonably be restored. The finish/color direction will remain consistent with the historic character, using an aged bronze / dark historic metal appearance. Exterior lighting design concepts are included with this submission as Attachment C. The concepts show historically compatible fixture directions, including antique gas-lantern, forged-iron sconce, coach-style lantern, and decorative historic lantern options. Warm lighting and a gas-flame-look or flicker-light effect are acceptable design directions. Phase 3 - Emprize Brew Mill Signage Phase 3 addresses repair or replacement of the Emprize Brew Mill exterior signage. The design intent is custom lettering in a gold / copper color, mounted on or integrated with aged-bronze tin or solid metal. The signage concept is intended to coordinate with the historic storefront, lighting, and metal finishes while remaining visually distinctive. Attachment D uses a broader conceptual Emprize Brew Mill facade/signage image to show overall sign placement and historic character. Attachment E provides an additional signage concept view focused more directly on the Emprize Brew Mill sign band. Both images are conceptual only and are included to communicate desired material, color, lettering, and general historic character. Phase 4 - Step Repair Phase 4 includes repair of the damaged exterior step serving the storefront area. Timing for this work will depend on Landmarks/permit approval, suitable temperatures for the required materials and repair methods, and contractor availability. Because the work is weather-sensitive, completion may need to be delayed until early spring 2027 if temperatures or site conditions are not suitable during the winter construction period. Page 6 of 11 ATTACHMENT A - EXISTING 198 MAIN STREET STOREFRONT Previously approved and installed storefront - design reference for 200 Main Street Reference note: The storefront shown above is the existing 198 Main Street storefront and serves as the architectural reference for the new window and door system proposed at 200 Main. Existing right-side door: The door on the right side of the 198 Main storefront is existing. No change or replacement of that door is proposed as part of this project. Page 7 of 11 ATTACHMENT B - 200 MAIN STREET STOREFRONT CONCEPT Conceptual application of the 198 Main storefront character to 200 Main Street Concept intent: New storefront windows and two new entry doors at 200 Main will match the general style, proportions, dark framing, and historic character of 198 Main. Glass specification: Clear, transparent, see-through glass. The proposed glazing is not intended to be mirrored, highly reflective, tinted, or opaque. Interior visibility should be maintained. Concept image: This image is provided to communicate design intent for Landmarks review and is not a final construction drawing or exact product specification. Page 8 of 11 ATTACHMENT C - PHASE 2 EXTERIOR LIGHTING CONCEPTS Historic lighting direction for 200 Main Street Lighting direction: Phase 2 may use one or more fixture styles consistent with the concepts shown above. Preferred characteristics include aged bronze or dark historic finishes, warm light output, and traditional forms compatible with the existing downtown facade. Gas-lantern or flame-look lighting is included as an acceptable historic design option. Related Phase 2 work: Repair or replace damaged exterior lighting and repair existing decorative tin where practical. If replacement of tin/metal is necessary, the replacement will remain compatible in profile and use an aged-bronze or similarly dark historic finish. Page 9 of 11 ATTACHMENT D - PHASE 3 EMPRIZE BREW MILL SIGNAGE CONCEPT Primary conceptual facade/signage image - Emprize Brew Mill signage direction Design intent: The Emprize Brew Mill name is shown as custom signage integrated across the storefront sign band, coordinated with the historic facade, exterior lighting, and metal/awning character. Material / finish direction: Lettering is intended to have a warm gold or copper appearance on an aged-bronze tin or solid-metal background, consistent with the overall historic palette. Concept only: The image above is conceptual only and is included to communicate overall style, placement, color, and character. It is not a final fabrication drawing, sign schedule, exact dimension, or final product specification. Page 10 of 11 ATTACHMENT E - ADDITIONAL SIGNAGE CONCEPT Additional conceptual view focused on Emprize Brew Mill signage character Additional concept: This secondary concept further illustrates the desired Emprize Brew Mill sign language, emphasizing custom lettering, historic proportion, and coordination with bronze-toned metalwork. Concept only: This additional image is also conceptual and intended only to communicate sign style, lettering direction, and material character for Landmarks review. Page 11 of 11

Source: City of Menasha website. First collected Nov 21, 2026.